Article

Legislative tax announcements and GDP: Evidence from the United States, Germany, and the United Kingdom

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

We study the announcement effect of legislated tax changes on GDP in the US, Germany, and the UK. Using, as the shock of interest, narratively identified information about future tax changes at the quarter of their introduction to the legislative body, we analyse the dynamic results of Local Projections. After drafting tax cuts, economic activity declines (increases) in the US (the UK), but remains unaffected in Germany. When allowing the responses to vary over the business cycle, we find evidence that US GDP drops regardless of the business cycle, whereas UK GDP rises only during non-recessionary times. German GDP rises (drops) during recessions (non-recessions).

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

... Economists worldwide [1][2][3] have fundamental controversies over how to regulate the economy during a crisis or rapid growth. Specific consequences await global business after the COVID-19 pandemic [4]. ...
... Therefore, the author's choice was modeling for small open economies. The Mandel-Fleming model has proven very well in applied research [2]. In addition, to determine the efficiency of the economy's response to economic policy measures, it is not necessary to collect a cumbersome database. ...
Article
The protracted COVID-19 pandemic and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine have caused a severe and deep crisis in Ukraine and colossal physical destruction. The restoration of the country, its economy and the entire socio-economic system determines the urgency of providing predictive indicators to identify the fastest results. The purpose of the article was to forecast the effectiveness of the government's economic policy based on the Mandel-Fleming model for the development of Ukraine's economy. The article used the method of analysis and synthesis and the system approach, the method of economic modeling, economic forecasting, the method of mathematical and vector analysis, the graphic method, as well as the main provisions of the Mandel-Fleming macroeconomic model for open economics in the short term. The article proposes to forecast the effectiveness of real government measures under the condition of using multipliers of the Mandela-Fleming model for Ukraine’s economic development after the deep socio-economic crisis caused by the war. In predict applied, chain schemes are presented that show the effectiveness of specific monetary and fiscal policy measures. It was proposed approach of forecasting the effectiveness of implementing the government’s monetary and fiscal policy measures, taking into account positive or negative multiplicative coefficients according to the Mandel-Fleming model, depending on the exchange rate regime for the recovery of the economy and economic development of Ukraine. The research has an applied aspect and is suitable for use in decision-making by the government regarding the implemented economic policy
... Empirical studies demonstrate the interdependence of economies at both the economic and the monetary level too. According to Soyres and Gaillard (2022), Himounet (2022), Castañeda and Cendejas (2022), Feldkircher (2015), Engel (2016), Lee and Werner (2018), Hayo and Mierzwa (2022), Lewis et al. (2022) the consequences of these changes in trade patterns for the synchronization of economic activity are important because they can have implications for macroeconomic policies. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: The alignment of economic cycles is created naturally, by the gradual harmonization of the economic development of economies that are open and cooperating with each other, which gradually over decades has led to their significant economic interconnection, to the creation of the so-called global economy. Aims: The main aim of this paper is to analyze the impact of individual financial crises on economic cycle alignment as well as the naturally increasing correlation between interacting economies themselves. Methods: We have analysed the impact of individual financial crises on economic cycle coherence as well as the naturally increasing correlation between interacting economies. Sample: We examined the historical evolution of the correlation on ten-year periods from 1961 to 2020. Results: The calculated correlations of the percentage GDP growth of the selected 40 countries with the global percentage GDP growth over the last 61 years have shown that the interconnectedness of major economies has reached an advanced level. Conclusions: The higher the correlation of GDP growth of the selected countries with global GDP growth, the higher the effect of economic booms as well as recessions will be multiplied. Implications: This analysis has so far failed to include the impact of the admittedly extremely short but extremely sudden and fully global recession caused by COVID 19.
Chapter
Full-text available
En el presente documento se analiza la incidencia de los ciclos económicos y políticos en la recaudación tributaria en México Para conseguirlo, se utilizan datos de panel para las 32 entidades federativas de 2008 a 2018 en su especifi-cación Pooled (agrupados) y en su especificación de efectos fijos La recolección de ingresos propios se aproximó con dos indicadores: el primero es la recau-dación local por la Secretaría de Hacienda y Crédito Público y el segundo es un indicador de esfuerzo fiscal que aproxima la diferencia entre lo que recauda un estado y su capacidad fiscal total Para controlar los ciclos políticos, se creó una variable dicotómica para los años de elecciones de la gubernatura estatal Los resultados indican que la recolección de recursos propios se relaciona con la actividad económica y los años de elecciones estatales en México Durantt etapas de bonanza económica se generan más ingresos públicos, debido a que la actividad económica estimula la contratación de personal, expedición de permisos, plusvalía de inmuebles y otras actividades gravadas por las haciendas locales . En los años de elecciones estatales, pueden surgir perturbaciones económicas como consecuencia de la incertidumbre económica que genera, también algunos contribuyentes pueden evitar el pago de impuestos, sabedores de que las autoridades desean evitar el costo político de cobrar impuestos
Article
Full-text available
We here examine the frequent claim that an increase in the tax base and a decrease in tax evasion will compensate for a loss in tax revenues caused by a lower tax level. Using a unique data set for the estimated underground economy in Italy from 1982 to 2006, we found that a loss in tax revenues equivalent to 1% of the GDP would be partly compensated by an increase in GDP of 0.55%. The compensation would come from 0.31% of the GDP increase and from 0.24% of the reductions in the underground economy. These results apply to an economy with a high tax level (>32%) and a high underground economy (≥25%). Applying a high-resolution lead–lag method to the data, we ensured that tax changes were leading the GDP and, thus, a potential cause for changes in the GDP.
Article
Full-text available
This paper quantifies the dynamic macroeconomic effects of tax changes in Germany, allowing for anticipation effects of preannounced tax reforms. Identification is achieved using a narrative approach, which provides information about the timing of tax reforms. An anticipated cut in taxes has a positive effect on output with a peak multiplier of 1.7, not observed until nine quarters after implementation. This positive effect is accompanied by significant negative anticipation effects on output, consumption, investment, hours worked and wages. Our results suggest that policymakers should take anticipation effects into account when implementing fiscal policy measures.
Article
Full-text available
This paper provides new estimates of the macroeconomic effects of tax changes using a new narrative dataset for the United Kingdom. Identification is achieved by isolating “exogenous” tax policy changes using the Romer and Romer narrative strategy. I find that a 1 percent cut in taxes increases GDP by 0.6 percent on impact and 2.5 percent over three years. The findings are remarkably similar to Romer and Romer narrative estimates for the United States, reinforcing the view that tax changes have powerful and persistent effects. “Exogenous” tax changes are also shown to have contributed to important episodes in the UK business cycle.
Article
Full-text available
This paper characterizes the dynamic effects of shocks in government spending and taxes on U. S. activity in the postwar period. It does so by using a mixed structural VAR/event study approach. Identification is achieved by using institutional information about the tax and transfer systems to identify the automatic response of taxes and spending to activity, and, by implication, to infer fiscal shocks. The results consistently show positive government spending shocks as having a positive effect on output, and positive tax shocks as having a negative effect. One result has a distinctly nonstandard flavor: both increases in taxes and increases in government spending have a strong negative effect on investment spending. © 2001 the President and Fellows of Harvard College and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Article
Full-text available
We consider the fiscal multiplier and spillover in an environment in which two countries are caught simultaneously in a liquidity trap. Using an optimizing two-country sticky price model, we show that the fiscal multiplier and spillover are contrary to those predicted in textbook economics. For the country with government expenditure, the fiscal multiplier exceeds one, the currency depreciates, and the terms of trade worsen. The fiscal spillover is negative if the intertemporal elasticity of substitution in consumption is less than one and positive if the parameter is greater than one. Incomplete stabilization of marginal costs due to the existence of the zero lower bound is a crucial factor in understanding the effects of fiscal policy in open economies.
Article
Full-text available
This paper uses a dynamic general equilibrium model to analyze and quantify the aggregate effects of the timing of tax rate changes enacted in 2001 (which called for successive rate reductions through 2006) and 2003 (which made immediate tax rate cuts scheduled for 2004 and 2006). The phased-in nature contributed to the slow recovery from the 2001 recession, while the elimination of the phase-in helped explain the increase in economic activity in 2003. The simulations suggest while the tax policy was a drag on the economy in 2001 and 2002, it increased economic growth in 2003, once phase-ins were eliminated. (JEL D58, E32, E62, H24, H25, O41)
Article
We investigate whether the effect of tax news depends on the state of the economy. Using U.S. quarterly data, we show that news about future tax cuts are more contractionary during recessions. This nonlinearity is mainly due to the response of durable consumption and, especially, nonresidential investment.
Article
This study evaluates how the state of the economy, as measured by the rate of unemployment, influences the short-term effects of tax changes on output and employment. I examine the effects of narratively identified tax changes by adopting two alternative approaches to estimating state-dependent impulse response functions that have been widely used in the recent literature. Both approaches suggest that short-term effects of tax changes on output and employment are smaller during times of higher unemployment. I argue that increased labor market slack and tighter credit conditions in contractionary periods can reduce the responsiveness of labor supply to changes in labor income taxes, resulting in smaller effects on output from tax changes.
Article
Unconventional fiscal policy uses announcements of future increases in consumption taxes to generate inflation expectations and accelerate consumption expenditure. It is budget neutral and time consistent. We provide preliminary evidence for the effectiveness of such policies using changes in value-added tax (VAT) and household survey data for Poland. We find households increased their inflation expectations and willingness to purchase durables before the increase in VAT. Future research has to ensure income, wealth effects, or intratemporal substitution channels cannot explain these results and ideally exploit exogenous variation in VAT in a fixed nominal interest rate environment.
Article
We investigate whether US government spending multipliers are higher during periods of economic slack or when interest rates are near the zero lower bound. Using new quarterly historical US data covering multiple large wars and deep recessions, we estimate multipliers that are below unity irrespective of the amount of slack in the economy. These results are robust to two leading identification schemes, two different estimation methodologies, and many alternative specifications. In contrast, the results are more mixed for the zero lower bound state, with a few specifications implying multipliers as high as 1.5.
Article
After the Global Financial Crisis a controversial rush to fiscal austerity followed in many countries. Yet research on the effects of austerity on macroeconomic aggregates was and still is unsettled, mired by the difficulty of identifying multipliers from observational data. This paper reconciles seemingly disparate estimates of multipliers within a unified and state-contingent framework. We achieve identification of causal effects with new propensity-score based methods for time series data. Using this novel approach, we show that austerity is always a drag on growth, and especially so in depressed economies: a 1% of GDP fiscal consolidation translates into a loss of 3.5% of real GDP over five years when implemented in a slump, rather than just 1.8% in a boom. We illustrate our findings with a counterfactual evaluation of the impact of the UK government's shift to austerity policies in 2010 on subsequent growth.This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
Article
This paper studies whether fiscal corrections cause large output losses. We find that it matters crucially how the fiscal correction occurs. Adjustments based upon spending cuts are much less costly in terms of output losses than tax-based ones. Spending-based adjustments have been associated with mild and short-lived recessions, in many cases with no recession at all. Tax-based adjustments have been associated with prolonged and deep recessions. The difference cannot be explained by different monetary policies during the two types of adjustments. Studying the effects of multi-year fiscal plans rather than individual shifts in fiscal variables we make progress on question of anticipated versus unanticipated policy shifts: we find that the correlation between unanticipated and anticipated shifts in taxes and spending is heterogenous across countries, suggesting that the degree of persistence of fiscal corrections varies..Estimating the effects of fiscal lans, rather than individual fiscal shocks, we obtain much more precise estimates of tax and spending multipliers. Keywords: fiscal adjustment, output, confidence, investment JEL Classification: H60, E62
Article
Fiscal consolidations achieved by means of spending cuts are much less costly in terms of output losses than tax-based ones. The difference cannot be explained by accompanying policies, including monetary policy, and it is mainly due to the different response of business confidence and private investment. We obtain these results by studying the effects of the adoption of fiscal consolidation plans (rather than isolated shocks), that is combinations of tax increases and spending cuts, some unanticipated, other anticipated, in a sample of 16 OECD economies. Institutional subscribers to the NBER working paper series, and residents of developing countries may download this paper without additional charge at www.nber.org.
Article
This paper studies the short-run macroeconomic effects of legislated tax changes in Germany using a vector autoregression (VAR) approach. Identification of the tax shock follows the narrative approach recently proposed by Romer and Romer (2010). Results indicate a moderate, but statistically significant, reduction in output as well as a strong offsetting monetary policy reaction following announcement of the tax policy. In response to a 1 percent increase in the tax-to-GDP ratio, the peak output reduction is about 0.7 percent. Distinguishing between anticipation and implementation effects suggests that tax changes affect GDP prior to actual implementation, whereas effects around the implementation period are insignificant, which is arguably due to the offsetting, forward-looking monetary policy reaction.
Article
Standard vector autoregression (VAR) identification methods find that government spending raises consumption and real wages; the Ramey--Shapiro narrative approach finds the opposite. I show that a key difference in the approaches is the timing. Both professional forecasts and the narrative approach shocks Granger-cause the VAR shocks, implying that these shocks are missing the timing of the news. Motivated by the importance of measuring anticipations, I use a narrative method to construct richer government spending news variables from 1939 to 2008. The implied government spending multipliers range from 0.6 to 1.2. Copyright 2011, Oxford University Press.
Article
This paper investigates the impact of tax changes on economic activity. We use the narrative record, such as presidential speeches and Congressional reports, to identify the size, timing, and principal motivation for all major postwar tax policy actions. This analysis allows us to separate legislated changes into those taken for reasons related to prospective economic conditions and those taken for more exogenous reasons. The behavior of output following these more exogenous changes indicates that tax increases are highly contractionary. The effects are strongly significant, highly robust, and much larger than those obtained using broader measures of tax changes. (JEL E32, E62, H20, N12)
Article
We provide empirical evidence on the effects of tax liability changes in the United States. We make a distinction between "surprise" and "anticipated" tax shocks. Surprise tax cuts give rise to a large boom in the economy. Anticipated tax liability tax cuts are instead associated with a contraction in output, investment and hours worked prior to their implementation. After their implementation, anticipated tax liability cuts lead to an economic expansion. We build a DSGE model with changes in tax rates that may be anticipated or not, estimate key parameters using a simulation estimator and show that it can account for the main features of the data. We argue that tax shocks are empirically important for U.S. business cycles and that the Reagan tax cut, which was largely anticipated, was a main factor behind the early 1980’s recession.
Article
Although there is now widespread agreement in the economics profession that discretionary "counter-cyclical" fiscal policy has not contributed to economic stability and may have actually been destabilizing at particular times in the past, there is one important condition when discretionary fiscal policy can play a constructive role: In a sustained downturn when aggregate demand and interest rates are low and when prices are falling or may soon be falling.This short note begins by summarizing the general case against using fiscal policy for stabilization. It then considers the argument for using a "hyperexpansive" monetary policy to reduce the risk that a low rate of inflation will lead to a deflationary situation in which monetary policy becomes ineffective. Such a policy would increase the risk of asset price bubbles and of a misaligned exchange rate.Discretionary fiscal policy provides an alternative way to stimulate the economy when aggregate demand and interest rates are low and when prices are falling or may soon be falling. A stimulus can be achieved without increasing budget deficits if the fiscal policy acts by providing an incentive for increased private spending. Specific examples for the US and Japan are considered.
Article
This paper introduces methods to compute impulse responses without specification and estimation of the underlying multivariate dynamic system. The central idea consists in estimating local projections at each period of interest rather than extrapolating into increasingly distant horizons from a given model, as it is done with vector autoregressions (VAR). The advantages of local projections are numerous: (1) they can be estimated by simple regression techniques with standard regression packages; (2) they are more robust to misspecification; (3) joint or point-wise analytic inference is simple; and (4) they easily accommodate experimentation with highly nonlinear and flexible specifications that may be impractical in a multivariate context. Therefore, these methods are a natural alternative to estimating impulse responses from VARs. Monte Carlo evidence and an application to a simple, closed-economy, new-Keynesian model clarify these numerous advantages.
Article
We propose a nonparametric method for automatically selecting the number of autocovariances to use in computing a heteroskedasticity and autocorrelation consistent covariance matrix. For a given kernel for weighting the autocovariances, we prove that our procedure is asymptotically equivalent to one that is optimal under a mean-squared error loss function. Monte Carlo simulations suggest that our procedure performs tolerably well, although it does result in size distortions.
Article
Corruption in the public sector erodes tax compliance and leads to higher tax evasion. Moreover, corrupt public officials abuse their public power to extort bribes from the private agents. In both types of interaction with the public sector, the private agents are bound to face uncertainty with respect to their disposable incomes. To analyse effects of this uncertainty, a stochastic dynamic growth model with the public sector is examined. It is shown that deterministic excessive red tape and corruption deteriorate the growth potential through income redistribution and public sector inefficiencies. Most importantly, it is demonstrated that the increase in corruption via higher uncertainty exerts adverse effects on capital accumulation, thus leading to lower growth rates.
The macroeconomic effects of Legislated tax changes in Germany
  • Hayo
Are government spending multipliers greater during periods of slack? Evidence from twentieth-century historical data
  • Owyang