Content uploaded by Michael J. Reiss
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Michael J. Reiss on Dec 22, 2022
Content may be subject to copyright.
Evolutionary Perspectives on Childhood Trauma
!"#$
%&'
('%&'
)*%&'
Abstract
"' +++
"$"" $+ "
"+ $$+
,$* +
' $$'$
'','$
"$$"*,'''
'"$$$'$-$$"
$$ ' $$+ ,
', $'*''$
Key words
.'.+.-$$"$.'
.$
1 An evolutionary perspective on why parents may maltreat their children
%"'"$'%
+'"" %!$'+$
% %"'"$' $
'/01230124.*012501026*
%"'" $"+
""'+ '%"$$"+'"'
'+*+'"$
"$'
""+ $$'$$$
,/!6 '"$/78
01206$'$'-""'
''"++
,+ '"',#
$ +"$+
$ %"' +$
9$' /6+"$+' +
$"+"/+6+
" $ '% ''
"$'*,+
2
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
% +''$/01256
"
!+''+''A $++
$+"$
%$"'/*901016%
" $ '
/"#B01016+"+$+
+$' /+"
253?6</''6/$6" /'6
$%"++ $''
'+'+,
'$$ '"-' '-
/'01256*%'
"%$+"/-01256
%" " " '"
C+"'+ DE$++$'
$
*"DE'
" "$''''+
+."""
"$+"+A"
$""/$$"/66"/$$"+6+
+ "'%$+9$'+
, *+" '$$
"$''",
+$$$' ' +
$+
#, $'%"$6-$$"
$+6$ 6++ '
6$$+ 9'+
' + '$'
+' $' $#$$
'E$$'%" '
''
2 Parent-offspring conflict: can child maltreatment be adaptive for the parent?
2.1 Introduction
& $ "''''
$++ '$'+"
'''' $
"+$' $' ')+
'+++%++
0
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
'&-$$"$$$$$'
'$'$$$$"#"'
"+""'""
"'"'
$' E
"
2.2 Stepparents
F$+ -#2541"
'$'%$'$'
$'+"'+'%D!
$$E$+ &24 +*'(''
25 #!''%$' $
#" '$"''$
' '%'$$$'""$$$
+" "+"'$'/01016
#$+25>12551 "
7 "*+
+$'"'% ' % '
'+"/"7 8*
25536 "$ $' +" &
' $'++$'%
'" E7 *
'-','
F$$$'%+ "$'
'$%+'+%
''"$$"
'$
7 *E"" '++
+ ' $'"'
''+$-''%"'"
"$'" +/+01256E
,''%"$$'*'
"+'"%%,'" "
+" "'% '/("
01256$'"'A $'
F ,' $'/("8
!'011?6 +
'$'E$"$+
+"+ +E+"+ +"
!"$''"+"
$"'"'''
'++'"" /$$8011?6
?
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
'" +,+ %$DE$'"
$''$$")
+ +:"'
"% +'/& 8"01126
2.3 Fathers
"$'+"$'"+$'
$+'% '+"'
'+""E F'
''' D'"'E''$$"
$', $E"
''$$'D E'
$"" '$-F21GC$"0-;G"
''% /)011@.'012?60-;G
' ""$$
*',
$$%'++ '$
+"*$,$+%
'"DE$$"
+'% ""'''''
"DE+$'
'E"" E+$
',-F$ "'
'$'++$"
%+'
2.4 Mothers
# '$+-"
''$'++'$'"
%$$'$"/
+ ++6) ' ,'
''$$$''
#% ''' $$
','' ' +
$'' +'
'"F $' F"
$'' ,%$'
F+A" *
%$DE "
/01246 -$$'
'DE-$$' +++
+"$+' '
''$'
+$$""+ "$$/)+
;
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
2535=25546' + '
&'$+$'"
)$$ /255501156 "'"'
$' '$'+"'+
+'" "'""$$ "#
"$$$''$"
+"7$$/0125.'6'$
'$"
" '*'"+$"$
'$'' + ,
"$$+"'% +%$'"
$' "+"'%
+$$'+$"+"
,$'$ "+"
+
3 A life history take on child maltreatment
$ $-DE
/ 6'%<"$
$$"' $$"$""
$*'"$$"$+$"
""B',%+$
"H9$"%$+"+ +$
" H+ $%$
F$ /2551.25506),2
BOX 1: ‘Fast’ and ‘slow’ life histories
! "#!
$
$"
%!!
! "#!
& $
$"
'%' '
""+"$$$"$
$ "+" '+"
"$+ /'01256$
-'+'$"'
''$$" +"
'+ ' ""
! ''"'" "$
@
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
'''A'/01246 "'
'"'+$ / %"
'+6#'"
%$''+ "
("+''% "$
' '++F
$ '"+#*"
'$+ /87(01256+
" $'$'F "'% +
, "'$
,$ "+
"+$ '"+$
' ,$ ''
+ % $"
+++'% '
"'%'%'+-
"+'"', '+$
,'""+'+
+"'$""" /01246
!"$, +$+'-
% $$'"+
$$+'
"-'+/01236*"""
"+"+-
''%'%+"'
"'+'%'%-
" /(%"01226$$$+
"$""'+'+
! $"-'$$+ '
"$"'+$
'
# $"$$''
+"$!''%$
$'""/7801206$'
-$$#'''E"-' "'
'" ' " "
" + +% ,' ' $ $'
""'+++ /(01256
"/*6 '$$+$$+
'/"01236 '%
"$% '+'
$+ $ /!01016
' ,"
%$$$"%$ '
3
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
+%" " "/7+
011?6$"D$E ' $+
F$$'/!'8$$012@6%*
"' ''"" )+"
'$$""
$' ;1'
4 How children have adapted, with reference to attachment theory
+' $'
+'"'
++#, '#$
'$$$"
$E'/' $6$$'
'* " " '
"""++ E''$'
''" $
''*"" "'"+$
'"+"
'"$ '$'$
"$''$'"
"$#"$'
"+""''+
'+ /012?.(012@6'
""+''+'
"""'"
"""'
$$ ' "
"" $ "$$"-'
"/*012;6%'"
+" , +
''/01246'%"$
'$ 'F"+"-
'*'
' $'+ )+ /2535=25546
+$+$'"+'
"/ '6#$ +' " "
+ "+")+
+"+'"
" D E#)+ $
++" "
"D E
4
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
)+ $++ $'+ #
$'"' '%$
' 'D'
$ E/6' '
' E-")+ "
'%$' $'+
'$'
)+ E%$+ "/254>6$
$$%$'<D-ED-
'+E'/25>36+$" '
D"E$+$$+"
$$'+'
"",/! 801216),0$
$$'
BOX 2: Secure and insecure attachment (percentages reflective of UK and US
populations)
! '()*+,!
"% !
"#- "#
!',
!"
! '(.)+,
"%-
! &"#
"
!'+ '(/)+,
!!! "#
& "#(
!!"#$
"
!" '(/*+,(
0! "%
(!!
!"#
'1".**2,"
)+ +'D'E
'+''
$' '++$+
$'$+""'
$+,
""+,
/7% 01016
>
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
"$$'+= ,+
,' " "'#$
+ $$
$$""$+
"""'%"'"+$$'
% #$$ "" '
+,' ""
+'/7% 01016$F %
$ 2551 -''
!'/25556 )% /25546+"%<34
$
5
9$%"F+'+$$
'+'A '
+$$'
'"$$ '
% +"' ++I"
$$$'$'" " +$'
DE
'$+''
+$'# $
'A"+$""
+"'$$$'
$'++"' '
+%' +
#$""-"'
+/&01216$$
# '+" "
$$' 'A/!'2555.
25556'+' ""
$%$"
9+'""""
$/!'2555. 255501156#$$+
$'/'"6+
'"$"7"'$"
'$$'
'"/ 2555012@6"
$+"+$-"/$$
012@6
*'$% $$'C$ '
'C,'$''" +
'
4.1 Fear system
5
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
'+"E$ "
+" '- -/&6,/J-!K
012;6' " $"$
' F% '
# ' " "
&,$%$"'
$%"'$$
+/9'01216
F'#$'
$ ' "/7,012;6,'
''%""'"
'#%$'"
''+E&, +$
'/7 0114.25556) &-
"+,"""
'$$"
"$$+"$+'
"'"'+$
$ '$"
%"""" $'"
/L'012?.01226
'"'" &,'$ '
-+"/01216#%$$$"$'
$', $
' '' $
''" , "$+
%$"",+" $-$$"
'" '$$"
/$$012@6$+"'
""$' " "/!'25556
4.2 Internal models
$''FD'E$
/255501156"$$$''%
+$'
++'D+E'"
'"$$" +$"
$-" '''/%
'6' "'E
%" ''$."+
''$"
++$ $$ $"'+$
$'+"+"%),?
21
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
BOX 3: The effect of social support on internal models
6! !!!
!"%!-
0!"
6 ! !- -
!"#
!"!
-
"# '7 /289,"
#'' +"'F
+% ++$"
'$$ +'%
+'""/ 6$
" +
"$$$"
'+ +'"' $-/'6
" ' -%"/'+'6#
" 'C'"E
"'$' ,
*%"+'
$/701156.+
'"$
$
#'$$$"'C
'++"+ "
'' /01156"'
"""
+ $$"
%"$B"/D''+ E6$
"-%,"+
' + '$/"6'+
"% -"' +,"
"''$ +%
/"6
#'"'$$''/
#AB01016'' $+%
$+"$""+'
"''''
!/01136""" ,+
,'$'+
" '"','
+ " +
'," $'
22
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
"+ $$"""
'$'
#'"+
'' "$$+
'/69A+
''+"*%
' '$'
'
5 How does an evolutionary perspective view epigenetics, differential susceptibility and
resilience?
")%E /8)%25506'+'$+
$"''+ 'E'""
$'++D$ E+++
$"#$$+'+
+'% ++'+'""%
"$$"''"$
'% ++/(0122012@6'$
$+'+/+"6$
""+'$$
F $ ,$'+' ,$
'$$'"++
'"++$
$++'"$,$/)% 2554.
!'2555.')% 011>.!'$$012@6
++'"'$$"''"'
"'" '
+$
$ *'$$
'"$$ '
""' '/"" +%
"$'''6$'+ '
" ++""
"$"$
+ '$'DE/)%'-
L+"#AB0122.)% '012;6&
",'$
'C'' +'D+E#$
'A'++'DE
'$+ '" '""
"""+"
"""/))% 01206+%
DEC'DE+
20
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
'/L 012?6&
'+"'""'
#$+"DE' ++$+'
$$DE
""'$'/),;6'
+'$+ '/L 012?6
'""'" ""
""$$'
"''$$+ ''
/)%'-L+"#AB012@6!"
"@/01226'"
/)%'-L+"01226
BOX 4: Vignette
!/:"%4;"#
!- !(
"(
" %
&(!-
"3 !&
!;!
"7;
!!"7
-
! - (" -
;! ! &
! "%!(
- ";
( <
-"7!-
! & ! !"
7 "
!
!6(" !
!!
!!!;"
3 !
!"%(
(
"=!-
!
"
2?
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
%!(
&
"( !
!"-
(&
"
-!"#
-!!;-!>
-(!--
("
;!
;-! "%
!- !;"
! !
!;"
D#%"E$'$$
+$" $'"$""
!$$" ' -""
$$$""'' "
'/6*
"$$'+'"' '
" + $$'#$
' ' $'
Key points
!,':
,"+"
*'$'+' +$
',"+"
)+$+'#
+ "+"'#
"A"''+
)++'+" $"
$" $ %
#$$"$ ''%
'""9'%
"" '-'+$"+"'
, C$'"'
"'
''+'C$
$F$$"$$
'
2;
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
'"$+'' +
%%+'
''
References
7/254>66 6%%
%"<+'
)%'-L+"#AB/012267$$+
"'"'-"<'-
1 23?5-@0
)%'-L+"#B/012@6$$ $
<"M','$'$$+
6?!66?>2-;15
)L)% /01206(-'"
'$"<"$$-+
@83/2605-;1
)"L"/011@6"
+F;
59/564;5-4@;
)% /25546''""<
A8?32-?>2
)% '/012;6(-' <
$$+ '$713>4->5
)+ /2535=255466 B6 <&'
! &/01216-6 #?
6/06N%<($&
!'/255561%(%
"!'+"<!'+" &
!'$$7/012@6$ "<
'H#<$$7C #
!?"<"23?-
2>2
!&L L')"L
/01016"'"''%"'
'$'$ " "
50/462151-215>
7 */25536 " '$<$
#<)7'%(!
"9,$<9,$ &5-0>
7)/01206,
"-D=106/2605-?5:
7$$")&B %(&!&
!/01156,%$$"-
6D6163/20622?@-22;?
2@
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
7 /01146"''"$$"
$$",;A3204@-
0>;
7+O7"(*/011?6'$
,+'<$'$+"+%
251137/?603>-044:
7% /010166 ?9,$<9,$ &
)7(/012567'<
6?!70/26222-2?5
))(%O%*/01246) %
$<-+:
%:12/;6@32-@>4
(*L'&/012?6! $-""
1 7;?-;>
O' &+&&B7/01226
$$ '$ '- -,'
'A=?!35/462322-2305
77!'"7 /25556"
,'$$$ 6
A!E-6 %89633->;
("!!'/01256$E$$ -
%"$-F 'F
$' '"$':;
33/@6@02-@?2
(O/01226<"$ " <
;52/;6?@3-?34
(O/012@6&$$$<+ "
+"''#<(O!
A 7<"035-0>?
(%O +7*+/01226$$
' '% <$
;%100/36212@-2103
(7&F!)7B))/01256&+
+$$$ $B
A6 %116/;>60?5>;-0?5>>
!)%7/25506 0/--6+'<
$ 135/46@5@-312
"77(L/6("'
"B<%"+%$6 D 1
'!")!/01256"+%"
+"'+"$ -$$'
"''"$$":10520?-2?4
)/25556AA% %<
!8*
)/01156F#FC"
!'+"<)%&$
23
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
)/012@6O+''"''
P+"Q<'
=77040-0>?
L /012?69<''+
'$$+'$'
18?25-?02
'O+%O( 7$(O
L*7/012?6$%
*'+ N-''""
?%==%280/24406<012?0;11
O'&!/01216#3 B#
1# !'+"<!'+" &
7,/012;6!'"'$A6
%1110>42-0>4>
L&/01226*"' <+$
''""''$$
#=A70@2-0>1
'/25>367 $'<
$"'$$$+#<)B
)N"'61 3<+,
5@-20;
)/01256A!3%(6!'<"
(/012?6-+<$$$+ 'E$'
3;=120-2@
(/01236AA6 %=
1 ."<& " &
+(&"%(L/01256!'+ $<
'$);(
G148/362152-2210
9'!&7B"!/01216'
' '"$
1 22/26215-22>
&!/0121671 5*"7!<
("
/25516B"<"$' #
9045-054
J-!K/012;6 $''<''
"$$+,'
5??
$$7/012@6!"<,""$'
'-#<$$7C #
!?<"002-
0?3
$$7/01256'E<$+'
62/262@-?;
')% /011>6' '
$'%#<&! -6 #
?60N%<($&2?2-2@4
24
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
/25506#B9,$<9,$ &
-77+-!'L!/01256#"
= $'''"-''- <
$''' "$"
$' " 1 31/262>5-010
"'(%OL#-!'()% /01236
$-''+$$$$$ -$"$'
%27/@6334-34;
$$7(*)/01236
'+=;622?3-;?
(/01246 %"
77=;623;21-;2>
+"/253?69''$" HI#20;21-
;??
LL'A#L/01016<
""$'$:;
:82/063?5-3@3
#B)%'-L+"!")A'/01016
<'+ $'- ''
<$$+ %
:;61/?6040-051
*I"LN")I'%%B77"-
&'+(&%9E"LB%(
L$'/012;6!+' "
+ ;6 6
653/;6;24-;0;
*9/01016 <====-'=$-==-
''/<001026
*'(/ (6/254;67+ ;
3/;62@-0>
*)(/01256!
%""" H=;6:25/36?@2-?30
*)(/01026!
"'+$H
26/260>?-05;
2>
(8*)/01006
'#+8&-'/6:
:/02;-0046!'+"<!'+" &
<212124=54>252230?30@123
