ArticlePDF Available

Scavenging Behaviour of Red Deer Cervus elaphus Linnaeus, 1758 (Artiodactyla: Cervidae) in Eastern Spain

Authors:

Abstract

A male red deer was repeatedly observed scavenging in eastern Spain. This is the first time this behaviour of the red deer being recorded by means of camera traps. Scavenging behaviour of herbivores may have implications for wildlife biologists and managers.
627
ACTA ZOOLOGICA BULGARICA
Short Communication
Acta Zool. Bulg., 74 (4), December 2022: 627-629
Published online 17 October 2022
http://www.acta-zoologica-bulgarica.eu/2022/002618
Scavenging Behaviour of Red Deer Cervus elaphus Linnaeus,
1758 (Artiodactyla: Cervidae) in Eastern Spain
Irene Estellés-Domingo1, Olga Egea-Casas1, Javier Martínez2, Andrés López-Peinado1,
Javier Ruiz De La Cuesta1, Clara García-Ripollés3 & Pascual López-López1
1 Movement Ecology Lab, Cavanilles Institute of Biodiversity and Evolutionary Biology, University of Valencia. C/ Catedrático
José Beltrán 2, E-46980 Paterna, Valencia, Spain; E-mail: ireneestellesdomingo@gmail.com
2 VAERSA, Valenciana de Aprovechamiento Energético de Recursos S.A., Avinguda de les Corts Valencianes 20, 46015 Valencia,
Valencia, Spain; E-mail: javier.marvalle@gmail.com
3 Environment Science and Solutions S.L., Valencia, Spain; E-mail: clara.ripolles@gmail.com
Abstract: 
of the red deer being recorded by means of camera traps. Scavenging behaviour of herbivores may have
implications for wildlife biologists and managers.
Key words: Camera-trap, golden eagle, herbivores, mammals, scavenging.
Introduction
Herbivory plays a key role in maintaining key eco-
system services and in structuring food webs in both
terrestrial and aquatic communities. Herbivores
are primary consumers in the base of food chains
( 2008). However, there are exceptional
events, in which herbivores consume meat and even
exhibit carnivore behaviour ( 1989). In this
situation, scavenging might occur when there is a
lack of minerals in the diet. Previous studies have
reported red deer (Cervus elaphus L., 1758) feeding
on Manx shearwater Punus punus (Brünnich,
1764) chicks in 1987 in Rhum, United Kingdom
( 1988). Other studies have reported simi-
lar scavenging behaviour of herbivorous species, e.
g. Hermann’s tortoise Testudo hermanni (et
al. 2016), crested porcupine Hystrix cristata (-
 et al. 2020), Egyptian spiny-tailed lizard Uro-
mastyx aegyptia microlepis ( et al. 2011)
and domestic sheep (Ovis sp.) ( 1988, -
 1989). Herbivores are adapted to digest plants
using particular digestive enzymes such as cellulase
as well as symbiotic microbiota ( 2018).
Nonetheless, this diet cannot provided all the miner-
als needed for their development and reproduction
( 1989).
Fig. 1. The Iberian Peninsula and the Valencia Province
highlighted in grey (left); the study area (black dot), east
of Spain (right).
628
Estellés-Domingo I., Egea-Casas O., Martínez J., López-Peinado A., De La Cuesta J. R., García-Ripollés C. & López-López P.
Fig. 2. A–C. Red deer scavenging on rabbit carrion. D–H. Red deer scavenging on a chicken carrion.
Scavenging Behaviour of Red Deer Cervus elaphus Linnaeus, 1758 (Artiodactyla) in Eastern Spain
629
In this note, we report our camera-based obser-
vations on the scavenging behaviour of a red deer in
a habitat in Spain.
Materials and Methods
The study area was located in the Valencia Prov-
ince, east of Spain (Fig. 1). Remains of rabbit,
chicken and wild boar Sus scrofa were left as baits
in a selected area for trapping golden eagles Aquila
chrysaetos for studies of movement ecology (see
e.g.  et al. 2022). Two camera traps
(Moultrie M-999i model, 20 Megapixels) were
placed in the area; they were programmed to take
three consecutive pictures each time they were trig-
gered, with no delay and all day-round (24 h/day).
Cameras were installed to detect if targeted eagles
visited carrion disposal. They were checked every

Results
On August 4th, August 26th and September 7th 2020,

on small carcasses of rabbit Oryctolagus cuniculus
and chicken Gallus gallus domesticus (Fig. 2). Af-
ter detailed observation of all camera-trap pictures,
the attendance of eagles and other carnivores such
as stone marten Martes foina, red fox Vulpes vulpes
and wild boars were also recorded. We also observed

having carrion with bones. All observations corre-
sponded to the same individual in the same location.
Discussion
Scavenging by herbivorous species might take place
  -
sium, phosphorus, sodium, potassium and proteins.
This is particularly important for the former three
compounds as they are crucially important mineral
elements for the development and growth of antlers
( 1989); these elements might be scarce in
the limestone soils of the study area. In this con-
text, scavenging could be an adaptation of deer for
providing minerals through bones intake. Thereby,
scavenging could help them to compensate the sea-


        
trapping several golden eagles and Bonelli’s eagles
in the study area ( et al. 2019), this was the
       
There are not many studies reporting this unusual
behaviour and, to the best of our knowledge, none
of them includes camera trap documents that evi-
dence this behaviour. Therefore, this study empha-
sises the usefulness of camera traps for exploring
of animal behaviour (see review in  et al.
2017). Our observations could also be of interest for
other researchers working on herbivory and species
interactions. Camera traps can add new information
that allows understanding conditions determining
this rare behaviour on ruminant biology. The use of
         
well as the disturbance to wildlife in the course of
the observations.
References
 1989. Carnivorous herbivores: mineral nutrition
and the balanced diet. Trends in Ecology and Evolution
4 (6): 155–156.
   
island populations of red deer Cervus elaphus and sheep
Ovis. Journal of Zoology 216 (3): 565–573.
       
        
M. D. 2017. A review of camera trapping for conserva-
tion behaviour research. Remote Sensing in Ecology and
Conservation 3 (3): 109–122.

 2011. First evidence of scavenging behaviour
in the herbivorous lizard. Journal of Arid Environments
75: 671–673.

 2020. Evidence of scavenging behaviour



 
breeding season in long-lived raptors. Current Zoology
68 (1): 57–67.
 2016. A note on
scavenging behaviour of adult Hermann’s tortoise (Testudo
hermanni). Biologica Nyssana 1 (7): 53–55.
 2019. Holidays? Not
for all. Eagles have larger home ranges on holidays as a
consequence of human disturbance. Biological Conserva-
tion 231: 59–66.
 2008. Herbivory from individuals to ecosystems.
Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution and Systematics
39: 133–152.
 2018. Nutritional ecology of the ruminant. Cornell
University Press. Ithaca, New York, USA.
Received: 10.02.2022
Accepted: 17.04.2022
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Cutting-edge technologies are extremely useful to develop new workflows in studying ecological data, particularly to understand animal behaviour and movement trajectories at the individual level. Although parental care is a well-studied phenomenon, most studies have been focused on direct observational or video recording data, as well as experimental manipulation. Therefore, what happens out of our sight still remains unknown. Using high-frequency GPS/GSM dataloggers and tri-axial accelerometers we monitored 25 Bonelli’s eagles (Aquila fasciata) during the breeding season to understand parental activities from a broader perspective. We used recursive data, measured as number of visits and residence time, to reveal nest attendance patterns of biparental care with role specialization between sexes. Accelerometry data interpreted as the Overall Dynamic Body Acceleration, a proxy of energy expenditure, showed strong differences in parental effort throughout the breeding season and between sexes. Thereby, males increased substantially their energetic requirements, due to the increased workload, while females spent most of the time on the nest. Furthermore, during critical phases of the breeding season, a low percentage of suitable hunting spots in eagles’ territories led them to increase their ranging behaviour in order to find food, with important consequences in energy consumption and mortality risk. Our results highlight the crucial role of males in raptor species exhibiting biparental care. Finally, we exemplify how biologging technologies are an adequate and objective method to study parental care in raptors as well as to get deeper insight into breeding ecology of birds in general.
Article
Full-text available
The vegetarian diet of many herbivorous mammals is supplemented with proteins of animal origin, especially in young individuals and in breeding females, to provide key proteins necessary for both growth and breeding. Among porcupine species, only the Cape porcupine (Hystrix africaeaustralis) has been observed to consume carrion flesh. From June to August 2019, a pigeon carcass was placed together with corn in 7 study settlements and near 2 monitored capture-traps, in order to assess the carrion flesh feeding habits of the crested porcupine (Hystrix cristata). Scavenging behaviour was recorded on four occasions. All the recorded individuals were adults and at least one was female. This demonstrates that the crested porcupine occasionally does eat flesh. Such evidence raises important questions concerning the relationship between feeding habits and the physiological needs of this herbivorous rodent.
Article
Full-text available
Human-wildlife conflicts are the object of raising concern in conservation biology. People living in urban areas are rapidly increasing worldwide and consequently the temporal pattern of occupation of natural areas for recreation is changing as well, resulting in an ever-increasing concentration of people during weekends and holidays. This is particularly evident in affluent societies, where more recreationists visit natural areas on holidays and weekends, causing disturbance to wildlife in the so-called "weekend effect". Here, we tested the response to disturbance of 30 Bonelli's eagles tracked by high-frequency GPS/GSM telemetry. We analysed daily home-range size, a measure of changing behaviour that integrates their vital requirements, throughout the annual cycle, considering three different levels (95%, 75% and 50% kernel density estimators). Our results showed that eagles made a higher ranging effort on weekends and holidays throughout the annual cycle. This was particularly evident during the non-breeding period, when larger home-ranges were observed. Higher ranging effort can lead to conservation problems such as extra energy expenditure, hunting interference, and eventually nest and/or territory abandonment, decreasing eagles' fitness. Measures aimed at reducing human-wildlife conflicts including spatio-temporal limitation of leisure activities particularly during the most critical periods (i.e., incubation, chick rearing) are urgently needed. Finally, where possible, high quality information of animal movement should be incorporated into conservation plans in order to delineate efficient spatially-explicit management measures.
Article
Full-text available
An understanding of animal behaviour is important if conservation initiatives are to be effective. However, quantifying the behaviour of wild animals presents significant challenges. Remote-sensing camera traps are becoming increasingly popular survey instruments that have been used to non-invasively study a variety of animal behaviours, yielding key insights into behavioural repertoires. They are well suited to ethological studies and provide considerable opportunities for generating conservation-relevant behavioural data if novel and robust methodological and analytical solutions can be developed. This paper reviews the current state of camera-trap-based ethological studies, describes new and emerging directions in camera-based conservation behaviour, and highlights a number of limitations and considerations of particular relevance for camera-based studies. Three promising areas of study are discussed: (1) documenting anthropogenic impacts on behaviour; (2) incorporating behavioural responses into management planning and (3) using behavioural indicators such as giving up densities and daily activity patterns. We emphasize the importance of reporting methodological details, utilizing emerging camera trap metadata standards and central data repositories for facilitating reproducibility, comparison and synthesis across studies. Behavioural studies using camera traps are in their infancy; the full potential of the technology is as yet unrealized. Researchers are encouraged to embrace conservation-driven hypotheses in order to meet future challenges and improve the efficacy of conservation and management processes.
Article
Full-text available
Report of the first observation of scavenging behaviour in the population of Testudo hermanni boettgeri that has been monitored for six years in the village Kunovica near the city of Niš in Serbia. On 31 May 2015 at 10:18 a.m., the adult tortoise was observed while eating a dead European green lizard (Lacerta viridis).
Article
Optimal foraging theory predicts flexibility in feeding behaviour which enables species to survive in harsh environments where food resources may be scarce and unpredictable in space and time. In this study we explored the hypothesis that the lizard Uromastyx aegyptia microlepis, a species living in dry desert areas may behave as an omnivore under conditions of limited food availability. To do so, we examined the diet of this species based on 294 faecal pellets collected in the field. This species has been traditionally considered as a strict herbivore. However, our study based on a population in the Qatar desert provides the first evidence of scavenging behaviour for Uromastyx. We found remains of mammals, reptiles, birds and insects in their faecal pellets. We also found significant differences between our study zones in the type of food consumed by lizards. This highlights the importance of environmental conditions and human activity on lizard behaviour. The consumption of vertebrate carcases w...
Article
Guidelines for submitting commentsPolicy: Comments that contribute to the discussion of the article will be posted within approximately three business days. We do not accept anonymous comments. Please include your email address; the address will not be displayed in the posted comment. Cell Press Editors will screen the comments to ensure that they are relevant and appropriate but comments will not be edited. The ultimate decision on publication of an online comment is at the Editors' discretion. Formatting: Please include a title for the comment and your affiliation. Note that symbols (e.g. Greek letters) may not transmit properly in this form due to potential software compatibility issues. Please spell out the words in place of the symbols (e.g. replace “α” with “alpha”). Comments should be no more than 8,000 characters (including spaces ) in length. References may be included when necessary but should be kept to a minimum. Be careful if copying and pasting from a Word document. Smart quotes can cause problems in the form. If you experience difficulties, please convert to a plain text file and then copy and paste into the form.
Article
On Foula, Shetland, sheep were observed biting off the legs, wings or head of unfledged young Arctic terns. Large numbers of tern chicks and a few Arctic skua chicks were found with amputations characteristic of these attacks by sheep. On Rhum, Inner Hebrides, red deer were watched biting the heads off manx shearwater chicks and occasionally also chewing the shearwaters' legs and wings to excise bone. Killing of birds and the selective ingestion of bone-rich parts by ruminants has not previously been widely documented. It is presumably a response to mineral deficiencies in the vegetation, and it may only occur in rare situations where ruminants feed on mineral-deficient vegetation on which there are dense colonies of ground-nesting birds.
Article
Herbivores not only consume resources, but they are resources for other consumers. Consequently, they have much potential to mediate effects that cascade up and down trophic chains in ecosystems. The way those effects are mediated depends on individual-scale properties of herbivores including constraints determining resource limitation, herbivore feeding mode, the adaptive trade-off to balance nutrient intake and predation risk avoidance, and the need to maintain homeostatic balance of elemental chemistry in the face of widely varying elemental composition of plant resources. These factors determine the rates of ecosystem functions such as production, decomposition and nutrient cycling. This review integrates those factors to build a conceptual framework for looking at herbivore-mediated effects in ecosystems. The framework systematically resolves how herbivores and carnivores directly and indirectly interact with plants to shape ecosystem functions. It can be used to motivate new field experimentation aimed at elucidating mechanisms of trophic control of ecosystem function.