ArticlePDF Available

Personality profiles of karate masters practising different kumite styles

Authors:
  • Wroclaw University of Health and Sport Sciences
  • Wroclaw University of Health and Sport Sciences

Abstract

Background and Study Aim: As far as common adaptive effects are concerned, long-term karate training based on kumite technique (socially acceptable form of hand-to-hand-fighting) results in increased resistance to opponent’s strikes and ability to tolerate pain and certain type of body injuries. Therefore, it could be assumed that karate masters possess most of all certain personality traits, but kumite technique (style) is not a factor that significantly modifies this relationship and the profile of the world champions of the kumite style may differ from this model. The goal of the study is to verify this hypothesis. Material and Methods: In total 150 best Polish kumite competitors were included in the study; 30 each from five techniques (styles) of karate, including: semi contact- World Karate Federation recognised by the International Olympic Committee (in this paper: WKF) and shōtōkan; full contact - Oyama; mix fighting - shidōkan; knockdown - kyokushin. The subgroup of kumite karate champions (KKC, n = 23) consisted of winners of the gold medals of the world championships, whereas the subgroup of karate masters (KM) consisted of other athletes (n=127). Personality measurements were based on big five NEO-FFI scales (neuroticism, extraversion, openness to experience, agreeableness, conscientiousness). Results: It is true that karate masters have distinctive personality traits (which include: low neuroticism and high conscientiousness), whereas it would be false to assume that kumite technique (style) is not a factor that significantly modifies this relationship. WKF karate athletes exhibits the lowest neuroticism when compares to other ones (p<0.01); Oyama karatekas exhibits lower extraversion than WKF, shidōkan and kyokushin athletes (p<0.05). It turned out to be true that personality profiles of gold medal winners of the World Karate Championships of kumite style (KKC) may differ from the model of the remaining KM. Conclusions: The new empirical argumentation is an important premise for conducting in-depth personality studies on athletes at every stage of a sports career. Such knowledge combined with studies of other predispositions and adaptive effects (that are in relation to unique events determined by various types of sports) is a prerequisite for embodying social and health-related mission of sports in an optimal manner.
2018
|
VOLUME 14
|
247
© ARCHIVES OF BUDO
|
SCIENCE OF MARTIAL ARTS
is is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0),
which permits use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non-commercial and is otherwise in compliance with the license.
Personality profiles of karate masters practising
different kumite styles
Paweł Piepiora1ABCDE, Kazimierz Witkowski1BCDE, Zbigniew Piepiora2BCD
1 Combat Sports Team, Chair of Sport Didactics, Faculty of Sport Sciences, Wroclaw University School of Physical
Education, Wroclaw, Poland
2
Department of Spatial Economy, Faculty of Environmental Engineering and Geodesy, Wroclaw University of
Environmental and Life Sciences, Wroclaw, Poland
Received: 21 May 2017; Accepted: 01 February 2018; Published online: 20 August 2018
AoBID: 1214 3
Abstract
Background and Study Aim:
As far as common adapve eects are concerned, long-term karate training based on kumite technique (so-
cially acceptable form of hand-to-hand-ghng) results in increased resistance to opponent’s strikes and abil-
ity to tolerate pain and certain type of body injuries. Therefore, it could be assumed that karate masters pos-
sess most of all certain personality traits, but kumite technique (style) is not a factor that signicantly modies
this relaonship and the prole of the world champions of the kumite style may dier from this model. The
goal of the study is to verify this hypothesis.
Material and Methods:
In total 150 best Polish kumite competors were included in the study; 30 each from ve techniques (styles) of
karate, including: semi contact- World Karate Federaon recognised by the Internaonal Olympic Commiee
(in this paper: WKF) and shōtōkan; full contact - Oyama; mix ghng - shidōkan; knockdown - kyokushin.
The subgroup of kumite karate champions (KKC, n = 23) consisted of winners of the gold medals of the world
championships, whereas the subgroup of karate masters (KM) consisted of other athletes (n=127). Personality
measurements were based on big ve NEO-FFI scales (neurocism, extraversion, openness to experience,
agreeableness, conscienousness).
Results:
It is true that karate masters have disncve personality traits (which include: low neurocism and high con-
scienousness), whereas it would be false to assume that kumite technique (style) is not a factor that sig-
nicantly modies this relaonship. WKF karate athletes exhibits the lowest neurocism when compares to
other ones (p<0.01); Oyama karatekas exhibits lower extraversion than WKF, shidōkan and kyokushin ath-
letes (p<0.05). It turned out to be true that personality proles of gold medal winners of the World Karate
Championships of kumite style (KKC) may dier from the model of the remaining KM.
Conclusions:
The new empirical argumentaon is an important premise for conducng in-depth personality studies on ath-
letes at every stage of a sports career. Such knowledge combined with studies of other predisposions and
adapve eects (that are in relaon to unique events determined by various types of sports) is a prerequisite
for embodying social and health-related mission of sports in an opmal manner.
Key words:
big ve NEO-FFI • kata • poomse • sports psychology • tori • uke
Copyright:
© 2018 the Authors. Published by Archives of Budo
Conflict of interest:
Authors have declared that no compeng interest exists
Ethical approval:
The study was approved by the local Ethics Commiee
Provenance & peer review:
Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed
Source of support:
Departmental sources
Author’s address:
Paweł Piepiora, Wroclaw University School of Physical Educaon, Paderewskiego 35 Str., 51-612 Wroclaw,
Poland; e-mail: pawel.piepiora@awf.wroc.pl
Authors’ Contribution:
A Study Design
B Data Collection
C Statistical Analysis
D Manuscript Preparation
EFunds Collection
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
248
|
VOLUME 14 | 2018 www.archbudo.com
Original Article
INTRODUCTION
In sports psychology, issues related to personal-
ity are raised especially from the perspecve of
organizers, teachers and educators when various
inter-individual psychophysical properes and
behaviours of people praccing sport or pursu-
ing health goals through the physical acvity are
described and explained [1-3]. Numerous psy-
chological theories can be disnguished. One of
them, trait theory (also referred to as the dispo-
sional theory) is an approach to the study of
human personality [4-9]. This theory is based on
factor analysis and may turn out very useful in
diagnosing the psychological prole of individ-
ual athletes and construcng psychological mod-
els of athletes of a given discipline (or guravely
speaking: of their strengths and weaknesses).
Studies on personality of athletes conducted
so far revealed that compared with those who
do not pracce any sport they exhibit various
levels of conscienousness and extraversion.
Athletes are more social and consistent [10-18].
Substanal dierences were also found between
athletes praccing team sports and individ-
ual sports. However, this issue raises legimate
controversy, as many sciensts consider com-
bat sports athletes persons training individual
sports. This disncon is only parally true (jus-
ed). Let us focus on combat sports that are in
the program of the Olympic Games. In order to
execute their sports mission, a boxer, swordsman,
or wrestler has to ght directly with a compet-
itor (socially acceptable form of hand-to-hand-
ghng). In case of a judo athlete praccing kata
(as well as sports compeon of this style that
is however not included in the programme of
the Olympic Games) requires a partner who has
to respect the role of uke (a person who does
not interfere with the goal of tori; on the con-
trary a partner should help achieving this goal).
Therefore, considering representaves of these
Olympic combat sports as those who pracce
individual sports primarily fails to meet criteria of
logic. On the other hand, karate and taekwondo
athletes (leaving aside the criteria of Olympic
compeon which involve kumite) can train and
compete in line with principles applicable in indi-
vidual sports. This means that an opponent does
not interfere with them directly through physi-
cal contact or, as in the case of sports games,
manipulang an item (a ball, puck, shulecock,
etc.), at the same me staying in close contact
(racket sports, volleyball) or even very oen in
direct physical contact (hockey, football, etc.).
Exercises and compeon using kata (karate) or
poomse (taekwondo) techniques give karate ath-
lete and taekwondo athlete comfort of not being
disturbed directly by an opponent.
The queson of why some karate and taekwondo
athletes but also judo athletes decide on sports
career involving compeon based on kata
(poomse) techniques remains open. This issue is
important because it is jused to claim that the
group of individual sports (disnguished also by
some sciensts for research-related purposes)
does not meet methodological criteria of ade-
quate distribuon. Therefore, it is not surpris-
ing that players of team sports games showed
greater neurocism and extraversion than ath-
letes pracsing individual disciplines [19-24]. The
nature of compeng as a group against a group
is so obvious that especially in-depth interdisci-
plinary studies will probably reveal other common
traits that disnguish team-sport game leaders
from other players and perhaps also from ath-
letes praccing other disciplines.
On the other hand there is some empirical evi-
dence that personality proles of athletes of
individual disciplines who represent a diverse
sports level do not signicantly dier from each
other [25-42]. Thus, the theory of traits may
turn out to be important for studying traits
of athletes also because it sll remains unde-
termined whether there are personality traits
that predispose to success in sport regardless
of the discipline being pracced. Sport success
in team games (at least two players against two
players, as in double games, e.g. racket sports
or volleyball beach) – regardless of leading role
of the leaders – is always a derivave of the
eort put in by all team members. Failure is
oen the result of one (or several) mistake(-s)
made by only one team member. In individual
sports involving high energy expenditure (the
majority of athlecs compeon, weightliing,
cycling etc.) physical predisposions are a suc-
cess-determining factor.
Since mutual interference in such a way that
oensive and defensive acons are directed to
the opponent’s body directly (protectors only
parally protect against negave eects – fatal
cases are also known in fencing) is a common
factor in combat sports (except for expressive
forms of compeon: kata, poomse), mental
toughness and other personality traits acquire
parcular importance. This assumpon is
Kumite – is a karate
compeon, during which
two athletes use various
kicking, punching and blocking
techniques towards each
other with control in order
to gain points and win the
compeon. Permissible
contact depends on maral /
karate style regulaons [71].
Kyokushin – is a style of
stand-up, knockdown karate,
developed by Masutatsu
Oyama which means the
“Ulmate Truth”. It is based
on Sosai’s point and circle
concept by which one draws
a circle around one point and
aaches the lines around the
circle [72].
Oyama karate – full-contact
karate style, created by
Shigeru Ōyama (1983).
Shidōkanis a style of mix
ghng karate; founded in
1980 [73].
Shotokan – semi contact
style of karate started and
pioneered by Sensei Gichin
Funakoshi. Inially, shotokan
was the name of the rst
karate dojo (the “honbu dojo” –
central dojo), but over me it
became the name of the style
of karate taught / pracsed by
Sensei Funakoshi [74].
Sports psychologynoun
is scienc study of mental
state of athletes, focusing on
issues, such as movaon,
concentraon, stress and self-
condence [75].
Sport psychology – is an
interdisciplinary science that
draws on knowledge from
many related elds, including
biomechanics, physiology,
kinesiology and psychology.
It involves the study of
how psychological factors
aect performance and how
parcipaon in sport and
exercise aect psychological
and physical factors [76].
Kata – predetermined and
choreographed physical
exercises, which together
with free exercises (randori),
Piepiora P et al. – Personality profiles of karate master s...
© ARCHIVES OF BUDO
|
SCIENCE OF MARTIAL ARTS 2018
|
VOLUME 14
|
249
jused as one of long-term karate training
based on kumite technique (which means that
the eect applies to all praconers of this
technique) results in increased to the oppo-
nent’s strikes and ability to tolerate pain and
certain type of body injuries.
If these premises and assumpons are true,
it could be assumed that karate masters pos-
sess most of all certain personality traits, but
kumite technique (style) is not a factor that
signicantly modies this relaonship and the
prole of the world champions of the kumite
style may dier from this model. The goal of
the study is to verify this hypothesis.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Study design
Personality proles based on the big ve NEO-
FFI scales: neurocism, extraversion, openness
to experience, agreeableness, conscienous-
ness, oen represented by the acronyms
OCEAN or CANOE were applied as an empiri-
cal criterion for verifying the hypothesis [43-
47]. Beneath each global factor, there are
several correlated and more specic primary
factors (for example extraversion is associated
with: gregariousness, asserveness, excitement
seeking, warmth, acvity and posive emo-
ons). Each of ve scales consists of 12 items
(the raw score in each scale ranges from 0 to
48). The higher the numerical score in the scale,
the greater the intensity of given trait (greater
number of diagnosc responses reects higher
intensity of traits of given person).
The following inclusion criteria were applied:
long-term sports experience; licence of kumite
in one of ve predetermined types of karate;
impeccable opinion given by the instructor;
documented sports achievements at vari-
ous compeon levels (naonal, connental,
global). Exclusion criteria: ethical or unsports-
manlike lifestyle; no recommendaon from the
instructor. The design has been approved by
the local ethics commiee.
Participants
In total 150 best Polish kumite competors
were included in the study; 30 each from ve
techniques (styles) of karate, including: semi
contact- World Karate Federaon recognised
by the Internaonal Olympic Commiee (in this
arcle: karate WKF) and shōtōkan; full con-
tact- Oyama karate; mix ghng - shidōkan;
knockdown - kyokushin. Current (and former)
members of the naonal team, medallists of
World European and Polish Championships
were among karate athletes. The average age
of parcipants amounted to 27.7 years (18 to
39 years).
Regardless of the karate technique (style)
trained, a group of 23 “kumite karate cham-
pions” (KKC) was disnguished. It consisted
of those who won at least one golden medal
in kumite karate world championships. The
remaining group (n=127) consisted of silver
and bronze medallists of world championships,
medallists of the European and Polish champi-
onships. This was the reference group (“karate
masters”).
The study was carried out during seminars,
training camps of the naonal team and
naonal compeons in 2012-2016.
Statistical analysis
The stascal analysis of data is performed
using Stasca v.12 soware. It involved indi-
cators of descripve stascs: arithmec mean
value, median, standard deviaon (in tables
referred to as SD or ±), error of the mean, range
(minimum÷maximum results and lower÷upper
quarle), variaon coecient, skewness, stan-
dard error (SE) and condence intervals. We
used analysis of variance (ANOVA). The signif-
icance of dierences between groups was es-
mated by means of Student’s t-test.
RESULTS
Generally personality prole of karate athletes
pracsing various types of kumite is similar (mod-
erate neurocism, openness to experience and
agreeableness as well as high conscienousness
and extraversion), suggesng that this part of ver-
ied hypothesis is true (Tables 1 to 5). On the
other hand, statement that kumite type (style) is
not a factor that signicantly modies this model
is untrue. WKF karate athletes exhibit the low-
est level of neurocism among athletes studied
(Table 6, Figure 1) as well as the lowest intersub-
ject variability in case of this trait (Table 6).The
ANOVA analysis indicates lack of homogeneity
in case of neurocism (p<0.001) and extraver-
sion (p<0.05) (Table 7). Post-hoc test revealed
lectures (kōgi) and discussions
(mondō) form the four crical
pillars of Kōdōkan jūdō
educaon [77].
Kata – prescribed paerns or
sequences of techniques [78]
Kata (form) – is executed as
a specied series of a variety
of moves, with stepping and
turning, while aempng
to maintain perfect form.
Kata reects a transion
and ow from one posture
and movement to another,
teaching the karateka proper
form and posion, and
encouraging them to visualize
dierent scenarios for the use
of each moon and technique
in imaginary bout. There
are various forms of kata
developed through dierent
karate styles.
Poomse (kata in taekwondo)
– it is tradionally understood
as the style of conduct
which expresses directly
or indirectly mental and
physical renements as well
as the principles of oense
and defence resulng from
culvaon of taekwondo spirit
and techniques. Nowadays,
poomse is involved in
compeon in the taekwondo
technique modality.
Tori – the person who applies
a technique in judo training.
The receiver of the technique
is referred to as uke [78].
Racket sport noun any of
various sports that use a
racket and ball or shulecock,
e.g. tennis, badminton or
squash [75].
250
|
VOLUME 14 | 2018 www.archbudo.com
Original Article
that only WKF karate athletes exhibit lower neu-
rocism than each group of other kumite kara-
tekas and greater extraversion (p<0.01) only than
Oyama karate athletes at stascally signicant
levels (at least p <0.01). Oyama karatekas show
lower extraversion than shidōkan and kyokushin
karate athletes as well as lower agreeableness
than shidōkan karatekas (Table 7).
It turned out to be true that personality proles
of Kumite karate world champions (KKC) may dif-
fer from the prole of the remaining KM. KKC
exhibits very low neurocism (p<0.001) and con-
scienousness, extraversion and agreeableness
greater than the ones of KM. On the other hand
both groups of karatekas are similar in terms
of moderate openness to experience (Table 8,
Figure 2). Nevertheless variance analysis conrms
the greatest probability of dierences in terms of
neurocism and conscienousness both by t-test
and variance rao test (F-test) results (Table 8).
DISCUSSION
The results of our studies on personalies of
karate athletes pracsing kumite style, per-
formed with the use of the big ve NEO-FFI
method, conrm that their personalies are gen-
erally consistent with proles of athletes training
other sports disciplines (moderate neurocism,
openness to experience and agreeableness as
well as high conscienousness and extraversion).
Therefore, the most general conclusion is that
test results may be interpreted based on well-
known psychological theories: temperament is
a relavely constant biological property of an
organism that genecs-related; and personality
is a noon structured on temperament that is
shaped by environment [48]; in case of athletes
these include regular training smuli and experi-
ence gained during compeon.
Since personality evolves, changes during a life-
me and temperament is constant and unchange-
able, the fundamental cognive dilemma from the
study-related perspecve raises several impor-
tant methodological issues. First of all, because
we do not possess knowledge about personality
of studied karate athletes from the previous peri-
ods of their sporng career, we cannot infer about
how their long-term training could have aected
possible changes of this important human prop-
erty. Second of all, it is unlikely that with large
motor similarity of karate training and regard-
less of multude of kumite techniques (styles)
(from semi contact to knockdown), formal exer-
cises and parcipaon in combats (during training
and compeon) could have a decisive impact on
shaping personality of praconers, leaving aside
inuence of their instructor and other enes in
the closest social environment of a karate athlete.
Third of all, we lack empirical knowledge about
comprehensive impact of an instructor (his or her
personality) and other social factors on the per-
sonality of a karate athlete. Therefore, compara-
ve results of world champions (KKC) with other
karate masters (KM) pracsing various types of
kumite style have the greatest cognive value at
the current stage of studies on this phenomenon.
It is an open queson to determine whether the
personality prole of world champions has been
shaped only in the course of a long-term sport-
ing career or whether they manifested already at
Table 1. Estimated results of WKF karatekas (n = 30) related to their personality prole according to the big ve NEO-FFI scales.
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean
SD Median
Range Variation coe-
cient Skewness
results
min÷max
quartile lower÷up-
per
Neuroticism 8.93
±2.60 8.50 12
3÷15
3
7÷10 29.092 0.5203
Extraversion 32.60
±3.84 32 16
26÷42
4
30÷34 11.773 0.6460
Openness to experience 26.60
±6.36 29 23
15÷38
9
22÷31 23.911 −0.2292
Agreeableness 29.30
±5.69 29.50 32
14÷46
4
27÷31 19.414 0.2549
Conscientiousness 37.30
±4.34 37 18
29÷47
6
34÷40 11.64 0.1503
Piepiora P et al. – Personality profiles of karate master s...
© ARCHIVES OF BUDO
|
SCIENCE OF MARTIAL ARTS 2018
|
VOLUME 14
|
251
Table 3. Estimated results of Oyama karatekas (n = 30) related to their personality prole according to the big ve NEO-FFI scales.
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean
SD Median
Range Variation
coecient Skewness
results
min÷max
quartile
lower÷upper
Neuroticism 15.17
±7.29 16.50 29
00÷29
11
9÷20 48.08 −0.109
Extraversion 28.83
±6.18 29.50 22
19÷41
8
25÷33 21.42 0.234
Openness to experience 27.43
±6.02 27.50 23
17÷40
9
23÷32 21.95 0.662
Agreeableness 28.40
±4.92 28.00 22
17÷39
7
25÷32 17.31 0.107
Conscientiousness 35.03
±7.29 34.50 25
22÷47
13
29÷42 20.81 −0.135
Table 4. Estimated results of shidōkan karatekas (n = 30) related to their personality prole according to the big ve NEO-FFI scales.
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean
SD Median
Range Variation coef-
cient Skewness
results
min÷max
quartile lower÷up-
per
Neuroticism 13.90
±8.11 13.50 29
00÷29
11
8÷19 58.33 0.402
Extraversion 31.33
±4.46 31 17
23÷40
5
29÷34 14.23 0.041
Openness to experience 27.03
±6.02 27 25
16÷41
7
23÷30 22.27 0.422
Agreeableness 31.23
±5.55 30.50 26
22÷48
6
28÷34 17.77 0.850
Conscientiousness 35.57
±6.39 35.50 24
22÷46
9
32÷41 17.97 −0.282
Table 2. Estimated results of shōtōkan karatekas (n = 30) related to their personality prole according to the big ve NEO-FFI scales.
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean
SD Median
Range Variation coef-
cient Skewness
results
min÷max
quartile lower÷up-
per
Neuroticism 14.50
±5.62 15 25
00÷25
5
13÷18 38.75 −0.735
Extraversion 31.30
±5.14 51.5 19
23÷42
7
27÷34 16.42 0.144
Openness to experience 26.70
±6.80 28 23
15÷38
12
20÷33 25.46 −0.152
Agreeableness 29.60
±5.59 29 32
14÷46
7
26÷33 18.89 0.307
Conscientiousness 34.97
±6.91 36 27
20÷47
11
29÷40 19.76 −0.433
252
|
VOLUME 14 | 2018 www.archbudo.com
Original Article
the beginning of karate pracce: very low neu-
rocism (desired trait), conscienousness, extra-
version and agreeableness greater than other
beginning karatekas and moderate openness to
experience similar to other karatekas (see Table
8 and Figure 2).
In our opinion, the results provide new arguments
about the health aspects of combat sports training
(socially acceptable form of hand-to-hand-ght-
ing), maral arts and self-defence, as the so-called
sports of life [49-54]. When we state that we are
concerned only with the socially acceptable form
of combat (such as kumite style), we leave aside
a pathological phenomenon of neogladiatorship,
which is related to maral arts [55], is promoted
by electronic media and is also present in science.
This complex of phenomena is the subject of in-
depth studies of innovave agonology experts that
have become more popular from 2015 [56-58]. It
is not dicult to prove the instrumental use of sci-
ence. The authors of published studies on contem-
porary gladiators do not cricise the pathological
aspect of this phenomenon even if given publica-
on provides knowledge about death and body
injuries as a result of massacring an opponent who
is oen already lying down [e.g. 59].
On the other hand, there are few empirical
papers addressing the phenomena of mental
Table 5. Estimated results of kyokushin karatekas (n = 30) related to their personality prole according to the big ve NEO-FFI scales.
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean
SD Median
Range Variation
coecient Skewness
results
min÷max
quartile
lower÷upper
Neuroticism 14.63
±6.81 16.50 25
2÷27
9
9÷18 46.50 0.005
Extraversion 32.33
±4.82 32 18
24÷42
8
28÷36 14.92 0.237
Openness to experience 25.33
±5.74 24 23
15÷38
7
22÷29 22.65 0.478
Agreeableness 28.83
±6.04 29 27
19÷46
9
23÷32 20.95 0.767
Conscientiousness 35.47
±7.75 34.50 30
18÷48
11
30÷41 21.86 −0.075
Table 6. Summarised results of karatekas related to their personality prole according to the big ve NEO-FFI scales.
Group of
karatekas
Extraversion Neuroticism Openness to experience Agreeableness Conscientiousness
mean
SD
SE
condence
−95%;
+95%
mean
SD
SE
condence
−95%; +95%
mean
SD
SE
condence
−95%; +95%
mean
SD
SE
condence
−95%; +95%
mean
SD
SE
condence
−95%;
+95%
all
(n = 150)
31.28
±5.06
0.41
30.46; 32.1
13.43
±6.70
0.55
12.35; 14.51
26.62
±6.16
0.50
25.63; 27.61
29.47
±5.58
0.46
28.57; 30.37
35.67
±6.61
0.54
34.6; 36.73
Individual kumite techniques (styles); each group consisted of 30 people
WKF 32.60
±3.84
0.70
31.17; 34.03
8.93
±2.60
0.47
7.96; 9.9
26.60
±6.36
1.16
24.22; 28.98
29.30
±5.69
1.04
27.18; 31.42
37.30
±4.34
0.79
35.68; 38.92
shōtōkan 31.30
±5.14
0.94 29.38;
33.22
14.50
±5.62 1.03 12.4; 16.6 26.70
±6.80 1.24 24.16; 29.24 29.60
±5.59
1.02 27.51;
31.69
34.97
±6.91
1.26 32.39;
37.55
Oyama karate 28.83
±6.18
1.13
26.53; 31.14
15.17
±7.29
1.33
12.44; 17.89
27.43
±6.02
1.10
25.19; 29.68
28.40
±4.92
0.90
26.56; 30.24
35.03
±7.29
1.33
32.31; 37.76
shidōkan 31.33
±4.46 0.81 29.67; 33.0 13.90
±8.11
1.48 10.87;
16.93
27.03
±6.02 1.10 24.79; 29.28 31.23
±5.55
1.01 29.16;
33.31
35.57
±6.39
1.17 33.18;
37.95
kyokushin 32.33
±4.82
0.88
30.53; 34.13
14.63
±6.81
1.24
12.09; 17.17
25.33
±5.74
1.05
23.19; 27.48
31.23
±5.55
1.10
26.58; 31.09
35.57
±7.75
1.42
32.57; 38.36
Piepiora P et al. – Personality profiles of karate master s...
© ARCHIVES OF BUDO
|
SCIENCE OF MARTIAL ARTS 2018
|
VOLUME 14
|
253
eects of karate training [60, 61] or especially
personality shaping in the broad context of pos-
ive health and survival ability through a rao-
nal, long-term training of combat sports and
maral arts. Although sciensts studying predis-
posions to broadly understood hand-to-hand-
ghng (self-defence and combat sports) focus
on specic tests and motor smulaons [49, 54,
62-65] as well as on fun forms of maral arts [66,
67], they emphasize that these tests and motor
simulaons contain a mental component in their
assumpons and interpretaon of empirical data.
The most recent publicaons disnguish muldi-
mensional tests, some of which idenfy abilies
(talent) of hand-to-hand-ghng [68]. Stanislaw
Dadelo [69] discovered signicant correlaons
between the S-Index (the percentage of scues
won relave to all scues conducted by given
subject during TFVP) and professional acv-
ity, theorecal and praccal preparaon, men-
tal traits (indicators directly informing us about
intellectual potenal) of 118 male guards from
Lithuania.
All indicators of TFVP (“tesng ghts in a ver-
cal posture”), in our opinion, can be correlated
also with psychological personality tests indica-
tors already at the inial stage of each combat
Figure 1. Visualization of personality profiles of karate athletes (each group consisted of 30
people) practicing various kumite techniques (styles).
Table 7. Variance analysis
of the results of the big five NEO-FFI scales (df 148) obtained by
gold medal winners of the World Karate Championships (KKC) and other karate masters in
kumite style (KM).
NEO-FFI
Variable
ANOVA
Probability for post hoc test (value p)
WKF
Oyama
shidōkan
F
p
shōtōkan
Oyama
shidōkan
kyokushin
Oyama
shidōkan
kyokushin
shidōkan
kyokushin
kyokushin
Neuroticism
4.80
0.001
0.001
0.000
0.003
0.001
0.686
0.716
0.936
0.443
0.7466
0.6569
Extraversion
2.71
0.033
0.311
0.004
0.323
0.835
0.055
0.979
0.420
0.052
0.0069
0.4351
Openness to
experience
0.49
0.745
0.950
0.603
0.787
0.430
0.647
0.835
0.394
0.803
0.1915
0.2899
Agreeableness
1.14
0.341
0.835
0.532
0.181
0.746
0.405
0.258
0.595
0.051
0.7636
0.0973
Conscientiousne
ss
0.61
0.654
0.176
0.189
0.314
0.287
0.969
0.727
0.771
0.756
0.8009
0.9536
It turned out to be true that personality profiles of Kumite karate world champions (KKC) may
differ from the profile of the remaining KM. KKC exhibits very low neuroticism (p<0.001) and
conscientiousness, extraversion and agreeableness greater than the ones of KM. On the other
hand both groups of karatekas are similar in terms of moderate openness to experience (Table
8, Figure 2). Nevertheless variance analysis
confirms the greatest probability of differences in
terms of neuroticism and conscientiousness both by t-test and variance ratio test (F-test) results
(Table 8).
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Neuroticism Extraversion Openness to
experience
Agreeableness Conscientiousness
WKF shōtōkan Oyama shidōkan kyokushin
Figure 1. Visualization of personality proles of karate athletes (each group consisted of 30 people) practicing various
kumite techniques (styles).
Table 7. Variance analysis of the results of the big ve NEO-FFI scales (df 148) obtained by gold medal winners of the World Karate Championships
(KKC) and other karate masters in kumite style (KM).
NEO-FFI
Variable
ANOVA
Probability for post hoc test (value p)
WKF shōtōkan Oyama shidōkan
F p
shōtōkan
Oyama shidōkan kyokushin Oyama shidōkan kyokushin shidōkan kyokushin kyokushin
Neuroticism 4.80 0.001 0.001 0.000 0.003 0.001 0.686 0.716 0.936 0.443 0.7466 0.6569
Extraversion 2.71 0.033 0.311 0.004 0.323 0.835 0.055 0.979 0.420 0.052 0.0069 0.4351
Openness to
experience 0.49 0.745 0.950 0.603 0.787 0.430 0.647 0.835 0.394 0.803 0.1915 0.2899
Agreeableness 1.14 0.341 0.835 0.532 0.181 0.746 0.405 0.258 0.595 0.051 0.7636 0.0973
Conscientiousness 0.61 0.654 0.176 0.189 0.314 0.287 0.969 0.727 0.771 0.756 0.8009 0.9536
254
|
VOLUME 14 | 2018 www.archbudo.com
Original Article
sports training. There is sucient empirical evi-
dence that S-Index and F-Index (i.a. the percent-
age of ghts won relave to all ghts conducted
by given subject) correlate lowly with results of
recommended motor tests [49, 62-65, 68, 69].
At the inial stage of training (before trainees
learn ghng techniques typical of given com-
bat sport or intervenon techniques in the case
of self-defence training TFVPs are mostly won
by persons demonstrang talent for this acvity
(hand-to-hand-ghng). It is obvious that some
gied persons exhibit also very high tness level
and this has nothing to do with their movaon
to undertake training of combat sports. Unique
studies of Niedomagała [65] provided evidence
that young judo athletes (a total of girls and boys),
who won all TFVPs (F-Index 100%) in 5-person,
4-person, 3-person tesng groups, proved their
high eecveness more frequently during tour-
naments ghng in a three-year stage of pre-
liminary judo training. Unfortunately, there is
no empirical knowledge about the S-Index and
F-Index relaonship with scores achieved in psy-
chological personality tests. This results in limited
possibilies of broader interpretaon not only of
the results of our studies from the interdisciplin-
ary perspecve.
Furthermore, we distance ourselves from the par-
adigm of associang all study results concerning
Table 8. Variance analysis of results of the big ve NEO-FFI scales obtained by karate athletes practising kumite style (each group consisted of 30 people).
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean SD Variance analysis
KKC
(n = 23)
KM
(n =127) t-test p variance ratio test
(F-test) p
Neuroticism 4.39 ±2.190 15.06 ±5.883 −8.572 0.0000 7.220 0.0000
Extraversion 34.22
±3.753 30.75 ±5.096 3.112 0.0022 1.843 0.0977
Openness to experience 28.30
±6.413 26.31 ±6.084 1.431 0.1545 1.111 0.6876
Agreeableness 33.22
±5.776 28.79 ±5.289 3.638 0.0004 1.192 0.5325
Conscientiousness 41.26 ±4.505 34.65 ±6.432 4.715 0.0000 2.039 0.0551
Table 8. Variance analysis of results of the big five NEO-FFI scales obtained by karate
athletes practising kumite style (each group consisted of 30 people).
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean SD
Variance analysis
KKC
(n = 23)
KM
(n =127)
t-test
p
variance
ratio test
(F-test)
p
Neuroticism
4.39
±2.190
15.06
±5.883
8.572
0.0000
7.220
0.0000
Extraversion
34.22
±3.753
30.75
±5.096
3.112
0.0022
1.843
0.0977
Openness to
experience
28.30
±6.413
26.31
±6.084
1.431
0.1545
1.111
0.6876
Agreeableness
33.22
±5.776
28.79
±5.289
3.638
0.0004
1.192
0.5325
Conscientiousness
41.26
±4.505
34.65
±6.432
4.715
0.0000
2.039
0.0551
Figure 2. Personality profiles of gold medal winners of the World Karate Championships of
kumite style (KKC) and other karate masters in kumite style (KM).
DISCUSSION
The results of our studies on personalities of karate athletes practising kumite style, performed
with the use of the big five NEO-FFI method, confirm that their personalities are generally
consistent with profiles of athletes training other sports disciplines (moderate neuroticism,
openness to experience and agreeableness as well as high conscientiousness and extraversion).
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Neuroticism Extraversion Openness to
experience
Agreeableness Conscientiousness
KKC (n = 23) KM (n = 127)
**
** **
**
Figure 2. Personality proles of gold medal winners of the World Karate Championships of kumite style (KKC) and
other karate masters in kumite style (KM).
Piepiora P et al. – Personality profiles of karate master s...
© ARCHIVES OF BUDO
|
SCIENCE OF MARTIAL ARTS 2018
|
VOLUME 14
|
255
adapve eects of long-term training of karate
and other combat sports primarily with the possi-
bility of achieving successes at the highest levels
of compeon for the longest possible period of
professional sports career. There is a close asso-
ciaon between health-related mission of com-
bat sports and maral arts and not only as one
of the most aracve “sports of life” with uli-
tarian values) and awareness of many patholo-
gies that are also present in this type of physical
acvity. The need to overcome numerous barri-
ers in promong health-related values primarily
of combat sports [70] is only apparently obvious
but at the same me very dicult achieve in the
world dominated by electronic media. Direct ght
is such an aracve product that lm careers of
masters in karate and other combat sports are
not surprising. However, we are concerned about
the fact that combat sports athletes undertake a
role of neogladiators and that is why we acvely
parcipate in the World Congress of Health and
Maral Arts in Interdisciplinary Approach (so far
organised twice: in 2015 and 2018).
CONCLUSIONS
The new empirical argumentaon is an important
premise for conducng in-depth personality stud-
ies on athletes at every stage of a sports career.
Such knowledge combined with studies of other
predisposions and adapve eects (that are in
relaon to unique events determined by various
types of sports) is a prerequisite for embody-
ing social and health-related mission of sports in
an opmal manner. Thus, the basic criterion for
vericaon of theorecal foundaons and acvi-
es related to training is both innovaveness of
formulated rules for creang high quality of life
(which cannot omit sports acvity, including ele-
ments of combat sports) and the degree of com-
pliance of these rules with applicaons.
REFERENCES
1.
Kosińska H. Osobowość sportowca. In: T.
Tyszka, editor. Psychologia i sport. Warszawa:
AWF; 1991 [in Polish]
2.
Gracz J. Czy ktoś widział osobowość? Czyli
o znaczeniu osobowości w działalności spor-
towej. Sport Wyczynowy 1994; 1-2 [in Polish]
3.
Gracz J, Sankowski T. Psychologia aktywności
sportowej. Poznań: Akademia Wychowania
Fizycznego im. Eugeniusza Piaseckiego w
Poznaniu, Seria: Podręczniki 58; 2007 [in Polish]
4.
Caell RB. The scienc analysis of person-
ality. Balmore: Penguin; 1965
5.
Eysenck HJ. Fact and con in psychology.
Balmore: Penguin; 1966
6. Eysenck H, Nias DK, Cox DN. Sport and per-
sonality. Adv Behav Res Ther 1983: 4 (1): 1-56
7.
Eysenck HJ. Keane M. Cognive psychology.
Hove: LEA; 1995
8.
Jarvis M. Sport Psychology. London: Routledge
Modular Psychology; 1999
9.
Kassin SM. Psychology. USA: Prence-Hall,
Inc. 2003
10.
Schurr KT, Ashley MA, Joy KL. A mulvari-
ante analysis of male athlete characterscs:
sport type an success. Mulvar Exp Clin Res
1977; 1: 53-68
11. Highlen PS, Benne BB. Psychological char-
acteriscs of successful and non-successful
elite wrestlers: an exploratory study. J Sport
Psychol 1979; 1: 123-137
12.
Rychta T. Kierunki badań nad osobowością
ludzi uprawiających sport. In: III Konferencja
Humanistystyczne Podstawy Kultury Fizycznej:
aktualny stan badań. Poznań: AWF Poznań;
1979 [in Polish]
13.
Gould D, Weiss M, Weinberg R. Psychological
characteriscs of successful and non-suc-
cessful Big Ten wrestlers. J Sport Psychol
1981; 3: 69-81
14.
McGill JC, Hall JR, Ratli WR et al. Personality
characteriscs of professional rodeo cowboys.
J Sport Behav 1986; 9: 143-151
15. Clingman JM., Hiliard DV. Some personalisty
characterisc of super-adherer: following
those who go beyond tness. J Sport Behav
1987; 10: 123-136.
16.
Garland DJ, Barry JR. Personality and leader
behaviours in collegiate football: a muldi-
mensional approach to performance. J Res
Pers 1990; 24: 355-370.
17. Chirivella EC, Marnez LM. The sensaon of
risk and movaonal tendencies in sports:
an empirical study. Pers Indiv Dier 1994;
16: 777-786
18.
Bleidorn W, Kandler C, Hulsheger UR et al.
Nature and nurture of the interplay between
personality traits and major life goals. J Pers
Soc Psychol 2010; 99: 366-379
19.
Taylor D, Doria J. Self-serving and group-serv-
ing bias in aribuon. J Soc Psychol 1981;
113: 201-211
20.
Piedmont R, Hill D, Blanco S. Predicng athlec
performance using the ve-factormodel of per-
sonality. J Pers Individ Dier 1999; 27: 769-77
21. Busato V, Prins F, Elshout J et al. Intellectual
ability, learning style, personality, achievement
movaon and academic success of psychol-
ogy students in higher educaon. J Pers Individ
Dier 2000; 29: 1057-1068
22.
Bernatek, Cwyl S., Dudziak D et al. Cechy
temperamentu i osobowość zawodników
sportów walki i zespołowych gier sportowych.
In: D. Parzelski, editor. Psychologia w spor
-
cie. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu
Warszawskiego; 2006: 50-57 [in Polish]
23.
Shrivastaval P, Gopal R, Singh Y. A Study of
Personality Dimensions in Sports Performance.
J Exer Sci Physiother 2010; 1: 39-42
24.
Ilyasi G, Salehian MH. Comparison of personal-
ity traits between individual and team athletes.
Middle East J Sci Res 2011; 9 (4): 527-530
25.
Rychta T. Osobowość a zachowanie celowe
sportowców. Warszawa: COS; 1998 [in Polish]
26.
Piedmont RL, Hill D, Blanco S. Predicng ath-
lec performance using the ve factor model
of personality. J Pers Individ Dier 1999;
27:769-777
27.
Backmand H, Kapiro J, Kujala U et al. Personality
and mood of former elite athletes: a descrip-
ve study. Int J Sports Med 2003; 22: 215-221
28.
McKelvie SJ, Lemieux P, Stout D. Ekstraversion
and neurocism in contact athletes, no contact
athletes and non-athletes: a research note. J
Sport Psychol 2003; 5 (3): 19-27.
29.
Aidman E, Schofield G. Personality and
Individual Dierences in Sport. Milton: Wiley;
2004
256
|
VOLUME 14 | 2018 www.archbudo.com
Original Article
30.
Piepiora P, Witkowski K. Personality traits
of compeve athletes according to type of
pressure exerted on opponents. S Afr J for Res
Sport Ph 2018; 40(1): 97-109
31.
Bara Filho MG, Scipiao Ribeiro LC, Garcia
FC. Comparsion of personality characteris-
cs between high-level Brazilian athletes and
nonathletes. Rev Braz Med Exporte 2005;
11(2): 114-118
32. Robbins S, Judge T. Organizaonal Behavior.
London: Prense Hall; 2008
33.
Anghel A, Banica I, Ionescu S. Personality fea
-
tures of elite athletes considering the criterion
of the sport pracced. Sport Science Review
2009; 1: 5-6
34.
Brewer B. Sport Psychology. London: WB; 2009
35.
Allen MS., Greenlees I, Jones M. An inves-
gaon of the ve-factor model of personal-
ity and coping behaviour in sport. J Sport Sci
2011; 29: 841-850
36.
Tok S. The Big Five personality traits and risky
sport parcipaon. Soc Behav Pers Int J 2011;
39: 1105-1012
37.
Binboga E, Guven S, Catikkas F et al.
Psychophysiological responses to compe-
on and the Big Five personality traits. J Hum
Kinet 2012; 33: 187-194.
38.
Allen MS, Greenlees I, Jones M. Personality in
sport: a comprehensive review. Int Rev Sport
Exer Psychol 2013; 6: 184-208
39.
Mirzaei A, Nikbakhsh R, Sharififar F. The
relaonship between personality traits and
sport performance. Eur J Exp Biol 2013; 3
(3): 439-442
40.
Tomczak M, Bręczewski G, Sokołowski M et
al. Personality traits and stress coping styles
in the Polish Naonal Cadet Wrestling Team.
Arch Budo 2013; 2: 161–168.
41.
Allen MS, Laborde S. The role of personality
in sport and physical acvity. Curr Dir Psychol
Sci 2014; 23: 460-465
42.
Piepiora P, Piepiora D, Witkowski K. Personality
of the karatekas versus kumite sport ght sys-
tems (in view of the karate culture as the regu-
lator of this interdependence). J Combat Sport
Maral Arts 2016; 7 (1): 35-41
43. Wiggins J. The Five-Factor model of person-
ality. New York: The Guildford Press; 1996
44.
McCrae R, Costa Jr P. Personality in Adulthood:
A Five-Factor theory perspecve. New York:
Guilford Press; 2003
45.
Costa Jr P, McCrae R. Personality inventory Five
Factor model test. In: Zawadzki B, Strelau J,
Szczepaniak M et al., editors. NEO-FFI - Inwentarz
Osobowości NEO-FFI. Warszawa: Pracownia
Testów Psychologicznych; 2007 [in Polish]
46.
John OP, Naumann LP, Soto CJ. Paradigm
shi to the integrave Big-Five trait taxon-
omy: History, Measurement, and Conceptual
Issues. In: John OP, Robins RW, Pervin LA,
editors. Handbook of personality: Theory
and research. New York, NY: Guilford Press;
2008: 114-158
47.
Soto CJ, John OP, Gosling SD et al. The develop-
mental psychometrics of Big Five self-reports:
acquiescence, factor structure, coherence, and
dierenaon from ages 10 to 20. J Pers Soc
Psychol 2008; 94: 718-737
48.
Zimbardo P, Johnson RL, McCann V.
Psychology: Core Concepts. Sixth Edion.
Pearson Educaon Inc.; 2010
49.
Syska JR. Psychomotoryczne efekty uprawi-
ania przez kobiety nowoczesnych form
gimnastyczno-tanecznych z elementami samo-
obrony. [PhD Thesis]. Warszawa: Akademia
Wychowania Fizycznego Józefa Piłsudskiego;
2005 [in Polish]
50.
Kalina RM, Barczynski BJ. Presge and impact
Archives of Budo for scienc research of the
maral arts. Arch Budo 2010; 6(1): 53-55
51.
Bąk R. Combat sports and maral arts as an ele-
ment of health-related training. In: Kalina RM,
editor. Proceedings of the 1st World Congress
on Health and Maral Arts in Interdisciplinary
Approach; 2015 Sep 17-19; Czestochowa,
Poland. Warsaw: Archives of Budo; 2015:
190-192
52.
Boguszewski D. Zdrowotne aspekty sportów i
sztuk walki. Warszawa: Warszawski Uniwersytet
Medyczny; 2017 [in Polish]
53.
Biernat E, Krzepota J, Sadowska D. Maral Arts
as a Form of Undertaking Physical Acvity in
Leisure Time Analysis of Factors Determining
Parcipaon of Poles. Int J Environ Res Public
Health 2018; 15(9): 1989
54.
Kalina RM, Jagiełło W. Non-apparatus, Quasi-
apparatus and Simulaons Tests in Diagnosis
Posive Health and Survival Abilies. In: Ahram
T, editor. Advances in Human Factors in Sports,
Injury Prevenon and Outdoor Recreaon.
AHFE 2017. Advances in Intelligent Systems
and Computing. Cham: Springer; 2017:
121-128
55.
Kalina RM, Barczyński BJ. Long way to the
Czestochowa Declaraons 2015: HMA against
MMA. In: Kalina RM, editor. Proceedings of
the 1st World Congress on Health and Maral
Arts in Interdisciplinary Approach. 2015 Sep
17-19; Czestochowa, Poland. Warsaw: Archives
of Budo; 2015: 1-11
56.
Kalina RM. Agonology as a deeply esoteric
science an introducon to maral arts ther-
apy on a global scale. Procedia Manufacturing
2015; 3: 1195-1202
57.
Kalina RM. Agonology – the prospect of an
eecve defence of peace and unrestricted
freedom of sciensts. Arch Budo 2016; 12:
1-13
58.
Kalina RM, Barczyński BJ. Mixed assessments
as mental and pedagogic basis of innovave
self-defence. Arch Budo 2017; 13: 187-194
59.
Hishinuma ES, Umemoto KN, Nguyen TG et
al. Epidemiology of mixed maral arts and
youth violence in an ethnically diverse sam-
ple. Violence Vict 2012; 27(1): 439
60.
Boostani MH, Boostani MA, Rezaei AM. Sport
psychology in professional karate athletes: give
psychological guidelines in order to improve
their act in the compeons. Ann Biol Res
2013; 4 (1): 48-52
61.
Piskorska E, Mieszkowski J, Kochanowicz A
et al. Mental skills in combat sports – review
of methods anxiety evaluaon. Arch Budo
2016; 12: 301-313
62.
Kalina RM, Chodała A, Dadeło S et al. Empirical
basis for predicng success in combat sports
and self-defence. Kinesiology 2005: 37(1): 1-13
63. Kalina RM, Jagiełło W, Chodała A. The result
of “tesng ghts in a vercal posture” as a
criterion of talent for combat sports and self-
defence – secondary validaon (part I: the
reliability). Arch Budo Sci Maral Art Extreme
Sport 2015; 11: 229-238
64. Kalina RM, Jagiełło W, Chodała A. The result
of “tesng ghts in a vercal posture” as a
criterion of talent for combat sports and self-
defence – secondary validaon (part II: the
accuracy). Arch Budo Sci Maral Art Extreme
Sport 2016; 12: 163-180
65. Niedomagała W. The result of “tesng ghts
in a vercal posture” as a selecon criterion
for professional training of judo sport – prog-
nosc value TFVP. Arch Budo Sci Maral Art
Extreme Sport 2016; 12: 181-190
66.
Jagiełło W, Kalina RM, Klimczak J et al. Fun
forms of maral arts in posive enhancement
of all dimensions of health and survival abili-
es. In: Kalina RM, editor. Proceedings of the
1st World Congress on Health and Maral Arts
in Interdisciplinary Approach. 2015 Sep 17-19;
Czestochowa, Poland. Warsaw: Archives of
Budo; 2015: 32-39
67. Klimczak J, Kalina RM, Jagiełło W. Fun forms
of maral arts in diagnosing and reducing
aggressiveness – mental eects of a one-
day course for Polish animators of sport. In:
Kalina RM, editor. Proceedings of the 1st
World Congress on Health and Maral Arts in
Interdisciplinary Approach. 2015 Sep 17-19;
Czestochowa, Poland. Warsaw: Archives of
Budo; 2015: 187-189
68.
Kalina RM. Muldimensional tests as a funda-
mental diagnosc tool in the prophylacc and
therapeuc agonology – the methodological
basis of personal safety (Part II: motor and psy-
chomotor muldimensional tests). Arch Budo
Sci Maral Art Extreme Sport 2018; 14: 1-14
69.
Dadeło S. Czynniki determinujące kompe-
tencje pracowników ochrony na Litwie. Studia i
Monograe. Warszawa: Akademia Wychowania
Fizycznego Józefa Piłsudskiego; 2005 [in Polish]
70.
Kalina RM. Cognive and applicaon barriers
to the use of “agonology in prevenve and
therapeuc dimension”. Salmon P, Macquet
AC, editors. Advances in Human Factors in
Sports and Outdoor Recreaon. Proceedings
of the HFE 2016 Internaonal Conference
on Human Factors in Sports and Outdoor
Recreaon. 2016 Jul 27-31; Florida, USA. Adv
Intell Sys Com 2017; 496: 25-35
71.
Piepiora P, Migasiewicz J, Witkowski K. The
tradional karate training and sports ght sys-
tems of kumite. Rocz Nauk Wyż Szk Wychow
Fiz Tur Białyst 2016; 18(4): 62-67
Piepiora P et al. – Personality profiles of karate master s...
© ARCHIVES OF BUDO
|
SCIENCE OF MARTIAL ARTS 2018
|
VOLUME 14
|
257
Cite this arcle as: Piepiora P, Witkowski K, Piepiora Z. Personality proles of karate masters pracsing dierent kumite styles. Arch Budo 2018; 14:
247-257
72.
Witkowski K, Piepiora P, Dula M. Karate kyo-
kushin jako forma spędzania czasu wolnego.
Rocz Nauk Wyż Szk Wychow Fiz Tur Białyst
2016; 18(4): 54-61 [in Polish]
73.
Piepiora P, Szmajke A, Migasiewicz J et al. The
karate culture and aggressiveness in kumite
competors. Ido Movement Cult J Maral
Arts Anthropol 2016; 16(2): 41-47
74.
Piepiora P, Piepiora Z. The philosophy of karate
in terms of the dojo-kun and the niju-kun on
the example of shotokan style. Rocz Nauk Wyż
Szk Wychow Fiz Tur Białyst 2016; 16(2): 45-51
75.
Diconary of Sport and Exercise Science.
Over 5,000 Terms Clearly Dened. London:
A & B Black; 2006
76.
Weinberg RS, Gould D. Foundaons of Sport
and Exercise Psychology. Champaign, IL:
Human Kinecs; 2010
77. De Crée C. Kōdōkan Jūdō’s Three Orphaned
Forms of Counter Techniques – Part 1: The
Gonosen-no-kata – “Forms of Post-Aack
Iniave Counter Throws”. Arch Budo 2015;
11: 93-123
78.
Budō: The Martial Ways of Japan. Tokyo:
Nippon Budokan Foundaon; 2009
... The remaining dimensions of neuroticism, openness to experience and agreeableness, are, as in the case of non-athletes, at an average level [10][11][12][13][14][15][16]. But the personality data of the champions are low for neuroticism, high for extraversion and conscientiousness, and the average for the remaining personality dimensions [17][18][19][20][21][22][23]. Thus, athletes in relation to non-athletes are characterised by higher levels of extraversion and conscientiousness, while champions are additionally distinguished by a low level of neuroticism, and their openness to experience and agreeableness are at an average level [24][25][26]. ...
... This indicates that there are differences in athletes' personalities depending on the sport they practice. The obtained data indicate a significant influence of sport on the personality formation of the researched athletes and confirm previous research reports [10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19][20][21][22][23][24][25][26]. Differences between athletes and non-athletes [6][7][8][9] as well as between athletes due to the sport practised should be considered here [27][28][29]32]. ...
... Therefore, there were no significant differences among karateka's in all five personality factors, while among handball players (despite the lack of differences in raw results) high conscientiousness and -additionally, in seniors − high extraversion were noted. It should be noted that in Olympic karate (combat sport) [22,27,38] and handball (team sport) [39,40], there is direct contact with the opponent, but it is karate that is characterised as a method of self-defence [41][42][43][44][45][46], which is a utilitarian factor specific only to combat sports [30,31,47]. In our study, we did not note this difference in the studied personality profiles. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background and Study Aim: Research on personality in sport often concerns the senior stage, that is why we are interested in the junior stage. The aim of this research is the personality traits profiles of athletes training combat sport and team sport at the level of the Polish representation of juniors and seniors. Material and Methods: The subjects of the study were members of the Polish junior and senior national teams in Olympic karate (n = 41) and handball (n = 39) from the 2020/2021 season. We based our comparative analysis on the Five-Factor Model of Personality, known as the Big Five, was used to measure personality. The NEO-FFI Personality Questionnaire was used as the research tool. The study was conducted electronically. Statistical analyses were performed using the Microsoft Excel methods package. Results: The Polish national junior and senior Olympic karate team sportsmen do not differ in personality (their profiles are identical and average level in all dimensions). Likewise, players of the Polish junior and senior handball teams do not differ in personality. However, their profiles are similar - the seniors are distinguished only by a high level of extraversion. Moreover, when comparing the personality of Olympic karate juniors and seniors (combat sport) with that of handball juniors and seniors (team sport), no statistically significant differences were found in the raw test results. Conclusions: The researched population of athletes, personality was probability formed at the junior level and remained unchanged at the senior level, apart from motor skills, technical-tactical skills, and sports experience that developed with age. Such a conclusion is valid on the assumption that seniors, when they were juniors, did not differ in personality traits from the young athletes we studied.
... Karate culture manifests itself in the everyday functioning of karatekas in the society [9]. Therefore, the relationship between karate culture and society, and the effect of this relationship in the form of formed personality of karatekas [10], is an important area of research in the field of sport and health psychology. Previous research in this area shows that the personality profiles of karatekas are similar to those of other athletes [11], but, at the same time, they are not the same for combat sports [12], individual sports [13] and team sports [14]. ...
... In this sense, the correlation of low neuroticism and high conscientiousness in the personality of Ukrainian karatekas relates to the ability to predict professional success and associations with the mental and physical health of the subjects. This is consistent with the personality profiles of karate champions [10,12,22]. It should be noted that the coach has a contribution to the formation of the personality of karatekas [53]. ...
Article
Full-text available
This article is a continuation of the research on personality in combat sports in karate. The authors’ goal was to verify the relationship between personality and age of kyokushin karate practitioners. The male national team of Ukraine in karate kyokushin (N = 7) participated in the personality study with the use of the Big Five model. The NEO-FFI (NEO Five-Factor Inventory) Personality Questionnaire was applied as a research tool and the package of statistical methods IBM SPSS Statistics 27.0 (IBM Polska, Warszawa, Poland) was used to compute the research results. The study showed that there were differences in the intensity of openness to experiences between individual samples only at the level of the statistical trend. Masters showed a higher level of openness to experiences in relation to juniors (p = 0.081) and seniors (p = 0.097). Also, a negative and strong correlation between the intensity of neuroticism and conscientiousness among the respondents was noted. A conclusion was drawn that, with age, karatekas probably manifest greater openness to experience, which is the result of their sports experience, high sports level and pro-health values of karate. On the other hand, good emotional adaptation of karatekas is strictly related to conscientiousness.
... Development of the karateka occurs through the acquisition and improvement of physical [10] and mental [11] skills. Therefore, physical and mental training should be treated with the same amount of consideration at every stage of karate practice [12]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background and Study Aim: Regular physical activity by mentally disabled people can contribute to their better functioning in society. Karate training through its comprehensive psychomotor emphasis can complement rehabilitation and therapeutic activities. Therefore, the aim was to analyze karate training for people with mental disabilities in order to develop a universal pattern of activities for them. Material and Methods: A two-week covert observation of karate classes was conducted on 4 mentally disabled 19-year-olds: 2 from kyokushin karate (a woman with Down syndrome and a man with Asperger syndrome) and 2 from shotokan karate (a man with Down syndrome and a man with Asperger syndrome). Results: Three universal karate class schemes have been developed - for people with Down syndrome, with Asperger syndrome, and inclusive classes for able bodied people and mentally disabled people. The proposed schemes maximize the training effects of the mentally disabled and fully fit into the karate culture. Conclusions: It is recommended to conduct karate classes for mentally disabled people based on the developed schemes. The presented schemes of karate classes are characterized by high effectiveness.
... To me: at a sufficient level, because detailed knowledge of physical skills has always been, is, and will be, guarded by the coaching staff of a given style, club or national team. An important novelty in the "Karate Compendium" is the presentation of the mental skills of a karateka [27]. In the existing literature, one can find a lot of information about budo, bushido, philosophy, ethics, conventionally called the spiritual side. ...
Article
Full-text available
In the public sphere, a noticeable loss of the identity of Budo fighting methods in favour of the escalating phenomenon of neo-gladiatorism takes place. Therefore, any form of promotion of Budo values should be disseminated to the largest possible audience. Hence, the purpose of this article was an expert point of view of the 2021 publishing novelty entitled “Karate Compendium”. The “Karate Compendium” is the essence of karate knowledge. This is an important piece of literature explaining what karate is and what karate is not, and clearly opposes the escalation of the phenomenon of neo-gladiatorism. The book creates a new direction to disseminate knowledge about Budo forms of physical activity.
... We cannot ignore trust and commitment, two variables that are definitely related to each other [63,2,62], and are also related to loyalty, especially in the case of non-profit organisations [30,103,119,117] and those that are also sports-related [120,95]. And we take into [55,5,68,56]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Despite society’s growing interest in sports, the total membership of federations is the same as ten years ago. This study aims is knowledge about the principal factors that influence the “loyalty” of Spanish karate federation members. From a population of 72,910 members of karate federations a sample of 629 individuals was obtained, with a sampling error of 3.97 a confidence level of 95.5% and p = 0.5; q = 0.5. The data obtained were collected from 11 of Spain’s 19 regional federations (71% are men and 29% women, all of them members of karate federations). The largest group is aged between 45 and 64, a majority of whom have been members for more than 20 years. Part I: literature review. This work makes an in-depth exploratory of over one hundred relevant. Part II: original research). A correlational study based on a survey of sportsmen who are members of Spanish karate federations included the variables that can influence the fidelity of the karate federation. Each of the indicators has followed a 5-point Likert scale (1 = strongly disagree; 5 = strongly agree). All loyalty indicators show an average above 4.10, although with a high standard deviation. All loyalty items are directly related (at a significance level of p<0.01) with all indicators of other empirical variables (perceived quality, commitment, trust, satisfaction and happiness). One of the novelties of this study is the consideration of happiness as a strategic variable. This study shows that it is not enough to just be a member of a federation, since members need to be happy and feel satisfied with the federation if their loyalty is to be maintained and improved and even result in recommendations to potential sportsmen and women. Another of the innovations in this paper is its field of study, namely loyalty in sports governing bodies.
... It is worth mentioning that the proposed Ape Index classification for karate athletes is a cognitive novelty in the sport sciences (more precisely: in the science of martial arts [42,43]). Taking into account the knowledge of kumite systems, somatotypes, and Ape Index of karate athletes, it is possible to accurately adjust for them the specialization in kata or kumite in Olympic [44], sport (style) [45], and traditional [46] karate. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background and Study Aim: In traditional karate, the kumite competition is dominated by hand techniques. Due to the specific nature of this competition, most probably a hypothesis is true that kumite athletes will have an athletic body build with a predominance of upper limbs. The aim of this study was to verify this hypothesis and the knowledge on the anthropometric predispositions of traditional karate competitors specializing in kumite. Material and Methods: Subjects (n = 30) are randomly selected, active Polish traditional karate competitors competing in kumite – senior female karatekas (n = 15) and senior male karatekas (n = 15), with dan master degrees, with a professional experience (national and international) of 4 years or more. The anthropometric method was used. The Rohrer Index of the subjects was calculated. Based on the data obtained, the Ape Index classification for karate players. Then the Ape Index of the tested persons was compared to the number of ranking points they obtained during the Poland season of 2021/2022. Basic descriptive statistics and Spearman’s rank correlation were performed, assuming a significance level α of 0.05. Results: Senior female karatekas are characterized by a leptosomic build type and symmetrical range of limbs. Senior male karatekas are characterized by a pyknic type of build with a positive Ape Index. In senior female karatekas, a correlation was observed between the Ape Index and the number of ranking points. Among the senior male karatekas, no correlation was observed between the Ape Index and the number of ranking points. Conclusions: The hypothesis regarding the athletic built of athletes practicing traditional karate turned out to be false in relation to the researched sample. In the studied population of traditional karatekas, senior females have a predisposition to kata and kumite competition in the semi-contact formula. On the other hand, the studied senior males have a predisposition to kumite in the knockdown formula.
... Modern Olympic combat sports include boxing [16], fencing [17], judo [18], karate [19], partly modern pentathlon [20], taekwondo [21] and wrestling [22]. Competition in fencing and wrestling has been present since the first modern Olympic Games in Athens in 1896. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background and Study Aim: The gradual introduction of combat sports into the modern Olympic disciplines was dictated by their popularity, global prestige and meeting International Olympic Committee (IOC) guidelines. The perspective of spatial differentiation and development of Olympic combat sports is the premise of this paper. The aim of the paper is an in-depth reflection on the phenomenon of the geography of the Olympic combat sports from the Far East – judo, karate and taekwondo. Material and Methods: Judo, karate and taekwondo results from the Olympic Games posted on the IOC website were analysed. For this purpose, the method of secondary source analysis was used. Two new indicators were then constructed to relativize the data: the Olympic Games medal winning frequency index (M); the Olympic Games points winning frequency index (P). A cartographic method – choropleth map and proportional symbol map – was used to illustrate the results. The natural interval method was used to determine class intervals. Results: Regarding the number of medals won, Japan dominates in judo, Turkey in karate and South Korea in taekwondo. However, regarding the weight of medals won, Japan dominates in both judo and karate, and South Korea in taekwondo. Unfortunately, Japan is not a member of CISM (Conseil International du Sport Militaire), and karate is not competitive at the highest level in this organization of athlete-soldiers. Conclusions: The obtained results show the impact of geography on sport. The countries where judo, karate and taekwondo originated dominate the Olympic competition in these disciplines of Far Eastern combat sports.
... Karateka's self-confidence is reflected in the ability to make decisions at a given moment and to deal with problems in a given situation [12]. Systematic repetition of given techniques, combinations, combat fragments and tactics, depending on the somatic conditions of the opponent, will have a positive effect and increase the level of self-confidence in a karateka [13]. On the other hand, the mental resistance of a karateka is emphasized in bravery and in fighting to the very end despite adversities [14]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background and Study Aim: The widely understood mental training was adopted as the background of the work as it has a sound grounding in numerous scientific papers as well as in the experience of trainers and coaches. The aim of the paper was to verify the opinions of kyokushin karatekas on mental training. Material and Methods: The Polish representation of juniors and seniors in karate kyokushin (n = 48) from the 2021/2022 season took part in the study. The average training experience in the entire sample of respondents was 12.7 years. Three people are kata competitors and 45 people are kumite competitors. A diagnostic survey method was used, and for this purpose the authors’ own questionnaire was used. Results: The investigated athletes pay a significant role to mental preparation: they cooperate with sports psychologists and mental trainers; some of them also carry out their own mental training. Standard methods of mental preparation as well as meditation and wakefulness are used by the surveyed karatekas. These methods help to reduce the level of stress, which some of them experience before the competition day, while others experience stress on the day of the competition. The training level of their opponents does not affect their stress level. Conclusions: For the studied athletes, mental training is very important. Karatekas cooperate with specialists, and also independently undertake mental exercises from the karate culture array. Practicing mental training by karatekas reduces their stress level. Most of them experience stress only on the competition day and this stress is related only to the starting situation.
... Previous studies on personality in sport have shown that there is a profile that characterizes athletes. Low neuroticism, high extraversion and conscientiousness as well as average openness to experience and agreeableness are characteristic of athletes of each discipline [5][6][7][8][9][10][11][12][13][14]. And in terms of the relationship between personality and gender, the results are inconclusive. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background & Study Aim: Previous studies on personality in sport have shown that there is a profile that characterizes athletes. But in terms of the relationship between personality and gender, the results are not clear. The aim of the study was the knowledge about the personality of male and female practicing competitive football. Material & Methods: The study was chosen deliberately: the first male team and the first female team of the 1 Sports Club “Ślęza” Wrocław (n = 60), thirty male players and thirty female players were selected for the study. The NEO-FFI Personality Inventory was used as the method. Results: A statistically significant difference was noted only in the neuroticism scale. Conclusions: The personality of people practicing football was typical for active sports people (low neuroticism, high extraversion and conscientiousness, and average openness to experience and agreeableness) but female football players were more neurotic (less emotionally stable) in relation to male football players. The view was taken that sports activity and gender shape the personality of athletes.
... Sport teaches people to live in society. It is conducive to the development of character, consistency in behavior, and persistence in pursuing the goal (Piepiora et al., 2018). Also, sports competition is an opportunity to overcome one's weaknesses, reveal one's abilities, skills and predispositions, and test oneself. ...
Article
Full-text available
More and more research reports assert that sport experience has an influence on shaping the personality of athletes. This paper aims at validating the connection between personality and sport experience. The research subject of were young Polish male athletes (N = 1,260) aged 20–29, out of 42 sports disciplines, with sport experience ranging from 3 to 12 years. In order to test the personality of the research subjects, a five-factor model of personality called the Big Five was applied. Statistical calculations and analyses were carried out with ver. 25 of the IBM SPSS Statistics software. The research has shown that all personality traits correlate in a statistically significant way with sport experience (p < 0.001): there is a negative correlation of sports experience with neuroticism and a positive correlation with traits such as extraversion, openness to experience, agreeableness, and conscientiousness. Thus, we have identified a relationship between sport experience and personality traits of the researched Polish male athletes—the longer the sport experience, the lower level of neuroticism and higher levels of extraversion, openness to experience, agreeableness, and conscientiousness. Duration of sport experience has a considerable influence on forming the personality of Polish male athletes. However, the interpretation of just the results regarding high level of extraversion and conscientiousness distinguishes Polish male athletes (20–29 years old) from the Polish male population of non-training people.
Article
Full-text available
In traditional karate, there are three elements of training – kihon, kata, kumite. Under these names are hidden sets of exercises relevant to the type of workout. As kihon (school of fundamental techniques) is defined as fundamental techniques of karate. Kata (formal training) are systems consisting of fragments without fighting enemies according to a predetermined pattern. Kumite (contact of hands) is a fight that is practiced in three forms - training, sports, out of sports. At the karate competition two competitors are played: kata and kumite. All styles of karate are characterized by separate rules of kumite. The reason for this is the different philosophy of masters of different styles concerning the fight and sporting duels outcome. Nowadays, there are four systems of kumite: semi-contact, knockdown, full-contact, mixed fighting. Karate, like other martial arts, compared to the contemporary condition of art’s survival through sport unifies and moves toward simpler forms. It is accompanied by impoverishment of the spiritual side. The solution to this problem is to find a balance between all aspects of karate: training for health, sports training, recreation and self-defense. The sport is not the cause of collapsing the culture of karate. People are responsible and their approach to training.
Article
Full-text available
Background and Study Aim: The philosophy of karate can have a huge impact on the daily life of an individual. In the shotokan karate are two codes: the dojo-kun and the niju-kun. They form the pillars of the philosophy of this martial art. Material and methods: The aim of the study is to analyze the principles of the dojo-kun and niju-kun. The analysis of data is conducted. The results are presented in the form of source texts – understanding the dojo-kun and niju-kun in the perspective of different authors. Results: Philosophical aspect of the dojo-kun and the niju-kun is manifested not only on respect for moral norms but it also applies in particular to self-control and emotional zone. The relationship between language and emotion is very clear, and thoughts are often saturated with feelings. Thus, disclosed herein is a fact that there are inextricable links between culture, psychology and socjology. Conclusions: All elements of the psychophysical karate form a kind of culture – the culture of karate. People from the area of the culture of karate treat practicing karate as a method of self-realization. Their overall objective is to develop and improve their lives by continuous spiritual and physical-improvement.
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of this paper is to present kyokushin karate as a form of leisure. For his needs have been pairing the various functions and aspects. They are presented in terms of four functions in a specially prepared questionnaire. The study involved 120 people aged from 13 to 19 years. This article presents karate as a form of leisure. It shows what functions it fulfills in our lives and proved that well they correlate with functions of leisure time, as described in the literature on the theory of recreation.
Article
Full-text available
Background: The aim of this paper was to analyze selected sociodemographic and economic factors that determine practicing martial arts (MA) in Poland. Our hypothesis states that MA constitute a niche sport, which is a result of conditions shaping the decision to undertake them: perception through the lens of the media/entertainment business (rather than primary values), insufficient space for practicing, as well as high costs. Methods: The study was based on a survey conducted on a representative sample of Poles (n = 12,183). Results for 470 participants declaring some level of proficiency in MA were presented (including 124 declaring active participation). In order to verify statistically significant differences, a Chi-Square test, single-agent logistic regression analysis, and adds ratio were applied. Results: 3.0% of respondents declared basic skills in MA, while advanced skills were declared by 0.9% participants. Only 1% were active practitioners. The leading motivation was "pleasure" (62.1%), followed by "keeping fit and maintaining healthy body shape" (21.8%) and "health" (7.3%). The probability of participation in MA decreased with age (40 years of age being the turning point). As for young people, there is a 15 times lower chance of married individuals undertaking MA, while possessing advanced skills doubles the probability. School provides a place to practice MA during school years, but there is a problem with continuation at a later age (18.8% declaring classes organized at school vs. 5.4% organized at work). Conclusions: Reversing the trend of decreasing popularity of MA requires promotion on each level of education and creating opportunities to continue participation after graduation. There is a need to increase the availability of cheap sport facilities in the vicinity of the place of residence or work. In case of adults, it is important to build platforms facilitating contact with MA centers.
Article
Full-text available
This study attempted to create the psychological profiles of the personality of athletes practising individual and team disciplines, according to the type of pressure exerted on the opponent in a competitive situation. The selected criterion for division into the types of pressure exerted on the opponent was physical contact with the opponent during a competition. Polish competitive male athletes (n=120) were purposefully selected for the study from four sport disciplines: bodybuilding (n=30), WKF karate (n=30), volleyball (n=30) and football (n=30). Their age ranged between 20 and 29 years. The personality tests were performed using the NEO-FFi method. There are differences between the sport disciplines where pressure is exerted indirectly on the opponent and those practising disciplines with pressure exerted directly on the rivals in the neuroticism and conscientiousness scales. The groups studied, except for the comparison of volleyball players and footballers, differ among each other in the neuroticism scale, while volleyball players are less agreeable and conscientious than other athletes. The results show the personality of the athletes depend on the type of pressure exerted on the opponent in relation to individual and team disciplines. This approach allows building profiles of the personality of successful players.
Article
Full-text available
According to the accurate recognition of John Harasymowicz " fighting reveals different features of human na‑ ture, such as anxiety, aggression, vanity, pride, abilities, physical disposition, and knowledge as well as interde‑ pendence between these features ". In this article particular attention was paid to the phenomenon of anxiety, which arises in different circumstances and almost always has an impact on physical, mental and behavior‑ al health of people, especially athletes. The consequences of its influence are still unknown. Understanding the way how emotions influence the course of sports rivalry is a key element for controlling weaknesses, par‑ ticularly during a fight. Therefore, the aim of this study was to review the scientific literature concerning the anxiety phenomenon in combat sports, with particular emphasis on the most commonly used research tools in the psychological analysis of anxiety among combat sports athletes, including the different varieties of this phenomenon. For a detailed analysis were selected the current English and Polish‑language original papers and reviews. They were retrieved mainly from electronic literature databases (Medline, PubMed, EBSCO) and from the available library resources. Analysis also taking into account comparisons between the intensity of anxiety according to different types of sports, gender, age, level of education, sports experience, number of injuries, as well as the difference between winners and losers. It also presents basic information about the impact of a coach, train‑ ing methods and about selected relaxation techniques. On the other hand, it is shown that combat sports and martial arts can be regarded as a form of relaxation.
Article
Full-text available
Aim and Objectives: The aim is to test three hypotheses. The first one reads: practising different styles of karate, with different rules of kumite, differentiates competing athletes in terms of aggressiveness. The second hypothesis postulates that: the culture of karate or other sport has an impact on the level of aggressiveness of kumite practitioners. The last hypothesis is that: the more brutal a combat system, the greater is the aggressiveness of the kumite system competitors. Material and Methods: The study used the Aggression Questionnaire (BD-100) and the Social Approval Questionnaire (SAQ). For analysis of the research were used variance analysis, one group T significance test and post-hoc tests. Four styles of karate representing different systems of kumite sports competition were specifically selected for the study including: shotokan (semi-contact), kyokushin (knockdown), Oyama (full contact), shidokan (mixed fighting). In addition, the results obtained were compared with the results of orienteers representing a non-contact sport) and with the average results of physical education students at Wroclaw Academy of Physical Education. Results: Karate practitioners fighting in the semi-contact (shotokan karate) system have a substantially lower overall level of aggressiveness, both physical and verbal, and suspiciousness than other competitors in kumite systems. Karatekas competing in mixed fighting (shidokan karate) are characterized by significantly higher levels of physical aggressiveness and irritability than karatekas fighting in less violent forms of kumite. Karate practitioners representing knockdown (kyokushin karate) tend to have a significantly higher overall level of aggressiveness, both physical and verbal, and suspiciousness than representatives of the semi-contact (shotokan karate) system. The results for mixed fighting (shidokan karate) practitioners show they are significantly less physically aggressive and irritable than full contact (Oyama karate) fighters and relatively more negative and resentful than those competing in knockdown (kyokushin karate). All the results of the karatekas, the orienteers and the students on the BD-100 scale measured in tetrons are average indicators of aggressiveness. Conclusions: 1. Practising different styles of karate, with different rules of kumite, does not differentiate competing athletes in terms of aggressiveness. 2. It is sport itself has an impact on karatekas (kumite competitors) aggressiveness levels. 3. Regardless of the brutality of sportsmanship systems kumite level of aggressiveness all karate is inadequate.
Conference Paper
Many of the recommendations relating to the estimated of positive health (also by WHO experts) emphasizes the need to measure the following somatic health indicators: BMI, resting HR, systolic and diastolic heart pressure, aerobic capacity, muscle strength, flexibility, balance. Ignored is the need to measure the mental health, social health. Innovative is a comprehensive approach that takes into account the two stages. First – the subjective sense of various positive health indices covers three dimensions: somatic A, mental B, social C and D dimension, which represents sense of indices and assessment reflecting individual’s survival abilities. The second – the measurement of these indicators using mainly non-apparatus, quasi-apparatus and simulations tests. Simple tools measuring positive health and survival abilities can ensure high reliability of the diagnosis. The necessary condition is to meet methodological criteria.
Article
Permanent peace and scientific knowledge are the greatest common good. Nevertheless, people still cannot cope with the age-old problem – struggle with oneself. With their agonistic nature. The most explicit indicators of lost “struggles with oneself” involve invariably the unbridled expansion of power and the escalation of violence and aggression. A phenomenon which has been effectively hidden so far is the fact that scientists make their actions similar to the most destructive powerful people. Familiarising oneself with the reality is the supreme value and at the same time the main objective of science. Thus, it is possible to achieve it if fundamental ethical norms are obeyed. On the other hand, for those who have it, power is a goal itself. People in power treat all moral norms nearly always in instrumental way. Agonology (science about struggle) provides methodology and tools which allow to study such phenomena in theoretical and empirical manner, but also methods to effectively counteract destruction from micro to macro scale. Agonology remains however an unknown science. Agonology has been created by four Polish scientists and each of five detailed theories has been published in Polish. If demoralization reaches so deeply into the social structures (academics take over the methods typical for the most destructive people in power), thus the only sensible question is to consider two issues: whether it is an isolated incident identified in one country, or rather more common phenomenon but with yet unknown scale and range, because it is effectively hidden from the public? This two-stage settlement of the question is the main goal of cognitive cycle exhaustive study Editors Archives of Budo due to the possibility of intellectual, strictly merits and editorial is able to share in the global space science (competently, possibly the most carefully and promptly). Therefore, also educational mission of agonology will be completed towards the widest recipient possible, i.e. the major application objective of these studies.