Content uploaded by Martin Moore-Ede
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Martin Moore-Ede on Jan 30, 2023
Content may be subject to copyright.
Available via license: CC BY 4.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
LIGHTS SHOULD SUPPORT CIRCADIAN RHYTHMS: EVIDENCE-BASED SCIENTIFIC CONSENSUS
!"#$%
&'(!& )* +,&,,("
-,)"&+&$./')&+"&(&&&
-,0,+)"1,20,
%* +$,&&!&+$,&&0,2()"
(.2()
-!-
3,"((,"* "11", &
("4&&"*,&&.5&+6&+(-&
.**& +(,&1"1,&'((
&&1,,*+1,, &&" 1"'(
*& ,*&&,**
&&789+((" :*&&"1."
(*%;&.+<=>*.*,1&(
&&&&&77;&&,% 1, *&+(&&
" 1&&, ,&:&&&,(,**+.*
,&+&&((.(11,&'(&("
? "1 +,+,(@
*(,A B&&& C<>;<7
;D7
0$-!/)-0/$
- (,"*&& *+&,(E*,*+,6&
&&&&" &*"(&*&3:7777(+
&1.1("(F7777G77777,EH&,F7777
7,EH1,", && (" I%,JK
.++,(*&,",%,&"&+"(
(1*&*.1"&&(**E "=79+,
.*JK,&&("*&"77 ,("
,"(777 1(L,1( (
-&&,*+ (+*"(&1& &*&&&,
1&+1, 1"(1E",*87"JK
0M,E*,(,(" ,E*,&&((1
&..(+J%<K"77>.,4&&+
/(NF/H0(&"+!&&F0!HJ<K&+"
(L..&&,**11F(,*H, &&(1,
* (&,&. &(, 1+,
&&,*("+.(+&,(1"
1*,&*"&&&&&&
,&1&&*&&J8=K
&7&&((1+ 1",&+("("4&'
F( O(H(*((,"+&*,+4&
(,&&,(&&(3'P,&(J7K. '
(* N4&&"1",N(1,.&&*&(+1,&
;D7
.(*&, & *,&+(JKE*,1,&'(
((,(:&,1&,, &&" ("
1,(%;7 *"+ *&&"*
((&F*!QH, ,+1,&.'
(,(&,,&&,&&,*&+J%
8K
-1,,*1,&(,(" *&&"
1,*((*&(&&,*J<K.R77
1S"((,"1".1%,,&,+
&1,'('789+(""&&,**
**J>K
& T,:&1"((,"+((N+1,'(
& &&&&" ,., *1","((
&:,( +&:&&,&1&, 1.
&,"&&.&.,&+"&:(+&&((&&
&1&&,&&,"1&+ &&
METHODS
Survey Popula!on:
&+,1. ?&&@C?(@:777*.&:&
&*,11.*77;*71"=%88,M,,:
,,+ *.*,1+, *.&.1,
+8%,,( &:1 & &
;D7
*,1.1+8<F8>9H+&:&,&*
*&*&:&,,"&'(%;F89H+
&*& *,"F89H
-%;**,1(+F A>U(A%<;H*.&
?&&@C?(@&77;G7,"*++
*F%%;9H.1$ &=<F;>9H.1,*>F<=9H.
1, &F%;9H.1,S$.V7F%79H.1
(F7;9H.1+&-*,1&+&+%;*.
.&+"*I* "& A, &F,&,(
, ,1T&, .&H, &F,
&,( 1*&1*&,S &," H
-.7&.* "*+ , &%8&.
*+ , &",1(,*& *++M,&+**
+& .&,&,(&M,
Survey Design
3" .*+(1",+&-".*+&,
&&,, N(&:&,.+.(**AHIW.H
$&H' &%HQ&8H13.**&&
&&&,1,((. +**-: (
.*E**&" 1&:&,.+.(*
*AHIW.H("(H(%H(8H("(
De&ni!on of Consensus
;D7%
0((,*+&(& *E&:&M,&(, ,
( +1E*&0**&"&,,.
,++1&1.*&*1(*&*&( :
.1.T,( +*>7>89( L&&*
&,J;=K0(,".**,".1
+1&+ *&*.:&,..+*
F<<>9H,** -*?Q&@?1@.
& 1+&1 ?(@?("(@.& 1+E*
*&" -?IW.@*& .&1+
,+(+&*&:&*&..&".+
+1E&,+ &,&&,*&
RESULTS
,.&%,+%7 -1
-:+&, +(,E*,1((,(
"F"(1(&&(H&(1, +&&"
(-.(&,1,&&" *+
F=89H,*(&&" &&,F=;%9H-.
&,&(" (". "(+87
877,E&&& (&&" F>789H *
" ,&*F>%>9H- T"F8=9H+*&
.?(&@.?.1@&(" ("&
*(1,&.&,
;D78
CONSENSUS STATEMENTS 9
!1,&&" *+ (( =8
,*(&&" &&, =;%
!(,"E*,"(&&& (
&&" =8
!(,"E*,"(&&*( ;<%
Increasing indoor light intensity during day!mea:
X&&&& (&&" >78
X& *" ,&* >%<
Increasing indoor light intensity at nightb:
X&,*+&&" =7<
X&,**+&, *,& =%<
Repe!!ve and prolonged exposure to light at night bright enough to cause circadian
disrup!on:
X&+1&&. <><
X&+1"1 >%>
X&+* ;>%
Human Sensi!vity to Blue Wavelengths
-"*+*!Q *&&*,
**E "%;7 1,*+1*&, =>
- *.(+&& %<7%=8 1,(
"*+*!Q *&&* =>
Blue-enriched (460-495nm) light in the evening (during the three hours before
bed!me)c
X,*&,* 1,*( " >7
X*"&&" 1,*(
" >88
X,*&&" 1,*( " >7
Exposure to 460-495nm blue light at night:
X,** *,& =7<
X,*&&" ;%;
PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS
'(,(F,(,1+1 H,5
1,&*&&"*1 ;8
-+&&,*,(,1+1 &1,&
1"H (((.& "& * 1"*+ ,
.H,&(1,&+(( "
M,+, >7
EXPERT OPINION
-1,&+((" ,& * (
&&,& && *,F-H+(
,& ;<>
0&(("4&&"+(11,+&+
&,(&&,*, =
'(.(%<7%=8 1,&,&".(1? "1 >=
;D7<
+,+,(@
-.,4&&,**.*,&+&&
((T,("1,&&"(
1,&& ;8=
-(:&,"(+&&((
,1* N.*1,(*N, =7<
, (+ (+87877*,E, & *1*(E*,
"
1, (+ (+87877,E, & *1*("
&, (1(,(F77877*,EH:*1
-1A .&&,.&
-&+&, *&+&&((-.(
&,&(("(&,*+&&"
F=7<9H&,**+&, *,&F=%<9H-.
&,**(E*,((1(,(&,&&
,*&+1&&. F<><9H1"1F>%>9H*
F;>%9H- T"+*(.(,**F?(&@
?.1@H**(E*,((.1(,(
&,&&,*&&&,F<7>9H*F<7;9H1,
&.&,
-+&, *&+1,.(.
, , &&" -.(&,?"*+
*!Q *&&*, **E "%;7 1,*+
1*&, @F=>9H? *.(+&& %<7%=8
1,("*+*!Q *&&*@F=>9H
;D7>
-.&,?1,&F%<7%=8 H((F,(,
1+1 H,*&,* F>79H*"&&" F>889H
,*&&" F>79H1,*( "-.
(&,E*,%<7%=8 1,((,** *,&
F=7<9H,*&&" @F;%=9H
-+,+&, *&&**&+&&&&
((-.&,?(,(F,(,1+1 H
,51,&*&&"*1@F;89H?+&&
,*,(,1+1 &1,&1"H (((
.& "& * 1"*+ ,.H,&(1,&+
(( "M,+,@F>79H
-*&*.E**1, *&+&&&&+
( * +((-.&,?1,&+((
" ,& * (&&,& &&
*,F-H+(,&@F;<>9H?&(("4&&"+(
11,+&+&,(&&,*,F=9H
, N(E**.&,?.,4&&,**
.*,&+&&((T,("1,&&"
( 1,&& F;8=9H?'(.(%<7
%=8 1,&,&".(1? "1 +,+,(@F>=9H-"
&&,?(:&,"(+&&
((,1* N.*1,(*N,@F=7<9H
;D7;
NO CONSENSUS %
;D7=
Increasing indoor light intensity during day!med
X&&*( 8==
Repe!!ve and prolonged exposure to light at night bright enough to cause circadian
disrup!on:
X&+*&& %%
&+&&, <7>
X&+* <7;
Increasing the 460-495nm blue content of indoor light during day!mee
X&&&& <<
X&&*( %>
Repe!!ve and prolonged exposure to 460-495nm blue-enriched light during nocturnal
hoursf
X&+1&&. %>8
X&+*&& =
X&,& " *(,&& 87<
X&+&&, %=
X&+* %8;
X&+* <8%
PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS
'(,,((L,51,&*&&"
*1 8%=
)(1(1,&(,((L "&1,
+&,(&&,*, 8<%
'((.(1,&,(" 1,&,(
((*&+.%S>.*& 87;
, (+ (+87877*,E, & *1*(E*,"
, 0("+77*,E .,.., & *1*("
+, 0((+77877*,EM,*+ .
-1A .&&,F,**1".+*H.&
;D7 7
-1 +.&.F<<<9H&,.& *
1.*+M,&+.,1(,**.&.*"
, &*.", &..
(( 1..,1(,*.(:&6&1(+,,
+"+,++" -+ +.A
0&(("(&,**+&,
*,&
E*,%<7%=8 1,((,** *,&
-(:&,"(U+&&((,
1* N.*1,(*N,
(&,&, , &F1,&&,
1,1(,*H
/ A
!**(E*,((1(,(&,&&,*
&+&&,, &,1(,*
1(" ,**F&&,&, &
,1(,*H
0)0/$
(%;&*&*. ,**.*,1&&&(:
. ( &, ?
@-&&,.,**1"&,
;D7
*&:& 1, ,*6& && " +*&"
1,&((&+M,(,("-&:&E*
( ? !"# $
@
,&'(( &(( 1&,"&*77
77, * .5(" 4&((& *8, S.5+&&87<7
, S.5+ P,&( J<K - 1,( ((,( (,
FQ$H&".&(N1"7%$1N+"&.#*&
0 , ,T$ ,JK,&'(.+
9 7(;79 71"( *&
," 1 &N *& + (( . ' & ("
(+,* 1"(,"1&&(P,&((J7
K
/ + ,1&&&, ,,&,+1,&
'( "1N,, -&&&&(, (+
*"(&*&.molecular & :1"7>$1N"("
&.#6"&!1&Y,(J7K,M,"1,
(JK-1&, *&&"*((&F*!QH
&&&& (&"&*"Z%;7 1,
(JK ,+1,&.'(,(&,,&&,
&&,*&+J8KE*,&&((
1&.1"1&&,&&&&,(1
*&&,*&:&*+/0(&"+!&&
;D7
F0!HFK &&&J;K$0$-E&("( J=K
E*,((,4&(,("&+1&&
,&,,"1&,((,"1".,&
&&((& (&&,4&" , &
1& &*&"."".: *+((
,"*& (".-+*+1.
&,&1& ,"+&&&:-**,.
*&*,,".&&.*,1+, *
.&:,1&. ?&&@C?(@&77;FL
:*+/0!&&(&:(J<KH+. ..1+"
-.*&+**&*1"&.
&.&( *" .,+..
&*(,. *,1&..,4&"
+ .((,(.&,".&,& "1,*
*
3,&.&,8 "
+&,"&&3;+ T"F87<G<8%9H+*
?(&S.1@1,,4&+&+* (
? &@1(&,1..F<<<9H,**&0
(,*+&&(((+,(+& "11.
&? &@..&T,:+ &
;D7
*1&++ ".&,*&:&,&,1
&. ?&&@C?(@&,"E&777S"
&*&((1* +1,*'(+
&,,%;7 1,&'(+" .,(:&"& * (&
("4&&"J<K- 5E&,,((.& :1,
&""(&"&!& +(:&,
&&((,&%9,&"+,&*
(,( J%8K * +*,&+, &
*J<>K.*&&((+ ?&@? ,@
!3!$
,N 33,%&'%%()*&
%+, 1(A)"U=;
W*$$/5!-$, &"5,"F$HA
,&+(E*, *,-./77U
11A8
-3'W[$!#&6&+&,*/,0,*,
7<U78AG
% ,&"!-Q[:#&(*01+,
&1 Q.1"$&,(AM,&+0
,*1"'($(! 0(&-*77=U8: %>G8
8 W 2,-,'(((&.1"1
"**7U
5*ASS& &,*& S*S&&SS77=S*SN&7S<<7;=8\(],H
;D7 %
< ,!,5W'." (1(( (&
.*"&&A1T&(,"^;8777)W1*&**
7U5*ASS... E(S&S77S77<;7=%+,*+
> +W!QY,&(&"+L.*(::((
12 348:7<87<<
; !QQ6&+(O ((A&
&&&*&" /,-,*,57U45A%G%<
= )$-E&("( $-&N *(L.
(($-E&("( )* +, &7U
5*ASS*(S*S,S*,1S&&_ S:77%77_87;*+
7 )* +("7787=("( A:+Q
&' *U3,7U5*ASS...(,(S&, S!7--77
77
+7;W 1"3,& *A1,A*17U
5*ASS(&& SS&S7;SS7%7
,*)7;U5*ASS&,*,S+S.S.(1,1,.1,
("(*,&(( 7;,(_
Q1"$1+1,',N((6,7%U514A8G8
% V1.W((6,7;U553A>%><
8 &Q2+( ((" *&&&
" *+70,77U10: =7
< ' ,*&"1&, &&*,&"
("4&&"'(N7
;D7 8
5*ASS... (N& S((.1(S&S%===%S(( ,
1& ,*1T& (N
> (8&05'9:%;2 2<,2 2=4
5*ASS...1( && S*S(1&&" ((
; !6'Q 2$,* ( +1,&*
*1&,("A&,(,+10,2 =3)13A7=87=
= Q,Q$,'[Q N#,* A
&&(\%;+&7U163A7%;%
7 2''',&-3Y,(-&&&&&&,(,A
'+ $1N"("&7>-7;U39A
<G=
[Q,5,!&*&"*&, .EE*,
*"& &.'(,.*&&->077U35A%78G%8
#[',&!#, *+ *( E "1,(F` E
Z%>= H,**(&+QMSQS((&&*0+>,7U280A
7=;>
0(&"+!&&?'8&
0')+@',*A;7A+@'77U98A8<><%
% Q'W#0 *&+)*('((3
!#7U*5*ASS(S77<STT 77<7
8 3(,Q&',-(( * ,+*
*(*.N I ((
&+&&:/7%U9A8>G8>
;D7 <
< (.30#,(Q,-6&+&"&((&,*
&"*"(&* A*,":B&&67>U41A<G
> W'T!#3( " &(**&*",&
&&,+, &*A N&,"
05,2 =44A=%7
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS:
!Q,5,+&."+,11#',(
Q+&.(*&(+&,,"
+*+,&,
3,(A3+,(a,,".1*&+& *(
1.*1"W,0&
,&1,A&&(,"!#
&1,.(&+ "N,"
*L!# ,&*
COMPETING INTERESTS:
[*)=;>%%7$78<878=;%#<=<<=
=7;<8=W!7=;<>77)7;%7<***&-S)7=S7%>;
(W,0&&&&* N*&"((,&&,(
"('&& *+ M,"W,0&0!0$
;D7 >
**&&((" F/7787%H&
3,&&+&0&&.1& *"$+
(,&"& &:&*&,1&,
*&P&+
/!0
7777777=88>7<7=
7777777;;8887
7777777=8<7=7<
!"#$7777777;=%%7<
;D7 ;
