ArticlePDF Available

Addressing digital technology gap challenges: The Nigerian experience

Authors:

Abstract

The purpose of this is to understand the concept of the digital divide and examine the ways in which the divide can be bridged in Nigeria. A qualitative research approach was used to generate data and the technique of content analysis was used to change them to information for analysis. The world is saturated with information and communication technologies that have changed the way people work and connect to one another. These technologies play a great role in people's interactions, their pursuit of education, and certain careers in life. For some scholars in the developed world, the era of the digital revolution is over; it is now the post-digital era. However, for a developing country like Nigeria, though digitalization is seen as a necessity, there are still many challenges hindering its progress. Digital technologies are perceived as a double-edged sword with positive and negative impacts. Apart from the digital divide, some of these technologies have been abused or misused. According to the findings, the digital gap in Nigeria is caused by infrastructural inequalities and deficit and intentional institutional and political phenomenon. The threats posed by the digital divide call for an all-inclusive approach that should result in improved economic development. It is recommended that closing the digital divide in Nigeria is critical to making socioeconomic growth in Nigeria more equitable and sustainable.
N i g e r i a n J o u r n a l o f
S o c i a l D e v e l o p m e n t
95
NGJSD | www.arabianjbmr.com
© 2023, Authors, ZARSMI.
Nigerian Journal of Social Development, 11(1) 2023, 95-100
ISSN: 2814-1105
Open Access Journal
Research Article
Homepage: www.arabianjbmr.com
AOJP
Addressing digital technology gap challenges: The Nigerian experience
Okoye Nonso Sunday
Chukwuemeka Odumegwu Ojukwu University, Igbariam, Nigeria.
Email: chinonsookoye41@yahoo.com
Uchenna Timothy Umeifekwem (PhD.)
Chukwuemeka Odumegwu Ojukwu University, Igbariam, Nigeria.
Email: ukochenna2011@yahoo.com
Okechukwu Innocent Eme
Department of Public Administration and Local Government Studies, University of Nigeria, Nsukka.
Eme.okechukwu@unn.edu.ng
A RT I CL E I NF O
Keywords:
Digital divide, infrastructural
deficit, Information
Communication Technology,
Nigeria, poverty and
Telecommunication
Article History:
Received: 09 Feb 2023
Accepted: 05 Jun 2023
Available Online: 10 Jun 2023
1. INTRODUCTION
Global technology evolution, no doubt, has exposed Nigeria’s deficiency in the area of information and
communications technology (ICT) infrastructure development. While developed countries of the world are coming up
with new technologies that will drive the digital age, Nigeria and other developing countries are trying to play the catch-
up owing to lack of adequate ICT infrastructure. In Nigeria, in rural communities, the individuals are still residing in the
state of backwardness and are overwhelmed by the conditions of poverty, illiteracy and unawareness. It is necessary for
the development of rural communities, to generate awareness among individuals in terms of digitalization and use of
technologies. Most of the conversation in the broadband industry in Nigeria today is about the 5G; its advantages and
when it is going to be fully deployed. The global COVID-19 outbreak has also not helped the popularity of this mobile
technology especially as public concerns about its health implications grow. According to Mba(2020), there are rounds of
beliefs that COVID-19 is caused by radiation emitted from 5G masts. These beliefs might be unavoidable due to the
overwhelming description of how much 5G would transform a lot of processes in the world. Potential use cases of 5G
such as vehicles communicating with each other, telemedicine and precision surgery are very mind-boggling and one can
only imagine that these kinds of futuristic living can only come at a cost. However, relying on the fact that neither the
World Health Organisation, WHO nor any research linked the coronavirus to any telecom technologies such as 5G, it is
worth it to continue to broadcast the socio-economic benefit of the technology. Each generation of networks brought with
it a significant milestone in the development of mobile communication. The main advantage of 5G is that it will deliver
blazing fast and clear internet and call connections with very low power consumption. Imagine the following; using your
Android phone to browse for up to a week on a single charge, being able to download a 2Gb movie in less than 2 minutes.
The speed and low power will also enable the internet of things technology where sensors and smart devices will
communicate with each other or where all the devices in your home can be controlled with just a single remote control.
With 5G, cities and other municipalities will operate more efficiently. Imagine being sent an alert on your mobile phone
about huge traffic on your usual road to work, with also descriptions of alternatives routes to take to avoid the traffic. All
these will work efficiently on 5G.
N ig er ia J o ur na l of S o ci al D ev el o pm en t (N GJ S D)
96
NGJSD | www.arabianjbmr.com
© 2023, Authors, ZARSMI.
Presently, internet services in Nigeria are currently provided on 2G, 3G, and increasingly 4G mobile networks.
Investors have shifted from the deployment of 2G coverage, which currently stands at 89%, towards 3G and increasingly
4G coverage at 74% and 37% respectively (National Bureau of Statistics, 2018b; Nigerian Communications Commission,
2019).
Currently, the broadband penetration rate of Nigeria is about 39 percent as measured in terms of 3G and 4G
connections divided by the total population. Although this rate indicates that the primary objective of the first National
Broadband plan was achieved by increasing broadband penetration from the 6% rate in 2012 by a multiple of 5, the
penetration is very deficient in fixed connection(World Bank, Nigeria Digital Economy Diagnostic Report, 2019) . Mobile
broadband connections which are high-speed internet access delivered over a mobile phone network such as CDMA, GSM
or 3G, 3.5G or 4G LTE account for approximately 99.8% of the broadband base while fixed connections that deliver
broadband from the backbone of the internet by using base stations to transfer the signal from building to building, like a
satellite are at 0.2%. Also, based on the services available online and usage patterns today, the current broadband speed
definition of 1.5 Mbps in rural areas and 3Mbps in urban areas in Nigeria is inadequate to meet the robust 4G requirements
now and 5G broadband technologies, going forward. In comparison with other countries with similar income levels as
Nigeria, the current download speed of Nigeria lags behind. At a download speed of 1.5Mbps, Nigeria’s download speed
lags behind Kenya and South-Africa by 6.12 and 6.9Mbp respectively. Thus, speed, quality of service, access available
via public institutions through fixed connections i.e. schools, hospitals, and MDAs has made the end-user adoption of
broadband technology not to reflect the increased penetration of the technology. This calls for more investment in fixed
broadband infrastructure because they are far more reliable, less likely to be strangled by slow speeds and data usage caps.
Fixed infrastructure will also be required to support the 4th Industrial Revolution applications including Smart City, IoT,
Artificial Intelligence, Autonomous vehicles and other advanced technologies that would rely on the advent of 5G (World
Bank, Nigeria Digital Economy Diagnostic Report, 2019). Experts and government officials, including Vice President
Yemi Osinbajo have said that Nigeria needs a whopping $25 billion annually over the next 10 years to build and develop
the necessary infrastructure to take the nation to the next level. The World Bank has projected that Nigeria will surpass
the United States in population by 2050 and most likely become the third largest population by 2050 after China and India
with a population of about 460 million people. These statistics signify the population that investors consider when they
decide to invest in Nigeria (Okonji, 2017). Fundamentally, our inability to deploy; technology infrastructure, internet
connectivity and computers constitute technological divide. The main objective of this research paper is to understand the
meaning and challenges of digitalization gap and how it could be addressed in Nigeria.
Contextualizing Technology | Digital Gap
The term "technology gap" also known as “digital divide” describes the disparity between individuals, households,
businesses, and geographical areas with varying socioeconomic levels in terms of their access to information and
communication technologies (ICTs) and their use of the Internet for a number of purposes (Akanbi & Akanbi, 2012). A
good technology is one that has the potential to bridge the technological gap, which is defined as the difference between
what has been done (or is understood) today and what is required to implement a future mission (Crandall, 2001). Between
people who have access to the internet and dependable equipment and those who don't, there is a technology gap. The
technology gap is the line dividing people with access to computers, the accompanying skills, and Internet use from those
without either of those resources (Ani, Uchendu & Atseye, 2007). The phrase "technology gap" is increasingly used to
describe the social effects of some community segments' unequal access to information and communications technology
and to the acquisition of relevant skills (Cronin, 2002). For full involvement in economic, political, and social life, access
to computers, the Internet, and the ability to efficiently use this technology are becoming increasingly crucial. A necessity
for guaranteeing equity in access to the information economy, enabling governments to meet their goals for electronic
service delivery, and enabling people to take advantage of the prospects for economic growth presented by the information
age is having access to online technologies (Cronin, 2002). The gap between those who have access to various information
and communication technologies and those who do not is typically understood to be the digital divide. Computers and the
Internet dominate these forms. Cellphones, especially smart phones, and other digital gear and software are occasionally
also included. The idea is discussed in discussions about informational and social inequality. In this regard, common
concepts include inclusion and exclusion within specific social units.
According to Compaine (2001), the term "technology gap" is more broadly defined as the gap between those who
have access to and the resources to use new information and communication tools, such as the internet, and those who do
not. It also refers to the gap between those who have the knowledge, expertise, and abilities to use the technologies and
those who do not. The technology gap can exist between people who live in urban and rural areas, between educated and
illiterate people, between different socioeconomic levels, and globally between countries with more and less industrialized
economies. Dawood et al. (2019) identified nine types of the technology gap, which are as follows:
Infrastructural divide; access divide; literacy divide; language divide; information and knowledge divide; job divide;
healthcare divide; entertainment divide and; demographic divide
N ig er ia J o ur na l of S o ci al D ev el o pm en t (N GJ S D)
97
NGJSD | www.arabianjbmr.com
© 2023, Authors, ZARSMI.
Finally, Eke-Okpala, (2011) stated that the factors leading to technology gap are disparities in Internet access:
availability; affordability; and quality of service.
Digitalization Gap in Nigeria: The Problematic and Consequences
In Nigeria, more than 70 percent of the population resides in rural communities. For leading to progression of
individuals, communities and nation, there is a need to make efforts that are dedicated towards promoting development of
rural communities. The Government of Nigeria has made considerable efforts, such as the Digital Nigeria Campaign,
which was initiated in 2000s. The main objective of this campaign is to cause reduction in the digital Nigeria divide and
Information and Communications Technologies (ICT) has proven to be a tool that has led to its successful implementation
(ADB, 2004; World Bank, 2019). Digital Nigeria is a national program, which focuses upon providing universal digital
literacy and universal accessibility of all digital resources to the citizens. The vision is focused upon three main aspects,
i.e. creation of digital infrastructure, delivery of governance and services on demand and digital empowerment of citizens.
Digital Nigeria program focuses upon restructuring of several existing schemes to lead to transformation (World Bank,
2019). The vision of the program has led to transformation of the country into a digitally-empowered society and
knowledge economy through infrastructural reforms, such as, high speed internet, lifelong digital identification for all
citizens, mobile banking for all, accessibility to Common Service Centres (CSC), shareable private spaces on an easily
accessible public cloud and cyber security. The program will also ensure that all government services and information will
be available anytime, anywhere and on any device that is easy to use, available on a major scale and is safe. It is one of
the major steps that have been initiated by the Government to motivate and connect the Nigerian economy. The program
symbolizes the vision of the Government of Nigeria to establish connection between citizens of Nigeria and promote
empowerment opportunities among them.
In the present existence, there have been formulations of measures and programs that are promoting digitalization of
rural communities. Furthermore, the rural individuals have generated awareness in terms of the fact that when they will
recognize the significance of education and learn to make use of technologies, they will be able to bring about
improvements in their lives. Through digitalization of rural communities, there have been improvements in governance
and management, education, health care facilities, transportation, agriculture, farming practices, infrastructure and so
forth. Furthermore, the individuals are able to make improvements in their livelihoods opportunities. The main concepts
that have been taken into account in this research paper include, concept of digitalization in rural areas, benefits of digital
Nigeria program, digital Nigeria and empowerment of rural communities, estimated impact of digital Nigeria by 2030 and
problems and challenges. The establishments of vision to create a digital economy have enabled the individuals to bring
about improvements in various areas and promote transformations (Gebremicheal & Jackson, 2006). In the last 20 years,
the global Internet usage has experienced a quantum leap. There are currently about 4.39 billion Internet users in the world,
this is an increase of 366 million (9%) from 2018 levels (Global Web Index, 2019). Interestingly, Nigeria has been a part
of this remarkable trend. The overall Internet users in Nigeria increased to 111.6 million in 2018 from 98.6 million in 2017
(Nigerian Communications Commission 2019). In Africa, Nigeria is the leading country in Internet usage (Statista, 2019).
According to Adeleke(2021) who posited that the end of the twentieth century, digital divide was conceptualized mainly
in terms of the division between those with and without telephone access. After the late 1990s, there was a change in the
conceptualization to describe the split between those with and without Internet access. This split or divide has been
attributed to economic and social inequalities between individuals, businesses, households or geographic areas (Dawood,
Ghazali, and Samat, 2019). This spit is known as digital divide. The digital divide is a term used to describe the
disadvantage in access to information which people without access to ICT suffer (Cullen, 2001).
Nigeria’s digital divide refers to the inequality of Nigerian individuals, groups, or organizations with regard to access
to ICT infrastructure or to the internet for daily activities. The digital divide has been attributed to many factors among
which is the high cost of computer equipment, lack of ICT skill and poor knowledge of available search engines (Omolara,
2016). Lack of access to ICT makes it difficult for people to access information. The benefits of having access to ICT are
numerous. ICT has the potential to promote other sectors of the economy such as agriculture, education, health, bank,
defence etc. In times of emergency, ICT becomes an indispensable tool for overcoming the barriers of time and distance
(Wikipedia, 2023) Education, lack of electrical infrastructure, income, urban drift and a variety of other social and political
factors contribute to Nigeria's growing digital divide (Nwegbu, 2017). Efforts are currently being made to reduce the
digital divide in Nigeria including collaboration between government agencies and technology corporations like Google,
Cchub, Andela, StarBridge Africa, Microsoft and Intel. Intel Corporation (2007) using libraries as E- Learning Theory
facilities, and proposing governmental policies such as salary enhancement and social security (Cullen, 2017). Other
methods of minimizing the digital divide include setting up more computer centres (cybercafes), expansion of the existing
infrastructure, training on computer use and low tariff charges as ways of minimizing the digital divide in Nigeria
(Omolara, 2016).
Speaking at the graduation lecture of Course 29, at the National Defence College Abuja on ‘Enhancing Digital
Technology in the Oil and Gas Sector of Nigeria for National Development’, the former minister of state for petroleum
resources, Timipre Sylva, insisted that investment in digital technology in the petroleum industry is critical for Nigeria’s
N ig er ia J o ur na l of S o ci al D ev el o pm en t (N GJ S D)
98
NGJSD | www.arabianjbmr.com
© 2023, Authors, ZARSMI.
economic growth. As Sylva rightly noted COVID-19 disrupted economic activities especially the oil industry, leading to
a near shutdown of production causing oil prices to fall drastically. He said it accentuated the need for digitalisation, as
oil producing countries sought more efficient production techniques (Umuteme, 2021).
In this way, according to Sylva, technology is helping countries and companies to crack the issues of efficiency
through multi-functional tools, such as Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Automation; Big Data and Data Analytics; Internet
of Things and Electronic Monitoring; and 3D Virtual Modelling and Drone Technology. With proven natural gas reserves
of 206.53 trillion cubic feet; and average production of about 7, 575 million standard cubic feet per day (MMSCFD) which
reflects in the sectors contribution of about 10 per cent to Nigeria’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP), just as crude oil
exports represent about 86 per cent of total export earnings; and about 40 per cent of government revenue.
In Nigeria’s oil and gas industry, digital technology is gradually converting the traditional processes of exploration,
exploitation, and production by delivering the most significant openings in invention. Being tech-savvy is making many
oil companies more flexible, adaptive and competent in an increasingly competitive world. This has led to increased
investment in technology as oil companies seek to be more efficient while trying to drastically cut down on manual
processes which is the major cause of high production costs. Through the deployment of Artificial Intelligence and
automation, the Nigerian oil and gas industry have enjoyed huge application in a variety of areas, covering surveying,
monitoring, planning, forecasting, and safety, in the exploration and production of hydrocarbons. The information can be
mechanically harmonised with an active database linked to maintenance scopes and schedules accessed through a 3D
representation of the platform or a production facility, which can be freely retrieved remotely by operators.
Technology gap has a lot of consequences. According to Repsol (2013), access issues with ICTs make diverse groups
more unequal since they prohibit some people from taking use of the opportunities they present. For instance, during the
lockdown, when many students were required to complete their lessons online, some students were unable to continue
their academics as usual due to a lack of a reliable connection and the necessary devices. The same thing applied to
working from home: adults without the necessary equipment and knowledge had trouble carrying out their regular jobs.
The consequences of technology gap according to Foster& Pushak(2011) include:
Social isolation, especially as a result of the pandemic, has increased among people who do not have access to the
Internet. Additionally, people living in rural areas without reception are virtually cut off from communication services.
Difficulty in accessing education: the lack of access to ICTs makes it difficult for both children and adults to access
education. According to a report by the International Telecommunication Union (ITU), published together with UNICEF,
63% of young people between 15 and 24 years of age do not have an internet connection at home.
A barrier to accessing work: people face greater difficulties in finding a job, not only because digital know-how is
increasingly necessary but also because they are unable to check online job websites where these offers are published.
Social differences are another. The obstacles to connecting to the digital world make the differences between groups
more evident. Geographical differences are also intensified between regions and countries, which directly affects their
possibilities for growth. Dependence and vulnerability is another. Technological discrimination means that some people
have less independence in performing certain tasks, which in turn makes them more vulnerable (e.g., digital crime).
2. CONCLUSION
When it comes to national integration, information and communication technologies (ICTs) are critical instruments
since they allow for increased access to health and education services while also creating economic possibilities for under-
served populations groups. Closing the digital gap is crucial to making socioeconomic progress equitable and sustainable
across the globe. However, providing the technological infrastructure tends to be halted by many challenges, which may
be as the result of poor infrastructure and access to basic amenities like road and electricity. Despite these, there is rapid
growth in mobile and internet penetration; there are also clear interdependencies between telecommunications services
and economic development. Data for the analyses were gotten from documentary sources from World Bank Development
Indicator Database, Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) statistical bulletin and Nigeria Communication Commission (NCC)
publications. The results of this work provided evidence to support the earlier work that digital divide in a polity has
negative consequences and needs to be addressed quickly by Nigerian Government. Thus, there is need to create a
conducive competitive climate for the growth of the industry in order to allow more private investment. Also, considering
the relevance of the telecommunication industry to economic growth and development policy makers should ensure that
telecommunication policies are transparent and stable. Policies and regulations should be made to promote a conducive
and competitive climate for foreign investment so that the capital required for building telecom infrastructure can be met.
Recommendations
In view of the above findings and analysis on the challenges of digitalization divide in an infrastructure deficit polity,
the following recommendations provide the way forward :
N ig er ia J o ur na l of S o ci al D ev el o pm en t (N GJ S D)
99
NGJSD | www.arabianjbmr.com
© 2023, Authors, ZARSMI.
Government role and collaborative efforts
As Nigeria seeks to diversify her economy and make it less dependent on oil, experts believe there is need for
government to proactively support initiatives aimed at deploying infrastructure to connect more people and businesses
online via collaboration, scalable business solutions, and capacity development programmes. The federal government
should, as a matter of necessity work steadfastly towards closing the infrastructure deficit in the nation’s information and
communications technology industry by expediting and deepening the implementation of the National Broadband Plan,
which seeks to grow broadband penetration by 30 per cent in 2018.
2.2.1 Closing ICT infrastructure deficit
More than any other sector, poor infrastructure has been the bane of ICT development in the country and a leading
cause of deficiencies in quality of telecommunications services, from broadband penetration to reliability of mobile
network services. This infrastructure deficit is preventing many Nigerians from gaining affordable and reliable access to
ICT services. These challenges notwithstanding, the private sector is striving to deepen ICT infrastructure in Nigeria to
enable the country deliver better quality of service at lower prices to its teeming population. The critical issues and
challenges in the sector are begging for attention and government must work earnestly to find ways to resolve them.
Government and the private sector must therefore rise to address the country’s infrastructure deficit in ICT in order to
boost speedy development in the digital age. One of the companies that have made investments in good quality
infrastructure facilities to close the digital deficit gap is MainOne. Despite the challenging economic environment in the
country, MainOne has defied the odds and is making a mark in broadband penetration in West Africa and Nigeria in
particular. MainOne continues to invest significantly in growing and covering the broadband ecosystem in West Africa
and growing its leadership position in the industry. From initial investments of over $240 million to deploy a world-class
submarine cable system, followed by investments in a next generation IP NGN network, a growing regional and metro
terrestrial fiber optics network and a Tier III Data Centre, MainOne intends investing over $100 million within the next
five years as a sign of its commitment to improving broadband services in West Africa(Okonji, 2017).
2.2.2 Improved Strategy and Techno-Business Ecosystem
To drive this growth, Nigeria needs a combination of increased access to faster and better quality Internet
connectivity infrastructure, an upskilled tech talent pool, a vibrant start-up ecosystem, access to investment and partnership
opportunities both regionally and internationally. By developing strategy and policy to provide an enabling environment
that would support the private sector to bridge the digital divide is significant. For instance, The minister for Digital
Economy recently appreciated the UK government for support to the country’s digital sector including the development
of the national broadband plan which he noted had led to 10 per cent increase in broadband penetration in Nigeria since it
was launched. He said, “The ICT sector growth rate of 14.70 per cent in 2020 has helped Nigeria pull out of
recession(O’Peters, 2021).
2.2.3 Improved and Sustained Investment
Nigeria digital skills have to be secured and improved upon by encouraging the youths in technology through good
policies that create enabling environment. This will make the country develop its technology and grow its digital economy
to an enviable level. With the world tilting to a knowledge-based economy driven by Artificial Intelligence (AI), Internet
of Things (IoT), and big data, an AI education platform technology firms, scholars and other stakeholders, have
emphasized the need for Nigeria to invest in technology to address the dearth of skills amongst Nigerian youths.
3. REFERENCES
African Development Bank Group, (2014), An Infrastructure Action Plan For Nigeria, Tunis Belvedere: African
Development Bank Group.
Akanbi, B. E., & Akanbi, C. O. (2012), Bridging the digital divide and the impact on poverty in Nigeria. Computing
Information Systems & Development Informatics, 3(4), 8187.
https://doi.org/10.22624/AIMS/CISDI/V3N4P2x
Ani O. E., Uchendu, C., & Atseye, E. U. (2007). Bridging the digital divide in Nigeria: A study of Internet use in Calabar
Metropolis, Nigeria, Library Management, 28(6/7), 355365. https://doi.org/10.1108/01435120710774495
Compaine, B. M. (Ed.). (2001).The digital divide: Facing a crisis or creating a myth? Massachusetts: The MIT Press.
Crandall, R. W. (2001). Universal service, equal access, and the digital divide. In R. G. Noll (Ed.), Bridging the
digital divide (pp. 2937). California Council on Science and Technology. https://ccst.us/wp-
content/uploads/2001Digital.pdf
Cronin, B. (2002). The digital divide. Library Journal 127 (3); 48-59
Cullen, Rowena. "67th IFLA Council and General Conference August 16-25, 2001"
Dawood, S. R. H., S. Ghazali, and N. Samat. 2019. “Digital Divide and Poverty Eradication in the Rural Region of
Northern Peninsular Malaysia.” Indonesian Journal of Geography 51 (2): 67–77.
economy-policy-and-strategy/file
N ig er ia J o ur na l of S o ci al D ev el o pm en t (N GJ S D)
100
NGJSD | www.arabianjbmr.com
© 2023, Authors, ZARSMI.
Eke-Okpala, H. N. (2011). Digitizing resources for University of Nigeria repository: Process and challenges. Webology,
8(1),Article 85. http://www.webology.org/2011/v8n1/a85.html
Foster, V. & Pushak, N., 2011. Nigeria’s Infrastructure: A Continental Perspective. Africa Infrastructure Country
Diagnostic (AIC) Country Report, Washington: World Bank.
Gebremicheal, M. D., & Jackson, J. W. (2006). Bridging the gap in sub-Saharan Africa: A Holistic look at information
poverty,The Journal for Development of Communication and the region’s digital divide. Government
Information Quarterly, 23(2), 267280. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.giq.2006.02.011
Global Web Index. 2019. “Digital 2019: Global Internet Use Accelerates.” https://wearesocial.com/blog/2019/01/digital-
2019-global-internet-use-accelerates.
Law Insider (2021). Technology gap definition. Retrieved on November 13, 2022 from
https://www.lawinsider.com/dictionary/technology-gap
National Bureau of Statistics. 2018b. “Telecoms Data.” https://nigerianstat.gov.ng/elibrary?queries[search]=intern.
Nigerian Communications Commission(2020),Available at https://www.ncc.gov.ng/docman-main/industry-
statistics/policies-reports/883-national-digital-
Nigerian Communications Commission. 2019. “Industry Statistics.”
ttps://www.ncc.gov.ng/stakeholder/statisticsreports/industry-overview.
O” Peters, T. (2023),UK, Nigeria partner to bridge technological gap, https://punchng.com/uk-nigeria-partner-to-bridge-
technological-gap/ 16th March 2021
Okonji, E(2017), Bridging Nigeria’s ICT Infrastructure Gap
https://www.thisdaylive.com/index.php/2016/11/24/bridging-nigerias-ict-infrastructure-gap/
Omolara, Tayo (2016). "Impact of the digital divide on computer use and internet access on the poor in Nigeria" (PDF).
Journal of education and learning. 5 (1).
Onaleye, T., (2020) NBS Report: ICT Contribution to Nigeria’s GDP Rises to 17.8% even as Real GDP Drops to
N15.89 Trillion in Q2 2020. [Online], Available at: https://technext.ng/2020/08/24/nbs-report-ict- contribution-
to-nigerias-gdp-rises-to-17-8-even-as-real-gdp-drops-to-n15-89-trillion-in
q22020/#:~:text=The%20contribution%20of%20the%20Informati
on,Bureau%20of%20Statistics%20(NBS).&text=Reports%20show%20that[Accessed 16 April 2023].
Richard Adeleke (2020): Digital divide in Nigeria: The role of regional differentials, African Journal of Science,
Technology, Innovation and Development, https://doi.org/10.1080/20421338.2020.1748335, Pp1-16.
Statista, (2020),Which brand or type of smartphone do you have?. [Online]Available at:
https://www.statista.com/statistics/387227/market-share-of-smartphone-manufacturers-in-the-uk/[Accessed 23
April 2023].
Statista. 2019. “Number of Internet Users in Selected Countries in Africa.”
https://www.statista.com/statistics/505883/number-of-internet-users-in-african-countries/.
Steele C. (2019). What is the Digital Divide?Retrieved on November 13, 2022 from
http://www.digitaldividecouncil.com/what-is-the-digital-divide/
Umuteme, B. (2021). Investment in technology: Make or break for Nigeria’s oil, gas industry, Blueprint
World Bank, (2019),World Bank Statistical Database.[Online] Available at:
https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/nigeria/overview [Accessed 9 October 2019].
World Bank, (2020), Nigerian Economic Outlook. [Online]Available at:
https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/nigeria/overview[Accessed 17 March 2020].
World Bank, (2020), World Bank Development Indicator. [Online]Available
at:https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.KD.ZG?locations=NG-GB[Accessed 11 March 2020].
... Studies described the disparity as a widening digital divide and lag in Internet use in DCs that leave DCs in the technological wake and preclude progress on the Sustainable Development Goals (United Nations, 2023). The digital divide describes the gap between individuals, households, businesses, and geographical areas with access to information and communication technologies or the Internet of Things (IoT) to improve living standards or business processes (Okoye et al., 2023). While developing countries (DCs) desire that technology evolution would help place their businesses on the radar of transformation, success, and sustainability (Matthess & Kunkel, 2020), it is widely argued whether DCs can achieve business transformation objectives and economic prosperity like developed nations given the increasing barriers to access to digital resource. ...
... However, there is a gap in the research on how DS can be used as a tool to manage and transform businesses in DCs. Existing studies (Agboola et al., 2019;Ofosu-Ampong, 2021;Okoye et al., 2023;Vasilescu et al., 2020;Wezel & Ree, 2023), among others, have provided limited information on DS as a business management and transformational tool in DCs. They focused on the scale of serving a larger population through technology adoptions in specific sectors, leveraging digital financial services to improve revenue generation and banking operations, addressing the digital divide's impact on business operations, and the economic effects of digitalization. ...
... DS potentially reshapes every aspect of modern business (Nwaiwu, 2018;Olanrewaju & Willmott, 2013). However, despite the overwhelming values of DS in business, many business owners and leaders in DCs have yet to explore the potency of digital solutions to manage and transform their businesses to capture more value due to the digital divide and skill gap (Okoye et al., 2023;World Bank Group, 2022). ...
Article
Despite valuable business opportunities and solutions that digital technologies offer, studies show that many business leaders have yet to explore the potential of digital solutions to manage and transform their businesses to capture more value. Through a semi-structured interview with business leaders and managers in Lagos, Nigeria, and content analysis, this paper explored how business leaders may leverage the potency of digital strategies to manage and transform business operations in developing nations like Nigeria to obtain more value. The result provided a distinctive insight into the dynamics around digital strategy adoption in business and the inclusive effects, evidencing that managing and transforming business operations in developing nations is achievable by adopting soft and hardware digital solutions at all levels of the business process. This paper advances the discussion on digital strategy adoption in business and recommends a paradigm shift of businesses in developing countries to a digitally evolved business construct to streamline processes, unlock new opportunities, and benefit from the potency of digital solutions. The paper underscores the government and other stakeholders' roles in driving digital strategy adoption in developing nations' businesses. The recommendation in this paper could be rewarding to influencing change in the process and management of business operations in developing nations, creating an opportunity for theoretical expansion and implementation of digital strategies for business management and transformation to achieve operational efficiency and sustainability objectives.
... On their part, Okoye et al. (2023) used a qualitative research approach to examine the concept of the digital divide and how the divide could be bridged in Nigeria. Their finding revealed that the digital divide in Nigeria is caused by infrastructural inequalities and deficits and intentional and political phenomena. ...
... Suggested strategies for bridging the divide and addressing the disparities include among others:  Improved Infrastructure. Inadequate infrastructure as pointed out by Okoye et al. (2023) and Ravi et al. (2024) is a major lack in rural Nigeria. To mitigate it, the government should partner with technological companies to expand broadband internet access in rural communities that will ensure reliable and high-speed internet connections and invariably enable access to online health resources and AIpowered tools. ...
Article
Full-text available
Artificial Intelligence (AI) has globally been acknowledged to be a force to reckon with in improving diverse sectors of human endeavours. AI, being the most prominent example of digital technology, is acclaimed to have the ability to revolutionize communication and healthcare industries by providing information and healthcare services even to underserved communities. AI has thrown societies into an era where access to information, particularly in the realm of artificial intelligence, holds significant implications for social, economic, and political empowerment. AI in medical practice is still in the infancy stage in sub-Saharan Africa, Nigeria inclusive. The little adoption of AI in the Nigerian healthcare sector is majorly concentrated in urban communities. Rural Nigerians face significant challenges in accessing vital health information, particularly with the emergence of AI technologies causing disparities in AI health information access exacerbated by the digital divide. Despite the potential of AI to revolutionize healthcare, rural communities are hindered by limited internet connectivity, inadequate infrastructure, socioeconomic constraints, and disparities in digital literacy. The paper therefore employed a qualitative research approach using systematic reviews to explore the multifaceted barriers preventing rural Nigerians from accessing AI-based health information and examines the implications of these disparities on healthcare outcomes and patient empowerment. Drawing upon existing literature and data, the paper proposes strategies to address the digital gap and promote equitable access to AI-driven healthcare information dissemination ensuring that rural populations are not left behind in the era of digital health innovation. It concluded that addressing the disparities is sure to improve healthcare outcomes and patient empowerment. The researchers recommended collaborative efforts involving all stakeholders in mitigating the divide and promoting equitable access to AI health information, thereby fostering a more inclusive and just society. The paper is anchored on Digital Divide Theory and Community-Based Participatory Research (CBPR).
... The digital divide is one of the main issues. Nigeria experiences unequal access to digital technology, much like many other developing nations (Okoye, Uchenna, and Okechukwu, 2023). This difference is particularly noticeable between rural and urban locations, as the latter frequently lack the infrastructure required for efficient e-administration. ...
Article
Full-text available
E-administration solves several issues with conventional bureaucratic methods, and its application is essential to modern governance; the increase in time efficiency is one important benefit. E-administration shortens the time needed to perform and provide public services by automating repetitive processes. In the Nigerian Federal Civil Service, where protracted bureaucratic procedures have traditionally impeded service delivery, this efficiency is especially crucial and it is being targeted through the deployment of e-administration in the civil service procedures since the outbreak of Covid-19 pandemic. Therefore, this paper is an exploration of impacts of e-administration in achieving time efficiency in service delivery by the Federal Civil Service in Nigeria. Using the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) as its theoretical framework, the paper discussed how e-administration impacts time efficiency in Nigeria's Federal Civil Service delivery following the COVID-19 outbreak. The paper adopted a qualitative and analytical approach using data from secondary sources which included government records, journals and online resources. This paper emphasized how digital solutions enhanced the replacement of manual, paper-based processes in the Federal Civil Service after Covid 19. It further revealed how time efficiency in the delivery of public services has improved because of e-administration. Citizens now receive more dependable services as a result of digital platforms' ability to handle documents, execute tasks and run online applications more quickly. The paper however identified enduring difficulties associated with the adoption of e-administration in the Federal Civil Service of Nigeria. The shortcomings include unequal access to e-administration which has inspired huge digital divide between urban centers and rural areas where public service deliveries are equally needed. Another challenged identified is associated with reluctance to change as many personnel in the civil service lack the inspiration to acquire digital skills. The paper also considered publicly expressed worries about data security as a limitation. The paper concluded that digital service integration should be standardized across public service systems and departments and address digital infrastructural deficit that would ensure cut edge access to internet and digital tools including in the rural areas, so that the objective of achieving time efficiency in service delivery through e-administration could be optimally realized.
... Not all students have equal access to AI tools or the technological infrastructure required to benefit from them entirely. Okoye et al. (2023) argue that this disparity could exacerbate existing educational inequalities, where students from disadvantaged backgrounds may struggle to compete with peers with greater access to AI resources. Institutions must consider policies ensuring equitable access to AI technologies and providing all students with the tools and training necessary to participate in AI-integrated learning environments. ...
Article
Full-text available
Integrating artificial AI technologies in education has revolutionised teaching, learning, and assessment worldwide. In Nigerian tertiary institutions, students increasingly rely on AI tools for assignments, research, and exam preparation, raising concerns about the integrity of traditional assessment methods. This paper explores the impact of AI technologies on academic performance and the challenges they pose to accurately evaluating student capabilities. It argues for the urgent need to redefine assessment strategies in Nigerian higher education to preserve academic standards while harnessing the benefits of AI. The study highlights ethical concerns such as data privacy, access inequality, and over-reliance on AI tools, which can undermine critical thinking skills. It provides countermeasures and policy recommendations, including establishing AI usage guidelines, promoting equitable access to technology, and integrating assessments that prioritise critical thinking and problem-solving skills. By adopting these innovative policies, Nigerian tertiary institutions can enhance the quality of education and ensure that students develop genuine skills and academic excellence. This paper calls for immediate action to align education with the realities of the AI age, ensuring sustainable and authentic student outcomes.
... Top among the numerous challenges and hindrance of internal communication in Nigeria is the continuous widening of technological gap (Okoye et al., 2023). The gap is characterized by disparities in access to and proficiency in digital communication tools (Okocha and Edafewotu, 2022). ...
Article
Full-text available
This conceptual paper delves into the augmentation of organizational effectiveness through internal communication with specific focus on the Channel Expansion Theory. Consequently, organizations strive to enhance their overall effectiveness by diversifying and broadening their array of communication channels for stakeholders’ satisfaction and organizational excellence. While the theory highlights the influence of experiences on channel richness and the importance of prompt feedback, its practical application faces challenges across different organizational contexts, influenced by industry, size, and culture. Besides elucidating the foundational tenets of the theory, this paper provides a nuanced comprehension of communication dynamics within organizational contexts. In high power distance culture like Nigeria, the paper scrutinizes how expanded communication channels empower employees voice while concurrently reinforcing internal communication strategies. Against the backdrop of existing research which underscores impediments to internal communication in Nigerian firms by attributing hindrance to internal communication to corporate politics, hierarchical structures, centralized communication, technological gaps, and power distance cultural disparities. To address these impediments, the paper advocates for further research on power dynamics and hierarchies in organizational setting as well as how channel expansion can mitigate arbitrary managerial powers to ensure the intended goals and purposes of channel expansion are achieved while also ensuring organizational listening.
... Research findings paint a stark picture of the country's digital divide, highlighting the direct correlation between poverty, infrastructure, and digital access (Okoye, et. al., 2023). The disparity goes beyond mere access to digital tools; it extends to the competence and capacity to leverage these and future innovative tools effectively in advancing economic activities, education, and in the case of the Church, ministry. ...
Conference Paper
The rapid evolution of digital media technologies presents unique opportunities and challenges for the Church's engagement within the modern digital landscape. This paper examines the Church's integration with digital technology, categorizing existing literature into five main areas: effective use of technology; observational or exploratory studies on technology usage, theories of the practice; theories of the science and the art; and innovation in technology. Highlighting the scholarly discourse surrounding the Church's use of digital media technologies, this analysis underscores the necessity for a strategic approach tailored to the Church's specific needs. It argues that transitioning from tool dependency to innovation is the surest way to advance our place and relevance as a Church in the digital ecosystem. Also, the author advocates for the development of innovative technologies, including a bespoke social media platform designed to support the Church and its members' ritual experiences without compromising privacy or exploiting emotions. The paper questions the potential for technology that respects the profound impact of religion on individuals' hearts and souls, cautioning against data harvesting and mining practices that undercut the Church's values. By shifting from reliance on generic tools to promoting innovation, the paper argues for enhancing the Church's relevance in the digital ecosystem, thereby enriching religious experiences amid the complexities of modern technology.
... The disparity in the availability of ICT facilities in some areas of the country especially rural areas continues to pose a great threat to the development of e-learning. Only a small percentage of the population in rural areas have access to computer and electronic devices for online learning [20][21][22]. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
E-learning has been a main disruption in teaching and learning in the world, which has no doubt changed the narratives in the education sector. The advancements in the field of information and communication technologies have been a huge leap in the development of e-learning and presented a novel approach to education, with the switch from the conventional learning environment to transfer of knowledge online. During and after the COVID-19 pandemic it became imperative for more institutions of learning to adopt it. Despite the undeniable benefits of e-learning, usability has become the bane of its smooth implementation. This chapter highlights challenges associated with e-learning solutions and buttress the fact that usability will go a long way to give both teachers and learners a good user experience and give e-learning its pride of place in disruptive technologies. To successfully re-image education, more attention should be focused on ensuring usability of software solutions.
Article
Full-text available
This study empirically analyzed the spatial distribution of Internet usage in Nigeria and identified its key determinants using data on the 36 states and the Federal Capital Territory from 2016 to 2018. In contrast to previous studies, the approach is disaggregated and spatial to better reflect state level disparities in Internet usage and its associated determinants. The data were obtained from the National Bureau of Statistics, United Nations Development Programme Report and other official sources, and were analyzed using stepwise linear regression and Global Moran’s I. The study showed evidence of disparities in Internet usage among the various regions in Nigeria, with noticeable clusters of high values for Internet usage in Lagos, Oyo, Ogun, Kaduna, Kano and Abuja. In contrast, Ekiti, Ebonyi and Bayelsa states had low concentrations of Internet users. Across the nation, between the north and south and its urban and rural areas, Internet usage followed various clear economic and social contours. Market size, employment, income, access to electricity, urbanization, gender (female), age (60 years and above) and telephone density were significant factors in Internet usage. The results of this study can provide basis for regional specific policies in order to increase Internet penetration in disadvantaged locations.
Article
Full-text available
We recruited 20 community members in Ido Local Government Area, Oyo state and Yewa Local Government Area, Ogun state in Nigeria to explore experiences and perceptions of Internet access and computer use. Face-to-face interviews were conducted using open-ended questions to collect qualitative data regarding accessibility of information and communication technology. Twenty low-income community members volunteered to participate in the study. The results centered around affordability of computers and Internet access, exposure to information on the Internet, increasing access to the Internet, training on computer use, benefits for job searching, and networking. The results indicated the lack of Internet access, affordability of computers and Internet usage, poverty, lack of computer skills, and poor infrastructures were contributors to the digital divide.
Article
Full-text available
Infrastructure made a net contribution of around one percentage point to Nigeria's improved per capita growth performance in recent years, in spite of the fact that unreliable power supplies held growth back. Raising the country's infrastructure endowment to that of the region's middle-income countries could boost annual growth by around 4 percentage points. Among its African peers, Nigeria has relatively advanced power, road, rail, and ICT networks that cover the national territory quite extensively. Extensive reforms are ongoing in the power, ports, ICT, and domestic air transport sectors. But challenges persist. The power sector's operational efficiency and cost recovery has been among the worst in Africa, supplying about half of what is required, with subsequent social costs of about 3.7 percent of GDP. The water and sanitation sector has inefficient operations, with low and declining levels of piped water coverage. Irrigation development is also low relative to the country's substantial potential. In the transport sector, Nigeria's road networks are in poor condition from lack of maintenance, and the country has a poor record on air transport safety. Addressing Nigeria's infrastructure challenges will require sustained expenditure of almost 14.2billionperyearoverthenextdecade,orabout12percentofGDP.Nigeriaalreadyspendsabout14.2 billion per year over the next decade, or about 12 percent of GDP. Nigeria already spends about 5.9 billion. It is well placed to raise the funds needed for infrastructure, given the strength of the national economy, abundant oil revenues, and efforts at electricity cost recovery and other improvements to operations and management.
Article
Full-text available
This paper reports on the implementation of digitization of resources at the University of Nigeria, Nsukka (UNN); the processes involved and the challenges faced. In the context of the establishment of a digital library in University of Nigeria, the study aimed to: establish progress that has been made by UNN in digitizing their resources; report the process of digitizing these materials; find out problems encountered in the digitization project; and proffer solutions to the problems encountered. To elicit the necessary information, a literature review of studies done on digitization was carried out. Additionally, information on digitization of University of Nigeria resources was gathered through the University website as it contained necessary information that guided the study. The research was started off mid 2009 and concluded in December, 2009. Researcher's personal experiences and observation methods were also employed in the course of this study. The paper gives an overview of digitization and the digitization initiative in the University of Nigeria, Nsukka including the processes. A lot of challenges are facing the successful digitization of resources in University of Nigeria. Such major deterrents in the project include legal aspect and finances. Other factors were also discussed and the ways forward to the hindrances highlighted. This paper establishes that there are challenges militating against the digitization project in the University of Nigeria, Nsukka (UNN) which demands immediate attention. However, solutions are proffered, which can help in ameliorating the challenges raised.
Article
Purpose The paper aims to discuss and investigate the prevalence of digital divide in Nigeria, using University of Calabar in Calabar Metropolis as a case study. Design/methodology/approach Validated questionnaires were administered to internet users at designated cyber café in the University of Calabar, Calabar, Nigeria. Findings The findings of the survey show the prevalence of various forms of digital divide such as gender, marital status, age and educational level of the internet users in Nigeria. Practical implication The federal/state governments as well as university managements in Nigeria should formulate relevant policies to reduce various forms of digital divide that are prevalent in the Nigeria. Originality/value The paper recommends the need to effectively address the issue of digital divide in whatever form in Nigeria towards global integration in the digital economy.
Universal service, equal access, and the digital divide
  • R W Crandall
Crandall, R. W. (2001). Universal service, equal access, and the digital divide. In R. G. Noll (Ed.), Bridging the digital divide (pp. 29-37). California Council on Science and Technology. https://ccst.us/wpcontent/uploads/2001Digital.pdf
Bridging the gap in sub-Saharan Africa: A Holistic look at information poverty,The Journal for Development of Communication and the region's digital divide
  • M D Gebremicheal
  • J W Jackson
Gebremicheal, M. D., & Jackson, J. W. (2006). Bridging the gap in sub-Saharan Africa: A Holistic look at information poverty,The Journal for Development of Communication and the region's digital divide. Government Information Quarterly, 23(2), 267-280. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.giq.2006.02.011
Bridging Nigeria's ICT Infrastructure Gap
  • E Okonji
Okonji, E(2017), Bridging Nigeria's ICT Infrastructure Gap https://www.thisdaylive.com/index.php/2016/11/24/bridging-nigerias-ict-infrastructure-gap/
Report: ICT Contribution to Nigeria's GDP Rises to 17.8% even as Real GDP Drops to N15.89 Trillion in Q2 2020
  • T Onaleye
Onaleye, T., (2020) NBS Report: ICT Contribution to Nigeria's GDP Rises to 17.8% even as Real GDP Drops to N15.89 Trillion in Q2 2020. [Online], Available at: https://technext.ng/2020/08/24/nbs-report-ict-contributionto-nigerias-gdp-rises-to-17-8-even-as-real-gdp-drops-to-n15-89-trillion-in q22020/#:~:text=The%20contribution%20of%20the%20Informati on,Bureau%20of%20Statistics%20(NBS).&text=Reports%20show%20that[Accessed 16 April 2023].