ArticlePublisher preview available

Mediating Roles of Karma and Self‐Enhancement in the Effect of Religious and Spiritual Primes on Bystanders’ Reporting Intention

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract and Figures

Religious priming promotes engagement in prosocial action, however, findings about spiritual priming are relatively scant. Using Hindu (India) and Christian (U.S.) participants, a two‐part study was conducted. The aim of the first part (i.e., Study 1) was to observe which motives to volunteer (i.e., egoistic or altruistic) related to religiosity and spirituality. Findings show that religiosity had a positive impact on egoistic volunteering, while spirituality had a positive impact on altruistic volunteering. The aim of the second part (i.e., Study 2) was to apply the findings from Study 1 to test priming effects in public service announcements about domestic violence prevention. The mediating effects of karma and self‐enhancement in the relationship between religiosity or spirituality and reporting intention was also examined. Findings show that the religious ad was more effective than the spiritual ad in priming religiosity and spirituality among Hindus; that is, karma mediated the effect of religiosity and spirituality on their reporting intention. Among Christians, spiritual primes were effective, and self‐enhancement mediated the impact of spirituality on reporting intention; at the same time, religious primes led to the direct impact of religiosity and spirituality on reporting intention. Overall, the apparent efficacy of religious and spiritual priming is promising, and the findings indicate the significance of spirituality in domestic violence prevention messaging. Theoretical and managerial implications are discussed. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Mediating roles of karma and self-enhancement in the effect
of religious and spiritual primes on bystanders' reporting
intention
Sidharth Muralidharan
Temerlin Advertising Institute, Southern
Methodist University, Dallas, Texas, USA
Correspondence
Sidharth Muralidharan, Temerlin Advertising
Institute, Southern Methodist University,
P.O. Box 750113, Dallas, TX 75275, USA.
Email: sidmurali@smu.edu
Funding information
Meadows School of the Arts at Southern
Methodist University; Temerlin Advertising
Institute at Southern Methodist University
Abstract
Religious priming promotes engagement in prosocial action; however, findings about
spiritual priming are relatively scant. Using Hindu (India) and Christian (U.S.) partici-
pants, a two-part study was conducted. The aim of the first part (i.e., Study 1) was to
observe which motives to volunteer (i.e., egoistic or altruistic) related to religiosity
and spirituality. Findings show that religiosity had a positive impact on egoistic
volunteering, while spirituality had a positive impact on altruistic volunteering. The
aim of the second part (i.e., Study 2) was to apply the findings from Study 1 to test
priming effects in public service announcements about domestic violence prevention.
The mediating effects of karma and self-enhancement in the relationship between
religiosity or spirituality and reporting intention were also examined. Findings show
that the religious ad was more effective than the spiritual ad in priming religiosity and
spirituality among Hindus; that is, karma mediated the effect of religiosity and spiritu-
ality on their reporting intention. Among Christians, spiritual primes were effective,
and self-enhancement mediated the impact of spirituality on reporting intention; at
the same time, religious primes led to the direct impact of religiosity and spirituality
on reporting intention. Overall, the apparent efficacy of religious and spiritual priming
is promising, and the findings indicate the significance of spirituality in domestic vio-
lence prevention messaging. Theoretical and managerial implications are discussed.
KEYWORDS
karma, priming, public service announcements, religiosity, self-enhancement, spirituality
1|INTRODUCTION
Factors that influence consumer behaviour is an important area of
study (Paul & Bhukya, 2021), and one such factor is beliefs.For
example, trust is a positive belief that has been found to influence
purchase intentions (Chakraborty et al., 2022). Beliefs inform behav-
iour, and religion and its beliefs, provide a framework that can spur
pro-social action.
Though altruistic tendencies exist, previous findings indicate that
volunteering among the religious stems from egoistic motives. For exam-
ple, maintaining a strong social network positively influenced formal
volunteering or volunteering guided by religious membership (van Tienen
et al., 2011). In this way, volunteering can enhance one's social network
(Becker & Dhingra, 2001). On the contrary, spirituality closely relates to
altruism (Saroglou, 2013), but findings about the influence of spirituality
on volunteering are relatively scant. Therefore, we divided the current
study into two parts. The first part (i.e., Study 1) was a preliminary explo-
ration of two factors (i.e., egoism and altruism) important to religiosity
and spirituality that might motivate volunteering. The purpose of the
second part (i.e., Study 2) was to apply the findings of Study 1 to a
behavioural outcome (i.e., bystander intervention) of priming cues in
health messaging about domestic violence prevention.
Received: 28 September 2021 Revised: 13 April 2022 Accepted: 25 April 2022
DOI: 10.1111/ijcs.12820
Int J Consum Stud. 2023;47:189201. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ijcs © 2022 John Wiley & Sons Ltd. 189
... Religious devotion is often associated with mental well-being (Godinic, Obrenovic, and Khudaykulov 2020), and this relationship is closely linked with spirituality (La Ferle, Muralidharan, and Roth-Cohen 2022), which reflects an individual's quest for personal fulfillment and meaning (Marmor-Lavie and Stout 2016). Religion refers to an external framework offering a belief system (Rinallo, Scott, and Maclaran 2012), whereas spirituality "is an internal construct representing an independent journey of selfactualization" (Muralidharan andPookulangara 2022, 1124). Although spirituality is distinct from religion, it can also include religious practices (Isaac, Hay, and Lubetkin 2016). ...
... For instance, research has demonstrated that Islamic and Christian symbols can positively influence consumer attitudes toward the ads (Henley et al. 2009;Ustaahmeto� glu 2020). Similarly, Muralidharan (2023) discovered that PSAs incorporating religious appeals enhanced the intention to seek help among Hindu viewers. These findings are consistent with those of Taylor, Halstead, and Haynes (2010), who observed that the inclusion of Christian symbols in service advertising significantly increased purchase intentions among Christian consumers. ...
Article
Advertising scholars have studied the persuasiveness of religious symbols in ads for more than two decades. However, the extent to which religious appeals influence attitudes and behavioral intentions remains a contentious issue. This study aims to provide conclusive insights by analyzing inconsistent findings across studies on the persuasiveness of religious appeals. We reviewed and analyzed 35 empirical studies (N = 7,983) using a meta-analytic approach. Our results reveal that whereas religious appeals positively influence attitudes and the overall persuasion, they do not significantly impact behavioral intentions. We also tested several moderating factors, including type of religious symbol, brand context, advertising domain, product type, gender, cultural context, and religious affiliation. Notably, type of religious symbol and gender significantly moderated the effect of religious appeals on the overall persuasiveness. As a result, this meta-analysis seeks to make a definitive contribution to the debate on the effectiveness of religious appeals in advertising by conducting a statistical synthesis. It addresses a critical gap in the literature by examining how and to what extent advertising messages combined with religious appeals influence the overall persuasion, offering valuable insights for both scholars and advertising professionals.
... weaker) belief in karma are more honest and less concerned about immediate benefits in favour of long-run consequences (Kopalle et al., 2010). Furthermore, such consumers are more likely to engage in prosocial behaviours, such as helping others in need (Muralidharan, 2023) and donating time or money (Chen et al., 2022), especially when exposed to self-threatening or uncertain situations (Converse et al., 2012). Consistent with the above, such consumers also refrain from self-enhancing conversations in which they gossip about others and brag about their own past positive experiences, thereby leaning toward more generous and respectful conversations (Valenzuela et al., 2018). ...
... In particular, our findings elucidate the role of belief in karma, which determines tourists' intention to travel to foreign destinations once the pandemic will be over. Second, the present research corroborates prior literature on the determining role of belief in karma in a variety of domains, such as charitable donation behaviours (Chen et al., 2022;Kulow & Kramer, 2016;Muralidharan, 2023) and interpersonal conversation (Valenzuela et al., 2018). More particularly, the research expands this literature stream by showing that belief in karma significantly influences tourists' post-pandemic intention to travel abroad under a pandemic context and, by extension, in threatening situations. ...
Article
The COVID-19 pandemic has dramatically affected tourists’ travelling intention, especially regarding foreign destinations. Amid this health emergency, many studies have explored the psychological antecedents of tourists’ intention to travel. However, none has investigated the role of belief in karma. The present research is the first to examine the influence of this cultural factor on tourists’ post-pandemic intention to travel abroad rather than domestically. A survey study with 1,586 Chinese respondents showed that stronger belief in karma is associated with a decreased intention to travel abroad, and this negative relationship is mediated by pandemic-related anxiety toward travelling. Our findings also carry theoretical and managerial implications.
Article
Little is known about how religious beliefs (i.e. karmic beliefs and beliefs in a just world) can active individuals’ social entrepreneurship. Integrating the justice motive theory within stimulus-organism-response framework, our study aims to explore the individual, complementary, congruent, and incongruent impacts of karmic beliefs and belief in a just world on social entrepreneurial intention as well as the mediation role of empathy and moral obligation in this relationship. Using a sample of 401 individuals and employing polynomial regression with response surface analysis, findings indicate that karmic beliefs and belief in a just world serve as significant stimuli which not only inspire empathic and moral organisation, but indirectly reinforce individuals’ social entrepreneurial intentions. Moreover, high levels of both karmic beliefs and beliefs in a just world can enhance organisms (empathy and moral obligation), and behavioural responses (social entrepreneurial intentions), but imbalanced levels of these beliefs erode such organisms and responses. Some practical implications have been recommended to foster social business ventures based on the findings of the current study.
Article
The role of karma in sustainable consumption remains unknown. This study thus offers a karmic perspective of pro-environmental consumption, wherein consumers' personal (moral) norms regarding being more pro-environment are activated by three karma dimensions: duty orientation, indifference to rewards, and equanimity. Drawing on the norm activation model, a sample of 552 participants recruited in the five largest cities in Vietnam using the mall-intercept survey approach, and an emerging analysis technique – polynomial regression with response surface analysis, the findings show that three karma dimensions individually and jointly activate consumers' personal moral norms, which in turn stimulate consumers to consume in a more environmentally friendly manner. Moreover, the ascription of responsibility is significantly related to consumers’ pro-environmental intentions and behaviors, while awareness of consequences is only significantly correlated with intentions to behave in a pro-environmental manner. Theoretical and managerial implications are discussed in the context of sustainable consumption.
Article
Full-text available
The demand for Ayurveda products has been increasing over the last decade, and consumption values are critical in understanding the driving forces behind the success of these products. This study examines an initial‐trust–mediated model using theory of consumption values (TCV) to predict consumer’s intention to purchase Ayurveda products. The conditional, functional, emotional, epistemic and social values in the TCV were used to build an initial‐trust–mediated model. The proposed model was analyzed using a sample of 440 usable responses. The outcomes revealed that the five consumption values used in the model influenced initial trust. Intention to purchase Ayurveda products was found to be influenced by the four consumption values, except social values. Initial trust strongly mediated the effect between consumption values and intention to purchase Ayurveda products. This study provides theoretical, practical, and managerial implications for marketers and other professionals in the natural, eco‐friendly, and green products sector.
Article
Full-text available
The International Journal of Consumer Studies (IJCS) is a distinguished 45 year old peer‐reviewed international journal in the field of multidisciplinary consumer research. This paper takes stock of the work published since 1977 (n=2088) and examines the impact of published research by applying network analysis technique using VOSviewer. In particular, it examines the overall citations received, the most cited papers and authors and their contributions to the field of consumer research. The advancement of research in the field of consumer research is discussed and directions for future research is provided to undertake novel research.
Article
Full-text available
This research examines how consumers’ religiosity influences response to marketing communication mediums that are viewed either actively (e.g., holiday gift cards that are actively sought out) versus passively (e.g., holiday ads that a consumer is passively exposed to). Using an experimental method, this research first shows that consumer religiosity positively influences retailer evaluations. Next, this research examines how an actively viewed marketing communication (using the context of holiday gift cards) versus a passively viewed marketing communication (using the context of holiday ads) influences consumers’ evaluations of retailers and the explanatory mechanisms underlying those evaluations. Results show that consumers with higher extrinsic religiosity have higher pride in response to gift cards as opposed to ads, which leads to higher retailer evaluations. In contrast, consumers with higher intrinsic religiosity have lower guilt in response to gift cards as opposed to ads, which also leads to higher retailer evaluations. These findings are discussed in relation to the literature on pride and guilt and build off belief congruence theory. Additionally, implications for marketers and retailers are identified.
Article
Full-text available
Moralizing religions encourage people to anticipate supernatural punishments for violating moral norms, even in anonymous interactions. This is thought to be one way large-scale societies have solved cooperative dilemmas. Previous research has overwhelmingly focused on the effects of moralizing gods, and has yet to thoroughly examine other religious moralizing systems, such as karma, to which more than a billion people subscribe worldwide. In two pre-registered studies conducted with Chinese Singaporeans, we compared the moralizing effects of karma and afterlife beliefs of Buddhists, Taoists, Christians, and the non-religious. In Study 1 (N = 582), we found that Buddhists and Taoists (karmic religions) judge individual actions as having greater consequences in this life and the next, compared to Christians. Pointing to the specific role of karma beliefs in these judgements, these effects were replicated in comparisons of participants from the non-karmic religions/groups (Christian and non-religious) who did or did not endorse karma belief. Study 2 (N = 830) exploited religious syncretism in this population by reminding participants about either moral afterlife beliefs (reincarnation or heaven/hell), ancestor veneration beliefs, or neither, before assessing norms of generosity in a series of hypothetical dictator games. When reminded of their ancestor veneration beliefs, Buddhists and Taoists (but not Christians) endorsed parochial prosocial norms, expressing willingness to give more to their family and religious group than did those in the control condition. Moral afterlife beliefs increased generosity to strangers for all groups. Taken together, these results provide evidence that different religious beliefs can foster and maintain different prosocial and cooperative norms.
Article
Full-text available
To understand the growing trend of gender-themed empowerment advertising, such as “femvertising” and “dadvertising,” this content analysis evaluates the scope and configuration of power and empowerment in magazine advertisements targeting women, men, and the general audience. Based on an interdisciplinary framework, different sources and dimensions of empowerment as well as types of social power are analyzed. Results suggest that empowerment advertising is a highly targeted strategy appealing to primarily female consumers. Female empowerment is typically represented through agentic power while male empowerment focuses on physicality. Results also highlight the emphasis on personal empowerment and the individualistic nature of empowerment advertising narratives.
Article
Full-text available
While religious cues are used in advertising efforts, research has yet to adequately understand perceived motives behind such religious cue use and how this influences consumers’ evaluations of a brand. Thus, this research addresses this gap through two studies examining cue measures, businesses’ motives for using cues, consumer affect, and brand evaluations. Specifically, Study 1 (an exploratory study) explores evaluations and associations evoked by religious cues representative of Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, and Hinduism. Study 2 narrows down the focus to Christianity and Islam to probe the outcome of religious cue use on businesses employing them in their advertisements. Specifically, Study 2 finds that consumers perceive businesses’ motives behind religious cue use as primarily trying to reach a specific target market but also as trying to witness and communicating reverence to God. Surprisingly, religious cue condition (Christian, Muslim, or none) did not directly influence business evaluations. Further analysis revealed that when affect toward the ad with religious cue was included in the model, that Muslim cue condition had a significant influence on affect, and such affect significantly influenced business evaluations. Interestingly, no similar effect could be established for the Christian condition. Discussion builds on the theory of visual rhetoric. Implications for marketing practice are also provided. The studies are limited by data collection only in the United States.
Book
This third edition provides a comprehensive framework of values, knowledge, and skills for spiritually sensitive and culturally appropriate social work practice with diverse religious and nonreligious people. It includes 40 case examples and stories that illustrate theory and practice related to health, mental health, youth work, gerontology, end of life, and other fields. Each chapter includes learning exercises to promote readers' personal and professional development. Spiritual perspectives include Buddhism, Christianity, Confucianism, Hinduism, Indigenous, Islam, Judaism, Existentialism, and Transpersonal and Deep Ecological Theories. Intersectionalities of diversities of spiritual perspective, culture, gender, disability, and LGBTQI issues are addressed. Skills are presented for spiritual assessment, mindfulness, meditation, ritual, forgiveness, administration, and community collaboration. International surveys and global perspective address social work practices, codes of ethics, and principles for inclusive compassion and justice.
Article
Although it is well‐established that religious individuals tend to volunteer more than the non‐religious, few studies have examined motivations to volunteer as a potential explanation for this relationship. The present research takes a functional approach to examine whether religiosity drives volunteerism by promoting certain motivations for volunteering. Two common theories of religious prosociality are considered: (1) religious belief increases volunteering through internalized prosocial values, and (2) religious service attendance increases volunteering by fostering social relationships, hence increasing social reasons for volunteering. In two studies, Values‐based and Social‐based motivations to volunteer are tested as mediators in the relationship between religiosity (both belief and service attendance) and volunteering. Study 1 used a predominantly university student sample (N = 130) to predict volunteering intentions, whereas Study 2 employed an Australian community sample (N = 772) to predict self‐reported volunteer hours. Both studies show consistent findings that the Values motive mediated the relationship between religious belief and volunteering, whereas the Social motive did not mediate the relationship between religious service attendance and volunteering. We find support for the theory that religious beliefs boost volunteerism by promoting humanistic reasons for volunteering.
Article
Domestic violence is an ongoing health issue around the world, propelling individuals and organizations to seek out new and innovative ways to mitigate its widespread reach. Focusing on the potential of religion to positively impact messaging, the current study examines how Christian symbolism might be used to encourage intervention behavior using public service announcements (PSAs). Using a between‐subjects design of Christian Americans as the respondent pool, a religious symbol versus a control ad was utilized. Levels of religiosity were also measured and factors impacting the construct assessed. Findings revealed religiosity, the importance of religion in one's life, was the underlying motivator for highly religious people to act rather than a religious cue. Within religiosity, the perceived strength of faith to one's identity held greater value than church attendance and frequency of prayer. Theoretical implications are discussed as well as insights for people working in public service messaging.