Evaluating the efficacy of simulators and multimedia for refreshing ACLS skills in India

Georgetown University Hospital & Washington Hospital Center, Department of Emergency Medicine, USA.
Resuscitation (Impact Factor: 4.17). 11/2009; 81(2):217-23. DOI: 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2009.10.013
Source: PubMed


Data on the efficacy of the simulation and multimedia teaching modalities is limited, particularly in developing nations. This study evaluates the effectiveness of simulator and multimedia educational tools in India.
Advanced Cardiac Life Support (ACLS) certified paramedic students in India were randomized to either Simulation, Multimedia, or Reading for a 3-h ACLS refresher course. Simulation students received a lecture and 10 simulator cases. The Multimedia group viewed the American Heart Association (AHA) ACLS video and played a computer game. The Reading group independently read with an instructor present. Students were tested prior to (pre-test), immediately after (post-test), and 3 weeks after (short-term retention test), their intervention. During each testing stage subjects completed a cognitive, multiple-choice test and two cardiac arrest scenarios. Changes in exam performance were analyzed for significance. A survey was conducted asking students' perceptions of their assigned modality.
One hundred and seventeen students were randomized to Simulation (n=39), Multimedia (n=38), and Reading (n=40). Simulation demonstrated greater improvement managing cardiac arrest scenarios compared to both Multimedia and Reading on the post-test (9% versus 5% and 2%, respectively, p<0.05) and Reading on the short-term retention test (6% versus -1%, p<0.05). Multimedia showed significant improvement on cognitive, short-term retention testing compared to Simulation and Reading (5% versus 0% and 0%, respectively, p<0.05). On the survey, 95% of Simulation and 84% of Multimedia indicated they enjoyed their modality.
Simulation and multimedia educational tools were effective and may provide significant additive benefit compared to reading alone. Indian students enjoyed learning via these modalities.

15 Reads
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The role of e-learning in contemporary healthcare education is quickly developing. The aim of this study was to examine the relationship between the use of an e-learning simulation programme (Microsim, Laerdal, UK) prior to attending an Advanced Life Support (ALS) course and the subsequent relationship to candidate performance. An open label, multi-centre randomised controlled study was conducted. The control group received a course manual and pre-course MCQ four weeks prior to the face to face course. The intervention group in addition received the Microsim programme on a CD. The primary outcome was performance during a simulated cardiac arrest at the end of the course. Secondary outcomes were performance during multiple choice exams, resuscitation skills assessments and feedback to Microsim programme. 572 participants were randomised (287 Microsim, 285 control). There were no significant differences in the primary outcome (performance during a standard cardiac arrest simulation) or secondary outcomes. User evaluations were favorable. 79% would recommend it to colleagues. 9% stated Microsim could replace the entire ALS course, 25% parts. Over 70% of participants' perceived that Microsim improved their understanding of the key learning domains of the ALS course. Distributing Microsim to healthcare providers prior to attending an ALS courses did not improve either cognitive or psychomotor skills performance during cardiac arrest simulation testing. The challenge that lies ahead is to identify the optimal way to use e-learning as part of a blended approach to learning for this type of training programme.
    Full-text · Article · Jul 2010 · Resuscitation

  • No preview · Article · Feb 2011 · Resuscitation
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Studies show that students, trained to perform compressions between 40 and 50mm deep, often do not achieve sufficient depth at retention testing. We hypothesized that training to achieve depths >50mm would decrease the proportion of students with depth <40mm after 6 months, compared to students trained to a depth interval of 40-50mm. A basic life support (BLS) self-learning station was attended by 190 third year medicine students. They were first offered the possibility to refresh their skills, following the instructions of a 15min abbreviated Mini Anne™ video (Laerdal, Norway) using a full size torso and a face shield. This was followed by further training using Resusci Anne Skills Station™ software (Laerdal, Norway). Voice feedback was provided according to randomisation to a standard group (SG) 40-50mm and a deeper group (DG) >50mm. Quality of compressions was tested after 6 months. The SG and DG groups consisted of 90 (67% female) and 100 (58% female) participants respectively. At the end of training, all students reached the target depth without overlap between groups. After 6 months, the proportion of students achieving a depth <40mm was 26/89 (29%) in the SG vs. 12/89 (14%) in the DG (P=0.01). The proportion of students with a depth >50mm was 5/89 (6%) for the SG and 44/89 (49%) in the DG (P<0.001). The educational strategy to train students to a deeper depth, reduced shallow compressions 6 months after training.
    Full-text · Article · Jun 2011 · Resuscitation
Show more