ArticlePublisher preview available

Can environmental protection tax force enterprises to improve green technology innovation?

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

The introduction of an environmental protection tax enables a smooth shift from the sewerage charge system to the environmental protection tax scheme. This, in turn, promotes a more sustainable development of enterprise growth, emphasizing eco-friendliness. This is of immense importance in advancing environmentally aware practices and sustainability. Based on data collected from A-share listed companies in Shanghai and Shenzhen from 2014 to 2021, this paper investigates the influence of environmental protection taxes on the advancement of green technology and the underlying mechanisms. Taking the execution of the Environmental Protection Tax Law in 2018 as a quasi-natural experiment, a double-difference model is employed to examine the causal relationship between environmental protection taxes and the adoption of green technology by companies. The findings indicate that the introduction of an environmental tax could markedly enhance the extent of green technological innovation within corporations. The evidence arising from the testing mechanism implies that such a tax can encourage firms to boost their investments in research and development, upgrade their innovative human capital, and mitigate financing limitations. The study found that there is heterogeneity in the promotion effect of the environmental protection tax on the green technological innovation of businesses in different regions and provinces with varying tax burdens and types of equity capital. Further research shows that the environmental protection tax has a greater impact on the promotion of utility model patent applications for green technology innovation. This paper presents empirical evidence to support further enhancement of the environmental protection tax system. It recommends designing the environmental protection tax policy with consideration for enterprises and local conditions and bolstering the system’s capacity for guiding and stimulating enterprises’ green development.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Vol.:(0123456789)
Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2024) 31:9371–9391
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-023-31736-6
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Can environmental protection tax force enterprises toimprove green
technology innovation?
CongLi1· YaoTeng2· YunxuZhou3· XuetingFeng1
Received: 21 October 2023 / Accepted: 20 December 2023 / Published online: 8 January 2024
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2024
Abstract
The introduction of an environmental protection tax enables a smooth shift from the sewerage charge system to the environ-
mental protection tax scheme. This, in turn, promotes a more sustainable development of enterprise growth, emphasizing
eco-friendliness. This is of immense importance in advancing environmentally aware practices and sustainability. Based
on data collected from A-share listed companies in Shanghai and Shenzhen from 2014 to 2021, this paper investigates the
influence of environmental protection taxes on the advancement of green technology and the underlying mechanisms. Taking
the execution of the Environmental Protection Tax Law in 2018 as a quasi-natural experiment, a double-difference model
is employed to examine the causal relationship between environmental protection taxes and the adoption of green technol-
ogy by companies. The findings indicate that the introduction of an environmental tax could markedly enhance the extent
of green technological innovation within corporations. The evidence arising from the testing mechanism implies that such
a tax can encourage firms to boost their investments in research and development, upgrade their innovative human capital,
and mitigate financing limitations. The study found that there is heterogeneity in the promotion effect of the environmen-
tal protection tax on the green technological innovation of businesses in different regions and provinces with varying tax
burdens and types of equity capital. Further research shows that the environmental protection tax has a greater impact on
the promotion of utility model patent applications for green technology innovation. This paper presents empirical evidence
to support further enhancement of the environmental protection tax system. It recommends designing the environmental
protection tax policy with consideration for enterprises and local conditions and bolstering the system’s capacity for guiding
and stimulating enterprises’ green development.
Keywords Environmental protection tax· Corporate green technology innovation· R&D investment· Innovative human capital·
Financing constraints
Introduction
Since the introduction of economic reforms, China’s econ-
omy has experienced consistent growth. However, its unso-
phisticated development approach has caused significant
environmental damage. This is due to the rapid development
pace of enterprises with low technological proficiency and
a low-level industrial structure, which exacerbates environ-
mental pollution. Green technological innovation encom-
passes all technological innovation activities that support
enterprises in controlling pollution and is crucial for accel-
erating the shift to sustainable development modes for com-
panies (Xu etal. 2023). Therefore, promoting green tech-
nological innovation has become an effective strategy for
reducing pollution. Since 2018, China has implemented an
environmental protection levy on businesses that discharge
Responsible Editor: Nicholas Apergis
* Yunxu Zhou
yunxu@qdu.edu.cn
Cong Li
qdulc2016@163.com
Yao Teng
tanya2426@163.com
Xueting Feng
fengxueting0328@163.com
1 School ofEconomics, Qingdao University, Qingdao,
Shandong, China
2 School ofEconomics andManagement, China University
ofPetroleum-Beijing, Beijing, China
3 College ofInternational Education, Qingdao University,
Qingdao, Shandong, China
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... Levinsohn and Petrin [13] found that environmental regulations, by increasing compliance costs for businesses, alter production decisions and production technology choices, thereby affecting overall production efficiency. In the Chinese context, the research by Li et al. [14] pointed out that environmental regulation may inhibit economic growth in some areas dominated by heavy industry, indicating that environmental regulation may become a constraint on economic growth. Cai and Ye [15] also found that China's new environmental law suppressed corporate total factor productivity (TFP), and the impact lasted for two years. ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper explores the impact of China’s environmental protection tax reform on economic growth through empirical research. Using the “fee to tax” policy implemented in China in 2018 as a natural experiment, the analysis is conducted using a strengthened double-difference (DID) model. It is found that environmental protection tax reform has a significant positive impact on regional economic growth, and this conclusion still holds after several robustness tests. In order to explore the mechanism of environmental protection tax in-depth, this paper analyzes the three dimensions of science and technology innovation investment, foreign direct investment, and tax administration intensity. The results show that environmental protection tax does not promote technological innovation of enterprises as expected, but may instead inhibit R&D and innovation activities by increasing the cost pressure on enterprises. The positive impact of environmental protection tax on economic growth is mainly realized by increasing the intensity of tax administration. Furthermore, this paper analyzes the heterogeneity in urban geographic locations and administrative levels, finding that environmental protection taxes have a significant positive effect on economic growth in central and northeastern regions and in cities with lower administrative levels, while they have a negative effect in the eastern region and in cities with higher administrative levels.
... Some scholars believe that EPT has a negative effect on the economy [16] and that there is no blue dividend [17] or that the realization of the double dividend is conditional [18]. Furthermore, scholars have explored the implementation effect of EPT from multiple angles, such as technological innovation [19], industrial structure [20], energy efficiency [21,22], and enterprise performance [23]. The results of different theoretical models lead to different conclusions. ...
Article
Full-text available
As one of China’s important environmental and economic policies, the environmental protection tax (EPT) is important in promoting economic and social green transformation. In this study, the green total factor productivity (GTFP) of 283 prefecture-level cities in China from 2013 to 2022 was calculated using a Super Slack-Based Model (Super-SBM) and the Malmquist-Luenberger (ML) index, which includes undesirable outputs. Moreover, the implementation effect of environmental tax on promoting urban green transformation is identified through the difference-in-differences (DID) model. This study revealed that (1) an EPT can significantly increase the GTFP of a city and promote its green transformation. (2) Industrial structure optimization and technological innovation are important mechanisms through which EPT drives urban green transformation. (3) The implementation effect of EPT in promoting urban green transformation presents significant policy differences across geographic locations, whether cities are key environmental protection cities or types of resource-based cities. EPT can significantly promote the green transformation of local cities, which in turn can positively affect the green transformation of neighboring cities. Based on this study’s conclusions, suggestions are put forward to improve the EPT system to promote urban green transformation.
Article
Full-text available
Our study moves beyond conventional constraints that primarily examine patent counts, establishing a novel conceptual framework that comprehensively synthesizes dual dimensions—both the volume and caliber of environmental innovations—in the aftermath of environmental taxation implementation. In contrast to prior scholarship, this investigation extends past the mere assessment of policy-driven innovation promotion, conducting an in-depth examination of how environmental fiscal measures reconfigure innovation architecture and elevate innovation excellence. Using a comprehensive panel dataset of Chinese A-share listed companies from 2012 to 2022, we employ a difference-in-differences methodology with multiple robustness checks to establish causal relationships. Our findings reveal three key insights: First, contrary to the Porter Hypothesis, EPT implementation shows a negative correlation with green innovation activities in pollution-intensive sectors, particularly pronounced among private enterprises, smaller firms, and highly competitive markets. Second, the tax policy demonstrates asymmetric effects across patent categories, predominantly constraining invention patents while having a lesser impact on utility models. Third, while the aggregate volume of environmental patent applications decreases, we document a significant improvement in mean innovation quality, especially in utility model patents. The quality-enhancement effect strengthens over time, even as the quantity-reducing impact gradually attenuates. Through detailed mechanism analysis, we identify corporate liquidity constraints and reduced R&D expenditure as primary channels through which EPT affects innovation outcomes. These findings contribute to the theoretical discourse on environmental regulation and corporate innovation by highlighting the quality-quantity trade-off in green innovation responses to environmental taxation. Our results provide important policy implications for optimizing environmental fiscal instruments to promote sustainable technological advancement while maintaining innovation quality.
Article
Full-text available
The aim of this study is to conduct a systematic literature review (SLR) of Green Technology Innovations to synthesize empirical results about how it is examined in the literature during the period 2020 to 2024. Furthermore, this study makes a connection between business and Emerging Green Technology (EGT) advancements for sustainability. The benefits of using green technology in business, particularly in developing nations, are also emphasized. The Systematic Literature Review (SLR) was carried out using the "PRISMA flow diagram method" and "inclusion/exclusion criteria." 57 articles have been considered for review finally from 75 publications. This study used TCM framework to give an in-depth understanding of prevalent theories, contexts, characteristics, and methodology applied in Green Technology Innovations research between the period of 2020 to 2024. This research offers insightful information for companies and policymakers who are looking to build a sustainable society and will be a useful tool for developing economies to develop sustainable strategies to promote long-term corporate growth.
Article
Full-text available
Colombia enfrenta importantes desafíos ambientales debido a los efectos del cambio climático, que podrían generar graves desastres como olas de calor, tormentas, sequías, los cuales repercutirían en la disponibilidad de agua potable y la seguridad alimentaria, además de reducir el PIB y aumentar la pobreza y la desigualdad. Ante este escenario, el país ha implementado políticas para promover prácticas empresariales más sostenibles. Este artículo tiene como objetivo analizar el impacto de los incentivos tributarios en la inversión ambiental de los establecimientos industriales de Colombia, utilizando datos de la Encuesta Ambiental Industrial (EAI) y la Encuesta Anual Manufacturera (EAM) entre 2014 y 2019. Para estimar el impacto de los incentivos fiscales sobre la inversión ambiental se utilizó la técnica Propensity Score Matching y para estimar la brecha en la inversión se empleó la descomposición Blinder-Oaxaca. Los resultados sugieren consistentemente que los establecimientos que recibieron beneficios tributarios realizan en promedio una mayor inversión ambiental que aquellos que no los recibieron. Adicionalmente, se encontró que los establecimientos que hicieron inversión ambiental fueron también los que más residuos generaron. Estos hallazgos resaltan la efectividad de las políticas tributarias para fomentar la inversión ambiental, aunque subrayan la necesidad de un monitoreo riguroso de posibles efectos secundarios que puedan afectar el cumplimiento de los objetivos sostenibles.
Article
Full-text available
In recent years, environmental challenges related to climate change and air pollution have increasingly raised national and international concerns. For this purpose, different countries have adopted mechanisms such as environmental taxes to protect the environment, so this research aims to identify and classify the consequences of environmental taxes from different dimensions. The current study is applied in terms of purpose and meta-synthesis regarding data analysis. In this regard, by referring to the 1209 articles published in reliable domestic and international databases from 2002 to January 2024, 58 articles were identified with the Prisma method; Shannon's entropy has also been used to rank the concepts. In addition, the output of the meta-synthesis method has also been validated using the opinions of 8 experts. The present study of the consequences of environmental tax is presented using Sandelowski and Barroso's seven-step meta-synthesis method. The research findings indicate that 16 concepts and 89 codes for environmental tax consequences were identified. The results also show that in relation to the consequences of environmental tax, emission of climate pollutants, promoting the sustainable development of companies, promoting green development, and reducing economic growth in the short term have the most weight. The findings of the present research can be helpful for legislators and researchers interested in the field of environmental taxation, as they can gain a comprehensive understanding of the consequences of environmental taxation and measure the importance of each of these consequences.
Article
Purpose Environmental, social and governance (ESG) greenwashing is a form of social responsibility response that appears compliant but is substantively oppositional. As an abnormal social behavior, existing research has rarely focused on the deep-seated strategic logic behind ESG greenwashing. Business strategy emerges as the linchpin for companies undertaking a series of decision-making actions. Consequently, this research seeks to provide new insights into the strategic drivers behind corporate greenwashing and the role of institutional investors in mitigating these practices. Design/methodology/approach The research utilizes empirical analysis based on data from Chinese A-share listed companies on the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges from 2010 to 2022. ESG performance data is sourced from the Bloomberg ESG Disclosure Ratings and Thomson Reuters’ Asset4 database. Business strategy is assessed using six key indicators. The study employs institutional theory as the analytical framework, examining the impact of business strategy on ESG greenwashing and investigating the internal mechanisms driving these behaviors. Findings The study finds that compared with defender strategies, prospector strategies are more likely to lead to ESG greenwashing behavior. Specifically, aggressive business strategies tend to facilitate corporate ESG greenwashing. Mechanism analysis indicates that, compared to defenders, prospectors induce ESG greenwashing by increasing information asymmetry (reputation effect) and being constrained by financing limitations (profit-seeking effect). From an external governance perspective, this study finds that institutional investor ownership can mitigate the impact of business strategy on ESG greenwashing. Furthermore, additional research confirms that in heavily polluting industries, the positive effect of business strategy on ESG greenwashing is more pronounced, whereas implementing the Environmental Protection Tax Law curtails the impact of business strategy on ESG greenwashing. Originality/value This study analyzes the role of business strategy in ESG greenwashing, particularly in the context of emerging economies such as China, contributing uniquely to the literature on corporate decision-making and green management. The research extends the application of institutional theory to the field of corporate environmental strategy and introduces the concepts of reputation and profit-seeking effects, offering fresh perspectives on understanding ESG greenwashing behavior. It also provides empirical evidence of the governance role of institutional investors in addressing managerial opportunism related to ESG greenwashing, enriching the existing theoretical framework. Finally, the study highlights the need to establish stronger institutional and managerial mechanisms to effectively tackle corporate greenwashing, offering valuable insights for future research and practice.
Article
Full-text available
Against the pressing backdrop of global climate change, various environmental issues are becoming increasingly prominent, posing unprecedented challenges to both the global economic system and business operations. Green technology innovation, as a critical response to climate change, is vital not only for the sustainable development of firms, but also for fostering the harmonious coexistence of the economy and environment. However, whether climate change itself affects green technology innovation activities is still a topic that needs to be explored in depth. This paper utilizes data from the China Meteorological Administration (CMA), State Intellectual Property Office of China (SIPO), and CRNDS database to empirically examine the impact of climate change on green technology innovation of Chinese A-share listed firms from 2011 to 2020. The findings indicate the following: (1) Climate change significantly inhibits green technology innovation. (2) Entrepreneurs’ green human capital can mitigate the negative impact of climate change on green technology innovation. (3) When faced with higher investor attention or stronger environmental regulation, firms will pay more attention to their green technology innovation when adversely affected by climate change. (4) Resource-based cities show greater resilience against the negative impacts of climate change on green technology innovation compared to non-resource-based cities, suggesting that climate change-induced adaptive behavior may break the resource curse. (5) Mature, non-polluting, high-tech, and non-manufacturing firms are more effective in resisting the inhibitory effects. This research contributes to understanding climate risks and managing them effectively.
Article
Full-text available
Digital inclusive finance eases credit constraints on innovative small and medium-sized enterprises which contributes to urban green technology innovation in China. Government intervention plays an essential role in the development of digital inclusive finance. Based on the panel data of 243 cities in China from 2011 to 2019, this paper empirically examines the relationship between digital inclusive finance and urban green technology innovation as well as the intrinsic mechanism of government intervention. The findings show that, even after a series of robustness tests, digital inclusive finance can promote the quantity and quality of green technology innovation. In terms of its mechanism, digital inclusive finance can empower green technology innovation by complementing traditional financial development and stimulating green consumption, both in terms of supply and demand. At the same time, in the dynamic process of digital financial inclusion from low to high, the development of traditional finance and green consumption level on the marginal promotion of green technology innovation continues to strengthen. The nonlinear relationship test reveals that there is a significant double threshold effect on the positive impact of digital inclusive finance on urban green technology innovation with the evolution of government intervention. The innovation incentive effect of digital financial inclusion will be marginal decreasing with the increase of government intervention. Further considering the heterogeneity of urban geographic location and environmental regulation, it is found that digital financial inclusion promotes green technology innovation more in eastern and high-environmental regulation cities. Based on the above research conclusions, this paper argues that while developing digital inclusion finance, government support policies should be adjusted promptly to constantly stimulate the “Metcalfe’s law” effect of digital inclusive finance enabling green technology innovation.
Article
Full-text available
In recent years, the world has witnessed an alarming rise in extreme events, posing significant challenges to the survival and growth of enterprises. In response, adopting a green development strategy has emerged as an imperative for businesses to bolster their resilience. It is crucial to recognize that not all enterprises possess the same level of resilience, thereby highlighting the disparities in their ability to withstand adversity. Consequently, scholars have been fervently engaging in discussions and research to identify the most effective paths of green development, enabling enterprises to enhance their resilience and adeptly navigate through crises. This study employs questionnaires to scrutinize the influence of environmental regulation, environment social and government performance, and technological innovation on enterprise resilience by constructing structural equations that encompass both external constraints and internal corporate management. The findings demonstrate that environmental regulations can stimulate technological innovation for the purpose of promoting sustainable development, thereby bolstering enterprise resilience; By incorporating environment social and government principles into their operations, enterprises can instil a culture of environmental consciousness and proactively incentivize innovative solutions, ultimately enhancing their capacity to adapt swiftly and recover from crises; The practice of environmental regulation and the incorporation of environment social and government concepts serve as a catalyst for enterprises to engage in technological innovation, thereby promoting technological advancement and enhancing corporate resilience.
Article
Full-text available
The environmental protection tax (EPT) is an important environmental policy in China. However, it remains unclear whether the EPT has reduced environmental pollution effectively since its implementation in 2018. Based on the panel data of 229 prefecture-level cities in China during 2015–2019 and the difference-in-differences (DID) model, this study empirically assesses the causal effect of the EPT on environmental pollution. It is found that the EPT has a significantly negative effect on industrial sulfur dioxide (SO2) and industrial soot (dust) emissions but has no significant impact on industrial wastewater emissions. The mechanism analysis reveals that the EPT has the tax enforcement effect and energy efficiency effect, that is, the EPT reduces pollution emissions through increasing actual tax burden and improving the efficiency of energy utilization. However, the innovation effect is weak, which is only effective in reducing industrial SO2 emissions. Finally, we compare how different types of cities responded to the EPT. The results show that the EPT has limited effect on environmental pollution in large cities and southern China.
Article
Full-text available
Enhancing green total factor productivity (GTFP) is essential for achieving the objective of green development, and the effect of environmental protection tax (EPT), a crucial instrument for addressing environmental challenges, on green TFP is crucial. Based on provincial panel data from 2004 to 2020 in China, this study uses inter-provincial differences in environmental protection tax rates as a quasi-natural experiment and utilizes a synthetic control method to assess the impact of the “changing sewage charge to tax” on regional GTFP. The empirical results suggest that EPT can help enhance GTFP, a finding that still holds after regional placebo tests, time placebo tests, and difference-in-differences robustness tests. The mechanism test demonstrates that EPT influences GTFP via the industrial structure impact and the green technological innovation effect. According to heterogeneity research, regions with a high level of marketization and financial growth are more significantly affected by environmental protection tax policy. This paper offers crucial empirical data for assessing the efficacy of environmental protection tax policy and enhancing the environmental tax system.
Article
This paper exploits a natural Market-based Environmental Regulation (MER) experiment (the 2007 Sulfur dioxide (SO2) Emissions Trading Pilot (ETP) of the 11th five-year plan (FYP)) to assess the empirical relevance of the Porter hypothesis in the context of Chinese firms. MER effects on firms' emissions intensity and innovation performances are quantified by combining a unique sample of 3,198,000 individual firms (including >516,126 SO2 emitting plants) with a Propensity Score Matched Difference-in-Differences (PSM-DID) quasi-experimental framework over the 2001–2014 period. Empirical results show how ETP significantly reduces plant-level SO2 emission intensity while incentivizing polluters to effectively innovate, thus locally reconciling economic and environmental objectives. Findings are robust to replacement variables, restricted samples, parallel trend assumption, and placebo tests, indicating that effective policy and secular smooth time effects are individually captured. Further mechanistic tests suggest that MERs trigger green innovation behaviors of local governments and firms whereas the heterogeneity analysis confirms why large enterprises and regions exposed to strong environmental controls achieve emission reductions more effectively. Implications for global policy are proposed to systematize MER in future environmental planning.
Article
Purpose Green innovation and sustainability are two contemporary initiatives that are gaining more and more attention from researchers, academics and industry professionals as they are considered important business strategies to improve environmental conditions and obtain better organizational performance. Besides, the growth of uncontrolled economic activities leads to an imbalance of economic, social and environmental values in different sectors. However, little is known about the mediating role that economic, social and environmental sustainability has in the relationship between green innovation and firm performance. Previous literature has focused on developed economies, but not on a developing economy such as that of Mexico. Therefore, this research aims to fill this existing gap by exploring the mediating effects of sustainability in the relationship between green innovation and firm performance. Design/methodology/approach A theoretical research model that theorizes, through ten hypotheses, the antecedents and consequences of the mediating effect of economic, social and environmental sustainability and the occurrence between green innovation and firm performance is proposed. The model is tested through PLS-SEM using data that were collected using a questionnaire survey that was distributed among companies in the automotive industry in Mexico. In total, a sample of 460 responses was obtained. Findings The results suggest that green innovation has significant positive effects on economic and environmental sustainability, as well as on firm performance, but not on social sustainability. The results also indicate that the relationship between green innovation and firm performance improves considerably with the mediation of economic, social and environmental sustainability. Research limitations/implications Despite the present study focused on an industrial sector that is commonly at the forefront of technological development, it was limited to a specific region of Mexico. Thus, its results must be taken with caution as more extensive results including other regions and nations will be required to further validate the results obtained from the present study. Practical implications The findings of this study have important implications for both policymakers and managers of manufacturing firms in the automotive industry as they can be used as a basis to formulate better strategies and policies to enhance the capabilities of companies to develop innovations that could reduce environmental risks and other consequences of climate change. Originality/value The present study adds to the innovation and sustainability body of knowledge by analyzing and discussing the mediating role of sustainability in the relationship between green innovation and firm performance. It also generates new knowledge about the mediating effect that sustainability has on the relationship between green innovation and firm performance, particularly in the context of a developing economy such as that of Mexico.