Conference PaperPDF Available

An Exploration of the Potential for Using Modular Housing Solutions to Address the UK's Housing Shortage

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The UK construction industry is affected by a shortage of affordable housing exacerbated by a shortage of skilled labour. This paper explores opportunities to use modular homes to address the UK's housing shortage. In developing this paper, a questionnaire-based survey was undertaken following a detailed review of relevant literature. The survey of industry professionals involved 70 structured questionnaires sent online. A lack of affordable new homes is identified in this paper as one of the most pressing issues within the sector. Again, a lack of investment in apprenticeships is identified to have led to skilled trades shortages in the industry. The survey reported in this paper found that modular homes would provide homes quicker and cheaper. Other benefits of modular housing are the use of eco-friendlier materials, waste reduction and reduced CO2 emissions from construction processes and from reduced transportation. Reduced maintenance requirements also reduced life-cycle costs in modular homes however traditional housing was seen as having longer lifespans. Due to restrictions in place at the time relating to the COVID 19 pandemic, detailed confirmatory interviews could not be conducted. Further research could investigate the costs to contractors of establishing their own manufacturing facilities. Opportunities to improve awareness of the benefits of modular homes can also be explored in future work. Future research could also explore the potential of increased integration of Value Engineering and Building Information Modelling (BIM) into modular house building and to evaluate the potential benefits they provide.
Content may be subject to copyright.
An Exploration of the Potential for Using Modular Housing Solutions to
Address the UK’s Housing Shortage
Joseph Kwame Ofori-Kuragu, joseph.ofori@aru.ac.uk
Anglia Ruskin University, UK
Reece Hill, reece.hill@sdc.co.uk
SDC Builders Ltd, UK
Abstract
The UK construction industry is affected by a shortage of affordable housing exacerbated by a
shortage of skilled labour. This paper explores opportunities to use modular homes to address the
UK’s housing shortage. In developing this paper, a questionnaire-based survey was undertaken
following a detailed review of relevant literature. The survey of industry professionals involved 70
structured questionnaires sent online. A lack of affordable new homes is identified in this paper as
one of the most pressing issues within the sector. Again, a lack of investment in apprenticeships is
identified to have led to skilled trades shortages in the industry. The survey reported in this paper
found that modular homes would provide homes quicker and cheaper. Other benefits of modular
housing are the use of eco-friendlier materials, waste reduction and reduced CO2 emissions from
construction processes and from reduced transportation. Reduced maintenance requirements also
reduced life-cycle costs in modular homes however traditional housing was seen as having longer
lifespans. Due to restrictions in place at the time relating to the COVID 19 pandemic, detailed
confirmatory interviews could not be conducted. Further research could investigate the costs to
contractors of establishing their own manufacturing facilities. Opportunities to improve awareness of
the benefits of modular homes can also be explored in future work. Future research could also
explore the potential of increased integration of Value Engineering and Building Information
Modelling (BIM) into modular house building and to evaluate the potential benefits they provide.
Keywords
Modular, Housing, offsite-construction, skills shortage, construction
1.0 Introduction
The construction industry contributes to nearly £117 billion pounds to the UK’s economy, 6% of the
total revenue with the industry responsible for providing 2.4 million jobs in the UK making up 6.6%
of all jobs (Rhodes 2019). Due to the ever-growing population across the UK and the rest of the
world, there has been an increasing argument for the countries housing shortage and the
unavailability of homes needed at an affordable price for first time buyers and young families. These
current challenges are creating pressure on house builders to change the way in how builders develop
(Zandari & Hashemi 2017).
In 2014, UK house prices were valued at the second highest in the world when measured at a price
per square meter (Hilber 2015). According to Marshall Recruitment (2019), the “price-to-income
Ofori-Kuragu and Hill, 2021
Proceedings of the CIB International Conference on Smart Built Environment, ICSBE 2021 2
multiplied by salary in the greater London area was around 8.5 times the average salary.
Furthermore, in the rest of the UK, property prices have increased as much as 5 times the average
income for a property. The UK house price growth over the past 40 years has increased faster than
any other Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development country (OECD) and has
outgrown earnings. This has consequently produced a housing affordability crisis. As well as the
increase in house prices throughout the UK, housing unit sizes in the UK are a considerable amount
smaller than in comparison with other European countries (Hilber 2015), with UK homes around
38% smaller than Germany and 40% smaller than in Netherlands (Statistics Sweden 2005). The
number of homes needed in England are up to 345,000 per year (Wilson & Barton 2020). Back in
2018/2019, the total number of homes in England increased by around 241,000 homes providing a
9% increase than the previous year, although still lower than the estimated quantity needed. The
current skills shortage in the sector is believed to be holding back efforts to resolve the housing crisis
and the number of homes that are built. With around 87% of construction companies looking to
expand production, around 100,000 vacancies, one in four (24%) of housebuilders explain that
finding skilled trades are becoming the largest challenge (Owen, 2015). Furthermore, the UK
workforce isn’t getting any younger with the Office for National Statistics (ONS) revealing that 20%
of construction workers are over fifty with 15% being over sixty (Marshall Recruitment 2019).
In this context, modular housing has been explored as a solution, with the government and the
construction industry suggesting that, modular homes could be the answer to resolving both the skills
shortage and housing shortage which the UK faces. It is expected that Modular homes will provide
cheaper housing options, whilst removing the need for large numbers of skilled workers due to units
being constructed in quality-controlled factories off-site. This paper explores the opportunities to use
modular construction solutions to address the housing deficit and the opportunities this will bring.
2.0 Literature Review
2.1 Modular Homes
Lopez & Froese (2016) define modular housing as housing that is partially built in a plant, shipped
to a development site, and placed on a foundation, where the roof structure and exterior finishes are
completed. This involves using pre-manufactured components constructed in a factory, consisting
of lightweight, load-bearing composite panels that are used to form the walls, ceilings and roofs of a
structure (Glenn Low 1987). Modular homes are cost effective when compared to conventional
homes due to being built in a factory environment that provides ideal production conditions
compared to site construction (Lindal 1982). Modular construction has established a strong market in
residential buildings due to the speed benefits, quality and cost savings that are achieved (Lawson
2010). This system of construction uses an inside out approach completing the interior surface,
electrical, plumbing, mechanical fixings before completing the exterior. This differs from the
traditional on-site assembly sequence constructing from the outside in (Ferver 1980).
Off-site construction, manufactured construction, off-site manufacturing and modern methods of
construction are all generic terms used interchangeably in extant literature to describe modular
construction (Goulding et al. 2012). The underlying idea involved in all these concepts is that some
activities relating to construction projects are moved away from the construction site into controlled
factory environments within manufacturing establishments (Jaillon & Poon 2010). These are
described in some literature as a panacea to the many problems associated with cost, time and quality
associated with traditional construction processes (Goulding et al. 2013).
Ofori-Kuragu and Hill, 2021
Proceedings of the CIB International Conference on Smart Built Environment, ICSBE 2021 3
Lynn (2017) opines that pre-manufactured homes provide a financial economical solution to the
housing crisis. This is because of the reduction in labour costs and materials. The ready-built factory
units reduce the need for the skilled trades and the materials wastage is heavily reduced due to
machines producing the sufficient amount of material needed.
Ofori-Kuragu and Osei Kyei (2021) projected that the future of construction lies in the development
of production-based systems which take the bulk of construction activity away from site into factory-
based environments. Design for Manufacture and Assembly (DfMA) and offsite construction present
an opportunity to achieve this using prefabricated and pre-manufactured component in factory
environments. These present many benefits including reduced costs, reduced time and higher quality
of completed projects. These premanufacturing techniques can be adapted to modular housing to
deliver the identified benefits.
2.2 UK’s housing affordability crisis
The UK is currently in a housing crisis and despite the rapid increase in housebuilding, the UK house
prices have grown by 160% since 1996 (Dmitracova 2019). Ferguson (2016) though states that the
average house price has increased significantly more risen to an extraordinary 281% across the UK
with statistics showing that London figures have increased a further 501% (Nationwide house price
index). The reason behind the increase in property value is down to the lack of available homes
therefore increasing the demand (Hall 2020). Hall (2020) goes on to explain that:
“When there is a high demand for a good or service, its price rises. If there is a large supply of a
good or service but not enough demand for it, the price falls”.
In 2014, UK house prices were the second highest in the world, only topped by Monaco with house
price growth increasing faster than any other OECD country (Hilber 2015). Since the late 1990’s, the
mortgage rates have tumbled with interest rates being fixed on a five-year-fixed-rate term. One of the
many issues causing the housing crisis is the average earnings to house cost ratio. Currently, the UK
house now costs almost eight times the average salary with banks and building societies typically
lending people a maximum of four and a half times individuals income (Chu 2018). Because of this,
the home ownership has slumped to 63% due to the soaring house prices relative to earnings
(Independent 2018).
Figure 1 2017 House prices to earnings (Marshall Recruitment, 2019)
Ofori-Kuragu and Hill, 2021
Proceedings of the CIB International Conference on Smart Built Environment, ICSBE 2021 4
2.3 UK’s Current skills shortage
Lloyds Banking Group believes that skills shortage and planning systems are preventing solutions
for the housing crisis. A severe shortage of skilled workers in the housebuilding industry are
hindering efforts to tackle the UK’s housing crisis (Flockhart 2016). It has been reported that the
current UK construction workforce is too small to meet with the UK Governments housing demands.
In 2017 the government had pledged to develop 300,000 new homes a year by 2020. A massive
concern to this is that RICS have confirmed that a shortfall in skilled construction workers in the UK
is currently at its highest point since 2007 (RICS 2019). According to the (CIOB) the industry must
employ over 150,000 new workers by 2021 in order to keep up with the demands from the
Government. Light (2017) disagrees by suggesting that Britain actually need a considerable amount
more estimating that around 400,000 people each year must be recruited providing an equivalent
statistic of one person every 77 seconds.
Approximately 87% of construction companies plan to increase their companies yet while all these
vacancies are becoming available, 24% of housebuilders have confirmed that finding the candidates
with the appropriate skills are becoming “the biggest challenge” (Owen 2015). It is evident that the
lack of skilled trades is causing huge disruptions to the housing shortage and that moving forwards,
the Government must invest into training schemes and apprenticeships to offset the reduced number
of skilled professionals in the industry.
2.4 Affordability of Modular housing
In recent years due to the industry unsuccessfully supplying enough homes to keep up with the
increase in population, a growing interest in the modular construction industry from both investors
and developers have been the main topic (Lopez & Froese 2016). Modular homes are offering
several benefits over traditional. Some of the advantages are a reduction in construction time due to
the units being constructed in a factory, high quality as the factories are quality controlled and
cheaper costs providing financial saving for suppliers and buyers reducing property prices.
Modular construction has long been developed and used in the construction industry within
residential as a means of a quicker production supply and a quicker turn around (Velamati 2012).
Mass production could allow new homes and apartments to be radically cheaper due to the design
behind modular construction (Barnett 2018). Some experts believe factory-built properties could
resolve the housing crisis due to mass production opportunities and better quality control provided by
factory conditions.
2.5 Modular Construction impacts on skills shortage and productivity
Modular housing can address the skills shortage and tackle the domestic sector (Sean et al. 2015).
The UK have an ageing workforce with 12% of construction workers under the age of 24. With the
lack of skilled workers in the industry and the lack of skilled trades coming through the
apprenticeship scheme, the means for modular housing will help solve the UK’s skills shortage. The
Government in 2015 expressed concerns about the lack of training stating that, “structure of industry
training is not sufficient to deliver the skilled workforce required to build enough adequate housing”
(Wilson & Barton 2020).
Ofori-Kuragu and Hill, 2021
Proceedings of the CIB International Conference on Smart Built Environment, ICSBE 2021 5
Modular construction will reduce the need for large amounts of skilled trades and will provide a
lower skill demand due to houses being factory built. Traditional methods of construction will
demand a high number of onsite skills that the industry lack although by transferring to modular
methods of construction, 90% of activities will be completed prior to site delivery. Off-site
manufacturing can attract and develop non-skilled resources throughout the industry without relying
on limited skilled resources (KPMG 2016). In addition, modular construction will address the skills
shortage and allow the government and developers to continue developing the despite the increase in
the skills shortage. Off-site construction will speed up the delivery of new homes and will allow
projects to be delivered on time or earlier by around 50% (Construction news 2016). There is
evidence to suggest that schedules can be saved by almost 60% when comparing to traditional
methods of construction.
Banks et al. (2018) presents a 40-storey mixed-use development in central London, UK which
successfully employed the principles of DfMA across all engineering disciplines for the project. In
this project, the delivery team developed effective off-site construction solutions across the entire
project including the superstructure, facades, bathrooms and mechanical and electrical services.
These were all designed, coordinated and facilitated using DfMA through advanced digital
engineering and building information modelling techniques. According to Banks et al. (2018), the
project was delivered with reduced programme and cost with an improved safety record, higher
quality and reliability in a more sustainable way through reduced vehicle movements and a greater
efficiency in the management of site logistics.
2.6 Limitations of Modular Construction
Modular homes are designed, manufactured and preassembled off-site before being transported to its
final location (Warszawski1999). Although modular construction comes with many benefits there are
also limitations and disadvantages. Taylor (2010) explains that modular homes are limited when
creating the floor plan because of transportation from the factory to site. Modular homes have a
width of no more than 14 to 16 feet although can be 60 to 70 feet in length (Warszawski 1999).
Taylor (2010) goes on to suggest that it’s not feasible to deliver the modular homes very far due to
the road size restrictions. Due to delivery playing a key role into transporting the modular home to its
final location, contractors must consider transport limitations. These limitations can be time delays,
permits needed due to oversize vehicles, and dimensional limitations.
Golawski (2018) points out that there are no design limitations preventing modular methods although
KPMG (2016) argues against this by suggesting that modular methods will only provide a limited
number of materials and layouts because of factory mass production. Gassett (2015) agrees by
confirming that modular homes lack customisation, and that design is limited. Project planning is
another key factor producing yet another limitation. Sites in Japan, USA and Sweden have come
across problems where clients would like to apply a variation in the scope of works and unlike
traditional, modular construction has proven to be much more difficult when alterations are need
(Kamali & Hewage 2016). Kamali & Hewage (2016) argue that modular homes provide a high initial
cost and that although this method of construction is cheaper, a considerable amount of capital is
initially needed when purchasing these products. This is because modular homes completed in a
factory and transported to their final destinations demand an upfront cost before purchase.
Ofori-Kuragu and Hill, 2021
Proceedings of the CIB International Conference on Smart Built Environment, ICSBE 2021 6
3.0 Research Methodology
This paper is based on a detailed review, critique and analysis of contemporary literature on the
subject. This literature review was based on industry reports, academic journals and scholarly reports
that provided the secondary data (Naoum 2013) and also a basis for the development of the survey
instrument. Following the review, a questionnaire-based survey was used to collate views of industry
stakeholders in relation to modular construction. The survey helped to collect views of respondents
on the issues arising from the review. It helped to better understand their perspectives on how the UK
could move towards an increased use of modular approaches in housing and its potential to resolve
the UKs housing crisis. Owing to the prevailing restrictions on movement at the time of the survey,
questionnaires were administered online using a survey tool called Sogosurvey. This online platform
allowed the dissemination of questionnaires to respondents and their collation once completed. The
results were presented using tables and charts developed with Microsoft Excel.
4.0 Findings and Discussion
The review of literature for this paper shows a rising housing deficit in the UK despite increased
housebuilding (Dmitracova 2019). Whilst many factors may be responsible for this, the high and
rising building costs, as acknowledged by Ferguson (2016); Hilber (2015), is a significant
contributor to low home-ownership rates resulting in a rising housing deficit. Addressing home
ownership costs will this bring the housing deficit. Evidence from the review confirmed that the
many acknowledged benefits of modular construction would enhance the application of modular
approaches in housing developments. Amongst the many benefits included speed of construction,
reduced costs, quality of construction and reduced life-cycle costs ((Lawson 2010) which can be
applied to modular housing. Other benefits of premanufactured housing development include the
affordability of homes (Barnett 2018), quick production and short turnaround times (Velamati 2012).
Despite the proven benefits, there are limitations associated with their use such as higher initial costs
(Kamali and Hewage 2016), industry aversion to and negative perceptions associated with the
technology (Gassett 2015), constraints arising from transporting large modular units (Warszawski
1999) among other factors.
The field survey results provide some insights into the low uptake of modular approaches. A total of
70 questionnaires were sent out with 56 responses providing an 80% feedback response. All the data
was collected and analysed using simple statistical analysis. Respondents in the survey consisted of
7% Architects, 21% Surveyors, 7% Designers, 9% Project Managers, 5% Company Directors, 2%
Planners, 5% Estimators, 13% Site Managers, 7% Contract Managers, 20% Contractors and 4%
Clerk of Works. The results show that the most common sector represented by respondents to the
survey were individuals that worked within commercial establishments in the construction industry
with a percentage of 46%. The data received also indicated that the majority worked for main
contractors with a figure showing of 54%.
Of the respondents, 5% had a master’s degree, with a further 9% achieving a professional
qualification. 37% achieved a bachelor’s degree, 21% gained an HND/HNC, 7% achieving A-levels
and 19% completing a City and Guilds. Generally, therefore, the respondents comprised of a high
proportion of professional level industry stakeholders with a good level of professional and technical
knowledge of construction. The results also showed that 45% “strongly agreed” or “agreed” with
modular construction having a good potential to become an alternative to conventional building
methods with 30% disagreeing whilst 25% were unsure. This generally is in line with trends from
literature which show a potential for modular building to become the mainstream approach to
construction as argued in Ofori-Kuragu and Osei-Kyei 2021. However, the results also show that
Ofori-Kuragu and Hill, 2021
Proceedings of the CIB International Conference on Smart Built Environment, ICSBE 2021 7
whilst a majority see the many benefits of modular housing solutions, the proportion of stakeholders
in the industry who are yet to be convinced of these benefits is still significant. This can be explained
by the limitations identified from literature as inhibiting the uptake of modular approaches and
provides the possible reasoning for the trends in results.
On the potential benefits of modular solutions in the housing sector, 29% of respondents suggested
that the overall speed of constructing the homes would increase providing better production levels. A
further 25% believed that the materials used in modular homes are more eco-friendly, with another
20% opining that waste reduction levels would be significantly reduced as pods and other
premanufactured modular home units are built in controlled environments. 16% explained that
transportation emissions would be reduced due to majority of materials used being from one factory.
The remaining 10% of respondents highlighted the thermal insulation benefits that modular would
bring to the industry. There is an overall acknowledgement of the benefits in line with literature such
as Lawson (2010). However, the small relative percentages of those endorsing the identified benefits
further reinforce the current levels of hesitancy in relation to the uptake of offsite techniques in the
reviewed literature such as Kamali and Hewage (2016); Gassett (2015) and KPMG (2016). This
demonstrates that additional sensitisation and education for industry stakeholders on the potential
benefits of modular techniques would help increase levels of awareness and encourage the uptake of
these approaches. On the prospects of modular housing becoming the mainstream method of
construction in the housing sector in the future, 50% of respondents agreed with the prospect with
18% disagreeing as shown in figure 2. This shows that whilst a larger overall percentage of
respondents see the potential imminent increase in the adoption of in modular solutions in housing,
this is not necessarily backed up by an awareness of potential or proven benefits. The knowledge gap
relative to the potential benefits of modular housing appears to be the major reason for the low levels
of responses to questions on benefits and uptake.
Figure 2 Potential of Modular Housing as Main Approach to Housing Development
The overall outcomes of the review in this paper and the survey of industry professionals shows the
potential of modular approaches to deliver quality housing faster and cheaper amongst other benefits.
This has a potential to address the high housing deficit in the UK by producing more affordable
homes. The survey shows a general appreciation of these benefits associated with modular home
construction however the results show low levels of appreciation of these benefits. The high start-up
costs associated with modular home production is also an issue that needs addressing.
Ofori-Kuragu and Hill, 2021
Proceedings of the CIB International Conference on Smart Built Environment, ICSBE 2021 8
5.0 Conclusions and Further Research
This study revealed that one of the main issues within the UK housing sector is the lack of adequate
new and affordable developments. The housing crisis affects an estimated 8.4 million people in
England alone. Due to a lack of sustained investment in apprenticeships over the last 20 years,
contractors face acute skills trades shortages. These factors, amongst others, contribute to the current
housing deficit in the UK. This paper explored the potential of modular housing to address this.
The paper identified benefits of modular housing to include speed of construction, eco-friendlier
materials, waste reduction and reduced CO2 emissions from construction processes and from
reduced transportation. The study also identified modular homes as having the potential to provide
cheaper housing options. Reduced maintenance requirements also reduced life-cycle costs however
traditional housing was seen as having a longer lifespan. Despite the acknowledged benefits and the
opportunities presented by modular housing solutions, the numbers of respondents whose responses
demonstrate an awareness of the potential and the benefits of modular solutions in housing are
relatively low. This points to a low level of awareness of the potential benefits that modular solutions
offer and a weak understanding of the associated benefits. Industry-wide educational efforts in this
regard will be beneficial.
Further work could explore innovative ways to enhance awareness within the industry of modular
housing and the opportunities the approach brings. Further research could also investigate the costs
associated with contractors establishing their own manufacturing facilities as a means to reducing the
time and costs for offsite manufacture of construction components. Research could also explore the
potential of increased integration of Value Engineering and Building Information Modelling (BIM)
into modular house building and the evaluate the potential benefits.
6.0 References
Banks C., Kotecha, R., Curtis, J., Dee, C., Pitt, N., and Papworth, R. (2018) Enhancing high-rise
residential construction through design for manufacture and assemblya UK case study
Proceedings of Inst of Civil Engineers Management, Procurement & Law 2018 pp.171-194
Chu, B., 2018. UK houses now cost almost eight times average earnings, says ONS. The
Independent 26th April 2018 London
Dmitracova, O., 2019. Building more homes won’t solve UK housing crisis, new report argues.
[Online] Available at: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/uk-housing-crisis-rent-
price-new-build-a9071731.html
Department for Communities and local Government., 2017. Fixing our broken housing market.
Department for Communities and local Government London
Department for Communities and Local Government., 2015. Land value estimates for policy
Department for Communities and Local Government London
Ferver, W.G., 1980. Modular homes. [Online] Available at:
https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/e4/73/96/6566eae767ee73/US4222208.pdf
Glenn Low, R., 1987. Modular construction system. [Online] Available at:
https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/ec/4b/4d/03bf78cd614639/US4712352.pdf
Ofori-Kuragu and Hill, 2021
Proceedings of the CIB International Conference on Smart Built Environment, ICSBE 2021 9
Goulding J.S, Arif M, Pour-Rahimian F, and Sharp M.D (2013) Offsite Construction: Sustainable
Innovation Futures Using SMART Approaches Proceedings of the CIB World Building Congress,
Construction and Society Conference held from the 5th 9th May 2013 in Brisbane, Australia
Goulding, J., Rahimian, Farzad Pour, Arif, M and Sharp, M (2012) Offsite Construction: Strategic
Priorities for Shaping the Future Research Agenda Architectoni.ca 2012, 1, pp. 62-73
Hilber, C., 2015. UK Housing and Planning Policies: the evidence from economic research. Centre
for Economic Performance London School of Economics and Political Science London
Hall, M., 2020. How does supply and demand affect the housing market? [Online] Available at:
https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/040215/how-does-law-supply-and-demand-affect-
housing-market.asp
Hashemi, A., 2017. Prefabrication in the UK Housing Construction Industry. Proceedings of 5th
International Conference on Zero Energy Mass Customised Housing - ZEMCH 2016 20th - 23rd
December 2016, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Jaillon Lara & Poon, ChiSun (2010) Design issues of using prefabrication in Hong Kong
Construction Management & Economics, 28:10, pp.1025-1042
Johnson, W., 2007. Lessons from Japan: A comparative study of the market drivers for
prefabrication in Japanese and UK private housing development MSc Thesis presented to the
University college London London
Kamali, M; Hewage, K., 2016 Life cycle performance of modular buildings: a critical review
Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews
Kenton, W., 2019. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). [Online]
Available at: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/o/oecd.asp
KPMG,2016. Smart Construction- How offsite manufacturing can transform industry KPMG
London
Lawson, R.M., 2010. Sustainability and Process Benefits of Modular Construction. Proceedings
TG57 - Special Track 18th CIB World Building Congress May 2010 Salford, United Kingdom
Lawson, M. Ogden, RG., 2014. Design in modular construction. Taylor and Francis Florida
Lindal, W., 1982. Modular home construction. [Online] Available at:
https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/a9/8a/24/260ce7177928b7/US4512120.pdf
Lynn, A., 2017. Is modular housing really cheaper? [Online] Available at:
https://www.developmentfinancetoday.co.uk/article-desc-5393_is-modular-housing-really-cheaper
Accessed: 20th May 2021
Marshal Recruitment, 2019. What is Causing a Construction Skills Shortage? [Online] Available
at: https://marshall-recruitment.co.uk/construction-skills-shortage/ Accessed: 20th May 2021
Morgan Sindall., 2020. Modular Construction in 2020:Have we reached a tipping point?Available at:
https://construction.morgansindall.com/sites/default/files/downloads/Modular%20Construction%20-
%20Oxford%20Roundtable%20FINAL.pdf Accessed: 15th March 2021
Ofori-Kuragu and Hill, 2021
Proceedings of the CIB International Conference on Smart Built Environment, ICSBE 2021 10
Ofori-Kuragu and Osei-Kyei 2021 Mainstreaming pre-manufactured offsite processes in
construction are we nearly there Construction Innovation Volume 21 Issue 4 February 2021
Oliveira, S., Burch, J., 2017. Making Modular Stack up: Modern Methods of Construction in Social
housing. Centre for Architecture and Built Environment Research, Department of Architecture and
the Built Environment, University of the West of England Bristol
Owen, J., 2015. Shortage of skilled workers holding back efforts to tackle Britain’s housing crisis.
[Online] Available at: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/shortage-of-skilled-
workers-holding-back-efforts-to-tackle-britain-s-housing-crisis-10509296.html
Pinsent Masons., 2017. Modular Construction in UK Housing. Pinsent Masons London
Rhodes, C., 2019. Construction industry statistics and policy. Briefing paper Number 01432. UK
Parliament London
Ruddick, G., 2015. Housebuilders sitting on 6000,000 plots of land. 30th December 2015 The
Guardian London
Sean, R. S., Wood, J.B. and Hairstans, R (2015) Increasing need for Offsite Construction and
Manufactured Infrastructure in the UK Economy Proceedings of CIAT Symposium Held in London
in Dec. 2015
Steidle, J., 2019. Time and Cost Efficiency for Modular Construction. [Online] Available at:
http://cic.org.uk/news/article.php?s=2019-11-18-time-and-cost-efficiency-for-modular-construction
Accessed 30th April 2021
Taylor, Mark D (2010) A definition and valuation of the UK offsite construction sector,
Construction Management and Economics, 28:8, pp. 885-896
Telford, W., 2019. UK’s £5bn construction industry under threat from lack of workers. [Online]
Available at: https://www.business-live.co.uk/commercial-property/uks-5bn-construction-industry-
under-16807053 Accessed 25th April 2021
The Guardian., 2019. Can modular homes solve the UK’s housing crisis? [Online] Available at:
https://www.theguardian.com/music/2019/aug/06/flatpacked-homes-can-modular-buildings-solve-
the-uks-housing-crisis
Wainwright, O., 2017. Britain has enough land to solve the housing crisis it’s just being hoarded.
The Guardian 31st January 2017 London
Wilson, W & Barton, C., 2020. Tackling the under-supply of housing in England. Briefing Paper
Number 07671 UK Parliament London
Warszawski, A. (1999) Industrialized and Automated Building Systems: A Managerial Approach,
2nd edn, Taylor & Francis, Oxford
Willmott Dixon., 2020. Off-site manufacturing. Factory assembly of key project elements means
faster deliver and better quality. [Online] Available at:
https://www.willmottdixon.co.uk/expertise/off-site-manufacturing Accessed 31st Oct. 202
... Lagos State can address its housing shortage by adopting modular housing. Several nations (like Australia, Germany, Korea, Sweden, the UK, the US, and Japan) have successfully adopted modular housing to solve housing crises, thus making housing affordable for different classes of their citizens (Ferdous et al., 2019;Ofori-Kuragu and Hill, 2021;Mckeever, 2024). Though it should be acknowledged that modular housing is not a silver bullet, it is a scalable and cost-effective option that is particularly well-suited for renters and buyers on a tight budget (Wates, 2024;Bunch, 2024). ...
Article
Full-text available
Housing affordability has long been a concern primarily for low-income earners, but increasingly, it affects even middle-income earners, especially in urban locations like Lagos State. Modular homes appear to be a promising housing option, considering their attributes. Therefore, this study was undertaken to find out how Estate Surveyors and Valuers (ESVs) in Lagos State, Nigeria, perceive the qualities of modular housing that could enhance housing affordability. Quantitative research using a questionnaire survey was carried out. One hundred copies of the questionnaire were administered, and 75% were found useful for analysis. The data was analysed using the mean, percentages and relative importance index (RII). The outcome of the analysis showed that respondents agreed that modular housing attributes such as time-saving, reduces waste and high energy efficiency standards, among others promote affordable housing. Moreover, the study revealed that there are five major challenges to the adoption of modular homes for affordable housing, namely: regulatory requirements (mean = 4.813), resistance in the construction industry to investing in technologies for building modular homes (mean = 4.027), lack of knowledge (mean = 4.013), scepticism about the durability of modular housing (mean = 3.907), and a limited number of modular housing manufacturers and suppliers (mean = 3.907). It was therefore suggested that the government should amend the pertinent laws and building rules to make regulatory requirements an enabler, and professional associations should put in place extensive training programmes and awareness campaigns to curb the challenges of lack of knowledge and scepticism about the durability of modular housing.
... The methodological approach accentuated by Ofori-Kuragu & Hill, (2021) and Assaad et al., (2023) is the OSC approach, based on the capacity of OSC approach to overcome some challenges of BFS such as long project duration, disturbance to remediated site, and difficulty to access and navigate the site. The possibility of this measure is in the capacity of OSC approach to adapt to peculiar constraining site conditions, commence manufacturing of building components in the factory while site remediation is ongoing to save time, fewer workers on site and less onsite activities (Gao et al., 2020;Ofori-Kuragu & Hill, 2021). ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The housing shortage in the UK has remained a prevalent and pressing issue, prompting a need for innovative and sustainable solutions. One contributing factor to this is limited availability of land, including brownfields sites. The offsite construction (OSC) approach has been recognized as a viable and eco-friendly solution to addressing the issue, yet its potential on brownfield site (BFS) remains largely unexplored. Prior research of literature suggested that integrating OSC on brownfield site has the capacity to support housing supply , while addressing some of the challenges of developing on BFS. A focus group discussion was conducted to establish industry opinion on the factors militating against the wide adoption of OSC approach on BFS for housing development despite the promises both concepts hold to support sustainable housing delivery. The study found that the UK government actively promotes BFS redevelopments and OSC approach to achieve sustainability goals, protect the greenbelt, and mitigate the housing crisis through policy and financial instruments. The study further grouped the findings of adopting OSC approach on BFS under process, human impact and sustainability. The result contributes to the literature by promoting the integration of OSC approach and BFS development and offer valuable insights for policymakers on the efficiency and effectiveness of government support instruments in relation to OSC and BFS for sustainable housing solutions.
Article
Full-text available
Modular homes appear to be a promising housing option that keeps pace with the rapid rate of urbanisation, especially in growing cities like Lagos. Consequently, this study investigates how professionals in the built environment perceive modular homes, with an emphasis on how they could be a potential solution to the deficit of housing in Lagos State, Nigeria. The primary goals are to navigate the multifaceted aspects of modular housing, examine its merits, identify barriers to its adoption, and gauge its feasibility in the Nigerian context. To achieve these, 200 questionnaires were disseminated among professionals in the built environment in Lagos, and 147 (73.5%) were returned. Descriptive and inferential statistics were used for data analysis. Key findings revealed that modular housing, due to its rapid construction timelines, is a time-efficient solution. However, concerns about initial investment costs and design flexibility emerged as potential barriers to adoption. There is also a clear acknowledgement of the environmental benefits of modular housing, with reduced construction waste indicating its sustainability. Factor analysis is pivotal for revealing deeper insights. For instance, respondents' lack of in-depth knowledge about modular housing was a primary barrier, accounting for 62.67% of the variance. Similarly, advocacy for modular housing was seen as a significant strategy for its adoption, with 52.38% variability. However, challenges remain. A predominant belief among respondents is that modular homes might be inferior in quality to homes built using traditional construction methods. Furthermore, bureaucratic hurdles in obtaining permits could deter investors and developers from undertaking modular housing projects. In conclusion, although modular housing offers a beacon of hope for solving mass housing problems in burgeoning cities like Lagos, clear challenges remain. This study recommends more vigorous advocacy efforts, targeted government intervention, and robust public-private partnerships.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose: The purpose of the paper is to explore the current state of popular Modern Methods of Construction (MMC) and premanufactured construction in the construction industry and propose a framework for future implications for practice and future research. Methodology / approach: This technical paper is based on a narrative review of extant literature on the subject. First the Scopus search engine was used to retrieve relevant papers on MMC, offsite and premanufactured construction. Secondly, institutional literature such as reports by industry professional and trade bodies, literature from leading technology firms and contractors with experience of MMC were extracted. These two strands of literature were synthesized and a comprehensive discussion on the topic was provided. Findings: Results show that journal publications on MMC and premanufactured construction have increased in the last decade. The paper found significant advances in the development of pre-manufactured and offsite construction approaches with many benefits. Offsite and premanufactured construction are viable and sustainable systems currently suitable for wider adoption as the mainstream construction method. Originality: Not much published work has been undertaken on the current state of development globally and the viability of these construction approaches. This paper evaluates evidence from academic and industry sources to address this gap. A framework has been developed which can help the industry’s industrialization drive. Research limitations: This technical paper based on an integrative review of relevant literature could have benefited from interviews of professionals with experience of offsite and premanufacture techniques and from a wider availability of current academic publications on the subject. Validation of the framework has not been undertaken.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
This paper aims to explore how prefabricated methods of construction could address housing shortages in the UK. The available literature is reviewed to evaluate current conditions of housing as well as prefabricated methods of construction in the UK. Advantages and limitations of prefabrication are investigated and discussed in relation to the current conditions. Interviews are also conducted as well as case studies in order to understand the challenges and to provide first hand information on current industry practises in the UK housing construction industry. Findings indicate that although offsite construction is widely known and acknowledged, there is little encouragement and incentives to maximise the use of prefabrication in the UK. Extra costs, larger lead time and engineering issues are found to be the key factors preventing the innovative processes of prefabricated construction in the UK’s residential sector.
Article
Full-text available
The offsite construction sector is now established as a significant contributor to the delivery of UK construction industry output. The exact value of this contribution is questionable and has been subject to substantial debate in recent literature. Existing offsite construction sector valuation methodologies have been based upon market research questionnaires and estimates of turnover and manufacturing output. Considerable attention has been given to the definition of the terms used to describe the various constituent technologies and manufacturing processes. However there has been limited reference to its size, sector classification, employment statistics and value added to the UK gross domestic output. A method is presented for the determination of the UK offsite construction sector gross output and value added. Historical data for the period 1998 to 2008 with growth forecasts up to 2013 are offered. A breakdown of the sector, examining the common standard industrial activity classification codes (SIC), the gross output and value added for each sub-sector is provided. The results show that there has been significant underestimation of the gross output and value added when compared to previous studies. An understanding of the broad and diverse nature of the offsite construction sector is provided with data that demonstrate an overview of the sector's historical performance. The data will assist government and industry in benchmarking, market research and forecasting the further growth and diffusion of offsite construction techniques.
Book
Industrialized and Automated Building Systems presents a detailed and balanced evaluation of the benefits and drawbacks of industrialized building systems, and considers technological, managerial and economical aspects of industrialization, automation in the industrialized building process in production, construction and design, and information technologies in design, production and construction on site.
Article
UK Government and construction industry advisors are becoming ever more interested in increasing the use of offsite modern methods of construction (MMC) within the private housing sector as a solution to current quality and efficiency problems. However, industry uptake remains below that of many countries with comparable economies, with UK housebuilders seemingly reluctant to invest in innovative building technologies. The Japanese private housing sector, on the other hand, paints a very different story, with prefabricated housing manufacturers dominating a significant proportion of the housing market. After an introduction to the key themes, this report will explore the drivers for offsite fabrication in the Japanese housing market, paying particular attention to building cycles and prevailing development systems, the cultural preference for new-build houses, attitudes towards land ownership and the demand for customised dwellings. Next, the report will investigate the major drivers for innovation in the UK housebuilding industry, focusing on Government reports and initiatives that promote offsite MMC, perceived advantages and barriers for greater uptake within the construction industry, and strategies used by the housebuilding industry to minimise market and site-specific risk in the emerging market environment. The final chapter will discuss the applicability of the Japanese model of prefabricated housing manufacture in the UK context, highlighting some possible crossover benefits and making some suggestions as to how these can be realised.
Enhancing high-rise residential construction through design for manufacture and assembly-a UK case study Proceedings of Inst of Civil Engineers Management
  • C Banks
  • R Kotecha
  • J Curtis
  • C Dee
  • N Pitt
  • R Papworth
Banks C., Kotecha, R., Curtis, J., Dee, C., Pitt, N., and Papworth, R. (2018) Enhancing high-rise residential construction through design for manufacture and assembly-a UK case study Proceedings of Inst of Civil Engineers Management, Procurement & Law 2018 pp.171-194
UK houses now cost almost eight times average earnings, says ONS. The Independent 26 th
  • B Chu
Chu, B., 2018. UK houses now cost almost eight times average earnings, says ONS. The Independent 26 th April 2018 London
Building more homes won't solve UK housing crisis
  • O Dmitracova
Dmitracova, O., 2019. Building more homes won't solve UK housing crisis, new report argues.
Modular construction system
  • Glenn Low
Glenn Low, R., 1987. Modular construction system. [Online] Available at: https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/ec/4b/4d/03bf78cd614639/US4712352.pdf
UK Housing and Planning Policies: the evidence from economic research. Centre for Economic Performance London School of Economics and Political Science London Hall, M., 2020. How does supply and demand affect the housing market?
  • C Hilber
Hilber, C., 2015. UK Housing and Planning Policies: the evidence from economic research. Centre for Economic Performance London School of Economics and Political Science London Hall, M., 2020. How does supply and demand affect the housing market? [Online] Available at: https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/040215/how-does-law-supply-and-demand-affecthousing-market.asp