Content uploaded by David Wright
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by David Wright on Dec 15, 2022
Content may be subject to copyright.
https://doi.org/10.1177/20530196221140145
The Anthropocene Review
1 –28
© The Author(s) 2022
Article reuse guidelines:
sagepub.com/journals-permissions
DOI: 10.1177/20530196221140145
journals.sagepub.com/home/anr
Impact of farming on African
landscapes
David K Wright1,2
Abstract
As the continent with the deepest record of human history, the relationship between landscape
formation and human subsistence practices is inseparable. The activities that constitute ‘farming’
are open for some matter of discussion, but essentially speak to the co-evolution of human,
plant and animal reproductive systems along a continuum of interdependence. This process is
ever evolving, but has resulted in the formation of landscapes in which anthropogenic processes
characterize ecosystem functionality in nearly all biomes on the continent. Practices of cultivation,
broadly conceptualized, across Africa are varied in the ways in which they have transformed
ecological systems and landscapes. The use of fire as a landscape management tool dates to the
Pleistocene, and penning of wild sheep to the early Holocene. The alteration of the landscape of
fear by these types of human activities had fundamentally restructured trophic systems in Africa
prior to the introduction of agriculture. However, the introduction of animal herding and intensive
forms of plant cultivation by the middle Holocene correlated to even more significant ecological
changes. The creation of agricultural landscapes has had a negative impact on biodiversity in
some locations, whereas other some practices at different points in time have positively affected
biodiversity. It is now recognized that humans have long influenced the evolution of landscapes
wherever they live, but the current research focuses on where, when and how socio-ecological
processes become coupled in the palaeoecological record.
Keywords
agriculture, anthropogenic land change, domestication, Ecology of Fear, human ecology, human-
environment interactions, Niche Construction Theory, subsistence systems, trophic webs
Introduction
The transition of human subsistence practices based entirely on hunting and gathering to one based
on agriculture has been commonly referred to as ‘revolutionary’ for our species. The emergence of
1University of Oslo, Norway
2Chinese Academy of Sciences, China
Corresponding author:
David K Wright, Institute of Archaeology, Conservation
and History, University of Oslo, Blindernveien 11, Oslo
0371, Norway; State Key Laboratory of Loess and
Quaternary Geology, Institute of Earth Environment,
Chinese Academy of Sciences, Xi’an, 710061, China.
Email: d.k.wright@iakh.uio.no
1140145ANR0010.1177/20530196221140145The Anthropocene ReviewWright
review-article2022
Review
2 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
agriculture went hand-in-hand with population growth, the growth of cities, transportation and
writing systems, significant biological changes in human microbial taxa and body morphologies
and a radical reorganization of earth’s biome as the scale of land clearance accelerated towards the
end of the Holocene, ca. 12,000 years ago (ka; Ellis et al., 2021; Stephens et al., 2019). The culmi-
nation of this process has been coined as the ‘Anthropocene’, a geologic epoch of earth in which
human-driven formation processes outstrip natural-driven processes across the entire face of the
planet (Crutzen and Stoermer, 2000). A formal designation of the Anthropocene epoch by the
Anthropocene Working Group (AWG) of the International Union of Geological Sciences has been
established as beginning in the early 1950s based on the presence of artificial radionuclides in sedi-
ments, which heralds the advent of the nuclear age (Zalasiewicz et al., 2021). The ca. 1950 chron-
ostratigraphic marker (or ‘Golden Spike’) of the Anthropocene corresponds to what some have
called the ‘Great Acceleration’ in which there are myriad detectable anthropogenic impacts on
earth’s geologic framework as a result of cumulative deforestation, industrialization and urbaniza-
tion (Steffen et al., 2007, 2015). However, farming systems did not emerge rapidly or organically,
nor are they completed – they have long antecedents in human land management practices that
extend deep into the Pleistocene and they are subject to ongoing evolutionary processes in adjust-
ment to changing realms of biodiversity and climate change (Boivin et al., 2016; Hoag and
Svenning, 2017).
This paper will provide a critical thematic review of the roots of farming and evaluate its evo-
lutionary impacts on the formation of landscapes over long time cycles on the African continent
leading up to the present day. Following a brief overview of the continent’s diverse geography and
how farming itself can be defined in this context, the application of ecological theories of fear and
trophic cascades in the context of African farming systems will be outlined. The paper then explores
two broad, transformative socio-cultural phenomena: the termination of the African Humid Period
(AHP, ca. 8–4.5 ka) and the emergence of the Iron Age (ca. 5–2 ka), both of which significantly
impacted the formation of the landscape of pre-colonial Africa and have influenced the complexion
of socio-ecological systems today.
The coupling of sociological processes with impacts detectable in the palaeoecological record
can be difficult to disentangle with precision, but as humanity’s evolutionary homeland, the African
continent hosts landscapes from which the longest records of human-environmental impacts can
potentially be traced (Boivin et al., 2016). Farming systems are ecological niches that have been
forged over millennia of co-evolution between humans and the myriad species with which we
interact. The purpose here is not to argue for or against the AWG definition of the Anthropocene as
a geologic epoch, but rather to contextualize the emergence of the present landscape using a his-
torical ecological approach. The research programme of historical ecology situates human-medi-
ated disturbances to landscapes as critical features of ecological succession (e.g. Balée, 2006;
Crumley, 2021; Lane, 2010) and is therefore not looking for a ‘Golden Spike’ marking the emer-
gence of an epoch, per se. As will be argued below, the impacts of human land tenure are measur-
able from the diachronic view afforded by humanity’s long history in Africa on millennial
timescales (sensu Lane, 2019) and important for understanding what may lie ahead (Anderson
et al., 2006; Fraser et al., 2007; Nogués-Bravo et al., 2018).
The Anthropocene has become understood to be far more than a geologic phenomenon – it has
come to assume significant political and moral implications as it is the only geologic epoch to be
defined by, as well as caused by, a single species (Burdon, 2020; Lewis and Maslin, 2015). Critics
of the Anthropocene concept argue that it is the only geologic epoch which is simultaneously
denaturalized and ‘renaturalized’ being caused unevenly by humans (beneficiaries of global capi-
talism being the prime causal agents), but presenting concomitant global impacts (Malm and
Hornborg, 2014). Another critique is that the Anthropocene is stratigraphically and conceptually
Wright 3
indistinguishable from the Holocene since the latter epoch is primarily characterized by anthropo-
genic formation processes, particularly in the second half, and the distance afforded by time to
observe changes in the sedimentary record are not yet available (Gibbard and Lewin, 2016).
Understanding that there are epistemological considerations of what the Anthropocene entails,
there is growing scientific consensus that the geologic Anthropocene has antecedents and studying
its roots offers the best path towards developing a future with levels of biodiversity that can sustain
robust ecosystem functionality (Brondizio et al., 2016). Land host management practices that
emphasize conservation of indigenous, sympathetic plant and animal species have proven to create
invaluably durable islands of productivity against soil and biologic degradation (Kendall and
Drew, 2019; Sinclair et al., 2019). From this vantage point, this paper critically reviews ecological
(niche) construction across Africa as an extension of long-term co-evolutionary dynamics.
Statistical modelling of previously published data will be undertaken, but the primary objective of
this review is to use case studies to understand how recursive ecological regime shifts can unfold,
feeding into one another over space and time as niches are constructed, respond and are further
modified to accommodate biotic and abiotic pressures that constitute them.
Geographic setting for farming systems in Africa
Africa is a continent of extraordinary diversity in geology, topography and climate systems, which
has resulted in a wide array of biodiversity among the endemic plant and animal taxa (Figure 1).
The intricate interrelationships between bedrock geology and soil systems to plant and animal
communities were analysed by Bell (1982) in a landmark paper, which was one of the first to
clearly hypothesize the correlation between nutrient-rich soils of the volcanic plains and the occur-
rence of grassy savannah lands in much of the subcontinent. Grasslands are perpetuated by attract-
ing grazers who spread seeds in their dung to fertilize the plains, maintaining the savannah
ecosystem. In this way, if water availability and slope are held constant, igneous (volcanic) land-
forms predict the occurrence of grasslands (Bell, 1982). On the other hand, the older, weathered
bedrock landforms of metamorphic and sedimentary formations possess fewer nutrients available
to plants, which Bell (1982) hypothesizes encourages the storage of scarce nutrients above the
ground in forests (e.g. miombo woodlands, tropical canopy), attract browsing animals such as
elephants (Loxodanta sp.) and giraffes (Giraffa camelopardalis), who maintain woodland com-
munities. These trophic webs interfinger with one another across Africa and have created differen-
tiated ecological areas from which a diverse range of human subsistence practices has emerged.
A stronger predictor of plant communities than geology is rainfall and topography, which, in
the tropical regions of Africa, are strongly dependent upon one another. The long axis of the
African continent (between 37°N and 35°S) falls roughly equidistantly across the tropical belt of
the Equator along a north-south trajectory. With the annual migration of the Earth and associated
precessional tilt towards and away from the sun relative to the reference aspect taken, there is a
ridge of converging low pressure known as the Intertropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ) that fol-
lows the area of maximum annual insolation. Rainfall associated with monsoonal convection
from the oceans towards the inland regions occurs along the ITCZ in the tropical regions of the
continent. Given the predictable annual cycle of Earth’s orbit, there is a patterned annual distribu-
tion of rainfall associated with the migration of the ITCZ. The Mediterranean and cone of south-
ern African are influenced by different higher/lower latitude atmospheric pressure cells bringing
winter/summer rainfall, respectively.
The distribution of precipitation is not uniform across space due to the effects that elevation
has on condensing moist air, and elevation is highly variable in eastern half of Africa due to
continental rifting processes (Hession and Moore, 2011). The East African Rift System (EARS)
4 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
has formed over the last ca. 40 million years as the East Africa Plate has separated from the
Somali Plate via a series of complex faults and tectonic processes (Tiercelin and Lezzar, 2002).
The EARS runs south from the modern-day country of Israel/Palestine forming a trough in the
Red Sea, into Ethiopia after which it bifurcates into east and western branches that extend to
Malawi (Figure 1b). Extended pushing and pulling of landforms has resulted in extreme con-
trasts between highland and lowland settings across relatively small distances. Because moisture
condenses when air is cooled, the highlands create updraft zones for the convection of tropical
moisture that condenses on the windward side of uplands, leaving the leeward side drier. Central
and western Africa contain large low-lying river basins (Niger, Congo) that are split by the Yola
Rift and have seasonally high annual rainfall. Most of southern Africa is semi-arid to arid in high
elevation settings except along the coastlines, which have Mediterranean type climates. The
circumstances of this geography have created a landscape of variable resource distributions,
which have been hypothesized as foundational to the emergence of our species as bipedal, large-
brained apex predators (Potts, 1996).
Figure 1. Maps of African geography. (a) Vegetation distributions as mapped by White (1983). The
units are mapped in chloropleth distribution from 1 to 80 according to White (1983: Table 4, pp. 57–66),
excluding water; (b) Geology supergroups mapped by the Geological Survey of Canada (Chorlton, 2007).
Faults mapped and distributed by ESRI in 2001; (c) Anthrome construction ca. AD 1700 as mapped by Ellis
etal. (2010) – see also Supplementary Information in Ellis etal. (2021); (d) Annual average precipitation
from 1970 to 2000 (Fick and Hijmans, 2017); (e) January average precipitation 1970–2000 (Fick and
Hijmans, 2017) with GTOPO30 hillshade background (www.doi.org/10.5066/F7DF6PQS). Dashed line
shows the estimated average position of the ITCZ; (f) July average precipitation 1970–2000 (Fick and
Hijmans, 2017) with GTOPO30 hillshade background (www.doi.org/10.5066/F7DF6PQS). Dashed line
shows the estimated average position of the ITCZ.
Wright 5
What is a farmer?
To better understand the impact of farming on landscape formation, an extended definition of
‘farming’ will be proffered here. In the post-Industrial era, contrasts between ‘untouched’ tropical
landscapes of central Africa and highly managed commercial viticulture regions of southern Africa
or pastoral grasslands of eastern Africa seem rather stark. However, past landscapes and subsist-
ence practices were not so clearly separated, and that which constitutes a ‘farmer’ or a ‘forager’ is
a matter of interpretation and occasional vigorous debate (Crowther et al., 2018; Kusimba, 2005;
Terrell et al., 2003). Modern notions of property and tenancy introduced during the colonial era
have demarcated land tenure and management practices into distinct zones, which were rare prior
to ca. 100 years ago.
The simplest definition of a farmer is a person who practices agriculture using domesticated
taxa. The humans, plants and non-human animals engaged in farming generally benefit from an
evolutionary fitness perspective, and therefore ‘domestication’ is not a process of human dominion
or co-opting of nature, but rather co-evolution that is ongoing and lies along a spectrum of expres-
sion (Bogaard et al., 2021). The production cycle of farming consists of four crucial elements: (1)
propagation, (2) husbandry, (3) harvesting/slaughter and (4) storage/maintenance (Harris, 2007).
Whether they are plants or animals, a farmer is engaged in management over the stages of their
foods’ life cycles from seed to the point of consumption. This definition stands in contrast to a
forager, who may engage in one or more of these elements, but not all simultaneously. However,
as Flannery (1968: 68) argues, every forager knows that if a seed is placed in the ground, a plant
will grow. Armed with this knowledge, foragers have been actively managing landscapes since
time immemorial, since doing so has been the crucial element to human evolutionary fitness
(Boivin et al., 2016; Thompson et al., 2021a).
Agronomists with the World Agroforestry Centre (ICRAF) have identified five primary farming
systems in Africa: Highland Perennial (HP), Maize Mixed (MM), Cereal Root Crop (CRC), Agro-
Pastoral (AP) and Highland Mixed (HM), which is based on the Food and Agriculture Organization
of the United Nations land use scheme (Figure 2; Dixon et al., 2001; Garrity et al., 2012). Their
analyses identify HP systems as primarily residing in eastern Africa and are largely based on cash
and staple crops (especially maize and coffee) in densely populated upland settings. HP systems
are less dependent on rainfall than other systems due to their highland settings where precipitation
is generally more stable than in lowland settings. MM systems extend over 91 million hectares of
eastern and southern Africa, colonizing formerly forested regions within subhumid zones. MM
systems heavily focus on legumes, maize and cash crops for export with household livestock rear-
ing. CRC systems are located in the Guinea-Savanna vegetation zone (White, 1983) south of the
Sahara. The cereal, root and tuber crops that constitute the vast majority of the productive output
of the CRC region are heavily dependent on increasingly precarious rainfall. The region is classi-
fied as ‘parkland’ with large stands of tree canopy remaining from which people collect shea nuts,
but crop yields in CRC systems are generally lower than in other regions. AP systems are located
in the semi-arid, drought-prone regions of northern, eastern and southern Africa. They may include
limited cultivation of pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum) and sorghum (Sorghum bicolor), but are
primarily focused on grass conservation and livestock production. Traditionally AP systems relied
on seasonal transhumance, but there has been a growing shift to sedentary forms of farming as land
tenure systems have become increasingly regulated. Finally, HM farming systems occupy over 40
million hectares in portions of Ethiopia, Eritrea, western Cameroon, Lesotho and Angola. The cool
and humid climate conditions have encouraged extensive land clearance for cereal crop production
and intensification of farming practices for high-yield outputs. These five systems are practiced by
over 70% of the population of Africa at the time that the ICRAF report was generated and have
deep roots in historical land management practices (Garrity et al., 2012).
6 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
Like all lifeforms, humans take part in networks of ecological niche construction, whereby
reciprocal choices and actions taken by organisms for subsistence and/or reproduction alter the
habitats of one another. Niche Construction Theory (NCT) argues that a feedback loop develops
between different organisms in an ecosystem in which symbiotic forms of habitat alteration
becomes mutually beneficial to a certain range of organisms, which accelerates over time under
stable climatic conditions (Laland et al., 2016). Using NCT, landscape formation can be viewed as
a multipronged, recursive process in which different actors exert influence on the biome. Returning
to Bell (1982), the occurrence of grazers on nutrient-rich volcanic soils promotes the propagation
of grasses, which, in turn, further encourage the presence of grazers and myriad sympathetic spe-
cies. A critical element of NCT is the concept of ‘ecological inheritance’ in which the evolutionary
dynamics between the components cohabiting a landscape reflect long legacies of natural selection
suited to the co-engineered habitat (Laland et al., 2016).
The practice of agriculture constructs an ecosystem (niche) that is ultimately dependent on the
continuance of its four constituent elements (listed above), however farming practices depend on
critical antecedents from managed landscapes inherited from foragers. Beyond the immediate plot
under cultivation or patch of grass being grazed by a domesticated animal, a regional ecology
called an anthrome evolves in response to the selective pressures exerted via anthropogenesis.
Mapped estimations of anthrome extents in Africa ca. AD 1700 indicate that a relatively small por-
tion of the African continent had been evidentially transformed fully to anthromes by this time
(Figure 1c), however the evidence for ecological transformations is difficult to pinpoint in time and
space (Ellis et al., 2010, 2021). Garrity et al. (2012: 49) largely attribute farming systems in mod-
ern Africa to postcolonial-era rural development programmes and economic structural adjustment
policies, but there is a considerable body of research that finds deep connections between modern
Figure 2. Map of sub-Saharan Africa showing dominant farming systems based on data from Dixon etal.
(2001) and updated by Garrity etal. (2012). Shapefiles published by the Food and Agriculture Organization
of the United Nations (Auricht and Dixon, 2015).
Wright 7
agricultural practice and precolonial farming systems (Altieri et al., 2015; Edwards et al., 1993;
Samberg et al., 2013; Wright et al., 2019). Domesticated landscapes are boundless and recursive,
in a state of constant co-evolution between gradients of wild, feral, domesticated and domesticate-
sympathetic species, and require deep understandings of the subtle ecological drivers that form
landscapes. Given the imprecision of proxy records to understanding past landscape formations,
ecological theory provides a solid foundation to inform the impact of agriculture on landscapes.
Ecologies of fear
This review critically applies historical ecological theory to understand niche formation in the
context of human technological developments beginning with the introduction of farming systems
across the African continent. The Darwinian model of natural selection among organisms is predi-
cated on differential rates of reproduction based on fitness within a trophic system (Darwin, 1859).
According to Darwin and over a century and a half of subsequent evolutionary biological research,
organisms better adapted to an environmental context have a better chance of reproducing com-
pared to those who are not as well adapted. A critical component of the trophic system is the tense
relationship between predators and prey – the former balance the reproductive success of the latter
to maintain quasi-equilibrium when viewed intergenerationally (Brown et al., 1999; Rosenzweig
and MacArthur, 1963). ‘Prey’ in all their various forms have evolved to avoid predation and adopt
elusive strategies to maximize their reproductive fitness. Within the context of the broader land-
scapes they inhabit, this behavioural dynamic is mitigated by the ‘ecology of fear’ in which there
is a continuum between N-driven (population size) versus μ-driven (fear) systems (Brown et al.,
1999; Rosenzweig and MacArthur, 1963). In μ-driven systems, the predator reduces the number of
prey mostly by fear when driving them out of preferred habitat into suboptimal foraging patches
rather than by killing them. Humans have had deep histories of entanglement in the evolutionary
ecologies wherever we go and have profoundly influenced the biology of a wide range of species
based on size- or trait selective harvesting techniques and defaunation dating deep into the
Pleistocene (Sullivan et al., 2017). On a regional level, Thompson et al. (2021a) apply this model
to fire-sculpted ecologies created by foragers in northern Malawi (Figure 3) after 92,000 years ago
(see also, Thompson et al., 2021b). However, fear-based ecologies are not the exclusive domain of
hunter-gatherers.
Human systems of food production have long been recognized as having transformative effects
on the environment (Aschmann, 1973; Helbaek, 1960; Montgomery et al., 1973; Sherratt, 1980).
Land clearance for planting or pasture, water diversion for irrigation and terracing represent three
of the myriad ways in which humans changed the natural land surface agriculture to cultivate food.
The knock-on effects of these activities include enhanced soil erosion and salinity, eutrophication,
deforestation, chaparral growth and eventual urbanization. In addition, the selective removal of
non-productive species (called ‘weeds’ or ‘vermin’ or even ‘predators’) is foundational to the con-
struction of a niche that is good for the perpetuation of farming systems. Modern ecological studies
frame these relationships as human-wildlife conflicts or interactions (e.g. Manfredo and Dayer,
2004), but structural adjustment of wildlife relative to a human presence is as old as the niches
within which we evolved (Sullivan et al., 2017).
Examining the underpinnings of the conversion of the landscape to one in which natural (non-
anthropogenic) processes predominated more of the African continent’s functional ecology to one
in which farming systems (plant and animal agriculture) are the dominant drivers requires a refram-
ing of understanding trophic webs. The question is whether farming systems of the Iron Age, or
earlier, conceptually represent an initial phase of the Anthropocene, which geologists have largely
resolved is the epoch in which we are currently living (Zalasiewicz et al., 2021). Oft-cited counter
8 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
arguments to an early Anthropocene before AD 1950 are that population and impact levels of early
farmers were too low to induce recursive, continental-scale anthropogenic effects (Steffen et al.,
2007), and natural variability in solar radiation and atmospheric CO2 concentrations account for
pre-industrial climate conditions (Steffen et al., 2011). However, early farming techniques involved
Figure 3. Locations of human or palaeoecological reconstruction discussed in order of the text: (a)
Northern Malawi Pleistocene foragers (Thompson etal., 2021b); (b) Fayum Depression (Linseele etal.,
2014); (c) Jebel Moya (Barich, 2014; Brass, 2018; (d) Takarkori (Dunne etal., 2018) and Wadi Teshuinat
(Mercuri, 2008); (e) Tunisian Maghreb (Mulazzani etal., 2016); (f) Mezzak Plateau (Gallinaro and di
Lernia, 2018); (g) Zemmur region (Borrell etal., 2018); (h) El-Khil and Kaf That el-Ghar caves (Martínez-
Sánchez etal., 2018a, 2018b, 2021; (i) GeoB7920-2 sediment core (Dupont and Schefuß, 2018); (j) Lake
Tilla (Salzmann etal., 2002); (k) Selima Oasis (Haynes etal., 1989); (l) Segedim Depression (Schulz,
1994); (m) Ounjougou (Huysecom etal., 2004); (n) Sai Island (Florenzano etal., 2019); (o) Ifri Oudadane
(Morales etal., 2013) and Ifri n’Etsedda (Linstädter etal., 2016); (p) Tin-a-Hanakaten (Aumassip, 1984);
(q) Nile River runoff proxies (Blanchet etal., 2015; Hennekam etal., 2014; (r) Gajiganna (Höhn etal.,
2021); (s) Canary Islands (von Suchodoletz etal., 2010); (t) Mandara Mountains (Diaz etal., 2018);
(u) Butana Group (Out etal., 2016; Winchell etal., 2017; (v) Kintampo Group (Logan and D’Andrea,
2012) (w) Wandakara (Russell etal., 2009); (x) Gourits River terraces (Damm and Hagedorn, 2010) (y)
Garoua (Wright etal., 2017); (z) Iron Age Burkina Faso sites (Höhn and Neumann, 2012) (aa) Laikipia
Plateau (Muiruri etal., 2022); (bb) Gola Forest (Kandeh and Richards, 2011); (cc) Usambara Mountains
(Msuya etal., 2008; Munishi etal., 2008) and coastal Kenyan sites (Culley etal., 2021; Wright, 2007).
Palaeoecological sites are connoted in italicized font and red triangles.
Wright 9
far more land clearance units per capita compared to Industrial-Era agriculture (Ruddiman, 2007;
Ruddiman and Ellis, 2009) and methane production from early farming practices were likely sig-
nificant on a global scale (Fuller et al., 2011). The incomplete nature of the archaeological record,
particularly in Africa, impedes precise scaling of changes in land cover (Kay and Kaplan, 2015;
Morrison et al., 2021), but the anthrome ecologies of today have clear historical antecedents.
The introduction of new trophic dynamics into an ecological system undergoing extrinsically
driven change (e.g. aridification, burning, salinization, grazing) accelerates the race towards reach-
ing a tipping point in which the ecology enters a new biofunctional state (Andersen et al., 2009;
Folke et al., 2004; Kinzig et al., 2006). Behaviourally Modified Trophic Cascades (BMTC) are the
indirect ecological impacts of predation or disturbances that occur outside the zone where direct
impacts are detected (Schmitz et al., 2004). Agricultural technologies, particularly from by plant-
cultivating Iron Age farmers, were accompanied by more settled residential practices. Humans are
alpha predators with advanced lethal technologies that other members of the animal kingdom take
exceptional care to avoid (Frid and Dill, 2002; Zbyryt et al., 2018). Thus, farming settlements were
places for many species of wildlife to avoid, while other sympathetic species such as mice, scav-
enging carnivores and certain species of monkeys are attracted to these zones. In the case of the
introduction of domesticated plants or animals into a novel ecosystem, the direct impacts of land
clearance and husbandry as well as indirect impacts related to human settlement and land investi-
ture associated with agriculture are agents of significant landscape transformation akin to what is
called the Anthropocene, but may be difficult to detect in the palaeoecological record (Braje and
Erlandson, 2013; Ellis, 2011; Ruddiman, 2013). In order to link socio-ecological processes for the
purpose of assessing when, where and how anthromes were created, we must rely on inferences
drawn from places with long archaeo-ecological records from which substantial landscape trans-
formations have been documented and may have been influenced by novel forms of human
technology.
Neolithic pastoral ecologies of northern Africa
There is probably no single ecosystem on Earth that witnessed an ecological transformation in the
pre-Industrial Era at a scale substantially comparable to that which took place in the Sahara during
the Holocene. At 10 ka, the Sahara was a complex mosaic of savannah and forests and hosted thou-
sands of lakes (Hély et al., 2009). This was the so-called AHP – a period of extended high rainfall
across the tropical northern latitudes that was the result of a more northerly placement of the ITCZ
relative to today (DeMenocal and Tierney, 2012; Gasse, 2000). Due to chronic undersampling,
prehistoric precipitation levels are difficult to estimate, but vegetation reconstructions indicate that
the ITCZ was between 5° and 7° north of its present position (Hély et al., 2014). Simulation models
suggest overall precipitation may have been as much as 25% (Kutzbach and Liu, 1997) to 40%
(Prell and Kutzbach, 1987) higher than at present, which is consistent with proxy data (Gasse,
2000; Tierney et al., 2017). The mosaic landscape was discontinuously dotted with wetlands and
small lakes (Quade et al., 2018), which was a significantly more attractive biome for human habita-
tion than present conditions. However, the Sahara is vast and topographically diverse, and there
were many places within the Sahara during the AHP that had ecologies relatively similar to those
that are found today (Hildebrand et al., 2018; Zerboni and Nicoll, 2019).
The timing and geography of the termination of the AHP is a matter of debate with some
proxy evidence indicating an abrupt transition from wet to dry conditions (e.g. Bloszies et al.,
2015; Bristow et al., 2018; Collins et al., 2017; DeMenocal et al., 2000; Salzmann and Hoelzmann,
2005) and some that indicate a slower, step-wise transition (e.g. Francus et al., 2013; Kröpelin
et al., 2008; Lézine et al., 2005; Neumann, 1989; van der Lubbe et al., 2017). Climate models
10 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
consistently underestimate the speed with which many regions of the Sahara became arid rela-
tive to the proxy record (Claussen et al., 2017). Poor parameterization of climate models accounts
for some of the discrepancy and most recently the problems are overcome by structuring in ‘tip-
ping points’ triggered by changes in land-atmospheric feedbacks (Hopcroft and Valdes, 2021),
but the pace of aridification in some portions of northern Africa appears to have exceeded orbital
forcing alone.
Proxy evidence shows a general north-to-south termination of the AHP due to the failure of
the summer monsoon to progressively penetrate inland relative to Atlantic Ocean moisture
sources (Gasse, 2000; Tierney et al., 2017). Concurrent to changes in the moisture balance, there
is a progressive shift in plant community composition from tropical woodland/grassland mosaics
that characterized the AHP to herbaceous, xerophilic communities beginning after 8 ka, but
accelerating between 7.4 and 7 ka (a detailed review of the evidence is provided in Hildebrand
et al., 2018). In the Nubian aquifer of the southeastern Sahara, the presence of evaporitic sedi-
ments indicates aridity beginning ca. 5.7 ka, reaching modern conditions by 4.5 ka (Pachur and
Hoelzmann, 2000). Lake evaluation indexes, analyses of δ18O isotopes and clay mineral charac-
terization from central Mediterranean sapropels, capturing runoff from Libyan, Algerian and
Tunisian drainageways, converge on a general interpretation that termination of the AHP initi-
ated after 6.5 ka with the most intense phase of aridification occurring between 5.5 and 5 ka
(Drake et al., 2018; Wu et al., 2017). Across western Africa, a time-transgressive termination of
the AHP is identified in proxy records from 20.8°N to 5.5°N dating from ca. 5.5 to 3 ka
(DeMenocal et al., 2000; Shanahan et al., 2015). The dominant driver of the transition from
humid to dry conditions was changes in orbital conditions, which displaced the ITCZ from a
more northerly to a more southerly position.
However, the termination of the last AHP is comparatively remarkable because the tempo of the
ecological transition was so variable and spatially discontinuous, particularly in the Sahara (Collins
et al., 2017; Itambi et al., 2010; McGee et al., 2013). A bivariate bagplot of a 3000-year running
average of 3 million years (Myr) of orbital precession (Berger and Loutre, 1991) vs. a northern
African humidity index based on elemental analyses of a Mediterranean sediment core (Grant
et al., 2017) demonstrates that the period from 8.5 to 5 ka is outside the fence of disparity of the
5993 data points analysed (Figure 4). A Cook’s Standard Distance bivariate analysis likewise dem-
onstrates that the terminal AHP in the Holocene was an outlier in relation to normalized climate
parameters over the last 3 Myr (Figure 5). Other outlying climate conditions occurred within the
last ca. 1 Myr, some of which are tied to well-known non-anthropogenic forcing factors (e.g.
Mount Toba eruption of 74 ka) or were during extreme climatic anomalies within the geologic
record (Marine Isotope Stage [MIS]6, MIS5e). It is important to underscore that the discordant
spatial-temporal records of slow versus rapid termination of the AHP confound a simplistic inter-
pretation of broad-brush regional statistical data.
Termination of the last AHP is only one event of many in which there is disparity between
orbital forcing and atmospheric conditions governing precipitation across northern Africa, but
there is at least one potential extrinsic forcing mechanism that differs from previous threshold-
crossing events. In this regard, the introduction of domesticated animals must be considered
when examining tipping points in the ecology of northern Africa and creation of a novel anthro-
pogenic ecosystem. There is some debate on the timing, but it is generally accepted that domes-
ticated animals, including goats (Capra hircus), sheep (Ovis ovis) and cattle (Bos taurus) arrived
in the Fayum Depression from southwestern Asia by 7.35 ka (Figure 3; Linseele et al., 2014)
with potentially earlier occurrences in the surrounding circum-Nile River and Western Desert
regions dating as far back as 8.1 ka (Barich, 2014; Brass, 2018; Osypinska et al., 2021). Evidence
for dairying and intensive wild cereal foraging has been identified from organic residues in
Wright 11
ceramics and palaeobotanical remains from ca. 8 ka at the site of Takarkori in SW Libya, spread-
ing eastward thereafter (Dunne et al., 2018; Mercuri et al., 2018). Neolithic technological com-
plexes are dated to 7.4 ka in the Tunisian Maghreb (Mulazzani et al., 2016), on the Messak
plateau of southwestern Libya from 8.3 ka (Barich, 1998; Gallinaro and di Lernia, 2018), the
Zemmur region in Western Sahara ca. 6.4 ka (Borrell et al., 2018), the El-Khil and Kaf Taht el-
Ghar caves of northern Morocco from 7.4 ka (Martínez-Sánchez et al., 2018a, 2018b, 2021).
Based on the available evidence, there is a general westward and southward expansion of
Neolithic economies from North African points of origin that transpires over the ensuing 2000–
3000 years (di Lernia, 2013; Wright, 2017).
Figure 4. Bivariate bagplot run of 3000-year running averages over 3 Myr of orbital precession (Berger
and Loutre, 1991) versus a northern African humidity index (Grant etal., 2017) in aplpack in R. Values
outside the fence (>2.5-σ) are classified as outliers. Data and R code for the statistical model is available
at https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.16964947.v1.
Figure 5. Cook’s Standard Distance run of 3000-yr running averages over 3 Myr of orbital precession
(Berger and Loutre, 1991) versus a northern African humidity index (Grant etal., 2017) in carData in
R. Outlier values relative to 15× distance to the mean value are identified. Greater Cook’s Standard
Distance indicates greater disparity between orbital and humidity indexes. Data and R code for the
statistical model is available at https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.16964947.v1.
12 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
During the incipient phases of livestock herding in the Sahara, the direct footprint of pastoral
occupation was small because occupations at most sites were ephemeral (Marshall and Hildebrand,
2002). There are indirect forms of evidence such as an increase in the numbers of Steinplätze (fire-
places/hearths) (Gabriel, 1987; Gallinaro, 2018) and population modelling based on gross analysis
of radiocarbon ages (Manning and Timpson, 2014) suggesting that the numbers of sites occupied
by pastoralists during the terminal phases of the AHP may have been equivalent to those of fisher-
hunter-gatherers from the preceding zenith of the AHP. With equivalent numbers of humans living
on a landscape, equivalent ecological impacts should be expected. However, two factors separate
the early and middle Holocene phases of Saharan occupations: (1) the climate was in a precession-
ally driven state of aridification due to the southward displacement of the ITCZ, and (2) livestock
economies were unprecedented features of this landscape.
BMTC theory argues that there will be recursive effects to the ecology of a region with the
introduction of a novel, significant trophic element into a system, which is called ‘turnover’ (Turner
and Gardner, 2015). Trophic systems rely on relative stability of population dynamics, but when a
new species or selective pressure is introduced, there can be a radical reorganization of the system.
Within the context of savannah-forest mosaics, fire produces an open landscape (Scherjon et al.,
2015), which are habitats that animals who have evolved within such mosaics would tend to avoid.
Grazing animals are more vulnerable to predation in open grasslands. The avoidance of open land
as landscapes revegetate following a fire allow floral succession to unfold – primary colonizing
mosses yield to short grass, which yields to tall grasses, which yields to savannah-forest mosaic
(Hoffmann et al., 2012).
The evidence for fire across the Sahara is found throughout the Holocene (Baumhauer et al.,
2004; Marlon et al., 2013) and likely extends deep into the Pleistocene (Hoag and Svenning, 2017).
However, charcoal particles counted from an offshore sediment record adjacent to the western
Sahara show high (>6 × 103 particles cm−3) levels of charcoal during the AHP, which significantly
increases between 7 and 6 ka (10 × 103 particles cm−3) (Dupont and Schefuß, 2018). From 6 to 3 ka,
charcoal levels averaged 4 × 103 particles cm−3, which is attributed to an overall reduction in avail-
able fuel load for burning (Dupont and Schefuß, 2018). A charcoal record from Lake Tilla in north-
eastern Nigeria also finds continuous burning throughout the Holocene with only slight variability
(Salzmann et al., 2002). Neolithic sites at the Selima Oasis in Sudan (Haynes et al., 1989), Segedim
depression in northern Niger (Schulz, 1994) and Ounjougou in southern Mali (Huysecom et al.,
2004) likewise have charcoal records indicative of landscape-scale fires.
Due to their long, continuous presence in the region, fires on the Saharan landscape alone could
not have induced a threshold-crossing event. The presence of grazers in the region also has a deep
evolutionary history. But, ecological turnover is normally catalyzed in multiple ways, and in this
instance is argued to have been forced by a combination of an altered landscape of fear in which
livestock were encouraged to graze in areas that would have previously been avoided in concert
with natural (orbital) climatic changes. Allowing livestock to fodder in a drying or recently burned
grassland would have promoted the growth of shrub vegetation at the expense of grass, which
reduced vegetation transpiration into the atmosphere and enhanced dust entrainment and albedo.
Livestock preferentially feed on grass relative to scrub vegetation (de Leeuw, 1979; McNaughton,
1985), and as they forage across an area, nascent sprouted grass resources will be depleted, which
reduces the overall species diversity and leaves shrubs to predominate an area’s floral ecology
(Huang et al., 2018). Within the context of a drought, seed germination is retarded in favour of
herbaceous sprouters, which further encourages the growth of shrubland at the expense of grass-
lands (Parra and Moreno, 2018). Such a phenomenon reduces the plant functional diversity of a
region, and a qualitative reduction in this metric is the best-fit scenario for present-day climate
models that explain the end of the AHP (Groner et al., 2018; Hopcroft and Valdes, 2021).
Wright 13
In locations where proxy data have been collected, there is ample evidence of rapid ecological
turnover in concert with the introduction of domesticated livestock in areas that were in the process
of undergoing an orbitally-induced transition to more arid conditions. For example, there is a shift
from grassy woodlands to shrubland documented at Sai Island, Sudan and adjacent Nile River
regions concurrent with increasing presence of livestock grazing during the middle Holocene
(Florenzano et al., 2019). The spread of psammophilous shrub vegetation at Wadi Teshuinat in the
Libyan Sahara at the expense of grasses is attributed to aridification of the region in combination
with selective grazing by herbivores, especially after 4.9 ka (Mercuri, 2008). The arrival of domes-
ticated animals at Ifri Oudadane, Morocco at 7.3 ka correlates to a decrease in arboreal pollen and
grasses and an increase in maquis (shrub) vegetation (Morales et al., 2013). At nearby Ifri n’Etsedda,
Morocco between 7.4 and 6.8 ka (Linstädter et al., 2016), and Tin-a-Hanakaten, Algeria at 7.2 ka
(Aumassip, 1984), similar turnovers to non-arboreal pollen taxa at the expense of arboreal pollen
are documented when domesticated animals are first identifiable in the archaeological record. On
a broader scale, sediment proxies from the Nile River between 8.7 to 6 ka show abrupt transitions
between grassy and shrub-dominant conditions within the context of a slow decline in precipitation
(Blanchet et al., 2015; Hennekam et al., 2014). On the other hand, woody savannah biomes such
as Mege, in the floodplain environment of Gajiganna in what is now northeastern Nigeria, have
undetectable changes in the charcoal composition associated with the introduction of livestock
after ca. 3.8 ka and only minor changes with Iron Age settlement after 2.4 ka (Höhn et al., 2021).
The persistence of generally wetter biome until ca. 0.95 ka and different land use practices of the
Chad Basin compared to surrounding areas show that there is no one-size-fits-all model to land-
scape formation in relation to early agricultural practices.
While overall numbers of pastoralists were undoubtedly low in the incipient phases of domesti-
cation, the knock-on effects of localized threshold crossing events can accumulate to impact a
region’s ecology. Zerboni and Nicoll (2019) argue that erosion of desert pavements from trampling
since the Neolithic has enhanced aeolian production, which is a general marker of the Anthropocene
as expressed in northern Africa. Rapid upticks in dust deposition in marine sediment records across
the eastern mid-Atlantic during the Holocene are consistent with a rapid and large-scale retreat in
vegetation and lowering of lakes sufficient to produce an aeolian sediment source (Egerer et al.,
2017, 2018), which temporally correlates with the introduction of livestock into the region.
Anomalous dust flux detected in a 180 ka sediment core in the Canary Islands between 8 and 7 ka
is interpreted as a potential footprint of the expansion of pastoral economies into the western
Sahara, despite a lack of direct evidence for a significant archaeological presence (von Suchodoletz
et al., 2010). A similar uptick in aeolian quartz is also noted in middle to late Holocene ocean sedi-
ment cores adjacent to the western Sahara, which is attributed to potential human disturbances
associated with the introduction of livestock (Pokras and Mix, 1985). On the site level, there is a
significant increase in aeolian activity coeval with the arrival of domesticated animals and decline
in arboreal cover at Tin-a-Hanakaten, Algeria (Aumassip, 1984). An accelerated period of erosion
in a pedo-sedimentary sequence from the foothills of the Mandara Mountains in northern Cameroon
occurs during the Late Holocene, which corresponds to increased archaeological settlement of the
region (Diaz et al., 2018). Model simulations indicate that increased dust flux reduced convective
(summer monsoon) rainfall during the middle Holocene by approximately 13% in the Sahara and
58.6% in the Sahel (Messori et al., 2019; Thompson et al., 2019). Orbital parameters alone insuf-
ficiently explain such anomalies in the long sedimentary records. The spatial discontinuity of the
termination event as captured by models (Hopcroft and Valdes, 2021) and the proxy records
(Adeleye et al., 2021) support the notion that local disturbance ecologies, potentially associated
with human technologies, could have accelerated the tempo and magnitude of some threshold
crossing events during the terminal AHP in northern Africa.
14 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
Late Holocene human ecologies of Africa
While middle Holocene landscape transformations in arid and semi-arid northern Africa associated
with the introduction of domesticated animals represents one potential avenue of anthrome con-
struction, the coeval evolving relationship between humans and plants is another facet of niche
construction to explore. Changes to the composition of plant communities within biomes are foun-
dational to inducing broad-scale ecological succession. Climate variability will exert selective
pressure on different plant taxa, depending on how adapted to the given environment those species
are. However, it is a well-established ecological tenet that trophic systems are in continuous dise-
quilibrium relative to changing climates and balances between prey and predators will fluctuate
according to their evolutionary fitness (Davis, 1986). Within the context of anthropogenic ecolo-
gies this disequilibrium has presented opportunities for highly social niche constructors like our
species to maximize food security. This is because our ability to strategically plan and communi-
cate knowledge intergenerationally has resulted in ecological succession that has, to this point,
provided a net benefit to our evolutionary fitness. However, the broader context of niche construc-
tion and ecological turnover beyond the scope of our immediate habitats are only now becoming
apparent.
Intensive human exploitation of plants in Africa can be traced to the early Holocene (before
10 ka) at sites in the Libyan Sahara (Dunne et al., 2016; Mercuri et al., 2018). During the AHP,
northern Africa was populated by ceramic-using forager-fisher-gatherers who practiced high resi-
dential mobility in the early phases, but transitioned to ‘delayed return’ modes of subsistence dur-
ing the terminal phases of AHP (Gatto and Zerboni, 2015; McDonald, 2016; Stojanowski and
Knudson, 2014). As the landscape transitioned to more arid conditions, increasingly transhumant
forms of subsistence took root in the form of animal pastoralism (see previous section). Traditionally,
it has been argued that animal pastoralism preceded the use of domesticated plants (Marshall and
Hildebrand, 2002), but recent archaeological investigations demonstrated that intensive uses of
plant resources, including wild ancestors of sorghum (Sorghum arundinaceum) by 10 ka the Nile
River Valley (Venkateswaran et al., 2019) and domesticated cereals and pulses (Hordeum vulgare,
Triticum monococcum/dicoccum, Triticum durum, Triticum aestivum/durum, Lens culinaris and
Pisum sativum) appearing by 7–6 ka at Ifri Oudadane, Morocco (Morales et al., 2013), in the
Butana Group at the confluence of the Blue and White Nile rivers (Out et al., 2016; Winchell et al.,
2017). Forms of pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum) were domesticated by 4.9 ka in the western
Sahara (Burgarella et al., 2018) and spread outward after 4.5 ka (Ozainne et al., 2014), but non-
domesticated taxa were utilized by foraging populations for many millennia prior (Kahlheber and
Neumann, 2007; Mercuri et al., 2018). The domestication of African rice (Oryza glaberrima) has
been traced archaeobotanically to between 10 and 2 ka from the Inland Niger Delta region follow-
ing a long process in which climate change and selective propagation culminated in the ultimate
domestication of this specific species (Cubry et al., 2018). Prior to the ultimate domestication of
any plant or animal, the wild ranges of the organisms are widespread and artificial culling and
propagation activities are multilocal. Plant foraging creates an opportunity for niche construction
in which the harvesting of edible plants resulted in modification of the environment favourable to
humans, which reciprocally intensified over time ultimately resulting in domestication of select
species in certain locations. However, the impacts of niche construction are not exclusively con-
fined to emergent domesticate loci.
The Iron Age of Africa is associated with a significant transformation of landscapes into which
it spread, beginning after 5–4.5 ka in the borderlands region of northern Nigeria and Cameroon
where the Bantu language family has its roots and spreading throughout sub-Saharan Africa by 2 ka
(Henn et al., 2008; Koile et al., 2022; Prendergast et al., 2019; Russell et al., 2014). In the initial
Wright 15
phases, Iron Age farmers engaged in mosaic farming practices with adoption of crops like pearl
millet, yams (Dioscorea rotundata) and African rice along with household livestock rearing while
continuing to harvest wild or managed forest and aquatic resources (Lane, 2004; Neumann et al.,
2012). Until recently, limited evidence of anthropogenic disturbance ca. 4 ka in the rainforests of
central Africa and phylogenetic analyses of Bantu languages had indicated that early Iron Age
farmers initially avoided rainforest environments, preferring instead savannah ecosystems
(Grollemund et al., 2015), however more recent phylogeographic analyses have called this hypoth-
esis into question finding evidence for Bantu language expansion into the central Congo rainforests
by 4.4 ka (Koile et al., 2022). The spread of southeast Asian domesticates such as manioc (Manihot
esculenta), bananas (Musa sp.), yams (Dioscorea sp.) and taro (Colocasia esculenta) are believed
to have originated from the northeast of the continent and spread into tropical climes of Africa
between 2.5 and 1.5 ka (Power et al., 2019). The spread of the Iron Age from its homeland in west-
central Africa to the east and eventually south took the form of genetic replacement of indigenous
hunter-gatherer groups in Malawi (Lipson et al., 2022), whereas post 3 ka admixture between
extant pastoralists and hunter-gatherers with late-coming Iron Age farmers in Kenya, Uganda and
Botswana call into question the ‘package migration’ model of farming, iron and Bantu languages
into southern Africa espoused by mid-to-late 20th century archaeologists (Wang et al., 2020).
Instead, farming, land clearance patterns and related technologies are assumed to have spread more
syncretically, manifesting themselves in regionally distinct manners (Crowther et al., 2018).
Mixed foraging/farming practices during the Iron Age were retained deep into the Holocene in
the northern Congo Basin (Bleasdale et al., 2020), at Kintampo sites in central Ghana (Logan and
D’Andrea, 2012) and in the riparian coastal regions of Kenya (Culley et al., 2021; Wright, 2007),
while other regions, particularly in southern Africa, experienced a more complete transformation
into fully domesticated landscapes (Badenhorst, 2011; Davies et al., 2022). The degree to which
iron production is associated with charcoal production and landscape clearance is hotly debated
(Bayon et al., 2012; Garcin et al., 2018; contra Giresse et al., 2018), nevertheless either through
direct or indirect land management processes, the transformation of most of sub-Saharan Africa
into some form of an anthrome before the Industrial Era follows trajectories documented elsewhere
on Earth (Ellis et al., 2020, 2021), largely entrenched by 3 ka (Stephens et al., 2019). Although the
spatial extent of African lands directly under cultivation by 3 ka has been modelled to have been
relatively low (<1%; Cao et al., 2021; Kay and Kaplan, 2015), the knock-on effects of land clear-
ance for food and technological production in prehistory have been estimated as exceeding those
of today (Kaplan et al., 2011; Ruddiman and Ellis, 2009).
Niche construction in the African context involved significant amounts of land clearance in
order to maximize opportunities for desirable species at the expense of myriad economically non-
advantageous plants. However, this form of niche construction had ecological impacts that are
identifiable in regional proxy records. For example, a study of δ13C and δ15N from terrestrial leaf
waxes from Lake Wandakara, Uganda shows acceleration of deforestation and eutrophication ca.
1 ka attributed to human agricultural land management practices (Russell et al., 2009). Soil indura-
tion/ferralitic crust formation and aeolian activation correlate to land clearance across western
Africa (Da Costa et al., 2015). Extensively disturbed ferrosolic agricultural landscapes have been
measured as having reduced biodiversity (Brussaard et al., 2007; Padonou et al., 2015). Long sedi-
ment core records consistently attribute upticks in erosion and sedimentation particularly with Iron
Age land clearance for cultivation (Bayon et al., 2012; Garcin et al., 2018; Neumann et al., 2010).
These correspond to terrestrial records, such as in the Gourits River Basin in Western Cape Province
of South Africa, where initial settlement of herders after 1.6 ka degraded the natural vegetation
cover and correlates to the initiation of a period of sediment erosion, followed by a more substan-
tial period of erosion following European settlement of the region beginning 0.4 ka (Damm and
16 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
Hagedorn, 2010). Furthermore, on a global scale, agricultural farmlands are net contributors of
atmospheric carbon as they reduce the carbon pool, which has added to the rise of temperatures
associated with global warming (Lal, 2001).
Research conducted in the middle Benoué River Valley of northern Cameroon provides a longi-
tudinal view of landscape succession concurrent with the construction of settlement mounds. There
are a total of 39 documented settlement mounds north of the present-day city of Garoua (Wright
et al., 2017). Stable isotopic reconstruction of the landscape around the site of Langui-Tschéboua
demonstrates a significant reduction in the prevalence of woody (C3) vegetation before and after
mound construction (Figure 6; Wright et al., 2019). There are also contrasting ecological impacts
between highland and lowland contexts with the isotopic ecology of the former region retaining
more tree cover following human settlement contemporaneous to lowland contexts (Figure 7;
Wright et al., 2019).
Across western Africa, the identification of anthropogenic parklands resulting from clearance of
woody vegetation occurs in a variety of ecological contexts and can be particularly difficult to
identify in riparian settings particularly when modelled with natural climate variability (Heinrich
and Moldenhauer, 2002; Höhn et al., 2021). Early Iron Age sites from northern Burkina Faso show
widespread cultivation interspersed with long intervals of fallowing from ca. 2 to 1 ka after which
shorter fallow periods and more intensive livestock production as well as decreasing precipitation
resulted in the creation of a more open (grassy) landscape (Höhn and Neumann, 2012). A landscape
succession study on the Laikipia Plateau of central Kenya similarly shows a transition from a
closed forest ecosystem at 2.3 ka to an open woodland/grassland environment by 1.6 ka (Muiruri
et al., 2022) also within a generally drying climate regime (Taylor et al., 2005). Maintenance of an
open landscape using fire and grazing is attested by charcoal and fungal spores after 0.9 ka (Muiruri
et al., 2022) and conforms with recent studies on rangeland/parkland creation and mechanisms of
perpetuation (Phelps et al., 2020; Western et al., 2021). The alteration of habitat, either through
direct forms of land clearance, coppicing and husbandry or as a result of indirect ecologies of fear
from increasing sedentism on mounds or culturally bounded rangelands, has profoundly trans-
formed the landscape of virtually all of sub-Saharan Africa, beginning ca. 5–4.5 ka, accelerating
after 2–1 ka to the point where current ecosystem functionality has been utterly dependent on
humans for at least the last millennium.
Figure 6. δ13C isotopic profile of Langui-Tschéboua settlement mound, Benoué River Valley (Wright
etal., 2019). The regression line is an exponential fit of values from the occupation levels of the mound.
The earlier proxy (5.9 ka) is from the underlying alluvial substrate.
Wright 17
Farming is not intrinsically deleterious to a flourishing ecological system – adverse impacts to
biodiversity are contextual and circumstantial (Muthee et al., 2022). For example, a 7-year study
of shifting cultivation plots in Ivory Coast found profound short-term reductions in microbial com-
munities during periods of cultivation, but once fallowed, bacterial flora in ferrolitic soils recov-
ered to pre-disturbance levels within the cycle of a single rainy season (Persiani et al., 1998). A
similar comparative study of arthropod diversity in southern Benin found high occurrences of
species richness on formerly cultivated (but presently forested) plots (Lachat et al., 2006). A broad
survey of coincident non-human vertebrates and human populations show strong positive correla-
tions between archaeological sites and endemic species richness (Fjeldså and Burgess, 2008).
Studies of regions that receive high amounts of precipitation consistently demonstrate that while
deforestation and soil erosion associated with land clearance and agriculture diminish biodiversity,
flora and fauna inhabiting these regions are resilient provided there are sanctuaries for refugee
populations.
Furthermore, many anthropogenic activities related to agriculture have been documented as
enhancing ecosystem biodiversity and resilience. For example, studies from the Central Rift Valley
of Kenya (Marshall et al., 2018) and Tanzania (Storozum et al., 2021) find long-term augmentation
of fertility within cattle enclosures compared to non-enclosure areas from Pastoral Neolithic con-
texts lasting thousands of years beginning after ca. 4 ka. Studies across western Africa consistently
find soil ‘ripening’ within the context of abandoned villages and settlement mounds (a.k.a. tom-
bondu), which have been compared to the formation of terra preta dark earth soils of the Amazon
Basin (Fairhead and Leach, 2009). Pastoralists are critical for the redistribution of nitrogen and
phosphorus around the landscapes of eastern Africa and the soil and plant communities of the
region have come to depend on them (Augustine, 2003).
Traditional human land management practices can be important components of maintaining and
augmenting biodiversity. The promotion of agroforestry such as honey harvesting, provisioning of
tree byproducts such as fruits or nuts and carbon sequestration services have significantly increased
landscape resilience in the places where they are practiced (Muthee et al., 2022). A comparative
study of managed and unmanaged agricultural lands in Burkina Faso demonstrates that farmers
were crucial agents in conserving cornerstone plants for ecosystem functioning (Nacoulma et al.,
2011). Areas of former human settlement within the Gola Forest, Sierra Leone have higher densi-
ties of extent plant and bird species compared to areas that have no evidence of former occupation
(Kandeh and Richards, 2011). Herders such as the Maasai of eastern Africa are critical agents in
Figure 7. δ15N‰ (vs. AIR) and δ13C‰ (vs. VPDB) for samples collected in onsite (filled shapes) and
offsite (open shapes) samples for Bé (yellow circles), Langui-Tschéboua (black triangles) and GRA-1 (green
squares) (Wright etal., 2019). Standard ellipses generated in the SIBER package in R (Jackson etal., 2011)
at the 95% (2-σ) confidence interval.
18 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
conservation of predatory cats due to the deep cultural connections they have with them (Goldman
et al., 2010). Domestication of wild plant species and arboriculture by farmers in the Usambara
Mountains, Tanzania have been documented as a means of conserving local plant diversity, which
has recursive effects enhancing ex-situ microbial and faunal biodiversity (Msuya et al., 2008;
Munishi et al., 2008). In prehistoric Fayum, limited, selective coppicing of tamarisk (Tamarix sp.)
yielded only minimal disturbances to overall species abundance of different woodland communi-
ties (Marston et al., 2017), similar to the effects reported in the Chad Basin discussed above (Höhn
et al., 2021).
Conclusion
Agriculture and its associated human settlement practices have transformed the African land-
scape on an unprecedented scale in the geologic record, but it did not emerge out of nowhere. If
the Anthropocene is marked by the supplanting of natural geologic formation processes by arti-
ficially (human-) driven processes, there will be no Golden Spike to pound to mark its onset in
Africa. Historical ecologists recognize that anthropogenic landscapes are the result of long and
cumulative processes of human intervention in the life cycle of plants and animals (Armstrong
et al., 2017) and as the continent that has the longest human settlement history, Africa hosts the
oldest anthropogenic landscapes. Over time, the process of landscape domestication has shifted
from selective culling of non-consumable plants via coppicing, burning and weeding and propa-
gation of consumables in the early Holocene to active protection of productive species (e.g.
goats, patches of fertile soil in which favourable plants germinate) in the middle to late Holocene
to one in which there is wholesale clearance of flora and fauna for industrial scale agriculture in
the modern era.
Fundamentally, whether agriculture enhances or diminishes overall biodiversity depends on the
scale of land clearance, complexity of the ambient ecological composition of the landscape and the
degree to which farmers consciously and actively promote conservation of endemic plant and ani-
mal species (Bhagwat et al., 2008; Brussaard et al., 2007; Tscharntke et al., 2005). In some cases,
human intervention into landscape processes result in a net gain for biodiversity, but there are
many instances in which biodiversity incurs a resulting net loss. In other words, conscious self-
removal of humans as the centrepieces of a μ-driven (fear-based) landscape has proven to be criti-
cal for preserving elements of the natural world needed for robust ecosystem functionality.
Ecological systems that have undergone systematic co-evolutionary adaptation to human activ-
ity, which presently includes the vast majority of the earth’s surface and oceans, are now utterly
dependent on humans to sustain them in their present formulations. Just as pre-agricultural forms
of anthropogenesis related to burning and coppicing altered BMTCs via novel recasting of land-
scapes’ ecologies of fear, plant cultivation reorganized relationships between microbial and plant
and animal communities. These impacts are not limited to archaeological sites – they cascade
across biogeographic regions and ecospheres (biosphere, hydrosphere, lithosphere, atmosphere).
These processes are ongoing and confound precise ordination of an Anthropocene epoch using
ecological biomarkers because they occur fluidly across time and space.
Acknowledgements
I have had the distinct privilege of having hundreds of conversations about this topic with innumerable
friends, colleagues and students over the years, and I have learned immensely from each and every one. In
particular, I have gained the most from my conversations with farmers and pastoralists in various parts of
Africa whose deep knowledge of the land they live on has inspired me to dig deeper and deeper to understand
Wright 19
it even a fraction as well as they do. I thank three anonymous reviewers of this paper, editor Robert Costanza
and commenters who have looked at fragments or draft versions over the years.
Funding
The author received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
ORCID iD
David K Wright https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1704-0423
Note
Data and R code for the statistical models are available at https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.16964947.v1.
References
Adeleye MA, Connor SE and Haberle SG (2021) A quantitative synthesis of Holocene vegetation change in
Nigeria (Western Africa). The Holocene 31(11–12): 1681–1689.
Altieri MA, Nicholls CI, Henao A, et al. (2015) Agroecology and the design of climate change-resilient farm-
ing systems. Agronomy for Sustainable Development 35(3): 869–890.
Andersen T, Carstensen J, Hernández-García E, et al. (2009) Ecological thresholds and regime shifts:
Approaches to identification. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 24(1): 49–57.
Anderson NJ, Bugmann H, Dearing JA, et al. (2006) Linking palaeoenvironmental data and models to under-
stand the past and to predict the future. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 21(12): 696–704.
Armstrong CG, Shoemaker AC, McKechnie I, et al. (2017) Anthropological contributions to historical ecol-
ogy: 50 questions, infinite prospects. PLoS One 12(2): e0171883.
Aschmann H (1973) Man’s impact on the several regions with Mediterranean climates. In: di Castri F and
Mooney HA (eds) Mediterranean Type Ecosystems: Origin and Structure. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer,
pp.363–371.
Augustine DJ (2003) Long-term, livestock-mediated redistribution of nitrogen and phosphorus in an East
African savanna. Journal of Applied Ecology 40(1): 137–149.
Aumassip G (1984) Le site de Ti-n-Hanakaten et la néolithisation sur les marges orientales du Sahara central.
Cahiers ORSTOM.Série Géologie 14(2): 201–203.
Auricht C and Dixon J (2015) Africa Farming Systems 2015. Canberra: Food and Agricultural Organization
of the United Nations.
Badenhorst S (2011) Measuring change: Cattle and caprines from Iron Age farming sites in Southern Africa.
The South African Archaeological Bulletin 66(194): 167–172.
Balée W (2006) The research program of historical ecology. Annual Review of Anthropology 35: 75–98.
Barich BE (1998) People, Water and Grain: The Beginning of Domestication in the Sahara and the Nile
Valley. Rome: L’Erma di Bretschneider.
Barich BE (2014) Northwest Libya from the early to late Holocene: New data on environment and subsistence
from the Jebel Gharbi. Quaternary International 320: 15–27.
Baumhauer R, Schulz E and Pomel S (2004) Environmental changes in the central Sahara during the Holocene
- the Mid-Holocene transition from freshwater lake into Sebkha in the Segedim depression, NE Niger.
In: Smykatz-Kloss W and Felix-Henningsen P (eds) Paleoecology of Quaternary Drylands. Berlin,
Heidelberg: Springer, pp.31–45.
Bayon G, Dennielou B, Etoubleau J, et al. (2012) Intensifying weathering and land use in Iron Age Central
Africa. Science 335(6073): 1219–1222.
Bell RHV (1982) The effect of soil nutrient availability on community structure in African ecosystems. In:
Huntley BJ and Walker BH (eds) Ecology of Tropical Savannas. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, pp.193–216.
Berger A and Loutre MF (1991) Insolation values for the climate of the last 10 million years. Quaternary
Science Reviews 10(4): 297–317.
20 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
Bhagwat SA, Willis KJ, Birks HJB, et al. (2008) Agroforestry: A refuge for tropical biodiversity? Trends in
Ecology & Evolution 23(5): 261–267.
Blanchet CL, Frank M and Schouten S (2015) Asynchronous changes in vegetation, runoff and erosion in the
Nile River watershed during the Holocene. PLoS One 9(12): e115958.
Bleasdale M, Wotzka H-P, Eichhorn B, et al. (2020) Isotopic and microbotanical insights into Iron Age agri-
cultural reliance in the Central African rainforest. Communications biology 3(1): 619.
Bloszies C, Forman SL and Wright DK (2015) Water level history for Lake Turkana, Kenya in the past 15,000
years and a variable transition from the African Humid Period to Holocene aridity. Global and Planetary
Change 132: 64–76.
Bogaard A, Allaby R, Arbuckle BS, et al. (2021) Reconsidering domestication from a process archaeology
perspective. World Archaeology 53: 56–77.
Boivin NL, Zeder MA, Fuller DQ, et al. (2016) Ecological consequences of human niche construction:
Examining long-term anthropogenic shaping of global species distributions. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 113(23): 6388–6396.
Borrell F, Alcalde G, Clemente I, et al. (2018) Early Holocene occupations at Ashash Rock Shelter (Zemmur,
Western Sahara). Journal of African Archaeology 16(1): 83–103.
Braje TJ and Erlandson JM (2013) Human acceleration of animal and plant extinctions: A Late Pleistocene,
Holocene, and Anthropocene continuum. Anthropocene 4: 14–23.
Brass M (2018) Early North African cattle domestication and its ecological setting: A reassessment. Journal
of World Prehistory 31(1): 81–115.
Bristow CS, Holmes JA, Mattey D, et al. (2018) A late Holocene palaeoenvironmental ‘snapshot’ of the
Angamma Delta, Lake Megachad at the end of the African Humid Period. Quaternary Science Reviews
202: 182–196.
Brondizio ES, O’Brien K, Bai X, et al. (2016) Re-conceptualizing the Anthropocene: A call for collaboration.
Global Environmental Change 39: 318–327.
Brown JS, Laundre JW and Gurung M (1999) The ecology of fear: Optimal foraging, game theory, and
trophic interactions. Journal of Mammalogy 80(2): 385–399.
Brussaard L, de Ruiter PC and Brown GG (2007) Soil biodiversity for agricultural sustainability. Agriculture
Ecosystems & Environment 121(3): 233–244.
Burdon PD (2020) Obligations in the Anthropocene. Law and Critique 31(3): 309–328.
Burgarella C, Cubry P, Kane NA, et al. (2018) A western Sahara centre of domestication inferred from pearl
millet genomes. Nature Ecology & Evolution 2(9): 1377–1380.
Cao B, Yu L, Li X, et al. (2021) A 1 km global cropland dataset from 10 000 BCE to 2100 CE. Earth System
Science Data 13(11): 5403–5421.
Chorlton LB (2007) Generalized Geology of the World: Bedrock Domains and Major Faults in Gis Format:
A Small-Scale World Geology Map with an Extended Geological Attribute Database, Open File 5529.
Ottawa: Geological Survey of Canada. https://doi.org/10.4095/223767.
Claussen M, Dallmeyer A and Bader J (2017) Theory and modeling of the African Humid Period and the
Green Sahara. In: von Storch H (ed.) Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Climate Science. Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
Collins JA, Prange M, Caley T, et al. (2017) Rapid termination of the African Humid Period triggered by
northern high-latitude cooling. Nature Communications 8(1): 1372.
Crowther A, Prendergast ME, Fuller DQ, et al. (2018) Subsistence mosaics, forager-farmer interactions,
and the transition to food production in eastern Africa. Quaternary International 489: 101–120.
Crumley CL (2021) Historical Ecology: A robust bridge between archaeology and ecology. Sustainability
13(15): 8210.
Crutzen PJ and Stoermer EF (2000) The “Anthropocene”. IGBP Newsletter 41: 17–18.
Cubry P, Tranchant-Dubreuil C, Thuillet AC, et al. (2018) The rise and fall of African rice cultivation revealed
by analysis of 246 new genomes. Current Biology 28(14): 2274–2282.
Culley C, Janzen A, Brown S, et al. (2021) Iron Age hunting and herding in coastal eastern Africa: ZooMS
identification of domesticates and wild bovids at Panga ya Saidi, Kenya. Journal of Archaeological
Science 130: 105368.
Wright 21
Da Costa PYD, Nguetnkam J-P, Mvoubou CM, et al. (2015) Old landscapes, pre-weathered materials, and
pedogenesis in tropical Africa: How can the time factor of soil formation be assessed in these regions?
Quaternary International 376: 47–74.
Damm B and Hagedorn J (2010) Holocene floodplain formation in the southern Cape region, South Africa.
Geomorphology 122(3–4): 213–222.
Darwin C (1859) On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection. London: John Murray.
Davies B, Power MJ, Braun DR, et al. (2022) Fire and human management of late Holocene ecosystems in
southern Africa. Quaternary Science Reviews 289: 107600.
Davis MB (1986) Climatic instability, time lags, and community disequilibrium. In: Diamond J and Case T
(eds) Community Ecology. New York, NY: Harper & Row, pp.269–284.
de Leeuw PN (1979) Species preferences of domestic ruminants grazing Nigerian savannah. In: Ajayi SS
and Healstead LB (eds) Wildlife Management in Savanna Woodland. London: Taylor and Francis,
pp.110–122.
DeMenocal P, Ortiz J, Guilderson T, et al. (2000) Abrupt onset and termination of the African Humid Period:
Rapid climate responses to gradual insolation forcing. Quaternary Science Reviews 19(1–5): 347–361.
DeMenocal P and Tierney J (2012) Green Sahara: African humid periods paced by earth’s orbital changes.
Nature Education Knowledge 3(10): 12.
Diaz N, Dietrich F, Sebag D, et al. (2018) Pedo-sedimentary constituents as paleoenvironmental proxies in
the Sudano-Sahelian belt during the Late Quaternary (southwestern Chad Basin). Quaternary Science
Reviews 191: 348–362.
di Lernia S (2013) The emergence and spread of herding in northern Africa: Critical reappraisal. In: Mitchell
P and Lane PJ (eds) The Oxford Handbook of African Archaeology. Oxford: Oxford University Press,
pp.523–536.
Dixon J, Gulliver A and Gibbon D (2001) Farming systems and poverty: Improving farmers’ livelihoods in
a changing world. Report no. 63492. Rome and Washington, DC: Food and Agriculture Organization
& World Bank.
Drake NA, Lem RE, Armitage SJ, et al. (2018) Reconstructing palaeoclimate and hydrological fluctuations
in the Fezzan basin (southern Libya) since 130 ka: A catchment-based approach. Quaternary Science
Reviews 200: 376–394.
Dunne J, di Lernia S, Chłodnicki M, et al. (2018) Timing and pace of dairying inception and animal hus-
bandry practices across Holocene North Africa. Quaternary International 471: 147–159.
Dunne J, Mercuri AM, Evershed RP, et al. (2016) Earliest direct evidence of plant processing in prehistoric
Saharan pottery. Nature Plants 3: 16194.
Dupont LM and Schefuß E (2018) The roles of fire in Holocene ecosystem changes of West Africa. Earth and
Planetary Science Letters 481: 255–263.
Edwards CA, Grove TL, Harwood RR, et al. (1993) The role of agroecology and integrated farming systems
in agricultural sustainability. Agriculture Ecosystems & Environment 46(1–4): 99–121.
Egerer S, Claussen M, Reick C, et al. (2017) Could gradual changes in Holocene Saharan landscape have
caused the observed abrupt shift in North Atlantic dust deposition? Earth and Planetary Science Letters
473: 104–112.
Egerer S, Claussen M and Reick C (2018) Rapid increase in simulated North Atlantic dust deposition due to
fast change of northwest African landscape during the Holocene. Climate of the Past 14: 1051–1066.
Ellis EC (2011) Anthropogenic transformation of the terrestrial biosphere. Philosophical Transactions of the
Royal Society of London A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences 369(1938): 1010–1035.
Ellis EC, Beusen AHW and Goldewijk KK (2020) Anthropogenic biomes: 10,000 BCE to 2015 CE. Land
9(5): 129.
Ellis EC, Gauthier N, Klein Goldewijk K, et al. (2021) People have shaped most of terrestrial nature for at
least 12,000 years. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
118(17): e2023483118.
Ellis EC, Klein Goldewijk K, Siebert S, et al. (2010) Anthropogenic transformation of the biomes, 1700 to
2000. Global Ecology and Biogeography 19(5): 589–606.
22 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
Fairhead J and Leach M (2009) Amazonian Dark Earths in Africa? In: Woods WI, Teixeira WG, Lehmann J,
et al. (eds) Amazonian Dark Earths: Wim Sombroek’s Vision. Dordrecht: Springer, pp.265–278.
Fick SE and Hijmans RJ (2017) WorldClim 2: New 1-km spatial resolution climate surfaces for global land
areas. International Journal of Climatology 37(12): 4302–4315.
Fjeldså J and Burgess ND (2008) The coincidence of biodiversity patterns and human settlement in Africa.
African Journal of Ecology 46(s1): 33–42.
Flannery KV (1968) Archaeological systems theory and early Mesoamerica. In: Meggars B (ed.)
Anthropological Archaeology in the Americas. Washington, DC: Anthropological Society of Washington,
pp.67–86.
Florenzano A, Mercuri AM, Fornaciari R, et al. (2019) Plants, water and humans: Pollen analysis from
Holocene archaeological sites on Sai Island, northern Sudan. Palynology 43: 22–33.
Folke C, Carpenter S, Walker B, et al. (2004) Regime shifts, resilience, and biodiversity in ecosystem man-
agement. Annual Review of Ecology Evolution and Systematics 35: 557–581.
Francus P, von Suchodoletz H, Dietze M, et al. (2013) Varved sediments of Lake Yoa (Ounianga Kebir,
Chad) reveal progressive drying of the Sahara during the last 6100 years. Sedimentology 60(4): 911–934.
Fraser DGE, Termansen M, Sun N, et al. (2007) Using past climate variability to understand how food systems
are resilient to future climate change. In: Zollitsch W, Winckler C, Waiblinger S, et al. (eds) Sustainable
Food Production and Ethics. Vienna, Austria: Wageningen Academic Publishers, pp.139–144.
Frid A and Dill LM (2002) Human-caused disturbance stimuli as a form of predation risk. Conservation
Ecology 6(1): 11.
Fuller DQ, van Etten J, Manning K, et al. (2011) The contribution of rice agriculture and livestock pastoralism
to prehistoric methane levels: An archaeological assessment. The Holocene 21(5): 743–759.
Gabriel B (1987) Palaeoecological evidence from Neolithic fireplaces in the Sahara. African Archaeological
Review 5(1): 93–103.
Gallinaro M (2018) Mobility and Pastoralism in the Egyptian Western Desert: Steinplätze in the Holocene
Regional Settlement Patterns. Rome: All’Insegna del Giglio, Sapienza Universitá di Roma.
Gallinaro M and di Lernia S (2018) Trapping or tethering stones (TS): A multifunctional device in the Pastoral
Neolithic of the Sahara. PLoS One 13(1): e0191765.
Garcin Y, Deschamps P, Ménot G, et al. (2018) Early anthropogenic impact on western Central African rain-
forests 2,600 y ago. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
115(13): 3261–3266.
Garrity D, Dixon J and Boffa J-M (2012) Understanding African Farming Systems: Science and Policy
Implications. Sydney: Australian International Food Security Centre.
Gasse F (2000) Hydrological changes in the African tropics since the Last Glacial Maximum. Quaternary
Science Reviews 19(1–5): 189–211.
Gatto MC and Zerboni A (2015) Holocene supra-regional environmental changes as trigger for major socio-
cultural processes in northeastern Africa and the Sahara. African Archaeological Review 32(2): 301–333.
Gibbard PL and Lewin J (2016) Partitioning the Quaternary. Quaternary Science Reviews 151: 127–139.
Giresse P, Maley J, Doumenge C, et al. (2018) Paleoclimatic changes are the most probable causes of the
rainforest crises 2,600 y ago in Central Africa. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the
United States of America 115(29): E6672–E6673.
Goldman MJ, Roque De Pinho J and Perry J (2010) Maintaining complex relations with large cats: Maasai
and lions in Kenya and Tanzania. Human Dimensions of Wildlife 15(5): 332–346.
Grant KM, Rohling EJ, Westerhold T, et al. (2017) A 3 million year index for North African humidity/aridity
and the implication of potential pan-African humid periods. Quaternary Science Reviews 171: 100–118.
Grollemund R, Branford S, Bostoen K, et al. (2015) Bantu expansion shows that habitat alters the route and
pace of human dispersals. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of
America 112(43): 13296–13301.
Groner VP, Raddatz T, Reick CH, et al. (2018) Plant functional diversity affects climate–vegetation interac-
tion. Biogeosciences 15(7): 1947–1968.
Harris DR (2007) An evolutionary continuum of people–plant interaction. In: Denham T and White P (eds)
The Emergence of Agriculture. New York, NY: Routledge, pp.26–44.
Wright 23
Haynes CV, Eyles CH, Pavlish LA, et al. (1989) Holocene palaeoecology of the eastern Sahara; Selima Oasis.
Quaternary Science Reviews 8: 109–136.
Heinrich J and Moldenhauer K-M (2002) Climatic and anthropogenic induced landscape degradations of
West African dry savanna environments during the later Holocene. Quaternary International 93–94:
127–137.
Helbaek H (1960) Ecological effects of irrigation in ancient Mesopotamia. Iraq 22(1–2): 186–196.
Hély C, Braconnot P, Watrin J, et al. (2009) Climate and vegetation: Simulating the African Humid Period.
Comptes Rendus Geoscience 341(8–9): 671–688.
Hély C, Lézine AM and Contributors A (2014) Holocene changes in African vegetation: Tradeoff between
climate and water availability. Climate of the Past 10(2): 681–686.
Henn BM, Gignoux C, Lin AA, et al. (2008) Y-chromosomal evidence of a pastoralist migration through
Tanzania to southern Africa. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of
America 105(31): 10693–10698.
Hennekam R, Jilbert T, Schnetger B, et al. (2014) Solar forcing of Nile discharge and sapropel S1 formation
in the early to middle Holocene eastern Mediterranean. Paleoceanography 29(5): 343–356.
Hession SL and Moore N (2011) A spatial regression analysis of the influence of topography on monthly
rainfall in East Africa. International Journal of Climatology 31(10): 1440–1456.
Hildebrand E, Garcea EAA, Florenzano A, et al. (2018) Multiscalar perspectives on Holocene climatic and
environmental changes in the Sahara and Nile corridor, with special consideration of archaeological sites
on Sai Island, Sudan. In: Mercuri AM, D’Andrea AC, Fornaciari R et al. (eds) Plants and People in the
African Past: Progress in African Archaeobotany. Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp.215–245.
Hoag C and Svenning J-C (2017) African environmental change from the Pleistocene to the Anthropocene.
Annual Review of Environment and Resources 42(1): 27–54.
Hoffmann WA, Geiger EL, Gotsch SG, et al. (2012) Ecological thresholds at the savanna-forest boundary:
how plant traits, resources and fire govern the distribution of tropical biomes. Ecology Letters 15(7):
759–768.
Höhn A, Breunig P, Gronenborn D, et al. (2021) After the flood and with the people – Late Holocene changes
of the woody vegetation in the southwestern Chad Basin, Nigeria. Quaternary International 593–594:
224–235.
Höhn A and Neumann K (2012) Shifting cultivation and the development of a cultural landscape during the
Iron Age (0–1500 AD) in the northern Sahel of Burkina Faso, West Africa: Insights from archaeological
charcoal. Quaternary International 249: 72–83.
Hopcroft PO and Valdes PJ (2021) Paleoclimate-conditioning reveals a North Africa land–atmosphere tip-
ping point. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 118(45):
e2108783118.
Huang Y, Wang K, Deng B, et al. (2018) Effects of fire and grazing on above-ground biomass and species
diversity in recovering grasslands in northeast China. Journal of Vegetation Science 29(4): 629–639.
Huysecom E, Ozainne S, Raeli F, et al. (2004) Ounjougou (Mali): A history of Holocene settlement at the
southern edge of the Sahara. Antiquity 78(301): 579–593.
Itambi AC, von Dobeneck T and Adegbie AT (2010) Millennial-scale precipitation changes over Central
Africa during the late Quaternary and holocene: Evidence in sediments from the Gulf of Guinea. Journal
of Quaternary Science 25(3): 267–279.
Jackson AL, Inger R, Parnell AC, et al. (2011) Comparing isotopic niche widths among and within communi-
ties: SIBER - stable isotope Bayesian ellipses in R. Journal of Animal Ecology 80(3): 595–602.
Kahlheber S and Neumann K (2007) The development of plant cultivation in semi-arid West Africa. In: Denham
TP, Iriarte J and Vrydaghs L (eds) Rethinking Agriculture: Archaeological and Ethnoarchaeological
Perspectives. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press, pp.320–346.
Kandeh HBS and Richards P (2011) Rural people as conservationists: Querying neo-Malthusian assumptions
about biodiversity in Sierra Leone. Africa 66(1): 90–103.
Kaplan JO, Krumhardt KM, Ellis EC, et al. (2011) Holocene carbon emissions as a result of anthropogenic
land cover change. The Holocene 21(5): 775–791.
24 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
Kay AU and Kaplan JO (2015) Human subsistence and land use in sub-Saharan Africa, 1000 BC to AD 1500:
A review, quantification, and classification. Anthropocene 9: 14–32.
Kendall A and Drew D (2019) The rehabilitation of pre-Hispanic agricultural infrastructure to support rural
development in the Peruvian Andes: The work of the Cusichaca Trust. In: Isendahl C and Stump D
(eds) The Oxford Handbook of Historical Ecology and Applied Archaeology. Oxford: Oxford University
Press, pp.422–440.
Kinzig AP, Ryan P, Etienne M, et al. (2006) Resilience and regime shifts: Assessing cascading effects.
Ecology and Society 11(1): 20.
Koile E, Greenhill SJ, Blasi DE, et al. (2022) Phylogeographic analysis of the Bantu language expansion sup-
ports a rainforest route. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
119(32): e2112853119.
Kröpelin S, Verschuren D, Lézine AM, et al. (2008) Climate-driven ecosystem succession in the Sahara: The
past 6000 years. Science 320(5877): 765–768.
Kusimba SB (2005) What is a hunter-gatherer? Variation in the archaeological record of eastern and southern
Africa. Journal of Archaeological Research 13(4): 337–366.
Kutzbach JE and Liu Z (1997) Response of the African monsoon to orbital forcing and ocean feedbacks in the
middle Holocene. Science 278(5337): 440–443.
Lachat T, Attignon S, Djego J, et al. (2006) Arthropod diversity in Lama forest reserve (South Benin), a
mosaic of natural, degraded and plantation forests. In: Hawksworth DL and Bull AT (eds) Arthropod
Diversity and Conservation. Dordrecht: Springer, pp.3–23.
Laland K, Matthews B and Feldman MW (2016) An introduction to niche construction theory. Evolutionary
Ecology 30(2): 191–202.
Lal R (2001) World cropland soils as a source or sink for atmospheric carbon. In: Sparks DL (ed.) Advances
in Agronomy, vol. 71. San Diego, CA: Academic Press, pp.145–191.
Lane PJ (2004) The ‘moving frontier’ and the transition to food production in Kenya. Azania 39: 243–264.
Lane PJ (2010) Developing landscape historical ecologies in eastern Africa: An outline of current research
and potential future directions. African Studies 69(2): 299–322.
Lane PJ (2019) Just how long does ‘long-term’ have to be?: Matters of temporal scale as impediments to
interdisciplinary understanding in historical ecology. In: Isendahl C and Stump D (eds) The Oxford
Handbook of Historical Ecology and Applied Archaeology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.49–71.
Lewis SL and Maslin MA (2015) Defining the Anthropocene. Nature 519(7542): 171–180.
Lézine A-M, Duplessy J-C and Cazet J-P (2005) West African monsoon variability during the last deglacia-
tion and the Holocene: Evidence from fresh water algae, pollen and isotope data from core KW31, Gulf
of Guinea. Palaeogeography Palaeoclimatology Palaeoecology 219(3–4): 225–237.
Linseele V, Van Neer W, Thys S, et al. (2014) New archaeozoological data from the Fayum “Neolithic” with
a critical assessment of the evidence for early stock keeping in Egypt. PLoS One 9(10): e108517.
Linstädter J, Kehl M, Broich M, et al. (2016) Chronostratigraphy, site formation processes and pollen record
of Ifri n’Etsedda, NE Morocco. Quaternary International 410: 6–29.
Lipson M, Sawchuk EA, Thompson JC, et al. (2022) Ancient DNA and deep population structure in sub-
Saharan African foragers. Nature 603(7900): 290–296.
Logan AL and D’Andrea AC (2012) Oil palm, arboriculture, and changing subsistence practices during
Kintampo times (3600–3200 BP, Ghana). Quaternary International 249: 63–71.
Malm A and Hornborg A (2014) The geology of mankind? A critique of the Anthropocene narrative. The
Anthropocene Review 1(1): 62–69.
Manfredo MJ and Dayer AA (2004) Concepts for exploring the social aspects of human–wildlife conflict in
a global context. Human Dimensions of Wildlife 9(4): 1–20.
Manning K and Timpson A (2014) The demographic response to Holocene climate change in the Sahara.
Quaternary Science Reviews 101: 28–35.
Marlon JR, Bartlein PJ, Daniau A-L, et al. (2013) Global biomass burning: A synthesis and review of
Holocene paleofire records and their controls. Quaternary Science Reviews 65: 5–25.
Marshall F and Hildebrand E (2002) Cattle before crops: The beginnings of food production in Africa. Journal
of World Prehistory 16(2): 99–143.
Wright 25
Marshall F, Reid REB, Goldstein S, et al. (2018) Ancient herders enriched and restructured African grass-
lands. Nature 561: 387–390.
Marston JM, Holdaway SJ and Wendrich W (2017) Early- and middle-Holocene wood exploitation in the
Fayum basin, Egypt. The Holocene 27(12): 1812–1824.
Martínez-Sánchez RM, Vera Rodríguez JC, Peña-Chocarro L, et al. (2018a) The Middle Neolithic of
Morocco’s north-western Atlantic strip: New evidence from the El-Khil Caves (Tangier). African
Archaeological Review 35(3): 417–442.
Martínez-Sánchez RM, Vera-Rodríguez JC, Pérez-Jordà G, et al. (2018b) The beginning of the Neolithic in
northwestern Morocco. Quaternary International 470: 485–496.
Martínez-Sánchez RM, Vera-Rodríguez JC, Pérez-Jordà G, et al. (2021) Revisiting the Epipalaeolithic-
Neolithic transition in the extreme NW of Africa: The latest results of the chronological sequence of the
cave of Kaf Taht el-Ghar (Tétouan, Morocco). African Archaeological Review 38(2): 251–274.
McDonald MMA (2016) The pattern of neolithization in Dakhleh Oasis in the Eastern Sahara. Quaternary
International 410: 181–197.
McGee D, DeMenocal PB, Winckler G, et al. (2013) The magnitude, timing and abruptness of changes in
North African dust deposition over the last 20,000yr. Earth and Planetary Science Letters 371–372:
163–176.
McNaughton SJ (1985) Ecology of a grazing ecosystem: The Serengeti. Ecological Monographs 55(3):
259–294.
Mercuri AM (2008) Human influence, plant landscape evolution and climate inferences from the archaeo-
botanical records of the Wadi Teshuinat area (Libyan Sahara). Journal of Arid Environments 72(10):
1950–1967.
Mercuri AM, Fornaciari R, Gallinaro M, et al. (2018) Plant behaviour from human imprints and the cultiva-
tion of wild cereals in Holocene Sahara. Nature Plants 4(2): 71–81.
Messori G, Gaetani M, Zhang Q, et al. (2019) The water cycle of the mid-Holocene West African mon-
soon: The role of vegetation and dust emission changes. International Journal of Climatology 39(4):
1927–1939.
Montgomery E, Bennett JW and Scudder T (1973) The impact of human activities on the physical and social
environments: New directions in anthropological ecology. Annual Review of Anthropology 2(1): 27–61.
Morales J, Pérez-Jordà G, Peña-Chocarro L, et al. (2013) The origins of agriculture in north-West Africa:
Macro-botanical remains from Epipalaeolithic and early neolithic levels of Ifri Oudadane (Morocco).
Journal of Archaeological Science 40(6): 2659–2669.
Morrison KD, Hammer E, Boles O, et al. (2021) Mapping past human land use using archaeological data:
A new classification for global land use synthesis and data harmonization. PLoS One 16(4): e0246662.
Msuya TS, Mndolwa MA and Kapinga C (2008) Domestication: An indigenous method in conserving plant
diversity on farmlands in west Usambara Mountains, Tanzania. African Journal of Ecology 46(s1):
74–78.
Muiruri V, Marchant R, Rucina SM, et al. (2022) Late Holocene environmental change and anthropogenic:
Ecosystem interaction on the Laikipia Plateau, Kenya. Ambio 51: 785–798.
Mulazzani S, Belhouchet L, Salanova L, et al. (2016) The emergence of the Neolithic in North Africa: A new
model for the Eastern Maghreb. Quaternary International 410: 123–143.
Munishi PKT, Philipina F, Temu RPC, et al. (2008) Tree species composition and local use in agricultural
landscapes of west Usambaras Tanzania. African Journal of Ecology 46(s1): 66–73.
Muthee K, Duguma L, Majale C, et al. (2022) A quantitative appraisal of selected agroforestry studies in the
Sub-Saharan Africa. Heliyon 8(9): e10670.
Nacoulma BMI, Schumann K, Traoré S, et al. (2011) Impacts of land-use on West African savanna vegetation:
A comparison between protected and communal area in Burkina Faso. Biodiversity and Conservation
20(14): 3341–3362.
Neumann FH, Scott L, Bousman CB, et al. (2010) A Holocene sequence of vegetation change at Lake Eteza,
coastal KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology 162: 39–53.
Neumann K (1989) Holocene vegetation of the eastern Sahara: charcoal from prehistoric sites. African
Archaeological Review 7(1): 97–116.
26 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
Neumann K, Bostoen K, Höhn A, et al. (2012) First farmers in the Central African rainforest: A view from
southern Cameroon. Quaternary International 249: 53–62.
Nogués-Bravo D, Rodríguez-Sánchez F, Orsini L, et al. (2018) Cracking the code of biodiversity responses to
past climate change. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 33(10): 765–776.
Osypinska M, Osypinski P, Belka Z, et al. (2021) Wild and domestic cattle in the ancient Nile Valley: Marks
of ecological change. Journal of Field Archaeology 46(7): 429–447.
Out WA, Ryan P, García-Granero JJ, et al. (2016) Plant exploitation in Neolithic Sudan: A review in the light
of new data from the cemeteries R12 and Ghaba. Quaternary International 412: 36–53.
Ozainne S, Lespez L, Garnier A, et al. (2014) A question of timing: Spatio-temporal structure and mecha-
nisms of early agriculture expansion in West Africa. Journal of Archaeological Science 50: 359–368.
Pachur HJ and Hoelzmann P (2000) Late Quaternary palæoecology and palæoclimates of the eastern Sahara.
Journal of African Earth Sciences 30(4): 929–939.
Padonou EA, Lykke AM, Bachmann Y et al. (2015) Bowalization: Its impact on soil, biodiversity, and human
livelihoods in West Africa. In: Daniels JA (ed.) Advances in Environmental Research. New York, NY:
Nova Science Publishers, pp.187–198.
Parra A and Moreno JM (2018) Drought differentially affects the post-fire dynamics of seeders and resprout-
ers in a Mediterranean shrubland. The Science of the Total Environment 626: 1219–1229.
Persiani AM, Maggi O, Casado MA, et al. (1998) Diversity and variability in soil fungi from a disturbed tropi-
cal rain forest. Mycologia 90(2): 206–214.
Phelps LN, Chevalier M, Shanahan TM, et al. (2020) Asymmetric response of forest and grassy biomes to cli-
mate variability across the African Humid Period: Influenced by anthropogenic disturbance? Ecography
43: 1118–1142.
Pokras EM and Mix AC (1985) Eolian evidence for spatial variability of late Quaternary climates in tropical
Africa. Quaternary Research 24(2): 137–149.
Potts R (1996) Evolution and climate variability. Science 273: 922–923.
Power RC, Güldemann T, Crowther A, et al. (2019) Asian crop dispersal in Africa and late Holocene human
adaptation to tropical environments. Journal of World Prehistory 32(4): 353–392.
Prell WL and Kutzbach JE (1987) Monsoon variability over the past 150,000 years. Journal of Geophysical
Research 92(D7): 8411–8425.
Prendergast ME, Lipson M, Sawchuk EA, et al. (2019) Ancient DNA reveals a multistep spread of the first
herders into sub-Saharan Africa. Science 365(6448): eaaw6275.
Quade J, Dente E, Armon M, et al. (2018) Megalakes in the Sahara? A review. Quaternary Research 90:
253–275.
Rosenzweig ML and MacArthur RH (1963) Graphical representation and stability conditions of predator-prey
interactions. The American Naturalist 97(895): 209–223.
Ruddiman WF (2007) The early anthropogenic hypothesis: Challenges and responses. Reviews of Geophysics
45(4): RG4001.
Ruddiman WF (2013) The Anthropocene. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences 41(1): 45–68.
Ruddiman WF and Ellis EC (2009) Effect of per-capita land use changes on Holocene forest clearance and
CO2 emissions. Quaternary Science Reviews 28(27–28): 3011–3015.
Russell JM, McCoy SJ, Verschuren D, et al. (2009) Human impacts, climate change, and aquatic ecosystem
response during the past 2000 yr at Lake Wandakara, Uganda. Quaternary Research 72(3): 315–324.
Russell T, Silva F and Steele J (2014) Modelling the spread of farming in the Bantu-speaking regions of
Africa: An archaeology-based phylogeography. PLoS One 9(1): e87854.
Salzmann U and Hoelzmann P (2005) The Dahomey gap: An abrupt climatically induced rain forest fragmen-
tation in West Africa during the late Holocene. The Holocene 15(2): 190–199.
Salzmann U, Hoelzmann P and Morczinek I (2002) Late Quaternary climate and vegetation of the Sudanian
zone of northeast Nigeria. Quaternary Research 58(1): 73–83.
Samberg LH, Shennan C and Zavaleta E (2013) Farmer seed exchange and crop diversity in a changing agri-
cultural landscape in the southern highlands of Ethiopia. Human Ecology 41(3): 477–485.
Scherjon F, Bakels C, MacDonald K, et al. (2015) Burning the land: An ethnographic study of off-site fire
use by current and historically documented foragers and implications for the interpretation of past fire
practices in the landscape. Current Anthropology 56(3): 299–326.
Wright 27
Schmitz OJ, Krivan V and Ovadia O (2004) Trophic cascades: The primacy of trait-mediated indirect interac-
tions. Ecology Letters 7(2): 153–163.
Schulz E (1994) The southern limit of the Mediterranean vegetation in the Sahara during the Holocene.
Historical Biology 9(1–2): 137–156.
Shanahan TM, McKay NP, Hughen KA, et al. (2015) The time-transgressive termination of the African
Humid Period. Nature Geoscience 8(2): 140–144.
Sherratt A (1980) Water, soil and seasonality in early cereal cultivation. World Archaeology 11(3): 313–330.
Sinclair P, Isendahl C and Barthel S (2019) Beyond rhetoric: Towards a framework for an applied histori-
cal ecology of urban planning. In: Isendahl C and Stump D (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Historical
Ecology and Applied Archaeology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.524–539.
Steffen W, Broadgate W, Deutsch L, et al. (2015) The trajectory of the Anthropocene: The Great Acceleration.
The Anthropocene Review 2(1): 81–98.
Steffen W, Crutzen J and McNeill JR (2007) The Anthropocene: Are humans now overwhelming the great
forces of nature? AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment 36(8): 614–621.
Steffen W, Grinevald J, Crutzen P, et al. (2011) The Anthropocene: conceptual and historical perspectives.
Philosophical Transactions of The Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences
369(1938): 842–867.
Stephens L, Fuller D, Boivin N, et al. (2019) Archaeological assessment reveals Earth’s early transformation
through land use. Science 365(6456): 897.
Stojanowski CM and Knudson KJ (2014) Changing patterns of mobility as a response to climatic deterioration
and aridification in the middle Holocene southern Sahara. American Journal of Physical Anthropology
154(1): 79–93.
Storozum MJ, Goldstein ST, Contreras DA, et al. (2021) The influence of ancient herders on soil development
at Luxmanda, Mbulu Plateau, Tanzania. CATENA 204: 105376.
Sullivan AP, Bird DW and Perry GH (2017) Human behaviour as a long-term ecological driver of non-human
evolution. Nature Ecology & Evolution 1: 0065.
Taylor D, Lane PJ, Muiruri V, et al. (2005) Mid- to late-Holocene vegetation dynamics on the Laikipia
Plateau, Kenya. The Holocene 15(6): 837–846.
Terrell JE, Hart JP, Barut S, et al. (2003) Domesticated landscapes: The subsistence ecology of plant and
animal domestication. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 10(4): 323–368.
Thompson AJ, Skinner CB, Poulsen CJ, et al. (2019) Modulation of mid-Holocene African rainfall by dust
aerosol direct and indirect effects. Geophysical Research Letters 46(7): 3917–3926.
Thompson JC, Wright DK and Ivory SJ (2021a) The emergence and intensification of early hunter-gatherer
niche construction. Evolutionary Anthropology Issues News and Reviews 30(1): 17–27.
Thompson JC, Wright DK, Ivory SJ, et al. (2021b) Early human impacts and ecosystem reorganization in
southern-central Africa. Science Advances 7(19): eabf9776.
Tiercelin J-J and Lezzar K-E (2002) A 300 million years history of Rift Lakes in Central and East Africa: An
updated broad review. In: Odada EO and Olago DO (eds) The East African Great Lakes: Limnology,
Palaeolimnology and Biodiversity. Dordrecht: Springer, pp.3–60.
Tierney JE, Pausata FS and DeMenocal PB (2017) Rainfall regimes of the Green Sahara. Science Advances
3(1): e1601503.
Tscharntke T, Klein AM, Kruess A, et al. (2005) Landscape perspectives on agricultural intensification and
biodiversity – ecosystem service management. Ecology Letters 8(8): 857–874.
Turner MG and Gardner RH (2015) Organisms and landscape pattern. In: Turner MG and Gardner RH (eds)
Landscape Ecology in Theory and Practice: Pattern and Process. New York, NY: Springer, pp.229–285.
van der Lubbe HJ, Krause-Nehring J, Junginger A, et al. (2017) Gradual or abrupt? Changes in water source
of Lake Turkana (Kenya) during the African humid period inferred from Sr isotope ratios. Quaternary
Science Reviews 174(Supplement C): 1–12.
Venkateswaran K, Elangovan M, Sivaraj N, et al. (2019) Chapter 2 - Origin, domestication and diffusion of
Sorghum bicolor. In: Aruna C, Visarada KBRS and Bhat BV (eds) Breeding Sorghum for Diverse End
Uses. Duxford: Woodhead Publishing, pp.15–31.
28 The Anthropocene Review 00(0)
von Suchodoletz H, Oberhänsli H, Faust D, et al. (2010) The evolution of Saharan dust input on Lanzarote
(Canary Islands)—Influenced by human activity in the northwest Sahara during the early Holocene? The
Holocene 20(2): 169–179.
Wang K, Goldstein S, Bleasdale M, et al. (2020) Ancient genomes reveal complex patterns of population
movement, interaction, and replacement in sub-Saharan Africa. Science Advances 6(24): eaaz0183.
Western D, Mose VN, Maitumo D, et al. (2021) Long-term changes in the plant ecology of an African
savanna landscape and the implications for ecosystem theory and conservation management. Ecological
Processes 10(1).
White F (1983) The Vegetation of Africa: A Descriptive Memoir to Accompany the UNESCO/AETFAT/UNSO
Vegetation Map of Africa. Paris: UNESCO.
Winchell F, Stevens CJ, Murphy C, et al. (2017) Evidence for sorghum domestication in fourth millen-
nium BC eastern Sudan: Spikelet morphology from ceramic impressions of the Butana Group. Current
Anthropology 58(5): 673–683.
Wright DK (2007) Tethered mobility and riparian resource exploitation among Neolithic hunters and herders
in the Galana River basin, Kenyan coastal lowlands. Environmental Archaeology 12(1): 25–47.
Wright DK (2017) Humans as agents in the termination of the African Humid Period. Frontiers in Earth
Science. Epub ahead of print 26 January 2016. DOI: 10.3389/feart.2017.00004.
Wright DK, MacEachern S, Ambrose SH, et al. (2019) Iron Age landscape changes in the Benoué River
Valley, Cameroon. Quaternary Research 92(2): 323–339.
Wright DK, MacEachern S, Choi J, et al. (2017) Iron Age landscapes of the Benue River Valley, Cameroon.
Journal of Field Archaeology 42(5): 394–407.
Wu J, Liu Z, Stuut J-BW, et al. (2017) North-African paleodrainage discharges to the central Mediterranean
during the last 18,000 years: A multiproxy characterization. Quaternary Science Reviews 163: 95–113.
Zalasiewicz J, Waters CN, Ellis EC, et al. (2021) The Anthropocene: Comparing its meaning in geol-
ogy (chronostratigraphy) with conceptual approaches arising in other disciplines. Earth s Future 9:
e2020EF001896.
Zbyryt A, Bubnicki JW, Kuijper DPJ, et al. (2018) Do wild ungulates experience higher stress with humans
than with large carnivores? Behavioral Ecology 29(1): 19–30.
Zerboni A and Nicoll K (2019) Enhanced zoogeomorphological processes in North Africa in the human-
impacted landscapes of the Anthropocene. Geomorphology 331: 22–35.