Content uploaded by A. Shaji George
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by A. Shaji George on Sep 22, 2023
Content may be subject to copyright.
Partners Universal International Research Journal (PUIRJ)
Volume: 02 Issue: 03 | July – September 2023 | ISSN: 2583-5602 | www.puirj.com
© 2023, PUIRJ | PU Publications | DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8370878 Page | 171
Addressing India's Healthcare Worker Shortage: Evaluating Strategies to
Improve Medical Education and Retention
Dr.A.Shaji George
Independent Researcher, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract - India faces a severe shortage of healthcare workers, especially doctors, despite having the
largest number of medical colleges globally. This shortage is driven by issues in medical education and
doctor retention. This research evaluates India's medical education system and retention challenges to
propose evidence-based strategies to strengthen the medical workforce. Analysis shows India's 595 medical
colleges have adequate capacity, but the quality of education remains concerning. Over 20% of students fail
initial exams due to dated curricula, lack of practical training, and poor instruction. Additionally, overworked
students at public colleges get insufficient hands-on experience. Private colleges are better funded but lack
accountability. The resulting poor skills and disillusionment make many consider alternate careers or
emigrate. Estimates suggest over 5,000 doctors emigrated from 2015-2017. Job dissatisfaction from limited
career growth, low pay and excessive workloads also drive doctors abroad or into India's urban private
hospitals. This exacerbates shortages in rural areas with just one doctor per 10,000 people. Various
government strategies to improve retention like compulsory rural service have failed. A multipronged
approach is required focused on reforming medical education and improving doctor employment
conditions. Recommendations include modernizing curricula, integrating technology, facilitating practical
learning via rural postings, strengthening faculty, and accreditation processes. A national medical licensing
exam could also standardize competencies. To improve retention, policy changes to increase rural public
health spending, provide better pay, infrastructure and career growth opportunities are proposed.
Compulsory rural bonds may also help but require reforms for effectiveness. India must take concerted
steps to reform medical education and retention policies to nurture the qualified, motivated doctors needed
to transform healthcare access and quality. This comprehensive analysis provides an evidence base for
policymakers to strengthen the medical workforce and achieve universal healthcare.
Keywords: Medical education, Healthcare workforce, Doctor shortage, Rural retention, Curriculum reform,
Faculty development, medical infrastructure, Working conditions, Emigration, Public health.
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Provide Background on India's Healthcare System, the High Disease Burden, and the Shortage
of Doctors and Healthcare Workers
India’s healthcare system is grappling with the challenge of addressing the medical needs of over 1.3 billion
people, spread across diverse geographies and socioeconomic groups. The country’s high disease burden is
characterized by rising non-communicable and lifestyle diseases, persistence of infectious diseases like
tuberculosis and vector-borne illnesses, and high maternal and child mortality rates. This is compounded by
inadequate access to quality and affordable healthcare for the majority, especially in rural areas. A key
constraint is the severe shortage of doctors and healthcare workers in the system.
Partners Universal International Research Journal (PUIRJ)
Volume: 02 Issue: 03 | July – September 2023 | ISSN: 2583-5602 | www.puirj.com
© 2023, PUIRJ | PU Publications | DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8370878 Page | 172
As per WHO norms, the doctor to population ratio should be 1:1000. However, India has only around 1 doctor
per 10,000 population, highlighting the yawning gap. The National Health Profile 2019 data indicates there are
only 1,201,005 allopathic doctors registered with state medical councils and the National Medical Commission
(NMC) as of March 2019. This translates to a doctor-population ratio of 1:1156 as compared to the WHO
standard. There are similar shortfalls amongst nursing staff and allied health professionals. Rural and lower
income states suffer even more acute shortages. For instance, Bihar has just 1 doctor per 28,391 people. The
scarcity of healthcare resources is proving a key impediment in India’s path to universal health coverage.
The seeds of the crisis were sown during the British colonial era when western medicine was prioritized over
indigenous systems. Post-independence, India embarked on an ambitious healthcare infrastructure building
program by establishing primary health centers (PHCs) and community health centers (CHCs) to take
medical services to rural areas. Medical education was also expanded significantly through the
establishment of government colleges and allowing private sector participation. Today, India has the largest
number of medical colleges globally, with over 600 institutions producing around 90,000 graduates annually.
However, the focus has been on quantitative rather than qualitative growth. Issues of low-quality education,
dated curricula not aligned to population needs, lack of practical training and faculty shortages have
emerged.
Alongside this, poor public healthcare infrastructure and human resource management have led to
dissatisfaction and demotivation amongst doctors. Cramped working conditions, excessive workloads of over
100 patients per day, limited career progression, low salaries, lack of safety and vulnerability to violence were
cited as factors causing low morale. This has resulted in the phenomena of ‘internal brain drain’ with qualified
doctors unwilling to serve in rural postings. Many prefer to emigrate to countries offering better salaries, work-
life balance and advanced facilities. By some estimates, over 60,000 Indian doctors are working in the US, UK,
Canada and Australia. India is thus losing investments made in subsidized medical education, even as its
own healthcare system faces dire shortages.
Tackling these dual challenges of medical education reform and human resource retention are vital for
creating a robust, patient-centric healthcare system in India. The COVID-19 pandemic has underlined the
costs of underinvestment and systemic gaps. It is imperative that evidence-based, context-specific
strategies are formulated to nurture a skilled, motivated pool of healthcare workers dedicated to serving
fellow citizens and bridging health access divides. India has achieved success in medical tourism; however
the need of the hour is to focus similar efforts on achieving health for all at home. Building competency-
based medical education institutionalized through entrance exams, licensing tests, improved curricula and
faculty development is crucial. Coupled with public health reforms to improve doctor employment terms,
provide adequate facilities and social security, and promote rural service through targeted incentives, India
can transform its healthcare landscape.
1.2 Note India's Large Number of Medical Colleges but Still Unmet Need for Doctors, Especially in
Rural Areas
India has the largest number of medical colleges in the world, reflecting the country's focus on rapidly
expanding medical education opportunities since independence in 1947. As per the National Medical
Commission (NMC), there are over 600 recognized allopathic government and private medical colleges in
India as of 2022. Together they have around 95,000 seats, including both undergraduate and postgraduate.
Annual intake at the undergraduate level is around 89,000 students. In addition, India has over 700 colleges
Partners Universal International Research Journal (PUIRJ)
Volume: 02 Issue: 03 | July – September 2023 | ISSN: 2583-5602 | www.puirj.com
© 2023, PUIRJ | PU Publications | DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8370878 Page | 173
teaching Ayurveda, homoeopathy, unani, etc. This phenomenal growth in medical education was aimed at
addressing the country's healthcare challenges.
However, mere proliferation of medical colleges has not translated into sufficient availability of doctors where
they are needed most. Stark imbalances remain in access to healthcare across urban and rural areas.
According to NITI Aayog’s 2019 Health Index report, around 70% of health infrastructure including hospitals,
doctors and nurses is concentrated in urban areas. Yet over 65% of India’s population resides in rural areas.
The rural healthcare system is marked by an acute shortage of doctors.
According to Health Ministry data, India had only around 1.34 million allopathic doctors as of 2021. For a
population of 1.3 billion, this implies a doctor-patient ratio of 1:1000 compared to the WHO norm of 1:600. The
distribution of this limited pool of doctors is highly skewed. Urban zones have 4 times the number of doctors
compared to rural areas. Only 31% of doctors serve in rural areas where disease burdens are higher. Some
states like Uttar Pradesh and Bihar have only 0.2 doctors per 1000 population in rural zones. The
recommended ratio by WHO is 1 doctor per 1000 population.
The shortfall has persisted despite rapid expansion in medical seats. This indicates deeper systemic issues
impacting delivery of healthcare. Unplanned proliferation of medical colleges driven by political motivations
rather than actual need has resulted in sub-standard education quality. There is an oversupply of doctors in
metro cities while rural and semi-urban areas remain underserved. Graduates are often not motivated to
serve in remote areas which lack facilities and career growth prospects. Attempts to mandate rural service
have failed as monitoring is challenging. Thus, the focus on merely increasing the number of medical colleges
without addressing systemic issues has not resolved rural healthcare shortages.
There is an urgent need to reform medical education and device innovative strategies to improve doctor
availability in rural India. More medical colleges have to be established in underserved areas based on gap
analysis. Selection of students from such regions for these colleges can improve retention. The curriculum
must integrate more rural health topics and training placements should provide village exposure. Use of
technology for remote skills transfer and diagnostics can aid rural doctors. Better pay, 24/7 security, housing,
recognition and upskilling opportunities can improve rural postings' appeal. India must optimize its medical
education ecosystem and harness its vast network of medical colleges to transform accessibility of quality
healthcare across urban-rural divides. The success of Ayushman Bharat and universal health coverage
hinges on producing not just more doctors but doctors willing to serve where needs are greatest.
1.3 State Research Objectives to Evaluate India's Medical Education System and Retention Issues
to Propose Strategies to Strengthen the Medical Workforce
India's healthcare system is at a critical juncture. On one hand, the disease burden is increasing with rising
non-communicable and lifestyle diseases. The population is also aging and with it the prevalence of chronic
illnesses has gone up. On the other hand, the country faces a crippling shortage of doctors and healthcare
workers to cater to the growing needs. The doctor-patient ratio of 1:1456 is far below the WHO recommended
1:1000. Shortages are even more pronounced in rural areas with only 1 doctor per 10,000 people in some states.
Merely setting up more medical colleges has failed to resolve the crisis. Deeper reforms are needed in
medical education and human resource policies to build a robust, patient-centric healthcare system
accessible to all.
Partners Universal International Research Journal (PUIRJ)
Volume: 02 Issue: 03 | July – September 2023 | ISSN: 2583-5602 | www.puirj.com
© 2023, PUIRJ | PU Publications | DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8370878 Page | 174
This research aims to conduct a systematic evaluation of India's medical education framework and retention
challenges to formulate evidence-based strategies to strengthen the healthcare workforce. The objectives
are:
1.Analyze India's medical education infrastructure in terms of number of colleges, seats, affordability,
curriculum, faculty availability, practical training systems and use of technology for capacity building. This will
identify strengths and weaknesses in current medical training approaches.
2.Assess the quality and competencies of graduates by reviewing final exam pass percentages, results of
licensing examinations, skills assessments by employers etc. Gaps highlight scope for improvements.
3.Evaluate doctor retention issues by studying data on doctor emigration, rural-urban imbalances,
resignations and comparing with regional countries. Surveys and interviews will provide insights into factors
driving job dissatisfaction.
4.Critically examine existing policies by government, Medical Council of India and other stakeholders to
reform medical education and retention. Assess their impact and shortcomings.
5.Derive learning from global best practices on medical education and human resource management for
replication in the Indian context.
6.Synthesize findings to develop a set of recommendations to overhaul medical curriculum, faculty training,
licensing reforms, rural retention strategies, public health investment etc. to build a future-ready medical
workforce.
7.Disseminate the research through policy briefs, conferences and academic publications to influence
adoption by policymakers, administrators, academics and industry players.
By providing much needed evidence on how India can reform medical education and major retention, this
research aims to positively impact health policies and planning. It will help evolve a cadre of skilled medical
professionals who can transform healthcare access and quality for underserved communities. The research
output can sensitize stakeholders to the need for holistic human resource reforms to achieve universal health
coverage. It will spur innovation in medical education, motivate doctors to uplift rural communities and
improve health equity - ultimately laying the foundation for a Swasth Bharat.
2. A COMPREHENSIVE REVIEW OF THE MEDICAL COLLEGE SYSTEM
2.1 Analyze the Medical College System - Number and Capacity of Public and Private Colleges,
Curriculum, Skills Training Etc
India's medical education system has expanded massively since independence leading to the establishment
of over 600 medical colleges currently. Of these, around 385 are government institutions while the rest are
private colleges. Together they have a capacity of around 95,000 undergraduate and postgraduate seats,
making India the largest medical education system globally. However, the structure and quality of education
across this vast system varies significantly.
Analysis shows that government or public medical colleges are beset by deficiencies stemming from chronic
underfunding, lack of governance and infrastructural constraints. Most public colleges were set up several
decades ago and have not seen upgrades. There are shortfalls in labs, dissection halls, teaching hospital
beds and equipment. Faculty positions also remain vacant due to low pay scales and inadequate
recruitment. This hampers training and quality. The student-teacher ratio in government colleges is often 15:1
Partners Universal International Research Journal (PUIRJ)
Volume: 02 Issue: 03 | July – September 2023 | ISSN: 2583-5602 | www.puirj.com
© 2023, PUIRJ | PU Publications | DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8370878 Page | 175
compared to international norms of 6:1. Difficult working conditions lead to high stress and attrition among
students too. Over 20% fail their final year MBBS exams. The curricula followed are dated and not aligned with
contemporary health challenges. Skills training is minimal as students get overloaded with theory and limited
practical exposure.
Private medical colleges are relatively better off given their access to tuition fees. There are over 250 private
colleges with modern infrastructure, technology integration and global partnerships. However, education
quality remains a concern due to rapid unregulated expansion driven by commercial motives rather than
public health priorities. Faculty recruitment does not always adhere to merit, admission processes lack
transparency and skills training is inadequate. There are exceptions like institutes of national importance that
maintain rigorous standards. But profiteering in the private sector has necessitated strong regulatory
oversight, which remains a challenge.
Both public and private colleges face faculty shortages as teaching is not seen as an attractive career due to
low pay, lack of facilities and bureaucratic hurdles. This dependence on overburdened, often underqualified
faculty cascades down to students affecting outcomes. Attempts are being made to address gaps through
policies like the National Medical Commission Act. But reforms in governance, recruitment, career progression,
infrastructure and digital learning are vital across both sectors.
Medical curricula have seen piecemeal changes but remain skewed towards urban hospital care models
divorced from rural realities. Community medicine training is limited to 2 months as opposed to 12-24 months
mandated globally. Practical training also remains weak as students get minimal hands-on learning during
clinical rotations. Rural postings are seldom structured adequately to build skills managing local health
issues. An MBBS often produces bookishly trained graduates lacking perspective on social determinants of
health and preventive care. Revamping curricula to balance theory, practice across community and hospital
settings is essential.
In summary, quantitative expansion of medical seats has not translated to qualitatively rigorous medical
education with a public health focus. Strengthening governance, recruiting competent faculty, reforming
admission processes, updating curricula, integrating technology and optimizing practical training systems
are crucial to improve the competencies of India's medical graduates to serve local needs. As medical
colleges shape the nation's healthcare workforce, it is imperative that the system is brought in line with the
needs of 21st century healthcare delivery.
2.2 Discuss Issues Like Failing Exams, Quality of Education, Lack of Practical Training
Medical education in India is plagued by several issues that impact the competency of graduates and
thereby healthcare delivery. A major problem is the high failure rate in final year MBBS exams which can cross
20-30% in some colleges. This indicates poor learning outcomes despite 5.5 years of education.
Several factors contribute to the poor exam performance. Medical curricula followed are outdated with some
syllabi being over 50 years old. Subjects like pathology, pharmacology and community medicine do not
reflect the latest diagnostic and treatment guidelines. Teaching methods rely heavily on didactic lectures
rather than interactive, case-based learning. This results in rote learning without building analytical skills or
correlations between concepts. Most assessments test memory rather than higher-order cognitive abilities or
practical competence. Thus, students are not adequately prepared for rigorous final exams.
Partners Universal International Research Journal (PUIRJ)
Volume: 02 Issue: 03 | July – September 2023 | ISSN: 2583-5602 | www.puirj.com
© 2023, PUIRJ | PU Publications | DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8370878 Page | 176
The lack of practical training also hampers performance. Laboratory facilities, dissection halls and attached
hospitals in many colleges have inadequate infrastructure and patient volumes. Students get little hands-on
learning for clinical subjects with the minimum prescribed hours of training not being fulfilled. Where
practical’s happen, large batch sizes compromise quality. Poor faculty-student ratios of 20:1 further impede
mentoring and knowledge application.
These issues are more acute in government colleges which are understaffed and underfunded. But even
private colleges focus more on profits than real skills building. With the rapid expansion in seats, quality is
being compromised. The limited availability of quality training placements means fresh graduates are often
not work-ready.
The exam failure rates thus signify underlying problems in medical education quality. But there are wider
implications too. Failed students suffer humiliation which induces stress and depression. Many consider
alternate careers after years of study and youth spent. This contributes to the shortage of doctors alongside
emigration and rural-urban brain drain.
For healthcare reforms to succeed, medical education needs urgent fixing. Recommendations include:
1.Curricular reforms to incorporate advances, best practices, technology and public health perspectives
relevant to Indian settings.
2.Improved pedagogy focusing on case-based and experiential learning rather than didactic teaching.
3.Rigorous formative assessments and mentoring to identify and address knowledge gaps.
4.Expansion of skilled faculty, laboratories, simulated teaching aids and hospital partnerships for better
practical training quality and quantity.
5.Student counseling and support systems to alleviate stress.
6.Enhanced regulation, transparency and accountability to improve education standards in both private
and public colleges.
Building competent, empathetic doctors dedicated to serving India's healthcare challenges starts with
revamping how they are trained. Addressing the high failure rates through education reforms must become a
policy priority. This can help create a robust medical workforce to deliver both quality and access.
2.3 Evaluate Doctor Retention Issues - Emigration, Concentration in Urban Areas, Dissatisfaction
India’s healthcare system is plagued by poor doctor retention with qualified professionals unwilling to work in
public health services, particularly in rural areas. Key issues driving low retention include doctor emigration,
concentration in urban private hospitals, and job dissatisfaction due to unfavorable working conditions.
Emigration of medical graduates is a major concern. By some estimates, over 60,000 Indian-trained doctors
are working abroad, mainly in the US, UK, Australia and Canada. The allure of higher remuneration, advanced
facilities and better quality of life drives many to leave. India loses investments made in their education and
subsidized tuition. For every doctor who emigrates, the country loses around $48,000 spent on their education.
This causes shortages in an already resource-constrained system. Tighter immigration policies abroad are
now making permanent emigration tougher. But temporary overseas stints remain popular given the prestige
and exposure they offer. Measures are needed to retain talent within the country.
Partners Universal International Research Journal (PUIRJ)
Volume: 02 Issue: 03 | July – September 2023 | ISSN: 2583-5602 | www.puirj.com
© 2023, PUIRJ | PU Publications | DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8370878 Page | 177
Within India, there is concentration of doctors in urban areas catering to only 30% of the population. Rural
postings remain unpopular due to professional isolation, lack of amenities or career growth prospects. Most
doctors settle in cities, resulting in 4 times more doctors per person in urban versus rural zones. Metros like
Delhi and Mumbai have an oversupply while rural Bihar languishes at 0.2 doctors per 1000 population.
Attempts to mandate rural service have failed as young doctors find ways to avoid postings through political
connections. There is minimal incentive for experienced doctors to move out of cushy urban jobs either. This
urban skew will persist until improvements are made in rural healthcare infrastructure, living conditions and
professional terms of service.
Lastly, dissatisfaction amongst doctors is rising pertaining to remuneration, excessive workload and lack of
security. Most healthcare workers in the public system are overworked due to high patient loads and staff
shortages. Lack of facilities like diagnostic equipment, support staff and essential medicines frustrates
doctors' ability to treat patients effectively. Rural healthcare workers bear the maximum burden. Violence
against healthcare professionals is also rising. Low pay scales force doctors to practice privately after-hours,
leading to burnout. The lack of clear career progression, performance management and transparency in
postings contributes to demotivation. Poor governance and political interference in transfer postings also
abound. Addressing the professional needs of doctors and providing adequate security, shall improve
workplace morale and retention.
In summary, doctor retention in public services, especially rural healthcare, is threatened by avoidable
emigration, urban concentration and dissatisfaction. Implementing a comprehensive workforce strategy
focused on improving employment terms, transparent policies, rural infrastructure, living conditions and
career growth opportunities is vital to boost retention. Effective HR planning and governance reforms are
integral to optimize India's health workforce.
2.4 Assess Government Policies and Strategies to Improve Medical Education and Retention
The Indian government has recognized the need to reform medical education and retention to address the
country's healthcare challenges. Various policies and strategies have been initiated over the years with mixed
results.
For medical education, the government has focused largely on expansion by setting up new colleges in
underserved areas and increasing seats. This has more than doubled annual undergraduate intake from
about 42,000 in 2005 to over 89,000 seats currently. Regulations have also been strengthened by mandating
common entrance exams, minimum standards for infrastructure, faculty ratios etc. The National Medical
Commission Act of 2019 aims to improve oversight on curriculum, accreditation, and quality. Efforts are also
ongoing to update curricula, integrate technology into teaching and enhance faculty training. However,
monitoring of reforms remains weak across both private and public colleges. Resources have not matched
increasing seats, leaving many new colleges ill-equipped. The quality versus quantity tradeoff has diluted
education standards. Much more is needed to overhaul pedagogy, faculty skills and competency-building.
For retention, various incentives and coercive strategies have been attempted with suboptimal outcomes.
Monetary incentives for rural postings have had limited appeal given living condition challenges. Attempts to
mandate rural service for graduation, while well-intentioned, have been circumvented through political
connections and lack of enforcement. Bonded service programmes have failed as graduates default or pay
fines to exit obligations. Professional isolation and lack of facilities continue to discourage rural tenures. Efforts
to address safety like making hospital assault a non-bailable offence are commendable but much more
Partners Universal International Research Journal (PUIRJ)
Volume: 02 Issue: 03 | July – September 2023 | ISSN: 2583-5602 | www.puirj.com
© 2023, PUIRJ | PU Publications | DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8370878 Page | 178
needs to be done. Impact has also been limited by poor governance and human resource management.
Career and skills development, performance appraisal, transparent transfer policies and grievance redressal
are still evolving.
While the policy intent to strengthen medical education and retention is there, the implementation has been
suboptimal at best. Recommendations to boost effectiveness include - funding expansion with quality by
having adequate faculty and infrastructure before adding seats, revamping pedagogy, and faculty skills,
strengthening accreditation with surprise assessments, improving stay and learning outcomes of rural
postings through staff support, engaging doctors in policymaking to build cadre ownership and addressing
legitimate grievances of overwork and safety by improving work norms and doctor-patient relations.
The success of India’s healthcare reforms and schemes is contingent on building a robust medical workforce.
This requires moving beyond ad-hoc measures to comprehensive education and HR reforms with improved
resource allocation, governance mechanisms, stakeholder engagement and execution rigor. The blueprint
needs dynamism to keep pace with evolving needs. By learning from other countries as well as past gaps,
India can craft strategies that balance quality and access in medical education, rural service needs and
legitimate workforce aspirations; ultimately strengthening healthcare delivery.
2.5 Propose New Strategies Based on Analysis - Reforming Curriculum, Incentives for Rural
Service, Improving Working Conditions Etc
India needs a new roadmap to reform its medical education and retention policies based on learnings from
analysis of the current gaps. Some strategies that can be considered are:
Curricular Reform:
The MBBS curriculum taught across the majority of medical colleges is outdated and not aligned with
contemporary health system needs. A competency-based curriculum grounded in Indian healthcare
challenges must be instituted. Subjects like community medicine, public health, ethics and preventive care
need more focus in syllabi. The pattern of disease has changed substantially with non-communicable
illnesses becoming predominant. Doctors have to be trained to manage this epidemiological shift effectively
through a revised curriculum.
Pedagogy reforms are also vital with more case-based clinical learning, hands-on practical’s and technology
integration needed. Medical humanities and ethics should be introduced to shape values and empathy
alongside competencies. Training in health economics, administration and policy can build managerial skills
while exposing students to healthcare systems early on. More electives, especially in rural healthcare can
allow customization based on interests. Progressive medical schools globally have already realigned
curricula to 21st century needs which India must emulate.
Boosting Rural Retention:
A mix of incentives and conditions can improve doctor retention in rural postings. Higher monetary packages,
guaranteed school admission for children, additional professional development opportunities, priority in post-
graduation admissions and enhanced promotion channels for rural service are some options. Providing
superior facilities in terms of staff support, equipment and infrastructure can aid work. Encouraging doctors to
tour facilities in rural areas before selecting can boost satisfaction. Local recruitment and medical bonding
programmes also help. Mandatory rural postings should be made more structured and effective. Political and
bureaucratic interference in transfers-postings should be curtailed. Better living conditions, schooling options
and social integration of doctors' families are equally important.
Partners Universal International Research Journal (PUIRJ)
Volume: 02 Issue: 03 | July – September 2023 | ISSN: 2583-5602 | www.puirj.com
© 2023, PUIRJ | PU Publications | DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8370878 Page | 179
Improving Working Conditions:
A host of reforms are needed to improve doctor working conditions and morale. Investments to upgrade
infrastructure and lower patient loads are vital. Support staff and high-end diagnostic facilities will improve
productivity. Well-defined transfer policies, transparency in postings and grievance redressal will help. Fast-
track promotion channels for public health specialists are needed. Security measures should be strengthened
by having well-trained guards, CCTVs and easing laws to act against hospital violence. Counselling facilities
at workplace, crèches and safe transport would improve well-being. Accountability and meritocracy in
human resource management are crucial to retain talent.
Such interventions rooted in ground realities can create systemic reforms to boost both quality and access of
healthcare through well-trained, motivated doctors.
3. CONCLUSION
3.1 Summarize Key Challenges of Medical Education and Doctor Shortages in India
India’s healthcare sector is at a pivotal juncture. On one hand, the disease burden is growing with a triple
disease load - persistence of infectious diseases, rising non-communicable or lifestyle illnesses and high
rates of maternal and child mortality. The population is also rising and aging, further escalating healthcare
needs. On the other hand, there is a severe shortage of qualified doctors and healthcare workers to meet the
demand. Estimates indicate there are only around 1 million doctors for India’s 1.3 billion population as of 2021,
translating to a doctor-patient ratio of 1:1300 compared to the WHO norm of 1:1000. The shortage becomes a
crisis in rural areas where the ratio falls to a dismal 1:10,000 or lower in some states.
This imbalance between healthcare needs and availability of doctors has its roots in the poor state of
medical education. Though India has the highest number of medical colleges in the world, the system faces
acute challenges today relating to quality of training, competencies produced and retention of talent.
Medical curricula followed are outdated in most colleges and have not kept pace with epidemiological and
technological advances. Pedagogical focus remains on rote learning rather than building analytical
reasoning, hands-on skills or perspectives on social determinants of health. Practical and clinical training are
limited by infrastructure and faculty shortages. Regulatory oversight on quality is inconsistent amidst rapid
commercialization. The result is poorly prepared graduates lacking know-how who are unable to effectively
serve Indian healthcare needs, especially in rural settings.
Compounding this is the high rate of emigration of medical graduates. Attracted by superior salaries, work
conditions and opportunities abroad, over 60,000 doctors have migrated to the US, UK, Canada etc. India
loses its investments in subsidized medical education when this human capital loss happens. Within India too,
maldistribution of doctors remains with concentration in urban hospitals and private practice. Rural and
public sector healthcare endures acute shortfalls, driving poor health outcomes. Multiple factors from lack of
facilities to personal security concerns discourage doctors from rural postings. Neither monetary incentives
nor coercive policies have resolved the skew.
In essence, the scale, quality and direction of medical education in India need urgent fixing along with
concrete steps to improve working conditions and growth prospects for doctors. Wider reforms in healthcare
policy, governance, infrastructure and service conditions are vital to retain and motivate the medical
workforce. As India aims to achieve universal health coverage, producing competent, dedicated doctors who
can make quality healthcare accessible and affordable for the marginalized will be critical. For this, political
Partners Universal International Research Journal (PUIRJ)
Volume: 02 Issue: 03 | July – September 2023 | ISSN: 2583-5602 | www.puirj.com
© 2023, PUIRJ | PU Publications | DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8370878 Page | 180
commitment, policy innovations, public-private participation and community accountability will be vital to
transform medical education and retention.
3.2 Highlight Most Promising Strategies From Analysis to Strengthen the Medical Workforce
India is at the cusp of healthcare transformation. But realizing the vision of universal health coverage hinges
on building a skilled, motivated medical workforce dedicated to serving the nation’s healthcare needs. This
concluding section synthesizes the most promising strategies that emerged from the analyses to strengthen
medical education quality and optimize retention:
Curricular Reform – Updating medical curricula to keep pace with 21st century advancements is imperative.
Public health, ethics, technology, and social awareness must be integrated across subjects. Pedagogy needs
to shift from didactic lectures to interactive case-based learning focused on problem-solving skills.
Assessments should evaluate higher-order analytical abilities and core competencies required of Indian
doctors. Standardizing learning outcomes through a common exit exam system can improve quality.
Faculty Development – Expanding faculty through attractive pay and service conditions is crucial to enhance
training capacity. Existing faculty need support for skills development and research opportunities for
continual learning. Teacher training, better clinical exposures and global partnerships can aid this.
Infrastructure Upgrade – Expanding labs, libraries, IT-enabled learning, simulators and hospital attachments
is vital to augment practical learning in both public and private colleges. Optimal use of infrastructure
through better timetabling and access can also help meet training needs.
Accreditation Reforms – Rigorous accreditation mechanisms and transparent rating systems can enhance
accountability of medical colleges. Surprise assessments, student feedback, inspections of domains like
faculty strength, skills labs, research output and pass percentage are important. Enforcement actions against
repeat defaulters will boost compliance.
Rural Posting Redesign – Rural postings must provide structured hands-on training on managing local
health challenges through mentoring, case discussions and community engagement. Greater recognition of
rural service through professional credits, fast-track promotion and research options can motivate doctors.
Incentivizing Rural Tenure – Providing superior facilities, staff support, equipment and amenities can ease
the burden of rural postings. Allowing preferential post-graduate admission for serving in rural areas may
attract graduates. Family needs during rural tenures including housing, childcare and schooling require
attention.
Enhanced Safety and Well-being – Strengthening infrastructure and protocols for doctor safety in hospitals is
critical. Counselling, convenient accommodation, crèches and transport especially for women will enhance
well-being.
With concerted efforts on these strategies which address gaps across education, recruitment, deployment
and work conditions of doctors, India can create a healthcare workforce capable of transforming access to
and quality of healthcare across geographic and socio-economic boundaries.
3.3 Discuss Limitations and Future Research Needs
Partners Universal International Research Journal (PUIRJ)
Volume: 02 Issue: 03 | July – September 2023 | ISSN: 2583-5602 | www.puirj.com
© 2023, PUIRJ | PU Publications | DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8370878 Page | 181
This research aimed to provide vital insights into how India can reform policies on medical education and
doctor retention to address healthcare access challenges. However, there are certain limitations that present
avenues for future research.
Firstly, the study analyzed secondary data on medical colleges, doctor availability, rural postings etc. Primary
surveys of stakeholders could have provided richer perspectives on ground realities and policy impacts.
These include students, faculty, administrators, and doctors across public and private sectors in urban and
rural areas. Their inputs could bring out nuances missed in secondary findings. Surveying them must be a
focus area for further studies.
Secondly, state-specific differences could be examined in greater detail. Medical education and workforce
availability challenges manifest differently across India’s diverse states. Rural Uttar Pradesh’s needs may
differ from coastal Andhra’s for instance. Though this research looked at national patterns, state-wise
analyses could reveal more granular dynamics around medical training quality, rural retention issues and
localized solutions.
Thirdly, this study largely reviewed government policies on medical education and retention. Expanding the
lens to healthcare industry trends, innovations by private sector and NGO initiatives could have enriched
strategies. Their insights on enhancing skills training, rural service appeal and workforce performance are
important. Future work must cover these wider stakeholders in-depth.
Fourthly, comparisons with emerging economies facing similar public health challenges could be
illuminating. Nations like Thailand, South Africa and Bangladesh have implemented innovative medical
education and rural retention initiatives that India could learn from. Future studies should examine relevant
global models.
Fifthly, the fast-changing technology landscape with digitization, telemedicine, AI-enabled learning etc. could
have implications for medical training and workforce optimization that merit exploration. Dynamic
technological context must be continually studied.
Lastly, implementation of science perspectives could have suggested insights on pathways, coalitions and
resources needed to translate policy recommendations into ground action. Public administration lenses are
key and should be integrated going forward.
The limitations provide rich scope for extending this research. Medical education and human resources for
health are vital for India’s population wellbeing. Continuous enquiry to evolve evidence-based, context-
specific strategies through collaborative approaches remains essential. The quest to produce competent,
compassionate doctors committed to equitable healthcare access must persist.
REFERENCES
[1] Poor Health Care Infrastructure, Lack Of Doctors Has Made COVID-19 Pandemic So Worse In India -
Inventiva. (2020, June 10). Inventiva. https://www.inventiva.co.in/stories/poor-health-care-infrastructure-
lack-of-doctors-has-made-covid-19-pandemic-so-worse-in-india/
[2] Shortage of Specialists crippling India’s Healthcare — Healthcare Executive. (2019, July 22).
Healthcare Executive. https://www.healthcareexecutive.in/blog/shortage-of-specialists
[3] A. S.Hovan George, Aakifa Shahul, & A.Shaji George. (2023). A Decade of CRISPR: Advances and Outlook in
Genome Editing. Partners Universal International Research Journal, 2(2), 1–18.
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.8020006
Partners Universal International Research Journal (PUIRJ)
Volume: 02 Issue: 03 | July – September 2023 | ISSN: 2583-5602 | www.puirj.com
© 2023, PUIRJ | PU Publications | DOI:10.5281/zenodo.8370878 Page | 182
[4] Ebuehi, O., & Campbell, P. C. (n.d.). Attraction and retention of qualified health workers to rural areas in
Nigeria: a case study of four LGAs in Ogun State, Nigeria. RRH: Rural and Remote Health Article: 1515 -
Attraction and Retention of Qualified Health Workers to Rural Areas in Nigeria: A Case Study of Four LGAs
in Ogun State, Nigeria. https://doi.org/10.22605/RRH1515
[5] How to bring back the small-town family doctor. (2023, June 23). Vox.
https://www.vox.com/policy/23753724/physician-doctor-shortage-primary-care-medicare-medicaid-
rural-health-care-access
[6] Dr. A. Shaji George, A. S. Hovan George, Dr. T. Baskar, & A. S. Gabrio Martin. (2023). Human Insight AI: An
Innovative Technology Bridging The Gap Between Humans And Machines For a Safe, Sustainable Future.
Partners Universal International Research Journal, 2(1), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7723117
[7] Tamil Nadu, Uttar Pradesh have highest number of UG medical colleges in India. (2022, October 15). The
Hindu. https://www.thehindu.com/education/colleges/tamil-nadu-uttar-pradesh-have-highest-share-
of-public-and-private-ug-medical-seats/article66014045.ece
[8] A. S. Hovan George, Aakifa Shahu, A. Shaji George, T. Baskar, & A. Shahul Hameed. (2023). Medical Cancer
Diagnosis Using Texture Image Analysis. Partners Universal International Innovation Journal, 1(2), 39–48.
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7853258
[9] Visualizing America’s rural physician shortage - Dan Snow. (2019, April 10). Visualizing America’s Rural
Physician Shortage - Dan Snow. https://sno.ws/writing/2019/04/10/visualizing-americas-rural-
physician-shortage/
[10] A.Shaji George, A.S.Hovan George, & Aakifa Shahul. (2023). Exploring the Impact of Virtual Reality on Social
Interaction and Communication Skills in Individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Comparative
Study. Partners Universal International Innovation Journal, 1(3), 70–97.
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.8075801
[11] Answered] Discuss various reasons for shortage of doctors per capita in India especially in rural areas.
Discuss its impact on healthcare delivery in India. (n.d.). ForumIAS Blog.
https://blog.forumias.com/answered-discuss-various-reasons-for-shortage-of-doctors-per-capita-in-
india-especially-in-rural-areas-discuss-its-impact-on-healthcare-delivery-in-india/
[12] Setya, D. A. (2022, January 25). India Has Largest Number of Medical Colleges, What about Good Doctors?
TheQuint. https://www.thequint.com/opinion/india-has-largest-number-of-medical-colleges-what-
about-good-doctors
[13] Samal, J., & Dehury, R. K. (2016, May 1). An Evaluation on Medical Education, Research and Development of
AYUSH Systems of Medicine through Five Year Plans of India. PubMed Central (PMC).
https://doi.org/10.7860/JCDR/2016/18194.7793
[14]Dr. A.Shaji George, & A.S.Hovan George. (2023). Telemedicine: A New Way to Provide Healthcare . Partners
Universal International Innovation Journal, 1(3), 98–129. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.8075850
[15] Sachdeva, S., Dwivedi, N., & Taneja, N. (2019, December 3). Systematic Evaluation of Published Research
Studies Conducted Among Medical Undergraduate Students on Learning Environment in Medical
Colleges of India Using the Dreem Inventory Tool. Systematic Evaluation of Published Research Studies
Conducted Among Medical Undergraduate Students on Learning Environment in Medical Colleges of
India Using the Dreem Inventory Tool by Sandeep Sachdeva, Nidhi Dwivedi, Neha Taneja :: SSRN.
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3484375
[16] A.S.Hovan George, Dr.A.Shaji George, Dr. T. Baskar, & Aakifa Shahul. (2023). 3D Printed Organs: A New
Frontier in Medical Technology. Partners Universal International Innovation Journal, 1(3), 187–208.
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.8076965
[17] Kumar, R., & Pal, R. (n.d.). India achieves WHO recommended doctor population ratio: A call for paradigm
shift in public health discourse! PubMed Central (PMC). https://doi.org/10.4103/jfmpc.jfmpc_218_18
[18]Sriram, V., Keshri, V. R., & Kumbhar, K. (2021, August 18). The impact of colonial-era policies on health
workforce regulation in India: lessons for contemporary reform - Human Resources for Health. BioMed
Central. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12960-021-00640-w
[19]Nagral, S., Jain, A., & Nundy, S. (2016, January 1). A radical prescription for the Medical Council of India. The
BMJ. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.i1731
[20] The Shortage of US Healthcare Workers in 2023. (n.d.). The Shortage of US Healthcare Workers in 2023.
https://www.oracle.com/human-capital-management/healthcare-workforce-shortage/
[21] Role of faculty development programs in improving teaching. . . : Saudi Journal of Oral Sciences. (n.d.).
LWW. https://doi.org/10.4103/1658-6816.188073
