Available via license: CC BY-NC 4.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 85
INNOVATIVE BUSINESS MODELS DRIVEN BY AI
TECHNOLOGIES: A REVIEW
Oluwatoyin Ajoke Farayola1, Adekunle Abiola Abdul2, Blessing Otohan Irabor3,
& Evelyn Chinedu Okeleke4
1Independent Researcher, Dallas, Texas, USA
2Independent Researcher, Maryland, USA
3Independent Researcher, Lagos, Nigeria
4Ericsson LM Lagos, Nigeria
_______________________________________________________________________________
*Corresponding Author: Oluwatoyin Ajoke Farayola
Corresponding Author Email: oluwatoyinafarayola@gmail.com
Article Received: 10-10-23 Accepted: 19-11-23 Published: 26-11-23
Licensing Details: Author retains the right of this article. The article is distributed under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License
(http://www.creativecommons.org/licences/by-nc/4.0/) which permits non-commercial use, reproduction
and distribution of the work without further permission provided the original work is attributed as specified
on the Journal open access page
_______________________________________________________________________________
ABSTRACT
In an era where artificial intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing business paradigms, this study delves
into the intricacies of AI-driven business models, offering a nuanced understanding of their
emergence, evolution, and impact on traditional business strategies. This scholarly inquiry aims to
dissect the role of AI in reshaping business models, highlighting the interplay between
technological innovation and business strategy. The study meticulously examines the integration of
AI into various business facets by employing a systematic and thematic analysis of a diverse range
of literature, including academic journals, industry reports, and case studies. This methodological
approach facilitates a comprehensive understanding of AI's role in business innovation, addressing
both the opportunities and challenges it presents. The findings reveal that AI-driven business
OPEN ACCESS
Computer Science & IT Research Journal
P-ISSN: 2709-0043, E-ISSN: 2709-0051
Volume 4, Issue 2, P.85-110, November 2023
DOI: 10.51594/csitrj.v4i2.608
Fair East Publishers
Journal Homepage: www.fepbl.com/index.php/csitrj
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 86
models are characterized by enhanced operational efficiency, data-driven decision-making, and
customer-centric approaches. These models signify a transformative shift from conventional
business strategies, demanding a reevaluation of leadership roles and ethical considerations in the
digital age. The study identifies key challenges in AI implementation, such as technical
complexities and ethical dilemmas, while uncovering AI's vast opportunities for business growth
and competitive advantage. Conclusively, the study recommends a balanced approach to AI
integration, emphasizing the need for ethical AI practices, continuous adaptation, and a synergy
between AI capabilities and human insights. It advocates for business leaders to embrace AI not
just as a technological tool, but as a catalyst for sustainable and innovative business growth. This
scholarly work contributes significantly to the discourse on AI in business, providing a
foundational framework for future research and practical application in AI-driven business
innovation.
Keywords: Artificial Intelligence, Business Models, Digital Transformation, AI Integration,
Leadership in AI, Ethical AI Practices.
_______________________________________________________________________________
INTRODUCTION
The Emergence of AI in Modern Business: An Overview
The emergence of artificial intelligence (AI) in modern business has been a transformative force,
reshaping industries and creating new paradigms for how companies operate and compete. The
integration of AI into business models has become a pivotal aspect of contemporary business
strategy, offering unprecedented opportunities for innovation, efficiency, and competitive
advantage.
AI-driven business models, as conceptualized by Hahn et al. (2020), are characterized by the use
of AI technologies to enhance or create at least one component of the business model. This
integration of AI has led to the creation of new businesses and has significantly altered existing
ones. Unlike traditional data-driven models, AI-driven models are based on a set of techniques that
learn and improve autonomously, reducing the need for explicit human programming. This
autonomy in learning and adaptation is a key characteristic that sets AI-driven business models
apart, enabling businesses to respond more dynamically to market changes and customer needs.
The impact of AI on small businesses, particularly during challenging times such as the COVID-19
pandemic, has been profound. Coltey et al. (2022) highlight the role of AI in enabling small
businesses to navigate rapidly changing market conditions. By leveraging AI-driven tools, such as
natural language processing (NLP), businesses can automate market research, adapt to changing
conditions, and maintain operational efficiency even in times of crisis. This adaptability is crucial
for small businesses that often lack the resources of larger corporations.
In the insurance sector, the influence of AI is equally significant. Zarifis, Holland, and Milne.
(2019) identify four emerging business models in the insurance industry driven by AI and data.
These models range from insurers taking a smaller part of the value chain and allowing AI and
data-centric companies to dominate, to technology-focused companies using their AI prowess to
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 87
enter the insurance market. This model diversity illustrates AI's versatility in reshaping traditional
industries and creating new opportunities for innovation and growth.
The integration of AI into business models is not without its challenges. The need for significant
investment in technology, the requirement for specialized skills, and the management of ethical
and privacy concerns are some of the hurdles businesses face. However, the potential benefits,
including enhanced decision-making capabilities, improved customer experiences, and new
avenues for growth, make the integration of AI a strategic imperative for businesses looking to
thrive in the modern economy.
The emergence of AI in modern business is a defining feature of the current economic landscape.
AI-driven business models offer a new paradigm for businesses operating, competing, and
innovating. From small businesses to large corporations, the integration of AI is creating new
opportunities and challenges, reshaping industries, and redefining the future of business.
Defining AI-Driven Business Models
The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into business models represents a significant
evolution in the way companies operate and strategize. AI-driven business models are
characterized by the incorporation of AI technologies to enhance, innovate, or create new aspects
of a business's operations, products, or services. This section delves into the key characteristics,
evolution, and the intersection of AI with traditional business strategies, drawing on recent
scholarly literature.
AI-driven business models are distinguished by their ability to leverage data and machine learning
(ML) technologies to create more efficient, responsive, and intelligent business processes. Ahmed
and Miskon (2020) discuss the role of AI and ML in digital transformation, particularly in the
manufacturing sector. They emphasize how AI-driven models utilize large datasets generated by
the integration of devices in the Internet of Things (IoT) environment to gain rapid insights and
enhance decision-making processes. This approach is pivotal in achieving resiliency and
efficiency, especially in sectors like manufacturing where integrating intelligent and integrated
systems is crucial (Ahmed & Miskon, 2020).
In the realm of customized manufacturing, AI-driven models are reshaping traditional production
paradigms. Wan et al. (2020) explore the implementation of AI in customized manufacturing
factories, highlighting how AI technologies enable manufacturing systems to adapt to external
needs and extract process knowledge. This includes the development of intelligent production
models, networked collaboration, and extended service models. The AI-driven customized
manufacturing factory is characterized by its self-perception, operations optimization, dynamic
reconfiguration, and intelligent decision-making capabilities. These characteristics underscore the
transformative impact of AI on manufacturing, moving towards more flexible and efficient
production methods (Wan et al., 2020).
The integration of AI in customer service, especially in the e-commerce sector, provides another
perspective on AI-driven business models. Ping (2019) focus on the constructs of AI customer
service in e-commerce, illustrating how AI can assist human agents, enhancing service quality and
productivity. The integration of AI in customer service is a response to the limitations of
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 88
traditional models, such as limited availability and inefficiency. AI-driven customer service
models in e-commerce are characterized by their ability to provide personalized and efficient
service, leveraging technologies like chatbots and automated response systems (Ping, 2019).
The evolution of business models in the AI era is marked by a shift from traditional, often rigid,
business processes to more dynamic, data-driven, and customer-centric approaches. AI-driven
business models merge the capabilities of AI, ML, and IoT to create systems that are not only
efficient and resilient but also capable of continuous learning and adaptation. This evolution
signifies a move towards more personalized, responsive, and intelligent business operations,
catering to the specific needs of customers and the market.
The intersection of AI with traditional business strategies involves rethinking conventional
business practices. AI-driven models do not merely supplement traditional strategies but often
redefine them, creating new value propositions and competitive advantages. This intersection is
evident in various sectors, from manufacturing to customer service, where AI technologies are
used to enhance operational efficiency, customer engagement, and innovation.
AI-driven business models represent a significant shift in the business landscape, characterized by
their use of AI and ML to innovate and improve various aspects of business operations. From
manufacturing to customer service, the integration of AI is transforming traditional business
models, leading to more efficient, adaptable, and intelligent business processes.
Key Characteristics of AI-Driven Business Models
AI-driven business models are reshaping the landscape of various industries by integrating
advanced artificial intelligence (AI) technologies into their core operations and strategies. These
models are characterized by several key features that distinguish them from traditional business
models. This section explores these characteristics, drawing insights from recent scholarly
literature.
One of the primary characteristics of AI-driven business models is their focus on leveraging AI for
enhanced decision-making and operational efficiency. Metelskaia et al. (2018) present a business
model canvas specifically designed for AI solutions, which outlines the critical elements of AI-
driven business models. This canvas includes components such as value propositions that AI, the
use of multi-sided platforms for customer segments, automated services for customer relationships,
and the integration of social networks in marketing channels, uniquely tailors. The canvas also
highlights the importance of investors as key partners and emphasizes research and development
(R&D) and human resources as essential resources. This framework demonstrates how AI-driven
business models are constructed differently from traditional models, focusing on AI's unique
capabilities to create value (Metelskaia et al., 2018).
In the healthcare industry, AI-driven business models are particularly transformative. Kulkov
(2023) examines the next-generation business models for AI start-ups in healthcare, identifying
three unique design elements: value creation, delivery to customers, and market communication.
These elements are framed within 16 unique models and three unifying design themes, illustrating
the diverse ways AI can be integrated into healthcare business models. This study underscores the
role of AI in creating new value propositions in healthcare, such as personalized medicine and
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 89
efficient patient care, and highlights the importance of AI in communicating and delivering these
values to the market (Kulkov, 2023).
Another key characteristic of AI-driven business models is their application in customized
manufacturing. Wan et al. (2020) discuss the implementation of AI in customized manufacturing
factories, focusing on intelligent production, networked collaboration, and extended service
models. These factories are characterized by their self-perception, operations optimization,
dynamic reconfiguration, and intelligent decision-making capabilities. Integrating AI technologies
allows these manufacturing systems to adapt to external needs and extract process knowledge,
leading to higher production flexibility and efficiency. This study demonstrates how AI-driven
models can transform traditional manufacturing processes into more agile and responsive systems
(Wan et al., 2020).
AI-driven business models are marked by their innovative use of AI to create new value
propositions, enhance operational efficiency, and transform traditional business processes. These
models leverage AI's unique capabilities to analyze data, learn autonomously, and make intelligent
decisions, leading to more dynamic and responsive business operations. The integration of AI in
various sectors, from healthcare to manufacturing, illustrates the transformative potential of these
models, offering new opportunities for growth and innovation.
The key characteristics of AI-driven business models include their focus on leveraging AI for
enhanced decision-making, operational efficiency, and the creation of new value propositions.
These models are reshaping industries by introducing innovative ways to integrate AI into business
operations, demonstrating the transformative impact of AI on the modern business landscape.
Evolution of Business Models in the AI Era
The advent of artificial intelligence (AI) has ushered in a new era in business, fundamentally
altering traditional business models and introducing innovative paradigms. This evolution is
characterized by a shift towards more technologically advanced, data-driven, and customer-centric
approaches. This section explores the transformation of business models in the AI era, drawing on
insights from recent scholarly literature.
A significant aspect of this evolution is the changing nature of human-machine interaction and its
impact on competitive business strategies. Delbufalo, Di Bernardo and Risso, (2022) delve into the
dynamics of human-machine interaction in the digital era, emphasizing the need for businesses to
strike a balance between artificial and human intelligence. They argue that the competitiveness of
companies in the AI era hinges on sustainable strategies that effectively integrate both human
creativity and AI's mechanical thinking. This integration is crucial in decision-making processes,
where AI can provide data-driven insights while humans contribute with creative and strategic
thinking. The study highlights the importance of redefining business models to accommodate AI
and human intelligence roles, ensuring that businesses remain innovative and competitive
(Delbufalo, Di Bernardo & Risso, 2022).
The role of AI in brand engagement and social interaction represents another facet of the evolving
business models. Marrone and Testa (2022) explore the impact of brand algorithms and social
engagement in the digital era, focusing on how AI and related technologies transform marketing
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 90
strategies and customer relationships. They discuss how AI, big data, and the Internet of Things
(IoT) are key drivers in revolutionizing communication and relationships between individuals,
products, and brands. The study underscores the influence of AI-mediated algorithms on value
creation and customer engagement, highlighting the shift towards more personalized and
interactive marketing approaches. This evolution reflects a broader trend in business models where
digital transformation and AI are central to creating and maintaining customer relationships
(Marrone & Testa, 2022).
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) with the advancements of 5G technology is
revolutionizing business models and driving digital transformation across various sectors (Banda,
Mzyece, & Mekuria, 2022). This synergy is fostering the development of new, innovative services
and applications, such as enhanced image recognition and sophisticated natural dialogue AI
systems. These technological advancements are not only streamlining operational processes but are
also opening new channels for customer interaction and service provision. The convergence of AI
and 5G is indicative of a shift towards more interconnected, intelligent, and agile business models,
leveraging the high-speed and extensive capabilities of 5G networks to maximize AI's potential
(Banda, Mzyece, & Mekuria, 2022).
In summary, the evolution of business models in the AI era is marked by a greater integration of
AI and technology in various aspects of business operations. A shift towards more data-driven
decision-making characterizes this transformation, enhanced human-machine interaction, and
innovative customer engagement and marketing approaches. Integrating AI with other advanced
technologies like 5G further accelerates this evolution, leading to more agile, efficient, and
customer-centric business models.
The Intersection of AI and Traditional Business Strategies
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into traditional business strategies marks a pivotal
shift in the business landscape, blending the strengths of AI with established business practices.
This intersection is creating new paradigms for innovation, strategy development, and competitive
advantage. This section explores how AI is being integrated into traditional business strategies,
drawing on insights from recent scholarly literature.
In the education technology (EdTech) sector, the integration of AI and learning analytics is
revolutionizing traditional business models and strategies. Alam and Mohanty (2022) discuss the
transformation in EdTech companies, where AI and learning analytics are being used to create
personalized educational experiences. This integration reflects a shift from traditional educational
models to more data-driven, customized approaches. The study highlights the challenges and
motivations influencing this transition, emphasizing the need for a deeper understanding of data
and its potential to enhance learning experiences. This example illustrates how AI can be
integrated into traditional sectors like education, transforming them with innovative, data-driven
strategies (Alam & Mohanty, 2022).
Wisniewski (2020) addresses the broader implications of AI in business, focusing on the need for
future decision-makers and leaders to understand and leverage AI in their strategies. The paper
discusses the integration of AI into business curricula, emphasizing the importance of preparing
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 91
leaders who can navigate the complexities of AI and its impact on business. This approach reflects
a growing recognition of AI's strategic importance and the need for a new generation of business
leaders who are adept at integrating AI into traditional business models and strategies. The study
underscores the transformative potential of AI in reshaping business education and, by extension,
business practices (Wisniewski, 2020).
Fenwick, Vermeulen, and Corrales (2018) work explores the business and regulatory responses to
AI, particularly in the context of dynamic regulation and innovation ecosystems. They discuss how
businesses and regulators are adapting to the challenges posed by disruptive AI technologies. The
paper highlights the importance of dynamic regulation and the creation of innovation ecosystems
that foster partnerships between established corporations and AI-focused startups. This approach to
managing AI's impact suggests a strategic alignment between traditional business practices and the
innovative potential of AI. The study provides insights into how businesses can strategically
manage AI's disruptive nature while leveraging it for competitive advantage (Fenwick, Vermeulen,
& Corrales, 2018).
The intersection of AI and traditional business strategies is characterized by a synergistic blend of
innovation and established practices. This integration is leading to the transformation of various
sectors, from education to broader business practices. The key lies in understanding and leveraging
AI's potential within the context of traditional business models, preparing future leaders for this
new landscape, and adapting regulatory and strategic frameworks to accommodate AI's disruptive
potential.
Significance and Scope of AI in Business Innovation
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into traditional business strategies represents a
significant paradigm shift, offering new opportunities for innovation and competitive advantage.
This intersection is reshaping how businesses operate, strategize, and interact with their
stakeholders. This section examines the convergence of AI with traditional business strategies,
drawing insights from recent scholarly literature.
Alam and Mohanty (2022) delve into the intersection of AI with learning analytics in the context
of educational technology (EdTech) companies. They discuss how these companies are integrating
AI into their business models and strategies to provide personalized educational experiences. This
integration reflects a broader trend where traditional industries like education are being
transformed by AI, leading to more data-driven and customized approaches. The study highlights
the challenges and motivations influencing this transition, emphasizing the need for a deeper
understanding of data and its potential to enhance learning experiences. This example illustrates
how AI can be integrated into traditional sectors, transforming them with innovative, data-driven
strategies.
Fenwick, Vermeulen, and Corrales (2018) address the business and regulatory responses to AI,
particularly focusing on dynamic regulation and innovation ecosystems. They discuss how
businesses and regulators are adapting to the challenges posed by disruptive AI technologies. The
paper highlights the importance of dynamic regulation and the creation of innovation ecosystems
that foster partnerships between established corporations and AI-focused startups. This approach to
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 92
managing AI's impact suggests a strategic alignment between traditional business practices and the
innovative potential of AI. The study provides insights into how businesses can strategically
manage AI's disruptive nature while leveraging it for competitive advantage.
The intersection of AI and traditional business strategies is characterized by a synergistic blend of
innovation and established practices. This integration is leading to the transformation of various
sectors, from education to broader business practices. The key lies in understanding and leveraging
AI's potential within the context of traditional business models, preparing future leaders for this
new landscape, and adapting regulatory and strategic frameworks to accommodate AI's disruptive
potential.
Objectives and Structure of the Review
The aim of this study is to explore and understand the transformative impact of Artificial
Intelligence (AI) on business models, focusing on how AI technologies are reshaping business
strategies and operations in the contemporary business landscape.
The objectives of the study are:
1. To identify the key characteristics of AI-driven business models, examining the unique
features and components that distinguish these models from traditional business
approaches.
2. To analyze the evolution of business models in the AI era, understanding how the
integration of AI technologies has transformed business practices across various industries
and sectors.
3. To explore the intersection of AI and traditional business strategies, investigating how AI is
being combined with conventional business approaches and the resulting synergies and
challenges.
4. To assess the significance and scope of AI in business innovation, evaluating the overall
impact of AI on business practices, including the opportunities and challenges it presents
for businesses in different contexts.
Limitations of the Literature Review
This literature review on the impact of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in business models
acknowledges several inherent limitations. Firstly, the rapid evolution of AI technology means that
some reviewed literature may not reflect the most current developments and trends. Secondly,
there is a potential bias in the sources, primarily academic journals and industry reports, which
might emphasize certain aspects of AI in business while overlooking others. Thirdly, the vast and
diverse applications of AI across various industries imply that not every sector or innovative use of
AI is comprehensively covered. Finally, the interdisciplinary nature of AI in business leads to
varying definitions and interpretations of AI-driven business models, posing challenges in drawing
generalized conclusions. These limitations highlight the need for a cautious interpretation of the
findings, recognizing that the review provides a snapshot of a rapidly evolving field.
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 93
METHODOLOGY
Approach to Literature Review: Systematic and Thematic Analysis
The methodology for this literature review on AI-driven business models is anchored in a
systematic and thematic analysis approach. This method involves a structured process of
searching, selecting, and synthesizing relevant literature to ensure a comprehensive understanding
of the topic. Predefined criteria guide the systematic review process and aims to minimize bias,
providing a transparent and replicable framework for analysis (Bulatnikov & Constantin, 2021).
The thematic analysis component of the methodology involves identifying, analyzing, and
reporting patterns (themes) within the data. This approach allows for the integration of diverse
perspectives and insights on AI in business models, facilitating a nuanced understanding of the
subject. The thematic analysis is particularly useful in synthesizing complex and multifaceted
topics, such as the integration of AI in business strategies and operations (Sureeyatanapas et al.,
2020).
Criteria for Selecting Relevant Literature on AI and Business Models
The criteria for selecting literature in this review are centered around relevance, quality, and
recency. Relevance is determined by the extent to which the literature addresses AI in the context
of business models. This includes studies focusing on the integration of AI technologies in
business strategies, the evolution of business models in the AI era, and the impact of AI on
business innovation and operations.
Quality is assessed based on the credibility of the source and the rigor of the research
methodology. Peer-reviewed academic journals, reputable industry reports, and in-depth case
studies are prioritized to ensure the reliability of the information. The research methodology of the
selected literature is also scrutinized for its robustness and appropriateness in addressing the
research questions.
Recency is another crucial criterion, given the rapid development of AI technologies and their
applications in business. Literature published within the last five years is primarily considered to
capture the most current trends, practices, and insights in the field. However, seminal works that
have significantly contributed to understanding AI in business models are also included, regardless
of their publication date.
The approach to this literature review combines systematic and thematic analysis to ensure a
comprehensive and nuanced understanding of AI-driven business models. The selection criteria
focus on relevance, quality, and recency, ensuring that the review is grounded in credible and
current literature that accurately reflects the evolving landscape of AI in business.
Sources of Information: Academic Journals, Industry Reports, and Case Studies
In the exploration of AI-driven business models, the sources of information are pivotal in shaping
the understanding and insights derived. Academic journals stand as a cornerstone in this regard,
offering peer-reviewed, scholarly articles that provide a robust theoretical foundation and
empirical evidence. Wiener, Saunders, and Marabelli (2020) work exemplifies this, offering a
critical literature review and a multiperspective research framework that is invaluable for
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 94
understanding big-data business models. These academic insights are crucial for grounding the
review in a solid theoretical base.
Industry reports complement academic journals by providing practical, real-world insights into the
application of AI in business. Enholm et al. (2022) demonstrate this through their systematic
literature review, which elucidates how organizations leverage AI technologies for added business
value. These reports offer a glimpse into the industry's current state, trends, and future directions,
making them an essential component of the literature review.
Case studies from academic and industry sources provide detailed, context-specific insights.
Gomes et al. (2022) contribute to this by presenting a systematic literature review on AI-based
methods for business processes. These case studies are instrumental in understanding AI's practical
application, challenges, and successes in business, offering a nuanced view that complements the
broader perspectives provided by academic journals and industry reports.
Framework for Analyzing and Synthesizing Collected Data
The framework for analyzing and synthesizing the collected data in this literature review is a
meticulous process that involves several stages. Initially, the literature is categorized based on its
relevance to AI in business models. This categorization is crucial for maintaining focus and
ensuring that the review addresses the study's core themes.
The next stage involves a thematic analysis, where common patterns, trends, and divergences
within the literature are identified and examined. This approach is critical for synthesizing a
coherent narrative around AI-driven business models. The thematic analysis also allows for the
integration of diverse perspectives, as seen in the works of Wiener, Saunders, and Marabelli
(2020), and Enholm et al. (2022), ensuring a comprehensive understanding of the subject.
Finally, the review critically evaluates the findings in light of the study's objectives and the broader
context of AI in business. This evaluation considers the strengths, limitations, and implications of
the literature, as highlighted in the systematic reviews by Gomes et al. (2022) and others. This
critical evaluation is essential for providing a comprehensive understanding of the current state of
AI-driven business models and identifying areas for future research.
RESULTS
Summary of AI-Driven Business Models Identified in the Literature
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into business models has become a focal point for
modern enterprises, revolutionizing the way businesses operate and compete. The literature reveals
a variety of AI-driven business models, each harnessing the power of AI in unique ways to create
value and gain competitive advantage.
Mishra and Tripathi (2021) discuss an integrative business approach where AI is not just an add-on
but a core component of the business model. This approach is akin to the cloud Software as a
Service (SaaS) model, where AI solutions integrate seamlessly with other digital systems such as
Customer Relationship Management (CRM) and Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP). In this
model, AI drives the digital data flow, enhancing business processes and decision-making. The
subscription-based model ensures a steady revenue stream while continuously providing value
through AI-driven insights and improvements.
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 95
Pfau and Rimpp (2021) explore AI-enhanced business models in the context of digital
entrepreneurship. They classify the roles of AI applications at the strategic level and their influence
on business models. Their research, based on case studies, provides practical examples of how
both startups and established tech giants are using AI. This classification scheme helps in
understanding the diverse applications of AI in business and its impact on creating innovative
business models.
John, Olsson, and Bosch (2023) present a framework for AI-driven business development, based
on a multi-case study. Their research highlights the practices and challenges experienced by
companies in developing, deploying, and evolving AI models. The framework identifies key
activities and roles within the organization, optimizing the integration of AI into business
processes. This approach is crucial for companies looking to leverage AI not just for incremental
improvements but as a strategic tool for business development.
The literature presents a dynamic and evolving landscape of AI-driven business models. From
integrative approaches that blend AI with existing digital systems to innovative applications in new
ventures and strategic frameworks for AI implementation, these models demonstrate the
transformative potential of AI in business. The common thread across these models is the strategic
integration of AI to enhance business processes, drive innovation, and create sustainable
competitive advantages.
Common Patterns and Strategies in AI Integration
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into business processes has become increasingly
prevalent, with various patterns and strategies emerging across different industries. The literature
reveals common approaches and methodologies that businesses adopt to effectively integrate AI
into their operations.
Fteimi and Hopf (2021) discuss the role of AI in knowledge management, highlighting the
importance of developing an integrative framework that aligns AI with organizational knowledge
processes. Their research underscores the need for businesses to adapt their knowledge
management strategies to incorporate AI, ensuring that AI tools are effectively utilized to enhance
knowledge development, transfer, storage, and evaluation. This approach is critical for businesses
to leverage AI in improving decision-making and operational efficiency.
Sai et al. (2022) explore the integration of AI in the procurement stage of supply chains,
particularly through the use of chatbots. Their study demonstrates how AI-powered chatbots can
be seamlessly integrated with existing Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems to automate
and streamline procurement processes. This integration enhances efficiency, contributes to cost
reduction, and improves supplier relationships. The study emphasizes the strategic role of AI in
transforming traditional supply chain operations into more dynamic and responsive systems.
Cao (2021) provides insights into the application of AI in the retail sector, identifying key
strategies for AI-related data management and value creation. The study reveals how retailers use
AI to transform various business processes, including customer engagement, inventory
management, and sales forecasting. The research highlights the value creation logics of AI
applications in retail, such as automation, hyper-personalization, complementarity, and innovation.
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 96
These strategies demonstrate how AI can be leveraged to create a competitive advantage and drive
business growth.
The literature identifies common patterns and strategies in AI integration across different business
sectors. These include the adaptation of knowledge management processes to incorporate AI, the
strategic use of AI in supply chain operations, and the application of AI in retail for data
management and value creation. These patterns and strategies reflect the diverse ways in which
businesses are leveraging AI to enhance efficiency, improve decision-making, and create new
opportunities for growth and innovation.
Analysis of Key Components in Successful AI Business Models
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into business models has become a pivotal factor in
driving innovation and efficiency. A critical analysis of the key components that contribute to the
success of AI business models reveals several essential elements.
Ilieva et al. (2021) emphasize the significance of decision-making support in Business Intelligence
(BI) systems driven by AI. They argue that AI is the core of next-generation analytics,
empowering BI with enhanced capabilities. The integration of AI in BI platforms facilitates
predictive modeling, particularly in e-commerce, where machine learning (ML) is used for
constructing predictive and clustering models. This integration is crucial for businesses to make
informed decisions, optimize operations, and stay competitive. The study also highlights the
importance of self-service BI models and the potential threats posed by big data, suggesting
directions for future research in this domain.
Popa, Amaba, and Daniels (2021) present a framework outlining best practices for successful AI
projects, using a case study in the oil and gas industry. Their framework emphasizes the integrity,
quality, and accuracy of data, and governance principles such as responsibility, equitability, and
reliability. The study demonstrates how AI and ML technologies, coupled with a clear work-break-
down structure (WBS), can significantly improve productivity. The Job Task Analysis (JTA)
model, a data-focused approach, is proposed for managing processes, people, and platforms,
prioritizing problem framing, analytics framing, data, methodology, model building, deployment,
and lifecycle management. This integrated approach leads to substantial business value, optimizing
operations and enhancing decision-making processes.
Trakadas et al. (2020) discuss the digitization of the manufacturing industry under the Industry 4.0
concept, focusing on the integration of AI in manufacturing systems. They propose a holistic
approach to AI integration, promoting collaboration across different dimensions of the
manufacturing process. The study introduces an architectural approach that includes extending the
functionality of existing layers in the Reference Architectural Model for Industry 4.0, defining new
layers for collaboration, and addressing security concerns with AI-powered mechanisms. This
approach aims to optimize business intelligence, incorporate human-in-the-loop, and ensure secure
federation across manufacturing sites, thereby enhancing the overall efficiency and effectiveness
of manufacturing operations.
The key components of successful AI business models include the integration of AI in decision-
making processes, particularly in BI systems; the application of best practices and frameworks for
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 97
AI project delivery, emphasizing data integrity and governance; and the holistic integration of AI
in manufacturing systems, focusing on collaboration and security. These components are essential
for businesses to effectively leverage AI technologies, driving innovation, efficiency, and
competitive advantage in various industry sectors.
Data Utilization and Management
The effective utilization and management of data are fundamental to the success of AI-driven
business models. This section explores how businesses leverage data in AI applications, focusing
on strategies for data utilization and management.
Mishra and Tripathi (2021) discuss the integration of AI in business models, particularly
emphasizing the role of data in enhancing AI solutions. They highlight that AI business models are
akin to cloud SaaS models, where AI solutions collaborate with other digital systems like CRM
and ERP. The key to this integration is the effective management of digital data, which fuels
business enhancements over time. The study underscores the importance of a strategic approach to
data management in AI, where businesses must ensure that data flows seamlessly and securely
through their systems. This approach not only improves the efficiency of AI solutions but also
enhances their adaptability and scalability in various business contexts.
Zarifis, Holland, and Milne (2019) evaluate the impact of AI in the insurance sector, identifying
four emerging AI- and data-driven business models. These models range from insurers taking a
smaller part of the value chain and allowing others with superior AI and data capabilities to
dominate, to technology-focused companies using their AI prowess and data to add insurance
provision. The study emphasizes the critical role of data in these models, where the effective use of
AI depends on the availability and quality of data. This includes new sources of data and
customers, which can be leveraged to improve effectiveness and explore new business
opportunities.
Lakhan (2022) explores data science and AI applications in business, focusing on how these
technologies transform strategic decision-making and operations. The paper highlights that the
core of AI and data science is the ability to make informed decisions based on data analysis rather
than intuition. This transformation is evident in various sectors, where businesses use AI and data
science for predictive modeling, business analytics, and developing recommender systems. The
study points out that the success of these applications hinges on the effective management and
analysis of data, which enables businesses to gain insights and make strategic decisions.
Data utilization and management are crucial components in AI business models. Effective data
management strategies enhance the efficiency and adaptability of AI solutions, as seen in the
integration of AI with CRM and ERP systems. The insurance sector provides a clear example of
how AI and data-driven models can transform traditional business models, emphasizing the need
for quality data and innovative approaches to data usage. Finally, the broader applications of data
science and AI in business underscore the transformative power of data-driven decision-making
across various sectors. These insights highlight the importance of data as a key enabler in the
successful implementation and scaling of AI in business models.
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 98
Challenges Faced by Businesses Implementing AI Models
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into business models presents a range of challenges
that companies must navigate to successfully leverage this technology. This section explores these
challenges, drawing insights from recent studies.
Kutz et al. (2022) explore the implementation of AI technologies in the manufacturing sector,
highlighting the transition from proof-of-concept and pilot projects to full-scale real-world
applications as a significant challenge. They note that this gap often arises from technical
complexities, a lack of specialized expertise, and the need for substantial investment in
infrastructure and training. The study underscores the importance of aligning AI initiatives with
business objectives and existing technological ecosystems, identifying these as crucial factors for
successful AI integration in manufacturing environments.
Von Garrel and Jahn (2022) focus on the implementation of AI-based business models in small
and medium-sized manufacturing enterprises. They emphasize the difficulty these enterprises face
in keeping up with global competition due to limited resources and expertise in AI. The paper
proposes a socio-technical framework to assist these enterprises in building AI-based business
models. It highlights that the challenges are not just technological but also involve organizational
and cultural aspects, such as resistance to change, lack of understanding of AI capabilities, and the
need for a strategic approach to innovation.
Nortje and Grobbelaar (2020) present a framework for implementing AI in business enterprises,
addressing the readiness aspect. They identify several dimensions critical for AI implementation
readiness, including employee and culture, technology management, organizational governance,
strategy, infrastructure, knowledge and information, and security. The study underscores that a
significant challenge for businesses is not just the adoption of AI technology but also preparing the
organization across these dimensions. This includes developing a culture that embraces AI,
ensuring effective leadership and governance for AI initiatives, and addressing security concerns
associated with AI technologies.
The challenges in implementing AI in business models are multifaceted, involving technical,
organizational, and cultural aspects. Transitioning from pilot projects to full-scale implementation
requires not only technical expertise and investment but also strategic alignment with business
goals. Small and medium-sized enterprises face unique challenges due to resource constraints,
necessitating frameworks that consider their specific needs. Lastly, organizational readiness across
various dimensions is crucial for successful AI integration, highlighting the need for a holistic
approach that encompasses technology, culture, governance, and strategy. These insights provide a
comprehensive understanding of the hurdles businesses face in integrating AI into their models and
the strategies required to overcome them.
Technical and Operational Hurdles
Various technical and operational challenges accompany the integration of Artificial Intelligence
(AI) into business models. Whitfield and Zborowski (2019) provide insights into these hurdles,
particularly in the context of the offshore oil and gas industry, which has seen a significant shift
towards digital technologies, including AI.
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 99
A primary technical hurdle is the integration of AI with existing systems and processes. In
industries like oil and gas, where operations are complex and data-intensive, integrating AI tools
requires technical expertise and a deep understanding of the operational context. This challenge is
compounded by the need to ensure that AI systems are reliable and can operate effectively in harsh
and unpredictable environments.
Another significant hurdle is the management and analysis of the vast amounts of data generated in
such industries. AI systems rely heavily on data for training and decision-making, but the sheer
volume and complexity of the data can be overwhelming. Ensuring data quality and relevance is
crucial, as is the development of robust data management and analysis frameworks that can handle
the scale and complexity of the data involved.
Operational challenges also arise from the need to align AI initiatives with business objectives.
Implementing AI requires a strategic approach that considers the impact on various aspects of the
business, from operations and finance to human resources and compliance. This alignment is
critical to ensure that AI initiatives deliver tangible business benefits and support the overall goals
of the organization.
Opportunities Unearthed Through AI Business Models
Despite these challenges, the implementation of AI in business models also presents significant
opportunities. The same study by Whitfield and Zborowski (2019) highlights how AI can lead to
improvements in operational efficiency, cost savings, and enhanced safety in the offshore oil and
gas industry.
One of the key opportunities is the potential for AI to optimize operations. By analyzing data from
various sources, AI systems can identify patterns and insights that can lead to more efficient and
effective operational processes. This can result in significant cost savings, as well as improvements
in productivity and performance.
AI also offers the potential for enhanced decision-making. With the ability to process and analyze
large volumes of data at high speed, AI systems can provide valuable insights that support more
informed and timely decision-making. This can be particularly valuable in industries where
decisions need to be made quickly and in response to rapidly changing conditions.
Furthermore, AI can play a crucial role in improving safety. In industries like oil and gas, where
operations can be hazardous, AI can help to identify potential risks and provide early warnings of
potential issues. This can help to prevent accidents and ensure the safety of personnel and assets.
While the implementation of AI in business models presents technical and operational challenges,
it also offers significant opportunities. The integration of AI can lead to improvements in
operational efficiency, decision-making, and safety, among other benefits. These opportunities
highlight the potential of AI to transform business models and drive innovation across various
industries.
DISCUSSION
Interpreting the Impact of AI on Business Model Innovation
The advent of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has ushered in a new era of business model innovation,
fundamentally altering how businesses operate and compete. Schmeiss and Friederici (2019)
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 100
highlight the German government's strategy to foster 'AI Made in Germany', emphasizing the role
of AI in driving productivity and GDP growth. This strategy underscores the transformative impact
of AI on business models, particularly in how startups leverage AI for novel technology-based
business models. The German approach illustrates the potential of AI to automate and transform
existing business models, contributing significantly to economic growth.
Huang et al. (2021) delve into the broader context of the Fourth Industrial Revolution, marked by
digital transformation driven by disruptive technologies including AI. This transformation is
reshaping every aspect of business, from operations to product delivery and customer engagement.
Trustworthy AI, as discussed by Huang and colleagues, is central to this transformation, offering a
framework for businesses to integrate AI in a manner that is secure, reliable, and ethical. The
concept of Digital Engineering, as part of this transformation, highlights the shift in engineering
processes, emphasizing the role of AI in revolutionizing these processes.
Kop (2020) addresses the European perspective, focusing on the legal and regulatory aspects of
deploying data-driven technologies like AI. The European Data Act, as discussed by Kop, presents
a crucial opportunity for shaping how AI is utilized in business models within the EU. This act
emphasizes the need for harmonized legislation and concrete incentives for data sharing and reuse,
which are fundamental to AI-driven innovation. Kop's analysis points to the importance of legal
frameworks in enabling or hindering the adoption of AI in business models.
The impact of AI on business model innovation can be seen in several key areas. Firstly, AI
enables the automation of various business processes, leading to increased efficiency and cost
savings. This automation extends beyond routine tasks to more complex decision-making
processes, where AI's ability to analyze vast amounts of data can lead to more informed and timely
decisions. Secondly, AI opens up new avenues for product and service innovation. Businesses can
leverage AI to develop new offerings or enhance existing ones, creating value propositions that
were previously unattainable.
Another significant impact of AI is on customer engagement and experience. AI-driven tools such
as chatbots, personalized recommendations, and predictive analytics allow businesses to engage
with customers in more meaningful and personalized ways. This not only improves customer
satisfaction but also provides businesses with valuable insights into customer preferences and
behaviors.
However, the integration of AI into business models is not without challenges. As highlighted by
the references, there are technical, operational, and regulatory hurdles to overcome. Ensuring the
trustworthiness and ethical use of AI is paramount, as is navigating the complex legal landscape
surrounding data use and AI deployment. Businesses must also contend with the cultural and
organizational changes required to effectively integrate AI into their operations.
The impact of AI on business model innovation is profound and multifaceted. AI presents
opportunities for increased efficiency, innovation, and customer engagement, but also poses
challenges that businesses must navigate. The successful integration of AI into business models
requires a strategic approach that considers technical, operational, and regulatory aspects, ensuring
that AI is used in a manner that is ethical, legal, and aligned with business objectives.
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 101
Addressing the Challenges: Strategies and Solutions
In the rapidly evolving landscape of AI-driven business models, organizations face a myriad of
challenges that can impede the successful integration and implementation of AI technologies.
These challenges range from technical hurdles to strategic and operational issues. However, by
adopting targeted strategies and solutions, businesses can effectively navigate these challenges,
unlocking the full potential of AI for sustainable growth and competitive advantage.
One of the primary challenges in implementing AI in business models is the technical complexity
associated with deep learning and other AI technologies. As noted by May and Kiritsis (2019), the
unpredictability of market demands and the need for high-quality production in the manufacturing
industry exemplify the technical challenges businesses face. They propose a holistic framework
that integrates state-of-the-art ICT technologies, AI models, and inspection tools to achieve zero-
defect manufacturing. This approach underscores the importance of a comprehensive strategy that
encompasses technology integration, quality control, and continuous adaptation to market changes.
Thomas (2020) highlights the significance of digital convergence and fusion in creating
competitive differentiation. The integration of digital systems and AI technologies can revitalize
business processes, leading to innovative strategies and enhanced operational efficiency. This
convergence requires a deep understanding of the technological landscape and a strategic approach
to integrating digital technologies with business operations. The case study of the State Bank of
India, as discussed by Thomas, illustrates how digital convergence can lead to significant
improvements in business operations and strategic management.
Furthermore, the collaborative approach towards research and development challenges in
industries such as oil and gas, as discussed by Iqbal et al. (2022), provides valuable insights into
overcoming AI implementation hurdles. Their study on the IBTIKAR Digital Lab demonstrates the
effectiveness of a collaborative environment that brings together business users, IT, and data
management. This approach emphasizes the need for cross-functional collaboration and the
development of a supportive infrastructure to facilitate AI integration.
To address the technical and operational challenges, businesses must focus on developing robust
AI strategies that are aligned with their overall business objectives. This involves investing in the
right AI technologies, fostering a culture of innovation, and ensuring that the AI initiatives are
scalable and sustainable. Additionally, businesses should prioritize data management and analytics
capabilities, as these are critical components of successful AI implementation.
Another key strategy is to foster collaboration and knowledge sharing across different departments
and teams. By breaking down silos and encouraging cross-functional collaboration, businesses can
leverage diverse perspectives and expertise, leading to more innovative and effective AI solutions.
Moreover, continuous learning and adaptation are crucial in the dynamic field of AI. Businesses
should invest in ongoing training and development programs to keep their workforce updated with
the latest AI technologies and practices. This not only enhances the technical capabilities of the
team but also ensures that the organization remains agile and responsive to changes in the AI
landscape.
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 102
Overcoming the challenges associated with AI-driven business models requires a multifaceted
approach that encompasses technical expertise, strategic planning, collaborative efforts, and
continuous learning. By adopting these strategies, businesses can effectively integrate AI
technologies into their operations, driving innovation, efficiency, and competitive advantage.
Leveraging Opportunities: A Pathway to Sustainable Growth
In the realm of business, the advent of AI technologies has opened up a plethora of opportunities,
fundamentally altering the landscape of sustainable growth. Escajeda (2018) emphasizes the
critical role of embracing entrepreneurship, technology, and innovation in navigating through
strategic inflection points in legal education, a principle that can be extrapolated to the broader
business context. The integration of AI into business models is not just a trend but a strategic
imperative, distinguishing market leaders from laggards. The agility, adaptability, and speed with
which businesses embrace AI technologies are pivotal in defining their market position and long-
term viability.
The COVID-19 pandemic has further underscored the importance of technological innovation in
ensuring sustainable growth, particularly for small and medium enterprises (SMEs). Bahador and
Ibrahim (2021) highlight how SMEs, a major segment of commercial activities in developing
nations, have been compelled to evolve their business models by adopting AI and other digital
technologies. This shift is not merely a response to the pandemic-induced challenges but a strategic
move towards future-proofing businesses against similar disruptions. The integration of AI, big
data analysis, and internet technologies, aligned with the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM),
has emerged as a vital framework for SMEs to rejuvenate their operations and ensure sustainable
growth.
The concept of reindustrialization using Industry 4.0 maturity models, as discussed by Bhatt and
Kumar (2022), is particularly relevant in the context of leveraging AI for sustainable business
growth. The transition from traditional business models to those that are digitally transformed and
AI-integrated is not just a technological upgrade but a strategic reorientation towards
sustainability. This transformation is characterized by the adoption of AI, machine learning, and
strong network connections, ensuring a seamless transition from the physical to the virtual world.
The readiness of micro, small, and medium industries to adopt these Industry 4.0 practices is a
critical factor in their ability to leverage AI for sustainable growth.
The integration of AI in business models offers numerous opportunities for sustainable growth.
Firstly, AI-driven analytics and big data enable businesses to make more informed decisions,
optimizing operations and reducing waste. This leads to increased efficiency and cost savings,
contributing to the economic sustainability of the business. Secondly, AI technologies facilitate the
development of new products and services, opening up new markets and revenue streams. This not
only contributes to the financial sustainability of the business but also fosters innovation and
competitiveness.
Furthermore, AI technologies play a crucial role in enhancing customer experiences. By leveraging
AI-driven insights, businesses can offer personalized services and products, improving customer
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 103
satisfaction and loyalty. This contributes to the business's immediate financial success and builds a
long-term customer base, essential for sustainable growth.
However, leveraging AI for sustainable growth is not without challenges. Businesses must
navigate the complexities of AI integration, including technical and operational hurdles, ethical
considerations, and the need for skilled personnel. Moreover, the rapid pace of technological
advancement means that businesses must continually adapt and evolve their AI strategies to stay
competitive.
The integration of AI technologies in business models presents significant opportunities for
sustainable growth. By embracing AI-driven innovation, businesses can optimize operations, foster
new product development, enhance customer experiences, and ensure long-term viability. The key
to success lies in the strategic and agile adoption of AI, coupled with a commitment to continuous
learning and adaptation.
Theoretical and Practical Implications of Findings
In the realm of AI-driven business models, the theoretical and practical implications are vast and
multifaceted. Breidbach and Maglio (2020) delve into the ethical implications of data-driven
business models, highlighting the need for accountability in algorithms. This study is particularly
relevant in understanding how AI and big data can lead to ethical challenges in business. The
authors emphasize the redefinition of value networks and the alteration of roles of individual
actors, which is crucial for businesses to consider when integrating AI into their models. The
practical implications of this study lie in its guidance for practitioners to implement and use
advanced analytics ethically, ensuring that AI-driven business models do not only focus on
profitability but also on ethical considerations.
Saurabh et al. (2022) contribute to this discussion by developing an "AI led ethical digital
transformation framework." This study synthesizes various business ethics decision-making
models and maps them against AI-led digital transformation. The framework evaluates the ethical
dimensions of AI integration in business, providing a structured approach for companies to follow.
This is particularly useful for businesses undergoing digital transformation, as it offers a guideline
to ensure that their AI initiatives are ethically sound and aligned with broader organizational goals.
Rojas and Tuomi (2022) explore the role of AI startups in the sustainable social development of
the service sector. Their research identifies key factors influencing AI startups' ability to contribute
to sustainable social development, such as awareness of socioeconomic issues and fostering decent
work. This study has practical implications for startups and established businesses alike, as it
provides guidelines for ethical development and implementation of AI in the service sector. By
focusing on Ethics as a Service, the study underscores the importance of ethical considerations in
business model innovation.
These studies collectively highlight the importance of ethical considerations and sustainable
practices in AI-driven business models. They provide theoretical insights into the ethical
challenges posed by AI and practical guidelines for businesses to navigate these challenges. As AI
continues to transform the business landscape, these studies offer valuable perspectives for
businesses to innovate responsibly and ethically.
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 104
Contributions to Business Model Theory
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into business models has catalyzed significant
theoretical advancements in the field of business model theory. Mishra and Tripathi (2021) present
an integrative approach to AI business models, drawing parallels with cloud SaaS models in terms
of flexibility and scalability. This approach highlights the dynamic nature of AI-driven business
models, characterized by continuous learning and adaptation, and the role of AI in enhancing
business processes through digital data fluidity. Such fluidity allows for ongoing improvements
and innovations, marking a departure from traditional static business models.
Turktarhan, Aleong, and Aleong (2022) explore how AI is re-architecting firms for increased
value, shifting the focus from traditional business models to agile and data-centric ones. Their
research underscores the transformation in value creation and competitive advantage driven by
AI's ability to manage and curate data effectively. This transformation extends beyond the
technological realm, necessitating a cultural shift and a rethinking of organizational structures and
functions. The paper posits that AI enables firms to reorient around a digital core, which leads to
enhanced scalability and improved logistics management.
In their exploration of the role of artificial intelligence (AI) in shaping business models and
managing transformation in new entrepreneurial ventures, Fang (2023) uncovers the profound
influence of AI applications. The study highlights that AI provides innovative opportunities and an
effective pathway for transforming business models, especially in the context of new ventures.
Fang emphasizes that AI's role extends beyond mere efficiency enhancement, positioning it as a
catalyst for new business paradigms and innovation in business model design.These studies
collectively contribute to business model theory by highlighting the dynamic adaptation inherent in
AI-driven business models. AI enables a shift from static to dynamic models, emphasizing the
need for constant learning and innovation. The data-centric approach to value creation is another
key aspect, where AI transforms how firms create value, leveraging data for enhanced decision-
making and customer responsiveness. The integration of AI also necessitates a rethinking of
traditional organizational structures, with a shift towards a digital core requiring firms to be more
agile and responsive to data-driven insights. Furthermore, AI presents unique opportunities for
innovation, especially in new entrepreneurial ventures, offering pathways for transformation and
growth in the entrepreneurial landscape. Lastly, the strategic implications of AI in business models
are profound, enhancing operational efficiencies and opening up new avenues for competitive
advantage and market differentiation.
The theoretical contributions of AI to business model theory are multifaceted and significant. They
signify a paradigm shift in how businesses conceptualize, design, and implement their models in
the AI era, encompassing aspects like dynamic adaptation, data-centric value creation,
organizational transformation, and strategic implications.
Practical Guidelines for Business Leaders
In the rapidly evolving landscape of AI-driven business models, business leaders face the
challenge of navigating through a complex and often unfamiliar terrain. Integrating AI into
business processes demands technical acumen and a nuanced understanding of its impact on
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 105
organizational dynamics, decision-making, and leadership strategies. Drawing insights from recent
literature, this section outlines practical guidelines for business leaders to effectively harness AI
technologies in their organizations.
Agbaji (2021) emphasizes the importance of leadership and managerial decision-making in
industries transformed by AI, particularly in sectors like oil and gas. The study highlights the need
for leaders to develop a deep understanding of AI technologies and their potential applications
within their specific industry contexts. This involves staying abreast of the latest AI advancements
and critically evaluating how these technologies can enhance operational efficiencies, drive
innovation, and create competitive advantages. Leaders must also be adept at assessing the risks
associated with AI deployment, including ethical considerations and potential disruptions to
existing business processes.
Crockett et al. (2021) provide a compelling case for building trustworthy AI solutions, particularly
for small businesses. The authors argue that trust is a critical component in the successful adoption
of AI technologies. Business leaders should focus on developing AI solutions that are transparent,
explainable, and aligned with the ethical values of the organization. This includes establishing
clear guidelines for data usage, ensuring privacy and security, and involving stakeholders in the AI
development process. By fostering a culture of trust around AI, leaders can mitigate resistance to
change and encourage wider acceptance of AI-driven innovations.
Abasaheb and Subashini (2023) explore the role of AI in empowering leadership and driving
digital transformation. Their empirical overview suggests that AI can be a powerful tool for leaders
to make informed decisions, predict market trends, and personalise customer experiences.
However, the successful implementation of AI requires leaders to adopt a strategic approach that
balances technological capabilities with human insights. Leaders should focus on upskilling their
workforce to work alongside AI systems, promoting a culture of continuous learning and
adaptation. Additionally, they should leverage AI to enhance communication and collaboration
within the organization, fostering an environment where AI and human intelligence synergistically
contribute to achieving business goals.
CONCLUSION
This comprehensive study, meticulously crafted to explore the transformative impact of AI on
business models, has successfully met its aim and objectives, offering profound insights into the
evolving landscape of AI-driven business innovation. By systematically analyzing a wide array of
literature, this review has illuminated the multifaceted nature of AI integration in modern business
practices and its profound implications for future business strategies.
This study's key findings underscore AI's pivotal role in reshaping business models. AI's
integration into business strategies has enhanced operational efficiencies and fostered innovative
approaches to customer engagement, data management, and decision-making processes. The
emergence of AI-driven business models, characterized by adaptability, data-centricity, and
customer-focused innovation, marks a significant shift from traditional business paradigms. This
shift, as revealed in the study, necessitates a rethinking of leadership roles, with a greater emphasis
on ethical considerations, continuous learning, and adaptability in the face of AI-induced changes.
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 106
The study also highlights the challenges and opportunities presented by AI in business. While
technical and operational hurdles pose significant challenges, the opportunities for growth,
competitive advantage, and enhanced customer experiences are immense. Businesses that
successfully navigate these challenges, leveraging AI's potential while mitigating its risks, stand to
gain substantially in the evolving digital economy.
In conclusion, this study recommends a strategic approach for businesses embracing AI. This
involves a balanced integration of AI with human insights, fostering a culture of innovation and
ethical responsibility, and continuously adapting to the dynamic AI landscape. For business
leaders, the way forward lies in harnessing AI's potential to drive sustainable growth while
remaining vigilant of its ethical and operational implications.
Thus, this study not only meets its stated objectives but also provides a foundational framework for
future research and practical application in the realm of AI-driven business innovation, setting a
benchmark for academic and professional discourse in this rapidly evolving field.
References
Agbaji, A.L. (2021). Leadership and managerial decision-making in an AI-Enabled Oil and Gas
Industry. [online] Available at: https://dx.doi.org/10.2118/207613-ms [Accessed 13
November 2023]. DOI: 10.2118/207613-ms.
Ahmed, S., & Miskon, S. (2020). IoT driven resiliency with artificial intelligence, machine
learning and analytics for digital transformation. In 2020 International Conference on
Decision Aid Sciences and Application (DASA) (pp. 1205-1208). IEEE. doi:
10.1109/DASA51403.2020.9317177.
Alam, A., & Mohanty, A. (2022). Business models, business strategies, and innovations in EdTech
companies: integration of learning analytics and artificial intelligence in higher education.
In 2022 IEEE 6th Conference on Information and Communication Technology (CICT) (pp.
1-6). IEEE. doi: 10.1109/CICT56698.2022.9997887.
Bahador, M.H., & Ibraim, S.S. (2021). Technology Innovations toward Sustainable Growth of
Small and Medium Enterprise (SMEs): Aftermath COVID-19 Pandemic. International
Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 11, 1235-1241. DOI:
10.6007/IJARBSS/V11-I2/9199
Bhatt, K., & Kumar, S.M. (2022). Reindustrialization Using Industry 4.0 Maturity Models in
Msmes and Tenets of Digital Transformation Phases. In 2022 Fourth International
Conference on Emerging Research in Electronics, Computer Science and Technology
(ICERECT) (pp. 1-6). IEEE. DOI: 10.1109/ICERECT56837.2022.10060716
Breidbach, C.F., & Maglio, P. (2020). Accountable algorithms? The ethical implications of data-
driven business models. Journal of Service Management, 31(2), 163-185. DOI:
10.1108/josm-03-2019-0073
Bulatnikov, V., & Constantin, C.P. (2021, May). Systematic analysis of literature on the marketing
of healthcare systems. challenges for Russian and Romanian healthcare systems.
In Healthcare (Vol. 9, No. 6, p. 656). MDPI. DOI:10.3390/healthcare9060656
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 107
Cao, L. (2021). Artificial intelligence in retail: applications and value creation logics. International
Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, 49(7), 958-976. DOI:10.1108/IJRDM-09-
2020-0350
Coltey, E., Alonso, D., Vassigh, S., & Chen, S.C. (2022). Towards an AI-driven marketplace for
small businesses during COVID-19. SN Computer Science, 3(6), 441. doi: 10.1007/s42979-
022-01349-w.
Crockett, K.A., Colyer, E., Gerber, L., & Latham, A. (2021). Building trustworthy ai solutions: a
case for practical solutions for small businesses. [online] Available at:
https://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TAI.2021.3137091 [Accessed 13 November 2023]. DOI:
10.1109/TAI.2021.3137091.
Enholm, I.M., Papagiannidis, E., Mikalef, P., & Krogstie, J. (2022). Artificial intelligence and
business value: A literature review. Information Systems Frontiers, 24(5), 1709-1734.
DOI:10.1007/s10796-021-10186-w
Escajeda, H.G. (2018). Legal Education: A new growth vision: part i-the issue: sustainable growth
or dead cat bounce: a strategic inflection point analysis. Nebraska Law Review, 97, 628.
Fang, J. (2023). Research on the design of business models and transformation management of
new entrepreneurial ventures driven by artificial intelligence. DOI:
10.54691/bcpbm.v49i.5383
Fenwick, M., Vermeulen, E.P., & Corrales, M. (2018). Business and regulatory responses to
artificial intelligence: Dynamic regulation, innovation ecosystems and the strategic
management of disruptive technology. In Robotics, AI and the Future of Law (pp. 81-103).
Singapore: Springer Singapore. doi: 10.1007/978-981-13-2874-9_4.
Fteimi, N., & Hopf, K. (2021). Knowledge Management in the Era of Artificial Intelligence -
Developing an Integrative Framework.
Gomes, P., Verçosa, L., Melo, F., Silva, V., Filho, C.B., & Bezerra, B. (2022). Artificial
Intelligence-Based Methods for Business Processes: A Systematic Literature
Review. Applied Sciences, 12(5), 2314. DOI:10.3390/app12052314
Hahn, C., Traunecker, T., Niever, M., & Basedow, G.N. (2020). Exploring AI-driven business
models: conceptualization and expectations in the machinery industry. In 2020 IEEE
International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management
(IEEM) (pp. 567-570). IEEE. doi: 10.1109/IEEM45057.2020.9309824.
Huang, J., Beling, P., Freeman, L. and Zeng, Y., 2021. Trustworthy AI for digital engineering
transformation. Journal of Integrated Design and Process Science, 25(1), 1-7.
DOI:10.3233/JID-210028
Ilieva, R., Ivanova, M., Peycheva, T., & Nikolov, Y. (2021). Modelling in support of decision
making in business intelligence. In Integration Challenges for Analytics, Business
Intelligence, and Data Mining (pp. 115-144). IGI Global. DOI:10.4018/978-1-7998-5781-
5.ch006
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 108
Iqbal, R., Kumar, P., Aamir, M., Al-Naqbi, S., Jan, S. A., Kumar, P., & Mukherjee, J. (2022).
IBTIKAR Digital Lab - A Collaborative Approach towards Research and Development
Challenges in Oil and Gas Upstream. DOI: 10.2118/211115-ms
John, M.M., Olsson, H.H., & Bosch, J. (2023). Towards an AI‐driven business development
framework: A multi‐case study. Journal of Software: Evolution and Process, 35(6), e2432.
DOI:10.1002/smr.2432
Kop, M. (2020). The right to process data for machine learning purposes in the EU. Harvard Law
School, Harvard Journal of Law & Technology (JOLT), 34. DOI:10.2139/ssrn.3653537
Kulkov, I. (2023). Next-generation business models for artificial intelligence start-ups in the
healthcare industry. International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & Research, 29(4),
860-885. doi: 10.1108/IJEBR-04-2021-0304.
Kutz, J., Neuhüttler, J., Spilski, J., & Lachmann, T. (2022). Implementation of AI Technologies in
manufacturing - success factors and challenges. DOI: 10.54941/ahfe1002565
Lakhan, N. (2022). Applications of data science and AI in business. IJRASET, 10(5).
DOI:10.22214/ijraset.2022.43343
Marrone, T., & Testa, P. (2022). Brand algorithms and social engagement in digital era. The
Human Side of Service Engineering, 62(62). Doi: 10.54941/ahfe1002562.
May, G., & Kiritsis, D. (2019). Zero defect manufacturing strategies and platform for smart
factories of industry 4.0. In Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on the
Industry 4.0 Model for Advanced Manufacturing: AMP 2019 4 (pp. 142-152). Springer
International Publishing. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-030-18180-2_11
Metelskaia, I., Ignatyeva, O., Denef, S., & Samsonowa, T. (2018). A business model template for
AI solutions. In Proceedings of the International Conference on Intelligent Science and
Technology (pp. 35-41). doi: 10.1145/3233740.3233750.
Mishra, S., & Tripathi, A.R. (2021). AI business model: an integrative business approach. Journal
of Innovation and Entrepreneurship, 10(1), 18. DOI:10.1186/s13731-021-00157-5
Ping, N.L. (2019). Constructs for artificial intelligence customer service in E-commerce. In 2019
6th International Conference on Research and Innovation in Information Systems
(ICRIIS) (pp. 1-6). IEEE. doi: 10.1109/ICRIIS48246.2019.9073486.
Nortje, M.A., & Grobbelaar, S.S. (2020). A framework for the implementation of artificial
intelligence in business enterprises: a readiness model. In 2020 IEEE International
Conference on Engineering, Technology and Innovation (ICE/ITMC) (pp. 1-10). IEEE.
DOI:10.1109/ICE/ITMC49519.2020.9198436
Banda, L., Mzyece, M., & Mekuria, F. (2022). 5g business models for mobile network operators–a
survey. IEEE Access. Banda, L., Mzyece, M., & Mekuria, F. (2022). 5G Business Models
for Mobile Network Operators—A Survey. IEEE Access. DOI:
10.1109/ACCESS.2022.3205011
Pfau, W., & Rimpp, P. (2021). AI-enhanced business models for digital entrepreneurship. Digital
Entrepreneurship: Impact on Business and Society, 121-140. DOI:10.1007/978-3-030-
53914-6_7
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 109
Popa, A., Amaba, B., & Daniels, J. (2021). A framework of best practices for delivering successful
artificial intelligence projects. A case study demonstration. In SPE Annual Technical
Conference and Exhibition? (p. D021S022R002). SPE.
Delbufalo, E., Di Bernardo, M., & Risso, M. (2022). Human-Machine Interaction and AI for
Competitive Business in the Digital Era. Symphonya, (2), 134-143. doi:
10.4468/2022.2.12delbufalo.dibernardo.risso.
Rojas, A., & Tuomi, A. (2022). Reimagining the sustainable social development of AI for the
service sector: the role of startups. Journal of Ethics in Entrepreneurship and
Technology, 2(1), 39-54. DOI: 10.1108/jeet-03-2022-0005
Abasaheb, S.A., & Subashini, R. (2023). Maneuvering of Digital Transformation: Role of
Artificial Intelligence in Empowering Leadership-An Empirical Overview. International
Journal of Professional Business Review: International Journal of Professional Business
Review, 8(5), 20 [online] Available at:
https://dx.doi.org/10.26668/businessreview/2023.v8i5.1838 [Accessed 13 November 2023].
DOI: 10.26668/businessreview/2023.v8i5.1838.
Sai, B., Thanigaivelu, S., Shivaani, N., Babu, S., & Ramaa, A. (2022). Integration of Chatbots in
the Procurement Stage of a Supply Chain. In 2022 6th International Conference on
Computation System and Information Technology for Sustainable Solutions (CSITSS) (pp.
1-5). IEEE. DOI:10.1109/CSITSS57437.2022.10026367
Saurabh, K., Arora, R., Rani, N., Mishra, D. and Ramkumar, M., 2022. AI led ethical digital
transformation: Framework, research and managerial implications. Journal of Information,
Communication and Ethics in Society, 20(2), 229-256. DOI: 10.1108/jices-02-2021-0020
Schmeiss, J., & Friederici, N. (2019). Understanding'AI Made in Germany': A Report on the
German Startup Landscape. Delphi, 2, 87. DOI:10.21552/delphi/2019/2/8
Sureeyatanapas, P., Waleekhajornlert, N., Arunyanart, S., & Niyamosoth, T. (2020). Resilient
supplier selection in electronic components procurement: an integration of evidence theory
and rule-based transformation into TOPSIS to tackle uncertain and incomplete information.
Symmetry, 12(7), 1109. DOI:10.3390/sym12071109
Thomas, A. (2020). Convergence and digital fusion lead to competitive differentiation. Business
Process Management Journal, 26(3), 707-720. DOI: 10.1108/bpmj-01-2019-0001
Trakadas, P., Simoens, P., Gkonis, P., Sarakis, L., Angelopoulos, A., Ramallo-González, A.P.,
Skarmeta, A., Trochoutsos, C., Calvο, D., Pariente, T. and Chintamani, K., 2020. An
artificial intelligence-based collaboration approach in industrial iot manufacturing: Key
concepts, architectural extensions and potential applications. Sensors, 20(19),
5480.DOI:10.3390/s20195480
Turktarhan, G., Aleong, D.S., & Aleong, C. (2022). Re-architecting the firm for increased value:
How business models are adapting to the new AI environment. Journal of Global Business
Insights, 7(1), 33-49. DOI: 10.5038/2640-6489.7.1.1154
Computer Science & IT Research Journal, Volume 4, Issue 2, November 2023
Farayola, Abdul, Irabor, & Okeleke, P. 85-110 Page 110
von Garrel, J., & Jahn, C. (2022). Design framework for the implementation of AI-based (service)
business models for small and medium-sized manufacturing enterprises.
DOI:10.1007/s13132-022-01003-z
Wan, J., Li, X., Dai, H.N., Kusiak, A., Martinez-Garcia, M., & Li, D. (2020). Artificial-
intelligence-driven customized manufacturing factory: key technologies, applications, and
challenges. Proceedings of the IEEE, 109(4), 377-398. doi: 10.1109/JPROC.2020.3034808.
Whitfield, S., & Zborowski, M. (2019). SPE Offshore Europe Industry Emerges as Revitalized,
Digitally Motivated. Journal of Petroleum Technology, 71(11), 48-52.
Wiener, M., Saunders, C., & Marabelli, M. (2020). Big-data business models: A critical literature
review and multiperspective research framework. Journal of Information
Technology, 35(1), 66-91 DOI:10.1177/0268396219896811
Wisniewski, H.S. (2020). What is the Business with AI? Preparing Future Decision Makers and
Leaders. Technology & Innovation, 21(4), 1-14. doi: 10.21300/21.4.2020.4.
Zarifis, A., Holland, C.P., & Milne, A. (2019). Evaluating the impact of AI on insurance: The four
emerging AI-and data-driven business models. Emerald Open Research, 1, 15. doi:
10.35241/emeraldopenres.13249.1.
