Chapter

Using Student Participation to Improve Higher Education Models: Lessons From the Development of a Comprehensive Student Participation Plan

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

The literature shows that despite the strength of the principles shared around the importance of the strategic participation of students in the good management of higher education institutions, the practice is far below the desired standards. This chapter explores the power of comprehensive student participation plans to improve higher education models by fostering the development of a broader and multidimensional culture of student participation. Empirical contribution draws on the recent and innovative experience developed at the University of Évora, a public university in Portugal, a south European country. At the end, it is expected that the lessons learned from this experience might help worldwide higher education systems and institutions, administrators, faculty, and trustees to understand how specific countries structure their higher education systems and how they are dealing with global critical issues, thus increasing awareness and capacity to develop solutions addressing identified challenges.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

... This role would have primarily concentrated on producing engaging content and using focused marketing techniques to ensure SSG programs were effectively communicated to all students. Student engagement and involvement could have been increased by effectively communicating the recompenses of joining and the applicability of SSG programs through interesting, appealing material and focused marketing techniques (Costa et al., 1970). ...
Article
Full-text available
Student engagement programs served as catalysts for student development, community building, and active participation in campus life. This research explored the state of student engagement programs within the Supreme Student Government (SSG), focusing on their effectiveness and levels of student participation. Utilizing the 5 Whys methodology, the study identified and analyzed critical challenges and opportunities related to student motivation, program structure, and alignment with student interests. The findings revealed that internal communication breakdowns and budget constraints were significant factors impeding the effectiveness of SSG programs. Student participation was only moderate due to conflicting schedules with classes and insufficient program marketing. The rigid structure of SSG programs and a lengthy approval process further limited their ability to meet student needs. A disconnect between program content and student interests hindered engagement. The research concluded that the root causes of these problems lay in the need for more structured communication channels, a complex approval process, and misalignment with student interests. By addressing these underlying motives, recommendations included enhancing internal communication, allocating funds as efficiently as possible, and creating an inclusive learning environment. These strategies aimed to develop more effective and appealing student engagement programs, ultimately fostering a more active and engaged student body.
Article
Full-text available
Resumo: Apesar de um discurso generalizado em torno da importância estratégica da participação dos estudantes na boa gestão das instituições de ensino superior como forma de fomentar a inclusão e superar desigualdades, a prática encontra-se muito aquém dos padrões desejados. Este artigo apresenta resultados preliminares de uma inquirição a estudantes universitários sobre participação estudantil no âmbito de um projeto transnacional e interuniversitário em que a Universidade de Évora é instituição parceira. O projeto STUPS-Participação Estudantil Sem Fronteiras tem como objetivo geral estabelecer as bases de uma rede europeia focada no desenvolvimento de novas práticas para promover a participação estudantil em contexto de ensino superior. Neste texto são exploradas as perceções, nomeadamente as vantagens e obstáculos identificados por estudantes universitários através de um questionário eletrónico aplicado na Universidade de Évora em 2020. No final, espera-se que os resultados obtidos possibilitem a identificação de dimensões chave que permitam refletir de uma forma ampla e sustentada sobre os diversos desafios que se colocam neste domínio e, ao mesmo tempo, fundamentar sugestões de mudança nos processos de funcionamento democrático das instituições de ensino superior tendo em vista o aumento da participação de categorias de estudantes sub-representados e desfavorecidos nos processos de tomada de decisão.
Article
Full-text available
Este ensaio apresenta perspectivas para a incorporação do conceito de student engagement no repertório teórico dos estudos sobre educação superior no Brasil. Discutindo as raízes do termo, propõe que seja traduzido como engajamento estudantil, em referência à tradição dos estudos latino-americanos sobre o estudante universitário e seus movimentos políticos. Revisa a literatura da corrente norte-americana e europeia sobre o student engagement, bem como as obras seminais latino-americanas que tratam do “estudante engajado” desde a Reforma de Córdoba. Apresenta as ideias de participação e inovação pedagógica como possíveis caminhos de desenvolvimento conceitual e prático do conceito de engajamento estudantil. Explora as relações entre essas noções e a realidade brasileira. Ressalta a formação política para a participação cidadã como componente fundamental do engajamento estudantil, considerando que a constituição do estudante como sujeito político é decisiva para o futuro da educação superior.
Article
Full-text available
The aim of this article is to explore student participation in teaching and learning, focusing on third-year students’ experiences in a Swedish teacher education programme. Student participation is here defined as students being active and engaged in the classroom; students impacting on curriculum design; and students’ feeling of belonging to a community. The research reported is based on an interview study and analyses processes, benefits and challenges of, as well as motivations for, student participation. The findings revealed that students have diverse understandings of student participation and that the degree of participation is dependent on students’ and teachers’ engagement, expectations and responsibility. Student teachers also connected student participation to their learning and future profession as teachers. The students mainly discussed intrinsic motivations (beneficial to learning) for student participation, but there were also traces of altruistic motivations (learning citizenship). Extrinsic motivations (university benefits), however, were absent. Voices of resistance to student participation were also present; these students preferred a more teacher-led education and were not used to a high degree of participation. Students’ understandings of student participation challenge teacher–student roles in teacher education specifically, but also in higher education generally. It is important to acknowledge students’ diverse understandings of student participation. Overall, based on students’ experiences, student participation creates engagement and motivation for learning here and now and for the future profession. The study indicates that student participation has an inherent value beyond benefitting measurable outcomes, where democratic values, engagement and learning for the future profession are promoted.
Article
Full-text available
Although student participation in HE governance continues to be a value in Europe, the terms of participation are rapidly changing. The reasons lie broadly in the modernisation agenda for European universities: new public management approach in institutional governance and rising tuition fees. As a result, institutional preference for student participation is changing from decision-making function in governing towards an advisory function in quality assurance and new styles of student engagement in institutional efforts to enhance student experience and in the student centered learning. In other words, while the formal student participation in governing appears to be weakening, the informal student participation is strengthening.
Article
Full-text available
Student belonging and engagement has received increased attention in the context of an expanding and more diverse higher education student population. Student retention is regarded as a priority with many universities augmenting their retention strategies to instil a sense of belonging. This article provides insights into first year Business Management students’ experiences of starting their degrees and retention interventions at a university in the South of England. It is based on findings from an ongoing study that applied Wenger’s social theory of learning and adopted an appreciative inquiry approach to focus group interviewing to investigate students’ perceptions. Students developed a sense of belonging, constructed learner identities, made sense of their learning and gained confidence, but also experienced instances of tension and frustration that raise questions about the extent to which sociality practices within evolving communities of practice can address diverse engagement and identity development needs and mitigate disengagement.
Article
Higher education institutions (HEIs) have a fundamental role in transforming societies aimed at a more sustainable future. Through knowledge creation and dissemination, research, education and outreach, institutions of higher education lead the path towards sustainable development. The aim of this paper is to identify, based on a review of the literature, how HEIs promote sustainable development. An analysis of both international declarations and the scientific literature on education for sustainable development shows that emphasis is given to discussions on development, education, research, and training. This highlights the need for a stronger role of universities to promote sustainable development paths, expanding and disseminating knowledge, building capacity through training, and working with local communities to increase their resilience.
Article
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to highlight the urgent need for a genuinely effective and attainable citizenship education model in Hong Kong’s schools, which focusses on promoting student participation in school governance. It is an empirical citizenship education management model for school leaders that illustrates the predictive effects of personally responsible, participatory, justice-oriented and patriotic citizenship, necessarily supported by school management practices, school ethos and teacher beliefs. Design/methodology/approach A total of 3,209 students from 51 secondary schools in Hong Kong participated in a quasi-experimental design questionnaire survey. A structural equation model (SEM) was applied to confirm the model. Findings The results of the SEM show that the values and cultural practices held by a school’s teachers drive the implementation of its citizenship education. Moreover, it is well known that organizational values can exert a powerful influence and it is the same within educational structures: management practices in schools have an impact on ethos, teachers’ beliefs and student participation in school governance. Practical implications The paper provides practical proposals for school leaders to create opportunities for student participation in school governance. Originality/value This study builds on existing literature and provides school leaders with a practical model for implementing student participation in school governance.
Article
Quality teaching is increasingly prioritized in higher education. One reason is that government funding requires students to succeed in their studies and be ready for employment. In response, educators throughout the Western world have generated large quantities of evidence-based, practical, often uncritical research about what works to improve teaching, learning and student success. Much of this research carries the label student engagement. But student engagement is a complex construct used to identify what students do, think and feel when learning and how teachers can improve that doing, thinking and feeling in instructional settings. Despite its extensive coverage of learning and teaching, the paper asks whether something is missing from student engagement. It recognizes the complexity of the engagement construct and examines its key ideas but identifies three missing elements: critique; learning agency/democracy; as well as purposes, knowledge and values that transcend powerful political discourses in neo-liberal times.
Article
This article aims at analysing and discussing student participation in Portuguese higher education institutions and, specifically, in university governance. In a first moment, it describes this participation under both the previous (1988–2007) and the new legal frameworks (since 2007). A discussion of the changes introduced by this last framework and the extent to which it has contributed to the erosion of student participation in governance is undertaken. Next, the article deals with the ways students are involved in quality assessment at both its systemic and institutional levels. The case of a specific Portuguese university is used as an example of how this involvement takes place. The article concludes with a discussion on the main features of Portuguese student participation in governance, focusing on its effectiveness and suggesting measures for improvement.
Article
The role and contribution of students to the governance of university departments is a relatively neglected area of inquiry. This study investigated the factors which student representatives perceived to help or hinder their effectiveness as student members of departmental committees. Twenty students from a range of disciplines were interviewed about their experiences in the student representative role. Students reported complex motivations and conceptions of the representative role and were particularly sensitive to the perceptions and expectations of academic staff. Role ambiguity was the greatest challenge reported by student representatives, and the overall effectiveness of the role was perceived to be reliant on the willingness and ability of academic managers and staff to engage in constructive dialogue with students. It is argued that universities need to adopt a more proactive approach to the development and support of student leaders and representatives. Yes Yes
Plano para a Igualdade de Género da
  • R P Costa
  • F Henriques
  • A Carmo
  • C Pomar
  • L Alegre
  • L Sousa
  • T Furtado
  • C Peralta
Costa, R. P., Henriques, F., Carmo, A., Pomar, C., Alegre, L., Sousa, L., Furtado, T., & Peralta, C. (2022). Plano para a Igualdade de Género da Universidade de Évora [Gender Equality Plan for the University of Évora]. Évora: Universidade de Évora. Available at: https://www.uevora.pt/universidade/ documentos-institucionais/plano-para-a-igualdade-de-genero2
Student Participation in Higher Education Governance in Europe. Industry and Higher Education
  • M Klemenčič
Klemenčič, M. (2012). Student Participation in Higher Education Governance in Europe. Industry and Higher Education, 66(Winter), 32-33.
Plano Integral de Participação Estudantil da Universidade de Évora
  • J C Novas
  • R P Costa
  • A Fialho
  • P Moreira
Novas, J. C., Costa, R. P., Fialho, A., & Moreira, P. (2022). Plano Integral de Participação Estudantil da Universidade de Évora 2022-2026 [Comprehensive Student Participation Plan of the University of Évora 2022-2026].
Student engagement in neo-liberal times: What is missing? Higher Education Research & Development
  • N Zepke
Zepke, N. (2018). Student engagement in neo-liberal times: What is missing? Higher Education Research & Development, 37(2), 433-446. doi:10.1080/07294360.2017.1370440
Participação estudantil (sem fronteiras)? Perceções, potencialidades e obstáculos em contexto de Ensino Superior
  • Costar
  • Novasj
  • Silvap
  • R.Costa
From student voice to shared responsibility: effective practice in democratic school governance in European schools
  • T Huddleston
Huddleston, T. (2007). From student voice to shared responsibility: effective practice in democratic school governance in European schools. Council of Europe.
Education for Sustainable Development Goals: learning objectives