ArticlePublisher preview available

Engineering properties of marine soft clay stabilized by alkali residue and steel slag: an experimental study and ANN model

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

Solid wastes are increasingly used to stabilize marine soft clay. Disposals of alkali slag and steel slag cause serious problems in Lianyungang City. These two waste materials are used to produce the compound cementitious material by mixing with GGBS, replacing the cement to treat the soft clay in Xuwei Port. The raw materials are collected from fields. The orthogonal test is performed to investigate the unconfined compressive strength (UCS) of the treated soil. The influence of alkali slag-soft soil (SR-S) ratio, the steel slag-GGBS (SS-GGBS) ratio, the curing agent, and the curing time are considered, followed by the investigation of reaction mechanisms. The optimal mixing ratio is recommended when the SR-S ratio is 1:1 and the curing agent content equals 10%. A well-documented dataset is developed by summarizing 1069 data of UCS from the literature. A PSO-BP-NN model is developed using the collected data and the experimental data so that generalization is guaranteed. The model is feasible to predict the UCS of treated soil by considering characters of the material properties and experimental techniques. This study aims to provide a reference for initially determining the mixing ratio of cementitious materials at field treatments.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
RESEARCH PAPER
Engineering properties of marine soft clay stabilized by alkali residue
and steel slag: an experimental study and ANN model
Xuefei Wang
1
Zicheng Zhang
1
Zihao Song
1
Jiale Li
1
Received: 16 September 2021 / Accepted: 13 February 2022 / Published online: 17 May 2022
ÓThe Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2022
Abstract
Solid wastes are increasingly used to stabilize marine soft clay. Disposals of alkali slag and steel slag cause serious
problems in Lianyungang City. These two waste materials are used to produce the compound cementitious material by
mixing with GGBS, replacing the cement to treat the soft clay in Xuwei Port. The raw materials are collected from fields.
The orthogonal test is performed to investigate the unconfined compressive strength (UCS) of the treated soil. The
influence of alkali slag-soft soil (SR-S) ratio, the steel slag-GGBS (SS-GGBS) ratio, the curing agent, and the curing time
are considered, followed by the investigation of reaction mechanisms. The optimal mixing ratio is recommended when the
SR-S ratio is 1:1 and the curing agent content equals 10%. A well-documented dataset is developed by summarizing 1069
data of UCS from the literature. A PSO-BP-NN model is developed using the collected data and the experimental data so
that generalization is guaranteed. The model is feasible to predict the UCS of treated soil by considering characters of the
material properties and experimental techniques. This study aims to provide a reference for initially determining the mixing
ratio of cementitious materials at field treatments.
Keywords Marine soft clay Soil treatment Solid wastes Unconfined compressive strength PSO-BP-NN
Orthogonal test
1 Introduction
The total coastline of China reaches 18,000 km, where the
marine sedimentary soft soil is widely distributed. Differ-
ent from soil types in Europe, silty clay and layered silty
sand are the main concerns [28]. The marine clay is
deposited during marine regressions several thousand years
ago. The sediment changes from coarse particles to fine
particles gradually with the rise of sea level, leading to a
larger transportation distance of the terrigenous material.
Due to the differences in geological origins and geo-
graphical locations, structures of the soil skeleton are not
the same along the coastline [17,44]. However, the
geotechnical properties of the marine soft clay are similar
with characteristics of high moisture content, large void
ratio, high compressibility, low permeability, sensitivity,
and low shear strength [47,83]. In general, the soil tends to
be weaker from the north region to the south region
[97,103].
Several soil improvement methods have been proposed
to enhance the soil strength and stabilize the marine soft
clay. The common techniques are preloading, stone col-
umn, pile support, and plastic drainage slab being classified
as the mechanical method [16,54,96,103]. The chemical
improvement methods include the seep in situ mixing,
surface stabilization by cement, fly ash, bentonite, gypsum,
and blast furnace slag [19,22,64,68]. The soil replace-
ment method is effective in shallow foundation treatment,
controlling settlements, and improving bearing capacities.
This method has wide adaptability to clay, saturated soft
soil, and silty clay [4,42,111]. However, the cement and
lime stabilized soil consumes large amounts of energy and
resource; besides, the emission of CO
2
from cement fab-
rications causes serious problems to both environment and
human lives [4]. Therefore, supplementary cementitious
materials are necessary to develop waste or by-products in
construction projects.
&Jiale Li
jiale.li@hebut.edu.cn
1
School of Civil and Transportation Engineering, Hebei
University of Technology, Tianjin 300401, China
123
Acta Geotechnica (2022) 17:5089–5112
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11440-022-01498-5(0123456789().,-volV)(0123456789().,-volV)
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... Several regression models have been used to assess the relationship between the ICMV and in situ data, but the accuracy is limited. Therefore, the ANN model is used to build the prediction model by integrating various characteristic values [56]. Zaman et al. [67] developed an ANN model to correlate the resilient modulus with subgrade soil properties. ...
Article
Full-text available
The quality control of subgrade compaction depends on post-evaluations. The potential bias is caused by the limited coverage of spot tests at the construction site. Intelligent compaction is developed by integrating the sensing system on the vibratory roller and used at the construction site of the Rongwu highway to monitor the compaction quality in real time. The compaction meter value (CMV) is recorded for three months. The sand cone tests are performed following the roller passes. The CMV is proven to be proportional to the roller pass, and it is feasible to represent the compactness of subgrade soils. The linear regression model is developed based on the in situ measured compactness first. An artificial neural network (ANN) model is proposed to correlate the CMV and the compactness by considering the influences of soil properties and control parameters. The prediction model demonstrates good correlations. This study aims to establish a reliable model to improve the feasibility of IC, filling the gap between the continuously recorded CMV and the compactness. This model is to be integrated into the IC system for real-time assessing the compaction quality of subgrade.
... The specific optimization process is shown in Fig. 19. This model has been proven to be effective in the study of highway construction [60,61]. ...
Article
The compaction quality of a highway subgrade is influenced by the compaction parameters and soil properties. Current practice lacks reliable models to assess this multivariate situation. This paper describes a monitoring and evaluation method based on intelligent compaction (IC) and artificial neural networks (ANNs) to assess the compaction quality of a highway subgrade. Field compaction tests were conducted at various roller speeds and vibratory modes. The compactness was predicted using a particle-swarm-optimization optimized backpropagation neural network (PSO-BP-NN) model. The model was integrated into the IC system to automatically evaluate compaction quality. It also demonstrated the advantage of high prediction accuracy with multiple input variables of operation parameters and soil gradation. By efficiently controlling subgrade compaction, the model can be employed for engineering practice and facilitate IC applications.
Article
Temperature segregation of asphalt mixture is one of the major reasons for pavement damage. The premise of ensuring desired properties of the asphalt mixture is to propose a reliable measuring method to monitor temperature variations before paving. Few existing studies focus on this issue due to the absence of suitable and efficient measuring instruments. This study proposes an innovative method to evaluate the temperature variation of asphalt mixture throughout the transportation process by combining the infrared camera and machine learning algorithms. Static and dynamic field tests are performed to measure the contact and non-contact temperatures of the asphalt mixture. A set of temperature measuring probes is specially designed. Influences of the measuring depth, measuring location, and environmental conditions are considered. Correlations between the infrared temperature and the contact temperature are identified using regression model, Support Vector Regression (SVR), and Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost). The accuracy of the proposed model is verified against the experimental result.
Article
Full-text available
Küresel ısınma ve iklim değişikliği Dünya'nın en önemli ve hızla çözülmesi gereken problemlerinden biri haline gelmiştir. Atmosferdeki kızılötesi ışınları tutarak küresel ısınma ve iklim değişikliğine sebep olan sera gazlardan bir tanesi de CO2 gazıdır ve çimento üretimi ile salınan CO2 gazı toplam salınımın %8’ini oluşturmaktadır. CO2 salınımının yanı sıra çimento üretiminde ortaya çıkan nitrik oksitler asit yağmurlarına neden olmaktadır. Atık ya da doğal mineralli malzemeler kullanılarak üretilen geopolimer beton, geleneksel betona göre daha az su kullanımı ve CO2 emisyonunu artırmaması açısından çevresel anlamda sürdürülebilirdir. Geopolimerler farklı kür koşullarında farklı malzemeler ve alkalin aktivatör kullanarak elde edilebilmektedir. Bu derleme makalede çimento yerine alümina silikat oranı yüksek atık malzemelerin bir alkalin aktivatör ile bağlayıcı özellik kazanması esasına dayanan geopolimerlerin zemin iyileştirme çalışmalarında kullanımı incelenmiştir.
Article
Full-text available
Expansive/swell-shrink soils exhibit high plasticity and low strength, which lead to settlement and instability of lightly loaded structures. These problematic soils contain various swelling clay minerals that are unsuitable for engineering requirements. In an attempt to counter the treacherous damage of such soils in modern geotechnical engineering, efforts are underway to utilize environmentally friendly and sustainable waste materials as stabilizers. This study evaluates the strength and consolidation characteristics of expansive soils treated with marble dust (MD) and rice husk ash (RHA) through a multitude of laboratory tests, including consistency limits, compaction, uniaxial compression strength (UCS), and consolidation tests. By using X-ray diffraction (XRD) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analyses, the effect of curing on UCS after 3, 7, 14, 28, 56, and 112 days was studied from the standpoint of microstructural changes. Also, the long-term strength development of treated soils was analyzed in terms of the interactive response of impacting factors with the assistance of a series of ANN-based sensitivity analyses. It is found from the results that the addition of MD and RHA lowered down the water holding capacity, thereby causing a reduction in soil plasticity (by 21% for MD and 14.5% for RHA) and optimum water content (by 2% for MD and increased by 6% for RHA) along with an increase in the UCS (for 8% MD from 97 kPa to 471 kPa and for 10% RHA from 211 kPa to 665 kPa, after 3 days and 112 days of curing, respectively). Moreover, from the oedometer test results, initially increased up to 6% dosage and then dropped with further increase in the preconsolidation pressure. Furthermore, the compression index dropped with an increase in the preconsolidation pressure and addition of MD/RHA, while the coefficient of permeability (k) of RHA stabilized soil was higher than that of MD-treated samples for almost all dosage levels. The formation of the fibrous cementitious compounds (C-S-H; C-A-H) increased at optimum additive dosage after 7 days and at higher curing periods. Hence, the use of 10% RHA and 12% MD as replacement of the expansive soil is recommended for higher efficacy. This research would be helpful in reducing the impacts created by the disposal of both expansive soil and industrial and agricultural waste materials. 1. Introduction Expansive soils or soft soils are hydrophilic due to the presence of water-sensitive clay minerals resulting from environmental and seasonal moisture variations, which cause myriad problems in civil engineering works. They are highly problematic and cause annual economic loss ranging from several millions to billions of dollars, thus exceeding damage caused by other geological disasters [1–5]. Soft expansive clays are extremely sticky when they are wet and are as hard as a rock when they are in a dry state, thus rendering their compaction to be cumbersome [6, 7]. These swelling soils are prevalent across the globe, covering approximately 33% area of Sudan, 20% of both Indonesia and India, 12% region of Syria, and approximately 6% of China [8]. Such soils are abundantly present in various Asian regions, including Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Malaysia, and Oman, and their presence significantly impedes the construction work and causes long-term stability problems [9, 10]. They exhibit a higher affinity for moisture; that is, they swell upon water uptake and shrink when water dissipates [7, 11]. In some cases, the volume rises up to three or even more times the original volume, thus exerting a swelling pressure on overlying foundation structures [12], which results in crack development of the foundations of residential buildings, highways and airfield pavements, and underground utilities [13, 14]; particularly, the lightly loaded structures undergo excessive damage near the ground surface [15]. The expansive soils are stabilized by assessing a variety of additives as “green stabilizer” [16], which have long been incorporated for improving their engineering and microstructural behavior by other researchers: lime [17], cement [18], fly ash [19], rice husk ash [20–23], waste ceramic dust [24–26], nanosilica [27, 28], calcium carbide residue [29], microbial biopolymers [30, 31], and so on. Of these, lime and cement are more commonly used additives in pavements construction and lightly loaded infrastructure. However, the effectiveness of lime as well as cement in soils containing sulfates (SO4) is poor [32]. In addition, these stabilizers impart brittleness to soils, which is highly undesirable in dynamic loading conditions in case of pavements [11]. Mostly, the soil stabilizers are broadly grouped into three major categories: (i) traditional additives (e.g., CaO and cement), (ii) by-product additives (marble dust, cement kiln dust such as CKD, and fly ash), and (iii) nontraditional additives (e.g., ammonium compounds, sulfonated oils, and polymers) [7, 33]. The inevitable problem of handling industrial and agricultural waste on the global level is a serious challenge. These wastes could be incorporated either alone or in conjunction with other chemical agents for ameliorating the soil characteristics in order to vilify their negative environmental impacts and to achieve sustainability [34, 35]. The scope of this study is limited to the selection of marble dust (MD) and rice husk ash (RHA) owing to their indigenous availability. MD sludge is produced in large quantity, which is openly landfilled, thus leading to environmental damage and health risks. Positive results have been achieved in the construction industry when it was incorporated in soil, bricks, production of cement, concrete, and so on [36–38]. After performing a multitude of consolidated undrained triaxial compression on recycled tire treated-cement treated samples at 7, 14, and 28 days of curing, it was found that the undrained shear strength parameters improved significantly due to the formation of cementation compounds [39]. Demolished tile material improved the plasticity index and pH of soft soil, and its addition lowered down the water holding capacity, while the maximum dry density was recorded to be increased by almost 10% [40]. Furthermore, Firat et al. [37] used marble dust in soil stabilization for road construction where the medium to low plasticity soil was used as road base filling material. The tests results on the samples treated with up to 15% marble content and cured for 112 days indicated an increased amount of Tobermorite, thereby increasing the compression strength. These results are encouraging and show that marble dust utilization can be a viable option concerning the environmental aspect. In addition, the replacement of MD in concrete has yielded cost-effectiveness and sustainability [41, 42]. On the other hand, rice husk is a widely used agriculture waste in the rice-milling process that transforms to RHA upon burning and contains a high amount of amorphous silica. When the RHA reacts with calcium hydroxide, they generate cementitious gels, which helps to improve the compression strength of soil [21, 43, 44]. It has been established from previous studies that RHA is a very reactive pozzolanic material, and it can efficaciously stabilize high plastic expansive soils either solely or in combination with lime and/or other additives [45, 46]. Unfortunately, the raw agricultural waste materials and industrial effluents are usually disposed of openly over land or inside the water bodies [47]. Such waste materials must be handled with great care in order to attain a green environment. However, the chemical soil stabilization of expansive soils has largely been in practice across many countries [33, 48]; this technique is less commonly brought to practice in the developing countries of Asia. To the authors’ knowledge, no study to date is available explaining the independent roles of locally produced marble waste and rice husk ash on the compression strength and consolidation behavior of clays with high plasticity cured for long curing periods in the context of microstructural tests. Therefore, the objective of this study is to analyze the effect of long-term curing on the mechanical and morphological performance of expansive soil using marble dust/rice husk ash. An extensive laboratory soil testing was performed to evaluate the index properties (consistency limits) and engineering properties (compaction, compression strength, and consolidation) of the soil with varying quantities of additives, and the long-term strength development of treated soils was analyzed in terms of the interactive response of impacting factors with assistance of ANN-based sensitivity analysis. In addition, the change in microstructural features and morphology was studied by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis. 2. Site Location The study area is located in Nandipur town (32°15′22″ N 74°15′50″ E) of Gujranwala city, Pakistan, with an elevation of 225 to 231 m, from where expansive soil specimens were obtained (Figure 1). The region is susceptible to natural and artificial slope instability. Preliminary investigation of the area revealed the diagonal cracking of boundary walls and the presence of polygonal desiccation cracks over the inclined face of embankments running along the pavements that could be attributed to the swelling of the expansive soil, as shown in Figures 2(a) and 2(b).
Article
Full-text available
Modern coastal cities continue to expand to the sea, but the marine silt foundation has high water content and poor bearing capacity. Therefore, it is necessary to find economical and rapid ways to reduce the water content of the silt and improve the bearing capacity of the silt foundation. The steel slag is considered to be incorporated into silt to effectively reduce the moisture content of soil and improve the bearing capacity of the foundation due to its hard texture and strong water absorption capacity. In this paper, the shear strength characteristics of marine silt modified by steel slag were studied using an automatic triaxial instrument, as well as the relationship between steel slag incorporation and modified silt density. Experimental results showed that the incorporation of steel slag can effectively improve the shear strength of the silt. Besides, the influences of water content, steel slag incorporation, and confining pressure on the stress-strain curve characteristics and failure deviatoric stress of modified silt were also analyzed. The addition of steel slag increases the failure deviatoric stress of the silt. However, the increase of water content will weaken the effect of steel slag incorporation. The shear strength index of improved silt with different steel slag incorporation was compared with that of traditional soil, verifying the feasibility of its application in engineering construction.
Article
Full-text available
Tunnel face is important for shallow tunnels to avoid collapses. In this study, tunnel face stability is studied with soft computing techniques. A database is created based on the literature which is used to train some broadly adopted soft computing techniques, ranging from linear regression to the artificial neural network. The soil dry density, cohesion, friction angle, cover depth and the tunnel diameter are used as the input parameters. The soft computing techniques state whether the face support is stable and predict the face support pressure. It is found that the artificial neural network outperforms the other techniques. The face support pressure is predicted with the artificial neural network for statistically distributed samples, and the failure probability is obtained with Monte Carlo simulations. In this way, the stability of the tunnel face can be reliably assessed and the support pressure can be estimated fairly accurately.
Article
Full-text available
Gypseous soils are soils that contain sufficient quantities of gypsum that are considered collapsible soil. The present study's objective is to predict the shear strength parameters (c, ϕ), collapse potential (CP), and compression index (Cc) from the gypseous soils' physical properties using a wide range of 220 collected data from various published articles. The linear and nonlinear approaches were used in this study, and the outcomes of the models were compared with artificial neural network (ANN) performance. The developed models predicted the shear parameters, compression index, gypsum content, and collapse potential as a function of accessible laboratories measurable such as specific gravity, moisture content, density, and Atterberg limits with acceptable accuracy. The soils' gypsum content (Gc) was also correlated well based on the total soluble salts (TSS), sulfate (SO3), and pH values using the nonlinear Vipulanandan correlation model. Based on the adjusted (R2), mean absolute error (MAE), and the root-mean-square error (RMSE), the linear and nonlinear models predicted the shear strength parameters, compression index, and collapse potential of the gypseous soils very well. The regression model predictions were comparable to the outcomes from the ANN model predicting.
Article
The reliable correlation model for intelligent compaction (IC) is to be developed by integrating characteristics of the filling material and control parameters of the vibratory roller. Key characteristics of the backfill soil from the construction site of Rongwu Highway are tested through the modified Proctor test and the direct shear test. A well-documented dataset is built by summarizing 4000 shear strengths from open literature and 246 data from laboratory tests in this study. The PSO-BP-NN model is developed based on this dataset to predict the shear strength and compactness of the subgrade soil in the scope of mechanical properties and compaction powers. The importance analysis of the input variables is performed with the Random Forest algorithm. The influence mechanism is analyzed in sequence. The plain soil and the lime soil demonstrate typical compaction curves, and the lime soil is less sensitive to the influence factors. An optimal compaction power exists for determining the optimal moisture content utilizing the shear strength, tending to be less conservative. The moisture content is the most important factor for the compactness, followed by the compaction power; the particle size is suggested to be considered for real-time evaluations. The compaction mechanism is mainly attributed to the water film theory and the electrochemical property of the filling soil. This study aims to provide a reliable model to estimate the compactness in the aspect of material properties so as to enhance the accuracy of the IC model.
Article
The disposal and recycling of dredged materials (DM) are of great significance to sustainable development, and carbonation stabilization using steel slag is potentially a green method of utilizing DM. However, the underdeveloped dehydration process hinders the large-scale application of carbonation stabilization. Therefore, to find a more efficient and economical way of recycling DM, a continuous treatment combining the foam drying process with the carbonation stabilization process by introducing ground steel slag fist into dredged slurries was proposed. The effects of ground steel slag in the processes of foam drying and carbonation stabilization were individually assessed at the laboratory scale. The results showed that ground steel slag can stabilize the foam more easily and remarkably increase the drying rate. The optimum dry density of the foamed slurry is 0.60 g/mL, and the drying time is reduced by 58.3%. Ground steel slag is still active in the carbonation stabilization process after 24 h of drying. After carbonation stabilization, the maximum unconfined compressive strength of the modified soil reaches 2007 kPa, which is 8.5 times the value without carbonation stabilization. Moreover, it should be noted that the optimum moisture content for carbonation stabilization differs from that for compaction, which is an important distinction for practical application of the proposed technology. Through microscopic tests including X-ray diffraction (XRD), thermogravimetry (TG), and scanning electron microscopy (SEM), it is found that the strength of the modified soil derives from the carbonation reaction of steel slag. The product of carbonation stabilization is mainly spindle-shaped calcium carbonate with a particle size of <1 μm but a high degree of polymerization.
Article
Steelmaking wastes have been reused in civil construction to decrease environmental damages. This work evaluated the use of fines of oxidising electric arc furnace (EAF) steel slag (FEAF) as stabilising agents of two different soils Tests for geotechnical characterisation of soils and chemical, physical, and morphological characterisation of FEAF were carried out. Natural soils and soil-FEAF mixtures were subjected to standard Proctor compaction, unconfined compression strength (UCS), California Bearing Ratio (CBR), and resilient modulus (RM) tests. FEAF provided UCS increases up to 128%, maximum dry density increases up to 6% and optimal moisture content reductions up to 10%. The highest improvements were provided by 15% of FEAF (UCS increases from 7 to 56 days of A-7-5(19) and A-2-7(0) soils were 60% and 21%, respectively). Regardless of the curing period, CBR index of A-7-5(19) soil with 15% FEAF was 60–65% of CBR index of A-2-7(0) soil containing 15% FEAF. Similar reductions (27–29%) in CBR swelling were observed in both soils. Incorporation of 15% FEAF into A-7-5(19) and A-2-7(0) soils provided RM increases of 30% and 45%, respectively. Mechanical properties increases were attributed to filler effects and improvements in cementitious reactions FEAF improved soils’ performance, enabling their use in pavement design and earthworks.
Article
Geotechnical structures, design of embankment, earth and rock fill dam, tunnels, and slope stability require further attention in determining the shear strength of soil and other parameters that govern the result. The shear strength of soil commonly obtained by conducting laboratory testing such as Unconfined Compression Strength (UCS) Test and Unconsolidated Undrained (UU) Test. However, random errors and systematic errors can occur during experimental works and caused the findings imprecise. Besides, the laboratory test also consuming a lot of time and some of them are quite costly. Therefore, soft computational tools are developed to improve the accuracy of the results and time effectively when compared to conventional method. In this study, Artificial Neural Network (ANN) was employed to develop a predictive model to correlate the moisture content (MC), liquid limit (LL), plastic limit (PL), and liquidity index (LI) of cohesive soil with the undrained shear strength of soil. A total of 10 databases was developed by using MATLAB 7.0 - matrix laboratory with 318 of UCS tests and 451 of UU tests which are collected from the verified site investigation (SI) report, respectively. All the SI reports collected were conducted in Sarawak, Malaysia. The datasets were split into ratio of 3:1:1 which is 60:20:20 (training: validation: testing) with one hidden layer and eight hidden neurons. The input parameter of Liquidity index (LI) has shown the highest R-value (regression coefficient) which are 0.926 and 0.904 for UCS and UU model, respectively. In addition, the predictive models were tested and compare with the predicted and observed cohesion obtained from the collected experimental results. In summary, the ANN has the feasibility to be used as a predictive tool in estimating the shear strength of the soil.