ChapterPDF Available

International Accreditation of HEIs Located in Conflict-Affected Areas: Challenges and Opportunities

April 2024

In book: Evaluating Global Accreditation Standards for Higher Education (pp.164-185)
Publisher: IGI Global

Authors:

HE Higher Education Ranking

Higher education institutions (HEIs) located in conflict-affected regions face unique challenges in pursuing international accreditation, which plays a crucial role in ensuring academic quality and global recognition. This chapter explores the multifaceted challenges faced by HEIs in conflict-affected areas on their journey toward international accreditation, while also shedding light on the opportunities that can emerge from this endeavor. Drawing from case studies and empirical research, this study identifies key obstacles such as security concerns, resource limitations, infrastructure deficiencies, and academic isolation. By analyzing these challenges and opportunities, this chapter contributes to the discourse on higher education in conflict zones and offers insights for policymakers, educators, and accreditation bodies seeking to support the development of HEIs in such contexts.

Content uploaded by Mustafa Kayyali

Content may be subject to copyright.

164

Chapter 11

DOI: 10.4018/979-8-3693-1698-6.ch011

ABSTRACT

Higher education institutions (HEIs) located in conﬂict-aﬀected regions face unique challenges in pur-

suing international accreditation, which plays a crucial role in ensuring academic quality and global

recognition. This chapter explores the multifaceted challenges faced by HEIs in conﬂict-aﬀected areas

on their journey toward international accreditation, while also shedding light on the opportunities that

can emerge from this endeavor. Drawing from case studies and empirical research, this study identiﬁes

key obstacles such as security concerns, resource limitations, infrastructure deﬁciencies, and academic

isolation. By analyzing these challenges and opportunities, this chapter contributes to the discourse on

higher education in conﬂict zones and oﬀers insights for policymakers, educators, and accreditation

bodies seeking to support the development of HEIs in such contexts.

INTRODUCTION

In a world undergoing rapid transformation, the significance of quality higher education has surged to

the forefront of national priorities. It has emerged as an indispensable vehicle for empowering individu-

als, fostering innovation, and ensuring global competitiveness. This pursuit of academic excellence

knows no boundaries, extending its reach even to the most challenging and conflict-ridden corners of

our globe. Within this intricate and demanding backdrop, we embark on a profound exploration of the

global accreditation standards that underpin the very fabric of higher education.

International Accreditation

of HEIs Located in Conict-

Affected Areas:

Challenges and Opportunities

Mustafa Kayyali

https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3300-262X

HE Higher Education Ranking, Syria

165

International Accreditation of HEIs Located in Conict-Aected Areas

Our book chapter, bearing the evocative title, “International Accreditation of Higher Education

Institutions (HEIs) in Conflict-Affected Areas: Unveiling Challenges and Embracing Opportunities,”

ventures into the heart of a compelling narrative. It seeks to unravel the intricate interplay between HEIs

located in regions marred by conflict and the aspirational journey toward international accreditation. In

a world characterized by the constant changeability of educational paradigms, accreditation emerges as

a pillar of quality assurance, offering a robust framework that empowers institutions to aspire to and at-

tain excellence. As we embark on this intellectual odyssey through the maze corridors of accreditation,

we shall navigate the multifaceted terrain of international accreditation entities. These entities stand as

the forefront of global education standards, wielding tremendous influence in shaping the contours of

quality education on a planetary scale. Our chapter, however, does not merely touch the surface; rather,

it delves deep, peruse these categories with a discerning eye. Moreover, we illuminate the profound

significance of these entities in facilitating educational programs that endeavor to meet the exacting

benchmarks of quality.

In this chapter, we will explore, in meticulous detail, the challenges and opportunities that define

the journey of HEIs located in conflict-affected regions toward international accreditation. The odyssey

of these institutions is a testament to the indomitable human spirit and the unwavering commitment to

knowledge dissemination, even amidst the most daunting adversities. We invite you to join us on this

intellectual expedition, as we chart the course through turbulent waters toward the shores of educational

excellence. The chapters ahead will not only dissect the multifaceted challenges but also celebrate the

remarkable opportunities that arise when resilience meets innovation. Together, we shall unravel the

tapestry of accreditation and discover how it can serve as a beacon of progress, not only in stable regions

but also in the most testing environments.

Accreditation is a process through which educational institutions are evaluated and recognized for

meeting specific quality standards. It serves as a mark of assurance that an institution provides educa-

tion that meets acceptable levels of quality. While accreditation processes can vary from one region to

another, international accreditation is particularly valuable because it signifies recognition on a global

scale. For HEIs in conflict-affected areas, international accreditation offers several compelling advan-

tages. Firstly, it provides a mechanism to enhance the quality of education provided, aligning it with

global standards. This, in turn, improves the prospects of students and graduates, as their qualifications

are more likely to be recognized and respected worldwide. International accreditation opens doors to

collaboration and partnerships with institutions from around the world. These collaborations can lead

to the exchange of knowledge, resources, and expertise, which can be invaluable for HEIs operating in

resource-constrained environments. International accreditation can enhance the resilience of HEIs in

conflict-affected areas. By meeting rigorous standards and demonstrating their commitment to quality,

these institutions are better prepared to weather the challenges posed by conflict and instability. The

journey of Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) located in conflict-affected areas toward international

accreditation is a complex and demanding one, marked by formidable challenges and inspiring oppor-

tunities. These institutions, despite.

OBJECTIVES

The primary objective of this chapter is to thoroughly examine the difficulties and advantages that Higher

Education Institutions (HEIs) encounter when seeking international accreditation in countries affected

20 more pages are available in the full version of this document, which may

be purchased using the "Add to Cart" button on the product's webpage:

www.igi-global.com/chapter/international-accreditation-of-heis-located-in-

conflict-affected-areas/344933?camid=4v1

Related Content

Teaching-to-Learn: Its Effects on Conceptual Knowledge Learning in University Students

Melissa McConnell Rogers (2021). International Journal of Innovative Teaching and Learning in Higher

Education (pp. 1-14).

www.igi-global.com/article/teaching-to-learn/289863?camid=4v1a

The Resurrection of the First Accounting Course: The Case for Blended Teaching in Financial

Accounting

Gregory J. Krivacek (2023). International Journal of Innovative Teaching and Learning in Higher Education

(pp. 1-17).

www.igi-global.com/article/the-resurrection-of-the-first-accounting-course/333627?camid=4v1a

Examining the Benefits of Teaching Active Study Strategies as a Part of Classroom Instruction

Melissa McConnell Rogers (2020). International Journal of Innovative Teaching and Learning in Higher

Education (pp. 41-55).

www.igi-global.com/article/examining-the-benefits-of-teaching-active-study-strategies-as-a-part-

of-classroom-instruction/260948?camid=4v1a

Closing the Gap Between Students' Career Readiness and Employers' Expectations: An

Innovative Competency-Based Approach

Jennifer L. Doherty-Restrepo, Katherine Perez, Michael Creeden, Bridgette Cram and McLudmer Charite

(2023). International Journal of Innovative Teaching and Learning in Higher Education (pp. 1-14).

www.igi-global.com/article/closing-the-gap-between-students-career-readiness-and-employers-

expectations/327348?camid=4v1a

Reviews from Selected Authors in Higher Education

Article

Feb 2025

Juana Thyra

This paper provides a comprehensive review of the scholarly contributions of Dr. Mustafa Kayyali, a distinguished researcher in quality assurance and higher education. With a strong academic foundation in Quality Management and Evaluation, Dr. Kayyali has significantly impacted the fields of accreditation, quality assurance, and higher education rankings. His extensive body of work, comprising over 20 published papers and 45 book chapters, offers valuable insights into best practices, innovative strategies, and the evolving landscape of higher education quality assurance. This study critically analyzes his key publications, highlighting their theoretical frameworks, methodologies, and implications for academic institutions and policymakers. By synthesizing his contributions, this paper aims to provide a deeper understanding of quality assurance in higher education and its role in institutional excellence and global competitiveness.

Exploring the Evolving Ecosystem of Higher Education Worldwide

Article

Oct 2024

The landscape of higher education (HE) has undergone significant transformations in recent decades, shaped by global trends, economic pressures, technological advancements, and shifting societal expectations. This article explores the evolving ecosystem of higher education worldwide, examining the dynamics between public and private institutions, the impact of digital technologies, and the growing demands for innovation, accessibility, and equity in educational offerings. It explores the role of governments, market forces, and institutions in navigating these changes and investigates the implications of these transformations for students, educators, and society at large. Through an in-depth analysis of global trends, the article presents a comprehensive overview of the current state of higher education and identifies emerging challenges and opportunities that are shaping its future. Keywords: Ecosystem, Higher Education (HE), Private Higher Education, Public Higher Education, Technology, Equity and Access, Lifelong Learning

Reviews on 50 Papers on Higher Education after 2022

Article

Jun 2024

Juana Thyra

This paper presents a comprehensive review of fifty scholarly articles on higher education published after 2022, highlighting key trends, innovations, and challenges within the field. The review is categorized into several themes: pedagogical advancements, digital transformation, equity and access, policy and governance, and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on educational practices. Through a critical analysis of these themes, the paper identifies emerging patterns and significant findings that contribute to the evolving landscape of higher education. The study aims to provide educators, policymakers, and researchers with a synthesized understanding of current developments and future directions in higher education, emphasizing the importance of adapting to a rapidly changing academic environment.

Quality assurance, internationalization, and ranking of higher education institutions in the context of the Syrian War

Thesis

Full-text available

Jul 2022

Mustafa Kayyali

It is very difficult to maintain stable and advanced conditions for the functioning of higher education institutions in exceptional cases that universities might stand against, or in the unstable situations that any higher education institution might face such as low funding, failure in management, poor planning, low student enrollment or any other reasons.In the event of such cases, HEIs can request support or funding from the government, independent funders, or international bodies. In the event that obtaining support is not possible, or if the steps to change management or develop the strategy, or the use of experts or attract new students are of no use, HEI can request to merge with another university so that the new merged university (consisting of the two universities) will be more able to deal with these urgent difficulties, and more able to develop plans that contribute to improving and developing its operation in a way that contributes to avoiding potential difficulties. When the exceptional case of the university’s operation is caused by compelling external conditions, such as epidemics, and the COVID-19 epidemic was an example of these compelling conditions in the past three years, it would be difficult for the university to implement a rescue plan independently. Hence, there should be cooperation with the government and the rest of the partners, stakeholders, financiers, and the board of trustees in a way that contributes in a way that contributes to the university’s continuity of operation, and this is what we have clearly seen by providing government support to many universities around the world, which contributes to overcoming the epidemic crisis. The most difficult condition ever, and which it is very compelling for HEIs to deal with, is to ensure the quality assurance of universities and higher education institutions in the afflicted areas and areas witnessing conflicts and wars. These wars lead to the fragmentation of any country, the collapse of its economic and social structure, the loss of qualified teaching staff, and the loss of a large number of students. This study seeks to provide a model for the latter case, which is the state of a country that is witnessing conflicts and wars that affect its higher education system (Syria as a case study). Certainly, wars have devastating effects on all sectors of any affected country, but the main focus of this research is to determine the damage that the war will cause to the higher education sector, how higher education institutions can implement an appropriate quality system, and what strategies, plans, curricula, and operating systems can be applied by universities in the event of the occurrence of war in a manner that ensures that the minimum required quality assurance standards are met. In the case under study for this research, I have chosen my country, Syria: a country that has been witnessing for about 11 years a war that does not seem to have an end, and there does not seem to be an end to the country’s tragedy or the process of building or reconstruction of what has been destroyed. Nor does it seem that there is any clear future for the country, its institutions, its universities, or its higher education system.

Higher Education Peacebuilding in Conflict-Affected Societies: Beyond the Good/Bad Binary

Article

Full-text available

Sep 2022

Purpose – This comparative case study looks towards the diverse approaches of higher education to support peacebuilding, from policy and philosophy to pedagogical practices, in conflict-affected and post-conflict settings. The achievement of global development goals is dependent on addressing access to quality education in conflict- affected contexts, including higher education. However, in settings affected by conflict, higher education is often perceived to be a luxury, not a necessity. This study explores whether and how higher education might support peace and development through the unique perspective of the “three faces” of higher education in conflict contexts. Design/methodology/approach – The paper is designed as a qualitative comparative case study. The research examines the work of university educators in two institutions in Afghanistan and Somaliland, highlighting the challenges and opportunities they face working in conflict-affected societies and their pedagogical responses to conflict. Data for the research was collected through in-depth interviews, documents, and digital artifacts with 12 university educators across the two institutions. The faculty teach a wide variety of subjects in the social sciences and humanities, subjects including and in addition to those specific to peace and development studies. To strengthen the interpretation of data, multiple coders were involved and intercoder reliability was conducted. Findings – Findings indicate a number of challenges and opportunities that university lecturers and their institutions face in teaching for peace in conflict-affected contexts, particularly as it relates to the “three faces” of higher education to support, impede, or reveal the complicated nuances of peacebuilding in conflict settings. Member-checking was employed with participants to enhance the reliability of the analysis. Originality/value – In the end, the paper contributes new empirical insights into higher education in conflict-affected contexts, particularly from the standpoint of faculty. Critical perspectives and implications for curriculum, pedagogy and research are offered.

Exploring the value of a risk-management quality-assurance model to support delivery of quality higher education in the conflict-affected northwest of Syria

Article

Full-text available

Jan 2022

Universities worldwide are adopting quality-assurance programmes to improve the quality of their services, however, the value of Western quality-management models developed for stable contexts, in conflict-affected contexts is questionable. This study sought to review the quality management strategies, policies and practices of two higher education institutions (HEIs) in the non-regime conflict-affected northwest of Syria (NWS), selected as representative of the emerging HE sector in the area since 2015, and to explore the potential benefits of a risk-management approach to quality assurance, a model that places context at its heart to help mitigate identified risks that might undermine delivery of quality HE. A mixed-method approach, was adopted, combining an analysis of the two HEIs administrative documents, with fourteen semi-structured interviews with senior administrative and teaching staff, and a survey of 120 of their 2019/20 graduates. Findings indicated that a risk-management approach would allow HEIs in NWS to develop strategies, policies and practices that would better respond to their conflict-affected realities, and the need for a more transparent and democratic management approach to decision-making and management/staff/student relations and communication. A set of risk-management quality assurance recommendations are offered for consideration by all Syrian HEIs in NWS, to allow the development of management policies, strategies and practices that mitigate risks to delivery of quality HE services. Equally important is to acknowledge the resilience and adaptability of the two study universities, and their commitment to sustaining access to HE for local and displaced communities, despite ongoing insecurity and deteriorating economic and social conditions .

Higher education strategy in digital transformation

Article

Full-text available

Sep 2021
Educ Inform Tech

Digital transformation in the global higher education industry determines the future roadmap to a sustainable education management strategy. This research paper aims to develop a qualitative model that advocates how digital transformation as a propelling force could be used to build competitive advantages for universities. Building competitive advantage is a relative, evolving, and important concept in strategy formulation. In recent years, specifically in the education industry, the notion of building competitive advantage is challenged by global phenomena such as digital transformation globalization, information exchange, digitization and social media in most of the global industries. These phenomena have collectively made the process of building competitive advantage rapidly changing, short-term and contextual. These findings aid the evolution of strategic management practices in universities by providing empirical insights in determining the impactful changes and their connection to evolutionary learning. It also stresses the importance of using the developed model as a decision support system to generate, regulate and retain student experience and expectations. This research paper provides first-hand insight into the impactful changes affecting universities’ vision and how they can turn these changes to their advantages and set a road map to design-develop models to integrate and regulate these essential changes in their strategies using evolution learning mechanism and digital transformation strategy.

Security implications of climate development in conflict-affected states: Implications of local-level effects of rural hydropower development on farmers in Herat

Article

Full-text available

Oct 2021
POLIT GEOGR

Development initiatives aimed at mitigating or adapting to climate change impacts may result in unanticipated effects especially in conflict-affected contexts. To improved understanding of the implications of future climate development projects in conflict-affected states, this article qualitatively examines the experiences of local communities in the Zinda Jan district, located downstream from the Salma Dam in Herat Province, Afghanistan. Conducted in 2018, the research questions what local-level side effects (LLSEs) were experienced by communities downstream of the Salma Dam after its 2016 inauguration, and how these LLSEs might affect the potential for sustainable peace. The article builds from 25 in-depth interviews with local stakeholders in the Zinda Jan district, and highlights how communities generally experienced increased water scarcity after the completion of the dam in 2016, due to poor water management and lack of necessary infrastructure related to the dam. This water scarcity was a factor in grievances related to water access among local communities, and increased the likelihood of related communal violence. However, local perspectives also indicate desire for joint management of water resources between the state and civilians, from the source to their farms. The article provides important insight for research and policy actors to better understand the implications of future climate development projects in conflict-affected states, and their inherent contribution and/or risk to broader peace processes.

Unveiling the Research Landscape of Sustainable Development Goals and Their Inclusion in Higher Education Institutions and Research Centers: Major Trends in 2000–2017

Article

Full-text available

Mar 2021

The Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) have become the international framework for sustainability policy. Its legacy is linked with the Millennium Development Goals (MDG), established in 2000. In this paper a scientometric analysis was conducted to: (1) Present a new methodological approach to identify the research output related to both SDGs and MDGs (M&SDGs) from 2000 to 2017, with the aim of mapping the global research related to M&SDGs; (2) Describe the thematic specialization based on keyword co-occurrence analysis and citation bursts; and (3) Classify the scientific output into individual SDGs (based on an ad-hoc glossary) and assess SDGs interconnections. Publications conceptually related to M&SDGs (defined by the set of M&SDG core publications and a scientometric expansion based on direct citations) were identified in the in-house CWTS Web of Science database. A total of 25,299 publications were analyzed, of which 21,653 (85.59%) were authored by Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) or academic research centers (RCs). The findings reveal the increasing participation of these organizations in this research (660 institutions in 2000–2005 to 1,744 institutions involved in 2012–2017). Some institutions present both a high production and specialization on M&SDG topics (e.g., London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine and World Health Organization); and others with a very high specialization although lower production levels (e.g., Stockholm Environment Institute). Regarding the specific topics of research, health (especially in developing countries), women, and socio-economic issues are the most salient. Moreover, it has been observed an important interlinkage in the research outputs of some SDGs (e.g., SDG11 “Sustainable Cities and Communities” and SDG3 “Good Health and Well-Being”). This study provides first evidence of such interconnections, and the results of this study could be useful for policymakers in order to promote a more evidenced-based setting for their research agendas on SDGs.

Providing care under extreme adversity: The impact of the Yemen conflict on the personal and professional lives of health workers

Article

Full-text available

Feb 2021

The war in Yemen, described as the world’s ‘worst humanitarian crisis,’ has seen numerous attacks against health care. While global attention to attacks on health workers has increased significantly over the past decade, gaps in research on the lived experiences of frontline staff persist. This study draws on perspectives of frontline health workers in Yemen to understand the impact of the ongoing conflict on their personal and professional lives. Forty-three facility-based health workers’ interviews, and 6 focus group discussions with community-based health workers and midwives were conducted in Sana’a, Aden and Taiz governorates at the peak of the Yemen conflict. Data were analyzed using content analysis methods. Findings highlight the extent and range of violence confronting health workers in Yemen as well as the coping strategies they use to attenuate the impact of acute and chronic stressors resulting from conflict. We find that the complex security situation – characterized by multiple parties to the conflict, politicization of humanitarian aid and constraints in humanitarian access – was coupled with everyday stressors that prevented health workers from carrying out their work. Participants reported sporadic attacks by armed civilians, tensions with patients, and harassment at checkpoints. Working conditions were dire, and participants reported chronic suspension of salaries as well as serious shortages of essential supplies and medicines. Themes specific to coping centered around fatalism and religious motivation, resourcefulness and innovation, and sense of duty and patriotism. Our findings demonstrate that health workers experience substantial stress and face various pressures while delivering lifesaving services in Yemen. While they exhibit considerable resilience and coping, they have needs that remain largely unaddressed. Accordingly, the humanitarian community should direct more attention to responding to the mental health and psychosocial needs of health workers, while actively working to ameliorate the conditions in which they work.

Organizational Advocacy of Cultural Competency Initiatives: Lessons for Public Administration

Article

Mar 2016

Cultural competency initiatives in the public sector continue to grow, from programming efforts to organizational policy implementation. These initiatives build off decades of similar experiences and practices in associated fields of public administration. This study reviews existing advocacy in health care, social work, and other public sector organizations. Specifically, the study reviews public service academies, associations, honor societies and accrediting body practices that, by example, can help by informing, guiding and advocating cultural competency initiatives in public administration. Future implications and opportunities are explored and presented.

Transformation of higher education in Ukraine: Impact of the war and objectives for post‐war recovery

Article

Nov 2023

Processes of globalisation, sustainable development, the Covid‐19 pandemic, and other current circumstances influence the development of higher education. Higher education institutions in Ukraine also face challenges related to the military aggression by the Russian Federation since 2014, martial law since February 2022 and efforts to prepare for a post‐war recovery. The article outlines key areas that merit closer attention including an analysis of changes occurring in higher education in Ukraine before and during the war; the network of higher education institutions in Ukraine; admissions processes; trends in higher education quality assurance and enhancement; and international aid for the support and development of higher education in Ukraine. The analysis outlines changes that have taken place in higher education in Ukraine as a result of the destruction of infrastructure and a decrease in institutional capability of universities in eastern Ukraine and Crimea, as well as massive migration. We identify main innovations and specific features of the admissions process in 2022 compared to admissions processes in 2021. The government of Ukraine, following martial law, introduced restrictions that affected international academic mobility, which is carried out online, or to the extent possible as blended learning. Finally, we outline tasks for post‐war higher education recovery and development and underline the key role of universities in the post‐war recovery of Ukraine.

Role of Yemen higher education institutes in rebuilding the post-war Yemen

Article