ArticlePublisher preview available

Positive Schemas, Coping, and Quality of Life in Pediatric Recurrent Abdominal Pain

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Pediatric recurrent abdominal pain is commonly associated with negative impacts on quality of life (QOL). Positive schemas (core beliefs about the self with subthemes of self-efficacy, optimism, trust, success, and worthiness) are a resilience factor that has not yet been examined within a pediatric recurrent pain context. This cross-sectional study examined (a) associations between positive schemas, pain coping, and youth QOL, and (b) exploratory analyses to investigate whether specific positive schema subthemes predicted QOL outcomes in youth with recurrent abdominal pain. Participants were 98 youth with recurrent abdominal pain (i.e., pain related to a disorder of gut–brain interaction [DGBI] or organic cause) who completed measures on positive schemas, QOL, and pain coping. Age and diagnostic status were controlled for in analyses. Positive schemas were significantly positively correlated with emotional, social, school, and overall QOL, as well as with approach and problem-focused avoidant coping, and significantly negatively correlated with emotion-focused coping. Worthiness was the strongest and only significant predictor of youth social functioning. Positive schemas may be an important cognitive resilience factor to consider within interventions for pediatric recurrent pain.
Vol.:(0123456789)
1 3
Journal of Clinical Psychology in Medical Settings (2024) 31:37–47
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10880-023-09952-6
Positive Schemas, Coping, andQuality ofLife inPediatric Recurrent
Abdominal Pain
SoeunLee1 · RachelTomlinson1· MargaretN.Lumley1· KevinC.Bax2· DhandapaniAshok2·
C.MeghanMcMurtry1,2,3,4,5
Accepted: 24 February 2023 / Published online: 23 March 2023
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, part of Springer Nature 2023
Abstract
Pediatric recurrent abdominal pain is commonly associated with negative impacts on quality of life (QOL). Positive schemas
(core beliefs about the self with subthemes of self-efficacy, optimism, trust, success, and worthiness) are a resilience factor
that has not yet been examined within a pediatric recurrent pain context. This cross-sectional study examined (a) associations
between positive schemas, pain coping, and youth QOL, and (b) exploratory analyses to investigate whether specific posi-
tive schema subthemes predicted QOL outcomes in youth with recurrent abdominal pain. Participants were 98 youth with
recurrent abdominal pain (i.e., pain related to a disorder of gut–brain interaction [DGBI] or organic cause) who completed
measures on positive schemas, QOL, and pain coping. Age and diagnostic status were controlled for in analyses. Positive
schemas were significantly positively correlated with emotional, social, school, and overall QOL, as well as with approach
and problem-focused avoidant coping, and significantly negatively correlated with emotion-focused coping. Worthiness was
the strongest and only significant predictor of youth social functioning. Positive schemas may be an important cognitive
resilience factor to consider within interventions for pediatric recurrent pain.
Keywords Pediatric abdominal pain· Positive schemas· Quality of life· Coping
Introduction
Pediatric gastrointestinal (GI) disorders encompass a range
of abdominal and digestive disorders experienced by chil-
dren and adolescents (herein “youth”). The cause of pediat-
ric GI disorders varies and can be conceptualized as a dis-
order of gut–brain interaction (DGBI), previously referred
to as ‘functional’ gastrointestinal disorders, or those that
cannot be fully explained by a pathologic cause, including
functional abdominal pain and irritable bowel syndrome;
(Hyams etal., 2016; Sayuk, 2021) or ‘organic’ in nature
(can be identified by pathologic abnormalities in the GI tract,
such as Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD); Diefenbach &
Breuer, 2006). Regardless of cause, youth with GI disorders
commonly report recurrent abdominal pain as a symptom
(Diefenbach & Breuer, 2006; Hyams etal., 2016). Moreover,
youth with IBD can also experience IBS-related symptoms
(e.g., pain) while in remission (Teruel etal., 2016), sug-
gesting that recurrent abdominal pain may be a common
experience for youth with both DGBI and ‘organic’ abdomi-
nal disorders. The maintenance of pediatric GI symptoms,
such as recurrent pain, is best conceptualized by a biopsy-
chosocial approach, which emphasizes the importance of
psychological (e.g., cognitions, emotions) and social factors
(e.g., environmental stressors, parents/family), in addition to
the biological ones (Reed-Knight etal., 2017). Youth with
recurrent abdominal pain report significantly lower physi-
cal, emotional, social, and academic quality of life (QOL)
compared to youth with other chronic conditions (Warsch-
burger etal., 2014), and are at risk of experiencing chronic
pain in adulthood (Jawaid etal., 2019; Walker etal., 2010).
* Soeun Lee
soeun@uoguelph.ca
1 Pediatric Pain, Health, andCommunication Lab,
Department ofPsychology, University ofGuelph, Guelph,
ONN1G2W1, Canada
2 Department ofPaediatrics, Western University, London, ON,
Canada
3 Pediatric Chronic Pain Program, McMaster Children’s
Hospital, Hamilton, ON, Canada
4 Department ofAnesthesia, McMaster University, Hamilton,
ON, Canada
5 Children’s Health Research Institute, London, ON, Canada
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... Higher overall optimism was associated with better self-reported health-related quality of life (HRQoL) or subjective health among female high school students (Piko et al., 2020) and youth with cancer (Mannix et al., 2009;Sulkers et al., 2013) and heart disease (Wang et al., 2014). In contrast, overall optimism was not associated with self-reported physical functioning among youth consulting at a pediatric gastroenterology service (Lee et al., 2023). ...
Article
Full-text available
Objective: High levels of optimism (and low levels of pessimism) are associated with improved physical health in adults. However, relatively less is known about these relations in youth. The present study aimed to review the literature investigating optimism, pessimism, and physical health in children and adolescents from populations with and without health conditions. Methods: We conducted a scoping review up until February 2024. Studies were included if they sampled youth (average age ≤18 years) and treated optimism or pessimism as predictors of health behaviors or outcomes. Data on study and sample characteristics, health outcome, optimism construct, and findings were extracted from eligible papers and results were synthesized. Results: Sixty studies were retained. Most studies were conducted in North America, with adolescents, and used cross-sectional designs and self-reported measures of health. Measures of optimism and pessimism differed across studies. Roughly one-third of studies sampled medical populations. Health categories included substance use, diet and physical activity, sexual health practices, medical adherence, other health behaviors, cardiometabolic health, subjective health/health-related quality of life, pain, sleep, and oral health. Generally, we observed adaptive associations between optimism and health. Higher optimism and lower pessimism were most consistently associated with lower rates of substance use and lower cardiometabolic risk. Conclusions: The presence of optimism or the absence of pessimism appears to be associated with various adaptive health outcomes among youth with and without health conditions. Developmental, methodological, and clinical considerations for future research are discussed, such as conducting longitudinal studies with objective measures of health and psychometrically validated instruments.
Article
Objectives Abdominal pain adversely impacts children with functional gastrointestinal disorders (FGIDs) or organic gastrointestinal disorders (OGIDs); findings are inconsistent regarding diagnosis and health-related quality of life (HRQoL). This study utilizes a positive psychology framework to understand the experience of youth with abdominal pain (i.e., do positive psychological factors, such as optimism and pain self-efficacy, relate to higher HRQoL). Consistent with a protective factor model of resilience, in which personal assets may serve as buffers between risk factors and negative outcomes, optimism and pain self-efficacy were examined as they relate to HRQoL in youth with abdominal pain. Specifically, exploratory moderational analyses examined a) if optimism and pain self-efficacy moderate the relation between pain and HRQoL, and b) whether diagnostic status moderated the relation between optimism/pain self-efficacy and HRQoL. Methods In a cross-sectional, observational study, youth (n = 98; Mage = 13, SD = 2.8) experiencing abdominal pain related to FGIDs or OGIDs and one of their parents participated. Measures included pain intensity, optimism, pain self-efficacy, and HRQoL. Analyses controlled for diagnosis, age, and gender. Results Higher pain and age related to lower HRQoL. Higher levels of optimism and pain self-efficacy associated with HRQoL beyond demographics. Optimism and pain self-efficacy did not moderate the relation between pain and HRQoL. Diagnostic status did not moderate the relation between optimism or pain self-efficacy and HRQoL. Discussion Our results suggest positive relations between positive psychological factors (optimism, pain self-efficacy) and HRQoL in youth with abdominal pain. Such factors could be further examined in intervention studies.
Article
Full-text available
Background The optimal form of health care delivery for paediatric to adult inflammatory bowel disease transition of care is unknown. The primary purpose of this study was to establish current standard of care across Canada among adult gastroenterologists. Methods Adult gastroenterologists interested in transition care were identified. Twenty-five anonymous surveys and 17 semistructured interviews representing 9 adult gastroenterology centers across 6 provinces were completed. Questions focused on the transition process, referral practices, information transfer and access to multidisciplinary resources. The need for expert guidance and transition-related quality indicators were identified. The interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed and coded in duplicate for qualitative thematic analysis. Results Transition practices included the following: transition clinic (n = 4) versus direct transfer (n = 5). Most transition patients were referred to academic centers. Transfer volume per center ranged from 12 to 100 per year. Transfer of information was optimized with shared electronic medical record and comprehensive referral package. The majority of the programs lacked consistent access to a multidisciplinary team. The strongest attributes related to health care provider interest in transition and complete information transfer. Areas for improvement included increased resource allocation: financial, logistical and personnel. All agreed that a consensus-based guidfmeline for adult phase of transition would be beneficial. Potential quality indicators included adherence to care, depression/anxiety scores and patient knowledge. Conclusions This Canadian study of adult gastroenterologists revealed that while practice patterns vary, most agree that a transition clinic with access to multidisciplinary resources would be beneficial. A consensus-based guideline and quality indicators to assess performance may standardize the adult phase of transition and optimize outcomes.
Article
Full-text available
Background Pain is a common symptom in pediatric inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) and is associated with poor health outcomes, yet additional knowledge about the psychosocial correlates of pain is needed to optimize clinical care. The purpose of this study is to systematically review the psychosocial factors associated with pain and pain impact in youth diagnosed with IBD within a developmentally informed framework. Methods Manual and electronic searches yielded 2641 references. Two authors conducted screening (98% agreement), and data extraction was performed in duplicate. Average study quality was rated using the National Institutes of Health Quality Assessment Tool. Results Ten studies (N = 763 patients; N = 563 Crohn disease, N = 200 ulcerative/ indeterminate colitis) met the inclusion criteria. Findings showed consistent evidence that higher levels of child depression symptoms and child pain catastrophizing were associated with significantly greater pain and pain impact (magnitude of association ranged from small to large across studies). Greater pain and pain impact were also associated with higher levels of child anxiety symptoms, child pain threat, child pain worry, and parent pain catastrophizing. Within the included studies, female sex and disease severity were both significantly associated with pain and pain impact. Study quality was moderate on average. Conclusions There is evidence that child psychosocial factors are associated with pain and pain impact in pediatric IBD; more studies are needed to examine parent- and family-level psychosocial factors. Youth with IBD should be routinely screened for pain severity, pain impact, and psychosocial risk factors such as anxiety/depression.
Article
Full-text available
Research has established that negative self-schemas are potent risk factors for depressive symptoms among children and adolescents. However, few studies have examined whether positive self-schemas provide unique information about children and adolescents’ depressive symptoms and their well-being. Further, examining the stability of cognitive content during this developmental transition is also relevant. Informed by positive (clinical) psychology and cognitive-developmental frameworks, this study examined a) the longitudinal stability of children and adolescents’ self-schemas and b) the prospective associations of positive and negative self-schemas to children and adolescents’ depressive symptoms and life satisfaction in a community sample of 139 children and adolescents (Mage = 11.20, SD = 1.21) and their parent/guardian. Results provided preliminary evidence that negative and positive self-schemas exhibit stability over time. Positive self-schemas also predicted unique variance in children and adolescents’ depressive symptoms, above and beyond negative self-schemas. Only negative self-schemas were uniquely associated with children and adolescents’ life satisfaction over time. These results suggest there may be utility in incorporating positive self-schemas into models of child and adolescent depression. As well, these results may provide important information regarding appropriate timing for the prevention of child and adolescent depression and bolstering of well-being.
Article
Full-text available
Background Pediatric functional abdominal pain disorders (FAPDs) are disorders of brain‐gut dysregulation. Psychological factors are known to be related to etiology, maintenance, and exacerbation of pediatric FAPDs. With the evolving literature in the past two decades, a better understanding has emerged of precisely which psychological factors are associated with childhood FAPDs. Purpose This narrative literature review summarizes the literature of both child and parent psychological factors in pediatric FAPD. Where anxiety and depression were major targets in the older literature, present‐day focus is increasingly on pain‐specific cognitions and coping strategies including disease threat and catastrophizing. In addition, parental reaction to a child's pain is increasingly recognized as an important moderator of a child's outcomes and has become an area for clinical intervention. Screening for these factors and integrative treatment approaches are recommended in childhood FAPD.
Article
Full-text available
Research in developmental psychology highlights youth’s self-schemas as one possible pathway to improve adolescents’ functioning and promote positive developmental outcomes. Despite this, the trajectory of positive and negative self-schemas is relatively understudied. This study addresses this limitation by empirically examining the trajectory of self-schemas in a community sample of 623 youth (M = 13.04 years; 54% female; 49% African American, 4% Biracial, 47% European American) who were followed over a seven-year period. Caregivers completed measures of parenting practices, maternal rumination and negative inferential style, and adolescents completed a computerized behavioral task assessing self-schemas (i.e., mental frameworks that guide attention, interpretation, and memory of one’s experiences). Multilevel growth curve modeling results demonstrated a quadratic slope for negative self-schemas and no mean-level change for positive self-schemas. These trajectories did not vary by gender or racial group. However, parenting factors differentially influenced the trajectories. Specifically, higher levels of parental involvement at baseline, or an active interest and engagement in a child’s experiences and activities, related to lower levels of negative self-schemas during adolescence. Additionally, higher levels of parental rumination and parental negative control at baseline related to lower levels of youth positive self-schemas at baseline. These findings contribute to models of youth cognitive development.
Article
Full-text available
Objective Chronic pain is central to juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA) and is predictive of impaired functioning. Whereas most work has focused on identifying psychosocial risk factors for maladaptive outcomes, we explored the idea that child and parental psychological flexibility (PF) represent resilience factors for adaptive functioning of the child. We also explored differences between general vs pain-specific PF in contributing to child outcomes. Methods Children with JIA (age eight to 18 years) and (one of) their parents were recruited at the Department of Pediatric Rheumatology at the Ghent University Hospital in Belgium. They completed questionnaires assessing child and parent general and pain-specific PF and child psychosocial and emotional functioning and disability. Results The final sample consisted of 59 children and 48 parents. Multiple regression analyses revealed that child PF contributed to better psychosocial functioning and less negative affect. Child pain acceptance contributed to better psychosocial functioning, lower levels of disability, and lower negative affect, and also buffered the negative influence of pain intensity on disability. Bootstrap mediation analyses demonstrated that parental (general) PF indirectly contributed to child psychosocial functioning and affect via the child’s (general) PF. Parent pain-specific PF was indirectly linked to child psychosocial functioning, disability, and negative affect via child pain acceptance. Conclusions Our findings indicate that child and parental PF are resilience factors and that pain acceptance buffers the negative impact of pain intensity. Implications for psychosocial interventions that target (pain-specific) PF in children and parents are discussed.
Article
Objectives Abdominal pain adversely impacts children with functional gastrointestinal disorders (FGIDs) or organic gastrointestinal disorders (OGIDs); findings are inconsistent regarding diagnosis and health-related quality of life (HRQoL). This study utilizes a positive psychology framework to understand the experience of youth with abdominal pain (i.e., do positive psychological factors, such as optimism and pain self-efficacy, relate to higher HRQoL). Consistent with a protective factor model of resilience, in which personal assets may serve as buffers between risk factors and negative outcomes, optimism and pain self-efficacy were examined as they relate to HRQoL in youth with abdominal pain. Specifically, exploratory moderational analyses examined a) if optimism and pain self-efficacy moderate the relation between pain and HRQoL, and b) whether diagnostic status moderated the relation between optimism/pain self-efficacy and HRQoL. Methods In a cross-sectional, observational study, youth (n = 98; Mage = 13, SD = 2.8) experiencing abdominal pain related to FGIDs or OGIDs and one of their parents participated. Measures included pain intensity, optimism, pain self-efficacy, and HRQoL. Analyses controlled for diagnosis, age, and gender. Results Higher pain and age related to lower HRQoL. Higher levels of optimism and pain self-efficacy associated with HRQoL beyond demographics. Optimism and pain self-efficacy did not moderate the relation between pain and HRQoL. Diagnostic status did not moderate the relation between optimism or pain self-efficacy and HRQoL. Discussion Our results suggest positive relations between positive psychological factors (optimism, pain self-efficacy) and HRQoL in youth with abdominal pain. Such factors could be further examined in intervention studies.
Article
Objective Map the current literature investigating autonomy development, identity development, and peer relationships in young people aged 10–24 years with chronic pain. Methods A scoping review method was used to systematically search four databases (APA PsycNET, PubMed, Web of Science, and Cinahl) for peer-reviewed articles. Search results were screened against inclusion and exclusion criteria to ensure they met the objective. Eligible papers were assessed for quality, their data relating to the objective were extracted, and results are synthesized. Results Searches returned 3,815 papers after the removal of duplicates, with 42 papers included in the full review. The majority of papers investigated peer relationships (86%). Fewer papers investigated autonomy (43%) and identity (21%) development. Included papers were mostly quantitative (64%), with fewer qualitative (34%) and mixed-methods papers (2%). Overall, we found bidirectional relationships between chronic pain in young people, their social development, and a range of functional outcomes. However, the mechanisms underlying these relationships remain relatively unexplored. Conclusions Review results are mapped onto the model proposed by Palermo et al. (2014). Guided by this model, clinical treatment for young people with chronic pain should consider social development. The model also sets out a future research agenda focused on exploring: (a) identity development, (b) the mechanisms underlying the relationships between social–developmental domains, pain, and outcomes, (c) a variety of participants and populations, and (d) a variety of methods, including longitudinal study designs.
Article
Objectives: Pediatric chronic pain has often been examined from a risk perspective, and relatively less is known about the individual and family-level resilience factors that help youth with chronic pain maintain their quality of life. This cross-sectional study: (a) examined the relations among purported youth and parent resilience (youth pain acceptance and pain self-efficacy, parent psychological flexibility) and risk (youth pain intensity, parent protectiveness) factors with youth quality of life, and (b) tested exploratory statistical mechanisms that may explain relations between parent and youth variables. Methods: Participants included 122 youth (10 to 17▒y; M=14.26, SD=2.19) seen in an interdisciplinary pediatric chronic pain program and a parent. Youth completed measures of their average pain, quality of life, pain acceptance, and pain self-efficacy. Parents completed measures of their pain-related psychological flexibility and behavioral responses to pain (i.e., protectiveness, distraction, monitoring, minimizing). Results: Youth pain acceptance, pain self-efficacy, and parent psychological flexibility were highly positively correlated with each other, and with overall youth quality of life. Evidence for a buffering effect of pain acceptance and pain self-efficacy on the association between pain intensity and quality of life was not found. Protectiveness was found to be a significant mediator of the relation between parental psychological flexibility and youth quality of life. Discussion: The results are discussed in the context of the resilience-risk framework and current understandings of the role of parental factors for pediatric chronic pain.