PreprintPDF Available

Evidence for the Need of Combined Math and ELA Intervention In developing Integrated Intervention Curriculum for 9th and 10th Grade

Authors:
  • Rudimental Knowledge
Preprints and early-stage research may not have been peer reviewed yet.

Abstract

This preprint pertains to data collected on how effective handwriting in ELA remediation in compared to computer based or hybrid models. This concept is then applied to math remediation. \
Evidence for the Need of Combined Math and ELA Intervention
In developing Integrated Intervention Curriculum for 9th and 10th Grade
The number of students who are underperforming on their grade level has increased since
the pandemic. This phenomenon necessitates remediation of most, if not all subject areas on all
grade levels. Traditionally, teachers past the 5th grade level would teach one subject if not for the
year, for their entire career. However, the growing gaps in AISD and selected charter schools in
the Austin area show that an integrative intervention approach may be beneficial (SAS). This
document will refer to certain concepts: use of hand writing for math remediation (Koedinger,
Wilcox), use of hand writing in ELA intervention (Graham, Li, McCarroll), and certain teaching
strategies that will enhance the curriculum and further give students the opportunity for retention
of knowledge and application of knowledge (NCTM).
The use of handwriting in both ELA and Mathematics can engage students better than
typing (Graham, Li) as well as expose teachers to gaps in understanding as well as time on task.
This application of handwriting may lead to the increase of learning potential through the
engagement of mathematics by teaching scaffolded lessons to the students. For mathematics,
there are certain modes of instruction needed for maximum engagement and retention. For
instance, the differentiation from geometric, or logical, concepts to Algebra through algebraic
expressions, proofs, graphing, and linguistic expressions allows for the students to engage in
tiered, differentiated, and engagement through a multiple intelligences standpoint (NCTM,
Wilcox, Gardner). For English Language Arts, the constant exposure of grade level material
coupled with linguistic analysis and lexical development as standard practice could lead to an
increase of student performance through an increase of learning potential (NCTM, Wilcox, Li).
Along with teacher encouragement and the availability of many online resources, a learning
environment can shift to more of a research environment where the students have access to
growing knowledge at their own pace.
The concepts for ELA intervention could also apply for maths. For instance, if an Algebra
I class is learning polynomial long division, the students can be given many methods on how to
operate the problem. In addition to this, the remediation of this algebraic operation can be
applied as follows: graphing the operation as a function, using the lambdoma matrix for long
division practice, and aural instruction coupled with note taking on polynomial division (NCTM,
TEKS). As there is evidence of correlating student performance and the exposure of grade level
material in math (NCTM), an math curriculum can be taught through a lesson of the day
mentality. However, this same material can allow students to think about the next level of
difficulty for this math concept; as well as integrate remediation and real-world applications
during that same lesson. Math intervention could also engage in lexical building throughout the
year to alleviate the translation from the colloquial language to the academic language. This
allows for the tie-in of the current ELA curriculum and the math curriculum to reinforce the
curriculum to increase student learning potential and retention (NCTM).
In conclusion, the need for remediation of all subjects is needed, especially after the
students have engaged in distance and hybrid learning for the past two years. Although tested and
taught individually, a combined approach to remediation can tackle what is an interdependent
issue as both scores of ELA and Maths are suffering.
Works Cited
Gardner, Howard, and Thomas Hatch. “Educational Implications of the Theory of
Multiple Intelligences.” Educational Researcher, vol. 18, no. 8, Nov. 1989, pp. 4–10,
doi:10.3102/0013189X018008004.
Graham, Steve, and Naomi Weintraub. “A Review of Handwriting Research: Progress and
Prospects from 1980 to 1994 - Educational Psychology Review.SpringerLink, Kluwer
Academic Publishers, https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%252FBF01761831.
Hero, Barbara. “The Historical Context of the LAMBDOMA Matrix and Its Applications.
IEEE Xplore, https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1427116.
Koedinger, Kenneth. “How Handwritten Input Helps Students Learning Algebra Equation
Solving.Academia.edu, 17 Dec. 2015,
https://www.academia.edu/17528025/How_Handwritten_Input_Helps_Students_Learning_Alge
bra_Equation_Solving?from=cover_page.
Li, Jun. Principles of Effective English Language Learner ... - Eric.
https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED562799.pdf.
McCarroll, Hope, and Tina Fletcher. “Does Handwriting Instruction Have a Place in the
Instructional Day? the Relationship between Handwriting Quality and Academic Success.
Taylor & Francis, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/2331186X.2017.1386427.
NCTM, National Council of Teachers. Principles to Actions - National Council of
Teachers of ...
https://www.nctm.org/uploadedFiles/Standards_and_Positions/PtAExecutiveSummary.pdf.
“SAS/IntrNet Application Dispatcher.Application Dispatcher,
https://rptsvr1.tea.texas.gov/cgi/sas/broker.
TEKS. STAAR Standards Snapshot – Algebra I.
https://www.gpisd.org/cms/lib01/TX01001872/Centricity/Domain/901/STAAR_Standards_Snap
shot_Math_New_TEKS_Feb_2014_Algebra_I.pdf.
Wilcox, Brad. Monroe, Eula. “Integrating Writing and Mathematics.” Reading Rockets,
23 Aug. 2017, https://www.readingrockets.org/article/integrating-writing-and-mathematics.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
Handwriting is a foundational skill needed by students to demonstrate competency in reading, writing, and math. Occupational therapists who work in schools are tasked with providing remedial services for students who demonstrate deficits in underlying handwriting mechanics, as opposed to deficits in following handwriting conventions. Despite this, therapists frequently find the referred student has none of the expected mechanical constraints, but instead lacks knowledge of letter, number, and punctuation mark formation. This is often an outcome of not being exposed to explicit handwriting instruction. As a result, the researchers sought to determine whether a relationship exists between academic success in reading, writing, and math and the quality of handwriting by comparing standards-based report card grades in reading, writing, and math to scores from the Handwriting Without Tears Screener of Handwriting Proficiency. Results indicated a significant positive correlation exists between academic success in writing and reading and quality of handwriting. The implications of this research suggest there is a further need to explore whether instructional time should be allocated for handwriting instruction in the classroom, potentially contributing to increased academic success for students.
Article
Full-text available
Teachers often find it difficult to integrate writing and mathematics while honoring the integrity of both disciplines. In this article, the authors present two levels of integration that teachers may use as a starting point. The first level, writing without revision, can be worked into mathematics instruction quickly and readily. The second level, writing with revision, may take more time but enables teachers to connect the writing process more fully with mathematics instruction. Six examples are provided, including student work, in which teachers have successfully attended to the goals of both writing and mathematics.
Article
Full-text available
Contemporary handwriting research has focused on skilled performance, the developing capabilities of children, atypical development, the effectiveness of various letter forms, instructional techniques, and the construction and evaluation of assessment instruments. This paper critically reviews and synthesizes research conducted between 1980 and 1994 in each of these areas, providing suggestions for future research. Considerable progress was made during this time period in understanding the processes involved in handwriting control and development as well as in teaching students with handwriting difficulties. In addition, advances in theory, experimental procedures, on-line recording devices, and computerized instructional programs resulted in an increased level of sophistication. Thus, the prospects for future research in this area are promising.
Article
A new approach to the conceptualization and assessment of human intelligences is described. According to Gardner's Theory of Multiple Intelligences, each human being is capable of seven relatively independent forms of information processing, with individuals differing from one another in the specific profile of intelligences that they exhibit. The range of human intelligences is best assessed through contextually based, "intelligence-fair" instruments. Three research projects growing out of the theory are described. Preliminary data secured from Project Spectrum, an application in early childhood, indicate that even 4- and 5-year-old children exhibit distinctive profiles of strength and weakness. Moreover, measures of the various intelligences are largely independent and tap abilities other than those measured by standard intelligence tests.
Multiple Intelligences
Multiple Intelligences." Educational Researcher, vol. 18, no. 8, Nov. 1989, pp. 4-10, doi:10.3102/0013189X018008004.
The Historical Context of the LAMBDOMA Matrix and Its Applications
  • Barbara Hero
Hero, Barbara. "The Historical Context of the LAMBDOMA Matrix and Its Applications." IEEE Xplore, https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/1427116.
Standards Snapshot -Algebra I
  • Teks
  • Staar
TEKS. STAAR Standards Snapshot -Algebra I.