ArticlePDF Available

HP-TACO: A high-pressure triaxial compression apparatus for in situ x-ray measurements in geomaterials

AIP Publishing
Review of Scientific Instruments
Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Triaxial compression experiments are commonly used to characterize the elastic and inelastic behavior of geomaterials. In situ measurements of grain kinematics, particle breakage, stresses, and other microscopic phenomena have seldom been made during such experiments, particularly at high pressures relevant to many geologic and man-made processes, limiting our fundamental understanding. To address this issue, we developed a new triaxial compression device called HP-TACO (High-Pressure TriAxial COmpression Apparatus). HP-TACO is a miniaturized, conventional triaxial compression apparatus permitting confining pressures up to 50 MPa and deviatoric straining of materials, while also allowing in situ x-ray measurements of grain-scale kinematics and stresses. Here, we present the design of and first results from HP-TACO during its use in laboratory and synchrotron settings to study grain-scale kinematics and stresses in triaxially compressed sands subjected to 15 and 30 MPa confining pressures. The data highlight the unique capabilities of HP-TACO for studying the high-pressure mechanics of sands, providing new insight into micromechanical processes occurring during geologic and man-made processes.
Content may be subject to copyright.
HP-TACO: A High-Pressure TriAxial COmpression Apparatus
HP-TACO: A High-Pressure TriAxial COmpression Apparatus for In-Situ
X-ray Measurements in Geomaterials
G. Shahin1and R.C. Hurley2
1)Hopkins Extreme Materials Institute, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD USA
2)Hopkins Extreme Materials Institute, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD USA
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD USA
(*Electronic mail: rhurley6@jhu.edu)
(Dated: 15 November 2022)
Triaxial compression experiments are commonly used to characterize the elastic and inelastic behavior of geomate-
rials. In-situ measurements of grain kinematics, particle breakage, stresses, and other microscopic phenomena have
seldom been made during such experiments, particularly at high pressures relevant to many geologic and man-made
processes, limiting our fundamental understanding. To address this issue, we developed a new triaxial compression
device called HP-TACO (High-Pressure TriAxial COmpression Apparatus). HP-TACO is a miniaturized conventional
triaxial compression apparatus permitting confining pressures up to 50 MPa and deviatoric straining of materials, while
also allowing in-situ x-ray measurements of grain-scale kinematics and stresses. Here, we present the design of and first
results from HP-TACO during its use in laboratory and synchrotron settings to study grain-scale kinematics and stresses
in triaxially-compressed sands subjected to 15 MPa and 30 MPa confining pressure. The data highlights the unique ca-
pabilities of HP-TACO for studying the high-pressure mechanical of sands, providing new insight into micromechanical
processes occurring during geologic and man-made processes.
I. INTRODUCTION
The mechanical behavior of soils and rocks in triaxial states
of stress governs their performance in man-made settings and
their contribution to geologic processes in the Earth’s up-
per crust. Laboratory studies employing conventional triaxial
stress experiments have been employed extensively to char-
acterize the mechanical behavior of geomaterials across pres-
sures regimes1,2. In such tests, two principal stresses are im-
posed on a sample. Specifically, imposing axial strain under a
constant pressure in the fluid surrounding the sample (which
is typically within a sealed membrane) induces a proportional
increase in the first and third principal stresses. Conventional
triaxial testing has revealed the peak strength of rocks and
soils, the strain localization patterns that develop after peak
strength, and the brittle-to-ductile transitions that frequently
occur as confining pressures are increased1–3.
In recent decades, in-situ x-ray imaging has been used to
monitor microscopic processes of rocks and soils during tri-
axial testing, revealing rich grain-scale kinematics and de-
formation patterns3–8. Such measurements play an important
role in our understanding of the micromechanics of strain lo-
calization and the local fluctuations in particle motion and
porosity during macroscopic soil testing. Prior triaxial test-
ing on sands with in-situ x-ray imaging has primarily been
limited to pressures below about 7 MPa6, below the level
relevant to many geologic and man-made processes. Other
in-situ measurements, such as acoustic emissions, have been
performed at higher pressures9. Recent testing on rocks
with in-situ imaging has employed confining pressures of
100 MPa and axial stresses of 200 MPa, providing access to
the brittle-to-ductile transition in some rocks, such as porous
limestone10–13. The more common low-pressure regimes (<7
MPa) are below those required to induce significant particle
fragmentation without deviatoric loading; such a pressure is
critical for anchoring the plastic yield surface to the hydro-
static axis in pressure-dependent plasticity models. Moreover,
testing has not typically employed measurements such as 3D
x-ray diffraction (3DXRD), which enables quantifying grain-
resolved stress tensors within individual grains14. We have
therefore developed a testing capability that provides access
to higher pressures and permits use with a variety of x-ray fa-
cilities and measurement modalities, thanks to a combination
of a unique design and light weight.
In this paper, we describe a new triaxial apparatus for test-
ing a variety of geomaterials in laboratory and synchrotron
x-ray facilities with confining pressures up to 50 MPa and ax-
ial stresses over 1 GPa in the smallest specimens. In Sec. II
we describe the apparatus design. In Sec. III we describe the
sample preparation procedures used in executing experiments
in HP-TACO. In Sec. IV we briefly describe two experiments
and preliminary results. In Sec. V we provide conclusions.
Technical drawings for reproduction of the instrument are pro-
vided in the supplementary materials.
II. LOAD FRAME DESIGN
The High-Pressure TriAxial COmpression Apparatus (HP-
TACO) described in this paper is a miniaturized version of
a conventional triaxial apparatus. It is not a true triaxial ap-
paratus but, as is conventional in soil and rock mechanics,
employs a pressurized fluid on the outside of a membrane
to constrain two of three principal stresses on samples. HP-
TACO was designed to: permit high-resolution laboratory-
based XRT imaging in an RX Solutions EasyTom 160; permit
high-resolution synchrotron-based XRT imaging and 3DXRD
measurements; permit lateral confining pressures up to 50
MPa on samples; permit axial compression of samples; ac-
commodate sample sizes ranging from 1.5 mm diameter for
synchrotron experiments to 15 mm diameter for laboratory ex-
HP-TACO: A High-Pressure TriAxial COmpression Apparatus 2
periments.
With these goals in mind, HP-TACO was designed and con-
structed with five critical subsystems: a light-weight chassis; a
fluid-control system for cell pressure; an axial loading system;
a sample environment system; a computerized control system.
Here, we briefly describe each subsystem. The subsystems are
visible in Fig. 1, which shows HP-TACO in operation within
a laboratory x-ray tomography machine (Fig. 1). The internal
features and HP-TACO components are also illustrated in Fig.
1. More technical details are provided in Table I and dimen-
sioned drawings are provided as supplementary material.
The load frame chassis was constructed primarily using
machinable Al-6061 and off-the-shelf T-slotted aluminum
framing. The chassis accommodates a dumbbell-shaped x-
ray translucent pressure cell (in the fluid system) and an axial
loading system. The chassis is lightweight, providing versatil-
ity for mounting in laboratory x-ray machines and at a variety
of synchrotron x-ray facilities where rotation stage weight re-
strictions are as low as 10 kg.
The fluid system contains and pressurizes the confining
fluid imposed on the exterior of membranes containing sam-
ples. As shown in Fig. 1, its critical features include:
a customized 20 mm diameter, 2 mm wall thickness Al-
6061 pressure cell which permits, with the low instrument
weight amenable for use on precision rotation stages, high-
resolution XRT and 3DXRD up to confining pressures of at
least 50 MPa; a Cetoni Nemesys 50 MPa syringe pump with
high-pressure stainless-steel tubing; an analog pressure gauge
to monitor the cell pressure during experiments; a quick-
disconnect feature for disconnecting the pump from the pres-
sure cell during measurements while maintaining the cham-
ber pressure in the cell. The dumbbell shape of the pressure
cell accommodates the approach of cone beam laboratory x-
ray sources close to the sample location to enhance geometric
magnification.
The axial loading system imposes axial stress on samples.
The system contains the following features, many of which
are visible in Fig. 1: a 1-inch stroke NEMA 34 linear stepper
motor actuator (Haydon Kerk Pittman) with 2500 counts-per-
revolution encoder and maximum load capacity of approxi-
mately 2250 N; a miniature 2225 N load cell (Futek LCM300)
for monitoring the axial load imposed on a sample; a drive
piston connected in line with the load cell and actuator and
featuring a hemispherical tip to impose axial sample loads.
The sample environment system maintains the intended ge-
ometry and environmental conditions of samples. A portion
of the system is visible in Fig. 1 and features: a support pis-
ton cylinder that remains fixed to the load frame base during
sample changes and features a central channel connected to a
suction port in the base; a quick-disconnect suction port in the
load frame base that can be used in conjunction with a hand-
operated vacuum pump to draw a light vacuum in the sample
environment; variable-diameter platens that can be bolted into
the top of the support piston to accommodate samples with di-
ameters of 1.5, 1.8, 5, 10, and 15 mm; variable-diameter neo-
prene membranes (Piercan USA) that can be placed around
platens and samples and sealed with vacuum grease and a vac-
uum drawn in the sample environment.
HP-TACO’s final subsystem is a computerized control and
monitoring system. The system contains the following fea-
tures: a Windows 10 laptop with appropriate Nemesys Qmix-
ELEMENTS (for the pump), LabView (for the load cell),
and IDEA Drive (for the actuator) software; an Ametek
PCM48026E IDEA Drive Stepper Motor Controller to which
the actuator connects and which connects to the laptop for
monitoring actuator extension; a high speed and resolution
USB encoder which connects to the load cell and computer
and aids in monitoring the axial load on the sample through
LabView; a 24 V 200 Amp power supply for the actuator.
In addition to the control system’s software and hardware,
HP-TACO also features variable-length cable arrays, ranging
from 5 m to 10 m. These arrays help to manage the ten wires
needed for connecting the actuator’s encoder and power input
to the stepper motor controller and power supply. The step-
per motor controller and power supply must be placed outside
of x-ray tomography machines, or must be located away from
sample environments in synchrotron x-ray hutches, necessi-
tating long cables for cable strain relief.
III. SAMPLE PREPARATION AND EXPERIMENT
PROCEDURE
The workflow of HP-TACO involves sample preparation,
experiment execution, and in-situ measurements. First, sam-
ples are prepared outside of HP-TACO. Membranes are placed
around the variable-diameter platens and sand is poured into
the membranes to a desired height, or a drilled and parallelised
rock sample is placed within the membrane. A small anvil is
inserted into the top of the membrane and the sample is sealed
with vacuum grease and bolted into the support piston. The
pressure cell is then screwed on the load frame base. A light
vacuum is optionally drawn in the sample environment using
a hand pump. The pressure cell is filled with tap water before
the axial loading system is placed on top and the pressure cell
is sealed.
Next, with the drive piston not in contact with the anvil,
the chamber pressure is gradually raised to a desired level at
10 kPa/s using the QmixELEMENTS software and the inter-
nal pressure monitor on the Cetoni Nemesys. For synchrotron
studies with small samples, the pump-tube connected to the
cell is then disconnected at the quick-disconnect feature which
maintains the chamber pressure. HP-TACO is then mounted
in the x-ray path so that the remaining steps of the prepara-
tion and experiment can proceed while monitoring the sample
with in-situ x-ray radiography. For laboratory studies with
larger samples, the pump remains connected during this stage
and a servo-control algorithm maintains the constant chamber
pressure during linear actuator extension. The drive piston
connected to the linear actuator is brought into grazing con-
tact with the anvil touching the top of the sample using the
IDEA Drive software. Axial loading proceeds by extending
the stepper motor by a desired distance. The distance is typ-
ically small and is dictated by the need to maintain strains of
2% or less between sequential XRT images for digital image
correlation or discrete particle tracking. The axial load mea-
HP-TACO: A High-Pressure TriAxial COmpression Apparatus 3
10
5
5
6
6
7
9
9
8
1
1
2
23
4
10
9
11
12
12 13
13
14 15
16
16 17
18
19
20
16
x-ray
source
1
16
9
5
FIG. 1. HP-TACO. (1) NEMA actuator, (2) plate, (3) Futek force-cell, (4) custom-built (CB) adapter, (5) CB plate, (6) CB piston, (7) CB pin,
(8) pressure gauge, (9) CB pressure cell, (10) Cetoni Nemesys 50 MPa syringe pump (11) Neoprene membrane (Piercan USA) containing a
sample, (12) CB anvil, (13) CB piston, (14) O-ring, (15) O-ring, (16) CB base plate, (18) high-pressure stainless steel tube, (19) high-pressure
quick disconnect system, and (20) high-pressure valve. The right figure shows HP-TACO in operation inside an X-ray tomography system.
TABLE I. HP-TACO components, manufacturer/supplier and model number. Numbers are linked to Figure 1. DW refers to drawings shared
as supplementary information. CB referes to custom-built.
Num Item Supplier Model Number
1 Actuator Haydon Kerk Pittman Size 34 Series 87000 Captive Lead-Screw Linear Actuator
2 Frame item CB DW8
3 Force cell Futek LCM 300
4 Frame item CB DW9
5 Frame item CB DW5
6 Frame item CB DW6
7 Frame item CB DW7
8 Pressure guage McMaster-Carr 3842K41
9 Frame item CB DW2
10 Pump Cetoni Nemesys 50 MPa
11 Neoprene membrane containing sample Piercan or CB
12 Frame item CB DW4
13 Frame item CB DW3
14 O-ring McMaster-Carr 9452K117
15 O-ring McMaster-Carr 9452K6
16 Frame item CB DW1
17 Air quick disconnect McMaster-Carr 5012K124
18 Tubes 1/16" McMaster-Carr 51755K36
19 Quick-disconnect McMaster-Carr 5220T17 3907N11
20 Valve McMaster-Carr 4715K11
sured by the load cell is monitored in LabView for any sig-
nificant stress drops indicative of sample failure or rearrange-
ment. The pump tube connected to the cell is then discon-
nected to allow the load frame to rotate freely in preparation
of acquiring x-ray measurements.
Between each increment of axial loading, in-situ XRT and
3DXRD (at synchrotron facilities) measurements are made.
These measurements involve rotating the entire HP-TACO ap-
paratus 180or 360for XRT measurements and then again
360for 3DXRD measurements. During the first rotation, be-
tween 1120 and 2881 x-ray radiographs are obtained for labo-
ratory and synchrotron XRT, respectively. During the second
HP-TACO: A High-Pressure TriAxial COmpression Apparatus 4
rotation, if performing 3DXRD, 3600 diffraction patterns are
obtained, each at 0.1angular increments of rotation.
After completing one x-ray scan, the pump is reconnected
to the pressure cell. The pump and the quick-disconnect fea-
ture are brought to a pressure equal to the pressure inside the
cell before the valve is opened to connect the pump fluid and
the cell fluid. The pump is set on a servo-control mode to
maintain the constant cell pressure while another loading in-
crement is being carried out.
IV. INITIAL EXPERIMENTS AND RESULTS
There were two initial experimental campaigns performed
with HP-TACO. The first campaign involved the compression
of Ottawa sand under confining pressures ranging from 10
MPa to 45 MPa with in-situ XRT at JHU. The goal of this
campaign was to quantify the micro- and meso-scale mecha-
nisms (grain breakage, deformation banding) of sand in sup-
port of developing a mechanism-based constitutive model15.
The second experimental campaign involved axial compres-
sion of single-crystal quartz grains under confining pres-
sures ranging from 25 MPa to 40 MPa with in-situ XRT and
3DXRD at APS. The goal of this campaign was to measure
particle-resolved stress and force evolution during deforma-
tion band development and progression. The remainder of this
section describes the initial experiments and results.
A. Definition of sample stresses
The axial load measured by the load cell minus to the load
after cell pressurization will be denoted n, the cell pressure
will be denoted pc, and the initial cross-sectional area of a
sample will be denoted a. Sample stress is given by
σi j =
n
a+pc0 0
0pc0
0 0 pc
.(1)
The mean, p, and the deviatoric stress, q, are given by
p=1
3σi jδi j ,and q=r3
2si jsi j ,(2)
where si j =σij pδi j is the deviatoric stress tensor.
B. First experiments: Ottawa sand with XRT
Experiments were performed at JHU in an RX Solutions
EasyTom 160 MicroCT. Ottawa sand (Humboldt Co., d50 =
175 µm) was poured into a 5 mm Piercan neoprene mem-
brane (mounted onto a 5 mm diameter aluminum platen) to a
height of 10 mm. An aluminum platen was inserted into the
membrane on top of the sample and sample preparation pro-
ceeded as described in Sec. III. The fluid in the pressure cel
FIG. 2. Triaxial compression test on Ottawa sand. (a) Stress-strain
curve for test at 15 MPa confining pressure. Insets show XRT im-
ages at four strain levels indicated by numbers. (b) Horizontal slice
through XRT image at 0% strain. (c) Vertical slice through XRT im-
age at 14% axial strain. (d) Grain displacements found from dDIC
between three strain increments as described in text.
(outside of the membranes containing samples) were pressur-
ized to between 10-45 MPa with the goal of studying the mi-
cromechanics underlying the brittle-to-ductile transition. The
experiment featuring 15 MPa confining pressure is presented
in this paper as an example. Other tests will be described in a
dedicated publication elsewhere.
The specimen was deformed with XRT measurements
made at 2% axial strain increments. XRT measurements in-
volved acquiring radiographs at 1,120 angles (eight images
per angle) equally over 360rotation with an x-ray source
voltage of 100 kV and current of 70 W. The stress-strain curve
is shown in Fig. 3a. Stress drops observed in this curve reflect
the sample stress relaxation that occurs during XRT measure-
ments. The stress is quickly recovered upon further axial load-
ing. The stress-strain curve reflects sample strengthening.
XRT images were reconstructed using the X-Act software
provided by RX Solutions. Images featured a pixel size of
approximate (6 µm)3. A horizontal slice of an XRT image at
scan number 1 is shown in Fig. 2b showing ample solid-to-
void contrast for image segmentation16. A vertical slice of the
XRT image of scan number 7 is presented in Fig. 2c, showing
deformation patterns indicative of strain localization. XRT
images were processed to separate the grains from the void
space using a binarization operation that takes advantage of
Otsu’s method16. Individual grains were also labeled using
a watershed segmentation algorithm. After binarization and
segmentation, continuum digital image correlation (DIC) and
discrete digital image correlation (dDIC) were performed in
SPAM with the goal of quantifying the continuum strains and
the translation and rotation of individual particles16. Figure 2d
shows the result of displacement tracking using dDIC between
three incremental strain steps during the experiment. Strain
localization in an inclined shear band is evident, consistent
HP-TACO: A High-Pressure TriAxial COmpression Apparatus 5
with the dashed yellow lines in Fig. 2c. Additional results
will be provided in a separate publication.
C. First experiments: single crystal quartz with XRT and
3DXRD
Experiments on single crystal quartz were performed at
the APS beamline ID-1-E with in-situ XRT and 3DXRD,
the latter measurement to obtain the stress tensors within in-
dividual particles17. The grains used in these experiments
were single-crystal quartz, ball- and jet-milled from blocks of
hydrothermally-grown quartz (Sawyer Technical Materials),
as in our prior studies18. Grains were sieved to a size of ap-
proximately 106 - 150 µm before experiments.
Sample and HP-TACO preparation procedures were nearly
identical to those used in the experiments on Ottawa sand de-
scribed in Sec. IV B except samples were only 1.5 mm in
diameter and membranes were custom-made from a silicone
rubber material (AS40 Addition Cure Silicone Rubber from
Easy Composites UK). Samples were prepared to be approxi-
mately 2.5 mm in height before axial compression.
The experiment shown here involved pressurizing the sam-
ple to 30 MPa and then quasi-statically axially-compressing
the sample in displacement increments of 50 µm each. Be-
tween each displacement increment, XRT and 3DXRD mea-
surements were made by rotating the entire load frame 360
twice. During the first rotation, 2881 x-ray radiographs
were obtained at 0.125angular increments using a Retiga
4000DC CCD camera; XRT reconstructions were performed
in TomoPy19. During the second rotation, 3600 x-ray diffrac-
tion patterns were obtained at 0.1angular increments using a
GE-41RT area detector; 3DXRD analysis was performed us-
ing MIDAS20. The measurement and data analysis methods
will be described in more depth elsewhere.
A total of 12% axial strain was imposed on the sample com-
pressed to 30 MPa confining pressure. The chamber pressure
was monitored manually between x-ray measurements by in-
specting the analog pressure gauge (Fig. 1) and did not change
by more than 5% from its initial value throughout the duration
of any of the experiments.
Figure 3a shows a horizontal slice through the XRT image
obtained at zero sample strain, showing decent solid-to-void
contrast for image segmentation. Figure 3b shows the maxi-
mum intensity over all 3,600 diffraction patterns obtained dur-
ing diffraction measurements. Portions of this image highlight
the aluminum (Al) rings generated by pressure cell as well as
the SiO2rings from the sample. Clear diffraction peaks are
visible in individual diffraction images used to obtain Fig. 3b.
The analysis of these peaks for grain stresses and orientations
will be presented in-depth in a future publication. Figure 3c
shows the stress-strain curve for the experiment with insets
showing XRT images at two strain.
V. CONCLUSIONS
We developed a new triaxial compression apparatus for
subjecting sands and rocks to confining pressures up to 50
MPa. Our first results support our ability to reach desired
sample stress levels while also performing in-situ XRT and
3DXRD measurements. Ongoing experiments on sand and
sandstone are being performed: (1) to understand the kine-
matics and particle stress fluctuations associated with local re-
arrangements occurring within deformation bands; (2) to un-
derstand the microscale mechanisms of deformation during
triaxial compression of rocks.
SUPPLEMENTAL MATERIAL
See supplemental material for dimensioned drawings of all
custom-built components of the instrument described in this
paper.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors gratefully acknowledge funding from the U.S.
NSF Award CBET-1942096 and the U.S. Defense Threat Re-
duction Agency (DTRA) Award #HDTRA-1-20-2-0001. The
content of the information does not necessarily reflect the po-
sition or the policy of the federal government, and no official
endorsement should be inferred. We acknowledge the APS
for synchrotron beamtime. Use of the APS, an Office of Sci-
ence User Facility operated for the US Department of Energy
(DOE) Office of Science by Argonne National Laboratory,
was supported by US DOE Contract DE-AC02-06CH11357.
DATA AVAILABILITY STATEMENT
The data that support the findings of this study are available
from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
REFERENCES
1T.-f. Wong, C. David, and W. Zhu, “The transition from brittle faulting to
cataclastic flow in porous sandstones: Mechanical deformation,” Journal of
Geophysical Research: Solid Earth 102, 3009–3025 (1997).
2J. Desrues and G. Viggiani, “Strain localization in sand: an overview of the
experimental results obtained in grenoble using stereophotogrammetry, In-
ternational Journal for Numerical and Analytical Methods in Geomechanics
28, 279–321 (2004).
3G. Viggiani, N. Lenoir, P. Bésuelle, M. Di Michiel, S. Marello, J. Desrues,
and M. Kretzschmer, “X-ray microtomography for studying localized
deformation in fine-grained geomaterials under triaxial compression,”
Comptes Rendus Mécanique 332, 819–826 (2004).
4K. A. Alshibli, S. Sture, N. C. Costes, M. L. Frank, M. R. Lankton, S. N.
Batiste, and R. A. Swanson, “Assessment of localized deformations in sand
using x-ray computed tomography, Geotechnical Testing Journal 23, 274–
299 (2000).
HP-TACO: A High-Pressure TriAxial COmpression Apparatus 6
FIG. 3. Triaxial compression test on quartz. (a) Horizontal slice through the XRT image obtained during zero sample strain. (b) Maximum
intensity over all 3,600 diffraction patterns obtained during one 360rotation for 3DXRD measurements. Inset shows two SiO2peaks on a
single diffraction pattern. Top two quadrants highlight Al and SiO2rings used in 3DXRD analysis. Bottom half shows all SiO2ring locations.
(c) Stress-axial strain curve with insets showing segmented XRT images.
5S. A. Hall, M. Bornert, J. Desrues, Y. Pannier, N. Lenoir, G. Viggiani, and
P. Bésuelle, “Discrete and continuum analysis of localised deformation in
sand using x-ray µct and volumetric digital image correlation,” Géotech-
nique 60, 315–322 (2010).
6R. Alikarami, E. Andò, M. Gkiousas-Kapnisis, A. Torabi, and G. Viggiani,
“Strain localisation and grain breakage in sand under shearing at high mean
stress: insights from in situ x-ray tomography,” Acta Geotechnica 10, 15–
30 (2015).
7E. Andò, S. A. Hall, G. Viggiani, J. Desrues, and P. Bésuelle, “Grain-
scale experimental investigation of localised deformation in sand: a discrete
particle tracking approach,” Acta Geotechnica 7, 1–13 (2012).
8E. Andò, S. Hall, G. Viggiani, J. Desrues, and P. Bésuelle, “Experimental
micromechanics: grain-scale observation of sand deformation,” Géotech-
nique Letters 2, 107–112 (2012).
9S. J. Hangx and N. Brantut, “Micromechanics of high-pressure compaction
in granular quartz aggregates,” Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid
Earth 124, 6560–6580 (2019).
10F. Renard, B. Cordonnier, D. K. Dysthe, E. Boller, P. Tafforeau, and
A. Rack, “A deformation rig for synchrotron microtomography studies of
geomaterials under conditions down to 10 km depth in the earth, Journal
of synchrotron radiation 23, 1030–1034 (2016).
11M. Voltolini, H. Barnard, P. Creux, and J. Ajo-Franklin, “A new mini-
triaxial cell for combined high-pressure and high-temperature in situ syn-
chrotron x-ray microtomography experiments up to 400° c and 24 mpa,”
Journal of synchrotron radiation 26, 238–243 (2019).
12A. Cartwright-Taylor, I. G. Main, I. B. Butler, F. Fusseis, M. Flynn, and
A. King, “Catastrophic failure: How and when? insights from 4-d in situ x-
ray microtomography, Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth 125,
e2020JB019642 (2020).
13I. Butler, F. Fusseis, A. Cartwright-Taylor, and M. Flynn, “Mjölnir: a
miniature triaxial rock deformation apparatus for 4d synchrotron x-ray mi-
crotomography, Journal of synchrotron radiation 27, 1681–1687 (2020).
14H. F. Poulsen, S. F. Nielsen, E. M. Lauridsen, S. Schmidt, R. Suter,
U. Lienert, L. Margulies, T. Lorentzen, and D. Juul Jensen, “Three-
dimensional maps of grain boundaries and the stress state of individual
grains in polycrystals and powders, Journal of applied crystallography 34,
751–756 (2001).
15M. Cil, R. Hurley, and L. Graham-Brady, “Constitutive model for brittle
granular materials considering competition between breakage and dilation,”
Journal of Engineering Mechanics 146, 04019110 (2020).
16O. Stamati, E. Andò, E. Roubin, R. Cailletaud, M. Wiebicke, G. Pinzon,
C. Couture, R. Hurley, R. Caulk, D. Caillerie, et al., “Spam: software for
practical analysis of materials,” Journal of Open Source Software 5, 2286
(2020).
17J. Oddershede, S. Schmidt, H. F. Poulsen, H. O. Sørensen, J. Wright, and
W. Reimers, “Determining grain resolved stresses in polycrystalline mate-
rials using three-dimensional x-ray diffraction, Journal of Applied Crys-
tallography 43, 539–549 (2010).
18R. C. Hurley, E. B. Herbold, and D. C. Pagan, “Characterization of the crys-
tal structure, kinematics, stresses and rotations in angular granular quartz
during compaction,” Journal of Applied Crystallography 51, 1021–1034
(2018).
19D. Gürsoy, F. De Carlo, X. Xiao, and C. Jacobsen, “Tomopy: a framework
for the analysis of synchrotron tomographic data,” Journal of synchrotron
radiation 21, 1188–1193 (2014).
20H. Sharma, R. M. Huizenga, and S. E. Offerman, “A fast methodol-
ogy to determine the characteristics of thousands of grains using three-
dimensional x-ray diffraction. i. overlapping diffraction peaks and parame-
ters of the experimental setup,” Journal of applied crystallography 45, 693–
704 (2012).
... Data were obtained at the ID-1-E beamline of APS. The triaxial compression instrument used in the experiments is shown in Fig. 1A and is described in detail in ref. 67 and was used in a previous study on triaxial compression of Ottawa sand (13). Samples of single-crystal alpha-quartz were manufactured from blocks of hydrothermally grown SiO 2 provided by Sawyer Technical Materials, LLC. ...
... To prepare samples in the triaxial compression instrument, a membrane of about 1.4 mm inner diameter and 3 mm outer diameter was first made using an aluminum mold and AS40 Addition Cure Silicon Rubber from Easy Composites Ltd. The membrane was then placed around a 10-mm pin mounted on the lower shaft of the triaxial compression instrument shown in the Inset to figure 1A and in ref. 67. Grains were poured into the membrane to a desired height and a top pin with a diameter of 1.58 mm (tool steel ejector pin, part 93772A103 from McMaster-Carr) was inserted into the top of the membrane. ...
... Vacuum grease was applied to the exterior of the membrane where it contacted the bottom pin and top ejector pin to prevent fluid from entering the sample environment. The triaxial compression apparatus was then assembled as described in ref. 67 and a top shaft with a 3.125 mm radius hemispherical tip was brought into contact with the cap of the ejector pin. The fluid in the Al tube shown in Fig. 1A was then pressurized to the desired confining pressure and the experiment proceeded by quasistatically imposing small axial strain increments to samples, between which axial sample strain was paused for XRCT and 3DXRD measurements. ...
Article
Critical state and continuum plasticity theories have been used in research and engineering practice in soil and rock mechanics for decades. These theories rely on postulated relationships between material stresses and strains. Some classical postulates include coaxiality between stress and strain rates, stress-dilatancy relationships, and kinematic assumptions in shear bands. Although numerical and experimental data have quantified the strains and grain kinematics in such experiments, little data quantifying grain stresses are available. Here, we report the first-known grain stress and local strain measurements in triaxial compression tests on synthetic quartz sands using synchrotron X-ray tomography and 3D X-ray diffraction. We use these data to examine the micromechanics of shear banding, with a focus on coaxiality, stress-dilatancy, and kinematics within bands. Our results indicate the following: 1) elevated deviatoric stress, strain, and stress ratios in shear bands throughout experiments; 2) coaxial principal compressive stresses and strains throughout samples; 3) significant contraction along shear bands; 4) vanishing volumetric strain but nonvanishing stress fluctuations throughout samples at all stages of deformation. Our results provide some of the first-known in situ stress and strain measurements able to aid in critically evaluating postulates employed in continuum plasticity and strain localization theories for sands.
... Based on the work of Senetakis and Coop [2014], an inter-particle shearing device is built to characterise the inter-particle friction angle by measuring the resulting forces at the contact point using a 6-axis forcemeter, similar to the one used in Shahin and Hurley [2022]. The friction angle is taken as the maximum value registered as the pair of particles are sheared. ...
... As a powerful extension of traditional microscopy work, non-destructive X-ray CT imaging has been enabling investigations that were not previously possible such as the insitu monitoring of 3D microstructural changes occurring in materials under active loading, with the continuous introduction of ever more sophisticated setups (e.g. Renard et al. 2016;Voltolini et al. 2019;Shahin and Hurley 2022;Francois et al. 2022). In this work, X-ray micro CT imaging was used to study the microstructural expression of macroscopic compaction in a minicore of Boise sandstone, and test the aforementioned hypothesis regarding the role and evolution of grain size distributions (GSDs). ...
Article
Full-text available
MicroCT imaging is performed before and after confined compression testing of a minicore of Boise sandstone to extract quantitative information on the microstructural controls on compaction initiation and distribution, and to test whether grain size distributions tend to conform to a power law through comminution. In contrast with traditional compaction studies, this analysis focuses on local statistics among regions of a given sample as opposed to global statistics in a sample set. The original workflow includes a segmentation strategy and the definition of a series of metrics that are evaluated throughout the entire image volumes before and after testing. The results suggest that local porosity and sorting are the main controls on local strength, whereas neighborhoods with larger mean grain size do not appear to be more prone to yielding. Furthermore, our observations appear to confirm the tendency of grain size distributions to become self-similar through the elimination of same size neighbors at all scales, consistent with the concept of fractal compression.
Article
The problem of indentation has myriad applications in the infrastructure industry, especially in design of shallow foundations. The framework offered by plasticity theory and metal working have been used to understand the mechanics of indentation. The results of a series of experiments on indentation of granular ensemble conducted inside a XRCT set up are presented here. The indentation was carried out in 3 stages – in both intrusion and extrusion directions and the evolving displacement was mapped. The region of deformation of the ensemble is localized around the indenter and reduces with increasing depth of indentation. Further, other microstructural parameter such as the coordination numbers, zones of localization, shear bands etc were all mapped through the indentation process – under both intrusion and extrusion.
Article
An existing open and modular designed micro X-Ray Computed Tomography (μXRCT) system is extended by a test rig in order to combine mechanical and hydro-mechanical experiments with μXRCT characterization. The aim of the system is to cover the complete resolution range of the underlying μXRCT system in combination with a broad load capacity range. A characteristic feature of the developed setup is that it consists mainly of standard components. This makes the shown test rig potentially interesting for other researchers considering extending an existing μXRCT system with an apparatus for mechanical and hydro-mechanical in situ testing. For the load frame, an uniaxial 10 kN universal testing machine with a digital control system was employed, which was extended by two aligned rotational stages. The uniaxial load capacity is ±3.1 kN and can be combined with torque moments of up to ±15 N m both limited by the used rotational stages. The setup is designed in such a way that different x-ray transparent cells (flow cells, oedometer cells, triaxial cells, etc.) can be integrated to generate three-dimensional stress/strain states as required for porous media research. Three applications demonstrate the possible versatile use of the system. As part of these examples, we show how corresponding x-ray transparent cells are designed and implemented. Finally, we discuss the presented approach’s technical advantages and disadvantages and suggest improvements.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
MicroCT imaging is performed before and after confined compression testing on a minicore of Boise sandstone in order to extract quantitative information regarding the microstructural controls on compaction initiation and distribution, with the ultimate goal of formulating compressibility predictions at in situ conditions. In contrast with traditional compaction studies, our analysis focuses on local statistics among regions of a given sample as opposed to global statistics in a sample set. The original workflow includes a segmentation strategy and the definition of a series of metrics that are evaluated throughout the entire image volumes before and after testing. The results suggest that local porosity and sorting are the main controls on local strength, whereas neighborhoods with larger mean grain size do not appear to be more prone to yielding. This is consistent with previous findings on confined comminution which emphasize the tendency of grain size distributions to become self-similar through the elimination of same size neighbors at all scales. INTRODUCTION The limited ability to predict the onset and development of compaction at the pore scale in high porosity reservoir rocks undergoing depletion represents a substantial barrier to the optimization of appraisal and production planning. Compaction may be potentially beneficial as a pressure support mechanism but can also be a hindrance to overall flow properties through reservoir compartmentalization and fines production/migration. This topic has been the focus of many studies both within industry and academia (Fatt, 1958; Zhang et al., 1990a; Schutjens et al., 1998; Wong and Baud, 1999; Olsson et al., 2002). Beyond conventional reservoir operations, better understanding of the mechanical behavior of confined granular aggregates is of interest in many other subsurface applications from 4D seismic interpretation to storage and subsidence, but also across industries in environmental and civil engineering domains. As a powerful extension of traditional microscopy work, non-destructive X-ray CT imaging has been enabling investigations that were not previously possible. An example is the in-situ monitoring of 3D microstructural changes occurring in materials under active loading, with the continuous introduction of ever more sophisticated setups (e.g. Renard et al., 2016; Voltolini et al., 2019; Shahin et al., 2022; Francois et al., 2022).
Article
Full-text available
Critical processes including seismic faulting, reservoir compartmentalization, and borehole failure involve high‐pressure mechanical behavior and strain localization of sedimentary rocks such as sandstone. Sand is often used as a model material to study the mechanical behavior of poorly lithified sandstone. Recent studies exploring the multi‐scale mechanics of sand have characterized the brittle, low‐pressure regime of behavior; however, limited work has provided insights into the ductile, high‐pressure regime of behavior via in‐situ measurements. Critical features of the ductile regime, including grain breakage, grain micromechanics, and volumetric strain behavior therefore remain under‐explored. Here, we use a new high‐pressure triaxial apparatus with in‐situ x‐ray tomography to provide new insights into deformation banding, grain breakage, and grain micromechanics in Ottawa sand subjected to triaxial compression under confining pressures between 10 and 45 MPa. We observed strain‐hardening at pressures above 15 MPa and strain‐neutral responses at pressures below 15 MPa. Compacting shear bands and grain breakage were observed at all pressures with no significant variation due to grain size, except for minor increases in breakage in less‐rounded sands. Grain breakage emerged at stress levels lower than the assumed yield threshold and more intense breakage was associated with thinner deformation bands. Contact sliding at inter‐grain contacts demonstrated a bifurcation into a bimodal distribution, with intense sliding within deformation bands and reduced but non‐negligible sliding outside of deformation bands, suggesting that off‐band zones remain mechanically active during strain hardening.
Article
Full-text available
An X-ray transparent experimental triaxial rock deformation apparatus, here named ‘Mjölnir’, enables investigations of brittle-style rock deformation and failure, as well as coupled thermal, chemical and mechanical processes relevant to a range of Earth subsurface environments. Designed to operate with cylindrical samples up to 3.2 mm outside-diameter and up to 10 mm length, Mjölnir can attain up to 50 MPa confining pressure and in excess of 600 MPa axial load. The addition of heaters extends the experimental range to temperatures up to 140°C. Deployment of Mjolnir on synchrotron beamlines indicates that full 3D datasets may be acquired in a few seconds to a few minutes, meaning full 4D investigations of deformation processes can be undertaken. Mjölnir is constructed from readily available materials and components and complete technical drawings are included in the supporting information.
Article
Full-text available
Spam, the Software for the Practical Analysis of Materials is a Python library that has evolved to cover needs of data analysis from 3D x-ray tomography work and correlated random fields with mechanical applications. Spam is first and foremost a measurement package that extends the extremely convenient framework of NumPy [@numpy] and SciPy [@SciPy2020] by providing or accelerating tools for the material- science/mechanics oriented analysis of 2D images or 3D volumes representing field measurements. Typical uses are either the measurement of displacements fields between images of a deforming sample from which strains can be computed, or the characterisation of a particular microstructure (correlation length or particle orientation). The package is organised into a library of Python tools which are expected to be used in user-written scripts and a number of more sophisticated standalone scripts.
Article
Full-text available
Catastrophic failure of brittle rocks is important in managing risk associated with system‐sized material failure. Such failure is caused by nucleation, growth, and coalescence of microcracks that spontaneously self‐organize along localized damage zones under compressive stress. Here we present X‐ray microtomography observations that elucidate the in situ micron‐scale processes, obtained from novel tri‐axial compression experiments conducted in a synchrotron. We examine the effect of microstructural heterogeneity in the starting material (Ailsa Craig microgranite; known for being virtually crack‐free) on crack network evolution and localization. To control for heterogeneity, we introduced a random nanoscale crack network into one sample by thermal stressing, leaving a second sample as‐received. By assessing the time‐dependent statistics of crack size and spatial distribution, we test the hypothesis that the degree of starting heterogeneity influences the order and predictability of the phase transition between intact and failed states. We show that this is indeed the case at the system‐scale. The initially more heterogeneous (heat‐treated) sample showed clear evidence for a second‐order transition: inverse power law acceleration in correlation length with a well‐defined singularity near failure and distinct changes in the scaling exponents. The more homogeneous (untreated) sample showed evidence for a first‐order transition: exponential increase in correlation length associated with distributed damage and unstable crack nucleation ahead of abrupt failure. In both cases, anisotropy in the initial porosity dictated the fault orientation, and system‐sized failure occurred when the correlation length approached the grain size. These results have significant implications for the predictability of catastrophic failure in different materials.
Article
Full-text available
The mechanical behavior of porous sandstones is generally modeled using concepts from granular mechanics, often overlooking the effect of cementation. To probe the key differences between sand and sandstone mechanics, we performed triaxial deformation experiments on Ottawa quartz sand at 5‐ to 40 MPa effective confining pressure. At 5 MPa, the samples are able to dilate. At higher confinement, the aggregates show continuous compaction, displaying strain hardening. The stress‐strain behavior is nonlinear, and the exact onset of inelastic compaction could not be determined accurately. Measured P‐wave velocities show the development of anisotropy. With increasing axial strain, the along‐axis velocities tend to increase, while velocities perpendicular to the compression axis tend to decrease (at low pressure) or remain constant (at high pressure). In samples deformed under elevated pressure conditions, acoustic emission event locations are diffuse. Microstructural investigations show an increase in grain chipping and crushing with increasing confining pressure, but no evidence of localized compaction could be observed. The nature of the pore fluid, either decane or water, does not significantly influence the mechanical behavior at strain rates of 10⁻⁶ to 10⁻⁴ s⁻¹. Grain angularity and grain‐size distribution also did not significantly change the mechanical behavior. We infer that our observations indicate that the lack of cementation introduces additional degrees of freedom for grains to slide, rotate, and reorganize at the sample scale, precluding the existence and sustainability of stress concentrations beyond the grain scale. This results in progressive compaction and hardening, and lack of compaction localization.
Article
Full-text available
A new experimental triaxial cell for in situ synchrotron X-ray micro-computed tomography aimed at imaging small samples of (6 mm × 19 mm) at high temperatures (up to 400°C) and pressures (up to 24 MPa confining) is presented. The system has flow-through capabilities, independent axial and radial pressure control, and has been developed and tested at the 8.3.2. beamline at the Advanced Light Source. The characteristics of this new experimental rig are described, along with the challenges, mainly concerning the combination of X-ray transparency with vessel strength at high temperature, and solutions found during the development stage. An experiment involving oil shale pyrolysis under subsurface conditions, highlighting the importance of a device able to operate in this pressure and temperature range, is also introduced. The availability of this cell enables an unprecedented range of experiments in the Earth Sciences, with a special focus on subsurface geothermal processes.
Article
Full-text available
Three-dimensional X-ray diffraction (3DXRD), a method for quantifying the position, orientation and elastic strain of large ensembles of single crystals, has recently emerged as an important tool for studying the mechanical response of granular materials during compaction. Applications have demonstrated the utility of 3DXRD and X-ray computed tomography (XRCT) for assessing strains, particle stresses and orientations, inter-particle contacts and forces, particle fracture mechanics, and porosity evolution in situ. Although past studies employing 3DXRD and XRCT have elucidated the mechanics of spherical particle packings and angular particle packings with a small number of particles, there has been limited effort to date in studying angular particle packings with a large number of particles and in comparing the mechanics of these packings with those composed of a large number of spherical particles. Therefore, the focus of the present paper is on the mechanics of several hundred angular particles during compaction using in situ 3DXRD to study the crystal structure, kinematics, stresses and rotations of angular quartz grains. Comparisons are also made between the compaction response of angular grains and that of spherical grains, and stress-induced twinning within individual grains is discussed.
Article
Full-text available
A hard X-ray transparent triaxial deformation apparatus, called HADES, has been developed by Sanchez Technologies and installed on the microtomography beamline ID19 at the European Radiation Synchrotron Facility (ESRF). This rig can be used for time-lapse microtomography studies of the deformation of porous solids (rocks, ceramics, metallic foams) at conditions of confining pressure to 100 MPa, axial stress to 200 MPa, temperature to 250°C, and controlled aqueous fluid flow. It is transparent to high-energy X-rays above 60 keV and can be used for in situ studies of coupled processes that involve deformation and chemical reactions. The rig can be installed at synchrotron radiation sources able to deliver a high-flux polychromatic beam in the hard X-ray range to acquire tomographic data sets with a voxel size in the range 0.7–6.5 µm in less than two minutes.
Article
Full-text available
Strain localisation plays a key role in the deformation of granular materials. Such localisation involves bands of just a few grains wide, which dominate the material's macroscopic response. This grain-scale phenomenon presents challenges for continuum modelling, which is the rationale behind models that explicitly take micro-scales into account. These in turn require micro-scale experimental analysis. In this work, X-ray tomography is used to image a small sample of oolitic sand while it deforms under triaxial compression. Grains are followed with a technique combining recent developments in image correlation and particle tracking. From these rich data, the evolution of the material in a subvolume of a thousand grains inside the sample (which contains 53 000 grains) is presented. The subvolume is chosen to lie inside the shear band that appears at the sample scale. Three-dimensional (3D) grain kinematics are analysed in three increments: the beginning of the test, the peak of the sample's macroscopic axial stress response and the residual stress state. When the sample's deformation is homogeneous (increment one) or fully localised (increment three), the kinematics of the grains in the subvolume appear to be representative of the kinematics occurring at the sample scale, allowing micro-mechanical observations to be made. In the transition from homogeneous to localised deformation (increment two), however, the scale of observation requires a zoom out of the subvolume to the sample scale in order to capture the complex mechanisms at play.
Article
A constitutive model is presented for brittle granular materials based on a recent reformulation of the breakage mechanics theory. The primary objective of the study is to capture peak strength with subsequent strain softening in dilatant specimens under shearing and the simultaneous evolution of breakage and dilation. The predictive performance of the model is assessed relative to two experimental datasets from the literature. The influence of the model parameters on the overall material response is described through a detailed calibration procedure based on a benchmark experimental dataset. Comparison of the results of drained triaxial compression experiments on two sands with the predictions of the model indicates that the enriched model can successfully capture the evolution of stress-strain behavior at different confinement levels. The predicted response of dilatant specimens exhibits stress- and density-dependent peak strength and strain softening toward the critical state, which is in agreement with experimental evidence. The simulations of Kurnell sand can reproduce the transition of the volumetric strain from -0.05 to 0.14 as the confining pressure increases from 760 to 7,800 kPa. The predicted breakage of specimens subjected to different confining pressures is slightly higher than experimental measurements, whereas they exhibit similar trends. The proposed framework is capable of qualitatively reproducing many aspects of the experimentally observed stress-dilatancy-breakage relationship in brittle granular materials.
Article
The internal fabric and localized deformation patterns of triaxial sand specimens were investigated using computed tomography (CT). Three displacement-controlled, conventional, drained axisymmetric (triaxial) experiments were conducted on dry Ottawa sand specimens at very low effective confining stresses (0.05, 0.52, and 1.30 kPa) in a microgravity environment aboard the Space Shuttle during the NASA STS-79 mission. CT scanning was performed on these flight specimens, as well as on an uncompressed specimen and a specimen tested in a terrestrial laboratory at 1.30 kPa effective confining stress. CT demonstrated high accuracy in detecting specimen inhomogeneity and localization patterns. Formation of deformation patters is dependent on the effective confining stress and gravity. Multiple symmetrical radial shear bands were observed in the specimens tested in a microgravity environment. In the axial direction, two major conical surfaces were developed. Nonsymmetrical spatial deformation was observed in the 1-G specimen. Analysis tools were developed to quantify the spatial density change. Void ratio variation within and outside the shear bands is calculated and discussed.