ArticlePublisher preview available
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

Some men sexually attracted to types of persons (e.g., women) or things (e.g., animals) also have internalized sexual attractions: sexual arousal by the idea of being the type of person or thing to whom they are attracted. Consequently, some of these men develop erotic target identity inversions, in which they imitate, yearn to be, or identify as an instance of their erotic target. Erotic Target Identity Inversion Theory predicts that for every external erotic target to which men are attracted, a subset of men will develop an internalized sexual attraction, which may cause an erotic target identity inversion. We examined these predictions in Internet surveys of three samples of men with paraphilic sexual interests: 322 men attracted to amputees, 1501 men attracted to animals, and 402 men attracted to severely obese persons. All samples included substantial minorities of men reporting internalized sexual attractions and erotic target identity inversions specific to their external sexual attractions (e.g., men attracted to amputees who are also aroused by the fantasy of being amputees and wish to become amputees). The correlation between degree of each internalized sexual attraction and degree of its corresponding erotic target identity inversion was approximately 1.0 after correction for attenuation. In each sample, participants’ specific internalized sexual attraction was positively correlated with autogynephilia, likely the most common internalized sexual attraction in men. Erotic Target Identity Inversion Theory can potentially explain a variety of otherwise puzzling phenomena, including transgender identity among female-attracted natal males and men seeking amputations of healthy limbs.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Vol.:(0123456789)
1 3
Archives of Sexual Behavior
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-023-02647-x
SPECIAL SECTION: THE PUZZLES OFSEXUAL ORIENTATION ANDGENDER DIVERSITY
Elaborating andTesting Erotic Target Identity Inversion Theory
inThree Paraphilic Samples
J.MichaelBailey1 · KevinJ.Hsu2· HenryH.Jang3
Received: 2 April 2023 / Revised: 2 June 2023 / Accepted: 7 June 2023
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2023
Abstract
Some men sexually attracted to types of persons (e.g., women) or things (e.g., animals) also have internalized sexual attrac-
tions: sexual arousal by the idea of being the type of person or thing to whom they are attracted. Consequently, some of these
men develop erotic target identity inversions, in which they imitate, yearn to be, or identify as an instance of their erotic target.
Erotic Target Identity Inversion Theory predicts that for every external erotic target to which men are attracted, a subset of
men will develop an internalized sexual attraction, which may cause an erotic target identity inversion. We examined these
predictions in Internet surveys of three samples of men with paraphilic sexual interests: 322 men attracted to amputees, 1501
men attracted to animals, and 402 men attracted to severely obese persons. All samples included substantial minorities of men
reporting internalized sexual attractions and erotic target identity inversions specific to their external sexual attractions (e.g.,
men attracted to amputees who are also aroused by the fantasy of being amputees and wish to become amputees). The cor-
relation between degree of each internalized sexual attraction and degree of its corresponding erotic target identity inversion
was approximately 1.0 after correction for attenuation. In each sample, participants’ specific internalized sexual attraction
was positively correlated with autogynephilia, likely the most common internalized sexual attraction in men. Erotic Target
Identity Inversion Theory can potentially explain a variety of otherwise puzzling phenomena, including transgender identity
among female-attracted natal males and men seeking amputations of healthy limbs.
Keywords Paraphilias· Erotic target identity inversions· Erotic target location errors· Autogynephilia· Apotemnophilia·
Autozoophilia· Autolipophilia· Sexual orientation
Introduction
In a seminal article, Freund and Blanchard (1993) discussed
how some male paraphilias can be conceptualized as erotic
target location errors. Erotic target location errors consist
of a mislocation of an external erotic target. For example,
some heterosexual men mislocate their attraction to women,
who comprise their external erotic target, from women’s
primary and secondary sexual characteristics onto women’s
clothing (e.g., panties) or non-sexual body parts (e.g., feet).
Other heterosexual men mislocate their erotic target within
themselves, resulting in autogynephilia, sexual arousal by
the idea of being a woman (Blanchard, 1989a, 1991). The
novel contribution of Freund and Blanchard’s (1993) article
was the proposal that erotic target location errors also occur
among men with atypical external erotic targets. For exam-
ple, the article included several illustrative case vignettes of
pedophilic men sexually aroused by the idea of being children
and who imitated them or wished to become like them. It also
described a young man who had the strong erotic desire to
be a cartoon animal called “Puppy Smith.” Freund and Blan-
chard named erotically motivated desires to assume alterna-
tive identities erotic target identity inversions.
Although their observations were novel and striking,
Freund and Blanchard (1993) did not provide an elaborate
theory. They merely offered: “This theory predicts that, for
every class of sexual object, there will be small subgroups
of men who develop fetishes for clothing associated with the
desired object, who develop the erotic fantasy of being the
* J. Michael Bailey
jm-bailey@northwestern.edu
1 Department ofPsychology, Northwestern University, 2029
Sheridan Rd., Evanston, IL60208, USA
2 Department ofPsychological andSocial Sciences,
Pennsylvania State University, Abington, PA, USA
3 Department ofPsychological andBrain Sciences, Texas
A&M University, CollegeStation, TX, USA
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... It has been observed that paraphilias occur much more frequently among natal males than natal females (e.g., American Psychiatric Association, 2022; Bártová et al., 2021;Bhugra et al., 2010;Dawson et al., 2016;Konrad et al., 2015;Joyal & Carpentier, 2017;Yakeley & Wood, 2014), although systematic reviews of this issue have not been conducted. A recent study of three distinct paraphilias-acrotomophilia, zoophilia, and lipophilia (attraction to amputees, animals, and obese persons, respectively)-found rates of females ranging from 10.5% (lipophilia) to 13.3% (zoophilia) (Bailey et al., 2023). ...
... However, at least one subset of paraphilias share a specific structure, comprising a truly interesting observation. Internalized sexual attractions consist of paraphilias in which an erotic target is internalized into the self, resulting in sexual arousal by the idea of being an instance of that target (Bailey et al., 2023;Freund & Blanchard, 1993;Lawrence, 2009). The example that has been best studied is autogynephilia, a natal heterosexual male's sexual arousal by the thought or fantasy of being a woman Lawrence, 2013). ...
... In the seminal paper on the phenomenon (which referred to "erotic target location errors"), the authors hypothesized that "for every class of sexual object, there will be small subgroups of men who develop fetishes for clothing associated with the desired object, who develop the erotic fantasy of being the desired object, and who develop the sustained wish to transform their own bodies into facsimiles of the desired object" (Freund & Blanchard, 1993, p. 562). A recent test of this hypothesis was confirmed for three paraphilic samples (Bailey et al., 2023). The existence of persons (predominately male) aroused by imitating or becoming the type of person or thing to whom they are especially attracted, across a wide range of erotic targets (e.g., women, amputees, children, and anthropomorphic animals) suggests that deep rather than superficial similarities motivate the classification of internalized sexual attractions and perhaps paraphilias in general. ...
Article
Full-text available
Is the category paraphilia a natural kind? That is, do different paraphilias share anything scientifically interesting or are they classified together because they are unusual and sometimes problematic? We investigated this question systematically in 11 samples of paraphilic males (N = 4,617) and 11 samples of control males (N = 1,494). Primary data consisted of responses to the 11-item Paraphilic Interests Scale. Contrary to our initial hypothesis, the scale mean was similar for paraphilic and control samples. Using logistic regression and the same items, we derived three highly correlated measures that robustly discriminated paraphilic and control samples (ds ranging from 0.86 to 0.92). These successful measures capitalized on the unanticipated fact that some items (especially those assessing transvestism and masochistic humiliation) were positively associated with membership in paraphilic samples, while others (especially those assessing voyeurism) were negatively associated with such membership. Subsequent analyses focused on one of the measures, the Paraphilic Interests Scale Contrast (PISC). Consistent with prior findings distinguishing paraphilias and homosexual orientation, PISC was not elevated among homosexual males compared with heterosexual males among the control groups. Within four paraphilic samples, PISC was positively associated with additional paraphilic phenomena. Results provide tentative support for both the proposition that paraphilia is a natural kind and the usefulness of PISC as a measure of paraphilia.
... The concept of erotic target identity inversion is the most compelling explanation of autogynephilia, and it theorizes that this sexuality develops from an internalization of sexual attraction to women, resulting in sexual arousal by the fantasy of being a woman (Bailey et al., 2023;Freund & Blanchard, 1993;. When this internalization is complete, autogynephilic individuals do not experience sexual attraction to others, a phenomenon called analloeroticism. ...
... Third, while most autogynephilic individuals retain sexual attraction to women, some completely internalize their sexual attraction to women and experience a lack of sexual attraction to others (Bailey et al., 2023;Freund & Blanchard, 1993;. It is expected that male cross-dressers and transfeminine individuals would therefore report higher rates of analloeroticism, compared with those not likely motivated by autogynephilia. ...
Article
Full-text available
Autogynephilia is a natal male’s propensity to be sexually aroused by the thought or fantasy of being a woman. Both male cross-dressers and transfeminine individuals (a broad range of individuals born male with a feminine gender identity; e.g., trans women) have been shown to be motivated or characterized by autogynephilia. Although there is a lack of research on whether other potentially related aspects of sexuality are comparable between them, the conceptual framework of autogynephilia offers several predictions that can be tested empirically. Following these predictions, the present study examined whether 10 diverse aspects of sexuality differed between 519 male cross-dressers and 288 transfeminine individuals recruited from online communities, as well as between both groups and 293 cisgender men and 301 cisgender women recruited as control groups. The overwhelming majority of male cross-dresser and transfeminine participants identified as heterosexual, bisexual, asexual, or pansexual. Compared with transfeminine participants, male cross-dressers reported more core and general autogynephilia, paraphilic interests, sociosexual orientation, sexual compulsivity, and problematic pornography use, but less bisexual attraction. Compared with cisgender men and women, male cross-dressers and transfeminine participants as a combined sample reported more bisexual attraction, sexual orientation ambiguity, core and general autogynephilia, paraphilic interests, analloeroticism, sexual compulsivity, and problematic pornography use, but less perceived desirability as a partner. Differences were larger comparing male cross-dressers and transfeminine participants with either control group than with each other. Results suggest that while autogynephilia is especially important to the sexuality of male cross-dressers, it also figures importantly in the sexuality of transfeminine individuals, even if it is expressed and organized differently.
... For instance, Asmundson offers an extensive overview of psychological coping mechanisms, potentially elucidating aspects connected to cross-dressing and bisexuality (Asmundson, 2022). Additionally, the study by Bailey, Hsu, and Jang delves into the Erotic Target Identity Inversion Theory in paraphilic samples, exploring the interplay between sexuality, identity, and coping mechanisms, which may include cross-dressing (Bailey et al., 2023). Moreover, Curtis and Morris present a single case study, "Cross-dressing as a meaningful occupation," focusing on the personal significance of cross-dressing as a coping strategy (Curtis & Morris, 2015). ...
... Regarding jurisdiction, legislative safeguards for gender expression exist to guarantee that individuals who cross-dress are granted fair housing, education, and employment opportunities without bias or discrimination. Irrespective of the classification of cross-dressing, concepts and behaviours associated with crossdressing are consistently classified under exhibitionism, sexuality, and transgenderism (Bailey et al., 2023;Plemons, 2021). However, these categories are outside of S.R.'s. ...
Article
Cross-dressing refers to the act of donning garments often associated with the opposite gender. Throughout history, cross-dressing has been extensively recorded and is frequently linked to stereotypes such as deviance, fetishism, exhibitionism, sexual deviance, and homosexuality. Coping mechanisms refer to psychological strategies employed by the subconscious mind to shield individuals from feelings of anxiety, social repercussions, and unmanageable circumstances in the immediate present. This study aimed to elucidate that Cross-Dressing is not just attributable to perceptions of sexual deviance and transvestism, but rather, other factors contribute to an individual's adoption of Cross-Dressing. The research methodology employed in this study is a single-design case study. The study found that the participants experienced the loss of their beloved mother as a catalyst for adopting a Cross-Dressing lifestyle, perceiving it as a means to compensate for the void created by her death. The findings of this study indicate that cross-dressing behaviour serves as a long-lasting method for individuals to repress their emotions related to loss rather than being primarily attributed to transvestism or preconceptions of sexual deviance associated with the subject of investigation.
Article
Full-text available
Blanchard proposed that autogynephilia is a natal male’s paraphilic sexual arousal in response to the thought or fantasy of being a woman. Furthermore, based on evidence collected from natal males with gender dysphoria, Blanchard argued that autogynephilia is the fundamental motivation among nonhomosexual males (i.e., those not exclusively attracted to men) who pursue sex reassignment surgery or live as transgender women. These ideas have been challenged by several writers who have asserted, or offered evidence, that autogynephilia is common among women. However, their evidence was weakened by problematic measures and limited comparison groups. We compared four samples of autogynephilic natal males (N = 1549), four samples of non-autogynephilic natal males (N = 1339), and two samples of natal females (N = 500), using Blanchard’s original measure: the Core Autogynephilia Scale. The autogynephilic samples had much higher mean scores compared with non-autogynephilic natal males and natal females, who were similar. Our findings refute the contention that autogynephilia is common among natal females.
Article
Full-text available
This paper is a systematic review and meta-analysis on sexual orientation identity development milestones among people who are lesbian, gay, bisexual, or another sexual minority identity (LGB+). Common milestones measured in the 30 studies reviewed were becoming aware of queer attractions, questioning one’s sexual orientation, self-identifying as LGB+, coming out to others, engaging in sexual activity, and initiating a romantic relationship. Milestones occurred in different sequences, although attraction was almost always first, often followed by self-identification and/or sexual activity; coming out and initiating a romantic relationship often followed these milestones. Meta-analysis results showed that the mean effect sizes and 95% confidence intervals varied by milestone: attraction [Mage=12.7 (10.1, 15.3)], questioning one’s orientation [Mage=13.2 [12.8, 13.6]), self-identifying [Mage=17.8 (11.6, 24.0)], sexual activity [Mage=18.1 (17.6, 18.6)], coming out [Mage=19.6 (17.2, 22.0)], and romantic relationship [Mage=20.9 (13.2, 28.6)]. Nonetheless, results also showed substantial heterogeneity in the mean effect sizes. Additional meta-analyses showed that milestone timing varied by sex, sexual orientation, race/ethnicity, and birth cohort. Although patterns were found in LGB+ identity development, there was considerable diversity in milestone trajectories.
Chapter
Full-text available
Sexual orientation is conventionally understood as relative attraction to men versus women. It has recently been argued that male sexual orientation in particular can be extended to include other dimensions of sexual attraction besides gender. One such dimension is sexual maturity, or relative attraction to children versus adults. A less familiar dimension is location, or relative attraction to other individuals versus sexual arousal by the fantasy of being one of those individuals. Erotic target identity inversions (ETIIs) refer to some men’s sexual arousal by the fantasy of being the same kinds of individuals to whom they are sexually attracted. Thus, ETIIs reflect the movement from external attraction to internal attraction on the dimension of location. ETIIs can motivate men to change their appearance and behavior to become more like the individuals to whom they are sexually attracted. ETIIs also provide a compelling theoretical explanation for otherwise puzzling phenomena, such as cross-dressing among heterosexual men, desire for limb amputation, and the furry phenomenon. Despite its scientific and clinical value, the concept of ETIIs has been underappreciated and understudied. This chapter reviews the ETIIs that have been previously identified in the literature, addresses important issues related to ETIIs, discusses the causes and development of ETIIs, and proposes future directions for research.KeywordsErotic target identity inversionAutogynephiliaApotemnophiliaAutopedophiliaParaphiliaSexual orientation
Article
Full-text available
Introduction: Stunkard's figure rating scale is a widely used tool to assess weight status and, more recently, body image perception in people with obesity. However, large population-based studies on Europeans linking this scale's silhouettes with measured BMI values are lacking. Therefore, we used measured weight and height data from the Swedish Obese Subjects (SOS) reference cohort to assign a mean BMI to each of the 9 Stunkard Scale silhouettes and to define silhouette cutoff values for categorizing people with obesity and overweight. Methods: A total of 1,128 participants from the SOS reference cohort were included (54% females, BMI = 25.2 [ranging from 17.6 to 45.4] ±3.8 kg/m2, and age = 50 [ranging from 36 to 62] ±7 years [means ± standard deviation]). Patients estimated their own body size by choosing a silhouette of the Stunkard Scale. A mean BMI, based on measured weight and height, was assigned to each male and female silhouette of the Stunkard Scale. Measured BMI values were compared with BMI values calculated by simple linear regression analysis. ROC analysis was used to test accuracy of discrimination and the Youden index to assess optimal cutoff. Results: Figure ratings and BMI were strongly correlated in men, r (518) = 0.76, p < 0.001 and women, r (606) = 0.80, p < 0.001. Silhouette selection significantly predicted BMI values in men, β = 16.03, t (518) = 25.30, p < 0.001, and women, β = 12.06, t (606) = 32.98, p < 0.001, and explained a significant proportion of variance in BMI values in men, R2 = 0.55, F (1, 518) = 639.98, p < 0.001, and women, R2 = 0.64, F (1, 606) = 1,087.88, p < 0.001. ROC curve analyses resulted in an optimal cutoff value of 6 for identifying people with obesity and 5 for overweight. Conclusion: Stunkard's figure rating scale can be used with confidence to assess weight status. Silhouette selection accurately classifies subjects as overweight or obese.
Article
Full-text available
It is generally accepted within psychology and among trans health providers that transgender people who transition do so because they have a gender identity that is incongruent with their birth-assigned sex, and distinct from their sexual orientation. In contradiction to this standard model, the theory of autogynephilia posits that transgender women’s female gender identities and transitions are merely a by-product of their sexual orientations. While subsequent research has yielded numerous lines of evidence that, taken together, disprove the theory, autogynephilia is still often touted by anti-transgender groups, including trans-exclusionary feminists. Here, I provide an updated overview of the scientific case against autogynephilia. Following that, I will forward an alternative ‘embodiment fantasies’ model that explains all the available findings better than autogynephilia theory, and which is more consistent with contemporary thinking regarding gender and sexual diversity. I will also demonstrate how autogynephilia theory relies on essentialist, heteronormative, and male-centric presumptions about women and LGBTQ+ people, and as such, it is inconsistent with basic tenets of feminism.
Article
Full-text available
Background Men sexually interested in children of a specific combination of maturity and sex tend to show some lesser interest in other categories of persons. Patterns of men's sexual interest across erotic targets' categories of maturity and sex have both clinical and basic scientific implications. Method We examined the structure of men's sexual interest in adult, pubescent, and prepubescent males and females using multidimensional scaling (MDS) across four datasets, using three large samples and three indicators of sexual interest: phallometric response to erotic stimuli, sexual offense history, and self-reported sexual attraction. The samples were highly enriched for men sexually interested in children and men accused of sexual offenses. Results Results supported a two-dimensional MDS solution, with one dimension representing erotic targets' biological sex and the other dimension representing their sexual maturity. The dimension of sexual maturity placed adults and prepubescent children on opposite ends, and pubescent children intermediate. Differences between men's sexual interest in adults and prepubescent children of the same sex were similar in magnitude to the differences between their sexual interest in adult men and women. Sexual interest in adult men was no more associated with sexual interest in boys than sexual interest in adult women was associated with sexual interest in girls. Conclusions Erotic targets' sexual maturity and biological sex play important roles in men's preferences, which are predictive of sexual offending. The magnitude of men's preferences for prepubescent children v. adults of their preferred sex is large.
Article
Full-text available
There is no accepted definition of the term paraphilia despite its being listed as an essential feature of a class of mental disorders known as the paraphilic disorders. The origin of the term, history of its inclusion as a diagnosis, and logical flaws inherent in the various definitions are discussed in this review. We examine the basis for pathologizing individuals with paraphilias, consider what paraphilias can tell us about how humans develop their sexual interests, and question the usefulness of dividing sexual interests into paraphilias and normophilias. The construct of the paraphilias appears to be poorly conceived and has outlived its usefulness. Expected final online publication date for the Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, Volume 16 is May 7, 2020. Please see http://www.annualreviews.org/page/journal/pubdates for revised estimates.
Article
The number of population-based studies focused on the prevalence of paraphilic sexual interests in men is very low and for women, the subject remains largely unexplored. The two main aims of this study are to investigate the prevalence of paraphilias and to explore sex differences in an online representative sample of Czech men and women using various dimensions of sexual experience. We collected data about sexual motivations and behavior from a representative online sample of 10,044 Czechs (5,023 men and 5,021 women). In a standardized online interview, participants answered questions about selected dimensions of sexual experience within specific paraphilic patterns: sexual preferences, sexual arousal, sexual fantasies in the past 6 months, pornography use in the past 6 months, and experience with paraphilic behaviors. Our results show that 31.3% of men (n = 1,571) and 13.6% of women (n = 683) admitted to at least one paraphilic preference. Moreover, 15.5% of men and 5% of women reported more than one paraphilic preference. Except for beating/torture and humiliation/submission, in terms of real experience with such behaviors almost all paraphilias were more common among men than among women. Our results indicate that the high prevalence of some paraphilic patterns might render their pathologization problematic.
Article
Introduction: Erotic target identity inversions (ETIIs) are poorly studied paraphilias that involve sexual arousal by the idea or fantasy of being the object of one's sexual desires. Aim: To conduct a large non-clinical online survey to investigate self-reported sexual arousal, behavioral expression, and psychological correlates of 4 proposed ETIIs. Methods: A total of 736 natal males and 549 natal females responded to items about self-reported sexual arousal to the idea of acting as an animal (autoanthropomorphozoophilia) or the idea of acting as a child or infant (autonepiophilia), natal males reporting arousal to the idea of acting as a woman (autogynephilia), and natal females reporting arousal to the idea of acting as a man (autoandrophilia). Data pertaining to sexual orientation, childhood gender nonconformity, gender identity discomfort, autism, masochism, and humiliation were also collected. Main outcome measures: The main outcome was a measure of self-reported arousal and expression of the ETIIs being explored using 4 items: arousal level (-3 to 3) when imagining being the erotic target exemplar; frequency of engagement in dressing or behaving like their preferred target (0-4); strength of feeling that they would be better off as the target (0-4); and the frequency of consideration of making physical changes to look or function more like the target (0-4). Results: Mild levels of reported sexual arousal to the idea of being the preferred erotic target were common among the 4 groups, characterizing about half of them. Gender identity discomfort was associated with autogynephilia, autoandrophilia, and autoanthropomorphozoophilia. Greater gender nonconformity was associated with autogynephilia, autoandrophilia, and autonepiophilia. Autism scores were associated with autoandrophilia and autonepiophilia. Masochism was not associated with ETII scores, but humiliation was. Clinical implications: Findings suggest that it may be important to distinguish between subgroups of those with different levels and types of ETII arousal/expression. Strengths & limitations: Strengths of this study include the large, non-clinical sample of men and women for the investigation of ETIIs and the inclusion of measures of psychological correlates. The use of an Internet sample with self-report measures may be unrepresentative, although the Internet has the advantage of allowing recruitment from stigmatized or unusual groups. The cross-sectional nature limits our conclusions, as no causal inferences can be made. Conclusion: The results support the concept of ETIIs as a paraphilic dimension in non-clinical samples and the possible role of gender-related psychological factors. Brown A, Barker ED, Rahman Q. Erotic Target Identity Inversions Among Men and Women in an Internet Sample. J Sex Med 2019;XX:XXX-XXX.