Conference PaperPDF Available

Instability Mode Recognition of Grid-Tied Voltage Source Converters with Nonstationary Signal Analysis



With the increasing penetration of voltage-source-converter (VSC) -interfaced distributed generations(DGs) in power systems, oscillation issues have been widelyconcerned whereas the root cause and nature of the oscilla-tion is sometimes not clear in real cases. This paper focuseson the instability mode recognition (IMR) based on a com-plete data-driven approach applied to the oscillation waveswhich can be obtained from the on-site recordings. To thisend, we explore the Hilbert-Huang Transform (HHT) fordiagnosing the root cause of instability, using only raw datasuch as the current and voltage waveforms which are acces-sible by operators. Special attention is paid to distinguishbetween the sub-synchronous oscillation (SSO) and the lossof synchronization (LOS) as they are two primary instabil-ity forms of grid-tied VSC which manifest with very similarwaveforms. The pros and cons of the considered signalanalysis tools in SSO and LOS recognition are discussed andnew lines of investigations are proposed. The analysis andresults presented in this paper could shed light on futuredata-driven analysis, e.g., serving as model-free or hybridmodel database for artificial intelligence-based stabilitydiagnosis and recognition. (PDF) Instability Mode Recognition of Grid-Tied Voltage Source Converters with Nonstationary Signal Analysis. Available from: [accessed Apr 18 2022].
Instability Mode Recognition of Grid-Tied
Voltage Source Converters with
Nonstationary Signal Analysis
Yu Zhang1, Sjur Føyen2, Chen Zhang1, Marta Molinas3, Olav Bjarte Fosso2, Xu Cai1*
1 Key Laboratory of Control of Power Transmission and Conversion, SJTU, Shanghai, China
2 Department of Electric Power Engineering, NTNU, Trondheim, Norway
3 Department of Engineering Cybernetics, NTNU, Trondheim, Norway
Abstract- With the increasing penetration of voltage-
source-converter (VSC) -interfaced distributed generations
(DGs) in power systems, oscillation issues have been widely
concerned whereas the root cause and nature of the oscilla-
tion is sometimes not clear in real cases. This paper focuses
on the instability mode recognition (IMR) based on a com-
plete data-driven approach applied to the oscillation waves
which can be obtained from the on-site recordings. To this
end, we explore the Hilbert-Huang Transform (HHT) for
diagnosing the root cause of instability, using only raw data
such as the current and voltage waveforms which are acces-
sible by operators. Special attention is paid to distinguish
between the sub-synchronous oscillation (SSO) and the loss
of synchronization (LOS) as they are two primary instabil-
ity forms of grid-tied VSC which manifest with very similar
waveforms. The pros and cons of the considered signal
analysis tools in SSO and LOS recognition are discussed and
new lines of investigations are proposed. The analysis and
results presented in this paper could shed light on future
data-driven analysis, e.g., serving as model-free or hybrid
model database for artificial intelligence-based stability
diagnosis and recognition.
Index terms: signal analysis, converter, oscillation, stability,
mode recognition, synchronization, HHT, EMD.
Nowadays, while the power grid is taking the benefit
of voltage source converters (VSCs) to enable the
integration of various distributed generations (DGs), it
also suffers from harmonic oscillation issues caused by
power electronic devices, most of which are due to the
control interaction against the grid. In this context, two
kinds of instability issues of grid-tied VSCs have been
frequently reported in practical systems, i.e., the sub-
synchronous oscillation (SSO) and the loss of
synchronization (LOS) [1]. Both the SSO and LOS are
common oscillations in the 0~100Hz frequency range and
their oscillation waveforms appear very similar at visual
inspection and FFT spectral analysis.
A. Motivation
In the past years, extensive works have been conduct-
ed to resolve the oscillation issues of the grid-tied VSCs,
especially those relating to stability. Although analytical
This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of
China, under Grant 5183700.
approaches provide the necessary understanding and
insight into these new forms of stability issues, they are
merely applicable to simple systems. For practical and
complex power systems, modeling the entire system in
detail is often restricted by intellectual property issues
when different vendors are involved. Besides, prevailing
methods based on linear analysis are not sufficient and
often fail to reveal the real essence of harmonics observed
in Fourier spectra, because in such models, no physical
source is represented to which harmonics like those com-
ing from PWM, can be attributed. Therefore, the current
model-based methods have limited abilities to distinguish
among different modes of instability with similar mani-
festations. For example, if we want to know the reason
for the emergence of oscillation near the DG plants, one
usual way is to model the whole system and try to repro-
duce the phenomenon. However, this approach not only
implies a huge modelling effort but may also fail to evoke
the same instability scenario.
To complement the modelling approach and provide
insight from the real system, data-driven approaches can
be opted in such cases, and the main advantage is the
straightforward use of the on-site signals which carry
detail information of the oscillation. To this end, a pre-
liminary step is to identify the instability kind, referred to
as instability mode recognition (IMR). The restriction of
IMR analysis for power system operators is that, in most
cases, only the interfacing electrical data (e.g., voltage,
current and power) is available for analysis. The lack of
internal data of VSC control poses a great challenge to
the IMR, which means the IMR should be based on lim-
ited accessible signals, such as voltage and currents.
B. Nonstationary Signal Analysis
Frequency is an elemental descriptor of an oscillation,
and one might expect different instability modes to show
distinct frequency characteristics, yet the ordinary Fourier
spectra may be not enough in this context. To be specific,
frequency modulation (FM) effect has been reported in
both control-involved waveform distortion [2, 3] and
harmonic oscillation [4], indicating that the instantaneous
frequency (IF) [5, 6] of VSC is constantly varying, rather
than discrete frequency components, as is commonly
recognized. Besides, the site signals can be rather com-
plex that both the amplitude and the frequency are vary-
ing with time. However, the FFT lacks the ability to ana-
lyze such nonstationary signals, and therefore might not
be suitable for IMR.
In this regard, nonstationary signal processing meth-
ods such as time-frequency analysis (TFA) emerge as
promising candidates to explore. There are basically two
mainstreams of TFA, according to the definitions of IF.
The first is based on the orthogonality of the signal with
certain set of bases, e.g., short-time Fourier transform
(STFT), Gabor transform, wavelet transforms, which also
have the same and intrinsic problem of the uncertainty
principle as the FT, so that the frequency resolution will
lessen if a higher time resolution is obtained by a thinner
time window [7]. The second frequency definition is
based on the phase time derivative of the complex signal
(Section III.A) which is inherently capable to indicate the
varying frequency and amplitude of nonstationary signals.
However, the definition itself is derived from mono-
component signals, and is not suitable for signal contain-
ing more than one component.
One prominent solution is the Hilbert-Huang trans-
form (HHT) [8]. The key point is to use the empirical
mode decomposition (EMD) technique to sift intrinsic
mode functions (IMFs) from the signal, which generally
represent components with distinct physical meanings.
After the decomposition process, Hilbert transform (HT)
is applied on each IMF to process the complex signal,
from which the IF and instantaneous amplitude can be
calculated. Nevertheless, the strength of EMD is restrict-
ed when two signals of close frequency and amplitude are
mixed together, resulting in the well-known mode mixing
issue [9], which has been thoroughly addressed but was
not yet solved. Further effort including the ensemble
EMD (EEMD) [10], masking signal [11, 12] and hetero-
dyning [13] were reported to mitigate the mode mixing
issue, yet there are still some restrictions when using
these extended techniques. Moreover, a new method
called Fourier decomposition method (FDM) is proposed
in [7], which is a promising way to decompose the nar-
row-band signals and can be a good alternative to EMD.
In addition, to improve the computing stability and per-
formance of HT, direct quadrature (DQ) and normalized
Hilbert transform (NHT) are proposed in [14] to give a
better estimation of the instantaneous frequency.
C. Aim of This Paper
The IMR is urgently called for monitoring and fault
analysis of the high-penetrated DG integration, and HHT
has shown its great potential to extract the IF from the
field signals. To the best of authors’ knowledge, IMR has
been rarely reported in power system utilities, yet there
has not been any attempt on utilizing data-driven-based
approaches for this purpose. This paper aims to make an
initial exploration that can further indicate its potential
usefulness. To motivate a measurement-based analysis of
the instability phenomena, we firstly derive the expres-
sion of the oscillation signals for SSO and LOS, and
present a simple FFT-based spectra. Then, HHT-based
method is applied to the same signals, and naturally pro-
vides an entirely different inherently nonlinear and non-
stationary perspective. We follow up with discussion on
the obstacles which must be overcome to pave way for
real time IMR.
Control I
sdq, ref
Fig. 1 Schematic diagram of a grid-tied VSC.
(a) Voltage and frequency waveform profiles for the SSO case
(b) Voltage and frequency waveform profiles for the LOS case
Fig. 2 POC Voltage and PLL frequency profiles of the SSO and LOS.
Beat wave effect can be clearly seen for both cases. is three-phase
POC voltage,  is PLL frequency,  and  are  axis voltage
and current. Each of the signals are scaled to per unit values.
Although the mechanism of the SSO and LOS has
been well understood, currently the analytical expressions
of the instability signals are not yet derived. Therefore,
we try to recreate the instability signals first, according to
the mechanisms described below.
A. Mechanism of The SSO and LOS
The schematic diagram of the grid-tied VSC is shown
in Fig. 1. SSO is basically caused by insufficient damping
due to strong control interaction against the grid, espe-
cially for low SCR systems, which, therefore, can be
triggered by both loss of transmission line or mild change
of system condition. It is a small-signal instability issue
0.8 11 .2 1.4 1.6 1 .8
0.8 11 .2 1.4 1.6 1 .8
0.8 11 .2 1.4 1.6 1 .8
0.8 11 .2 1.4 1 .6 1.8 t ( s)
Ch ange of S CR
t (s)
t (s)
t (s)
0.8 11 .2 1.4 1 .6 1.8
0.8 11 .2 1.4 1 .6 1.8
0.8 11 .2 1.4 1 .6 1.8
0.8 11 .2 1.4 1 .6 1.8
Volt age di p
Frequency saturation
t (s)
t (s)
t (s)
t (s)
that occurs in a slowly varying steady-state operating
point. When SSO happens, any involving states would
oscillate around their equilibrium point, including  axis
voltage , current  and the frequency of PLL ,
as is shown in Fig. 2(a). Therefore, the output voltage is
both frequency and amplitude modulated (AM-FM) due
to the varying PLL frequency, which agrees with the
findings in [4]. Beat wave effect can be observed in the
voltage signal at point of connection (POC).
On the other hand, LOS is definitely one kind of
large-signal instability caused by severe voltage dip, e.g.,
short circuit. The basic reason for the LOS is that the PLL
frequency diverges upwards during the transient and fail
to get back even after the restoring of grid voltage [15],
as is shown in Fig. 2(b). Once the LOS occurs, the refer-
ence frame of VSC control will never be aligned with the
voltage vector at POC, instead, it rotates with a frequency
slip and begins to swing. However, the current control
still keeps stable and track its reference well, because the
instability only involves the PLL. If the converter does
not suffer overmodulation, the current could be near
perfectly controlled on the  axis, which is well illus-
trated in Fig. 2(b). Although there is no AM-FM modula-
tion with LOS signal, the voltage at POC contains at least
two components at different frequencies, and the beat
waves effect is also observed in the POC voltage signals.
Beat waves are also evident in the  currents.
B. Modelling of The Oscillation Signals
According to the waveforms in Fig. 2(a), assume all
signals in  frame comprise a DC component and a
sinusoidal component for the SSO case. Then, the refer-
ence voltage is represented by:
() = +cos(+)
() = +sin(+) (1
and the PLL frequency is modelled by:
() =[1+cos(+)] (2
where ,, denote the oscillation amplitude, the
harmonic frequency on the  axis, , the phase
angle,  and  the DC component of the voltage, and
the synchronous frequency. The phasor form of (8) is:
where =+
and =−
. Next, the PLL angle is
added to (3) to get the voltage phasor on  axis:
, =arctan( 
⁄ )
() =()d =+
Equation (4) indicates that the PCC voltage consists of
three frequency-modulated signals, as is shown in Table I.
The center frequencies of these FM signals are ,(+
),(), that is one center fundamental frequency
00.05 0 .1 0.15 0.2 0 .25 0.3 0. 35 0.4 0.45
(b) Plot of PCC Voltage Us for LOS
00.05 0 .1 0.15 0.2 0 .25 0.3 0. 35 0.4 0.45 t ( s)
(a) Plot of PCC Voltage Us for SSO
t (s)
Fig. 3 Recreated artificial signals of instability of the PCC voltage
based on assumed modelling in equations (4) and(5).
Instantaneous Frequency
and two harmonic frequencies in each side. Besides, the
mirror frequency effect, firstly reported in [16], is also
reflected in this modelling while the amplitude of mirror
frequency component vanishes when  axes are sym-
metric, i.e.,
= 
= −
, which also agrees with
the findings in [16]. Besides, it should be noted that the
frequency of each component of the VSC is oscillating,
which is beyond the describing capability of the ordinary
linear modelling, for it is only applicable when the fre-
quency oscillation is minor, i.e., 0. In short, the
waveform of PCC voltage during the SSO includes three
AM-FM components of which the IFs are varying around
different center frequencies.
For the LOS, assume that the current could always be
controlled and is equal to its reference. Then, the PCC
voltage is formulated by:
()()= denotes the grid voltage vec-
tor, () =()d is the PLL frequency, and is
the summation of current phase and impedance angle.
This indicates, theoretically, that the LOS waveform only
contains the background grid voltage and one single FM
signal with IF of ().
According to the voltage expression in (4) and (5), the
PCC voltage could reflect the frequency information of
the oscillation in VSC, which is crucial to determine
which kind of instability is dominant To verify the signal
modeling, we use the following values to recreate the
signals, and the transient period is temporarily ignored for
the sake of simplicity:
 =0.5, =0.0,=1.0,= 0.5,
=1.2,=0.8,=0.15,,= 0,=
forSSO: =2×50Hz,=2 ×15Hz
for LOS: () =2×60Hz
Fig. 4 FFT spectrum of PCC voltage with different time windows. Top
and bottom subplots are FFT spectra with time windows of 2s and 0.5s.
The recreated signals are plotted in Fig. 3. These arti-
ficial signals resemble the voltage signals in Fig. 2, and
the beat wave effect is observed for both SSO and LOS.
We remark that (4)~(5) is only one possible modelling.
C. Fourier Analysis on Steady Oscillations
The frequency-domain spectrum with the steady state
is investigated via Fast Fourier Transformation (FFT).
The FFT spectra are plotted in Fig. 4.
Firstly, we applied FFT on both SSO and LOS at time
period of two seconds, and plot the result on the top fig-
ures, where the frequency resolution is good. Two main
sidebands can be observed in SSO, mostly due to the AM
effect (beat wave effect) of the signal, and even more tiny
sidebands at ± are distinguishable, which is actu-
ally the spectra of FM effect. While for the LOS, there
are only two main components in the signal, which is the
50Hz background grid voltage and VSC output voltage at
the saturated PLL frequency of 60Hz.
Next, if we reduce the time window to 0.5s, as is
shown in the bottom subfigures of Fig. 4., then the fre-
quency resolution is reduced so that the Fourier spectra is
blurred, due to the well-known uncertainty principle. For
FFT with sampling frequency and samples, the
frequency resolution and required time window are:
∆ =⁄ ⇒ = 
= 1 ∆
It implies that if we want to get a better resolution of the
frequency, the time window should be extended to sever-
al seconds. Therefore, Fourier analysis is applicable at the
steady stage of oscillation.
In real systems, the signals can be nonstationary, espe-
cially for the LOS, which is beyond the capability of FFT
analysis. Any other Fourier or wavelet based short-time
transform also need enough steady periods for the good
performance of TFA. In the following sections, we begin
to explore the capabilities of HHT, which has the inherent
ability to process nonstationary signals, to give new indi-
cators and criterions for the IMR.
A. The Hilbert-Huang Transform
Suppose ()= ()cos() be a mono-component
signal with varying amplitude and frequency, where ()
is the instantaneous amplitude (IA) and () be the phase
angle. To obtain the phase angle, the quadrature signal is
required, i.e., ()= ()sin(), which can be obtained
from the Hilbert transform (HT):
() = 1
−  (7
Then, complex signal ()= ()+() =()() is
built from the signal () and its quadrature (), where
the phase angle can be calculated by:
()=arctan(() () ), (8
Then, the IF is defined by:
d . (9
This definition is elegant and meaningful. However,
for the signals from the real world, it can be difficult to
directly apply due to the following two reasons. First,
most of the signals are multi-component and need separa-
tion before calculating the IF with (9). Second, HT has
many problems in finite signal processing that sometimes
yields a poor estimation of the quadrature, which would
cause the incorrect computation of the IF and IA.
To solve the first issue, Huang put forward the EMD
to sift IMFs from the signal [8]:
1. Let =1 and () be the initial residual ();
2. Find the extrema of ();
3. Interpolate the maxima (minima) to get the upper
(lower) envelope () and ();
4. Compute the mean of the envelop and assign it as
the new residual: +() =(()+())/2;
5. Subtract the -th IMF: ()=()+();
6. Check if the stop criterion is meet [8]. If not, then
let =+1 and loop back to procedure No.2.
Finally, the origin signal is decomposed to a series of
IMFs [(),,−()] and one last residual ():
()=() + ()
= (10
Each IMF is regarded as a mono-component signal,
which is intuitively true. However, mode mixing issue is
found in EMD when IFs of two components are close to
each other. It is theoretically proved in [9] that, for the
following signal:
It is only possible to separate each component easily if
 <1 and  < 0.67, where =
and  = 
Otherwise, the mode mixing will occur and these two
components are unable to be separated by ordinary EMD.
For example, if we directly use EMD to decompose the
SSO signal, the first IMF will be almost the same as the
raw signal, as is shown in Fig. 5, because the IF of the
components in SSO (see Table I) are quite close with
each other so that to cause the mode mixing. This indi-
cates that the first IMF comprises of more than one com-
ponent and thus the IF shown as Hilbert spectra is mean-
ingless, as is plotted in Fig. 6, because the definition is
SSO (Twin = 2.0 sec)
020 40 60 80 100
SSO (Twin = 0.5 sec)
020 40 60 80 100
LOS (Twin = 2.0 sec)
020 40 60 80 100
LOS (Twin = 0.5 sec)
020 40 60 80 100
only applicable for mono-component signals. The same
thing will happen for the LOS signal as well because the
IF of PLL is close to that of the background grid voltage.
B. Signal Heterodyning for Decomposition
To solve the mode mixing issue, the frequency ratio
between each IMF should be relatively large. To this end,
frequency heterodyning is one possibility to alleviate the
mode mixing issue, because the spectra of a signal can be
shifted by multiplying a heterodyning signal [13]. Given
a two-component real signal:
Its spectra can be shifted by signal heterodyning:
() =()2cos2
where ∆=  and ∆=. Let  be
slightly lower (or greater) than the smaller (larger) one of
{,}, then it will be possible to find such  to meet
the requirement of decomposition. Two components of
higher frequency are also produced, which is obviously
out of the octave of the first two. Therefore, the IMFs for
these high-frequency components can be filtered or de-
composed easily and should be discarded.
For balanced three-phase systems, the space vector of
voltage and current can be obtained by Clarke transform
on three-phase signals. Therefore, complex demodulation
can be adopted instead of signal heterodyning for better
performance, since it can shift the frequency without
producing high frequency components. We give an ex-
ample on how the complex demodulation works. Given a
two-component complex signal:
() =()j2π+()j2π (14
Complex rotation j2π is adopted for heterodyning:
() =Re{()j2π}
The decomposition performance relates much with the
heterodyning frequency. For the SSO, because there are
three oscillating components at the center frequency of
,(+),(), and it can be hard to choose a
single heterodyning frequency to separate them all. One
possible solution is to set  =50Hz, so that the center
frequencies of each will be shifted to 0Hz and ±, re-
spectively. According to the expressions in Table I, the
last two components will mix with each other as one
single component with mean frequency of :
̃()cos+tan−̃() 
⁄ 
Fig. 5 EMD for the artificial SSO signal  where mode mixing occurs.
Fig. 6 Hilbert spectra for the first IMF (IMF1 in Fig. 5) of SSO through
the ordinary EMD. The colormap denotes the IA of the complex signal.
Fig. 7 Hilbert spectra for the IMF of instability mode of SSO (left) and
LOS (right) with different heterodyning frequencies.
where ̃() denotes the oscillating term in Table I. If <
, then the oscillation of the IF will be lessened, which
will be shown later that can pose a threat to the IMR if
the indicator becomes less distinct. Therefore, some other
frequencies should be tried so as to find the best one.
For illustration, we decomposed the artificial signals
by three heterodyning signals at 50Hz,45Hz and 42.5Hz.
The IFs representing the instability mode of the SSO are
plotted in Fig. 7(a)(c)(e). It can be seen that the mean of
IF is 65Hz, and the vibration frequency of the IF is 15Hz,
which coincides with the analysis above. For the SSO,
the IF variation of 65Hz-component with  =50Hz is
lower than that of the others, which verified the analysis
above. In comparison, the IFs of the instability mode for
LOS case are plotted in Fig. 7(b)(d)(f). A 60-Hz compo-
nent is observed in the spectra and there is no distinct
oscillation on the IF as is found in the SSO case. When
 =42.5Hz, the best decomposition performance for
500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000
(sam pl es)
SSO is witnessed, as the (+) component is isolated
from the others; While for the LOS, this heterodyning
frequency gives the worst result for the frequency shift is
not enough for EMD to work well. It shows that the IF
can be a good indicator to distinguish the LOS from SSO.
C. The Proposed Method
1) Algorithm for extracting the instability signal
Now an overview of the whole procedure to separate
the instability oscillation signal from either SSO or LOS
is described below. Some additional measures are taken
to improve the decomposition of the results:
1. Apply Clarke Transform to the three-phase signal,
or skip this if a single-phase signal is used;
2. Take signal heterodyning or complex demodula-
tion to shift the spectra (try on different  for the
good of EMD performance);
3. Pass the signal through a lowpass filter;
4. Decompose with EMD to obtain IMFs;
5. Calculate the IF and IA for each IMF by HT, DQ,
NHT or other else methods;
6. Add the heterodyning frequency to each IF, and
plot the Hilbert spectrum.
The lowpass filter is used to smooth the transients and
remove high frequency dynamics and noises, which is
crucial to get good results. This step should be placed
after the frequency shifting, which could facilitate the use
of filter with lower cut-off frequency. Besides, this pro-
cess is regarded as one standard preprocess of EMD for
the purpose of anti-aliasing, and discrete events so that
we can process EMD with a lower sampling frequency.
2) Criteria on instability mode recognition
From the procedure above, the first criterion to judge
whether an oscillation within 0~100Hz is SSO or LOS is
by observing the IF oscillation:
Criterion I: In steady oscillating period, if regular os-
cillation is observed in the target IF, of which the oscil-
lating frequency is the same as the frequency difference
between the mean of the target IF and the fundamentals,
then the instability mode should be the SSO; otherwise, it
should be the LOS.
Naturally, real measurement devices contain transients
as well. The transient also conveys information of the
type of instability, due to the frequency evolution process
with different kind of instability. As is shown in Fig. 2,
the frequency of PLL is not constant during the voltage
dip, but keeps climbing until reaching the limitation.
Therefore, the transient period will help with the IMR of
the VSC, which gives rise to the second criterion:
Criterion II: If a recognizable rise is observed in the
target IF in the transient process, then the instability
mode should be the LOS; otherwise, it should be SSO.
As HHT is intended precisely for extraction of physi-
cally relevant information of multicomponent, nonlinear
and nonstationary waveforms, there is no need to restrict
analysis to the steady state, which means that the pro-
posed method to extract the target IF is also applicable to
the transients. We shall show in the following section
how the HHT-based IMR algorithm enables joint use of
transient and steady-state stages.
A. Verification on Simulation Signals
The first case will demonstrate the procedure for both
the SSO and LOS. The circuit topology is shown in Fig. 1,
and the simulation settings are the same as well to trigger
the SSO and LOS, of which the waveforms are shown in
Fig. 2. Only the signals of POC can be used for IMR, e.g.,
voltage and current. A heterodyning frequency of 45Hz is
adopted for the LOS and 43Hz for the SSO. Three-phase
POC voltage signals are processed in this case, which is:
(1) passed through a 3rd-order Butterworth lowpass filter,
(2) rotated (heterodyned) with a 45Hz/43 Hz complex
exponential, (3) decomposed with EMD. Then, through
the direct quadrature [14], the instantaneous frequency is
yielded for each IMF. The heterodyning frequency is
added to the IF. Finally, the Hilbert spectrum is calculat-
ed from the IF and IA, then filtered with a gaussian filter
for a smooth appearance.
The resulting spectra are shown in Fig. 8, where the
analysis is based on windows from = 0.3s to =2.5s.
The long duration of the signal is needed to ensure that
the heterodyned signal has enough periods for EMD to
work well. But this is not an insurmountable restriction,
for example, joint use of masking signals and heterodyn-
ing has potential to reduce the required length of the time
window. As can be clearly seen from the first figure, the
VSC suffered a period of low voltage before the fault is
cleared, during which the IF of one IMF went through an
obvious rising, which indicates that the oscillation mode
is LOS. While for the other one, a distinct oscillating
frequency appears suddenly above the fundamental fre-
quency, hence the oscillation mode is SSO.
(a) (b)
Fig. 8 Hilbert spectra of the voltage measurements after heterodyning
and EMD. (a) LOS. Dashed black line is the PLL frequency. (b) SSO.
For comparison, the dashed black line is the PLL frequency for the LOS,
and the PLL frequency plus the oscillating frequency for the SSO.
B. Measurement quality
At first sight it might be unclear how to select meas-
urements for IMR. Which is the better choice of voltage
and current to be a good indicator? Where should the
measurements be located? To answer these questions, we
discuss a few challenges with the decomposition and
some traits of the signals. The current and voltage meas-
urements are decomposed by the aforementioned process
and the results are plotted in Fig. 9 and Fig. 10, we will
see that the current signal is more distinct as an instability
indicator for the LOS case, and decomposition of the
current is not strictly necessary. This is because the con-
verter regulates the current to follow the frequency of the
PLL, while it (almost) suppresses the fundamental. The
same argument does not hold true for the PCC voltage
measurements, as the current at the fundamental is sup-
pressed, the grid PCC voltage must equal the grid voltage.
In the SSO case for a single VSC, there is no such clear
distinction between the current and voltage measurements,
for they will both have a nonnegligible fundamental and
hence must be decomposed. The LOS presents the great-
est challenge for IMR, due to the short duration of the
fault. The amplitude of the LOS and fundamental should
be slowly varying or constant in the entire window, lest
the frequency information be obscured.
(a) (b) (c) (d)
Fig. 9 Hilbert spectra for current and voltage for the LOS case, with or
without decomposition. (a) current without EMD, (b) current with EMD,
(c) voltage without EMD, (d) voltage with EMD.
(a) (b) (c) (d)
Fig. 10 Hilbert spectra for current and voltage for the SSO case, with or
without decomposition. (a) current without EMD, (b) current with EMD,
(c) voltage without EMD, (d) voltage with EMD.
The PCC current meets this criterion (no need for de-
composition) for the single converter case, but we present
a multi-converter system to illustrate that it is not always
so. The performance of the proposed decomposition is
examined in multi-converter network, as is illustrated in
Fig. 11, where two converter stations are connected in
parallel to a bus with a local load. The SC fault is applied
on the common bus for 200ms to trigger the LOS.
The spectra for the LOS case are shown in Fig. 12. It
seems as if the target IMF of the PCC voltage is hardly
visible, as its amplitude is very low compared to the fun-
damental. More importantly, the LOS ramp is not visible.
However, if we decompose the PCC current, then we
could obtain the spectra in Fig. 13(a), which looks much
clearer than the voltage. It seems that the current is a
better indicator than the voltage, for it wouldn’t attenuate
as the distance increases, but the decomposition is needed
because the PCC current contains both the LOS signal
from the faulted VSC and the normal signal at 50Hz.
Moreover, the LOS IMF can be weakened by the load
current, as is shown in Fig. 13(b), which indicates that
measuring the current that goes to the grid is not very
robust. Therefore, the measurement position is also very
crucial to the IMR and need further exploration.
= 0.3pu
= 0.3pu
= 0.1pu
= 1pu
= 0.5pu
Fig. 11 Test case for multi-converter network scenario.
Fig. 12 Hilbert spectrum of the PCC voltage for multi-converter system.
(a) (b)
Fig. 13 Hilbert spectrum of the current (a) PCC current which excludes
the load current; (b) grid current which includes the load current.
(a) (b)
Fig. 14 Hilbert spectra for the decomposed current when overmodula-
tion happens in (a) LOS and (b) SSO.
C. Overmodulation Effects
Both LOS and SSO are likely to inflict overmodulation
on the converter. Though normally interpreted in terms of
the harmonic spectrum, we apply the same procedure to
see the instantaneous properties of POC current during
overmodulation, the results are shown in Fig. 14.
The same analysis on the POC voltages is omitted,
though it yields similar spectra. The LOS ramp is still
captured very well, as overmodulation takes effect only
after the fault is cleared. However, the LOS IMF exhibits
larger frequency oscillations than the SSO in steady state,
which is caused by more severe overmodulation of LOS
than of SSO. Therefore, the performance of the proposed
method highlights the importance of criterion II. Further
investigations are needed to determine if the steady state
can be included in IMR, or if overmodulated SSO and
LOS IMFs are practically indistinguishable.
This paper focuses on the IMR issue of the VSCs via
interfacing measurement signals. We concluded that two
ordinary kinds of instability within 0~100Hz, namely the
SSO and LOS, can be identified and be distinguishable
from each other by complete data-driven approach. We
firstly recreate the PCC voltage signal for the SSO and
the LOS, in order to obtain the key features of the signals
from their mathematical expressions. FFT is firstly ap-
plied to get the frequency spectrum for the initial cogni-
tion of the instability signals. It is found that the frequen-
cy component of the converter output voltage and the
background grid voltage are so close that the EMD de-
pendent mode mixing issue can possibly happen, which is
then verified by applying EMD on the raw signal of PCC
voltage. Complex demodulation (signal heterodyning) is
adopted to shift the background 50Hz signal to a very low
frequency component, so that the instability IMF can be
isolated and analyzed. In this way, the residual signal
only contains the converter output that reflects the fre-
quency variation in the converter. Two criteria for IMR
of SSO and LOS are put forward, where we remark on
the importance of transient stage of the signals. Besides,
we also discuss on the need for decomposition for voltage
and current signals, improve the performance on multi
converter system, and make suggestion on the measure-
ment location. Finally, we observed the current signal
could be distorted due to overmodulation and thus the
corresponding IMF profile will be affected. However,
since the signal hasn’t been rebuilt to reflect the over-
modulation effect, this issue is not well resolved and
hence need further investigation.
[1] J. Shair, H. Li, J. Hu, and X. Xie, "Power system stability issues,
classifications and research prospects in the context of high-
penetration of renewables and power electronics," Renewable
and Sustainable Energy Reviews, vol. 145, 2021, doi:
[2] G. Kulia, M. Molinas, L. Lundheim, and B. B. Larsen, "Towards
a real-time measurement platform for microgrids in isolated
communities," Procedia engineering, vol. 159, pp. 94-103, 2016.
[3] G. Kulia, M. Molinas, and L. Lundheim, "Tool for detecting
waveform distortions in inverter-based microgrids: a validation
study," in 2016 IEEE Global Humanitarian Technology
Conference (GHTC), 2016: IEEE, pp. 525-531.
[4] R. Ma, Z. Yang, S. Cheng, and M. Zhan, "Sustained Oscillations
and Bifurcations in Three-phase VSC Tied to AC Gird," IET
Renewable Power Generation, 2020.
[5] B. Boashash, "Estimating and interpreting the instantaneous
frequency of a signal. I. Fundamentals," Proceedings of the IEEE,
vol. 80, no. 4, pp. 520-538, 1992, doi: 10.1109/5.135376.
[6] B. Boashash, "Estimating and interpreting the instantaneous
frequency of a signal. II. Algorithms and applications,"
Proceedings of the IEEE, vol. 80, no. 4, pp. 540-568, 1992, doi:
[7] P. Singh, "Breaking the limits: redefining the instantaneous
frequency," Circuits, Systems, and Signal Processing, vol. 37, no.
8, pp. 3515-3536, 2018.
[8] N. E. Huang et al., "The empirical mode decomposition and the
Hilbert spectrum for nonlinear and non-stationary time series
analysis," Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A:
mathematical, physical and engineering sciences, vol. 454, no.
1971, pp. 903-995, 1998.
[9] G. Rilling and P. Flandrin, "One or Two Frequencies? The
Empirical Mode Decomposition Answers," IEEE Transactions
on Signal Processing, vol. 56, no. 1, pp. 85-95, 2008, doi:
[10] Z. Wu and N. E. Huang, "Ensemble empirical mode
decomposition: a noise-assisted data analysis method," Advances
in adaptive data analysis, vol. 1, no. 01, pp. 1-41, 2009.
[11] O. B. Fosso and M. Molinas, "EMD mode mixing separation of
signals with close spectral proximity in smart grids," in 2018
IEEE PES innovative smart grid technologies conference Europe
(ISGT-Europe), 2018: IEEE, pp. 1-6.
[12] R. Deering and J. F. Kaiser, "The use of a masking signal to
improve empirical mode decomposition," in Proceedings.
(ICASSP'05). IEEE International Conference on Acoustics,
Speech, and Signal Processing, 2005., 2005, vol. 4: IEEE, pp.
iv/485-iv/488 Vol. 4.
[13] N. Senroy and S. Suryanarayanan, "Two techniques to enhance
empirical mode decomposition for power quality applications," in
2007 IEEE Power Engineering Society General Meeting, 2007:
IEEE, pp. 1-6.
[14] N. E. Huang, Z. Wu, S. R. Long, K. C. Arnold, X. Chen, and K.
Blank, "On instantaneous frequency," Advances in adaptive data
analysis, vol. 1, no. 02, pp. 177-229, 2009.
[15] D. Dong, B. Wen, D. Boroyevich, P. Mattavelli, and Y. Xue,
"Analysis of phase-locked loop low-frequency stability in three-
phase grid-connected power converters considering impedance
interactions," IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol.
62, no. 1, pp. 310-321, 2015, doi: 10.1109/TIE.2014.2334665.
[16] A. Rygg, M. Molinas, C. Zhang, and X. Cai, "A Modified
Sequence-Domain Impedance Definition and Its Equivalence to
the dq-Domain Impedance Definition for the Stability Analysis of
AC Power Electronic Systems," IEEE Journal of Emerging and
Selected Topics in Power Electronics, vol. 4, no. 4, pp. 1383-
1396, 2016, doi: 10.1109/JESTPE. 2016.2588733.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Full-text available
Recently large-scale integration of power-electronic-based devices has made system-level oscillations occur frequently, which posed a big challenge for modern power grids. Previous studies mainly treated sustained oscillations under the framework of (linear) small-signal stability and/or by incorporating the impact of current saturation, but seldom considered system nonlinearity like phase-locked-loop. In this paper, we establish a sixth-order nonlinear model for a three-phase voltage-source converter tied to AC grid, and study its dynamics completely from nonlinear system theory and signal analysis technique, with all parameters including current controllers, phase-locked-loop, line inductance, and grid voltage. We find that the operation point usually becomes unstable by Hopf bifurcation, and the sustained oscillations are possible only for super-critical Hopf bifurcation. Based on these observations, sustained periodic oscillation should be treated as limit cycle even without saturation. With saturation, some other phenomena have also been found, such as saturation-induced instability and saturation-restricted oscillation. In addition, we discover that for sustained oscillations, the usual purely sinusoidal three-phase currents exhibit the form of $\sin[2\pi{f_1}t + c\sin ({2\pi f_{dq}}t)]$ or $\cos[2\pi{f _1}t + c\sin ({2\pi f _{dq}}t)]$, where $f_1$ ($f_{dq}$) denotes basic (modal oscillation) frequency with $c$ a constant. This work could provide an improved understanding of sustained oscillations and associated system dynamics in an overall perspective manner.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) is a signal analysis method that separates multi-component signals into single oscillatory modes called intrinsic mode functions (IMFs). These IMFs can generally be associated to a physical meaning of the process from which the signal is obtained. When the phenomena of mode mixing occurs, as a result of the EMD sifting process, the IMFs may lose their physical meaning hindering the interpretation of the results of the analysis. Previous research presents a rigorous mathematical analysis that shows how EMD behaves in the case of a composite two-components signal, explaining the roots of the mode mixing problem. Also, the frequency-amplitude region within which a good separation is achieved with EMD is well identified and discussed. However, a solution that offers good IMF separation when components reside within the same octave is not yet available. In this paper, a method to separate spectral components that reside within the same octave, is presented. This method is based on reversing the conditions by which mode mixing occurs presented in the paper One or Two frequencies? The Empirical Mode Decomposition Answers, in [3]. Numerical experiments with signals containing spectral components within the same octave shows the effective separation of modes that EMD can perform after this principle is applied. This separation technique has potential application for identifying the cause of different oscillatory modes with spectral proximity present in the smart grid.
Full-text available
This paper describes a platform for obtaining and analyzing real-time measurements in Microgrids. A key building block in this platform is the Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) used to analyze the electrical voltage and current waveforms to identify the instantaneous frequency and amplitude of the monocomponents of the original signal. The method was used to analyse the frequency fluctuation and obtain information about the linearity of electrical current and voltage waveforms measured in the field. Comparison between grid-connected and stand-alone microgrid voltage and currents’ monocomponents were conducted. Fluctuations in the grid frequency occurred in both the grid-connected and stand-alone microgrid, but the degree of the observed fluctuations were different, revealing more apparent nonlinear distortions in the latter. The observed instantaneous frequency from the collected data indicates potential nonstationary electrical signals when compared to synthetic data containing periodic signals coming from nonlinear loads. This observation leads us to expect the next generation of real-time measuring devices for the micro power grids to be designed on the principle of instantaneous frequency detection. Further efforts will be directed to a more rigorous characterization of the nonstationary nature of the signals by analyzing more and longer set of data.
Full-text available
Representations of AC power systems by frequency dependent impedance equivalents is an emerging technique in the dynamic analysis of power systems including power electronic converters. The technique has been applied for decades in DC-power systems, and it was recently adopted to map the impedances in AC systems. Most of the work on AC systems can be categorized in two approaches. One is the analysis of the system in the \textit{dq}-domain, whereas the other applies harmonic linearization in the phase domain through symmetric components. Impedance models based on analytical calculations, numerical simulation and experimental studies have been previously developed and verified in both domains independently. The authors of previous studies discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each domain separately, but neither a rigorous comparison nor an attempt to bridge them has been conducted. The present paper attempts to close this gap by deriving the mathematical formulation that shows the equivalence between the \textit{dq}-domain and the sequence domain impedances. A modified form of the sequence domain impedance matrix is proposed, and with this definition the stability estimates obtained with the Generalized Nyquist Criterion (GNC) become equivalent in both domains. The second contribution of the paper is the definition of a \textit{Mirror Frequency Decoupled} (MFD) system. The analysis of MFD systems is less complex than that of non-MFD systems because the positive and negative sequences are decoupled. This paper shows that if a system is incorrectly assumed to be MFD, this will lead to an erroneous or ambiguous estimation of the equivalent impedance.
Full-text available
The Carson and Fry (1937) introduced the concept of variable frequency as a generalization of the constant frequency. The instantaneous frequency (IF) is the time derivative of the instantaneous phase and it is well-defined only when this derivative is positive. If this derivative is negative, the IF creates problem because it does not provide any physical significance. This study proposes a mathematical solution and eliminate this problem by redefining the IF such that it is valid for all monocomponent and multicomponent signals which can be nonlinear and nonstationary in nature. This is achieved by using the property of the multivalued inverse tangent function which provides basis to ensure that instantaneous phase is an increasing function. The efforts and understanding of all the methods based on the IF would improve significantly by using this proposed definition of the IF. We also demonstrate that the decomposition of a signal, using zero-phase filtering based on the well established Fourier and filter theory, into a set of desired frequency bands with proposed IF produces accurate time-frequency-energy (TFE) distribution that reveals true nature of signal. Simulation results demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed IF that makes zero-phase filter based decomposition most powerful, for the TFE analysis of a signal, as compared to other existing methods in the literature.
This paper concerns with the emerging power system stability issues, classification, and research prospects under a high share of renewables and power electronics. The decades-old traditional power system is undergoing a fast transition with two most prominent features: 1) high-penetration of renewable power generators, utilizing intermittent renewable sources such as wind and solar, and 2) high-penetration of power electronic devices in the generation e.g., wind turbine converters and solar power inverters, transmission e.g., flexible ac or dc transmission system converters, and distribution/utilization systems e.g., electric vehicle and microgrid. The development of modern power systems with dual high-penetrations, i.e., high-penetrations of renewables and power electronic devices, influences the power system dynamics significantly and causes new stability issues. This paper first overviews equipment-level features and system-level stability challenges introduced under the dual high-penetration scenario of the modern power system. Next, the impacts of emerging stability challenges on various aspects of the classical stability issues and classifications are highlighted. Under this context, this paper discusses the validity and limitations of the existing classical and extended power system stability classifications proposed by different IEEE/Cigre Working Groups. Furthermore, a new power system stability classification framework is proposed, which not only maintains the inherent logic of the classical classification but also provides wide coverage and future adaptability of the emerging stability issues. Finally, various classification-oriented research prospects in the power system stability domain are highlighted.
Synchronous reference frame (SRF) phase-locked loop (PLL) is a critical component for the control and grid synchronization of three-phase grid-connected power converters. The PLL behaviors, especially its low-frequency dynamics, influenced by different grid and load impedances as well as operation mode have not been investigated yet, which may not be captured by conventional linear PLL models. In this paper, we propose a state-feedback quasi-static SRF-PLL model, which can identify and quantify the inherent frequency self-synchronization mechanism in the converter control system. This self-synchronization effect is essentially due to the converter interactions with grid impedance and power flow directions. The low-frequency nonlinear behaviors of the PLL under different grid impedance conditions are then analyzed, which forms the framework of evaluating the impacts of the large penetration level of distributed generation units, weak grid, microgrid, and large reactive power consumption in terms of the frequency stability of PLL. Specifically, the PLL behavior of the converter system under islanded condition is investigated to explain the PLL instability issues and the related islanding-detection methods in early publications and industry reports.
Conference Paper
Joint time-frequency characterization techniques are gaining importance in power quality studies of time-varying waveform distortions. In this context, the performance of the recently introduced empirical mode decomposition (EMD) as a second order filter is examined in this paper. The original EMD technique is incapable of separating components whose frequencies lie within the same octave. Using appropriate masking signals, the EMD can be made more discriminating for closely spaced frequency components. However, limitations still remain, and this paper discusses some aspects thereof. A frequency shifting technique is suggested to further enhance the discriminating property of EMD. Synthetic data similar to signals found in power quality studies are employed for demonstration purposes.