ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

In order to prevent overconsumption, it is crucial to understand the causes of conspicuous consumption. The purpose of this study is to determine how self-esteem (SE) and a sense of belonging (SOB) relate to conspicuous consumption (CC). With an average age of early 20s in the Jakarta and Java region, 127 representatives of Generation Z are surveyed to collect data. Results revealed that both Self-Esteem and Sense of Belonging were strongly correlated with Conspicuous Consumption, according to correlation and regression analysis. We suggest for young adults to not purchase goods or items impulsively to avoid conspicuous consumption rather than displaying one's wealth. Limitation and future research are discussed in context of the study's findings.
IDEAS: Journal of Management and Technology, 2(2) 2022, 49-56 E-ISSN: 2808-1803
IDEAS: Journal of Management and Technology
Available at: http://e-journal.president.ac.id/presunivojs/index.php/IDEAS
HOW SELF-ESTEEM AND SENSE OF BELONGING DRIVES
CONSPICUOUS CONSUMPTION
Alicia Listiani Tenia1, Nabilah Putri Justine2, Christian Haposan Pangaribuan3
1Sampoerna University, alicia.tenia@my.sampoernauniversity.ac.id
2Sampoerna University, nabilah.justine@my.sampoernauniversity.ac.id
3Sampoerna University, christian.pangaribuan@sampoernauniversity.ac.id
ABSTRACT
In order to prevent overconsumption, it is crucial to understand the causes of conspicuous
consumption. The purpose of this study is to determine how self-esteem (SE) and a sense of
belonging (SOB) relate to conspicuous consumption (CC). With an average age of early 20s
in the Jakarta and Java region, 127 representatives of Generation Z are surveyed to collect
data. Results revealed that both Self-Esteem and Sense of Belonging were strongly correlated
with Conspicuous Consumption, according to correlation and regression analysis. We
suggest for young adults to not purchase goods or items impulsively to avoid conspicuous
consumption rather than displaying one’s wealth. Limitation and future research are
discussed in context of the study’s findings.
Keywords: Identity, Luxury Brand, Self-Esteem, Sense of Belonging, Conspicuous
Consumption
1. Introduction.
I don’t do fashion, I am fashion.” One of the quotes from a well-known French fashion designer, Coco Chanel,
whose name is now associated with one of the most exclusive fashion labels, Chanel, demonstrates how fashion
is today created by individuals rather than being followed by the masses. Numerous studies have examined how
closely a person’s wardrobe reflects their identity. As each outfit tells a tale connected to a culture somewhere
that helps identify an origin and a society that one represents (Johnson and Koech), fashion has a deeper
significance that has cultural values in its application in addition to just serving as a depiction of identity. There
are many different things that affect how someone dresses, including culture, compared with the results from
society and family groups, the environment, the media, current fashion trends, and individual personalities
(Tajuddin, 2018). All aspects of fashion, encompassing clothes, accessories, shoes, and footwear, have quite a
volatile, transient quality to them, yet they can simultaneously serve as a cultural “identity” component (Pozzo,
2020). In his paper, Efremov et al., (2021) shows that clothing is a form of self-expression and personality that
is used to complement some of the shortcomings in a person to achieve spiritual or psychological balance. The
use of fashion as a means of self-expression, as a representation of a culture or of particular traits, or both, has
an impact on how a person fits into society.
Some studies have verified that fashion is a form of self-expression and represents the cultural identity of
people. According to Thao (2021), the way people dress shows who they are in society and allows them to
50 IDEAS: Journal of Management and Technology, 2(2) 2022, 49-56
portray a message. Moreover, fashion and culture tend to be inseparable since the clothing that people wear is
influenced by the customs that exist in society (Tajuddin 2018). However, as fashion continues to evolve and
become more diverse as the times do, the clothing that people choose to wear is subject to societal and cultural
views (Stolovy, 2021) which means fashion is not a seeking, anticipated representation of a reinterpreted
traditional value that serves some purpose or aim. Instead, what makes people automatic is a vivid and
revitalizing idea deserving of being depicted for society’s approval (Anyanwu and Chiana, 2022). Ga-Eun Oh
(2021) argue through his research that consumers frequently purchase and use well-known brands to boost their
self-esteem and be perceived as belonging to a high social class. Since one can tell who in society is based on
their clothing, people of high social standing make sure that others are aware of their position by dressing in
luxury labels (Maketivilia, 2018) which are thought to be distinguished by a high price point justified by
excellent quality, workmanship, exclusivity, and a sense of rarity (Aycock, 2021).
Nowadays, clothing is used to display one’s wealth and social status. Individuals who wear well-known or
branded clothes are often perceived as belonging to a higher social class. Changes in the concept of fashion in
terms of meaning cause problems that arise involving the community. The urgency of people to appear and look
attractive by wearing branded clothes causes excessive consumption. It appears that conspicuous consumption is
a form of consumer’s desire to demonstrate social status and impress people with their possessions by acquiring
luxury items (Dantas & Abreu, 2020). This issue has detrimental effect on society, especially for Generation Z
who is currently considered as the biggest consumer group (Grigoreva et al., 2021). Spending money to buy
expensive clothes is probably done because of the desire to be accepted and respected in society through a
position that is usually characterized by wealth. In this study, consumption behavior in buying clothes is
affected by self-esteem and sense of belonging which leads to conspicuous consumption.
Many people are worried about how others will perceive them in addition to their own self-identity, which note
by Trang and Selassie (2020) that it makes the tendency to identify themselves based on how they want to be
perceived by others. Many studies explained the relationship between self-esteem and consumption, in which
Eastman et al. (2018) stated the identity that is created then shapes the social identity to get verification and
avoid the drop of self-esteem in society. They can achieve this, for example, by consuming or displaying things
that represent achievement in relation to the wounded portion of their sense of self. A study from Stuppy et al.
(2020) notes that in order to avoid a drop in self-esteem, consumers choose what they consume based on what
they anticipate about their perception of themselves. Eastman et al. (2018) in their research explain that through
consumption of products, consumers who may be conspicuous and who confer or symbolize status for
individuals and important people around them are motives for status consumption to increase social status. They
emphasized that in this case, rather than for the function, people purchase products for symbolic of wealth or
exclusivity. The majority of the time, consumers associate products and brands with prestige based on the
qualities of the objects themselves, hedonistic ideals, and interactions with other people (Sahin, 2021).
Moreover, previous literature suggests consumption is used to describe status among upper-class individuals
(Wang et al., 2020) and a striking relationship between self-esteem and consumption (Neave et al., 2020; Zheng
et al., 2018).
Self-Esteem
Self-esteem refers to how a person values and perceives themselves. According to (Topçu, 2018), the cognitive
elements of self-esteem refer to self-acceptance and confidence in one's capabilities and achievements. This will
help the individuals to evaluate positive or negative reaction to their self. Furthermore, as mentioned by Oztek
and Cengel (2020), an individual who valued himself/herself negatively will struggle with his/her negative
emotion and tends to be self-contradictory by venting to low-level activities that can be carried out immediately.
Belonging
A sense of belonging is considered an important factor in self-esteem. It is an emotion when someone feels
secure by being accepted into a group of people. Consumers who feel excluded will seek validation and
acceptance from others and it might change their consumption behavior to adjust to with his/her associative
group (Argan, et al., 2022). Liu and Huang (2018) mentioned that young people pay great attention to other
people's views in their social life, it is indicated by concrete actions to seek belonging and gain recognition from
others such as conspicuous consumption.
51 IDEAS: Journal of Management and Technology, 2(2) 2022, 49-56
Conspicuous Consumption
Conspicuous consumption is often referred to as consumers practice by purchasing products with the purpose of
showing a person’s wealth (Sahin & Nasir, 2021). It is associated with a theory of the Veblen Effect, which
implies the tendency of consumers to purchase luxury goods to achieve social status or a situation when a
demand of a product increases as the price increases. Adolescents tend to indulge in conspicuous consumption
to have a sense of belonging in social group, shape their self-confidence, and gain prestige (Kolańska-Stronka &
Gorbaniuk, 2022). Moreover, Assimos, et al., (2019) also stated that conspicuous consumption is a way for an
individual to increase social prestige and impress others by acquiring possessions that display a certain social
status.
Conceptual Framework
Based on our observations and findings, much of the research indicates the relationship between self-esteem and
conspicuous consumption. Little is known about this hypothesis among Generation Z. Therefore, in this
research, the researchers developed a hypothetical model (Fig.1). The purpose of this model is to shows a link
between self-esteem and its effect on conspicuous consumption among generation Z, determine how self-esteem
exerts a direct impact on sense of belongingness, on the other hand, also leads to conspicuous consumption. The
conceptual model and hypotheses are presented.
Figure 1: Hypothetical Model
Based on the review of some literature, the following hypotheses can be derived:
H1: Self-esteem positively relates to a person’s sense of belongingness
Previous study has mentioned that a person’s self-esteem depends on the degree to which she judges that she is
worthy of being accepted and respected by others (Perry & Lavins-Merillat, 2018). It shows that if a person
feels worthy and accepted by others, she will experience an enhancement in self-esteem, whereas if she feels
rejected by society, it will decrease her self-esteem. Thus, we hypothesized the relationship between sense of
belonging and conspicuous consumption:
H2: A person’s sense of belonging positively influences conspicuous consumption
Next, As argued by Oh (2021) in his article, lack of acceptance and respect among individuals can trigger a need
or desire for status and acceptance through conspicuous consumption. Moreover, consumers seek validation
from others by buying luxury goods in a conspicuous manner. They believe that acquiring goods that other
people desire creates a sense of belonging (Olsson, 2020). Therefore, if a person seeks a sense of belonging and
gain recognition from others, they might feel a need to purchase goods in a conspicuous manner. Hence, our
third hypothesis is as follows:
H3: A person’s level of self-esteem has an influence on the emergence of a person’s conspicuous consumption
Furthermore, previous studies showed that to avoid the drop of self-esteem, people tend to spend more in buying
products (Stuppy et al., 2018). If a person is at a low self-esteem level, he consumes more in buying high-priced
Self-Esteem
Conspicuous Consumption
Sense of Belonging
H1
H2
H3
52 IDEAS: Journal of Management and Technology, 2(2) 2022, 49-56
goods to increase his self-esteem which will make conspicuous consumption appear. In the present study, we
adopt this view to be tested.
2. Method
Sample
We choose to gather individuals with a wide range of attributes, including age, gender, and educational level, to
be responders on a survey about conspicuous consumerism and its associations with self-esteem and belonging.
A person's self-esteem and sense of belonging have been found to influence the appearance of conspicuous
consumption, and when a person's self-esteem is low, they will behave more consumptively to hide their
imperfections in order to thrive in the environment (Vindiani, 2019; Ramadhan, 2014). We collected samples
using online questionnaires that were disseminated via Twitter, Instagram, and WhatsApp. There were 127
responses to the poll, 81 of whom were female (64.3%), 44 of whom were male (34.9%), and one respondent
(0.8%) preferred not to mention. The majority of respondents (80.2%) were between the ages of 17 and 20;
17.5% were older than 20; and the remaining 2.4% were under 20. With a percentage of 89.7%, university
students make up almost 90% of the respondents. Workers compose the next largest group, at 7.1%, with
students making up the remaining respondents.
In this study, the respondents’ responses to a questionnaire with five possible answers are represented using a
Likert scale. The survey method consists of 15 questions in total.
Table 1. Likert Scale
Score
5
4
3
2
1
Procedure
For collecting the data required, we initially conduct a survey on the subject of our research in order to get the
essential data. We applied for permission from the academic lecturer standing as the research supervisor when
the questionnaire was finished. Following permission, we began seeking out respondents to share survey forms
using online platforms, such as sharing in WhatsApp groups or direct messaging with each person. In addition,
the researcher makes the form available for free to anyone interested to participate in a survey via Instagram
stories. We give the respondents a brief explanation of conspicuous consumption and other components in the
survey they must complete.
In the first section, the participants’ answered basic personal information, including age, gender, and
status/occupation. The questions that follow are divided up into three categories: self-esteem, sense of
belonging, and conspicuous consumption. Respondents were already required to complete each question
honestly, including their thoughts and emotions. Approximately 5 minutes are needed to complete the survey.
Researchers pledge that they will only utilize the anonymous, confidential information and data they collect for
their own research.
Measurement
The survey measures the participant’s reaction to questions that are divided into three components, which are
self-esteem, sense of belonging, and conspicuous consumption, in order to determine how much of an impact
self-esteem and belonging have on conspicuous consumption in a person. There are only five possible responses
to each question: strongly agree, agree, nearly agree, disagree, and strongly disagree, denoted by the numbers 1
to 5.
Data Analysis
53 IDEAS: Journal of Management and Technology, 2(2) 2022, 49-56
The study adopted a Green’s (1991) procedures to estimate the relationship hypothesized in the current model.
Based on the number of variables, the Green’s approach gives answers about the number of respondents
required for a research. The sample size for the coefficient of determination is N 50 + 8m, where m is the
number of predictors in the model (R2). In this study, there are 3 variables, so we need to at least have 74
respondents for the data analysis. The objective of this research is to determine whether low self-esteem
influences someone to behave consumptively or vice versa, and how it relates to conspicuous consumption
behavior. This research also focuses on the study to determine whether a person's sense of belonging to their
environment will have an effect on conspicuous spending and purchases.
3. Results and Discussion
Measurement Validation
In this research, we use SmartPLS 3 (Ringle, et al., 2015) as our tools to measure both the validation and
structural modelling. First, we conduct reliability and validity test. SOB1 was deleted after first running the PLS
Algorithms because the indicator loading was far below 0.70. Then, we use Cronbach’s Alpha to evaluate the
reliability. Cronbach’s Alpha for each instrument are Conspicuous Consumption = 0.782; Self-Esteem = 0.776;
and Sense of Belonging = 0.834. Alpha ≥0.70 are considered as acceptable and at satisfactory level of reliability
(Taber, 2017). Moreover, the results of the test also showed that composite reliability were above 0.70,
indicating that the variables used in this analysis are valid and reliable (Table 2). Next, average variance
extracted (AVE) values for all variables were above 0.5 and squared root of AVE was greater than the
correlation between latent variables (Table 3). It shows that the convergent and discriminant validities of each
construct are adequate. In addition, we use VIF (Variance Inflation Factor) in multicollinearity tests (Table 4) to
determine the correlation between the independent variables in the regression model. Our multicollinearity
results indicated that there is no collinearity among the variables, or the variables are uncorrelated with one
another (VIF< 5).
Table 2. Reliability and Validity Test
Variables
Items
Outer
Loadings
Cronbach’s
Alpha
rho_A
Composite
Reliability
AVE
Conspicuous
Consumption
CC1
0.593
0.782
0.824
0.851
0.540
CC2
0.819
CC3
0.780
CC4
0.579
CC5
0.855
Self-Esteem
SE1
0.758
0.776
0.785
0.848
0.529
SE2
0.695
SE3
0.618
SE4
0.810
SE5
0.742
Sense of Belonging
SOB2
0.784
0.834
0.845
0.889
0.667
SOB3
0.841
SOB4
0.811
SOB5
0.829
Table 3. Discriminant Validity
Conspicuous Consumption
Self-Esteem
Sense of Belonging
Conspicuous Consumption
0.735
Self-Esteem
0.732
0.727
Sense of Belonging
0.720
0.553
0.816
54 IDEAS: Journal of Management and Technology, 2(2) 2022, 49-56
Table 4. Multicollinearity test - Collinearity Statistics (VIF)
CC1
CC2
CC3
CC4
CC5
SE1
SE2
1.603
2.005
2.020
1.232
2.207
1.655
1.330
SE3
SE4
SE5
SOB2
SOB3
SOB4
SOB5
1.282
1.849
1.680
1.679
2.025
2.011
1.834
PLS Path Modeling and Hypotheses Testing
In SmartPLS, we performed PLS-SEM algorithm and bootstrapping analysis by using 95% as the significant
level to find the standard error and p value for each variable. The first hypothesis was Self-esteem positively
relates to a person’s sense of belongingness. The result of bootstrapping analysis (Table 5) displayed that =
0.553, SE = 0.070, t = 7.862, P < 0.05). It indicates that self-esteem positively affected a person’s sense of
belonging. Our second hypothesis was A person’s sense of belonging positively influences conspicuous
consumption. The result showed that sense of belonging = 0.454, SE = 0.061, t = 7.461, P < 0.05) is
significantly affected conspicuous consumption. The third hypothesis was person’s level of self-esteem has an
influence on the emergence of a person’s conspicuous consumption. The results implied that self-esteem =
0.481, SE = 0.068, t = 7.098, P < 0.05) positively influences the emergence of a person’s conspicuous
consumption. Since all the P-values < 0.05, it can be said that all hypotheses are significant. These hypotheses
testing was also supported by the R square value of .679 (R2 = 0.679, adjusted R2 = 0.672) and .31 (R2 = 0.306,
adjusted R2 = 0.299). It explained 68% of variance in conspicuous consumption and 31% in sense of belonging.
Table 5. Hypotheses Testing
Hypothesis
Original
Sample (O)
Sample
Mean (M)
Standard
Deviation
(STDEV)
T Statistics
(|O/STDEV|)
P
Values
H1
Self-Esteem Sense
of Belonging
0.553
0.565
0.070
7.862
0.000
H2
Sense of Belonging
Conspicuous
Consumption
0.454
0.455
0.061
7.461
0.000
H3
Self-Esteem
Conspicuous
Consumption
0.481
0.481
0.068
7.098
0.000
Discussion
The purpose of this research is to find the factors that affect a person’s conspicuous consumption. In this
research, we use three variables which are self-esteem, sense of belonging, and conspicuous consumption. The
proposed model hypothesized and examined how one’s sense of self-worth and belonging affected their
spending habits, which resulted in conspicuous consumption. This study discovered that people’s sense of self-
esteem and belonging has a positive impact on how much they spend on goods to preserve their existence in
society. Self-esteem positively relates to a person’s sense of belonging. It means that a person who has high self-
esteem, most likely will be more confident in their social life and feel accepted by others. The result supported
by Afroz and Tiwari (2021), they mentioned that an increase in level of self-esteem occurred when a person
feels supported by his or her group. Our findings add to the literature on a person’s sense of belonging had a
positive influence on conspicuous consumption. This result showed that the more a person feel the need to be
accepted in his group, he will try to seek recognition from others through conspicuous consumption or spending
money to buy luxury goods. This conspicuous consumption behavior usually occurs among adolescence because
at that age, they tend to have a high desire to make themselves as attractive as possible to be accepted in their
social group (Luckyta, 2019). Moreover, a study by Zhang et al., (2022) also highlighted that students with
conspicuous identities will try to gain prestige to differentiate themselves from other social groups that indicated
by their high levels of consumption. One major finding concerns regarding the consumption that a person spent.
Luckyta (2019) in his study explained that adolescents engage in the majority of consumer activity, according to
55 IDEAS: Journal of Management and Technology, 2(2) 2022, 49-56
reality, because they want to appear young and fashionable. In addition, formal institutions, such as schools,
place a premium on appearance. This adds to the literature on a person’s level of self-esteem had relation on
their spending habit and can lead to conspicuous consumption. Our research demonstrates that the lower a
person’s self-esteem, the more he will try to boost his self-esteem by increasing consumption in luxury goods.
4. Conclusion and Implications
Implications
From the theoretical perspective, one of the most important contributions of this study is its finding on the
relationship between self-esteem, sense of belonging, and conspicuous consumption. All variables are
significant and influence each other's, which shows that young adults compensate for their low self-esteem and
retain a sense of belonging by engaging in conspicuous consumption. By focusing on the factors that cause
generation Z to engage in conspicuous consumption, we also found that young adults view their consumption as
an indicator to determine a person’s social position. They increase their consumption of luxury items to be
recognized by their peers and to achieve a higher social status in society. They also compete for ownership of
such goods, which leads to overconsumption. Moreover, young adults tend to consume goods that do not hold
any practical value. Therefore, it is recommended for young adults to not purchase goods or items impulsively,
avoid conspicuous consumption, and only purchasing goods that they truly need rather than displaying one’s
wealth. On the other hand, since the demand of luxury consumption increases, it will benefit the luxury goods
industry and leads to higher income.
Limitation and Future Research
This study has several limitations. First, most of the respondents of the survey are female (>50%) and may lead
to gender bias. The result of the study with the limited number of male respondents may lead to the notion that
female tends to engage in conspicuous consumption rather than male. So, further research is needed to provide
evidence that gender could be an important mediator variable in analyzing conspicuous consumption. Second,
the sample used in the study is small and may not represent the entire generation Z population. Most of our
respondents are students that reside in Jakarta and Tangerang. In order to have more in-depth research regarding
the factors that drives conspicuous consumption in generation Z, future researcher could add other variables
such as advertising and social media since both plays a huge role in influencing consumer decision making and
increasing desire to engage in conspicuous consumption. Furthermore, future researchers could also add more
samples to provide data that can represent the population by reaching generation Z in others region.
References
Afroz, Shagufta & Tiwari, P.S.N (2021). Importance of Belongingness in Healthy Youth Development. Sch J
Arts Humanit Soc Sci. P.255.
Anyanwu, E. C., & Chiana, C. A. (2022). Socio-Cultural Influences on Fashion Consumption Behaviour of
University Students. ARRUS Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, 2(1).
Argan, et al., (2020). The Delicate Balance of Social Influences on Consumption: A Comprehensive Model of
Consumer-Centric Fear of Missing Out. Research Article. Vol. 194.
Assimos, et al., (2019). Conspicuous Consumption and its Relation to Brand Consciousness, Status
Consumption and Self-Expression. BBR. Brazilian Business Review, vol. 16, no. 4, p.353.
Aycock, Murphy B. (2021). Consumer Motivations and Perceived Value in Online Second-Hand Luxury
Fashion Shopping. Graduate Theses and Dissertations. p.20.
Dantas, B. L. L., & Abreu, N. R. (2020). An analysis of the influence of the conspicuous consumption of fast
fashion on identity construction on Instagram. Revista de Administração Mackenzie, 21(5), p.4.
Efremov, Jordan, et al. (2021). Expression of Personality through Dressing. Research Article. Vol. 69 (1). p.28
Grigoreva, Ekaterina. A., Liliya F. G & Elvira A. P. (2021). Consumer Behavior in the Information Economy:
Generation Z. International Journal of Financial Research, 12(2). p.166.
Johnson, Sharon K., Koech, Beatrice A. (2022). Influences of Cultural Attire in Contemporary Fashion for
Posterity of African Culture. Africa Design Review Journal. Article. Vol. 1 (2). p. 60.
Kolańska-Stronka, Magdalena & Gorbaniuk, Oleg. (2022). Materialism, conspicuous consumption, and brand
56 IDEAS: Journal of Management and Technology, 2(2) 2022, 49-56
engagement in self-concept: a study of teenagers. Current Issues in Personality Psychology, 10(1), p.
45.
Liu, Kai & Huang, Xiaoling. (2018). Research on Conspicuous Consumption in Travel Behaviors of the College
Students. International Symposium on Social Science and Management Innovation. Vol.68. p.264.
Luckyta, Hanof Vindiani. (2019). Hubungan Harga Diri dengan Perilaku Konsumtif Produk Fashion di Toko
Online pada Mahasiswi Perbankan Syariah UIN Maulana Malik Ibrahim Malang. Research article. p.
30-77.
Maketivilia, Yolande. (2018). The Relationship Between Fashion Consciousness and Self-Concept. Thesis.
National College of Ireland. p. 7.
Neave, L., Tzemou, E., & Fastoso, F. (2020). Seeking attention versus seeking approval: how conspicuous
consumption differs between grandiose and vulnerable narcissists. Psychology & Marketing, 37(3),
418-427.
Oh, Ga-Eun. (2021). Social class, Social Self-esteem, and Conspicuous Consumption. Research Article.
Heliyon, Volume 7, Issue 2, e06318. p.2.
Olsson, Marco Bojic. (2020). Do You Really Need It? A Qualitative Study of Conspicuous Consumption in
Relation to Self-Identity. Research Article, p.1.
Oztek, M. Yaman & Cengel, Ozgur. (2020). The Role of Self-Esteem and Materialism on Conspicuous
Consumption Tendency: A Futuristic Approach. Research Article, p.539.
Perry, Justin C., & Lavins-Merillat, Bethany D. (2018). Self-Esteem and School Belongingness: A Cross-
Lagged Panel Study Among Urban Youth. Professional School Counseling, 22(1).
Pozzo, Barbara. (2020). Fashion between Inspiration and Appropriation. Article. 9. 5. 10.3390/laws9010005.
p.2.
Sahin, Onur & Nasir, Suphan. (2021). The effects of status consumption and conspicuous consumption on
perceived symbolic status. The Journal of Marketing Theory and Practice. Vol 30(3), p.1.
Stolovy T. (2021). Styling the Self: Clothing Practices, Personality Traits, and Body Image Among Israeli
Women. Frontiers in psychology, 12, 719318.
Stuppy, Anika, et al., (2019). I Am, Therefore I Buy: Low Self-Esteem and the Pursuit of Self-Verifying
Consumption. Journal of Consumer Research. Vol.46(5), p. 956-973.
Taber, Keith. S (2017). The Use of Cronbach’s Alpha When Developing and Reporting Research Instruments in
Science Education. Res Sci Educ, p.6.
Tajuddin, Fatjri Nur. (2018). Cultural and Social Identity in Clothing Matters Different Cultures, Different
Meanings. European Journal of Behavioral Science. p.20-23. ISSN 2538-807X.
Thao, Jenifer. (2021). Cultural Impact on Identity and How it is Expressed through Dress. Apparel
Merchandising and Product Development Undergraduate Honors Theses. p. 13.
Topçu, U. C. (2018). Conspicuous Consumption in Relation to Self-Esteem, Self-Image and Social Status: An
Empirical Study. Springer Proceedings in Business and Economics, p.700-701.
Wang, Z., Jetten, J., & Steffens, N. K. (2020). The more you have, the more you want? Higher social class
predicts a greater desire for wealth and status. European Journal of Social Psychology, 50(2), 360-375.
Zhang, Qi et al., (2022). Exploring the impact of a conspicuous identity on college students’ campus loans:
Evidence from China. Journal Frontiers in Psychology. p.2.
Zheng, X., Baskin, E., & Peng, S. (2018). Feeling inferior, showing off: The effect of nonmaterial social
comparisons on conspicuous consumption. Journal of Business Research, 90, p.196-205.
... Individuals contribute to the formation of their selfesteem by displaying their financial power through conspicuous consumption (Campbell, 1995;Eastman et al., 1999). Additionally, Tenia et al. (2022) found a strong correlation between self-esteem, sense of belonging, and conspicuous consumption among Generation Z in Jakarta and Java. Academic research findings indicate a positive relationship between self-esteem and conspicuous consumption (Khan & Dhar, 2006;Souiden et al., 2011;Lewis & Moital, 2016;Widjajanta et al., 2018). ...
... Another manifestation of this behavior is that individuals tend to portray themselves with better or superior qualities than they actually possess on social networks, thereby creating a new ideal self. Tenia et al. (2022) similarly found a strong correlation between self-esteem, sense of belonging, and conspicuous consumption among Generation Z in Jakarta and Java. Their results indicate that young adults engage in conspicuous consumption to compensate for low self-esteem and to secure a sense of belonging, viewing luxury consumption as a means to achieve higher social status. ...
... Contrary to previous research (Khan & Dhar, 2006;Souiden et al., 2011;Lewis & Moital, 2016;Widjajanta et al., 2018), this study did not find a direct and positive effect of self-esteem on conspicuous consumption. This finding is complemented by the work of Güneş et al. (2023) and Tenia et al. (2022), which suggests that individuals with low self-esteem may engage in conspicuous consumption to alleviate negative emotions and secure a sense of belonging. These nuanced understandings challenge the assumption that higher self-esteem always leads to greater conspicuous consumption, pointing to the need for further research to explore these intricate relationships. ...
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of this study is to investigate how envy of others affects the conspicuous consumption and overspending habits of Instagram users. Additionally, the study aims to examine the effect of self-esteem and social norms on conspicuous consumption and overspending. This empirical study used a proposed model, which was tested through the distribution of questionnaires to a sample of 346 Turkish Instagram users. Path analyses were performed to validate the research hypothesis. The study findings elicited the effect of Instagram users’ envy towards others has a significant and positive effect on both conspicuous consumption and overspending. Additionally, the study found that injunctive norms, which reflect the perceived social approval or disapproval of others, have a direct and positive effect on conspicuous consumption. On the other hand, descriptive norms, representing the perception of others' actual behavior, did not have a direct effect on conspicuous consumption. Regarding self-esteem, the results did not support the hypothesis that self-esteem has a direct and positive effect on conspicuous consumption. Furthermore, the study found a significant and positive relationship between conspicuous consumption and overspending, indicating that individuals who engage in conspicuous consumption are more likely to exceed their budget limits and engage in impulsive buying behaviors.
... The post-shopping experience influences later purchases; as a result, when customers discover they have overindulged or have had a bad postshopping experience, they feel regret and put constraints on their future purchases [9]. The younger generation tends to be more adaptable and flexible in keeping up with technological improvements as a result of technological advancements [10]. Correspondingly, knowledge will spread more swiftly. ...
Article
Full-text available
An increasing number of college students have taken out campus loans. This trend has had a negative impact on their learning and development. Using survey data about Chinese college students, this study explores the influence of a conspicuous identity and conformity on campus loan behavior and usage intention. Identify economics posits that identity is a key factor affecting individual behavior and decision-making. Differentiated identify is linked to differentiated social groups and constituted through specific value orientations, social norms and codes of conduct. This study shows that college students with a conspicuous identity are more likely to take out campus loans and more willing to take out such loans in the following year. The discussion on heterogeneity shows that a conspicuous identity has significantly positive effects on campus loan behavior for students in groups with higher consumption and grade, while conformity has significantly positive effects on campus loan behavior when students are in lower-grade groups. Compared with students who have never used campus loans, students who have taken out are more willing to take them out again in the future. Finally, avoidance strategies of campus loan debt are provided from two perspectives, namely, identity construction and the classification of education.
Article
Full-text available
This study aimed at investigating the social-cultural influences on fashion consumption behaviour among undergraduate university students basing on the theory of reasoned action (TRA). The population of the study was mainly the Management Science students from two universities from the South-East and South-South Zones of Nigeria. The sample size was 278 while valid response was 256. The survey was based on likert scale structured questionnaire, while the proposed model was tested with the SPSS version 21 Simple Regression Analysis (SRA). It was found that culture, opinion leadership, social class, family and ethnicity have significant influence on fashion consumption among undergraduate students. The study recommends amongst others that marketers in the fashion business should continuously scan their social-cultural environment and assess its influence on consumer’s behaviour both at the personal and societal level with a view to enhancing their capacity to recognize, resist as necessary, and make international decision that will both be beneficial to them and their customers.
Article
Full-text available
Research has shown that women tend to use clothes to present or disguise their bodies and that clothing practices can be predicted by body image. This study explored the relationships between clothing practices, personality traits, and body image among Israeli women, using the Big Five personality traits model (NEO-FFI) and a body image measure (MBSRQ) to explore clothing styles and practices among Israeli women (N = 792, Mean age = 42.19). It found that women with more openness to experience (OR = 1.8; IC 95%: 1.05–3.0), who seek fashion (OR = 2.05; IC 95%: 1.37–3.05) and individuality (OR = 3.96; IC 95%: 2.46–6.3) are more likely to exhibit an urban, sophisticated style of dress. These women are less motivated by comfort (OR = 0.49; IC 95%: 0.31–0.77) and camouflage (OR = 2.05; IC 95%: 1.37–3.05), that are associated with casual, minimalist style of dress. This study indicates that openness to experience may foster body-positive clothing practices. In this way, their choice of clothing can help women overcome objectification and cultural body-ideal pressures, promoting self-validation and mastery.
Thesis
Full-text available
The secondhand luxury fashion market is growing four times faster than the primary luxury fashion market and already represents a $24 billion market today (Beauloye, 2019; Siwak, 2020). Younger generations such as millennials and Gen Z are buying and selling preowned luxury products almost three times faster than any other age group (Beauloye, 2019). Digital selling platforms such as The RealReal and Vestiaire Collective are fueling the growth of the secondhand luxury fashion market (Beauloye, 2019). Despite the increased consumer interests and sales growth in the secondhand luxury fashion market, existing research has not concentrated on the underlying motivations of secondhand luxury fashion consumption. Most previous studies focused on motivational drivers for new luxury fashion products (e.g., Turunen & Pöyry, 2019). The purpose of this study is to examine consumers' motivations and perceived value from online secondhand luxury fashion retailers. In particular, this study targeted millennial and Gen Z consumers. The current study developed a theoretical framework based on the mental accounting theory (Thaler, 1985, 2008). The framework examined the impacts of five motivations-economic, critical, hedonic, fashion, status seeking-on perceived value, which
Article
Full-text available
Clothing and fashion allow the multiplication of multiple personalities into one human being. The tendency to be "someone else", even if it is only with some detail in the clothes, is based on the possibility of transformation of the individual. That transformation is done by masking man, more precisely, the aspiration of one person to transform at least for a short period of time. The possibilities offered by fashion, that a person can be someone else with the help of clothes, cosmetics or make-up are really great. One of the most important functions of clothing and apparel is to achieve a sense of spiritual balance. In fact, with the help of clothing, certain shortcomings of a person are compensated and, in that way, a certain psychological balance is achieved. The extent to which following fashion reduces the feeling of inferiority is seen in the fact that in most countries fashion is most closely followed by young people and immigrants, because it seems to them that dressing according to the latest fashion equals them with others.
Article
Full-text available
This study aims to propose and test a framework for status consumption in the context of perceived symbolic status. This paper fills the gap in the literature by proposing an integrated model focusing on the drivers and consequences of status consumption, conspicuous consumption, and symbolic status. We conducted an online survey among 990 people, and we tested the structural path relationships using AMOS. The results show that, first, status consumption and conspicuous consumption relate to perceived symbolic status. Second, the product symbolic status of the self relates to the product symbolic status of others. Third, the average product symbolic status of the self is higher than the average of the product symbolic status of others. Finally, when consumers are susceptible to normative interpersonal influences, they are more susceptible to status consumption and conspicuous consumption. Thus, consumers have a higher tendency to attribute the symbolic status of self to product and brand use than others. The implications of these findings are expected to make a contribution to the literature and lead to a better understanding of brand differentiation, positioning, and advertising decisions.
Article
Full-text available
Previous research has suggested the negative relationship between self-esteem and conspicuous consumption since conspicuous consumption is aimed to gain social recognition and signal status. However, it has not been much explored how this relationship holds depending on social classes. We propose subjective social class will moderate the relationship between social self-esteem and conspicuous consumption. We also hypothesize the mediating roles of social dominance orientation and life satisfaction in the proposed moderation effect. By conducting the survey with the American sample, we tested these predictions. In Study 1, we showed that the negative relationship between social self-esteem and conspicuous consumption appeared only among high subjective social class individuals. In Study 2, we replicated Study 1 and further demonstrated that social dominance orientation and life satisfaction respectively mediated the interactive effect of subjective social class and social self-esteem on conspicuous consumption. The results suggest that among individuals who perceive themselves to be in a high social class, a low level of social self-esteem is conducive to conspicuous consumption. The theoretical implications and limitations of the present investigation are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
The article examines the features of consumer behavior of Generation Z, the largest consumer group in the world today. The authors highlight the ability and willingness to purchase goods and services online as the main trends in changing consumer behavior, while the main means of getting information, choosing a product (service), and paying for a purchase today are smartphones and tablets actively used by representatives of Generation Z. Generation Z has been determined to be digital consumers boldly shopping online. They stay online most of their time (working online, studying online, social media from 3 to 6 hours a day, watching movies and entertainment content online, etc.) and before purchasing anything, Generation Z expects to access to and evaluate information, reads reviews, and conducts its research. Generation Z looks forward to co-creation with brands, participation in teams, and collaboration with managers; it expects innovation from their employers, leaders, and brands. Due to this digital literate consumption, it makes highly informed, more pragmatic, and analytical decisions than representatives of previous generations. The article also shows that social networks are becoming the main channel for delivering advertising information to a young audience with a focus on visual content (video, infographics) and the shortest formats possible: Generation Z consumes information fragmentarily, as they use several devices simultaneously.
Article
Youth development is the deliberate progression of providing all youth with the support, relationships, experiences, resources, and opportunities needed to become effective and proficient adults. The objective of this study was to understand the important role of belongingness in Subjective Well-being of adolescents. A sample of 197 adolescents from Eastern Uttar Pradesh, participated in this study. The extreme group strategy was used to identify subjects as high and low on the basis of the scores of Belongingness Motive Scale (Afroz S. & Tiwari PSN 2017). Subjective well-being scale (Roop Nagpal1982) was administered to get the data. The result of One Way Analysis of Variance showed that High and low groups of belongingness significantly differed on p<.01 level for positive affect, Negative affect, Rootedness & belongingness, Structural and Cohesive aspect of Family and Subjective well-being score. The result was congruent with the previous results and also added the existing literature that a strong sense of belongingness contributes to individual and community well-being (Cherry K. 2019).
Article
The current study explores the underlying psycho-social motivations of consumer-centric fear of missing out (FoMO) and, in turn, its effects on consumption behavior. More specifically, we add to the literature by investigating the complex set of relationships between the antecedents of consumer-centric FoMO (consumer need for uniqueness – CNFU and consumer independence), its underlying dimensions (desire for belonging and anxiety of isolation), and its consequences on (conformity and conspicuous) consumption. The data were collected from a total of 1156 consumers residing in the United States and Turkey, a developed and a developing country, using convenience sampling. Confirmatory factor analyses, as well as structural equation modeling, were applied. The findings revealed negative effects of consumer independence on consumer-centric FoMO, whereas CNFU had a counter-intuitive positive effect, as proposed. In turn, the underlying dimensions of FoMO, desire for belonging and anxiety of isolation, affected consumption consequences in the opposite direction with positive and negative influences respectively. Moreover, consumer-centric FoMO mediated the association between individual consumer differences and socially-motivated consumption behavior. The theoretical and applied implications of these results are discussed.