PreprintPDF Available

Quantum Computing for Sustainable Energy: Optimizing Wind Farm Layout for Improved Energy Efficiency

Authors:
Preprints and early-stage research may not have been peer reviewed yet.

Abstract

Wind energy has become an increasingly important source of renewable energy in recent years, with wind farms being constructed in various locations around the world. The layout of these wind farms, which consists of the arrangement and spacing of individual wind turbines, plays a critical role in their overall performance and efficiency. In particular, the optimal layout of a wind farm can significantly increase the amount of energy generated, as well as reduce costs associated with construction and maintenance. One approach to optimizing the layout of a wind farm is through the use of quantum computing. Quantum computers have the potential to solve complex optimization problems much faster than classical computers, making them a promising tool for optimizing the layout of wind farms. In this paper, the authors discuss the use of quantum computing for wind farm layout optimization and its potential benefits.
1
Quantum Computing for Sustainable Energy:
Optimizing Wind Farm Layout for Improved
Energy Efficiency
Jitesh Lalwani1,2and Babita Jajodia3
1Artificial Brain Tech Inc, 2055 Limestone RD, STE 200-C, Wilmington, Delaware, USA 19808
2Artificial Brain Technology (OPC) Private Limited, Pune, India 411057
3Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering,
Indian Institute of Information Technology Guwahati, India
Email: {jitesh.lalwani@artificialbrain.us, babita@iiitg.ac.in}
Abstract—Wind energy has become an increasingly important
source of renewable energy in recent years, with wind farms being
constructed in various locations around the world. The layout of
these wind farms, which consists of the arrangement and spacing
of individual wind turbines, plays a critical role in their overall
performance and efficiency. In particular, the optimal layout of
a wind farm can significantly increase the amount of energy
generated, as well as reduce costs associated with construction
and maintenance. One approach to optimizing the layout of a
wind farm is through the use of quantum computing. Quantum
computers have the potential to solve complex optimization
problems much faster than classical computers, making them
a promising tool for optimizing the layout of wind farms. In this
paper, the authors discuss the use of quantum computing for
wind farm layout optimization and its potential benefits.
Index Terms—Optimization, QAOA (Quantum Approximate
Optimization Algorithm), Quantum Annealing, Quadratic Un-
constrained Binary Optimization (QUBO), Quantum Computa-
tion
I. INTRODUCTION
Wind energy has become an increasingly important source
of renewable energy in recent years [1], with wind farms being
constructed in various locations around the world. The layout
of these wind farms, which consists of the arrangement and
spacing of individual wind turbines, plays a critical role in their
overall performance and efficiency. In particular, the optimal
layout of a wind farm can significantly increase the amount
of energy generated, as well as reduce costs associated with
construction and maintenance.
The optimization of a wind farm layout [2] can be repre-
sented mathematically as an optimization problem, where the
objective is to maximize the power output of the wind farm.
This can be expressed as follows:
Maximize P =XPi(1)
where Pis the total power output of the wind farm, and Pi
is the power output of the ith wind turbine.
There are various factors that can affect the power output
of a wind turbine, including the wind speed, the direction
of the wind, and the physical characteristics of the turbine
itself. These factors can be represented by variables in the
optimization problem, such as wind speed (v), wind direction
(θ), and turbine characteristics (c).
One approach to optimizing the layout of a wind farm is
through the use of quantum computing. Quantum computers
have the potential to solve complex optimization problems
much faster than classical computers, making them a promis-
ing tool for optimizing the layout of wind farms. In this paper,
the authors discuss the use of quantum computing for wind
farm layout optimization and its potential benefits.
II. ANOV ERVIEW OF QUA NT UM COMPUTING
Quantum computers are based on the principles of quantum
mechanics, which is the fundamental theory of matter and
energy at the atomic and subatomic scale. Quantum computers
use quantum bits (qubits) instead of classical bits to store and
process information. Qubits have the unique ability to exist in
multiple states simultaneously, which allows them to perform
certain operations much faster than classical computers.
One of the key principles of quantum mechanics is super-
position [3], which refers to the ability of a quantum system
to exist in multiple states at the same time. For example, a
qubit can represent both a ‘0’ and a ‘1’ simultaneously. This
allows quantum computers to perform many calculations in
parallel, which can significantly reduce the time required to
solve problems.
Another important principle of quantum computers is entan-
glement [4], which refers to the ability of two or more qubits
to become correlated in a way that cannot be explained by
classical physics. This allows quantum computers to perform
certain operations much faster than classical computers.
III. OPTIMIZATION USING QUAN TU M COMPUTING
Quantum computers have the potential to solve complex
optimization problems much faster than classical computers.
This is due to their ability to perform parallel computations
[5] and explore a larger search space simultaneously. In the
context of wind farm layout optimization, quantum computers
can be used to explore the various possible configurations of
wind turbines in a wind farm and determine the optimal layout
that maximizes the power output.
2
One approach to using quantum computers for wind farm
layout optimization is through the use of quantum annealing.
Quantum annealing is an optimization technique that uses
quantum fluctuations to search for the global minimum or
maximum of a given objective function. In the context of wind
farm layout optimization, the objective function could be the
power output of the wind farm, as described above.
Quantum annealing can be performed using a special type
of quantum computer known as a quantum annealer. These
devices consist of a number of qubits, which are the quantum
equivalent of classical bits. The qubits are used to represent
the variables in the optimization problem, such as wind speed,
wind direction, and turbine characteristics. The quantum an-
nealer then uses quantum fluctuations to search for the optimal
configuration of these variables that maximizes the objective
function.
IV. BEN EFI TS O F QUANTUM COMPUTING FOR WIND
FARM LAYOUT OPTIMIZATION
There are several potential benefits to using quantum com-
puting for wind farm layout optimization. One of the main
benefits is the speed at which quantum computers can solve
complex optimization problems. Classical computers can take
a significant amount of time to find the optimal solution to an
optimization problem, especially for problems with a large
number of variables and constraints. In contrast, quantum
computers can potentially solve these problems much faster,
thanks to their ability to perform parallel computations and
explore a larger search space simultaneously.
Another benefit of using quantum computing for wind farm
layout optimization is the potential to find more accurate and
reliable solutions. Classical optimization algorithms may get
stuck in local minima or maxima, meaning that they can only
find sub-optimal solutions. Quantum algorithms, on the other
hand, have the potential to escape these local minima and find
the global minimum or maximum of the objective function.
This can lead to more accurate and reliable solutions, which
can translate into significant improvements in the performance
and efficiency of wind farms.
In addition, quantum computing can help to optimize wind
farm layouts in real-time, enabling on-demand optimization
of the layout based on changing conditions. This can be
particularly useful in dynamic environments, such as offshore
wind farms, where conditions can change rapidly. By using
quantum computers to optimize the layout in real-time, it may
be possible to further increase the overall power output of the
wind farm.
V. BUSINESS BE NE FIT S BY U SI NG QUA NT UM COMPUTING
FO R WIND FARM OPTIMIZATION
Here are some potential examples of how the use of
quantum computing for wind farm layout optimization might
provide specific business benefits, with some rough estimates
of the potential impact:
1) Improved efficiency: By optimizing wind farm layout
with quantum computing, businesses could potentially
increase power output by 5-10% while reducing the
number of turbines needed by up to 25%. This could
lead to cost savings of $500,000-$1,000,000 per year for
a typical wind farm.
2) Increased competitiveness: By using quantum computing
to optimize wind farm layout, businesses could poten-
tially reduce the Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE) by 5-
10% compared to competitors using traditional optimiza-
tion methods. This could make them more competitive
in the energy market and potentially increase revenue by
$1,000,000-$2,000,000 per year.
3) Enhanced sustainability: Quantum computing can help to
optimize wind farm layout in a way that minimizes land
use and the number of turbines needed, potentially reduc-
ing the environmental impact of wind energy production
by up to 50%. This could enhance the sustainability
profile of the business and improve its reputation with
customers and stakeholders.
4) New revenue streams: By optimizing wind farm layout to
take advantage of specific weather patterns or other fac-
tors that affect power output, businesses could potentially
increase revenue by up to $500,000 per year by selling
electricity to the grid at times of peak demand.
It is important to note that these estimates are rough and will
vary depending on the specific circumstances of the wind farm
in question. Factors such as the size of the wind farm, the
wind resource, and the cost of turbines and other infrastructure
will all impact the potential business benefits of quantum
computing for wind farm layout optimization.
VI. CONSTRAINTS AND CO ST FUNCTION FOR WIND FARM
OPTIMIZATION
A. Constraints
Constraints are conditions or limits that must be satisfied
by the solution to an optimization problem. In the context
of optimization problems, constraints are used to restrict the
possible solutions to a particular problem in order to make
it more tractable or to ensure that the solution meets certain
requirements.
There are several constraints that can be considered when
using quantum computers for wind farm layout optimization.
These constraints may vary depending on the specific require-
ments of the optimization problem and the capabilities of the
quantum computer being used. Some possible constraints to
consider include:
1) Turbine layout constraints: You may want to ensure that
the wind turbines are spaced apart and positioned in a way
that minimizes interference between them. This could
be represented as a constraint on the minimum distance
between turbines and the layout of the turbines within the
wind farm.
2) Power output constraints: You may want to ensure that the
power output of the wind farm meets certain criteria, such
as being able to meet a certain percentage of the energy
demand of a particular region. This could be represented
as a constraint on the total power output of the wind farm.
3) Land use constraints: Depending on the location of the
wind farm, you may need to consider land use constraints,
3
such as the availability of land and any environmental or
conservation concerns.
4) Infrastructure constraints: You may need to consider the
availability and cost of infrastructure, such as roads and
transmission lines, in determining the optimal layout of
the wind farm.
5) Financial constraints: You may want to consider the cost
of construction and maintenance of the wind farm in
determining the optimal layout. This could be represented
as a constraint on the total cost of the wind farm.
6) Wind conditions: The layout of the wind farm should take
into account the wind conditions at the site, including the
direction and strength of the wind.
7) Distance to the power grid: The layout of the wind farm
should consider the distance to the nearest power grid
connection, as this can impact the cost and feasibility of
transmitting the power generated by the wind farm.
8) Environmental impact: The layout of the wind farm
should take into account any potential environmental
impacts, such as impacts on wildlife or the surrounding
landscape.
9) Legal constraints: The layout of the wind farm should
take into account any legal constraints, such as zoning
regulations or permits that may be required for the
project.
Again, it’s important to carefully consider the specific re-
quirements and goals of your wind farm project in order to
determine the most appropriate constraints to include in your
cost function.
By considering these constraints and incorporating them
into the optimization problem, it is possible to find a layout
that meets the specific requirements and constraints of the
wind farm while also maximizing the power output.
B. Cost Function
A cost function is a mathematical formulation that describes
the costs associated with different choices or actions being
taken in a particular problem. The goal of a cost function is
to minimize or maximize the overall cost by making optimal
choices or decisions [6] [7].
Here is a cost function based on the above constraints:
Cost =w1×T ur bine Layout C onstraints
+w2×P ower Output C onstraints
+w3×Land Use Constraints
+w4×Infrastructure C onstraints
+w5×F inancial C onstraints
+w6×W ind C onditions
+w7×Distance to P ower Grid
+w8×Environmental Impact
+w9×Legal Constraints
(2)
where w1, w2, ..., w9 are the weights associated with each
constraint, and Turbine Layout Cost, Power Output Cost, ...,
Legal Constraints Cost are the costs associated with each
constraint. These costs can be calculated based on the specific
requirements and constraints of the wind farm.
This is just one example of how you might structure a cost
function for wind farm layout optimization. It’s important to
carefully consider the specific requirements and goals of your
wind farm project (for example wake effect [8], different hub-
height wind turbines [9], etc) in order to determine the most
appropriate form and parameters for the cost function.
VII. QUAN TU M OPTIMIZATION ALGORITHMS
A. Quantum Annealing
Quantum annealing [10] is a quantum optimization algo-
rithm that can be used to find the minimum value of a cost
function. It works by encoding the cost function into the
ground state of a quantum system, which is then used to find
the minimum value of the function by adiabatically evolving
the system over time.
In the context of wind farm layout optimization, quantum
annealing could be used to find the optimal layout of turbines
that maximizes power output and other performance metrics,
while minimizing costs and other constraints. To use quantum
annealing for this purpose, the relevant constraints and objec-
tives would need to be encoded into the cost function. This
might include terms that represent the power output of the
wind farm, the cost of installing and maintaining the turbines,
and any environmental or other constraints that need to be
considered. By minimizing this cost function, the quantum
annealing algorithm could find the layout that maximizes
power output and minimizes costs, subject to the various
constraints and limitations of the particular wind farm.
Here is an example of how quantum annealing might be
used to optimize the layout of a wind farm:
Suppose that we want to design a wind farm that consists
of 10 turbines, and we want to find the layout that maximizes
power output while minimizing costs and satisfying various
other constraints. To use quantum annealing to solve this
optimization problem, we would need to encode the relevant
constraints and objectives into the cost function.
For example, the cost function might include terms that
represent the power output of the wind farm (which we want to
maximize), the cost of installing and maintaining the turbines
(which we want to minimize), and any environmental or other
constraints that need to be considered (such as the minimum
distance between turbines). We could then use quantum an-
nealing to minimize this cost function and find the layout that
maximizes power output and minimizes costs, subject to the
various constraints and limitations of the particular wind farm.
To solve this optimization problem using quantum anneal-
ing, we would need to encode the cost function into the
ground state of a quantum system, and then use a quantum
annealer to adiabatically evolve the system over time to find
the minimum value of the function. This process would involve
setting up the quantum annealer with the appropriate qubits
and couplers, and running the quantum annealing algorithm
to find the optimal layout.
Here is a step-by-step algorithm for using the D-Wave
quantum annealer to optimize wind farm layout:
4
Step 1: Define the optimization problem to be solved,
including the number of decision variables, constraints, and
the objective function to be minimized or maximized.
Step 2: Choose a quantum optimization algorithm, such as
the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA)
or Quantum Adiabatic Evolution (QAE), to solve the opti-
mization problem.
Step 3: Define the quantum circuit that will be used to
implement the chosen algorithm. This may include defining
the quantum and classical registers, as well as the number of
qubits and gates needed.
Step 4: Initialize the quantum circuit and set the initial state
of the qubits. This may involve defining a custom initial state
or using a predefined state such as the uniform superposition
state.
Step 5: Define the cost function that will be used to evaluate
the performance of the quantum circuit. This may involve
defining the energy levels of the qubits or the weights of the
couplers in the quantum circuit.
Step 6: Set the number of layers or iterations that the
quantum circuit will be run for. This is typically referred to
as the “p” parameter in QAOA.
Step 7: Run the quantum circuit and measure the output to
obtain the optimal solution to the optimization problem.
Step 8: Analyze the results and fine-tune the quantum circuit
as needed to improve the performance of the algorithm. This
may involve adjusting the number of layers, the initial state
of the qubits, or the cost function.
Step 9: Repeat the optimization process until the desired
level of accuracy is achieved.
It is important to note that this is just a simple exam-
ple, and the actual process of using quantum annealing to
optimize a wind farm layout would be more complex and
would depend on the specific details and constraints of the
problem (for example, optimization for wake effect uniformity
[11]. Additionally, the performance and accuracy of quantum
annealing algorithms can vary depending on the complexity
and size of the optimization problem, and further research
and development is needed to understand the capabilities and
limitations of quantum annealing in real-world scenarios.
B. Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA)
Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA)
[12] is a quantum algorithm that can be used to find ap-
proximate solutions to optimization problems. In the context
of wind farm layout optimization, the QAOA would involve
defining a cost function that takes into account the various
constraints that you listed, and then using the QAOA to find
a layout for the wind farm that approximately minimizes this
cost function.
To use the QAOA to find an approximate solution to this
optimization problem, you would need to define the cost
function in terms of a set of quantum operations, and then
use the QAOA to find the optimal values of the parameters
that minimize the cost function. This involves specifying the
number of layers in the QAOA, as well as the type of quantum
operations to be used at each layer. It’s important to carefully
consider the specific requirements and goals of your wind farm
project in order to determine the most appropriate parameters
and settings for the QAOA.
Here is a step-by-step guide for using QAOA to optimize
the layout of a wind farm:
Step 1: Define the quantum and classical registers: The
quantum register will hold the qubits that represent the vari-
ables in the optimization problem, and the classical register
will hold the measurement results of these qubits.
Step 2: Create the QAOA circuit: This circuit will consist
of a series of parametrized gates, which will be applied to the
quantum register in a specific order to encode the optimization
problem.
Step 3: Set the initial state of the qubits: This can be done
using a variety of techniques, such as starting all qubits in the
|0state or using a custom initial state.
Step 4: Set the cost function: This function defines the
objective of the optimization problem, and will be encoded
into the QAOA circuit as a Hamiltonian operator.
Step 5: Set the number of layers (p) in the QAOA circuit:
The number of layers determines the depth of the circuit
and can have a significant impact on the performance of the
algorithm.
Step 6: Run the QAOA algorithm: This will involve ap-
plying the parameterized gates in the circuit to the quantum
register and measuring the resulting state.
Step 7: Retrieve the optimal parameters and resulting cost:
These can be obtained from the result of the QAOA algorithm.
Step 8: Obtain the optimal solution: This can be done by
post-processing the measurement results obtained in step 6 to
find the configuration of the variables that minimize the cost
function.
VIII. CONCLUSION
In summary, quantum computing has the potential to sig-
nificantly improve the optimization of wind farm layouts. By
using quantum algorithms such as quantum annealing, it is
possible to find more accurate and reliable solutions to the
optimization problem, leading to increased power output and
efficiency. Additionally, the ability of quantum computers to
perform parallel computations and explore a larger search
space simultaneously can help to solve these optimization
problems much faster than classical computers. While there
are still challenges to be addressed in the development and
deployment of quantum computers for wind farm layout
optimization, this technology has the potential to revolutionize
the way we design and operate wind farms.
REFERENCES
[1] A. D. S¸ahin, “Progress and recent trends in wind energy,” Progress in
energy and combustion science, vol. 30, no. 5, pp. 501–543, 2004.
[2] M. Samorani, “The wind farm layout optimization problem,” in Hand-
book of wind power systems. Springer, 2013, pp. 21–38.
[3] D. Bouwmeester and A. Zeilinger, “The physics of quantum information:
basic concepts,” in The physics of quantum information. Springer, 2000,
pp. 1–14.
[4] R. Horodecki, P. Horodecki, M. Horodecki, and K. Horodecki, “Quan-
tum entanglement,” Reviews of modern physics, vol. 81, no. 2, p. 865,
2009.
5
[5] D. C. Marinescu, “The promise of quantum computing and quantum
information theory-quantum parallelism,” in 19th IEEE International
Parallel and Distributed Processing Symposium. IEEE, 2005, pp. 3–pp.
[6] J. Choi, S. Oh, S. Park, J.-K. Kim, and J. Kim, “Proper Cost Hamiltonian
Design for Combinatorial Optimization Problems: A Boolean Function
Approach,” in 2021 International Conference on Information Network-
ing (ICOIN), 2021, pp. 469–472.
[7] S. P. Premaratne and A. Matsuura, “Engineering the Cost Function of
a Variational Quantum Algorithm for Implementation on Near-Term
Devices, arXiv preprint arXiv:2006.03747, 2020.
[8] R. Shakoor, M. Y. Hassan, A. Raheem, and Y.-K. Wu, “Wake effect
modeling: A review of wind farm layout optimization using Jensen’s
model,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 58, pp. 1048–
1059, 2016.
[9] Y. Chen, H. Li, K. Jin, and Q. Song, “Wind farm layout optimization
using genetic algorithm with different hub height wind turbines, Energy
Conversion and Management, vol. 70, pp. 56–65, 2013.
[10] G. Rose and W. Macready, “An introduction to quantum annealing,”
D-Wave Systems, 2007.
[11] K. Yang, G. Kwak, K. Cho, and J. Huh, “Wind farm layout optimization
for wake effect uniformity, Energy, vol. 183, pp. 983–995, 2019.
[12] E. Farhi, J. Goldstone, and S. Gutmann, “A quantum approximate
optimization algorithm,” arXiv preprint arXiv:1411.4028, 2014.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
An important phase of a wind farm design is solving the Wind Farm Layout Optimization Problem (WFLOP), which consists in optimally positioning the turbines within the wind farm so that the wake effects are minimized and therefore the expected power production maximized. Although this problem has been receiving increasing attention from the scientific community, the existing approaches do not completely respond to the needs of a wind farm developer, mainly because they do not address construction and logistical issues. This paper describes the WFLOP, gives an overview on the existing work, and discusses the challenges that may be overcome by future research.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Heat dissipation, leakage, and other physical phenomena limit our ability to build increasingly faster solid state devices, while quantum computation holds out the promise to solve efficiently most difficult problems in computational sciences such as simulation of quantum systems, integer factorization, database searching and the computation of discrete logarithms.
Article
The basic objective of wind farm layout optimization is to maximize the energy produced by wind farms. However, when wind turbines are arranged in a limited space like an onshore wind farm, specific wind turbines may have greater wake exposure than other wind turbines. This phenomenon can be conspicuous in a mixed layout that consists of turbines with different capacities and hub heights. In this study, we developed and tested a new objective function to increase wind farm energy output while making the wake loss of each wind turbine uniform. The purpose of this function is to adjust the wake effects of all of the wind turbines on a wind farm to similar levels, thereby promoting the operational stability of all of the wind turbines. Layout optimization was performed using a simulated annealing algorithm, which is a heuristic method, with actual wind conditions for an existing wind farm in operation. Then, the results obtained using the proposed method were compared with those yielded by layout optimization for energy maximization. The layout generated using the proposed objective function had lower energy output than that obtained by energy maximization. However, this difference was small and the proposed method prevented wake effect concentration on specific turbines by making the wake effect levels uniform.
Conference Paper
The superposition principle plays the most central role in all considerations of quantum information, and in most of the “gedanken” experiments and even the paradoxes of quantum mechanics. Instead of studying it theoretically or defining it abstractly, we will discuss here the quintessential experiment on quantum superposition, the double-slit experiment (Fig. 1.1). According to Feynman [1], the double-slit “has in it the heart of quantum mechanics”. The essential ingredients of the experiment are a source, a double-slit assembly, and an observation screen on which we observe interference fringes. These interference fringes may easily be understood on the basis of assuming a wave property of the particles emerging from the source. It might be mentioned here that the double-slit experiment has been performed with many different kinds of particles ranging from photons [2], via electrons [3], to neutrons [4] and atoms [5].
Article
Layout optimization is one of the methods to increase wind farm’s utilization rate and power output. Previous researches have revealed that different hub height wind turbines may increase wind farm’s power output. However, few researches focus on optimizing a wind farm’s layout in a two-dimensional area using different hub height wind turbines. In this paper, the authors first investigate the effect of using different hub height wind turbines in a small wind farm on power output. Three different wind conditions are analyzed using nested genetic algorithm, where the results show that power output of the wind farm using different hub height wind turbines will be increased even when the total numbers of wind turbines are same. Different cost models are also taken into account in the analysis, and results show that different hub height wind turbines can also improve cost per unit power of a wind farm. At last, a large wind farm with commercial wind turbines is analyzed to further examine the benefits of using different hub height wind turbines in more realistic conditions.
Article
All our former experience with application of quantum theory seems to say: {\it what is predicted by quantum formalism must occur in laboratory}. But the essence of quantum formalism - entanglement, recognized by Einstein, Podolsky, Rosen and Schr\"odinger - waited over 70 years to enter to laboratories as a new resource as real as energy. This holistic property of compound quantum systems, which involves nonclassical correlations between subsystems, is a potential for many quantum processes, including ``canonical'' ones: quantum cryptography, quantum teleportation and dense coding. However, it appeared that this new resource is very complex and difficult to detect. Being usually fragile to environment, it is robust against conceptual and mathematical tools, the task of which is to decipher its rich structure. This article reviews basic aspects of entanglement including its characterization, detection, distillation and quantifying. In particular, the authors discuss various manifestations of entanglement via Bell inequalities, entropic inequalities, entanglement witnesses, quantum cryptography and point out some interrelations. They also discuss a basic role of entanglement in quantum communication within distant labs paradigm and stress some peculiarities such as irreversibility of entanglement manipulations including its extremal form - bound entanglement phenomenon. A basic role of entanglement witnesses in detection of entanglement is emphasized.
Progress and recent trends in wind energy
A. D. Ş ahin, "Progress and recent trends in wind energy," Progress in energy and combustion science, vol. 30, no. 5, pp. 501-543, 2004.