Article

An ethnographic study of police culture in a rural Kansas police agency

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Purpose The study examined rural police culture in one Kansas police agency. Design/methodology/approach This study used a qualitative ethnographic approach using in-depth interviews and non-participant observations to construct and interpret the culture of rural police through the lens of officers working in one rural police agency. Findings Five themes were found that described the complexities rural police officers face at this research site, including the law being at the center of officers’ actions, the nature of crime, officers serving as jack of all trades, community relationships and enforcement of crimes by teenagers, and how outside pressures from the community and increased concern for citizens' safety affect officers' daily lived experiences. Originality/value There is a dearth of scholarly literature addressing rural and small-town policing. This study is the first known qualitative study to be conducted on rural Kansas police, allowing a snapshot of the workings of rural Kansas police.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
In rural areas, police experience unique work-related health and safety risks attributable to a multitude of factors, ranging from inaccessible backup to navigating inclement weather alongside geographic obstacles. Although the result of institutional and organizational structures, operational (job content) and organizational (job context) risk must be recontextualized in the rural context. In the current study, I contextualize understandings of risk, referring to a lack of safety shaped by either a physical, administrative, legal, or emotional feeling of vulnerability—or a combination of such—for rural officers that results from occupational experiences of understaffing and insufficient material resources. Drawing on transcripts from 14 focus groups with 49 officers across rank, I extrapolate the effects of understaffing on officer experiences of work-role overload and the resulting stress. Findings reveal how officers’ perceptions of risk are impacted by such factors, and how risk is interpreted as either preventable (i.e., organizational) or unavoidable (i.e., operational). In this context, risk knowledges of occupational realities shape the occupational role and well-being of officers working in rural and remote detachments. Preliminary policy implications are presented.
Article
Full-text available
This research uses the responses from more than 500 officers serving a Midwestern city to understand their perceptions of themselves, fellow officers, the police department, neighborhood organizations, and the larger community in relation to community policing. Based on this data, the authors explore how community policing might be used to create a greater convergence of purpose among citizens, neighborhoods, organizations, and the broader well-being of the community. Findings indicate that officers doubt the ability of citizens to rise above their own self-interest, but they think that they and their fellow officers can do so. Furthermore, findings suggest the need for an overarching community agenda to prevent neighborhoods from becoming “civic cocoons” and to promote convergence of purpose between neighborhoods and the broader community. Finally, this research suggests that police departments that engage in transparent decision making that carefully balances departmental and community interests are better able to encourage this collaboration.
Article
Full-text available
Contingency theory argues that the performance of an organization is contingent on how well it fits the context within which it is embedded. This study explores the public-safety concerns of nearly 6,000 law enforcement agencies serving populations less than 50,000. Property offenses, domestic violence, and drugs were the most frequently reported concerns, whereas gangs and violent crimes were often ranked lower. Rankings of public-safety concerns varied across agencies and were affected by population density, violent and property crime, type of agency, department size, and region. Findings suggest that the context in which police organizations are located plays a role in shaping public-safety concerns, which is an important step in broadening our knowledge about the priorities, goals, and behaviors of police organizations.
Article
Full-text available
Police researchers have long speculated on the importance that culture plays in the everyday functioning of officers. Most characterizations of police culture focus on describing the various elements and facets of a single phenomenon among occupational members (e.g., group loyalty, crime fighter image, organizational tension with supervisors, etc.). Little work has been done in synthesizing what we “know” about this occupational culture, as textbook depictions highlight broad generalizations that tend to differ from text to text. A conceptual model of the police occupational culture is presented here that explains its causes, prescriptions, and outcomes. This monolithic model is then critiqued based on research that highlights the complexity of culture, noting variation across organizations and within by rank and style. The article also assesses the ways in which police culture thought is beginning to change, as departments diversify demographically and philosophically. The article concludes with recommendations for future studies of police culture.
Article
The code of silence—the informal prohibition of reporting misconduct by fellow police officers—has long been viewed as a serious obstacle in control of police misconduct and achievement of police accountability. The purpose of this article is to study the key correlates of police officers’ reluctance to report. Relying upon a theory of police integrity and the accompanying methodology to study the code, a police integrity survey was administered in 2013 and 2014 to measure the contours of police integrity among 604 police officers from 11 police agencies located in the Midwest and the East Coast of the United States. The questionnaire contains descriptions of 11 scenarios describing various forms of police misconduct, each followed by seven questions measuring officer views of scenario seriousness, the appropriate and expected discipline, and willingness to report misconduct. Multivariate analyses reveal that the key factor related to the police officers’ reluctance to report is the perception that the other officers would not report. The code is also negatively related to familiarity with the official rules, evaluation of misconduct as serious, and the expectation of harsher discipline. The methodology can be used either by the police agencies themselves or by the civilian oversights to assess the nature and extent of the code in the police agency.
Article
Using a factorial designed survey instrument, this study represents one of the first attempts to comprehensively assess situational, officer, organisational, and neighbourhood factors effecting the decision of officers to arrest juveniles in the rural U.S. Findings suggest that situational, officer, and organisational characteristics affect the decision to arrest in rural communities. Officers were more likely to arrest juveniles who were older, disrespectful, under the influence of alcohol/drugs, and committed a more serious offence. Officers who were white, better educated, had children, had more juvenile case experience, had more frequent juvenile training, showed less favourable attitudes towards rehabilitation, and showed more favourable attitudes towards court sanctions at younger ages were more likely to arrest juveniles. Additionally, officers from smaller departments, state agencies, and non-watchman style departments were significantly more likely to arrest. Overall, the strongest indicator of arrest was seriousness of offence as juveniles committing a more serious offence were nearly eight times more likely to be arrested. Directions for future research are addressed.
Article
The focus of this article is to examine the relationship between police culture and community policing (CP) and the extent to which this culture is an obstacle or enabler of the successful implementation of CP. Drawing data from a sample of 1970 officers assigned to three distinct police functions (patrol, plainclothes, and airports in Turkey), we employed structural equation modelling to examine two issues: the relationship between six identified dimensions of police culture (authoritarianism, cynicism, social cohesion, loyalty, work alienation, and autonomy) and assessing possible noninvariance in their attitudes toward CP among officers assigned across the three police functions. Findings suggest that while social cohesion, loyalty, and cynicism are positively related to support CP, autonomy and alienation are negatively related to support CP. The multigroup analyses indicated that, overall, police officers’ departmental assignment does not affect their attitudes toward CP.
Article
Purpose Much of the commentary about police culture treats it as a monolithic and problematic feature of the police occupation that inhibits change and progress. The purpose of this paper is to draw on surveys completed by over 13,000 sworn police to describe officers’ occupational outlooks and explore the extent to which they vary across individuals and police agencies. Design/methodology/approach This paper draws upon employee survey data from 89 US police and sheriff departments collected in 2014-2015 to examine police culture through officers’ views of the community, police work, and police administration and to explore the extent to which these beliefs and opinions are affected by personal characteristics and organizational affiliation. Findings Results indicate that officers’ perspectives are more positive than might be expected and do not vary greatly by officer personal characteristics. They differ more substantially across police agencies. This suggests that police culture is to a significant extent an organizational phenomenon, not simply an occupational one. Originality/value Examining the views and perspectives of over 13,000 sworn police employed in 89 different police organizations provides a more representative and generalizable picture of police culture than previous studies that typically analyzed officers in only one police department.
Article
This title offers an ethnographical investigation of contemporary police culture based on fieldwork across a range of ranks and units in the UK police force. By drawing on over 600 hours of direct observation of operational policing in urban and rural areas and interviews with over 60 officers, the author assesses what impact three decades of social, economic, and political change have had on police culture. The book offers understandings of the policing of ethnicity, gender, and sexuality, and the ways in which reform initiatives are accommodated and resisted within the police force. The author also explores the attempts of one force to effect cultural change both to improve the working conditions of staff and to deliver a more effective and equitable service to all groups in society. Beginning with a review of the literature on police culture from 30 years ago, the author goes on to outline the new social, economic, and political field of contemporary British policing. Taking this as a starting point, the remaining chapters present the main findings of the empirical research in what is a comprehensive analysis of present-day policing culture.
Article
Purpose – Policing is associated with a pronounced occupational subculture. Policing is also known for physical and mental stressors that are, arguably, more than other professions. The purpose of this paper is to hypothesize that those police officers who perceive themselves as not a part of the subculture (i.e. “out-group”) would experience more occupational stress in comparison to those who perceive themselves as a part of it (i.e. “in-group”). Design/methodology/approach – The authors use data from the Work and Family Services for Law Enforcement Personnel in the US survey (Delprino, 1997) and OLS regression to assess the direct association between officers’ perceptions of policing subculture membership and occupational stress. Findings – Results support the hypothesis, with in-group officers reporting significantly less occupational stress than out-group officers. This finding holds, with slight variations, when demographic and experiential variables are introduced as controls. Research limitations/implications – Findings are from an earlier survey and based on responses from 1,632 officers in 51 agencies. They are geographically limited. Practical implications – The importance of the protective function of subculture needs to be taken into account when attempting to deal with police stress. Social implications – This study provides ideas on how departments can utilize occupational subcultures to deal with the stress experienced by members. Originality/value – The relationship between police subculture and stress has not been examined empirically before. This study documents the positive impact of police subculture in terms of helping members deal with stress.
Article
The past three decades have seen an increase in research on the attitudes of juveniles toward the police. This research suggests that juveniles are generally less positive in their attitudes toward the police than are adults. However, most research on juvenile attitudes has focused on youth residing in metropolitan areas, ignoring the role of geographical location in explaining perceptions. Using survey data, the present study examined the attitudes of rural youth toward the police. The findings suggest that although the level of support among rural teenagers did not mirror the levels found within the adult literature, rural teenagers may be more supportive of the police than their metropolitan counterparts. Furthermore, whereas White teenagers were generally more positive in their perception of the police than were Black teenagers, race was not a significant predictor of attitudes toward the police. Still, many of the variables identified as theoretically relevant in the existing literature were significant predictors of the attitudes of juveniles residing in rural areas.
Article
The study of criminal justice in the United States has maintained a consistent urban focus. While this is to some degree understandable, valuable comparative perspectives are lost w hen rural areas are ignored. The present study attempts to lay a groundwork for the studi' of rural police. The literature that addresses the impact of communit v and political structures upon stiles of policing is reviewed. Though they are few in number, studies that have examined rural settings indicate a marked difference in the nature of police behavior. This work attempts to document that e vpectation. This is an exploratorY studi' that wvas conducted through the use offield-research techniques. The determinants of police action were sought in a number of contexts. Both formal and informal community structures were examined to understand the motivation for police action. Like their urban counterparts, rural police patrols were observed to be primarily reactive in nature. This was due to the thorough integration of the police into the informal normative si stem. Because consensus about the tolerable limits of crime and deviance was Widespread, the sheriffs department was able to provide services largely compatible with the desires of the public. Four specific kinds of situations (trqffic offenses, drunks, domestic affairs and felonies) are presented to further illustrate this point. The behavior of rural police was most like that of urban officers in matters of less discretion felonies. The paper concludes hb, identi/fing the bulA of ruralpatrol as (consensual in nature.
Article
Community policing has become a popular approach. Discussions of community policing have focused on urban and suburban departments, generally ignoring rural and small town police organizations. Ironically, many of these departments have a history of practices that correspond directly to the principles of community policing. For example, officers in these agencies typically know the citizens personally, have frequent face-to-face contact with them, and engage in a variety of problem-solving activities that fall outside of law enforcement. In neglecting small town and rural police, researchers have denied themselves an important natural laboratory for studying community policing.
Article
This paper examines the 'Blue Code of Silence' and its contribution to police corruption. After offering evidence for the existence of such a code, the paper locates the origins of the code in the work and culture of policing. The paper also examines cases, commission reports and an original case study to understand how the code is reinforced. Based on 'participant observation' research of the New York County Prosecutor's Official Corruption Unit, the paper also illustrates how the code impedes investigations by police overseers. Finally, the paper discusses various measures to address the code of silence.
Article
This paper deals with the question of the extent to which the ambitions of community policing are realized in practice. Five elements may be considered as the main ambitions of community policing: proximity, a focus on a wide range of problems in the neighbourhood, prevention, cooperation with other agencies and the promotion of citizen involvement. This observational study of community policing in the Netherlands shows that in practice, these ambitions are only realized to a limited extent. This implementation deficit is a result of several factors: the vague, blurred professional image of community policing (in many cases also for community police officers themselves), its open and indefinite nature, the way this work is often embedded within police organizations, the limited capacities, skills and expertise of community police officers and the increasing managerial emphasis in the Dutch police on so-called core business tasks.
Article
Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to show that policing research frequently commits two errors: focusing on urban police units and failing to incorporate theory. The current research considers the policing style adopted by officers in a rural setting and tests the utility of Work Redesign, a theory that explains the importance and role of satisfaction with work. Design/methodology/approach – Rural police officers in community policing and traditional motorized patrol assignments were surveyed regarding policing style, the perceived importance of various tasks, and time allocation. Findings – Findings suggest that community policing has a role in rural areas; however, officers generally endorse the practices of traditional motorized patrol uniformly while only community policing officers endorse COP practices. Research limitations/implications – Although generalizing findings derived from several police agencies to other agencies should be done with caution, the findings are potentially important to agency decision makers regarding assignment and implementation of community policing programs. Originality/value – This paper is of interest to those investigating: the impacts of assignment at the officer level, community policing, the influence of job satisfaction on work, and rural law enforcement.
Article
Much has been written about policing in America. We know a good deal about its structure and function, operations, culture, etc. Based on this wealth of knowledge, we have drawn conclusions about the causes of observed dysfunctions in the institutional arrangements of policing. This has led, from time to time, to a variety of police reform efforts, the most recent of which is the furor over community policing. Some have argued that police policy has been driven by research conducted for and in urban American police departments and that the portability of those policies to rural American police departments may be inappropriate. This paper seeks to explore the urban/rural divide by comparing the attitudes of police officers from a large urban American police department with those of police officers from five small town rural American police departments. Significant differences in the attitudes between the urban and rural American police officers are found and the implications, pursuant to the limited generalizability of these findings, are examined.
Article
Studied American public opinion toward alternate operational strategies for police services, using data from the ABC News Poll of Public Opinion on Crime. The analysis examined preferences of 2,447 adults (aged 18+ yrs) for alternate police strategies in relation to demographic characteristics and cognate attitudinal measures. Results show 57% of Ss felt that police should respond only to calls for help that the caller says involves a crime or suspected crime. Preference for full-service policing (FSP) was higher among Blacks, older persons, residents of small towns and rural areas, residents of the Northeast, residents of predominately Black neighborhoods, and residents of age-homogeneous neighborhoods. Attitudinal measures provided indirect support for the contention that preference for FSP may be related to a perceived lack of alternative resources rather than perception of crime. It is concluded that adoption of an operational strategy that focuses on police resources on crime calls to the exclusion of service and order maintenance functions is likely to be in opposition to the preferences of nearly one-half of the US public. (21 ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Much of the prior literature concerning police behavior has focused on the activities and citizen interactions of officers employed by large agencies located in urban jurisdictions. Using data collected through the systematic observation of police officers employed by small-town and rural agencies, the present study explores issues related to the work of police officers in smaller jurisdictions. Specifically, we present observational data that provides a detailed description of how these officers spend time on their shifts. In addition, observational data is used to identify the problems these officers confronted, as well as their relationship with the citizens they encountered. Similarities and differences between observed small-town and rural officers and their more urban counterparts are identified and discussed.
On the beat: interactions and relations in rural and urban police forces
  • M Cain
Cain, M. (1971), "On the beat: interactions and relations in rural and urban police forces", in Cohen, S. (Ed.), Images of Deviance, Penguin, New York, NY, pp. 62-67.
Rural police job functions
  • B Maguire
  • W Faulkner
  • R Mathers
  • C Rowland
Maguire, B., Faulkner, W., Mathers, R. and Rowland, C. (1991), "Rural police job functions", Police Studies: The International Review of Police Development, Vol. 14 No. 4, pp. 180-187.
  • C Moustakas
Moustakas, C. (1994), Phenomenological Research Methods, Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA, Los Angeles, CA.
A Study of Police: A Comprehensive Study of the World's Greatest, yet Most Difficult
  • N E Trautman
Trautman, N.E. (1990), A Study of Police: A Comprehensive Study of the World's Greatest, yet Most Difficult, Profession, Charles C Thomas, Springfield, IL.