ArticlePublisher preview availableLiterature Review

Antimicrobial photodynamic therapy in the nonsurgical treatment of periodontitis in patients with HIV infection: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

The aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis (SRM) was to evaluate the effectiveness of the adjunctive use of antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (aPDT) in non-surgical periodontal treatment (NSPT) in subjects with Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) and periodontitis. This SRM was registered in PROSPERO (CRD42023410180) and followed the guidelines of PRISMA 2020. Searches were performed in different electronic databases. Risk of bias was performed using the Cochrane Risk of Bias tool (RoB 2.0) for randomized clinical trials (RCT). Meta-analysis was performed using Rev Man software. The mean difference (MD) measure of effect was calculated, the random effect model was applied with a 95% confidence interval, and heterogeneity was tested by the I² index. The certainty of the evidence was rated using GRADE. A total of 1118 records were screened, and four studies were included. There was a greater reduction in the microbial load of periodontopathogens after NSPT with aPDT. Meta-analysis showed that probing depth (post 3 and 6 months) and clinical attachment loss (post 6 months) were lower for the aPDT-treated group than the NSPT alone: MD -0.39 [-0.74; -0.05], p = 0.02; MD -0.70 [-0.99; -0.41], p < 0.0001; MD -0.84 [-1,34; -0.34], p = 0.0001, respectively. Overall, the studies had a low risk of bias and, the certainty of evidence was rated as moderate. It is suggested that aPDT is a promising adjuvant therapy, showing efficacy in the reduction of the microbial load and in some clinical parameters of individuals with periodontitis and HIV.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Vol.:(0123456789)
Lasers in Medical Science (2024) 39:155
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10103-024-04087-y
REVIEW ARTICLE
Antimicrobial photodynamic therapy inthenonsurgical treatment
ofperiodontitis inpatients withHIV infection: asystematic review
andmeta‑analysis
GabrielPereiraNunes1 · RenatadeOliveiraAlves1· MatheusHenriqueFaccioliRagghianti1·
TamiresPassadoriMartins1· AlexandreHenriquedosReisPrado2· LarissaPereiraNunes1· MariaClaraFariaPoli1·
ArlesNaisaAmaralSilva3· FrancineBenetti2
Received: 29 August 2023 / Accepted: 15 May 2024
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer-Verlag London Ltd., part of Springer Nature 2024
Abstract
The aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis (SRM) was to evaluate the effectiveness of the adjunctive use of antimicro-
bial photodynamic therapy (aPDT) in non-surgical periodontal treatment (NSPT) in subjects with Human Immunodeficiency
Virus (HIV) and periodontitis. This SRM was registered in PROSPERO (CRD42023410180) and followed the guidelines of
PRISMA 2020. Searches were performed in different electronic databases. Risk of bias was performed using the Cochrane
Risk of Bias tool (RoB 2.0) for randomized clinical trials (RCT). Meta-analysis was performed using Rev Man software. The
mean difference (MD) measure of effect was calculated, the random effect model was applied with a 95% confidence interval,
and heterogeneity was tested by the I2 index. The certainty of the evidence was rated using GRADE. A total of 1118 records
were screened, and four studies were included. There was a greater reduction in the microbial load of periodontopathogens
after NSPT with aPDT. Meta-analysis showed that probing depth (post 3 and 6 months) and clinical attachment loss (post 6
months) were lower for the aPDT-treated group than the NSPT alone: MD -0.39 [-0.74; -0.05], p = 0.02; MD -0.70 [-0.99;
-0.41], p < 0.0001; MD -0.84 [-1,34; -0.34], p = 0.0001, respectively. Overall, the studies had a low risk of bias and, the cer-
tainty of evidence was rated as moderate. It is suggested that aPDT is a promising adjuvant therapy, showing efficacy in the
reduction of the microbial load and in some clinical parameters of individuals with periodontitis and HIV.
Keywords Photodynamic therapy· Non-surgical periodontal therapy· Human immunodeficiency virus· Periodontitis·
Periodopntal diseases· Oral-healthy
Introduction
Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) is characterized by
attacks on human cells, promoting a progressive decrease
in CD4+-T lymphocytes and, consequently, reducing the
immune response, which makes individuals more suscepti-
ble to other infections [1, 2]. The last World Health Statistics
Report, published in 2022, by the World Health Organiza-
tion (WHO), showed that 1.5million new cases of HIV were
diagnosticated in 2020, and 37.7million people living with
this infection [3]. Therefore, HIV infection is still a public
health problem that requires attention from healthcare pro-
viders worldwide [3]. The oral manifestations need attention
among the secondary infections in HIV patients since they
are considered one of the main signs of the infection and
occur in more than 50% of the infected population [2, 4].
Periodontitis is characterized by the progressive destruc-
tion of the tooth-supporting tissues (periodontium) [5].
While the etiology of periodontitis is primarily bacterial, it
is currently accepted that periodontal disease is mediated by
the host response and influenced by local or systemic dys-
biosis [6]. Periodontitis also represents an important public
* Gabriel Pereira Nunes
Gabriel.p.nunes@unesp.br
1 Department ofPreventive andRestorative Dentistry,
Araçatuba School ofDentistry, São Paulo State University
(UNESP), Rua José Bonifácio 1193, Araçatuba,
SP16015-050, Brazil
2 Department ofRestorative Dentistry, School ofDentistry,
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais (UFMG), Belo
Horizonte, MinasGerais, Brazil
3 Department ofDiagnosis andSurgery, School ofDentistry,
São Paulo State University (UNESP), Araraquara, SP, Brazil
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... Therefore, monitoring the microecological environment of cytokines could potentially serve as a diagnostic tool for assessing an individual's periodontal disease status and susceptibility to the condition. Furthermore, technological advances such as antimicrobial photodynamic therapy have shown promise as an adjunct therapy to reduce the microbial load in individuals with periodontitis and enhance periodontal results [26,27]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Periodontal health in men with HIV remains understudied, despite suggestions of associations between HIV infection and gingival pocketing, periodontal attachment loss, and gingival inflammation. As antiretroviral therapy (ART) has improved the quality of life for people living with HIV (PLWH), aging-related risk factors and comorbidities, including periodontitis, have emerged. This study aims to assess alveolar bone height, gingival crevicular fluid (GCF) cytokines, and periodontal disease activity in men with and without HIV. Methods Ninety-three men (50 HIV+, 43 HIV-) aged 35–70 years were recruited from Columbia University Irving Medical Center clinics. Periodontal examination, GCF collection, and intraoral radiographs were collected. Statistical analysis was conducted with t-tests for continuous variables and chi-squared tests for categorical variables. Results While no significant differences were observed in bleeding on probing, clinical attachment loss and pocket depths, men with HIV exhibited significantly greater alveolar crestal height on radiographs compared to men without HIV (HIV + 3.41+/-1.35 mm, HIV- 2.64+/-1.01 mm; p = 0.004), reflecting greater alveolar bone loss. Conclusions Men living with HIV demonstrate increased alveolar bone loss compared to those without HIV, possibly mediated by elevated IL6 levels. These results underscore the importance of comprehensive oral health management in PLWH and highlight the need for further research understanding the mechanisms linking HIV infection, cytokine dysregulation, and periodontal health.
Article
Background The One Health approach involves collaboration across several sectors, including public health, veterinary and environmental sectors in an integrated manner. These sectors may be disparate and unrelated, however to succeed, all stakeholders need to understand what the other stakeholders are communicating. Likewise, it is important that there is public acceptance and support of One Health approaches, which requires effective communication between professional and institutional organisations and the public. To help aid and facilitate such communication, written materials need to be readable by all stakeholders, in order to communicate effectively. There has been an exponential increase in the publication of papers involving One Health, with <5 per year, in the 2000s, to nearly 500 published in 2023. To date, readability of One Health information has not been scrutinised, nor has it been considered as an integral intervention of One Health policy communication. The aim of this study was therefore to examine readability of public-facing One Health information prepared by 24 global organisations. Methods Readability was calculated using Readable software, to obtain four readability scores [(ⅰ) Flesch Reading Ease (FRE), (ⅱ) Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level (FKGL), (ⅲ) Gunning Fog Index and (ⅳ) SMOG Index] and two text metrics [words/sentence, syllables/word] for 100 sources of One Health information, from four categories [One Health public information; PubMed abstracts; Science in One Health (SOH) abstracts (articles); SOH abstracts (reviews)]. Results Readability of One Health information for the public is poor, not reaching readability reference standards. No information was found that had a readability of less than 9th grade (around 14 years old). Mean values for the FRE and FKGL were (19.4 ± 1.4) (target >60) and (15.6 ± 0.3) (target <8), respectively, with mean words per sentence and syllables per word of 20.5 and 2.0, respectively. Abstracts with “One Health” in the title were more difficult to read than those without “One Health” in the title (FRE: P = 0.0337; FKGL: P = 0.0087). Comparison of FRE and FKGL readability scores for the four categories of One Health information [One Health public information; PubMed abstracts; SOH abstracts (articles); SOH abstracts (reviews)] showed that SOH abstracts from articles were easier to read than those from SOH reviews. No One Health public-facing information from the 100 sources examined met the FKGL target of ≤8. The most easily read One Health information required a Grade Level of 9th grade (14–15 years old), with a mean Grade Level of 15.5 (university/college level). Conclusion Considerable work is required in making One Health written materials more readable, particularly for children and adolescents (<14 years of age). It is important that any interventions or mitigations taken to support better public understanding of the One Health approach are not ephemeral, but have longer lasting and legacy value. Authors of One Health information should consider using readability calculators when preparing One Health information for their stakeholders, to check the readability of their work, so that the final material is within recommended readability reference parameters, to support the health literacy and stakeholder-directed knowledge of their readers.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose: The aim of this study was to compare clinical periodontal conditions in HIV-positive people on HAART with an HIV-negative group, in addition to investigating factors associated with periodontitis in the entire sample. Methods: This was a cross-sectional study. Data were collected by oral clinical examination for the diagnosis of periodontitis, review of medical records, and application of a questionnaire containing personal data, deleterious habits, and oral hygiene habits for the other variables. The results were analyzed by Pearson's χ 2 test and Student's t-test. A logistic regression model was constructed for the multivariate analysis and periodontitis was defined as a dependent variable. The analysis was performed on the entire sample (HIV+ and HIV-) and also on the group consisting of only people living with HIV. Results: Individuals older than 43 years old and with HIV were more likely to develop moderate and severe periodontitis (47.80 and 4.84 times, respectively). When analyzing only HIV+, in addition to age (OR = 2.795; CI = 1.080-7.233), the use of nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NNRTIs) (OR = 2.841; CI = 1.135-7.112) was also associated with moderate and severe periodontitis. Conclusion: It was possible to observe a higher prevalence of periodontitis among individuals with HIV, showing an association between the virus, advanced age, and moderate or severe periodontitis.
Article
Full-text available
Objective The objective of this systematic review and meta-analysis (SRM) was to answer the question as to whether the use of ultrasonic irrigation (UI) results in better antimicrobial activity in root canal disinfection compared to conventional irrigation (CI). Methods A literature search was performed in the main scientific databases, carried out until October 2021. The eligibility criteria were randomized clinical trials (RCTs). Two meta-analyses were conducted using R software with the “META” package. The mean difference (MD) and odds ratio (OR) measure of effect were calculated. The fixed effect model was applied with a 95% confidence interval. The Cochrane collaboration scale was used to assess risk of bias and the GRADE tool to assess the quality of evidence. Results A total of 1782 records were screened, and 12 studies meeting the criteria were included in this review. A low risk of bias was observed for most domains, except allocation concealment that was considered unclear. The certainty of evidence was classified as moderate in the OR meta-analyses and low in the MD meta-analyses. Ultrasonic irrigation resulted in a better antimicrobial effect in both meta-analyses, MD 1.42 [1.60; 1.23] p < 0.0001, I² = 80%; and OR 3.86 [1.98; 7.53] p< 0.0001, I² = 28.7%. Conclusion Within the limitations of this SRM, UI presented better antimicrobial efficacy than CI. Clinical Relevance UI should be used by clinicians as it promotes better antimicrobial efficacy in patients undergoing endodontic treatment.
Article
Full-text available
Periodontitis is a disease characterized by tooth‐associated microbial biofilms that drive chronic inflammation and destruction of periodontal‐supporting tissues. In some individuals, disease progression can lead to tooth loss. A similar condition can occur around dental implants in the form of peri‐implantitis. The immune response to bacterial challenges is not only influenced by genetic factors, but also by environmental factors. Epigenetics involves the study of gene function independent of changes to the DNA sequence and its associated proteins, and represents a critical link between genetic and environmental factors. Epigenetic modifications have been shown to contribute to the progression of several diseases, including chronic inflammatory diseases like periodontitis and peri‐implantitis. This review aims to present the latest findings on epigenetic influences on periodontitis and to discuss potential mechanisms that may influence peri‐implantitis, given the paucity of information currently available.
Article
Full-text available
Background The objective of this systematic review and meta-analysis (SRM) was to assess the evidence between the association of oral lichen planus and periodontal disease, evaluating the periodontal clinical parameters and biomarkers levels. Methods This systematic review and meta-analysis followed PRISMA and was registered in PROSPERO (CRD42020181513). Searches were accomplished in databases for articles published until June 2021. The meta-analysis was performed with the variables: plaque index (PI), gingival index (GI), probing depth (PD), and clinical attachment loss (CAL). The mean difference was applied with a 95% confidence interval. Results Six articles were included. Qualitative analysis showed the levels of biomarkers (matrix metalloproteinases, interleukins, and periodontal microbiological profile) are increased in subjects with periodontal disease and oral lichen planus. In the meta-analysis, these subjects also presented increases in all periodontal clinical parameters evaluated: GI—gingivitis 0.22 [0.14, 0.31] p < 0.0001 and periodontitis 0.12 [0.06, 0.19] p = 0.0003; PI—gingivitis 0.22 [0.12, 0.31] p < 0.0001 and periodontitis 0.15 [0.08, 0.23] p < 0.0001; PD—gingivitis 0.27 [0.06; 0.48] p = 0.0107 and periodontitis 0.11 [0.01; 0.21] p = 0.0299; and CA—periodontitis 0.06 [0.01, 0.12] p = 0.0176. Conclusions Evidence suggests a significant relationship between the severity of periodontal disease and the presence of oral lichen planus. Although the association is biologically plausible, further studies are needed using populations and well-defined biochemical and clinical outcomes with consideration of potential confounding factors. Clinical relevance This SRM provides information on the interaction between OLP and periodontal disease and guides clinicians to make evidence-based decisions and suggests recommendations for further high-quality studies.
Article
Background: No systematic review/meta-analysis has been conducted on the microbiological profile associated with the occurrence of periodontitis in patients with HIV. The aim of this study was to evaluate the prevalence of identified bacteria in HIV-infected patients with periodontal disease. Methods: Three English electronic databases (MEDLINE (via PubMed), SCOPUS, and Web of Science) were searched systematically from the beginning to February 13, 2021. The frequency of each identified bacteria in HIV-infected patients with periodontal disease was extracted. All meta-analysis methods were performed using STATA software. Results: Twenty-two articles met inclusion criteria and were enrolled into the systematic review. This review analyzed a total of 965 HIV-infected patients with periodontitis. The prevalence of periodontitis was higher in HIV-infected male patients (83% (CI 95%: 76 - 88%)) compared to females (28% (CI 95%: 17 - 39%)). In our study, the pooled prevalence of necrotizing ulcerative periodontitis and necrotizing ulcerative gingivitis in patients with HIV infection was 67% (CI 95%: 52 - 82%) and 60% (CI 95%: 45 - 74%), while a lower prevalence of linear gingivitis erythema was reported (11% (CI 95%: 5 - 18%)). More than 140 bacterial species were identified from HIV-infected patients with periodontal disease. High prevalence of Tannerella forsythia (51% (CI 95%: 5 - 96%)), Fusobacterium nucleatum (50% (CI 95%: 21 - 78%)), Prevotella intermedia (50% (CI 95%: 32 - 68%)), Peptostreptococcus micros (44% (CI 95%: 25 - 65%)), Campylobacter rectus (35% (CI 95%: 25 - 45%)), and Fusobacterium spp. (35% (CI 95%: 3 - 78%)) in HIV-infected patients with periodontal disease was found. Conclusions: Our study demonstrated that the prevalence of the red and orange complex of bacteria in HIV patients with periodontal disease is relatively high.
Article
BACKGROUND : To evaluate the effectiveness of the use of antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (aPDT) in root canals disinfection in cases of endodontic retreatments. METHODS : This Systematic Review was registered in PROSPERO (CRD42021260013) and followed the guidelines of the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA). Searches were performed in the electronic databases PubMeb, Scopus, Web of Science, Embase, Web of Science, Clinical Trials and Cochrane Library. Methodological quality and risk of bias were assessed by the Cochrane Risk of Bias tool for randomized clinical trials (RCT) and by the Newcastle-Ottawa (NOS) qualifier for non-RCT (prospective) studies. Meta-analysis was performed using R software, version 3.6.3 with the “META” package assistant by the RStudio platform. The odds ratio (OR) measure of effect was calculated and the random effect model was applied with a 95% confidence interval, and heterogeneity tested by the I2 index. The certainty of evidence was rated using GRADE. RESULTS : Regarding the 1513 studies screened, 10 met the eligibility criteria and were included, and 8 used in the quantitative synthesis. Meta-analysis showed that all of studies data presented a significant difference before and after of antimicrobial photodynamic therapy in the microbial load reduction in secondary endondontic infections (OR 0.15 [0.07; 0.32], p<0.0001). Overall, the studies had a low risk of bias and, the analysis of evidence by GRADE assessment was rated as moderate. CONCLUSION : It is suggested that aPDT is a beneficial and promising tool, showing efficacy in reducing the microbial load in cases of endodontic retreatment.
Article
Aim: The aim of this study was to evaluate combined efficacy of methylene blue mediated antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (a-PDT) using 660 nm diode laser versus Er, Cr: YSGG laser as an adjunct to scaling and root planing on improving the Probing depth (PD), Clinical attachment level (CAL), Plaque Index (PI) and Gingival Index (GI).clinical parameters in Supportive periodontal therapy. Materials and method: In this split-mouth, double-blind, randomized controlled trial, we compared a-PDT versus Er,Cr:YSGG as an adjunct to scaling and root planning (SRP) with SRP alone in Supportive periodontal therapy. A total of 36 subjected were enrolled. In each patient, two quadrants constituted the control group (Group I - Scaling and root planing SRP alone), one site in other quadrant constituted the test group 1 (Group II - SRP followed by application of Er, Cr: YSGG laser), and another site in different quadrant constituted the test group 2 (Group III - SRP followed by antimicrobial Photodynamic therapy using diode laser). The diode laser was operated at a peak power of 70 mW using a 0.6 mm diameter fiber-optic tip. Each site was irradiated with a power density of 28mW/cm2, for 10 seconds, thus delivering a total energy of 16.72 J/cm2 per tooth. Whereas, the Er,Cr:YSGG laser's parameters were set to 1 W of power, 10% air, and 15% water. The same procedure was repeated at 1st, 2nd and 3rd week for both the laser therapies. Plaque index (PI), Gingival index (GI), Probing depth (PD,) and Clinical attachment level (CAL) were measured by a single examiner at baseline and 3 months follow up. Inter group analysis of the parameters were done using One-way ANOVA and pairwise comparison was carried out by Tukey's post hoc test. Intra group analysis was performed using Students's paired t test. Statistical significance was set to p < 0.05. Results: There were no significant differences between participants for clinical parameters at baseline. PI, GI PD, and CAL significantly improved at 3 months follow up compared to baseline in both the study groups (Group II - SRP + Er,Cr:YSGG, Group III - SRP + a-PDT) with P < 0.05. Adjunctive use of Er,Cr:YSGG laser with SRP showed better clinical outcomes than a-PDT with SRP. Conclusion: Nonsurgical periodontal therapy of chronic periodontitis using Er, Cr: YSGG, and a-PDT as an adjunct to SRP was significantly more effective than SRP alone in reducing PD, CAL, GI, and PI at 3 months follow up. Adjunctive use of Er,Cr:YSGG laser with SRP showed better clinical outcomes than a-PDT with SRP. However, the long-term positive benefits of the laser therapies are yet unknown and more research with longer follow-ups are required.
Article
Aim To assess the clinical periodontal and microbiological parameters in patients having chronic necrotizing ulcerative periodontitis (NUP) after the administration of adjunctive photodynamic therapy and non-surgical periodontal therapy in smokers, mal-nutrition and HIV positive individuals. Materials and Methods A total of 30 individuals with NUP were selected for the present clinical trial, where both Group I and Group II had equal number of patients respectively (15 each). The groups were divided on the basis of provision of treatment where patients in Group I underwent scaling and root planing (SRP). Furthermore, Group II patients were subjected to adjunctive phtotodynamic therapy and SRP (aPDT + SRP). Full mouth plaque scores (fmpS), full mouth bleeding on probing (fmBOP), periodontal pocket depth (PPD) and clinical attachment levels (CAL) were the clinical periodontal parameters that were carefully evaluated. Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans (Aa), Porphyromonas gingivalis (Pg) and Tannerella forsythia (Tf) were the bacteria species which were evaluated. The assessments were done at baseline, three (3) months and six (6) months respectively. Results All periodontal parameters including fmpS, fmBOP, PPD and CAL significantly improved in both Group I and Group II respectively. Group II patients subjected to aPDT + SRP reported higher reduction in mean PPD in comparison to Group I patients at follow up (p<0.05). At follow-up, similar results were also reported for CAL gain where Group II (aPDT +SRP) patients reported higher CAL gain in comparison to patients who underwent SRP only (p<0.05). From baseline to follow-up, all the bacterial levels exhibited reduction in both study groups i.e Group I (SRP) and Group II (aPDT + SRP) respectively (p<0.05). However, Group II patients prominent reduction in the counts of Aa and Tf at the three-month interval, whereas Aa seem to reduce in HIV and smoking individuals at the six-month interval. Moreover, the levels of Pg and Tf significantly reduced at 3 months and only Aa at 6 months in patients with mal-nutrition respectively (p<0.05). Conclusion The use of photodynamic treatment as an adjunct to scaling and root planing enhanced clinical periodontal results and reduced bacterial content in patients having NUP.
Article
Objective The objective of the present study was to determine the in vitro Azole antifungals susceptibility of Candida spp. strains isolated from HIV-positive patients with periodontitis. Methods Oral examination was performed in 500 HIV-positive patients, of which 228 were included in the study for having periodontitis which and separated in two groups based on their TCD4⁺ T-cells: (A) n = 110 (≤200 CD4⁺); (B) n = 118 (>200 CD4⁺). Candida spp. were isolated from the subgingival biofilm and crevicular fluid by seeding on CHROMagar plates and confirmed by endpoint PCR and MALDI-TOF. The susceptibility test in vitro for five antifungals was performed using the disc diffusion method. Results From the 228 HIV-positive patients with periodontitis, 174 were positive to Candida spp., and 204 isolations were obtained. 138 (67.64%) were C. albicans, and 66 (32.35%) were Candida non-albicans species. The most frequent Candida non-albicans species in order of frequency were C. glabrata with 48 (23.52%), C. tropicalis with 10 (4.9%), C. krusei with 7 (3.43%), and C. dubliniensis with 1 (0.49%). All species presented resistance to any antifungal: 149 to 5-fluorocytosine (73.0%), 149 to fluconazole (73.0%), and 144 to voriconazole (70.7%). Miconazole and econazole presented the highest susceptibility rates with 129 (63.2%) and 130 (63.7%) isolations, respectively. Conclusion The Candida spp. involved in periodontitis of HIV-positive patients have a multi-resistant feature. It is necessary to implement recurrent research regarding the antifungal resistance of the Candida spp. that take part in periodontitis pathogenesis to promote an effective treatment in HIV patients.