Conference PaperPDF Available
- 1 -
Utilizing e-Ticketing to Increase Productivity and Minimize Shortage of
Karthik Subramanya, S.M. ASCE,1 Sharareh Kermanshachi, Ph.D., P.E., M. ASCE2,
Apurva Pamidimukkala, S.M. ASCE3 and Karthikeyan Loganathan Ph.D4
1Ph.D. Student, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Texas at Arlington, 425
Nedderman Hall, 416 Yates Street, Arlington, Tx 76019
2(Corresponding Author) Associate Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, University of
Texas at Arlington, 425 Nedderman Hall, 416 Yates Street, Arlington, Tx 76019
3Ph.D. Student, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Texas at Arlington, 425
Nedderman Hall, 416 Yates Street, Arlington, TX 76019
4Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, University of Texas at Arlington, 425
Nedderman Hall, 416 Yates Street, Arlington, TX 76019. Email:
State departments of transportation (DOTs) are constructing and managing more highway projects
than ever before despite limited funds and a shortage of inspectors. A few DOTs and general
contractors have implemented e-Ticketing technology to increase their workforce productivity and
efficiency, but the majority are still using conventional paper methods because they do not fully
comprehend the benefits of the technology. The goal of this study is to quantify the impact of e-
Ticketing technology on the number of inspectors required for a project and on the level of
productivity. A comprehensive literature review and stakeholder survey were conducted and
revealed that all 20 DOTs reported workforce shortages. A comparison was made between the
required number of inspectors prior to and after the implementation of e-Ticketing, and it was
found that projects requiring multiple inspectors could reduce their workforce by 25% by
implementing e-Ticketing. The findings of this research will enable state DOTs to reduce the
number of inspectors on-site, thereby circumventing the shortage of workers.
KEYWORDS: Construction, e-Ticketing, Productivity, DOT, Workforce Shortage
State DOTs have limited inspection personnel and financial resources to meet the increasing
demand for highway construction and rehabilitation projects (Oechler et al., 2018; Rouhanizadeh
and Kermanshachi 2020; Safapour et al., 2020; Subramanya et al., 2020), and the shortage of
inspectors foretells the possibility of quality shortfalls (Taylor and Maloney 2013; Kermanshachi
et al., 2017). A recent study conducted by the Indiana DOT expressed the agency's difficulty in
staffing over the past decade as a result of inspectors quitting their positions or moving to the
private sector. (Cai et al., 2020). The Kentucky Transportation Cabinet (KYTC) also reported a
shortage of inspectors, due to the increased demand for construction (Rush 2021). According to Li
- 2 -
et al., some state DOTs are unable to replace retiring inspectors and engineers, and Anderson et
al. observed that while many state DOTs have improved their ability to retain and manage their
workforce, they still face a shortage of skilled employees (Subramanya and Kermanshachi 2021).
The resignation and retirement of highly qualified inspectors and engineers have significant
impacts on highway inspection capabilities (Newcomer et al., 2019; Nipa et al., 2022).
Researchers are continually searching for new ways to enhance the productivity and
operational efficiency of highway construction by utilizing cutting-edge technology (Nipa and
Kermanshachi 2022). A study by the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) demonstrated that
integrating 3D modelling with GPS sensors could yield faster highway construction with greater
worker safety. Some organizations have achieved a 50% increase in output and up to 75%
reduction in inspection costs by utilizing this combination. The FHWA also encourages Electronic
Construction (e-Construction) to minimize delays in project management, store and retrieve
documents securely, and increase real-time management (FHWA 2018; Patel et al., 2019;
Embacher 2020). By saving 1.78 inspector hours per day and producing/documenting 2.75 times
the data, e-Construction could save contractors up to $40,000 yearly per construction project
(Weisner et al., 2017). PennDOT expects a $23.4 million annual operational savings, including
$5.9 million in construction documentation reductions (Brinckerhoff 2017). Paperless inspection
and construction administration are two examples of operational savings that can be attributed to
a reduction in storage and supply costs. The Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT)
standardized its project management, field data collection, and documentation procedures by
employing a specialized technology platform, smart devices, and formal collaborative
partnerships. They used e-Construction for all their construction projects to speed up data
collection and handle issues that arise in field operations and claim that their $1.1 million
investment led to $22 million in administration process cost savings annually (Torres et al., 2018).
E-Ticketing is a novel approach that has been pilot tested by state DOTs since 2015
(FHWA 2021; Sadasivam and Sturgill 2021; Tripathi et al., 2022; FHWA 2022), but only a handful
of states have implemented the technology. Many studies have been conducted to investigate its
numerous advantages, but they have not measured the increased productivity that results from its
use. As this is a strong motivator for stakeholders adopting the technology, the goal of this research
is to quantify the increase in productivity of DOT’s highway construction inspectors and engineers
that results from implementing e-Ticketing technology.
Decreased productivity in the paper ticketing process: This section focuses on understanding
the limitations of the current ticketing process. Producing, sorting, recording, and archiving paper
tickets is a time-consuming and expensive process for both state DOTs and general contractors.
(Kermanshachi et al., 2019; Sadasivam and Sturgill 2021; Robertson et al., 2022). These
documents, which include bills of materials as well as inspection reports, proper documentation,
and a number of other informational records, are commonly required by contractors and owner's
representatives during a project. Since most highway construction work is carried out at the job
site, documents must be transferred to computers, demanding re-entry of data, or remain in a bulky
inaccessible paper format.
The practice of physically collecting delivery truck load codes exposes inspectors to
several safety dangers such as walking alongside traffic and boarding trucks to collect paper tickets
(Subramanya et al., 2022). Handing off and entering data through paper tickets is a time-
- 3 -
consuming and resource-intensive process that necessitates several "touchpoints" along the way,
and the paper tickets lack material traceability since it is not uncommon for them to be lost or
damaged, resulting in delayed billing and a waste of considerable time/resources. In contrast,
digitally saved data can be retrieved with ease. Illegible data is another concern, as most asphalt
plant owners still use dot matrix printers with carbon copies. Despite the recent technological
advancements, some DOTs require administrative personnel to manually scan each paper ticket
into document management software, which is a time-consuming and repetitive task.
Increased Productivity with e-Ticketing: The FHWA defines e-Ticketing as a software platform
that facilitates the collection and information transfer for items as they are transported from the
plant to the job site in real time. E-Ticketing is more efficient than a paper-based system because
it automates routine tasks such as collecting and summarizing paper tickets and reduces the
workload of highway inspectors, enabling them to focus on other inspection tasks (Nipa and
Kermanshachi 2019; Subramanya et al., 2022). It also conserves the manpower and resources
required for paper printing, storage, and archiving of records, and expedites payment transactions.
E-Ticketing streamlines data administration by capturing data electronically and providing
opportunities for automatic transfers and archiving documents. It also eliminates lost or damaged
tickets, eliminates handoffs involving paper tickets, and automatically creates, transmits, and saves
data in a consistent, trustworthy, and efficient manner. Electronic data collection for load deliveries
enables more secure and efficient inspections (Sturgill et al., 2019), faster project delivery, more
timely payments (Subramanya and Kermanshachi 2022), less effort for ticket management, and
real-time comparisons of theoretical and actual tonnage (Nipa and Kermanshachi 2019; Tripathi
et al., 2022). Additionally, inspectors' exposure to potentially hazardous working circumstances
could be significantly decreased, and contractors' operational efficiency may be increased (Nipa
et al., 2019; Subramanya et al., 2022).
This study's research methodology consists of four parts, as depicted in Figure 1. First, the authors
reviewed previous research that was conducted on workforce shortages and the benefits of
implementing e-Ticketing technology in highway construction projects. Second, a survey
questionnaire was developed to explore ways that inspection staffs’ productivity could be
improved by implementing e-Ticketing technology. QuestionPro, an online survey platform, was
used to construct and distribute the survey to those who had worked in highway/bridge
construction projects, and 53 participants completed them. Third, the survey responses from
industry professionals were descriptively analyzed to forecast any increase in the inspection staffs
productivity. The following are samples of the survey questions: (1) How frequently does your
organization face shortages of inspectors and engineers? (2) What is the average time taken to scan
a day’s batch of paper tickets into document management software? (3) How many man hours per
inspector per day can be saved by adopting e-Ticketing technology? Finally, the survey data and
findings from the existing literature were combined to address the industry's workforce shortage.
- 4 -
Figure 1: Research methodology
Demographics of participants: Of the 53 respondents, 39 respondents had more than 10 years of
experience in highway construction projects and 14 had less than 10 years of experience. Hence,
the majority of the participants had extensive knowledge of highway construction that would
enable them to provide reasonable responses relevant to the current research goals. More than 70%
- 5 -
of the respondents were state DOT employees, most of which were from the Indiana and
Washington DOTs, although a variety of states at various stages of e-Ticketing adoption were
included. Contractors represented 11%, and 5% were material suppliers. More than 75% visited
construction sites on a regular basis, while 25% did not. Figure 2 illustrates the various DOT
participants who responded to the survey. To get more stratified data, the survey was circulated
to all the stakeholders involved in implementing e-Ticketing. The survey sample was stratified to
better understand the technology's overall implications.
Figure 2: Distribution of DOT participants by state
Workforce Shortage of Inspectors and Engineers: The survey questions pertaining to the extent
of the shortage of inspectors required responses based on a Likert scale, and 27.45% of the state
DOTs indicated a “frequent” workforce shortage, 11.76% responded “All the time,” and 0% of the
respondents responded “Never. This indicates that every state DOT is facing some level of
shortage (Figure 3).
Figure 3: Workforce shortage of inspectors and engineers
7State DOT List
Total Respondents = 37 participants
Never, 0%
Rarely, 7.84%
17.65%All the time,
- 6 -
Productivity Gains: Another question was designed to determine whether implementing e-
Ticketing increases inspectors productivity on job sites or whether the advantage is primarily
minimizing human errors. The productivity gains could only be estimated by determining the time
required for each step of the paper ticket processing, and 25% of the respondents estimated that it
would take them 30 to 60 minutes to manually scan a batch of tickets, 20.9% estimated 1 to 2
hours, 20.9% estimated less than 15 minutes, and a few reported that it would take them 4 hours.
A detailed breakdown is shown in Table 1.
One of the last steps in manual ticketing is processing the invoices for payment. As per
the frequency analysis shown in Table 2, this task is also considered time-consuming and was
estimated by 24.4% of the respondents to take 30 to 60 minutes; 26.8% estimated that it would
take them 15 to 30 minutes. It also should be noted that it is not uncommon for tickets to be lost
or misplaced, which delays the billing process.
Table 1: Time It Takes Inspectors to Manually Scan One Day’s Tickets
Time Taken
Table 2: Time It Takes to Match Up Tickets and Pay Invoices
Time Taken
Less than 15 minutes
15 - 30 minutes
30 - 60 minutes
1 2 hours 
2 hours and more
Overall, these operations, when combined with inefficiencies in the paper ticketing process
identified in the literature review, take more than one hour for many respondents, making the
manual system very time-consuming. Respondents were also asked how many hours could be
saved by adopting an e-Ticketing system, and Table 3 shows that 38.8% of respondents estimated
that it would save between 30 minutes and one hour per day, 20.4% estimated 1 or 2 hours, and
24% per cent estimated less than 30 minutes. The varied responses are observed in the dataset as
the time saved by inspectors or engineers will differ based on project cost and duration. Also, the
state DOTs have different processes for handling the material tickets and the administrative work.
Table 3. Time Saved Inspectors per Day by e-Ticketing
Time Taken
30 minutes or less 
- 7 -
30 minutes to 1 hour
1 2 hours
2 - 3 hours
4 hours or more
Inspector/engineer Requirement: Table 4 depicts the difference between the number of
inspectors required at a project job site with and without using e-Ticketing and shows that paper
ticketing requires more inspectors. The number is obviously the same for both processes for
projects that only need only one inspector. Hence the same analysis was conducted after removing
the two responses that indicated that only one inspector was needed because of the small size of
the project. The corrected percentage of inspectors needed reduces the workforce by
approximately 25%. This is also representative of all categories of projects based on various costs
in the United States, as it is a subset of the total population and indicates that mandating and
implementing the e-Ticketing platform throughout the U.S. could reduce the number of inspectors
and engineers needed for highway construction projects by 25%.
Table 4: Percentage of Inspectors Saved due to Adoption of e-Ticketing
Inspectors needed without adoption of e-Ticketing
Inspectors needed with adoption of e-Ticketing
Percentage of inspectors saved
Analysis after removal of projects which require a single inspector
Inspectors needed without adoption of e-Ticketing
Inspectors needed with adoption of e-Ticketing
Percentage of inspectors saved
The goal of the survey questionnaire was to quantify the effect that e-Ticketing technology would
have on inspectors’ productivity. The participants estimated that the implementation of an e-
Ticketing platform would save each inspector between 30 and 90 minutes per day that would be
required for manually scanning paper tickets into document management software, matching them
up with the invoices, paying invoices, and calculating cumulative loads manually. From the
analysis of the survey responses, it is evident that the productivity of inspectors and engineers is
directly proportional to the number of tickets produced at the job site, which is a function of project
duration or project cost. The increase in their productivity is directly related to the amount of time
saved per day per project by using e-Ticketing technology. The study also investigated whether
implementing e-Ticketing can reduce the number of inspectors required for highway construction
projects, and it was deduced from Table 4 that for projects that require more than one inspector, e-
Ticketing would eliminate approximately 25% of the inspector workforce. In the majority of
medium-to-large scale projects not utilizing e-Ticketing technology, one standalone inspector
- 8 -
would be needed to collect the paper tickets, record the truck numbers, calculate the cumulative
loads, and manually enter the information into Excel spreadsheets. With the adoption of e-
Ticketing, this entire repetitive process can be automated, and the inspectors can be reassigned to
another project that needs work related to quality control and quality assurance. This in turn helps
in minimizing the problem of workforce shortage of inspectors and engineers.
Statewide adoption of e-Ticketing can be of great benefit for organizations coping with
dwindling workforces, rising expenses, and delayed schedules. By utilizing e-Ticketing, State
DOTs could realize significant savings, and alleviate the nation's chronic workforce shortage of
highway construction inspectors. By combining it with other more recent technologies, highly
experienced personnel could serve as a central monitoring resource for multiple highway
construction projects. The widespread adoption of e-Ticketing technology has the potential to
delay the retirement of some personnel and by delivering fulfilling employment in a nice, secure,
and adaptable workplace environment, entice those who have already retired to return to work
part-time. The experienced inspectors can remotely work from the office and monitor the progress
of work. Delaying the retirement of inspectors who are passionate about the industry and equipping
them with technological advancements will further help in minimizing the problem of workforce
shortage. In addition, the e-Ticketing technology will facilitate the storage of immense quantities
of previously unavailable data, including value of the contract, timeframe, true cost, actual
timeline, accumulated tonnage/waste, inspection checklist data, type of material, project size,
number of trucks, number of inspectors, etc., that can be utilized to establish predictive models for
operational cost and quality requirements.
We gratefully acknowledge the support and generosity of the Transportation Consortium of South-
Central States (Tran-SET), without which the present study could not have been completed.
Anderson, L., C. Cronin, D. Helfman, B. Cronin, B. Cook, M. Venner, and M. Lodato. (2012)
NCHRP Report 693: Attracting, Recruiting, and Retaining Skilled Staff for
Transportation System Operations and Management. Transportation Research Board of
the National Academies, Washington, D.C.,
Brinckerhoff, P. (2017). Addressing Challenges and Return on Investment (ROI) for Paperless
Project Delivery. (e-Construction):[techbrief] (No. FHWA-HRT-16-068). United States.
Federal Highway Administration. Office of Research, Development, and Technology.
Cai, H., J. Jeon, X. Xu, Y. Zhang, and L. Yang. (2020). Automating the Generation of
Construction Checklists. No. FHWA/ IN/JTRP-2020/23. Purdue University, Joint
Transportation Research Program, West Lafayette,
Embacher, R. 2021. “Use of Material Delivery Management System (MDMS) for Asphalt Paving
Applications.” (No. MN 2021-10). Minnesota. Dept. of Transportation. Office of Policy
Analysis, Research & Innovation.
Federal Highway Administration. 2020. e-Ticketing and digital as-builts. U.S. Department of
Transportation, Washington, D. C.
- 9 -
Federal Highway Administration. 2021. Every day counts. U.S. Department of Transportation,
Washington, D. C.
Kermanshachi, S., Anderson, S. D., Goodrum, P., & Taylor, T. R. 2017. Project scoping process
model development to achieve on-time and on-budget delivery of highway
projects. Transportation Research Record, 2630(1), 147-155.
Kermanshachi, S., Safapour, E., Anderson, S., Goodrum, P., Taylor, T., & Sadatsafavi, H.
(2019). Development of multi-level scoping process framework for transportation
infrastructure projects using IDEF modeling technique. In Proceedings of Transportation
Research Board 98th Annual Conference.
Li, Y., S. Al-Haddad, T. R. Taylor, P. M. Goodrum, and R. E. Sturgill. (2019). Impact of
Utilizing Construction Engineering and Inspection Consultants on Highway Construction
Project Cost and Schedule Performance. Transportation Research Record: Journal of the
Transportation Research Board, 2019. 2673: 716725.
Newcomer, C., Withrow, J., Sturgill, R. E., & Dadi, G. B. (2019). Towards an automated asphalt
paving construction inspection operation. Advances in Informatics and Computing in
Civil and Construction Engineering, 593-600.
Nipa, T. J., & Kermanshachi, S. (2022). Resilience measurement in highway and roadway
infrastructures: Experts' perspectives. Progress in Disaster Science, 14, 100230.
Nipa, T. J., Kermanshachi, S., & Subramanya, K. (2022). Development of Innovative Strategies
to Enhance the Resilience of the Critical Infrastructure. In Construction Research
Congress 2022 (pp. 111-120).
Nipa, T. J., Rouhanizadeh, B., & Kermanshachi, S. (2019). Utilization and implementation of the
E-ticketing technology to electronically track the delivery of construction materials.
In CSCE Annual Conference.
Oechler, E., K. R. Molenaar, M. Hallowell, and S. Scott. (2018). State-of-Practice for Risk-
Based Quality Assurance in State Departments of Transportation. Engineering,
Construction and Architectural Management, Vol. 25, No. 7, pp. 958970.
Ogunrinde, O., Nnaji, C., & Amirkhanian, A. 2020. Application of emerging technologies for
Highway Construction Quality Management: A Review. Construction Research Congress
Patel, D., Sturgill, R., Dadi, G., & Taylor, T. 2019. Evaluating the performance of e-construction
tools in highway resurfacing projects. Proceedings of the 36th International Symposium
on Automation and Robotics in Construction (ISARC).
Robertson, G., Zhang, S., & Bogus, S. M. (2022). Challenges of Implementing E-Ticketing for
Rural Transportation Construction Projects. In Construction Research Congress 2022
(pp. 453-462).
Rouhanizadeh, B., & Kermanshachi, S. 2020. Challenges and strategies incorporated with
Transportation Construction Inspection. Construction Research Congress 2020.
Rush, S. (2021) Risk-Based Construction Inspection. Master’s the- sis. University of Kentucky,
- 10 -
Sadasivam, S., & Sturgill, R. (2021). e-Ticketing Handout [tech note] (No. FHWA-HRT-22-044).
United States. Federal Highway Administration. Office of Research, Development, and
Safapour, E., Kermanshachi, S., & Jafari, A. (2020). Effective project management principles
and strategies in transportation infrastructure projects. In Creative Construction e-
Conference 2020 (pp. 126-135). Budapest University of Technology and Economics.
Sturgill, R. E., Dadi, G. B., Van Dyke, C., Patel, D., Withrow, J., & Newcomer, C. (2019). E-
Ticketing and Advanced Technologies for Efficient Construction Inspections (No. KTC-
19-14/SPR18-554-1F). University of Kentucky Transportation Center.
Subramanya, K., & Kermanshachi, S. (2021). Exploring Utilization of the 3D Printed Housing
as Post-Disaster Temporary Shelter for Displaced People. In Construction Research
Congress 2022 (pp. 594-605).
Subramanya, K., & Kermanshachi, S. 2021. Impact of COVID-19 on transportation industry:
comparative analysis of road, air, and rail transportation modes. In International
Conference on Transportation and Development (pp. 230-242).
Subramanya, K., & Kermanshachi, S. 2022. E-Ticketing Technology in Construction Projects:
Adoption, Benefits, and Challenges. In Construction Research Congress 2022 (pp. 381-
Subramanya, K., Kermanshachi, S., & Pamidimukkala, A. 2022. Evaluation of E-Ticketing
Technology in Construction of Highway Projects: A Systematic Review of Adoption
Levels, Benefits, Limitations and Strategies. Frontiers in Built Environment, 128.
Subramanya, K., Kermanshachi, S., & Patel, R. 2022. The Future of Highway and Bridge
Construction: Digital Project Delivery Using Integrated Advanced Technologies. ASCE
International Conference on Transportation & Development.
Subramanya, K., Kermanshachi, S., & Rouhanizadeh, B. (2020). Modular Construction vs.
Traditional Construction: Advantages and Limitations: A Comparative Study. In Creative
Construction e-Conference 2020 (pp. 11-19). Budapest University of Technology and
Taylor, T., and W. Maloney. (2013). NCHRP Synthesis of High- way Practice 450: Forecasting
Highway Construction Staffing Requirements. Transportation Research Board of the
National Academies, Washington, D.C.,
Torres, H., Mauricio Ruiz, J., Chang, G.K., Anderson, J. and Garber, S. (2018). Report No.
FHWA-HRT- 16-030: automation in highway construction part i: implementation
challenges at state transportation departments and success stories, available at:
Tripathi, A., Patel, D., Sturgill, R., & Dadi, G. B. (2022). Analysis of E-Ticketing Technology for
Inspection Performance and Practicality on Asphalt Paving Operations. Transportation
Research Record,
Weisner, K., B. Cawley, and A. Sindlinger. 2017. The Age of e-Construction. Public Roads,
FHWA- HRT-17-005, Vol. 81, No. 1.
... It is difficult for state DOTs to meet the growing demand for highway construction and rehabilitation projects due to a limited number of inspection personnel and financial resources (Subramanya et al., 2022d;Rouhanizadeh and Kermanshachi 2020), and the lack of inspectors portends the possibility of quality shortfalls (Taylor and Maloney 2013). Recent research carried out by the Indiana Department of Transportation emphasized the difficulties in staffing they have experienced over the last decade due to inspectors leaving their employment to transfer to the private sector and elsewhere (Cai et al., 2020). ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Digital material delivery such as electronic ticketing (e-Ticketing) is a proven method for increasing the productivity of field inspectors and engineers. A wide range of studies have been conducted that focused on implementation standards, pilot testing, and challenges in the deployment of e-Ticketing technology; however, few have quantified it’s benefits for the highway construction sector. Therefore, the objective of this study is to quantitatively evaluate the benefits of e-Ticketing technology for highway construction projects, based on available project data and generated electronic tickets. To accomplish this objective, a literature review was performed; a survey was developed, conducted, and analyzed; and on-site project data were evaluated to identify the amount of time that could be saved in highway construction projects. The results showed that e-Ticketing technology could significantly increase the productivity of field inspectors, as it would reduce the manual ticketing process by approximately 80%, enabling inspectors and administrative workers to focus on other demanding tasks. The findings of the study also revealed that it could save up to four inspector man-hours, which is crucial in mitigating the workforce shortage faced by the sector. The time savings and increase in productivity levels would allow departments of transportation (DOTs) to focus on other emerging technologies such as digital as-builts, intelligent compaction, and drone monitoring. The findings of the study will aid DOT decision-makers and engineers in quantitatively analyzing the benefits of the e-Ticketing platform, thereby decreasing project costs, improving inspector safety, mitigating the shortage of inspectors, and focusing on other emerging technologies.
Technical Report
Full-text available
The construction of highway infrastructure has devoted significant resources towards e-Construction to reduce the paperwork and automate the tasks in daily operations. Electronic Ticketing (e-Ticketing) is one such component of e-Construction that aids in the digital transfer of material tickets such as asphalt and concrete which accounts for more than fifty per cent of construction costs. Despite the benefits of e-Ticketing, many state departments and agencies are unwilling to transition into this technology. No studies have identified the cause of the delay in the implementation process, developed a framework to comprehend the platform's full potential, quantified savings, and suggested strategies for overcoming limitations. Therefore, this study aims to (1) Indicate inefficiencies in the conventional paper ticketing framework and identify suitable technology to overcome the inefficiencies. (2) Identify benefits, quantify the reduction in inspection staff and time savings incurred by implementing e-Ticketing technology. (3) Develop a multi-criteria decision-making model for implementation of e-Ticketing platform in the perspective of state DOTs and general contractors. (4) Identify and rank the major limitations in the process of implementing e-Ticketing technology and suggest suitable strategies to overcome them. To achieve the study's objective, review section is followed by a semi-structured interview and survey results. Based on the survey responses collected from 20 state DOTs, the study categorized the critical effectiveness indicators into 3 categories and ranked the operational challenges using the Relative Importance Index. The study analyses the critical effectiveness indicators (CEIs) of e-Ticketing technology and presents a fuzzy index-based decision-making model for evaluating the adoption priorities. A comparison was made between the required number of inspectors prior to and after the implementation of e-Ticketing, and it was found that projects requiring multiple inspectors could reduce their workforce by 25% by implementing e-Ticketing. The study's findings will assist practitioners with an assessment tool to gain insights relating to priority levels in implementing the e-Ticketing technology.
Full-text available
Highway and bridge construction projects are subject to cost and schedule overruns, as well as workforce shortages in remote locations, both of which can result in disputes over the quality of the end product. E-ticketing technology can improve the quality, however, while decreasing cost overruns and schedule delays. Despite the benefits of E-ticketing, many state departments and agencies are unwilling to transition into this technology. This study aims to identify the potential barriers to implementing E-ticketing, determine the adoption rate of state agencies/departments, and evaluate the benefits of employing an E-ticketing platform. The changes in technological trends in highway construction that are related to material tracking, inspection, and digitization are qualitatively analyzed, using meta-synthesis and interpretative analytical techniques. Key technologies that have the potential to be integrated into the E-ticketing platform to mitigate the limitations faced at the time of implementation are also discussed. The study’s findings suggest that the implementation process and regulations of an E-ticketing platform vary drastically from state to state, and a common set of guidelines is essential for obtaining long term success. The study advocates four key recommendations for widespread implementation of the E-ticketing platform and suggests directions for further research. The results of this study will assist DOT’s decision-makers and engineers in developing a common E-ticketing platform, adopting policies and guidelines, decreasing the costs of their projects, providing the initial investment, running pilot tests, enhancing the safety of their inspectors, and completing their projects in a timely and efficient manner.
Full-text available
This study aims to identify the factors that affect level of resilience of transportation infrastructure from different points of view, including construction, and managemfent as well as factors of resilience related to resources, investment, and funding. To fulfill the purpose of the study, a survey was developed. Results indicated that not only the physical characteristics of a roadway segment but also the characteristics of the construction and management of the roadway influence the level of resilience of transportation infrastructures. Also, knowledge and experience of the management team responsible for the roadway will influence the level of resilience of transportation infrastructures.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Cost overruns, schedule delays and quality issues negatively impact the majority of transportation infrastructure projects, and inspectors and project engineers are in short supply in rural and remote areas. Researched and tested technologies can solve most of the industry's challenges, but their level of acceptance and implementation is still quite low. The primary research goals of this study include (1) investigating current highway construction technologies that produce massive metadata related to costs, schedules, quality, and safety parameters; (2) exploring the need to integrate emerging and tested technologies into a single platform; and (3) proposing integrations that can produce semi-automated or simplified daily operations. An extensive literature review was conducted to understand the primary limitations of highway construction and the availability of tested technologies to overcome them. The findings of the study clearly indicate that integrating emerging technologies will open a wide array of opportunities such as predicting accurate construction costs, reducing the amount of time to complete projects, and increasing the overall quality of highway projects, and streamlining and centralizing the workforce system by implementing technology will solve the ongoing problem of workforce shortages. The findings of this study will help state DOTs better understand the value of each data layer that technology introduces throughout the deployment phase and the meaningful insights it can deliver using AI, machine learning, and big data.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Electronic ticketing (e-ticketing) is the process of digital ticket delivery, and it can be combined with different technologies to produce a wide variety of benefits in the construction transportation industry. Many transportation departments and agencies are not willing to adopt this technology due to some limitations imposed by technology or organization policies. Therefore, the aim of this paper is to perform analysis of E-Ticketing adoption and its changes during the Covid-19 pandemic, evaluate the benefits and limitations of the technology, and determine the technology integration with other available automation platforms in construction industry. The outcome of study will help in validating that the primary uses of e-ticketing are not safety and documentation; it is also a tool for rendering automated inspections and reducing the cost and increasing the overall quality of transportation construction projects during and after the pandemic. This study incorporated an extensive literature review on policies, memos, guidelines, news articles, and research publications pertaining to the limitations, benefits, and key technologies that can be integrated into e-ticketing platforms. A qualitative analysis of recent technological trends indicated that intelligent compaction, drone surveying, infrared sensors, advanced imaging, and thermal profilers can be integrated into an e-ticketing platform to extract better results that are paramount to a project’s success. Four findings from this study will assist project stakeholders in developing guidelines and policies, reducing costs, and increasing the overall safety of the project. The main contribution of the paper is a framework for the platform that combines e-ticketing and other emerging technologies to facilitate efficient automated inspections, billing, and telematics in the construction transportation industry.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The concept of resilience for the transportation infrastructure is relatively new, which means that the current literature provides little information and few recommendations for achieving or improving the resilience of roadway network. The goal of this study is to develop a list of strategies to enhance the resilience of the transportation infrastructures and to provide recommendations for implementing them. To this end, a comprehensive review of the existing literature was performed, and a list of potential factors that have impact over transportation infrastructure was prepared. Based on the outcome of the literature review, a survey was developed and distributed to experts in the field of transportation infrastructure. Ninety-two (92) survey responses were collected and analyzed, and based on the analysis, resilience enhancement strategies for transportation infrastructures were developed. The findings of this paper demonstrate that maintaining an optimum number of nodes in the network to ensure the easy and efficient rerouting of traffic from a damaged link or node enhances resilience significantly. Incorporating optional routes at the beginning of a new project or for a roadway expansion will also eventually increase the resilience of the network. This study will help practitioners in selecting and adopting the appropriate strategies that enhance the resiliency of the transportation infrastructure.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The frequency in occurrence of a natural disaster is increasing rapidly. The rate at which the families recover from these disruptions and return to normal day-today operations is very essential. The loss of housing and the need for temporary shelter is the immediate after effect of a natural disaster. The objective of this study is to analyze whether 3-Dimensional Printing (3DP) can be a viable alternative to the conventional process of providing shelters and housing to displaced people. The conventional process of disaster relief has many challenges, and 3DP technology provides an opportunity to provide immediate, cost-effective relief to people whose homes were severely damaged or destroyed by a disaster. Investing in the 3D printing of temporary shelters may not seem prudent to stakeholders at this time, but the growth of the use of 3D printing and additive manufacturing in the construction industry will play a key role in accelerating the reach of this new technology to disaster-damaged areas. The potential of 3D printing for producing and rendering temporary housing/shelter after a natural disaster is assessed in this paper from different perspectives such as cost, time, safety, environmental impact, and transportation logistics. The authors of the study performed a thorough literature review to understand the recent technological advancements related to 3D printing and then evaluated the opportunities and challenges of adopting the technology in disaster-struck regions for the purpose of shelters and housing. The findings of this study will guide decision-makers in evaluating the feasibility of applying 3D printing in disaster-struck areas.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The outcome of novel coronavirus (COVID-19) has a profound impact on all industries including the transportation sector. Transportation industry which is deemed as an essential activity should continue to operate through the lockdowns while making it certain to exercise social distancing. Although some researchers, Departments of Transportation (DOT's), Federal Highway Administration (FHWA), and private organizations have provided vital information and guidelines to mitigate the unintended consequences of the pandemic, the impacts of COVID-19 on various types of transportation modes have been rarely analyzed and compared. This paper gives rich information into the system and cognizance of the effect of COVID-19 and the developments that the Transportation area has needed to embrace so as to cling to the lockdown rules while being operational and productive. The study contributes towards advising policymakers, stakeholders and agencies on certain insights gained from the management of the COVID-19 from a transportation area point of view. Moreover, four key regulations are concluded for leaders inside the transportation framework business to reevaluate and act to manage the pandemic emergency. This research analyzes how each sector has addressed the short-term and long-term effects of the pandemic and results of the study concluded that the survival of transportation industry is not solely reliant on the duration of the COVID-19 pandemic but on the resilience adapted by the different sectors to cope up with the situation. The findings also indicate that transportation departments should include a management plan to reduce the aftermaths of the pandemic and use the lockdown as an opportunity to address surging maintenance backlogs, improve technology, and safeguard the workforce.
E-construction is becoming increasingly attractive in the highway construction industry as the industry faces reductions in staffing and resources. Specifically, the addition of e-construction methods can offer a boost in efficiency and safety in resurfacing projects. Electronic ticketing (e-ticketing), paver-mounted thermal profiling, and intelligent compaction were recently incorporated into a study coordinated by the Kentucky Transportation Cabinet, United States, to assess these e-construction technologies on two resurfacing projects. This study aimed to investigate the accuracy of the data collected and the time savings that come with the incorporation of technology in construction. This manuscript focuses explicitly on the performance of e-ticketing, since it showed the most promising results during the study. An analysis of the data shows that e-ticketing offers the same data typically collected from traditional tickets. E-ticketing reduced the amount of time needed to retrieve material tickets and facilitated comparisons of theoretical tonnages to actual tonnages, in the same manner as traditional approaches. Inspectors also reduced their exposure to hazardous jobsite conditions through the use of e-ticketing, while contractors strengthened their operational efficiency. It is crucial that all stakeholders involved in e-ticketing projects practice partnering and collaboration to take advantage of the benefits of this emerging technology. This paper’s primary contribution is to document lessons learned and to evaluate the performance of e-ticketing technology in relation to safety, time savings, remote inspections, and accuracy compared with traditional practices on an asphalt paving project.