ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

This review explores how improvisation has been studied and approached in music education research in Finland. A mapping of visions of improvisation pedagogy (VIP) by Siljamäki and Kanellopoulos (2020) is employed as the frame for analysing how the phenomenon of improvisation has been approached in research articles published in FJME between 1985–2015 as well as latest doctoral research in Finland. The results brought about the manifoldness of improvisation approaches in the selected articles and the foci ranged widely, which is in line with international research literature. More research could be conducted on improvisation experiences amongst school aged children, as well as both collaborative and vocal improvisation. The VIP was found useful for exploring and understanding the manifoldness of the phenomenon of improvisation and viewing improvisation from the perspective of diversity instead of juxtaposing distinctive methods or ways of approaching improvisation. The VIP is suggested for deployment of pedagogues, practitioners and music educator students for understanding the diversity of approaches to improvisation and the conflictual potential of these approaches as well as the construction of visions for improvisation pedagogy in pedagogical moments. Furthermore, more research on developing improvisation pedagogy and taking into account the unique aspects of improvisation is suggested.


9I5,=@>5AR?=
$'(&, )* &%$&% % )++)
$+) "" "),*+")))3
"*)+)*+*" $+")%
2+'$172
#ADFCJ=G55H=CCB=@A=S>CB?5ACB=B5=G9HD985;C;=G9HA5<8C@@=GII89HJC=J5HH5F>CH5
B==BAIG==?=@@=GH5>5GCG=55@=GH5CDD=A=GH5?I=B<MJ=BJC=BH=5,=@>5AQ?=5,=@>5AQ?=
6,ICA9GG5=ADFCJ=G55H=CCBG=GQ@HMBMHAIG==??=?5GJ5HH5>=9B?CI@IHI?G99B>C
JIC89GH5@Q<H=9B-=??5B9B/Q?9JQ(M?M=G9GGQJ5@H5?IBB5@@=G9BCD9HIGGIIB
B=H9@A5BD9FIGH9=GG5)D9HIG<5@@=HIG=ADFCJ=G55H=C@@5CB?=BD9F=55HH99GG5G5A5D5=BC
5FJC?I=B@5I@5A=G9@@5GC=HH5A=G9@@5>5AIG==?=B?IIBH9@I@@5%I=H9B?=BJ=9@QJICBB5
M@Q?CI@IBCDD=@5=GH5(9=C@@IHCG5@@=GHIBIHAIG==?=@@=G99B?9?G=BHQQBAIG==?=B
HIBB9=@@5$IBHIB9B>5JICBB5J5=B?II89GCG5CD9HH5>=GH5GICA5@5=G9GG5D9FIG
?CI@IGG5G=GQ@@MHH==ADFCJ=G55H=CH5CD9HI?G99BG5*5FHH=#ADFCJ=G55H=C=@A=SBACB=
B5=GIIG>5GI<H99@@=G9BJQ<Q=B9BHIH?=HHIH=9HC9H9B?=BD985;C;=G9GH5BQ?S?I@A5GH5,=@>5AQ
?=6G9?QD=FGH5@C=HIA=B9BIG9=G==BH=9H99B5@C=<=B>5?CI@I?IBH==BCJ5HCG5GM=HQG==<9B
9HH9==ADFCJ=G55H=CC@9J=9@QJ5?==BHIBIHCG5?G=>C?5=G9BAIG==??=?5GJ5HH5>5BHMS?5@ID5??=5
J5=??5CD9HIGGIIBB=H9@A5G==<9BJ9@JC=HH5=G=)D9HIG<5@@=HIG-QAQB?5HG5I?G9BH5
JC=HH99B5CB@=GQHQMAAQFFMGHQ=ADFCJ=G55H=C=@A=SBACB=B5=GII89GH5J5GH5??5=B5G9HH9@IB
H5=M?G=@S@@=GH9BA9B9H9@A=9B9G=HH9@MBG=>55B>CHH5=ADFCJ=G55H=CB?C?CDCH9BH=55@=JC=H5=G==B
CHH55,ICA9GG5AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9B?QMHHSSB
#ADFCJ=GC=BH=CBGCG=55@=GH5HC=A=BH55F=7?GCB>5G9BJC=G5BC5C@9J5BCG5?5=
?9B@5=GH5@ICJ55HC=A=BH55>5H5=H99BH9?9A=GHQ#ADFCJ=GC=BH=J55H==GQJ9@HQA=G9GHQ9FC5J=5
H5=HC>5>5HC=A=BHC>59=?QG=HQJC=85=89BHH=G9GH=HC=GH55H5=5FJ=C=85G5AC=B?F=H99F9=B?I=B
GQJ9@@MGHQH5=GQJ9@HQA=GHQ?HGIFB5F8#ADFCJ=G55H=CCB<9H?9GGQGMBHMJQQ>5G==BQ
?9G?9=GHQCBDFCG9GG=J5FG=B5=G9B5FJ=C=H5J5BH5=9G=H9@HQJQB@CDDIHI@C?G9BG=>55BWH5=G9B
@=GQ?G=#ADFCJ=GC=BB=BA9F?=HMGHQAIG==?=BCDD=A=G9GG5>5CD9HH5A=G9GG5DIC@H5J5H@I?I=G5H
HIH?=AI?G9H>5=ADFCJ=G55H=CCB<9FQHHQBMH9B9B9JQGGQAQQF=B?==BBCGHIGH5B==B?5BG5=B
JQ@=G9GGQ?I=BGICA5@5=G9GG5HIH?=AIG?CBH9?GH=GG5G9BACB=B5=G9BH5F>CIA5BBQ?S?I@A5GH5
,=@>5AQ?=BC:=AA/#ADFCJ=G55H=CJC=HIH?=AIGH9BAI?55BH=9HM=GGQC@CGI<H9=GG5GMJ9BHQQ>C
CD=HHI5?9<=HHQQ@ICJIIHH5A5<8C@@=GH555G=C=89BHC=G=B?5HGCA=GH5>5?C?9A=GH5J5<J=GH55
=HG9HIBH9AIGH5>5HIBHC5J5D5IHH55HCHIHI=GH5?55JC=GH5>5BCFA9=GH5G9?Q<5F>C=HH55GCG=55
@=G=5H5=HC>588=GCBNN5F5IFB5F8<5DD9@@"5FF=GCB*CIB8
,=@>5AQ?=5,=@>5AQ?=60F=;<H%5B9@@CDCI@CG#ADFCJ=G55H=CB
CD9HH5A=G9B9GH9=HQCBHIH?=HHI>5HC89HHIJ5=?IHH5J=?G=H9?=>S=?G=9G=A9F?=?G=F9GIFGG=9BDIIH
H99BHICH9GIIBH5IHIB99BD5=BCHI?G9B>5@ICJII89BMAAQFFM?G9BG9?Q?C?9AI?G9BDIIH
H99BMC%CIHGCID=8CI/5GH5J5@A=GHIBIHJQ=HSGHIH?=AI?G9B=CGC=HH559HHQ
CBHQF?9QQH5F?5GH9@@5AMSGC@CGI<H9=H5>C=GG5AIG==?=@@=B9BCDD=A=B9B>5=ADFCJ=G55H=CB
ACB=B5=B9BH5F>CIA5JC=A5<8C@@=GHI5G9BG=>55B9HHQC@9H9HH5=G==BBQ=BH5D5<HIJ5B5IHC
A55HH=G9GH=,=@>5AQ?=BC:=AA/B9AAQB<ICA=CH5HI@=G=?==BB=HHQQAMSG<55GH9=G==B>C=H5
=ADFCJ=G55H=C5G9HH55?QG=HM?G=@@9CD9HH5A=G9GH5>5CDD=A=G9GH5-C=G=BG5BC9BCBHQF?9QQ
H5F?5GH9@@5=ADFCJ=G55H=CB5=BIH@55HI=GIIHH5>CHH5G9BH5F>C5A5H<MS8MHB==BAIG==?=@@=G9@@9
CDD=A=G9@@9?I=B=<A=G9?G=?5GJ5A=G9@@9>5GCG=55@=G9@@9?MJM??MM89@@9?HG,=@>5AQ?=6
HI@=G=J5H?5=?=@@9A5<8C@@=G=?G=
/BA/C9A3B


-QGGQ?5HG5I?G9GG5H5F?5GH9@9B=ADFCJ=G55H=CH5ACB=B5=GII89BBQ?S?I@A5GH5?QMHHQ9B
5=B9=GHCB5'IG==??=?5GJ5HIG@9<89GGQ>I@?5=GHI>5HIH?=AIG5FH=??9@9=H5JICG=B5W
B5@MMHH=G9BQ?9<M?G9BQ<MS8MBBQBM<H9=GHMSGGQDFC:9GGCF=%5B9@@CDCI@C?G9B?5BGG5,=@
>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG?9<=HHQAQQB==ADFCJ=G55H=CD985;C;==?5BGIIBH5I?G=5>5J=
G=C=H5<5J5=BBC@@=GH5J55?5FHC=HIGH5>CH5HQGHQ9H99BDQ=B?IHGIB@M<9BH99@@Q/#*/=G=CBGC: 
=ADFCJ=G5H=CBD985;C;M@C=H5B9G=HH9@9AQ@@Q/#*?5FHC=HI?G9B?QG=HH99@@=GHQH5IGH55>CB?5
>Q@?99B9G=HH9@9B5B5@MMG=BHI@C?G=5G9?Q<ICA=C=H5?5BG5=BJQ@=G9B>5?5BG5@@=G9BHIH?=AI?G9B
F5>5D=BB5@H5BB9B?I=B@CD9H5B5FH=??9@=BDC<H=A5@@5=ADFCJ=G55H=CBHI@9J5=GIIHH5GIC
A5@5=G9GG5AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9B?9BHQGGQ9G=HH9@9B@M<M9GH=J==A95=?5=G=5JQ=HSGHS=HQ>C=GG5
=ADFCJ=G55H=CCB?9G?9=G9GGQCG5GG5
03529,6$$7,2168817$8.6,$+$9$,112//,67$9$".$572,786
-QGGQ?5HG5I?G9GG55B5@MMHH=G9BQ?9<M?G9BQ?QMHQB,=@>5AQ9B>5%5B9@@CDCI@C?G9B
HIH?=AIG5FH=??9@=GG59G=H9@HMQ/#*?5FHC=HIGH5,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG>C?5?I
J5GH55=ADFCJ=G55H=CBACB=B5=GIIHH5/#*D9FIGHII?5BG5=BJQ@=GH9B$. )@IC?=H9@HI>9B
@9<H=9B?C@A9BJICG=?MAA9B9B5=?5B5>I@?5=G9A=9BHIH?=AIG5FH=??9@9=89B(5B5@MM
G==BWA=H9B=ADFCJ=G55H=CGH5AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9B5@5@@5CB?=F>C=H9HHIHIH?=HHI>5DI<IHHI
,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG/#*?5FH5@@5?HG%IJ5<5J5=BBC@@=GH5AA9G=GQ?9<Q@@Q
AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9B?=F>5@@=GII89GG59G==BHMB99H9F=@5=GH5GI<H5IHIA=G>5@Q<9GHMA=GH5D55
=ADFCJ=G55H=CCBG9?QBQ=89BDC<>5@H5BCIG9J5HBQ?MAQQ=ADFCJ=G55H=CD985;C;==?5@@9
?5FH5BI@?C?9<Q@@Q,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG
CD//")?5EGG5=ADECI=F55G=CCBFH<G5HGHA=F9FG5?5BF5=BIR@=F9FFRAHF==??=?5FI5GH?F9BGHG?=AHF?=E>5@@=FHH
89FF5,=@>5AR?=$5B9@@CDCH@CFFHCA3GRGR?5GF5HFG5I5EG9B4,=@>5AR?=
%IH9BM@@Q?IJ5GG5BQ?MM/#*?5FH5B?9G?9@@QCB?QG=HH99@@=G9GH==ADFCJ=G55H=CD985;C
;=B9B<9H?=>32/5=571/:;=;3<BJ5B'5B9B>CGG5D985;C;=CBJICFCJ5=?IHIGGI<H99GG5
CDD=>5B?5BGG5>5H9?99DQQHS?G=Q*985;C;=G9@@5<9H?9@@QD985;C;=BCA5@Q<9GHMA=GH5D5>5
GI<H5IHIA=B9B=ADFCJ=G55H=CCBJQ@=HHMMCDD=>5@@9G9?QH=9HC=G9GH=9HHQH=98CGH5A5HH5AI@H=
%3>=@BA


AC855@=G9GG5JICFCJ5=?IHI?G9GG5B==B=@A9=89B9@9=89BDI<99B>59HQ=GMM?G=9B?I=B@==??99B
>5AIG==?=BJQ@=HM?G9@@Q*985;C;=BCA5GIIBH5IHIA=B9B>5@Q<9GHMA=GH5D5=ADFCJ=G55H=CCB
AMSGJ5=<H9@99H5JC=HH9=89B>5M@@M??9=89BAI?55B<9H?=<9H?9@HQ9@=9F=@Q<9GHMA=GH5DC>5JC=
G=GQ@HMQG5A5B5=?5=G9GH=IG95AD=5,5A55B5=?55BB9AMSG@ICJ5H>5F5?9BH5J5HH=9HMB@5=G=5
J=G=C=H5>5BQ?MA=Q=ADFCJ=G55H=CBD985;C;==?5@@9,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CGW
,9@J=HHQQ?G9B=A=H9BGICA5@5=G9GG5AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9BHIH?=AI?G9GG5GI<H5I8IH55B>5
DI<IH55B=ADFCJ=G55H=CGH5J5@=HG=BHQ<QB?5HG5I?G99B5=B9=GHC?G='IG==??=?5GJ5HIG@9<89GGQ
JICG=9BWJQ@=@@Q>I@?5=GHIHJ9FH5=G5FJ=C=8IH5FH=??9@=H(>C=GG5=ADFCJ=G55H=C
=@A9B99B=A9??99GGQH==J=GH9@AQGGQH5=5FH=??9@=B9BG=AAQ=G9@@QG=JI@@5@?IGMGQMGHQ<QB
?5HG5I?G99BC@=BQ=89B5FH=??9@9=89B>QQA=B9B989@@Q9G=H9@@MB?=F>5@@=GIIG5B5@MMG=B,=@>5AQ
?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG5=B9=GHCBI@?CDIC@9@@9?CG?5M?G=?QQB'IG==??=?5GJ5HIG@9<89GGQ
>I@?5=GHI=GH55FH=??9@9=GH59=C@@IHG55JIHH5BIHM@=?MAA9BHQG=H99F5IGH5!CC;@9G7<C@5F
JICH99BA9BB9GGQ
03529,6$$7,21787.,08686,,..,.$69$786/(+'(66>B
%5HG5I?G99BJ5@=HHI>9BHIH?=AIG5FH=??9@9=89B5=<99HC@=J5HACB=DIC@=G=5>5?=F>C=HH5>5H98IG
H=J5HB==BAIG==??=H9F5D=5BAIG==??=DGM?C@C;=5B?I=BAIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9B5@55FH=??9@9=G
G5H5F?5GH9@H==BAIG==?=@@=GH5?9<=HHMA=GHQ*55B5B9BCD9HH5>5?G=CD=G?9@9J=9B?QG=HM?G=Q
=ADFCJ=G55H=CGH5>5G9BCD9HH5A=G9GH5$IBHIB9B+=?5B8=G9?Q=ADFCJ=G55H=CB
CD9HH5A=G9BAICHC>5"ICJ=B9B%IIG=B9B>CH?5CJ5HC@@99HAMSG?5BG5=BJQ@=G9B
HIH?=AI?G9B5=<9=89B9B9AA=GHSGGQ?HG,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG&=GQ?G=5FH=?
?9@9=GG59G=H9@H==B<=GHCF=5@@=G=5>5D985;C;=G=5H5IGHC>5A9B9H9@A=GHQ>C=GG5=ADFCJ=GC=BH=
CBC@9BB5=B9BCG5AIG==?=@@=GH5HC=A=BH55$IBHIB9B%5B??IB9BAIG==??=
?5GJ5HI?G9B>5AIG==??=H9F5D=5BF5>5D=BHC>5=ADFCJ=G55H=CBBQ?S?I@A5GH5F??=@Q
G9?QH9CF9H=GC=H==B@5GH9BAIG==?=@@=GH5QQB=@9=??=QAD5FHN5?=>5NNJ=I@ID985;C;==?5B
?5HG5I?G9B@=GQ?G=*CIH=5=B9B=<9=89B?5HH5IGC@=?@IGH9FC=HIBIHH5J5@@5>CGG5I@?C
DIC@9@@9>Q=H99AC>5>CH?5?5BG5=BJQ@=G9GGQHIH?=AI?G9GG5C@=HIBB=GH9HHI?IH9BA9F?=HMGH9B
>55FJC>9BH5=GCG=55@=GH9B5GD9?H=9B>5M<H9=GHC=A=BB5@@=G9B=ADFCJ=G55H=CBHIH?=A=B9B?HG
,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG/C=?I=H9B?=BG5BC59HHQD=9B99B@I?IAQQFQQBGI<
H9IH9HHIB55=<9=H5C@=@55>5GH=9F=@5=G=5
#ADFCJ=G55H=CBFCC@=5GICA5@5=G9BAIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9B<=GHCF=5GG5>5?QMH9HM=GGQA9B9
H9@A=GGQHC=J5H9G==B%5B??IG9B>5$IBHIG9BHIH?=AIG5FH=??9@=H%5B??IB9B
H5F?5GH9@99@@9B.F<CB>5&==G5-9B?IBII8=GHIGHMSHQGICA5@5=G9BAIG==??=?5G
J5HI?G9BD5F=GG5@IJI@@5>CGG5=ADFCJ=G55H=C>5QQB=@9=??=C@=J5H?9G?9=G9GGQCG5GG5
/5=?IHH9=H5C@=<59HHI?5BG5=BJQ@=G9GH=AIIBAI5GG5B;@5BB=GG5AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9GG5
BCIGG99GH5@ICA=G9B>5GQJ9@HQA=G9B55@@CGH5>C?5?I=H9B?=BCB>QQBMHGI<H99@@=G9BJQ<Q=G9?
G=A5<8C@@=G9GH=D985;C;=G9BMAAQFFM?G9B>5JQ@=B9=89BDIIHH99GH5>C<HI9B?HG,=@>5AQ?=
6$IBHIG9B5FH=??9@=9G=HH9@995@7FCN9A9B9H9@AQQ>CGG5=ADFCJ=G55H=CBQ<
8QQBCG5B5?9<C@@=GH5AIG=GC=BH=5YAIG==?=@@=G9BGICF=HI?G9BZD5F5BH5A=G9BJQ@=B99BQ9AH
'C@9AA=GG55FH=??9@9=GG5=ADFCJ=G55H=CBQMHHQMHMM:C=<<=::7A3</;CA7797<=>>7;7A3<8/B/7B=
83<9367BBI;7A3<DI:7<33<I&=GQ?G=$IBHIG9B5FH=??9@=GG5CB<5J5=HH5J=GG5=ADFCJ=G55H=CD/
>/CBC;7A3<8/D=7;//<BC;7A3<937<=</G9?QDI:7<33<IA=A7//:7A33<DC=@=D/79CBC9A33<8/7BA3<BCB97;7A33<
=BC5J5F<5=G?5GJ5HI?G9BD5F==BG=>C=HHIJ55FH=??9@=C@=AD5FHN5?=BH9CF99HH=B9B
H5F?5GH9@I@5GH9BJ5D55GH5AIG=GC=BB=GH5/M;CHG?MB@9=??=H9CF=5B?5IHH5"QB9<8CHH559HHQ
@5GH9B=ADFCJ=G55H=CH5D=HQ=G=5FJCGH55@5GH9BCA5B?I@HHIIF=BBQ?S?I@A5GH55=?I=G?9G?9=GH9B
5FJ=C=BH=A9B9H9@A=9BG=>55BAD5FHN5?=(==B$IBHIB9B?I=BAD5FHN5
?=?=BBCGH5J5H9G==B?9<C@@=GIIHH5>5@==?9HHQ:C=<<=::7A3</CG5B5@5GH9B=ADFCJ=G55H=CH5
,5AC=<=B5=?C=<=BIFB5F8CB?5BG5=BJQ@=G9GGQHIH?=AIG?CBH9?GH=GG59G=HHQBMHH9C
F99HH=G=5D9FIGH9@I>5?9<C@@=GII89B<ICA=C=A=G99B@5GH9B=ADFCJ=GC=BB=GG5
/BA/C9A3B


/5D55H5=ADFCJ=G55H=CH5H5F?5GH9@@55BG9?QF??=@QB9HHQ"ICJ=G9B>5%IIG=G9B
5FH=??9@9=GG5"ICJ=G9B>5%IIG=G9BJ9FH5=@9J5GG5HIH?=AI?G9GG5AIG==?=B5A
A5HH=CD=G?9@=>5HHIHIGHI=J5HJ5D55G99B=ADFCJ=G55H=CCB?5<89B9F=J==HH99@@=G9BJQ@=B99B
QQB=A5=G9A5BH5=G5B5@@=G9B?IJ5=@IB5JI@@5)G5@@=GHI>=9B<9B?=@S?C<H5=B9B?C?9AIG
DFCG9GG=GH5G9?Q5=9AD=9B?C?9AIGH9B>5?CI@IHI?G9BA9F?=HMGBQMHHQMHMMB==B=HG9?C9
H=@5BH99GG5?I=B=ADFCJ=G55H=CCBGI<H5IHIA=G9GG5A=?QHI?995=9AA=BHQGGQ5FH=??9@=GG5
9G=H9HHMQH9CF=55D985;C;=G9GH5<9H?9GHQ>CGG5B==BCDD=@5G?I=BCD9HH5>5HICJ5HCDD=A=G>5
CD9HIGH=@5BH99G99BCA5B<=GHCF=5BG5>5H5JC=HH99BG5AI?5B55BF??=@QB5FH=??9@=CB
DI<99BJICFCAIG==??=H9F5D=5BDIC@9@H5H5F>CH9BBQ?S?I@A=5AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G99B?IH9B
=HG9=@A5=GI@ICJII89BHCH9IHH5A=B9BG9?QJICFCJ5=?IHI?G9B5=?55BG55A=B9B>5H5F?5GH9@I
AIG==?=@@=G9B?CF?95H5GC=GII89BG=>55B9AHF??=@QD5=BCHH55AIG==?=BCD9HI?
G9B@55>9BH5A=GH55=9AD55Y?C?9AI?G9@@=G9AD55B>5@ICJ9AD55BGIIBH55BZ9AH
'C@9AA=GG55FH=??9@9=GG5=ADFCJ=G55H=CCBGI<H5I8IH55BJ5D55B=ADFCJ=G55H=CBH5D55B
/D=7;3</;C=B=</>5AC6B/CBC;7A3</II<33<FC5CB?I=H9B?=B<5J5=HH5J=GG5G==BQ9HHQ"ICJ=G9B
>5%IIG=G9BHI@C?I@A5CB;CA7797::7AB3<B/7B=83<9367BBI;7<3<?IBH55GF??=@QB
5FH=??9@=GG5D5=BCHHIJ5HG9?QD/>/CBC;7A3<D=7;//<BC;7A3<?I=BA=A7//:7A3<DC=@=D/79CBC9A3<B/7
7BA3<BCB97;7A3<HI@C?I@A5H/5=??5F??=@QB9AHDI<99BJICFCCBAIG==??=H9F5D9IHH=G9GH5
BQ?S?I@A5GH5?=F>C=H9HHIG9BJC=BQ<8QD5=BCHH5J5B?C?CB5=GJ5@H5=G9B?5GJIB>5CDD=A=G9B
A9F?=HMGHQAIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9BMH=A9GGQ
/5D55BGQ9GHM?G9BD985;C;==??5>CGG5=ADFCJ=G55H=CBQ<8QQBC@9BB5=G9B5CG5B5CB
?==BBCGH5BIHIG95AD55HIH?=>55$IBHIB9BH5F?5GH9@99AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9BCD=G?9@=
>C=89BCDD=A=GDQ=JQ?=F>C>5?IBH55G+=?5B8=CA55D985;C;=GH5HC=A=BH55BG5?F==H
H=G9BD985;C;==?5BBQ?S?I@A5GH5H5=H99BD9FIGCD9HI?G9GG5'C@9AA=GG55FH=??9@9=GG5/D=7<
AC6B/CBC;7<3<II<33<G9?QD/>/CBC;7<3<8/D=7;//<BC;7<3<BQMHHQMHM=JQH;CA7797::7A3<=>>7;7A3<
F=BB5@@5=ADFCJ=G55H=CCBGI<H5IHIA=G9GG5%IH9BM?G=<55GH5H9@@I=GH5CD=G?9@=>C=GH5HCH955
Y#ADFCB5JI@@5CDD=@5GG55HMS?5@I>5>5?9=BC>5=@A5=GH5=HG9QQBG9?QFC<?9IHH5>5J5FAIIHH5
HIC859G==BCA=5BQ?9AM?G=QQB>55>5HI?G=55B,CG=55@=G9HH5=8CH?=BG55J5HGMJMMHHQ=AD
FCJ=G55H=CGG5?CG?5G9CBM<89GGQHCH9IH9HHIB5M<HQD5@>CB?IIBH9@I5?I=BCA55GC=HHC5Z
$IBHIB9B'=9@9B?==BHC=GH5CBGCG=55@=GH9BH5=HC>9B?9<=HHMA=G9BBQ?S?I@A5>CH5
9=C@9J=9@QH5FD99?G=AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9BHIH?=AI?G9GG5>5AIG==?=BCDD=A=G9GG5BCGH9HHI
9G==B?HG,=@>5AQ?=6
*55B5G9B>5*CIH=5=G9B5FH=??9@9=GG5=ADFCJ=G55H=CH5@Q<9GHMHQQB;C=B==<
A7B=CBC<33</9@=H=9HHMMBAIG==?=BHMM@=GIIBB5BH5=HF58=H=CBGQQBHS=<=BG=HCIHIB99B5*CIH=
5=G9B?5HG5I?G9GG5DIF9I8IH55B>5NNJ=I@ID985;C;==?5BGCFA=HIGG?99AC=<=B>CB?5
JC=G5BC598IGH5J5BAMSGBGG:7:/877<A7B=CBC<CBB//A7/<BC<B78CCBB/-QAQHI@999G==BH5J5GH5?C
FCGH55AIG==??=HMM@==B?II@IJ=9B9@9A9BHH=9BJ55H=JIIHH5?IH9BHQGGQH5D5I?G9GG5696CD=B
D9F=BH99BACB=AIH?5=GH5A9@C8=5B<5FACB=5B>5FMHA==?5B?QG=HH9@MQ9AH*55B5G9B
J9FH5=@9J5DC=?=HH5=GHIH?=AIGG9BG=>55BH5F?5GH9@99@5GH9BFMHA=B?9<=HMGHQ?9<=HMGD
GM?C@C;=G9GH5BQ?S?I@A5GH5>CGG5<MS8MBB9HQQB=ADFCJ=G55H=CH9<HQJ=QM?G=@SGICF=HI?G9B5
F5>5HIGG5>5AICHCCBG=8CHIGG5?CBH9?GH=GG5>C?5CBC@@IHGICG=HI=B9AD==F=G9B5=B9=GHCB
AIC8CGH5A=G9BH9?B==??5AMSG?5BG5=BJQ@=G9GGQHIH?=AI?G9GG5,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG

$9$,172-$.$16$//,6(1-$.$16$,19>/,6(1787.,08.6(15$-$3,11$/7$
89@@Q9G=H9@HM>9BHI@CGH9BD9FIGH99@@5=ADFCJ=G55H=CBQMHHQMHMMACB=DIC@=G9B5GICA5@5=G9G
G5AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9BHIH?=AIG?9BHQGGQ1?G=?QQB5=B9=GHCCBJ5@=?C=8I=GH5'IG==??=?5G
J5HIG@9<89BHIH?=AIG5FH=??9@9=GH59=D5=BCHHIBIHD9@?QGHQQB?J5BH=H5H==J=G==BA9B9H9@A==B
-QAQ9FC55GIIF9GH=?5BG5=BJQ@=G9GHQHIH?=AIG?9BHQGHQ>CGG5?J5BH=H5H==J=G9HA9B9H9@AQH
CJ5HG9@?9QGH=9B=H9B?QMH9HHMA9B9H9@AQ9AD==F=G=GGQHIH?=AI?G=GG5,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@C
%3>=@BA


DCI@CG-C=G55@H59AD==F=G=QHIH?=AIG5=B9=GHC5C@=@Q<9GGG5?5BG5=BJQ@=G9B
?=F>5@@=GIIG?5HG5I?G9BHIH?=AIG5FH=??9@9=GH5,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG?IBH55G
'IG==??=?5GJ5HIG@9<89GGQ>I@?5=GHI>9BHIH?=AIG5FH=??9@=9BG9@?9Q9B9AA=GHS?9G?=HHM=H9C
ZMM\\Q[MMVS]^IQTM^IIVPQ[\WZQITTQ[MMVRI\IQÅTW[WÅ[MMV\IZSI[\MT]]V<]\SQU]S[M\RWQ[[I
9AD==F=GHQA5H9F=55@=5?9FQHH==BC@=J5H>C?C5@5?CI@I@5=GH9B*55B5B9BH5=AIG==??=5
5AA5H=?G99BCD=G?9@9J=9B"ICJ=B9B%IIG=B9B$IBHIB9BD5F=GG5-QAQ
CG5@@=GHI>=9B=?Q>5?5IA5J5GH55?5BG5=BJQ@=GHQHIH?=AIGH5>CGG5?CF?95?CI@IHI?G9BD5F=GG5
H9<HMHIH?=AIGCBC@@IH9B9AA=GHSGGQ?HG,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG?IBH55G
=ADFCJ=G55H=CCB@==HHMJQQHIH?=AIGH5CBM@Q5GH9=?Q=GH9BD5F=GG5H9<HM9F=HHQ=BJQ<QBB==B
?5BG5=BJQ@=G9GH=9AH?I=B?5BG5@@=G9GH=%5BG5=BJQ@=G9BHIH?=AI?G9B@=B>55J5GH55AMSG
=BGHFIA9BH55@=G9B>5M?G=@S@@=G9BGICF=HI?G9BJ5<J598IGHIG@5I@5A=G9BCA5BQQB9B?QMHSB
H5=M<H9=GS@@=G9BAIG=GC=BB=BG=>55B?HG,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG
#ADFCJ=GC=8IBAIG==?=BHMM@=@5>=GG5C@=J==HH9=HQDCDI@55F=AIG==?=B<5@@=HG9JII89GH5A=B
?QJC=BQ<8Q?5BG5@@=G9GG5?CBH9?GH=GG5AIG==?=BCD9HI?G9@@9HMMD=@@=G9BQD==FH99BQ/Q?9JQ
,9BG=>55B?5BG5=BJQ@=G9GGQ?CBH9?GH=GG5G9@?9QGH=6@I9G>5>5NNCJ5HC@@99H98IGH9HHI=B5
?C@A5GCG5GG5HIH?=AI?G=GH5,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG%5BG5=BJQ@=G9GGQHIH
?=AIG?9BHQGGQC@=?I=H9B?=B<5J5=HH5J=GG5G9@?9QJ=BCIA5G=@@QDIC@9H9AD==F=GHQ5=B9=GHC5
G=GQ@HQJ=GHQHIH?=AI?G=GH5C@=HCH9IH9HHI.,GG5,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG
'=9@9B?==BHC=GH5C@=<ICA5H59HHQHIH?=>C=H5,ICA9B?CBH9?GH=GG59=C@9B==B?QQB
?==BBCGH5BIH=ADFCJ=G55H=C=A/</BC=B3ACC<B/CBC<CBB/:C=D//>@=A3AA7/?IH9BGQJ9@HQA=GHQ>5
5=BC5GH55BM<89GGQ5FH=??9@=GG5*CIH=5=B9BBCIG=9G==BBGG:7ACC<B/CBC<CB/A7/<BC<B78CCA
%5BG5=BJQ@=G9GGQHIH?=AI?G9GG5BQAQ?5?G=GI<H5IHIA=GH5=ADFCJ=G55H=CCBCJ5HC@@99H98IG
H9HHI=B5BC=BJ==89GCG5GG5HIH?=AIG5FH=??9@9=GH5,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG,9B
G=>55B=ADFCJ=G55H=CH5@Q<9GHMHH==B/D=7;3</;C=B=</?5<89GG55FH=??9@=GG5M<89?GQGHQ
-QAQ9FC55?5BG5=BJQ@=G9GHQHIH?=AIG?9BHQGHQ>CGG5;C=B==<A72=BBC@Q<9GHMA=GH5D5=ADFCJ=
GC=BH==BC@=<5@@=HG9J5?IBH55GJ5D55G99B>5/D=7;33<;C=B==<D9FIGHIJ55@Q<9GHMA=G
H5D559G==BHM=JQ<=H9B,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG
">,7?6787.,0867$820(66$
-QHQ?5HG5IGH5J5FH9BH5F?5GH9@=BAMSGHC<HCF=BJQ=HSGHIH?=AI?G=5J==A9=G9BJIC89B5=?5
B5AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9B5@5@@5/==A95=?5=G=BCB,IH9@5BJQ=HSG?=F>5)I@IBM@=CD=GHCG
H5>CGG5<QB@558I@@=G9BHIH?=AI?G9BA9B9H9@A=BCGC=HH559HHQ9F=HM=GHI?95H5FJ=HG9J=9BCDD=
@5=89BHC=A=>IIHH5>5CG5@@=GIIHH5JC=855BHI?955@7FCN9A9B9H9@AQBGDCBH55B=IHH5J5D55
H5=@A5=GI5>5?9?G=A=GHQJ55H=J=@@5<5F>C=HH9=@@5,IH9@5%IBJQ=HSG?=F>55B?II@IJ5H
9F=@@=G9H5FH=??9@=HCH9H55B<ICA=CCB,IH9@5BHIH?=AI?G9BJC=G5BC598IGH5J5BG9?Q/D=7<B/
9HHQ;C=B==<A72=BBC/GI<H5IHIA=GH5=ADFCJ=G55H=CCB>CGG5=>>7;7A3<8/:C=<<=::7A3<;CA7797::7A3<
9367BBG;7A3<@=GQ?G=D=7;//<BC;7<3<A=A7//:7<3<DC=@=D/79CBCA>57BA3<BCB97;7<3<CJ5H?9G?9=G9GGQCG5G
G5,IH9@5BHIH?=AIGHIC9G==B?C?CB5=GJ5@H5=G9B=@A5=GIB=<A=G?QG=HM?G9BG9?Q?5GJIB
A9F?=HMGHQCG5B5AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9BH9CF9H=GC=BH=5G9?Q@=GQ?G=?QMHQBHSQ>CGG5?IIBH9@I
=ADFCJ=G55H=C>5JICFCJ5=?IHIGCJ5H?9G?9=G9GGQCG5GG5,9?QF??=@QB5FH=??9@=9HHQ
,IH9@5BJQ=HSGHMSBCGH5J5H9G==B=B<=A=@@=GHQ?5GJI5>5?9<=HHMA=GHQCG5B5AIG==??=?5GJ5HIGH5
9B989?$MJQG?M@QBM@=CD=GHCGH5HIH?=JQ=HSGHMSGGQQB=ADFCJ=G55H=CH5D985;C;=
G9B5JQ@=B99BQ>5NN=5>565FC??=5M<8=GHQJQGGQAIG==?=B<5FACB=5B>5H9CF=5BCD9HI?G9GG5
M@=CD=GHCCD=G?9@=>C=@@99B989?=BHIH?=AIGH5F>C55BQ?S5@55;C=B==<G9?QBGG:7:/877<A72=BCAB/
/A7/<BC<B78/93A937A3ABIGI<H5IHIA=G9GH5=ADFCJ=G55H=CCB=>>7;7A3<8/;CA7797::7A3<9367BBG;7A3<
DI:7<33<I>CGG5CDD=A=GH5>5=ADFCJ=G55H=CH5=HC5H9GH5HH==B?J5BH=H5H==J=G=BA9B9H9@A=B-IH
?=AIGCGC=HH==ADFCJ=G55H=CBHI?9J5BCDD=A=GH5DCG=H==J=G9GH=AIHH5AMSGCDD=A=GDFCG9GG=B
F==DDIJII89B5=9AA5GH5CG55A=G9GH5>5H5=8C=GH5?IB?MG99GGQCBHMM@=@5>==BG=8CHHIG=GQ@HS
+=?5B8=BJQ=HSGHIH?=AIG-5=89M@=CD=GHCB,=69@=IG?5H9A=5GG5J5D55BGQ9GHM?G9B
/BA/C9A3B


D985;C;==?5GH5G=GQ@HQQB==B;C=B==<A72=BBC/?I=B/D=7<B/AC6B/CBC;7AB/;C=B==<8/II<33<;CA7797:
:7A3<=>>7;7A3<8/9367BBG;7A3<DI:7<33<I+=?5B8=?I=H9B?=BHIC9G==BJ5D55H5GQ9GHMGHQ5=B99B5
>CGG5?9G?=SGGQCBCDD=@55BHC=A=>II89BD=7;//<BC;7<3<8/D/>/CBC;7<3<AIG==?=@@=G9BHC=A=B
B5B=ADFCJ=G55H=CB>5?CFJ5?II@C@@5GC=HH5A=G9B?5IHH59AHW@5BH99B
AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9B5=B9FM<AQGGQJ5@A=GHIB99BAIHH5AIG==??=H9F5D=5B5@55B?9G?=HHMJQ
JQ=HSGHIH?=AIGCGC=HH55AIG==??=DGM?CH9F5D=5BA9B9H9@A=9BJC=J5BHI?95DCH=@5=H5>CH?5
CJ5HG9@J=MHMB99H?=8IHI?G9GH5>5G==<9B@==HHMJ=GHQHF5IA55HH=G=GH5?C?9AI?G=GH5"QB9BHIH
?=AI?G9GG55B=ADFCJ=G55H=CCBAIIHC?G9B>5?CAAIB=?55H=CBJQ@=B9H9F5D9IHH=G9GG5H=@5B
H99GG5>C@@C=BG=HQ@Q<9GHMHQQBB==BD=7;//<BC;7A3<?I=B7BA3<BCB97;7A3<JQ@=B99BQIG9=B/D=7;3::/
AC6B/CBC;7A3::/II<33<>5;C=B==<AIHH5AMSG;C=B==<A72=BBC</
#ADFCJ=G55H=CH5CB,ICA9GG5HIH?=HHIAIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9BHC<HCF=B?CI@IHI?G9GG5J=9@Q
GI<H99@@=G9BJQ<QB%IBH5F?5GH9@I5@55>9BB9H55BAI=<=B5=B9FM<A==BG9?QH5=H99@@=G==B>5
GCJ9@H5J==BHC<HCF=BHIH?=AI?G==B>C=H5JC=H9<8Q-5=89M@=CD=GHCGG5@SMHMMIG9=H5HIH?=AI?G=5
>C=GG5=ADFCJ=G55H=CCB>CD59F=HHQ=B?9G?9=B9B9@9A9BHH=G=A9F?=?G="=FJCG9B>5,MF
>Q@QBH5=H99@@=G9HHC<HCF=BHIH?=BBCH?5BG5BAIG==?=B5=B9FM<AQGHQH5F?5GH9@9J5H=ADFC
J=G55H=CH5?5BG5BAIIG=?CBHMSJQ@=B99BQGQJ9@HQA=G9GGQ"=FJCB9B,MF>Q@QHC=G=B
G5BC9B=A/</BC=B3ACC<B/CBC<CBB/:C=D//>@=A3AA7/-5=H9=@=>5?CI@IHI?G9GH5J5@A=GHIB99B)?G5@5B
H5=H99@@=G9BHC<HCF=BHIH?=BBCB?=F>5@@=G9GG5CG=CGG5=ADFCJ=G55H=CCBA9F?=HM?G9@@=G9GGQ
CG5GG5>5BQMHHQMHMM5G9BBC=HIA=G9BH5D5B5>5:C=<<=::7A3</CG5B5AIIG=??CIHH5M@9=GSHMSG
?9BH9@MGGQ'IG==??=H9?BC@C;=5B5=B9FM<AQGGQ)@5FH9?9<=HH=GCJ9@H5J5GG5HC<HCF=B
HIH?=AI?G9GG59@9?HFC5?IGH=G9BAIG==?=B9G=HHQA=G9B>5=ADFCJ=GC=BB=BD985;C;=G=5JQ@=B9=HQ
"QB9B?==BBCGHI?G9B?C<H99BG5CBQQB==ADFCJ=G55H=CGG5GCB=7=ADFCJ=G5H=CB>CB?5<QB
AQQF=HH9@99AIG==??==ADFCJ=G55H=CB5@5@5>=?G=H5=M<89?G=HMM@=GIIBB5?G=AI=89B>CI?CGG5
)@5FH9BAI?55BQQB==ADFCJ=G55H=C@@9HIBBIGCA5=GH5CB@55>9BB9HHI=BGHFIA9BHH=H9?B==??5
9LH9B898=BGHFIA9BH5@H97<B=EI9G9DQH5J5@@=GH9B=BGHFIA9BHH=9B<MS8MBHQA=B9BACB=
AIH?5=G9HGD9H?F=AQ=G9HGC=BB=HG9?QFMHA==?5BDIIHHIA=B9B9AH)@5FH9BHIH?=AI?G9B
JC=G5BC598IGH5J5B=ADFCJ=G55H=CGG5/D=7<B/AC6B/CBC;7AB/II<33<8/;C=B==<
2+',17$,03529,6$$7,21021,1$,688'(1-$$,187/$$78,688'(10(5.,7<6
-QAQB?5HG5I?G9BD9FIGH99@@5JC=855BG5BC59HHQCBH5FJ9HH5@=GQHQ9H9B?=B9AD==F=GHQHIH
?=AIGH5?CI@I=?Q=GH9BCDD=@5=89B>5CD9HH5>=9B?C?9AI?G=GH5G9?Q@5I@IQQB9B9HHQM<H9=GHC=
A=BB5@@=G9B=ADFCJ=G55H=CBD5F=GG5#ADFCJ=G55H=CBGIIBH5I?G=9B/#*?5FHC=HIGC@=HC=A=J5
JQ@=B9AIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9B5@5BHIH?=AI?G9BH5F?5GH9@IIB=ADFCJ=G55H=CBACB=B5=GIIHH5
G=@AQ@@QD=HQ9B%5HG5I?G9GG5BCIG=9G==B?9BHQB@55>IIG>5ACB=DIC@=GIIGG9?Q=ADFCJ=
G55H=CBACB=I@CHH9=GIIGACB=H=9H9=GMMG>5@55>55@5=GIIGA=?QCBM<H9B9JQ?5BG5=BJQ@=G9B
HIH?=AI?G9B?5BGG5,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CG-QAQ?CFCGH55H5FJ9HH5<ICA=C=85
=ADFCJ=G55H=CB>5G9BH5F>CIA5BACB=B5=GIIGAMSGAIG==??=?5GJ5HI?G9B?QMHQBHS>9B?9
<=HHQA=G9GGQ/#*?5FHC=HIGH5JC=<MS8MBHQQAMSG?QMHQBBS@@=G9BQJQ@=B99BQ<5J5=BBC@@=G
H5A55BA=H9B=ADFCJ=G55H=CCB>5=ADFCJ=GC=BH==BGI<H5IHIA=B9BJC=J5HC@@5?9G?=BQ=G9GH=
F=GH=F==85GG5WA=H9BCD9HH5>5B>5CDD=>5BH5=FM<AQB>QG9BH9B9F=@5=G9H>5M?G=@S@@=G9H@Q<9G
HMA=GH5J5H=ADFCJ=G55H=CCBJC=J5HM<H9=G9B=ADFCJ=G55H=CB<9H?9@@Q?C<85H9GG55BGMBBMHHQQ
SWVÆQS\MRIRI\IQU]WLW[\II]][QIUMZSQ\aS[QqRI]]\\IaUUqZZa[\qS\[;QTRIUqSQ3I
B9@@CDCI@CGW&Q<9GHMA=GH5DC>9BG5A5BGIIBH5=GIIGH5=9F=@5=GIIGG9?QJ5<JIIG
H5=<9=??CIGJC=J5HJ5=?IHH55AMSGG==<9BA=H9BD985;C;=B9BH=@5BB99H9B99H5=A=H9B
D985;C;=CA55HI@C?I@A55BG5GQQH9@99GI<H99GG5CDD=>55B>5<QB9BHI@C?I@A55BG5(Q=B
C@@9B/#*?5FHC=HIGJC=G=HC=A=5HI?9B5AIG==?=BCD9HH5>5B?CI@IHI?G9BH5=D985;C;=BCA5B
CD9HI?G9B>5=ADFCJ=G55H=CB@Q<9GHMA=GH5J5BH5F?5GH9@IGG5=ADFCJ=G55H=CBD985;C;==?5B>5
ACB=B5=GII89BBQ?S?I@A5GH5WCB?CH5FJ9HH5@=GQHQA5<8C@@=GII?G=5HIHIGHI59F=@5=G==B=AD
FCJ=GC=BB=BAICHC=<=B?9<=HHMQ=ADFCJ=GC=>5B5H5=MAAQFHQQGMJ9AA=BB==BH9CF99HH=G9GH=
%3>=@BA


?I=B?QMHQBBSGGQA=H9B=ADFCJ=GC=BH=A5<8C@@=GHIIG=H9B9HHQG9JC=H5F>CH5B==B?C?CB5=G
J5@H5=GH5AIG==?=@@=GH5CDD=A=GH5?I=B<MJ=BJC=BH=5G9?QCD9HH5>=@@99HHQCDD=J=@@9
=9AA5BHIH?=AI?G9B$IBHIB9B*5FHH=>5HQAQB?5HG5I?G9BJ5@CGG5CB
H5FJ9@=GQHQMAAQFFMGHQ=ADFCJ=G55H=CGH5G9?Q=ADFCJ=G55H=CD985;C;==?5GH5#ADFCJ=G55H=CB
A9F?=HMGAIG==?=@@=G9@@9>5GCG=55@=G9@@9CDD=A=G9@@9CBHIH?=HIGH=HC89HHI,=@>5AQ?=5
6>5=ADFCJ=G55H=CGH5CBHI@@IH?9G?9=B9BAICHCB==89BCA=B5=GD==FH9=89B9G==BCH
H5A=G99B?CFCGH5A=G99B>5?9<=HHQA=G99B>CH?5CJ5H9@=BHQF?9=HQAIG==?=@@9>5G9BFCC@=@@9
=<A=G9@QAQGGQ,=@>5AQ?=%5B9@@CDCI@CGW(Q=BC@@9BCB?F==HH=B9BH5FJ9
@=GQHQMAAQFFMGHQ=ADFCJ=G55H=CD985;C;==?5GH5>C?5CHH55<ICA=CCB=ADFCJ=G55H=CCB
@==HHMJQH5=BIH@55HI=G9HCA=B5=GD==FH99H?IH9BACB=I@CHH9=GII89B9DQJ5FAII89B>59DQAI
?5JII89BG=9HQA=G9B,=@>5AQ?=5G9?QHIFJ5@@=GH9BC@CGI<H9=89BF5?9BH5A=G9B>5GC
G=55@=G9BJICFCJ5=?IHI?G9B>CH?5CJ5H?9G?9=G9GGQCG5GG5=ADFCJ=G55H=CB?5IHH5CDD=A=G9GG5
>5=ADFCJ=GC=BB=GG5,=@>5AQ?=6-QAQCB@=B>5GG5AMSGBM?M=G9BCD9HIGGIIBB=H9@A5B
?5BGG5>C?5D5=BCHH55=<A=GH9BJQ@=GHQ?5BGG5?QMA=GHQ>5?5GJI5YM<89GGQH9?9A=G99B>5>5
?5A=G99B?9G?=BQ=G99BMAAQFFM?G99B>5?I@HHIIF=G99BCG5@@=GIIH99BZ?IH9B*5FHH=>5<C@5
CJ5HH==J=GHQB99H1<89GGQ=ADFCJ=GC=A=B9B>C?5JC=H=9HM=GGQC@CGI<H9=GG5HI?95
G9?QM<H9=GHC=A=BB5@@=G9BCDD=A=G9B9HHQGCG=55@=G9BJICFCJ5=?IHI?G9BH5=HC>5?HG,=@>5AQ?=
6JC=G=BQ=BC@@9BHI@9J5=GII89GG5C@@5HQF?9QHMS?5@IB==BHI@9J=9BAIG==?=BCD9HH5>=9B
?CI@IHI?G9GG5>5HMSGGQ?I=BCDD=A=G9BH5=HC>9B>5GCG=55@=G9BH5=H5JII89B?9<=HHQ>QBQ
-QAQB?5HG5I?G9B@CDDIIBG55HH5A=G9BCBA5<8C@@=GH5BIH,ICA9B?5H9A=5B
,HF5H9;=G9B(9IJCGHCB-5G55FJC=B9BM<H9=G?IBH5C<>9@A5BF5<C=HH5A5>5
-5=89M@=CD=GHCB?CCF8=BC=A5FHGEI5@HIH?=AIG<5B?9FH5G*I6@=7,9FJ=79
;\ZI\MOQK;\MX[\W_IZL[-Y]ITQ\a___IZ\[MY]ITÅ!!!RI
",,77((7
-."ADECI=F55G=CCBI==G5G55BAHF==??=?5FI5GH?F9FF5HF9=89B?RF=GG9=89B?5HGG5?HG9BFRI9@GRA=B9B@HCI5
AHF=FC=BG=@HCI5GHCGG5A=B9BFDCBG55B=@5H@5A=B9BAHF==?=@@=B9B?9?F=A=B9B>5FDCBG55B=AHF==?=@@=B9B
?RKGGRKGKA=B9B-RARB?5GF5H?F9BCF5@G5G9=BG=9GC=F9BDRRGX?F9BE5>5G5<5?HGH@CFF5B5@@5=ADECI=F>CG5?RK
G9GG==BAKXF,=@>5AR9B>5$5B9@@CDCH@C?F9B?=E>5@@=FHHF5B5@KKF=FFR
-.=B9=FGCBI5@=BG5?E=G99E=G>5F=G99E5HFA9B9G9@ARB?RKGGXCBD9EHFG9@GH>5?HI5=@GHG5E?9AA=BGHG?=AHF5EG=?
?9@=FF5,=@>5AR?=>5$5B9@@CDCH@CF
>+7((7
227A=<%$QHZORRNDWPXVLFDOLPSURYLVDWLRQLQHGXFDWLRQ%ULWLVK-RXUQDORI0XVLF(GXFDWLRQ
Ŋ
:/<<3&0XVLF3V\FKRWKHUDS\ZLWK5HIXJHH6XUYLYRUVRI7RUWXUH,QWHUSUHWDWLRQVRI7KUHH&OLQLFDO&DVH
,GH8=9F,GH8=5&HF=75!9@F=B?=,=69@=HF7589AK
;>/@BH/97 7KH9\JRWVNLDQ'HƓQLWLRQRI0XVLFDO3OD\$&ROOHFWLYHDQG&RPSUHKHQVLYH
"BG9EDE9G5G=CBC:2CHB;<=@8E9B]F&HF=7&5?=B;&HF==??=?5FI5GHFZ
HH/@/$XGLDWLRQEDVHGLPSURYLVDWLRQWHFKQLTXHVDQGHOHPHQWDU\LQVWUXPHQWDOVWXGHQWVōPXVLF
57<=9I9A9BG#CHEB5@C:+9F95E7<=B&HF=78H75G=CBZ
/BA/C9A3B


3<3239 -<9+C@9C:)=5BC"ADECI=F5G=CB=B-957<=B;!5EACBK.F=B;CA6=B98&5G9E=5@F
6HOHFWHGIURPWKH%DURTXH3HULRGDQG-D]]6WDQGDUG5HSHUWRLUH7RZDUGVD&RPSUHKHQVLYH$SSURDFK
#KIRF?K@R.B=I9EF=GKC:#KIRF?K@R
C@</@2#C8=@K=BG9BG=CB=B7<=@8E9B]F=ADECI=F5G=CB5B87CADCF=G=CB)FK7<C@C;KC:&HF=7
Z
C@</@2#([DPLQLQJH[SHULHQWLDOGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQLPSURYLVDWLRQDQGFRPSRVLWLRQLQFKLOGUHQōV
AHF=7A5?=B;E=G=F<#CHEB5@C:&HF=78H75G=CBZ
G=&@5FFECCA-957<9EF]5B8&HF=7,D97=5@=FGF])9E79=I986=@=GKGC"AD@9A9BGG<9'5G=CB5@
,G5B85E8F:CE&HF=78H75G=CB#CHEB5@C:+9F95E7<=B&HF=78H75G=CB
6/>>3::&'HYHORSLQJWKHFRPSOHWHSLDQLVW$VWXG\RIWKHLPSRUWDQFHRIDZKROHEUDLQ$SSURDFKWR
SLDQRWHDFKLQJ%ULWLVK-RXUQDORI0XVLF(GXFDWLRQŊ
@719A=<-5?=B;58I5BG5;9C:FGEH7GHE9GC=ADECI=F9=B=BFGEH7G=CB9J5AD@9F:ECA9@9A9BG5EKF7<CC@
FODVVURRPV,Q5.6DZ\HU(G6WUXFWXUHDQG,PSURYLVDWLRQLQ&UHDWLYH7HDFKLQJ&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
Z
@997:L&HF==??=?5FI5GH?F9B>5AHF==??=G9E5D=5BK<G9=F=RE5>5D=BGC>5&HF==??=?5FI5GHFZ
/@@7A=<#=C<27DONLQJPXVLF(PSRZHULQJFKLOGUHQDVPXVLFDOFRPPXQLFDWRUV%ULWLVK
#CHEB5@C:&HF=78H75G=CBZ
7@D=<3<#,CC@CFC=GCBA5<G=Z%5H@5I5I=H@=FG=BK?K?5BF5BAHF==?=BFRI9@GR>RBR>59F=GGR>RBR,=69@=HF
?5G9A=5B?5BF5BAHF==??=>H@?5=FH>5!9@F=B?=-5=89K@=CD=FGCB,=69@=HF?5G9A=5
C=D7<3<CCA7<3<)#0XVLLNNLNDVYDWXVŊŊ
C<BC<3< 'DOFUR]HU\WPLLNNDMDPXXVLNNRXV0XVLLNNLNDVYDWXVŊ
C<BC<3< 3LDQRQYDSDDQV¦HVW\NVHQSHGDJRJLLNNDŊPXVLLNNLNDVYDWXNVHQRSLVNHOLMDW
UHŴHNWRLPDVVDNRNHPXNVLDDQ0XVLLNNLNDVYDWXVŊŊ
C<BC<3< &HF==??=3&HF=74-9C?F9FF5,%5=G=B9B!=@AC@5&%#HBGHB9BGC=A
)9EHFCD9GH?F9BAHF==?=B?HI5G5=G99B>5?RF=GKXBCDD=A=FGH@CFG9B5EI=C=BG=IHCF=@HC?5@@5$CH@HGH?F9B
VHXUDQWDUDSRUWLW2SHWXVKDOOLWXVŊ
/<99C<3<"'/=<E9R/=F9EEKF?CB9ZHHF=RRB=@HIHBFHCA5@5=F9FF5AHF==??=?5FI5GH?F9FF5
0XVLLNNLNDVYDWXVŊ
=CBA=C>72=C'"ADECI=F5G=CB=BG<9B;@=F<DE=A5EKAHF=77@5FFECCA-957<9EF]D9E79DG=CBF5B8
SUDFWLFHV0XVLF(GXFDWLRQ5HVHDUFKŊ
"9A/:/$C<G55A=FD=FG99FFRZ$C<G=HH89B@5=FG59F==BGK>KKGGR,->H@?5=FHF5E>5!9@F=B?=
-5=89K@=CD=FGCB,=69@=HF?5G9A=5
":/@B3@9A9BGFC:9@97GEC57CHFG=7AHF=7=ADECI=F5G=CB5B8D9E:CEA5B79)985;C;=75@GCC@?=G
,GH8=5&HF=75!9@F=B?=-5=89K@=CD=FGCB,=69@=HF?5G9A=5
%3>=@BA


">3BCA6/::7BCA"#)9EHFCD9GH?F9BCD9GHFFHHBB=G9@A5BD9EHFG99GKWWSVZZZRSKƓVLWHV
GHIDXOWƓOHVGRFXPHQWVSHUXVRSHWXNVHQBRSHWXVVXXQQLWHOPDQBSHUXVWHHWBSGIYLLWDWWX
#//</<3<#,PSURYLVDDWLRWHKW¦Y¦W0,',\PS¦ULVW¸VV¦ŊYXRWLDLGHQODVWHQU\WPLQNHKLW\NVHQ
WXWNLPXNVHVVD0XVLLNNLNDVYDWXVŊ
#/@BB70XXWWXYDPXXVLNNRXVNRXOXQPXVLLNLQRSHWXNVHVVD0XVLLNNLNDVYDWXVŊ
#/@BB76=:/6¦YHOW¦M\\GHQM¦OMLOO¦ŊPXVLLNLQWHNLM¦WWXOHYDLVXXGHQNRXOXVVD+HOVLQNL8QLJUDƓD
(K2@=CD=FGCD5=BC
#=CB7/7<3<7RZDUGVHFOHFWLFLVPLQMD]]YLROLQHGXFDWLRQ%DFNJURXQGVWXG\RQƓQJHULQJVFKHPHV
DSSURDFK0XVLLNNLNDVYDWXVŊŊ
%79/<27,9HE55>C<G5>55I5=2<89FFRA9G5=I5@@5AA9$E==GG=F9BD985;C;==?5BBR?X?H@A5CD9GG5>5
CDD=@5FFH<G99F99BFC=GCBCD9GH?F9FF5&HF==??=?5FI5GHFZZ
%79/<27'9;CG=5G=B;&HF=75@5B8)985;C;=75@;9B7K=B5%95EB=B;CAAHB=GKZ575F9
C:E989F=;B=B;5;ECHDD=5BC^I5D55FR9FGKF_7CHEF9=BAHF=7G957<9E98H75G=CB3'9HICGG9@H
AHF==?=@@=FD985;C;=F9FG5GC=A=>HH89FG5CDD=A=FK<G9=FXFFRZ-5D5HFGHG?=AHFI5D55BFR9FGK?F9B
EK<ARCD9GH?F9FG5AHF==??=?5FI5GG5>=9B?CH@HGH?F9FF54,GH8=5&HF=75!9@F=B?=,=69@=HF?5G9A=5
&7:8/;L975 E99=ADECI=F5G=CB=B7<CE5@F9GG=B;FB97C@C;=75@D9EFD97G=I9+9F95E7<,GH8=9F=B
&HF=78H75G=CB
&7:8/;L976)@HE5@DCFF=6=@=G=9FC:=ADECI=F5G=CB=BAHF=798H75G=CBB97C@C;=75@D9EFD97G=I9CB
FKRUDOLPSURYLVDWLRQDQGZHOOEHLQJ7DLGH\OLRSLVWRQ6LEHOLXV$NDWHPLD6WXGLD0XVLFD
&7:8/;L97/<3::=>=C:=A#&5DD=B;I=F=CBFC:=ADECI=F5G=CBD985;C;K=BAHF=798H75G=CB
E9F95E7<+9F95E7<,GH8=9F=B&HF=78H75G=CBZ
&CB3:/JD@CE=B;G<9DCFF=6=@=G=9FC:5@7ECL965F98AHF=798H75G=CBGC:CFG9EG<95;9B7KC:FGH89BGF
ZLWKVSHFLDOQHHGV$SUDFWLWLRQHULQTXLU\LQDVSHFLDOVFKRRO$FWD8QLY2XOX(2XOX2XOXQ\OLRSLVWR
&G@8L:L#!KG?KDC@??5>5<KDD=IRDHH<9ICB9B$5BF5BAHHF=??CFRI9@GRIRBRD9E=BB9FC=GG5>5B5
,=69@=HF?5G9A=5B?5BF5BAHF==??=>H@?5=FH>5!9@F=B?=-5=89K@=CD=FGCB,=69@=HF?5G9A=5
'799/<3<%)L93DL&HF==??=?5FI5GH?F9BCF5FGC9=@9B>5GRBRRB-9C?F9FF5#%CH<=IHCE=)
)55B5B9B%/R?9IRGC=A&HF==??=?5FI5GHF'R?X?H@A=5?5FI5GH?F99BCD9GH?F99B>5GHG?=AH?F99B
,HCA9BAHF==??=?5FI5GHFF9HE5 =,&EKZ
D/< /<3< 5HŴHFWLYLW\DQGWKHSHGDJRJLFDOPRPHQW7KHQRUPDWLYLW\RISHGDJRJLFDOWKLQNLQJDQG
DFWLQJ-RXUQDORI&XUULFXOXP6WXGLHVŊ
)L93DL7HDFKLQJSRSXODUPXVLFLQ)LQODQGZKDWōVXSZKDWōVDKHDG",QWHUQDWLRQDO-RXUQDORI0XVLF
(GXFDWLRQŊ
*@756B%/<3::=>=C:=A#"B:CEA5@AHF=7@95EB=B;=ADECI=F5G=CB5B8G957<9E98H75G=CBE=G=F<
#CHEB5@C:&HF=78H75G=CBZ
/BA/C9A3B
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.