ArticlePDF Available

Agribusiness sustainability due to social entrepreneurship in Vietnam

Authors:
  • WSB Merito University Gdańsk

Abstract

Global common challenges badly affecting agricultural sustainability embrace, amongst others, countering global climate change, natural resources depletion, living habitat degradation and environmental pollution (Dana, 1994b, 1994a). Sustainable agriculture is essential to feed the world population that exceeds eight billion people. Farmers' social entrepreneurship is a precondition to keep the agribusiness sustainable to counter global common challenges and to follow the trend of circular economy. To investigate the development of social entrepreneurship and its impact on agriculture sustainable development in the Mekong delta, the agricultural region in the Southwest Vietnam, the author has gathered secondary information from trustworthy sources of data base, both traditional and websites of government and public institutions. The findings of this study serve as a basis to put forward solutions for sustaining agribusinesses and their social entrepreneurship. From that, we propose multilevel solutions for policy makers and agribusinesses in this part of Vietnam.
Int. J.
Entrepreneurship and Small Business
, Vol. X, No. Y, xxxx
1
Copyright © 20XX Inderscience Enterprises Ltd.
Agribusiness sustainability due to social
entrepreneurship in Vietnam
Nguyen Huu Tinh
Thu Dau Mot University,
06 Tran Van On, Thu Dau Mot City, Binh Duong, Vietnam
Email: tinhnh@tdmu.edu.vn
Nguyen Hoang Tien*
WSB University in Gdansk,
Aleja Grunwaldzka 238A, 80-266 Gdańsk, Poland
Email: vietnameu@gmail.com
*Corresponding author
Nguyen Thi Thu Trang and Doan Van Trai
Ho Chi Minh City University of Industry and Trade,
140 Le Trong Tan, Tan Phu ward, HCMC, Vietnam
Email: trangntthu@hufi.edu.vn
Email: traidv@hufi.edu.vn
Abstract: Global common challenges badly affecting agricultural sustainability
embrace, amongst others, countering global climate change, natural resources
depletion, living habitat degradation and environmental pollution (Dana,
1994b, 1994a). Sustainable agriculture is essential to feed the world population
that exceeds eight billion people. Farmers’ social entrepreneurship is a
precondition to keep the agribusiness sustainable to counter global common
challenges and to follow the trend of circular economy. To investigate the
development of social entrepreneurship and its impact on agriculture
sustainable development in the Mekong delta, the agricultural region in the
Southwest Vietnam, the author has gathered secondary information from
trustworthy sources of data base, both traditional and websites of government
and public institutions. The findings of this study serve as a basis to put
forward solutions for sustaining agribusinesses and their social
entrepreneurship. From that, we propose multilevel solutions for policy makers
and agribusinesses in this part of Vietnam.
Keyword: agriculture; sustainability; farming business; agribusiness; social
entrepreneurship; global climate change; circular economy; Mekong delta;
Vietnam.
Reference to this paper should be made as follows: Tinh, N.H., Tien, N.H.,
Trang, N.T.T. and Trai, D.V. (xxxx) ‘Agribusiness sustainability due to social
entrepreneurship in Vietnam’, Int. J. Entrepreneurship and Small Business,
Vol. X, No. Y, pp.xxx–xxx.
2
Biographical notes: Nguyen Huu Tinh is a PhD holder and Lecturer at Thu
Dau Mot University. His specialisation is in business and financial and
accounting issues. He has over ten years of academic teaching experience. He
has published more than 40 papers domestic and worldwide.
Nguyen Hoang Tien is a Professor at WSB Merito University. He has over
15 years of academic teaching experience and research in management. His
specialisation is in contemporary business and international entrepreneurship.
He has published more than 500 research papers worldwide.
Nguyen Thi Thu Trang is a Lecturer at Ho Chi Minh City University
of Industry and Trade. Her specialisation is in business and related
socio-environmental issued. She has over five years of academic teaching
experience. She has published more than 50 papers domestic and worldwide.
Doan Van Trai is a PhD holder and Lecturer at Ho Chi Minh City University of
Industry and Trade. His specialisation is in business and financial and
economic issues. He has over five years of academic management and teaching
experience. He has published more than 30 papers domestic and worldwide.
1 Introduction
The Mekong delta lying in the South-West Vietnam is a key agricultural economic region
of this country, with relatively stable growth and positive changes in the economic
structure over the past years. The Mekong delta is focusing on innovating its growth
model, in order to improve its competitive edge and to create more value from output
products for the market and consumers. The Mekong delta is also facing many challenges
from extreme weather condition and climate phenomena. For the purpose of sustainable
development, the agricultural economy of the Mekong delta needs to be restructured
towards a sustainable agricultural ecosystem to satisfactorily solve the problems of green
production, adapting new technology and protecting Earth’s environment (AGDARD,
2018, 2019, 2020). This transformation of production models and methods is all about
approaching the circular economy idea and concept (Muscio and Sisto, 2020; Nam and
Hanh, 2019). However, to be more successful, the issue of social entrepreneurship for the
enterprises that are farmers, especially with small scale, needs to be well discussed and
analysed. The circular economy is an irreversible trend towards environmental protection,
green economic growth, sustainable agricultural development in the context that natural
resources are gradually being exhausted, environmental degradation and pollution are
increasing. Furthermore, the environment and climate change is becoming more and
more intense (Nhan, 2019; PM, 2022; Crespi et al., 2018; Chekouri and Chibi, 2017).
Enterprises, especially the SMEs participating in circular agricultural economy, need to
work together through the implementation of concepts and models of community and
social entrepreneurship (Saadaoui and Jbir, 2021). Building a circular economy based on
social entrepreneurship orientation of farmers and agribusinesses can be considered as an
appropriate development direction of Vietnam’s agriculture in the coming decades. In
that context, social entrepreneurial spirit alongside the social responsibility awareness of
the agribusiness community is considered as the most important factor contributing to the
rapid development of the circular economy towards sustainable development. In recent
Agribusiness sustainability due to social entrepreneurship in Vietnam
3
years, agriculture in the Mekong delta has gradually followed the trend of globalisation
and integration with international markets. Therefore, the mainstream trends such as
sustainable development, circular economy, community and social entrepreneurship seem
to have become familiar to local farmers and agribusinesses (Ha, 2021; FAO, 2022). This
article focuses on studying the impact of social entrepreneurship on the sustainability of
the agriculture via the circular economy of Vietnam’s provinces and cities of Mekong
delta region, thereby proposing a number of developmental solutions for the local
government there.
2 Theoretical and conceptual background
2.1 Social entrepreneurship
Issues related to sustainability are becoming increasingly important. Therefore, today’s
businesses are often oriented towards environmental protection, saving natural resources,
energy security and food safety, green consumption, social entrepreneurship and circular
economy. Sustainability in business success is determined by the satisfaction of all
stakeholder groups from farther to closer socio-economic stratification, from short term
oriented to long term oriented in the natural and social environment. Social enterprises
with sustainable business strategies often attach importance to social and community
goals, towards the idea of social justice and inclusion (Bilan et al., 2017). Social
entrepreneurs with deep social embedment in rural communities are often owners and
managers of SMEs that rely on local communities and local governments to mobilise
resources to grow and rise to the higher levels of social integration and environmental
sustainability (Von Friedrichs and Wahlberg, 2016).
To enhance the sustainability of social enterprises, it is necessary to make them social
entrepreneurs. Social entrepreneurship is designated to connect micro and small
agribusinesses locating in the far-off agricultural clusters of developing economies
(Goyal and Sergi, 2015). Social entrepreneurship can be used to exploit new business
opportunities due to the trend of sustainable agricultural development, a circular
agricultural economy with the aim of minimising challenges from climate change, with
the use of renewable energy and with the limit of natural resources (Raudeliūnienė et al.,
2014). Social entrepreneurship is seen as a socialised and community-based business and
entrepreneurial activities with the aspiration to become a game-changer in sustainable
agricultural development and circular agricultural economy. These business and
entrepreneurial activities are not merely profit-driven, but also focus on solving social
problems, dealing with environmental challenges posed by climate change and limited
natural resources (Peredo et al., 2004). Social start-ups are often small, medium, or even
micro-sized. Therefore, their joint social entrepreneurial activities are increasingly
significant with characteristics such as: social identity, pro-entrepreneurial culture,
cooperation mechanism, access to the knowledge and entrepreneurial capacity (Ferris and
Voia, 2012). Social entrepreneurs are motivated principally by the urgency to change the
surroundings, recognition and fulfilment of social needs, boosting the networking capital
for social innovations and inclusions (Kuratko, 2011). Social entrepreneurship has
revealed its very specific nature, development motivation and mainly driven purpose in
its approach to business sustainability issues (Castellano et al., 2017). Thus, social
entrepreneurship education is really something that needs to be implemented, especially
4
in terms of and regarding its identity, knowledge, capacities, performance and visions
towards business, society, environment and unlimitedly further such as the existential
threats of the Earth and mankind (Orhei et al., 2015; Frederick, 2018).
2.2 Circular economy
Circular economy can be understood as a sustainable and ideal socio-economic model, in
which activities related to production, business and distribution are directed towards
extending the maximum life cycle of anything or even everything such as products,
services, production inputs such as raw materials and auxiliary materials, other entities
related to the operation of business and society; limiting and eliminating the negative
impacts of this process on people health and wealth, the social environment and the
natural environment (Pearce and Turner, 1990; Ha, 2021; FAO, 2022).
In terms of benefits brought about between traditional economy and circular
economy, the benefits from the circular economy are more sustainable and contribute
positively to the trend of green consumption and green growth around the world.
Developing such a circular economy is synonymous with responsibility and readiness to
respond to global challenges and issues such as degradation of natural resources,
environmental pollution, climate change going hand in hand with improving the
competitiveness of the economy and the business entities within. The circular economy
reuses and minimises the exploitation of natural resources, enhances treatment and limits
waste and emissions to the natural environment and atmosphere (Okada and Samreth,
2017; Khan et al., 2020). In terms of benefits for the society, circular economy reduces
social costs in management, environmental protection and response to climate change,
and at the same time create many new job opportunities, new commodity markets,
contributing to the protection of health and improving the quality of human life.
Particularly for businesses, the circular economy will help reduce the risk of
overproduction, limit the situation of resource scarcity, and create motivation to continue
research and development to innovate technology, minimise production costs, costs of
business operations and supply chain efficiency (Artiach, 2020).
The circular economy is seen through three key principles including (Atienza, 2019;
Al-Marhubi, 2021; Ahmad et al., 2019; Sasaki, 2021; Qi and Li, 2017):
Conserving and developing natural resources through strict control and
rationalisation of their exploitation, regeneration of natural habitats and especially
the development and popular use of renewable energy resources (Güney, 2021;
Bayale et al., 2021).
Optimising the return of resources by circulating the input production materials and
manufactured products as quickly as possible in all biological and engineering
cycles.
Improve the overall efficiency of the system through minimising negative
externalities, treating waste, redesigning the model of the production process right
from the very beginning.
Agribusiness sustainability due to social entrepreneurship in Vietnam
5
2.3 Agribusiness sustainability
The activities of agribusinesses have a great impact on the natural environment, no less
than other production and business activities. This also leads to greenhouse effects,
excessive water consumption, and soil pollution from fertilisers and pesticides. Factors
related to climate change are also considered to have a negative impact on the agricultural
sector. The agricultural circular economy includes activities serving to reduce, reuse, and
recycle everything in the waste treatment process. In the circular economy, waste is also
seen as an underutilised and undervalued resource. To maximise the treatment, utilisation
and recycling of waste, circular economy agribusiness aim to be completely at
zero-emissions to the environment and achieve the highest economic benefits (Sasaki,
2021; Qi and Li, 2017). The circular agricultural economy also connects production and
livestock activities in a highly sustainable way, also aiming to reduce environmental
emissions to near zero (Okada and Samreth, 2017).
A circular agricultural economy will minimise negative impacts on the environment
in order to sustainably feed a rapidly growing world population. The circular agricultural
economy is based on the principle of minimising the use of external production inputs
and minimising the impact on the natural environment in the agricultural production
process. The organic wastes from livestock and farming are converted into nutrient-rich
natural fertilisers for reuse on agricultural farms, significantly reducing input costs
compared to applying synthetic fertilisers (Khan et al., 2020). In different localities,
farmers’ activities related to livestock raising, irrigation have produced various types of
liquid biological waste. This is a source of nutrients with many necessary organic
substances that can be applied directly to feed the plants. The amount of biomass from
plant and animal waste can be used directly to produce different types of biofuels, heat
and electricity, helping the circular economy reduce dependence on chemical and fossil
fuels (Mien, 2021). Reducing waste and increasing efficiency in agricultural production
will support the development of a circular economy. Furthermore, high-tech agriculture
can also provide similar support through investment in research and development to
ensure that only the right amount of the substance is used at the right time and in the right
place to avoid unnecessary, excessive use, reducing the input resources and minimising
the detrimental impact on the natural environment.
3 Investigating the case of Mekong delta in Vietnam
3.1 Agriculture and agribusinesses in the Mekong delta
From underdeveloped localities to developing agribusiness clusters: The Mekong
delta is an affluent delta with a complicated system of rivers and canals, with the
largest agricultural area and output in Vietnam. This place is the cradle of mainly
small and medium-sized agribusinesses and the vast majority of households are self-
cultivated on the land they own. Medium-sized enterprises are often located in
clusters in large towns or developing cities that are capitals of provinces. Outlying
areas are less developed regions that are dominated by family, micro and small
businesses.
6
Clan culture (family-based) instead of business culture (market oriented): The
Mekong delta region has the lowest urbanisation rate in Vietnam, except for the
northern mountainous provinces and the Central Highlands. Here, instead of the
market exchange-oriented business culture model, there exists a family culture and a
clan culture. Households, due to their tiny size, still maintain the main subsistent and
self-sufficient agricultural economic model. Neighbouring households often help,
care and support each other for coexistence and development. Therefore, this place
can be considered as the cradle of social entrepreneurship and community
entrepreneurship development in the field of agriculture, including farming, animal
husbandry and aquaculture, etc.
Favourable and unfavourable conditions for an introduction of circular economy: In
the Mekong delta, like many other localities across Vietnam, the circular economy
model is being implemented for practical benefits both in the short term and in the
long term. The Mekong delta region has been and will suffer enormous damage due
to climate change. Firstly, sea level rise causes salt water intrusion that gradually
limits the area available for farming and husbandry. Secondly, the prolonged drought
has made a lot of hectares of forests and crop areas to be burned, causing great
damage to farmers. With rich but not unlimited resources and gradually shrinking,
the idea of a circular economy in this area has become increasingly clear. People
have also gradually realised the importance of protecting and using natural resources
economically and where possible, using renewable energy sources instead.
3.2 Application of circular economy towards agribusiness sustainability
Contribution of circular economy to the agribusiness sustainability: The circular
economy helps to limit and reduce the large amounts of emissions into the
atmosphere and waste both liquid and solid into the natural environment. The
circular economy in the Mekong delta has helped small and medium-sized
enterprises, micro and family enterprises, households save resources, cut production
and operating costs, improve own competitiveness and sustainability in particular
and sustainability of the local economy in general. Businesses of all sizes can
support and share with each other within the framework of participating in the
circular economy, turning the process of growing, breeding, production, exchange
and distribution into a closed circle, recycling and minimising waste and rubbish
expelled into the environment.
Applicability of circular economy to enhance agribusiness sustainability:
Agribusinesses can connect with each other to form a closed circular supply chain
with the output of one farm being the input of the other. Agribusinesses operate in
the fields of production, cultivation, farming, trading and distribution with different
types of seeds and plants. In order to improve the sustainability, they must connect
each other’s inputs to outputs to limit the waste of inputs and the output wastes, and
also limit the travel distance from one business to another to cut unnecessary and
harmful CO2 emissions to the natural environment. Secondly, agribusinesses and
households are gradually moving towards and gradually gaining access to clean and
renewable and unlimited energy sources with relatively competitive investment costs
and usage prices compared to traditional sources.
Agribusiness sustainability due to social entrepreneurship in Vietnam
7
3.3 Social entrepreneurship in boosting agricultural circular economy and
sustainability
The place of social entrepreneurship in circular economy: Social entrepreneurship is
conceived as a much more sophisticated and complex concept than the
entrepreneurship in the traditional way of thinking. Social entrepreneurship and
social enterprises are significant parts and play a vital role in implementing and
sustaining the circular economy. The circular economy requires the cooperation and
close connection of agribusinesses together into a chain of links that closely
cooperate with each other not only for individual goals but also towards the interests
of the community and society and the environment. Circular economy is a new
concept and its actual implementation in Mekong delta will certainly face
unpredictable challenges, if not risks or even threats from many sides. Thus, local
social entrepreneurship will contribute many innovative ideas that exploit current
potentials and opportunities or improve the status quo, finding the most optimal and
sustainable development directions for a circular economy with plenty of room for
development, perfecting and upgradation to new heights.
The impact of social entrepreneurship on agribusiness sustainability: Social
entrepreneurship has a very positive impact on the sustainability of the agribusiness
system in the Mekong delta. These agribusinesses are inherently small and medium
enterprises, if not small and micro enterprises, or self-farming and self-employed
family agribusinesses and households, which are rather very fragile and volatile if
staying apart. Therefore, they need mutual support. It can be said that without the
spirit of social entrepreneurship that is a precondition to guarantee business
sustainability, this whole agribusiness system cannot maintain its existence and
development to this day. The spirit of social entrepreneurship arouses the solidarity
of the local community, the solidarity of the village, the solidarity and mutual
support, instead of being based on the rule ‘do it on your own if you can’ so that
every link in the agribusiness system can rise, become strong and support the
remaining links within or even serve the expansion of the next newly formed links in
the system.
Social entrepreneurship in connecting circular economy and agribusiness
sustainability: In essence, social entrepreneurship is actually a bridge for the circular
economy towards the sustainability of enterprises within the developing agribusiness
system in Mekong delta. Social entrepreneurship helps raise awareness of the role
and the significance, deploying the substantive contents of the circular economy to
all agribusinesses so that they can connect with each other and participate in the
adequate links and contribute to the sustainability of the system through saving
natural resources, increasing the use of renewable energy as an alternative, limiting
emissions, waste expelling to the environment through either recycle or utilise them
in different ways. Social entrepreneurship is seen as an important linker of all
important parts in the circular agricultural economy. Moreover, social
entrepreneurship will provide new ideas for farmers to further promote the
development of the burgeoning circular economy towards the sustainability of the
entire agribusiness system in the Mekong delta.
8
4 Conclusions
4.1 Theoretical and practical contributions
4.1.1 Theoretical contribution
This study has made sound theoretical contributions to the research problem through
profound revisiting and clarifying the key relevant concepts present in the business and
management literature: social entrepreneurship, circular economy, sustainability through
the lens of small and medium enterprises of the agriculture in developing countries. The
article also related these concepts with each other for general understanding and to form
an overall conceptual system serving a basis for further empirical analysis later in this
study.
4.1.2 Practical contribution
This study provides a comprehensive understanding about the context of overall business
and farming activities and the specificity of agriculture and agribusiness system in the
Mekong delta. Furthermore, this study also helps us understand more about the essence
of newly formed and still in burgeoning stage circular economy in the context of Mekong
delta, the largest agricultural area nationwide but the least developing part of Vietnam
economy, and how it could be applied in boosting the sustainability of agricultural
industry. The practical investigation also unveils the current state and the role of local
social entrepreneurship and community solidarity in bridging the circular economy
toward business sustainability.
4.2 Recommended developmental solutions
Enhancing social entrepreneurship education and knowledge on circular economy:
To develop and perfect a circular economy based on the spirit of social
entrepreneurship of farmers and agribusinesses in the Mekong delta, the state and
local authorities need to have a plan to improve their knowledge, skills and hands-on
experience of what is happening in developed countries within the scope of social
entrepreneurship and circular economy for members of the agrarian economic
community here. Because, in fact, the Mekong delta is still one of the low-lying
areas of Vietnam both literally and figuratively, lagging behind both in updating
human knowledge in the production and business process and regarding the level of
socio-economic development compared to other provinces nationwide. Moreover,
human resource training and development need to be carried out continuously
because the knowledge and practical experience may become outdated and lose its
applicability due to dynamic changes in the environment and business context of the
world. Finally, we must localise the world knowledge and experience to suit the
business context of Vietnam and especially that of the Mekong delta.
Identify and systemise factors affecting agribusiness sustainability: The factors
affecting the sustainability of agribusiness need to be identified and systemised in
order to be classified into the related and unrelated groups. From there,
agribusinesses, local and state government authorities and policy makers can propose
appropriate means of intervention to improve the sustainability of the whole
Agribusiness sustainability due to social entrepreneurship in Vietnam
9
agribusiness system or certain groups of them in the Mekong delta. This study pays
more attention to the factors related to social entrepreneurship to enhance them
because the author believes that this group of factors has a greater impact on the
agribusiness sustainability via the development and improvement of the local
circular economy here.
Enhance social entrepreneurship related factors affecting agribusiness
sustainability: Social entrepreneurship has been a tradition and strength of
agribusinesses in the Mekong delta, where micro and small businesses, family
businesses and households are there concentrated and main driven part of the local
economy. Authorities and businesses themselves need to honour, capitalise on, and
promote these advantages to enhance the sustainability of the entire agricultural
system and the local economy. Firstly, it is necessary to promote the spirit of
solidarity and mutual assistance, regardless of difficulties or advantages, towards the
common community interests. Secondly, it is necessary to significantly raise the
entrepreneurial spirit of individuals and communities, continuously innovate, seek to
discover new business ideas and exploit new business opportunities, especially in the
context of the circular agricultural economy. Its perfection seems to be the main and
only trend towards the sustainability of the business system, communities and the
society as a whole.
4.3 Limitations and further research
4.3.1 Limitations
Despite the obtained research results, this study experiences several limitations. First of
them is the sole focus on the Mekong delta region in Vietnam without referring to other
similar parts of the country that has a long standing agrarian and cultivation traditions.
The next flaw of this study is that it provides no detailed about previous related studies.
Due to the page limitation of a typical research paper, author is determined to focus on
practical issues and empirical studies as a top research priority. The last limitation that
seems to be obvious is that there is no specified research methodology regarding how
data were collected, analysed and transferred into research results. However, in the
abstract the author has already stated that he has gathered secondary information from
trustworthy sources of data base, both traditional and websites of government and public
institutions.
4.3.2 Further research
To complete and perfect this study or carry out similar related research in the future,
author advise potential contributor to expanded the scope of analysis that must covers all
parts and corners of Vietnam. Furthermore, the next study should continue the topic with
the partition of research objects scope into households, micro enterprises, family
enterprises, small enterprises, medium enterprises to seek more precise research results
regarding each of these groups. Finally, future contributors should extend and enlarge
their research with comparative analysis with neighbouring agriculture-based economies
in the ASEAN, such as Thailand, Malaysia, Philippines, Indonesia to draw research
results-based conclusions that are more generalised to the level of the region.
10
Acknowledgements
This article is funded by WSB Merito University in Gdansk (Poland), Thu Dau Mot
University (Vietnam) and Ho Chi Minh City University of Industry and Trade (Vietnam).
References
AGDARD (2018, 2019, 2020) Report on Activities in 2018, 2019, 2020, Department of Agriculture
and Rural Development, An Giang Province, Vietnam.
Ahmad, Y., Abdi, D.A.B. and Yehualashet, D.L. (2019) ‘Natural resource endowment and
firm-level innovation in Africa: evidence from crosscountry analysis’, African Journal of
Science, Technology, Innovation and Development, Vol. 11, No. 1, pp.61–75.
Al-Marhubi, D. (2021) ‘Do natural resource rents reduce labour shares? Evidence from panel data’,
Apple. Econ. Lett., Vol. 28, No. 20, pp.1754–1757.
Artiach, A. (2020) On the Circular Economy, The Environment & The People, Medium, 20 January
[online] https://sustainabilityx.co/on-circular-economy-the-environment-and-the-people-
5459d724ab36 (accessed 21 August 2021).
Atienza, M. (2019) ‘The rent curse: natural resources, policy choice, and economic development’,
Eco. George., Vol. 95, No. 5, pp.519–520.
Bayale, N., Ali, E., Tchagnao, A-F. and Nakumuryango, A. (2021) ‘Determinants of renewable
energy production in WAEMU countries: new empirical insights and policy implications’,
Int. J. Green Energy, Vol. 18, No. 6, pp.602–614.
Bilan, Y., Mishchuk, H. and Pylypchuk, R. (2017) ‘Towards sustainable economic development via
social entrepreneurship’, Journal of Security and Sustainability Issues, Vol. 6, No. 4,
pp.691–702.
Castellano, S., Khelladi, I. and Menvielle, L. (2017) ‘Unveiling the sustainable facet of the
conventional entrepreneur – a cognitive approach’, International Journal of Entrepreneurship
and Small Business, Vol. 31, No. 3, pp.434–450.
Chekouri, S.M.A. and Chibi, M.B. (2017) Algeria and the natural resource curse: oil abundance
and economic growth’, Middle East Development Journal, Vol. 9, No. 2, pp.233–255.
Crespi, G., Katz, J. and Olivari, J. (2018) ‘Innovation, natural resource-based activities and growth
in emerging economies: the formation and role of knowledge-intensive service firms’,
Innovation and Development, Vol. 8, No. 1, pp.79–101.
Dana, L.P. (1994a) ‘A Marxist mini-dragon? Entrepreneurship in today’s Vietnam’, Journal of
Small Business and Management, Vol. 33, No. 2, p.95.
Dana, L.P. (1994b) ‘The Doi-Moi model: an ethnographic account of entrepreneurship, innovation,
and change in former French Indo-China’, Entrepreneurship, Innovation, and Change, Vol. 3,
No. 1, pp.61–84.
FAO (2022) Circular Economy: Waste-to-Resource & COVID-19, Food and Agriculture
Organisation of the United Nations.
Ferris, J.S. and Voia, M.C. (2012) ‘What are the significant determinants of entrepreneurship?’,
International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Small Business, Vol. 17, No. 4, pp.415–454.
Frederick, H.H. (2018) ‘The emergence of biosphere entrepreneurship: are social and business
entrepreneurship obsolete?’, International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Small Business,
Vol. 34, No. 3, pp.381–419.
Goyal, S. and Sergi, B.S. (2015) ‘Social entrepreneurship and sustainability understanding the
context and key characteristics’, Journal of Security and Sustainability Issues, Vol. 4, No. 3,
pp.269–278.
Güney, T. (2021) ‘Renewable energy consumption and sustainable development in high income
countries’, Int. J. Sustain. Dev. World Ecol., Vol. 28, No. 4, pp.376–385.
Agribusiness sustainability due to social entrepreneurship in Vietnam
11
Ha, T.H. (2021) Develop a Circular Economy for Efficient Management and Use of Resources,
People’s Electronic Newspaper [online] https://nhandan.vn/dang-va-cuoc-song/phat-trien-
king-te-tuan-hoan-de-quan-ly-va-su-dung-hieu-qua-nguyen-tainguyen-641799/ (accessed
22 January 2023).
Khan, M., Khan, A., Ali, K., Popp, J. and Oláh, J. (2020) ‘Natural resource rent and finance: the
moderation role of institutions’, Sustainability, Vol. 12, No. 9, pp.1–23.
Kuratko, D.F. (2011) ‘Entrepreneurship theory, process, and practice in the 21st century’,
International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Small Business, Vol. 13, No. 1, pp.8–17.
Mien, N.T. (2021) ‘Developing circular economy in agriculture in Vietnam: some issues and
recommendations’, Journal of Political Theory, No. 3-2021, Institute of Economics, National
Academy of Politics Ho Chi Minh City.
Muscio, A. and Sisto, R. (2020) ‘Are agri-food systems really switching to a circular economy
model? Implications for European research and innovation policy’, Sustainability, Vol. 12,
p.5554, DOI: 10.3390/su12145554.
Nam, N.H. and Hanh, N.T. (2019) Implementing Circular Economy: International Experience and
Policy Implications for Vietnam, Science Journal of Vietnam National University, Hanoi,
No. 10/2019.
Nhan, T.T.M. (2019) ‘Experience in building a circular economy and conditions for transformation
in Vietnam’, Finance Magazine, 1 December.
Okada, K. and Samreth, S. (2017) ‘Corruption and natural resource rents: evidence from quantile
regression’, Apple. Econ. Lett., Vol. 24, No. 20, pp.1490–1493.
Orhei, L.E., Nandram, S.S. and Vinke, J. (2015) ‘Social entrepreneurship competence: evidence
from founders of social enterprises in Romania’, International Journal of Entrepreneurship
and Small Business, Vol. 25, No. 1, pp.80–105.
Pearce, D.W. and Turner, R.K. (1990) Environmental and Resource Economics, JHU Press,
Baltimore, USA.
Peredo, A.M., Anderson, R.B., Galbraith, C.S., Honig, B. and Dana, L.P. (2004) ‘Towards theory
of indigenous entrepreneurship’, International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Small
Business, Vol. 1, Nos. 1/2, pp.1–20.
PM (2022) Decision No. 687/QD-TTg Dated June 7, 2022, On the Approval of the Circular
Economy Project in Vietnam.
Qi, S. and Li, Y. (2017) ‘Threshold effects of renewable energy consumption on economic growth
under energy transformation’, Chinese Journal of Population Resources and Environment,
Vol. 15, No. 4, pp.312–321.
Raudeliūnienė, J., Tvaronavičienė, M. and Dzemyda, I. (2014) ‘Towards economic security and
sustainability: key success factors of sustainable entrepreneurship in conditions of global
economy’, Journal of Security and Sustainability Issues, Vol. 3, No. 4, pp.71–79.
Saadaoui, F. and Jbir, R. (2021) ‘Petroleum endowment and economic growth: examination of the
resource curse phenomenon’, Energy Sources B Energy Econ. Plann., Vol. 16, No. 7,
pp.603–616.
Sasaki, H. (2021) ‘Non-renewable resources and the possibility of sustainable economic
development in an economy with positive or negative population growth’, Bull. Econ. Res.,
Vol. 73, No. 4, pp.704–720.
Von Friedrichs, Y. and Wahlberg, O. (2016) ‘Social entrepreneurship in the rural areas – a sports
club’s mobilization of people, money and social capital’, International Journal of
Entrepreneurship and Small Business, Vol. 29, No. 2, pp.199–216.
Article
This study investigates the dynamics of Circular Economy (CE) practices in Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs), emphasizing their critical role in promoting sustainability. As we investigate the many implications on SMEs' adoption of CE, we pay special attention to the diverse consequences of internal and external stakeholder pressure. Furthermore, we underline the importance of positive managerial perceptions and offer a new perspective by viewing CE orientation as a mediating force. Our data collection was conducted in three phases using a survey methodology, yielding 196 responses from Estonian SMEs. The findings call into question the notion that stakeholder pressures are consistent, revealing varied influences on CE procedures. Significantly, increased CE orientation emerges as a driving element in improving organisational response to external stakeholder pressure. This study advances our understanding of the intricate relationships between stakeholder dynamics, managerial perceptions, and CE practices, providing valuable insights essential for SMEs to navigate the path towards sustainable practices. This study presents both theoretical and practical contributions and suggests avenues for future research to further explore the multifaceted nature of the relationships uncovered in this study.
Article
Full-text available
Brand is an important part of an enterprise's business activities. In the modern age, a brand is not simply a product or service but also a concept of value, vision and emotions it brings to consumers. It helps shape and develop a company's reputation, attract customers and create trust in customers' hearts. Starbuck is one of the most famous brands worldwide in the coffee sector and Macdonalds is known for its convenient fast food system with excellent product quality and classy customer experience. However, to achieve that, Macdonalds and Starbucks had to comply with a number of brand identity system design requirements to match their views on the brand. "Requirements in designing a brand identity system" to highlight the perspectives on the brand approach of Starbucks and Macdonalds and the basic requirements in designing the identity system of these brands. From the above perspectives, it is possible to draw comments on the successes, limitations and solutions in the brand identity systems of these two businesses.
Article
Full-text available
In the business system, customers play a particularly important role in determining the success or failure of the business. When competition in the market becomes increasingly fierce, attracting and retaining customers is very difficult, customer relationship management is a very important thing that businesses need to do to have loyal customers. Today, many business owners are using CRM (customer relationship management) solutions. with the purpose of analyzing customer habits and needs on the basis of available data, managing campaigns and improving business efficiency. Although the economic situation continues to face many difficulties, Vietnam's retail market has been gradually expanding, with great potential in the future, especially the modern retail market. Attracts a lot of domestic and foreign investment capital and has a certain appeal to the people. In recent years, domestic and foreign retailers have developed rapidly, creating fierce competition in the market. In that context of fierce competition, Coop Mart supermarket will need to answer the question: "How to keep customers and let them use our products or services for a long time?"
Article
Full-text available
Shopping applications have a tremendous influence on client purchasing behavior in the e-commerce era. This research focuses on finding out what elements influence customers' online buying behavior, and there are six of them: Perceptions of utility, perceived ease of use, app design, payment system, epistemic and external influence were discovered. Using Lazada as a case study, the results reveal that the payment system and external impact were removed before reaching the SEM model. Meanwhile, App design and Epistemic are the two technology-oriented characteristics with the greatest influence on online purchasing behavior via the intermediate variable of Purchasing intention. Many other elements can be included in future research or applied in another e-commerce enterprise in Vietnam.
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of this article is to determine the factors affecting the education quality of lecturers at the Faculty of Business Administration at the University of Economics, Ho Chi Minh City. This study is based on the theoretical basis and research method to provide research results from which to conclude the factors affecting lecturers' education quality. Research methods include: Qualitative research methods find the basic content of documents, find issues related to the research topic and identify problems that need to be solved; Quantitative research methods used cognitive factors that affect education quality and considered the level of influence of each influencing factor related; In addition, the method of in-depth interviews with a team of education experts is applied to develop proposals to improve quality of teaching for teachers.
Article
Artificial intelligence (AI) has emerged as a transformative technology, revolutionizing various aspects of business operations, including human resources (HR) management. This study aims to analyze the impact of AI on the HR recruitment process in businesses located in Hanoi, Vietnam. Through a mixed-methods approach, involving surveys and in-depth interviews with HR professionals from 20 companies, the research examines the current level of AI adoption, its effects on recruitment efficiency and effectiveness, and the challenges encountered during implementation. The findings reveal that while AI adoption in HR recruitment is still in its early stages, businesses that have embraced AI-powered tools have experienced improved efficiency in candidate screening, enhanced job-candidate matching, and reduced time-to-hire. However, the study also uncovers significant challenges, including the need for specialized AI skills, concerns about job displacement, and the importance of striking a balance between automation and human touch in the recruitment process. The research offers valuable insights and recommendations for businesses in Hanoi aiming to harness the potential of AI in HR recruitment, emphasizing the need for strategic planning, workforce upskilling, and the development of ethical guidelines. The study contributes to the growing body of knowledge on AI applications in HR and provides a context-specific understanding of AI's impact on recruitment practices in Hanoi's business landscape. Artificial intelligence (AI) has become an indispensable tool in the human resources recruitment process sector, playing a decisive role in creating innovative and advanced learning opportunities for students in Vietnam. Under the influence of AI, the human resources recruitment process sector is undergoing a potential digital transformation, bringing great benefits to both students and teachers. The article uses quantitative research, surveyed by 150 experts and managers in the field of human resources recruitment process sector. Research results on the impact factors of AI in digital transformation of Vietnam's education sector show: Machine learning and data analysis system (β'1 = 0.246) and Smart Evaluation System (β'5 = 0.223) is the most influential, followed by Virtual Learning Experience (β'2 = 0.124), Online Learning Platform (β'4 = 0.205), Smart Tutoring System (β'3 = 0.204) all have influence affects the operation of artificial intelligence in digital transformation of Vietnam's education sector. Based on practical research, the influencing factors of artificial intelligence in digital transformation of Vietnam's human resources recruitment process sector. The article has proposed 05 implications for improving the operation of artificial intelligence in digital transformation of Vietnam's human resources recruitment process sector.
Article
Full-text available
Artificial intelligence (AI) has become an indispensable tool in the education industry, playing a decisive role in creating innovative and advanced learning opportunities for students in Vietnam. Under the influence of AI, the education industry is undergoing a potential digital transformation, bringing great benefits to both students and teachers. The article uses quantitative research, surveyed by 150 experts and managers in the field of education. Research results on the impact factors of AI in digital transformation of Vietnam's education sector show: Machine learning and data analysis system (β'1 = 0.246) and Smart Evaluation System (β'5 = 0.223) is the most influential, followed by Virtual Learning Experience (β'2 = 0.124), Online Learning Platform (β'4 = 0.205), Smart Tutoring System (β'3 = 0.204) all have influence affects the operation of artificial intelligence in digital transformation of Vietnam's education sector. Based on practical research, the influencing factors of artificial intelligence in digital transformation of Vietnam's education sector. The article has proposed 05 implications for improving the operation of artificial intelligence in digital transformation of Vietnam's education sector.
Article
Full-text available
The author builds a research model and measures elements impacting student satisfaction by using the research model of earlier relevant studies to ascertain the factors influencing student satisfaction with the quality of training services at Foreign Trade University. Using SPSS 20.0 statistical software and a research sample size of 320, the findings of the study have determined six criteria that influence students' satisfaction with the caliber of the training services provided by the university. Foreign Trade University (
Article
Artificial intelligence (AI) has become an indispensable tool in the education industry, playing a decisive role in creating innovative and advanced learning opportunities for students in Vietnam. Under the influence of AI, the education industry is undergoing a potential digital transformation, bringing great benefits to both students and teachers. The article uses quantitative research, surveyed by 150 experts and managers in the field of education. Research results on the impact factors of AI in digital transformation of Vietnam's education sector show: Machine learning and data analysis system (β'1 = 0.246) and Smart Evaluation System (β'5 = 0.223) is the most influential, followed by Virtual Learning Experience (β'2 = 0.124), Online Learning Platform (β'4 = 0.205), Smart Tutoring System (β'3 = 0.204) all have influence affects the operation of artificial intelligence in digital transformation of Vietnam's education sector. Based on practical research, the influencing factors of artificial intelligence in digital transformation of Vietnam's education sector. The article has proposed 05 implications for improving the operation of artificial intelligence in digital transformation of Vietnam's education sector.
Article
The purpose of this article is to determine the factors affecting the startup intention of lecturers at the Faculty of Business Administration at the Foreign Trade University, Ho Chi Minh City. This study is based on the theoretical basis and research method to provide research results from which to conclude the factors affecting lecturers' intention to start a business. Research methods include: Qualitative research methods find the basic content of documents, find issues related to the research topic and identify problems that need to be solved; Quantitative research methods used cognitive factors that affect entrepreneurial intention and considered the level of influence of each influencing factor related to entrepreneurial intention; In addition, the method of in-depth interviews with a team of experts on creative entrepreneurship intentions for teachers is applied to develop proposals to improve entrepreneurship intentions for teachers.
Article
Full-text available
This paper introduces model uncertainty into the empirical study of the determinants of renewable energy generation at the regional level. The Bayesian Model Averaging (BMA) approach applied to the panel data of West African Economic and Monetary Union (WAEMU) countries, spanning the period of 1990-2017. The results suggest that, among the considered regressors, those reflecting countries' socioeconomic and financial conditions as well as internal environmental prospects tend to receive high posterior inclusion probabilities. Then, the study explores the relationship between these regressors and renewable energy production by employing the Fully Modified Ordinary Least Squares (FMOLS) and Dynamic Ordinary Least Squares (DOLS) long-run estimators. The findings reveal that renewable energy consumption, real GDP per capita, investment in energy, urbanization, and unemployment spur renewable energy production, whereas CO 2 emissions and energy imports inhibit renewable energy production. Findings from this study have important policy implications for WAEMU countries with regard to achieving the 7th objective of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), which advocates the access to affordable, reliable, sustainable, and modern energy for all.
Article
Full-text available
This study aims to analyse the relationship between renewable energy, non-renewable energy, economic growth and sustainable development in high-income countries. This analysis uses data from 20 high-income countries covering the 1990-2015 period and finds that there is a cointegration relationship among the considered variables. According to the estimation of long-term coefficients for the cointegrated variables, renewable energy consumption has a statistically significant positive effect on sustainable development in the long run. In high-income countries, a 1% increase in renewable energy consumption increases sustainable development by 0.326%. In contrast, non-renewable energy consumption has a statistically significant negative effect on sustainable development in the long run. In high-income countries , a 1% increase in non-renewable energy consumption reduces sustainable development by 1.004%. According to the Granger causality estimates obtained in this study, renewable energy is the cause of sustainable development in both the short and long term. These findings demonstrate the importance of renewable energy consumption to sustainable development in high-income countries. Therefore, while high-income countries increase renewable energy consumption, they should decrease non-renewable energy consumption as much as possible. ARTICLE HISTORY
Article
Full-text available
The shift from a linear model to a circular model can significantly reduce the negative pressures on the environment and contribute to restoring biodiversity and natural capital in Europe. In this view, research and innovation (R&I) play a relevant role in setting the modalities of this transition. Therefore, the European Commission (EC) recently promoted dedicated research activity instruments in this vital area of the economy and in society as a whole. This paper aims to shed light on current public efforts on R&I supporting the transition to the CE (circular economy) model, opening a critical debate on the actual relevance of the CE in current R&I policy with its major research policy schemes in the recent programming periods of 2007–2013 and 2014–2020. Looking at the most significant EC programs sponsoring R&I, it seems that the will to increase the sustainability of the agri-food system and to foster the socio-technical transition towards circularity is evident but not very relevant. The data presented leaves some open questions concerning the effective commitment of European countries to promoting resource efficiency via R&I.
Article
Full-text available
This study empirically examines the nexuses between the natural resource rent and financial development in the context of the emerging economy of Pakistan, between 1984 and 2018, by subsuming the important role of institutional quality in this context under symmetric, asymmetric, and threshold settings. The literature to date provides no evidence on the asymmetric relationship between natural resource rent and financial development, and the moderation role of institutional quality in this connection. We show that natural resource rent negatively influences financial development, whereas institutional quality boosts financial development and positively moderates the relationship in the context of Pakistan. Also, we find a single significant threshold value of 3.097 above which the relationship of resource rent-finance turns nonlinear—as up to this threshold the coefficient is 3.228, which declines slightly to 2.804 above the threshold level. This implies that regulators should maintain at least an institutional quality level of up to 3.097 to experience the most desired financial benefits of the natural resource rent in Pakistan. Moreover, the results corroborate the existence of asymmetries in the relationship between the natural resource rent and financial development. This empirical evidence provides fresh insight for stakeholders regarding ambiguous natural resource rents and financial sector development nexuses and recommends that planning organs in Pakistan and other countries in a similar development cadre should use institutional quality as a tool to avoid the resource curse and view natural resources as a blessing rather than a curse.
Article
Full-text available
In this paper, we examine the interaction between oil exports’ revenues and long-run economic growth in Algeria over the period 1979–2013. Advanced econometric procedures including the cointegration VARX (VAR with exogenous variables) model, over-identifying restrictions, bootstrapping, persistent profiles and Generalized Impulse Response Function are utilized in the empirical analysis. The results show a strong and positive association between oil revenue and long-run economic growth, but negative linkages between the volatility of oil revenues and growth in Algeria. Our impulse response analysis also provides evidence that a positive shock in oil revenues increases the level of real output, and appreciates the real exchange rate.
Article
This paper examines the impact of oil resources endowment, measured by proven reserves and oil rents, on the economic growth in presence of quality of governance factors. To address this issue, we first summarize the previous research by reviewing, from the economic literature, the main explanations of what many regard as 'curse' of petroleum resource and, in a larger context, evoke the different relationships between natural resources and economic growth. Then, a panel data econometric model is fitted to a dataset consisting of 40 countries and sampled over a period of 17 years. The empirical results confirm, on one hand, the main hypothesis that proven oil resources negatively explain the economic growth. On the other hand, it is shown that oils rents are slightly positively correlated to the economic growth. The manipulation of the set of explanatory variables in the model does not change this overall negative correlation between growth and petroleum endowment, thus proving the counter-intuitive assumption that oil wealth limits the opportunities for economic growth. The results also confirm the old hypothesis that natural resources are negatively correlated to the countries' GDP through the quality of their economic and financial institutions.
Article
The purpose of this study is to investigate how the long‐run growth rate of per capita output is determined when an economy is subject to non‐renewable resource constraints and the population growth is negative by using a theoretical model. From this, we can examine the effect of population decline and the effect of depletion of natural resources on economic growth. Our results show that irrespective of whether the population growth rate is positive or negative, the long‐run growth rate of per capita output can be positive depending on conditions. This result suggests that even an economy with non‐renewable resources and declining population can obtain sustainable economic growth.
Article
Using a panel dataset of 95 countries from 1980 to 2014, we find that natural resource rents have a causal negative effect on labour shares. This effect is robust to estimation methods and control variables.
Article
This paper investigates the impact of a country’s natural resource endowment on the innovation propensity of firms in Africa. It was expected that firms in resource-rich countries have less incentive to innovate than firms in resource-poor countries due to the destructive effects of large resource rents on supportive institutions and political order. The data used for the empirical analysis were obtained from the World Bank’s enterprise surveys global development indicators and the African Economic Outlook reports. The hierarchical nature of the analysis called for a multilevel mixed effect modelling strategy. Results suggest that firms in resource-rich countries are not necessarily less innovative than firms in resource-poor countries. High natural resource endowment appeared to reduce firm-level innovation only if associated with poor institutional and technological capabilities. The innovativeness of firms in resource-rich sub-Saharan Africa countries was found to be lower than that of firms in North African countries. The negative effect of poor institutional quality appeared to be dampened among firms with better innovation capabilities. The findings imply that building effective institutional environments and enhancing firm-level innovative efforts would help mitigate the ‘resource curse’ which, in turn, is dictated by the resulting types of political settlements in resource-rich African countries.