Content uploaded by Sunil Ramdas
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Sunil Ramdas on Jun 30, 2023
Content may be subject to copyright.
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
1
POSITIVE LEADERSHIP PRACTICES ENHANCES FLOURISHING IN
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY ORGANISATION IN INDIA
ABSTRACT
Purpose: Organisational leaders are focusing on employee flourishing by incorporating
dimensions of happiness, feeling good and thereby functioning well. The study examines the
influence of positive leadership on employee flourishing, among software professionals in
Information technology organisations in India and the mediating effect of psychological
empowerment and trust, within the ambit of positive leadership as available.
Methodology: Exploratory Sequential mixed method designs was adopted using four valid and
reliable scales with a 983 respondents. Stratified and judgemental sampling techniques were used
to identify respondents and the ITO’s. Convergent approach was used to compare findings from
qualitative and quantitative data. Structural equation model and AMOS were used to check the
model fitness and structural relationship.
Findings: The results indicate that software professionals do experience positive leadership and
trust, and thereby feel psychologically empowered leading to flourishing. The qualitative
findings support the statistical analysis. The correlation between the constructs is significant and
exhibits noteworthy associations with the research model. This study highlights the association
of immediate supervisors and employees, wherein the former acts as an intrinsic motivator in
affecting organizational and individual-level positive behavioural outcomes.
Implications: The study indicates that both leadership and flourishing are intertwined.
Significantly adding value to the subject on the study constructs by contributing towards positive
psychology and broaden-and-build theories. Organisations must look at interventions programs
designed to enhance positive leadership, empowerment, trust and flourishing among software
professionals in ITO’s. Positive leadership practices are operationalised within a goal-setting
framework towards enhancing employee flourishing.
Originality/value: This novel paper has the potential to stimulate the empirical studies on
dependent variables through relationship of positive leadership.
Keywords: Positive Leadership; Positive Psychology; Leadership Behaviour; Psychological
Empowerment; Trust; Flourishing;
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
2
INTRODUCTION
A positive and entrepreneurial strategic approach is always advantageous to organisations that
operate in hostile business environments. In turbulent times, organisations need leaders who can
build trustworthy workplace and empowering employees through positive psychology. Global
economies are expanding rapidly today and in the process, looking at young talents for future
leadership roles. However, the challenge lies in focusing on long-term goals, specifically the
human capital, vis a vis employee growth and development through positive leadership. A
leader’s positivity can be contagious if engaged consistently. However, employees' prejudice due
to their opinions or experiences of their leader’s affirmative behaviour can overshadow positive
behaviours of the leader. So trust in the workplace and psychological empowerment can offset
this state of affairs and allow employees to fully benefit from positivity. As existing notions of
leadership theories barely provide justification for positivity of a leader (Norman, and Luthans,
2008: Blanch et al., 2016).However, trust and empowerment in the presence of positive
leadership behaviours can provide sparse evidence too. Although theories of leadership have
examined the leader’s positive aspects in terms of behaviour or style, the effects of positive
leadership have not been explored (Avolio and Luthans, 2006).Based on our understanding, the
basic difference between leadership theories that are in vogue today is that a servant leader
focuses on the followers' needs, while a transformational leader emphasises upon larger
organizational goals. Authentic leaders emphasise on honest relationships with followers, built
on ethical foundation; while ethical leaders focus on the importance of ethical standards, beliefs
and values. Finally, empowering leaders focus on enhancing employees by sharing power. The
salient points of leadership theories (mentioned above)do highlight the importance of positivity;
however, none has actually gone on to define positive leadership
(
Youssef-Morgan, and
Luthans,2013) universally. The prevailing approach that has been in vogue do confirm that
positive leadership effectively builds upon these leadership theories by applying positive
psychology practices (Seligman, 1998), represented through positive organisational scholarship
(Cameroon, Dutton and Quinn, 2003) and positive change (Cooperrider and Srivastva,
1987).Further, these theories essentially assert that positive leaders need to remain both
methodical and cohesive over time and across circumstances, while focusing on the heliotropic
effect and positive deviance (Cameron, 2012). As a theory in management science, the concept
of positive leadership may be new; nevertheless, its philosophies have been practiced since long,
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
3
based on heliotropic effect, positivity, spirit of entrepreneurship, and positive deviance, creating
thereby an environment of trust among leaders and employees through virtuous behaviour and
affirmative action’s. It’s important to demonstrate positive leadership behaviour towards
achieving ones potential through positivity, empowerment and resilience do influence employee
flourishing at the workplace (Jordan, 2016: Youssef-Morgan and Luthans, 2013:Cameron, 2012:
Seligman, 2011). The study defines that “positive leadership lines up closely with business
strategy to drive higher level of performance by promoting optimism and focusing on
employee’s strengths, positive perspective and recognition.”
Positive psychology (Seligman and Csikszentmihalyi, 2000), positive organizational behaviour
(Luthans, 2002) and positive organisational scholarship (Cameroon, Dutton and Quinn, 2003)
have had significant effects for appreciating individual welfare; however, not much has been
discussed on employee flourishing (Kelloway et al., 2013).A leader’s positivity is contagious and
influences follower’s voluntary behaviours in goal achievement. It confirms the exercise of
psychological capital by the leader attesting to the premise that these behaviours are fundamental
to positive leadership.
A leader’s optimistic sentiments are often related with their physical ability, well-being and
features like hopefulness and spirit (Algoe and Fredrickson, 2011).Extant research has confirmed
that the behaviour of an immediate supervisor does have an inordinate influence on employee
psychological welfare (Gilbreath and Benson, 2004). However, it may be worth pondering upon
whether only an optimistic approach of a leader influences employee flourishing. Research
indicates that leaders’ empowering behaviour does motivate employees to foster innovative
behaviour, and thereby better individual performance, in turn, enhancing organisational
performance (Meng and Sun, 2019). Additionally, we have also noted that ‘trust’ effectively is
the spirit of leadership, and it's impossible to flourish without having trusting relationship with
leaders (Crnokrak, 2017). Thus, trust, empowerment, impartiality and institutional uprightness
are interrelated, and are significant factors constructing positive leadership (Zbierowski, 2016).
Herein, it may be noted that although some of the constructs (i.e. trust, spirit of leadership etc.)
have been well-defined in extant literature, there is little empirical evidence that effectively
correlates positive leadership vis a vis its influence on trust, psychological empowerment and
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
4
employee flourishing at the workplace, especially within the context of Asian countries, and
particularly in India.
The information technology sector in India is growing rapidly and requires leaders to manage
human resources effectively in a cross cultural environment. This enables them to look at
positivity and building trust to enhance engagement at workplace. Historically speaking,
information technology sector has been challenged by leadership crises across levels, and
organisations are constantly looking at lateral hires to fill-in these positions. In fact, ITOs
generally look at developing leadership practices by investing on their employees to develop
their competencies in order to manage people and businesses better. Therefore, software
professionals often have a tough time, since they have to deal with both technology and people.
While on the one hand, they have to support their team members in their development and
manage clients, on the other, they have to manage the ‘technicalities’ programming of projects
towards achieving the expected results, often with multiple operational constraints. To
understand these factors, trust in the workplace and psychological empowerment are being used
as mediating variables, as they are crucial to understand and appreciate leadership behaviour.
The objective of this study is to examine software professionals’ experience of positive
leadership (PL), psychological empowerment (PE), trust and flourishing (FL) in the backdrop of
information technology organisations (TOs) in India. Additionally, we also investigate both the
indirect and direct mediating effect of trust and PE via both PL and FL.
DEVELOPMENT OF THEORY AND HYPOTHESES
This study adopted the positive leadership model’s framework
(Blanch
et al., 2016) to understand
the influence of certain positive employee behavioural outcomes. Notably, both positive
leadership and employee flourishing have been built on the broaden-and-build theory proposed
by Fredrickson’s (1998) based on positive psychology. Additionally, we also adopted Putnam’s
(1995) seminal work on trust to explore the individual’s association and self-confidence to
manage social conditions,which effectively fosters trust at the workplace. We also referred to
Spreitzer’s (1995) work on psychological empowerment to understand an individual’s
experience of the dimensions of competence, impact, self-direction and meaning at workplace.
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
5
POSITIVE LEADERSHIP
In today’s high-performing information technology organizations, it is imperative for leaders to
build trust in the workplace by acknowledging and valuing employees’ loyalty and treating them
fairly with respect. This empowers employees, while developing their strengths. The literature
indicates that in order to drive employees’ performance and their development into future
leaders, while creating value for the organisation, a leader’s positivity and emotional intelligence
(EI) are key components. Notably, the theoretical context of positive leadership has evolved over
time to include affirmative behaviours, ranging from transformational, ethical, authentic,
spiritual and servant leadership. Effectively the underlying belief across these leadership styles
focuses on both enabling and maintaining high standards of employees’ performance, by
engaging in shared constructive interactions between a leader and followers. Literature on
positive leadership has gained momentum, especially owing to the ‘positive psychology
movement ‘that evolved through positive forms of leadership theories, focusing on strengths,
positive perspective and recognition. However, empirical understanding, the developmental
process at large, along with the implementation of positive leadership and its sub-dimensional
behaviour seem to be ‘under-researched’, especially in the Asian context, and specifically in
India (Sunil and Patrick, 2019: 2018).
Positive leadership begins with the process of spreading positivity in an organisation, while
nurturing it over time as an integral part of organizational culture, in order to develop an
optimistic human capital. As noted earlier, a leader’s positivity forecasts and contributes towards
employee empowerment, effectively as a consequence of transformational leadership. Through
employee empowerment, transformational leaders inspire their followers by managing their
strengths towards their objectives and motivation (Bass, 1999). These leaders inspire their
followers by supervising them as persons (Bass, 1999) and this thought has been suggested by
Luthans (2002) and Arakawa and Greenberg’s (2007), whereby they stated that effective
leadership in essence is all about developing strengths and enhancing employee value, while
acknowledging their contribution towards both individual as well as organisational well-being.
Authentic leadership on the other hand, is drawn on positive organisational behaviour, which
develops employees’ strengths and psychological capacities towards positive outcomes at the
workplace (Gardner et al., 2005: Luthans, 2002)providing them a perspective on “what goes
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
6
right with them, what gives them life, what is experienced as good, what is inspiring and
extraordinary” (Cameron, 2008).Earlier, Arakawa and Greenberg’s (2007) had stated that a
positive perspective helps in interpreting problems by providing solutions, which in turn,
supports the findings on ‘resiliency’. Empowering leaders ensure that they give a free-hand to
employees in decision-making. Herein, it may be noted that Cameron (2012) for instance, has
enormously contributed to the study of positive leadership, vis a vis its influence, in the context
of developed economies. The authors have even suggested that leaders who choose to adopt
positive mannerisms create an optimistic work culture through trust in the workplace and
employee wellbeing. However, there seems to be a lack of empirical work, establishing the
relationship between positive leadership (directly or indirectly or otherwise) on employees
‘psychological and social well-being (Andony et al., 2016: Kelloway et al., 2013) and flourishing
(Seligman, 2011)
FLOURISHING
Seligman’s (2011) PERMA Theory advocated:“positive emotion; engagement, relationships,
meaning and purpose, and accomplishment are essential for individual’s well-being and
flourishing”. Further, the author also adopted the definition of Keyes’ (2002) seminal work on
flourishing, whereby he stated: individuals “having high levels of both hedonic and eudaimonic
well-being” is supported by positive psychology. Flourishing has been a fundamental concept in
positive psychology that is a blend of emotional, psychological, and social well-being. When
individuals begin to develop and prosper both personally and professionally, it reflects
flourishing, supporting the theory of subjective well-being. Flourishing inspires Positive
Organizational Scholarship (POS), leading to positive outcomes at the workplace, leading to both
individual and organisational profitability and well-being (Adams et al., 2019: Cameron and
Spreitzer, 2012). Work-related identities (Dutton et. al., 2010) also promote flourishing. Dutton,
et. al., (2010) stated: "Positive institution (pro-social practices) develops optimistic individuals
through the facilitation of positive identity construct) leading to an experience of positivity, i.e.
employee flourishing.“The factors mentioned herein help individuals to experience positive
emotions, such as increased self-confidence, a determination to succeed, and accountability
towards meaningful job. This quite fits the ‘requirement’ of employees working in ITOs, as they
need software professionals who are self-motivated and are committed towards their work
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
7
objectives. Therefore ,ITO’s leaders need to develop a work environment that fosters flourishing,
which consequently leaves a positive impression on the employees’ work experiences. Past
evidence indicates that individuals with high levels of ‘hedonic and eudaimonic well-being
experience, tend to engage in optimistic behaviour, leading to flourishing thereof (Seligman,
2011). However, by and large, extant literature does indicate a mixed relationship between
positive leadership and flourishing, especially among software professionals in India; thus this
study posits the first hypothesis:H1: Positive leaders do influence flourishing.
TRUST
We adopted Putnam’s (1993and 1995) and (Yamagishi and Yamagishi, 1994) works in order to
form a theoretical base, and thereby explore an individual’s relationship and confidence to
handle social situations, fostering social trust and/or trust. We have noted earlier that the
outcome of trust, does lead to employee increased collaboration, problem-solving ability and
transparent communication, which in turn, goes on to facilitate healthy and positive relations at
the workplace, while enhancing well-being both at an individual and an organisational level and
consequently raising organisational profits (Patrick and Sunil, 2019a: Ferres and Travaglione
2003). Trust has often been defined as a circumstance, which emotionally warrants confidence in
persons. The level of trust that an employee displays is possibly the logical outcome of effective
leadership, stemming from appropriate organisational policies and practices. Trust may also be
perceived as the leader’s attitude and his/her own perception of being trustworthy. In the context
of ITOs, when software professionals trust, they tend to emulate their leader's confidence by
exhibiting positive attitude, acting as a performance driver, enhancing better performance (Rubel
et al., 2018). Importantly, although trust is not ‘perceptible’ and tangible like remuneration and
perks, it is indeed a key component in encouraging organisational welfare and efficiency, thereby
bringing about a decline in costs. Existing literature stated that trust positively influences a
leader’s behavioural outcomes; although there is not much empirical evidence approving this
relationship (Andony et al., 2016, Cui et al., 2015). This study examines trust vis a vis employee
flourishing among Indian software professionals working in ITOs. Based on this and the
discussion that precedes, we put forth our second hypothesis:H2: Trust impacts flourishing.
PSYCHOLOGICAL EMPOWERMENT
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
8
We adopted Spreitzer’s (1995) theoretical work on dimensions of empowerment to investigate
the software professionals ‘experiencing empowerment, vis a vis their anticipated outcomes.
Since the 1980s, there has been an increased interest among researchers in the concept of
empowerment within psychology literature. Seibert, et al., (2011) defined personal
(psychological) empowerment (PE) as "intrinsic task motivation reflecting a sense of self-control
concerning one's work and an active involvement with one's work role."Thus, PE tends to
enhance a software professional’s level of motivation, his/her ability to take decisions, enhances
the performance level as well as well-being (Jena, Bhattacharyya and Pradhan, 2019: Patrick and
Sunil, 2019).
It is also observed in the literature that PE has a significant influence on organisational culture
due to its association with contextual factors and employees’ work behaviour. This may be owed
to the effects of positive leadership theories. This occurs because, ultimately, it is the leader’s
positivity that influences PE and organisational commitment (Walumbwa and Lawler, 2003),
leading to the development of employee trust, while enhancing both individual and
organisational performance and well-being (Lee, Jang and Lee, 2018). This study aims to
understand the influence of PE on flourishing. Although few literature review indicates a strong
relationship between PE and wellbeing (Rantika and Yustina, 2017: Pradhan et al., 2017), but
there seems to a lack of empirical evidence, supporting this relationship, especially within the
context of Indian software professionals in India. This discussion thereby leads us to our third
hypothesis:H3: Psychological empowerment does influence flourishing.
There seems to be a hardly any empirical evidence to establish the relationship between positive
leadership out rightly or otherwise on employee welfare, well-being (Andony et al., 2016) and/or
with mediators such as trust or PE. Nevertheless, ealier studies have indeed highlighted the
importance of trust; yet there are gaps in terms of understanding the mediating influence of trust,
employee work on performance, immediate supervisor’s actions, PE, work engagement, and
flourishing. Similarly, PE was found to have an indirect effect on leadership theories and
employee outlook (Barroso Castro et al., 2008), job satisfaction and satisfaction with life (Nelet
al., 2015: Dewettinck and Van Ameijde, 2011). Although Biswas-Diener, (2011) and Pradhan,
et. al., (2017) suggested that there may be an indirect effect with an individual’s well-being, but
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
9
there does not seem to be much empirical evidence with reference to flourishing. Additionally,
literature has also suggested that antecedents to trust in workplace have been relatively
unexplored (Patrick and Sunil, 2019a: Andony et al., 2016: Cui et al., 2015), especially in the
Indian context. Moreover, existing literature has revealed varied outcomes as regards the
facilitating aspect of PE and trust on theories of positive leadership (authentic, ethical, servant,
empowering, transformational). However, as mentioned earlier, there seems to be hardly any
empirical evidence supporting the constructs (i.e. leadership and flourishing) under the aegis of
positive leadership, in the context of ITOs in India. Based on these discussions, we frame the
next two hypotheses of our study:H4: Psychological Empowerment may have a mediating
effect on positive leadership and flourishing. H5: Trust may have a mediating effect on
positive leadership and flourishing.
The impetus for the examiners came from the obvious vacuum and varied outcomes in literature.
The literature provides insufficient empirical evidence integrating PL with TW, PE and FL.
Evidence co-relating PL with TW, PE, and flourishing showed mixed results. Although trust
plays a central role, its effect has not been researched (Cui et al., 2015). However, the mediating
effect of PE and TW has not been investigated on PL and flourishing. Organizational studies
continue to investigate the construct of flourishing. As it is an important employee experience
and the study attempts to explore. Developing PE and trust especially among software
professionals will lead to positive outcomes personally and professionally. Due to inadequate
empirical evidences about the mediating effect from available literature the authors proposed that
leaders through empowerment and trust may try to encourage positive emotions, interpersonal
flourishing and flourishing at the workplace (Cameron, 2010). Software professional’s self-
efficacy and positive emotions may have a significant relationship between trust and
empowerment (Biswas-Diener, 2011).Thus, flourishing is perceived as key positive
consequences of positive behaviours at the workplace, i.e. empowerment and trust. There is
some evidence that positive leadership results in increased flourishing due to factors such as
empowerment and trust (Zbierowskia and Górab 2014). When software professionals experience
positive work environment due to empowerment and trust, they may find the work meaningful
leading to the fulfilment of organisational and personal goals for software professionals to
flourish
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
10
Conceptual Model:
Figure 1: Encapsulates the theoretical archetype that directed this examination. In this study, PL
is viewed as an occupation (job) resource that certainly impacts PE, trust and FL. From Figure 1,
we deduce that PL should positively relate to FL, and may even have an indirect effect on FL
through PE and trust. This is why we proposed
METHODOLOGY
The study adopted a exploratory sequential mixed methods design approach, resulting in both
qualitative and quantitative investigation. This approach harness rigorous quantitative evidence,
as well as to capture the nuance and context-specificity, via qualitative work. Convergent
approach was used to compare findings from qualitative and quantitative data sources. For
example, the investigator can gather qualitative data to assess the personal experiences of
patients while also gathering data from survey instruments measuring the quality of care. The
two types of data can provide validation for each other and also create a solid foundation for
drawing conclusions about the intervention. To identify the ITOs and its respondents, the study
used stratified and judgemental sampling technique. Notably, these ITOs comprised both Indian
and foreign MNCs based out of India, and the participants were selected from the premium 25
ITOs, which form a part of India's $146-billion IT, sector.
Flourishing
(FL)
Positive Leader
Behaviour (PLB)
Psychological
Empowerment(P
E)
Trust
H4
H
3
H5
H1
H2
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
11
The qualitative data was used to explore quantitative findings. This explanatory sequential
design typically involves two phases: (1) an initial quantitative instrument phase, followed by (2)
a qualitative data collection phase, in which the qualitative phase builds directly on the results
from the quantitative phase. In this way, the quantitative results are explained in more detail
through the qualitative data. For example, findings from instrument data about costs can be
explored further with qualitative focus groups to better understand how the personal experiences
of individuals match up to the instrument results. This kind of study illustrates the use of mixed
methods to explain qualitatively how the quantitative mechanisms might work. The qualitative
questions were collected through the interview method. Based on the grounded theory the
datareceived were coded and analysed to quantify and examine the presence, meanings and
associations of certain words, themes, and/or concepts categorising them into themes. This
provided an understanding about the cultural insights (positive leadership experiences) through
analysis of text. This provided a direction for grouping them based on the sub-themes and its
relationship for analysis. This also highlighted those aspects that software professionals
(participants) frequently talked about in depth about their experiences at workplace due to their
immediate supervisor positive behaviour.
This method effectively helped us interpret the viewpoints of software professionals about their
positive experiences of their immediate supervisor leadership behaviour in terms of strength-
based approach, providing positive perspective and recognition at workplace. The data
(subjective) was analysed with reference to grounded theory (Glaser and Straus, 2017), which
involves coding and categorising of subjective data. Followed by thematic analysis (Cho and lee,
2014). Further, the most frequented phrases (positive statements)were grouped together to
construct themes and sub-themes. To further examine the nuances of immediate supervisor’s
leadership behaviours based on 1) strength-based approach: i.e. encouragement through a)
mentoring and coaching b) training programs c) providing similar tasks as per strength.2)
Positive perspective: a) regular support and guidance b) solving problems and helping in
understanding them c) assigning technical resources as additional support. 3) Recognition: a)
regular appreciation b) monthly c) quarterly d) once a year/not regular.
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
12
Notably, these quantitative findings supported in testing our model, the theories considered,
along with subjective experiences empirically. Our rationale was that the qualitative items would
complement the results of quantitative items, increasing thereby the credibility of the study,
whereby, we could possibly integrate the results of both the methods, and then discuss the
outcomes and draw implications. Importantly, the integration of the mixed methods did result in
higher quality of inferences (Tashakkori and Teddlie 2003).The inclusion parameters for
respondent identification was minimum of three years (3) of total work experience, out of which
minimum one and half years (1.6) in the current organisation, which in turn, must be among the
top twenty-five (25) ITOs as per National Association of Software and Services Companies
(NASSCOM) listing. Four consistent, binding and unvarying scales were espoused and
administered. This tenure (inclusion criteria) gives software professionals a better understanding
of their immediate supervisor and the organisational practices and culture and how immediate
supervisors respond to various situations during the time frame with consistency (eg: on
boarding, appraisals, project reviews & release and strength development, etc.)
Data were collected in three stages (August – Nov 2018: Dec – March2018-19 and May -
September 2019); this helped in minimising bias by including personal, social and economic
factors over fourteen (14) months, wherein five(5) items were actually reverse coded. As
mentioned earlier, the interview method was used for qualitative questions. We personally
visited the ITOs to collect data by meeting the respondents and administering the questionnaire;
however, some data were also collected through e-mails, and through online medium, using
Google.doc. The questionnaire was administered to 1800 respondents, out of which we received
983 fully completed questionnaires, yielding thereby a response rate of 54.6%.Notably, a
minimum of 30 software professionals were surveyed from each organisation.
The objective data was measured using statistical methods. Preliminary analyses were
conducted using SPSS (SPSS Inc., 2010), Sobel’s test and AMOS (Arbuckle, 2017). Both
Structural equation model (SEM) and AMOS were used to check the model fitness. All the fit
measures of the variables (CFI; GFI; NFI; RMSEA; and χ2/df) indices were in the acceptable
range (Bollen, 1989), confirming thereby the validity of the measure. Once the model fit was
established, we tested the hypotheses, using path coefficient analysis and Sobel’s test in order to
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
13
understand the mediating effect. Notably, the hypotheses model was tested and found to be fit
with the mediation variable, reporting p value <0.05, which effectively indicates a significant
mediating effect. The single factor obtained revealed a variance of 13.42%, which was lesser
than 50% of the overall variance of the scale. This also went on to prove that there was no
common minimum bias (CMB). Further, the study construct items were loaded mutually for their
respective constructs, along with single latent factor method. The factor loading analysis
indicates a clear distinction amid the dependent and the independent inclusion, along with the
discriminant variables.
MEASURING TOOLS
Four standardised, valid and reliable structured questionnaires were adopted to collect primary
data from the software professionals of top 25Indian ITOs.
Table 1: Indicating the Cronbach Alpha reliability for each of the scales for the present sample
n=983
Instrument Author/s Year
No.
of
items
Cronbach
alpha
The Positive Leadership
Measure ,
Margaret H. Greenberg
and Dana Arakawa 2007 20 0.85
Psychological
Empowerment Spreitzer, Gretchen M. 1995 12 0.90
Flourishing Scale Ed Diener and Robert
Biswas-Diener 2009 08 0.90
The participants responded to the items (in Table 1) through a seven-point scale, wherein 1
represented ‘very strongly disagree’to 7 represents ‘very strongly agree’. Notably, using the
seven-point scale does offer a balance, having sufficient points of discrimination, without
keeping several response options (Nunnally, 1978). The open-ended questions were content
analysed. All the demonstrated variables were within a limitation to the un-rotated sole factor,
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
14
adopting exploratory factor analysis (EFA) in SPSS 20.0 software. The participants’
demographics are presented in frequencies and percentages. Descriptive statistics (Mean and
Standard Deviation -SD), are presented for the variables under investigation. The correlation
values that strengthen the relationships are also presented. The influence of independent
variables on the dependent variable was measured using classical linear regression analysis.
Additionally, path analysis was analysed using SEM, and Sobel’s test for testing our proposed
model. Further, to examine the indirect influence of variables, we used the method propounded
by Preacher and Hayes, (2009).We also used SPSS's bootstrapping, Sobel test (Preacher and
Hayes, 2004) and AMOS (Arbuckle, 2010) for estimating the indirect effect in the simple
mediating model. Notably, the right processes of variables (CFI; GFI; NFI; RMSEA; and χ2/df)
guidelines were within a conventional range (Bollen, 1989), confirming cogency of the process
thereof.
RESPONDENTS PROFILE
All the respondents were software professionals having minimum three (3) years of total work
experience, and a minimum of one and half (1.5) years within the current organisation. The
sample distribution consisted of 61.7% men, and (38.3%) women respondents. 60.2% among
them were graduates, while 39.8% were post-graduates.39.2% were in the age group 26-30
years, while 28.6% were in the age group of 31-40 years. Lastly, (51.4%) were married, while
the rest (i.e. 48.6%) were single.
RESULTS
Mixed methods give a voice to study participants and ensure that study findings are grounded in
participants’ experiences. The qualitative data indicated that software professionals experienced
positive leadership behaviour at workplace in terms of immediate supervisors recognising their
work, providing positive perspective and developing their strengths to support them perform and
deliver their tasks. The quantitative analysis indicated that PL, PE, trust and FL are all
approximately normally distributed as per skewness and kurtosis values. Thus, it may be
affirmed that software professionals working in ITOs in India do experience PL, PE, trustand
flourishing. Importantly, significant correlations exist between these constructs; for instance,
both PE and trust mediate the relationship between PL and FL. The overall intensity of the
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
15
relationship among the dimensions of PL, PE, trust and FL were notably moderate to low, though
all relationships were significant at the (.01level). The highest relationship was found between
PE and FL, followed by PL and FL, while the least was PL and trust (Refer Table 2).This was
followed by calculating the means for all measures, and gauging correlations amid the
constructs. Notably, all the constructs exhibited significant associations with the research model,
where in the fitness was ‘acceptable’, indicating thereby that the model does fit the data well,
indicating a p value =<0.001.χ2 (180)/df(46) =3.91, CFI = 0.98, RMSEA = 0.46; thus, the results
meet our expectation.
Objective 1: To measure software professionals’ experience of PL, trust in workplace, PE and
FL.
The Study results indicate that Indian software professionals do experience PL, due to their
immediate supervisors, who advocate being optimistic in terms of work-related attitude; provide
support and recognise their contribution with a mean score (4.92). Further, among the sub-
dimensions of PL, we note that 'perspective' had the highest mean (5.11), alluding to the fact that
the supervisors did support the software professionals/employee in terms of solution orientation,
and help them in terms of perceiving a problem positively. This was followed by ‘recognition’
(4.83), alluding to the fact that the supervisors did frequently encourage and reward the
accomplishments of the employees. Further, in terms of ‘strengths’ (4.83), the results affirm that
the supervisors did appreciate their employees’ strengths, while matching their talents to tasks
(Arakawa and Greenberg, 2007).
Additionally, it may be noted that software professionals strongly agreed that they experienced
PE holistically (5.57) (i.e. along with its sub-dimensions). They experienced high 'meaning'
(5.86), followed by 'impact' (5.52), 'self-determination' (5.49) and 'competence' (5.42). However,
they moderately 'agreed' to 'competence', i.e. their confidence about their capability to do their
work well. Furthermore, they also 'agreed' to 'self-determination'; i.e. they were free to make
their decisions, and perform their assignments in their own ways without being micromanaged.
They also experienced emotional development through SI and emotion, due to the prevailing
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
factor of ‘trust’(4.47).
Thus, they experienced
relationships, meaning and accomplishment
The qualitative study served
as
experiences from the
immediate supervisor
perspective and acknowledging ones
understand the results,
and further interpret the quantitative results.
Table 2 (insert):
Interprets the vi
Source: The Author’s Analysis
Interestingly,23.5%
of the software professionals
was no support or guidance,
and 14%
Table 3: Descriptive Statistics, Model
1. Positive Leadership (PL) and its dimensions and its influence on Flourishing (FL).
2. PE and its dimensions and its influence on Flourishing (FL)
3. Trust and its influence on Flourishing (FL)
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
Thus, they experienced
FL (5.40) due to positive
relationships, meaning and accomplishment
at the workplace (
Refer Table
as
a guiding principle in order to understand
and appreciate
immediate supervisor
,
in terms of developing strengths, providing positive
perspective and acknowledging ones
’
contribution via recognition. This allowed
and further interpret the quantitative results.
Interprets the vi
ewpoint of software professionals through qualitative responses
Source: The Author’s Analysis
of the software professionals
did not experience
development,
and 14%
expressed lack of recognition and
encouragement.
Table 3: Descriptive Statistics, Model
Summary, nova
and Coefficient values of:
1. Positive Leadership (PL) and its dimensions and its influence on Flourishing (FL).
2. PE and its dimensions and its influence on Flourishing (FL)
3. Trust and its influence on Flourishing (FL)
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
16
emotion, engagement,
Refer Table
3).
and appreciate
positive
in terms of developing strengths, providing positive
contribution via recognition. This allowed
us to better
ewpoint of software professionals through qualitative responses
development,
13% felt there
encouragement.
and Coefficient values of:
1. Positive Leadership (PL) and its dimensions and its influence on Flourishing (FL).
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
17
Source: The Author’s Analysis
Table 4: A Pearson product-moment correlation coefficient indicated a significant correlation
between the variables at p = 0.01
Positive
Leadership
Psychological
Empowerment
Trust
Positive Leadership
1
Psychological
Empowerment
.398
**
1
Trust
.251
**
.296
**
1
Flourishing
.413
**
.691
**
.321**
**. Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
*. Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).
Source: The Author’s Analysis
The strongest relationship was seen between FL and PE (.691), while the weakest significant
relationship was between trust and PL (.251). Further, in order to test the hypotheses, we used
multiple regressions that resulted in positive leadership, influencing both the dependent and
mediating variables. After controlling for demographic variables and PL, trust in workplace and
PE were significantly associated with FL. Notably, PL successfully predicts FL (R2=17.6,
P<0.01), while trust successfully predicts FL (R2=9.2%, P<0.01), and PE (R2=4.93, P<0.01).
PL
STG
PER
REC
PE
MEN
IMP
SD
COMP
Trust
FLR
Mean
4.92
4.83
5.11
4.83
5.57
5.86
5.52
5.49
5.42
4.47
5.56
SD
0.66
0.828
0.792
0.814
0.635
0.713
0.714
0.787
0.731
0.678
0.678
Model
Summary R2 17.6
49.3
9.8
Annova
F
63.638
217.119
96.944
Sif
0.000b
0.000b
0.000b
B
0.108
0.21
0.113
0.192
0.355
0.152
0.98
0.312
Coefficient
t
3.379
6.943
3.604
6.010
9.068
4.837
0.98
9.846
Sig
0.001
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.00
0
0.327
0.000
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
18
H1. Positive leadership does influence flourishing
PL, along with its dimensions significantly influences FL, thereby predicting a variance of
(17.6%) at (P < 0 .001). Among the sub-dimensions, strength, perspective and recognition
significantly predicted FL at (P<0.001) levels (Refer Table3). Thus, H1 is accepted, whereby we
affirm that PL does significantly influence FL.
H2: Trust does influence impact flourishing (FL)
Software professionals did acknowledge that they did have an emotional connect with their
immediate supervisors, resulting in experiencing trust at workplace, which in turn, influenced
flourishing at a variance of (9.8%)at (P< 0.000)level, (Refer Table3). Thus, H2too is accepted.
H3: Psychological Empowerment does influence flourishing
PE predicts (49.3%) of the variance, and thereby significantly influences FL at P< 0.000 level.
Among the sub-dimensions, meaning’ (B=0.192, P<.000) ‘self-determination’ (B=.152, P<.000)
and impact (B=.357, P<.000) significantly predict FL (Refer Table 3), indicating thereby that PE
is indeed adequate in influencing FL, while affirming that H3too is accepted.
H4: Psychological Empowerment does indirectly influence the relationship amid positive
leadership and flourishing.
The model specifies that PE (intervening variable) mediates with the three predictors of PL and
FL, at an indirect variance of(60.36% at P<0.001 level). Notably, the ratio of the indirect to the
direct effect is (1.5%, Refer Figure 2).Additionally, it may also be noted that PL does influence
FL both directly and indirectly through PE; therefore, H4 is also accepted(refer to table 5).
Figure 2: demonstrating the direct and in-direct paths amid PL and PE; PE and FL; PL and FL;
PL-PE-FL. IV: Independent Variable.
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
Source: Author’s analysis
Table 5: Gist of outcome of Sobel’s test for mediation of the relationship between Positive
Leadership (PL) and Flourishing (FL) by Psych
Hypothesized
Sobel Test Percentage of the total Ratio of the indirect
Mediating Effect Statistic
H4: PL - PE –
FL 11.469
______________________________________________________________________________
Source: The Author’s Analysis
Table 6: Regression Analysis for Significance of Mediation of PE in the Path PL
IV DV
PL FL
PL PE
PL FL
PE
PL
.385(.398)
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
Table 5: Gist of outcome of Sobel’s test for mediation of the relationship between Positive
Leadership (PL) and Flourishing (FL) by Psych
ological Empowerment (PE)
Sobel Test Percentage of the total Ratio of the indirect
effect that is mediated to the direct effect P
FL 11.469
60.361 1.522
______________________________________________________________________________
Source: The Author’s Analysis
Table 6: Regression Analysis for Significance of Mediation of PE in the Path PL
Un-
Standardised
Coefficient
B
Standardised
Coefficient
Beta
t value p-
value
0.424 0.413 13.574
<.001
0.385 0.398 12.999
<.001
0.168 0.164 6.354
<.001
0.665 0.626 24.302
<.001
PE
FL
.424(.413)
For PE as IV
.665 (.626)
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
19
Table 5: Gist of outcome of Sobel’s test for mediation of the relationship between Positive
ological Empowerment (PE)
Sobel Test Percentage of the total Ratio of the indirect
effect that is mediated to the direct effect P
-value
<.001
______________________________________________________________________________
Table 6: Regression Analysis for Significance of Mediation of PE in the Path PL
- PE - FL
value
R
2
<.001
0.17
<.001
0.159
<.001
0.5
<.001
For PE as IV
.168 (.164)
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
Table 7. Relative standardize
d direct effect, relative standardized indirect effects and relative
total effects for independent variable Positive Leadership (PL), mediating variables
and dependent variables –
Flourishing (FL)
Mediation Path
Direct Effect
PL
PE
FL .168**
** effects are significant at p<.001 (2 tailed tests of significance)
Source: The Author’s Analysis
H5: Trust does mediate the relationship between positive leadership and flourishing.
Results indicate that trust (intervening variable) mediates with the three predictors of both PL
and FL at a mediating variance of (13.55 %, at P<0.001). The ratio of both the indirect and direct
effect is (0.15%, Refer Figure 3). PL influences FL both di
thus, H5 is supported (refer to Table 8).
Table 8: Summary of results of Sobel’s test for mediation of the relationship between Positive
Leadership (PL) and Flourishing (FL) by trust
Hypothesized
Sobel Test Per
Mediating Effect Statistic effect that is mediated to the direct effect P
H5: PL - trust –
FL 5.341 13.555
_____________________________________________________________________________
Source: The Authors Analysis
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
d direct effect, relative standardized indirect effects and relative
total effects for independent variable Positive Leadership (PL), mediating variables
Flourishing (FL)
Direct Effect
Indirect Effect Total Effect
.322** .490**
** effects are significant at p<.001 (2 tailed tests of significance)
Source: The Author’s Analysis
H5: Trust does mediate the relationship between positive leadership and flourishing.
Results indicate that trust (intervening variable) mediates with the three predictors of both PL
and FL at a mediating variance of (13.55 %, at P<0.001). The ratio of both the indirect and direct
effect is (0.15%, Refer Figure 3). PL influences FL both di
rectly and indirectly through trust;
thus, H5 is supported (refer to Table 8).
Table 8: Summary of results of Sobel’s test for mediation of the relationship between Positive
Leadership (PL) and Flourishing (FL) by trust
Sobel Test Per
centage of the total Ratio of the indirect
Mediating Effect Statistic effect that is mediated to the direct effect P
FL 5.341 13.555
0.1
56
_____________________________________________________________________________
Source: The Authors Analysis
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
20
d direct effect, relative standardized indirect effects and relative
total effects for independent variable Positive Leadership (PL), mediating variables
- PE (PE)
Decision
Partial Mediation
H5: Trust does mediate the relationship between positive leadership and flourishing.
Results indicate that trust (intervening variable) mediates with the three predictors of both PL
and FL at a mediating variance of (13.55 %, at P<0.001). The ratio of both the indirect and direct
rectly and indirectly through trust;
Table 8: Summary of results of Sobel’s test for mediation of the relationship between Positive
centage of the total Ratio of the indirect
Mediating Effect Statistic effect that is mediated to the direct effect P
-value
56
<.001
_____________________________________________________________________________
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
21
Gist of outcome of Sobel’s test for mediation of the relationship between Positive Leadership
(PL) and Flourishing (FL) by trust
Figure 3: Demonstrating the direct and mediating routes amidst PL and Trust; Trust and FL; PL
and FL; PL-Trust:-FL.
Source: The Author’s Analysis: Note: IV: Independent Variable
Table 9: Summary of Regression Analysis for Significance of Mediation of trust in
the Path PL – Trust - FL
IV DV
Un-
Standardised
Coefficient
B
Standardised
Coefficient
Beta
t value p-
value R
2
PL FL 0.424 0.413 13.574 <.001 0.17
PL Trust 0.258 0.251 7.778 <.001 0.063
PL FL 0.367 0.357 11.682 <.001 0.217
Trust 0.223 0.223 7.288 <.001
Source: The Author’s Analysis
TRUST
FL
PL
.258(.251)
.424(.413)
For PL as IV
.367(.357)
For TRUST as
IV .223(.223)
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
22
Table 10: Relative standardized direct effect, relative standardized indirect effects and relative
total effects for independent variable Positive Leadership (PL), mediating variables - Trust and
dependent variables - Flourishing (FL)
Mediation Path Direct Effect Indirect Effect Total Effect Decision
PL
trust
FL .428** .059** .487** Partial Mediation
** effects are significant at p<.001 (2 tailed tests of significance)Source: The Author’s Analysis
Source: The Author’s Analysis
DISCUSSION
The hypotheses, all being ‘accepted’, do indicate that PL predicts positivity, and foes have a
positive influence on software developers. They experienced PL at the workplace due to their
immediate supervisors going on to enhance their level of trust, PE and FL. Further, based on our
results, we also affirm that PL significantly predicts FL both directly and indirectly with trust in
workplace and PE, confirming thereby that overall; PL does have significant influence on the
study constructs.
Holistically speaking, the results revealed that IT leaders nurtured positive deviance in order to
accomplish both individual and organisational objectives with effectiveness. While most
leadership studies continue to focus explicitly around traits of leaders, researchers need to focus
on the quality of the process of influence by concentrating on positivity, trust and empowerment
which strengthens and sustains the leaders influence on followers. However it is relevant to
appreciate the significance of heliotropic effect and positive deviant performance, contributing
towards employee flourishing. The salience of this study is that it captures the software
professional’s experience of PL at workplace, as demonstrated by the immediate supervisor.
Evidences from this study both qualitative and quantitative go on to reinforce leadership
literature, by focusing on the relationship between the leader and the follower (i.e. employee),
which effectively stands out due to the intermediating factors of ‘enhanced trust’ (Brower et al.,
2000), empowerment (Shahid and Muchiri,2019) work engagement (Sunil and Patrick, 2021)
and wellbeing and flourishing (Cherkowski et al., 2020).
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
23
Our qualitative study points out that immediate supervisor do have higher level of engagement
with software professionals via positive perspective practices. When software professionals
experience meaning, impact, competence and self-determination, they become rationally alert,
emotionally accessible, and thereby are driven and motivated to carry out their assignments with
vigour and dedication. The quantitative results of the study indicate that apart from competence,
all the other sub-dimensions do have a positive relationship with FL, supporting thereby the
study of the Self-determination Theory (SDT) (Ryan et al., 2008).When software professionals
do experience meaning in their work, it goes on to contribute towards the larger organisational
objectives (self-determination and impact), which in turn, goes on to increase their level of well-
being (Kelloway et al., 2013), yielding therefore in lesser turnover intentions (Jena et al, 2019:
Rantika and Yustina,2017). Additionally, the software professionals’ trust is positively related to
their social associations, and is effectively reflected in the society at large, due to their free-
thinking and value systems. In fact, trust could even be the most important unnoticed benefit in
terms of flourishing. The study results go on to reinforce that trusting behaviour is indeed vital,
irrespective of the economy or the sector. It is also an important factor towards enhancing
employee well-being, and organisational performance at large. Interestingly, literature does not
seem to support the fact that trust is different for software professionals in different countries or
economies. Nevertheless, Edelman’s Trust Barometer report, (2019) suggested that Indians
software professionals are the most trusted globally.
The mediating hypothesis model was tested and was found to be a good fit. The structural
equation modelling approach permits to deal with more than one variable as sole latent variable.
By using the items means its sub-facets are its dimension pointers in the path-analysis indicating
significant relationship amid positive leadership directly and indirectly on flourishing via
psychological empowerment and trust. A positive leader's approach in ITO not only builds trust
among software professionals but also enhances psychological well-being, due to immediate
supervisors empowering behaviour. Path analysis indicated that psychological empowerment
positively influences flourishing. However, the self-efficacy of software professionals do
eliminate the shortcoming and provide them the capability to learn, develop and flourish
supporting previous research (Biswas-Diener, 2011: Cameron, 2010: Dutton, et al., 2010). The
results confirm that psychological empowerment does facilitate the association with flourishing
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
24
and positive leadership increases employees overall flourishing (Dewettinck and Van Ameijde,
2011: Cameron, 2010). The study also suggests a significant association with positive
leadership’s recognition and flourishing. The study’s mediating result aligns with previous
research indicating that positive leadership theories increases social well-being and flourishing
due to empowerment (Zbierowskia and Górab 2014: Cameron, 2012: Dhiman, 2011).The second
path analysis indicates that trust positively influences flourishing. When software professional’s
experiences trust it increases employee morale leading to self-efficacy, loyalty, higher
performance, efficiency (Covey and Merrill, 2018) and flourishing (Witt, 2017: McQuaid, 2016:
Keyes, 2014). Due to higher level of trust experienced by software professionals in workplace
they are likely to become organisations brand ambassadors (78%), demonstrate loyalty (74%),
appreciate organisational values (71%), and committed to their jobs (83%) as per (Edelman Trust
Barometer, 2019). Though Cui et al. (2015) indicated that social trust in workplace is being
moderately unexplored, the study accentuates that trust is abundant in facilitating flourishing.
Research indicates that trust and well-being is positively impacted due to the positive association
of immediate supervisor enhancing recognition, better engagement and employee flourishing
(Gough, 2018:Witt, 2017).
The mixed method outcomes in the study contributes to the existing debates in the leadership
studies (in terms of team member’s positive experiences).The study highlights the software
professional’s positive experiences in the process of underlining the importance of recognition,
strength based and positive perspective approach with reference to employee flourishing at
workplace. The mixed method analysis emphasise the importance of positive leadership and
further enhances the understanding of virtuous behaviour at workplace towards flourishing. The
outcomes of this method add new insights to one-another. Example: the quantitative survey
indicates the software professional’s perception of positive perspective demonstrated by
immediate supervisor is 5.11 Mean score in a scale of 7, whereas the qualitative analysis
indicates 87%. The qualitative study integrates with the quantitative results indicating that the
positive leadership sub-dimensions builds an atmosphere of trust, obligation and enablement,
which is essential for software developers to execute their tasks with higher level of engagement.
These factors allow them to explore new ideas, experiment, and support through recognition and
constructive feedback boosting their morale, self-confidence and trust (Tiwari and Lenka, 2019).
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
25
As organisations need to create value and develop leaders, positive leadership is a significant
behaviour that could enhance psychological empowerment and trust in workplace directly and
indirectly to enhance flourishing.
PRACTICAL IMPLICATION
The study highlighted the need for developing positive leadership practices, which are likely to
develop positive deviant performance of software professionals leading to positive work
environment and flourishing. The implications for practice thereby must look at interventions in
organisations that are specifically designed to enhance positive leadership, empowerment, trust
and flourishing among employees. Thus far, most of the studies conducted under the aegis of
service organisations considered at mitigating the negative deviance with reference to
organisational health index, especially stress, turnover etc. (Kelloway et al., 2008). However,
thestudy did indicate that in order to enhance employee flourishing, it is necessary to increase
positive experiences at the workplace via positive deviance interventions
Literature supported the effectiveness of leadership development interventions (Avolio, et al.,
2009), and the current studydoes indicate that when immediate supervisors practice positivity or
positive leadership, it is operationalized within a goal-setting framework (Locke and Latham,
2002), going on to enhance employee flourishing. Thus, in today’s world, it is almost obligatory
for organisations to invest on positive leadership programs, and trust development workshops,
which would enhance an individual’s positive practices, including affirmative behaviour in terms
of engaging in strength-based approach. Further, organisational practices and policies must
reflect upon positive practices and virtuous behaviour, so that employees can perform, and
achieve their optimal potential, and thereby contribute significantly to the larger organisational
objectives. Importantly, as ITOs require software professionals not only to excel in their
assignments but also to develop positive leadership traits to manage and work with teams,
customers and other stakeholders, the findings of our study would be highly relevant.
THEORETICAL IMPLICATION AND FUTURE RESEARCH
This study significantly adds value to the subject on PL, as we were unable to trace any study
that investigates all the four variables (i.e. PL, trust, PE and FL) in a single research. This study
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
26
shed light on the association of immediate supervisors and employees, wherein the former acts as
an intrinsic motivator in affecting organizational and individual-level positive behavioural
outcomes. Further, this study establishes trust in workplace and PE as a significant mediating
variable that in turn, influences FL, contributing thereby to extant literature thereof. On the other
hand, we did note that PE significantly increases the influence on DV (dependent variable-
flourishing) indirectly; while trust in workplace decreases the influence on DV indirectly,
although both do have significant interrelationship, and they influence DV.
The results also indicate that there is an influence of positive leadership on software
professionals in the given context of ITOs; however, this finding does demand a further re-look,
possibly through a longitudinal study based on the theories of organisational behaviour
(Kellowayand Francis, 2012). This study did focus on daily interaction between immediate
supervisor and the employees, asserting thereby the former’s affirmative behaviour (i.e. strength
development, positive perspective and recognition). Additionally, it may also be noted that PL
experienced by software professionals, does enhance leadership development; and these positive
behaviours do significantly influence workplace behaviour at large, concurring thereby with the
earlier study by Mullen and Kelloway, (2009).
The studies does have good inferences about the mediating roles of trust and psychological
empowerment between positive leadership and flourishing indicating that longitudinal and
experimental study will add further value to understand the causal relationships between the
constructs. Though theoretically literature indicates there is a strong rationale that positive
leadership theories as a contextual constructs relate to flourishing via perception or enhancement
of trust in workplace and psychological empowerment. Earlier studies indicate that longitudinal
research has resulted in leadership precedes employee well-being (Nielsen, Randall, Yarker, and
Brenner, 2008).
This study focused only on PL influencing FL; based on the same, future research could possibly
investigate how employees’ psychological and emotional well-being can be related to PL, trust
and PE. Future studies can also explore the leadership theories such as authentic (George, 2003)
servant (Greenleaf, 2002), social processes (Parry, 1998), leader-member-exchange (Graen and
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
27
Uhl-Bien, 1995), ethical (Brown et al., 2005) and transformational (Bass, 1985) are primarily
associated with positive deviance and flourishing. Employee well-being is determined by an
individual's job role (Spreitzer et al., 2005), suggesting investigating the various roles in ITO and
its influence on employee flourishing. Examination can lead to an organizational design
blueprint that leads to higher software professionals' experience of flourishing. Future research
can investigate in what conditions, role requirements, type and size of organizations; the
experience of flourishing may not be desirable or may also have an unfavourable influence and
positive leadership being not effective. Optimistic emotions increase the relationship amid
psychological empowerment and engagement (Spreitzer, 2007), indicating a substantial
relationship between engagement, well-being and employee thriving (Spreitzer et al., 2010).
Researchers can also investigate whether PE can affect team-members flourishing via leader’s
positive emotions or psychological capital indirectly (mediator). These studies will contribute
towards the positive psychology literature (Seligman and Csikszentmihalyi, 2000), as well add to
Frederickson’s (2001) theory of broaden-and-build. This study proposed only two mediators;
future researchers could investigate other constructs, both as mediators and moderators and/or
even as serial mediation in order to discuss the association of positive leadership vis a vis its
influence. Additionally, this paper focused on employee flourishing in the context of software
professionals, owing to the positive leadership qualities of the immediate supervisor. Lot of
emphasis has indeed been laid on the supervisor-team-member relationship (i.e. leader–member-
exchange) (Graen and Uhl-Bien, 1995). Thus, these aspects could also be scrutinized further to
lend newer insights, which in turn, would add value to literature, in terms of understanding
whether positive leadership does complement this theory.
The study used self-report instrument because the variables were individual and personal expect
positive leadership. The respondents were to talk about their experience about the constructs. In
the case of positive leadership they were sharing the experience based on their immediate
supervisor. Notably, to diminish common method bias, the questionnaire was administered in
three phases, the respondents of these organisations were met at different points in time some
items were reverse coded. On the other hand, mixed-method was espoused, where some of the
quantitative outcomes complemented qualitative data. The study items were well-designed with
multiple factor statements which reduces the CMB (Spector, 1987).
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
28
Conclusion
In today’s fast changing and uncertain economy, both leaders and employees need positivity, not
only to cope with current situation, but to build trust in workplace, empower, innovate and
flourish. When leaders do empower their team members, it adds ownership and accountability to
the existing role. This drives result-oriented performance, and thereby creates a sense of
appreciation and meaningfulness. The mixed method adds value to the study by improving the
rationality and consistency of the data and reinforces the causal inferences by providing the
opportunity to witness data convergence in terms of positive leadership experiences at
workplace. Positive leadership and flourishing are intertwined, i.e., the development of strength-
based, positive perspective and recognition do create positive organisational culture for software
professionals to flourish. Positive leaders effectively lay the foundations for true leadership
success and employee development towards flourishing. This study suggests that
supervisors/leaders have added influence on team members/employees in terms of experiencing
positivity in the workplace directly and indirectly leading to trust, psychological empowerment,
productivity, commitment, higher level of engagement, along with satisfaction and flourishing.
REFERENCES
Adams, G.B., Meyers, C.M and Sekaja, L. (2019).Positive Leadership: Relationships with
employee inclusion, discrimination, and well-being. Applied Psychology: An International
Review, 0 (0), 1–29 doi: 10.1111/apps.12230
Andony, T., Gorjian, N., and Finkelman, J. (2016).Effects of positive leadership and flow on
employee well-being through the PERMA Lens. Austin Journal of Psychiatry andBehavioral
Sciences, 3(1), 1051.
Andrzej Krzysztof Kozminski and Anna Katarzyna Baczynska, Ilona Skoczen and Pawel Korzynski
(2022), Towards leadership effectiveness: the role of leadership individual competencies and constraints.
Introduction of the Bounded Leadership Model. Leadership & Organization Development Journal Vol. 43
No. 4, 2022 pp. 596-611 Emerald Publishing Limited 0143-7739 DOI 10.1108/LODJ-04-2020-015
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
29
Arakawa, D., and Greenberg, M. (2007). Optimistic managers and their influence on productivity
and employee engagement in a technology organisation: Implications for coaching
psychologists. International Coaching Psychology Review, 2(1), 78–89.
Avolio, B.J. and Luthans, F. (2006). The High Impact Leader: Authentic, Resilient Leadership
That Gets Results and Sustains Growth, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY.
Avolio, B. J., Walumbwa, F. O., & Weber, T. J. (2009). Leadership: Current theories, research,
and future directions. Annual Review of Psychology, 60, 421–449.
doi:10.1146/annurev.psych.60.110707.163621
Barroso Castro, C., Villegas Perinan, M.M., and CasillasBueno, J.C. (2008). Transformational
leadership and follower’s attitudes: The mediating role of psychological empowerment.
International Journal of Human Resource Management, 19, 1842–1863.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/09585190802324601
Bass, B.M. (1999). Two decades of research and development in transformational leadership.
European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 8(9), 32.
Biswas-Diener, R. (2011).Manipulating happiness: Maria Montessori, International Journal of
Wellbeing, Vol. 1, No. 2, .214–225, DOI:10.5502/ijw. v1i2.4.
Brower, H.H., Schoorman, F.D., and Tan, H.H. (2000) A model of relational leadership:The
integration of trust and leader–member exchange. The Leadership Quarterly,11(2), 227–250.
Cameron, K.S.(2010).Five keys to flourishing in trying times, Leader to Leader, 2010(55), 45-51
Cameron, K. S. (2012). Positive leadership: Strategies for extraordinary performance. San
Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler.
Cameron, K., and Spreitzer, G. (2012).Applying a POS to bring out the best in organisations’,
Organisational Dynamics, 41, 85–88. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.orgdyn.2012.01.001.
Cameron, K.S., Dutton, J.E. and Quinn, R.E. (2003).Positive Organizational Scholarship –
Foundations of a New Discipline, Berrett-Koehler Publishers, San Francisco, CA.
Cherkowski, S., Kutsyuruba, B. and Walker, K. (2020). Positive leadership: animating purpose,
presence, passion and play for flourishing in schools, Journal of Educational Administration,
Vol. 58 No. 4, 401-415
Cooperrider, D.L. and Srivastva, S. (1987). Appreciative inquiry in organizational life, Research
in Organizational Change and Development, Vol. 1, 129-169
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
30
Covey, S. M. R., and Merrill, R. R. (2018). The speed of trust: The one thing that changes
everything. New York, NY: Simon and Schuster.
Cui, V., Vertinsky, I., Robinson, S., and Branzei, O. (2015). Trust in the workplace: The role of
social interaction diversity in the community and in the workplace. Business and Society, 1–35.
Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1177/0007650315611724
Dewettinck, K., and Van Ameijde, M. (2011). Linking leadership empowerment behaviour to
employee attitudes and behavioural intentions: Testing the mediating role of psychological
empowerment. Personnel Review, 40, 284–305. http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/00483481111118621
Dutton, J. E., Roberts, L. M., and Bednar, J. (2010).Prosocial practices, positive identities and
flourishing at work. In S. Donaldson, M. Csikszentmihalyi, and J. Nakamura (Eds.), Applied
positive psychology: Improving everyday life, schools, work, health, and society. Hove and New
York, NY: Psychology Press.
Ferres, N., and Travaglione, A. (2003). The development and validation of the workplace trust
survey (WTS): Combining qualitative and quantitative methodologies. Paper presented at
APROS, Mexico.
Fredrickson, B. L. (1998). What good are positive emotions’? Review of General
Psychology2(3): 300–319. doi: 10.1037/1089-2680.2.3.300
Graen, G.B., and Uhl-Bien, M. (1995). Relationship-based approach to leadership: Development
of leader-member exchange (LMX) theory of leadership over 25 years: Applying a multi-level
multi-domain perspective. The Leadership Quarterly, 6(2), 219–247.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/1048-9843(95)90036-5.
Gardner, W.L., Avolio, B.J., Luthans, F., May, D.R., and Walumbwa, F. (2005).Can you see the
real me? A self-based model of authentic leader and follower development. The Leadership
Quarterly, 16, 343–372. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.leaqua.2005.03.003
George, B. (2003). Authentic Leadership: Rediscovering the secrets to creating lasting value. San
Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
Gilbreath, B. & Benson, P.G. (2004). The contribution of supervisor behaviour to employee
psychological well-being. Work & Stress, 18, 255266.
Greenleaf, R. K. (2002). Servant leadership: A journey into the nature of legitimate power and
greatness (25th anniversary ed.) (L. C. Spears, Ed.). Paulist Press.
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
31
Hasanat, O., Alhelalat, J.A. and Valeri, M. (2021), Women Leadership in the Jordanian Hospitality
Sector: Obstacles and Future Opportunities , Valeri, M. and Katsoni, V. (Ed.) Gender and Tourism,
Emerald Publishing Limited, Bingley, pp. 149-158. https://doi.org/10.1108/978-1-80117-322-320211009
Jena, K. L., Bhattacharyya, P. and Pradhan, S. (2019). Am I empowered through meaningful
work? The moderating role of perceived flexibility in connecting meaningful work and
psychological empowerment. IIMB Management Review (2019) 31, 298–308.
www.elsevier.com/locate/iimb
Kelloway, E. K., Day, A., and Hurrell, J. J. (2008).Workplace interventions for occupational
stress. In M. Sverke, J. Hellegren, & K. Naswall (Eds.), The individual in the changing working
life (pp. 419-441). Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.
Kelloway, E. K., and Francis, L. (2012).Longitudinal research and data analysis. In R. R.
Sinclair, M. Wang & L. E. Tetrick (Eds.), Research methods in occupational health psychology:
Measurement, design and data analysis. New York, NY: Routledge.
Kelloway, E.K., Weigand, H., McKee, M.C., & Das, H. (2013).Positive leadership and employee
well-being.Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies, 20(1), 107– 117.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/1548051812465892
Keyes, C. (2014). Happiness, Flourishing, and Life Satisfaction.The Wiley Blackwell
encyclopedia of health, illness, behaviour, and society.747-751.
https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118410868.wbehibs45
Kumar., R. S., and Patrick., H. A. (2018). Driving performance through positive
leadership.Journal of Positive Management. Vol. 9, No. 3, 2018, pp. 17–33.
http://dx.doi.org/10.12775/JPM.2018.146
Luthans, F. (2002) Positive Organizational Behavior: Developing and Managing Psychological
Strengths. Academy of Management Executive, 16, 57-75.
Locke, E. A., and Latham, G. P. (2002).Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and
task motivation: A 35-year odyssey. American Psychologist, 57(9), 705–717.
https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.57.9.705
McQuaid, M. (2016).Five ways to flourish at work.Retrieved from https://www.
michellemcquaid.com/5-ways-flourish-work/(feb 2018)
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
32
Nielsen, K., Randall, R., Yarker, J and Brenner, S (2008). The effects of transformational
leadership on followers’ perceived work characteristics and psychological well-being: A
longitudinal study. Work and Stress-work stress. 22. 16-32. 10.1080/02678370801979430.
Norman, S.M., Avolio, B.J. and Luthans, F. (2010).The impact of positivity and transparency on
trustin leaders and their perceived effectiveness.The Leadership Quarterly,Vol. 21(3), 350-364.
Nunnally, J. C. (1978) ‘Psychometric theory’, (2nd ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill
Osland, J.S., Li, M. and E. Mendenhall, M. (2016), Introduction: Advancing the Field of Global
Leadership, Advances in Global Leadership (Advances in Global Leadership, Vol. 9), Emerald Group
Publishing Limited, Bingley, pp. 1-11. https://doi.org/10.1108/S1535-120320160000009002
Parry, W.K (1998). Grounded theory and social process: A new direction for leadership research,
The Leadership Quarterly, Volume 9, Issue 1, pp 85-105, ISSN 1048-9843,
https://doi.org/10.1016/S1048-9843(98)90043-1.
Pradhan, R. K., Hati, Lopamudra. and Kumar, Updesh. (2017).Impact of employee wellbeing on
psychological empowerment: the mediating role of happiness. International Journal of
Manufacturing Technology and Management. Vol. 31, No. 6,pp
Preacher, K. J., and Hayes, A. F. (2009).Beyond Baron and Kenny: Statistical mediational
analysis in the new millennium’, Communication Monographs, 76, 408–420
Putnam, R. D. (1993). The prosperous community: Social capital and public life. American
Prospect, 13, 35-42.
Putnam, R. D. (1995). Tuning in, tuning out: The strange disappearance of social capital in
America. Political Science Politics, 28, 664–683.
Rantika., D.S, &Yustina., I. A.(2017). Effects of ethical leadership on employee well-being: the
mediating role of psychological empowerment. Journal of indonesian economy and business
Volume 32, number 2, 2017, 121 – 137
Rubel, B.R.M., Rimi,N.N., Yusliza,Y.M. and Kee,H.M.D (2018).High commitment human
resource management practices and employee service behaviour: Trust in management as
mediator. IIMB Management Review (2018) 30, 316–329. www.elsevier.com/locate/iimb
Seibert, S. E., Wang, G., and Courtright, S. H. (2011). Antecedents and consequences of
psychological and team empowerment in organizations: A meta-analytic review. Journal of
Applied Psychology, 96(5), 981–1003.
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore IMR Doctoral Conference (IMRDC) Feb 2021.
S
SS
Su
uu
un
nn
ni
ii
il
ll
l
K
KK
Ku
uu
um
mm
ma
aa
ar
rr
r
R
RR
R
Unpublished work
33
Seligman, M. E. P. (2011). Flourish- A new understanding of happiness and well-being— and
how to achieve them. London: Nicholas Brealey Publishing.
Shahid, S. and Muchiri, M.K. (2019).Positivity at the workplace: Conceptualising the
relationships between authentic leadership, psychological capital, organisational virtuousness,
thriving and job performance. International Journal of Organizational Analysis, Vol. 27 No. 3,
pp. 494-523
Spreitzer, G.M. (1995). Psychological empowerment in the workplace: Dimensions,
measurement, and validation, Academy of Management Journal, 38, 1442–1465.
http://dx.doi.org/10.2307/256865
Tiwari, B., and Lenka, U. (2019). Employee engagement: A study of survivors in Indian IT/ITES
sector.IIMB Management Review. In Press, Journal Pre-proof.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.iimb.2019.10.003
Walumbwa, O.F and Lawler, J.J. (2003). Building effective organizations: transformational
leadership, collectivist orientation, work-related attitudes and withdrawal behaviours in three
emerging economies, The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 14:7, 1083-
1101, DOI: 10.1080/0958519032000114219
Witt, D. (2017). 3 coaching skills for managers that improve trust and well-being.
Retrieved from https://leaderchat.org/2017/02/07/3-coaching-skills-to-improve-trustand-
well-being/ ( July 2018)
Yamagishi, T., and Yamagishi, M. E. (1994).Trust and commitment in the United States and
Japan. Motivation and Emotion, 18, 129–166.
Zbierowski, P., and Górab, K. (2014). Positive leadership: Its nature, antecedents and
consequences. Journal of Positive Management, 5(1), 85–99. Retrieved from http://
dx.doi.org/10.12775/JPM.2014.008