Content uploaded by Paweł Adam Piepiora
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Paweł Adam Piepiora on Jan 12, 2022
Content may be subject to copyright.
2018
|
VOLUME 14
|
247
© ARCHIVES OF BUDO
|
SCIENCE OF MARTIAL ARTS
is is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0),
which permits use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non-commercial and is otherwise in compliance with the license.
Personality profiles of karate masters practising
different kumite styles
Paweł Piepiora1ABCDE, Kazimierz Witkowski1BCDE, Zbigniew Piepiora2BCD
1 Combat Sports Team, Chair of Sport Didactics, Faculty of Sport Sciences, Wroclaw University School of Physical
Education, Wroclaw, Poland
2
Department of Spatial Economy, Faculty of Environmental Engineering and Geodesy, Wroclaw University of
Environmental and Life Sciences, Wroclaw, Poland
Received: 21 May 2017; Accepted: 01 February 2018; Published online: 20 August 2018
AoBID: 1214 3
Abstract
Background and Study Aim:
As far as common adapve eects are concerned, long-term karate training based on kumite technique (so-
cially acceptable form of hand-to-hand-ghng) results in increased resistance to opponent’s strikes and abil-
ity to tolerate pain and certain type of body injuries. Therefore, it could be assumed that karate masters pos-
sess most of all certain personality traits, but kumite technique (style) is not a factor that signicantly modies
this relaonship and the prole of the world champions of the kumite style may dier from this model. The
goal of the study is to verify this hypothesis.
Material and Methods:
In total 150 best Polish kumite competors were included in the study; 30 each from ve techniques (styles) of
karate, including: semi contact- World Karate Federaon recognised by the Internaonal Olympic Commiee
(in this paper: WKF) and shōtōkan; full contact - Oyama; mix ghng - shidōkan; knockdown - kyokushin.
The subgroup of kumite karate champions (KKC, n = 23) consisted of winners of the gold medals of the world
championships, whereas the subgroup of karate masters (KM) consisted of other athletes (n=127). Personality
measurements were based on big ve NEO-FFI scales (neurocism, extraversion, openness to experience,
agreeableness, conscienousness).
Results:
It is true that karate masters have disncve personality traits (which include: low neurocism and high con-
scienousness), whereas it would be false to assume that kumite technique (style) is not a factor that sig-
nicantly modies this relaonship. WKF karate athletes exhibits the lowest neurocism when compares to
other ones (p<0.01); Oyama karatekas exhibits lower extraversion than WKF, shidōkan and kyokushin ath-
letes (p<0.05). It turned out to be true that personality proles of gold medal winners of the World Karate
Championships of kumite style (KKC) may dier from the model of the remaining KM.
Conclusions:
The new empirical argumentaon is an important premise for conducng in-depth personality studies on ath-
letes at every stage of a sports career. Such knowledge combined with studies of other predisposions and
adapve eects (that are in relaon to unique events determined by various types of sports) is a prerequisite
for embodying social and health-related mission of sports in an opmal manner.
Key words:
big ve NEO-FFI • kata • poomse • sports psychology • tori • uke
Copyright:
© 2018 the Authors. Published by Archives of Budo
Conflict of interest:
Authors have declared that no compeng interest exists
Ethical approval:
The study was approved by the local Ethics Commiee
Provenance & peer review:
Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed
Source of support:
Departmental sources
Author’s address:
Paweł Piepiora, Wroclaw University School of Physical Educaon, Paderewskiego 35 Str., 51-612 Wroclaw,
Poland; e-mail: pawel.piepiora@awf.wroc.pl
Authors’ Contribution:
A Study Design
B Data Collection
C Statistical Analysis
D Manuscript Preparation
EFunds Collection
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
248
|
VOLUME 14 | 2018 www.archbudo.com
Original Article
INTRODUCTION
In sports psychology, issues related to personal-
ity are raised especially from the perspecve of
organizers, teachers and educators when various
inter-individual psychophysical properes and
behaviours of people praccing sport or pursu-
ing health goals through the physical acvity are
described and explained [1-3]. Numerous psy-
chological theories can be disnguished. One of
them, trait theory (also referred to as the dispo-
sional theory) is an approach to the study of
human personality [4-9]. This theory is based on
factor analysis and may turn out very useful in
diagnosing the psychological prole of individ-
ual athletes and construcng psychological mod-
els of athletes of a given discipline (or guravely
speaking: of their strengths and weaknesses).
Studies on personality of athletes conducted
so far revealed that compared with those who
do not pracce any sport they exhibit various
levels of conscienousness and extraversion.
Athletes are more social and consistent [10-18].
Substanal dierences were also found between
athletes praccing team sports and individ-
ual sports. However, this issue raises legimate
controversy, as many sciensts consider com-
bat sports athletes persons training individual
sports. This disncon is only parally true (jus-
ed). Let us focus on combat sports that are in
the program of the Olympic Games. In order to
execute their sports mission, a boxer, swordsman,
or wrestler has to ght directly with a compet-
itor (socially acceptable form of hand-to-hand-
ghng). In case of a judo athlete praccing kata
(as well as sports compeon of this style that
is however not included in the programme of
the Olympic Games) requires a partner who has
to respect the role of uke (a person who does
not interfere with the goal of tori; on the con-
trary a partner should help achieving this goal).
Therefore, considering representaves of these
Olympic combat sports as those who pracce
individual sports primarily fails to meet criteria of
logic. On the other hand, karate and taekwondo
athletes (leaving aside the criteria of Olympic
compeon which involve kumite) can train and
compete in line with principles applicable in indi-
vidual sports. This means that an opponent does
not interfere with them directly through physi-
cal contact or, as in the case of sports games,
manipulang an item (a ball, puck, shulecock,
etc.), at the same me staying in close contact
(racket sports, volleyball) or even very oen in
direct physical contact (hockey, football, etc.).
Exercises and compeon using kata (karate) or
poomse (taekwondo) techniques give karate ath-
lete and taekwondo athlete comfort of not being
disturbed directly by an opponent.
The queson of why some karate and taekwondo
athletes but also judo athletes decide on sports
career involving compeon based on kata
(poomse) techniques remains open. This issue is
important because it is jused to claim that the
group of individual sports (disnguished also by
some sciensts for research-related purposes)
does not meet methodological criteria of ade-
quate distribuon. Therefore, it is not surpris-
ing that players of team sports games showed
greater neurocism and extraversion than ath-
letes pracsing individual disciplines [19-24]. The
nature of compeng as a group against a group
is so obvious that especially in-depth interdisci-
plinary studies will probably reveal other common
traits that disnguish team-sport game leaders
from other players and perhaps also from ath-
letes praccing other disciplines.
On the other hand there is some empirical evi-
dence that personality proles of athletes of
individual disciplines who represent a diverse
sports level do not signicantly dier from each
other [25-42]. Thus, the theory of traits may
turn out to be important for studying traits
of athletes also because it sll remains unde-
termined whether there are personality traits
that predispose to success in sport regardless
of the discipline being pracced. Sport success
in team games (at least two players against two
players, as in double games, e.g. racket sports
or volleyball beach) – regardless of leading role
of the leaders – is always a derivave of the
eort put in by all team members. Failure is
oen the result of one (or several) mistake(-s)
made by only one team member. In individual
sports involving high energy expenditure (the
majority of athlecs compeon, weightliing,
cycling etc.) physical predisposions are a suc-
cess-determining factor.
Since mutual interference in such a way that
oensive and defensive acons are directed to
the opponent’s body directly (protectors only
parally protect against negave eects – fatal
cases are also known in fencing) is a common
factor in combat sports (except for expressive
forms of compeon: kata, poomse), mental
toughness and other personality traits acquire
parcular importance. This assumpon is
Kumite – is a karate
compeon, during which
two athletes use various
kicking, punching and blocking
techniques towards each
other with control in order
to gain points and win the
compeon. Permissible
contact depends on maral /
karate style regulaons [71].
Kyokushin – is a style of
stand-up, knockdown karate,
developed by Masutatsu
Oyama which means the
“Ulmate Truth”. It is based
on Sosai’s point and circle
concept by which one draws
a circle around one point and
aaches the lines around the
circle [72].
Oyama karate – full-contact
karate style, created by
Shigeru Ōyama (1983).
Shidōkan – is a style of mix
ghng karate; founded in
1980 [73].
Shotokan – semi contact
style of karate started and
pioneered by Sensei Gichin
Funakoshi. Inially, shotokan
was the name of the rst
karate dojo (the “honbu dojo” –
central dojo), but over me it
became the name of the style
of karate taught / pracsed by
Sensei Funakoshi [74].
Sports psychology – noun
is scienc study of mental
state of athletes, focusing on
issues, such as movaon,
concentraon, stress and self-
condence [75].
Sport psychology – is an
interdisciplinary science that
draws on knowledge from
many related elds, including
biomechanics, physiology,
kinesiology and psychology.
It involves the study of
how psychological factors
aect performance and how
parcipaon in sport and
exercise aect psychological
and physical factors [76].
Kata – predetermined and
choreographed physical
exercises, which together
with free exercises (randori),
Piepiora P et al. – Personality profiles of karate master s...
© ARCHIVES OF BUDO
|
SCIENCE OF MARTIAL ARTS 2018
|
VOLUME 14
|
249
jused as one of long-term karate training
based on kumite technique (which means that
the eect applies to all praconers of this
technique) results in increased to the oppo-
nent’s strikes and ability to tolerate pain and
certain type of body injuries.
If these premises and assumpons are true,
it could be assumed that karate masters pos-
sess most of all certain personality traits, but
kumite technique (style) is not a factor that
signicantly modies this relaonship and the
prole of the world champions of the kumite
style may dier from this model. The goal of
the study is to verify this hypothesis.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Study design
Personality proles based on the big ve NEO-
FFI scales: neurocism, extraversion, openness
to experience, agreeableness, conscienous-
ness, oen represented by the acronyms
OCEAN or CANOE were applied as an empiri-
cal criterion for verifying the hypothesis [43-
47]. Beneath each global factor, there are
several correlated and more specic primary
factors (for example extraversion is associated
with: gregariousness, asserveness, excitement
seeking, warmth, acvity and posive emo-
ons). Each of ve scales consists of 12 items
(the raw score in each scale ranges from 0 to
48). The higher the numerical score in the scale,
the greater the intensity of given trait (greater
number of diagnosc responses reects higher
intensity of traits of given person).
The following inclusion criteria were applied:
long-term sports experience; licence of kumite
in one of ve predetermined types of karate;
impeccable opinion given by the instructor;
documented sports achievements at vari-
ous compeon levels (naonal, connental,
global). Exclusion criteria: ethical or unsports-
manlike lifestyle; no recommendaon from the
instructor. The design has been approved by
the local ethics commiee.
Participants
In total 150 best Polish kumite competors
were included in the study; 30 each from ve
techniques (styles) of karate, including: semi
contact- World Karate Federaon recognised
by the Internaonal Olympic Commiee (in this
arcle: karate WKF) and shōtōkan; full con-
tact- Oyama karate; mix ghng - shidōkan;
knockdown - kyokushin. Current (and former)
members of the naonal team, medallists of
World European and Polish Championships
were among karate athletes. The average age
of parcipants amounted to 27.7 years (18 to
39 years).
Regardless of the karate technique (style)
trained, a group of 23 “kumite karate cham-
pions” (KKC) was disnguished. It consisted
of those who won at least one golden medal
in kumite karate world championships. The
remaining group (n=127) consisted of silver
and bronze medallists of world championships,
medallists of the European and Polish champi-
onships. This was the reference group (“karate
masters”).
The study was carried out during seminars,
training camps of the naonal team and
naonal compeons in 2012-2016.
Statistical analysis
The stascal analysis of data is performed
using Stasca v.12 soware. It involved indi-
cators of descripve stascs: arithmec mean
value, median, standard deviaon (in tables
referred to as SD or ±), error of the mean, range
(minimum÷maximum results and lower÷upper
quarle), variaon coecient, skewness, stan-
dard error (SE) and condence intervals. We
used analysis of variance (ANOVA). The signif-
icance of dierences between groups was es-
mated by means of Student’s t-test.
RESULTS
Generally personality prole of karate athletes
pracsing various types of kumite is similar (mod-
erate neurocism, openness to experience and
agreeableness as well as high conscienousness
and extraversion), suggesng that this part of ver-
ied hypothesis is true (Tables 1 to 5). On the
other hand, statement that kumite type (style) is
not a factor that signicantly modies this model
is untrue. WKF karate athletes exhibit the low-
est level of neurocism among athletes studied
(Table 6, Figure 1) as well as the lowest intersub-
ject variability in case of this trait (Table 6).The
ANOVA analysis indicates lack of homogeneity
in case of neurocism (p<0.001) and extraver-
sion (p<0.05) (Table 7). Post-hoc test revealed
lectures (kōgi) and discussions
(mondō) form the four crical
pillars of Kōdōkan jūdō
educaon [77].
Kata – prescribed paerns or
sequences of techniques [78]
Kata (form) – is executed as
a specied series of a variety
of moves, with stepping and
turning, while aempng
to maintain perfect form.
Kata reects a transion
and ow from one posture
and movement to another,
teaching the karateka proper
form and posion, and
encouraging them to visualize
dierent scenarios for the use
of each moon and technique
in imaginary bout. There
are various forms of kata
developed through dierent
karate styles.
Poomse (kata in taekwondo)
– it is tradionally understood
as the style of conduct
which expresses directly
or indirectly mental and
physical renements as well
as the principles of oense
and defence resulng from
culvaon of taekwondo spirit
and techniques. Nowadays,
poomse is involved in
compeon in the taekwondo
technique modality.
Tori – the person who applies
a technique in judo training.
The receiver of the technique
is referred to as uke [78].
Racket sport – noun any of
various sports that use a
racket and ball or shulecock,
e.g. tennis, badminton or
squash [75].
250
|
VOLUME 14 | 2018 www.archbudo.com
Original Article
that only WKF karate athletes exhibit lower neu-
rocism than each group of other kumite kara-
tekas and greater extraversion (p<0.01) only than
Oyama karate athletes at stascally signicant
levels (at least p <0.01). Oyama karatekas show
lower extraversion than shidōkan and kyokushin
karate athletes as well as lower agreeableness
than shidōkan karatekas (Table 7).
It turned out to be true that personality proles
of Kumite karate world champions (KKC) may dif-
fer from the prole of the remaining KM. KKC
exhibits very low neurocism (p<0.001) and con-
scienousness, extraversion and agreeableness
greater than the ones of KM. On the other hand
both groups of karatekas are similar in terms
of moderate openness to experience (Table 8,
Figure 2). Nevertheless variance analysis conrms
the greatest probability of dierences in terms of
neurocism and conscienousness both by t-test
and variance rao test (F-test) results (Table 8).
DISCUSSION
The results of our studies on personalies of
karate athletes pracsing kumite style, per-
formed with the use of the big ve NEO-FFI
method, conrm that their personalies are gen-
erally consistent with proles of athletes training
other sports disciplines (moderate neurocism,
openness to experience and agreeableness as
well as high conscienousness and extraversion).
Therefore, the most general conclusion is that
test results may be interpreted based on well-
known psychological theories: temperament is
a relavely constant biological property of an
organism that genecs-related; and personality
is a noon structured on temperament that is
shaped by environment [48]; in case of athletes
these include regular training smuli and experi-
ence gained during compeon.
Since personality evolves, changes during a life-
me and temperament is constant and unchange-
able, the fundamental cognive dilemma from the
study-related perspecve raises several impor-
tant methodological issues. First of all, because
we do not possess knowledge about personality
of studied karate athletes from the previous peri-
ods of their sporng career, we cannot infer about
how their long-term training could have aected
possible changes of this important human prop-
erty. Second of all, it is unlikely that with large
motor similarity of karate training and regard-
less of multude of kumite techniques (styles)
(from semi contact to knockdown), formal exer-
cises and parcipaon in combats (during training
and compeon) could have a decisive impact on
shaping personality of praconers, leaving aside
inuence of their instructor and other enes in
the closest social environment of a karate athlete.
Third of all, we lack empirical knowledge about
comprehensive impact of an instructor (his or her
personality) and other social factors on the per-
sonality of a karate athlete. Therefore, compara-
ve results of world champions (KKC) with other
karate masters (KM) pracsing various types of
kumite style have the greatest cognive value at
the current stage of studies on this phenomenon.
It is an open queson to determine whether the
personality prole of world champions has been
shaped only in the course of a long-term sport-
ing career or whether they manifested already at
Table 1. Estimated results of WKF karatekas (n = 30) related to their personality prole according to the big ve NEO-FFI scales.
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean
SD Median
Range Variation coe-
cient Skewness
results
min÷max
quartile lower÷up-
per
Neuroticism 8.93
±2.60 8.50 12
3÷15
3
7÷10 29.092 0.5203
Extraversion 32.60
±3.84 32 16
26÷42
4
30÷34 11.773 0.6460
Openness to experience 26.60
±6.36 29 23
15÷38
9
22÷31 23.911 −0.2292
Agreeableness 29.30
±5.69 29.50 32
14÷46
4
27÷31 19.414 0.2549
Conscientiousness 37.30
±4.34 37 18
29÷47
6
34÷40 11.64 0.1503
Piepiora P et al. – Personality profiles of karate master s...
© ARCHIVES OF BUDO
|
SCIENCE OF MARTIAL ARTS 2018
|
VOLUME 14
|
251
Table 3. Estimated results of Oyama karatekas (n = 30) related to their personality prole according to the big ve NEO-FFI scales.
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean
SD Median
Range Variation
coecient Skewness
results
min÷max
quartile
lower÷upper
Neuroticism 15.17
±7.29 16.50 29
00÷29
11
9÷20 48.08 −0.109
Extraversion 28.83
±6.18 29.50 22
19÷41
8
25÷33 21.42 0.234
Openness to experience 27.43
±6.02 27.50 23
17÷40
9
23÷32 21.95 0.662
Agreeableness 28.40
±4.92 28.00 22
17÷39
7
25÷32 17.31 0.107
Conscientiousness 35.03
±7.29 34.50 25
22÷47
13
29÷42 20.81 −0.135
Table 4. Estimated results of shidōkan karatekas (n = 30) related to their personality prole according to the big ve NEO-FFI scales.
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean
SD Median
Range Variation coef-
cient Skewness
results
min÷max
quartile lower÷up-
per
Neuroticism 13.90
±8.11 13.50 29
00÷29
11
8÷19 58.33 0.402
Extraversion 31.33
±4.46 31 17
23÷40
5
29÷34 14.23 0.041
Openness to experience 27.03
±6.02 27 25
16÷41
7
23÷30 22.27 0.422
Agreeableness 31.23
±5.55 30.50 26
22÷48
6
28÷34 17.77 0.850
Conscientiousness 35.57
±6.39 35.50 24
22÷46
9
32÷41 17.97 −0.282
Table 2. Estimated results of shōtōkan karatekas (n = 30) related to their personality prole according to the big ve NEO-FFI scales.
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean
SD Median
Range Variation coef-
cient Skewness
results
min÷max
quartile lower÷up-
per
Neuroticism 14.50
±5.62 15 25
00÷25
5
13÷18 38.75 −0.735
Extraversion 31.30
±5.14 51.5 19
23÷42
7
27÷34 16.42 0.144
Openness to experience 26.70
±6.80 28 23
15÷38
12
20÷33 25.46 −0.152
Agreeableness 29.60
±5.59 29 32
14÷46
7
26÷33 18.89 0.307
Conscientiousness 34.97
±6.91 36 27
20÷47
11
29÷40 19.76 −0.433
252
|
VOLUME 14 | 2018 www.archbudo.com
Original Article
the beginning of karate pracce: very low neu-
rocism (desired trait), conscienousness, extra-
version and agreeableness greater than other
beginning karatekas and moderate openness to
experience similar to other karatekas (see Table
8 and Figure 2).
In our opinion, the results provide new arguments
about the health aspects of combat sports training
(socially acceptable form of hand-to-hand-ght-
ing), maral arts and self-defence, as the so-called
sports of life [49-54]. When we state that we are
concerned only with the socially acceptable form
of combat (such as kumite style), we leave aside
a pathological phenomenon of neogladiatorship,
which is related to maral arts [55], is promoted
by electronic media and is also present in science.
This complex of phenomena is the subject of in-
depth studies of innovave agonology experts that
have become more popular from 2015 [56-58]. It
is not dicult to prove the instrumental use of sci-
ence. The authors of published studies on contem-
porary gladiators do not cricise the pathological
aspect of this phenomenon even if given publica-
on provides knowledge about death and body
injuries as a result of massacring an opponent who
is oen already lying down [e.g. 59].
On the other hand, there are few empirical
papers addressing the phenomena of mental
Table 5. Estimated results of kyokushin karatekas (n = 30) related to their personality prole according to the big ve NEO-FFI scales.
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean
SD Median
Range Variation
coecient Skewness
results
min÷max
quartile
lower÷upper
Neuroticism 14.63
±6.81 16.50 25
2÷27
9
9÷18 46.50 0.005
Extraversion 32.33
±4.82 32 18
24÷42
8
28÷36 14.92 0.237
Openness to experience 25.33
±5.74 24 23
15÷38
7
22÷29 22.65 0.478
Agreeableness 28.83
±6.04 29 27
19÷46
9
23÷32 20.95 0.767
Conscientiousness 35.47
±7.75 34.50 30
18÷48
11
30÷41 21.86 −0.075
Table 6. Summarised results of karatekas related to their personality prole according to the big ve NEO-FFI scales.
Group of
karatekas
Extraversion Neuroticism Openness to experience Agreeableness Conscientiousness
mean
SD
SE
condence
−95%;
+95%
mean
SD
SE
condence
−95%; +95%
mean
SD
SE
condence
−95%; +95%
mean
SD
SE
condence
−95%; +95%
mean
SD
SE
condence
−95%;
+95%
all
(n = 150)
31.28
±5.06
0.41
30.46; 32.1
13.43
±6.70
0.55
12.35; 14.51
26.62
±6.16
0.50
25.63; 27.61
29.47
±5.58
0.46
28.57; 30.37
35.67
±6.61
0.54
34.6; 36.73
Individual kumite techniques (styles); each group consisted of 30 people
WKF 32.60
±3.84
0.70
31.17; 34.03
8.93
±2.60
0.47
7.96; 9.9
26.60
±6.36
1.16
24.22; 28.98
29.30
±5.69
1.04
27.18; 31.42
37.30
±4.34
0.79
35.68; 38.92
shōtōkan 31.30
±5.14
0.94 29.38;
33.22
14.50
±5.62 1.03 12.4; 16.6 26.70
±6.80 1.24 24.16; 29.24 29.60
±5.59
1.02 27.51;
31.69
34.97
±6.91
1.26 32.39;
37.55
Oyama karate 28.83
±6.18
1.13
26.53; 31.14
15.17
±7.29
1.33
12.44; 17.89
27.43
±6.02
1.10
25.19; 29.68
28.40
±4.92
0.90
26.56; 30.24
35.03
±7.29
1.33
32.31; 37.76
shidōkan 31.33
±4.46 0.81 29.67; 33.0 13.90
±8.11
1.48 10.87;
16.93
27.03
±6.02 1.10 24.79; 29.28 31.23
±5.55
1.01 29.16;
33.31
35.57
±6.39
1.17 33.18;
37.95
kyokushin 32.33
±4.82
0.88
30.53; 34.13
14.63
±6.81
1.24
12.09; 17.17
25.33
±5.74
1.05
23.19; 27.48
31.23
±5.55
1.10
26.58; 31.09
35.57
±7.75
1.42
32.57; 38.36
Piepiora P et al. – Personality profiles of karate master s...
© ARCHIVES OF BUDO
|
SCIENCE OF MARTIAL ARTS 2018
|
VOLUME 14
|
253
eects of karate training [60, 61] or especially
personality shaping in the broad context of pos-
ive health and survival ability through a rao-
nal, long-term training of combat sports and
maral arts. Although sciensts studying predis-
posions to broadly understood hand-to-hand-
ghng (self-defence and combat sports) focus
on specic tests and motor smulaons [49, 54,
62-65] as well as on fun forms of maral arts [66,
67], they emphasize that these tests and motor
simulaons contain a mental component in their
assumpons and interpretaon of empirical data.
The most recent publicaons disnguish muldi-
mensional tests, some of which idenfy abilies
(talent) of hand-to-hand-ghng [68]. Stanislaw
Dadelo [69] discovered signicant correlaons
between the S-Index (the percentage of scues
won relave to all scues conducted by given
subject during TFVP) and professional acv-
ity, theorecal and praccal preparaon, men-
tal traits (indicators directly informing us about
intellectual potenal) of 118 male guards from
Lithuania.
All indicators of TFVP (“tesng ghts in a ver-
cal posture”), in our opinion, can be correlated
also with psychological personality tests indica-
tors already at the inial stage of each combat
Figure 1. Visualization of personality profiles of karate athletes (each group consisted of 30
people) practicing various kumite techniques (styles).
Table 7. Variance analysis
of the results of the big five NEO-FFI scales (df 148) obtained by
gold medal winners of the World Karate Championships (KKC) and other karate masters in
kumite style (KM).
NEO-FFI
Variable
ANOVA
Probability for post hoc test (value p)
WKF
shōtōkan
Oyama
shidōkan
F
p
shōtōkan
Oyama
shidōkan
kyokushin
Oyama
shidōkan
kyokushin
shidōkan
kyokushin
kyokushin
Neuroticism
4.80
0.001
0.001
0.000
0.003
0.001
0.686
0.716
0.936
0.443
0.7466
0.6569
Extraversion
2.71
0.033
0.311
0.004
0.323
0.835
0.055
0.979
0.420
0.052
0.0069
0.4351
Openness to
experience
0.49
0.745
0.950
0.603
0.787
0.430
0.647
0.835
0.394
0.803
0.1915
0.2899
Agreeableness
1.14
0.341
0.835
0.532
0.181
0.746
0.405
0.258
0.595
0.051
0.7636
0.0973
Conscientiousne
ss
0.61
0.654
0.176
0.189
0.314
0.287
0.969
0.727
0.771
0.756
0.8009
0.9536
It turned out to be true that personality profiles of Kumite karate world champions (KKC) may
differ from the profile of the remaining KM. KKC exhibits very low neuroticism (p<0.001) and
conscientiousness, extraversion and agreeableness greater than the ones of KM. On the other
hand both groups of karatekas are similar in terms of moderate openness to experience (Table
8, Figure 2). Nevertheless variance analysis
confirms the greatest probability of differences in
terms of neuroticism and conscientiousness both by t-test and variance ratio test (F-test) results
(Table 8).
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Neuroticism Extraversion Openness to
experience
Agreeableness Conscientiousness
WKF shōtōkan Oyama shidōkan kyokushin
Figure 1. Visualization of personality proles of karate athletes (each group consisted of 30 people) practicing various
kumite techniques (styles).
Table 7. Variance analysis of the results of the big ve NEO-FFI scales (df 148) obtained by gold medal winners of the World Karate Championships
(KKC) and other karate masters in kumite style (KM).
NEO-FFI
Variable
ANOVA
Probability for post hoc test (value p)
WKF shōtōkan Oyama shidōkan
F p
shōtōkan
Oyama shidōkan kyokushin Oyama shidōkan kyokushin shidōkan kyokushin kyokushin
Neuroticism 4.80 0.001 0.001 0.000 0.003 0.001 0.686 0.716 0.936 0.443 0.7466 0.6569
Extraversion 2.71 0.033 0.311 0.004 0.323 0.835 0.055 0.979 0.420 0.052 0.0069 0.4351
Openness to
experience 0.49 0.745 0.950 0.603 0.787 0.430 0.647 0.835 0.394 0.803 0.1915 0.2899
Agreeableness 1.14 0.341 0.835 0.532 0.181 0.746 0.405 0.258 0.595 0.051 0.7636 0.0973
Conscientiousness 0.61 0.654 0.176 0.189 0.314 0.287 0.969 0.727 0.771 0.756 0.8009 0.9536
254
|
VOLUME 14 | 2018 www.archbudo.com
Original Article
sports training. There is sucient empirical evi-
dence that S-Index and F-Index (i.a. the percent-
age of ghts won relave to all ghts conducted
by given subject) correlate lowly with results of
recommended motor tests [49, 62-65, 68, 69].
At the inial stage of training (before trainees
learn ghng techniques typical of given com-
bat sport or intervenon techniques in the case
of self-defence training TFVPs are mostly won
by persons demonstrang talent for this acvity
(hand-to-hand-ghng). It is obvious that some
gied persons exhibit also very high tness level
and this has nothing to do with their movaon
to undertake training of combat sports. Unique
studies of Niedomagała [65] provided evidence
that young judo athletes (a total of girls and boys),
who won all TFVPs (F-Index 100%) in 5-person,
4-person, 3-person tesng groups, proved their
high eecveness more frequently during tour-
naments ghng in a three-year stage of pre-
liminary judo training. Unfortunately, there is
no empirical knowledge about the S-Index and
F-Index relaonship with scores achieved in psy-
chological personality tests. This results in limited
possibilies of broader interpretaon not only of
the results of our studies from the interdisciplin-
ary perspecve.
Furthermore, we distance ourselves from the par-
adigm of associang all study results concerning
Table 8. Variance analysis of results of the big ve NEO-FFI scales obtained by karate athletes practising kumite style (each group consisted of 30 people).
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean SD Variance analysis
KKC
(n = 23)
KM
(n =127) t-test p variance ratio test
(F-test) p
Neuroticism 4.39 ±2.190 15.06 ±5.883 −8.572 0.0000 7.220 0.0000
Extraversion 34.22
±3.753 30.75 ±5.096 3.112 0.0022 1.843 0.0977
Openness to experience 28.30
±6.413 26.31 ±6.084 1.431 0.1545 1.111 0.6876
Agreeableness 33.22
±5.776 28.79 ±5.289 3.638 0.0004 1.192 0.5325
Conscientiousness 41.26 ±4.505 34.65 ±6.432 4.715 0.0000 2.039 0.0551
Table 8. Variance analysis of results of the big five NEO-FFI scales obtained by karate
athletes practising kumite style (each group consisted of 30 people).
NEO-FFI
Variable
Mean SD
Variance analysis
KKC
(n = 23)
KM
(n =127)
t-test
p
variance
ratio test
(F-test)
p
Neuroticism
4.39
±2.190
15.06
±5.883
−8.572
0.0000
7.220
0.0000
Extraversion
34.22
±3.753
30.75
±5.096
3.112
0.0022
1.843
0.0977
Openness to
experience
28.30
±6.413
26.31
±6.084
1.431
0.1545
1.111
0.6876
Agreeableness
33.22
±5.776
28.79
±5.289
3.638
0.0004
1.192
0.5325
Conscientiousness
41.26
±4.505
34.65
±6.432
4.715
0.0000
2.039
0.0551
Figure 2. Personality profiles of gold medal winners of the World Karate Championships of
kumite style (KKC) and other karate masters in kumite style (KM).
DISCUSSION
The results of our studies on personalities of karate athletes practising kumite style, performed
with the use of the big five NEO-FFI method, confirm that their personalities are generally
consistent with profiles of athletes training other sports disciplines (moderate neuroticism,
openness to experience and agreeableness as well as high conscientiousness and extraversion).
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Neuroticism Extraversion Openness to
experience
Agreeableness Conscientiousness
KKC (n = 23) KM (n = 127)
**
** **
**
Figure 2. Personality proles of gold medal winners of the World Karate Championships of kumite style (KKC) and
other karate masters in kumite style (KM).
Piepiora P et al. – Personality profiles of karate master s...
© ARCHIVES OF BUDO
|
SCIENCE OF MARTIAL ARTS 2018
|
VOLUME 14
|
255
adapve eects of long-term training of karate
and other combat sports primarily with the possi-
bility of achieving successes at the highest levels
of compeon for the longest possible period of
professional sports career. There is a close asso-
ciaon between health-related mission of com-
bat sports and maral arts and not only as one
of the most aracve “sports of life” with uli-
tarian values) and awareness of many patholo-
gies that are also present in this type of physical
acvity. The need to overcome numerous barri-
ers in promong health-related values primarily
of combat sports [70] is only apparently obvious
but at the same me very dicult achieve in the
world dominated by electronic media. Direct ght
is such an aracve product that lm careers of
masters in karate and other combat sports are
not surprising. However, we are concerned about
the fact that combat sports athletes undertake a
role of neogladiators and that is why we acvely
parcipate in the World Congress of Health and
Maral Arts in Interdisciplinary Approach (so far
organised twice: in 2015 and 2018).
CONCLUSIONS
The new empirical argumentaon is an important
premise for conducng in-depth personality stud-
ies on athletes at every stage of a sports career.
Such knowledge combined with studies of other
predisposions and adapve eects (that are in
relaon to unique events determined by various
types of sports) is a prerequisite for embody-
ing social and health-related mission of sports in
an opmal manner. Thus, the basic criterion for
vericaon of theorecal foundaons and acvi-
es related to training is both innovaveness of
formulated rules for creang high quality of life
(which cannot omit sports acvity, including ele-
ments of combat sports) and the degree of com-
pliance of these rules with applicaons.
REFERENCES
1.
Kosińska H. Osobowość sportowca. In: T.
Tyszka, editor. Psychologia i sport. Warszawa:
AWF; 1991 [in Polish]
2.
Gracz J. Czy ktoś widział osobowość? Czyli
o znaczeniu osobowości w działalności spor-
towej. Sport Wyczynowy 1994; 1-2 [in Polish]
3.
Gracz J, Sankowski T. Psychologia aktywności
sportowej. Poznań: Akademia Wychowania
Fizycznego im. Eugeniusza Piaseckiego w
Poznaniu, Seria: Podręczniki 58; 2007 [in Polish]
4.
Caell RB. The scienc analysis of person-
ality. Balmore: Penguin; 1965
5.
Eysenck HJ. Fact and con in psychology.
Balmore: Penguin; 1966
6. Eysenck H, Nias DK, Cox DN. Sport and per-
sonality. Adv Behav Res Ther 1983: 4 (1): 1-56
7.
Eysenck HJ. Keane M. Cognive psychology.
Hove: LEA; 1995
8.
Jarvis M. Sport Psychology. London: Routledge
Modular Psychology; 1999
9.
Kassin SM. Psychology. USA: Prence-Hall,
Inc. 2003
10.
Schurr KT, Ashley MA, Joy KL. A mulvari-
ante analysis of male athlete characterscs:
sport type an success. Mulvar Exp Clin Res
1977; 1: 53-68
11. Highlen PS, Benne BB. Psychological char-
acteriscs of successful and non-successful
elite wrestlers: an exploratory study. J Sport
Psychol 1979; 1: 123-137
12.
Rychta T. Kierunki badań nad osobowością
ludzi uprawiających sport. In: III Konferencja
Humanistystyczne Podstawy Kultury Fizycznej:
aktualny stan badań. Poznań: AWF Poznań;
1979 [in Polish]
13.
Gould D, Weiss M, Weinberg R. Psychological
characteriscs of successful and non-suc-
cessful Big Ten wrestlers. J Sport Psychol
1981; 3: 69-81
14.
McGill JC, Hall JR, Ratli WR et al. Personality
characteriscs of professional rodeo cowboys.
J Sport Behav 1986; 9: 143-151
15. Clingman JM., Hiliard DV. Some personalisty
characterisc of super-adherer: following
those who go beyond tness. J Sport Behav
1987; 10: 123-136.
16.
Garland DJ, Barry JR. Personality and leader
behaviours in collegiate football: a muldi-
mensional approach to performance. J Res
Pers 1990; 24: 355-370.
17. Chirivella EC, Marnez LM. The sensaon of
risk and movaonal tendencies in sports:
an empirical study. Pers Indiv Dier 1994;
16: 777-786
18.
Bleidorn W, Kandler C, Hulsheger UR et al.
Nature and nurture of the interplay between
personality traits and major life goals. J Pers
Soc Psychol 2010; 99: 366-379
19.
Taylor D, Doria J. Self-serving and group-serv-
ing bias in aribuon. J Soc Psychol 1981;
113: 201-211
20.
Piedmont R, Hill D, Blanco S. Predicng athlec
performance using the ve-factormodel of per-
sonality. J Pers Individ Dier 1999; 27: 769-77
21. Busato V, Prins F, Elshout J et al. Intellectual
ability, learning style, personality, achievement
movaon and academic success of psychol-
ogy students in higher educaon. J Pers Individ
Dier 2000; 29: 1057-1068
22.
Bernatek, Cwyl S., Dudziak D et al. Cechy
temperamentu i osobowość zawodników
sportów walki i zespołowych gier sportowych.
In: D. Parzelski, editor. Psychologia w spor
-
cie. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu
Warszawskiego; 2006: 50-57 [in Polish]
23.
Shrivastaval P, Gopal R, Singh Y. A Study of
Personality Dimensions in Sports Performance.
J Exer Sci Physiother 2010; 1: 39-42
24.
Ilyasi G, Salehian MH. Comparison of personal-
ity traits between individual and team athletes.
Middle East J Sci Res 2011; 9 (4): 527-530
25.
Rychta T. Osobowość a zachowanie celowe
sportowców. Warszawa: COS; 1998 [in Polish]
26.
Piedmont RL, Hill D, Blanco S. Predicng ath-
lec performance using the ve factor model
of personality. J Pers Individ Dier 1999;
27:769-777
27.
Backmand H, Kapiro J, Kujala U et al. Personality
and mood of former elite athletes: a descrip-
ve study. Int J Sports Med 2003; 22: 215-221
28.
McKelvie SJ, Lemieux P, Stout D. Ekstraversion
and neurocism in contact athletes, no contact
athletes and non-athletes: a research note. J
Sport Psychol 2003; 5 (3): 19-27.
29.
Aidman E, Schofield G. Personality and
Individual Dierences in Sport. Milton: Wiley;
2004
256
|
VOLUME 14 | 2018 www.archbudo.com
Original Article
30.
Piepiora P, Witkowski K. Personality traits
of compeve athletes according to type of
pressure exerted on opponents. S Afr J for Res
Sport Ph 2018; 40(1): 97-109
31.
Bara Filho MG, Scipiao Ribeiro LC, Garcia
FC. Comparsion of personality characteris-
cs between high-level Brazilian athletes and
nonathletes. Rev Braz Med Exporte 2005;
11(2): 114-118
32. Robbins S, Judge T. Organizaonal Behavior.
London: Prense Hall; 2008
33.
Anghel A, Banica I, Ionescu S. Personality fea
-
tures of elite athletes considering the criterion
of the sport pracced. Sport Science Review
2009; 1: 5-6
34.
Brewer B. Sport Psychology. London: WB; 2009
35.
Allen MS., Greenlees I, Jones M. An inves-
gaon of the ve-factor model of personal-
ity and coping behaviour in sport. J Sport Sci
2011; 29: 841-850
36.
Tok S. The Big Five personality traits and risky
sport parcipaon. Soc Behav Pers Int J 2011;
39: 1105-1012
37.
Binboga E, Guven S, Catikkas F et al.
Psychophysiological responses to compe-
on and the Big Five personality traits. J Hum
Kinet 2012; 33: 187-194.
38.
Allen MS, Greenlees I, Jones M. Personality in
sport: a comprehensive review. Int Rev Sport
Exer Psychol 2013; 6: 184-208
39.
Mirzaei A, Nikbakhsh R, Sharififar F. The
relaonship between personality traits and
sport performance. Eur J Exp Biol 2013; 3
(3): 439-442
40.
Tomczak M, Bręczewski G, Sokołowski M et
al. Personality traits and stress coping styles
in the Polish Naonal Cadet Wrestling Team.
Arch Budo 2013; 2: 161–168.
41.
Allen MS, Laborde S. The role of personality
in sport and physical acvity. Curr Dir Psychol
Sci 2014; 23: 460-465
42.
Piepiora P, Piepiora D, Witkowski K. Personality
of the karatekas versus kumite sport ght sys-
tems (in view of the karate culture as the regu-
lator of this interdependence). J Combat Sport
Maral Arts 2016; 7 (1): 35-41
43. Wiggins J. The Five-Factor model of person-
ality. New York: The Guildford Press; 1996
44.
McCrae R, Costa Jr P. Personality in Adulthood:
A Five-Factor theory perspecve. New York:
Guilford Press; 2003
45.
Costa Jr P, McCrae R. Personality inventory Five
Factor model test. In: Zawadzki B, Strelau J,
Szczepaniak M et al., editors. NEO-FFI - Inwentarz
Osobowości NEO-FFI. Warszawa: Pracownia
Testów Psychologicznych; 2007 [in Polish]
46.
John OP, Naumann LP, Soto CJ. Paradigm
shi to the integrave Big-Five trait taxon-
omy: History, Measurement, and Conceptual
Issues. In: John OP, Robins RW, Pervin LA,
editors. Handbook of personality: Theory
and research. New York, NY: Guilford Press;
2008: 114-158
47.
Soto CJ, John OP, Gosling SD et al. The develop-
mental psychometrics of Big Five self-reports:
acquiescence, factor structure, coherence, and
dierenaon from ages 10 to 20. J Pers Soc
Psychol 2008; 94: 718-737
48.
Zimbardo P, Johnson RL, McCann V.
Psychology: Core Concepts. Sixth Edion.
Pearson Educaon Inc.; 2010
49.
Syska JR. Psychomotoryczne efekty uprawi-
ania przez kobiety nowoczesnych form
gimnastyczno-tanecznych z elementami samo-
obrony. [PhD Thesis]. Warszawa: Akademia
Wychowania Fizycznego Józefa Piłsudskiego;
2005 [in Polish]
50.
Kalina RM, Barczynski BJ. Presge and impact
Archives of Budo for scienc research of the
maral arts. Arch Budo 2010; 6(1): 53-55
51.
Bąk R. Combat sports and maral arts as an ele-
ment of health-related training. In: Kalina RM,
editor. Proceedings of the 1st World Congress
on Health and Maral Arts in Interdisciplinary
Approach; 2015 Sep 17-19; Czestochowa,
Poland. Warsaw: Archives of Budo; 2015:
190-192
52.
Boguszewski D. Zdrowotne aspekty sportów i
sztuk walki. Warszawa: Warszawski Uniwersytet
Medyczny; 2017 [in Polish]
53.
Biernat E, Krzepota J, Sadowska D. Maral Arts
as a Form of Undertaking Physical Acvity in
Leisure Time Analysis of Factors Determining
Parcipaon of Poles. Int J Environ Res Public
Health 2018; 15(9): 1989
54.
Kalina RM, Jagiełło W. Non-apparatus, Quasi-
apparatus and Simulaons Tests in Diagnosis
Posive Health and Survival Abilies. In: Ahram
T, editor. Advances in Human Factors in Sports,
Injury Prevenon and Outdoor Recreaon.
AHFE 2017. Advances in Intelligent Systems
and Computing. Cham: Springer; 2017:
121-128
55.
Kalina RM, Barczyński BJ. Long way to the
Czestochowa Declaraons 2015: HMA against
MMA. In: Kalina RM, editor. Proceedings of
the 1st World Congress on Health and Maral
Arts in Interdisciplinary Approach. 2015 Sep
17-19; Czestochowa, Poland. Warsaw: Archives
of Budo; 2015: 1-11
56.
Kalina RM. Agonology as a deeply esoteric
science – an introducon to maral arts ther-
apy on a global scale. Procedia Manufacturing
2015; 3: 1195-1202
57.
Kalina RM. Agonology – the prospect of an
eecve defence of peace and unrestricted
freedom of sciensts. Arch Budo 2016; 12:
1-13
58.
Kalina RM, Barczyński BJ. Mixed assessments
as mental and pedagogic basis of innovave
self-defence. Arch Budo 2017; 13: 187-194
59.
Hishinuma ES, Umemoto KN, Nguyen TG et
al. Epidemiology of mixed maral arts and
youth violence in an ethnically diverse sam-
ple. Violence Vict 2012; 27(1): 439
60.
Boostani MH, Boostani MA, Rezaei AM. Sport
psychology in professional karate athletes: give
psychological guidelines in order to improve
their act in the compeons. Ann Biol Res
2013; 4 (1): 48-52
61.
Piskorska E, Mieszkowski J, Kochanowicz A
et al. Mental skills in combat sports – review
of methods anxiety evaluaon. Arch Budo
2016; 12: 301-313
62.
Kalina RM, Chodała A, Dadeło S et al. Empirical
basis for predicng success in combat sports
and self-defence. Kinesiology 2005: 37(1): 1-13
63. Kalina RM, Jagiełło W, Chodała A. The result
of “tesng ghts in a vercal posture” as a
criterion of talent for combat sports and self-
defence – secondary validaon (part I: the
reliability). Arch Budo Sci Maral Art Extreme
Sport 2015; 11: 229-238
64. Kalina RM, Jagiełło W, Chodała A. The result
of “tesng ghts in a vercal posture” as a
criterion of talent for combat sports and self-
defence – secondary validaon (part II: the
accuracy). Arch Budo Sci Maral Art Extreme
Sport 2016; 12: 163-180
65. Niedomagała W. The result of “tesng ghts
in a vercal posture” as a selecon criterion
for professional training of judo sport – prog-
nosc value TFVP. Arch Budo Sci Maral Art
Extreme Sport 2016; 12: 181-190
66.
Jagiełło W, Kalina RM, Klimczak J et al. Fun
forms of maral arts in posive enhancement
of all dimensions of health and survival abili-
es. In: Kalina RM, editor. Proceedings of the
1st World Congress on Health and Maral Arts
in Interdisciplinary Approach. 2015 Sep 17-19;
Czestochowa, Poland. Warsaw: Archives of
Budo; 2015: 32-39
67. Klimczak J, Kalina RM, Jagiełło W. Fun forms
of maral arts in diagnosing and reducing
aggressiveness – mental eects of a one-
day course for Polish animators of sport. In:
Kalina RM, editor. Proceedings of the 1st
World Congress on Health and Maral Arts in
Interdisciplinary Approach. 2015 Sep 17-19;
Czestochowa, Poland. Warsaw: Archives of
Budo; 2015: 187-189
68.
Kalina RM. Muldimensional tests as a funda-
mental diagnosc tool in the prophylacc and
therapeuc agonology – the methodological
basis of personal safety (Part II: motor and psy-
chomotor muldimensional tests). Arch Budo
Sci Maral Art Extreme Sport 2018; 14: 1-14
69.
Dadeło S. Czynniki determinujące kompe-
tencje pracowników ochrony na Litwie. Studia i
Monograe. Warszawa: Akademia Wychowania
Fizycznego Józefa Piłsudskiego; 2005 [in Polish]
70.
Kalina RM. Cognive and applicaon barriers
to the use of “agonology in prevenve and
therapeuc dimension”. Salmon P, Macquet
AC, editors. Advances in Human Factors in
Sports and Outdoor Recreaon. Proceedings
of the HFE 2016 Internaonal Conference
on Human Factors in Sports and Outdoor
Recreaon. 2016 Jul 27-31; Florida, USA. Adv
Intell Sys Com 2017; 496: 25-35
71.
Piepiora P, Migasiewicz J, Witkowski K. The
tradional karate training and sports ght sys-
tems of kumite. Rocz Nauk Wyż Szk Wychow
Fiz Tur Białyst 2016; 18(4): 62-67
Piepiora P et al. – Personality profiles of karate master s...
© ARCHIVES OF BUDO
|
SCIENCE OF MARTIAL ARTS 2018
|
VOLUME 14
|
257
Cite this arcle as: Piepiora P, Witkowski K, Piepiora Z. Personality proles of karate masters pracsing dierent kumite styles. Arch Budo 2018; 14:
247-257
72.
Witkowski K, Piepiora P, Dula M. Karate kyo-
kushin jako forma spędzania czasu wolnego.
Rocz Nauk Wyż Szk Wychow Fiz Tur Białyst
2016; 18(4): 54-61 [in Polish]
73.
Piepiora P, Szmajke A, Migasiewicz J et al. The
karate culture and aggressiveness in kumite
competors. Ido Movement Cult J Maral
Arts Anthropol 2016; 16(2): 41-47
74.
Piepiora P, Piepiora Z. The philosophy of karate
in terms of the dojo-kun and the niju-kun on
the example of shotokan style. Rocz Nauk Wyż
Szk Wychow Fiz Tur Białyst 2016; 16(2): 45-51
75.
Diconary of Sport and Exercise Science.
Over 5,000 Terms Clearly Dened. London:
A & B Black; 2006
76.
Weinberg RS, Gould D. Foundaons of Sport
and Exercise Psychology. Champaign, IL:
Human Kinecs; 2010
77. De Crée C. Kōdōkan Jūdō’s Three Orphaned
Forms of Counter Techniques – Part 1: The
Gonosen-no-kata – “Forms of Post-Aack
Iniave Counter Throws”. Arch Budo 2015;
11: 93-123
78.
Budō: The Martial Ways of Japan. Tokyo:
Nippon Budokan Foundaon; 2009