ArticlePublisher preview available

Suppressing strain propagation in ultrahigh-Ni cathodes during fast charging via epitaxial entropy-assisted coating

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

Surface reconstruction and the associated severe strain propagation have long been reported as the major cause of cathode failure during fast charging and long-term cycling. Despite tremendous attempts, no known strategies can simultaneously address the electro-chemomechanical instability without sacrificing energy and power density. Here we report an epitaxial entropy-assisted coating strategy for ultrahigh-Ni LiNixCoyMn1−x−yO2 (x ≥ 0.9) cathodes via an oriented attachment-driven reaction between Wadsley–Roth phase-based oxides and the layered-oxide cathodes. The high anti-cracking and anti-corrosion tolerances as well as the fast ionic transport of the entropy-assisted surface effectively improved the fast charging/discharging capability, wide temperature tolerance and thermal stability of the ultrahigh-Ni cathodes. Comprehensive analysis from the primary and secondary particle level to the electrode level using multi-scale in situ synchrotron X-ray probes reveals greatly reduced lattice dislocations, anisotropic lattice strain and oxygen release as well as improved bulk/local structural stability, even when charging beyond the threshold state of charge (75%) of layered cathodes.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Nature Energy | Volume 9 | March 2024 | 345–356 345
nature energy
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41560-024-01465-2
Article
Suppressing strain propagation in
ultrahigh-Ni cathodes during fast charging
via epitaxial entropy-assisted coating
Chen Zhao  1,9, Chuanwei Wang  2,9, Xiang Liu1, Inhui Hwang  3, Tianyi Li  3,
Xinwei Zhou4, Jiecheng Diao5,6, Junjing Deng  3, Yan Qin1, Zhenzhen Yang1,
Guanyi Wang4, Wenqian Xu  3, Chengjun Sun3, Longlong Wu  7, Wonsuk Cha3,
Ian Robinson  5,7, Ross Harder3, Yi Jiang  3, Tekin Bicer  3, Jun-Tao Li2,
Wenquan Lu  1, Luxi Li  3 , Yuzi Liu  4 , Shi-Gang Sun  8,
Gui-Liang Xu  1 & Khalil Amine  1
Surface reconstruction and the associated severe strain propagation
have long been reported as the major cause of cathode failure during fast
charging and long-term cycling. Despite tremendous attempts, no known
strategies can simultaneously address the electro-chemomechanical
instability without sacricing energy and power density. Here we
report an epitaxial entropy-assisted coating strategy for ultrahigh-Ni
LiNixCoyMn1−xyO2 (x ≥ 0.9) cathodes via an oriented attachment-driven
reaction between Wadsley–Roth phase-based oxides and the layered-oxide
cathodes. The high anti-cracking and anti-corrosion tolerances as well as
the fast ionic transport of the entropy-assisted surface eectively improved
the fast charging/discharging capability, wide temperature tolerance and
thermal stability of the ultrahigh-Ni cathodes. Comprehensive analysis
from the primary and secondary particle level to the electrode level using
multi-scale in situ synchrotron X-ray probes reveals greatly reduced
lattice dislocations, anisotropic lattice strain and oxygen release as well as
improved bulk/local structural stability, even when charging beyond the
threshold state of charge (75%) of layered cathodes.
The high energy densities of Ni-rich layered oxides have made them
promising cathodes for next-generation battery system to meet the
ever-increasing energy demands of electric vehicles
13
. However, the
intrinsic high reactivity of highly delithiated Ni-rich cathodes with
electrolytes has led to a series of persistent structural fatigue issues
including the layered-to-spinel/rock salt phase transformation
4
and
lattice oxygen loss5 at the surface or in near-surface structures, which
deteriorate the cathode–electrolyte interphase (CEI) and increase
the cell impedance. The reconstructed surface often further blocks
the transport of lithium ions and electrons, leading to severe local
charge heterogeneity from the particles across the entire electrodes
6,7
.
Coupled with the inherent anisotropic lattice variation of layered
Received: 22 May 2023
Accepted: 17 January 2024
Published online: 29 February 2024
Check for updates
1Chemical Sciences and Engineering Division, Argonne National Laboratory, Lemont, IL, USA. 2College of Energy, Xiamen University, Xiamen, China.
3X-ray Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory, Lemont, IL, USA. 4Center for Nanoscale Materials, Argonne National Laboratory, Lemont, IL, USA.
5London Centre for Nanotechnology, University College London, London, UK. 6Center for Transformative Science, ShanghaiTech University, Shanghai,
China. 7Condensed Matter Physics and Materials Science Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, NY, USA. 8Collaborative Innovation Center
of Chemistry for Energy Materials, State Key Laboratory Physical Chemistry of Solid Surfaces, Department of Chemistry, Xiamen University, Xiamen,
China. 9These authors contributed equally: Chen Zhao, Chuanwei Wang. e-mail: luxili@anl.gov; yuziliu@anl.gov; xug@anl.gov; amine@anl.gov
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved
... Ptychography is a versatile imaging technique used in materials science, biology, and nanotechnology [1], [2]. Xray ptychography, widely adopted at synchrotron facilities [3], enables detailed examination of large volumes in thick samples with minimal preparation, benefiting applications like imaging integrated circuits, biological specimens, and strain analysis in nanostructures [2], [4]- [6]. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Ptychography is a computational imaging technique that achieves high spatial resolution over large fields of view. It involves scanning a coherent beam across overlapping regions and recording diffraction patterns. Conventional reconstruction algorithms require substantial overlap, increasing data volume and experimental time. We propose a reconstruction method employing a physics-guided score-based diffusion model. Our approach trains a diffusion model on representative object images to learn an object distribution prior. During reconstruction, we modify the reverse diffusion process to enforce data consistency, guiding reverse diffusion toward a physically plausible solution. This method requires a single pretraining phase, allowing it to generalize across varying scan overlap ratios and positions. Our results demonstrate that the proposed method achieves high-fidelity reconstructions with only a 20% overlap, while the widely employed rPIE method requires a 62% overlap to achieve similar accuracy. This represents a significant reduction in data requirements, offering an alternative to conventional techniques.
Article
Full-text available
Niobium‐based oxides have emerged as promising anode materials for minute‐level fast‐charging lithium ion batteries. However, the atomic mechanisms of their ultrafast ionic kinetics remain an enigma due to limitations in experimental characterizations. Here, Li⁺ accommodation behaviors and corresponding lattice distortion of high‐rate Mo3Nb2O14 anode are directly observed at the atomic‐scale by combining scanning transmission electron microscopy and in situ X‐ray diffraction. The sequential insertion of Li⁺ into hexagonal, pentagonal, and tetragonal tunnels is resolved directly, verifying a three‐stage reaction mechanism with anisotropic lattice evolution. Atomic elemental imaging quantifies the Mo/Nb cation ordering rather than previously supposed as disordering. Quantitative symmetry analysis of oxygen polyhedra reveals the rigidity of the Nb polyhedra but the flexibility of the Mo polyhedra, which synergistically renders a stable framework with ultrafast ionic transport. These results provide atomic insights into cation‐specific roles in niobium‐based anode materials, thus paving the way for the rational design of high‐performance electrode materials.
Article
Full-text available
The degradation of Ni‐rich cathodes during long‐term operation at high voltage has garnered significant attention from both academia and industry. Despite many post‐mortem qualitative structural analyses, precise quantification of their individual and coupling contributions to the overall capacity degradation remains challenging. Here, by leveraging multiscale synchrotron X‐ray probes, electron microscopy, and post‐galvanostatic intermittent titration technique, the thermodynamically irreversible and kinetically reversible capacity loss is successfully deconvoluted in a polycrystalline LiNi0.83Mn0.1Co0.07O2 cathode during long‐term charge/discharge cycling in full cell configuration. Contradicting the dramatic capacity loss, the layered structure remains highly alive even after 1000 cycles at 4.6 V while undergoing a three‐order of magnitude reduction in the mass transfer kinetics, leading to almost fully recoverable capacity under kinetic‐free conditions. Such kinetic dormant behavior after cycling is not simply ascribed to poor chemical diffusion by reconstructed cathode surface but highly synchronizes with the lattice strain evolution stemming from the structural heterogeneity between deeply delithiated layered and degraded rock‐salt phases at high voltage. These findings deepen the degradation mechanism of high‐voltage cathodes to achieve long‐cycling and fast‐charging performance.
Article
The low specific capacity and the poor capacity retention at extreme fast charging/discharging limit the nickel-rich layered cathode commercialization in electric vehicles, and the root causes are interface instability and capacity loss induced by birth defects and irreversible phase transition. In this work, we propose a lattice reconstruction strategy combining polyvinylpyrrolidone-assisted wet chemistry and calcination to prepare the aluminum-modified LiNi0.83Co0.11Mn0.06O2 (ANCM). Our method offers distinct advantages in tailoring birth defects (residual alkali and rocksalt phase), reducing Li vacancies and oxygen vacancies, exhibiting gradient Ni concentration distribution, suppressing the Li/Ni intermixing defects, lowering the lattice strain before and after recycling, and inhibiting the microcracks. The ANCM constructs robust crystal lattices and delivers an initial discharge capacity of 155.3 mAh/g with 89.2% capacity retention after 200 cycles at 5 C. This work highlights the importance of synthesis design and structural modification for cathode materials.
Article
This review systematically discusses the structure, reaction mechanisms, and challenges as well as countermeasures for high-voltage Li-rich, LiCoO 2 , and Ni-rich cathode materials, attributing their anion redox activity to O 2p non-bonding states.
Article
Full-text available
Cell-level battery models, most of which rely on the successful porous electrode theories, effectively estimate cell performance. However, pinpointing the contributions of individual components of an electrode remains challenging. In...
Article
Full-text available
Elevating the charge voltage of LiCoO2 increases the energy density of batteries, which is highly enticing in energy storage implementation ranging from portable electronics to e‐vehicles. However, hybrid redox reactions at high voltages facilitate oxygen evolution, electrolyte decomposition and irreversible phase change, and accordingly lead to rapid battery capacity decay. Here significantly improved high‐voltage cycling stability of Mg‐Al‐Eu co‐doped LiCoO2 is demonstrated. It is found that element co‐doping induces a near‐surface high‐entropy zone, including an innately thin disordered rock‐salt shell and a dopant segregation surface. The high‐entropy complex can effectively suppress oxygen evolution and near‐surface structure deconstruction. The phase change reversibility between O3 and H1‐3 and thermal stability of the cathode are greatly enhanced as well. As a result, the co‐doped LiCoO2 exhibits a remarkable cycling performance, retaining 86.3% and 72.0% of initial capacity over 800 and 2000 cycles, respectively, with a high cut‐off voltage of 4.6 V. The feasible co‐doping approach broadens the perspective for the development of stable lithium‐ion batteries with high operating voltages.
Article
Full-text available
The formation of inactive lithium by side reactions with liquid electrolyte contributes to cell failure of lithium metal batteries. To inhibit the formation and growth of inactive lithium, further understanding of the formation mechanisms and composition of inactive lithium are needed. Here we study the impact of gas producing reactions on the formation of inactive lithium using ethylene carbonate as a case study. Ethylene carbonate is a common electrolyte component used with graphite-based anodes but is incompatible with Li metal anodes. Using mass spectrometry titrations combined with 13C and 2H isotopic labeling, we reveal that ethylene carbonate decomposition continuously releases ethylene gas, which further reacts with lithium metal to form the electrochemically inactive species LiH and Li2C2. In addition, phase-field simulations suggest the non-ionically conducting gaseous species could result in an uneven distribution of lithium ions, detrimentally enhancing the formation of dendrites and dead Li. By optimizing the electrolyte composition, we selectively suppress the formation of ethylene gas to limit the formation of LiH and Li2C2 for both Li metal and graphite-based anodes. The formation of electrochemically inactive, or “dead”, lithium limits the reversibility of lithium metal batteries. Here the authors elucidate the (electro)chemical roles of ethylene gas produced from electrolyte decomposition on the formation of inactive lithium.
Article
Full-text available
Coatings and surface passivation are sought to protect high-energy-density cathodes in lithium-ion batteries, which suffer from labile oxygen loss and fast degradations. Here we develop the theory underlying the high-voltage-induced oxygen evolution crisis and report a lanthurizing process to regulate the near-surface structure of energy materials beyond conventional surface doping. Using LiCoO2 as an example and generalizing to Co-lean/free high-energy-density layered cathodes, we demonstrate effective surface passivation, suppressed surface degradation and improved electrochemical performance. High-voltage cycling stability has been greatly enhanced, up to 4.8 V versus Li+/Li, including in practical pouch-type full cells. The superior performance is rooted in the engineered surface architecture and the reliability of the synthesis method. The designed surface phase stalls oxygen evolution reaction at high voltages. It illustrates processing opportunities for surface engineering and coating by high-oxygen-activity passivation, selective chemical alloying and strain engineering using wet chemistry. Surface coating is a common method to combat the performance degradation of layered oxide cathodes in rechargeable batteries. Here the authors analyse coating design principles and demonstrate that a lanthurizing coating approach—which alters the atomic structure just beneath the cathode surface—leads to exceptionally high-voltage cycling stability.
Article
Full-text available
X‐ray radiation damage on the measuring system has been a critical issue regularly for a long‐time exposure to X‐ray beam during the in operando characterizations, which is particularly severe when the applied X‐ray energy is near the absorption edges (M, L, K, etc.) of the interest element. To minimize the negative effects raised by beam radiation, we employ quick X‐ray absorption spectroscopy (QXAS) to study the electrochemical reaction mechanism of a Ni‐rich layered structure cathode for lithium‐ion batteries. With the advanced QXAS technique, the electronic structure and local coordination environment of the transition metals (TMs) are monitored in‐operando with limited radiation damage. Compared to the conventional step‐mode X‐ray absorption spectroscopy, the QXAS can provide more reliable oxidation state change and more detailed local structure evolutions surrounding TMs (Ni and Co) in Ni‐rich layered oxides. By leveraging these advantages of QXAS, we demonstrated that the Ni dominates the electrochemical process with the Co being almost electrochemically inactive. Reversible Ni ions movement between TMs sites and Li sites is also revealed by the time‐resolved QXAS technique.
Article
Full-text available
The use of state-of-the-art Ni-rich layered oxides (LiNixCoyMn1−x−yO2, x > 0.5) as the cathode material for lithium-ion batteries can push the energy and power density to a higher level than is currently available1,2. However, volume variation associated with anisotropic lattice strain and stress that is being developed during lithium (de)intercalation induces severe structural instability and electrochemical decay of the cathode materials, which is amplified further when the battery is operating at a high voltage (above 4.5 V), which is essential for unlocking its high energy3–6. Even after much effort by the research community, an intrinsic strain-retardant method for directly alleviating the continuous accumulation of lattice strain remains elusive. Here, by introducing a coherent perovskite phase into the layered structure functioning as a ‘rivet’, we significantly mitigate the pernicious structural evolutions by a pinning effect. The lattice strain evolution in every single cycle is markedly reduced by nearly 70% when compared with conventional materials, which significantly enhances morphological integrity leading to a notable improvement in battery cyclability. This strain-retardant approach broadens the perspective for lattice engineering to release the strain raised from lithium (de)intercalation and paves the way for the development of high-energy-density cathodes with long durability.
Article
Full-text available
The high volatility of the price of cobalt and the geopolitical limitations of cobalt mining have made the elimination of Co a pressing need for the automotive industry¹. Owing to their high energy density and low-cost advantages, high-Ni and low-Co or Co-free (zero-Co) layered cathodes have become the most promising cathodes for next-generation lithium-ion batteries2,3. However, current high-Ni cathode materials, without exception, suffer severely from their intrinsic thermal and chemo-mechanical instabilities and insufficient cycle life. Here, by using a new compositionally complex (high-entropy) doping strategy, we successfully fabricate a high-Ni, zero-Co layered cathode that has extremely high thermal and cycling stability. Combining X-ray diffraction, transmission electron microscopy and nanotomography, we find that the cathode exhibits nearly zero volumetric change over a wide electrochemical window, resulting in greatly reduced lattice defects and local strain-induced cracks. In-situ heating experiments reveal that the thermal stability of the new cathode is significantly improved, reaching the level of the ultra-stable NMC-532. Owing to the considerably increased thermal stability and the zero volumetric change, it exhibits greatly improved capacity retention. This work, by resolving the long-standing safety and stability concerns for high-Ni, zero-Co cathode materials, offers a commercially viable cathode for safe, long-life lithium-ion batteries and a universal strategy for suppressing strain and phase transformation in intercalation electrodes.
Article
Full-text available
Additive manufacturing produces net-shaped components layer by layer for engineering applications1–7. The additive manufacture of metal alloys by laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) involves large temperature gradients and rapid cooling2,6, which enables microstructural refinement at the nanoscale to achieve high strength. However, high-strength nanostructured alloys produced by laser additive manufacturing often have limited ductility3. Here we use L-PBF to print dual-phase nanolamellar high-entropy alloys (HEAs) of AlCoCrFeNi2.1 that exhibit a combination of a high yield strength of about 1.3 gigapascals and a large uniform elongation of about 14 per cent, which surpasses those of other state-of-the-art additively manufactured metal alloys. The high yield strength stems from the strong strengthening effects of the dual-phase structures that consist of alternating face-centred cubic and body-centred cubic nanolamellae; the body-centred cubic nanolamellae exhibit higher strengths and higher hardening rates than the face-centred cubic nanolamellae. The large tensile ductility arises owing to the high work-hardening capability of the as-printed hierarchical microstructures in the form of dual-phase nanolamellae embedded in microscale eutectic colonies, which have nearly random orientations to promote isotropic mechanical properties. The mechanistic insights into the deformation behaviour of additively manufactured HEAs have broad implications for the development of hierarchical, dual- and multi-phase, nanostructured alloys with exceptional mechanical properties. An additive manufacturing strategy is used to produce dual-phase nanolamellar high-entropy alloys that show a combination of enhanced high yield strength and high tensile ductility.
Article
Full-text available
Li- and Mn-rich (LMR) cathode materials that utilize both cation and anion redox can yield substantial increases in battery energy density1–3. However, although voltage decay issues cause continuous energy loss and impede commercialization, the prerequisite driving force for this phenomenon remains a mystery3–6 Here, with in situ nanoscale sensitive coherent X-ray diffraction imaging techniques, we reveal that nanostrain and lattice displacement accumulate continuously during operation of the cell. Evidence shows that this effect is the driving force for both structure degradation and oxygen loss, which trigger the well-known rapid voltage decay in LMR cathodes. By carrying out micro- to macro-length characterizations that span atomic structure, the primary particle, multiparticle and electrode levels, we demonstrate that the heterogeneous nature of LMR cathodes inevitably causes pernicious phase displacement/strain, which cannot be eliminated by conventional doping or coating methods. We therefore propose mesostructural design as a strategy to mitigate lattice displacement and inhomogeneous electrochemical/structural evolutions, thereby achieving stable voltage and capacity profiles. These findings highlight the significance of lattice strain/displacement in causing voltage decay and will inspire a wave of efforts to unlock the potential of the broad-scale commercialization of LMR cathode materials.
Article
Full-text available
Electrostatic dielectric capacitors are essential components in advanced electronic and electrical power systems due to their ultrafast charging/discharging speed and high power density. A major challenge, however, is how to improve their energy densities to effectuate the next-generation applications that demand miniaturization and integration. Here, we report a high-entropy stabilized Bi2Ti2O7-based dielectric film that exhibits an energy density as high as 182 J cm−3 with an efficiency of 78% at an electric field of 6.35 MV cm−1. Our results reveal that regulating the atomic configurational entropy introduces favourable and stable microstructural features, including lattice distorted nano-crystalline grains and a disordered amorphous-like phase, which enhances the breakdown strength and reduces the polarization switching hysteresis, thus synergistically contributing to the energy storage performance. This high-entropy approach is expected to be widely applicable for the development of high-performance dielectrics.
Article
Advances in solid-state batteries have primarily been driven by the discovery of superionic conducting structural frameworks that function as solid electrolytes. We demonstrate the ability of high-entropy metal cation mixes to improve ionic conductivity in a compound, which leads to less reliance on specific chemistries and enhanced synthesizability. The local distortions introduced into high-entropy materials give rise to an overlapping distribution of site energies for the alkali ions so that they can percolate with low activation energy. Experiments verify that high entropy leads to orders-of-magnitude higher ionic conductivities in lithium (Li)-sodium (Na) superionic conductor (Li-NASICON), sodium NASICON (Na-NASICON), and Li-garnet structures, even at fixed alkali content. We provide insight into selecting the optimal distortion and designing high-entropy superionic conductors across the vast compositional space.