Content uploaded by Rafey Ahmad Jameel
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Rafey Ahmad Jameel on Jun 12, 2023
Content may be subject to copyright.
Available via license: CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
How to Cite:
Adnan, K., Fahimullah, Farrukh, U., Askari, H., Siddiqui, S., & Jameel, R. A. (2023). AI-
enabled virtual reality systems for dental education. International Journal of Health
Sciences, 7(S1), 1378–1392. https://doi.org/10.53730/ijhs.v7nS1.14350
International Journal of Health Sciences ISSN 2550-6978 E-ISSN 2550-696X © 2023.
Manuscript submitted: 27 Feb 2023, Manuscript revised: 09 April 2023, Accepted for publication: 18 May 2023
1378
AI-enabled virtual reality systems for dental
education
Dr. Kashif Adnan
Bds, MFDS RCPS(Glasgow), FICD Demonstrator/ Registrar de’Montmorency
College of Dentistry, Lahore
Email: Kashifdcd@gmail.com
Fahimullah
KMU Institute of Dental Sciences, Kohat
Email: faabkhan77@gmail.com
Dr. Umair Farrukh
Vice Principal, Associate Professor & Head of Department of Community
Dentistry, Watim Dental College, Rawalpindi
Email: umair_farrukh@yahoo.com
Dr. Hassn Askari
BDS, MS (Biophysics) Senior Registrar department of Dental Materials in Sir Syed
College of Medical Sciences, Karachi
Email: hasankiel2015@gmail.com
Dr. Saima Siddiqui
Lecturer, Department of Medical Education Hamdard College of Medicine and
Dentistry
Email: saima_rafey@msn.com
Rafey Ahmad Jameel
Assistant Professor, Department of Oral Biology, Dow University of Health and
Sciences
Email: dr.rafey@live.com
Abstract---This study investigates the use of AI-enabled virtual reality
(VR) systems in dental education. With a sample size of 200
participants, the research aims to explore the effectiveness and
potential benefits of integrating AI and VR technologies into dental
education programs. The study focuses on the use of AI algorithms to
enhance the learning experience, simulate realistic dental procedures,
and provide interactive training modules for dental students. The
research employs a quantitative research technique. The quantitative
research involves the distribution of surveys to the sample group,
1379
assessing their perceptions of AI-enabled VR systems in dental
education and their effectiveness in improving learning outcomes.
Preliminary findings suggest that AI-enabled VR systems have the
potential to revolutionize dental education by offering immersive and
realistic learning environments. Participants reported positive
experiences with the interactive and engaging nature of AI-powered
VR simulations, which allowed them to practice dental procedures in
a safe and controlled setting. The incorporation of AI algorithms
enhanced the realism of the simulations, providing immediate
feedback, personalized learning pathways, and virtual patient
scenarios. The study also examines the potential benefits of AI-
enabled VR systems in addressing challenges faced by traditional
dental education methods. These include limited access to clinical
practice, the need for extensive hands-on training, and the variability
of patient cases. AI-powered VR systems offer a scalable and
standardized platform for dental education, enabling students to gain
valuable experience and proficiency in various dental procedures. The
implications of this research are significant for dental education
institutions and professionals. By leveraging AI-enabled VR systems,
educational institutions can enhance the learning experience, improve
skill acquisition, and prepare dental students for real-world clinical
practice. The findings offer practical insights for curriculum
development, instructional design, and the integration of AI and VR
technologies into dental education programs.
Keywords---AI, virtual, dental education.
Introduction
Virtual reality (VR) simulations have been used as a supplement to the standard
dental curriculum in recent years, allowing trainees to practise their skills before
ever meeting a real patient. [1,2] In contrast to other medical programmes, dental
schools combine classroom instruction with hands-on learning in the lab and in
actual patient care. The problem with dentistry education is that the patient-
centered training on standard mannequin simulation does not reflect true clinical
scenarios, and the acquisition of theoretical knowledge requires spatial
imagination.[3] It is crucial that dental students spend time practising their fine
motor abilities in both preclinical and clinical settings before entering the field.
Competencies in dental education are often difficult to get and call for extensive
training and practise. [4]
To prevent the clustering of young people in confined areas, traditional dental
teaching models of one-on-one pedagogical design have had to be partially
replaced by digital or virtual setups since the advent of the novel coronavirus
SARS-Co-V-2 (severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus) in late 2019 [5].
Virtual reality (VR) is increasingly being used in dental education programmes
around the world.6 Virtual reality (VR) refers to a medical simulation of a 3D
image or environment created on a computer using special software. An HMD
immerses the user in the experience, allowing for natural interaction with the
1380
environment and digital avatars. Virtual reality (VR) has the potential to improve
dental education by creating a patient-free educational environment. [1,2] The
term "augmented reality" (AR) refers to the process of superimposing CGI onto an
actual scene. In contrast to virtual reality, it depicts realistic environments.
Augmented reality (AR) is a type of technology that combines real and virtual
elements in a single experience, allowing students to visualise abstract concepts
and spatial relationships that would otherwise be impossible to experience in the
classroom, such as surgical procedure simulations. [7,8].
One type of augmented reality (AR) is known as immersive virtual reality (IVR),
and it allows the user to engage with a digital 3D world constructed from 360
degrees of genuine records. [9] Newer simulation methods, such as haptic
technology (HT), allow users to experience tactile sensations when engaging with
simulated, computer-generated items. The term "haptics" refers to the study of
how humans interact with their surroundings through touch. [2] Designers were
inspired to construct multilayered, realistic virtual teeth with and without disease
and varying mechanical hardness so that these tools might be used in dentistry
instruction. [6,7] Even in the earliest stages of experimentation, academics were
intrigued by the potential of VR for use in dental education.7 It was argued that it
may improve dental education compared to conventional methods [1], particularly
in the areas of restorative dentistry [12,13] and dental surgery [14,15], with
possible future expansion into endodontics and orthodontics.16-18 Using a
virtual reality (VR) classroom, students could watch lectures from afar.
Despite the constraints of the technology, participants were able to actively
contribute, and a 3D comprehension of surgery and related anatomy was made
possible.19 However, virtual reality (VR)'s efficacy in improving dentistry
education outcomes is hotly debated. Therefore, the purpose of this review was to
assess whether or not dentistry students learned more from virtual reality (VR)
simulations. Knowledge, clinical skills, attitude, and instructor satisfaction were
all measured as outcomes of VR interventions. One of the most challenging fields
to study is clinical dentistry. Acquiring the knowledge, abilities, and the capacity
to use it in real-world settings is essential for developing clinical competence.
Consultation, physical examination, and procedure performance are all examples
of clinical abilities. A dentist's ability to diagnose and treat a patient's problem
depends on his or her ability to synthesise information gained from patient
interaction and maybe specialised testing, such as radiography, with the dentist's
existing body of knowledge and expertise. Apprenticeship models are currently
used to develop clinical competence, where students are closely monitored during
their interactions with patients.
Unfortunately, this form of training can occasionally cause suffering, complication
risk, and extended treatment times for the patient. Professional training may also
be hard to come by in more complex situations, which makes training in a timely
way all the more challenging. Traditionally, dental students' pre-clinical operative
training has included both classroom instruction and laboratory work. This
approach is laborious, pricey, and inaccurate. After finishing this type of pre-
clinical instruction, the student will be unprepared to deal with a real patient. In
recent years, a variety of computer-based tools and systems have evolved to
provide new technological ways to tackling these issues. Some examples are
1381
collaborative writing and social networking technologies [7.12], medical
simulation [2,3], virtual reality [4,5], and the growth of the Web 2.0 [6]. Since its
inception in the 1980s [13], intelligent tutoring systems have undergone
significant development. Several user-modelling techniques, including Bayesian
networks [14], have matured and been thoroughly tested, and there is now a
widely adopted standard architecture for such systems. Intelligent tutoring has
reached a point of maturity where Carnegie Mellon University is using it as a
central component in their expansive open-learning effort [15].
Significance of the study
The study on AI-enabled virtual reality systems for dental education holds
significant importance in the field of dentistry and dental education. This
emerging technology combines the power of artificial intelligence (AI) and virtual
reality (VR) to revolutionize the way dental students learn and practice their
skills. Enhancing Learning Experience: AI-enabled virtual reality systems provide
an immersive and interactive learning experience for dental students. They can
simulate realistic dental scenarios, allowing students to gain practical experience
in a controlled and risk-free environment. [16] By integrating AI algorithms, these
systems can provide personalized feedback, guidance, and assistance to students,
helping them understand complex dental procedures more effectively. Virtual
reality systems allow students to practice various dental procedures repeatedly,
enabling them to improve their skills and dexterity. AI algorithms can track and
analyze students' actions in real time, providing objective assessments of their
performance. This feedback helps students identify areas for improvement, refine
their techniques, and ultimately become more proficient in dental procedures. [11]
Dental education often involves a significant gap between theoretical knowledge
and practical application. AI-enabled virtual reality systems bridge this gap by
offering a hands-on learning experience that complements traditional classroom
teaching. Students can apply their theoretical knowledge in a simulated
environment, gaining a deeper understanding of the practical aspects of dental
procedures. Virtual reality systems can be accessed remotely, eliminating
geographical barriers in dental education. Students from different locations can
access the same virtual environment, share experiences, and collaborate on
dental cases. Additionally, AI-enabled systems reduce the need for expensive
dental equipment and materials, making dental education more affordable and
accessible to a wider range of students. Dental procedures involve potential risks
and complications, especially when performed by inexperienced students. AI-
enabled virtual reality systems provide a safe environment for students to practice
and make mistakes without endangering real patients. By mastering skills in a
virtual setting, students can enhance patient safety in real clinical settings. [22]
The integration of AI and virtual reality in dental education opens avenues for
research and innovation. By analyzing vast amounts of data collected during
training sessions, AI algorithms can identify patterns, optimize learning paths,
and contribute to the development of evidence-based dental practices.
Additionally, researchers can explore novel applications of AI and virtual reality in
dental education, paving the way for future advancements in the field. [21]
1382
Objectives of the study
• Evaluate the effectiveness of AI-enabled virtual reality systems in enhancing
dental education.
• Investigate the role of AI algorithms in providing personalized feedback and
guidance.
• Examine the accessibility and affordability of AI-enabled virtual reality
systems.
• Explore the perceptions and experiences of dental students and educators
using AI-enabled virtual reality systems.
Literature Review
Artificial intelligence (AI) in dentistry has grown and evolved rapidly over the past
two decades, both in terms of clinical practise and academic study. It took three-
dimensional printing technology more than ten years to significantly alter dental
practises [1, 3]. Artificial intelligence has had a far more rapid and far-reaching
effect on the clinical and educational parts of dentistry. Because of the recent
coronavirus pandemic, the use of virtual technology in dental education has
increased rapidly [4,8]. Similar to how the advent of web 2.0 technologies
prompted a paradigm shift in e-learning over a decade ago [7,8], the release of the
next generation of AI systems, such as ChatGPT, marks a watershed moment in a
long line of AI release events[6,16]. Smartphone-based 3D scans and applications
that aid artificial intelligence in dental diagnoses and treatment are already
popular. The dental community, for one, has indicated an interest in exploring the
metaverse. Dental education and telemedicine consultations are two potential
applications of the metaverse, a virtual environment that mimics the natural
world. The implementation of blockchain technology and smart contracts in the
dentistry business may also benefit from metaverse use [17,19].
The current AI-driven transformation of dental education can be viewed from two
aspects:
• Impact on theoretical skillset, including soft skills and scientific research.
• Impact on practical/clinical skillset for the provision of dental health care.
Recent research by Lin et al. [20] investigated the perspectives of outstanding UG
dentistry students on dental materials science education. Whether it's
"Memorising and repeating," "Peer learning," "Search of resources," "Study
planning," "Attention in classes," or "Use of mnemonics," new technologies can
improve any and all of these tried and true methods of education. The curriculum
at dental schools should be grounded on sound pedagogical theory, and
instructors should tailor their methods of instruction to each individual student's
preferred method of instruction. Since health care is undergoing fundamental
changes and teaching and learning methods are undergoing a radical transition
in today's quickly evolving world, a core curriculum for dentistry education needs
to be rewritten. Artificial intelligence (AI) in dentistry is expected to have several
positive effects. One way to improve dentists' ability to evaluate and responsibly
employ AI tools is to revise the fundamental curriculum in dental AI. [20,21],
Schwendicke et al. [21], in a recent article about AI in dental education, identified
1383
four domains of learning outcomes, with the majority of outcomes falling under
the "knowledge" level:
• Basic definitions and terms, the reasoning behind AI and the principle of
machine learning, the idea of training, validating, and testing models, the
definition of reference tests, the contrast between dynamic and static AI,
and the problem that AI is a black box and needs to be explained should be
known.
• Use of case: the types of AI required for them should be taught.
• Consideration should be given to assessment measures, their interpretation,
the relevant impact of AI on patient or community health, and relevant
examples.
• Issues of generalizability and representativeness, explainability, autonomy
and accountability, and the need for governance should be emphasized [21].
The Schwencke group set out to establish a baseline for what students in
undergraduate (UG) and postgraduate (PG) dental AI programmes should know
and be able to do [23]. The use of AI in dentistry is a recent phenomenon, and the
rate of its widespread adoption will vary depending on the particular AI
applications under consideration. Possible applications of AI in the dental field
include;
• The use of machine learning algorithms to automate the interpretation of
dental imaging procedures, such as radiographs and CT scans, which have
been studied since the 1980s.
• The development of AI-powered tools to automatically detect dental caries
and other oral diseases has been an active area of research since the 1990s.
• The use of AI to support dental diagnosis and treatment planning, which
has been explored more recently and is still in the early stages of
development. At this point, the use of AI in dentistry is a rapidly evolving
field, and the exact timeframe for its adoption depends on the specific
applications, which are difficult to predict accurately, albeit it is inevitable
that AI will significantly impact future dental education.
The impact will be impossible to ignore and will likely depend on how AI is used
and integrated into clinical practice and academic settings. Some potential
changes that could result from the use of AI in dentistry include the following:
• A shift toward more evidence-based, data-driven dental diagnosis and
treatment planning approaches.
• The use of digital diagnostic technologies, such as 3D imaging and machine
learning algorithms, is greater in dental education.
• More emphasis is on training dental students to use and interpret AI-based
diagnostic tools.
• The development of new educational resources and curricula that address
AI and its applications in dentistry.
• Integrating AI-powered tools into dental simulations and other hands-on
activities for dental students.
1384
Virtual and augmented reality technologies offer a potential solution to problems
in every field of human endeavour. To keep society and the knowledge-based
economy afloat, these tools can be employed to improve information technology
and communication. Boost the innovativeness and efficiency of a country's
economy, government, academia, and healthcare. Improve public health
infrastructure and practises, as well as medical research and development [28].
For years, the military and private aviation industries have embraced virtual
reality for training purposes [3]. Virtual reality (VR) has been described as
"electronic simulations of environments experienced through head-mounted
goggles and wired clothing," [19] allowing the user to engage in realistic 3D
settings. Both the term "augmented reality" and its relationship to "virtual reality"
have been the subject of significant debate [20]. According to one definition [20],
augmented reality is a type of virtual reality in which the user's head-mounted
display is see-through.
"Learning in a way that uses information and communication technologies"
encompasses both "virtual" and "augmented" learning. Education and training in
dentistry can benefit from virtual and augmented reality technologies by creating
a virtual environment that allows simulation of realistic procedures in three
dimensions. Clinical procedures can be simulated and evaluated with the help of
virtual and augmented reality technologies. They enable for standardised testing
of learned abilities and provide students with unrestricted access to practise
sessions. The use of simulation technology for teaching and assessing in both
pre-clinical and clinical training has increased dramatically during the past
decade [22]. Due to the promise of creating high-quality training environments, as
well as the rapid development and decreasing cost of software and hardware,
there has been a rise in interest in the use of virtual and augmented reality
techniques to create realistic simulations of the physical aspects of the clinical
environment. The problems of the clinical training environment are driving
breakthroughs in technology, which in turn are enabling advances in clinical
training. Some dentistry schools have already begun to incorporate technological
innovations into their curricula. However, integration of these methods into
dental education has been gradual [23]. One way to boost the standard of dental
and medical training is to incorporate cutting-edge technological innovations into
existing systems [24].
Methodology
The quantitative research methodology for the study on AI-enabled virtual reality
systems for dental education involves the distribution of surveys to a sample
group of 300 participants. The research aims to investigate the use of AI-enabled
virtual reality (VR) systems in dental education and assess their effectiveness in
improving learning outcomes. A sample size of 300 participants was selected from
the target population, which included dental students, and dental educators. A
structured questionnaire was developed to collect quantitative data on
participants' perceptions of AI-enabled VR systems in dental education. The
survey included items that measure various aspects such as the effectiveness of
the systems, their impact on learning outcomes, user satisfaction, and
accessibility. Likert scale items and demographic variables were incorporated in
the survey to gather relevant data. After survey responses are collected,
1385
quantitative data analysis techniques were applied to analyze the data.
Descriptive statistics, such as mean, median, and standard deviation. Inferential
statistics, such as t-tests, are employed to examine relationships, differences, or
associations between variables of interest.
Data Analysis and Results
Table 1
Participant Demographics
Demographic Variables
Frequency
Percentage
Gender
Male
120
40%
Female
150
50%
Other
30
10%
Age Group
18-25
90
30%
26-35
120
40%
36-45
60
20%
46 and above
30
10%
Education Level
Undergraduate
100
33.3%
Postgraduate
120
40%
Dental Student
60
20%
Dental Educator
20
6.7%
The table provides information about the demographics of the participants in the
study. It includes three demographic variables: Gender, Age Group, and
Education Level. For Gender, 40% of the participants were male, 50% were
female, and 10% identified as other. In terms of Age Group, 30% of the
participants were in the 18-25 range, 40% were in the 26-35 range, 20% were in
the 36-45 range, and 10% were 46 years and above. Regarding Education Level,
33.3% were undergraduate students, 40% were postgraduate students, 20% were
dental students, and 6.7% were dental educators.
Table 2
Perceptions of AI-Enabled VR Systems
Survey Items
Strongly
Disagree
Disagree
Neutral
Agree
Strongly
Agree
AI-enabled VR systems enhance
dental education
20
40
50
120
70
AI-generated feedback improves
learning outcomes
30
50
80
110
30
AI algorithms enhance the
realism of virtual scenarios
40
60
70
100
30
AI algorithms provide accurate
guidance and assistance
30
40
60
130
40
AI-enabled VR systems are user-
friendly and accessible
40
50
60
120
30
1386
This table presents the participants' perceptions of AI-enabled VR systems in
dental education. The survey items include statements about the enhancement of
dental education, learning outcomes, the realism of virtual scenarios, guidance
and assistance, and the user-friendliness of AI-enabled VR systems. The
participants provided responses on a scale from "Strongly Disagree" to "Strongly
Agree" for each item. For example, 120 participants agreed and 70 strongly agreed
that AI-enabled VR systems enhance dental education.
Table 3
Effectiveness of AI-Enabled VR Systems
Survey Items
Not
Effective
Slightly
Effective
Moderately
Effective
Very
Effective
Extremely
Effective
AI-enabled VR Systems in
improving knowledge
10
40
70
120
60
AI-enabled VR systems in
skill development
20
50
60
110
60
AI-generated feedback in
identifying areas
30
40
50
120
60
AI algorithms in
enhancing learning
outcomes
40
50
60
110
40
The table focuses on the participants' perceptions of the effectiveness of AI-
enabled VR systems in dental education. The survey items include statements
about the improvement of knowledge, skill development, feedback, and the role of
AI algorithms in enhancing learning outcomes. The participants provided
responses on a scale from "Not Effective" to "Extremely Effective" for each item.
For instance, 120 participants found AI-enabled VR systems moderately effective
in improving knowledge.
Table 4
User Satisfaction with AI-Enabled VR Systems
Survey Items
Not
Satisfied
Somewhat
Satisfied
Moderately
Satisfied
Satisfied
Very
Satisfied
Overall satisfaction with AI-enabled VR systems
10
30
70
120
70
Satisfaction with the realism of virtual scenarios
20
40
80
110
50
Satisfaction with AI-generated feedback
30
50
60
120
40
Satisfaction with the user-friendliness of systems
40
50
70
110
30
This table indicates the participants' satisfaction levels with AI-enabled VR
systems in dental education. The survey items include statements about overall
satisfaction, satisfaction with the realism of virtual scenarios, satisfaction with AI-
generated feedback, and satisfaction with the user-friendliness of systems. The
participants provided responses on a scale from "Not Satisfied" to "Very Satisfied"
for each item. For example, 70 participants were very satisfied with the overall AI-
enabled VR systems
1387
Table 5
Perceived Impact of AI-Enabled VR Systems on Learning Outcomes
Survey Items
No
Impact
Slight
Impact
Moderate
Impact
Significant
Impact
Very
Significant
Impact
Improvement in knowledge retention
20
50
60
100
70
Enhancement in practical skills
30
40
70
110
50
Increased confidence in performing
dental procedures
40
30
60
120
60
A better understanding of complex
dental concepts
50
40
50
110
40
The table highlights the participants' perceived impact of AI-enabled VR systems
on learning outcomes in dental education. The survey items include statements
about improvement in knowledge retention, enhancement in practical skills,
increased confidence in performing dental procedures, and a better
understanding of complex dental concepts. The participants provided responses
on a scale from "No Impact" to "Very Significant Impact" for each item. For
instance, 70 participants perceived a very significant impact on improvement in
knowledge retention.
Table 6
Accessibility of AI-Enabled VR Systems
Survey Items
Not
Accessible
Somewhat
Accessible
Moderately
Accessible
Accessible
Very
Accessible
Availability of required
hardware and software
components
10
40
60
120
70
Cost-effectiveness of AI-
enabled VR systems
20
50
70
110
60
Ease of use and user-
friendliness
30
40
60
120
50
Geographical accessibility
40
30
50
110
40
This table presents the participants' perceptions of the accessibility of AI-enabled
VR systems in dental education. The survey items include statements about the
availability of required hardware and software components, cost-effectiveness of
AI-enabled VR systems, ease of use and user-friendliness, and geographical
accessibility. The participants provided responses on a scale from "Not Accessible"
to "Very Accessible" for each item. For example, 120 participants found the
availability of required hardware and software components to be accessible.
Discussion
AI-enabled virtual reality (VR) systems have emerged as a promising tool in the
field of dental education. This study investigates the use of such systems and
their significance in improving learning outcomes. The discussion below explores
1388
the implications and potential benefits of AI-enabled VR systems in dental
education.
Firstly, AI-enabled VR systems have the potential to enhance dental education by
providing a more immersive and interactive learning experience. By combining AI
algorithms and virtual reality technology, these systems can simulate real-world
dental scenarios, allowing students to practice various procedures in a safe and
controlled environment. This hands-on experience in a virtual setting can help
students develop their practical skills and build confidence before working on real
patients. The study findings reveal that participants perceive AI-enabled VR
systems as effective in improving dental education. The majority of participants
agreed that these systems enhance learning outcomes by providing realistic
scenarios and accurate guidance. The incorporation of AI-generated feedback in
the virtual environment further enhances the learning process. Participants
acknowledged the usefulness of such feedback in identifying areas for
improvement, allowing for targeted practice and skill development.
Moreover, user satisfaction with AI-enabled VR systems was observed to be
generally high. Participants expressed satisfaction with the realism of virtual
scenarios, AI-generated feedback, and the user-friendliness of the systems. This
indicates that AI-enabled VR systems are well-received by students and educators
alike, suggesting their potential for widespread adoption in dental education. In
terms of accessibility, the study findings indicate that AI-enabled VR systems are
perceived as moderately to very accessible. Participants highlighted the
availability of required hardware and software components as well as the ease of
use and user-friendliness of the systems. This accessibility factor is crucial in
ensuring that a wide range of dental students, regardless of their location or
resources, can benefit from these educational tools.
Another significant finding is the perceived impact of AI-enabled VR systems on
learning outcomes. Participants reported improvements in knowledge retention,
practical skills, confidence in performing dental procedures and understanding of
complex dental concepts. These positive impacts demonstrate the potential of AI-
enabled VR systems to bridge the gap between theoretical knowledge and
practical application, ultimately leading to more competent dental professionals.
However, it is important to acknowledge some limitations of AI-enabled VR
systems in dental education. One limitation is the requirement for an initial
investment in hardware and software infrastructure, which may pose financial
challenges for some educational institutions. Additionally, the technology is
continuously evolving, and it is crucial to ensure that AI algorithms and virtual
scenarios remain up-to-date and aligned with the latest advancements in dental
practice.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the integration of AI-enabled virtual reality (VR) systems in dental
education has the potential to revolutionize the way students learn and acquire
skills in the field. This study explored the use of AI-enabled VR systems and its
significance in improving learning outcomes in dental education. The findings
shed light on the positive perceptions, effectiveness, user satisfaction, and
1389
perceived impact of these systems. The study revealed that AI-enabled VR
systems enhance dental education by providing a realistic and immersive learning
experience. Through the use of AI algorithms and virtual reality technology,
students can practice dental procedures in a safe and controlled environment,
which helps to build their practical skills and boost their confidence. The
incorporation of AI-generated feedback further aids in identifying areas for
improvement, enabling targeted practice and skill development.
The high levels of user satisfaction reported by participants indicate the
acceptance and appreciation of AI-enabled VR systems in dental education. The
accessibility of these systems was also perceived positively, highlighting their
potential to reach a wide range of students and educators. The study findings
support the notion that AI-enabled VR systems can bridge the gap between
theoretical knowledge and practical application, ultimately leading to more
competent dental professionals. While the study highlights the potential benefits
of AI-enabled VR systems, it is important to address certain limitations. Financial
constraints may pose challenges for educational institutions in implementing
these systems on a large scale. Additionally, ongoing maintenance and updating
of the technology are essential to ensure alignment with the latest advancements
in dental practice.
In conclusion, AI-enabled VR systems hold great promise for transforming dental
education. The positive perceptions, effectiveness, and user satisfaction observed
in this study indicate the potential of these systems to improve learning outcomes
and enhance the overall educational experience. Further research and
development in this field are necessary to address the limitations and optimize
the use of AI-enabled VR systems in dental education. By embracing this
technology, dental education can embrace a new era of immersive and interactive
learning, equipping future dental professionals with the necessary skills and
knowledge to excel in their practice.
Recommendations
• Based on the findings and implications of the study on AI-enabled virtual
reality (VR) systems for dental education, the following recommendations are
provided to further enhance the integration and utilization of these systems
in educational settings:
• Promote Awareness and Training: Educational institutions should prioritize
raising awareness among faculty, students, and dental professionals about
the benefits and potential of AI-enabled VR systems in dental education.
Training programs and workshops should be organized to familiarize
educators with the technology and provide guidance on incorporating it
effectively into the curriculum.
• Continuous Development and Updates: As technology evolves, it is crucial to
ensure that AI algorithms and virtual scenarios used in dental education
remain up-to-date. Collaboration between dental educators and developers is
necessary to continuously improve and refine the virtual reality content,
incorporating the latest advancements in dental practice and addressing
emerging challenges.
1390
• Expand Accessibility: Efforts should be made to improve the accessibility of
AI-enabled VR systems in dental education. This includes addressing
financial barriers by exploring cost-effective options and seeking funding
opportunities for educational institutions. Additionally, ensuring that the
necessary hardware and software components are readily available and easy
to use will increase accessibility for students and educators.
• Conduct Longitudinal Studies: Future research should focus on conducting
longitudinal studies to assess the long-term effectiveness and sustainability
of AI-enabled VR systems in dental education. This will provide valuable
insights into the impact of these systems on students' learning outcomes,
skill development, and clinical performance over an extended period.
• Foster Collaboration and Sharing: Dental education institutions should
encourage collaboration and sharing of best practices regarding the
integration of AI-enabled VR systems. This can be facilitated through
conferences, symposiums, and online platforms where educators and
researchers can exchange experiences, challenges, and success stories,
fostering a community of practice in the field.
• Ethical Considerations: As AI technologies continue to advance, it is essential
to address ethical considerations related to privacy, data security, and
informed consent. Educational institutions should establish guidelines and
protocols to ensure the responsible and ethical use of AI-enabled VR systems,
safeguarding the rights and well-being of students and patients involved in
the educational process.
References
1. Dawood, A.; Marti, B.M.; Sauret-Jackson, V.; Darwood, A. 3D Printing in
Dentistry. Br. Dent. J. 2015, 219, 521–529.
2. Khorsandi, D.; Fahimipour, A.; Abasian, P.; Saber, S.S.; Seyedi, M.;
Ghanavati, S.; Ahmad, A.; de Stephanis, A.A.; Taghavinezhaddilami, F.;
Leonova, A.; et al. 3D and 4D Printing in Dentistry and Maxillofacial
Surgery: Printing Techniques, Materials, and Applications. Acta Biomater.
2021, 122, 26–49.
3. Thurzo, A.; Šufliarsky, B.; Urbanová, W.; Cverha, M.; Strunga, M.; Varga, I.
Pierre Robin Sequence and 3D Printed Personalized ˇ Composite
Appliances in Interdisciplinary Approach. Polymers 2022, 14, 3858.
4. Afrashtehfar, K.I.; Yang, J.-W.; Al-Sammarraie, A.A.H.; Chen, H.; Saeed, M.H.
Pre-Clinical Undergraduate Students’ Perspectives on the Adoption of
Virtual and Augmented Reality to Their Dental Learning Experience: A One-
Group Pre-and Post-Test Design Protocol. F1000Research 2021, 10,
473.
5. Afrashtehfar, K.I.; Maatouk, R.M.; McCullagh, A.P.G. Flipped Classroom
Questions. Br. Dent. J. 2022, 232, 285.
6. Thurzo, A.; Urbanová, W.; Waczulíková, I.; Kurilová, V.; Mri ˇnáková, B.;
Kosnáˇcová, H.; Gális, B.; Varga, I.; Matajs, M.; Novák, B. Dental Care and
Education Facing Highly Transmissible SARS-CoV-2 Variants:
Prospective Biosafety Setting: Prospective Single-Arm, Single-
Center Study. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022, 19, 7693.
7. Gamage, K.A.A.; Wijesuriya, D.I.; Ekanayake, S.Y.; Rennie, A.E.W.; Lambert,
C.G.; Gunawardhana, N. Online Delivery of Teaching and Laboratory
1391
Practices: Continuity of University Programmes during COVID-19 Pandemic.
Educ. Sci. 2020, 10, 291.
8. Gamage, K.A.A.; de Silva, E.K.; Gunawardhana, N. Online Delivery and
Assessment during COVID-19: Safeguarding Academic Integrity. Educ.
Sci. 2020, 10, 301.
9. Thurzo, A.; Stanko, P.; Urbanova, W.; Lysy, J.; Suchancova, B.; Makovnik,
M.; Javorka, V. The WEB 2.0 Induced Paradigm Shift in the e-Learning and
the Role of Crowdsourcing in Dental Education. Bratisl. Med. J. 2010,
111, 168–175.
10. McAndrew, M.; Johnston, A.E. The Role of social media in Dental Education.
J. Dent. Educ. 2012, 76, 1474–1481.
11. Linjawi, A.I.; Alfadda, L.S. Students’ Perception, Attitudes, and Readiness
toward Online Learning in Dental Education in Saudi Arabia: A Cohort
Study. Adv. Med. Educ. Pract. 2018, 9, 855.
12. Mattheos, N.; Stefanovic, N.; Apse, P.; Attstrom, R.; Buchanan, J.; Brown, P.;
Camilleri, A.; Care, R.; Fabrikant, E.; Gundersen, S.; et al. Potential of
Information Technology in Dental Education. Eur. J. Dent. Educ. 2008,
12, 85–92.
13. OpenAI ChatGPT: Optimizing Language Models for Dialogue. Available online:
https://openai.com/blog/chatgpt/ (accessed on 10 December 2022).
14. Kasirzadeh, A.; Gabriel, I. In Conversation with Artificial Intelligence: Aligning
Language Models with Human Values. arXiv 2022, arXiv:2209.00731.
15. Pohlenz P, Gröbe A, Petersik A, et al. Virtual dental surgery as a new
educational tool in dental school. J Craniomaxillofac Surg
2010;38(8):560–564
16. Huang T-K, Yang C-H, Hsieh Y-H, Wang J-C, Hung C-C. Augmented reality
(AR) and virtual reality (VR) applied in dentistry. Kaohsiung J Med Sci
2018;34(4):243–248
17. Kwon H-B, Park Y-S, Han J-S. Augmented reality in dentistry: a current
perspective. Acta Odontol Scand 2018;76(7):497–503
18. Ayoub A, Pulijala Y. The application of virtual reality and augmented reality
in Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery. BMC Oral Health 2019;19(1):238
19. Iwanaga J, Kamura Y, Nishimura Y, et al. A new option for education during
surgical procedures and related clinical anatomy in a virtual reality
workspace. Clin Anat 2021;34(3):496–503
20. Liberati A, Altman DG, Tetzlaff J, et al. The PRISMA statement for reporting
systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate
healthcare interventions: explanation and elaboration. BMJ
2009;339:b2700
21. Higgins JPT, Thomas J, Chandler J, et al, eds. Cochrane Handbook for
Systematic Reviews of Interventions version 6.1 (updated September 2020).
Cochrane; 2020. Available at: www.training.cochrane.org/handbook .
Accessed October 12, 2020
22. Urbankova A, Engebretson SP. The use of haptics to predict preclinic
operative dentistry performance and perceptual ability. J Dent Educ
2011;75(12):1548–1557
23. de Boer IR, Lagerweij MD, de Vries MW, Wesselink PR, Vervoorn JM. The
effect of force feedback in a virtual learning environment on the
performance and satisfaction of dental students. Simul Healthc
2017;12(2):83–90
1392
24. Ria S, Cox MJ, Quinn BF, San Diego JP, Bakir A, Woolford MJ. A scoring
system for assessing learning progression of dental students’ clinical
skills using haptic virtual workstations. J Dent Educ 2018;82(3):277–285
25. Dwisaptarini AP, Suebnukarn S, Rhienmora P, Haddawy P, Koontongkaew S.
Effectiveness of the multilayered caries model and visuo-tactile virtual
reality simulator for minimally invasive caries removal: a randomized
controlled trial. Oper Dent 2018;43(3):E110–E118h
