Content uploaded by Anthony Anyanwu
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Anthony Anyanwu on Feb 19, 2024
Content may be subject to copyright.
Corresponding author Samuel Onimisi Dawodu
Copyright © 2024 Author(s) retain the copyright of this article. This article is published under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Liscense 4.0.
Artificial intelligence (AI) in renewable energy: A review of predictive maintenance
and energy optimization
Shedrack Onwusinkwue 1, Femi Osasona 2, Islam Ahmad Ibrahim Ahmad 3, Anthony Chigozie Anyanwu 4,
Samuel Onimisi Dawodu 5, *, Ogugua Chimezie Obi 6 and Ahmad Hamdan 7
1 Department of Physics, University of Benin, Nigeria.
2 Scottish Water, UK.
3 Independent Researcher, Plano, TX, U.S.A.
4 San Francisco, USA.
5 NDIC, Nigeria.
6 Independent Researcher, Lagos, Nigeria.
7 Cambridge Engineering Consultants, Amman, Jordan.
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
Publication history: Received on 18 December 2023; revised on 23 January 2024; accepted on 26 January 2024
Article DOI: https://doi.org/10.30574/wjarr.2024.21.1.0347
Abstract
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the renewable energy sector has emerged as a transformative force,
enhancing the efficiency and sustainability of energy systems. This paper provides a comprehensive review of the
application of AI in two critical aspects of renewable energy in relation to predictive maintenance and energy
optimization. Predictive maintenance, enabled by AI, has revolutionized the renewable energy landscape by predicting
and preventing equipment failures before they occur. Utilizing machine learning algorithms, AI analyzes vast amounts
of data from sensors and historical performance to identify patterns indicative of potential faults. This proactive
approach not only minimizes downtime but also extends the lifespan of renewable energy infrastructure, resulting in
substantial cost savings and improved reliability. Furthermore, AI plays a pivotal role in optimizing the energy output
of renewable sources. Through advanced data analytics and real-time monitoring, AI algorithms can adapt to changing
environmental conditions, predicting energy production patterns and optimizing resource allocation. This ensures
maximum energy yield from renewable sources, making them more competitive with traditional energy sources. The
paper delves into specific AI techniques such as deep learning, neural networks, and predictive analytics employed for
predictive maintenance and energy optimization in various renewable energy systems like solar, wind, and
hydropower. Challenges and opportunities associated with implementing AI in renewable energy are discussed,
including data security, interoperability, and the need for standardized frameworks. The synthesis of AI technologies
with renewable energy not only addresses operational challenges but also contributes to the global transition towards
sustainable and clean energy solutions. This review serves as a valuable resource for researchers, practitioners, and
policymakers seeking insights into the evolving landscape of AI applications in the renewable energy sector. As
technology continues to advance, the synergies between AI and renewable energy are poised to shape the future of the
global energy paradigm.
Keyword: Artificial Intelligence; Renewable Energy; Predictive Maintenance; Energy Optimization; Review
1. Introduction
The intersection of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and renewable energy represents a pivotal frontier in the pursuit of
sustainable and efficient energy solutions (Velásquez et al., 2023). As the global community grapples with the urgent
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
2488
need to transition towards low-carbon and environmentally conscious practices, the integration of AI technologies into
the renewable energy sector has emerged as a key enabler (Hassan et al., 2023). This paper provides a comprehensive
exploration of the profound impact of AI on two crucial facets of renewable energy systems: predictive maintenance
and energy optimization.
In recent years, the renewable energy landscape has witnessed unprecedented growth, driven by an increasing
awareness of climate change and a collective commitment to reducing reliance on fossil fuels (Burke and Stephens,
2018). However, the intermittent nature of renewable energy sources, such as solar and wind, presents operational
challenges that demand innovative solutions. AI, with its ability to harness the power of data analytics, machine learning,
and predictive modeling, stands out as a transformative force capable of addressing these challenges head-on (Ohalete
et al., 2023).
Predictive maintenance, a cornerstone of AI applications in renewable energy, has redefined the paradigm of equipment
management. By leveraging sophisticated algorithms, AI can analyze vast datasets from sensors, historical performance,
and environmental conditions to anticipate and prevent potential failures in renewable energy infrastructure
(Velásquez et al., 2023). This proactive approach not only ensures the reliability of energy systems but also minimizes
downtime and maintenance costs, thus enhancing the overall efficiency and economic viability of renewable energy
projects (Hoang and Nguyen, 2021).
Simultaneously, AI-driven energy optimization contributes to the maximization of energy output from renewable
sources (Kanase-Patil et al., 2020). Through real-time monitoring, predictive analytics, and adaptive algorithms, AI fine-
tunes operational parameters to capitalize on optimal conditions, ensuring that renewable energy systems achieve peak
performance (Liang et al., 2023). This not only enhances the competitiveness of renewable energy in the broader energy
landscape but also positions AI as a critical tool for navigating the complexities inherent in harnessing variable energy
sources.
As we embark on this journey to explore the symbiosis of AI and renewable energy, this review aims to shed light on
the current state, challenges, and future prospects of utilizing AI for predictive maintenance and energy optimization.
By dissecting the intricate interplay between cutting-edge technologies and sustainable energy solutions, we navigate
the path toward a greener and more technologically advanced energy future.
This paper aims to provide a comprehensive review of the integration of AI in addressing specific challenges within the
renewable energy sector, with a focus on predictive maintenance and energy optimization. The synergy between AI and
renewable energy technologies has the potential to revolutionize the industry by enhancing system reliability,
minimizing downtime, and optimizing energy output (Ahmad et al., 2022).
1.1. Renewable Energy
Renewable energy has assumed a central role in global efforts to transition towards sustainable and environmentally
conscious energy solutions. The growing significance of renewable energy sources, such as solar, wind, and hydropower,
stems from the escalating concerns about climate change, depletion of fossil fuel reserves, and the imperative to reduce
carbon emissions (Albert, 2021). As the world increasingly embraces these cleaner alternatives, it becomes imperative
to address the challenges associated with the reliability and efficiency of renewable energy systems (Cheng et al., 2024).
This paper explores the integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into the renewable energy sector, focusing on its
applications in predictive maintenance and energy optimization.
The escalating demand for energy, coupled with environmental concerns, has catalyzed a global shift towards
renewable energy sources. Solar, wind, and hydropower offer sustainable alternatives, reducing dependency on finite
fossil fuels and mitigating the environmental impact of traditional energy sources (Strielkowski et al., 2021). The
continuous advancements in renewable energy technologies have made these sources more accessible and cost-
effective, fostering widespread adoption.
Despite the positive trajectory, renewable energy systems face challenges that impede their seamless integration into
the mainstream energy grid. One significant challenge is the intermittency and variability of energy production from
renewable sources. Factors such as weather patterns and daylight availability impact the consistency of solar and wind
power generation. Additionally, the wear and tear on equipment, coupled with unforeseen faults, pose operational
challenges, necessitating effective maintenance strategies.
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
2489
Predictive maintenance involves anticipating equipment failures before they occur, reducing unplanned downtime and
maintenance costs. Traditional maintenance practices rely on fixed schedules, leading to unnecessary interventions and
potential disruptions. AI, specifically machine learning algorithms, transforms this paradigm by analyzing vast datasets
from sensors, historical performance, and environmental conditions (Rane, 2023). The AI algorithms can identify
patterns indicative of potential faults, enabling proactive and targeted maintenance.
Real-world applications of AI-driven predictive maintenance in renewable energy include the analysis of wind turbine
performance, detection of anomalies in solar panel efficiency, and monitoring the health of hydropower infrastructure.
By leveraging predictive maintenance, the renewable energy sector can ensure the longevity of its assets, improve
overall system reliability, and optimize maintenance costs.
Energy optimization is critical for maximizing the efficiency of renewable energy systems. The intermittent nature of
renewable sources necessitates adaptive strategies to align energy production with demand. AI, through real-time
monitoring and data analytics, enhances energy optimization by predicting production patterns and optimizing
resource allocation (Li et al., 2023).
AI-driven energy optimization is particularly beneficial in scenarios where energy demand fluctuates. For instance,
machine learning algorithms can forecast demand patterns and adjust the output of renewable energy systems
accordingly. Dynamic optimization algorithms can adapt to changing conditions, ensuring that renewable energy
sources operate at peak efficiency (Hannan et al., 2020). This not only improves the economic viability of renewable
energy projects but also enhances their competitiveness in the broader energy landscape.
In conclusion, the integration of AI in predictive maintenance and energy optimization is transforming the renewable
energy sector. By addressing operational challenges associated with equipment reliability and energy output variability,
AI technologies contribute to the sustainability and competitiveness of renewable energy sources (Şerban and Lytras,
2020.). As we advance into an era where clean energy solutions are imperative, the symbiotic relationship between AI
and renewable energy holds the key to a greener and more efficient future.
1.2. Predictive Maintenance in Renewable Energy
Renewable energy has emerged as a cornerstone in the global pursuit of sustainable and clean energy solutions. To
harness the full potential of renewable sources such as solar, wind, and hydropower, maintaining the reliability of the
infrastructure is crucial. Predictive maintenance, fueled by Artificial Intelligence (AI), has become a pivotal strategy in
addressing the operational challenges inherent in renewable energy systems (Ahmad et al., 2021).
Predictive maintenance involves the proactive identification of potential equipment failures before they occur, allowing
for timely interventions and reducing unplanned downtime. Unlike traditional approaches that rely on fixed schedules
or reactive responses to failures, predictive maintenance leverages data analytics and AI to forecast when maintenance
is required, optimizing the lifespan and performance of renewable energy assets.
The significance of predictive maintenance in renewable energy lies in its ability to enhance system reliability, minimize
downtime, and reduce maintenance costs. By predicting and preventing failures, renewable energy operators can
ensure a consistent and efficient energy supply, ultimately contributing to the overall sustainability and
competitiveness of renewable energy sources.
Renewable energy systems, despite their numerous advantages, face unique challenges in terms of maintenance (Basit
et al., 2020). Traditional maintenance approaches often involve periodic inspections or reactive responses to equipment
failures. This can lead to unnecessary downtime, increased maintenance costs, and challenges in scheduling
interventions, particularly in remote or offshore locations. The intermittent nature of renewable energy sources further
complicates maintenance planning. Wind turbines, for example, are subject to variable wind speeds, and solar panels'
efficiency is contingent on daylight availability. These challenges necessitate a shift towards more advanced and
proactive maintenance strategies.
AI, specifically machine learning algorithms, plays a pivotal role in predictive maintenance. These algorithms learn from
historical data, identifying patterns and correlations that can indicate impending equipment failures. In renewable
energy, machine learning can analyze vast datasets from sensors, performance records, and environmental conditions
to predict the health of the infrastructure (Hundi and Shahsavari, 2020). Machine learning algorithms used in predictive
maintenance include supervised learning, unsupervised learning, and reinforcement learning. Supervised learning
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
2490
models, for instance, can be trained on labeled datasets to predict specific failure modes, while unsupervised learning
can identify anomalies and deviations from normal operating conditions.
The effectiveness of AI in predictive maintenance relies heavily on the quality and diversity of data sources. In
renewable energy, key data sources include; Information from sensors embedded in renewable energy infrastructure,
providing real-time data on temperature, vibration, and other performance metrics (Ahmad and Zhang, 2021). Records
of equipment performance over time, offering insights into degradation patterns and failure modes. Data on weather
conditions, daylight hours, and other environmental factors influencing the operation of renewable energy systems.
In solar energy, AI-driven predictive maintenance can identify potential issues in photovoltaic (PV) panels. By analyzing
data on individual panel performance, AI algorithms can detect anomalies, such as reduced efficiency or degradation,
and predict when maintenance is required. This ensures optimal energy production and prolongs the lifespan of solar
installations. Wind turbines are susceptible to wear and tear, with components like bearings and gears experiencing
stress over time. AI can predict potential failures by analyzing data from sensors that monitor vibration, temperature,
and other indicators. By forecasting when specific components are likely to fail, operators can schedule maintenance
activities proactively, minimizing downtime and maximizing energy production (Patel, 2021). In hydropower systems,
the performance of turbines and generators is critical. AI can analyze historical performance data and real-time sensor
information to predict potential issues, such as cavitation or imbalance. Predictive maintenance in hydropower ensures
the continuous and efficient generation of electricity while preventing costly repairs and downtime.
Proactive identification and resolution of potential issues enhance the overall reliability of renewable energy systems.
Predictive maintenance minimizes unplanned downtime by addressing issues before they lead to equipment failures.
By optimizing maintenance interventions, AI contributes to extending the lifespan of renewable energy infrastructure.
Proactive maintenance reduces overall maintenance costs by avoiding expensive emergency repairs and unnecessary
interventions.
The effectiveness of AI relies on the quality and availability of data. Inadequate or unreliable data can compromise the
accuracy of predictions. Implementing AI for predictive maintenance requires an initial investment in sensors, data
infrastructure, and AI technologies, which may be a barrier for some operators (Javaid et al., 2022). Some AI models,
particularly deep learning models, can be perceived as "black boxes," making it challenging to interpret how predictions
are made.
Predictive maintenance powered by AI represents a paradigm shift in addressing maintenance challenges in renewable
energy (Afridi et al., 2022). By harnessing the capabilities of machine learning and leveraging diverse data sources,
operators can ensure the continuous and reliable operation of renewable energy systems. While challenges exist, the
benefits of enhanced reliability, minimized downtime, and extended infrastructure lifespan position AI-driven
predictive maintenance as a transformative strategy for the sustainable future of renewable energy.
1.3. Energy Optimization in Renewable Energy
Renewable energy sources, such as solar, wind, and hydropower, have become pivotal players in the global energy
landscape, championing the cause of sustainability. However, the inherent intermittency of these sources poses
challenges in matching energy supply with demand. Energy optimization, a process that fine-tunes operational
parameters to maximize efficiency and output, is the linchpin in ensuring the reliability and competitiveness of
renewable energy (Fernando et al., 2023). In this paper, we explore the definition, importance, and the transformative
role of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in energy optimization for renewable sources.
Energy optimization is the art and science of maximizing the efficiency and output of renewable energy systems (Khan
et al., 2023). It involves aligning energy production with demand, adapting to variable conditions, and ensuring that the
generated energy meets quality standards. In the context of renewable energy, optimization is crucial for addressing
the intermittent nature of sources like solar and wind, making them more reliable and economically viable alternatives
to traditional energy sources.
The importance of energy optimization extends beyond mere efficiency gains. It directly impacts the economic viability
of renewable energy projects, making them more competitive in the broader energy market. Additionally, optimized
energy production contributes to the overall stability and reliability of the power grid, fostering a seamless integration
of renewables into the existing energy infrastructure.
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
2491
Despite their environmental benefits, renewable energy sources face challenges in optimizing energy output; Solar and
wind energy production is contingent on environmental conditions, leading to fluctuations in energy output (Li et al.,
2021). The variability in renewable energy generation patterns makes it challenging to align production with fluctuating
energy demand. Efficient energy storage solutions are crucial for storing excess energy generated during peak
production periods for use during low-production periods.
AI-driven energy optimization begins with real-time monitoring and data analytics. Sensors placed in renewable energy
infrastructure continuously collect data on variables like wind speed, sunlight intensity, and equipment performance.
AI algorithms analyze this data in real-time to gain insights into current conditions and predict future energy production
patterns.
Adaptive algorithms, powered by machine learning, are at the forefront of AI's contribution to energy optimization.
These algorithms learn from historical data, adjusting operational parameters to optimize energy production based on
changing conditions. Machine learning models can forecast energy demand patterns, predict environmental changes,
and optimize the allocation of resources, ensuring that renewable energy systems operate at peak efficiency (Forootan
et al., 2022).
AI algorithms have been employed in solar energy farms to optimize the positioning of solar panels based on the sun's
position. By dynamically adjusting the tilt and orientation of panels, AI ensures maximum sunlight absorption
throughout the day, significantly improving energy yield. In wind energy, AI is used to predict wind patterns and
optimize the pitch and yaw of wind turbine blades. By adjusting the blade angles in real-time, wind turbines can capture
the maximum amount of energy from variable wind speeds, enhancing overall efficiency. AI-based energy optimization
in hydropower involves dynamically adjusting water flow through turbines based on real-time river flow data
(Villeneuve et al., 2022). This ensures that hydropower plants operate at peak efficiency while minimizing
environmental impact by optimizing water resource usage.
AI-driven energy optimization reduces operational costs by maximizing energy output without the need for excessive
infrastructure investments. By improving the economic feasibility of renewable energy projects, AI enhances their
competitiveness in the broader energy market. Optimizing renewable energy production reduces the reliance on fossil
fuels, contributing to a substantial reduction in carbon emissions. AI-based energy optimization aligns with sustainable
development goals, ensuring that renewable energy systems operate efficiently and responsibly.
AI-driven energy optimization stands as a game-changer for renewable energy. By addressing the challenges associated
with intermittency and variability, AI ensures that renewable sources reach their full potential. The economic and
environmental impact of AI in energy optimization is profound, paving the way for a sustainable and resilient energy
future (Bibri et al., 2024). As we continue to unlock new possibilities, the integration of AI and renewable energy is set
to redefine the dynamics of the global energy landscape.
1.4. Artificial Intelligence Techniques in Predictive Maintenance and Energy Optimization
Artificial Intelligence (AI) has emerged as a transformative force in the field of predictive maintenance and energy
optimization, revolutionizing the way we manage and enhance the efficiency of renewable energy systems (Mohammad
and Mahjabeen, 2023). This article provides an overview of key AI techniques utilized in predictive maintenance and
energy optimization, focusing on deep learning, neural networks, and predictive analytics.
Deep learning, a subset of machine learning, has gained prominence for its ability to extract intricate patterns and
representations from complex datasets. In predictive maintenance, deep learning excels at handling unstructured data,
such as images, time-series data, and sensor readings. Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) and Recurrent Neural
Networks (RNNs) are commonly employed deep learning architectures in predictive maintenance applications (Nasser
and Al-Khazraji, 2022). In wind energy, deep learning models can analyze historical data on turbine performance,
weather conditions, and sensor readings. This enables the prediction of potential failures, such as gearbox malfunctions
or blade degradation, allowing for proactive maintenance and minimizing downtime.
Neural networks, inspired by the human brain's structure and function, are versatile AI models that excel in learning
complex relationships within data. In predictive maintenance, neural networks are adept at recognizing patterns and
anomalies, making them valuable for fault detection and prognosis (Divya et al., 2023). Multi-layer perceptrons (MLPs)
and Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) networks are commonly employed neural network architectures. In solar energy,
neural networks can analyze historical data from solar panel arrays, considering variables like temperature, sunlight
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
2492
intensity, and output fluctuations. This allows the model to predict potential efficiency losses or malfunctioning cells,
enabling timely maintenance and optimization.
Predictive analytics involves utilizing statistical algorithms and machine learning techniques to analyze historical and
real-time data, enabling the prediction of future events. This approach is foundational in predictive maintenance,
providing insights into equipment health, potential failures, and optimal maintenance schedules. In hydropower
systems, predictive analytics can analyze historical turbine performance data, river flow rates, and environmental
conditions. By identifying patterns indicative of potential issues, operators can schedule maintenance activities to
prevent turbine failures and optimize energy production.
AI techniques enable predictive maintenance by forecasting potential issues before they lead to equipment failures. This
proactive approach minimizes downtime and extends the lifespan of renewable energy infrastructure. The ability of AI
to analyze vast datasets allows for data-driven decision-making in real-time. This ensures that maintenance
interventions and operational adjustments are based on accurate and up-to-date information. AI techniques contribute
to energy optimization by adapting to changing environmental conditions and demand patterns (Antonopoulos et al.,
2020). This leads to increased energy output, improved system efficiency, and enhanced competitiveness of renewable
energy sources.
The effectiveness of AI is heavily reliant on the quality and availability of data. Inaccurate or incomplete datasets can
compromise the accuracy of predictions and decision-making. Deep learning models, in particular, can be
computationally intensive, requiring significant processing power and resources (Menghani, 2023). This can pose
challenges for implementation in resource-constrained environments. Some AI models, especially deep learning
architectures, are often considered "black boxes" due to their complexity. Understanding how these models arrive at
specific predictions can be challenging, raising concerns about interpretability.
In conclusion, AI techniques are at the forefront of revolutionizing predictive maintenance and energy optimization in
the renewable energy sector. The application of deep learning, neural networks, and predictive analytics empowers
operators to proactively manage renewable energy infrastructure, maximize efficiency, and contribute to the
sustainable future of clean energy (Kanagarathinam et al., 2023). As technology continues to advance, the integration
of AI will play an increasingly pivotal role in shaping the reliability and efficiency of renewable energy systems.
1.4.1. Specific applications and advantages of each AI technique in the context of predictive maintenance
Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques, including deep learning, neural networks, and predictive analytics, have become
indispensable tools in predictive maintenance, elevating the reliability and efficiency of renewable energy systems (Fan
et al., 2023). Each technique brings distinct advantages to specific applications within the predictive maintenance
domain.
Deep learning excels in image recognition applications, making it invaluable for assessing the visual condition of
renewable energy infrastructure. For instance, in solar energy, deep learning models can analyze images of solar panels
to detect microcracks, discoloration, or other signs of degradation. In wind energy, deep learning proves effective in
analyzing time-series data from sensors. This allows for the detection of subtle anomalies in wind turbine performance,
such as irregular vibration patterns or changes in power output over time. Deep learning models autonomously extract
relevant features from raw data, eliminating the need for manual feature engineering (Hozhabr Pour et al., 2022). This
is particularly advantageous when dealing with complex and unstructured data in predictive maintenance. Deep
learning excels in capturing non-linear relationships within data, providing a more accurate representation of intricate
patterns that may be challenging for traditional methods to discern.
Neural networks are proficient in fault detection applications across various renewable energy systems. In hydropower,
for instance, neural networks can analyze sensor data to identify deviations from normal turbine performance, signaling
potential faults (Xu et al., 2024). Neural networks contribute to prognostics by predicting the remaining useful life of
components. This is valuable in scenarios where predicting the time until a critical part, like a wind turbine gearbox,
requires maintenance. Neural networks excel in recognizing complex patterns, making them ideal for predictive
maintenance tasks that involve identifying subtle indicators of equipment degradation or impending failures. Neural
networks are adaptable to changing conditions, allowing them to continuously learn and adjust predictions based on
evolving data patterns.
Predictive analytics is well-suited for modeling the probability of equipment failures. In solar energy, predictive
analytics can estimate the likelihood of inverter failures based on historical data and environmental conditions.
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
2493
Predictive analytics assists in scheduling maintenance activities optimally. In wind energy, it can recommend the most
efficient timing for blade inspections or lubrication based on historical performance and forecasted weather conditions.
Predictive analytics provides interpretable insights into the factors influencing maintenance predictions. This
transparency is essential for operators to make informed decisions about when and how to conduct maintenance.
Predictive analytics leverages statistical modeling techniques, offering a robust framework for understanding
relationships between variables and predicting future events with quantifiable uncertainty.
In summary, the specific applications and advantages of AI techniques in predictive maintenance demonstrate their
versatility and effectiveness in ensuring the reliability and longevity of renewable energy infrastructure. As technology
continues to advance, these AI-driven approaches will play a crucial role in shaping the future of maintenance practices
in the rapidly evolving landscape of clean energy (Stecuła et al., 2023).
1.4.2. Artificial Intelligence techniques employed in energy optimization
Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques have emerged as instrumental tools in optimizing energy production and
consumption, particularly in the realm of renewable energy (Fan et al., 2023) as explain in Figure 1. This article explores
two key AI techniques employed in energy optimization: machine learning for demand forecasting and dynamic
optimization algorithms.
Machine learning (ML) techniques play a pivotal role in energy optimization by facilitating accurate demand forecasting
(Antonopoulos et al., 2020). This application involves leveraging historical and real-time data to predict future energy
consumption patterns, enabling energy systems to adapt proactively.
ML models analyze historical data on energy consumption, considering factors such as time of day, day of the week, and
seasonal variations. These models can accurately predict future energy loads, allowing energy providers to optimize the
distribution of resources. ML is crucial for forecasting the availability of renewable energy sources. In solar energy, for
example, ML algorithms analyze weather patterns and historical solar radiation data to predict solar energy production,
assisting in grid management and resource allocation. ML models continuously learn from new data, improving their
accuracy over time. This adaptability ensures precise demand forecasts, reducing the likelihood of overproduction or
shortages. ML models can accommodate a variety of input variables, including weather conditions, economic indicators,
and social events (Lam et al., 2023). This flexibility allows for a more comprehensive understanding of the factors
influencing energy demand. Figure 1 shows the application of artificial intelligence.
Figure 1 Application of artificial intelligence (AI) technology-based integration of renewable energy sources (RESs)
and ESSs (Abdalla et al., 2021)
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
2494
Dynamic optimization algorithms are designed to adapt and optimize operational parameters in real-time, responding
to changing conditions and demands. These algorithms are crucial for ensuring that energy systems operate at peak
efficiency and adapt to the variable nature of renewable energy sources.
Dynamic optimization algorithms continuously assess the state of the energy grid, adjusting the distribution of power
to meet demand while minimizing losses. This is particularly important in integrating renewable sources like wind and
solar, which exhibit variable outputs. In systems with energy storage, dynamic optimization algorithms manage the
charging and discharging cycles based on real-time demand and supply conditions. This ensures efficient use of stored
energy and minimizes wastage. Dynamic optimization algorithms can make instantaneous adjustments to operational
parameters, ensuring that energy systems respond promptly to fluctuations in demand or changes in environmental
conditions (Xu et al., 2020). By dynamically optimizing the allocation of resources, these algorithms contribute to
maximizing energy production and minimizing waste, ultimately enhancing the economic and environmental
sustainability of energy systems.
The combination of machine learning for demand forecasting and dynamic optimization algorithms creates a synergistic
effect, enabling more effective and adaptive energy optimization strategies (Alabi et al., 2022).
For instance, accurate demand forecasts generated by ML models provide crucial input to dynamic optimization
algorithms. This ensures that energy systems are not only responding to current conditions but are also anticipating
future demand patterns. The integration of these techniques facilitates a holistic approach to energy optimization,
enhancing the overall efficiency and sustainability of renewable energy systems.
While these AI techniques hold immense promise, challenges such as data security, interoperability, and the need for
standardized frameworks must be addressed for widespread implementation. Additionally, ongoing research is
essential to refine existing algorithms and explore innovative approaches that further enhance the synergy between
machine learning and dynamic optimization in the context of energy systems (Forootan et al., 2022).
In conclusion, the application of AI techniques in energy optimization represents a paradigm shift in the management
of renewable energy resources. Machine learning for demand forecasting and dynamic optimization algorithms
collectively contribute to the adaptive, efficient, and sustainable operation of energy systems, paving the way for a
smarter and more resilient energy future.
1.4.3. Comparative analysis of different AI techniques in predictive maintenance and energy optimization
Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques, including deep learning, neural networks, and predictive analytics, play a crucial
role in enhancing the efficiency and reliability of renewable energy systems through predictive maintenance and energy
optimization (Karduri, 2019). A more detailed examination of these techniques offers insights into their specific
strengths, weaknesses, and optimal applications.
Deep learning excels in automatically identifying relevant features from large and complex datasets, making it suitable
for scenarios where manual feature engineering is challenging. Deep learning models, particularly neural networks with
multiple layers, are adept at capturing intricate non-linear relationships within data.
Training deep learning models can be computationally intensive, requiring powerful hardware and significant
processing resources. The inherent complexity of deep learning models often results in a lack of interpretability, making
it challenging to understand the decision-making process.
Deep learning is employed to analyze time-series data from wind turbines, enabling the prediction of potential faults or
irregularities in performance by detecting subtle patterns (Mansouri et al., 2021). Image recognition tasks, such as
identifying anomalies in solar panels through image analysis, showcase the capability of deep learning in solar energy
applications.
Neural networks, being versatile, excel in recognizing complex patterns within data, making them suitable for fault
detection and prognosis in predictive maintenance. Neural networks are adaptable to changing conditions, allowing
them to continuously learn and adjust predictions based on evolving data patterns. The effectiveness of neural networks
is highly dependent on the quality and quantity of labeled data available for training. Training neural networks can be
complex and time-consuming, requiring careful tuning of hyperparameters. Neural networks are effective in fault
detection applications, analyzing sensor data to identify deviations from normal turbine performance, enabling
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
2495
proactive maintenance (Chen et al., 2021). In wind energy, neural networks contribute to predicting the remaining
useful life of critical components, aiding in maintenance planning.
Predictive analytics, relying on statistical modeling, provides interpretable insights into the factors influencing
maintenance predictions, offering transparency in decision-making. The use of statistical techniques provides a robust
framework for understanding relationships between variables and predicting future events. Predictive analytics may
struggle to adapt to highly dynamic or nonlinear systems, where traditional statistical models may not capture intricate
patterns (Sri Preethaa et al., 2023). The effectiveness of predictive analytics relies heavily on the availability of historical
data, and sudden shifts in operating conditions may impact its accuracy. Predictive analytics can be applied to estimate
the likelihood of inverter failures based on historical data and environmental conditions. In wind energy, predictive
analytics assists in scheduling maintenance activities efficiently based on historical performance and forecasted
weather conditions.
The choice of AI technique depends on specific use cases, data characteristics, and operational requirements. Deep
learning and neural networks excel in scenarios where intricate patterns and non-linear relationships need to be
identified. Predictive analytics, with its interpretability and statistical modeling, may be preferable when dealing with
less dynamic systems and where a transparent decision-making process is crucial (Liu et al., 2022). A comprehensive
understanding of the strengths and limitations of each AI technique is essential for making informed decisions in
predictive maintenance and energy optimization in renewable energy systems.
1.5. Challenges and Opportunities
The fusion of Artificial Intelligence (AI) with renewable energy has opened new frontiers in the pursuit of sustainable
and efficient energy solutions (Velásquez et al., 2023). However, this integration comes with its share of challenges. This
paper explores the obstacles posed by data security and privacy concerns, interoperability issues, and integration
challenges with existing infrastructure, while also highlighting the vast opportunities for further research and
development in AI for renewable energy.
As AI applications in renewable energy heavily rely on the collection and analysis of vast amounts of data, ensuring data
security and privacy has become a paramount challenge. The interconnected nature of energy systems and the
transmission of sensitive information pose risks that demand vigilant attention. With the increasing reliance on
interconnected devices and smart grids, the vulnerability to cyberattacks rises. Malicious actors may attempt to disrupt
energy infrastructure, leading to potential economic and environmental repercussions. The collection of granular data,
especially from smart meters and sensors, raises concerns about individual privacy (Shateri et al., 2020). Balancing the
need for data-driven insights with protecting user privacy remains a delicate challenge.
Developing and implementing robust encryption methods and secure communication protocols can safeguard data
during transmission, reducing the risk of unauthorized access (Seth et al., 2022). Advancements in privacy-preserving
AI techniques, such as federated learning and homomorphic encryption, provide avenues to extract valuable insights
from data without compromising individual privacy. The heterogeneous nature of renewable energy systems, coupled
with diverse AI technologies, creates interoperability challenges. The lack of standardized frameworks can hinder
seamless communication between different components and systems, impeding the scalability and efficiency of AI
applications.
The coexistence of various AI models, each developed using different technologies, poses challenges in creating
interoperable systems that can exchange information effortlessly. The absence of universally accepted standards for
data formats, communication protocols, and interfaces complicates the integration of AI solutions across different
renewable energy platforms. Collaborative efforts to establish industry-wide standards for AI applications in renewable
energy can streamline interoperability and facilitate the exchange of information between diverse systems (Rane,
2023). Promoting the use of open-source platforms and tools can encourage the development of interoperable solutions,
fostering a collaborative ecosystem.
The integration of AI into existing renewable energy infrastructure poses challenges due to the need for retrofitting and
ensuring compatibility. Many renewable energy systems were not initially designed with AI integration in mind, making
the adaptation process complex.
Retrofitting AI into legacy renewable energy systems, which were not initially designed to accommodate advanced
technologies, requires careful planning to avoid disruptions and inefficiencies. Implementing AI solutions may entail
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
2496
high initial costs for upgrading infrastructure, acquiring new hardware, and training personnel, posing financial
challenges for some operators (Yaqoob et al., 2023).
Phased implementation of AI solutions, starting with specific components or subsystems, allows for a gradual
integration process that minimizes disruptions and spreads costs over time. Designing renewable energy systems with
adaptability in mind enables easier integration of AI technologies in the future, fostering a more responsive and efficient
energy infrastructure.
While challenges exist, they serve as catalysts for further research and development, offering exciting opportunities to
advance the application of AI in renewable energy.
Developing AI-driven predictive maintenance models that can accurately anticipate equipment failures, optimize
maintenance schedules, and reduce downtime in renewable energy systems (Ahmad et al., 2021). Research into AI
algorithms for real-time grid management, enabling better balancing of energy supply and demand, integration of
intermittent renewable sources, and efficient distribution of energy. Investigating AI techniques to optimize energy
storage systems, ensuring efficient charging and discharging cycles and maximizing the utilization of stored energy.
Exploring AI solutions for managing decentralized energy systems, such as microgrids, to enhance energy resilience,
reliability, and self-sustainability.
In conclusion, the integration of AI with renewable energy presents both challenges and opportunities. Addressing data
security and privacy concerns, tackling interoperability issues, and navigating integration challenges are critical for
realizing the full potential of AI in revolutionizing the energy sector. However, these challenges also pave the way for
innovative solutions, emphasizing the need for collaborative efforts, standardization, and ongoing research to drive
sustainable advancements in AI for renewable energy (Fan et al., 2023). As the energy landscape evolves, the synergy
between AI and renewable energy holds the promise of creating a cleaner, more efficient, and resilient energy future.
Recommendation
The examination of Artificial Intelligence (AI) applications in renewable energy, focusing on predictive maintenance
and energy optimization, has uncovered significant insights and advancements in the intersection of technology and
sustainable practices. AI techniques, including deep learning, neural networks, and predictive analytics, prove
invaluable in predicting equipment failures, optimizing maintenance schedules, and reducing downtime in renewable
energy systems. The use of machine learning for demand forecasting and dynamic optimization algorithms plays a
pivotal role in maximizing energy efficiency, adapting to variable conditions, and seamlessly integrating renewable
sources into the energy grid.
The implications of integrating AI into renewable energy systems extend beyond current achievements, shaping the
trajectory of the future energy landscape. AI-driven predictive maintenance enhances the reliability of renewable
energy infrastructure, ensuring proactive measures to address potential faults. This, in turn, boosts operational
efficiency and reduces the impact of unforeseen disruptions. Energy optimization through AI contributes to the
sustainability of renewable energy by efficiently utilizing resources, reducing waste, and enabling a smoother
integration of renewables into existing energy grids. The intersection of AI and renewable energy opens avenues for
continuous technological advancements. Innovations in AI algorithms, data analytics, and machine learning models can
lead to more sophisticated applications, further optimizing energy systems.
As we stand at the crossroads of technological innovation and sustainable energy solutions, a collective call to action is
necessary for researchers, practitioners, and policymakers to shape a future where AI and renewable energy are
inseparable allies. Researchers are urged to delve deeper into AI applications, exploring novel algorithms, improving
model interpretability, and refining predictive maintenance and energy optimization techniques. Robust research is the
foundation for the continued evolution of AI in renewable energy. Practitioners in the renewable energy sector are
encouraged to embrace AI technologies in their operations. Integrating predictive maintenance tools and energy
optimization systems into existing infrastructure can enhance overall system performance and longevity. Policymakers
play a crucial role in fostering an environment conducive to the integration of AI in renewable energy. This involves
creating frameworks that incentivize the adoption of AI technologies, ensuring data privacy, and promoting
collaboration between industries and research institutions.
Collaboration is key to the success of AI in renewable energy. By fostering interdisciplinary collaboration between
experts in AI, renewable energy, and related fields, we can harness collective knowledge and accelerate the development
and implementation of innovative solutions.
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
2497
2. Conclusion
In conclusion, the symbiosis of AI and renewable energy holds immense promise for a sustainable and technologically
advanced future. By heeding this call to action, we can collectively contribute to a paradigm shift in the energy sector,
where AI becomes an indispensable tool for optimizing renewable energy systems and steering us to ward a cleaner,
more resilient, and sustainable energy future.
Compliance with ethical standards
Disclosure of conflict of interest
No conflict of interest to be disclosed.
References
[1] Abdalla, A.N., Nazir, M.S., Tao, H., Cao, S., Ji, R., Jiang, M. and Yao, L., 2021. Integration of energy storage system
and renewable energy sources based on artificial intelligence: An overview. Journal of Energy Storage, 40,
p.102811.
[2] Afridi, Y.S., Ahmad, K. and Hassan, L., 2022. Artificial intelligence based prognostic maintenance of renewable
energy systems: A review of techniques, challenges, and future research directions. International Journal of
Energy Research, 46(15), pp.21619-21642.
[3] Ahmad, T. and Zhang, D., 2021. Using the internet of things in smart energy systems and networks. Sustainable
Cities and Society, 68, p.102783.
[4] Ahmad, T., Zhang, D., Huang, C., Zhang, H., Dai, N., Song, Y. and Chen, H., 2021. Artificial intelligence in sustainable
energy industry: Status Quo, challenges and opportunities. Journal of Cleaner Production, 289, p.125834.
[5] Ahmad, T., Zhu, H., Zhang, D., Tariq, R., Bassam, A., Ullah, F., AlGhamdi, A.S. and Alshamrani, S.S., 2022. Energetics
Systems and artificial intelligence: Applications of industry 4.0. Energy Reports, 8, pp.334-361.
[6] Alabi, T.M., Aghimien, E.I., Agbajor, F.D., Yang, Z., Lu, L., Adeoye, A.R. and Gopaluni, B., 2022. A review on the
integrated optimization techniques and machine learning approaches for modeling, prediction, and decision
making on integrated energy systems. Renewable Energy, 194, pp.822-849.
[7] Albert, M.J., 2021. The climate crisis, renewable energy, and the changing landscape of global energy politics.
Alternatives, 46(3), pp.89-98.
[8] Antonopoulos, I., Robu, V., Couraud, B., Kirli, D., Norbu, S., Kiprakis, A., Flynn, D., Elizondo-Gonzalez, S. and
Wattam, S., 2020. Artificial intelligence and machine learning approaches to energy demand-side response: A
systematic review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 130, p.109899.
[9] Basit, M.A., Dilshad, S., Badar, R. and Sami ur Rehman, S.M., 2020. Limitations, challenges, and solution approaches
in grid‐connected renewable energy systems. International Journal of Energy Research, 44(6), pp.4132-4162.
[10] Bibri, S.E., Krogstie, J., Kaboli, A. and Alahi, A., 2024. Smarter eco-cities and their leading-edge artificial
intelligence of things solutions for environmental sustainability: A comprehensive systematic review.
Environmental Science and Ecotechnology, 19, p.100330.
[11] Burke, M.J. and Stephens, J.C., 2018. Political power and renewable energy futures: A critical review. Energy
research & social science, 35, pp.78-93.
[12] Chen, H., Liu, H., Chu, X., Liu, Q. and Xue, D., 2021. Anomaly detection and critical SCADA parameters identification
for wind turbines based on LSTM-AE neural network. Renewable Energy, 172, pp.829-840.
[13] Cheng, Y., Zhao, G., Meng, W. and Wang, Q., 2024. Resources utilization, taxation and green education: A path to
sustainable power generation. Resources Policy, 88, p.104389.
[14] Divya, D., Marath, B. and Santosh Kumar, M.B., 2023. Review of fault detection techniques for predictive
maintenance. Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 29(2), pp.420-441.
[15] Fan, Z., Yan, Z. and Wen, S., 2023. Deep learning and artificial intelligence in sustainability: a review of SDGs,
renewable energy, and environmental health. Sustainability, 15(18), p.13493.
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
2498
[16] Fernando, E., Sutomo, R., Prabowo, Y.D., Gatc, J. and Winanti, W., 2023. Exploring Customer Relationship
Management: Trends, Challenges, and Innovations. Journal of Information Systems and Informatics, 5(3), pp.984-
1001.
[17] Forootan, M.M., Larki, I., Zahedi, R. and Ahmadi, A., 2022. Machine learning and deep learning in energy systems:
A review. Sustainability, 14(8), p.4832.
[18] Hannan, M.A., Tan, S.Y., Al-Shetwi, A.Q., Jern, K.P. and Begum, R.A., 2020. Optimized controller for renewable
energy sources integration into microgrid: Functions, constraints and suggestions. Journal of Cleaner Production,
256, p.120419.
[19] Hassan, Q., Sameen, A.Z., Salman, H.M., Al-Jiboory, A.K. and Jaszczur, M., 2023. The role of renewable energy and
artificial intelligence towards environmental sustainability and net zero.
[20] Hoang, A.T. and Nguyen, X.P., 2021. Integrating renewable sources into energy system for smart city as a
sagacious strategy towards clean and sustainable process. Journal of Cleaner Production, 305, p.127161.
[21] Hozhabr Pour, H., Li, F., Wegmeth, L., Trense, C., Doniec, R., Grzegorzek, M. and Wismüller, R., 2022. A machine
learning framework for automated accident detection based on multimodal sensors in cars. Sensors, 22(10),
p.3634.
[22] Hundi, P. and Shahsavari, R., 2020. Comparative studies among machine learning models for performance
estimation and health monitoring of thermal power plants. Applied Energy, 265, p.114775.
[23] Javaid, M., Haleem, A., Singh, R.P. and Suman, R., 2022. Artificial intelligence applications for industry 4.0: A
literature-based study. Journal of Industrial Integration and Management, 7(01), pp.83-111.
[24] Kanagarathinam, K., Aruna, S.K., Ravivarman, S., Safran, M., Alfarhood, S. and Alrajhi, W., 2023. Enhancing
Sustainable Urban Energy Management through Short-Term Wind Power Forecasting Using LSTM Neural
Network. Sustainability, 15(18), p.13424.
[25] Kanase-Patil, A.B., Kaldate, A.P., Lokhande, S.D., Panchal, H., Suresh, M. and Priya, V., 2020. A review of artificial
intelligence-based optimization techniques for the sizing of integrated renewable energy systems in smart cities.
Environmental Technology Reviews, 9(1), pp.111-136.
[26] Karduri, R.K., The Role of Artificial Intelligence in Optimizing Energy Systems. International Journal of Advanced
Research in Management Architecture Technology & Engineering (IJARMATE)(Feb 2019).
[27] Khan, T., Yu, M. and Waseem, M., 2022. Review on recent optimization strategies for hybrid renewable energy
system with hydrogen technologies: State of the art, trends and future directions. International Journal of
Hydrogen Energy, 47(60), pp.25155-25201.
[28] Lam, R., Sanchez-Gonzalez, A., Willson, M., Wirnsberger, P., Fortunato, M., Alet, F., Ravuri, S., Ewalds, T., Eaton-
Rosen, Z., Hu, W. and Merose, A., 2023. Learning skillful medium-range global weather forecasting. Science,
p.eadi2336.
[29] Li, J., Herdem, M.S., Nathwani, J. and Wen, J.Z., 2023. Methods and applications for Artificial Intelligence, Big Data,
Internet of Things, and Blockchain in smart energy management. Energy and AI, 11, p.100208.
[30] Li, J., Liu, J., Yan, P., Li, X., Zhou, G. and Yu, D., 2021. Operation optimization of integrated energy system under a
renewable energy dominated future scene considering both independence and benefit: A review. Energies, 14(4),
p.1103.
[31] Liang, H., Zhang, Z., Hu, C., Gong, Y. and Cheng, D., 2023. A Survey on Spatio-temporal Big Data Analytics
Ecosystem: Resource Management, Processing Platform, and Applications. IEEE Transactions on Big Data.
[32] Liu, N., Xie, F., Siddiqui, F.J., Ho, A.F.W., Chakraborty, B., Nadarajan, G.D., Tan, K.B.K. and Ong, M.E.H., 2022.
Leveraging large-scale electronic health records and interpretable machine learning for clinical decision making
at the emergency department: protocol for system development and validation. JMIR Research Protocols, 11(3),
p.e34201.
[33] Mansouri, M., Trabelsi, M., Nounou, H. and Nounou, M., 2021. Deep learning-based fault diagnosis of photovoltaic
systems: A comprehensive review and enhancement prospects. IEEE Access, 9, pp.126286-126306.
[34] Menghani, G., 2023. Efficient deep learning: A survey on making deep learning models smaller, faster, and better.
ACM Computing Surveys, 55(12), pp.1-37.
World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 2024, 21(01), 2487–2499
2499
[35] Mohammad, A. and Mahjabeen, F., 2023. Revolutionizing solar energy with ai-driven enhancements in
photovoltaic technology. BULLET: Jurnal Multidisiplin Ilmu, 2(4), pp.1174-1187.
[36] Nasser, A. and Al-Khazraji, H., 2022. A hybrid of convolutional neural network and long short-term memory
network approach to predictive maintenance. Int. J. Electr. Comput. Eng. (IJECE), 12(1), pp.721-730.
[37] Ohalete, N.C., Aderibigbe, A.O., Ani, E.C. and Efosa, P., 2023. AI-driven solutions in renewable energy: A review of
data science applications in solar and wind energy optimization.
[38] Patel, J.K., 2021. The Importance of Equipment Maintenance Forecasting. Int. J. Mech. Eng, 8, pp.7-11.
[39] Rane, N., 2023. Integrating Building Information Modelling (BIM) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) for Smart
Construction Schedule, Cost, Quality, and Safety Management: Challenges and Opportunities. Cost, Quality, and
Safety Management: Challenges and Opportunities (September 16, 2023).
[40] Rane, N., 2023. Integrating Leading-Edge Artificial Intelligence (AI), Internet of things (IoT), and big Data
technologies for smart and Sustainable Architecture, Engineering and Construction (AEC) industry: challenges
and future directions. Engineering and Construction (AEC) Industry: Challenges and Future Directions (September
24, 2023).
[41] Şerban, A.C. and Lytras, M.D., 2020. Artificial intelligence for smart renewable energy sector in europe—smart
energy infrastructures for next generation smart cities. IEEE access, 8, pp.77364-77377.
[42] Seth, B., Dalal, S., Jaglan, V., Le, D.N., Mohan, S. and Srivastava, G., 2022. Integrating encryption techniques for
secure data storage in the cloud. Transactions on Emerging Telecommunications Technologies, 33(4), p.e4108.
[43] Shateri, M., Messina, F., Piantanida, P. and Labeau, F., 2020. Real-time privacy-preserving data release for smart
meters. IEEE Transactions on Smart Grid, 11(6), pp.5174-5183.
[44] Sri Preethaa, K.R., Muthuramalingam, A., Natarajan, Y., Wadhwa, G. and Ali, A.A.Y., 2023. A Comprehensive Review
on Machine Learning Techniques for Forecasting Wind Flow Pattern. Sustainability, 15(17), p.12914.
[45] Stecuła, K., Wolniak, R. and Grebski, W.W., 2023. AI-Driven Urban Energy Solutions—From Individuals to Society:
A Review. Energies, 16(24), p.7988.
[46] Strielkowski, W., Civín, L., Tarkhanova, E., Tvaronavičienė, M. and Petrenko, Y., 2021. Renewable energy in the
sustainable development of electrical power sector: A review. Energies, 14(24), p.8240.
[47] Velásquez, J.D., Cadavid, L. and Franco, C.J., 2023. Intelligence techniques in sustainable energy: analysis of a
decade of advances. Energies, 16(19), p.6974.
[48] Villeneuve, Y., Séguin, S. and Chehri, A., 2022. A survey on AI-based scheduling models, optimization and
prediction for hydropower generation: Variants, chal-lenges, and future directions. Les Cahiers du GERAD ISSN,
711, p.2440.
[49] Xu, X., Wen, H., Lin, H., Li, Z. and Huang, C., 2024. Online detection method for variable load conditions and
anomalous sound of hydro turbines using correlation analysis and PCA-adaptive-K-means. Measurement, 224,
p.113846.
[50] Xu, Y., Yan, C., Liu, H., Wang, J., Yang, Z. and Jiang, Y., 2020. Smart energy systems: A critical review on design and
operation optimization. Sustainable Cities and Society, 62, p.102369.
[51] Yaqoob, I., Salah, K., Jayaraman, R. and Omar, M., 2023. Metaverse applications in smart cities: Enabling
technologies, opportunities, challenges, and future directions. Internet of Things, p.100884.
