ArticlePDF Available

Rewiring Puerto Rico: Power and Empowerment after Hurricane Maria

Authors:

Abstract

The 2017 Atlantic Hurricane Season brought forth multiple storms that not only stripped trees bare and dismounted roofs, but it also caught the Caribbean and Gulf Coast unprepared for the magnitude of destruction that such storms could bring, despite the best efforts of the messengers. Nearly half a year after the last hurricane season and half a year away from the onset of the next one, stories about the damage that Hurricane Irma and Maria caused have become hauntingly familiar. The stories less often told, though, are those about the long-term recovery efforts that have inevitably followed since the seas have calmed and the winds have died down.
!
[Pick!the!date]!
!
[Type!the!document!subtitle]!|!user!
!
Lily Bui
Rewiring Puerto Rico: Power and
Empowerment after Hurricane Maria
__________________________________________________________!
Alternautas is a peer reviewed academic journal that publishes content related to
Latin American Critical Development Thinking.
It intends to serve as a platform for testing, circulating, and debating new ideas
and reflections on these topics, expanding beyond the geographical, cultural and
linguistic boundaries of Latin America - Abya Yala. We hope to contribute to
connecting ideas, and to provide a space for intellectual exchange and
discussion for a nascent academic community of scholars, devoted to counter-
balancing mainstream understandings of development.
_________________________________________________________________!
!
How!to!cite:!
Bui!Lily.!(2018),!Rewiring!Puerto!Rico:!Power!and!Empowerment!after!Hurricane!
Maria.!!Alternautas,+5(2),!66-78.!URL!:!!
http://www.alternautas.net/blog/2018/10/29/rewiring-puerto-rico-power-and-
empowerment-after-hurricane-maria!
!
Editor!:!Alternautas!
http://www.alternautas.net!
London, UK.
ISSN - 2057-4924!
ALTERNAUTAS
(Re)Searching Development: The Abya Yala Chapter
Vol.5 – Issue 2 [December 2018]
ISSN - 2057-4924
Rewiring PR: Power and Empowerment after Hurricane Maria | 66
LILY BUI 1
Rewiring Puerto Rico: Power and
Empowerment after Hurricane Maria 2
Disasters unravel--infrastructures, institutions, societies, and assumptions. The 2017
Atlantic Hurricane Season brought forth multiple storms that not only stripped trees
bare and dismounted roofs, but it also caught the Caribbean and Gulf Coast
unprepared for the magnitude of destruction that such storms could bring, despite
the best efforts of the messengers. Nearly half a year after the last hurricane season
and half a year away from the onset of the next one, stories about the damage that
Hurricane Irma and Maria caused have become hauntingly familiar. The stories less
often told, though, are those about the long-term recovery efforts that have inevitably
followed since the seas have calmed and the winds have died down.
In Puerto Rico, Hurricane Maria decimated the electrical grid, leading to subsequent
failure of telecommunications systems, water filtration plants, emergency services,
and economic activity. Millions of people lived without power--some for days, others
for weeks, and the majority for months--and were left to rewire, arms outstretched in
the dark. But Puerto Rico’s rewiring encompasses more than just restoring its
generators, and it extends beyond the reach of transmission and distribution lines.
Hurricane Maria’s sobering effects on its energy sector have demanded serious
reflection on behalf of policymakers, communities, NGOs, universities, and the
private companies to challenge pre-hurricane energy systems, regulatory frameworks,

1 LILY BUI is a PhD candidate at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Department of
Urban Studies & Planning. Her research focuses on disaster risk reduction planning in island
communities.
2 This article was originally published in http://www.alternautas.net/blog/2018/10/29/rewiring-
puerto-rico-power-and-empowerment-after-hurricane-maria on October 29th, 2018.
67 | ALTERNAUTAS 5 (2) DECEMBER 2018
ownership models, and financing mechanisms. While there is consensus that the grid
infrastructure was aging and in disrepair before Hurricane Maria even hit (Koerth-
Baker, 2017), and that it should be made more resilient for the future (Heister &
Echenique, 2017; New York Power Authority, 2017), there is far less agreement
around how to do it, amongst competing motivations and value systems imbricating
actors within the energy stakeholder pool. The impulse to rebuild infrastructure has
come in tandem with the need to attract new capital to the island, motivating the
current state government to pursue a strategy to privatize the electric utility over the
next year and a half (Letter to FOMB, 2018). In no simple terms, this strategy has
been met with frenetic reactions, ranging from rejection to rapport.
However, in order to understand Puerto Rico’s process of rewiring, one must also
understand its complex (and rather circuitous) history of privatized utilities (Ayala,
2007). Further, in order to understand the restoration of the islands’ power in the
electrical sense, one must also understand the islands’ constitutions of power in the
political sense--namely, the ways in which the very processes meant to direct recovery
and healing can disempower individuals and groups. As a doctoral researcher who
studies disaster risk reduction planning on urbanized islands, I have found myself in
Puerto Rico multiples times both before and after the storm, over the course of the
past three years. The following article is motivated by the watershed moment that
Hurricane Maria has brought across all sectors in Puerto Rico, but most visibly,
energy. Here, I attempt to make sense of the dynamic and as-yet evolving social
processes behind the configuration of the future of Puerto Rico’s grid. Embedded
within these processes is a narrative that is as much about electrons as it is about
elections, charged with myriad intentions from all fronts. Who stands to gain and who
stands to lose from the decisions surrounding the grid’s reconstruction remains the
primary, paralysing set of questions.
Privatisation: now and then
In January 2018, Governor of Puerto Rico Ricardo Rosselló proposed a privatization
model for the Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority (PREPA):
Rewiring PR: Power and Empowerment after Hurricane Maria | 68
The Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority will cease to exist as it deficiently
operates today. Over the next few days the process will start, through which
PREPA assets will be sold to companies who will transform the generation
system into a modern, efficient, and less expensive one for the people (El
Nuevo Dia, 2017).
On June 21, 2018, the governor signed a bill to officially privatize PREPA and its
assets (Coto, 2018). As it stands, PREPA holds $9 billion (USD) in debt to its
bondholders (Williams-Walsh, 2017). Rosselló’s plan is a direct reaction to a pre-
hurricane effort to restructure the utility’s debt as well as the need to repair the grid
after Hurricane Maria with otherwise unavailable capital. It includes a two-pronged
approach: (i) selling generation assets to private investors and offering a concession
for a single private operator for transmission and distribution; and (ii) combining the
three commissions that currently make up Puerto Rico’s regulatory board: Puerto
Rico Energy Commission (PREC), the Public Service Commission for fuel and
transportation, and the Telecommunications Regulatory Board (Williams-Walsh,
2017). This means that PREPA’s currently vertically integrated electric utility would
be broken up, sold to, and eventually managed by various actors. In addition, instead
of having a dedicated energy regulator to oversee the operations and management of
the electric utility, these responsibilities would fall on a single regulator for multiple
utilities. The Puerto Rico Oversight and Management Board (PROMESA)3 supports
this move, indicating that privatization presents opportunities to modernize the grid,
reform pensions, and renegotiate labor and contracts. PROMESA was established by
a U.S. federal law to begin a process for restructuring Puerto Rico’s national debt.
Through PROMESA, the U.S. Congress established an appointed Fiscal Control
Board to oversee the debt restructuring (Biggs et al., 2017). As I will discuss later in
this article, the idea and ideology of privatization of utilities in Puerto Rico is not
novel in the slightest sense. However, the pain point is this: the announcement for

3 PROMESA was established by a U.S. federal law to begin a process for restructuring Puerto
Rico’s national debt. Through PROMESA, the U.S. Congress established an appointed Fiscal
Control Board to oversee the debt restructuring. See DeBonis, Mike (2016). "House passes
Puerto Rico fiscal rescue bill ahead of July cliff". The Washington Post.
69 | ALTERNAUTAS 5 (2) DECEMBER 2018
privatization seemingly came about without public hearing, participation, or much
transparency beforehand (Marxuach, 2018). Not only does lack of a public process
leave out key stakeholders such as PREPA’s labor unions and the electric utility’s
customers, it also reserves the visioning for a select group of actors behind closed
doors, straining attempts at cooperation (Merchant, 2018).
Being too quick to take a normative stance for or against the governor’s strategy solely
on the premise of privatization does not afford the space that the idea requires to take
history and context into account. Looking at the wider context of the relationship
between utilities and regulators elsewhere, as well as Puerto Rico’s past experiments
with privatization of other utilities, further enriches the story. First, regarding the
relationship between the utility and its regulator, PREPA was founded in 1941 as a
government-owned utility with a monopoly on electricity transmission and a near
monopoly on electricity generation (PREPA, n.d.; The Economist, 2017). As a result
of New Deal policies, state-managed utilities were commonplace at the time
(Tugwell, 1980). However, PREPA has essentially continued to regulate itself,
without an external regulating body, until 2014 when PREC was established by U.S.
Congressional Act No. 57, which stated the need to adopt “a regulatory and legal
framework through the creation of a robust independent entity that will ensure the
transformation of the electric power system of our Island for the benefit of present
and future generations” (S. No. 57-2014). Typically, public utilities commissions on
the United States mainland go hand in hand with the utilities themselves (Perez-
Arriaga, 2014). For example, in the State of Massachusetts, the Department of Public
Utilities oversees privately-owned utilities and makes critical regulatory decisions
such as long-term planning, changes in rates, and net metering. While the
relationship between utilities and their regulators is not always perfect, the
fundamental existence of regulators is rarely questioned. However, PREC’s very
recent establishment in Puerto Rico has undoubtedly introduced a player that was
not previously part of the ecosystem, inevitably resulting in tension. In addition, the
energy commission does not exist in a political vacuum: the president of PREC is
appointed by the governor, so perception of PREC is also shaped by partisan politics
(Puerto Rico Energy Commission, 2018).
Rewiring PR: Power and Empowerment after Hurricane Maria | 70
There is also a precedence for the privatization of public utilities on the islands. The
Puerto Rico Sewer & Aqueduct Authority (PRASA) faced financial crisis and water
quality issues in the 1990s. Declaring a state of emergency, Governor Pedro Rosselló
(the current governor’s father) created a strategy to privatize the water utility in order
to reduce the debt and deficit and increase efficiency (Cortina de Cardenas, 2011).
Consecutively, two private companies purchased and managed PRASA -- French
company Veolia, then Ondeo -- resulting in increased debt, deteriorating
relationships between PRASA and labor unions due to mismanagement of contracts,
and incidents of water pollution. The utility once again became publicly owned and
managed by PRASA in 2004, offering private contracts only for construction.
Similarly, in 1998, the Puerto Rican government privatized the Puerto Rico
Telephone Company (PRTC), the telecommunications utility, by selling it with twin
goals of reducing the debt and increasing efficiency in the growing wireless market
(Navarra, 1998).
Seemingly, the privatization of PRTC diversified the market for telecommunications
in Puerto Rico, and led to improved service quality (Brown & Respaut, 2017). Claro,
one of the wireless networks that emerged after the privatization of PRTC, and which
also has 26% of the market share, was one of the only companies with backup power
after Hurricane Maria made landfall and overall had faster recovery as a network than
other wireless networks. Looking at these two conflicting cases (i.e. PRASA and
PRTC), one can debunk the ideology of privatization as a panacea for debt reduction
and efficiency. The PRASA case demonstrates how privatization can be executed and
managed poorly. At the same time, the PRTC case indicates that immediate
resistance against privatization does not necessarily correlate with long-term
problems, either.
The question of renewables and alternative energy futures
The push for renewable energy alternatives has been both anticipatory of and
reactionary to an event like Hurricane Maria, a watershed moment for transition.
While public discourse about privatization privileges debate about ownership and
71 | ALTERNAUTAS 5 (2) DECEMBER 2018
regulatory models, the question of renewables (or not renewables) competes for
attention in the same vein. Currently, the majority of energy generation in Puerto
Rico comes from fossil fuels (petroleum, natural gas, and coal), with only 4.2% of its
energy generation coming from renewable sources like solar, wind, and hydroelectric
energy (Energy Transition Initiative, 2018). Researchers and professors within the
University of Puerto Rico (UPR) system have been lobbying for “distributed rooftop
photovoltaic systems, solar communities, and microgrids, combined with effective
demand response programs and energy storage” to push Puerto Rico toward
renewable energy alternatives since before Hurricane Maria (PaRes, 2018). To be
sure, renewables do not preclude privatization but the same group of researchers and
professors from the UPR hold firmly that replacement of fossil fuel-based generation,
if possible, would be successful if done so in sites that are “environmentally impacted
and where Puerto Rico has leverage to negotiate better agreements with private
investors.” As it stands, with a mainly fossil fuel-based grid, electricity rates in Puerto
Rico hover around an average of $0.24(USD)/kWh, below the Caribbean average of
$0.33(USD)/kWh but well above the U.S. mainland average of $0.13(USD)/kWh
(Energy Transition Initiative, 2018). Those pushing for renewables believe that less
dependence on fossil fuels can potentially be more cost-effective (Toussie & Dyson,
2018).
Several authors from the Professors Self-Assembled in Solidarity Resistance (PaRes)
at the University of Puerto Rico, in a public written testimony to PROMESA in
February 2018, proposed key ideas that might provide a path toward “sustainable
and resilient electric energy infrastructure,” among them, “no penalty to grid
defection” to prevent penalties that might be imposed to those who choose not to
consume energy through traditional means; transition to distributed energy” through
solar photovoltaic systems; and “transition to citizen-owned generation” in the form
of fairly regulated policy frameworks that allow for new ways to manage, operate, and
control the grid (Kantrow, 2017). Most importantly, the letter calls for the transition
toward sustainable energy to be a social process that includes public acceptance,
public participation, and public engagement. Given the existing anxieties about lack
of transparency in the process of privatization, stakeholders in the energy sector have
Rewiring PR: Power and Empowerment after Hurricane Maria | 72
created a space for dialogue. One such group that has organized opportunities to
engage diverse actors around the future of energy planning in Puerto Rico is the
National Institute of Island Energy and Sustainability (INESI), a “multidisciplinary
and multi-directional institute of the University of Puerto Rico that seeks to insert
the university community more effectively in the country's public energy policy and
in the resolution of energy and sustainability problems” (INESI, 2018). INESI has
organized various fora in which university actors and policymakers discuss past and
existing energy policies, as well as possible futures for the island’s grid reconstruction.
The forum invites participation from actors outside of Puerto Rico as well, including
researchers from universities on the U.S. mainland who specialize in energy and
planning.
Off-grid energy on the island, particularly for harder-to-reach, isolated communities
in the mountainous regions of Puerto Rico, has received attention after Hurricane
Maria. Casa Pueblo, a community-based organization that operates as a self-
supporting community center, has spearheaded solar energy initiatives both for its
own facilities and for small businesses where it is located in Adjuntas. The solar panels
played a significant role in post-Maria Puerto Rico, as they survived the wind and
falling debris from the hurricane. Because of this, Adjuntas was one of the first places
to restore power after the storm, meaning it was also able to restore critical services
like health care, radio communication, and charging stations (Klein, 2018).
IDEBAJO, a community-based environmental justice organization in Salinas,
promotes a similar vision of solar energy futures for Puerto Rico through Coqui Solar,
a project that seeks to turn Salinas into a solar-powered community by installing
photovoltaic panels on the Coqui Community Center (Llorens, 2018; IDEBAJO,
2018). Casa Pueblo and Coqui Solar have been active since before the hurricane, but
the storm provided a window of opportunity for raising awareness about the
resilience of renewable energy sources. They are also both exemplars of community
models of ownership in which the energy assets are owned and regulated by the
customers and members (O’Neill-Carrillo et al., 2017). Elsewhere, proposals for
community microgrid projects abound, surrounded by the rhetoric of resiliency
(Wernick, 2018; Roussie & Dyson, 2018). While reflective of the ideals of public
73 | ALTERNAUTAS 5 (2) DECEMBER 2018
participation and public engagement and progressive in their operationalization,
these models challenge the more top-down, centralized vision of the reconstruction
of the energy grid from players like PREC, PROMESA, and even PREPA. A wider
discussion about how (or whether) to integrate community solar and microgrid
technologies like those displayed by Casa Pueblo and Coqui Solar has not reached
crescendo. For certain, the road ahead toward a landscape in which renewables and a
privately owned electric utility can co-exist depends heavily on the ability of groups
like INESI continuing to push for dialogue and critical mass both on and off-island.
Privatization is not necessary to achieve sustainable energy goals, but given that
PREPA will inevitably become privatized by decree, Puerto Rico’s energy sector must
consider futures in which many renewable energy alternatives, like solar microgrids,
must operate alongside a privately owned electric utility – at least for now. What
must happen in tandem with planning for alternative energy resources – which
initiatives like Casa Pueblo and Coqui Solar are already doing -- is the development
of financing mechanisms, advocacy strategies, and diverse leadership for communities
to sustain potential alternative energy resources.
Electrification of Puerto Rico and the Caribbean
In summary, Puerto Rico has had a long relationship with privatization of its utilities.
This article seeks to contextualize the current discourse about privatization of PREPA
and its assets within a larger history. There are cases of privatization’s pitfalls as well
as its successes on the island. Second, it is worth noting that there is interest in
renewable energy on the island, most especially at the grassroots level. However,
challenges in capacity and political support have stalled efforts to move toward more
of the island’s energy production being from renewable sources, despite the
knowledge that renewables can be more resilient. Third, the uncertain fate of Puerto
Rico’s regulatory board for the island’s utilities impacts how the island and its people
can make decisions about its energy future.
Puerto Rico’s most recent disasters have daylighted problems that long existed before
the storms ever hit. However, in this critical period of recovery, the most important
Rewiring PR: Power and Empowerment after Hurricane Maria | 74
thing for Puerto Rico to do is to organize – at the top and bottom – to develop a
clear vision of the islands energy future, one that can be negotiated by as many
stakeholders as possible. These should include government entities, NGOs,
grassroots organizations, community leadership, PREPA, private energy companies,
local scientists, labor unions, universities, and more. The current state of the energy
sector is highly volatile and leads to short-term decision making, reduced consensus,
and high uncertainty in the market (Attar et al., 2018). It is also predicated upon key
principles of the neoliberal agenda, which offer few alternatives to the inevitable
privatization or capitalization of utilities. This agenda is currently being challenged
by smaller communities in Puerto Rico seeking alternatives to privatization with
more equitable ownership and distribution of energy resources in mind.
Beyond Puerto Rico, the future of energy in the Caribbean after the 2017 Atlantic
Hurricane Season is entangled in similar challenges regarding infrastructure,
reconstruction, and governance at local, regional, and national scales. The next
hurricane season could all too easily impact the energy systems in Antigua &
Barbuda, Cuba, Dominica, Haiti, the U.S. and British Virgin Islands, Montserrat,
Turks & Caicos, the Bahamas, Guadeloupe, St. Kitts & Nevis, St. Martin, the
Dominican Republic, and more. Caribbean utilities are heavily reliant on diesel and
have likewise struggled to create a regulatory and utility structure that will enable a
transition to cleaner energy. The reliance on diesel also creates a disincentive for
utilities to invest in renewables, since it would disrupt a pricing system based on fossil
fuels. Many vertically-integrated Caribbean utilities do not allow for independent
power producers to bid into the system (some of which include private companies),
a key mechanism for integrating renewable energy resources. Community solar
initiatives like the ones that have emerged in Puerto Rico point toward an energy
future that deviates from older models that rely on centralized grids and perhaps offer
an alternative to the Caribbean’s status quo.
Understanding what happened in Puerto Rico paints a picture of what could happen
again elsewhere in the region. It is important to acknowledge, too, that more than its
electrical grid is in disrepair. Similar problems of governance, financing, and equity
are reproduced across various sectors as the island rebuilds, among them: housing,
75 | ALTERNAUTAS 5 (2) DECEMBER 2018
forestry, tourism, healthcare, education, water, coastal management, and more. Yet,
the enduring spirit of Puerto Ricans is captured by a slogan that began to circulate
not long after the storm subsided: Puerto Rico se levanta. Puerto Rico will rise. In this
critical moment of rewiring comes an opportunity to bring ideas about innovative
approaches for resilience into light.
References
Attar, D., Beckwith, G., Chandra, N., Neuhoff, C. & Wiltberger, C. (2018). “Organizational
and Policy Needs for Microgrid Development in Puerto Rico Executive Summary.”
15.708 Global Organizations Lab: Puerto Rico Microgrids Project. MIT Sloan School
of Management.
Ayala, C. and Bernabe, R. (2007). Puerto Rico in the American Century: A History Since
1898. The University of North Caroline Press.
Biggs, Andrew G., Gonzalez, Arthur J., Matosantos, Ana J., & Skeel, David. (2017).
“Privatize Puerto Rico’s Power (Op-Ed).” Wall Street Journal. Available at:
https://www.wsj.com/articles/privatize-puerto-ricos-power-1498776904. Accessed 21
March 2018.
Brown, Nick, & Respaut, Robin. (2017). Puerto Ricans desperate for cell service turn to
Mexican carrier. Reuters. Avaialble at: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-
puertorico-slim/puerto-ricans-desperate-for-cell-service-turn-to-mexican-carrier-
idUSKCN1C7236. Accessed 21 March 2018.
Cortina de Cardenas, Susana Maria. (2011). Does private management lead to improvement
of water services? Lessons learned from the experiences of Bolivia and Puerto Rico
(Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Iowa, Iowa City. Available at:
https://ir.uiowa.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2326&context=etd. Accessed 21
March 2018.
Coto, Danica. (2018). “Puerto Rico gov. signs bill to privatize PREPA utility assets.” Electric
Light and Power. Available at: https://www.elp.com/articles/2018/06/puerto-rico-
gov-signs-bill-to-privatize-prepa-utility-assets.html. Accessed 31 August 2018.
Rewiring PR: Power and Empowerment after Hurricane Maria | 76
El Nuevo Dia. (2017). “Ricardo Rosselló announced a privatization model for PREPA.”
Available at:
https://www.elnuevodia.com/english/english/nota/ricardorosselloannouncedaprivatiz
ationmodelforprepa-2392103. Accessed 21 March 2018.
Energy Transition Initiative. (2017). Energy Snapshot: Puerto Rico. Retrieved from
https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy15osti/62708.pdf. Accessed 21 June 2018.
Heister, Jessica Leigh. & Echenique, Martin. (2017). “Puerto Rico's Grid Needs a Complete
Overhaul.” CityLab. Available at:
https://www.citylab.com/environment/2017/09/hurricane-maria-puerto-ricos-grid-
needs-a-complete-overhaul/540969. Accessed 21 March 2018.
IDEBAJO. (2018). https://idebajo.wordpress.com. Accessed 21 March 2018.
INESI. (2018). Available at: https://inesi.upr.edu/about.php. Accessed 21 March 2018.
Kantrow, Michelle. (2017). Energy experts present plan for PR to Judge. Retrieved from
http://newsismybusiness.com/experts-present-oboard. Accessed 21 June 2018.
Klein, Naomi. (2018). “The Battle for Paradise.” The Intercept. Available at:
https://theintercept.com/2018/03/20/puerto-rico-hurricane-maria-recovery.
Accessed 21 March 2018.
Koerth-Baker, Maggie. (2017). “Why Puerto Rico’s Electric Grid Stood No Chance Against
Maria.” FiveThirtyEight. Available at: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/why-
puerto-ricos-electric-grid-stood-no-chance-against-maria. Accessed 21 March 2018.
Letter to the Governor from the Financial Oversight and Management Board. Feb. 5, 2018.
Retrieved from https://media.noticel.com/o2com-noti-media-us-east-
1/document_dev/2018/02/05/Carta%20al%20Gobernador%20sobre%20el%20Pla
n%20Fiscal%20de%20la%20AEE_1517874696716_10253415_ver1.0.pdf.
Accessed 16 June 2018.
Llorens, Hilda. (2018). “The Making of a Community Activist.” Sapiens. Available at:
https://www.sapiens.org/culture/jobos-bay-community-activist. Accessed 21 March
2018.
Marxuach, Sergio. (2018). “Inconvenient Questions.” Center for the New Economy.
Available at: http://grupocne.org/2018/02/04/preguntas-inconvenientes-
inconvenient-questions/#ingles. Accessed 21 March 2018.
77 | ALTERNAUTAS 5 (2) DECEMBER 2018
Merchant, Emma F. (2018). “Puerto Rico’s Utility Moves Toward Privatization, With
Strained Cooperation.” GreenTechMedia. Available at:
https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/puerto-ricos-utility-moves-towards-
privatization-but-struggles-persist-in-b#gs.7TuPSDY. Accessed 21 March 2018.
Navarra, Mireya. (1998). Plan to Sell Puerto Rico Phone Company Leads to Strike. New
York Times. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/1998/06/19/us/plan-to-sell-
puerto-rico-phone-company-leads-to-strike.html. Accessed 21 March 2018.
New York Power Authority. (2017). “Build Back Better: Reimagining and Strengthening the
Power Grid of Puerto Rico.” Available at:
https://www.governor.ny.gov/sites/governor.ny.gov/files/atoms/files/PRERWG_Rep
ort_PR_Grid_Resiliency_Report.pdf. Accessed 21 March 2018.
O’Neill-Carrillo, E. Santiago, R., Méndez, Z., Vega, H., Mussa, J. Rentas, J. (2017).
“Capstone Design Projects as Foundation for a Solar Community,” Proceedings of
the 47th ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference, October 18 - 21, 2017,
Indianapolis, IN.
Pérez-Arriaga, I. J. (Ed.). (2014). Regulation of the power sector. Springer Science & Business
Media.
PaReS. (2018). Public letter to Honorary Judge Laura Swain, July 30, 2017.
Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority History. (n.d.). Available at:
http://www.fundinguniverse.com/company-histories/puerto-rico-electric-power-
authority-history. Accessed 21 March 2018.
Puerto Rico Energy Commission. (2018). Jose Roman, Interim President. Available at:
http://energia.pr.gov/en/staff-member/jose-h-roman-pe. Accessed 21 March 2018.
S. No. 57-2014. Available at: http://www.oslpr.org/download/en/2014/A-057-2014.pdf.
Accessed 21 March 2018.
The Economist. (2017). Be PREPA-ed: The story of Puerto Rico’s power grid is the story of
Puerto Rico. The Economist. Available at: https://www.economist.com/news/united-
states/21730432-even-hurricane-maria-hit-it-was-mess-story-puerto-ricos-power-
grid. Accessed 21 March 2018.
Toussie, Isaac & Dyson, Michael. (2018). “The Role of Renewable and Distributed Energy
in a Resilient and Cost-Effective Energy Future for Puerto Rico.” Rocky Mountain
Rewiring PR: Power and Empowerment after Hurricane Maria | 78
Institute. Insight brief. Available at: https://www.rmi.org/wp-
content/uploads/2017/12/Insight_Brief_Puerto_Rico_Resilient_CostEffective_Ener
gy.pdf. Accessed 21 March 2018.
Tugwell, F. (1980). Review: Energy and political economy. Comparative Politics, 13(1), 103-
118.
Wernick, Adam. (2018). “Renewable energy and resilient microgrids could help rebuild
Puerto Rico.” Public Radio International. Available at:
https://www.pri.org/stories/2017-10-26/renewable-energy-and-resilient-microgrids-
could-help-rebuild-puerto-rico. Accessed 21 March 2018.
Williams-Walsh, Mary. (2017). “Puerto Rico’s Power Authority Effectively Files for
Bankruptcy.” New York Times. Available at:
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/02/business/puerto-ricos-electric-power-
authority-effectively-files-for-bankruptcy.html. Accessed 21 March 2018.
... However, the lack of public participation in the post-hurricane context, ignoring the work and success of such grassroots initiatives, perpetuated both socioenvironmental inequalities and the democratic dysfunctions of the past (Bui 2018). The privatization of electricity, and other top-down articulations of energy sustainability that followed, revealed deep concerns over the transparency of decision-making in energy governance, with direct impacts on health. ...
Book
Full-text available
This book uses a unique typology of ten core drivers of injustice to explore and question common assumptions around what urban sustainability means, how it can be implemented, and how it is manifested in or driven by urban interventions that hinge on claims of sustainability. Aligned with critical environmental justice studies, the book highlights the contradictions of urban sustainability in relation to justice. It argues that urban neighbourhoods cannot be greener, more sustainable and liveable unless their communities are strengthened by the protection of the right to housing, public space, infrastructure and healthy amenities. Linked to the individual drivers, ten short empirical case studies from across Europe and North America provide a systematic analysis of research, policy and practice conducted under urban sustainability agendas in cities such as Barcelona, Glasgow, Athens, Boston and Montréal, and show how social and environmental justice is, or is not, being taken into account. By doing so, the book uncovers the risks of continuing urban sustainability agendas while ignoring, and therefore perpetuating, systemic drivers of inequity and injustice operating within and outside of the city. Accessibly written for students in urban studies, critical geography and planning, this is a useful and analytical synthesis of issues relating to urban sustainability, environmental and social justice. The Open Access version of this book, available at http://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/e/9781003221425, has been made available under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives 4.0 license. Funded by Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona Table of Contents Driver 1: Material and Livelihood Inequalities Driver 2: Racialized or Ethnically Exclusionary Urbanization Driver 3: Uneven Urban and Intensification and Regeneration Driver 4: Uneven Environmental Health and Pollution Patterns Driver 5: Exclusive Access to the Benefits of Urban Sustainability Infrastructure Driver 6: Unfit Institutional Structures Driver 7: Weakened Civil Society Driver 8: Limited Citizen Participation Driver 9: Power-Knowledge Asymmetries Driver 10: The Growth Imperative and Neoliberal Urbanism The book is fully open access here: https://www.routledge.com/Injustice-in-Urban-Sustainability-Ten-Core-Drivers/Kotsila-Anguelovski-Garcia-Lamarca-Sekulova/p/book/9781032117621
... However, the lack of public participation in the post-hurricane context, ignoring the work and success of such grassroots initiatives, perpetuated both socioenvironmental inequalities and the democratic dysfunctions of the past (Bui 2018). The privatization of electricity, and other top-down articulations of energy sustainability that followed, revealed deep concerns over the transparency of decision-making in energy governance, with direct impacts on health. ...
... The most highly publicized proposals have been directed at Puerto Rico, by far the largest electricity market among the islands affected by the 2017 hurricanes (see Klein 2018). Included in the raft of proposals and experiments proffered are Elon Musk's much-reported Twitter conversation with Puerto Rico's governor, smaller projects aiming to make use of community ownership, and in some highly fanciful cases, schemes using blockchain for financing solar installations (Cheslow 2018;Bui 2018;Malik 2018). ...
Article
In the wake of the 2017 hurricane season, discussions across the Caribbean have turned to the need to develop more resilient energy systems, particularly through the deployment of renewable energy sources. In this paper, we examine the post-Hurricane Maria rebuilding of Dominica’s electricity system in light of recent scholarship around the Anthropocene and the Caribbean, work that has heightened awareness of the entanglements between the earth’s geophysical forces and its socio-economic and geo-political relations. Drawing on archival research and key informants in Dominica, we describe the history of Dominica’s energy system, and then provide an overview of some of the energy rebuilding efforts in the country’s ongoing recovery from Hurricane Maria, particularly around the question of resilience. While we acknowledge critiques of resilience as a framework for disaster management, we also argue that resilience initiatives foster the potential for an Anthropocene reimagining of geosocial formations within the Caribbean. In the conclusion, we argue that the domain of energy, and in particular electricity, opens up important questions at the interface of social-ecological relations and the organization of collective life.
Book
Offering a comprehensive overview of Puerto Rico's history and evolution since the installation of U.S. rule, this book connects the island's economic, political, cultural, and social past. It explores Puerto Ricans in the diaspora as well as the island residents, who experience an unusual and daily conundrum: they consider themselves a distinct people but are part of the American political system; they have U.S. citizenship but are not represented in the U.S. Congress; and they live on land that is neither independent nor part of the United States. Highlighting both well-known and forgotten figures from Puerto Rican history, the book discusses a wide range of topics, including literary and cultural debates and social and labor struggles that previous histories have neglected. Although the island's political economy remains dependent on the United States, the book also considers Puerto Rico's situation in light of world economies. It argues that the inability of Puerto Rico to shake its colonial legacy reveals the limits of free-market capitalism, a break from which would require a renewal of the long tradition of labor and social activism in Puerto Rico in connection with similar currents in the United States.
Book
Part I: Introduction and Background.- Technological Aspects of Power Systems.- Industrial Structure and Organization of the Power Sector.- An Introduction to Power System Economics.- Part II: The Theory of Regulation.- Electricity Regulation: Principles and Institutions.- Regulations of Monopolies.- Regulation of Markets.- Part III: The Practice of Regulation.- Wholesale Electricity Markets.- Transmission.- Distribution.- Tariffs.- Retail Electricity Markets.- Advanced Topics.- Environmental Regulation in the Power Sector.- Electricity and Gas.- Open Issues in the Regulation of the Power Sector.
Organizational and Policy Needs for Microgrid Development in Puerto Rico Executive Summary
  • D Attar
  • G Beckwith
  • N Chandra
  • C Neuhoff
  • C Wiltberger
Attar, D., Beckwith, G., Chandra, N., Neuhoff, C. & Wiltberger, C. (2018). "Organizational and Policy Needs for Microgrid Development in Puerto Rico Executive Summary." 15.708 Global Organizations Lab: Puerto Rico Microgrids Project. MIT Sloan School of Management.
Privatize Puerto Rico's Power (Op-Ed)
  • Andrew G Biggs
  • Arthur J Gonzalez
  • Ana J Matosantos
  • David Skeel
Biggs, Andrew G., Gonzalez, Arthur J., Matosantos, Ana J., & Skeel, David. (2017). "Privatize Puerto Rico's Power (Op-Ed)." Wall Street Journal. Available at: https://www.wsj.com/articles/privatize-puerto-ricos-power-1498776904. Accessed 21 March 2018.
Puerto Ricans desperate for cell service turn to Mexican carrier
  • Nick Brown
  • Robin Respaut
Brown, Nick, & Respaut, Robin. (2017). Puerto Ricans desperate for cell service turn to Mexican carrier. Reuters. Avaialble at: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usapuertorico-slim/puerto-ricans-desperate-for-cell-service-turn-to-mexican-carrier-idUSKCN1C7236. Accessed 21 March 2018.
Puerto Rico gov. signs bill to privatize PREPA utility assets
  • Danica Coto
Coto, Danica. (2018). "Puerto Rico gov. signs bill to privatize PREPA utility assets." Electric Light and Power. Available at: https://www.elp.com/articles/2018/06/puerto-ricogov-signs-bill-to-privatize-prepa-utility-assets.html. Accessed 31 August 2018. Rewiring PR: Power and Empowerment after Hurricane Maria | 76
Ricardo Rosselló announced a privatization model for PREPA
  • Dia El Nuevo
El Nuevo Dia. (2017). "Ricardo Rosselló announced a privatization model for PREPA." Available at: https://www.elnuevodia.com/english/english/nota/ricardorosselloannouncedaprivatiz ationmodelforprepa-2392103. Accessed 21 March 2018.