Content uploaded by Jitesh Lalwani

Author content

All content in this area was uploaded by Jitesh Lalwani on Jan 01, 2023

Content may be subject to copyright.

1

Quantum Computing for Mars Exploration:

Opportunities and Challenges

Jitesh Lalwani1,2and Babita Jajodia3

1Artiﬁcial Brain Tech Inc, 2055 Limestone RD, STE 200-C, Wilmington, Delaware, USA 19808

2Artiﬁcial Brain Technology (OPC) Private Limited, Pune, India 411057

3Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering,

Indian Institute of Information Technology Guwahati, India

Email: {jitesh.lalwani@artiﬁcialbrain.us, babita@iiitg.ac.in}

Abstract—Quantum computing has garnered signiﬁcant atten-

tion in recent years for its potential to revolutionize a wide

range of ﬁelds, including space exploration. In this paper, the

authors investigate the potential for quantum computing to

revolutionize future Mars missions. Quantum computing offers

a number of advantages over classical computing, particularly

in the areas of optimization and simulation, which could be

leveraged to improve mission planning and resource allocation,

model and predict the Martian environment, and develop new

materials and manufacturing techniques. The authors provide

a detailed analysis of these and other opportunities presented

by quantum computing in the context of Mars exploration and

colonization, highlighting the potential for this technology to

signiﬁcantly enhance the success of future missions. However,

the authors also recognize that quantum computing presents

several challenges for space exploration and discuss some of

these challenges in the paper. Ultimately, the authors believe that

quantum computing has the potential to signiﬁcantly enhance

the success of future Mars missions, but it will require careful

planning and consideration to overcome its unique challenges.

Index Terms—Optimization, Quantum Annealing, Quadratic

Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO), Quantum Compu-

tation

I. INTRODUCTION

The ﬁeld of space exploration has made signiﬁcant strides

in recent years, with numerous successful missions to both the

Moon and Mars. As humanity looks to expand our presence

beyond Earth and explore the cosmos, it is evident that we

will need to develop advanced technologies to overcome the

various challenges that lie ahead. From optimizing interplan-

etary missions and establishing self-sustaining ecosystems, to

protecting against the harsh conditions of other celestial bodies

and establishing communication and navigation systems, the

development of new technologies will be crucial to our success

in space exploration and colonization. One technology that

has garnered signiﬁcant attention in recent years is quantum

computing, which has the potential to revolutionize a wide

range of ﬁelds, including space exploration.

In this paper, the authors investigate the potential for

quantum computing to revolutionize future Mars missions.

Quantum computing offers a number of advantages over

classical computing, particularly in the areas of optimization

and simulation, which could be leveraged to improve mission

planning and resource allocation [1], model and predict the

Fig. 1. Colonization of Mars

Martian environment, and develop new materials and manu-

facturing techniques. The authors provide a detailed analysis of

these and other opportunities presented by quantum computing

in the context of Mars exploration and colonization.

However, the authors also recognize that quantum com-

puting presents several challenges for space exploration and

discuss some of these challenges in the paper. [2].

Overall, the authors believe that quantum computing has the

potential to signiﬁcantly enhance the success of future Mars

missions, but that it will also require careful planning and

consideration to overcome the unique challenges it presents.

II. ANOV ERVIEW ON QUA NT UM COMPUTING

Quantum computing is a rapidly growing ﬁeld that utilizes

the principles of quantum mechanics to perform calculations

at a much faster rate than classical computers. Quantum

computers rely on quantum bits, or qubits, which can exist

in multiple states simultaneously, allowing them to perform

multiple calculations at once. This property, known as quantum

parallelism, allows quantum computers to perform certain

types of calculations much more efﬁciently than classical

computers.

One key area where quantum computers have the potential

to excel is in optimization problems, such as ﬁnding the

shortest path between two points or the minimum energy

2

conﬁguration of a system. Quantum computers can also be

used for simulation, allowing for the accurate modeling of

complex systems, such as materials or chemical reactions.

One notable example of the potential of quantum comput-

ing for optimization is the work of Farhi et al. [3], who

demonstrated the use of a quantum computer to solve the

“traveling salesman” problem, which involves ﬁnding the

shortest possible route between a set of cities. They showed

that a quantum computer was able to solve this problem

signiﬁcantly faster than a classical computer, even when the

number of cities was large. This has the potential to greatly

improve the efﬁciency of space missions, where minimizing

fuel consumption and other resources is critical.

III. QUAN TU M APP LI CATI ON S FO R MAR S EXP LO RATI ON

There are a number of ways in which quantum computing

could be used to enhance future Mars missions.

A. Optimizing Mars Exploration

Quantum computers have the ability to perform certain

types of optimization problems much more efﬁciently than

classical computers, making them well-suited for tasks such

as optimizing the use of resources. In the context of a Mars

mission, quantum computers could be used to optimize the

use of resources in a number of ways, including:

1) Trajectory Optimization: One potential application is in

the area of navigation, where quantum computers could be

used to optimize the trajectory [4] of a spacecraft, taking

into account factors such as fuel consumption and radiation

exposure.

Here are some potential constraints that could be used

to optimize the trajectory of a spacecraft using a quantum

computer:

•Fuel consumption: To minimize fuel consumption, one

could set a constraint on the total amount of fuel that

the spacecraft is allowed to use over the course of its

mission. This could be expressed as a maximum value

for the sum of the fuel consumption rates at each point

in the trajectory.

•Radiation exposure: To minimize radiation exposure, one

could set a constraint on the total amount of radiation that

the spacecraft is allowed to be exposed to over the course

of its mission. This could be expressed as a maximum

value for the sum of the radiation levels at each point in

the trajectory.

•Time: To minimize the total time required for the mission,

one could set a constraint on the length of the trajectory.

This could be expressed as a maximum value for the total

time taken to complete the mission.

•Distance: To minimize the total distance traveled by

spacecraft, one could set a constraint on the length of

the trajectory. This could be expressed as a maximum

value for the total distance traveled.

•Velocity: To minimize the maximum velocity reached by

spacecraft, one could set a constraint on the maximum

velocity that is allowed at any point in the trajectory.

•Acceleration: To minimize the maximum acceleration

experienced by the spacecraft, one could set a constraint

on the maximum acceleration that is allowed at any point

in the trajectory.

•Jerk: To minimize the maximum jerk experienced by the

spacecraft, one could set a constraint on the maximum

jerk that is allowed at any point in the trajectory. Jerk is

the rate of change of acceleration.

•Cost: To minimize the cost of the mission, one could set

a constraint on the total cost of the mission, which could

include factors such as fuel costs, maintenance costs, and

other expenses.

These are just a few examples of the types of constraints that

could be used to optimize the trajectory of a spacecraft using a

quantum computer. The speciﬁc constraints used will depend

on the speciﬁc goals and requirements of the mission.

a) Cost Function for Trajectory Optimization: Here is a

mathematical cost function that could be used to optimize the

trajectory of a spacecraft using a quantum computer, based on

the constraints listed in the above subsection.

Cost =w1×f uel consumption

+w2×radiation exposure +w3×time

+w4×distance +w5×velocity

+w6×acceleration +w7×jerk +w8×cost

(1)

In this cost function, the variables fuel consumption, radia-

tion exposure, time, distance, velocity, acceleration, jerk, and

cost represent the values of these quantities at each point in the

trajectory. The variables w1, w2, w3, w4, w5, w6, w7, andw8

are weighting factors that can be used to adjust the relative

importance of each of these quantities in the overall cost.

For example, if minimizing fuel consumption is the top

priority, then w1could be set to a high value, while the other

weighting factors could be set to lower values. On the other

hand, if minimizing radiation exposure is the top priority, then

w2could be set to a high value, while the other weighting

factors could be set to lower values.

By setting the weighting factors appropriately, the cost

function can be tailored to prioritize the speciﬁc goals and

requirements of the mission. A quantum computer can then be

used to ﬁnd the trajectory that minimizes this cost function,

subject to any additional constraints that may be necessary.

In general, when using a quantum computer to solve an

optimization problem, the goal is typically to either minimize

or maximize a particular objective function.

b) Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization

(QUBO) for Trajectory Optimization: A QUBO is a

mathematical optimization problem that seeks to ﬁnd the

values of a set of binary variables that minimize or maximize

a quadratic objective function. The objective function is

expressed as a sum of terms, each of which is a product of

two binary variables or a constant.

In general, a QUBO is written in the following format:

Minimize Cost =

n

X

i=1

wixi(2)

3

In this equation, “Cost” is the quantity that is being mini-

mized. It is a linear combination of variables, denoted by

x1, x2, . . . , xn. Each variable is multiplied by a corresponding

weight, denoted by w1, w2, . . . , wn.

The goal of this optimization problem is to ﬁnd the values

of the variables x1, x2, . . . , xn. that minimize the cost. This

is known as a quadratic unconstrained binary optimization

(QUBO) problem.

The variables x1, x2, . . . , xnare binary, which means that

they can take on only two values: 0 or 1. This makes the

problem particularly well-suited for solution by a quantum

computer, which can represent and manipulate binary values

using quantum bits (qubits).

The weights w1, w2, . . . , wnare constants that determine

the relative importance of each variable in the optimization.

For example, if w1is much larger than w2, then the value of

x1will have a much greater impact on the cost than the value

of x2.

In general, QUBO problems can be used to model a wide

variety of optimization problems, including those related to

resource allocation, scheduling, and routing. They have been

applied to a variety of ﬁelds, including ﬁnance, logistics, and

manufacturing.

2) Optimizing Resource Management on the Spacecraft:

Quantum computers could be used to ﬁnd the most efﬁcient

ways to use energy, water, and other resources on the space-

craft to ensure that they are used as efﬁciently as possible.

This could involve ﬁnding the most efﬁcient ways to use these

resources, such as minimizing waste and maximizing their

lifetime.

3) Optimizing Resource Management on the Surface of

Mars: Quantum computers could be used to ﬁnd the most

efﬁcient ways to use energy, water, and other resources to

support human settlements or scientiﬁc missions on the planet.

This could involve optimizing the use of renewable energy

sources, ﬁnding new sources of water, or identifying the most

efﬁcient ways to use resources to support human life and

scientiﬁc research.

4) Optimizing Mission Planning and Execution: Quantum

computers could be used to optimize mission planning and

execution by ﬁnding the most efﬁcient paths for spacecraft

to take, minimizing the amount of fuel and other resources

needed to complete the journey. They could also be used to

optimize the scheduling of scientiﬁc experiments and other

activities on the planet to maximize their scientiﬁc return.

B. Enabling Sustainable Living on Mars

Making life sustainable on Mars is a key goal of space

agencies and researchers around the world. In order to achieve

this goal, it is essential to ﬁnd ways to sustainably support

human life on the planet, including by providing the necessary

energy and resources. Quantum computing has the potential

to play a signiﬁcant role in making Mars missions more

sustainable by helping researchers ﬁnd new materials [5] for

energy storage and other applications.

1) Simulating Complex Systems for Mars Exploration::

Quantum computers also have the potential to be used for

simulation, allowing for the accurate modeling of complex

systems. For example, quantum computers could be used to

model the behavior of materials or chemical reactions on Mars,

helping to understand the geology of the planet and identify

potential resources. Quantum computers could also be used to

simulate the behavior of spacecraft systems, allowing for more

accurate predictions of how they will perform under different

conditions.

Furthermore, quantum computers could be used to simulate

the effects of various environmental factors on Mars, such as

radiation, temperature, and atmospheric conditions. This could

be particularly useful for predicting the long-term effects of

these factors on manned missions to Mars, helping to ensure

the safety and success of the mission.

Overall, the ability of quantum computers to perform sim-

ulations and optimization tasks at a much faster rate than

classical computers makes them a valuable tool for space

exploration, particularly in the context of Mars missions. By

leveraging the unique capabilities of quantum computers, it

may be possible to overcome many of the challenges faced

during space exploration and enhance the success of future

missions.

Here are a few examples of quantum simulation algorithms:

•Quantum Monte-Carlo Algorithms: These algorithms use

statistical techniques to simulate the behavior of a quan-

tum system [6]. They could potentially be used to model

the behavior of a chemical reaction on Mars by generating

a large number of random samples from the reaction and

using these samples to estimate the probability of dif-

ferent outcomes. The probability of a particular outcome

can be calculated using the formula

P=Ns

Nt

(3)

where P is the probability of the outcome, Nsis the

number of samples that result in the outcome, and Nt

is the total number of samples.

•Quantum Circuit Algorithms: These algorithms simulate

the behavior of a quantum system using quantum circuits,

which are circuits made up of quantum gates that can ma-

nipulate quantum states [7]. Quantum circuit algorithms

could potentially be used to model the behavior of a

chemical reaction on Mars by representing the atoms and

molecules involved in the reaction as quantum states and

using quantum gates to simulate the interactions between

these states.

For example, the Hadamard gate, which is a quantum

gate that ﬂips the sign of the wave function of a quantum

state, can be represented using the following matrix:

H=1

√21 1

1−1(4)

•Quantum Annealing Algorithms: These algorithms are

based on the idea of quantum annealing, which is a

technique for ﬁnding the global minimum of a function

by starting from a high-temperature state and gradually

cooling down to a low-temperature state [8]. Quantum

annealing algorithms could potentially be used to model

4

the behavior of a chemical reaction on Mars by repre-

senting the atoms and molecules involved in the reaction

as quantum states and using the quantum annealing

algorithm to ﬁnd the values of these states that minimize

the total energy of the system. The total energy of the

system could be represented using a cost function that

takes into account the speciﬁc goals and constraints of the

simulation, such as the energy required for the reaction

to occur or the desired products of the reaction. The

behavior of the system during the annealing process can

be described mathematically using the following formula:

H(s) = (1 −s)H0+sH1(5)

where H(s)is the Hamiltonian of the system at a

particular point in the annealing process, sis the an-

nealing parameter, which ranges from 0 to 1, H0is the

initial Hamiltonian of the system, and H1is the ﬁnal

Hamiltonian of the system. The Hamiltonian represents

the total energy of the system and determines the behavior

of the system during the annealing process.

2) Developing Novel Materials for Mars Batteries and

Fuel:: In addition to simulations, quantum computers can also

be used to optimize the design of new materials [9]. This is

done using quantum algorithms, which are designed to search

for materials with speciﬁc properties. For example, researchers

can use quantum algorithms to identify materials with high

energy densities, stability, or other desired properties. By doing

so, they can identify materials that are particularly well-suited

for use in energy storage and other applications on Mars.

One area where quantum computing could have a particu-

larly signiﬁcant impact is in the development of new materials

for fuel cells. Fuel cells are a type of energy-conversion device

that converts the chemical energy of a fuel into electricity.

They are a promising technology for use on Mars because they

can produce electricity without the need for oxygen, which

is not present in the Martian atmosphere. However, ﬁnding

materials that are stable and efﬁcient enough for use in fuel

cells on Mars has been a challenge. Quantum computing could

help researchers identify new materials that are more resistant

to the harsh conditions on Mars and therefore more suitable

for use in fuel cells.

3) Developing Sustainable Habitats, Growing Food, and

Extracting Resources on Mars:: One of the key challenges

of constructing habitats on Mars is ﬁnding materials that are

resistant to the extreme temperature ﬂuctuations and other

harsh conditions on the planet [10]. Quantum computing could

help researchers identify new materials that are more suitable

for use in constructing habitats on Mars. For example, re-

searchers could use quantum simulations to study the thermal

and structural properties of potential materials and determine

how they might perform in a habitat on Mars.

Another application of quantum computing on Mars could

be in the area of agriculture. One of the challenges of growing

food on Mars is ﬁnding materials that are capable of sup-

porting plant growth in the absence of a suitable atmosphere

and soil. Quantum computing could help researchers identify

new materials that are more suitable for use in agriculture on

Mars. For example, researchers could use quantum simulations

to study the properties of potential materials for use in

hydroponic or aeroponic systems, which are types of soil-less

cultivation methods that could be used to grow plants on Mars.

In addition to constructing habitats and growing food,

quantum computing could also be used to ﬁnd new materials

for extracting resources on Mars. Mars is rich in a variety of

resources, including water, minerals, and rare earth elements,

which could be valuable for supporting human exploration

and colonization of the planet. However, ﬁnding materials

that are capable of extracting these resources efﬁciently and

sustainably is a challenge. Quantum computing could help

researchers identify new materials that are more suitable for

use in resource extraction on Mars. For example, researchers

could use quantum simulations to study the properties of

potential materials for use in drilling and mining operations

on the planet.

Overall, quantum computing offers a powerful tool for

discovering and optimizing new materials for a wide range

of applications on Mars. Its ability to perform simulations and

optimize material design using quantum algorithms can help

researchers identify materials that are more efﬁcient, stable,

and resistant to the harsh conditions on the planet. As quantum

computing technology continues to advance, the authors can

expect to see even more exciting developments in the ﬁeld of

materials science and sustainability for Mars missions.

C. Secure and Reliable Communication

Another potential application of quantum computing in

Mars exploration is in the area of communication. Reliable

communication is essential for any space mission, as it allows

scientists and engineers to share data, coordinate activities, and

maintain contact with the ground team. However, traditional

methods of communication, such as radio waves, can be

subject to interference or degradation over long distances. This

can make it challenging to maintain reliable communication

between Earth and a spacecraft on Mars, especially during

periods when the planets are far apart in their orbits.

Quantum communication is a promising alternative to tra-

ditional methods of communication that relies on the prin-

ciples of quantum mechanics to transmit information [11].

Quantum communication systems use quantum states, such

as the polarization of photons, to encode and transmit infor-

mation. Because quantum states are extremely sensitive to

their environment, any attempt to intercept or tamper with

the information being transmitted would cause the quantum

states to change in a detectable way. This makes quantum

communication much less susceptible to interference or tam-

pering, making it a potentially more secure and reliable way

to transmit information over long distances [12]. One example

of a quantum communication system is the use of entangled

photons, which are pairs of photons that are linked together

and can transmit information over long distances. Quantum

communication systems have already been demonstrated in a

number of ground-based experiments and it is believed that

they could be used to transmit information between Earth and

Mars, providing a more reliable form of communication for

future missions.

5

In the context of Mars exploration, quantum communication

could potentially be used to establish reliable communication

channels between Earth and a spacecraft on Mars. This could

enable scientists and engineers to more easily exchange data

and coordinate activities, improving the efﬁciency and effec-

tiveness of the mission. Quantum communication could also

be used to establish secure channels for transmitting sensitive

or conﬁdential information, such as scientiﬁc data or mission

plans.

Overall, quantum communication is a promising technology

with the potential to improve the reliability and security of

communication in space exploration, including in the context

of Mars exploration.

D. Analyzing and Processing Data

Quantum computers have the potential to revolutionize

many ﬁelds, including space exploration. In the context of

a Mars mission, quantum computers could be used to an-

alyze and process data collected by spacecraft sensors and

instruments, such as data from telescopes and other scientiﬁc

instruments.

One of the key ways in which quantum computers could

be used to analyze and process data in a Mars mission is

through the use of machine learning algorithms [13]. Machine

learning algorithms are a type of artiﬁcial intelligence that

can learn and adapt based on data input, and they have the

potential to signiﬁcantly improve the efﬁciency and accuracy

of data analysis. Quantum computers have the ability to

perform machine learning algorithms [14] much faster than

classical computers, making them well-suited for tasks such

as analyzing data to search for signs of life on Mars or to

study the properties of the Martian surface and atmosphere.

Another potential use of quantum computers in data analysis

and processing in a Mars mission is in the simulation of

complex systems. Quantum computers have the ability to

simulate complex systems with a high degree of accuracy,

which could be used to study the properties of the Martian

surface and atmosphere or to understand the behavior of other

celestial objects in the solar system. By simulating these

systems, quantum computers could help to unlock new insights

and discoveries about Mars and our understanding of the

universe.

Overall, these demonstrate the potential of quantum com-

puters for data analysis and processing in a Mars mission.

By offering a new level of computational power, quantum

computers could help to unlock new insights and discoveries

about Mars and our understanding of the universe.

IV. CHALLENGES

There are several challenges associated with using quantum

computers for Mars exploration. Some of the key challenges

include:

•Development of quantum computers: Quantum computers

are still in the early stages of development, and there

are many technical challenges that must be overcome in

order to build and operate them at a large scale. These

challenges include issues with stability and reliability,

as well as the need to develop new technologies and

materials to support the operation of quantum computers.

•Fragility of quantum systems: Quantum computers rely

on fragile quantum states to perform calculations, and

any disruptions or errors in these states can signiﬁcantly

affect the accuracy of the computation. This makes quan-

tum computers more sensitive to noise and errors than

classical computers, and can make them more difﬁcult to

operate in challenging environments such as those found

in space.

•Complexity of programming: Quantum computers op-

erate using a different set of principles than classical

computers, and programming them can be more complex

and challenging. This can make it difﬁcult for researchers

to develop and use quantum algorithms for tasks in a

Mars mission.

•Communication and data transmission: One of the key

challenges of using quantum computers in space explo-

ration is the need to transmit data and communicate with

the quantum computer from a distance. This requires

the development of new technologies and methods for

transmitting data over long distances, such as through the

use of satellites or other types of relay systems.

Overall, these challenges demonstrate the need for con-

tinued research and development in the ﬁeld of quantum

computing in order to make it more widely available and

applicable to space exploration.

V. CONCLUSION

Quantum computing has the potential to signiﬁcantly en-

hance future Mars missions, particularly in the areas of

optimization, simulation, communication, and data analysis.

Although quantum computers still face challenges in their

development and deployment, this technology has the potential

to revolutionize Mars exploration. Careful planning and con-

sideration will be necessary to overcome these challenges and

effectively incorporate quantum computing into future Mars

missions.

REFERENCES

[1] S. E. Gaily and S. Imre, “Quantum Optimization in Large Resource

Management Systems,” in 2019 IEEE 20th International Workshop

on Signal Processing Advances in Wireless Communications (SPAWC),

2019, pp. 1–5.

[2] M. M ¨

oller and C. Vuik, “On the impact of quantum computing

technology on future developments in high-performance scientiﬁc

computing,” Ethics and Information Technology, vol. 19, no. 4,

pp. 253–269, aug 2017. [Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1007%

2Fs10676-017- 9438-0

[3] E. Farhi, J. Goldstone, and S. Gutmann, “A Quantum Approximate

Optimization Algorithm,” 2014. [Online]. Available: https://arxiv.org/

abs/1411.4028

[4] A. Shukla and P. Vedula, “Trajectory Optimization Using Quantum

Computing,” J. of Global Optimization, vol. 75, no. 1, p. 199–225, sep

2019. [Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10898-019-00754-5

[5] A. Delgado, P. A. M. Casares, R. dos Reis, M. S. Zini, R. Campos,

N. Cruz-Hern´

a ndez, A.-C. Voigt, A. Lowe, S. Jahangiri, M. A.

Martin-Delgado, J. E. Mueller, and J. M. Arrazola, “Simulating

key properties of lithium-ion batteries with a fault-tolerant quantum

computer,” Physical Review A, vol. 106, no. 3, sep 2022. [Online].

Available: https://doi.org/10.1103%2Fphysreva.106.032428

6

[6] A. Montanaro, “Quantum speedup of Monte Carlo methods,”

Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and

Engineering Sciences, vol. 471, no. 2181, p. 20150301, sep 2015.

[Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1098%2Frspa.2015.0301

[7] Nielsen, Michael A. and Chuang, Isaac L., Quantum Computation and

Quantum Information, 10th ed. USA: Cambridge University Press,

2011.

[8] D. de Falco and D. Tamascelli, “An introduction to quantum annealing,”

RAIRO - Theoretical Informatics and Applications, vol. 45, 07 2011.

[9] B. Bauer, S. Bravyi, M. Motta, and G. K.-L. Chan, “Quantum

Algorithms for Quantum Chemistry and Quantum Materials Science,”

Chemical Reviews, vol. 120, no. 22, pp. 12 685–12 717, oct 2020.

[Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1021%2Facs.chemrev.9b00829

[10] J. Liu, H. Li, L. Sun, Z. Guo, J. Harvey, Q. Tang, H. Lu, and M. Jia,

“In-situ resources for infrastructure construction on Mars: A review,”

Int. J. of Transportation Science and Technology, vol. 11, no. 1, pp.

1–16, 2022. [Online]. Available: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/

article/pii/S204604302100006X

[11] N. Gisin and R. Thew, “Quantum communication,” Nature Photonics,

vol. 1, no. 3, pp. 165–171, mar 2007. [Online]. Available:

https://doi.org/10.1038%2Fnphoton.2007.22

[12] Y.-A. Chen, Q. Zhang, T.-Y. Chen, W. Cai, S. Liao, J. Zhang, K. Chen,

J. Yin, J.-G. Ren, Z. Chen, S. L. Han, Q. Yu, K. Liang, F. Zhou, X. Yuan,

M. sheng Zhao, T. Wang, X. Jiang, L. Zhang, W. Liu, Y. Li, Q. Shen,

Y. Cao, C. Lu, R. Shu, J.-Y. Wang, L. Li, N.-L. Liu, F. Xu, X. Wang,

C.-Z. Peng, and J.-W. Pan, “An integrated space-to-ground quantum

communication network over 4,600 kilometres,” Nature, vol. 589, pp.

214–219, 2021.

[13] R. Divya and J. Dinesh Peter, “Quantum Machine Learning: A com-

prehensive review on optimization of machine learning algorithms,” in

2021 Fourth Int. Conf. on Microelectronics, Signals & Systems (ICMSS),

2021, pp. 1–6.

[14] N. Schetakis, D. Aghamalyan, P. Grifﬁn, and M. Boguslavsky, “Review

of some existing QML frameworks and novel hybrid classical–quantum

neural networks realising binary classiﬁcation for the noisy datasets,”

Sci. Rep., vol. 12, no. 1, p. 11927, 2022.