ArticlePDF Available

Tuberculosis Diagnosis Delays and Associated Institutional Barriers Among Tertiary Hospitals in Tharaka Nithi County, Kenya

Authors:

Abstract

Globally, delayed diagnosis of Tuberculosis (TB) is a significant contributor to spread of TB despite avaiability of diagnostic aligorithm and advanced diagnostic machine. Kenya is still grouped among high TB burden nations and has the highest TB incidences in East Africa. This has been associated with delays in diagnosis, resulted to either individual or community health and economic challenges. The purpose of this study was to assess health system related factors influencing timely diagnosis of TB in Tharaka Nithi County. A descriptive crossectional survey study design was adopted among 154 randomly selected patients and 12 purposively selected key informants in selected hospitals in Tharaka Nithi County. A self administered questionaire and key informant guide were used to collect data among patients and key informants respectively. Descriptive and inferential statistics were used to analyse data. Bivariate analysis was used to test the strength of association between health system related factors and duration of TB before diagnosis. Qualitative data was analysed thematically. Study findings revealed that most (70.86%, n=107) respondents delayed in diagnosis. Bivariate regression results revealed that multiple visits (OR=3.24;95%CI:1.55-6.76,p=0.002), long turnarround time (OR=2.38 ;95% CI:1.06-5.30;p=0.035), cash payment (OR=4.53;95%CI:1.82-11.23; p= 0.001), far diagnostic centers (OR=3.86;95%CI:1.71-8.73;p=0.001),lack of prior TB health education (OR=2.71; 95%CI: 1.29-5.64;p=0.008) and long laboratory results turnarround time (OR=2.49; 95% CI: 1.29-5.64; p=0.016) as significants associated with delayed diagnosis. Machine breakdown, misdiagnosis, and inadequate counselling on TB were identified as precipitators of diagnostic delay within a hospital. The study recommends empowerment of community based-hospital referral system, strengthening of collaboration between County government and independent service providers, equipping health facility and continuous training on TB diagnosis and care.
International Journal of Health Sciences and Research
Volume14; Issue: 3; March 2024
Website: www.ijhsr.org
Original Research Article ISSN: 2249-9571
International Journal of Health Sciences and Research (www.ijhsr.org) 170
Volume 14; Issue: 3; March 2024
Tuberculosis Diagnosis Delays and Associated
Institutional Barriers Among Tertiary Hospitals in
Tharaka Nithi County, Kenya
Linda B.K1, Onchangwa T.N1, Gitonga L.K1, Mukhwana E.S1, M’Kiunga K.S1
1School of Nursing and Public Health, Chuka University, Chuka, Kenya
Corresponding Author: Linda Bonface Kivuva
DOI: https://doi.org/10.52403/ijhsr.20240325
ABSTRACT
Globally, delayed diagnosis of Tuberculosis (TB) is a significant contributor to spread of TB
despite avaiability of diagnostic aligorithm and advanced diagnostic machine. Kenya is still
grouped among high TB burden nations and has the highest TB incidences in East Africa.
This has been associated with delays in diagnosis, resulted to either individual or community
health and economic challenges. The purpose of this study was to assess health system
related factors influencing timely diagnosis of TB in Tharaka Nithi County. A descriptive
crossectional survey study design was adopted among 154 randomly selected patients and 12
purposively selected key informants in selected hospitals in Tharaka Nithi County. A self
administered questionaire and key informant guide were used to collect data among patients
and key informants respectively. Descriptive and inferential statistics were used to analyse
data. Bivariate analysis was used to test the strength of association between health system
related factors and duration of TB before diagnosis. Qualitative data was analysed
thematically. Study findings revealed that most (70.86%, n=107) respondents delayed in
diagnosis. Bivariate regression results revealed that multiple visits (OR=3.24;95%CI:1.55-
6.76,p=0.002), long turnarround time (OR=2.38 ;95% CI:1.06-5.30;p=0.035), cash payment
(OR=4.53;95%CI:1.82-11.23; p= 0.001), far diagnostic centers (OR=3.86;95%CI:1.71-
8.73;p=0.001),lack of prior TB health education (OR=2.71; 95%CI: 1.29-5.64;p=0.008) and
long laboratory results turnarround time (OR=2.49; 95% CI: 1.29-5.64; p=0.016) as
significants associated with delayed diagnosis. Machine breakdown, misdiagnosis, and
inadequate counselling on TB were identified as precipiators of diagnostic delay within a
hospital. The study recommends empowerment of community based-hospital referral system,
strengthening of collaboration between County government and independent service
providers, equiping health facility and continuous training on TB diagnosis and care.
Keywords: Timely diagnosis, Health System Related, Tuberculosis, Delay, Barriers
INTRODUCTION
Approximately over 30 years after
declaration of TB as a global emergency [1],
it still remains the leading single cause [2] of
morbidity and mortality globally [1],[3] ,
affecting approximately 30% of global
population despite provision of proper
mitigation measures by various nations [1].
In 2015, WHO member state set in motion a
plan dubbed “TB eradicate by 2030,” with a
tripple targets approach of five years apart
[4],[5]. However, an aggregated decline of 9%
on TB incidence rate was attained between
2015 and 2020, compared to set target of
Linda B.K et.al. Tuberculosis diagnosis delays and associated institutional barriers among Tertiary Hospitals in
Tharaka Nithi County, Kenya
International Journal of Health Sciences and Research (www.ijhsr.org) 171
Volume 14; Issue: 3; March 2024
20% [4]. The decimal decline poses a greater
challenge on TB control. Thus resulting to
continued disease spread and advancement
within the community. Delayed diagnosis
of tuberculosis has been reported to
significantly perpertuate TB spread and
inhibit its eradication [6]. Thus the need to
identify the gap in tuberculosis diagnosis.
Literature on prevention and control of TB
has revealed that the rising number of
tuberculosis undiagnosed cases as
alarming[7]. In 2019 alone, approximately
three million TB case were believed not to
be diagnosed or reported[5]. This may be
associated with either patients or hospital
barriers. Among developing nations, many
studies conducted are on patients related
delay in TB diagosis. Thus the need to
investigate and address the gaps within
health care system. A study in Ethiopia
revealed that hospital delays in timely TB
diagnosis as contributor to high TB burden
in subsaharan region[8]. However, it has
been established that delays in diagnosis
differ greaterly among nations[9]. Some of
reported health factors include distance to
diagnostic center[7]; [8];[10]; [11],
misdiagnosis[2];[12], clinical inertia[13], high
workload[2], multiple visits to hospital[1]; [3];
[14], cash payment[2]; [3]; [7], machine
breakdown [15] and inadequate health
education[15];[16].
In 2021, the prevalence of TB in Kenya was
reported as 426 per 100,000
population[17];[18]. Inaddition, 40% and 52%
of TB cases were reported to be missing and
not diagnosed on time respectively[17]. This
poses a public health challenge to Kenya
population. Thus the need to investigate
hospital factors delaying diagnosis of TB.
This will provide useful information to aid
in setting policies and stratergies of TB
control in the county.
MATERIALS & METHODS
A hospital based descriptive crossectional
survery research design was adopted among
154 randomly selected patients and 12
purposively selected key informant in
Chuka and Chogoria Hospitals in Tharaka
Nithi County. A self administered pre-
design and pre-tested modified WHO
questionnaire was used to collect data
among patients respondents while a key
informant guide was adopted among the key
informants. Data was code and analysed
using MS Exel and SPSS v26 respectively.
Patients characteristics were presented using
descriptive statistics while bivariate analysis
were used to test the strenght of association
between health facility factors and duration
of tuberculosis before diagnosis. Qualitative
data was analysed thematically. The study
catergorised TB diagnosis time into either
delay (>21 days) or no delay (<21 day),
through assumption of a 21 day cutoff
adopted from WHO. Frequencies and
percentages were used to present study
results. Institutional ethical approval was
sought from Chuka University Ethics and
Research Committee (NACOSTI/NBC/AC-
08120) and NACOSTI research permit
(NACOSTI/p /23/24959). Permission for
data collection was sought from hospital
administrators. The researcher observed all
ethical considation during data collection.
RESULT
The researcher approached 154 patient
respondents, of which 3 were excluded due
to inadeqaute filling of the research tool,
resulting to 151 study respondents (98.0%
response rate). Data analysed revealed a
mean age of 38.71(SD, 13.65) years, median
and mode of 36.0 and 42.0 years
respectively among patients’ respondents. In
addition, nearly 30%(n=48) of the
respondents were aged 31-40 years. It was
further observed that more than a half of the
respondents were male[n=85(56.29%)] and
married[n=84(55.62%)]. Regarding
respondents’ education status only
18.54%(n=28) had attained post secondary
education. Almost a half of the respondents
were self employed[n=74(49.01%)] and had
household income
<10,000/=[n=88(58.28%), Table 1].
Linda B.K et.al. Tuberculosis diagnosis delays and associated institutional barriers among Tertiary Hospitals in
Tharaka Nithi County, Kenya
International Journal of Health Sciences and Research (www.ijhsr.org) 172
Volume 14; Issue: 3; March 2024
Table 1: Respondents socio-demographic characteristics
Variables
Frequency
Percent
Respondents’ gender
Male
85
56.29
Female
66
43.71
Totals
151
100.0
Respondents’ Age
20-30
33
21.85
31-40
48
31.79
41-50
44
29.13
Over 50
26
17.22
Totals
151
100.0
Respondents’
Marital status
Single
21
13.91
Married
84
55.62
Divorced
27
17.88
Widowed
19
12.58
Totals
151
100
Respondents’
education status
Never attended school
17
11.26
Primary
49
32.45
Secondary
57
37.75
Post secondary education
28
18.54
Totals
151
100.0
Respondents’
Occupation
Unemployed
47
31.13
Self employed
74
49.01
Government employed
30
19.86
Total
151
100
Respondents’ household income
<10,000/=
88
58.28
10,000-20,000/=
23
15.23
>20,000/=
40
26.49
Totals
151
100.0
TB diagnostic Duration
The study sought to identify percentage of
respondent experiencing delayed diagnosis.
The results are presented in figure 1 below.
It was observed that
majority[n=107(70.86%) of the respondents
delayed in T diagnosis while only
29.14%(n=44) were diagnosed on time
(Figure 1).
Figure 1: A bar graph of Uptake of diagnostic Services.
Hospital based barriers to timely
diagnosis
From table 2 below, respondents who
visited hospital more than three times prior
to diangosis were 3.24 times(95%;CI=1.55-
6.76;p=0.002) more likey to delay in
dignosis compared than those who visited
less than three times. Turn arround time of
more than three hours was reported to
increase diagnostic delay by 2.3
times(95%;CI=1.06-5.30;p=0.035)
compared to turnarround time of less than 3
hours. Similary, it was observed that
respondents worse laboratory investigation
results took more than 2 day were 2.4
times(95%;CI=1.18-5.26;p=0.016) more
likely to experience diagnostic delay
compared to respondents whose results took
Linda B.K et.al. Tuberculosis diagnosis delays and associated institutional barriers among Tertiary Hospitals in
Tharaka Nithi County, Kenya
International Journal of Health Sciences and Research (www.ijhsr.org) 173
Volume 14; Issue: 3; March 2024
less than 2 days. Respondents who didn’t
reveice health eduation on TB were 2.7
times (95%;CI=1.29-5.64;p=0.008) more
likely to delay in TB diagnosis than
respondend educated on TB before
diagnosis. With reference to insurance
payment, cash paying respondents were
4.5(95%;CI=1.82-11.23;p=0.001).
Respondents living more than five
kilometers from TB diagnostic centers were
3.8 times(95%;CI=1.71-8.78;p=0.001) more
likely to diagnostic delay than respondents
living less than five kilometers form
diagnostic centers.
Table 2: Association between hospital factors and TB diagnostic duration
Diagnostic Duration
Variable
Delay (%)
OR (95%CI)
P-
value
Prior visits with TB suggestive symptoms before
diagnsis of TB
<3 times
27(17.9)
*
*
>3 times
80(53.0)
3.24(1.55-6.76)
0.002
Consultation Turn around time
<3 hours
63(41.7)
*
*
>3 hours
44(29.2)
2.38(1.06-5.30)
0.035
Health Education on TB before diagnosis
Yes
27(17.9)
*
*
No
80(53.0)
2.71(1.29-5.64)
0.008
Laboratory tests turn around time
>2 days
82(54.2)
2.49(1.18-5.26)
0.016
<2 days
25(16.6)
*
*
Service Payment Methods
Cash
97(64.2)
4.53(1.82-11.23)
0.001
Insurances
10(6.6)
*
*
Distance to Diagnostic centers
<5 KM
15(9.9)
*
*
>5 KM
97(78.8)
3.86(1.71-8.73)
0.001
Health factors associated with delay in
diagnosis of TB: Qualitative findings
Theme 1: Misdiagnosis
Nurses and Clinical Officers interview
revealed that misdiagnosis among TB
sysmptomatic patients precipitated
diagnostic delay. Most tuberculosis patients
ended up been diagnosed with lower
respiratory tract infections particulary
pneumonia. Therefore, medication
presecribed resulted to subsiding of TB
sysmptoms and recurrence of sysmptoms
after the dosage was over.
“Majority of the patients when they come to
TB clinic usually report of been on
antibiotic treatment for pneumonia or other
diseases affecting the lower part of the
respiratory system before diagnosis of TB is
made. The antibiotics normally subsides the
symptoms then after the duration of taking
the drugs is over the symptoms emerge. This
results to prolonging the duration of TB
diagnosis. ” (Respondents No.1, 2 and 5).
The interview was further designed to
gather information of the caused of
misdiagnosis within the county, among the
respondents it was reported that, inadequate
onjob training, unclear chest imaging
results, low suspicion index and high
workload as contributors to misdiagnosis.
One of the respondents had this to say:
“When patients report in a hospital they
first go through the outpatient department.
In most cases we are few in the consultation
rooms and patients waiting to be seen are
very many. So it becomes very difficult to
ask patients questions pertaining to night
sweats, loss of weight, coughing among
other. But instead focus more on the
patients main complain.” (Respondents No.
10).
Another Clinical officer indicated that:
“Sometimes, we may send a patient for an
X-ray to help in the diagnosis. When we
review the films of the X-ray they are not
clear to help in making a
diagnosis”(Respondent No.10)
A nurse during the interview has this to
say:-
“There is few on-job training on the update
of TB among members not on the TB clinic
or outreach services. This results to failure
to be aware of recent diagnostic and
treatment plan of the diseases.”(Respondent
No.3)
Linda B.K et.al. Tuberculosis diagnosis delays and associated institutional barriers among Tertiary Hospitals in
Tharaka Nithi County, Kenya
International Journal of Health Sciences and Research (www.ijhsr.org) 174
Volume 14; Issue: 3; March 2024
Clinical officers at different hospital further
added that:-
Some of the health workers may have low
suspicion of the disease depending on the
information given by the patients resulting
into wrong treatment when one already has
TB.” (Respondent No. 1 & 10)
Theme 2: Inadequate Counselling
Health proffessional interviewd reported
that inadequate counselling or health
education resulted to unwanted delays in Tb
diagnosis. Inadditions, challenges such as
lack of privance, poor doctor patient
relationship, high workload and
communication barriers were identified as
hinderance to proper individual health
education. The nurses and clinial officers
had this to say:
“Majority of the patients are not educated
on reasons for examination, causes of
symptoms they are experiencing.
Furthermore, only a few patients are able to
recognize TB symptoms. Thus, they end up
leaving the hospital not understanding what
they are suffering from.”(Respondents No.
1,5 &10).
Similar observation were further
collaborated by clinical officers:
“As health care providers we are faced with
some challenges which prevent us from
providing proper counselling. For example,
communication becomes a challenges if you
met patients who do not understand
kiswahili or English, lack of privacy in the
consultation rooms, unsupportive health
professionals and high workload.”
(Respondents No. 2&6).
Theme 3: GeneXpert machine
breakdown
Laboratory technologists reported that
machine breakdown among the few
GeneXpert machines in the county was a
big problem:
“Sometimes the hospital GeneXpert
machine does not work, for example we
have been sending samples to chogoria for
the last two months.” (Respondent No. 9)
“Currently, the GeneXpert machine we have
operated under three modules, despite it
being a four module machine. The fourth
module has some problems.” (Respondents
No.3)
Another respondents had this to say:
“In the county we have three genexpert
machine, when one of them fails we receive
large number of samples(approximately 60).
So we tell the patients to go home they will
be called or texted when the results are
ready......high number of samples also
results in stockout of reagents for the
samples exceeds the normal approximated
montly analysis resulting to waiting for the
reagents to be bought a process which may
take approximately a week.”(Respondent
No. 11)
Theme 4: Distance to facility.
Delay in sputum results was reported as a
crucial barrier within health system whose
interaction with other barriers at individual
level such as lack of fare and distance to
hospital further minimized the chances of
commencing anti-TB treatment.
“Patients are very much disappointed when
they are told to come back tomorrow for
resultes and they fail to get them. Some of
the patients come from far areas and use
fare to come to hospital. If the come the
third time and fail to get results they
normally dont come again.” (Respondent
No. 5)
DISCUSSION
In this study majority (70.86%) of the
respondents experienced diagnostic delay.
This was slightly lower compared to
diagnostic delay (87.4%) reported in
India[19]. However, this finding didn’t
concur with findings of a study done in
Ethiopia which reported diagnostic delay of
50.9% [10] . This differences in the findings
may be associated with cutoff of delayed
diagnosis and study sample size. A
relationship between multiple visits to
health providers before diagnosis and
diagnostic duration was established. This
Linda B.K et.al. Tuberculosis diagnosis delays and associated institutional barriers among Tertiary Hospitals in
Tharaka Nithi County, Kenya
International Journal of Health Sciences and Research (www.ijhsr.org) 175
Volume 14; Issue: 3; March 2024
mirrored with finding of many studies that
reported multiple visits to health
proffessional as a risk factor to diagnostic
delay[1]; [7]; [14]; [19]; [20]; [21]. This may be due
to lack of patients’ satisfaction, poor quality
of care and health proffessional attitude
resulting to patients to seek consultation in
other facility. In this study, an assocaition
between long consultation turn around time
and diagnostic dealy was established. These
findings agreed with a systematic review
condicted among high burden nations which
reported that long turnarround time as a
barrier to timely TB diagnosis[1]. This may
be associated with busy schedules of
patients resulting to seeking care in either
chemist or private clinic, thus prolong
diagnostic time. Similary, delays in
laboratory results were identifed to
influence diagnostic delay in this study.
This was congruent with a study done in
Uganda[13]; [15].
There was a significant association between
health education before diagnosis and
duration of TB before diagnosis. This was in
line with findings of a study done in
Tanzania which revealed that more effort
was put on educating patients on
noncommunicable diseases, thus neglecting
communicable disease such TB health
education[12]. This may be associated with
raise of incidence rates of
noncommunicable disease, stigma assocated
with communicable disease, inadeqauate
knowledge among staffs about TB
managements updates. Moreover, in this
study, it was established that cash payment
method contributed to diagnostic delay. This
concurred with finding of studies done in
Nigeria[2];Indonesia[7] and Ethiopia[13]. This
may be due to the expenses the patients
incur before diagnosis is made. However, a
study conducted in Ghana revealed that
medical insurances were facilitors to TB
diagnosis[3]. An association was established
between distance to diagnostic centers and
duration of diagnosis in this study. This
findings concurred with other study finding
which established that long diastance to TB
diagnostic centers as a precipitator to
diagnostic delay[8]; [9]; [10]; [11]; [22]. However,
this finding did were not in line with finding
of a study done in Mombasa County,
Kenya[23].
In this study, it was revealed that inadequate
counselling of TB patients was a risk factor
to diagnostic delay from the interviews
conduted. This was agreed with as
conducted in Uganda, which reported that
inappropriate counselling of patients by
health care providers on TB resulted to
unacceptable delays[15]. This may be linked
with lack of privancy, high work load and
staff shortage. In addition, this study
reported misdiagnosis of tuberculosis
patients with other respiratory diseases as a
barrier to timely diagnosis. This was similar
to study finding from a study in West Pokot
County, Kenya, which reported that more
than eighty percent of the patients were
misdiagnosed and started on empirical
therapy despite having sysmptoms
suggestive of TB[6]. Moreover, other studies
reported of unclear chest imaging results[15],
staff shortage[24], inadequate onjob
trainging[6], non-adherence to guideline[2]
and clinical inertia[20] to precipitate
diagnostic delay. This was congruent with
findings of this study.
CONCLUSION
In this study a significant delay in diagnosis
was established. However, contributory
factors to the delay seems to be similar to
those of other African Nations. In addition,
misdiagnosis, multiple visits, distance to
diagnostic centers, long turnarround time
either in consultation or laboratory, lack of
TB health education, inadequate counselling
and machine breakdown were reported to
contribute to diagnostic delays within the
county. The study recommends
incorporation of people and developing their
skills to raise understanding of the policies
and infrastructures that the government
sector has at its disposal, through
establishment of specimen network
framework, and provision of necessary
resources need for TB control. There is also
need to do a research on patients level of
Linda B.K et.al. Tuberculosis diagnosis delays and associated institutional barriers among Tertiary Hospitals in
Tharaka Nithi County, Kenya
International Journal of Health Sciences and Research (www.ijhsr.org) 176
Volume 14; Issue: 3; March 2024
knowledge and its relationship with
diagnosis duration.
Declaration by Authors
Ethical Approval: Approved
Acknowledgement: None
Source of Funding: None
Conflict of Interest: The authors declare no
conflict of interest.
REFERENCES
1. Teo, A. K. J., Singh, S. R., Prem, K., Hsu,
L. Y., & Yi, S. (2021). Duration and
determinants of delayed tuberculosis
diagnosis and treatment in high-burden
countries: a mixed-methods systematic
review and meta-analysis. Respiratory
research, 22(1), 1-28.
2. Oga-Omenka, C., Wakdet, L., Menzies, D.,
& Zarowsky, C. (2021). A qualitative meta-
synthesis of facilitators and barriers to
tuberculosis diagnosis and treatment in
Nigeria. BMC Public Health, 21, 1-12.
3. Osei, E., Akweongo, P., & Binka, F. (2015).
Factors associated with DELAY in
diagnosis among tuberculosis patients in
Hohoe Municipality, Ghana. BMC public
health, 15(1), 1-11.
4. Chakaya, J., Khan, M., Ntoumi, F., Aklillu,
E., Fatima, R., Mwaba, P., ... & Zumla, A.
(2021). Global Tuberculosis Report 2020
Reflections on the Global TB burden,
treatment and prevention
efforts. International journal of infectious
diseases, 113, S7-S12.
5. World Health Organization. Global
Tuberculosis Report 2020. Geneva; 2020.
Available from:
https://www.who.int/publications/i/
item/9789240013131
6. Mbuthia, G. W., Olungah, C. O., &
Ondicho, T. G. (2018). Health-seeking
pathway and factors leading to delays in
tuberculosis diagnosis in West Pokot
County, Kenya: A grounded theory
study. PloS one, 13(11), e0207995.
7. Lestari, B. W., McAllister, S.,
Hadisoemarto, P. F., Afifah, N., Jani, I. D.,
Murray, M., ... & Alisjahbana, B. (2020).
Patient pathways and delays to diagnosis
and treatment of tuberculosis in an urban
setting in Indonesia. The Lancet Regional
HealthWestern Pacific, 5.
8. Arja, A., Bogale, B., & Gebremedhin, M.
(2022). Health system delay and its
associated factors among tuberculosis
patients in Gamo Zone public health
facilities, Southern Ethiopia: An institution-
based cross-sectional study. Journal of
Clinical Tuberculosis and Other
Mycobacterial Diseases, 28, 100325.
9. Alene, M., Assemie, M. A., Yismaw, L.,
Gedif, G., Ketema, D. B., Gietaneh, W., &
Chekol, T. D. (2020). Patient delay in the
diagnosis of tuberculosis in Ethiopia: a
systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC
infectious diseases, 20, 1-9.
10. Awoke, N., Dulo, B., & Wudneh, F. (2019).
Total delay in treatment of tuberculosis and
associated factors among new pulmonary
TB patients in selected health facilities of
Gedeo zone, southern Ethiopia,
2017/18. Interdisciplinary perspectives on
infectious diseases, 2019.
11. Haboro, G. G., Handiso, T. B., &
Gebretsadik, L. A. (2019). Health care
system delay of tuberculosis treatment and
its correlates among pulmonary tuberculosis
patients in Hadiya Zone public health
facilities, Southern Ethiopia. Journal of
Infectious Diseases and Epidemiology, 5(2),
1-6.
12. Verhagen, L. M., Kapinga, R., & van
Rosmalen-Nooijens, K. A. W. L. (2010).
Factors underlying diagnostic delay in
tuberculosis patients in a rural area in
Tanzania: a qualitative
approach. Infection, 38, 433-446.
13. Datiko, D. G., Jerene, D., & Suarez, P.
(2020). Patient and health system delay
among TB patients in Ethiopia: Nationwide
mixed method cross-sectional study. BMC
Public Health, 20(1), 1-10.
14. Wako, W. G., Wasie, A., Wayessa, Z., &
Fikrie, A. (2021). Determinants of health
system diagnostic delay of pulmonary
tuberculosis in Gurage and Siltie zones,
South Ethiopia: a cross-sectional
study. BMJ open, 11(10), e047986.
15. Zawedde-Muyanja, S., Manabe, Y. C.,
Cattamanchi, A., Castelnuovo, B., &
Katamba, A. (2022). Patient and health
Linda B.K et.al. Tuberculosis diagnosis delays and associated institutional barriers among Tertiary Hospitals in
Tharaka Nithi County, Kenya
International Journal of Health Sciences and Research (www.ijhsr.org) 177
Volume 14; Issue: 3; March 2024
system level barriers to and facilitators for
tuberculosis treatment initiation in Uganda:
a qualitative study. BMC health services
research, 22(1), 831.
16. Yasobant, S., Bhavsar, P., Kalpana, P.,
Memon, F., Trivedi, P., & Saxena, D.
(2021). Contributing factors in the
tuberculosis care cascade in India: a
systematic literature review. Risk
Management and Healthcare Policy, 3275-
3286.
17. Enos, M., Sitienei, J., Ong’ang’o, J.,
Mungai, B., Kamene, M., Wambugu, J., ...
& Weyenga, H. (2018). Kenya tuberculosis
prevalence survey 2016: challenges and
opportunities of ending TB in Kenya. PloS
one, 13(12), e0209098.
18. Ministry of Health. (2020). Mulika TB
Hospitalini, Maliza TB Kenya. Field Guide
on Systematic Screening of Active TB in
Kenya.(2020) National Tuberculosis and
Leprosy Program
19. Sahu, R., Verma, P., & Kasar, P. K. (2020).
Patient and health provider factors affecting
diagnostic delays of pulmonary tuberculosis
in Jabalpur district of Madhya Pradesh,
India: a cross-sectional study. International
Journal of Community Medicine and Public
Health, 7(1), 89.
20. Getnet, F., Demissie, M., Worku, A.,
Gobena, T., Tschopp, R., & Seyoum, B.
(2020). Longer delays in diagnosis and
treatment of pulmonary tuberculosis in
pastoralist setting, eastern Ethiopia. Risk
Management and Healthcare Policy, 583-
594.
21. Bogale, S., Diro, E., Shiferaw, A. M., &
Yenit, M. K. (2017). Factors associated with
the length of delay with tuberculosis
diagnosis and treatment among adult
tuberculosis patients attending at public
health facilities in Gondar town, Northwest,
Ethiopia. BMC infectious diseases, 17, 1-10.
22. Nyatichi, F. O., Amimo, F. A., Nabie, B., &
Ondimu, T. O. (2016). Factors contributing
to delay in seeking treatment among
pulmonary tuberculosis patients in Suneka
Sub-County, Kenya.
23. Limo, J., & Onyango, R. (2022). Diagnosis
Delay and Factors Associated with Delay
Among Tuberculosis Patients in Mombasa
County, Kenya.
24. Kunjok, D. M., Mwangi, J. G., Mambo, S.,
& Wanyoike, S. (2021). Assessment of
delayed tuberculosis diagnosis preceding
diagnostic confirmation among tuberculosis
patients attending Isiolo County level four
hospital, Kenya. Pan African Medical
Journal, 38(1).
How to cite this article: Linda B.K, Onchangwa
T.N, Gitonga L.K, Mukhwana E.S, M’Kiunga
K.S. Tuberculosis Diagnosis Delay and
Associated Institutional Barriers among Tertiary
Hospitals in Tharaka Nithi County, Kenya. Int J
Health Sci Res. 2024; 14(3):170-177. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.52403/ijhsr.20240325
******
... Tuberculosis(TB), despite availability of preventive and curative measures (Fang et al., 2019), remains a public health challenge, ranked among leading contributors of mortality globally, even with enactment of global and national control statergies (Junaid et al., 2021). Literature on TB control has reported that since the End TB strategies were implemented, a 2% annual decline on TB incidence had been reported by 2020, though at a slow rate resulting to failure in attaining set targets at 2020 (Bashorum et al., 2020., Linda et al., 2024). Many studies in both developed and developing nations have associated this with TB diagnostic delay (Abdullahi et al., 2021, Alene et al., 2020, Angelo et al., 2020). ...
Article
Full-text available
Tuberculosis (TB), despite availability of preventive and curative measures, remains a public health challenge, ranked among leading contributors of mortality globally, even with enactment of global and national control strategies. Enhancement of TB knowledge within the community may play a pivotal role in its control. Therefore, the aim of this study was to determine aspects of TB knowledge, examine sociodemographic determinants and investigate knowledge aspects influencing TB diagnostic duration among patients with tuberculosis in Tharaka Nithi County. A descriptive cross-sectional design was adopted among 154 randomly selected respondents visiting three selected hospitals in Tharaka Nithi County. A self administered questionnaire was used to collect data. Descriptive and inferential statistics were used to analyses data. The study reported that 82.78% of the respondents had inadequate knowledge, with 62.91% of them been diagnosed after recommended time. Inadequate knowledge was reported among various aspects of TB such as causative agent(71.52%), clinical presentations (83.44%), transmissibility methods (98.68%), treatment ways(70.86%) and preventive approaches(87.42%). Further analysis revealed poor knowledge on cause(p<0.003), transmissibility (p<0.023), disease presentation(p<0.023) and curative methods(p<0.005) as aspects of TB significantly associated with delayed diagnosis of TB. Therefore, the study recommends enhancement of community health awareness as an absolute necessary approach in promoting comprehension of TB disease. Thus improving population health seeking behavior.
Article
Full-text available
Tuberculosis (TB) care cascade is a recently evolved care model for patient retention across the sequential stages of care for a successful treatment outcome. The care cascade is multi-folded and complex in setting where the health system is reforming for its resilience. India, one of the countries with the highest burden of tuberculosis mortality and morbidity, is not an exception to this complexity. With the diverse challenges in the Indian health system and societal diversity, it is essential to understand the factors contributing to this TB care cascade. Thus, this study aims to map all the contributing factors to the TB care cascade in India. Further, it also captures the different patterns of factors explored so far in different countries' regions. This systematic literature review was conducted between October 2020 and February 2021 in India using PubMed databases, Web of Science, and Google Scholar. Two reviewers extracted the data from eligible studies to summarize and tabulate important findings. Data were extracted and tabulated for study design, location of the study, type of TB patients, methodological approach, system side challenges, and demand-side challenges in the study's findings. Out of 692 initial hits from the literature search, 28 studies were finally included to synthesize evidence in this review as per the inclusion and exclusion criteria. This review provides an insight into different factors such as the system-side (health workforce, institutional) and the demand-side (individual, societal) contributing towards the care cascade. The prime factors reflected in most of the studies were socioeconomic condition, disease awareness, myths/beliefs, addictions among the demand-side factors and accessibility, the attitude of the healthcare staff, delay in referral for diagnosis among the system-side factors. The accountability for addressing these diverse factors is recommended to close the gaps in the TB care cascade.
Article
Full-text available
Introduction: delayed diagnosis of Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection leads to accelerated individual to individual transmission. This study evaluated this aspect of delayed diagnosis among patients visiting Isiolo level four hospital in northern Kenya. Methods: this was a cross-sectional cohort study conducted during January, 2018-January, 2019 with systematically sampled 172 tuberculosis (TB) patients. Epidemiological and clinical characteristics were abstracted from records to serve as independent variables. Outcome variable was delayed diagnosis dichotomised into < 21 or > 21 days and treated as a binary outcome. Pre-tested interviewer-administered questionnaires, focused group discussions, and key informant interview guides were used to collect relevant information. Results: most (n=89, 57.8%) of the TB diagnosis fell in the category of > 21 day delay. Overall, among all patients, delay in days constituted a median of 27.6, a mean of 37.3 ± 57 days (range 0-414 days). Factors associated with delayed diagnosis (happening > 21 days) included (i) use of dispensary and private health facilities, (OR=4.3, 95% CI: 1.44,13.14; P=0.009) and (OR= 4.9, 95% CI: 1.64, 14.73; P=0.004), respectively (ii) Self-employed individuals (OR=21.7, 95% CI: 2.47,190.93; P=0.006) and employed individuals (OR=9.9, 95% CI: 1.14, 85.80; P=0.038) (iii) secondary-level education (OR=0.03, 95% CI: 0.01,0.21; P=0.000) and tertiary education (OR=0.033, 95% CI: 0.01, 0.23; P=0.001). Conclusion: delayed diagnosis of TB was found to be associated with health-seeking behaviour of TB patients, proxied by diagnosis facility, occupation, and education levels in our study area. Curtailment of local transmission of M. tuberculosis needs intensified health promotion and education in affected communities complemented with active case findings.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose: This study aimed to assess the extent of patient, health system and total delays in diagnosis and treatment of pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) in Somali pastoralist setting, Ethiopia. Patients and methods: A cross-sectional study among 444 confirmed new pulmonary TB patients aged ≥15 years in 5 TB care units was conducted between December 2017 and October 2018. Data were collected using a structured questionnaire and record review. We measured delays from symptom onset to provider visit, provider visit to diagnosis and diagnosis to treatment initiation. Delays were summarized using median days. Mann-Whitney and Kruskal-Wallis tests were used to compare delays between categories of explanatory variables. The Log-binomial regression model was used to reveal factors associated with health system delay ≥15 days, presented in adjusted prevalence ratio (APR) with 95% confidence interval (CI). Results: The median age of patients was 30 years, ranged from 15 to 82. The majority (62.4%) were male, and nearly half (46.4%) were pastoralists. The median patient, health system and total delays were 30 (19-48.5), 14 (4.5-29.5) and 50 (35-73.5) days, respectively. The median patient delay (35.5 days) and total delay (58.5 days) among pastoralists were substantially higher than the equivalent delays among non-pastoralists [p<0.001]. Of all, 3.8% of patients (16 of 18 were pastoralists) delayed longer than 6 months without initiating treatment. Factors associated with health system delay ≥15 days were mild symptoms [APR (95% CI) = 1.4 (1.1-1.7)], smear-negativity [APR (95% CI) = 1.2 (1.01-1.5)], first visit to health centers [APR (95% CI) = 1.6 (1.3-2.0)] and multiple provider contacts [APR (95% CI) = 5.8 (3.5-9.6)]. Conclusion: Delay in diagnosis and treatment remains a major challenge of tuberculosis control targets in pastoralist settings of Ethiopia. Efforts to expand services tailored to transhumance patterns and diagnostic capacity of primary healthcare units need to be prioritized.
Article
Full-text available
Background: Delay in diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) causes patients to have more severe disease, more complications and lead to higher mortality with disease spread. The aim of the study was to estimate patient proportion having delayed diagnosis of PTB and to estimate patient’ and health providers’ delay and associated factors.Methods: Cross sectional study on sample of 135 new sputum positive PTB patients from nine designated microscopy centres of Jabalpur district. Data collected on modified world health organization questionnaire. The criterion for defining delay was formulated keeping in mind the Revised TB Control Programme algorithm for diagnosis of PTB in PTB suspects. Mann Whitney U and Kruskal Wallis tests were used (α=5%).Results: Mean age was 33.87 (14.3) years. Males constituted 66.7%. Proportion of diagnostic delay was 87.4%. Median patient and health care personnel (HCP) interval were 39 days (IQR 22-75) and 34 days (IQR 12-79) respectively. Factors significantly associated with patient delay were poor knowledge about TB, smoking, symptoms perceived non serious, first action with symptom onset, and mode of transport patient used to reach the nearest public health facility. Stigma didn’t affected patient interval. Factors significantly associated with health providers’ delay were first consultations with; a non-formal HCP, private health facility, non-allopathic practitioner; consultation with multiple HCP’s; living more than half an hour away from public health facility.Conclusions: Unacceptable high delay in diagnosis, more from patient side. More attempts at increasing awareness are needed.
Article
Full-text available
Background We aimed to determine the prevalence of pulmonary TB amongst the adult population (≥15 years) in 2016 in Kenya. Method A nationwide cross-sectional survey where participants first underwent TB symptom screening and chest x-ray. Subsequently, participants who reported cough >2weeks and/or had a chest x-ray suggestive of TB, submitted sputum specimen for laboratory examination by smear microscopy, culture and Xpert MTB/RIF. Result The survey identified 305 prevalent TB cases translating to a prevalence of 558 [95%CI 455–662] per 100,000 adult population. The highest disease burden was reported among people aged 25–34 years (716 [95% CI 526–906]), males (809 [(95% CI 656–962]) and those who live in urban areas (760 [95% CI 539–981]). Compared to the reported TB notification rate for Kenya in 2016, the prevalence to notification ratio was 2.5:1. The gap between the survey prevalence and notification rates was highest among males, age groups 25–34, and the older age group of 65 years and above. Only 48% of the of the survey prevalent cases reported cough >2weeks. In addition, only 59% of the identified cases had the four cardinal symptoms for TB (cough ≥2 weeks, fever, night sweat and weight loss. However, 88.2% had an abnormal chest x-ray suggestive of TB. The use of Xpert MTB/RIF identified 77.7% of the cases compared to smear microscopy’s 46%. Twenty-one percent of the survey participants with respiratory symptoms reported to have sought prior health care at private clinics and chemists. Among the survey prevalent cases who reported TB related symptoms, 64.9% had not sought any health care prior to the survey. Conclusion This survey established that TB prevalence in Kenya is higher than had been estimated, and about half of the those who fall ill with the disease each year are missed.
Article
Full-text available
Background Early diagnosis and prompt treatment is essential for an effective tuberculosis (TB) control program. However, significant proportion of cases remains undiagnosed and untreated. Delay in diagnosis and treatment increases transmission. Hence, the study assessed the length of delay and associated factors with tuberculosis diagnosis and treatment among adults attending public health facilities in Gondar town, Northwest Ethiopia. Method An institution based cross-sectional study was conducted from February to May, 2016. A total of 296 adults who came to health facilities for treatment for pulmonary TB from February to May, 2016, were included in the study. Data were collected using a structured questionnaire through interviewing and record review, cleaned, coded, and entered into Epi-info version 3.5.3, and transferred into SPSS version 20.0 for further statistical analysis. A p-value of less than 0.05 at multiple linear regression analysis was considered statistically significant. ResultThe mean duration of the total delay (in days) for tuberculosis diagnosis and initiation of treatment was 41.6 days (SD = 16.6). In this study, the mean duration of patient delay and the median health system delay were 33.9 days (SD = 14) and 5 days (IQR = 4–7), respectively. Total delay for TB diagnosis and treatment was shorter among HIV positive people (β:-12.62, 95% CI: −20.72,-4.53). Longer patient delay was noted among rural dwellers (β: 8.0, 95% CI: 5.26, 10.75); increased household income (β:-0.006, 95% CI: −0.008,-0.004) was associated with a shorter delay. Health system delay was positively associated with seeking care from more than one health care providers (β: 0.28, 95% CI: 0.23, 0.34) and seeking initial care from primary level health care facilities (β: 0.10, 95% CI: 0.07, 0.13). Conclusion In this study, the majority of patients faced delayed in seeking health care and continued as sources of infection. Longer days of delay for TB diagnosis and treatment were noted among rural residents, who seek health care from informal care providers, and receive initial care from primary level health care facilities. In contrast, the length of delay for TB diagnosis and treatment was shorter among HIV positive people and individuals with increased household income. Therefore, public awareness on the symptoms of tuberculosis and seeking health care early is essential. Moreover, early diagnosis and treatment, especially among the rural dwellers and the poor should be focused.
Article
Tuberculosis is a major global public health problem and a leading cause of morbidity and mortality in Kenya. TB control has remained a major challenge for the TB control programme especially in this HIV/AIDS era and the emergence of multi-drug resistant TB (MDR-TB). Early identification of cases and commencement of effective chemotherapy is an effective method to control the spread of TB. Reliance on passive case finding means that patients play a key role in reducing delay to diagnosis and treatment. Patient delay (duration from onset of symptoms to first contact with a health care provider at a public health facility) is a major challenge to TB control and is dependent on several factors. The purpose of this study was to determine the duration from onset of symptoms to seeking appropriate TB treatment among pulmonary TB (PTB) patients and investigate the factors associated with patient delay in Suneka sub-County, Kisii County, Kenya. A cross-sectional survey, using a semi-structured questionnaire, was carried out at five public health facilities in the sub-County. Data entry, management and analysis were done using SPSS Version 15. The mean patient delay and associations between length of patient delay and the various independent variables was determined. Multiple logistic regression was performed to determine the factors independently associated with patient delay. The mean patient delay was 54 days and 65.4% of the study subjects had delayed for more than 30 days. Delay in seeking appropriate TB treatment among PTB patients in Suneka sub-County was associated with poor perception of services in public health facilities (OR=4.91; CI=1.6-15.3; P=0.0061), visiting a private clinic (OR=4.24; CI=1.5-11.6; P=0.0052) and stigma (OR=2.46; CI=1.9-12.2; P=0.0178). Most PTB patients in Suneka sub-County delay in presenting at public health facilities after the onset of major TB symptoms and the main factors responsible for this delay include having a poor perception of the quality of services offered in public health facilities, prior attendance at a private clinic and stigma associated with the disease. Delay was not found to be associated with the patient socio-demographic characteristics, knowledge of TB, distance or transport cost to the nearest public health facility. Since TB services are integrated in the general health care system, the findings highlight the need by the Ministry of Health (MOH) to improve service delivery at public health facilities and thereby encourage patients to seek early diagnosis and treatment of communicable diseases or reduce patient delays. Educational campaigns should go beyond providing general information about TB to emphasize embracing a positive attitude of transmission reduction through early treatment.
Diagnosis Delay and Factors Associated with Delay Among Tuberculosis Patients in Mombasa County
  • J Limo
  • R Onyango
Limo, J., & Onyango, R. (2022). Diagnosis Delay and Factors Associated with Delay Among Tuberculosis Patients in Mombasa County, Kenya.