ArticlePublisher preview available

Spatiotemporal use of a tributary by lake sturgeon over a 10-year period

Authors:
  • Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

A telemetry study was conducted on lake sturgeon to determine the seasonal use and environmental factors that stimulate movement within a tributary of a larger system. Over a 10-year period, 52 lake sturgeon implanted with acoustic transmitters were monitored through an array of Vemco receivers with the Blanche River, Ontario. An average of 68% of the tagged fish entered the tributary annually whereas only 19.2% of those were detected on known spawning areas approximately 54 km upstream. Water temperature, lunar phase, lake water level, presumed spawning fish, and water discharge were all considered significant variables associated with the onset of upstream migration. Water temperature (mean 12.9 °C) was the only variable that explained the timing and the arrival at the spawning grounds. Sturgeon remained at the spawning area for a mean duration 7.9 days; however, none of the variables examined explained the duration of stay. Water temperature was the only variable that explained departure from the spawning areas (mean 15.8 °C). Mean time spent in the river after spawning was 30.5 days. There was not a significant difference in sex or total length in relationship to the duration tagged fish stayed in the river after spawning. The entire Blanche River up to the insuperable rapids was used by the sturgeon with the exception of minor tributaries. Water temperature, river discharge, and fish size were all considered significant factors initiating out-migration back into the lake. This study demonstrated the importance and seasonal use of a tributary by lake sturgeon. Correlations from abiotic variable and seasonal response could be used to establish guidelines for water management purposes when the goal is to conserve or restore sturgeon populations within a river system. This study also illustrates the importance of tributaries in association to a larger waterbody for lake sturgeon.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Vol.: (0123456789)
1 3
Environ Biol Fish (2023) 106:853–874
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10641-022-01384-9
Spatiotemporal use ofatributary bylake sturgeon
overa10‑year period
LaurenMcDonald· TimHaxton
Received: 14 March 2022 / Accepted: 21 December 2022 / Published online: 28 December 2022
© Crown 2022
Abstract A telemetry study was conducted on lake
sturgeon to determine the seasonal use and environ-
mental factors that stimulate movement within a
tributary of a larger system. Over a 10-year period,
52 lake sturgeon implanted with acoustic transmitters
were monitored through an array of Vemco receiv-
ers with the Blanche River, Ontario. An average of
68% of the tagged fish entered the tributary annually
whereas only 19.2% of those were detected on known
spawning areas approximately 54km upstream. Water
temperature, lunar phase, lake water level, presumed
spawning fish, and water discharge were all consid-
ered significant variables associated with the onset
of upstream migration. Water temperature (mean
12.9°C) was the only variable that explained the tim-
ing and the arrival at the spawning grounds. Sturgeon
remained at the spawning area for a mean duration
7.9 days; however, none of the variables examined
explained the duration of stay. Water temperature
was the only variable that explained departure from
the spawning areas (mean 15.8°C). Mean time spent
in the river after spawning was 30.5days. There was
not a significant difference in sex or total length in
relationship to the duration tagged fish stayed in the
river after spawning. The entire Blanche River up to
the insuperable rapids was used by the sturgeon with
the exception of minor tributaries. Water temperature,
river discharge, and fish size were all considered sig-
nificant factors initiating out-migration back into the
lake. This study demonstrated the importance and
seasonal use of a tributary by lake sturgeon. Corre-
lations from abiotic variable and seasonal response
could be used to establish guidelines for water man-
agement purposes when the goal is to conserve or
restore sturgeon populations within a river system.
This study also illustrates the importance of tribu-
taries in association to a larger waterbody for lake
sturgeon.
Keywords Lake sturgeon· Interannual movement·
Long-term study· Tributary use
Introduction
Tributaries are important features moving water from
the landscape through lakes and larger rivers to the
ocean. These rivers were fundamental for the explora-
tion of new lands in North America and as a primary
means to transport goods back to European markets.
The levels of alteration to rivers increased with colo-
nial settlement and increasing populations. Rivers
became the main corridors for the transporting of
timber to mills and markets (Kelso etal. 1996). Later,
L.McDonald
KirklandLake, Canada
T.Haxton(*)
Aquatic Research andMonitoring Section, Ontario
Ministry ofNatural Resources andForestry, 2140 East
Bank Drive, Peterborough, ONK9J7B8, Canada
e-mail: tim.haxton@ontario.ca
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... Other studies have similarly found that some individual lake sturgeon will remain in overwintering areas, while others show seasonal movement patterns in and out of overwintering areas in spring and fall, e.g. in the Winnipeg River, Mani-toba, Canada (Barth et al. 2011). Our findings are also similar to a recent long-term study which demonstrated that lake sturgeon used the entire Blanche River, Ontario, (about 54 km) and used different river sections only during the spring and summer season (McDonald & Haxton 2023). 4.3.2. ...
... Blanche River, Ontario; McDonald & Haxton 2023), and hydroelectrically dammed rivers (e.g. Mississippi River, USA; Knights et al. 2002) can have drastically different flow regimes and temperature profiles compared to the intact, relatively shorter North French River, and river discharge can affect seasonal lake sturgeon movements (Borkholder et al. 2002, McDonald & Haxton 2023. Including considerations of the differences in methodologies and flow regimes when comparing results among studies is important for drawing contextualized conclusions and for comparing fish movement and behaviour between impacted and intact river systems. ...
Article
Full-text available
Most sturgeon populations are imperilled and living in fragmented rivers. Here, we studied namew (lake sturgeon Acipenser fulvescens ), fish important to Ililiwak (Moose Cree Peoples), in the North French River: a free-flowing, intact river in Kit Aski Nahnuun (the Moose Cree Homeland) in northern Ontario, Canada. This study was co-created alongside members of Moose Cree First Nation and used acoustic telemetry to passively track 20 tagged namew over 6 yr (2016-2022). Namew occupied the entire monitored river reach: about 45 km. Namew used 2 overwintering areas and occupied more overall river sections during spring and summer (out of 6 total seasons often used by Ililiwak). We did not detect namew moving upstream or downstream during freeze-up and winter. Generally, namew showed the greatest acceleration and travelled the longest distances during spring and summer, and they occupied shallower water during summer at lower water levels and deepest waters during freeze-up. We found an interaction between season and diurnal period, where namew occupied shallower depths and had higher acceleration at dawn and night relative to morning and afternoon in most seasons; dusk behaviour was variable among seasons. However, this pattern was absent in spring, when namew showed no diurnal pattern in acceleration and were in shallower water during morning and afternoon. Diurnal patterns were less pronounced, but detectable, during ice-affected seasons. This river provides year-round habitat for namew, and our data reveal distinct patterns of namew occupancy, movement, and behaviour in a free-flowing, intact river. Our work is an example of successfully co-creating research that addresses both scientific and community priorities.
... Telemetry is an important tool that can provide insight into sturgeon behavior (Wildhaber et al. 2011;Nelson et al. 2013), environmental stimuli for initiating movement (Goodman et al. 2013;Vine et al. 2019;Ecclestone et al. 2020;McDonald and Haxton 2023), and extent of movement (Fredrich et al. 2008;Wishingrad et al. 2014); help identify potential spawning areas (Wildhaber et al. 2011;Taylor and Litvak 2017) and significant habitat areas for the species (Hale et al. 2016;Novak et al. 2017); or ascertain population dynamics such as survival from long-term studies (Colborne et al. 2021;McDonald and Haxton 2023). Telemetry can both help assess reproductive population sizes (Kazyak et al. 2020) and can facilitate the identification of areas for which further, more targeted studies can be directed (e.g., Wildhaber et al. 2011;Taylor and Litvak 2017). ...
... Telemetry is an important tool that can provide insight into sturgeon behavior (Wildhaber et al. 2011;Nelson et al. 2013), environmental stimuli for initiating movement (Goodman et al. 2013;Vine et al. 2019;Ecclestone et al. 2020;McDonald and Haxton 2023), and extent of movement (Fredrich et al. 2008;Wishingrad et al. 2014); help identify potential spawning areas (Wildhaber et al. 2011;Taylor and Litvak 2017) and significant habitat areas for the species (Hale et al. 2016;Novak et al. 2017); or ascertain population dynamics such as survival from long-term studies (Colborne et al. 2021;McDonald and Haxton 2023). Telemetry can both help assess reproductive population sizes (Kazyak et al. 2020) and can facilitate the identification of areas for which further, more targeted studies can be directed (e.g., Wildhaber et al. 2011;Taylor and Litvak 2017). ...
Article
Full-text available
Sturgeons are a unique group of species that were historically widespread across the northern hemisphere. According to the latest IUCN Red list assessment, more than 80% of the species globally are threatened with extinction, making it essential to identify the life stages at which they are suffering from impacts the most, while at the same time to compare among river systems and populations based on standardized assessment techniques. All sturgeon have similar but not identical, life-history strategies. Therefore, monitoring techniques developed for one sturgeon species would be applicable to most other species. Monitoring can be conducted at each life stage. However, while each life stage will provide different information about the population, not all will necessarily help to assess population trend or status. Life stages that are highly variable prove to be less quantifiable even after expending very high effort. Collectively, these assessments could be very informative on population status, limitations, and trends. However, monitoring at each stage is time-consuming and expensive. Clearly defined objectives are therefore required when embarking on an assessment program. The objective of this study was to review the assessment techniques used for the different life stages including eggs, drifting larvae, age-0, juveniles, subadults, and adults to provide a common basis for population assessments that can be standardized to some extent and thus facilitate comparisons between the results obtained. For this purpose, this review presented the most common assessment techniques for each life stage, assessed the pros and cons of assessing each life stage, and examined if the methodology was qualitative or quantitative to assist in establishing long-term monitoring initiatives.
Article
Full-text available
Understanding how ectotherms may fare with rising global temperatures and more frequent heatwaves is especially concerning for species already considered at‐risk, such as long‐lived, late‐maturing sturgeon. There have been concerted efforts to collect data on the movement behavior and thermal physiology of North American sturgeon to enhance conservation efforts; thus, we sought to synthesize these data to understand how sturgeon respond to thermal stress and what capacity they have to acclimate and adapt to warming. Here, we combined a systematic literature review and meta‐analysis, integrating field‐based observations (distribution and spawning) and laboratory‐based experiments (survival, activity, growth, metabolism, and upper thermal limits) for large‐scale insights to understand the vulnerability of North American sturgeon to rising global temperatures. We summarized the preferred thermal habitat and thermal limits of sturgeon in their natural environment and using meta‐analytical techniques, quantified the effect of prolonged temperature change on sturgeon whole‐animal physiology and acute upper thermal limits. While acclimation did not have significant effects on physiological rates or survival overall, there were positive trends of activity and metabolism in young‐of‐the‐year sturgeons, likely offset by negative trends of survival in early life. Notably, North American sturgeon have a greater capacity for thermal tolerance plasticity than other fishes, increasing upper thermal limits by 0.56°C per 1°C change in acclimation temperature. But with limited laboratory‐based studies, more research is needed to understand if this is a sturgeon trait, or perhaps that of basal fishes in general. Importantly, with these data gaps, the fate of sturgeon remains uncertain as climate change intensifies, and physiological impacts across life stages likely limit ecological success.
Article
Full-text available
Survival of adult fishes is critical to the conservation and management of wild populations, particularly for long-lived, slow to reproduce species. Most sturgeon species are of conservation concern, but their long lifespans and large ranges have made estimation of adult survival rates challenging. In this study, acoustic telemetry was used to track 205 lake sturgeon (Acipenser fulvescens) tagged in the St. Clair and Detroit rivers of the Laurentian Great Lakes over seven years (2012–2019). The objective of this study was to determine if annual survival was related to sex, size, tagging location (river), or year post-tagging using Cormack-Jolly-Seber (CJS) models. Annual survival was high among all seven years (range of point estimates: 95–99%) and did not differ based on sex, tagging year, size at time of tagging, or tagging location. Lake sturgeon detection probability on acoustic receivers was high each year (range of point estimates: 82–99%) and increased as the number of receivers in the system increased. High survival rates of lake sturgeon were consistent with levels thought required for lake sturgeon to be self-sustaining in the St. Clair – Detroit river system. Our application of acoustic telemetry detections as input to CJS models demonstrated the usefulness of this approach and should be considered for population assessment studies throughout the Great Lakes and beyond.
Article
Full-text available
Understanding the spatial ecology of sturgeon (Acipenseridae) has proven to be a challenge due to the life history characteristics of these fish, especially their long life span, intermittent spawning, and long‐distance migrations. Within the Huron‐Erie Corridor (HEC) of the Laurentian Great Lakes, habitat use of 247 lake sturgeon (Acipenser fulvescens) was monitored over a three‐year period (2015–2017) with acoustic transmitters. Extensive spatial coverage of receivers throughout the St. Clair River, Lake St. Clair, and Detroit River between Lake Huron and Lake Erie (~150 km) allowed for continuous monitoring of the movements of acoustic‐tagged individuals. Sequence analysis of individual detection histories was used to describe lake sturgeon habitat use and to determine (1) whether distinct habitat‐use patterns occurred within the HEC; (2) whether the range of habitats occupied varied across seasons among sturgeon grouped by common patterns; and (3) whether variation identified was related to tagging sites in the two rivers or sex. Lake sturgeon were active throughout the HEC, but five distinct habitat‐use patterns were identified. River residents were not broadly distributed across entire rivers, but rather associated with particular segments (middle Detroit River, St. Clair River delta). Variations in habitat‐use sequences were in part related to three river tagging sites, but not sex, and did not produce groups with sequences that reflected all five habitat‐use patterns derived from cluster analysis. Lake sturgeon distribution was reduced to fewer habitat segments during winter and expanded to the maximum extent during the spring and summer. Conservation planning that incorporates behavioral diversity of habitat use is relatively rare due to a lack of observations on movements of individuals at biologically relevant spatial and temporal scales, but using telemetry and sequence analysis methods may promote the success of conservation and restoration efforts.
Article
Full-text available
Abiotic conditions and demographic factors can influence the timing of spawning. Behavioral plasticity allows females to select spawning conditions that are conducive to offspring development; however, reproductive costs associated with delaying spawning are not well understood. In this study, factors influencing timing of female spawning, residence time (RT), and reproductive success (RS) during two seasons were determined, and plasma testosterone concentrations were used to quantify atretic rates in a wild, lake sturgeon (Acipenser fulvescens) population. For the 123 females monitored, RT ranged from 1 to 23 days and was influenced by arrival date, temperature, discharge, and male number, with the latter having the largest influence. RS varied due to arrival date, temperature, discharge, male number, male length, and operational sex ratio. Two females had testosterone levels indicative of atresia and RS estimates lower than yearly means; however, most females had normal ovaries, suggesting little reproductive costs of plasticity in spawning ground residency time. Results demonstrate the multitude of factors influencing female reproductive behavior and RS, highlighting the importance of abiotic and demographic conditions to recruitment in wild populations.
Article
Full-text available
Population structure, distribution, abundance and dispersal arguably underpin the entire field of animal ecology, with consequences for regional species persistence, and provision of ecosystem services. Divergent migration behaviours among individuals or among populations are an important aspect of the ecology of highly mobile animals, allowing populations to exploit spatially or temporally distributed food and space resources. This study investigated the spatial ecology of lake sturgeon ( A cipenser fulvescens ) within the barrier free Huron‐Erie Corridor ( HEC ), which connects Lake Huron and Lake Erie of the North American Laurentian Great Lakes. Over 6 years (2011–2016), movements of 268 lake sturgeon in the HEC were continuously monitored across the Great Lakes using acoustic telemetry (10 years battery life acoustic transmitters). Five distinct migration behaviours were identified with hierarchical cluster analysis, based on the phenology and duration of river and lake use. Lake sturgeon in the HEC were found to contain a high level of intraspecific divergent migration, including partial migration with the existence of residents. Specific behaviours included year‐round river residency and multiple lake‐migrant behaviours that involved movements between lakes and rivers. Over 85% of individuals were assigned to migration behaviours as movements were consistently repeated over the study, which suggested migration behaviours were consistent and persistent in lake sturgeon. Differential use of specific rivers or lakes by acoustic‐tagged lake sturgeon further subdivided individuals into 14 “contingents” (spatiotemporally segregated subgroups). Contingents associated with one river (Detroit or St. Clair) were rarely detected in the other river, which confirmed that lake sturgeon in the Detroit and St. Clair represent two semi‐independent populations that could require separate management consideration for their conservation. The distribution of migration behaviours did not vary between populations, sexes, body size or among release locations, which indicated that intrapopulation variability in migratory behaviour is a general feature of the spatial ecology of lake sturgeon in unfragmented landscapes.
Article
Knowledge concerning critical habitats such as spawning sites is crucial to the preservation of vulnerable fish species like sturgeons. For lake sturgeon Acipenser fulvescens populations in the Lower St. Lawrence and Ottawa river systems, knowledge about spawning sites has been documented primarily in the grey literature, unpublished reports, or notes, with very little published in peer-reviewed literature. Here, we reviewed over 100 reports, articles, and unpublished observations in the Lower St. Lawrence and Ottawa river systems to synthesize available information concerning the location of lake sturgeon spawning sites, the level of spawning activity, and the methodologies used for assessments. In this review, 38 lake sturgeon spawning sites were identified. Of these sites, 11 were enhanced or artificially created for lake sturgeon. In the Lower St. Lawrence River, 68% of known spawning sites were located downstream from a dam compared to 47% in the Ottawa River. The use of the two artificially created spawning sites in the Lower St. Lawrence River has not yet been confirmed, while one site established in the Ottawa River has had confirmed spawning activity, although the spawning run size is unknown. In contrast, spawning has been confirmed for the seven natural spawning sites that have been artificially expanded in these systems, and two of these sites have large spawning runs. Information revealed by this review suggests that lake sturgeon populations in these large river systems rely on multiple spawning sites and that expanding natural spawning grounds may be more effective than creating new ones.
Article
Lake sturgeon movement in two adjacent unregulated Lake Superior tributaries, the Pic and White rivers, was assessed over several years to determine seasonal use, identify potential contributing factors for entry or exit migrations, and evaluate whether sturgeon using these tributaries constituted one or two populations. A total of 95 lake sturgeon implanted with radio transmitters were tracked using multiple stationary receivers augmented with boat-based manual surveillance during peak movement times. Both rivers were used by lake sturgeon during the open water (“ice off”) season. In general, spawning sturgeon moved to the first insuperable barrier (i.e., natural rapids) during the spawning season, and then moved downstream to deeper pools in mid- to late summer. Non-spawning sturgeon moved into the river concurrently but remained in lower portions of the river. Lake sturgeon emigrated from the Pic River and resided in Lake Superior during the winter season whereas a small portion of radio transmittered sturgeon, originally sampled in the Pic River, overwintered in the White River. River discharge and the interaction between discharge and water temperature were correlated with upstream movement, and river discharge was also correlated with outmigration. No genetic structuring was apparent between Sturgeon within the two rivers, consistent with telemetry data showing radio-tagged fish moving readily between the rivers. This study provided pertinent seasonal use information of unregulated Great Lake tributaries and may contribute to planning processes for future hydroelectric developments to minimize disruptions to lake Sturgeon populations.
Article
Acoustic telemetry is used to quantify fish movement, ecology, and habitat use and can contribute to assessing the success of species supplementation. In this field, a better understanding of the effects of tag burden (or the impact of an acoustic telemetry tag, which is related to the ratio of tag weight to body weight) is critical to ensure postrelease monitoring. Research on the effects of acoustic tag burden on imperiled fishes at different ontogenic stages, such as juvenile Lake Sturgeon Acipenser fulvescens, is limited. Our study provides key information for the selection of the largest acoustic tag with the greatest battery life possible (taking into account tag burden) to monitor the release success and movements of juvenile Lake Sturgeon stocked for reintroduction. We characterized tag burden effects by examining survival, TL, weight, Fulton's condition factor, and swim performance of individuals. We examined four groups of fish: control (anesthetized and no acoustic tag inserted; n = 24), sham control (anesthetized with incision sutured but no acoustic tag inserted; n = 24), Vemco V8 acoustic tag (2.0 g in air; n = 24), and Vemco V9 tag (4.4 g in air; n = 24). Acoustic tags were inserted into anesthetized fish, and the incision was sutured; tag burden (mean ± SE) ranged from 2.2 ± 0.06% to 4.6 ± 0.10% of total body weight. Results showed that the two tag burden treatments had no significant effects on growth or survival (compared to both control groups) across a 114‐d study period and that critical swim speed at 12–20 d postsurgery was not significantly impacted by increasing tag burden. Because neither of the acoustic tag sizes had significant deleterious effects on the metrics studied, we recommend using a larger V9 tag (i.e., the most powerful tag with the longest battery life) for postrelease monitoring of reintroduced juvenile Lake Sturgeon.
Article
Species translocations are increasingly being used as a management tool to mitigate population losses due to such factors as habitat degradation and fragmentation, but post‐introduction follow‐up is relatively sparse. Post‐translocation telemetry can assess success by identifying activity, emigrations, survival, habitat usage, and reproductive events, aiding in the continued management of translocated populations and informing future efforts. This study assessed movement of translocated adult lake sturgeon (Acipenser fulvescens) immediately post‐release and a decade later, and tested for associations between environmental variables and spawning movements. Prior to their translocation in 2002, 13 of 51 adult lake sturgeon were surgically implanted with radio telemetry tags and tracked for 1 year. In 2011 and 2013, eight additional adults were captured within the reintroduction site and implanted with radio‐tags. Six of the 13 sturgeon tagged in 2002 dispersed downstream over a dam during the early post‐release period. In spring 2014, tagged adults were tracked to the spillway at the release area's inflow, and spawning was confirmed by larval captures. Movement data for tagged adults differed between the two tracking periods, showing marked differences in behaviour over time. Water velocity was correlated with upstream and downstream spawning movements, with water temperature also correlated with downstream movement. Research regarding post‐translocation movement and dispersal provides insight on behavioural responses following translocation, and may improve outcomes by informing future efforts.
Article
Shortnose sturgeon (Acipenser brevirostrum) populations were decimated by a variety of anthropogenic activities throughout much of the 20th century. Understanding the spatial and temporal dynamics of spawning migrations within natal rivers is a critical information gap with regard to habitat protection and ultimately, species recovery. The objectives of this study were to document and describe seasonal movements of shortnose sturgeon in the Altamaha River system, Georgia. Passive acoustic telemetry was used to monitor the movements of 40 adult individuals from April 2011 through February 2014. Telemetry data revealed that during much of the year, the adults resided within the tidally influenced portion of the river, with most detections occurring near the freshwater–saltwater interface. Upstream movements to potential spawning habitat occurred during winter and early spring, and most fish returned to the lower estuary by April. Upstream migrations appeared to be triggered by environmental cues and were initiated when mean weekly temperatures in the lower Altamaha River were 11.6–16.9 °C. Unlike spawning migrations documented in northern rivers, the pattern of movement observed in this study was a single‐step migration without an apparent resting or staging period. Upstream migrations during nonspawning months were also observed and appeared to correspond with increasing discharge, which potentially resulted in increased channel navigability and habitat availability in nondrought years. This study further illustrates the clinal variations in life history typical of the species and may have important implications on river‐specific strategies for species recovery.