Conference PaperPDF Available

Using Drones to Attract K-12 Students Towards Construction: A Pilot Study of Middle School Students' attitudes, Perceptions, and Interests

Authors:

Abstract

Drones continue to support the growth of the construction industry; however, activities that use drones for K-12 education are still minimal and exploratory. Particularly, no studies have explored the use of drone technologies to attract students towards construction disciplines. The contribution of this study centers on better understanding how drones can be relied upon to create interest and motivation in K-12 students by showcasing the construction domain to the next generation of the workforce. This study investigated the attitudes and interests towards construction of eleven middle school students enrolled in a Summer Youth Camp at the Michigan Technological University. During this study, a construction-centric drone education activity was designed and implemented during a 3-hour long session within a large lab space. Students completed an adapted version of the S-STEM Survey before and after participating in the activity. Although differences in the survey scores for attitudes towards STEM subjects and interests in construction careers were noticed, no significant changes were observed by the educational activity. Ultimately, this study recommends the use of drones in K-12 activities and purposes exploring how students can be attracted to the construction disciplines as future research.
Using Drones to Attract K-12 Students Towards
Construction: A Pilot Study of Middle School
Students’ attitudes, Perceptions, and Interests
Josiane Isingizwe, Ph.D. Student
and Ricardo Eiris Ph.D.
Michigan Technological University
Houghton, MI
Gilles Albeaino, Ph.D. Candidate and
Masoud Gheisari, Ph.D.
University of Florida
Gainesville, FL
Drones continue to support the growth of the construction industry; however, activities that use
drones for K-12 education are still minimal and exploratory. Particularly, no studies have explored
the use of drone technologies to attract students towards construction disciplines. The contribution
of this study centers on better understanding how drones can be relied upon to create interest and
motivation in K-12 students by showcasing the construction domain to the next generation of the
workforce. This study investigated the attitudes and interests towards construction of eleven middle
school students enrolled in a Summer Youth Camp at the Michigan Technological University.
During this study, a construction-centric drone education activity was designed and implemented
during a 3-hour long session within a large lab space. Students completed an adapted version of the
S-STEM Survey before and after participating in the activity. Although differences in the survey
scores for attitudes towards STEM subjects and interests in construction careers were noticed, no
significant changes were observed by the educational activity. Ultimately, this study recommends
the use of drones in K-12 activities and purposes exploring how students can be attracted to the
construction disciplines as future research.
Key Words: Construction Drones, K-12 Education, Attitudes, Interests, Career Pathways
Introduction
Construction is one of the largest adopters of drones for commercial tasks (DroneDeploy, 2018). This
increased drone usage in construction has been linked to the aerial robots’ capability to access
unreachable or unsafe areas and perform tasks safely and time-efficiently (Albeaino & Gheisari,
2021). Even though technological advances such as drones are helping construction grow as an
industry, reports continuously show problems with workforce labor shortages (Olsen et al., 2012).
These workforce shortages are the result of older professionals leaving the industry once they reach
retirement age and a low influx of new professionals (Suryadi, 2018). Researchers indicate that there
are large difficulties to engage and retain new students in the construction disciplines (Bigelow et al.,
2018). Some studies report that there are negative perceptions (e.g., physically demanding, limited
career progression, unsafe) of the construction industry, with over 70% of parents indicating that they
would not advise their children to pursue construction careers (NCCER, 2020). Other researchers
point to the lack of representation of women, minorities, and persons with disabilities in a largely
white, male-dominated industry sector (Manesh et al., 2020) and that students simply do not get
sufficient exposure to the industry in terms of career exploration, work experiences, or field trips
(Bigelow et al., 2018).
Drones and robotics in the education domain have been used effectively to engage students and foster
interest in STEM careers. Middle school students are often the focus of these investigations within the
context of drone and robotics activities, as research has shown that students at this age-range start to
develop interests in STEM and begin to consider career aspirations (Almeda & Baker, 2020). To
engage middle school students, drone and robotics education leverages extracurricular events such as
competitions, workshops, and after-school programs (Ribeiro & Lopes, 2020). These events have
been successfully implemented in a limited number of STEM disciplines (e.g., computer science,
mathematics) to increase motivation and engagement (Chou, 2018; Bartholomew & Mayo, 2018) as
well as self-efficacy and interest (Tezza et al., 2020).
To address the growing need to engage a new generation of construction professionals, the goal of this
study is to explore the utilization of drones to attract middle school students towards considering
construction as a career path. A pilot intervention was designed and implemented using construction-
centric contents and drones to achieve this goal. Middle school students’ attitudes, perceptions, and
interests towards construction were captured before and after a pilot educational intervention. The
contribution of this study centers on better understanding how drones can be used to create interest
and motivation in K-12 students by showcasing the construction domain to the next generation of the
workforce.
Background
Drones also known as unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) or unmanned aerial systems (UASs) are
defined as remotely piloted aerial robotic platforms equipped with several onboard sensors (Albeaino
& Gheisari, 2021). In the construction domain, drones are being used in different phases, from pre-
construction (e.g., site planning, site mapping and surveying), construction (building inspection,
safety management), to post-construction (building maintenance, post-disaster reconnaissance)
(Albeaino & Gheisari, 2021). These type of drone applications in construction have been recognized
to save time, improve accessibility to compromised spaces, and reduce the cost of construction tasks
(Gheisari & Esmaeili, 2019).
In the educational domain, drones have been found to promote engagement, motivation, and interests
through the use of active, hands-on experiences (Sattar et al., 2017). Literature has identified that
drones can help students to transform abstract concepts into concrete learning (Tezza et al., 2020),
develop technical knowledge and skills (Chou, 2018), and acquire positive attitudes towards STEM
disciplines (Yousuf et al., 2019). Existing drone-based curricula designs provide opportunities to
understand the concepts of drones, use drones to accomplish some tasks (e.g., drone building, flying,
collecting data, programming), and conclude by reflecting on the acquired knowledge (Chou, 2018;
Bartholomew & Mayo, 2018; Tezza et al., 2020). To implement these curricula, researchers and
educators have utilized tangible drone hardware in combination with software tools for student
experimentation in laboratory or classroom environments (Khan, 2018; Chun, 2021).
Activities that use drones in the construction education domain are still minimal and exploratory.
Most existing activities in construction drones are mainly focused on higher education settings,
teaching college and university students drone regulations, flight operations, data collection, and data
processing (Eiris et al., 2018; Williamson III & Gage, 2019; Albeaino et al., 2022). Drone activities in
disciplines such as computer sciences, Mathematics, and aviation are situated within the context. For
example, computer sciences can do drone programming, Mathematics can do problem solving, and
Aviation can do drone flying. However, we have many constraints in construction due to legal and
safety concerns. Drone flights introduce liability and legal concerns, ranging from personal injury and
property damage caused by drone operation errors, to issues such as invasion of privacy, trespassing,
property rights, or insurance issues (Gheisari and Esmaeili 2019). Moreover, taking students to
construction sites is inherently difficult, as construction remains one of the most dangerous industries.
Research Motivation and Scope
The construction industry is in great need for a new generation of construction professionals to join
the workforce. Although, drones have been shown to have the capability to produce interest and
engagement in K-12 students (Burack et al., 2019), there are no studies that investigate how to expose
students to construction drones prior to their enrollment in higher education programs. This study
discusses the design and implementation of a construction-centric drone K-12 educational activity to
engage students at an early age. Particularly, middle school students were targeted, as students in this
age range start to develop career interests (Almeda & Baker, 2020). A pilot pre-, post- experimental
design was used to measure attitudes, perceptions, and interest metrics through a validated survey.
Research Methodology
Educational Context for Construction-Centric K-12 Drone Intervention
For this study, an educational activity for drones in construction was planned as part of a Summer
Youth Program at the Michigan Technological University (MTU). The Summer Youth Program at
MTU offers K-12 students’ hands-on explorations of STEM disciplines within campus. Students
enroll in a week-long program based on their preferences and the departmental offerings at MTU.
Multiple activities occur each morning and afternoon of the program, guided by faculty, staff, and
graduate students. The drone activity in this study was hosted within the “Building a Better World”
program in partnership with the Civil, Environmental, and Geospatial Engineering Department at
MTU. From the K-12 educational range, only students from 6th to 9th grade participated. This study
took place in a three-hour, three-part module on the morning of the second day within the week-long
program. The educational intervention was constrained and driven by this context and time module
requirements. Following is a description of design and implementation of the activity for this pilot
study.
Construction Educational Activity Design and Implementation
The education activity to expose K-12 students to construction disciplines was designed based on the
existing STEM literature that recommends three major components: (1) providing an understanding of
the drone concepts, (2) using drones to accomplish some tasks (e.g., drone building, flying, collecting
data), and (3) offering a reflection activity from the acquired knowledge (Chou, 2018; Bartholomew
& Mayo, 2018; Tezza et al., 2020). To achieve these components of previously successful K-12 drone
STEM activities, three modules were designed as shown in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Construction Drones Educational Activity Design
Module 1 What are Construction Drones? This module focused on introducing construction
drones to students. A discussion was provided regarding the different parts of drones (e.g., propellers,
batteries, data capturing sensors), construction drone applications using multiple sensors (e.g.,
building inspection task, quantity takeoffs, energy monitoring), and drone flight safety requirements
on construction sites. Additionally, an introductory description of the basic flight operations was
delivered for students prior to practicing their drone flight skills.
Module 2 Construction Drone Practice This module enabled students to perform hands-on flight
employing a Category 1 drone (less than 0.55 pounds; Ryze Tech Tello®) in an indoor lab
environment. The flight task was inspired by construction building inspection tasks, requiring pilots to
observe objects using an onboard camera sensor during a drone flight. Moreover, in this module,
students learned about construction drone flight operations and applications through a live flight.
Module 3 Drone Data Usage in Construction This module offered students the opportunity to
reflect on prior modules by using drone collected data. Through the use of Autodesk Revit®, students
performed a building inspection task using a point-cloud model of a residential building. A discussion
was held regarding the use of drones in construction through the data visualization task, elaborating
on the dimensions necessary to add a garage to the house project.
The implementation of this construction drone educational activity was done after approval from the
MTU Internal Review Board (IRB-1912793-2). Prior to the activity, parents and students provided
informed consent through an established protocol. The duration of the activity and the data collection
totaled 3 hours. Each module lasted for approximately 50 minutes and the data collection took 15
minutes before and after the drone activities. Before starting the construction drone educational
activity, a demographic questionnaire, and an attitudes, perceptions, and interest survey were
completed by the students. After completing the drone activity, the same attitudes, perceptions, and
interests survey was completed again. To make sure all operations were safe for the students, all
flights were conducted with a drone less than 0.55 pounds (Category 1), with a safety cage blocking
any exposed rotating parts that could lacerate human skin. Additionally, hardhats and safety glasses
were required at all times. All activities were overseen by a Federal Aviation Administration (FAA)
Part 107 remote pilot certificate holder. The activity modules were held in an indoor, controlled
laboratory space. Five Ryze Tello® drones and Tello® Propeller Guards were used for Module 2.
Students were split into small teams of three, each using one drone battery that delivers 10 to 15
minutes of flight time. All students used the Tello® companion app in an Apple iPad® device to
operate the drones.
Activity Evaluation and Metrics
To measure students' attitudes, perceptions, and interest towards construction, this study utilized a
pre-, post-test experimental design. Students completed an adapted version of the Middle/High School
(6th 12th) Student Attitudes towards Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math (S-STEM) Survey
(Unfried et al., 2015). This survey measures changes in student attitudes and perceptions in STEM
subjects, and interests in STEM careers. Adapted version of the S-STEM survey was used in this
study, consisting of 25 items divided into two sections. The first section of the survey had 18 items
with a 5-point Likert scale measuring students’ self-perception and attitudes towards STEM subjects
across three dimensions Math, Science, and Engineering. The Math dimension contained five
questions that were rated between 1 = Strongly Disagree, and 5 = Strongly Agree. The Science
dimension contained five questions that were rated between 1 = Strongly Disagree, and 5 = Strongly
Agree. The Engineering dimension contained eight questions that were also rated between 1 =
Strongly Disagree, and 5 = Strongly Agree. The survey questions used statements that revealed how
the students perceive themselves in relation to Math, Science, and Engineering (e.g., I am good at
math; I know I can do well in science; I am curious about how to construct things). The second
section of the survey used a 4-point Likert scale used to measure participants’ interests in STEM and
construction careers. The survey question in this second section described potential careers (e.g.,
Energy, Computer Science, Construction) and students rated their interests using a scale between 1=
Not at all interested, and 4 = Very interested. Each career name included its definition and short
description of their work environment.
Results and Discussion
Demographics
A total of 14 middle school students participated in the construction drone activity during the Summer
of 2022. From the 14 student participants, the data from 3 had to be discarded due to incomplete
responses. The remaining 11 participants (2 females and 9 males) were considered for analysis in this
study. In terms of participant demographics (Table 1), students ranged in age from 12 to 14 years,
with a mean age of 13 years. The sample collected included students in grades 7th through 9th, with the
majority (55%) being in 8th grade. The majority of participants were male (82%), and a small portion
female (18%). Most participants identified as White (73%), with a small percentage identifying as
other races (27%) (Asian, Indian, and 1 Unspecified). A large percentage of the students reported to
have used a drone more than once before (82%).
Table 1. Demographic information on Construction-Centric K-12 Drone Intervention participants
Participants
Categories
Number
Percentage
Sex
Male
9
82%
Female
2
18%
Age
Years
12-14
13
Race
White
8
73%
Other (e.g., Asian,
Indian, and 1
Unspecified)
3
27%
Grade
7th
2
18%
8th
6
55%
9th
3
27%
Have you ever used a
drone before?
No, Never
1
9%
Only Once
1
9%
A few times
9
82%
Attitudes and Interests
The data from pre- and post-test survey for the construction drone activity was analyzed with both
descriptive and inferential statistics. Table 2 shows the results from this analysis. A lower mean score
was obtained in the post-test attitudes and perception towards STEM subjects compared with the pre-
test results for Math (pre = 4.61; post = 4.39; delta = 0.22), Science (pre = 4.11; post = 3.99; delta =
0.12), and Engineering (pre = 4.19; post = 4.11; delta = 0.08). The largest score differential observed
was for Math (delta = 0.22) and the lowest overall score means were obtained for Science (pre = 4.11;
post = 3.99). These attitudes and perception results for the Math and Science dimensions of the survey
can be potentially attributed to the lack of student exposure in the construction drone activity to Math
or Science topics as typically done in a middle classroom setting (e.g., algebra problems, reading
assignments). Overall, both Math and Engineering scores were observed positive, with a mean score
above 4 (Agree) on the Likert scale of pre- and post-test survey. For the test results on interests in
STEM careers, it was found that the mean scores where high for all careers. It is important to
highlight that the pre- and post-test results for interest in Engineering (pre = 2.73; post = 3.27; delta =
0.54) and Construction (pre = 2.91; post = 3.27; delta = 0.36) careers show the largest mean scores
among all the survey careers (both pre and post-test). These career interest results could be explained
by the fact that the designed construction drone activity offered direct exposure to the construction
domain, while no exposure to the other careers in the survey was offered to the students.
The inferential statistical analysis was performed using a paired-samples t-test. This statistical
analysis revealed that there were no significant differences in the attitudes and perceptions students
regarding STEM subjects, or in the interest in STEM and Construction careers due to the construction
drone activity. The lack of significant differences between pre-test and post-test could be explained by
a small sample size. Although the construction drone activity data set only contained 11 students, the
results of this study suggest that there might be positive relation between interest in STEM and
Construction careers and the experiences offered by the construction drone activity.
Table 2. Adapted S-STEM Survey for Attitudes and Interests
Categories
Post-test
P-value
Mean (SD)
Attitudes towards STEM Subjects
Math
4.39 (0.17)
0.23
Science
3.94 (0.09)
0.15
Engineering
4.11 (0.18)
0.48
Interests in STEM Careers
Biology and Zoology
2.64 (0.11)
0.69
Mathematics
3.00 (0.11)
0.31
Computer Science
3.00 (0.08)
0.30
Chemistry
2.73 (0.09)
0.49
Energy
3.18 (0.07)
0.12
Engineering
3.27 (0.08)
0.14
Construction
3.27 (0.08)
0.37
Lessons Learned: Opportunities and Challenges
Opportunities: Throughout the construction drone activity, students displayed engagement and
excitement. Module 2 Construction Drone Practice, was observed to be the most engaging of the
activities to the students. Additionally, students displayed excitement about construction drones
through asking questions such as the drone costs, and taking pictures and videos while flying the
drones in the lab space. These observations regarding the hands-on nature of drone activities match
what prior studies have found in terms of drone effectiveness to attract students towards STEM
disciplines (Chou, 2018; Bartholomew & Mayo, 2018). It was also found that the simplicity and
accessibility of the Ryze Tello® drones enable the completion of the activities without major issues
for the duration of the activity. These drones were easy to fly and students quickly learned how to
employ the camera sensor to capture data within the lab space. Moreover, there was institutional and
parental buy-in to perform this activity. MTU provided the funds needed to perform this study and all
parents authorized their children to participate in the activity. It is particularly important to get
parents' interest, as research shows that parental approval significantly influences student engagement
and motivation in STEM (Bempechat & Shernoff, 2012).
Challenges: Despite the educational opportunities learned from this study, there were several
challenges observed. Although the drones selected were suitable for this type of study, there were
limitations in terms of flight time and network interference from multiple Ryze Tello® drones. During
the “Module 2 – Construction Drone Practice”, several flight interruptions were experienced during
the practice event. These interruptions occurred due to network issues with connection between the
ground control station and the drones, producing sudden disconnections and loss of control of the
drone. Another challenge faced by the researchers was the limited amount of time for the activity. The
overall activities lasted for three hours in a single exposure. This limited amount of time reduced the
ability of students to internalize the learned contents and constrained the design of the module to very
simple topics in construction and drones. A more comprehensive curriculum with a longer exposure
time (e.g., few days) is recommended to increase the effectiveness of such activities to engage,
motivate, and attract students towards construction.
Research Limitations
In disciplines such as computer science, mathematics, and aviation, drone activities are situated within
the context of their corresponding domains. For example, computer science students can get direct
exposure to programming using drones, mathematics students can do problem solving, and aviation
perform drone flights. However, construction disciplines students do not get direct exposure to
jobsites due to legal and safety issues. These constraints can potentially contribute to lower impact on
student engagement for construction in comparison to other disciplines. This study had several
limitations related to the sample size, the limited exposure time, and the lack of exposure to real-
world drone operations. First, the sample size was small and lacked diversity. The sample
composition consisted of only 7th through 9th grade middle school students with most of the
participants (73%) being from one race (White). Additionally, the sample ratio of male-to-female was
disbalanced, with a very small proportion of females (18%). Second, this study took place in a three-
hour module on the second day of the week-long program. The educational activity was constrained
and driven by this context and time each module required. Third, the drone activity design and
implementation of this study was not situated in a real-world construction site. The lack of exposure
to construction sites was due to safety concerns for flying drones by a large group of middle school
students. This is a common limitation of educational studies in higher education (Eiris et al., 2018;
Williamson III & Gage, 2019; Albeaino et al., 2022) that extends into this exploratory study.
Conclusion and Future Study
Although drones continue to support the growth of the construction industry, no studies have explored
how to employ drone technologies to attract K-12 students towards construction disciplines. An
experimental K-12 activity was designed to enhance students’ attitudes and perceptions towards
construction, as well as to provide a method to foster interest in construction domain careers. The
created K-12 educational activity was piloted with eleven middle school students, introducing them to
construction drones, allowing them to perform hands-on flight operations, and offering them
opportunities to reflect on drone-collected data through the use of point-clouds. Data was collected
from the middle school students before and after exposing them to the construction drone activity
through the use of an adapted version of the S-STEM Survey (Unfried et al., 2015). The S-STEM
survey measured changes in attitudes, perceptions, and interest regarding STEM and construction.
The results obtained from the pilot study showed mean score differences in attitudes and perceptions
towards STEM, and interests in construction careers. However, these results did not show statistically
significant differences, mainly due to the small study sample size.
We concur with previous researchers that drones can be effective in attracting students towards
construction as it has worked in other disciplines (Bartholomew & Mayo, 2018; Khan, 2018; Yousuf
et al, 2019; Tezza et al, 2020). Our results provide hints that drones might enable to engage students
in construction. However, further research is necessary to definitively answer this question. Future
studies exploring the attraction of K-12 students to construction disciplines should adapt the design
provided in this study for a larger cohort of participants. By collecting a larger sample with more
robust gender and racial/ethnic diversity, researchers would be able to understand what aspects of
drones and construction attract different types of students to construction. Furthermore, there is a need
to understand how exposure to real-world drones, actual construction sites, and practicing
construction professionals might enhance the design of the presented activity. Finally, other variables
such as knowledge, engagement and motivation, and self-efficacy should be explored to better
understand the mechanism that changes in students' attitudes, perceptions, and interests towards
construction.
References
DroneDeploy (2018). 2018 Commercial Drone Industry Trends. Retrieved from: https://dronedeploy-
www.cdn.prismic.io/dronedeploy-www%2Fae535fda-dfc9-4bcf-9743292df714e9fe_dd__
2018_trends _report-f.pdf (Last accessed on 9/21/2022)
Albeaino, G., Gheisari, M., & Issa, R. R. (2022). Integration of a UAS-Photogrammetry Module in a
Technology-based Construction Management Course. EPiC Series in Built Env., 3, 497-505.
Gheisari, M., & Esmaeili, B. (2019). Applications and requirements of unmanned aerial systems
(UASs) for construction safety. Safety Science, 118, 230240.
Albeaino, G., Eiris, R., Gheisari, M., & Issa, R. R. (2022). DroneSim: A VR-based flight training
simulator for drone-mediated building inspections. Construction Innovation.
Albeaino, G., & Gheisari, M. (2021). Trends, benefits, and barriers of unmanned aerial systems in the
construction industry: a survey study in the United States. Journal of Information
Technology in Construction (ITcon), 26(6), 84-111.
Manesh, S. N., Choi, J. O., & Shrestha, P. (2020). Critical Literature Review on the Diversity and
Inclusion of Women and Ethnic Minorities in Construction and Civil Engineering Industry
and Education. In Construction Research Congress 2020: Safety, Workforce, and Education
(pp. 175-184). Reston, VA: American Society of Civil Engineers.
Suryadi, J. (2018). Examining the Labor Shortage in the Construction Industry and Possible Solutions
Presented by Industry Members. CalPoly, SLO. Retrieved From: https://digitalcommons.
calpoly.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi? article =1187&context=cmsp (Last accessed on 9/21/2022).
Olsen, D., Tatum, M., and Defnall, C. (2012). How industrial contractors are handling skilled labor
shortages in the United States. 48th ASC Annual International Conference Proceedings.
Bigelow, B. F., Saseendran, A., & Elliott, J. W. (2018). Attracting students to construction education
programs: An exploration of perceptions by gender. International Journal of Construction
Education and Research, 14(3), 179-197.
National Center for Construction Education & Research (NCCER) (2020). Research & Marketing
Playbook for the Construction Industry. Retrieved from: https://nccer.actonservice.com/acton
/fs/blocks/showLandingPage/a/29279/p/p-0026/t/page/fm/0 (Last accessed on 9/21/2022)
Burack, C., Melchior, A., & Hoover, M. (2019). Do After-School Robotics Programs Expand the
Pipeline into STEM Majors in College?. Journal of Pre-College Eng. Edu. Research, 9(2), 7.
Almeda, M. & Baker, R.S. (2020). Predicting Student Participation in STEM Careers: The Role of
Affect and Engagement during Middle School. Journal of Edu. Data Mining, 12(2), 33-47.
Ribeiro, A. F., & Lopes, G. (2020). Learning robotics: a review. Current Robotics Reports, 1(1), 1-11.
Chou, P. N. (2018). Smart technology for sustainable curriculum: using drones to support young
students’ learning. Sustainability, 10(10), 3819.
Bartholomew, J. L., & Mayo, R. S. (2018). Development of a 4th-8th grade curriculum for flying and
programming mini drones. Master of Science Thesis, Utah State University.
Tezza, D., Garcia, S., & Andujar, M. (2020). Let’s Learn! An Initial Guide on Using Drones to Teach
STEM for Children. International Conference on HCI (pp. 530-543).
Sattar, F., Tamatea, L., & Nawaz, M. (2017). Droning the pedagogy: Future prospect of teaching and
learning. International Journal of Educational and Pedagogical Sciences, 11(6), 1632-1637.
Yousuf, A. Mustafa, M.A., Hayder, M.M., & Cunningham, K.R. (2019) Drone Labs to Promote
Interest in STEM. 2019 126th ASEE Annual Conference and Exposition, June 16-19.
Chun, H. (2021). A Study on the Utilization of Drone Education in the Fourth Industrial Revolution.
In Journal of Physics: Conference Series (Vol. 1875, No. 1, p. 012017). IOP Publishing.
Khan, M. J. (2018). Impact of Programming Robots and Drones on STEM Attitudes. 2018 ASEE
Annual Conference and Exposition, June 24-27, Salt Lake City, UT.
Williamson III, K.C., & Gage, G. (2019) Important Considerations for Implementing a Drone-based
Activity within a Construction Surveying Course. Annual Conference for the Associated
School of Construction Denver, Colorado, Apr. 2019.
Eiris, R., Zhou, S., & Gheisari, M. (2018). Integrating the Use of UAVs and Photogrammetry into a
Construction Management Course: Lessons Learned. International Symposium on
Automation and Robotics in Construction (ISARC) Jul. 2018
Bempechat, J., & Shernoff, D. J. (2012). Parental influences on achievement motivation and student
engagement. In the Handbook of research on student engagement (pp. 315-342). Springer.
Unfried, A., Faber, M., Stanhope, D. S., & Wiebe, E. (2015). The development and validation of a
measure of student attitudes toward science, technology, engineering, and math (S-STEM).
Journal of Psychoeducational Assessment, 33(7), 622-639.
... According to the included studies, we gathered data from n = 12 studies from the year 2015 to 2023. The research protocols of the included studies were allocated to several countries including n = 4 from Greece [25][26][27][28], n = 1 from Thailand [29], n = 1 from China [30], n = 1 Taiwan [12], n = 1 South Korea [31], n = 1 Croatia [32], n = 1 USA [33], n = 1 Brazil [34], and n = 1 non-specified [35]. For the children, adolescents, and adults examined, we collected data from n = 994 subjects ranging from 3rd grade to university students and graduates [12,25,26,31,[33][34][35]. For the teachers' or educators' performance, perception, or point of view, we collected data from n = 509 subjects, including different academic positions from school to university [27][28][29][30]. ...
... The research protocols of the included studies were allocated to several countries including n = 4 from Greece [25][26][27][28], n = 1 from Thailand [29], n = 1 from China [30], n = 1 Taiwan [12], n = 1 South Korea [31], n = 1 Croatia [32], n = 1 USA [33], n = 1 Brazil [34], and n = 1 non-specified [35]. For the children, adolescents, and adults examined, we collected data from n = 994 subjects ranging from 3rd grade to university students and graduates [12,25,26,31,[33][34][35]. For the teachers' or educators' performance, perception, or point of view, we collected data from n = 509 subjects, including different academic positions from school to university [27][28][29][30]. ...
... Most of the experimental processes referring to the use of drones for students were conducted in real-world contexts [12,25,26,33]. Finally, about the authors' methodology, most of them utilized a mixed method of collecting quantitative and qualitative data for analysis. ...
Article
Full-text available
Due to COVID-19, Industry 4.0 technologies have been deeply integrated into our lives, making it possible to interact, learn, and be productive. The rise of ICT has been established for a lot of years, transforming the educational process of many students with more and more educators applying them in school settings and considering them an essential part of teaching. ICT constantly evolves incorporates and utilizes all the recent and cutting-edge technology to help learners interact and learn in the most engaging and motivating way. The purpose of this literature review is to investigate a very fascinating and promising piece of robotic technology called a drone or unmanned aerial vehicle and how it has been integrated and utilized in the educational process of students to date. In the introduction, the main adoptions of ICT and drones are discussed. In the main part, we explore the possibilities and the applications of drone technology in the educational path from analysis of included studies and research, as well as discussing the students' and teachers' perceptions of their use. The results of this study of the application of drones in education show promising effects among students and teachers, but several limitations were identified, making it still difficult to generalize their use in the educational process. Furthermore, a need for a unified framework for reference is needed to be able to accommodate their use in school and academic environments.
Article
Full-text available
Unmanned Aerial Systems (UASs) have rapidly been integrated into the construction industry over the past few years, and their application is continually growing in this domain. The recent development in UAS regulations and technical capabilities have played a significant role in their popularity and wide deployment in various stages of the construction lifecycle. UASs could be used as a platform to enhance the construction practices in general; however, little is known about how construction professionals are adopting this technology in specific construction practices and the barriers they are facing for their successful implementation. The purpose of this study is to explore the current state-of-practice of UAS integration in construction from the industry professionals' viewpoint. A comprehensive survey study was conducted in the United States to identify the practical construction UAS application areas, their adopted technologies, as well as the benefits and barriers encountered during their implementation. Responses (n=56) showed that most common UAS applications include progress monitoring, site planning, and site surveying/mapping. Rotary-wing vehicles and visual and thermal cameras were the most used platforms and onboard sensors, respectively. Saving time, improving accessibility to compromised spaces, and reducing cost while accomplishing construction tasks were highly regarded as UAS implementation benefits in construction. Participants also considered flying in various weather conditions, within confined or congested areas, as well as the advanced technical know-how requirements, and the increased liability and legal challenges as barriers to using UASs in construction-related tasks. By understanding UAS adoption in construction, this study provides a roadmap to better identify the industry needs and guide researchers and professionals in investigating application areas and barriers that might have maximum benefits for the construction industry in the United States.
Article
Full-text available
Given the increasing need for skilled workers in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM), there is a burgeoning interest to encourage young students to pursue a career in STEM fields. Middle school is an opportune time to guide students’ interests towards STEM disciplines, as they begin to think about and plan for their career aspirations. Previous studies have shown that detectors of students’ learning, affect, and engagement, measured from their interactions within an online tutoring system during middle school, are strongly predictive of their eventual choice to attend college and enroll in a STEM major (San Pedro et al., 2013, 2014). In this study, we extend prior work by examining how the constructs measured by these detectors relate to the decision to participate in a STEM career after college. Findings from this study suggests that subtle forms of disengagement (i.e., gaming the system, carelessness) are predictive and can potentially provide actionable information for teachers and counselors to apply early intervention in STEM learning. In general, this study sheds light on the relevant student factors that influence STEM participation years later, providing a more comprehensive understanding of student STEM trajectories.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose of Review With the growing interest for STEM/STEAM, new robotic platforms are being created with different characteristics, extras, and options. There are so many diverse solutions that it is difficult for a teacher/student to choose the ideal one. This paper intends to provide an analysis of the most common robotic platforms existent on the market. The same is happening regarding robotic events all around the world, with objectives so distinctive, and with complexity from easy to very difficult. This paper also describes some of those events which occur in many countries. Recent Findings As the literature is showing, there has been a visible effort from schools and educators to teach robotics from very young ages, not only because robotics is the future, but also as a tool to teach STEM/STEAM areas. But as time progresses, the options for the right platforms also evolve making difficult to choose amongst them. Some authors opt to first choose a robotic platform and carry on from there. Others choose first a development environment and then look for which robots can be programmed from it. Summary An actual review on learning robotics is here presented, firstly showing some literature background on history and trends of robotic platforms used in education in general, the different development environments for robotics, and finishing on competitions and events. A comprehensive characterization list of robotic platforms along with robotic competitions and events is also shown.
Article
Full-text available
The study developed a sustainable curriculum in which one smart technology (drone) was employed to inspire student learning. The study investigated the effect of using drones on the development of students' spatial visualization and sequencing skills and examined related instructional tasks for drone use in the classroom. An after-school drone-flying program was developed at a public elementary school in Taiwan, with 10 third-grade students voluntarily participating in a six-week educational experiment. During drone programming training, young children used a visual block programming language on tablet computers to code lightweight drones. A two-phase research model was adopted to collect the necessary information. In the first phase of the model, a design-based research methodology facilitated the overall instruction preparation process for the four-week workshops. The second phase of the model emphasized a mixed-method research approach, employing a quasi-experimental pretest and post-test design to analyze the effect of drone use and a qualitative method to observe students' learning behavior and programming work. The results showed that drone programming significantly improved students' learning of spatial visualization and sequencing skills. Gender, as a potential variable, only influenced students' programming patterns. Specific programming styles, learning behaviors, and instructional design issues were identified for further discussion.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV) have gained tremendous interest in the construction management domain as a platform for progress monitoring, safety supervision, quality inspections, and overall job site logistics. With the continued growth of UAV application within construction domain, it is essential for construction program graduates to develop a general understanding of UAV operations, regulations, and integration with other technologies as a part of their construction curriculum. This document presents an exploratory case study to identify the potential opportunities and challenges of integrating a UAV and photogrammetry module into a building information modeling (BIM) undergraduate-level course. Photogrammetry and BIM integration with UAV have been selected as the use case because of their widely-used applications in construction domain. The module learning objectives as well as the technical components of flight operations, knowledge tests, and photogrammetry workflow integration are discussed in detail. This module provided an opportunity for students to obtain hands-on experience on both software and hardware sides of the UAV, Photogrammetry, and BIM integration. This allowed the students to successfully assess and implement these technologies in a realistic practice exercise. Challenges were found with the time required for student to be sufficiently effective pilots to perform the UAV flight operations under the hardware limitations of the study. Additional blockades were recognized during the integration of federal aviation administration (FAA) UAV regulations within the module. The contribution of this case study is to provide a better understanding of integrating the use of UAV and photogrammetry within an undergraduate construction curriculum.
Article
Purpose-This study aims to explore DroneSim, a virtual reality (VR)-based flight training simulator, as an alternative for real-world drone-mediated building inspection training. Design/methodology/approach-Construction, engineering and management students were asked to pilot drones in the VR-based DroneSim space and perform common flight operations and inspection tasks within the spatiotemporal context of a building construction project. Another student group was also recruited and asked to perform a similar building inspection task in real world. The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)-Task Load Index (TLX) survey was used to assess students' inflight workload demand under both Real and DroneSim conditions. Post-assessment questionnaires were also used to analyze students' feedback regarding the usability and presence of DroneSim for drone building inspection training. Findings-None of the NASA-TLX task load levels under real and DroneSim conditions were highly rated by students, and both groups experienced comparable drone-building inspection training. Students perceived DroneSim positively and found the VR experience stimulating. Originality/value-This study's contribution is twofold: to better understand the development stages involved in the design of a VR-based drone flight training simulator, specifically for building inspection tasks; and to improve construction students' drone operational and flight training skills by offering them the opportunity to enhance their drone navigation skills in a risk-free, repeatable yet realistic environment. Such contributions ultimately pave the way for better integration of drone-mediated building inspection training in construction education while meeting industry needs.
Conference Paper
Research about diversity in construction and civil engineering (CCE) has been conducted from both the academic and industrial points of view. Researchers have suggested several strategies to further attract women and ethnic minorities (WEMs) to CCE at both academic and industry levels, mainly due to the skilled labor shortage, as well as to preserve the future success of the U.S. economy. Accordingly, this literature review aims to present the current levels of diversity and inclusion of minorities in CCE at academic and industry levels, while it identifies effective strategies for increasing diversity, recognizes knowledge gaps, and suggests recommendations for future research. The review is conducted by searching relevant papers from leading construction management and engineering education peer-reviewed publications. The findings indicate that although the low participation of minorities in CCE industries and education has been studied a few times from a gender point of view, it has not received adequate attention from the ethnicity perspective, especially at the academic level. This paper contributes to the body of knowledge by bringing together information related to the underrepresentation of WEMs in CCE academia and workforce environments and identifying the potential reasons for this low participation.
Article
This paper attempts to examine what factors have caused the sustained labor shortage in the construction industry. Whether it be through the lens of general contractors, trade partners, or suppliers, all parties associated with the built-environment have experienced a form of labor shortage or an increase in older employees with few replacements readily available. The main purpose of this paper is to gather enough data and opinions from construction industry members to formalize the few key factors of the diminished labor force, primarily in California’s commercial construction sector. The lack of skilled workers has negatively impacted the quality and quantity of work able to be performed by trade partners in their respective fields. Conversely, this has impacted the amount of work general contractors can partake in. An additional aim for this research paper is to garner potential solutions that industry members have that can not only expand the current construction labor force, but to also increase awareness of the construction career path to high school students and young individuals. Results of an industry survey indicate that construction firms desire more outreach to high schoolers and college-aged citizens. Whether that be through their own outreach or by unions and vocational programs, there is an emphasis on educating and exposing young people to the construction industry as a worthwhile career. Whether this is through increased funding for trades-related programs by industry members, or initiating new forms of mentorship for students, it is imperative construction members collaborate to find an end to the labor shortage.