Article

Petsamo 1920–1940: Rhetoric of Colonialism and Finnishness

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

In 1920, Finland obtained a corridor to the Arctic Ocean, a land area that, until then, had been part of Russia. Petsamo, as the corridor was named in Finnish, was part of Finland from 1920 to 1944. As a new territorial acquisition, Petsamo raised expectations and was projected as a potential space for national expansionist policy. To answer the question of how Petsamo was to be put in use for building a strong and vital Finland, and not to become a burden and failure of Finnish state agency, many experts published views regarding how Petsamo should be developed. A dominating feature in this body of texts is a colonial mindset and rhetoric, promoting a comprehensive Finnish majority culture policy. These plans, including concrete actions, paved the way for a change in the region's environment and ethnic balance. The dominating discourse was that of ethnic Finnish settlement, and local features contradicting this were articulated as problems. From a Finnish majority perspective, Petsamo was often conceptualized as almost empty space waiting for a civilized and modern nation to take it into its possession and to develop it. The local Skolt Sami population became subject to much incomprehension and were viewed as a group doomed to perish under the pressure of a modern Finnish state.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

... Nevertheless, the memory of Finnish settler colonization lived on in Finland. Diaspora was perceived among the former settlers as an injustice, a forceful capture of the settlers' rightful homelands (Lahti 2021;Kullaa et al. 2022;Stadius 2021). ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Settler colonialism tries to master the land, use it, and derive bounty from it, putting tremendous strain on and wrecking environments. This chapter examines settler colonial crises and failures by discussing how the recent blockbuster films Ad Astra and Interstellar tackle imaginary settler projects in outer space in the context of environmental problems and the precariousness of habitability. In both films, the remedy for settler colonial crisis seems to be more settler colonialism. This involves a denial of the fundamental problems settler colonization causes. These films show how settler projects refuse to end, to die out, or to turn back, and how settler colonialism rejects critical self-reflection in the face of human and environmental disasters.
Article
Full-text available
The article charts a previously lesser-known aspect of research on the Skolt Sami by Väinö Tanner — his ideas on the Skolt Sami as a race. Tanner’s place in the scholarly field of racial theorizing and the discursive resources on which he relied are examined. One inspiring contemporaneous discourse was the Finnish hygienic discourse and the improvement of the nation’s health, towards which Tanner leaned. He reproduced aspects of the more aggressive eugenic discourse articulated by his ethnic peers, the Finland-Swedes, but the discourse on their racial superiority was unusable, given the agenda of his book, to elevate the Skolt Sami in the racial hierarchies. The economic organization of society was decisive for Tanner, rather than race, making him a Social evolutionist.
Article
Full-text available
German geopolitical writers in the 1930s proposed a tripartite division of the world into large panregions of American, European, and Japanese hegemony. This model is examined, with attention to imperialist ambitions in Africa. Six indicators of international relations (diplomatic ties, memberships in intergovernmental organizations, air-traffic links, trade and foreign investments, developmental aid, and arms sales and military intervention) are used to analyze the applicability of the model. The concept of Eurafrica is less valid now than it was before World War II because of waning colonial ties, activities of non-European states, and the marginal role of Africa in world affairs. Western European influence is decreasing in Africa. Eurafrica is still a premature geopolitical concept. -Authors
Article
Even though the university has the potential to help humanity in what amounts to a paradigmatic transition, it has been very restrictive and very selective in the kinds of knowledges it validates. In fact, the kinds of knowledges in which it has excelled are those most responsible for the paradigmatic crisis in which humanity finds itself. In a nutshell, the paradigmatic change calls for cognitive justice, justice for the different ways of knowing that circulate in society. Cognitive justice is the polar opposite of ‘anything goes’. The assumption is that there is no global social justice without global cognitive justice, justice among knowledges. Looking back, while privileging one specific kind of knowledge and, indeed, granting it a cognitive monopoly, the university has been the privileged site for producing and legitimating cognitive injustice. As a result, the immense epistemic diversity of the world has been ignored or suppressed. In the following, I will identify the problem and the promise for overcoming it.
Article
In the Peace Treaty of Tartu 1920 Finland was given a corridor to the Arctic Sea. This area of 10,000 km² called Petsamo, was situated along the eastern side of the present Russo-Norwegian border. For many Finns Petsamo was seen as part of a Greater Finland expansionist ideology. Petsamo remained part of Finland until 1944, and during that time tourism was intensified to this new Arctic Ocean part of Finland. However, the most significant single project for bringing modernity and the young Republic of Finland to Petsamo was the Kolosjoki nickel mine. Kolosjoki was a piece in a larger international struggle for natural resources to be used for economic and political gains both in times of war and peace. The Kolosjoki mine can be compared with other similar mining communities in the Arctic and Siberia. When compared with the Soviet Russian Piramid mining community on Svalbard, differences in architectural style also become a signifier. The Kolosjoki mining village was built in a functionalistic style that was eagerly adopted by Scandinavia and Finland at that time. An Arctic dimension, connected explicitly to the Arctic Ocean presence of Finland at that time, is mostly lacking in later Finnish collective history culture.
Book
Siirtomaa-aika on jo historiaa, mutta sen jäljet ovat yhä näkyvissä kaikkialla maailmassa. Vaikka asiasta ei ole juuri puhuttu, kolonialismi ja sen perintö ovat painaneet ja painavat yhä jälkensä myös Suomeen ja sitä koskeviin käsityksiin. Siirtomaasuhteita ja niiden vaikutuksia analysoidaan jälkikoloniaalisessa teoriassa tavalla, joka voi auttaa rakentamaan monikulttuuristuvaa yhteiskuntaa ja ymmärtämään sen mutkikkuutta. Tämä kirja esittelee tuota teoriaa ja tarjoaa välineitä sen soveltamiseksi Suomen oloihin. Kolonialismin jäljet koostuu kahdesta osasta. Jälkikoloniaaliseen ajatteluun johdattelevat suomennokset, joissa esitellään alan klassikkojen Edward W. Saidin, Gayatri Chakravorty Spivakin, Homi K. Bhabhan ja Avtar Brah'n ajattelua. Kirjan toinen osa sisältää suomalaisia tutkimusretkiä muun muassa kielen rasistisuuteen, saamelaisten alistamiseen, monikulttuuriseen kansalaisjärjestötoimintaan sekä etnisen toiseuden kulttuuriseen esittämiseen Suomessa.
Arktinen yhteistyö avaa Suomelle uusia mahdollisuuksia
  • Esko Aho
  • Paavo Lipponen
Aho, Esko, and Paavo Lipponen. 2018. "Arktinen yhteistyö avaa Suomelle uusia mahdollisuuksia" [Arctic cooperation opens new opportunities for Finland].
Arktiska framtider och resurser: Industriarvet som källa" [Arctic futures and resources: The industrial heritage as a source
  • Dag Avango
Avango, Dag. 2013. "Arktiska framtider och resurser: Industriarvet som källa" [Arctic futures and resources: The industrial heritage as a source]. Bebyggelsehistorisk tidskrift 65: 52-71.
Petsamon radan taloudelliset edellytykset [The economic conditions for the Petsamo railroad
  • Jalmar Castrén
Castrén, Jalmar. 1923. Petsamon radan taloudelliset edellytykset [The economic conditions for the Petsamo railroad]. Helsinki: Valtioneuvosto.
Den Elfvingska sillflottan och Petsamo
  • Ekström Söderlund
Ekström Söderlund, Birgitta. 2009. "Den Elfvingska sillflottan och Petsamo" [The Elfving herring fleet and Petsamo].
The Barents Region: A History of Subarctic Northern Europe
  • Lars Elenius
Elenius, Lars, ed. 2015. The Barents Region: A History of Subarctic Northern Europe. Oslo: Pax.
Petsamon taloudellisesta elämästä ja toimenpiteistä sen kehittämiseksi [On the economic life of Petsamo and the means to development
  • Östen Elfving
Elfving, Östen. 1924. Petsamon taloudellisesta elämästä ja toimenpiteistä sen kehittämiseksi [On the economic life of Petsamo and the means to development]. Helsinki: Valtioneuvosto.
Lapin asutuksen ja maankäytön historia myyttien ja todellisuuden ristivedossa" [The history of Lapland's settlement and land use in the cross-draught of myths and reality
  • Matti Enbuske
Enbuske, Matti. 2012. "Lapin asutuksen ja maankäytön historia myyttien ja todellisuuden ristivedossa" [The history of Lapland's settlement and land use in the cross-draught of myths and reality]. Faravid 36: 213-25.
Petsamo: Den finländska korridoren
  • Max Engman
Engman, Max. 2009a. "Petsamo: Den finländska korridoren" [Petsamo: The Finnish corridor].
Muistelmia Petsamon liikenteestä 1940-41
  • Harald Eriksson
Eriksson, Harald. 2006, "Muistelmia Petsamon liikenteestä 1940-41" [Memories of Petsamo traffic 1940-41]." In Pohjolan Klondyke [Nordic Klondyke], edited by Harald Ericsson and Janne Nokki, 11-63. Helsinki: Tullin julkaisusarja Merkurius 2.
Suomalaiset Jäämeren rannalla: Matkamuistelmia [The Finns on the Arctic Ocean's shore: Travel memoirs
  • Ervasti
Ervasti, August Wilhelm. 1884. Suomalaiset Jäämeren rannalla: Matkamuistelmia [The Finns on the Arctic Ocean's shore: Travel memoirs]. Helsinki: Weilin and Göös. Generation 2030. 2017. Generation 2030: Nordic Programme for Agenda 2030: Programme Description 2017-2020. 467/2017. Copenhagen: Nordic Council of Ministers.
Ryssänranta ja Suomen Alaska: Petsamo Helsingin Sanomien, Kalevan ja Rovaniemi-lehden kirjoittelussa vuosina 1921-1923 [The Russian shore and Finland's Alaska: Petsamo in the writings of Helsingin Sanomat, Kaleva, and Rovaniemi-lehti from 1921 to
  • Katja-Leena Heikkilä
Heikkilä, Katja-Leena. 2017. Ryssänranta ja Suomen Alaska: Petsamo Helsingin Sanomien, Kalevan ja Rovaniemi-lehden kirjoittelussa vuosina 1921-1923 [The Russian shore and Finland's Alaska: Petsamo in the writings of Helsingin Sanomat, Kaleva, and Rovaniemi-lehti from 1921 to 1923]. MA thesis, University of Oulu: http://urn.fi/ URN:NBN:fi:oulu-201711163112.
Ei alkua ei loppua: Saamelaisten puheenvuoro
  • Elina Helander
  • Kaarina Kailo
Helander, Elina, and Kaarina Kailo. 1999. Ei alkua ei loppua: Saamelaisten puheenvuoro [No beginning, no end: The voice of the Sami]. Helsinki: Like.
Petsamohon valaskaloja onkimahan
  • Jaakko Ikola
Ikola, Jaakko. 1924. Petsamohon valaskaloja onkimahan [To Petsamo to fish whales]. Jyväskylä: Gummerus.
Petsamon rata: Isänmaallinen unelma [The Petsamo railroad: A patriotic dream
  • Jalmari Kara
Kara, Jalmari [Kapteeni Teräs]. 1921. Petsamon rata: Isänmaallinen unelma [The Petsamo railroad: A patriotic dream]. Helsinki: Kirja.
Saamelaisten oikeusasemasta Ruotsi-Suomessa: Oikeushistoriallinen tutkimus Länsi-Pohjan Lapin maankäyttöoloista ja -oikeuksista ennen 1700-luvun puoliväliä [On the legal position of the Sami in Sweden-Finland: A legal history study on the conditions of land use and rights
  • Kaisa Korpijaakko
Korpijaakko, Kaisa. 1989. Saamelaisten oikeusasemasta Ruotsi-Suomessa: Oikeushistoriallinen tutkimus Länsi-Pohjan Lapin maankäyttöoloista ja -oikeuksista ennen 1700-luvun puoliväliä [On the legal position of the Sami in Sweden-Finland: A legal history study on the conditions of land use and rights in Vesterbotnian Lapland before the mid-1700s].
Ett marginellt Norden? Det finska Lapplands ställning från 1920-till 1940-talet
  • Maria Lähteenmäki
Lähteenmäki, Maria. 2001. "Ett marginellt Norden? Det finska Lapplands ställning från 1920-till 1940-talet" [A marginal Norden? The position of Finnish Lapland from the 1920s to the 1940s].
The Peoples of Lapland: Boundary Demarcations and Interaction in the North Calotte from 1808 to 1889
Historisk Tidskrift för Finland 86: 561-78. ---. 2006. The Peoples of Lapland: Boundary Demarcations and Interaction in the North Calotte from 1808 to 1889. Helsinki: Academia Scientiarum Fennica. ---. 2014. Väinö Voionmaa: Puolue-ja geopoliitikko [Väinö Voionmaa: Party-and geopolitician]. Helsinki: SKS. ---. 2017. Footprints in the Snow: The Long History of Arctic Finland. Helsinki: Prime Minister's Office.
Kaipauksieni maa: Lapinkävijän matkamuistoja [The land of my longing: Memories of a Lapland traveler
  • Armas Launis
Launis, Armas. 1922. Kaipauksieni maa: Lapinkävijän matkamuistoja [The land of my longing: Memories of a Lapland traveler]. Jyväskylä: Gummerus.
Lapin Sivistysseura ja saamenystävät 1930-luvulla" [The Lapland enlightenment society and the Sami friends in the 1930s]
  • Veli-Pekka Lehtola
Lehtola, Veli-Pekka. 2012. "Lapin Sivistysseura ja saamenystävät 1930-luvulla" [The Lapland enlightenment society and the Sami friends in the 1930s]. In Historian selkosilla: Jouko Vahtolan juhlakirja [In the wilderness of history: Festschrift to Jouko Vahtola], edited by Matti Enbuske, Matti Mäntylä, Matti Salo, and Reija Satokangas, 511-24. Rovaniemi: Pohjois-Suomen historiallinen yhdistys. ---. 2015. "Sámi Histories, Colonialism, and Finland." Arctic Anthropology 52 (2): 22-36. ---. 2017. "Vanishing Lapps, Progress in Action: Finnish Lappology and Representations of the Sámi in Publicity in the Early 20 th Century." Arctic and North 7: 83-102.
The Soul should have been Brought along': The Settlement of Skolt Sami to Inari in 1945-1949
---. 2018. "'The Soul should have been Brought along': The Settlement of Skolt Sami to Inari in 1945-1949." Journal of Northern Studies 12: 53-71.
Samers och indianers rätt till jorden: En historisk jämförelse inför Högsta domstolen
  • Magnus Mörner
Mörner, Magnus. 1980. "Samers och indianers rätt till jorden: En historisk jämförelse inför Högsta domstolen" [The Samis' and the Indians' right to the land: A historical comparison to the Supreme Court]. Historisk tidskrift 100: 419-51.
Nordströmrederiet och Petsamo
  • Raimo-Ragnar Nordström
Nordström, Raimo-Ragnar. 2009. "Nordströmrederiet och Petsamo" [The Nordström shipping company and Petsamo].
Petsamoa perimässä [Inheriting Petsamo
  • Sulo-Weikko Pekkola
Pekkola, Sulo-Weikko. 1930. Petsamoa perimässä [Inheriting Petsamo]. Porvoo: Werner Söderström.
Mietelmiä Lapista ja Petsamosta [Thoughts about Lapland and Petsamo
  • Viljo Puustinen
Puustinen, Viljo. 1922. Mietelmiä Lapista ja Petsamosta [Thoughts about Lapland and Petsamo]. Helsinki: Otava.
Imperiella visioner och den koloniala erfarenheten av ryska Alaska i finländsk press 1809-1867
  • Susanna Rabow-Edling
Rabow-Edling, Susanna. 2017. "Imperiella visioner och den koloniala erfarenheten av ryska Alaska i finländsk press 1809-1867" [Imperial visions and colonial experiences from Russian Alaska in the Finnish press 1809-1867]. Ennen ja nyt: Historian tietosanomat 17 (4) (website). https://journal.fi/ennenjanyt/issue/view/7156.
Petsamon maa: Suomen alue Jäämeren rannalla [The Petsamo land: Finland's area at the Arctic Ocean shore
  • J E Rosberg
Rosberg, J. E. 1919. Petsamon maa: Suomen alue Jäämeren rannalla [The Petsamo land: Finland's area at the Arctic Ocean shore]. Helsinki: Otava.
Voidaanko Petsamon aluetta käyttää maan hyödyksi: Keinoja ja tarkoitusperiä? [Can the area of Petsamo be used for the benefit of the country: Means and Goals?
  • Väinö Tanner
Tanner, Väinö. 1927. Voidaanko Petsamon aluetta käyttää maan hyödyksi: Keinoja ja tarkoitusperiä? [Can the area of Petsamo be used for the benefit of the country: Means and Goals?] Helsinki: Valtioneuvosto. ---. 1929. Antropogeografiska studier inom Petsamo-området, 1: Skoltlapparna [Anthropographical studies in the Petsamo Area, 1: Skolt Lapps]. Helsinki: Societas geographia Fenniae.
Valtion liiketoimintaa Petsamossa: Oy Petsamo Ab (1921-1929) [State business ventures in Petsamo
  • Erkki Taskila
Taskila, Erkki. 1980. Valtion liiketoimintaa Petsamossa: Oy Petsamo Ab (1921-1929) [State business ventures in Petsamo: Petsamo Ltd].
Petsamon suomalaistaminen: Koltat suomalaisuuden puristuksessa vuosina 1920-1925" [The fennization of Petsamo: The Skolts under Finnish pressure during 1920-1925
  • Tiina Törnqvist
Törnqvist, Tiina. 1998. "Petsamon suomalaistaminen: Koltat suomalaisuuden puristuksessa vuosina 1920-1925" [The fennization of Petsamo: The Skolts under Finnish pressure during 1920-1925]. MA thesis, University of Helsinki.
Where the World Ends? The Places and Challenges of Northern Cultural History
  • Marja Tuominen
Tuominen, Marja. 2011. "Where the World Ends? The Places and Challenges of Northern Cultural History." In They Do Things Differently There, edited by Bruce Johnson and Harri Kiiskinen, 43-80. Turku: University of Turku.
  • Marius Turda
Turda, Marius. 2010. Modernism and Eugenics. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Ruijan rantaa ja Ruijan merta [Finnmark shore and Finnmark sea
  • Ilmari Turja
Turja, Ilmari. 1928. Ruijan rantaa ja Ruijan merta [Finnmark shore and Finnmark sea]. Porvoo: Werner Söderström.
Lapin valtaus historiallisessa katsannossa
  • Jouko Vahtola
Vahtola, Jouko. 1991. "Lapin valtaus historiallisessa katsannossa" [The Occupation of Lapland in a historical perspective]. Faravid 15: 335-55.
Suomi Jäämerellä [Finland at the Arctic Ocean
  • Väinö Voionmaa
Voionmaa, Väinö. 1918. Suomi Jäämerellä [Finland at the Arctic Ocean].