ArticlePublisher preview available

How autonomy-supportive learning environments promote Asian international students’ academic adjustment: a self-determination theory perspective

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

We explored Asian international students’ successful learning experiences and adjustment through the lens of self-determination theory. To explore how international students perceive their classroom learning environments and learning experiences in more detail, a sequential explanatory mixed-methods approach was used. In the quantitative phase, empirical relationships between autonomy-supportive environments and affective (language anxiety), behavioral (discussion participation), and cognitive (adaptive beliefs about classroom assessments) learning components in the classroom were examined. In the qualitative phase, results from the quantitative study were further explored for additional explanations through follow-up interviews. Autonomy-supportive environments seemed to satisfy international students’ basic psychological needs, which decreased language anxiety and increased classroom participation and adaptive perspectives about classroom assessments. The discussion focuses on the theoretical and classroom implications of the quantitative and qualitative findings. This study contributes to the literature by suggesting a solid theoretical foundation to support successful academic adjustment among Asian international students.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Vol.:(0123456789)
Learning Environments Research (2023) 26:51–76
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10984-021-09401-x
1 3
ORIGINAL PAPER
How autonomy‑supportive learning environments promote
Asian international students’ academic adjustment:
aself‑determination theory perspective
HyunJinCho1 · ChantalLevesque‑Bristol1· MikeYough2
Received: 4 June 2020 / Accepted: 10 November 2021 / Published online: 15 January 2022
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature B.V. 2021
Abstract
We explored Asian international students’ successful learning experiences and adjust-
ment through the lens of self-determination theory. To explore how international students
perceive their classroom learning environments and learning experiences in more detail,
a sequential explanatory mixed-methods approach was used. In the quantitative phase,
empirical relationships between autonomy-supportive environments and affective (lan-
guage anxiety), behavioral (discussion participation), and cognitive (adaptive beliefs about
classroom assessments) learning components in the classroom were examined. In the
qualitative phase, results from the quantitative study were further explored for additional
explanations through follow-up interviews. Autonomy-supportive environments seemed to
satisfy international students’ basic psychological needs, which decreased language anxiety
and increased classroom participation and adaptive perspectives about classroom assess-
ments. The discussion focuses on the theoretical and classroom implications of the quanti-
tative and qualitative findings. This study contributes to the literature by suggesting a solid
theoretical foundation to support successful academic adjustment among Asian interna-
tional students.
Keywords Adjustment· Asian international students· Learning environment· Mixed-
methods· Self-determination theory
Introduction
The international student body constitutes a large part of US higher education, contribut-
ing to internationalization and diversity and bringing cultural and economic benefits to US
college culture (Mamiseishvili, 2012; Wu etal., 2015). This student body has been drasti-
cally increasing and has become an important population in higher education (Ecochard
* Hyun Jin Cho
cho193@purdue.edu
1 Purdue University, Center forInstructional Excellence, WestLafayette, IN47907, USA
2 Oklahoma State University, Educational Foundations, Leadership & Aviation, Stillwater,
OK74078, USA
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... Self-determination theory views motivation as the central element of human health, proposing that satisfying basic needs enhances the actualization of self-functioning. Fulfilling basic needs stimulates individuals' intrinsic motivation, facilitates self-growth, and fosters individual adaptation 26 . Ryan and Deci posit that facilitating the shift from extrinsic motivation to higher forms necessitates deliberating the roles of internal motivation, self-regulation, and well-being in fostering or impeding self-motivation and robust psychological growth 27 . ...
Article
Full-text available
This research explored the link between teacher-student relationships and learning engagement, considering perceived social support as a mediator and academic self-efficacy as a moderator. A total of 930 college students completed the Academic Self-Efficacy Scale, Teacher-Student Relationships Questionnaire, Multidimensional Scale of Perceived Social Support, and College Student Learning Engagement Questionnaire. Mediating and moderating effects were investigated using SPSS19.0 and one of its process plugins 3.5. The findings indicated (1) teacher-student relationships positively predicted learning engagement; (2) perceived social support mediated the link between teacher-student relationships and learning engagement; and (3) academic self-efficacy moderated the initial phase of the pathway to the mediating role of perceived social support. Moreover, the mediating effect was more significant at elevated academic self-efficacy levels. Establishing harmonious relationships between teachers and students, nurturing students’ confidence in their academic abilities , and expanding students’ access to social support were essential to boosting the educational involvement of college students. The study findings will help educators enhance college students’ engagement in learning and provide recommendations for educators to conduct educational and teaching activities.
... The concept of autonomy is central to this exploration and foundational within SDT. More intricate than making decisions independently, autonomy represents an innate psychological need that drives human behavior and influences overall wellbeing Cho et al., 2022;Feraco et al., 2022;Reeve & Cheon, 2021). ...
Thesis
Full-text available
Despite the theoretical proposition that needs-supportive teaching practices, guided by self-determination theory (SDT), can positively influence student academic outcomes, research examining the relationship between teachers' self-reported needs-supportive behaviors and objective measures of student performance, such as standardized test scores, is scarce. This study investigated the correlation between teachers' needs-supportive practices, as assessed by the Teacher as Social Context Questionnaire (TASCQ), and their students' academic achievement based on standardized test results. The sample consisted of 31 K-12 teachers from various grade levels in public schools located in Southwest Missouri. Participants completed the TASCQ, which measures needs-supportive teaching in terms of autonomy support, competence support, and relatedness support. The primary outcome measure was the percentage of students in each teacher's classroom who achieved proficiency or higher on standardized tests. Contrary to expectations, the study found no significant correlation between teachers' self-reported needs-supportive teaching practices and the percentage of their students achieving proficiency or higher on standardized tests. Furthermore, the study observed no significant correlations between the individual dimensions of autonomy, competence, and relatedness support and students' test performance. This research contributes to the field of educational psychology by highlighting the complexity of the relationship between teaching practices and student achievement, suggesting that sole reliance on standardized test scores may not fully capture the influence of needs-supportive teaching on student growth and development. Future research should explore alternative indicators of student success and investigate the potential long-term effects of needs-supportive teaching on student motivation, engagement, and well-being.
... Creating autonomy-supportive environments extends beyond individual teacher practices; it requires a school-wide culture that values autonomy, collaboration, and student agency in the learning process (Deci et al., 2017;Cho et al., 2022). Collaborative efforts among teachers, administrators, and policymakers are fundamental in fostering a systemic shift towards autonomy-supportive educational environments, thereby ensuring a comprehensive and enriching learning experience for students (Conklin, 2013). ...
Article
Full-text available
Introduction This research explores the intricate interplay among teacher-student relationships, perceived autonomy support, peer relationships, and their collective impact on the psychological well-being of 387 university students enrolled in French language courses across diverse academic institutions in China. Methods Employing Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM), this study aims to establish the validity and robustness of the proposed model. Data collection involved online surveys utilizing Likert scales and standardized measures to assess variables concerning educational relationships and psychological well-being. Results The findings reveal significant associations between teacher-student relationships, autonomy support, positive peer relationships, and psychological well-being. Importantly, analyses demonstrate the influential role of positive peer relationships in mediating the effects of teacher-student relationships and autonomy support on students’ psychological well-being. Discussion These outcomes emphasize the crucial significance of educational relationships in shaping students’ psychological well-being within academic settings. The findings contribute to understanding the nuanced dynamics of educational interactions and their profound implications for student well-being. This highlights the necessity of cultivating positive educational environments for enhanced student mental health.
... It can be said that a self-determined individual possesses both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation for learning, and by effectively participating in class and overcoming internal pressures and related anxieties, they can develop a positive self-concept while reducing selfhandicapping. Additionally, in a study by Choet al. (2022), it was found that self-determination skills training in educational environments meets the basic psychological needs of university students, which reduces the factors leading to self-handicapping, such as psychological pressure and anxiety, thereby increasing class participation and academic growth (Cho et al., 2023). ...
Article
Full-text available
Objective: The present study was conducted to determine the effectiveness of self-determination training on self-handicapping and academic procrastination among students. Methods and Materials: The present study is a quasi-experimental design with pre-test, post-test, and follow-up with a control group. The statistical population included all students studying at Farhangian University in Birjand at Imam Sajjad and Shahid Bahonar campuses in the academic year 2016-2017, totaling 1,950 individuals. The research sample included 40 students from Farhangian University who voluntarily enrolled and were randomly assigned to two groups of 20 each using a random numbers table. The experimental group participated in 12 sessions of 90 minutes each, one session per week over two months, undergoing an intervention program based on self-determination skills developed by the researchers based on Deci and Ryan's (1985) self-determination theory. The control group received no training during this period. The Jones and Rhodewalt (1982) Self-Handicapping Scale and the Solomon and Rothblum (1984) Academic Procrastination Scale were used to measure the variables. Data analysis was conducted using SPSS-23 software. Findings: The results of multivariate covariance analysis indicated that self-determination skills training had a significant effect on reducing student self-handicapping (F=104.88) and academic procrastination (F=34.74) (p<0.001), and these results persisted in the follow-up phase. Conclusion: Based on the findings, learning and applying self-determination skills by students can reduce self-handicapping and the occurrence of procrastination behaviors during their studies. Therefore, the results of this study have practical implications for psychologists and counselors at university counseling centers to utilize self-determination skills to reduce academic procrastination and self-handicapping among students.
... Autonomy-supportive behaviours encompass actions that involve encouraging optimal behavioural patterns and guidelines while considering others' perspectives (Deci & Ryan, 2000;Han, 2021). In this context, educators assume a pivotal role in nurturing motivation among students and shaping instructional approaches (Cho et al., 2022;Reeve & Cheon, 2021). Hence, a plausible interpretation could be suggested that the instructors may not sufficiently foster autonomy motivations among special needs university students. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Despite the significant emphasis on self‐determination in special education and the crucial role of mobile learning, there is a notable absence of path modelling studies that explore the effect of self‐determination on the usage of mobile learning by students with special needs. Objectives This study sought to investigate the intentions of mobile learning usage among students with special needs by proposing a model rooted in the technology acceptance model, complemented by extraneous constructs from self‐determination theory (competence, autonomy and relatedness). Methods The data of the study was obtained online from 1298 special needs university students with eight different types of disabilities. Data were analysed with descriptive statistics, confirmatory factor analysis, structural equation modelling and bootstrapping. Results and Conclusions The proposed model explained 78.4% of ease of use, 85.2% of usefulness, and 76.5% of intention. 11 of the 12 hypotheses tested within the scope of the model were supported. All hypotheses examining the impacts of self‐determination theory constructs on ease of use, usefulness, and intention were validated (8 hypotheses), with the exception of the autonomy → intention relationship. Substantial empirical evidence has been acquired to support the role of the self‐determination theory in exploring the intention toward mobile learning among university students with special needs. Concurrently, a robust theoretical framework has been introduced to the field of special education to elucidate the acceptance and utilization of technology by university students with special needs.
... The centrality of learner autonomy and control within SRL is expounded upon by Lewis and Vialleton (2011) and Murray (2014), highlighting the importance of choice and self-direction in the learning process. This is exemplified in ADLEs, where learners have the discretion to select learning paths, topics and activities that resonate with their interests and learning preferences (Cho et al., 2023). Such environments not only facilitate choice but also encourage learners to | 5 A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF EMPIRICAL STUDIES engage in reflection and to employ strategies that foster metacognitive skill development, which Lehmann et al. (2014) assert as critical in promoting metacognition. ...
Article
Full-text available
Adaptive learning technologies are closely related to learners' self‐regulatory processes in individual and collaborative learning. This study presents the outcomes of a systematic literature review of empirical evidence on adaptive learning environments to foster self‐regulation and shared regulation of learning in collaborative settings. We provide an overview of what and how adaptive technologies have been used to understand and promote self‐regulated learning in collaborative contexts. A search resulted in 38 papers being analysed. Specifically, we identified the seven main objectives (feedback and scaffolding, self‐regulatory skills and strategies, learning trajectories, collaborative learning processes, adaptation and regulation, self‐assessment, and help‐seeking behaviour) that the adaptive technology research has been focusing on. We also summarize the implications derived from the reviewed papers and frame them within seven thematic areas. Finally, this review stresses that future research should consider developing a converging theoretical framework that would enable concrete monitoring and support for self‐regulation and socially shared regulation of learning. Our findings set a baseline to support the adoption and proliferation of adaptive learning technology within self‐regulated learning research and development. Practitioner notes What is already known about this topic By providing personalized and learner‐centric adaptive learning environments (ADLEs), adaptive learning technology can support and foster self‐regulated learning (SRL) practices. It is possible to create a more student‐centred and effective learning environment by combining adaptive learning and collaborative learning. Socially shared regulatory activities can involve planning, monitoring, controlling and reflecting on a group's learning processes. What this paper adds Provides a systematic literature review of empirical evidence on ADLEs, SRL and socially shared regulation of learning (SSRL) in collaborative contexts. Summarizes the insights on (S)SRL through ADLEs in collaborative learning. Identifies challenges and opportunities for ADLEs to support (S)SRL in collaborative learning. Implications for practice and/or policy Learning analytics and educational technology researchers will be able to use the systematic review as a guide for future research. Learning analytics and educational technology practitioners will be able to use the systematic review as a summary of the field's current state.
... SDT posits that students' basic psychological needs tend to be positively associated with psychological well-being and full functioning [1], [2]. A significant body of the literature reveals that basic psychological needs is a significant predictor of adaptive learning outcomes [10], [11]. In particular, students' basic psychological needs are associated with students' autonomous motivation [12] [13]. ...
... Studies have identified disproportionate outcomes for students of color when it comes to faculty assessment of writing (Cronley & Kilgore, 2016;Rainey et al., 2019) with interventions focusing more on punitive practices towards the student (Alter & Adkins, 2001Hooper & Butler, 2008;Jarman-Rohde et al., 1997). Moreover, as the number of international students continue to enroll in U.S. colleges and universities, faculty must adapt andragogy in order to create learning environments that support inclusive methods and values the impact of culture on student learning outcomes (Cho et al., 2022). ...
Article
Full-text available
This study was carried out to examine the confidence of faculty in providing culturally responsive teaching from both a student and faculty perspective within the helping disciplines of counseling and social work. Researchers hypothesized that students and faculty would report higher percentages of confidence in being part of a culturally responsive learning environment. The study was conducted by means of questionnaires to both students and faculty. Data were collected using two types of questionnaires: students (n = 146) were given the Student Measure of Culturally Responsive Teaching (SMCRT) and the faculty (n = 14) were given the Culturally Responsive Teaching (CRT) Scale. Descriptive analyses of frequencies and cross-tabulations were conducted to observe how faculty rated their overall level of confidence to how students perceived the professor’s ability to create a culturally responsive environment. Other parametric tests assessed differences within and amongst groups. Only 23.1% (n = 51) of students reported an average score of 80% or higher for having a culturally responsive learning environment with all of the statements, but a majority of the student participants indicated lower than 80% confidence in their professor’s culturally responsive behaviors as it relates to their learning environment. In addition, roughly 33% (n = 5) of faculty rated their confidence level in supporting a culturally inclusive learning environment of 80% or higher. The results provide insight into implementing inclusive strategies to ensure that students and faculty are confident in providing more tangible experiences of operating within a culturally responsive learning environment.
... Some noteworthy learning environment studies have successfully combined quantitative and qualitative methods include Cho et al. (2023) who used a sequential explanatory mixed-method approach to investigate how autonomy-supportive learning environments improved the academic adjustment of 356 Asian international students. Aldridge et al. (1999) combined the use of the WIHIC with qualitative data-gathering methods to illuminate differences between Taiwan and Australia in the learning environments of 2950 juniorhigh science students. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study of first year high-school students in South Australia focussed on the effectiveness of using an innovative project-based mathematics strategy to improve the classroom learning environment and the student outcomes of enjoyment, academic efficacy and achievement. As well, we investigated the differential effectiveness of project-based mathematics for male and female students. A sample of 284 students from a co-educational private secondary school provided quantitative data about classroom learning environment as assessed with seven scales from the What Is Happening In this Class? (WIHIC), together with data about the three student outcomes assessed with one scale each. Our study also included a mixed-method design involving qualitative information collected through classroom observations and interviews with 20 students and 3 teachers to explain patterns emerging from the analysis of quantitative data.
... Autonomy-supportive behaviors include behaviors in which someone takes others' perspective into account promoting the best behavioral practice and guidelines Han, 2021). In this sense, teachers play a key role in fostering autonomous motivation in students and educational practice (Reeve and Cheon, 2021;Cho et al., 2022). ...
Article
Full-text available
Introduction Self-determination construct is a motivation theory used in professional and educational context to foster special needs teachers’ development of metacognition, and psychological wellbeing. The Learning Climate Questionnaire (LCQ) is a validate questionnaire used to underly teachers’ professional and personal competence, and improving social, emotional and career outcomes. The present paper aims to evaluate the degree of reliability (R1) and the adherence of construct validity to the construct of self-determination (R2) of the Italian adaptation of the LCQ. Methods A confirmatory factorial analysis was conducted to evaluate the factorial structure of the LCQ in a sample of Italian special needs teachers (N = 953). Teachers was asked to complete an online version of the LCQ. Construct validity was conducted by relating the learning climate with the basic psychological needs satisfaction, measured with PBNSF, and with academic motivation scale, measured with AMS. Results The analysis showed a good reliability (R1) and construct validity of the Italian adaptation of the questionnaire, with a high internal consistency compared to those obtained in other studies (R2). Discussion Teachers’ autonomy support and teacher-student relation can positively impact the students’ psychological factors and enhance students’ learning motivation and academic achievement. Findings reveal that higher levels of learning climate could also be a key factor in reducing teachers’ negative stress and mental health consequences. Conclusion This study may facilitate further research about the autonomy-supportive learning climate in educational settings in Italy.
Article
Full-text available
Across the world, teachers’ classroom assessment tasks and responsibilities are becoming more diverse due to increased migration. In this review, we address how migrant students are affected by assessment, both summative and formative, at the classroom level, with a focus on culturally responsive assessment (CRA). Previous research has shown that CRA practices mainly occur in student-centred classrooms. Furthermore, both student and teacher beliefs about teaching and learning might negatively affect migrant students’ opportunities to engage in assessment situations. Teaching and assessment practices should be negotiated and aligned with and included in classroom norms to be culturally responsive. We propose that what is generally considered a valid and reliable assessment practice might need to be adjusted to account for students’ cultural ways of knowing and participating and how this is expressed and communicated within the classroom.
Article
Full-text available
Background/Context One in three international students in the U.S. comes from China, propelled by a steep increase in undergraduate enrollment in U.S. colleges. This phenomenon has been accompanied by negative media discourse that portrays them as needy, passive, and unable to cope with their new educational demands. Purpose/Objective Using a hybrid sociocultural framework that privileges student agency and locates students within their sociocultural milieu, this study investigated strategies Chinese international undergraduates used to cope with challenges they faced in U.S. colleges. Population/Participants Eighteen participants—nine freshmen and nine sophomores— from three liberal arts colleges situated in an urban context took part in the study. Research Design This qualitative study followed participants through one academic year. Participants completed a demographic questionnaire, engaged in three semi-structured interviews at the beginning, middle, and end of their academic year, and wrote four journal prompts. Findings/Results Results reveal that student strategies cluster around themes of agency and self-reliance, as well as outreach and support. Students spent more time studying, used a range of learning techniques, developed self-help and psychological strategies, tapped into institutional and technological support, and reached out to teachers and peers for help. Conclusions/Recommendations Students’ coping strategies reveal fluid responses to intersecting and changing sociocultural expectations, nimbleness in their adaptations, and transience in the challenges faced. Other than contesting stereotypes around Chinese students, findings spell implications for differentiated and responsive college policies serving international students, faculty members, and local peers. It also points to the need to incorporate more longitudinal studies with clear conceptual frameworks so that novel and nuanced understanding of international students can emerge.
Article
Full-text available
Regardless of their level of academic preparedness, international students face distinct challenges that arise from language issues as well as ones of a personal and social nature, all of which can lead to frustration and failure (Bossio & Bylyna, 2006b). This article discusses an online survey carried out in a Canadian college that identified academic and sociocultural issues faced by international students and highlighted current or potential strategies from the input of 229 international students, 343 domestic students, and 125 professors. Findings reveal that counterproductive behavior may obstruct academic achievement and communication, and there is evidence of disagreement about international students’ academic strengths. A disconnect between participants was also found regarding academic expectations. Moreover, findings reveal that English language abilities are not the sole hindrance to academic success. Responses highlight the need for, and list steps toward, a more proactive and continual pedagogical evolution for faculty and postsecondary institutions to enhance the academic experience and success of international students.
Article
Full-text available
International students represent a large and increasing share of the diversity encountered on British campuses, with 19% of the student body coming from another country to study in the United Kingdom. While the concept of transition in the context of Higher Education (HE) is better understood as a process of change and adaptation to the HE culture, international transitions –undertaken by international students – present additional and specific challenges. These involve multiple additional cultural adjustments, to the host nation culture, the international student culture and the subject disciplinary culture. The scale and number of these challenges may lead to mental health issues and to students dropping out. The growing number of international students and their importance as a significant economic driver to the HE sector have been reflected in the literature, with an increasing number of publications on the topic. Various models have been elaborated to describe the process of academic and socio-cultural adjustment experienced by international students, along with concepts of acculturative stress and culture shock used to refer to the sometimes extreme emotional turmoil created by such cultural dissonances. University staff and students have different but key roles and responsibilities in supporting and facilitating international students’ adjustment, improving retention and enabling international students to reach their academic and personal goals in spite of the challenges that confront them. This literature review presents the different stage-models of international students’ acculturation and defines key concepts for international transitions such as acculturative stress and culture shock, thereby allowing for a better understanding of the international students’ academic and social journey. It describes the challenges international students meet in their transition to UK HE institutions and introduces literature identifying ways of better supporting the specific needs of those students. It concludes with a discussion on the limitations of the current international transitions discourse.
Article
In this study, we examined the role of self-esteem, hope, optimism, coping, acculturative stress, and social support on international students’ depressive symptoms and sociocultural adjustment. Seventy international students completed a self-report online survey. The most notable finding was that the international students used adaptive and maladaptive coping techniques at similar rates. Greater use of coping techniques, higher acculturative stress and less social support were associated with more depressive symptoms and more difficulty with sociocultural adjustment. Lower self-esteem, less hope, and less optimism were associated with more depressive symptoms, but not sociocultural difficulty. Clinical implications and future directions are also discussed.
Article
A research team consisting of educators of gifted students, a scientist, and experts in measurement developed a performance-based assessment of life science skills and abilities. Four high schools in the Southwestern United States were the settings for field testing and implementation. Five levels of ratings were given: unknown, maybe, probably, definitely, and wow. The majority of student scores were in the maybe and probably categories. Using six new measures (concept maps in life and physical science, math problem solving, spatial analytical performance assessment, life science performance assessment and physical science performance assessment), 23 students (M2) were selected for participation in science laboratories at an R1 university along with 20 students (M1) selected by conventional means. When the nine attribute scores of the performance-based assessment were compared, no significant difference was found t(41), p > .38, between M1 and M2 students. Performance-based assessments in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) will provide an alternative and a complement to standard achievement tests. They have the potential to identify and nurture exceptionally talented high school students across all demographic groups.
Article
Self-Determination Theory and Flow Theory propose that perceived autonomy fosters the positive qualities of motivation and flow-experience. Autonomy-support can help to maintain students’ motivation in very interesting learning activities and may lead to an increase in the positive qualities of motivation in less interesting learning activities. This paper investigates whether autonomy-supportive or controlling teaching behaviour influence students’ motivation and flow-experience in biology class. In study 1, 158 students of grade six worked on the adaptations of Harvest Mice (Micromys minutus) with living animals. The 153 sixth graders of study 2 dealt with the same content but instead worked with short films on laptops. Previous studies have shown that students perceive film sequences as less interesting than working with living animals. Students’ intrinsic motivation and flow-experience were measured at the end of the first and the third lesson. In study 1, autonomy-supportive teaching behaviour led to significant differences in students’ intrinsic motivation and flow-experience when compared to controlling teaching behaviour. In study 2, motivation and flow-experience were not always in line with theory. The positive effects of autonomy-supportive and the non-beneficial effects of the controlling teaching behaviour seem to be dependent on the interestingness of the teaching material.