ArticlePDF Available

The Kushiyara River Pact: The Stimulus for Indo- Bangladesh Hydro relations?

Authors:
3/28/23, 12:05 PM
The Kushiyara River Pact: The Stimulus for Indo-Bangladesh Hydro relations? | South Asia Journal
https://southasiajournal.net/the-kushiyara-river-pact-the-stimulus-for-indo-bangladesh-hydro-relations/
1/4
The Kushiyara River Pact: The Stimulus for Indo-
Bangladesh Hydro relations?
Image credit: https://www.legacyias.com/kushiyara-river-treaty/
by Rahul M Lad 18 March 2023
India and Bangladesh are close neighbours and share 54 rivers in between them. Out of these
rivers, the sole river Ganga has a proper management regime in place in the form of The Ganges
Waters Treaty 1996. Article IX of the treaty explicitly mentions that both India and Bangladesh are
responsible to conclude a treaty/arrangement with regards to other common rivers. But, the
negligible efforts from either riparian could not cut much ice. A noted water expert Ramaswamy
Iyer expressed the need to develop a management regime over at least six to seven rivers.
According to Iyer (1999), Sooner or later, agreements may have to be reached on at least some,
say six or seven, of these rivers. The low-intensity disputes over the utilization of these rivers
have already begun between India and Bangladesh. For instance, the proposed dam on river
Barak on the Indian side at Tipaimukh has raised concerns in Bangladesh as it is likely to affect
the fishing and Boro paddy production in the Sylhet division.
Amid these uncertain environment, the major breakthrough was achieved as both the countries
successfully signed a Pact over the management of shared river Kushiyara on September 2022.
The first water sharing deal since the historic Ganga Waters Treaty of 1996 was signed between
India and Bangladesh during Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina’s visit to India in September 2022. A
memorandum of understanding (MoU) was signed on the distribution of water from the Kushiyara
River, an outflow of the Barak River that travels through Bangladesh before entering Assam.
The Kushiyara pact assumes importance because it came into existence after a long gap of more
than 25 years. The last agreement over shared water between India and Bangladesh was The
Ganga Waters Treaty signed in 1996. The unnecessary silence prevailed on that front despite of
overwhelming numbers of common rivers being shared by these two neighbour countries.
Nonetheless, the impasse was finally broken by the implementation of an appropriate
management system for the sharing of the Kushiyara river. This may usher in a new era of
cooperation between India and Bangladesh on the transboundary river.
By
Rahul Lad
- March 18, 2023
1
2
3
3/28/23, 12:05 PM
The Kushiyara River Pact: The Stimulus for Indo-Bangladesh Hydro relations? | South Asia Journal
https://southasiajournal.net/the-kushiyara-river-pact-the-stimulus-for-indo-bangladesh-hydro-relations/
2/4
Even though the long-awaited agreement finally materialised, it may be considered a first step
towards greater expectations for the management of other common rivers that are now on the
waiting list.
After the Kushiyara, the attention has been shifted to one of the most awaited river i. e. Teesta.
The conflict over the sharing of river Teesta could not resolved due to bunch of reasons. The
Teesta River has caused conflict since the Ganges issue was resolved. Under a special deal signed
in July 1983, India and Bangladesh agreed that 36% of the Teesta water would go to Bangladesh
and 39% would go to India. The agreement was not, however, put into practise. Since then, there
have been numerous high-level political gatherings and talks, with the most recent taking place in
2010 during the 37th ministerial meeting of the Joint Rivers Commission.
In this meeting, the two countries decided to sign an agreement on Teesta water sharing by 2011.
The proposal calls for sharing 40% of the real flow at the Gazaldoba Barrage in West Bengal
between India and Bangladesh and 20% of the actual flow at Gazaldoba. The formula for
distributing water, however, was unsuccessful.
In 2011, draft agreement on the distribution of water from the Teesta river was produced during
the visit of Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to Bangladesh, according to which India would
receive 42.5 percent of the water and Bangladesh would receive 37.5 percent. For the sake of
maintaining the navigability of the river, the remaining 20% of water would be set aside. This
proposed arrangement, however, never materialised because of the West Bengal chief minister’s
objection. The non-cooperation by the Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee might be due to the
political compulsion in the state along with the reduced water flow in Teesta. But, However,
Banerjee knows she cannot keep denying water to Bangladesh, a country that shares 57 rivers
with India. “I support providing water to Bangladesh, but not from the Teesta, which sustains
north Bengal and does not have enough water to provide to Bangladesh. Instead, I suggested to
both Prime Ministers that a study be conducted to determine whether water might be provided to
Bangladesh from other rivers in the area, such as Torsa, Jaldhaka, or Raidak”, she said.
From the aforementioned claim, it is clear that the Teesta is the main point of contention that may
prevent India and Bangladesh from discussing their shared water resources on a bilateral basis.
But, as the Chief Minister of West Bengal stated, it is important to include the management of the
other rivers in order to build a cooperative environment. The Kushiyara pact must be seen as
major breakthrough in this regard.
Future Path roads
It is vital to prioritise rivers because there are 54 rivers that run between Bangladesh and India.
As one cannot have a management regime on all of the rivers at once, there must be some
standard for classifying the rivers for shared control. The criteria may include things like how
dependent the population is on the rivers, the irrigation system, the type of crops grown in the
basin, the length of the river, etc. The entire river system should be divided into two or three
phases based on these criteria. The rivers’ phase-wise management regime can then be
developed.
The statistics on water flow for the previous 30 to 40 years is unquestionably the most important
requirement to establish an agreement over shared water. The water sharing agreement between
India and Bangladesh was developed for the Ganga River using historical water flow data going
back 40 years. Thus, having aforementioned data is a vital prerequisite in order to get a water
sharing agreement on any common river. Both the governments should take studies in this regard.
Finally, it is concluded that the momentum created by the signing of the Kushiyara Accord must be
maintained. Both nations should adopt a flexible stance towards water sharing, which could create
new possibilities for the administration of shared water resources. While it is clear that Teesta
3/28/23, 12:05 PM
The Kushiyara River Pact: The Stimulus for Indo-Bangladesh Hydro relations? | South Asia Journal
https://southasiajournal.net/the-kushiyara-river-pact-the-stimulus-for-indo-bangladesh-hydro-relations/
3/4
rivers need a water sharing agreement quickly, just like Kushiyara, both countries must take the
necessary precautions to ensure that Teesta does not become a roadblock for other shared rivers.
References
1. Baten, M. A., & Titumir, R. A. M. (2016). Environmental challenges of trans-boundary water
resources management: the case of Bangladesh. Sustainable Water Resources
Management, 2(1), 13-27.
2. Iyer, R. R. (1999). Conflict-resolution: Three river treaties. Economic and Political Weekly,
1509-1518.
3. Thakur, J. (2020). India-Bangladesh Trans-Boundary River Management: Understanding the
Tipaimukh Dam Controversy. Observer Research Foundation, 18. Available at
https://www.orfonline.org/research/india-bangladesh-trans-boundary-river-management-
understanding-the-tipaimukh-dam-controversy-60419/ (Accessed on 2 December 2021).
Rahul Lad
The author is a senior research fellow in the geography department at Savitribai Phule Pune University in Pune,
India. He is pursuing Doctorate on Geostrategic Assessment of Transboundary River Water Sharing In South Asia
Region. His research interests include geopolitics, South Asian studies, India-Bangladesh relations, transboundary
river water sharing, and water politics.
EDITOR PICKS
POPULAR POSTS
Book review: The Black Coat, a novel by Neamat Imam
March 26, 2023
A Bangladeshi builds a $4b pharma in US with promises of cheap Covid treatment
November 20, 2022
Climate scientists explain Pakistan’s ‘unprecedented’ oods
September 13, 2022
Not Only in Ladakh, India Losing Ground in Bangladesh Too
June 18, 2020
Human Rights Violations in Kashmir: A Case Study of 2017
June 5, 2018
Bangladesh: An Open Letter to Foreign Minister Abdul Momen
June 6, 2020
3/28/23, 12:05 PM
The Kushiyara River Pact: The Stimulus for Indo-Bangladesh Hydro relations? | South Asia Journal
https://southasiajournal.net/the-kushiyara-river-pact-the-stimulus-for-indo-bangladesh-hydro-relations/
4/4
5759
3268
138
118
50
48
46
Blog
Commentary
Reviews
Issues
Issue 22 - Fall 2017
Issue 25 Summer 2018
Issue 27 Winter 2019
POPULAR CATEGORY
ABOUT US
Founded in 2011, South Asia Journal (SAJ) is a policy magazine focused on issues relating to South Asia. Bearing no
political aliation, the journals goal is to provide discerning, critical perspectives on the South Asian sub-continent
and its evolving relationship to the broader world. SAJ aims to highlight emerging regional trends, especially issues
which call for more emphasis among decision makers and policy framers.
Contact us: info@southasiajournal.net
FOLLOW US
© South Asia Journal
Contact Team Subscribe Submit Blog
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
The political definition of ‘natural geography’ with regard to trans-boundary waters may pose challenges to their environmental importance. Availability and distribution of trans-boundary waters may thus give rise to dissatisfaction, disbelief and dispute among its stakeholders. The Ganges, Brahmaputra and Meghna (GBM) basins, shared between Bangladesh and India, as a whole, receive more water than necessary over the year, but the spatial and temporal distribution of water availability are very uneven. Focused on the trans-boundary water regime of the GBM basins, this paper discusses core issues related to environmental security by analyzing various environmental impacts due to water diversion and its significance at the national and regional levels between Bangladesh and India. Both countries have built dams and barrages on these rivers to satisfy their water needs without considering the ecological settings. Consequently, the dwindling supply of water in dry season has become one of the key contested issues between the two countries. Negotiations, however, for water sharing in this region are mostly based on anecdotal rather than scientific evidences. Both Bangladesh and India classify river flow data as secret and use the lack of mutually acceptable data as a tactic to promote their own national interests. Reviewing the environmental challenges, the paper opines for an ecosystem orientation of international norms and regimes flows for the GBM basins.
Article
This paper is structured around three treaties: the Indus Treaty, the Mahakali Treaty and the Ganga Treaty. In each case, the paper covers very briefly the background to and nature of the dispute, the approach to a resolution, the major features of the treaty, the manner in which it has been operating, the difficulties encountered, and how these can be resolved. It then sets forth some explanations and reflections that arise from these cases, including the complex interaction between water issues and political relations: the twin dangers of big-country insensitivity or arrogance and small-country pathology; the need to guard against a doctrinaire approach to the question of 'bilateralism' versus 'regionalism'; and the importance of not equating inter-country co-operation exclusively with a few large projects.
Understanding the Tipaimukh Dam Controversy. Observer Research Foundation
  • J Thakur
Thakur, J. (2020). India-Bangladesh Trans-Boundary River Management: Understanding the Tipaimukh Dam Controversy. Observer Research Foundation, 18. Available at https://www.orfonline.org/research/india-bangladesh-trans-boundary-river-managementunderstanding-the-tipaimukh-dam-controversy-60419/ (Accessed on 2 December 2021).