ArticlePublisher preview available

Modeling and validation of impact forces for back‐calculation of pavement surface moduli

Wiley
Computer-Aided Civil and Infrastructure Engineering
Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

When an impact load is sufficiently small, its influence on the pavement structure is mainly from the surface layer material. To explore the influence depth of an impact load and back‐calculation of the pavement surface modulus, both numerical calculation and experimental testing were conducted, and the results are presented in this paper. The numerical calculation was performed through a DEM‐FDM‐coupled model. After a new modulus back‐calculation algorithm is formed by analyzing the numerical modeling results, experimental tests were also conducted for verification, and the results were analyzed. The max value of the falling weight impact force was closely related to the elastic modulus of the material, and the influence depth was controllable. Finally, it is proved that the method can be used to calculate the surface layer modulus and estimate the surface layer thickness.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Received: February  Accepted:  July 
DOI: ./mice.
INDUSTRIAL APPLICATION
Modeling and validation of impact forces for
back-calculation of pavement surface moduli
Mohan Zhao Yu Liu Hainian Wang Xinnan Xu Shaojie Xu
Key Laboratory of Special Area Highway
Engineering of Ministry of Education,
Chang’an University, Xi’an, China
Correspondence
Yu Liu, Key Laboratory of Special Area
Highway Engineering of Ministry of
Education, Chang’an University, Xi’an
, China.
Email: yul@chd.edu.cn
Funding information
National Natural Science Foundation of
China, Grant/Award Number: 
Abstract
When an impact load is sufficiently small, its influence on the pavement struc-
ture is mainly from the surface layer material. To explore the influence depth
of an impact load and back-calculation of the pavement surface modulus, both
numerical calculation and experimental testing were conducted, and the results
are presented in this paper. The numerical calculation was performed through
a DEM-FDM-coupled model. After a new modulus back-calculation algorithm
is formed by analyzing the numerical modeling results, experimental tests were
also conducted for verification, and the results were analyzed. The max value
of the falling weight impact force was closely related to the elastic modulus of
the material, and the influence depth was controllable. Finally, it is proved that
the method can be used to calculate the surface layer modulus and estimate the
surface layer thickness.
1 INTRODUCTION
Since the s, falling weight deflectometer (FWD) mea-
surements have been extensively used for evaluating
pavement situ conditions (Uddin et al., ). With FWD
testing, the pavement surface deflection is measured to
evaluate the overall bearing capability of pavement or
to back-calculate the pavement layer modulus (Goktepe
et al., ;Saric&Pozder,). In practice, the layer
modulus back-calculation is a matching process combin-
ing mechanical analysis with multi-layered elastic system
theory and comparing measured and calculated deflec-
tions.
The earliest simplified method was to perform modu-
lus back-calculation by compiling a nomogram or table.
Although the speed of back-calculation is relatively fast,
it has not been widely used due to the poor accuracy of
the back-calculation results (Tutumluer & Sarker, ).
In contrast, the iterative method has been widely used
due to its good computational accuracy and applicability
© Computer-Aided Civil and Infrastructure Engineering.
(Harichandran et al., ), and researchers have devel-
oped various back-calculation software programs based on
this method, such as CHEVDEF, BISDEF, and ELSDEF.
However, the iterative method requires a long calculation
time; simultaneously, it depends on the value of the initial
seed and the presence of problems such as local conver-
gence and the uniqueness of the solution (X. Zhang & Sun,
). To further improve the computational efficiency,
the database search method was proposed (Gopalakrish-
nan & Khaitan, ). Since this method is much faster
and more stable, it is suitable for road network surveys,
and the MODULUS software based on this method was
developed in the Strategic Highway Research Program.
However, the disadvantage of this method is that the
database should be established in advance. At the same
time, interpolation often induces large errors for data that
are not in the database (Zha, ). With the populariza-
tion of computer-aided engineering, the artificial neural
network (ANN; Sharma & Das, ) method and genetic
algorithm (GA; Fwa et al., ) method were proposed for
1238 wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/mice Comput Aided Civ Inf. ;:–.
... Early applications by Chang and Meegoda (1997) have been expanded with advanced computational techniques, allowing DEM to effectively model the internal structural performance of asphalt mixtures. Its adoption reflects its ability to simulate significant deformations and fractures, crucial for addressing the discrete and heterogeneous nature of asphalt materials (Jianzhong et al., 2023;Wan et al., 2024;Zhao et al., 2023), while employing straightforward constitutive laws Yi et al., 2021). Despite its strengths, current DEMbased crack models for asphalt mixture present several limitations that are the focus of ongoing research. ...
Article
Cracks impact the performance and durability of asphalt pavements, necessitating a comprehensive understanding of the mixture cracking behavior. While discrete element modeling has been implemented, many studies oversimplify the simulation of asphalt mortar, a critical component affecting mixture cracking resistance. This study proposes a mortar model that is applicable to both two-dimensional (2D) and, to a preliminary extent, three-dimensional (3D) simulations. The model incorporates a geometric representation of mortar distribution and a mechanical softening model to simulate damage accumulation and fracture. Laboratory and virtual Superpave indirect tensile tests were performed on asphalt mixtures with varying gradations at different aging levels. The virtual simulations successfully mirrored indoor test results in volumetric parameters , load-displacement behavior, and stress distribution. Minor differences in strength, strain, and fracture energy between virtual and indoor tests confirmed the accuracy of the mortar model. Notably, the 3D simulations provided a more accurate reconstruction of the cracking process, showing smaller discrepancies between virtual and indoor results, compared to the 2D simulations, with errors in stress, strain, and fracture energy of 5.6%, 5.7%, and 4.7%, respectively. Employing the mortar model in discrete element simulation revealed insights into fracture angle distribution and tendencies, enabling meticulous analysis of mixture damage characteristics and cracking behavior. This allows for the improved design of mixtures with excellent cracking performance and contributes to advancing computational methods that could complement laboratory testing.
... Furthermore, the FDM-DEM coupling method has also been adopted to simulate the interaction between the rock mass and the shield under the largestrain mode (Fang et al., 2023). And it was also used to explore the influence depth of an impact load and backcalculation of the pavement surface modulus, without original theory method algorithm innovation (Zhao et al., 2023). To sum up, such a coupling method provides the advantages of both DEM and FDM, that is, multiscale coupling analysis and high computational efficiency. ...
Article
Full-text available
The constraint action of the unbound aggregate layer underneath plays an important role in affecting the temperature strains in the top asphalt layer. The focus of the present paper is to investigate the interactive thermal contraction mechanisms between the asphalt mixture and granular base layers to offer a new perspective in promoting the understanding of the thermal cracking disease. In this paper, both experiments and simulations were conducted for the thermal contraction tests. A novel numerical modeling of virtual composite structures was proposed using wall‐zone coupling operation based on the finite difference and discrete element coupling method. The experimental composite structures containing three types of asphalt mixture overlays and five types of unbound aggregate base layers were developed for verification. The thermal contraction and restraint mechanism were revealed from both macro and microscopic scales. The proposed numerical modeling shows a 94% high accuracy. The particle displacement vector and contact force chain could explain the thermal contraction behavior of composite structures. Smaller particle motion displacement or stronger contact force chain result in a higher restraint strain of the asphalt overlay. The thermal contraction behavior can be coordinated through the compaction and loosening of unbound aggregates. The material parameters and cooling temperature differences in the asphalt overlay have slight effects on the constraint action of a base layer, while the gradation and mechanical parameters of the unbound aggregate layer show significant impaction. The parameters, cohesion C and friction angle φ, show a quadratic function with the restraint coefficient. This work has significant guidance on the selection of pavement structure and materials to improve the thermal cracking problem and lay the basis for the mechanical theoretical calculation to predict thermal cracking.
Article
Full-text available
The road layer modulus backcalculation based on the road deflection basin obtained by the Falling Weight Deflectometer is a key issue in road engineering. Traditional Falling Weight Deflectometer backcalculation method based on Artificial Neural Network has the disadvantages of poor generalisation ability and low convergence accuracy in terms of the dynamic modulus. In this paper, a hybrid neural network structure, combined with Residual Neural Network, Recurrent Neural Network and Wide & Deep (Abbreviated as ResRNN-W&D) structure, was proposed for Falling Weight Deflectometer deflection basin backcalculation. A case study using the United States Long-Term Pavement Performance database verified that the ResRNN-W&D structure can train Falling Weight Deflectometer data on multiple roads together and achieve fast and high-precision convergence, thereby greatly improving the availability of the multi-source heterogeneous data. Moreover, two transfer learning methods for the ResRNN-W&D structure were proposed to improve the divergence issue. It was found that the ResRNN-W&D structure has stronger generalisation ability than traditional Artificial Neural Network. ARTICLE HISTORY
Article
Full-text available
The measurement of pavement surface deflections under moving loads can be used for evaluation of pavement structural condition. The objective of this paper is to develop an innovative backcalculation method to calculate pavement layer moduli based on traffic speed deflectometer (TSD) measurements and analyze factors influencing backcalculation results. The backcalculation method is based on 2.5D finite element method (FEM) and constrained extended Kalman filter (CEKF). Field measurements at different pavement sections were used to verify the accuracy of backcalculation results. Parametric analysis was conducted to evaluate the influences of traffic loading and pavement structure variations in the field. It was found that the backcalculation results were considerably affected by the variation of asphalt layer thickness and dynamic loading due to pavement surface roughness. A heavy truck passing the adjacent lane during TSD testing could also cause variation of backcalculation results.
Article
Full-text available
For the construction process of striking and rolling to treat the foundation, the traditional compaction test must conduct core sampling and damage detection, which are time-consuming and strenuous. Furthermore, it is difficult to determine the actual overall compaction. Based on acceleration sensor and satellite positioning measurement technology, this paper designs and develops an acceleration information acquisition device for impact construction, which can auto monitor impact construction in large-scale pavement construction. This paper also proposes methods for analyzing the degree of impact acceleration and compaction, including: (1) comprehensive analysis of the functional requirements and structural levels of a device for the acquisition of information about impact acceleration; (2) development of an acquisition system for collecting information about impact acceleration installed on the roller; (3) proposal of a method for the processing and analysis of compaction information based on the collected acceleration information; and (4) proposal of an experimental scheme of to test impact acceleration and application of the whole set of developed equipment to practical engineering.
Article
Full-text available
Pavement condition monitoring is required to identify pavements in need of maintenance or rehabilitation. Early identification of reduction in pavement's structural resistance and improving the structural resistance by minor repairs can lead to significantly lower maintenance costs for transportation agencies. In this study, a cost‐effective wireless sensor that can be embedded in the road to measure the transient vibrations due to different applied loads was tested to determine its effectiveness in terms of pavement displacement measurements. Test results show that the vibration sensor, combined with the algorithms, can be embedded in new or existing pavements and used as an accurate wireless displacement sensor. The low cost of the sensor system allows the use of these sensors at high densities for monitoring the performance of an entire road network. Outputs from the developed system can be directly used to evaluate the condition and performance of pavement structure (increasing displacement over time indicating increasing pavement damage). In addition, displacement data from the system can be used to backcalculate pavement layer stiffnesses, which can be used to predict long‐term performance of the pavement structure. Reduction in pavement layer stiffness over time can be used to determine long‐term damage accumulation.
Chapter
Full-text available
The mechanical properties of existing flexible pavements determine the remaining life of pavement and the moment when rehabilitation program should be implemented. The calculation of these properties can be very difficult, time consuming and non-reliable process. To determine the structural capacity of the pavement non-destructive testing equipment used. One of the most commonly used NDT techniques is falling weight deflectometer (FWD) test. Based on FWD measurements backcalculation process must be carried out in order to obtain the modulus of elasticity of pavement layers. This can be done by several methods, different in complexity and accuracy. Artificial neural networks can be successfully used for fast backcalculation process with training based on synthetic deflection basin obtained with linear elastic theory.
Article
Smartphones have integrated various sensors (e.g. GPS, acceleration sensor) and can be used to evaluate roads roughness. In this study the theoretical algorithm, in which the vehicle suspension parameters were included, would be established to calculate International Roughness Index (IRI) from acceleration using smartphones. Firstly, based on Android Studio 2.0, a client application installed on smartphones was developed. Next, the physical parameters of a quarter actual vehicle model (QAVM) were identified utilizing the front wheel drop test in accordance with complex modal theory. Then, the relationships among acceleration, IRI and the profile elevation were established through the derivation of theoretical formula. Finally, a validation analysis was implemented to evaluate the feasibility and reliability of this methodology. The validation experimental results on three asphalt pavement segments indicated that the collected acceleration data utilizing smartphone were basically consistent with that by accelerometers. Meanwhile, IRI calculated by the proposed theoretical methodology was close to that obtained by digital survey vehicle (DSV) and the maximum relative error between them was below 10%. Overall, due to the consideration of vehicle dynamic characteristics, the proposed method could improve the measurement accuracy and enable various vehicles to be used for road roughness evaluation.
Conference Paper
Noise pollution has become an important issue. One of the main sources of noise in residential areas is represented by transportation and by the interaction between tyre and road surface. Several studies illustrate that traffic noise is affected by road properties such as acoustic absorption, surface texture, and mechanical impedance. This latter, function of the angular frequency ω, is defined as the ratio of a force applied on a structure to the induced velocity. Despite a growing interest in mechanical impedance there is still lack of results about its impact on traffic noise. Consequently, the aim of the study presented in this paper is to investigate the relationship between road acoustic response and mechanical impedance. Tests (EN 29052-part 1, ISO 7626-5) have been performed on different types of samples and materials, using an impact hammer and an accelerometer. Investigations are still in progress. First results seem to demonstrate that both frequencies and other noise-related characteristics could be affected by changes of mechanical impedance, boundary conditions, tests, and type of material
Article
Pavements are made up of several layers with different mechanical and functional characteristics. The correct design of the surface layer of a road may lead to pavements with better characteristics regarding the ride quality and the safety, but also pavements that may reduce noise. The use of low-noise pavements may be an effective measure to reduce the acoustic pollution generated by road traffic. This work aims to assess some functional characteristics of a rehabilitated urban street, after two months in service conditions. The pavement was fabricated with a gap-graded bituminous mixture of Stone Mastic Asphalt (SMA) type with crumb rubber (CR) from end-of-life (EOL) tires. This work studies the acoustic performance of the pavement, as well as other surface characteristics, such as the macrotexture depth (MPD) and the unevenness (IRI), establishing the relationship between them and the tire/road noise at different frequencies. Finally, the main vertical acceleration frequencies of the pavement/vehicle system at a driving speed of 50 km/h are also assessed and related to the pavement unevenness and conservation. According to the results, this mixture might be used as a noise mitigation measure within the Action Plans of urban areas with problems related to noise. It is observed that the macrotexture depth of the mixture contributes to its acoustic performance at low frequencies; however, the tire/road noise generated cannot be totally explained from a macrotexture point of view.
Article
Due to the difficulties of finite element method (FEM) to deal with discontinuous displacement field such as convergence, re-meshing, and high grid density of crack-tip singular field, a coupled DEM/FEM model was proposed by combining with the advantages of discrete element method (DEM). According to the virtual work equation and variational principle, the equations of coupled model system were derived. Based on the penalty function method, the formula of interface coupled force was derived and a program code was written. Then the presented coupled DEM/FEM model was demonstrated to verify the accuracy by numerical examples. The coupled model was applied to collapse process simulation of single-layer reticulated shells under impact loads and the numerical results and computational efficiency of three different computational models, including pure FEM, pure DEM and coupled DEM/FEM model were compared. The results show that the coupled DEM/FEM model applied to large-span spatial reticulated structures can save the computation time and improve the efficiency because of less calculation amount than pure DEM. Further, the coupled DEM/FEM model applied to solve strong nonlinear problem has good performance of stability while the pure FEM easily leads to convergence difficulty. © 2017, Editorial Office of Journal of Building Structures. All right reserved.