Available via license: CC BY-SA 4.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies
Website: https://journal-center.litpam.com/index.php/jolls/index
Email: jolls@litpam.com
DOI: https://doi.org/10.36312/jolls.v3i2.1348
November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
e-ISSN: 2808-1099
pp. 118-134
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|118
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies of the Singapore English
Language Curriculum: A Learning Experience of Lesson Study
1Lydia Fang Wu, 2Abdul Razak, 3Anna Maria Dashwood
1Education Department, National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore
2School of Languages, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Chancellory II, Penang, Malaysia
3School of Education, University of Southern Queensland, West Street Toowoomba, Australia
*Corresponding Author e-mail: lydia_fang-wu@moe.gov.sg
Received: July 2023; Revised: August 2023; Published: November 2023
Abstract
The innovative teaching strategies employed within the context of Singapore's educational framework have
been judiciously applied to enhance and enrich the English Language Curriculum. These have been
strategically integrated into the pedagogical landscape of English language education. By infusing the English
Language Curriculum with these innovative teaching strategies, educators and learners alike have been
afforded a dynamic and progressive educational experience that transcends traditional paradigms. Therefore,
the researchers investigate the teaching strategies planned and applied in the Singapore English language
curriculum. To attain the research aims, this study was conducted in a lesson study. The conducted Lesson
Study unfolded across a meticulously orchestrated tripartite framework encompassing distinct research stages:
training, instructional planning, and lesson observation. Initially, the data were subjected to a process of "open
coding," as per the methodological tenets. Subsequently, a process of categorical organization ensued,
wherein the data were systematically sorted into discrete categories. The finding showed that The intricate
interplay between lesson study and curriculum innovation has unfolded as a symphonic harmonization that
bridges the theoretical constructs of education with the practical realm of pedagogical implementation,
immersing itself deeply within the crucible of the classroom.
Keywords: innovative teaching strategies; English language curriculum; lesson study
How to Cite: Wu, L.F., Razak, A., & Dashwood, A.M. (2023). Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies
of the Singapore English Language Curriculum: A Learning Experience of Lesson Study. Journal of Language
and Literature Studies, 3(2), 118-134. doi: https://doi.org/10.36312/jolls.v3i2.1348
https://doi.org/10.36312/jolls. v3i2.1348
Copyright© 2023, Wu et al.
This is an open-access article under the CC-BY-SA License.
INTRODUCTION
The introduction of the revised English Language Syllabus can be understood as a
concerted nationwide endeavor aimed at confronting the enduring challenge at hand
(Bayram & Bıkmaz, 2018; Goh & Fang, 2017). The intent behind this initiative was to
effectively address the prevailing circumstances. However, the realization of the
articulated objectives as outlined in the syllabus necessitated a deliberate and nuanced
approach towards the cultivation of essential facets encompassing "skills, learner
strategies, attitudes, and behavior (Akiba et al., 2019; J. M. Amador & Carter, 2018). This
endeavor demanded a meticulous orchestration of various cognitive and linguistic
competencies, intricately interwoven with visual and graphic proficiencies. To
operationalize the desired outcomes delineated within the syllabus, a multifaceted
pedagogical strategy emerged as imperative. This encompassed a systematic
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|119
amalgamation of diverse aptitudes and cognitive processes, converging around six distinct
domains of language acquisition (J. Amador & Weiland, 2015). These domains not only
encapsulated the fundamental building blocks of language proficiency but also
encapsulated a comprehensive spectrum of 29 discrete learning outcomes, meticulously
elaborated upon within the pedagogical framework.
By substantively engaging with the instructional document, educators were
compelled to navigate the intricate interplay between these aforementioned facets. The
cohesive fusion of visual, graphic, linguistic, and cognitive dimensions was requisite for
the realization of the stipulated learning objectives (Asyari et al., 2016; Bayram & Bıkmaz,
2018). Consequently, this pedagogical undertaking transcended traditional paradigms by
fostering a holistic and integrative approach, underpinned by a nuanced comprehension
of the intricate connections between diverse cognitive and linguistic proficiencies
(Alderson & Hudson, 2013; Anthonissen, 2020). In essence, the promulgation of the
revised English Language Syllabus underscored an earnest endeavor to surmount a
persistent challenge. The realization of the envisaged outcomes was predicated upon a
meticulously orchestrated synergy of multifarious cognitive and linguistic attributes,
guided by the overarching framework comprising six distinct domains of language
learning (Al-Rawahi & Al-Mekhlafi, 2015; Azar & Nasiri, 2014). This holistic and
integrative pedagogical approach heralded a paradigm shift, encapsulating a broader
spectrum of aptitudes and proficiencies critical for the multifaceted development of
language skills among learners.
Aligned with the stipulated framework of the syllabus, the instructional landscape
has undergone a deliberate transformation, necessitating an expanded purview beyond
conventional grammar instruction encompassing word, phrase, and text domains (Bjuland
& Helgevold, 2018; Mashudi et al., 2023). This paradigm shift has engendered
multifaceted challenges for educators, who are now tasked with the intricate dissemination
of oracy skills and the adept integration of information and communication technology
within the pedagogical milieu (Akayoğlu, 2021; Alkhataba et al., 2018). Moreover, the
contemporary educational milieu presents an intricate tapestry of diversity, wherein
teachers are confronted with the imperative to effectively cater to the needs of a
heterogeneous cohort of students, characterized by disparate linguistic backgrounds and
varying levels of proficiency. In this dynamic context, pedagogical efficacy hinges upon
the facilitation of an inclusive learning environment that embraces linguistic diversity
while striving for equitable educational outcomes. Concomitantly, students are entrusted
with the formidable endeavor of navigating a comprehensive linguistic landscape,
encompassing both utilitarian communicative competence for everyday interactions and
the nuanced linguistic dexterity requisite for scholarly pursuits (Borghetti, 2013; Celce-
Murcia, 2007).
The acquisition of these multifaceted language proficiencies necessitates concerted
cultivation of effort and skill development, warranting judicious mediation through a well-
structured curriculum (Best et al., 2023; Canale, 2016). Consequently, the evolving
educational milieu underscores the pivotal role of curriculum design and instructional
methodologies in navigating the intricate interplay of linguistic intricacies and pedagogical
demands (Alvunger, 2018; Banegas, 2019). By assimilating oracy skills, leveraging
information and communication technology, and harnessing the dynamic capabilities of
a diverse student body, educators are positioned to facilitate a holistic and skill-oriented
language acquisition process. Concurrently, students are empowered to traverse the
intricate trajectory towards linguistic competence, encompassing everyday functional
adeptness and the requisite acumen for comprehensive textual engagement (Chan, 2020;
Miller et al., 2021). In essence, the curriculum emerges as a pivotal conduit, harmonizing
the intricate interplay of pedagogical interventions and student-centered skill
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|120
development, thereby charting an optimal path towards linguistic proficiency and
cognitive empowerment.
Over an extended duration, the modalities underpinning professional development
initiatives have primarily revolved around widespread dissemination and the training of
designated educators, often termed as key teachers (Coşgun & Savaş, 2023; He &
Bagwell, 2022). These instructional interventions are typically facilitated through
workshops, supplemented by the provision of tangible educational materials in both print
and digital formats. This comprehensive approach is designed to equip these key teachers
with the requisite tools to effectively navigate the transition towards a novel curriculum
(Kontovourki et al., 2018; Macaro et al., 2020). Subsequently, the accrued knowledge and
competencies are intended to be diffused among their peers, encompassing educators
spanning various grade levels. In order to instill a culture of thoughtful introspection and
strategic pedagogical contemplation, educational institutions at the tertiary level, in
conjunction with the Ministry of Education, have allocated dedicated intervals,
colloquially termed as "time-tabled" time, usually amounting to approximately an hour on
a weekly basis.
It is noteworthy, however, that the utilization of this allocated temporal space
diverges among different schools, lacking a standardized and enforceable framework for
its utilization. However, the mere allocation of designated time within the schedule is
insufficient to facilitate the organic emergence of collaborative planning and concerted
efforts to align pedagogical practices with the prescribed syllabus requirements (Arslan &
Curle, 2021; Roofe, 2021). It is imperative to recognize that the efficacy of this temporal
allocation hinges not solely on its presence but rather on the substantive discourse and
subsequent action arising from it. As discerned by a myriad of scholarly researchers, the
transformation of teacher beliefs and instructional paradigms is contingent upon tangible
evidence showcasing the tangible impact of these changes on student learning outcomes.
This transformative process inherently acknowledges the pivotal role played by contextual
dynamics in the construction and application of pedagogical knowledge. Hence, in order
to buttress the endeavors of educators, a collaborative nexus must be forged between the
project team and teachers within educational institutions.
The collaboration, rooted in mutual engagement and concerted effort, should be
geared towards discerning avenues to ameliorate the disparities observed in daily
pedagogical practices. Central to this process is the meticulous evaluation and adaptation
of instructional blueprints and curricular frameworks, underpinned by the stipulated
syllabus outcomes. Concurrently, this collaborative framework should also encompass the
amplification of pedagogical acumen and assessment methodologies, all seamlessly
interwoven within the broader tapestry of lesson study—a dynamic and introspective
approach to instructional enhancement (Lamb, 2015; Lamb & Ko, 2016). In summation,
the prevailing landscape of professional development necessitates a nuanced reevaluation
to foster a more robust and efficacious pedagogical evolution. The amalgamation of key
teachers' knowledge dissemination, time-tabled introspection, and collaborative
engagement within the broader context of lesson study constitutes a comprehensive
strategy to facilitate transformative shifts in teaching practices, informed by contextual
considerations and accentuated by empirically substantiated insights.
In this paper, researchers report the conceptualization, design, and findings of
research on the effectiveness of implementing innovative teaching strategies based on a
collaborative one-year pilot project, enhancing ELT (En-ELT) at seven secondary schools.
The study aimed to assist teachers as they implement the English Language Syllabus at
the lower secondary so that their students are better prepared for learning at the upper
secondary, deepen teacher leadership in school-based curriculum planning, development
and implementation, and infuse twenty-first-century competencies through contextualized
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|121
language teaching and learning (Goh & Fang, 2017; Ming Cheung & Yee Wong, 2014).
To facilitate curriculum innovation, the pilot was conducted by bringing teachers together
for lesson study to explore the use of strategy-rich lessons in class.
The research endeavor at hand was underpinned by a triad of principal inquiries,
which functioned as the guiding compass for this comprehensive study. These inquiries
were meticulously formulated to unravel the multifaceted dimensions of the Enhanced
English Language Teaching (En-ELT) paradigm, with a discerning focus on its
overarching impact on pedagogical competence, formative assessment practices, and
student attainment across the four key language domains of listening, reading, speaking,
and writing. The first research question sought to ascertain the efficacy of the En-ELT
framework in engendering the intended elevation of pedagogical efficacy among
educators. The second research question delved into the transformative potential of the
En-ELT paradigm within the realm of formative assessment practices. The third and final
research question embarked upon an exploration of the En-ELT's pervasive influence
across the entire spectrum of student achievement encompassing listening, reading,
speaking, and writing proficiencies.
Research Framework
Lesson study, a pedagogical methodology characterized by collaborative teacher
engagement, has garnered recognition as a potent and efficacious avenue for professional
development, particularly since its inception within Western educational landscapes, most
notably the United States (Lewis et al., 2011; Saito, 2012). This transformative approach
has subsequently diffused its influence across disparate Asian nations, notably extending
its impact to countries such as Singapore (Goh & Fang, 2017), while concurrently
undergoing adaptation and evolution within distinctive pedagogical frameworks, as
observed in the instances of learning study in locales including Hong Kong and Sweden.
Remarkably, the historical and cultural contexts of Japan and China have engendered a
long-standing tradition of lesson studies deeply ingrained within the fabric of educators'
routine practices (Ming Cheung & Yee Wong, 2014; Sharma & Pang, 2015). Within these
contexts, lesson study serves as a fundamental and intrinsic institutional platform, wherein
the crucible of the classroom environment is harnessed to incubate and assess innovative
curricular paradigms.
The insights gleaned from these pedagogical experiments furnish critical feedback
loops that resonate not only within the classroom but also resonate outwardly to inform
and influence national curricular mandates and educational policies. However, a
noticeable trend within the extant literature pertains to the prevailing dominance of
mathematics and science-focused case studies, thereby relegating inquiries pertaining to
the efficacy of lesson study within English language teaching (ELT) to a relatively
underexplored terrain. An appreciable paucity of documented successful cases delineating
the impact of lesson study on English language pedagogy is evident, further underscoring
the exigency for a comprehensive elucidation of its efficacy within this realm. In light of
this critical void, it becomes incumbent to underscore the indispensable imperative for an
illustrative English language case study.
This case study serves as a vanguard in amplifying the efficacy of lesson study
within the ambit of ELT, thus engendering a nuanced understanding of its adaptability
and transformative potential within diverse linguistic and instructional milieus. The
underlying rationale behind this endeavor resides in its capacity to not only underscore the
applicability of lesson study in ELT but also to delineate its inherent flexibility and
capacity for meaningful adaptations within a multiplicity of curriculum and teaching
contexts. In summation, the narrative landscape surrounding lesson study stands as an
evolving testament to its versatile and adaptive potential, spanning across diverse
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|122
educational contexts. Yet, a pivotal chasm exists, particularly within the realm of English
language instruction, wherein the extant scholarship is relatively constrained. It is
incumbent upon educators and researchers alike to engage in a concerted pursuit of
comprehensively examining the dynamics of lesson study within ELT, thereby unraveling
its latent efficacies and underscoring its pivotal role in shaping pedagogical
transformations across diverse linguistic landscapes and scholastic environments.
METHOD
Research Context
In Singapore, the maintenance of high student achievement in English at the
national examinations is commendable, yet the country must remain vigilant in
safeguarding language standards in light of emerging global challenges faced by its
students. Despite the successful outcomes in formal assessments, concerns arise due to the
prevailing imbalances within the daily classroom environment. These imbalances manifest
in uneven language practice and a predominant reliance on an examination-driven
pedagogy. The current classroom landscape is characterized by an inclination towards
traditional teacher-centered methods and a perpetuation of the "teacher as authority"
paradigm (Cohen et al., 2018). Consequently, the focus on rote memorization and
examination preparation overshadows the cultivation of more advanced cognitive skills
among students. As a consequence, their ability to critically analyze, synthesize
information, and engage in independent and creative thought is hindered.
For Singapore to effectively equip its students to navigate the complexities of an
interconnected world, it is imperative to reevaluate and revamp the existing pedagogical
approaches. Educators should strive to promote student-centered methodologies that
foster active learning, critical thinking, and creative problem-solving abilities. Embracing
progressive teaching strategies, such as inquiry-based learning, collaborative projects, and
experiential activities, can help bridge the gap between formal assessments and
comprehensive cognitive development. Furthermore, incorporating technology into the
educational landscape can enhance language learning and communication skills,
preparing students for the demands of a digitally driven-global society. By leveraging
online resources, interactive learning platforms, and language learning applications,
educators can create dynamic and engaging learning experiences that cater to diverse
student needs and learning styles. Therefore, the recognition of the discrepancies between
formal examination success and the development of essential cognitive competencies in
the classroom urges Singapore's educational stakeholders to foster a more balanced and
holistic language education. Emphasizing the cultivation of complex language skills and
critical thinking within the instructional setting will empower students to not only excel
academically but also effectively communicate and thrive in the face of new and evolving
global challenges.
Research Design
The present study is a Lesson Study (Cohen et al., 2018; Creswell, 2009). The
conducted Lesson Study unfolded across a meticulously orchestrated tripartite framework
encompassing distinct research stages: training, instructional planning, and lesson
observation. The initial phase, characterized by a pedagogical emphasis on experiential
learning, was meticulously structured to engender a comprehensive understanding and
practical assimilation of the underpinning teaching strategies. Within this trajectory, the
training module was meticulously bifurcated into two integral components, each imbued
with distinct pedagogical orientations. The inaugural segment of the training delved into
the theoretical bedrock underpinning each teaching strategy, thereby crystallizing an
insightful comprehension of its conceptual underpinnings and situational relevance within
diverse linguistic contexts. This pivotal juncture facilitated an intricate analysis of the
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|123
interplay between the different strategies, fostering an enriched understanding of their
seamless integration and progressive synergy. Furthermore, this theoretical exploration
was artfully interwoven with a nuanced revisitation of the principles underpinning
Assessment for Learning (AfL), thereby holistically contextualizing these tenets within the
ambit of the diverse teaching strategies.
Sequentially, the theoretical framework was seamlessly transitioned into
experiential implementation, marking a transformative bridge between theoretical
elucidation and practical enactment. As an embodiment of instructional planning,
educators were tasked with meticulously crafting a lesson plan outline, thoughtfully
extracted from a pre-existing, relevant unit of instruction. This contextual tethering served
to furnish a meaningful backdrop within which the selected teaching strategy could be
seamlessly embedded and evaluated. The culminating phase within this research trajectory
was marked by the instantiation of micro-teaching sessions, catalyzed by the meticulously
devised lesson plan outlines. These micro-teaching segments, facilitated by the
practitioners, served as an embodiment of the synthesized theoretical insights and
instructional planning endeavors. Moreover, these sessions effectively metamorphosed
into a vibrant arena for the synthesis of pedagogical theory, instructional pragmatism, and
empirical observation. In essence, the multifaceted Lesson Study journey embarked upon
a meticulously orchestrated symphony of training, instructional planning, and experiential
enactment. This intricately choreographed progression served as an exemplary
embodiment of the seamless integration of pedagogical theory and empirical praxis,
thereby underscoring the transformative potential of Lesson Study as a robust platform for
the synthesis and application of multifarious pedagogical dimensions.
Data Analysis
The current study is a Lesson Study that has two kinds of data, qualitative and
quantitative data. The qualitative data amassed through the meticulous execution of the
lesson study framework underwent a methodical analytical journey, guided by established
protocols. Initially, the data were subjected to a process of "open coding," as per the
methodological tenets. This involved the systematic allocation of discerning labels to the
textual substratum, thereby imbuing the corpus with a structured organizational
framework that facilitated subsequent analysis. Subsequently, a process of categorical
organization ensued, wherein the data were systematically sorted into discrete categories,
each representing distinct facets and dimensions that transpired during the course of the
lesson study. This categorical structuring, in turn, furnished the substratum for the
delineation of "core categories," which held the pivotal role of encapsulating overarching
patterns and emergent themes that germinated organically from the empirical terrain.
These core categories functioned as analytical signposts, elucidating the intricate
trajectories of the lesson study process as it unfolded across its various stages: training,
instructional planning, lesson observation, and the culminating colloquium.
A cardinal facet of this analytical journey involved the curation of choice
quotations, meticulously cherry-picked to encapsulate the essence of the emergent themes.
These select excerpts served as potent exemplars, crystallizing the salient aspects and
qualitative nuances encapsulated within the broader thematic scaffolding. As a result,
these choice quotations emerged as illustrative capsules, adeptly encapsulating and
foregrounding the qualitative subtleties that resonated throughout the lesson study
process. In essence, the qualitative data amassed during the lesson study underwent a
rigorous analytical metamorphosis, akin to the sculpting of raw material into refined
contours of meaning. This analytical odyssey, founded upon the principled edifice of open
coding and categorical organization, culminated in the identification of core categories
and their attendant thematic trajectories. The interwoven process of curating choice
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|124
quotations further enriched this analytical tapestry, effectively transmuting raw data into
a nuanced and insightful narrative that unveiled the intricacies and dynamics inherent to
the multifarious stages of the lesson study journey.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Research Findings
The culmination of data amalgamation from diverse sources engendered a tapestry
of multifaceted findings, encompassing a spectrum of salient domains intrinsic to the
educational landscape. This comprehensive expanse of investigation traversed pivotal
dimensions, including the professional development of educators, the intricate contours of
curriculum dissemination actualized through the pedagogical vehicle of lesson study, the
multifarious nuances underpinning assessment practices, and the consequential
intersections between student learning trajectories and ultimate academic outcomes.
Beyond these interwoven facets, the overarching impact of the project resonated across
the entire educational ecosystem, spanning teachers, teaching methodologies, and the
broader panorama of learning experiences.
Within the framework of this discourse, the present study situates itself with
deliberate precision, concentrating its analytical lens on the intricate interplay between
lesson study and the efficacious delivery of the English Language (EL) curriculum. In
doing so, the investigation adroitly directs its focus towards the intricate dynamics
surrounding the pedagogical practice and the corresponding responses elicited from
students, all catalyzed by the meticulous utilization of strategies intrinsic to lesson study.
This nuanced vantage point is ingeniously cultivated by foregrounding the perspectives of
both school advisors and teachers, thus underscoring the synergistic and collaborative
nature of the pedagogical exploration. Central to the crux of this paper is the resolute intent
to meticulously delineate the links between lesson study as a pedagogical paradigm and
its tangible manifestation within the realm of EL curriculum delivery. The analytical
expedition embarks upon an incisive exploration of pedagogical practice, discerningly
investigating how the intricate orchestration of lesson study strategies resonates within the
context of classroom instruction. A concurrent endeavor lies in unraveling the intricate
tapestry of student engagement and response, thereby offering a nuanced comprehension
of the transformative potential that ensues from the strategic integration of lesson study
within the EL curriculum.
Training
Commencing at the inception of each iterative cycle, a meticulously orchestrated
training regimen served as the foundational crucible for teachers' immersive engagement
with subject matter knowledge, firmly anchored within the contours of explicit
pedagogical strategies. The triad of retelling, process writing, and reciprocal teaching
formed the bedrock of this cognitive exploration, with their conceptual profundities
systematically unveiled through pedagogical exposition. The training schema adroitly
facilitated the fusion of theoretical apprehension with tangible contextualization,
effectuated by means of hands-on experiential activities and didactic video-clip exemplars.
This confluence engendered a contextual tapestry, ensconcing the theoretical constructs
within the vivid hues of practical classroom dynamics. Emanating as an intrinsic facet of
this training orchestration was the judicious emulation of the lesson study paradigm. This
emulation transpired across a multilayered framework, seamlessly interwoven within the
pedagogical tapestry.
Noteworthy within this emulative tapestry were the delineated junctures
encompassing instructional planning, microteaching enactments, and the ensuing
pedagogical critique. This tripartite continuum effectively simulated the iterative and
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|125
introspective ethos inherent to lesson study, thus entrenching the pedagogical cognizance
within a dynamic and experiential landscape. The probing of teachers' perceptual
responses to this comprehensive training trajectory, garnered through the conduit of a
structured teacher survey, brought to the fore a discernible acknowledgment of the utility
and applicability of the acquired knowledge, perspectives, and skills within their classroom
praxis. Evidenced by the quantified mean scores, which stood at 3.4 for retelling, 3.1 for
process writing, and 3.3 for reciprocal teaching, the educators' responses stood as a
testament to the cogent integration of pedagogical theory and practical application. This
perceptual validation underscored the robustness of the training schema in equipping
teachers with tangible pedagogical tools, thereby facilitating a dynamic and enriched
instructional milieu.
Instructional Planning
During the inaugural Cycle 1 of implementation, an insightful report offered by the
school advisors illuminated several pivotal observations pertaining to the intricate
dynamics inherent within the Reflective Learning (RL) framework. The report served to
unveil the nuanced complexities encompassing the early stages of lesson study,
particularly the nascent forays into the interpretive nuances of the pedagogical strategy. A
discerning analysis underscored the presence of initial setbacks, marked by tentative
undertakings, equivocal discernment, and a measure of incompleteness in comprehending
both the procedural mechanics of lesson study and the nuanced essence embedded within
the selected teaching strategy. The trajectory of the initial cycle bore witness to noteworthy
instances of procedural evolution, each lending crucial insights into the transformative
trajectory of the lesson study paradigm. One salient instance illuminated the emergent
evolution of collaborative planning, as a palpable departure from the initial proclivity
towards solo endeavors. Within this context, it became evident that the blueprinting of RL
plans had hitherto been predominantly orchestrated by instructional leaders or level
coordinators, reflecting a departure from the collaborative ethos intrinsic to lesson study.
During the subsequent Cycle 2, an insightful evaluation proffered by school
advisors illuminated noteworthy shifts within the pedagogical landscape, underscoring the
emergence of collaborative dimensions within the planning of the Reflective Learning
(RL) framework. Across all participating schools, discernible evidences of collaborative
engagement materialized, most notably observed among RL1 teachers. This collaborative
initiative manifested in comprehensive discussions encompassing the formulation of pre-
writing strategies, intricate deliberations concerning question formulation for the co-
construction of textual content, and productive conferencing sessions dedicated to the
refinement and enhancement of co-constructed paragraphs, shaped collectively through
interactive engagement with the class. Integral to this collaborative trajectory was the
experiential synthesis of pedagogical insights, which culminated in the coherent
articulation of instructions for autonomous student groups to independently replicate an
additional paragraph, encapsulating the quintessence of the RL pedagogical paradigm.
Despite these notable strides, the cycle bore witness to a set of preliminary challenges,
reflective of the nascent evolution of the RL framework.
As the pedagogical trajectory advanced into Cycle 3 during Year 2, a discernible
transformation surfaced within the demeanor of the educators, underscored by an
augmented acumen pertaining to the anticipatory dynamics inherent to the lesson study
process. This evolution was conspicuously rooted in a convergence of catalytic factors,
chief among them being the systematic maturation of the formalized advisory visit tool.
This evolved tool intricately delineated a structured framework of proactive engagements,
thereby furnishing educators with a lucid roadmap of sequential actions to be navigated
within the course of their pedagogical endeavors. This formalization not only engendered
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|126
a heightened sense of procedural clarity but also functioned as an experiential scaffold that
amplified educators' perceptual insights, concomitantly nurturing a coherent sense of what
lay ahead in the pedagogical journey. Furthermore, a pivotal inflection point was
precipitated by the transition from lesson outlines to more comprehensive and
meticulously curated lesson plans. This pivotal departure in instructional design
holistically enriched the pedagogical discourse by articulating a panoramic vista of
instructional trajectories, intricately interwoven within the broader tapestry of lesson
study. This evolution not only facilitated comprehensive discussions but also engendered
a heightened capacity for nuanced pedagogical reflection and refinement, thereby
affording educators the means to traverse the interplay between instructional aspirations
and pragmatic realizations with heightened precision and coherence.
Lesson Observations
During the inaugural phase of Cycle 1, a pronounced emphasis on the shared
endeavor of sharing and comparing crystallized as a pivotal facet within the pedagogical
landscape, particularly with regard to the retelling process at the secondary level.
However, the nuanced execution of this pedagogical imperative was not uniformly
attained with optimal efficacy. As per the discerning observations of the school advisors,
a discernible variance manifested in the successful implementation of this shared and
comparative pedagogical approach. Evidently, a subset of educators, accounting for
approximately 50 percent of the teaching cohort (equating to seven out of 14 educators),
effectively facilitated the pivotal process of student engagement in comparative analysis,
wherein students were tasked with discerning and elucidating discrepancies and variances
between the original text and their retellings.
Within the realm of Cycle 2, a discernible augmentation in the instructional
configuration unfolded through the strategic amalgamation of retelling with the process
writing pedagogical paradigm. This confluence engendered a harmonized instructional
synergy, accentuating the efficacy of idea generation for writing tasks. The amalgamation
facilitated a distinctive modality wherein students were equipped to seamlessly "borrow"
salient points from the provided textual material, simultaneously imbuing their
compositions with original ideational contributions. The symbiotic interplay between
these pedagogical facets furnished a dynamic trajectory, epitomizing a seamless fusion of
guided textual engagement and autonomous creative thought, thereby effectuating a novel
and enriched dimension within the writing process. This intricate pedagogical
orchestration resonated resonated not only within the confines of the student landscape
but reverberated through the perceptual echelons of both educators and school advisors.
The constructive integration of retelling and process writing underscored an experiential
continuity, thereby reinforcing the iterative practice of retelling that had initially been
cultivated within Cycle 1.
Within the purview of Cycle 3, a discernible manifestation of the reciprocal
teaching (RcT) strategy unfolded, permeating a substantial proportion of instructional
interactions. The Reflective Learning (RL) educators adeptly delineated the purpose and
modus operandi of RcT, articulating a coherent sequence that traversed from predictive
conjecture (P) to elucidatory elucidation (C), insightful interrogation (Q), and culminating
summation (S). This articulation was seamlessly punctuated by the judicious
incorporation of the specialized meta-linguistic facets intrinsic to the strategy.
Notwithstanding this adroit delineation, the actualization of the process was occasionally
punctuated by a modicum of intermittent unevenness, with the seamless rhythmic flow
not invariably maintained. However, this pedagogical trajectory confronted a nuanced
challenge that surfaced within the interpretive dimensions of RcT, particularly in its
bifurcated application across Class-RcT and Group-RcT contexts. This distinct
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|127
interpretation bifurcated across two distinct facets, each of which underpinned
pedagogical implementations of the strategy.
Teacher Learning
Across a triadic trajectory encompassing retelling, process writing, and reciprocal
teaching, the pedagogical odyssey of teacher learning with respect to Assessment for
Learning (AfL) traversed the expanse of three iterative cycles. Delving into the specific
realm of assessment practices, the present exploration unfurls the nuanced tapestry of the
instructors' engagement with AfL within the intricate folds of the aforementioned
pedagogical paradigms. In the context of retelling, the educators exhibited a generalized
cognizance of the transformative potential of AfL, discerning its latent capacity to wield a
tangible influence upon the trajectory of student learning. However, a discernible
disjuncture surfaced within this paradigm, as a notable subset comprising 50 percent of the
educator cohort, totaling seven out of 14, grappled with the subsequent operationalization
of assimilated AfL insights into pedagogical praxis. This disposition was conspicuously
mirrored in the realm of progress documentation, where a mere quintet of educators out
of the overall cohort proactively recorded students' academic advancements. This
discernible reticence, it could be contended, was inextricably linked to the embryonic stage
of the lesson study journey, notably evident in Cycle 1. During this nascent phase, a
distinct lack of intuitive focus on "student learning" as a central pivot to pedagogy hindered
the educators' proclivity to perpetually amass evidence of scholastic advancement.
Discussion
The dynamic interplay between lesson study and curriculum innovation unfolded
as a nuanced orchestration that seamlessly linked theoretical constructs with pedagogical
praxis, inherently embedded within the classroom crucible. This symbiotic nexus between
pedagogical theory and immediate enactment emerged as the quintessence of lesson
study's transformative potential, notably underscored by its strategic provision of structure
and procedural frameworks. Lesson study, functioning as a catalytic conduit for
curriculum innovation, stood as an experiential crucible where the unison of theory and
practice unfolded with palpable immediacy (Angeli & Valanides, 2009; Bayram &
Bıkmaz, 2018). At its core, lesson study wielded a profound pedagogical impetus, ushering
teachers into a realm where theoretical constructs converged seamlessly with classroom
realities. This transformative trajectory was adeptly facilitated by the prescient provision
of systematic structures and enduring routines that served as conduits for the
transmutation of theoretical paradigms into tangible instructional praxis.
Within the complex mosaic of lesson study, the structural scaffold manifested as a
keystone, acutely pivotal in facilitating the translation of pedagogical theory into
efficacious classroom practice. The meticulous employment of pedagogical tools,
conspicuously encapsulated within the contours of templates and thinking frames,
emerged as an instrumental catalyst, efficaciously operationalizing the intricacies of the
lesson study processes (J. Amador & Weiland, 2015; Lamb & King, 2021; Lamb & Ko,
2016). These tools, replete with prescriptive delineations, adroitly demystified the
intricacies of instructional planning, lesson observations, and culminating colloquia. As a
direct result, the pivotal ethos of lesson study was perpetuated across successive cycles,
forging an indelible imprint of pedagogical routines underscored by the cadence of
deliberation, negotiation, reflection, and consensus building. This cyclically reiterated
enactment, fortified by the scaffolding of clear "structures," culminated in the
crystallization of enduring pedagogical routines. These routines, perpetually honed
through successive cycles of lesson study, emerged as a pivotal pedagogical landscape
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|128
where deliberation seamlessly intertwined with consensus building and reflective
introspection.
This methodological continuum was particularly germane for the project schools,
poised as they were on the cusp of their foray into the English lesson study paradigm. This
contextually responsive approach garnered pronounced efficacy within these project
schools, thereby attesting to the pragmatic pertinence of leveraging lesson study as a
transformative medium for curriculum innovation. In essence, the entwined narrative of
lesson study and curriculum innovation underscored the profound efficacy of experiential
enactment in seamlessly bridging the theoretical-practical chasm (Mambu, 2022;
Nejadghanbar, 2021). The orchestrated infusion of pedagogical tools and procedural
frameworks converged harmoniously, fostering an enriched pedagogical ethos marked by
the iterative cadence of lesson study. This resonant symphony, emblematic of the
reciprocal relationship between theory and praxis, permeated the instructional milieu,
ultimately furnishing educators with a transformative crucible wherein curriculum
innovation thrived within the dynamic embrace of immediate classroom enactment.
Among the multifarious roles assumed by school advisors, three discrete functions
assumed paramount significance in shaping the outcomes of the educational innovation,
orchestrating a nuanced orchestration that was instrumental in driving transformative
progress. This triad of pivotal roles, encompassing facilitation, advisory guidance, and
problem-solving, collectively constituted a dynamic framework that profoundly resonated
within the pedagogical landscape, intrinsically interwoven with the lesson study paradigm
(Kao, 2023; Roofe, 2021). Functioning as facilitators, the school advisors embarked on a
multifaceted role characterized by an intricate blend of pedagogical modeling, protocol
enforcement, and collaborative leadership (Arslan & Curle, 2021; Chan, 2020). This
orchestration unfurled as a dynamic pedagogical choreography, with the advisors adroitly
exemplifying the lesson study protocol and exacting standards of pedagogical practice.
This pedagogical choreography extended beyond mere exemplification, engendering a
profound engagement that cohesively hinged upon the discerning appraisal of observed
pedagogical manifestations, achieved milestones within Reflective Learning (RL)
iterations, and ensuing commitments forged through collective deliberations. The strategic
navigational acumen of advisors was resonantly evident in their multifarious pedagogical
interactions, epitomizing a resolute commitment to crystallizing collective pedagogical
decisions and fostering a synergistic pedagogical trajectory.
Embedded within the advisory function, the school advisors assumed the mantle
of astute mentors, guiding teachers along the intricate labyrinth of pedagogical evolution.
This pedagogical mentorship was articulated through a multifaceted spectrum,
encompassing corrective interventions for conceptual misunderstandings, discerning the
contours of instructional "blind spots" that materialized during the RL progression, and
adeptly shedding light upon uncharted pedagogical territories. This multifaceted
mentorship was acutely tailored to the contextual exigencies and individual pedagogical
odysseys of educators, resonating as an embodiment of pedagogical sensitivity and
strategic foresight that underscored the transformative potential of advisory mentorship.
The role of problem solvers borne by the school advisors crystallized as a potent catalyst
for pedagogical refinement, orchestrated through the prism of prescriptive introspection
and strategic foresight. This facet was punctuated by a profound focus on future-oriented
actions that held the potential to elevate the pedagogical landscape of English language
teaching and learning (Chan, 2020; Mambu, 2022; Nejadghanbar, 2021). In the wake of
rigorous colloquia deliberations, the advisors astutely directed pedagogical focus toward
the cultivation of future-oriented actions, deeply rooted in the empirical bedrock of
generalizable principles derived from astute pedagogical practice. This dialectic interplay
between pedagogical foresight and tangible action delineated the quintessence of the
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|129
problem-solving role, emblematic of a transformative agency that galvanized the
pedagogical ecosystem.
The empirical findings gleaned from the study corroborate a discernible trajectory
wherein educators progressively fortified their capacity to seamlessly integrate Assessment
for Learning (AfL) into the pedagogical praxis, thereby orchestrating a tangible influence
upon the instructional landscape. This transformative progression was markedly
pronounced within the realm of Reflective Learning 2 (RL2), attesting to a crystallization
of pedagogical acumen that resonated within the confluence of teaching and AfL-infused
assessment practices. An overarching thematic resonance encapsulated within the findings
emanates from a pivotal transition within educators' pedagogical oeuvre (He & Bagwell,
2022; Macaro et al., 2020). This transition is emblematic of a gradual metamorphosis
wherein educators not only honed their proficiency in incorporating AfL as an active
pedagogical lever but also adeptly harnessed the informational insights gleaned from
student learning to effectuate judicious recalibrations within the pedagogical continuum.
This pedagogical recalibration, profoundly evident within the precincts of RL2,
engendered an observable shift in educators' engagement with student learning evidence –
a shift that traversed from the antecedent vestiges of scant documentation to a paradigm
characterized by conspicuous evidentiary substantiation.
This perceptible transformation was underpinned by a perceptual shift, aptly
encapsulated within the metaphorical notion of acquiring an "eye on student learning,"
denoting an astute acumen that facilitated the discerning assimilation and utilization of
student-centric insights within pedagogical navigation. This transformative juncture
within pedagogical practice culminated in the establishment of an intricate pedagogical
tapestry, wherein teaching and assessment forged a symbiotic resonance, intertwining in
a seamless symphony of pedagogical advancement (Kontovourki et al., 2018; Macaro et
al., 2020; Taşdemir & Karaman, 2022). This orchestration of pedagogical elements
catalyzed a perceptible amplification of pedagogical "visibility," where the heretofore
latent contours of pedagogical exchange were enunciated with pronounced lucidity. The
catalytic effect extended further, imposing a compelling sense of accountability upon the
pedagogical landscape – an accountability inextricably linked to learning outcomes. It is
within this ecosystem of pedagogical accountability that educators galvanized their agency
as proactive problem solvers, effectually transmogrifying pedagogical challenges into
potent crucibles for innovation and refinement.
Integral to this transformative pedagogical panorama is an alignment with the
observational tenets articulated in extant literature. A confluence of experiential
observation and theoretical postulation converges to substantiate the notion that
pedagogical innovation flourishes within the fertile grounds of communal engagement
with emerging pedagogical quandaries (Bocala, 2015; Goh & Fang, 2017). This interactive
milieu engenders a fertile terrain wherein the pedagogical community, in their quest to
grapple with nascent challenges, fosters a synergistic landscape characterized by the
unfettered exchange of experiential wisdom and innovative pedagogical praxis. Of
paramount significance is the strategic utilization of language acquisition strategies within
the English Language Syllabus, yielding an enriched pedagogical prism wherein students
are immersed within a milieu of efficacious language experiences, replete with salient
stimulus materials and exemplar models of proficient linguistic dexterity (Haerazi &
Nunez, 2022; Naqsyabandiyah & Dehghanitafti, 2023). This contextual emphasis finds a
harmonious congruence within the paradigm where student learning assumes the mantle
of a curriculum regulator. In such a paradigmatic equilibrium, the conventional focal
points of assessment, rote practices, and examination-centric pedagogy are eclipsed,
supplanted by a pedagogical ethos that pivots around the pivotal axis of experiential
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|130
practice, collaborative exploration, and immersive engagement with the pedagogical
journey.
The empirical trajectory encapsulated within the study unveils a transformative
odyssey wherein educators progressively embrace and adeptly wield the pedagogical
prowess of AfL integration (Angeli & Valanides, 2009; Kao, 2023). The journey,
resoundingly underscored by the transformative crucible of RL2, resonates as an
embodiment of pedagogical enlightenment, where educators assume the mantle of
proactive problem solvers and pedagogical stewards. This immersive transformation,
seamlessly interwoven with an acute sensitivity to language acquisition strategies,
permeates a pedagogical milieu wherein student learning unfurls as the fulcrum that
invariably orchestrates pedagogical design, thereby engendering a pedagogical landscape
characterized by experiential resonance, collaborative ethos, and an unswerving
commitment to the transformative potential inherent within the pedagogical odyssey.
CONCLUSION
The intricate interplay between lesson study and curriculum innovation has
unfolded as a symphonic harmonization that bridges the theoretical constructs of
education with the practical realm of pedagogical implementation, immersing itself deeply
within the crucible of the classroom. This symbiotic nexus between pedagogical theory
and immediate enactment emerges as the quintessence of lesson study's transformative
potency, a resonance magnificently exemplified through the strategic scaffolding and
procedural frameworks it offers. Lesson study stands as a dynamic catalyst for curriculum
innovation, where theory and practice coalesce in a profound experiential crucible,
encapsulating the profound significance of its structured approach. At its core, lesson study
propels educators into a realm where theoretical foundations are seamlessly woven into
the fabric of classroom reality.
This transformative trajectory is skillfully facilitated through the provision of
systematic structures and enduring routines that serve as conduits for the transmutation of
theoretical paradigms into tangible instructional praxis. The meticulous deployment of
pedagogical tools, enshrined within templates and thinking frames, emerges as an
instrumental catalyst, effectively operationalizing the intricate intricacies of the lesson
study processes. These tools, replete with prescriptive delineations, adeptly demystify the
complexities of instructional planning, lesson observations, and culminating colloquia. As
a direct consequence, the central tenets of lesson study reverberate across successive cycles,
engendering an indelible imprint of pedagogical routines that are honed and perfected
through the iterative cadence of deliberation, negotiation, reflection, and consensus
building. The profound implications of this methodological continuum are particularly
pronounced for project schools that find themselves at the nascent stages of their journey
within the English lesson study paradigm.
RECOMMENDATION
The findings and subsequent analysis offer a compelling recommendation, positing
that the project possesses a considerable reservoir of potential to effectively persuade
educators of its inherent merits. However, in order to foster a sustained engagement and
commitment on the part of teachers in championing the enduring viability of the
curriculum innovation, a comprehensive approach to project implementation is
imperative. This necessitates an emphasis on prolonged exposure to the utilization of
pedagogical strategies across all classroom settings and pertinent lessons, underpinned by
a concerted effort to facilitate the dissemination of exemplary practices that extend beyond
the confines of individual year levels. Moreover, the cultivation of a seamless transfer of
acquired knowledge among educators is paramount, positioning them as the vanguards of
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|131
transformative pedagogical methodologies. To navigate the course toward the refinement
of classroom practices, a deliberate and intentional infusion of strategy-rich lessons into
the school curriculum becomes imperative. This strategic integration must be imbued with
a continuous and unwavering commitment, fostering a pedagogical milieu that is both
dynamic and responsive. The symphony of innovation that reverberates within the
curriculum should encapsulate a harmonious convergence of theoretical constructs and
practical application, thereby engendering a pedagogical landscape marked by efficacy,
engagement, and transformative educational outcomes.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Researchers extend our sincere appreciation to the school advisors, teachers, and students
who participated in this study, offering invaluable insights, perspectives, and experiences
that enriched our understanding of the practical implications of these innovative strategies.
Their dedication to the pursuit of effective pedagogy and transformative learning
experiences has been a source of inspiration throughout this research journey. Researchers
acknowledge the role of our research institution, which provided the necessary resources,
infrastructure, and scholarly environment that enabled us to undertake this research with
rigor and depth. Their constant belief in our endeavors provided the motivation to
persevere and strive for excellence in this scholarly pursuit. The collaborative spirit and
collective efforts of these individuals and entities have been pivotal in shaping the
trajectory of this study, and their contributions are deeply appreciated and acknowledged.
REFERENCES
Akayoğlu, S. (2021). Teaching CALL to Pre-service Teachers of English in a Flipped
Classroom. Technology, Knowledge and Learning, 26(1), 155–171.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10758-019-09428-3
Akiba, M., Murata, A., Howard, C. C., & Wilkinson, B. (2019). Lesson study design
features for supporting collaborative teacher learning. Teaching and Teacher
Education, 77, 352–365. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2018.10.012
Alderson, J. C., & Hudson, R. (2013). The metalinguistic knowledge of undergraduate
students of English language or linguistics. Language Awareness, 22(4), 320–337.
https://doi.org/10.1080/09658416.2012.722644
Alkhataba, E. H. A., Abdul-Hamid, S., & Ibrahim, B. (2018). Technology-Supported
Online Writing: An Overview of Six Major Web 2.0 Tools for Collaborative-
Online Writing. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3151131
Al-Rawahi, L. S., & Al-Mekhlafi, A. M. (2015). The effect of online collaborative project-
based learning on English as a Foreign Language learners’ language performance
and attitudes. Learning and Teaching in Higher Education: Gulf Perspectives, 12(2), 74–
91. https://doi.org/10.18538/lthe.v12.n2.186
Alvunger, D. (2018). Teachers’ Curriculum Agency in Teaching a Standards‐Based
Curriculum. The Curriculum Journal, 29(4), 479–498.
https://doi.org/10.1080/09585176.2018.1486721
Amador, J. M., & Carter, I. S. (2018). Audible conversational affordances and constraints
of verbalizing professional noticing during prospective teacher lesson study. Journal
of Mathematics Teacher Education, 21(1), 5–34. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10857-016-
9347-x
Amador, J., & Weiland, I. (2015). What Preservice Teachers and Knowledgeable Others
Professionally Notice During Lesson Study. The Teacher Educator, 50(2), 109–126.
https://doi.org/10.1080/08878730.2015.1009221
Angeli, C., & Valanides, N. (2009). Epistemological and Methodological Issues for the
Conceptualization, Development, and Assessment of ICT–TPCK: Advances in
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|132
Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPCK). Computers & Education,
52(1), 154–168. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compedu.2008.07.006
Anthonissen, L. (2020). Cognition in construction grammar: Connecting individual and
community grammars. Cognitive Linguistics, 31(2), 309–337.
https://doi.org/10.1515/cog-2019-0023
Arslan, S., & Curle, S. (2021). Sustainable Development Goals in the English Language
High School Curriculum in Turkey. European Journal of Education, 56(4), 681–695.
https://doi.org/10.1111/ejed.12473
Asyari, M., Al Muhdhar, M. H. I., Susilo, H., & . I. (2016). Improving critical thinking
skills through the integration of problem based learning and group investigation.
International Journal for Lesson and Learning Studies, 5(1), 36–44.
https://doi.org/10.1108/IJLLS-10-2014-0042
Azar, A. S., & Nasiri, H. (2014). Learners’ Attitudes toward the Effectiveness of Mobile
Assisted Language Learning (MALL) in L2 Listening Comprehension. Procedia -
Social and Behavioral Sciences, 98, 1836–1843.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sbspro.2014.03.613
Banegas, D. L. (2019). Language Curriculum Transformation and Motivation Through
Action Research. The Curriculum Journal, 30(4), 422–440.
https://doi.org/10.1080/09585176.2019.1646145
Bayram, İ., & Bıkmaz, F. (2018). Exploring the Lesson Study Experience of EFL
Instructors at Higher Education: A Pilot Study. Journal of Qualitative Research in
Education, 6(3), 1–28. https://doi.org/10.14689/issn.2148-2624.1.6c3s15m
Best, M. C., Jones, K., Washington, J., Sullivan, J., Kearney, M., & Puchalski, C. (2023).
Evaluation of the Interprofessional Spiritual Care Education Curriculum in
Australia: Online. Palliative and Supportive Care, 21(1), 65–73.
https://doi.org/10.1017/S1478951522000244
Bjuland, R., & Helgevold, N. (2018). Dialogic processes that enable student teachers’
learning about pupil learning in mentoring conversations in a Lesson Study field
practice. Teaching and Teacher Education, 70, 246–254.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2017.11.026
Bocala, C. (2015). From Experience to Expertise: The Development of Teachers’ Learning
in Lesson Study. Journal of Teacher Education, 66(4), 349–362.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487115592032
Borghetti, C. (2013). Integrating Intercultural and Communicative Objectives in the
Foreign Language Class: A Proposal for the Integration of Two Models. The
Language Learning Journal, 41(3), 254–267.
https://doi.org/10.1080/09571736.2013.836344
Canale, G. (2016). (Re)Searching culture in foreign language textbooks, or the politics of
hide and seek. Language, Culture and Curriculum, 29(2), 225–243.
https://doi.org/10.1080/07908318.2016.1144764
Celce-Murcia, M. (2007). Rethinking the Role of Communicative Competence in
Language Teaching. In E. A. Soler & M. P. S. Jordà (Eds.), Intercultural Language
Use and Language Learning (pp. 41–57). Springer Netherlands.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4020-5639-0_3
Chan, J. Y. H. (2020). Towards English as an International Language: The Evolving ELT
Curricula and Textbooks in Hong Kong. International Journal of Applied Linguistics,
30(2), 244–263. https://doi.org/10.1111/ijal.12277
Cohen, L., Manion, L., & Morrison, K. (2018). Research Methods in Education (8th Edition).
New York: Routledge.
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|133
Coşgun, G. E., & Savaş, P. (2023). Professional Identity Development of English
Teachers: A Data‐Driven Model. Review of Education, 11(1), e3394.
https://doi.org/10.1002/rev3.3394
Creswell, J. W. (2009). Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods
Approaches (3rd Edition). SAGE Publications, Inc.
Goh, R., & Fang, Y. (2017). Improving English language teaching through lesson study:
Case study of teacher learning in a Singapore primary school grade level team.
International Journal for Lesson and Learning Studies, 6(2), 135–150.
https://doi.org/10.1108/IJLLS-11-2015-0037
Haerazi, H., & Nunez, J. L. (2022). Promoting Intercultural Competences and
Communication Skills through English Textbooks within Multilingual Education:
Intercultural Language Learning; English Textbooks. Journal of Language and
Literature Studies, 1(2), 75–82. https://doi.org/10.36312/jolls.v1i2.610
He, Y., & Bagwell, D. (2022). Supporting Teachers Working with English Learners:
Engagement and Impact of a Professional Development Program. TESOL Journal,
13(1). https://doi.org/10.1002/tesj.632
Kao, Y. (2023). Empowering Preservice English Teachers with Language Assessment
Literacy Concepts and Practices: Application of Vygotskian Concept‐Based
Language Instruction. The Modern Language Journal, 107(S1), 68–94.
https://doi.org/10.1111/modl.12818
Kontovourki, S., Philippou, S., & Theodorou, E. (2018). Curriculum Making as
Professionalism‐in‐Context: The Cases of Two Elementary School Teachers
Amidst Curriculum Change in Cyprus. The Curriculum Journal, 29(2), 257–276.
https://doi.org/10.1080/09585176.2018.1447308
Lamb, P. (2015). Peer-learning between pre-service teachers: Embracing Lesson Study.
International Journal for Lesson and Learning Studies, 4(4), 343–361.
https://doi.org/10.1108/IJLLS-03-2015-0012
Lamb, P., & King, G. (2021). Developing the practice of pre-service physical education
teachers through a dyad model of lesson study. European Physical Education Review,
27(4), 944–960. https://doi.org/10.1177/1356336X211004628
Lamb, P., & Ko, P. Y. (2016). Case studies of lesson and learning study in initial teacher
education programmes. International Journal for Lesson and Learning Studies, 5(2), 78–
83. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJLLS-02-2016-0005
Lewis, C., Friedkin, S., Baker, E., & Perry, R. (2011). Learning from the Key Tasks of
Lesson Study. In O. Zaslavsky & P. Sullivan (Eds.), Constructing Knowledge for
Teaching Secondary Mathematics (pp. 161–176). Springer US.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-0-387-09812-8_10
Macaro, E., Akincioglu, M., & Han, S. (2020). English Medium Instruction in Higher
Education: Teacher Perspectives on Professional Development and Certification.
International Journal of Applied Linguistics, 30(1), 144–157.
https://doi.org/10.1111/ijal.12272
Mambu, J. E. (2022). Co‐constructing a critical ELT curriculum: A case study in an
Indonesian‐based English language teacher education program. TESOL Journal,
13(3). https://doi.org/10.1002/tesj.667
Mashudi, A., Indah, R. N., & Syaifulloh, B. (2023). Syllabus Design of English Club:
Fostering Joyful Extracurricular for Tenth Graders. Journal of Languages and
Language Teaching, 11(2), 297. https://doi.org/10.33394/jollt.v11i2.7211
Miller, L. R., Klassen, K., & Hardy, J. W. (2021). Curriculum Design from Theory to
Practice: Preparing Japanese Students to Study Abroad Using Content‐Based
Wu, Razak, & Dashwood
Exploring Innovative Teaching Strategies … …
JOLLS: Journal of Language and Literature Studies, November 2023 Vol. 3, No. 2
|
|134
Language Teaching. The Curriculum Journal, 32(2), 215–246.
https://doi.org/10.1002/curj.68
Ming Cheung, W., & Yee Wong, W. (2014). Does Lesson Study work?: A systematic
review on the effects of Lesson Study and Learning Study on teachers and students.
International Journal for Lesson and Learning Studies, 3(2), 137–149.
https://doi.org/10.1108/IJLLS-05-2013-0024
Naqsyabandiyah, N., & Dehghanitafti, N. (2023). Developing Task-Based Learning
Materials to Improve Students’ Vocabulary Mastery Viewed from Linguistic
Awareness. Journal of Language and Literature Studies, 3(1), 37–52.
https://doi.org/10.36312/jolls.v3i1.1088
Nejadghanbar, H. (2021). Using Critical Incidents for Professional Development with
Iranian Novice English Teachers. TESOL Journal, 12(1).
https://doi.org/10.1002/tesj.521
Roofe, C. (2021). Curriculum as Place: The Social Relevance of the Secondary School
Curriculum in Jamaica. The Curriculum Journal, 32(2), 165–181.
https://doi.org/10.1002/curj.70
Saito, E. (2012). Key issues of lesson study in Japan and the United States: A literature
review. Professional Development in Education, 38(5), 777–789.
https://doi.org/10.1080/19415257.2012.668857
Sharma, S. A., & Pang, S. (2015). Creating New Opportunities for Lesson Study in an
Online Reading Clinic. Literacy Research: Theory, Method, and Practice, 64(1), 415–
428. https://doi.org/10.1177/2381336915617577
Taşdemir, H., & Karaman, A. C. (2022). Professional Development Practices of English
Language Teachers: A Synthesis of Studies Published Between 2006 and 2020.
Review of Education, 10(1). https://doi.org/10.1002/rev3.3350
