DISASTER-CONSTRUCTION-AND-RECONSTRUCTION-el.v

Abstract

Disaster is a topic that connects social sciences, medicine,
ethics, geophysics, as well as other sciences and disciplines. However, besides the benefits of preventing and mitigating disaster’s
effects, this wide range of various sciences also contributes with
their various methodologies and accounts. One of the most intriguing issues arises from the epistemological and ethical differences in defining basic concepts in disaster studies. Disasters can
be natural or the result of an inadvertent or intentional human act.
Such events kill or injure a significant number of people, or disrupt
life in a society. Though not always unpredictable, they come with
an unexpected impact and shock . However, to revise
the concept or a part of it, it would be necessary to return and remind readers of the first reactions to and social concerns over the
global spread of the SARS-CoV-2 virus, which caused COVID-19 and
the Coronavirus Pandemic. Considering the general perspective
on disaster as an event that is opposed to normal time or everyday
life, opens the space for revising concepts due to the generalization of what is meant by normality. Some social group’s everyday
life could be comprehended as catastrophic with less chance to
improve in a shorter time, e.g., those who are homeless, people
with vulnerable jobs, discriminated and marginal groups, etc. Disaster also questions the legitimacy of a political system, due to poor
preparation plans, or using the disaster to transform short-term
paternalism into an authoritarian grip on people’s everyday lives

Full text

edited volumes
DISASTER CONSTRUCTION AND
RECONSTRUCTION. LESSONS
FROM COVID-19 FOR ETHICS,
POLITICS AND LAW
9
788670
932715
Disaster Construction and
Reconstruction: Lessons
from COVID-19 for Ethics,
Politics and Law
EDITORS: DÓNAL O’MATHÚNA, VESELIN MITROVIĆ
The volume DISASTER CONSTRUCTION AND
RECONSTRUCTION: LESSONS FROM COVID-19
FOR ETHICS, POLITICS AND LAW has at least two
general aims. One of the aims of this volume has
been to reduce the disaster risks by dealing with
the post-disaster recovery through chapters which
examine the pandemic consequences, either
through the most appropriate ethical accounts,
or new recommendations. Specic protocols
have even been developed for dealing with the
pandemic. This knowledge should be used in
future disasters. Considering resilience among the
marginal, challenge trials, debates on mandatory
vs. compulsory vaccination, vaccine hesitancy and
rejection, human security and rights, and political
and social polarisations this volume oers fresh
insights into the ethical approaches which could or
should be applied in a next pandemic. The second
aim has been to address dierent crises which could
be triggered by pandemics: crises in the health
care, social, political, economic, and other systems.
Pandemics can also lead to psychological and
other, more personal, crises. The recent pandemic
brought a globally accepted narrative that after this
pandemic, nothing would be the same. In economic,
political, and social terms, the world became
dierent. Thisvolume brings one perspective on
these changes.
The Book DISASTER CONSTRUCTION AND RECONSTRUCTION.
LESSONS FROM COVID-19 FOR ETHICS, POLITICS, AND LAW ex-
plores and presents social constructs lying under disaster prepared-
ness, resilience, population needs, the role of crisis communication
and its relation to politics and marginalization, all over embraced
with ethical principles being dened or being forgotten in all dis-
asters, specically in COVID-19 pandemic. The concept “lessons
learned” is inwrought in the text, not only as concept explained,
but also as concept deconstructed at many levels and critically
reviewed. The Book oers multi- and interdisciplinary insight in
various perspectives on COVID-19 pandemic, arguing on pros and
con of implemented actions and proposes measures for future
reduction of social vulnerability in such disasters.
Prof. Iskra Alexandra Nola
The book DISASTER CONSTRUCTION AND RECONSTRUCTION.
LESSONS FROM COVID-19 FOR ETHICS, POLITICS AND LAW aims
to bring together various scientic perspectives toward exploring
COVID-19 crises and downs, resulting in lessons that can serve rel-
evant social actors as guides in the future answer to the pandemic.
Overall, the Volume put an accent on the signicance of prepared-
ness as a precondition for minimizing potential social vulnerabili-
ties. With such an achieved goal, this book greatly impacts all social,
public health, and ethical disciplines.
Prof. Vladimir Vuletić
The volume DISASTER CONSTRUCTION AND RECONSTRUCTION.
LESSONS FROM COVID-19 FOR ETHICS, POLITICS AND LAW ad-
dresses various ethical, social, legal, and political issues surrounding
the COVID-19 pandemic in relation to different stakeholders’ meas-
ures to react to it. This is done by way of addressing selected issues
that, taken together, allow to paint a rich and exemplary picture of
the wide variety of issues. Accordingly, the volume covers contri-
butions from disciplines such as sociology, philosophy, and politics.
Chapters cover a lot of topical ground, and commendably comple-
ment each other, thereby ensuring the volume’s “wholeness”.
Michael Kühler, PhD
www.idn.org.rs
edited volumes
•AndrijaKrešićusvominašemvremenu
• КабољојдемографскојбудућностиСрбије
•Кaevropskomdruštvu–ograničenjaiperspektive
•Multiculturalism in Public Policies
•Dugi(ne)razvoj
•TraditionalandNon-TraditionalReligiosity
•Xenophobia,IdentityandNewForms
ofNationalism
•Филозофијакризеиотпора:
МисаоиделоЉубомираТадића
•ContemporaryIssuesandPerspectives
onGenderResearch
•DierentFormsofReligiosity
andtheModernWorld
•ContemporaryReligiousChanges:
FromDesecularizationtoPostsecularization
•StrategicStreams2019:
EuropeanElectionsandTheFutureofEurope
•Србија:род,политике,становништво
•Promišljanjaaktuelnihdruštvenihizazova:
Regionalniiglobalnikontekst
•KsenijaAtanasijević:
Omenićegovoritimojadela
•IzazoviodrživograzvojauSrbijiiEvropskojuniji
•PoliticalandEconomicSelf-Constitution:
Media,PoliticalCultureandDemocracy
•ResettingtheLeftinEurope:Challenges,
AttemptsandObstacles
•Kulturnaautonomijanacionalnihmanjina
usvetlučinjenica
•ДруштвенеихуманистичкенаукеуСрбији
•Životzaideju:MisaoideloĐuraŠušnjića
•Klimatskepromene–Pravniidruštveniizazovi
•MonitoringMinorityRights:Twenty-veYears
ofImplementationoftheFrameworkConvention
fortheProtectionofNationalMinorities
•GovernanceofEnvironmentalChallengesinPost-
Pandemic Era
•DisasterConstructionandReconstruction:
LessonsfromCOVID-19forEthics,PoliticsandLaw
Disaster Construction and Reconstruction: Lessons from COVID-19 for Ethics, Politics and Law

DISASTER CONSTRUCTION AND RECONSTRUCTION:


PUBLISHED BY
Institute of Social Sciences
Belgrade, 2024
PUBLISHER
Goran Bašić
REVIEWERS
Michael Kühler, PhD
Prof. Iskra Alexandra Nola
Prof. Vladimir Vuletić
SERIES
Edited Volumes
SERIES EDITOR
Veselin Mitrović
ISBN 978-86-7093-271-5

edited volumes
EDITORS
Dónal O’Mathúna
Veselin Mitrović
DISASTER
CONSTRUCTION AND
RECONSTRUCTION:
LESSONS FROM COVID-19
FORETHICS, POLITICS AND LAW

CONTENTS

5
contents
7
Veselin Mitrović, DónalO’Mathúna
PREFACE
I. INTRODUCTION
10
Veselin Mitrović, DónalO’Mathúna
DISASTERS REVISED
II. FROM SOCIAL AND ETHICAL PERSPECTIVE
IN COVID-19 TO DISASTER STUDIES
26
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, DónalO’Mathúna
A SCOPING REVIEW OF ETHICAL ARGUMENTS
ABOUTCOVID-19 VACCINE MANDATES
56
Miroslav Radenković
ETHICAL CHALLENGES AND HESITANCY ASSOCIATED WITH
(MANDATORY) VACCINATION AGAINST COVID-19
74
Zoran Todorović, Dragan Hrnčić
RESEARCH ETHICS ISSUES IN BASIC AND CLINICAL
STUDIES DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMICS
94
Veselin Mitrović
DETECTING RESILIENCE ISSUES AMONG MARGINAL
GROUPS AS ABIOETHICAL GOAL
112
Slađana Ćurčić
RETHINKING HUMAN SECURITY IN THE POST-COVID-19
WORLD – LESSONS LEARNED FROM THE HUMAN-CENTRIC
APPROACH TOHEALTHSECURITY

6
contents
III. DISCOURSES AND CONCEPTS OF LAW
AND POLITICS IN COVID-19
134
Michael Buckley
CONSTRUCTIVISM IN TIMES OF POLITICAL CRISIS
152
Karen da Costa, Shlomit Zuckerman
HUMAN RIGHTS AND ETHICS IN THE MANAGEMENT OF THE
COVID-19 PANDEMIC: THE EXPERIENCES OF BRAZIL AND ISRAEL
170
Pavle Nedić, Marko Mandić
BETWEEN SECURITIZATION AND DESECURITIZATION: THE
SHIFTING DISCOURSE ON THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC IN SERBIA
190
Mirjana Dokmanović
TOWARDS GLOBAL HEALTH GOVERNANCE OR TOWARDS
GLOBAL CONTROL OF STATES AND PEOPLE?
216
Jovo Bakić
THE ATTITUDE OF FAR-RIGHT ORGANISATIONS TOWARDS
MEASURES AGAINST THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC IN SERBIA 2020–2022
239
ABOUT THE AUTHORS

7
edited volumes
Preface
-

-
-

-




-


Disasters: Core Concepts and Ethical Theories
-

-



8
Preface
-



-

-
-


-
-






Veselin Mitrović & Dónal O’Mathúna


I
INTRODUCTION

10
eelin Mirović, nal Mana dior oreord
eelin Mirović, nal Mana

11
edited volumes
Disasters Revised
 een and ili o ial, eal, Poliial,
and oial e in e een Pandei

-


-
-





-




-



-








12
eelin Mirović, nal Mana

-



-







-





-






-


-




-




13
edited volumes


-
-
-



-


-



-




-

-
-










-




14
eelin Mirović, nal Mana


-
-




-



-















-







-


15
edited volumes


-



-



-

-





-
-
-

-



-

-



-

-




16
eelin Mirović, nal Mana
-
-


-
-



-






-

-



-

-




-
-

-



-


17
edited volumes
-






-

-
-





-




2. Contributions

-


-
-
-








18
eelin Mirović, nal Mana




2.1. From Social and Ethical Perspective in COVID-19
toDisaster Studies
-


-
-

-
-

-





-


-

-
-



-


-


19
edited volumes

-
-

-



-
-




-





-




-

-


-



-




20
eelin Mirović, nal Mana





-





-

-


-





-
-

-


-




-


-


21
edited volumes

-








-
-




-







2.2. Discourses and Concepts of Law and Politics
inCOVID-19
-


-


-

-


22
eelin Mirović, nal Mana








-



-






-
-


-




-


-
-

-




23
edited volumes



-

-

-
-

-

-


-








REFERENCES
-
What is aDisaster. New Answers to Old Question

-
Proceedings of the Fourth International Symposium on Land-
slides
En-
cyclopedia of Natural Hazards.

The Wounded Storyteller-


24
Veselin Mitrović, Dónal O’Mathúna

Disaster Prevention and Management

-

Disasters:
Core Concepts and Ethical Theories



.Sociološki pregled

-
ZEMO



Ethics for Disaster


II
M  N 
PP N 
TO DISASTER STUDIES

26
ia aider
ia aider
Ministry of Health, Saudi Arabia
Annie Silleck
The Ohio State University, USA
nal Mana
College of Nursing and Center for Bioethics,
The Ohio State University, USA

27
edited volumes
 oin evie o ial ren
ao aine Mandae
Abstract -


-


-




-
-






Keywords

1. Introduction
-
-








28
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna

-

-

-



 iorial akrond

-



-
-
















-



29
edited volumes

-


-






-
-


-

-
-

-
-
-


-
-


-


-

-




30
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna

-
-

-


-
-




-








-


-

-

-
-






31
edited volumes
 


-
-







-
-
-




-
-




-






-


-


32
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna

-











 evie Meodolo


-

-


-



-

-





-



33
edited volumes



4.1. Identication of Research Question
-
-







-


-

Table 1.
PICO(T) term liaion iin or oin revie
Population General population
Intervention COVID-19 vaccination
Comparison Mandatory versus non-mandatory, or compulsory
versus non-compulsory
Outcomes Ethical reasons or arguments related to mandatory
COVID-19 vaccination practices
Type of studies Any type of study
4.2. Identication of relevant studies





34
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna
-



-
-




4.3. Selection of the eligible studies
-







4.4. Data extraction and analysis
-
-


-


-



35
edited volumes
 evie el
5.1. Collating and summarizing data and reporting the results
-
-
-



-
-

Figure 1.
5.2. Characteristics of the included articles
-
-



36
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna
Figure 2.
-



Figure 3.



-






37
edited volumes
-

Table 2.

Number ee ee
1 Freedoms
Freedom of conscience
Freedom of religion
Freedom of belief
Freedom of thought
Liberty
Negative liberty
Autonomy
2 Rights
Right to life
Right to freedom
Right to health
Right to make decision
Right to treatment
Right to free movement
Right to information
Parents rights
Right to education
Right to information on adverse events
Right to refuse
3 Duties
Duty towards society
Duty towards care of the patient
Duty towards family
Duty towards children
Duty towards elderly
4Other Ethics
Concepts
Solidarity
Dignity
Utilitarianism
Benecence
Non-malecence
Justice
Fairness
Informed Consent
5Public Health
Protection

38
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna
Number ee ee
6 Vaccine Science
Herd Immunity
Vaccine safety
Vaccine eectiveness
Preventive measure
Burden of the disease
Vaccine licensing
7 Vaccine hesitancy
8Policy and
pragmatic issues
Vaccine availability
Using least restrictive alternatives
Free-riders (the unvaccinated beneting
from those vaccinated)
Incentives and penalties
Exemptions (religious and/or medical)
 Main ial ren or Mandain 
Vaccines

-



6.1. Harm prevention
-
-


-



-



39
edited volumes
-

-
-







-
-

-


-









-
-


-







40
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna




6.2. Public health protection
-
-





-




-
-
-

-
-




-

-


-
-



41
edited volumes


-
-



-




-






-

6.3. Herd immunity



-
-










42
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna


-

-




-












-
-


-


6.4. Autonomy

-





43
edited volumes



-


-
-








-




6.5. Freedom of belief and religion




-


-







44
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna

-





-













-



 Main ial ren aain Mandain
 aine
7.1. Liberty and freedom








45
edited volumes



-



-



-

-

-
-

-
-


-



-
-

7.2. Informed consent



-



46
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna




-


-





-
-




-


-

7.3. Vaccine safety
-






-




47
edited volumes
-



-










7.4. Right to refuse




-



-


-





-
-


48
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna


8. Discussion
-

-
-















-
-



-




-
-



49
edited volumes






-

9. Conclusion
-

-


-


-


-

-




-
-
-







50
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna




-





-


-

-





-


-




-



-





51
edited volumes
REFERENCES

Journal
of Multidisciplinary Healthcare




-
International Journal of Social Research Methodology



-
-
Vaccine


The Lancet,
Principles of biomedical ethics

-

Alberta Law Review, 
-
Quality & Quantity




The Public Health Act C.C.S.M. c.
P210






52
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna


-
Sustainability
Mandatory Vaccinations: Precedent and
Current Laws




-

-
Vaccines





-
The Guardian


-




Vaccines


-



British Medical Bulletin


American Journal of Public Health,


53
edited volumes
-

PLOS ONE




-

-

-


BMJ
Global Health


-
European Journal of Pediatrics,  

-
Figshare


Public Health Reports,

National Geographic




Nature Human Behaviour

-


Facets


54
Zia Haider, Annie Silleck, Dónal O’Mathúna


Expert Review of Vaccines

Journal of
Applied Philosophy


-
Journal of Law and
the Biosciences










Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,

-
Procedia in Vaccinology

Jour-
nal of Medical Ethics


Human Rights Quarterly






-


55
edited volumes
-
Journal of Vaccines
& Vaccination

Medical Principles and Practice: International Journal of
the Kuwait University, Health Science Centre




World Health Organ-
isation


-



-

World Health Organization

Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pan-
demic




56
Mirolav adenković
Mirolav adenković
University of Belgrade, Faculty of Medicine
Department of Pharmacology,
Clinical Pharmacology andToxicology

57
edited volumes
ial allene and eian oiaed
i Mandaor ainaion aain

Abstract -


-



-


-


-


-
-




-
-


Keywords-

1. Introduction
-

-


58
Mirolav adenković

-

-
.

-





-


-


-
-









-


-






59
edited volumes



-

 e noraion and e 

-


-

-




-







-




-
-

-



60
Mirolav adenković







-

-







-



 aine eian
-




-


-
-





61
edited volumes


-

-


-

-


-



-

-
-



-




-
-

-

-

-
-


62
Mirolav adenković


-
-
-

-



4. Mandatory Vaccination


-





-
-




-
-



-

-




63
edited volumes

-



-


-
-


-




-




-






-


-
-

-



64
Mirolav adenković


-


-


-
-








-


-



 ial e






-




65
edited volumes
-



-
-



-



-


-
-




-


-

-











66
Mirolav adenković







-

-




-


-



-


-

-




-







67
edited volumes
-




-
-



-










-

-

 re e
-

-


-





68
Mirolav adenković

-


-
-











-
-

REFERENCES

-


-
World development

-

Clinicachimicaacta; international jour-
nal of clinical chemistry, 

-
The Lancet. In-
fectious diseases, 


69
edited volumes

The Lancet. Infec-
tious diseases, 

-

-
Viruses, 
-
Journal of Clinical Research and Bioeth-
ics, 



Mayo Clinic proceedings, 

-

Annals of internal medicine

-


-

The
Lancet. Public health, 



-

-
British journal of nursing (Mark Al-
len Publishing), 

-
-
BMJ global health, 


70
Miroslav Radenković


Vaccines. Kidney360, 



-

Euro surveillance
: bulletin Europeen sur les maladies transmissibles = European com-
municable disease bulletin, 


BMJ (Clinical research ed.), 


-
-
International journal of environmental research and public health,


Lung India : ocial organ
of Indian Chest Society, 



-
Vaccines, 



The Medical journal of Australia,



NPJ vaccines, 


Annals of internal medicine, 


71
edited volumes


JAMA network open, 

-

Trends in immunology


BMJ (Clinical research ed.), 


-
-

Nature communi-
cations


-



BMJ (Clinical re-
search ed.), 
-
-
Frontiers in public
health, 
-
Pediatrics, 


-
Human vaccines &immunotherapeutics,

-
Heading Towards Humans Again: Bioethics in the New Age
of Science


72
Miroslav Radenković


Vaccine


American journal of public health, 



-
Vaccine,


Journal of medical ethics, 



ArXiv


Social Science