Article

Reimagining Organicism: An Ecological Aesthetics of Music and Self-Organizing Structures in the Works of Salvatore Sciarrino

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

Does it make sense to refer to musical sounds as “animated beings”? What does it mean to treat music as an essential part of our sonic reality? How do Sciarrino’s music and his general aesthetic, both of which he describes as organic or ecological, respond to theories of organicism, ecological approaches to musical perception, and ties between the human and non-human worlds? In this article, I attempt to weave together a framework that facilitates fruitful answers to these questions. The starting points for this theorization of Sciarrino’s organicism are Holly Watkins’s (2017, 2018) biotic aesthetics of music and Eric Clarke’s (2005) ecological approach to the perception of musical meaning, which emphasize the role of the listener and question the stance that separates meaning from form, culture from nature, and the human from the non-human. Through analyses of examples from works including Lohengrin, Azione invisibile (1982–84), Il cerchio tagliato dei suoni (1997), and Studi per l’intonazione del mare (2000), I argue that Sciarrino’s music and thinking venture into a holistic reinvention of organicism. A key aspect of this organicism is its formal affinity with behaviors characteristic of systems of chaos, including self-similarity, circularity, and turbulence. In addition, I illustrate how the wide-ranging analogies that Sciarrino’s music draws to the world of animate and inanimate beings involve both formal issues and the bodily, performative, and societal dimensions of music-making.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Le mythème du Chaos est étudié à travers les oeuvres vocales de Xenakis. Il est représentatif de l’histoire, des préoccupations et de la sensibilité « contemporaines » (de la fin du XX e siècle) : bien que s’inspirant de l’Antiquité grecque, le traitement du texte oscille entre les pôles de l’abstraction pure et de l’expression signifiante. Furieux, tempétueux, le chaos xenakien peut résulter du traumatisme, de la folie, de la guerre, désigner l’état de ce qui n’a pas de forme, la béance, le déluge, la genèse, la perdition, être transition, processus, représenter l’Origine ou la Fin du monde. Ainsi le compositeur a-t-il voulu « traiter des abîmes » par la vocalité soliste ou chorale, remonter à « toute la richesse cosmique, mais chaotiquement ». Cet article ouvre un diptyque dont le second volet s’intitule « La Grande Mère néolithique dans Serment-Orkos » (publié par le Centre Iannis Xenakis, Université de Rouen). Le postulat est le suivant : les sciences dites du « chaos » et de la « complexité » relèvent elles-mêmes d’une anthropologie de l’imaginaire. Par ailleurs, il s’inscrit dans un champ de recherche sur la transdiction (notion explicitée sur le site du CEREdI, Université de Rouen), c’est-à-dire sur le son et la corporéité des transferts musico-littéraires.
Article
Sciarrino’s writings describe a compositional philosophy that prizes multidimensionality and spatiotemporal discontinuity (1998, 2004). Yet his simultaneous allegiance to teleology, holism, and fractal hierarchies reveals an underlying unifying organicism with which these qualities may initially seem to conflict. I take Sciarrino’s 1999 piano concerto Recitativo oscuro as a case study for examining the composer’s gestural organicism and its various contradictions and double meanings. First, close analysis of the opening piano solo demonstrates how seemingly contradictory aesthetic priorities—organic unity and temporal multiplicity—co-exist within a single passage. Drawing from Kramer’s (1988) concept of “gestural time,” Hatten’s (2004) theory of gesture, segmentation theories, and scholarship on intensity and temporal function, I show how temporal multiplicity in the piano solo arises through conflict between gestural energetics and contextual segmentation. I then expand my analysis to the full concerto, arguing that the orchestra’s cyclic and naturalistic sonic ecosystem causes the piano gestures to take on representative functions in addition to their energetic syntax, creating what Sciarrino (2001) calls “dimensional intermittence” as they reference distant temporal realms both within and beyond the concerto. I conclude by arguing that while the intensity profile of the earliest gestures and phrases is eventually reproduced across the form of the entire work, the concerto’s form nevertheless resists reductive understanding. Instead, listeners are invited to hear form through the complex mechanics and idiosyncrasies of “gestural behavior” (Sciarrino 1998).
Book
Kramer was one of the most visionary musical thinkers of the second half of the 20th century. In his The Time of Music, he approached the idea of the many different ways that time itself is articulated musically. This book has become influential among composers, theorists, and aestheticians. Now, in his almost completed text written before his untimely death in 2004, he examines the concept of postmodernism in music. Kramer created a series of markers by which we can identify postmodern works. He suggests that the postmodern project actually creates a radically different relationship between the composer and listener. Written with wit, precision, and at times playfully subverting traditional tropes to make a very serious point about this difference, Postmodern Music, Postmodern Listening leads us to a strongly grounded intellectual basis for stylistic description and an intuitive sensibility of what postmodernism in music entails. Postmodern Music, Postmodern Listening is an examination of how musical postmodernism is not just a style or movement, but a fundamental shift in the relationship between composer and listener. The result is a multifaceted and provocative look at a critical turning point in music history, one whose implications we are only just beginning to understand. - See more at: http://www.bloomsbury.com/uk/postmodern-music-postmodern-listening-9781501306044/#sthash.vxYmlumU.dpuf
Book
By the start of the 21st century many of the foundations of postwar culture had disappeared: Europe had been rebuilt and, as the EU, had become one of the world’s largest economies; the United States’ claim to global dominance was threatened; and the postwar social democratic consensus was being replaced by market-led neoliberalism. Most importantly of all, the Cold War was over, and the World Wide Web had been born. Music After The Fall considers contemporary musical composition against this changed backdrop, placing it in the context of globalization, digitization, and new media. Drawing on theories from the other arts, in particular art and architecture, it expands the definition of Western art music to include forms of composition, experimental music, sound art, and crossover work from across the spectrum, inside and beyond the concert hall. Each chapter considers a wide range of composers, performers, works, and institutions are considered critically to build up a broad and rich picture of the new music ecosystem, from North American string quartets to Lebanese improvisers, from South American electroacoustic studios to pianos in the Australian outback. A new approach to the study of contemporary music is developed that relies less on taxonomies of style and technique, and more on the comparison of different responses to common themes, among them permission, fluidity, excess, and loss.
Article
This paper, followed by two responses, discusses the application of ecological theory to an understanding of a number of issues in the aesthetics of music. It argues for an understanding of music as based in event perception, with an expanded conception of the sources that are specified by those events. Building on the theory of affordances, it considers the limitations of an information theoretic conception of musical complexity, discusses the importance of perceptual learning (understood as shaping by a structured environment) in understanding the affordances of music for different listeners, and raises the challenging problem of the terms in which musical materials might be appropriately described. The apparent tension between ecological and aesthetic positions—in which adaptation and accommodation seem to be at odds with a modernist aesthetic perspective which prioritizes the unsettling and defamiliarizing function of art—is confronted, before the paper concludes with some observations about different disciplinary perspectives on aesthetics, and matters of specificity and generality.
Article
Recent critiques of organicism in music studies have assumed that such features as part–whole integration and end-oriented development are essential to comparisons between music and the organic realm. Yet if what is thought to constitute organicism varies with perspectives on organisms in general, then perhaps it is time to take a different view of organicism’s historical legacy. What if the problem is not with the impression that music presents a semblance of the organic, but with the models of the organism brought in to give content to that semblance? In light of novel accounts of organic life currently being formulated by both scientists and thinkers affiliated with post-humanism, I propose to imagine an organicism that dispenses with humanistic conceits and prompts creative reflection on the points of connection between music and organic processes. To that end, this essay first dismantles conventional notions of wholeness and development before going on to consider aspects of the Western musical tradition through the twin lenses of self-organization and the systems theory of German sociologist Niklas Luhmann. In sum, the essay seeks to conserve affinities between music and the organic domain intuited by nineteenth-century listeners while transposing organicism into a register more in tune with contemporary scientific and philosophical thought. By adding new nodes to a critical network established over two centuries ago, this article argues that a post-humanist organicism challenges us to think afresh about what our bodies, our sociality, and our creativity share with non-human entities and ecologies.
Article
Résumé Dans l’atelier musical de Salvatore Sciarrino il y a très peu d’outils : des carnets, des papiers quadrillés, des papiers à musique, une gomme et des crayons. Les papiers quadrillés lui servent pour rédiger des diagrammes permettant de fixer et de contrôler le déroulement des figures sonores et des images musicales. Passage essentiel pour la création d’oeuvres instrumentales ou vocales, fondées sur des principes aptes à dramatiser l’agencement, la combinaison et la mise en résonance de ces figures dans l’espace sonore. Après ce travail préliminaire, le compositeur élabore la partition utilisant les signes traditionnels pour rendre ses partitions aussi claires et «universelles» que possible, expliquant dans une table des notes techniques la manière précise de réaliser les effets sonores et les procédés typiques de sa musique. Étant donné que Sciarrino façonne lui-même les textes de ses oeuvres vocales et théâtrales, cousant ensemble des phrases et des mots extraits de textes de différents auteurs, les carnets ne contiennent pas seulement des esquisses, des réflexions ou des titres d’oeuvres futures, mais aussi des citations recueillies un peu partout et des textes en cours d’élaboration adaptés à ses besoins poétiques, musicales et dramaturgiques. La nécessité de rendre les textes ductiles à son traitement vocal est un des buts principaux de cette élaboration semblable à un trope en creux. La concision et l’abolition des complexités syntaxiques facilitent le travail de fragmentation du texte en syntagmes, lesquels peuvent ainsi s’habiller des petites écailles sonores de ses figures mélodiques.
Article
This book brings together different work in the new field of physics called the chaos theory, an extension of classical mechanics, in which simple and complex causes are seen to interact. Mathematics may only be able to solve simple linear equations which experiment has pushed nature into obeying in a limited way, but now that computers can map the whole plane of solutions of non-linear equations a new vision of nature is revealed. The implications are staggeringly universal in all areas of scientific work and philosophical thought.
Article
This paper explores the extent to which ideas developed in The Senses Considered as Perceptual Systems and further refined in The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception (Gibson, 1966; 1979) can be applied to the analysis of perception and action in musical settings. The ecological approach to perception has rarely been applied to music, although some recent work in ecological acoustics, music theory and music psychology has begun to show an interest in direct perception of events and objects. We would argue that despite this pioneering work, Gibson’s most radical and controversial idea, that of the direct perception of affordances (Gibson, 1979), has not been adequately addressed in a musical context. Following an introduction to the theoretical background to affordances and a review of the ways in which previous authors have investigated ecological approaches to auditory perception, we show how both the production and perception of music can fruitfully be analysed using the concept of affordances, and how such an approach neatly integrates seemingly active and passive engagement with music. In addition, we place this ecological approach to music within a broader empirical context, giving examples of music-psychological, ethnomusicological and neuroscientific evidence which complement our more theoretical approach. In conclusion, we argue that the links between the performance, composition and reception are underpinned by the mutuality of perception and action.
Article
Typescript. Thesis (Ph.D.)--New York University, School of Education, 2006. Includes bibliographical references (leaves 223-226).
L’integrazione dell’estesico nel poetico nella poetica musicale poststrutturalista: Il caso di Salvatore Sciarrino, una ‘composizione dell
  • Carlo Carratelli
Lohengrin. Azione invisibile: Da Sciarrino a Laforgue
  • Marco Angius
A Polyphony of the Mind: Intertextuality in the Music of Salvatore Sciarrino
  • James Bunch
Centre de documentation de la musique contemporaine
  • Laurent Feneyrou
Ecological Psychology
  • Harry Heft
  • Michael Richardson
Heft, Harry, and Michael Richardson. 2013. "Ecological Psychology." In Oxford Bibliographies Online in Psychology. h ps://www.oxfordbibliographies.com/view/document/obo-9780199828340/obo-9780199828340-0072.xml.
Application of Chaos Theory and Fractal Geometry in the Music of György Ligeti
  • Brian J Lefresne
Lefresne, Brian J. 2005. "Application of Chaos Theory and Fractal Geometry in the Music of György Ligeti." MA thesis, University of O awa, Canada.
Conversation at the 60th International Festival of Contemporary Music, Biennale Musica 2016, Ca’ Giustinian
  • Marco Angius
  • Salvatore Sciarrino
  • Oreste Bossini
Introductory note to . Salvatore Sciarrino (website)
  • Salvatore Sciarrino
Imperceptible Beginnings and Inescapable Endings: Suspended and Enhanced Temporality in the Semanticized Form of Salvatore Sciarrino
  • Christian Utz
Formation and Process in Repetitive Post-Tonal Music
  • Antares Boyle
Narrativity, Descriptivity, and Secondary Parameters: Ecstasy Enacted in Salvatore Sciarrino’s Infinito Nero
  • Rebecca Leydon
Leydon, Rebecca. 2012. "Narrativity, Descriptivity, and Secondary Parameters: Ecstasy Enacted in Salvatore Sciarrino's Infinito Nero.'" In Music and Narrative Since 1900, ed. Michael L. Klein and Nicholas Reyland, 308-28. Indiana University Press.
Struktur und Wahrnehmung: Gestalt, Kontur, Figur und Geste in Analysen der Musik des 20
  • Christian Utz
Orchestra of Flute, Orchestra of Saxophone and Marco Angius
  • Salvatore Sciarrino
  • Michel Van Goethem
  • Mario Caroli
  • Michele Marasco
  • Giampaolo Pretto
  • Manuel Zurria
  • Daniele Berdini
  • Marco Bontempo
  • Gianluca Pugnaloni
  • Leonardo Sbaffi
  • Jonathan Faralli
Sciarrino, Salvatore, Michel van Goethem, Mario Caroli, Michele Marasco, Giampaolo Pre o, Manuel Zurria, Daniele Berdini, Marco Bontempo, Gianluca Pugnaloni, Leonardo Sbaffi, Jonathan Faralli, Orchestra of Flute, Orchestra of Saxophone and Marco Angius. 2000. Studi per l'intonazione del mare. Stradivarius. STR 33583.
Statische Allegorie und ’Sog der Zeit‘: Zur strukturalistischen Semantik in Salvatore Sciarrinos Oper
  • Christian Utz
Ausweglose Enden: Die Schlussbildung in Salvatore Sciarrinos Werken und die Semantiesierung musikalischer Strukturen
  • Christian Utz
Silences de l'oracle: Autour de l'oeuvre de Salvatore Sciarrino. Centre de documentation de la musique contemporaine
  • Laurent Feneyrou
Feneyrou, Laurent, ed. 2013. Silences de l'oracle: Autour de l'oeuvre de Salvatore Sciarrino. Centre de documentation de la musique contemporaine.
Notes on 12 Madrigali
  • Max Nyffeler
Nyffeler, Max. 2009. "Notes on 12 Madrigali." 12 Madrigali. CD booklet, 21-29. Col legno WWE 2009 CD 20287, compact disc.
Saxophonemes (website). h p://saxophonemes.fr/eng.saxophonemes.fr/La_Bocca_presentation_2.html
  • Salvatore Sciarrino
Sciarrino, Salvatore. 1997. Introductory note to La bocca, i piedi, il suono. Saxophonemes (website). h p://saxophonemes.fr/eng.saxophonemes.fr/La_Bocca_presentation_2.html. -----. 1998. Le figure della musica da Beethoven ad oggi. Ricordi. -----. 2001. Carte da suono (1981-2001). Edited by Dario Oliveri. Novecento. -----. 2006. Introductory note to Le stagioni artificiali. Salvatore Sciarrino (website). h ps://www.salvatoresciarrino.eu/data/composition/eng/202.html.
Statische Allegorie und 'Sog der Zeit': Zur strukturalistischen Semantik in Salvatore Sciarrinos Oper Luci mie traditrici
U, Christian. 2010. "Statische Allegorie und 'Sog der Zeit': Zur strukturalistischen Semantik in Salvatore Sciarrinos Oper Luci mie traditrici." Musik & Ästhetik 14 (53): 37-60.
Struktur und Wahrnehmung: Gestalt, Kontur, Figur und Geste in Analysen der Musik des 20. Jahrhunderts
-----. 2012. "Struktur und Wahrnehmung: Gestalt, Kontur, Figur und Geste in Analysen der Musik des 20. Jahrhunderts." Musik & Ästhetik 16 (64): 53-80.
  • Salvatore Sciarrino
  • Alfonso Alberti
  • Marianne Pousseur
  • Ensemble Risognanze
  • Tito Ceccherini
Sciarrino, Salvatore, Alfonso Alberti, Marianne Pousseur, Ensemble Risognanze and Tito Ceccherini. 2018. Lohengrin, col legno Beteiligungs-und Produktion GmbH. WWE 1CD 20264.
The keystone of this music is found in an organic conception of sound, in the inseparability of all its components." (La transformation du son naît de et avec l'exigence de synthèse plut&ocaron;t que de separation: le sens atomiste de la note tend à s'abolir, repousse aux limites de la perception
  • Un
  • Sciarrino Di Arpocrates
  • Writes
In a note wri en for the premiere of Un'immagine di Arpocrates, Sciarrino writes: "The keystone of this music is found in an organic conception of sound, in the inseparability of all its components." (La transformation du son naît de et avec l'exigence de synthèse plut&ocaron;t que de separation: le sens atomiste de la note tend à s'abolir, repousse aux limites de la perception [...] dans l'approximation, au point où l'on ne perçoit plus une succession de sons, mais au contraire un seul événement sonore, en exploitant un phénomène qu'on peut qualifier d' «inertie auditive ».