PosterPDF Available

Abstract

Methods of predictive maintenance for large-scale battery systems allow the early detection of fault potentials and the consequent replacement or repair of faulty components before severe compromises to system health, safety or performance must be made. While numerable methods exist for the detection of short-term faults such as thermal runaways or low-ohmic short circuits, predicting long-term errors, which develop and intensify over the scope of multiple months or years still proves difficult. This work presents a battery system model suited for the model-based prediction of such long-term faults. It incorporates the effects of cell-to-cell variations (CtCVs) and therefore allows the calculation of voltage and temperature distributions in the system. By comparing the measured temperature and voltage spread (ΔVcells(t) = max(Vcells(t))−min(Vcells(t))) of the potentially faulty system to their simulated equivalents, long-term errors such as internal micro short circuits or accelerated aging can be detected. In addition to the model design, the development of methods for predictive maintenance also requires synthetic testing and validation data, since faults in battery systems usually only occur sporadically and do not allow a methodical investigation. For this purpose, a modular test bench, which allows the insertion of faults with a defined intensity was used to generate experimental data showing the influence of high-ohmic short-circuits, increased cell connection resistances and accelerated aging processes on the system. By using this data new methods for predicative maintenance can be methodically developed and evaluated.
Model-based predictive maintenance for
Li-ion battery systems
1,2,3Alexander Reiter, 2Stefan Brand, 2Christian Rosenm¨uller, 1Susanne Lehner, 2Oliver Bohlen,
3Dirk Uwe Sauer
Motivation
Methods of predictive maintenance for large-scale bat-
tery systems allow the early detection of fault poten-
tials and the consequent replacement or repair of faulty
components before severe compromises to system
health, safety or performance must be made. While
numerable methods exist for the detection of short-
term faults such as thermal runaways or low-ohmic
short circuits, predicting long-term errors, which de-
velop and intensify over the scope of multiple months
or years still proves difficult. This work presents a
battery system model suited for the model-based pre-
diction of such long-term faults. It incorporates the
effects of cell-to-cell variations (CtCVs) and there-
fore allows the calculation of voltage and temperature
distributions in the system. By comparing the mea-
sured temperature and voltage spread (Vcells(t) =
max(Vcells(t)) min(Vcells(t))) of the potentially
faulty system to their simulated equivalents, long-term
errors such as internal micro short circuits or accel-
erated aging can be detected. In addition to the
model design, the development of methods for predic-
tive maintenance also requires synthetic testing and
validation data, since faults in battery systems usually
only occur sporadically and do not allow a method-
ical investigation. For this purpose, a modular test
bench, which allows the insertion of faults with a de-
fined intensity was used to generate experimental data
showing the influence of high-ohmic short-circuits, in-
creased cell connection resistances and accelerated ag-
ing processes on the system. By using this data new
methods for predicative maintenance can be methodi-
cally developed and evaluated.
Application &
operator
Algorithms
Physical systemLoad profile
Parallel model
Operation
strategy
Measures of predictive maintenance
Measured
signals
Simulated
signals
Comparison
Trend detection
Prognosis
< > = ~
Figure 1: Concept of model-based predictive maintenance
Authors and Contact
1Technology Development, MAN Energy Solutions
SE, 86153 Augsburg, Stadtbachstraße 1, Germany
2Institute for Sustainable Energy Systems (ISES),
University of Applied Sciences Munich, 80335 Munich,
Lothstraße 64, Germany
3Chair for Electrochemical Energy Conversion and
Storage Systems, Institute for Power Electronics and
Electrical Drives (ISEA), RWTH Aachen University,
52074 Aachen, Campus-Boulevard 89, Germany
Corresponding author:
Alexander Reiter: alexander.reiter@man-es.com
Electro-thermal battery system modeling
The battery system model allows the calculation of the average voltage
and temperature as well as the distributions (Vcells and Tcells) within
the system caused by cell-to-cell variations. A detailed description of the
model is given in [1]. In the following, the key aspects are highlighted:
Electrical cell model with Rs+ 2 RC impedance string and
zeroth-order hysteresis model.
Electrical system model with individual R,Cand SoCinit for
every cell + statistical model simplification using parameter
distributions for the calculation of confidence intervals.
0D thermal cell model with Joules and entropy heat generation.
Thermal system model for a commercial Li-ion battery module.
Electro-thermal battery model
Parameter
distribution
System
structure
Figure 2: Electro-thermal battery system model
Modular battery system test bench
Resistance-optimized
cell connectors
Li-ion cells (21700-type)
6s3p configuration
Easy cell swap
Figure 3: Modular battery system test bench
Developing reliable methods for predictive maintenance requires
extensive testing and validation against experimental data of sys-
tems in faulty condition. Since this data basis cannot be provided
by productive battery systems in the field, a modular battery sys-
tem test bench was designed. The test bench consists of 21700-
type cylindrical battery cells in 6s3p configuration with individual
voltage, current and temperature measurement. The system al-
lows the fast and simple exchange of individual cells as well as
the insertion of parallel and serial resistances. By this, the ef-
fects of accelerated aging of individual cells, increased contact
resistances and high-ohmic internal or external short-circuits can
be evaluated. Also, the fault intensities (e.g. the resistance of
the short-circuit) can be systematically varied. This allows the
generation of a data basis for the development of algorithms for
predictive maintenance.
Experimental data generation
During the experimental data generation, accelerated cell aging, increased connection resistances and high-ohmic short
circuits were considered as typical long-term fault scenarios [2]. The faults were replicated via additional serial resistors
(connection resistances), parallel resistors (external short circuit) or by exchanging one cell of the module by an aged cell.
The fault scenarios comprising different fault intensities (different resistances and SoHs) were evaluated for a 24 h load
profile representing stationary grid applications [3].
0 5 10 15 20
Time in h
-8
-4
0
4
8
System current in A
Load profile
Figure 4: Experimental data generated from modular test bench. Top left: Load profile used during data generation, Top right: Voltage
distribution for external short circuit at cell 3, Bottom left: Voltage distribution for increased connection resistance at cell 3, Bottom right:
Voltage distribution for accelerated aging at cell 3.
Further Work
In following work, the developed test bench will be used to create an exhaustive data matrix for the named faults in various
intensities. Also, the integration of additional faults will be considered. In the next step, the collected data will be used
to parameterize and validate a battery system model representing the faults. This would allow to replace the still rather
demanding measurements on the test bench by a simple simulation. For this approach, different positions of faulty cells as
well as cross-combinations of multiple faults at once shall also be investigated. In the last step, the measured and simulated
data sets will be used for the development of algorithms for the predictive maintenance of large-scale battery systems.
[1] A. Reiter, S. Lehner, O. Bohlen, and D. U. Sauer, “Electrical cell-to-cell variations within large-scale battery systems a novel
characterization and modeling approach,” Journal of Energy Storage, vol. 57, p. 106 152, 2023.
[2] M.-K. Tran and M. Fowler, “A review of lithium-ion battery fault diagnostic algorithms: Current progress and future challenges,”
Algorithms, vol. 13, no. 3, 2020.
[3] D. Kucevic, B. Tepe, S. Englberger, et al., “Standard battery energy storage system profiles: Analysis of various applications for stationary
energy storage systems using a holistic simulation framework,” Journal of Energy Storage, vol. 28, p. 101 077, 2020.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Digital twins for large-scale and investment-intensive Li-ion battery systems in marine and stationary applications have drawn increasing interest in recent years. Considering electrical cell-to-cell variations (CtCVs) within the underlying battery model of such a digital twin promises various advantages in the fields of model-based optimization and predictive maintenance. However, the existing approaches for both the characterization and modeling of CtCVs are unsuited for large-scale systems consisting of thousands of individual cells. In this context, this paper introduces a holistic tool chain comprising three main elements: First, a non-destructive method for the in-situ determination of resistance and capacity distributions within a battery system is presented. The method was evaluated on a commercial battery module for stationary applications consisting of 64 Ah pouch cells in 14s2p configuration. In the second step, the obtained distributions were used to parameterize a state-of-the-art multi-cell battery model, which allows the calculation of the voltage distribution within the system. The validation showed that the resulting model is able to calculate the voltage spread (Vcell,max(t)−Vcell,min(t)) with a mean average error of 1.1 mV for a 24 h load profile. In the third step, multivariate statistical analysis was used on the obtained parameters in order to simplify the original model and thereby reducing its computational demands. The simplification approach allows the calculation of envelope voltages curves within which a random cell can be found with a given probability. In comparison to the original model, the simplified model was able to represent the voltage extrema while reducing the computation time by a factor of 27. This renders the simplified model applicable for live digital twin applications for large-scale battery systems.
Article
Full-text available
The usage of Lithium-ion (Li-ion) batteries has increased significantly in recent years due to their long lifespan, high energy density, high power density, and environmental benefits. However, various internal and external faults can occur during the battery operation, leading to performance issues and potentially serious consequences, such as thermal runaway, fires, or explosion. Fault diagnosis, hence, is an important function in the battery management system (BMS) and is responsible for detecting faults early and providing control actions to minimize fault effects, to ensure the safe and reliable operation of the battery system. This paper provides a comprehensive review of various fault diagnostic algorithms, including model-based and non-model-based methods. The advantages and disadvantages of the reviewed algorithms, as well as some future challenges for Li-ion battery fault diagnosis, are also discussed in this paper.
Article
Full-text available
Lithium-ion batteries are used for both stationary and mobile applications. While in the automotive industry standard profiles are used to compare the performance and efficiency of competing vehicles, a similar comparative metric has not been proposed for stationary battery energy storage systems. Because standard profiles are missing, the comparable evaluation of different applications with respect to efficiency, long-term behavior and profitability is very difficult or not possible at all. This work presents a method to create these standard profiles and the results are available as open data for download. Input profiles including frequency data, industry load profiles and household load profiles are transformed into storage profiles including storage power and state of charge using a holistic simulation framework. Various degrees of freedom for the energy management system as well as for the storage design are implemented and the results are post-processed with a profile analyzer tool in order to identify six key characteristics, these being: full-equivalent cycles, efficiency, depth of cycles, resting periods, number of changes of sign and energy throughput between changes of sign. All applications examined in this paper show unique characteristics which are essential for the design of the storage system. E.g., the numbers for annual full-equivalent cycles vary from 19 to 282 and the efficiency lies between 83% and 93%. With aid of this work in conjunction with the open data results, users can test and compare their own cell types, operation strategies and system topologies with those of the paper. Furthermore, the storage power profiles and state of charge data can be used as a reference for lifetime and profitability studies for stationary storage systems.