ArticlePDF Available

Teaching Sustainable Healthcare through the Critical Medical Humanities

Authors:

Abstract

This article argues for a more critical, transformative and philosophically-underpinned approach to teaching Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). The standard approach presents the SDGs as uncontested and universally agreed-upon targets, which oversimplifies their complexity and inherent contradictions and engages only superficially with the central unifying theme of sustainability. Whilst environmentally friendly healthcare practices and reducing healthcare’s carbon footprint are important goals, conflating them with the sustainability agenda conveys an overly narrow message about what sustainability is and how we might achieve it. To address these issues, the article proposes a more radical approach that integrates critical medical humanities into sustainable healthcare education and SDG discussions. The Centre for Sustainable Health Education (SHE) at the University of Oslo is presented as an example of this approach. SHE delivers a radical curriculum which aims to raise awareness of the challenges, conflicts and compromises involved in striving for a fair and sustainable future. SHE's teaching methods encourage collaborative, critical, and interdisciplinary reflection, which helps students to engage with ongoing controversies and debates surrounding sustainability and the SDGs. Ultimately, this approach broadens our understanding of health, illness, and sustainability by illuminating and interrogating the power structures that shape these concepts.
Arcle Type: Comment
Title: Teaching Sustainable Healthcare through the Crical Medical Humanies
Authors: Eivind Engebretsen, Rika Sharma, Tony J. Sandset, Krisn Heggen, Ole Pe&er O&ersen,
Helen Clark, Trisha Greenhalgh
corresponding author
 ! "##$%!%&#' ( )*+,-./0
12/2$2&#3-45344
)63
 ! "##$%!%&#' ( )*+,
7863+)
 ! "##$%!%&#' ( )*+,
9:;
 ! "##$%!%&#' ( )*+,
< <3)96= 
 ! "##$%!%&#'
( )*+,
633(>?(:+376
$$*+6(*?+@+(:
7A(B:;33
C)D3!*6) C "2EAA9
Conicts of interest:7B>
;>C3;47
6>F4
3(G#0:;3A:A
4,33;;;3
4:;H;;;;;;
;I#;>3:A>4 J=:K#1
;3D:A;CF;3
347;3:AKL;2M$
>>K>4E
7;;:A;3>
40'*>;>
;33N!3
3;O;>34;;
L3;CF>;>;;
3K4
7 G
(>2%2%C(>
:6;;;:A
3347;O6
3;>;
;41GC
C;>3-34+6>;;3
3;>>33331#%DK
;;C3>33
3;;3
34##76633;;
33<34#2
73>B3;3
47>6LL3
3;#&#/36
;;34=D>F>6;K
+@>3;>H3G>3
3GI4#$73
;3>6347;
;K>34
D3;3:AL3>
;4#E#03C3;>;
>;4 ;>:A
>;;B3;3;3
;6>;>3D:A4#1+
>D>;3
43PO;;;F
DG;3>6
3FK;;42%
;3;K
4+3;36;6
3;;>33
32#;;L4;
3>;;>3F;
34
Example topic How it is covered in a ‘crical medical humanies’ informed curriculum
+3

;;3Q>G;C3
3K>36B3;;Q
>GM>3;33R
;3R


3
3L3;R33
3;;;
>;33R334
3
;3
;;
;
76 ;;;;
333;3R;
D>>O6>
6>;>C;
: KS
C3
3 *6>;33
3Q<3K;G;;33
;K3K>;3
P3;3443;
6R33;>
>;;33
42#
+;>6 ; ;T3K
C;K
;;C422G
>63;CL
3 47K33
G>>;:A33;F
;;334#0
7>6;>3;;3
;;6>L
;;C3L
4*;>363
;;:A4
6;;;K;;>
;>6C;3O3
;36;33;3
33;C;3334
D33;>
G3;3;336>3
;;3;33
4
References
#4 )+4)U0%U#473>-2%&%;34
(A+3(>,642%#$S2$4
24 < :;8!!>J68444V=47
;L-;;47@42%#/S&'&11#0E&%KEE04
&4 < 4 J=:K#1;;3
4(42%2%S26###E02K#E0&4
/4864);=;3;);-
36 J=:K#1;347@42%2#S&1'#%21$#%#K#%&4
$48:93++6@+8!W9344447@
333 J=:K#1;347@42%22S/%%#%&$1#22/K
#2'%4
E4!64)673343
2%224
04 7+(3+;@(>37)4=OP
442%#0S22#-#&'E%/24
'4 >*;@+RK(!!R94+
3-;442%2#S/&&-202K
'E4
14 J**+433-33664
342%#$8#S/##-2K04
#%4 R:4334=-*+*+
+6(8)873;334
-2%#E-&$ME4
##4 98)X3684-+;;
33432%#'S//-$$K$'4
#24 9:74=3-+3
+;;! (773#(>,62%#14
#&4 @+4=;N47@42%2#S&10#%20%
#'1K#1%4
#/4 )4 Y-7347@42%#2S&1'#%&#$#1$%4
#$4 @+473G>33G43;
-+42%%&S2$-204
#E4 4-;K
R4842%#0S#&-#K224
#04 9:3 < 4C>
L47@A42%#ES//-22$KE4
#'4 A747K;;3-+
;34V2%22S##$#/%4
#14 D4 4+-)S2%%$4
2%4 !8!6@R4;3K3-;
;K;334;4
2%2#S2//E2#KE&24
2#4 +37!;+ Z!9@+9(6)4+@4444!6:43
-2K>63;47@4
2%2&S0##2K#/4
224 @:R3+;;+*9+4:H+=I3
LK#1N!82%2#S&02-&%/
... De e elektive kurset om klimaendringer og helse er e av flere initiativer ved Senter for baerekraft i helseutdanningene ved Universitetet i Oslo (7). Det er et tilbud for legestudenter som ønsker å fordype seg saerskilt i temaet. ...
Article
Full-text available
In this conceptual paper, we argue that at times of crisis, what is sometimes called “evidence-based” or “science-driven” policymaking—establishing scientific truths and then implementing them—must be tempered by a more agile, deliberative and inclusive approach which acknowledges and embraces uncertainty. We offer pragmatism as one potential option, using examples from the UK to illustrate how such an approach might have changed particular crisis decisions and led to better outcomes. We propose that to better prepare for the next public health crisis, five pragmatism-informed shifts are needed in the science-policy relationship: from scientism to science-informed narrative rationality that emerges from practice; from knowledge-then-action to acting judiciously under uncertainty; from hierarchies of evidence to pluralist inquiry; from polarized camps to frame-reflective dialogue; and from an “inside-track” science-policy dialogue to greater participatory democracy. We suggest an agenda for a pragmatist-informed program of applied research on crisis public health policymaking.
Article
Full-text available
Evidence-based medicine has been the subject of much controversy within and outside the field of medicine, with its detractors characterizing it as reductionist and authoritarian, and its proponents rejecting such characterization as a caricature of the actual practice. At the heart of this controversy is a complex linguistic and social process that cannot be illuminated by appealing to the semantics of the modifier evidence-based . The complexity lies in the nature of evidence as a basic concept that circulates in both expert and non-expert spheres of communication, supports different interpretations in different contexts, and is inherently open to contestation. We outline a new methodology that combines a social epistemological perspective with advanced methods of corpus linguistics and elements of conceptual history to investigate this and other basic concepts that underpin the practice and ethos of modern medicine. The potential of this methodology to offer new insights into controversies such as those surrounding EBM is demonstrated through a case study of the various meanings supported by evidence and based , as attested in a large electronic corpus of online material written by non-experts as well as a variety of experts in different fields, including medicine.
Article
Full-text available
Artificial intelligence can help tackle the covid-19 pandemic, but bias and discrimination in its design and deployment risk exacerbating existing health inequity argue David Leslie and colleagues
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of this Consensus Statement is to provide a global, collaborative, representative and inclusive vision for educating an interprofessional healthcare workforce that can deliver sustainable healthcare and promote planetary health. It is intended to inform national and global accreditation standards, planning and action at the institutional level as well as highlight the role of individuals in transforming health professions education. Many countries have agreed to ‘rapid, far-reaching and unprecedented changes’ to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 45% within 10 years and achieve carbon neutrality by 2050, including in healthcare. Currently, however, health professions graduates are not prepared for their roles in achieving these changes. Thus, to reduce emissions and meet the 2030 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), health professions education must equip undergraduates, and those already qualified, with the knowledge, skills, values, competence and confidence they need to sustainably promote the health, human rights and well-being of current and future generations, while protecting the health of the planet. The current imperative for action on environmental issues such as climate change requires health professionals to mobilize politically as they have before, becoming strong advocates for major environmental, social and economic change. A truly ethical relationship with people and the planet that we inhabit so precariously, and to guarantee a future for the generations which follow, demands nothing less of all health professionals. This Consensus Statement outlines the changes required in health professions education, approaches to achieve these changes and a timeline for action linked to the internationally agreed SDGs. It represents the collective vision of health professionals, educators and students from various health professions, geographic locations and cultures. ‘Consensus’ implies broad agreement amongst all individuals engaged in discussion on a specific issue, which in this instance, is agreement by all signatories of this Statement developed under the auspices of the Association for Medical Education in Europe (AMEE). To ensure a shared understanding and to accurately convey information, we outline key terms in a glossary which accompanies this Consensus Statement (Supplementary Appendix 1). We acknowledge, however, that terms evolve and that different terms resonate variably depending on factors such as setting and audience. We define education for sustainable healthcare as the process of equipping current and future health professionals with the knowledge, values, confidence and capacity to provide environmentally sustainable services through health professions education. We define a health professional as a person who has gained a professional qualification for work in the health system, whether in healthcare delivery, public health or a management or supporting role and education as ‘the system comprising structures, curricula, faculty and activities contributing to a learning process’. This Statement is relevant to the full continuum of training – from undergraduate to postgraduate and continuing professional development. KEYWORDS Ecological crisis; human rights; planetary health; health professions education; sustainable healthcare