ArticlePDF Available

Makes Digital Sensemaking Sense?-A Roadmap for Digital Humanism in Increasingly Transhumanist Settings

Authors:
Daniela Brill at Johannes Kepler University of Linz
Daniela Brill
Claudia Schnugg
Claudia Schnugg
Christian Stary at Johannes Kepler University of Linz
Christian Stary
Download full-text PDFDownload full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

Keeping humans in the loop or bringing them back into the loop in dynamically changing socio-technical or socio-hybrid systems requires the human-centered arrangement of system designs and the adoption of digital artefacts according to human capabilities and needs. When transhumanist developments increasingly propagate through society, digital sensemaking could support their co-evolution in a sensible way. We discuss sensemaking to that end, and provide a roadmap on how to integrate sensemaking processes into capacity building processes and digitalization initiatives. Cite as: Brill, D., Schnugg, C., & Stary, C. (2022). Makes Digital Sensemaking Sense?—A Roadmap for Digital Humanism in Increasingly Transhumanist Settings. New Explorations: Studies in Culture and Communication, 2(3), https://jps.library.utoronto.ca/index.php/nexj/
BrillSchuggStary2022newExplorationsCorrectedFinalVersi
on.pdf
Content uploaded by Christian Stary
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Christian Stary on Jul 28, 2022
Content may be subject to copyright.
10+brill+schnugg+sta
ry.pdf
Content uploaded by Claudia Schnugg
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Claudia Schnugg on Jun 22, 2022
Content may be subject to copyright.
... · Co-construction processes (Spindler and Stary, 2019). · Sensemaking techniques for identifying meaning (Brill et al., 2022). ...
From Digital Twins to Digital Selves and Beyond – Perspectives for Social Modelling in a Trans-Humanist World
Article
Full-text available
The continuous propagation of Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques has led to engineering of so-called “humanoid” socio-technical settings, which include mimicking cognitive and social skills. With the advent of cyber-physical systems Digital Twins have become baseline representations of systems integrating cognitive and social behaviour models. When AI components become part of those representations capturing social relations and reflecting on behaviour, they are termed Digital Selves, and require specific development techniques. In this paper, we introduce a Knowledge Management approach to investigate the emergence of socially reflective behaviour like awareness and consciousness in artificial agents. We identify and explain mandatory properties of Digital Selves relevant for modelling digital societies that need to be studied and become part of a transparent and explainable knowledge base for trans-human developments.
View
... Finally, once Metaverse applications are linked to physical bodies, both on the cognitive level, e.g., by brain-computer interfaces, and beyond, e.g., using wearables, the immersion of human users could be seamlessly enriched through Digital Twins and aesthetic interaction qualities (cf. DigiSense project 6 [27]). Such integration capabilities require special attention for Metaverse developments: ...
Can a ‘Metaverse by Design’ Benefit from Digital Process Twins?
Chapter
Full-text available
  • Aug 2023
‘The Metaverse represents the next generation Internet’ - this industry belief challenges the current understanding of Internet-based interaction, and the way it progresses towards a cyber-physical network. Will development techniques for the Internet-of-Things (IoT), Internet-of-Behaviors (IoB), and Internet of Everything (IoE) deliver what is the essence of Metaverse applications? In this reflection paper this question is tackled through the lens of Digital Process Twins (DPTs), as they are already an effective and efficient technology for Cyber-Physical System (CPS) development. The argumentation of industry for establishing the Metaverse as the next generation Internet allows the identification and specification of design requirements. In this contribution these requirements are derived from conceptual inputs on Metaverse developments. The requirements are used for analyzing subject-oriented Digital Process Twin capabilities on whether they can support design and implementation of Metaverse applications. Benefits that can be delivered by executable Digital Process Twins models do not only concern the design (process) when being supported by subject-oriented abstraction and representation overcoming interoperability barriers, but also by the validation of behavior models and their synchronization at runtime, in particular with physical components increasing the immersion capabilities of Metaverse applications.KeywordsMetaverseDigital (Process) TwinCyber-Physical SystemInternet-of-Thingsdesign-integrated engineering
View
... The already instantiated DIGI-Sense phase 1 will be continued for several months to 'dance the change' and institutionalize embodied articulation (DIGI-Sense Phase 2 and 3) for organizational transformation processes. We expect transhuman actors to become part of those processes (Brill et al., 2022). ...
Digital Sensemaking: Sensemaking as a Driver of Transformation
Conference Paper
Full-text available
  • Jun 2022
This paper introduces the project "Digital Sensemaking" (DIGI-Sense) that tackles human needs in the envisioned digital revolution (Industry4.0, humanoid robots, Internet of Behaviours, Cyber-Physical-Systems) to enable meaningful transformation processes. Psychologists of work argue that digitalization at the workplace can lead to an overflow of information which challenges decision-making and sensemaking at work. Studies in organizational research show that sensemaking is fundamental for meaningful work1 experience of individuals and organizations because it plays a central role to give meaning to processes, shared experiences and to rationalize decisions and established routines. In digital transformation processes, well-known work processes easily become alienated to workers, embodied knowledge and material cornerstones are likely to become obsolete. Therefore, DIGI-Sense explores sensemaking in digitalization processes that incorporate tangible elements, digital twins, and robotics. As embodiment, materialities, movements, and aesthetics are core to sensemaking, the methodological design of the empirical study incorporates methods in social sciences and juxtaposes these more traditional approaches 1 We consider meaningful work as immersive perception and practice of doing where cognitive, social, and bodily involvement is streamlined and thus, coherent for the actor(s) to perform activities according to their intention and purpose. 652 IFKAD 2022-Knowledge Drivers for Resilience and Transformation Lugano, Switzerland 20-22 June 2022 ISBN 978-88-96687-15-4 || ISSN 2280-787X with methods from visual studies, arts-based initiatives and artscience collaboration in the form of a series of experimentations with performance artists. This paper will introduce the theoretical background and the development of the methodological approach applied in this research project.
View
The socio-aesthetic construction of meaning in digitally mediated environments: a digital sensemaking approach
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2024
  • AI Soc
Sensemaking has recently been identified as a driver of society developments, in particular in the context of designing a reasonable, valuable, and fair life. Since the construction of meaning is a crucial momentum in sensemaking processes, the authors investigate how meaning can be constructed in a sustaining form by utilizing digital means of expression, articulation, sharing of information, and creation of artscience artefacts. The authors report on results of exploring cyber-physical-systems with performative methodologies in the context of sensemaking to identify sensemaking processes of entering digital environments and share meaning-making activities through interaction. The collected data from two artscience studies reveal that activities beyond cognition facilitate sensemaking. Aesthetics and embodiment in performing actions are understood to play a role in sensemaking and subsequently effect on the construction of meaning. To investigate the role of the body and aesthetics in sensemaking in digital environments, we were particularly interested in sensemaking through embodied agency and aesthetic awareness, drawing from kinesthetic awareness of performance artists. In the performative activities digital behavior recognition and human task behavior were coupled, on the one hand by performers exploring digital environments actively reflecting on their performative process, on the other hand by a performance artist and choreographer creating performative experiences for audiences. It has been demonstrated in cyber-physical settings and can be utilized in upcoming developments further integrating virtual and physical worlds.
View
Researching the body and movement through artistic performative installations for collaborative digital sensemaking
Conference Paper
Full-text available
  • Sep 2023
When tackling digital transformation, Digital Sensemaking, as researched in the DIGI-Sense project, empowers humans to reflect on the meaning from an intertwined cognitive, aesthetic, and body perspective. Sensemaking is fundamental for meaningful (work) experience of individuals and organizations. Digital means can play a central role to give meaning to processes, shared experiences, and to rationalize established routines. As embodiment, materiali-ties, movements, and aesthetics are core to sensemaking, we have designed and explored a corresponding artscience installation. It implements the idea that collective digital drawing is a form of par-ticipatory sense-making that emerges from embodied, dynamical and collaborative interactions between co-performers. Performers could exert control over expressing drawings, by coordinating their movements with one another. This functionality is integrated in a setting with increasing task complexity-to further stimulate social collaboration and create rich visual feedback. In this way digital sensemaking could become an essential means for the encounter between two persons to sketch a common ground of their activity spaces.
View
From Digital Twins to Digital Selves and Beyond: Engineering and Social Models for a Trans-humanist World
Book
Full-text available
  • Jan 2022
Since digital twins increasingly become high fidelity digital models of eco-systems and their dynamic evolvement (cf. Durão et al., 2018) in the first part of this book we provide information on their background and their development in the context of Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS) and their industrial application. We discuss the engineering of so-called ‘humanoid’ socio-technical settings mimicking cognitive and social skills. This tendency lays ground to build up sovereignty on developing some digital identity or self, finally controlling individual development by digital means. Taking this role, digital twins are real-time models capable of controlling their adaptation and finally, next generation development, thus representing digital selves. They become the core of socio-trans-human developments. In the second part of this book we introduce relevant approaches to awareness and the emergence of consciousness in artificial agents. We start with discussing the awareness of identity in digital twins as prerequisite to social representations. We then discuss whether social behavior of digital selves can result as an emergent phenomenon. Progress in simulating emotions by using game-theoretical approaches is presented.
View
Digital Twin Generation: Re-Conceptualizing Agent Systems for Behavior-Centered Cyber-Physical System Development
Article
Full-text available
  • Feb 2021
  • SENSORS-BASEL
Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS) form the new backbone of digital ecosystems. Upcoming CPS will be operated on a unifying basis, the Internet of Behaviors (IoB). It features autonomous while federated CPS architectures and requires corresponding behavior modeling for design and control. CPS design and control involves stakeholders in different roles with different expertise accessing behavior models, termed Digital twins. They mirror the physical CPS part and integrate it with the digital part. Representing role-specific behaviors and provided with automated execution capabilities Digital twins facilitate dynamic adaptation and (re-)configuration. This paper proposes to conceptualize agent-based design for behavior-based Digital twins through subject-oriented models. These models can be executed and, thus, increase the transparency at design and runtime. Patterns recognizing environmental factors and operation details facilitate the configuration of CPS. Subject-oriented runtime support enables dynamic adaptation and the federated use of CPS components.
View
Collaborations of Art, Science and Technology: Creating Future Realities with Art and A.I.
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2020
Artists explore new territories in their work by exploring new media, imagining new futures, contextualizing ideas, creating aesthetic investigations into new environments, or posing questions and leading theoretical discussions. Interaction among art, science and technology can contribute to the creation of future societies – of future realities – on many levels, e.g., it can contribute to communication, create experience, enrich discussions, feed into scientific processes and support personal learning. Especially when it comes to something influential like current developments in Artificial Intelligence, contributions of artscience collaboration can be essential for designing a positive future reality for our society. Supporting collaborations in organizations through well-structured formats in the organization supports the realization of elaborate art on the topic that contributes to important developments in the organization as well as to an informed discussion with broad audiences and shareholder groups.
View
Sensemaking Reconsidered: Towards a broader understanding through phenomenology
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2020
We develop a typology of sensemaking in organizations that reconsiders existing sensemaking research by providing a more coherent and integrative conceptualization of what defines sensemaking and how it is connected with organizing. Drawing on existential phenomenology, we make the following core claims: (1) sensemaking is not a singular phenomenon but comprises four major types: immanent, involved-deliberate, detached-deliberate, and representational sensemaking; (2) all types of sensemaking originate and take place within specific practice worlds; (3) the core constituents of sensemaking within a practice world (sense–action nexus, temporality, embodiment, and language) are played out differently in each type of sensemaking. Furthermore, we elaborate the links between sensemaking and organizing, focusing especially on the connections between types and levels of sensemaking, and the consequences of sensemaking outcomes for organizing. Finally, we discuss how the typology contributes to the existing sensemaking perspective, outline methodological implications, and suggest ways of advancing sensemaking research.
View
The role of participatory design activities in supporting sense-making in the smart city
Conference Paper
Full-text available
  • Aug 2020
We examine the role of participatory design activities in supporting sense-making while anticipating technological effects in smart cities. The effects of technology are not univocal. Therefore, creating smart city visions that enclose multiple meanings requires providing environments where stakeholders make the often-implicit processes of meaning attribution to technology explicit. We develop and test three participatory design activities to anticipate value changes and controversies in smart cities, and analyze how these activities supported seven sense-making properties. Our results show that visibilizing, reframing, and imagining are key characteristics of participatory design activities in supporting sense-making. Visibilizing technological impacts 'makes things public,' revealing existing perspectives and fostering new ones. Reframing technological impacts enhances empathy for diverse interests instead of treating smart cities as technical problems. Imagining supports understanding connections between technology and society to anticipate impacts. Our insights contribute to the provision of participatory design activities to articulate multiple meanings around smart cities.
View
Digital Twin: Enabling Technologies, Challenges and Open Research
Article
Full-text available
  • May 2020
Digital Twin technology is an emerging concept that has become the centre of attention for industry and, in more recent years, academia. The advancements in industry 4.0 concepts have facilitated its growth, particularly in the manufacturing industry. The Digital Twin is defined extensively but is best described as the effortless integration of data between a physical and virtual machine in either direction. The challenges, applications, and enabling technologies for Artificial Intelligence, Internet of Things (IoT) and Digital Twins are presented. A review of publications relating to Digital Twins is performed, producing a categorical review of recent papers. The review has categorised them by research areas: manufacturing, healthcare and smart cities, discussing a range of papers that reflect these areas and the current state of research. The paper provides an assessment of the enabling technologies, challenges and open research for Digital Twins.
View
A critical inquiry into the hyperreality of digitalization in construction
Article
  • Jun 2021
The built environment is literally and metaphorically concrete but its creation from conception through design and construction involves many levels of abstraction. This spectrum of activities between concrete and abstract is complex and unexplored in construction but it will be shown that a deep understanding of this is required to make successful buildings in a modern age of digitalization. Abstraction is the simplification of an entity with a degree of generalization of purpose and causality but also used to promote the idealization of the entity. When abstractions are believed to be real then there are conditions of hyperreality. This article unpacks the nature of abstraction in the creation of the built environment through three vignettes of practice; considering: drawings, project planning and building modelling. Abstraction has been key to making buildings but is growing in significance because of building information modelling. The themes of loss of meaning, loss of control and loss of perspective are used to show that digitalization involves creating a dangerous illusion of the connection between data and reality thus creating a problematic hyperreality. This can be avoided by stronger thinking, more openness about abstractions and less exaggeration of their performance.
View
View
Embodying algorithms, enactive artificial intelligence and the extended cognition: You can see as much as you know about algorithm
Article
  • Jan 2021
  • J INF SCI
The recent proliferation of artificial intelligence (AI) gives rise to questions on how users interact with AI services and how algorithms embody the values of users. Despite the surging popularity of AI, how users evaluate algorithms, how people perceive algorithmic decisions, and how they relate to algorithmic functions remain largely unexplored. Invoking the idea of embodied cognition, we characterize core constructs of algorithms that drive the value of embodiment and conceptualizes these factors in reference to trust by examining how they influence the user experience of personalized recommendation algorithms. The findings elucidate the embodied cognitive processes involved in reasoning algorithmic characteristics – fairness, accountability, transparency, and explainability – with regard to their fundamental linkages with trust and ensuing behaviors. Users use a dual-process model, whereby a sense of trust built on a combination of normative values and performance-related qualities of algorithms. Embodied algorithmic characteristics are significantly linked to trust and performance expectancy. Heuristic and systematic processes through embodied cognition provide a concise guide to its conceptualization of AI experiences and interaction. The identified user cognitive processes provide information on a user’s cognitive functioning and patterns of behavior as well as a basis for subsequent metacognitive processes.
View
Affective atmospheres of sensemaking and learning: Workplace meetings as aesthetic and anaesthetic
Article
  • Jan 2020
  • MANAGE LEARN
The aim of this article is to explore sensemaking and learning processes with and through affective atmospheres. We engage with recent research within the ‘affective turn’ across the social sciences and humanities to conceptualize the significance of quasi-autonomous affective atmospheres that emanate from, and also condition, collectives of humans and non-humans. Drawing on this atmospheric scholarship, we propose and elaborate an atmospheric analysis of sensemaking and learning processes to examine how such atmospheres aesthetically transform, and anaesthetically constrain, the potential of bodies, including our own as researchers, to affect and be affected to sense and learn. Through empirical engagement with workplace meetings in a UK housebuilding firm, our analysis contributes by explaining how such atmospheres condition sensemaking that both registers the disorganizing novelty of events and reduces such ambiguity and equivocality to enable purposeful action. While extant research has suggested how the interplay of these two dimensions of sensemaking enables learning, our analysis contributes by drawing attention to how the production, maintenance and transformation of specific atmospheres in workplace meetings imbues affects that condition these two dimensions of sensemaking. Such atmospheres thus constitute vital, yet seldom discussed, phenomena in conditioning learning within organizational life.
View