ArticlePDF Available

Emerging Trends and Issues in English Language Teaching: A Bibliometric Analysis

Authors:

Abstract

English language has been considered a lingua franca and used as a medium of instruction in Pakistan. The English language has been taught with traditional methods of teaching, which fail to develop language competency among learners. The study has been designed to analyze Pakistan's emerging English teaching trends based on available literature. The data has been collected by secondary literature published in various research journals. The articles were selected by inclusion and exclusion criteria by searching with key words of English language teaching. We then selected various articles, read them, and used them as a resource. For this purpose, the content analysis was used by Braun and Clark (2006) by focusing on the content of the paper. It has been found that there needs to be more technology in language teaching and technological resources for teaching purposes, along with a shortage of language teaching skills and professional development of the teachers in English language teaching. Using technology in the classroom is recommended, adopting multi-model learning and communicative language teaching.
1004
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
Emerging Trends and Issues in English Language Teaching:
A Bibliometric Analysis
Moazma Abdul Aziz
1
, Amber Azizullah
2
and Sanober Baloch
3
https://doi.org/10.62345/jads.2024.13.1.83
Abstract
English language has been considered a lingua franca and used as a medium of instruction in
Pakistan. The English language has been taught with traditional methods of teaching, which fail
to develop language competency among learners. The study has been designed to analyze
Pakistan's emerging English teaching trends based on available literature. The data has been
collected by secondary literature published in various research journals. The articles were
selected by inclusion and exclusion criteria by searching with key words of English language
teaching. We then selected various articles, read them, and used them as a resource. For this
purpose, the content analysis was used by Braun and Clark (2006) by focusing on the content of
the paper. It has been found that there needs to be more technology in language teaching and
technological resources for teaching purposes, along with a shortage of language teaching skills
and professional development of the teachers in English language teaching. Using technology in
the classroom is recommended, adopting multi-model learning and communicative language
teaching.
Keywords: English Language, Trends and Issues, Teaching and Education.
Introduction
Teaching English is challenging for teachers because English is morphologically dissimilar from
the local languages, including Sindhi, Urdu, Balochi, Pashto, Punjabi, and other languages. In the
Pakistani context, when there is a lack of resources and professional development, it has been
challenging for teachers to teach the second language and attain the desired outcomes (Lashari et
al., 2018; Ahmed et al., 2023). This review paper aims to analyze the current trends and issues in
teaching the English language. We collected data by reviewing articles from various journals about
English language teaching trends and issues. The research articles were selected from Google
Scholar based on the keywords, then by Clark and Braun (2017).
English is widely used as a global language to facilitate communication between people who do
not speak English as their first language (Lashari et al., 2021). However, in today's society, English
should not only be seen as a language in isolation but also in the context of different sociocultural
and sociopolitical backgrounds and various ideologies (Blommaert, 2010; Fang, 2018; Nieto,
2017). For colonial history, English has gained its dominance in South Asia, particularly in
Pakistan. Besides this having political and economic reasons, and is now considered a language
1
Department of Education, Sindh Madressatul Islam University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Corresponding Author Email: moazmaabdulaziz111@gmail.com
2
Department of Education, Sindh Madressatul Islam University, Karachi, Pakistan.
3
Department of Education, Sindh Madressatul Islam University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Copyright: ©This is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.
Compliance with ethical standards: There are no conflicts of interest (financial or non-financial). This study did not receive any funding.
1005
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
(Kachru, 1998; Mahboob, 2009), permeating many aspects of people's daily lives (Lashari &
Umrani, 2023). Due to globalization, the role of English is increasing worldwide (Lashari et al.,
2023a; Magsi et al., 2023). In Pakistan, English is one of the official languages, especially for the
professional job (Rahman, 2005; Lashari & Umrani, 2023) because it can be used as the domain
power (Magsi et al., 2023; Simming et al., 2015). English can be used for self-improvement and
career success (Bukhari et al., 2023; Rahman, 2002). It can indicate social class, and people
prioritize a superior language (Shamim, 2008). But in the education system, the main reason or
source of failure of ordinary people is the minor use of the English language (Bruthiaux, 2002;
Lashari & Umrani, 2023).
The role of an English language teacher is very challenging when teaching English as a discipline
without available resources (Imran et al., 2022). English teachers should know their significant
role in improving their students' English language because English is the fastest-growing language
and official language of Pakistan; it is a professional language that promotes professional growth
(Bukhari et al., 2023; Simming et al., 2015).
Teachers are the fundamental building blocks of educational institutions, responsible for
transforming knowledge, skills, and values. The goal of class teachers is the development activities
to drive changes in teachers' practices, beliefs, attitudes, and, ultimately, the learning outcomes of
their students (Amur et al., 2023). As the educational landscape shifts, teachers face new
challenges, such as catering to their students' diverse learning styles and multiple intelligences
(Siddiqui et al., 2023). Hargreaves (1997) emphasizes that teachers require both in-classroom
support and external assistance to adapt to these new demands. Ongoing professional development
programs can allow teachers to renew their skills, knowledge, and visions for good teaching
(Simming et al., 2015; Siddiqui et al., 2023). Fullan and Hargreaves (1992a) the importance of
these programs enables teachers to introduce and utilize new practices.
Over the years, there has been a significant change in the way English language teachers are
perceived. Educational theories, from Behaviorism to Progressivism, reveal that teachers' roles
have transformed from threatening authority figures to facilitators (Bukhari et al., 2023; Lashari
et al., 2018). This shift can be seen in the difference between Skinner's (1976) approach of "skill
and drill" and Lowery's (2011) emphasis on effective teachers being flexible and making content
memorable rather than just memorable. It seems like primarily English teachers use inappropriate
and inadequate methods, strategies, and techniques of language teaching, which can't be
implemented CLT, but public school textbooks in English are based on it (Simming et al.,
2015; Abbasi & Lashari, 2017). According to Lashari et al. (2023), it can be the ideal approach.
In Pakistani public schools, CLT (communicative language teaching) is included in English
textbooks. The majority of English language teachers appear to improper teachers of English
language teaching and do not apply the proper, appropriate methods, strategies, techniques, and
pedagogies in general (Al-Shamiry, 2000; Lashari et al., 2023)
Additionally, they conclude that although Pakistani English teachers possess a considerable level
of "knowledgeable of the principles of CLT," their classroom practices do not demonstrate this
knowledge (Al-Shamiry, 2000). The availability and use of educational technology have improved
in the modern era, making storing vast amounts of data easier. Utilizing cutting-edge educational
technology helps manage sounds, images, instructional strategies, and many other things that this
technology can swiftly advance. One essential system that significantly contributes to English
language instructors' ability to make decisions in Pakistan's private schools is "education " (Bushra
et al., 2024).
1006
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
Educational institutes and organizations know that creativeness of English language teaching can
empower English language teachers, and English language teachers need to use interpersonal skills
in learning and teaching and as well as they should have to improve the effectiveness and the
quality of their teaching (Berestova et al., 2020). It is essential that English language teachers
should have to understand all the concepts of language teaching and should have to be confident
in their English language, also use technology to teach effectively and provide new ways of English
language teaching (Lashari et al., 2023)
English language teachers should be aware of innovative leadership styles and the proper use of
technology (Herrera & Lucas, 2020). Innovation is another name for creating new ideas and facing
challenges. Empower English language teachers and leaders should to know and be aware of the
further successful and effective integrating technologies of English language teaching and learning
techniques and strategies because, in simple words, the goal of all the discussion is that give
English language teachers more authority and power that they can take every decision by
themselves (Lashari et al., 2023; Lashari & Umrani, 2023).
Problem Statement
The English language has become the need of every institute, field, or profession because it is an
international language. The English language is the source of career success, dominance, and
power. Still, the main thing is that in our educational institute, primarily English language teachers
don’t know about the English language teaching trends and issues because most teachers don’t
practice in their fields. They are not trained, so they face many hurdles and difficulties while
teaching English. The main problem is that the various teachers come from diverse cultures, so
proficiency problems also occur when teaching the language subject.
Another problem is that, as we know, English is an international language. We are living in a
modern era of technology. Still, unfortunately, in our educational institutes, there is no usage of
integration of technology for teaching, no use of the new era’s modern method, which is not
applied in the classroom, and a lack of use of different kinds of methodologies, strategies,
techniques, and pedagogies of English language teaching. So, these all are problems of English
language teaching which exist in our educational institutes.
Study Objectives
English is the international language, and our topic is the Trends and Issues in English language
teaching. Hence, the object is to discover the emerging trends, issues, and problems in English
language teaching in our education system. To find out the teaching emerging trends of integrating
methods, techniques, strategies, and pedagogies of English language teaching and the main object
is to find the solutions to the problem which is creating problems during teaching the language
subject of English and also highlight the different ways and modes of English language teaching
in the educational institutes. This study will focus on all aspects mentioned in the study's objective.
Literature Review
With 65 different languages spoken there, Pakistan is a multilingual and multiethnic nation
(Rahman, 2005). Pakistan has had Urdu as its official language since gaining independence.
Conversely, English has a significant impact on Pakistani society and the social development of
an individual since it is the official language and has the privilege to enjoy in every part of life,
including the judiciary system, administration, military sector, and media journalism (Lashari et
al., 2023; Shamim, 2011). Ignoring its significance in obtaining employment in the public and
1007
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
commercial sectors is simple, given its well-known strategy and holding position (Lashari et 2023).
Pakistan set its vision for increasing the educational ratio in the country by making a solid primary
and high-level education sector within 100% by 2030 (Rahman, 2005). Still, it was barely able to
reach 62% because of poor enrollment and a low survival rate (Buriro et al., 2023). Students'
motivation and attitudes toward studying English might be influenced by the quality of English
instruction they get in the classroom (Al-Sohbani, 1997). Every year, ASER surveys elementary
schools in rustic and non-rural regions of the state to assess the state of literacy. The most recent
data indicates that, compared to other competencies, English learning countrywide still needs to
fulfill its desired ratio, as it's seen only at 55%. Learning in rural regions is still in dire straits
(Jamil, 2020). Sindh province has the lowest literacy rate at the provincial level, at just 27% (Jamil,
2020).
Teaching English with Technology
Language is one of the practical elements that affect international communication activities.
Students utilize the various parts of English tutorials, which help them increase their skills in
reading, writing, speaking, and listening to English for the betterment of their skill of
communication (Grabe & Stoller, 2002). Technology also plays a crucial part in giving instructions
and taking instructions. It is an essential part of teaching where facilitators facilitate the learner.
Technology is also the name of integration, so when we talk about technology with learning, we
must rethink technology and add it to our curriculum to support the English language learning
process (Eady & Lockyer, 2013).
Technology is an essential tool and instrument of teaching and learning. It is a significant and vital
part of teaching and learning. Teachers should use technology to support the subject and
curriculum syllabus so that the students will increase their technology knowledge and improve
their language skills (Costley, 2014). The plan should have to be aligned according to teaching and
technology, and must know the use of that. Teachers should know about the best approach to
teaching the English language because it is the most effective way a teacher teaches to his students
with the help of integrating technologies in the classrooms (Madiha et al., 2023). ICT encourages
computer-assisted language learning (CALL), e-learning (Lashari et al., 2023a), and multimedia-
assisted language (MALL); that’s why primarily countries use computer technology in educational
institutions because it's also happening in many countries, excessive use of computers is also the
cause non-development of many countries through the affecting of the educational system.
The utilization of ICT is essential to teaching the English language because it has become a critical
process of learning and teaching. The teacher should be prepared to teach the English language,
including the capacity of ICT in the teaching process. In this current era, technology is critical, but
its use is shallow in our classroom. This is why we are facing a lot of difficulties just because we
are not using this technology trend.
Traditional Method of Teaching (TMT)
The Traditional Method of Teaching "consists of giving the students grammatical rules and
paradigms," according to (Schackne, 1994). Lists of forms organized grammatically are called
paradigms. With this approach, vocabulary lists are also provided to the pupils with their mother
tongue translations. The pupils' proficiency with the language's facts is assessed. In the past, the
direct approachalso known as the oral or natural techniquewas used instead of this method
(GTM).
1008
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
Direct Method
According to Hubbard et al. (1983), the direct technique evolved in response to the grammatical
translation method. This technique relies on the idea that children learn a language through
listening and speaking. The students converse with one another. Writing and reading skills can be
acquired later. The audio-lingual approach is the third (Lashari et al., 2018).
Contemplative Application and Instructor Acquiring
It discusses an instructor inquiry and examination of their instructing practices. It involves
organized curiosity that goes beyond our current knowledge and actions to discover how to
improve or do things differently (Robinson & Mpalanzi, 2023). Teachers engage in a process of
inquiry to enhance their teaching practices beyond their current knowledge and actions. The
fundamental concept behind this process is reflection, which involves a teacher observing and
understanding the level of an ongoing process in the learning setting, relying on it, gaining from
it, and making things different to refresh their instruction method.
Method of Learning Language Through Meaningful Content
Learning language through meaningful content is a hugely meaningful idea to language learning
that pressurizes the integration of subject matter with language instruction. Unlike traditional EFL
lessons, which focus on communication-based material, CBI places greater emphasis on the
content itself. As an example of a communicative approach in teaching (CAT), the goal of learning
language through meaningful content is to improve learners' communicative competence through
various methods. Overall, CBI provides a more comprehensive and engaging learning experience
that can significantly benefit language learners (McCarthy & Carter, 2006).
Task-based Instruction (TBI)
Task-Based Instruction (TBI), also known as learning a Language from task or taking instruction
from task activities, was first proposed by N. S. Prabhu in his book, published by Oxford
University Press in 1987. Prabhu's idea of TBLT resulted from a five-year project on language
learning instruction. He discovered that students can learn a language just as effectively when
presented with non-linguistic problems as when presented with linguistic problems.
Some Media Use (4.0.) to Improve English Skill
Teachers use various methods and strategies to enhance English language skills while giving and
taking instructions. Specific mainstream platforms also play an essential role in improving English
language skills. Teachers use different media depending on the skill they want to improve. For
instance, social media platforms like Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram are used to improve writing
skills in English. Other media platforms are utilized for the progression of foreign language
techniques. Using the right technology and media in the instructional methods creates learners'
interest in participating in the material. However, some media used in the 4.0 era can be
complicated if not used properly. Therefore, achieving the goal of the giving and taking instruction
process starts with the instructor’s awareness of digital literacy. Teacher's impact is vital in the
students' self-improvement.
Aural-Oral, Functional Skills, or American Method of Language Teaching
The word audio lingual method's primary meaning is a technique of foreign language instruction
that emphasizes audio-lingual skills in reading and writing. This method consists entirely of
drilling in one form or another. This method was introduced by a man from America who was
1009
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
proficient in languages in the 1950s. It is based on the principle that a language primarily consists
of vocals used for social contact, and put upon the system, which comes in a secondary phase used
for saving languages which is spoken. This is burdening and highlights the importance of listening
and speaking skills upon the skills of reading and writing (Costley, 2014).
Content-Based Instruction Learning (CLIC)
The CLIC approach involves teaching English through cross-curricular content, allowing students
to learn the content and language simultaneously. Brinton, Snow, and Wesche (1989) define
Content-Based Instruction (CBI) as the study of both language learning and content-based learning
simultaneously, where content material determines the shape and matter of presenting a language
base. Although the provided is relevant to content-based instruction, its basics are generally
likened to Canada’s immersion programs, the most identified examples of content-based
instruction. It encompasses certain types of concentration as well as more programs (Stoller (2008)
gives through to content-based instruction learning to be a guardianship for principles that include
dialect and subject matter objectives. However, the differences are also visualized by learning a
language and its content.
Communicative Language Teaching
Our primary means of communicating with people about our ideas is language. It is a part of
existence. Individuals do only someone it in a certain amount of time. It's a product of nature.
McDonough and Shaw (2003) claim that frustration with the procedures of earlier teaching
approaches brings incensement to the methods and techniques of the Communicative approach to
teaching (Richards & Rodgers, 2001) add that The language teaching philosophies of the 1970s,
which mainly concentrated on grammar, gave rise to CLT. This concept is similar to that of
(Larsen-Freeman, 2000), who stated that while the earlier approaches to teaching languages had
been successful in getting pupils to "produce sentences accurately in a lesson, could not use them
appropriately when genuinely communicating outside of the classroom," some instructors have
noted this (Larsen, 2000).
Similarly, Howatt (1984) argues in a similar vein, Howatt (1984) believes "the original motivation
for adopting a communicative approach in the early seventies was remedial, an attempt to
overcome the inadequacies of existing, structural syllabuses, materials, and methods" (Rehman,
2004). The need for workers to connect with their employers and the rise in European immigration
in the 1970s led to the creation of the CLT (Savitri, 2010). It was particularly famous among British
peoples, North Americans, and Australians, who prefer learning language instruction as a short-
term subject in classrooms through partner and collaborative work, and English instructors have
knowledge and information to be aware of the need to adopt a collaborative, competency,
innovative skills to approach in education. (Holliday, 1994). Knight (2007) believes that
communicative language teaching for instructing other language speakers in English is "the current
dominant methodology." It is well-recognized as a popular and effective teaching tool that
encourages learners to communicate authentically (Cook 2005; Kumara, 1993). It has grown into
a dynamic force that affects how English language teaching (ELT) programmers plan, execute,
and assess their work practically everywhere in the world (Kumara, 1993).
Methodology
We used the review paper method as our methodology during our research on trends and issues in
English language teaching. We analyzed various articles related to our topic and summarized their
1010
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
findings. We noticed that many of these articles were in alignment with our research. Our study
was based on research papers obtained from several sources, including ResearchGate, Pertanika,
World Englishes, Open University Malaysia, Journal of Education and Educational Development,
PJAEE, Linguistics and Literature Review, Semantic Scholar, British International Science
Conference, International Scientific Online Conference, Journal of English Language and
Literature, Indian Journal of Applied Research, and International Journal on Studies in English
Language and Literature. We conducted a search using phrases such as "English language and
teaching," "English language teaching and pedagogy," "English language teaching and use of
technology," "trends and themes in the English language," "growing trends of English language
teaching," "technology on empowering English language teaching," "issues, problems and
solutions of English language teaching," "key issues in English language teaching," and "English
language as the developing language in Pakistan." More than sixty journals were found, of which
more than forty were read, and more than twenty-five met our criteria of being written in English
with full open access and relevant text.
Language in Education in Pakistan
According to the 1973 Pakistani constitution, English will continue to be the official language of
the country until plans are made for Urdu to take its place, which is expected to take 15 years.
Urdu will be the official native tongue or most spoken language of Pakistan (Coleman, 2010). The
fact is that English is credited as the tongue of personal and professional development in Pakistan
since it is the tongue of army personnel, government servants, and higher educational institutions
(Mahboob, 2002; Shamim, 2011). English frequently serves as a gatekeeping role because it is
required for admission to universities and programs that lead to positions of authority like
Pakistan's government services. Pakistani schools are separated into two categories: governmental
schools that teach Urdu and private schools that teach English (Khattak, 2014; Mustafa, 2015).
The main characteristic of Pakistan's unstable parallel education systems, which are the joint and
non-public zones, is apparently separating communication and instruction mediums (Waseem &
Asadullah, 2013).
The latter system represents the powerful, westernized, and elite segments of society, with English
as their preferred language of communication. Higher education institutes (HEIs) further
strengthen this Urdu-English medium split. While, Urdu serves as the language of teaching for a
smaller number of linguistic capitals, which are the language resources that people hold and
transfer through formal and informal networks and which impact their ability to advance in life. In
Pakistan, where the English and Urdu language gap goes beyond families and casual interactions
into more formal learning systems, linguistic capital can be considered an essential component of
learners' identities in educational institutions (Waseem & Asadullah, 2013).
Teachers should adapt to current trends, especially the use of technology such as the Internet,
mobile applications, and technology platforms. Students are well-versed in using these tools in
their daily lives. They actively seek resources supporting their learning goals, particularly
regarding technology and gadgets.
Additionally, teachers should use various strategies, methods, and practical examples to convey
the importance of the subject and language to their students. Teachers should also apply the law
of primary recency theory to enhance students' vocabulary and improve their learning abilities.
This approach encourages students to explore and learn on their own.
Instructors must be equipped to adapt to the latest trends, especially the utilization of technology
like the Internet, mobile applications, and technology platforms. Students are already proficient in
1011
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
using these tools daily. They constantly look for resources that can help them achieve their learning
goals, particularly regarding technology and gadgets. Therefore, teachers should be innovative in
their teaching approach, incorporating technology into the classroom along with traditional
textbooks.
Even so, allowing students to use mobile phones while learning English or other languages is also
important, but it must be done under the guidance of the instructor. The instructor must be able to
guide students when they want to choose the application to be used and motivate them to use their
time as efficiently as possible when using the internet.
Challenges in English Language Teaching
Previous research has identified several problems related to English literacy, both in Pakistan and
worldwide. The problem with today’s youth is that English is being taught as a main subject in
primary educational setup without focusing on the skills and expertise of teachers being able to
teach foreign languages. There is a severe shortage of certified and experienced teachers, as several
studies have found (Nawab, 2012; Bashiruddin & Qayyum, 2014). The second issue that has been
highlighted in foreign language studying is the crowded classroom sizes in Pakistan (Khan &
Khan, 2016). And other parts of the world (Shamim, 2012), which makes it difficult for instructors
to implement learner-centered instruction or complete collaborative projects (Hoque, 2009).
Control and discipline are further problems associated with large-sized classrooms, mainly when
speaking activities occur within the classroom (Littlewood et al., 2007). The second general source
of trouble for teachers is having sufficient materials for teaching according to their requirements.
According to reports, a further difficulty facing teachers in rural schools is a need for more funding
and instructional resource availability (Hungi et al., 2017). Modern trends or digital learning have
been formulated as the most effective source for teaching English (Yasin et al., 2014), even though
it has yet to be presented to teachers in Pakistani schools (Nawab, 2012). The skills and expertise
of instructors in teaching foreign tongues are a significant additional issue. Studies have frequently
shown that instructors have low confidence and speaking competence (Ahn, 2011; Shamim, 2008).
Due to their limited proficiency in English, teachers instruct learners in national or other native
tongues (Coleman, 2010).
Moreover, many instructors think that teaching in the selected tongue could make students nervous
and make them doubt their talking and hearing capabilities (Kuchah, 2009). Another significant
issue is a lack of understanding and communication between teachers and students, particularly in
rural regions. Educators frequently discover that they cannot converse with pupils in their native
language. This issue is highlighted by Pal et al. (2016) since most students struggle to learn their
native tongue because they are not skilled in it, using national language training in the classroom
can be problematic. The exact issue is identified by Akram (2017) accordingly, a student's learning
and performance are greatly influenced by their home environment and family history (Farooq et
al., 2011). Encouraging students is another problem that has been identified, especially in rural
places where kids rarely find use for the English they learn (Kam, 2002). View Bilal et al. (2013)
including innovative works in the syllabus to encourage learners to learn the foreign international
spoken languages (Kam, 2002).
The literature on guiding foreign language learners has recognized numerous urgent difficulties.
Second, in elementary schools, English is often included as a required subject for giving efficient
cognition to the one with the command to instruct it. There is reportedly a serious scarcity of
qualified international communication guides for basic schools in some countries (Hu, 2005; Hu,
2007; Kirkgöz, 2009; Nunan, 2003; Nur, 2003). Teachers sometimes experience difficulty
1012
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
teaching adult learners/students because of not having the proper training in that subject. The
condition is terrifying, particularly acute in underprivileged villages. It is suggested that learners
should emphasize improving their interaction skills more than their foreign language instruction
proficiency has grown due to English's widespread use as a lingua franca. Consequently, the
emphasis in more recent curricula for young learners has been on communicative skills. This has
frequently resulted in the introduction of Communicative Language in East Asia (Hu, 2002),
Thailand (Prapaisit & Hardison, 2008), Hong Kong (Carless, 2004; Ahn, 2011), Korea (Li, 1998;
Mitchell & Lee, 2003; Tinker, 2009).
Instructing with the help of task materials and task-wised guidance could be challenging for
educators to implement these cutting-edge techniques for various reasons. Therefore, it might not
be suitable for instructing big classes of kids in classrooms with little supplies. Teachers may also
find it challenging to apply it effectively if they only receive rudimentary tutoring in the premise
and empirical requisition that underpin it. (Butler, 2005; Littlewood, 2007). The academic heritage,
in the perception of Jin and Cortazzi (2003), they refer it as "cultures of learning," may be at odds
with these foreign methods (see, for example, Baker, 2008;) (2002; Littlewood, 2007). The topic
of resources is related to pedagogical policies. Textbooks are required in certain nations, including
Malaysia (Pandian, 2003) and South Korea (Butler, 2004). In several nations, teachers can select
books that the government has approved. These nations include Pakistan (Mahboob, 2002;
Shamim, 2011), Singapore, and China (Hu, 2005). The degree of international language
proficiency that they demand is another possible difficulty for educators. The literature frequently
notes teachers' low proficiency levels or inadequate self-efficacy in their potential (Baker, 2008;
Ghatage, 2009; Kuchah, 2009). Different educationist thinks that content-wised teaching requires
a specific academic setup and practices; this type of instruction is in the exact language, which
brings uncertainty to them about their skills, potential, and abilities, especially in hearing and
talking (Kuchah, 2009). Huge class sizes are creating problems generally in specific areas of the
globe (Wedgwood, 2007; Shamin, 2012). As a result, teachers often feel that implementing
teaching on behalf of students is difficult or impractical, as it is tough to observe learners' dialect
terms (Li, 1998) or pair and group work (Hoque, 2009). tool for thriving in the increasingly
globalized economy, highlighting the importance of further learning English.
In addition, the American and British language serves as the gatekeeper for the majority of
occupations, making it the language of every public institution within holding government ranks
and typically a demand for many executive jobs in Pakistan (Haidar, 2018; Rahman, 2005).
(Coleman, 2010). Comparably, higher education is also conducted in English, which aids in
evaluating national and international resources and promotes professional achievement and self-
improvement (Mansoor, 2004; Rahman, 2007; Rassool & Mansoor, 2009). Given the need for the
significance of the English language, it is noted that in the Pakistani environment, students with
exceptional English language proficiency can gain admission to prestigious universities more
swiftly than those with less proficiency (Zeeshan, 2013).
In Pakistan, American and British language is often taught as a second or international language,
and learners depend heavily on foreign materials to improve their fluency. However, when English
language teachers attempt to teach their students, they often need help with incorporating cultural
elements into their lessons. Brown (2007) argues that teaching the English language is an art that
cannot be separated from culture. Although English is primarily used in classrooms to teach all
subjects except for a few cultural subjects, the ultimate goal is to create an English-speaking
environment that allows learners to immerse themselves in the language and learn how to
1013
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
communicate effectively. The aim is to make the students use the English Language in real-life
matters.
Conclusion
The main aim of our study was to find out the emerging trends and current issues in teaching of
English language. We collected our data by reviewing the different kinds of articles from various
kinds of publications and journals that were related to the topic and different themes of English
language teaching trends, issues, and problems. After reading and analyzing different kinds of
articles, we found the problem of English language teaching is that the inadequate use of
integrating technology, technological teaching resources, lack of expertise in the language subject,
lack use of current methodologies, pedagogies of teaching, lacking of teaching practices, lack use
of multi-teaching approaches, improper use of strategies and techniques in the classrooms,
untrained English language teachers, highly demotivated and the diverse culture language were
the major problems of the English language teaching.
As we know, in Pakistan, the English language is the official language of Pakistan and the
international language. Hence, it is used in all professional and occupational work and jobs. It can
be used as a powerful source of making and establishing a career. Our article was based on English
language teaching trends, issues, and problems, so all trends and issues are mentioned above. Still,
the important thing is that to teach the English language, an instructor should play the role of
facilitator, motivator, supporter, helper, guide, and counselor. He should have expertise and
command of the subject. He should have practiced English language teaching and taken proper
training before and during teaching this English language subject because it is an international
language and every highly recommendable institute demands proficiency in English language
teaching.
Teachers are the backbone of every country’s educational institute. They are the biggest source of
knowledge, values, and skills transformation. They can change the beliefs, attitudes, and learning
outcomes of students, so they should teach the subject according to the subject requirements and
according to the mental, intelligence, and learning style level of the student.
References
Abbasi, A. M., & Lashari, A. A. (2017). Speech variations in Pakistani English and Singaporean
English. Journal of Social Sciences and Media Studies, 1(1), 36-49.
Ahmadi, M.R. (2018). The Use of Technology in English Language Learning: A Literature
Review. International Journal of Research in English Education.
Ahmed, I., Lashari, A. A., & Golo, M. A. (2023). Evaluating primary-level English textbooks of single
national curriculum through the lens of Bloom's Taxonomy. Pakistan Languages and Humanities
Review, 7(3), 352-361.
Akram, M. (2017). Learning and teaching English in Pakistan: Predicaments and
solutions. International Journal of Educational Sciences, 19(1), 10-14.
Al-Shamiry, R. (2000). Yemeni learners oral communicative competence in English: A study at the
tertiary level. Unpublished doctoral dissertation. Hyderabad, India.
Al-Sohbani, Y. A. (2013). An exploration of English language teaching pedagogy in secondary Yemeni
education: A case study. International journal of English language & translation studies, 1(3), 41-57.
Akmedovna, V. G. (2024). Content organization of the lesson using English language teaching
methodology and interactive games. In Interdisciplinary innovation and scientific research conference,
2(16), 18-20.
1014
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
Alkamel, M. A. A., & Chouthaiwale, S. S. (2018). The use of ICT tools in English language teaching
and learning: A literature review. Journal of English language and literature (JOELL), 5(2), 29-33.
Abilasha, R., & Ilankumaran, M. (2014). Trends in English language teaching: A novel
perspective. International journal on studies in English language and literature (IJSELL), 2(11), 46-
52.
Amur, A., Bukhari, S. U. P., & Lashari, A. A. (2023). Learning factors causing silence in English
language (L2) classrooms at the graduate level. Global Language Review, VIII, 226-235.
Berestova, A., Gayfullina, N., & Tikhomirov, S. (2020). Leadership and Functional Competence
Development in Teachers: World Experience. International Journal of Instruction, 13(1), 607-622.
Blommaert, J. (2010). The sociolinguistics of globalization. Cambridge University Press.
Bruthiaux, P. (2002). Hold your courses: Language education, language choice, and economic
development. TESOL quarterly, 36(3), 275-296.
Bukhari, S. U. P., Lashari, A. A., Rafaqat, A., Amur, A., & Buriro, S. A. (2023). Comparative Analysis
Of The Use Of Code-Switching And Immersive Approaches For Esl Learners. Journal of Namibian
Studies: History Politics Culture, 34, 2304-2320.
Bukhari, S. U. P., Kalhoro, I. A., Lashari, A. A., Soomro, I. A., Batool, S., & Amur, A. (2023). The
communication barriers and their impacts on the academic performance of graduate students. Journal
of Positive School Psychology, 7(5), 605-612.
Buriro, S. A., Mirjat, M. A., Pathan, R. L., Chandio, I., Lashari, A. A., & Gul, H. (2023). Eco-Friendly
Pedagogies For STEM Education: A Review. Journal of Namibian Studies: History Politics
Culture, 34, 3018-3044.
Bushra, A., Lashari, A. A., Khan, A., & Pervaiz, A. (2024). Content analysis of social development
curriculum for sustainable development in Pakistan. International Journal of Contemporary Issues in
Social Sciences, 3(1), 1132-1142.
Clarke, V., & Braun, V. (2017). Thematic analysis. The journal of positive psychology, 12(3), 297-298.
Costley, K. C. (2014). The positive effects of technology on teaching and student learning. Online
submission.
Eady, M., & Lockyer, L. (2013). Tools for learning: Technology and teaching. Learning to teach in the
primary school, 71.
Fang, F. G. (2018). Review of English as a medium of instruction in Chinese universities today: Current
trends and future directions: New language policies to promote multilingualism and language support
for EMI will be needed in Chinese tertiary contexts. English Today, 34(1), 32-37.
Grabe, W., & Stoller, F. L. (2009). 16. Teaching the written foreign language. Handbook of foreign
language communication and learning, 6, 439.
Hafiz, N. A., Islam, M., & Pasha, A. R. (2023). Exploring Language Learning through Culture:
Indigenisation of English in a Pakistani Context. Linguistics and Literature Review, 9(2), 98-127.
Haidar, S., & Fang, F. (2019). English language in education and globalization: A comparative analysis
of the role of English in Pakistan and China. Asia Pacific Journal of Education, 39(2), 165-176.
Harrop, E. (2012). Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL): Limitations and
Possibilities. Online Submission.
Herrera, V K. A., & Lucas, P. Á. M. (2020). A case study of English teachers classroom leadership
skills.
Imran, Q., Kazimi, A. B., & Lashari, A. A. (2022). Examining the impact of extrinsic and intrinsic
barriers to adopting information communication technology in classroom teaching in intermediate (K
12) colleges of Karachi, Pakistan. Journal of Positive School Psychology, 2458-2478.,
Jamil, B. R. (2020). ASER 2019-milestone gains–but no room for complacency.
Kachru, B. B. (1998). English as an Asian language. Links & letters, 89-108.
Khoiroini, M. Y., Pataningtias, E., Aryatama, D. K., Bachtiar, M. H., Nafia, Z. I., & Oktirisyani, F.
(2020). ELT Trends in Asia: Current Trends and Issues of English Language Teaching Practice.
1015
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
Lashari, A. A., Abbasi, F. N., Kurd, S. A., Mirjat, M. A., Mehmood, T., & Ahmad, S. (2023a). The
impact of mobile assisted language learning (MALL) on ESL students learning. Onomázein, (60
(2023): June), 137-148.
Lashari, A. A., Mahar, S. S., Solangi, M. A., Buriro, S. A., & Chang, S. H. (2023). Music education in
language and cognitive development: A critical review. PalArch's Journal of Archaeology of
Egypt/Egyptology, 20(2), 2101-2111.
Lashari, A. A., Mashori, G. M., Abbasi, A. M., & Talpur, Q. (2018). Motivation to learn english
language: a study of Shah Abdul Latif University, Khairpur, Sindh. International Journal of English
Linguistics, 8(1), 15-21.
Lashari, A. A., Munawar, I., Mastoi, M., Niaz, P., Buriro, S. A., & Golo, M. A. (2023). Unlocking the
potentials of ChatGPT: The efficacy of ChatGPT in ESL learning outcomes. PalArch's Journal of
Archaeology of Egypt/Egyptology, 20(1), 1135-1143.
Lashari, A. A., Umrani, S., & Buriro, G. A. (2021). LearnersSelf-regulation and Autonomy in Learning
English Language. Pakistan Languages and Humanities Review, 5(2), 115-130.
Lashari, A. A., & Umrani, S. (2023). Reimagining self-directed learning language in the age of artificial
intelligence: A systematic review. Grassroots (17260396), 57(1).
Madiha. Lashari, A. A., & e Ammara, U. (2023). Unlocking the future: investigating the impact of
smartphone use on academic performance and learning the language. International Journal of
Contemporary Issues in Social Sciences, 2(3), 44-55.
Magsi, S. A., Khaskheli, P. N., Soomro, A. R., & Lashari, A. A. (2023). Error analysis in academic
writing of post graduate engineering students of Sindh. Journal of Positive School Psychology, 1185-
1191.
Mahboob, A. (2009). English as an Islamic language: A case study of Pakistani English. World
Englishes, 28(2), 175-189.
Maley, A. (1992). Global issues in ELT. Practical English Teaching, 13(2), 73.
Maryam, F., Niazi, S., & Lashari, A. A. (2024). Tense and Aspect in Balti Language: Morphological
Perspective. Journal of Asian Development Studies, 13(1), 795-803.
Mart, C. T. (2013). The audio-lingual method: An easy way of achieving speech. International Journal
of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 3(12), 63.
Nieto, D. G. (2021). Making it official: The institutionalization of the hegemony of English. Education
policy analysis archives, 29(January-July), 96-96.
Qizi, K. D. S. (2021, February). The use of technology in english language learning. In Euro-Asia
Conferences (pp. 124-127).
Rahman, F. A. (2002). Strategies employed by good and weak English learners and factors affecting
the choice of strategies. Unpublished Master’s Thesis. Faculty of Education, Universiti Kebangsaan
Malaysia.
Rahman, S. (2005). Orientations and motivation in English language learning: A study of Bangladeshi
students at undergraduate level. Asian EFL Journal, 7(1), 29-55.
Robinson, N., & Mpalanzi, J. S. (2023). English language teaching methods and their influence on
pupilsacademic performance of the subject: A case of Ukumbi primary school, Kilolo District. Journal
of Education and Development (JED), 2, 2, 180-92.
Schackne, S. (1994). Extensive Reading and Language Acquisition: Is There a Correlation? A Two-Part
Study.
Siddiqui, A., Lashari, A. A., & Soomro, A. R. (2023). An investigation to design course of English for
legal purposes (ELP) from viewpoint of CBI in Sindh law college, Hyderabad. Global Language
Review, VIII, 167-177.
Siming, I. A., Asad, M. M., & Lashari, A. A. (2015). A Pilot study on a Cross Sectional Investigation
of Science and Engineering Undergraduates: Motivation towards Learning English in Pakistan. Journal
of Education and Vocational Research, 6(1), 61-67.
1016
Journal of Asian Development Studies Vol. 13, Issue 1 (March 2024)
Shamim, F. (2011). English as the language for development in Pakistan: Issues, challenges and
possible solutions. Dreams and realities: Developing countries and the English language, 14(1), 291-
310.
Shamim, F., & Rashid, U. (2019). The English/Urdu-Medium Divide in Pakistan: Consequences for
Learner Identity and Future Life Chances. Journal of Education and Educational Development, 6(1),
43-61.
Susilo, A. (2014, June). Exploring Facebook and WhatsApp as supporting social network applications
for English learning in higher education. Conference On Professional Development In Education
(PDE2014), Widyatama University Indonesia, Open University Indonesia and Open University
Malaysia.
Tazik, K., & Khany, R. (2019). A typology of research trends and themes in English for academic
purposes: From 1986 to 2015. Pertanika Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, 27(3), 1391-1411.
... So far, there have been several studies which applied bibliometrics methods to explore intellectual maps for related topics such as teacher education and sustainability (Gavinolla et al., 2023), trends and issues in English language teaching (Aziz et al., 2024;Emock Bakelak & Reyes Rodríguez, 2022;Seraj et al., 2024). However, to the best of our knowledge, there has not been a bibliometric study about the curriculum for English language teacher education. ...
Article
Full-text available
The widespread influence of English as an international language in the age of globalization has brought about substantial transformations in English language teacher education (ELTE) curricula and spurred increased research on this subject. However, a comprehensive analysis of the research status of ELTE curricula is still absent. To address this gap, the current study employs bibliometric analysis, a method for exploring and analyzing large volumes of scientific data, to construct an intellectual structure of research on the topic. Using data retrieved from the Scopus Database, comprising 267 publications, the study involves bibliometric analyses such as citation, co-authorship, and keyword co-occurrence. The results indicate a noteworthy increase in research volume over the last five years, with a predominant presence of publications from the Global North in terms of geographical distribution. Additionally, the most cited works primarily focus on innovative pedagogical methods in ELTE. Notably, the study identifies 10 clusters of topics representing newly emerged themes in ELTE curricula research. The findings underscore the significance of investigating ELTE curricula, positioning it as a promising research area. Therefore, this study is recommended as a foundational resource for future researchers exploring related subjects.
... Some of the digital tools that are developed are learning applications that act as supporting materials for learners to understand the lessons better (Klimova & Zamborova, 2022). In learning language, it is important for learners to practise the language skills and having supporting materials would really benefit them (Aziz et al., 2024). The language learning applications usually provide a vibrant and interactive alternative that can better meet the diverse needs of learners, some can even provide personalised learning for the learners. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study investigates students' readiness and perceptions towards using Unity, a development platform, for creating a Multimedia Interactive Package (MIP). With the growing demand for interactive digital content in education, it is crucial to understand students’ readiness and perceptions in engaging with a platform like Unity in developing a language learning application in the form of MIP. The study examines language students' technology readiness as well as their perceptions towards integrating technology into educational content creation. A quantitative approach was employed using a survey to gather data using a set of questionnaires. The sample involved university language students who enrolled in multimedia development courses. Results indicate that while students generally show enthusiasm for using Unity, students faced challenges that may affect their learning experiences. However, the perceived benefits, including enhanced creativity, interactivity, and practical skill development, contribute to a positive overall attitude. The findings suggest that with adequate support and training, Unity can be a valuable tool for developing educational MIPs, promoting both student engagement and technical proficiency.
Article
Full-text available
Pakistan is a multilingual and multicultural country where 72 language diverse languages are used for communication. Gilgit-Baltistan is one of the most well-known northern regions for its stunning natural beauty, distinct landscapes, evergreen forests, snow-capped mountains, and rich cultural heritage. Most of the Gilgit-Baltistan regional languages have been studied historically and culturally, but a few studies address this from a linguistic perspective. Balti language is one of them. Balti is a member of the more extraordinary Tibeto-Burman language family, specifically the Western Tibetan branch of the Tibetan language family. The present study analyses the tense and aspect markers in the Balti language. This study contributes to the regional language of Pakistan and analyzes the language in the morphological domain that is not mostly touched yet; also, studying tense and aspect markers in the Balti language from a morphological perspective is crucial for understanding the language's nuances within temporal expressions. The present study results show that Balti has a complex system of tense and aspect markers; using the qualitative research design, n= 50 root words (verbs) were collected from the Balti language within the framework of inflectional morphemes of tense markers for this study. Nine markers for tense and some of their aspect, including eḑ, en, s, yoḑ, and yoḑpə: set̪ , ʊk, t̪ ʊk, and sed̪ ʊkt̪ ʊk, are identified in the current study. These markers are attached to the corresponding root verbs to indicate the present simple, present progressive, past simple with progressive, future simple, and future participle. The study also develops a deep understanding of various future tense markers as connectors to root words based on the consonant and vowel sounds at the end of root words.
Article
Full-text available
This study aims to conduct a comprehensive content analysis of the BS Sociology HEC Pakistan curriculum, focusing on its alignment with the principles of Sustainable Development. The goal of the study is to determine how well the existing curriculum of the BS Sociology four-year program trains students for active engagement in sustainable development projects and how well it addresses important social development topics. A total of 22 courses of the BS Sociology curriculum were analysed. Using content analysis techniques, the study examined how inclusive, relevant, and successful the curriculum is in encouraging pupils to take on social responsibility. This research provides a view of curriculum reforms and enhances Education for Sustainable Development in Pakistan. The checklist method was used to examine the social development curriculum, highlighting the areas that still need improvement. This study aims to elaborate on the extent to which the BS sociology curriculum has adopted these characteristics of sustainable development for the bachelor of sociology degree. The analysis suggests that more fields related to sustainable development can be included to enrich the concept of sustainability.
Article
Full-text available
This article underscores the English language Teaching methods and their influence on the academic performance of the subject among public primary school pupils in Kilolo District in Tanzania. Using the descriptive research design, the study was conducted at Ukumbi Primary School, Kilolo, Iringa region to standards four and seven. The secondary data were collected using the documentary reviews from the Standard Four and Standard Seven national examinations results of English language subjects requested from the head teacher, whereas the primary data were collected using questionnaires, interviews, and introspection techniques which were purposefully administered to the Standard Four and Standard Seven classes to check onto the methods of teaching English language to public primary schools and their influences on the pupils' subject academic performance which seems to promote or deteriorate the learners' interests in English as the medium of instruction. The target sample sizes in Standard Four and Standard Seven were randomly selected for an unbiased information search. The data collected were summarized, organized, recorded-and presented using a variety of tools such as tables, charts, distribution and graphs with the help of Excel and MS Word features which helped the interpretation of the findings to get the relevant information of this article. The findings show that most of the pupils have problems with oral communication, and pronunciation including sound, stress, and intonation as the English Language teaching methods used hardly care about their learning. The article recommends that primary school teachers should be given special training on the English language teaching methods that favour the development of communicative abilities in primary school pupils.
Article
Full-text available
The study aims to explore the cultural facets of learning and using English language in a Pakistani context. Drawing on information collected from participants, the study also indicates the present status of the indigenisation of English in Pakistan. This mixed-method research used a convenience sampling strategy to collect data from 476 students through a questionnaire and from 15 teachers through semi-structured interviews. The findings of the study revealed that there is little explicit focus on culture during the teaching and learning of the English language. The collected data also show that students learn the target culture more than the local culture, mainly due to the use of foreign teaching materials. Moreover, both students and teachers seem ambivalent about the Indigenisation of English in Pakistan, although a shift in the status of English can be observed in its teaching and learning processes. The study further suggested to develop materials based on the local context in order to incorporate local culture and make English more indigenous.
Article
Full-text available
n recent times, there has been a remarkable surge in the development of digital technology and communication technologies used in language learning classes. The phenomenon has led to a notable shift in the educational milieu, specifically concerning the broadening of learning prospects beyond the conventional confines of the classroom. In recent years, the field of English as a Second Language Learning (ESL) has witnessed the emergence of mobile-assisted language learning (MALL) as an important area of research. The reason for this is its capacity to improve language acquisition by offering a realistic, socially dynamic, contextually responsive, and individualized mobile-mediated language learning setting. The study is an attempt to analyse the impact of mobile-assisted learning impact on learning the English language in public sector universities of Sindh. The study implied a quantitative method of data collection and analysis. The data has been collected with the help of a Google survey form from N=265 respondents of Sindh Madressatul Islam University who are enrolled in multiple departments in undergraduate programs. The data has been analysed by using SPSS. The reliability and goodness of fit tests have been used to ensure the reliability of the data set. The findings of the study show that mobile has a positive impact on language learning. Text messages and social media use help in communication skills. The learners use mobile for their classroom activities and subject understanding. The results of the study also presented empirical data supporting the enduring effects of mobile-assisted language learning. This study emphasizes the importance of mobile technology in facilitating the development of language competencies among L2 learners. Additionally, it explores the pedagogical implications that arise from these findings.
Article
Full-text available
The field of motivation, particularly in language learning, has experienced a significant surge in the popularity of self-directed language learning, primarily owing to the emergence of AI-assisted methodologies. This study aims to explore the potential benefits and implications of utilizing Chat GPT, a sophisticated artificial intelligence language model, to enhance and facilitate self-directed second language (L2) learning. The underpinning of this research depends upon examining an extensive synthesis of digital academic publications. The primary objective of this work is to provide a comprehensive examination and synthesis of the existing corpus of scholarly research on artificial intelligence (AI) in the context of learning a second language (L2 Self), as demonstrated in respected online academic publications. The primary objective of these scholarly articles was to examine the influence of ChatGPT on the development of second language (L2) proficiency, namely in the domains of L2 acquisition, L2 written expression, L2 oral communication, and L2 reading comprehension. A search methodology was utilized to retrieve relevant scholarly literature from Elsevier and Scopus Indexed Journals, as well as the Google Scholar databases, during one year. The procedure mentioned above led to the finding of N=25 articles from journals indexed by Elsevier and Springer links, Tandof Online and n=15 articles from Google Scholar. The relevant concepts include ChatGPT, learning a second language (L2 learning), artificial intelligence, and learning a language. The papers utilized in the analysis were obtained from reputable and well-regarded scholarly journals. The findings indicate a need for further academic research on the applications and outcomes of ChatGPT in second-language self-learning. This highlights the need for further research to assess the effectiveness of AI and develop guidelines for incorporating it into language education settings.
Article
Full-text available
This research investigates a comparison between code-switching and immersive approaches in enhancing the spoken language skills of ESL undergraduate learners. The study focuses on undergraduate Business English courses. They employed a qualitative phenomenological research methodology. The study comprises 10 undergraduate students, chosen purposively to represent varying language backgrounds and proficiency levels. Data collection involved classroom observations and reflective diaries. The observations contrasted students' experiences in an immersive versus code-switching environment, evaluating aspects like fluency, syntax, vocabulary, confidence, and participation. Thematic analysis was carried out for the study. The results revealed that the immersive approach led to greater fluency, improved grammatical understanding, substantial vocabulary growth, and increased self-confidence among students. In contrast, code-switching exhibited limitations in inhibiting fluency and independent speaking abilities. It is recommended to limit code-switching, implement an immersive approach in promoting active participation, foster supportive conditions, and integrate technology for effective language education.
Article
Full-text available
ChatGPT, a considerable language model chatbot released in late November 2022, has drawn much interest. However, there are still unanswered questions about its capabilities. With ChatGPT, an AI-driven conversational agent integrated into English Language Learning (ELL) programs, this empirical study report seeks to examine the practical outcomes. It is crucial to evaluate the practical efficiency of AI technologies in enhancing ELL outcomes as they develop. This study has been conducted to evaluate ChatGPT's effects on ELL students' English language competence, learner engagement, and learning outcomes. This study employed a quantitative research method to examine how ChatGPT affected students' learning outcomes in ESL classes at Sindh Madressatul Islam University in Karachi. N=205 students from undergraduate programs were taken in survey research. The quantitative survey correlational design has been used for the data collection and analysis. It has been found that there is a significant impact of ChatGPT in ESL classes. ChatGPT helps to learn more about ESL course content, assignments, activity-based tasks and better results.
Article
Full-text available
This study aims to analyse the application of Bloom's Taxonomy framework in categorising cognitive skills, as utilised in Single National Curriculum (SNC) English primary level textbooks. The current study employs qualitative method and content analysis as the selected approach for data analysis to obtain the robust results. The provided sample consists of primary-level textbooks that have been adopted in Federal Schools in accordance with the newly implemented Single National Curriculum Policy of 2021. The present study examines the sample of textbooks as per the Bloom’s Taxonmy of classification by using checklist. The results of the study indicate that textbooks examined consist of questions that primarily target lower order thinking abilities (LOTS), with around 89.8% of the items falling within this classification, while 10.2% represents to Higher Order Thinking skills (HOTS). The scope of the research study has been constrained to the cognitive domain as a result of time and resource constraints. It is recommended that SNC new English primary level curriculum should be student centered to focus on communicative competence, creativity and use of the language in day today bussiness and the curriculum should be revised as per the needs of subject and learners. The representative from all provinces should be the part of the curriculum design in order to design the English textbooks as per the needs of the multilingual and multicultural second language learners.
Article
Full-text available
Music education has been considered an essential broader discipline for centuries for educating the world on broader lessons and teaching with the help of rhythm and sounds. Music has been considered an important genre that represents emotions, feelings, and thoughts in a rhythm that can be considered well for the holistic development of children but has been ignored in the teaching and learning process. Music education has been an ignored subject to apply in education for healthy learning. The study has been designed to critically review the related literature to understand the role of music education holistic development of individuals, particularly language development. A comprehensive educational program that promotes students' holistic learning and development must include music instruction as a critical element for the cognitive learning of individuals. The paper uses secondary data for the analysis. In this regard, literature has been reviewed to understand the subject matter better. This paper gives detailed account advantages of music instruction, from social and cultural enrichment to the cognitive, linguistic, and emotional development of individuals. This study emphasizes the value of including music education in the larger educational framework by examining numerous research studies and practical examples. The literature review suggests a dire need to implement music education for the holistic development of individuals in today's world.