Content uploaded by Sylvia Nienhaus
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Sylvia Nienhaus on May 31, 2022
Content may be subject to copyright.
Nienhaus, S., & Stoltenhoff, A.-K. (2022). Doing Qualitative Mehrebenenanalyse –
Theoretische, methodologische und forschungspraktische Überlegungen. Forum Qualitative
Sozialforschung / Forum: Qualitative Social Research, 23(2). https://doi.org/10.17169/fqs-
22.2.3808
Veröffentlicht: 2022-05-30
Copyright (c) 2022 Sylvia Nienhaus, Ann-Kathrin Stoltenhoff
Dieses Werk steht unter der Lizenz Creative Commons Namensnennung 4.0 International.
https://creativecommens.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Am nachfolgenden Text wurden keine Änderungen vorgenommen.
Doing Qualitative Mehrebenenanalyse – Theoretische,
methodologische und forschungspraktische Überlegungen
Zusammenfassung
!"#$%"&'"( %)**(+,%
-(*"(./0123*4.5*36%"&'"(
$ $$%
7$8$
$$
+$/019
5*$:;
$$+!6
/0/0<(;=-(*"( "$ #+
:#
$ :5*
$#>&
(#$?$)5*
' =##
# -$"
Inhaltsverzeichnis
1"
/5*
/1)#*
//*
25*;:7
21*@A#
*4
2/(;*)#$:;
:A5*#"
B$5*A-$
B15*>$
B/$5*(
B2
&
!
!
=7,,B0+&
5C5(.+61B2D;EF/G3
>/2 6/ B
*/0//
Keywords
*;
4H
=H
*7*H
:H
+$;
H);
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
1. Einleitung
>%#
#.-"&&"/001H
-),-(=!/01B3)
*.-"&&"/0013:
*4%"&'"( %)**(+,%-(*"(./0123+
-7;
'$/
";(*4
.5*13+2:
$J$ B$
:5*+:#
<(;=-(*"( "$5*
< 6/0/0#
$K(;
=-(*"(.(=-/3$# &$
6$<L1M
2. Die QM
*4 (;=-(*"(
< # $
$
N"J+
')<$@
# $
7%
<*4N.<(=- 1/
6/0/032L/M
1 $#"N*4N@%"&'"(./01D
1EF3$:N%5N
.:O%6,- <"+*"(I*")"(/01D3
:
/ $4#(;=-(*"(H#5
<
2 '<$@;#;@;=$
$#+
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
2.1 Ursprünge des Modells
5**@%"&'"( *%)**(+,%(;
=-(*"(-7?$
/010$$ ?#
@%"&'"(#$
N":P"
:P-#*$.199F3
@%!"
>%#B
#(
#'#
#4
4>$#
**
<;'?$ =$
<4@#
$$#
= 6!
@-7
!
$4#
&$H$#4<
"<$
4-$##$
4$
!$N.<(=- 1/6/0/03L2M
%-(*"( 5*
)!
%?
# (=-
N"$
$)-7
# $N.<
(=- 1/6/0/03LBM
4$*4."6<"&199DH<O&="+6
/0113*.135*$
$ NO?$
O<)N.%)**"&&
19G/ 12H+==O6199D 1/3
B +$
$!$ 6
!:
$
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
-7%.%"&'"(
/012 119H6+"6%)/01D DB3
1#* ".%)**(+,%I
-(*"(/01D 12F 3ELEM
5*$
#
'+-7
H:%"&'"(./0123%)**(+,%
-(*"(./01D3*;.%O &!("&I!"+"&
/01BL1922M35**%"&'"(
./0123
$7 -(*"(<
N@ *4
>7
(7*:$
#-$! K
>@
><N.<(=- 1/6
/0/03LFM
E "1/:K)
#,,;C!;
&##'$
>J!)!
)
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
%O./01BL1922M3
*4 A
>A '
J$*F
$.%"&'"(/012
1/0H%)**(+,%I-(*"(/01D 1/9H6+"6%)/01D DE35*
>.&+,-/0113$#
N*$J *4
=
= :
7N.<(=- 1/6/0/03LGM
= #)'$; *;
,-"&;"+6,%*8&&"(./01/3-"&&"./0013
-7$*
%"&'"(./0123>#>
*4.%)**(+,%I-(*"(/01D 1/E3
=5*?#4"
N@$;N
.%"&'"(/012 1193.6+"6%)/01D DF3LDM
2.2 Ausgestaltung des Modells
6%"&'"(*$5*
N>.3*4$
4";
!#?#
""$#$7
<$N.O3+<
(;=-(*"( !#
"($7<$
*J$>
$G
N"#*4
!
! <
$7*$
F *; N-$N.O=/009 Q13
*8&&"(./00D3 N!
LRM <$
N.O=/009 3
G )-7N
*
+"N.,%("+"(
/01G Q2/3.-"&&"/001 /01BH-),-(=!/01B3
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
5*6$#!
6$#!
6$
>$#J$$ $
K8 -
>
#!*4
?#>#<
$7<$>$J
8*7;*;5*
*7;*;
< :
!A#
6?*7;*;
*?
*-*
#*4
-7 <$ #
!$J!
5*>!;
'$N.<(=- 1/6/0/03L9M
>%*5*
"4"
(4.%"&'"(
/012 1/DH6+"6%)/01D 903-%"&'"(
./0123%)**(+,%-(*"(./01D3,
"#"5*(N
$ $
:#NN
$'$*$N.%"&'"(
/012 1213<5*N
=- "$
($$(
J.($/000 /00G3N.12/3L10M
=#((5*
$$#:
%"&'"(%)**(+,%-(*"(./01D3
%"&'"(./0123'
(#"($J./3
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
/$7:"*
.1/93L11M
#:"
($
$J.%)**(+,%I-(*"(/01D 12G3"4
> -"&&"(./00E /0103#
$4 7
> -(*"(< K5*#
)4
>'
N*$J
$7 '7-7
#!
(7AK-$A
*"$7'
!:##
'(&
)K
"*#$
*"$
*$
!$ $$N
.<(=- 1/6/0/03L1/M
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
$% (#
?A
>A(;=
-(*"(? )
<5*$J
8<J -(*"(
K :$
>5*$J.113
N$"5*
#'?$%
$!
!$7<#
! #:#
4>!$N
.<(=- 1/6/0/03L12M
@#5*)$7
<-(*"((7
) !
(5*$
N" 4
$#
!$ <#
$ <
'$" $ "
>$#J$
!$#
(7*A
<$7
N
.<(=- 1/6/0/03L1BM
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
3. QM-Beispiele aus der qualitativen Forschungspraxis
>%"$
?$ J
((5*$
>J@
*4A#<
A#
$JL1EM
3.1 Schulische Medienbildung als neues Wissensfeld – eine Disziplin
übergreifende qualitative Mehrebenenanalyse
=O&="6%O./0193$
/01E/01D"
@*:
$4> 46O6%O./01B3D
4
75*%"&'"(./0123:
= @&$
J;@9 $)
=
"
) ($$"
$4($$
$ *$.199B;/01F3
>!.)+3
)$4($$&
4#"7.%"&"(+,%
/01B31B&$
#*
::;@# 6;@=#
.)++3)
<#(.+3.++3"
.=O&="6%O/019 E3L1FM
)("
$J *$.(I-&"**/00E3=O&="6%O
*$./3"#-
1/F'7&.$ #
%$&'(()*+,-.)/0)1+*233+#-
'7 *:
D "$$$74=O&="6%O
./0/13
9 <?@ *$$
'*$J#N:
@$N.(I-&"**/00E 13.
=O&="6%O/019 E3
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
":
#)"
$$#$
=O&="6%O'$-$.-*-3
STUVWXYZ[[\]Y^_Z^Y`XaY^_ZbYWVcdUeWXWXYfTVWXgYaeWYhVijkV`XlYmnWaeWXokaTlplei
N.-*-199E3 :N*N.-*-
/01/3N:@N.-*-/01F3+
-?'7 -
J*
('$-*-;$
N$=$+;+++
"-.:3N.=O&="6%O/019 F3
-"7
&$ ($$
@$*$.23
2=$ <$.O3L1GM
@*$*$4
%@N*N<
@J( *
:$ *$4
.=;3@N*N
$;'$$"$
.(;3'$=@ K
&.*$3&$
) .+3*$4 .++34$
'$$
$C
=
'$
$.O),)&=19DF
L19F9M3 &,&)I*O)"19DE3
'$
$
.O),)&=19DF
L19F9M3 &,&)I
*O)"19DE3
> *;
-$
"
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
$
>
$;%
.&,&)I*O)"19DE3
$;
%
&,&)I*O)"
19DE3
< *
@N
*N
.=;3
@
N
*N$;
'$$
"
*$
$4
@.
'$J
( *
:3
@
@.3$
;
.&
*$3
O 4 4
'7
&.$ $ $4563
199E /01/ /01F
+
&$
#
*$
./01E3
=1).+3.++3-.$
3.G 3L1DM
+#"
#">
"#-:&
O(6",-./00F3@(6./00D /01/ /01/ /01/3-
7'$ N
)*$;*$N.=O&="6%O
/019 FD3&&$
$ -7$
.923 *$.*$3*$
-7%@$
*$.#923@ +
&$$$
&@N*N
!$4(
$7!*$;*$
">
?$
)*;
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
-$"
.=13L19M
: *4
#$ %?-$
#5*%"&'"(./0123
.B23"4'$
"
"$"#$
"$=$
# <-7
8
>"A#:&
&$ *$-7A$
"
)#:
L/0M
=O&="6%O)$
* ;$'$
O),)&=.19DFL19F9M3&,&)*O)".19DE3
O'?$#
$$*
"
: (*
L/1M
3.2 Das Relevant-Machen sozialer Ungleichheit im frühkindlichen Bildungs-
und Betreuungsalltag – eine QM über drei Ebenen
:":J
=#$.O",/0/13>%
O'$$<
)@ 6+"6%)./01D3(
10<;
?-?7:;
:4.=/3
10 "('?$N,&74,
4N.,%+&3 1/01221/01E)
&7##+:O&&+< %O6+<
6+"6%)./01F3
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
:;
:;
.;
3
11 = 6
" */012*
/01E
*O$/01B
6/01E
* ;
"$
$
781/ 4
9:12.
31B
781E 4
9:.
31F
$
78
4
9:
.3
= &
"
"
-;
NN
=/:;:<#
5*.112 3L//M
%(%.*(,)199E3
+ :
@/;B?-:;
:#$
->O-
.=(8:+6</01D //G3
NN.@O&/010 2BD3verfol.6+"6%)
/01D 9G3
:;:1J"
/$;O2+$-
$":#
:CJ$.#6+"6%)/01D 1123
:#:CJ %$
.6;3'.//93#
=. " /2E3
#-$
"C&- "C&
11 >'4
1/ "-J=
12 >$ -$
1B K@"
1E "-;=
1F %:;C:-
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
" "C&"C&./EEH
=23
" 4 $
.+;
3
"
4
:;
:;
@
:;
:;
$
$q
@$
#!
%
q
+
:
1* %
$
:
%$
>$
:
:
;
?
-
:;
:;
;;
"
@
$
:;
:;
;
$q
"
:
:
/
+
.78
4
9:
4
9:1G3
%
$
:
%$
>$
:
:
;
?
-.'
"1q3
$;
;
:;
:;
@
?
"
q
@O
$q
:
+
<
";
&
$
1G >>#-
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
" 4 $
2
+$
%
$
:
%$
>$
:
:
;
?
-.'
"1
/q3
+$
"
&
-
:;
:;
@
"
&
-
q
:
=2#5*A"
#4.6+"6%)/019 B 3L/2M
""
" $-
="
$"$!
$#>;
6#-#='
)<(
4(;4
$$J+4(
L/BM
-?
*4
!$
""#
$= )
4 :$
.6+"6%)/01D 9E3$
4'$$
*.:("+"6="+6 %+(,%)"( -&=%OI
6+"@6/0/03 %+$#
?#
#*$;*$
$J *4
:KL/EM
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
4. Forschungspraktisches Arbeiten mit der QM – Kritik und
Desiderata
4.1 Stellenwert der QM und Vereinbarkeit unterschiedlicher
Forschungszugänge
@/ <
%"&'"(./0123-*4
$7<$
;(
42
$$@%5*
< (;=-(*"(<
N@% *%7
*4;'
'!>:
6%#
".%/0123
*4O#
'-'O#
#,$=
#?:5*
,$$J
"$>
""$
@ "$+$;
<O + *
<"$
)$$A#
4+
5*>#=
#" #
$$#;
:$">$$$
=$
:#K ?
'?$6 5*%$
N.<(=- 1/6/0/03L/FM
>#5*%$AO
%"&'"(./01235* 7
;$J
.1/E3+6+"6%)5*?$.
2/3(
<
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
)">
"?N$7
N.:("+"6="+6/0/0 BE3
%)**(+,%-(*"(./01D3
=*
#5*$J
"N"$N.1B23L/GM
"$$$
"+.13#J
""
(5*A %)**(+,%-(*"(
J@-(*"(<
%"&'"(./0123 N<
=LRM(7$$
?!<
!@$$LMN.1/B3=O&="6%O
)"$"#$
$4($$$
.2 !F3+!(.)+++3
?:"
$($$*$
7$> "
?'$
$(H
) $L/DM
4.2 Strukturen der QM und Strategien der Relationierung
J"$
%"&'"(./0123
N(:N.1/B3
:#!#
#4
$7 %$$
5*$ *J$.
)J$3("@
"$J@
:qL/9M
/
>5*
A%"&'"(#A
=4>$#N"
(:;
;-7
"
!N.1/F3@
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
$$$J ? -$
??$#.%)**(+,%I-(*"(/01D
1BB3>J@$
"./3 (
';$.%"&'"(/012 1203
L20M
+6+"6%)5*(2/
?$>
"<r$.:#
: "3
-$
=O&="6%O21
!"$ :$
:.*$@
&$3
.-$;*
"3L21M
%)**(+,%-(*"(./01D36O%&: #
=4 ;<%
$J./01E 2E/H6O%&/01231D%
($$.43=4
.%)**(+,%I-(*"(/01D 1B23
# K%)**(+,%-(*"(
N@"'?$
($qN.1B23
:$!>?$
?$@5$
-(*"(<
N" 5$'
-7"
$#(J
< >#
$ J
J$
$#N.<(=- 1/6/0/03L2/M
<A:A
-(*"( 5*7<
*J$?$
1D ":4);
$$4$*6O%&
,%+=="6%"&* ,%*+=-"@"+./00F3
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
N >@
#$% - %6
#6#
@ :
$ J $
@ #"
-*4$N.<(=-
1/6/0/03L22M
4.3 Fazit
@::$
*4%"&'"(./0123:
-" 5*@
•-7)
$H
•=
'H
•);H
•($7
4
$$?$L2BM
-K ?
'"$
4'$$J
"
"$?"#$:5*
*
<.=(8:+6< %+(,%)"( sK -(r%6-"I
,%""(/01D3*4
$+
$7'!$
#("L2EM
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
Literatur
$;" -I*# ,./01/3'$; *;
"$:%=>
%?@ AB.23 CCC101G1F9C;1221G/0L
!106/0/1M
:$ (H< 7I* *.%3./01D3C<
=.B #3O::
: H% *;I6 4./01F3>-
"':;:/;B?-
@=%D#E7F%<7%EG7C5FH
)&7 CCCC10992C/GG/0L!/G
/0//M
: <H% H- %I6 :./0/034I
9.2#3-)>-
%.199D3<@
" ).199D34J<O@>
$ )./01136.2$3@>>#
$ %./00F3<#IF<:
*.19DFL19F9M3KL-.MNON31)/(),/P1,,)2,Q$C*$
,I- *./00E3$A*A*$
:$+,I*-.%3
#?"%9#GIARHI$'&
< %4./0113%.B3,@4
% ,./01B3&;"7+6:IJ:.%3
C<%=.EE9;EGB3@>
% @./01D3*4+(:$ 7<I*
*.%3 C<=.B # 1EF;
1ED3O::
% @H% *I- (;=./01235*4
#FE<+: ?&I'
.%3 C<%4=;.119;12F3
@:
% %.19G/39<%<I=
% *I- (;=./01D35*4=
A!**+"I
+*.%3 S".1/2;
1BG3O::
*H& 'I! %./01BL1922M3<I
4= J<T#<#I$C*
$
<./0093((*#./00D3*AA
%=>%?@ AU.23 /0
CCC101G1F9C;10212B0L!106/0/1M
- )./0013"$*$;*$+
*%=>%?
@ V.13 E CCC101G1F9C;/19FFL!10
6/0/1M
- )./01B3*7*+6:IJ:.%3 C<
%=.1E2;1FF3@>
- (./00E3@$4%=>
%?@ W.23 2/ CCC101G1F9C;F219L
!106/0/1M
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
- (./0103@$4"
4@@$%
=>%?@ AA.23 E CCC101G1F9C;
1121B9BL!106/0/1M
-$ )./01B3IXI
@>
-$ -*-.%3.199E3Y)(1)2ZM([3N31\/12/()L/&-.*O)/]/^L\OML*23/()L
%#=%AVIU_IA``_I:$-
-
-$ -*-.%3./01/3<G"
a*O+*,b121,+)L\N2c)L)2d/eNb/fQ/YMLd/ghigjQ/:$-$
CC$$CCCtC/01/C/01/t02t0Dt*
L!106/0/1M
-$ -*-.%3./01F3"TI
%#=I:$-$
CC$$CCCC')$C/01DCt/01Gtt@
L!106/0/1M
& "I* ,.19DE3C% ?6;
%I&>
* <".199E3"4C4=;
4@; Vk 9E;11G
*# (./00D3Il<l+$
>
6 4./01D3m =%""I4 S
<IO::
6 4./0193@)#$::
.;3q"*4:
+6:.%3 %%#<#4;#I
B`IJ=nVUARX
CC$C7C$t/01DCCC11F/L
!/G/0//M
6 ;*./0123@6<<IT
#%I@>
6 ;*./01E3"<;5
*4A*8:,+
%$.%3 "4=.2B9;2FF3<J>$I(
6 ;*H -H$ OI@K ?./00F3--
*A*;$$4
$*+%=>%?
@ o.23 1B CCC101G1F9C;G21B/L!
106/0/1M
6 *./01B3>)'?$
"%4+*6 "%
* *( @ @I7!.%3
p1,\*L,cNL,-.*23Q/^12/12+)L(1,d1ZO12ML) ,/q[2(r*-.s/t[2(/gQ/Y)+.N()2/*2(/K2[Ou,)ZL[v1,Q
9#C%#.1DE;/103:
O",./0/13 5I%
II'O",' CCC101GDGCBG0F;L
!106/0/1M
*./01G3-7;:( *7
*"*% =>%?
@ AR./3 F CCC101G1F9C;1D//D1EL!106
/0/1M
;-./0/13u7>v$$
%4'7':+ ?&I
,=.%3 w< =; "IAo>VUVA?
#4=;./01;/1E3
&$>::
5CC;C
/2./3 B 46I;-5*4A
= $8
;-./0193*$4$;
4@N*N
" +#" )=#
CC7C101EB9FC$;2BD/DL!/G/0//M
# J./01D3=+(:$ 7<I*
*.%3 C<=.B # //G;
/203O::
# JH% H4K (H-$ )I =./01D3
<#$"$K$J= ko./3
/01D D2;100
@ ./0103@>+)$ "-I+
$.%3 I4C<.D 22B;2B93 ($(
@ ./00D3::@49!@6l$J
T<XBA.B3 /2;2/ CC;C01FD;;E/22E;B
L!19/0//M
wVTXT]YxTXeWjYy^_Z^Tz{Y|WVX}WVT~`XlYTjcYokaTlplecdUWY•TXaj`Xlc€pV•Y`XaYW•oeVecdUWV
<+@I,*(.%3 9
x)L2r)L[+*23,3),ZLM-.)2Q/y.)NL)+1,-.)/zL*2(O)3*23)2/*2(/)bZ1L1,-.)/{2+)L,*-.*23)2.1G;
FG3O::
@ ./01/3=<4$
'$$+@I,*(.%3 9
x)L2r)L[+*23,3),ZLM-.)2Q/y.)NL)+1,-.)/zL*2(O)3*23)2/*2(/)bZ1L1,-.)/{2+)L,*-.*23)2.19E;
/1B3O::
@ ./01/3$A&'$
‚pXc`•o~epXYeXYaeci`VceƒWXY„VTi~eiWX{Y…XY†TeXWVY‚WjjWV]YwWVXWVY‡dUXWeaWVYˆYwejj‰YŠeWU‹ƒWVYy•Vcl{z]
#ll<D#I64%<D##
.//9;/BE3@>#
Zu den Autorinnen
54Cm
*+#
" <
(;):
*4
'$:
')
O$
.#;3$::
-$
46
(;):
+#" <
O1G
BBD01:
";*4Œ;;
6!F64C!
*+#
"";)
$$
$
?$ =
O *
;$$%;
+$;
$
-$
;-
";)
+#"
$
,1
/B9B2
";*;$Œ
)(&CC;
C$C;;
CC;;$;
Zitation
64I ;-./0//35*4A
= $8L2EM%
=>%?@ VB./3 B
CCC101G1F9C;///2D0D
5CC;C
