PreprintPDF Available

The double-edged role of nitric oxide drives predictable microbial community organization according to the microenvironment

Authors:
Steven A. Wilbert
Steven A. Wilbert
Steven A. Wilbert
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Dianne K. Newman
Dianne K. Newman
Dianne K. Newman
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Download file PDF
Read file
Download citation

Abstract

Microbial assemblages are omnipresent in the biosphere, forming communities on the surfaces of roots, rocks, and within living tissues. These communities can exhibit strikingly beautiful compositional structures, with certain members reproducibly occupying particular spatiotemporal microniches. Yet often, we lack the ability to explain the spatial patterns we see within them. To test the hypothesis that certain spatial patterns in microbial communities may be explained by the exchange of redox-active metabolites whose biological function is sensitive to environmental gradients, here we developed a simple community consisting of synthetic Pseudomonas aeruginosa strains with a partitioned denitrification pathway: a strict consumer and strict producer of nitric oxide (NO), a key pathway intermediate. Because NO can be both toxic or beneficial depending on the amount of oxygen present, this system provided an opportunity to investigate whether dynamic oxygen gradients can tune metabolic cross-feeding in a predictable fashion. Using a combination of genetic analysis, different growth environments and imaging, we show that oxygen availability controls whether NO cross-feeding is commensal or mutually beneficial, and that this organizing principle maps to the microscale. More generally, this work underscores the importance of considering the double-edged roles redox-active metabolites can play in shaping microbial communities.
Available via license: CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Content may be subject to copyright.
!
1!
Title:'!"#$%&'()#*#%+#%$,&)#$&-$./0,/1$&2/%#$%,/3#4$5,#%/106()#$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./08$&,+6./960/&.$
1
!
611&,%/.+$0&$0"#$7/1,&#.3/,&.7#.0:$$
2
!
$$
3
!
;0#3#.$<:$=/)(#,0>!6.%$?/6..#$@:$A#B76.>CDCE$
4
!
$$
5
!
Contact'information:$
6
!
>$?/3/4/&.$&-$F/&)&+8$6.%$F/&)&+/16)$G.+/.##,/.+C$H6)/-&,./6$I.40/0'0#$&-$!#1".&)&+8C$J646%#.6C$
7
!
H6)/-&,./6C$K;<C$L>>DM$
8
!
D$?/3/4/&.$&-$N#&)&+/16)$6.%$J)6.#06,8$;1/#.1#4C$H6)/-&,./6$I.40/0'0#$&-$!#1".&)&+8C$J646%#.6C$
9
!
H6)/-&,./6C$K;<C$L>>DM$
10
!
$$
11
!
ECorrespondence:$
12
!
?/6..#$@:$A#B76.$
13
!
>DOO$G:$H6)/-&,./6$F)3%:C$P6/)$1&%#$>QR*RM$
14
!
J646%#.6C$H<$L>>DM$
15
!
!#)#5"&.#S$TDT*ULM*UMQU$
16
!
G76/)S$%V.W16)0#1":#%'$
17
!
$$
18
!
@#8B&,%4S$$J&)87/1,&(/6)$1&77'./0/#4C$7#06(&)/47C$7#06(&)/1$1,&44*-##%/.+C$./0,/1$&2/%#C$
19
!
./0,60#C$%#./0,/-/160/&.C$4560/6)$&,+6./960/&.C$7/1,&#.3/,&.7#.0C$&28+#.$+,6%/#.04C$"#$%&'(')*#!
20
!
*$+%,-)'#*$
21
!
'$
22
!
Abstract$
23
!
P/1,&(/6)$644#7()6+#4$6,#$&7./5,#4#.0$/.$0"#$(/&45"#,#C$-&,7/.+$1&77'./0/#4$&.$0"#$4',-61#4$
24
!
&-$,&&04C$,&1V4C$6.%$B/0"/.$)/3/.+$0/44'#4:$!"#4#$1&77'./0/#4$16.$#2"/(/0$40,/V/.+)8$(#6'0/-')$
25
!
1&75&4/0/&.6)$40,'10',#4C$B/0"$1#,06/.$7#7(#,4$,#5,&%'1/()8$&11'58/.+$56,0/1')6,$
26
!
4560/&0#75&,6)$7/1,&./1"#4:$X#0$&-0#.C$B#$)61V$0"#$6(/)/08$0&$#25)6/.$0"#$4560/6)$5600#,.4$B#$4##$
27
!
B/0"/.$0"#7:$!&$0#40$0"#$"85&0"#4/4$0"60$1#,06/.$4560/6)$5600#,.4$/.$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./0/#4$768$(#$
28
!
#25)6/.#%$(8$0"#$#21"6.+#$&-$,#%&2*610/3#$7#06(&)/0#4$B"&4#$(/&)&+/16)$-'.10/&.$/4$4#.4/0/3#$0&$
29
!
#.3/,&.7#.06)$+,6%/#.04C$"#,#$B#$%#3#)&5#%$6$4/75)#$1&77'./08$1&.4/40/.+$&-$48.0"#0/1$
30
!
"#$%&'(')*#!*$+%,-)'#*!40,6/.4$B/0"$6$56,0/0/&.#%$%#./0,/-/160/&.$560"B68S$6$40,/10$1&.4'7#,$
31
!
6.%$40,/10$5,&%'1#,$&-$./0,/1$&2/%#$YAZ[C$6$V#8$560"B68$/.0#,7#%/60#:$F#16'4#$AZ$16.$(#$(&0"$
32
!
0&2/1$&,$(#.#-/1/6)$%#5#.%/.+$&.$0"#$67&'.0$&-$&28+#.$5,#4#.0C$0"/4$4840#7$5,&3/%#%$6.$
33
!
&55&,0'./08$0&$/.3#40/+60#$B"#0"#,$%8.67/1$&28+#.$+,6%/#.04$16.$0'.#$7#06(&)/1$1,&44*-##%/.+$
34
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
2!
/.$6$5,#%/106()#$-64"/&.:$K4/.+$6$1&7(/.60/&.$&-$+#.#0/1$6.6)84/4C$%/--#,#.0$+,&B0"$#.3/,&.7#.04$
35
!
6.%$/76+/.+C$B#$4"&B$0"60$&28+#.$636/)6(/)/08$1&.0,&)4$B"#0"#,$AZ$1,&44*-##%/.+$/4$1&77#.46)$
36
!
&,$7'0'6))8$(#.#-/1/6)C$6.%$0"60$0"/4$&,+6./9/.+$5,/.1/5)#$7654$0&$0"#$7/1,&416)#:$P&,#$+#.#,6))8C$
37
!
0"/4$B&,V$'.%#,41&,#4$0"#$/75&,06.1#$&-$1&.4/%#,/.+$0"#$%&'()#*#%+#%$,&)#4$,#%&2*610/3#$
38
!
7#06(&)/0#4$16.$5)68$/.$4"65/.+$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./0/#4:$
39
!
$$
40
!
Introduction$
41
!
N/3#.$0"#$%/3#,4/08$&-$7/1,&(/6)$7#06(&)/1$40,60#+/#4$6.%$0"60$7/1,&(#4$,6,#)8$)/3#$6)&.#C$
42
!
0"#$5&0#.0/6)$-&,$7#06(&)/1$/.0#,610/&.4$/4$3640$Y\']/+6$#0$6):C$DO>R[:$P#06(&)/1$/.0#,610/&.4$16.$
43
!
(#$5&4/0/3#$&,$.#+60/3#$6.%$16.$"63#$5,&-&'.%$#--#104$&.$0"#$4',,&'.%/.+$#.3/,&.7#.0C$-,&7$
44
!
1&.0,/('0/.+$0&$.'0,/#.0$-)'2$0&$40/7')60/.+$0"#$/77'.#$4840#7$&-$6.$/.-#10#%$6./76)$&,$5)6.0:$
45
!
!"#,#-&,#C$0"#,#$/4$6.$/.1,#64/.+$655,#1/60/&.$-&,$0"#$.##%$0&$1"6,610#,/9#$6.%$5,#%/10$4'1"$
46
!
/.0#,610/&.4$Y=/%%#,$#0$6):C$DO>T[:$A'7#,&'4$#1&)&+/16)$7&%#)4$"63#$(##.$%#3#)&5#%$0&$(#00#,$
47
!
'.%#,406.%$"&B$4'1"$/.0#,610/&.4$/.-)'#.1#$0"#$+,&B0"$6.%$4'(4#^'#.0$4560/6)$5600#,./.+$&-$6$
48
!
1&77'./08$YN&)%-&,%$#0$6):C$DO>_`$A/#"6'4$#0$6):C$DO>L`$a609V#$#0$6):C$DODO[:$b&B#3#,C$0"#4#$
49
!
7&%#)4$085/16))8$-&1'4$&.$4/75)#$+,&B0"$V/.#0/14$/.3&)3/.+$6$4"6,#%$&,$#21"6.+#%$(#.#-/1/6)$
50
!
7#06(&)/0#$6.%$%&$.&0$1&.4/%#,$"&B$1"6.+/.+$7/1,&#.3/,&.7#.04$&3#,$476))$4560/6)$416)#4$16.$
51
!
/.-)'#.1#$0"#$/./0/60/&.$6.%c&,$^'6)/08$&-$/.0#,610/&.4$%#5#.%#.0$'5&.$0"/4$7#06(&)/0#:$I.$
52
!
56,0/1')6,C$%8.67/1$4560/&0#75&,6)$1"6.+#4$/.$&28+#.$636/)6(/)/08$/4$6$B#))*%&1'7#.0#%$
53
!
#1&)&+/16)$5"#.&7#.&.$7/1,&(#4$6,#$1&.-,&.0#%$B/0"$Y?6)$H&$#0$6):C$DO>L`$@,/1"#)4$#0$6):C$DO>L`$
54
!
d&B#,8$6.%$K,4#))C$DO>L`$;0#B6,0$#0$6):C$DO>T[C$('0$/4$&-0#.$&3#,)&&V#%$/.$0"#4#$7&%#)4:$$
55
!
?/--'4/()#C$,#%&2*610/3#$7#06(&)/0#4C$(#$0"#8$&,+6./1$&,$/.&,+6./1C$6,#$56,0/1')6,)8$
56
!
/.0#,#40/.+$0&$1&.4/%#,$/.$0"/4$1&.0#20C$64$0"#4#$7&)#1')#4e$,#610/3/08$/4$"/+")8$4#.4/0/3#$0&$)&16)$
57
!
1"#7/40,8:$a#1#.0$B&,V$"64$16))#%$600#.0/&.$0&$0"#$-610$0"60$1#,06/.$,#%&2*610/3#$7#06(&)/0#4$
58
!
"63#$0"#$5&0#.0/6)$0&$(#$(&0"$0&2/1$Y/:#:$+#.#,60#$,#610/3#$&28+#.$45#1/#4$'.%#,$&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4[$
59
!
&,$(#.#-/1/6)$Y/:#:$1&.0,/('0#$0&$#.#,+8$1&.4#,360/&.$'.%#,$6.&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4[C$0"#,#(8$"63/.+$0"#$
60
!
5&0#.0/6)$0&$5)68$%/--#,#.0$6.%$%8.67/1$,&)#4$/.$0"#$%#3#)&57#.0$&-$6$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./08$
61
!
Y?6")40,&7$#0$6):C$DODO[:$;'1"$%&'()#*#%+#%$#--#104$768$(#$56,0/1')6,)8$/75&,06.0$B"#.$0"#$
62
!
7#06(&)/0#$/.$^'#40/&.$/4$6.$/.0#,7#%/60#$/.$6$1&77&.$7#06(&)/1$560"B68:$f&,$#2675)#C$/-$0B&$
63
!
7/1,&(#4$6,#$,#)/6.0$&.$#61"$&0"#,$-&,$+,&B0"$%'#$0&$6.$/.0#,7#%/60#$0"60$16.$(#$0&2/1$0&$0"#$
64
!
5,&%'1#,$('0$/4$#44#.0/6)$-&,$0"#$1&.4'7#,C$/0$406.%4$0&$,#64&.$0"60$0"#/,$+,&B0"$6.%$4'(4#^'#.0$
65
!
#.3/,&.7#.06)$/75610$B/))$%#5#.%$&.$7/1,&#.3/,&.7#.06)$1&.%/0/&.4$0"60$0'.#$0"#$5,&5#,0/#4$&-$
66
!
0"#$#21"6.+#%$/.0#,7#%/60#:$!"#$5&0#.0/6)$-&,$36,/6()#$)&16)$/.0#,610/&.4$%'#$0&$4"/-0/.+$
67
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
3!
#.3/,&.7#.06)$+,6%/#.04$B&')%$0"#,#-&,#$(#$#25#10#%$0&$0'.#$B"#.C$B"#,#C$6.%$"&B$1#,06/.$
68
!
7/1,&(/6)$/.0#,610/&.4$B&')%$76./-#40$4560/&0#75&,6))8:$$
69
!
<4$6$40#5$0&B6,%4$0#40/.+$0"/4$+#.#,6)$"85&0"#4/4C$B#$4&'+"0$0&$1,#60#$6$4/75)#$48.0"#0/1$
70
!
7&%#)$4840#7$/.$B"/1"$0&$#25)&,#$0"#$#--#10$&-$0"#$7/1,&#.3/,&.7#.0$&.$0"#$/.0#,610/&.4$
71
!
(#0B##.$0B&$(610#,/6)$56,0.#,4$)/.V#%$3/6$6.$#21"6.+#%$,#%&2*610/3#$7#06(&)/0#:$f&',$1,/0#,/6$
72
!
+'/%#%$&',$%#3#)&57#.0$&-$4'1"$6$4840#7:$f/,40C$B#$,#^'/,#%$0"60$0"#$7#06(&)/0#$(#$
73
!
g6+60"&V6V&)&+/16)hC$6$B&,%$%#,/3#%$-,&7$N,##V$,&&04$7#6./.+$g1&75&4#%$&-$+&&%$6.%$#3/)hC$/.$
74
!
&0"#,$B&,%4C$6$7#06(&)/0#$0"60$/4$5,#%/106()8$g%&'()#*#%+#%hS$(#.#-/1/6)$&,$"6,7-')$611&,%/.+$0&$
75
!
/04$1&.0#20:$$;#1&.%C$B#$.##%#%$0&$(#$6()#$0&$7#64',#$6.%$5#,0',($0"#$7&40$/75&,06.0$
76
!
#.3/,&.7#.06)$56,67#0#,i&28+#.i0"60$6--#104$/04$5"84/&)&+/16)$-'.10/&.4:$$!"/,%C$B#$6/7#%$0&$
77
!
1&.0,&)$0"#$5,&%'10/&.$6.%$'0/)/960/&.$&-$0"/4$7#06(&)/0#$3/6$0"#$+#.#,60/&.$&-$7'06.0$40,6/.4$-,&7$
78
!
6.$/4&+#./1$(61V+,&'.%$/.$&,%#,$0&$-&1'4$40,/10)8$&.$0"#$16561/08$0&$76V#$&,$'4#$/0:$$f/.6))8C$B#$
79
!
4&'+"0$6$7#06(&)/1$#21"6.+#$0"60$/4$(,&6%)8$#1&)&+/16))8$,#)#36.0$61,&44$76.8$#.3/,&.7#.04:$$$
80
!
!"#$#21"6.+#$&-$./0,/1$&2/%#$YAZ[$7#0$6))$&-$&',$1,/0#,/6:$AZ$/4$V.&B.$/.$(&0"$0"#$
81
!
#'V6,8&0/1$6.%$7/1,&(/6)$B&,)%4$64$6$5&0#.0$4/+.6)/.+$7&)#1')#$6.%$6$"/+")8$,#610/3#$./0,&+#.$
82
!
45#1/#4$0"60$16.$%676+#$6$36,/#08$&-$1#))')6,$1&75&.#.04$Yj&)V$#0$6):C$DOOQ[:$I.$0"#$6(4#.1#$&-$
83
!
&28+#.C$AZ$/4$0&2/1$60$"/+"$1&.1#.0,60/&.4$(8$6.06+&./9/.+$f#*;$1#.0#,4$6.%$16'4/.+$?A<$
84
!
%676+#`$8#0$/.$0"#$5,#4#.1#$&-$&28+#.C$7'1"$)&B#,$)#3#)4$&-$AZ$16.$(#$0&2/1$%'#$0"#$
85
!
+#.#,60/&.$&-$5#,&28./0,/0#`$Y@&55#.&)$6.%$@&55#.&)C$DOD>`$\'7-0C$>LLR[:$P/1,&(#4$"63#$
86
!
.'7#,&'4$7#1"6./474$0&$%#6)$B/0"$)&B$)#3#)4$&-$AZ$0&2/1/08$4'1"$64$-)63&"#7&+)&(/.$5,&0#/.4$
87
!
Yf"5[$0"60$16.$,#%'1#$AZ$0&$./0,&'4$&2/%#$YADZ[C$&,$7#%/60#$/04$&2/%60/&.$0&$./0,60#$YAZU*[C$
88
!
%#5#.%/.+$&.$0"#$#.3/,&.7#.0$Y<,6/C$DO>>`$@&4V#.V&,36$#0$6):C$DOO_[C$6.%$&0"#,$%/&28+#.64#4$
89
!
16.$4#^'#40#,$AZ$Y;646V/$#0$6):C$DO>T`$X&&.$#0$6):C$DOOR[:$="/)#$AZ$"64$(##.$40'%/#%$/.$%#06/)$
90
!
B/0"$,#45#10$0&$0"#4#$5,&5#,0/#4C$/0$16.$6)4&$4'55&,0$#.#,+8$1&.4#,360/&.:$<0$0"#$,/+"0$
91
!
1&.1#.0,60/&.4C$6.%$/-$6$7/1,&(#$"64$0"#$,#^'/4/0#$761"/.#,8$0&$5,&1#44$/0C$/.$0"#$6(4#.1#$&-$
92
!
&28+#.C$AZ$16.$4#,3#$64$6$0#,7/.6)$#)#10,&.$611#50&,$Y!G<[$-&,$6.6#,&(/1$,#45/,60/&.$YH6,,$#0$
93
!
6):C$>L_L`$@6)V&B4V/C$>LL>[:$X#0$64$/04$1&.1#.0,60/&.$,/4#4C$6.%$/-$5,&%'1/.+$1#))4$&,$.#/+"(&,4$
94
!
6,#$'.6()#$0&$,#%'1#$/0$0&$./0,&'4$&2/%#$YADZ[C$/0$,#61"#4$0&2/1$)#3#)4$6.%$)#6%4$0&$)&16)$+,&B0"$
95
!
/."/(/0/&.$&,$%#60"$YF,'.#))/$#0$6):C$>LLM`$X'$#0$6):C$>LLL[:$$
96
!
AZ$5,&%'10/&.$/4$6$)6.%76,V$40#5$/.$%#./0,/-/160/&.C$B"#,#$0"#$4&)'()#$4'(40,60#$./0,/0#$
97
!
YAZD*[$/4$,#%'1#%$0&$+64#&'4$AZ:$?#./0,/-/160/&.$#$)#%!#.+-/.'!5)684$6$1,/0/16)$,&)#$/.$0"#$)&44$&-$
98
!
./0,&+#.$/.$4&/)4$Yf6.+$#0$6):C$DO>M`$@,/1"#)4$6.%$X6.+C$DO>L`$!/6.$#0$6):C$DO>L[:$I-$6.$&,+6./47$
99
!
1&.06/.4$6$-'))$560"B68$0&$4#^'#.0/6))8$,#%'1#$./0,60#$YAZU*[$k$AZD*$k$AZ$k$ADZ$k$./0,&+#.$+64$
100
!
YAD[C$"6,7)#44$AD$B/))$(#$,#)#64#%$/.0&$0"#$#.3/,&.7#.0$B"#,#$/0$16.$#3#.0'6))8$(#1&7#$,#181)#%$
101
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
4!
(8$./0,&+#.$-/2/.+$45#1/#4$Y@'85#,4$#0$6):C$DO>_[:$b&B#3#,C$/0$/4$(#1&7/.+$7&,#$1)#6,$0"60$0"#$
102
!
1&75)#0#$,#%'10/&.$&-$./0,60#$0&$./0,&+#.$+64$768$&11',$64$6$5&)87/1,&(/6)$1&77'./08$#--&,0$/.$
103
!
B"/1"$%/--#,#.0$7#7(#,4$1&.06/.$&.)8$6$4'(4#0$&-$0"#$%#./0,/-/160/&.$560"B68$YN&B%6$#0$6):C$
104
!
DODO`$b#40#,$#0$6):C$DO>L`$d81'4$#0$6):C$DO>R`$a/1"$#0$6):C$DOOU[:$;8.0"#0/1$"#$%&'(')*#!
105
!
*$+%,-)'#*$40,6/.4$"63#$(##.$4"&B.$0&$#21"6.+#$AZD*$'.%#,$40,/10)8$6.&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4C$)#6%/.+$
106
!
0&$5,#%/106()#$4560/6)$5600#,.4$0"60$6,#$4#.4/0/3#$0&$5b*%#5#.%#.0$6(/&0/1$./0,/0#$,#%'10/&.$0&$0&2/1$
107
!
./0,&+#.$45#1/#4$YF&,#,$#0$6):C$DODO`$d/)l6$6.%$m&".4&.C$DO>T[:$I.$6.$/.%#5#.%#.0$40'%8C$
108
!
#.3/,&.7#.06)$/4&)60#4$0"60$.60',6))8$%/--#,#%$/.$0"#/,$5&44#44/&.$&-$%#./0,/-/160/&.$+#.#4$B#,#$
109
!
'4#%$0&$1,#60#$6$7&%#)$0"60$5,#%/10#%$/.0#,610/&.4$3/6$%#./0,/-/160/&.$/.0#,7#%/60#4$YN&B%6$#0$6):C$
110
!
DODO[`$8#0C$/.$0"/4$164#C$AZ$5,&%'10/&.$B64$&.)8$1&.4/%#,#%$-&,$/04$5&0#.0/6)$0&2/1/08$,60"#,$0"6.$
111
!
/04$5&0#.0/6)$-&,$#.#,+8$1&.4#,360/&.:$I75&,06.0)8C$B"/)#$&)%#,$5"84/&)&+/16)$40'%/#4$"63#$4"&B.$
112
!
0"60$AZ$16.$4'55&,0$#.#,+8$1&.4#,360/&.$64$0"#$4&)#$0#,7/.6)$#)#10,&.$611#50&,$YH6,,$#0$6):C$
113
!
>L_L`$j&!B/.V#)$#0$6):C$>LL>[C$0&$&',$V.&B)#%+#C$0"#$6(/)/08$-&,$AZ$0&$(#$#21"6.+#%$(#0B##.$
114
!
1#))4$/.$6$76..#,$0"60$4'55&,04$+,&B0"$"64$.&0$(#$%#7&.40,60#%:$$
115
!
I.$0"/4$40'%8C$B#$'0/)/9#%$%/--#,#.0$7'06.0$40,6/.4$&-$0"#$%#./0,/-8/.+$&,+6./47C$"0!
116
!
*$+%,-)'#*!40,6/.$J<>QC$0&$0#40$0"#$"85&0"#4/4$0"60$0"#$4560/6)$/.0#,610/&.4$&-$40,6/.4$#21"6.+/.+$
117
!
AZ$16.$(#$5,#%/106()8$6)0#,#%$64$6$-'.10/&.$&-$&28+#.$/.$0"#$7/1,&#.3/,&.7#.0:$"0!*$+%,-)'#*$/4$
118
!
6$1&47&5&)/06.$&,+6./47C$.&0&,/&'4$-&,$(#/.+$6.$&55&,0'./40/1$"'76.$560"&+#.C$('0$6)4&$-&'.%$
119
!
/.$4#%/7#.04$6.%$4&/)4$Y<,6/C$DO>>[:$"0!*$+%,-)'#*$/4$6)4&$6$1)644/1$%#./0,/-/#,$0"60$#.1&%#4$6))$
120
!
#.987#4$.#1#446,8$-&,$0"#$1&75)#0#$,#%'10/&.$&-$./0,60#$0&$./0,&+#.$+64$6.%$16.$(#$#64/)8$
121
!
+#.#0/16))8$76./5')60#%C$5#,7/00/.+$0"#$1,#60/&.$&-$6$48.0"#0/1$AZ$1,&44*-##%/.+$1&77'./08:$Z',$
122
!
-/.%/.+4$B/0"$0"/4$7&%#)$1&77'./08$5,&3/%#$6$1&.1#50'6)$)#.4$0",&'+"$B"/1"$0&$/.0#,5,#0$7&,#$
123
!
1&75)#2$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./08$5600#,./.+$/.$.60',#$6.%$%/4#64#$/.3&)3/.+$0"#$#21"6.+#$&-$
124
!
6+60"&V6V&)&+/16)$7#06(&)/0#4:$
125
!
'$
126
!
Results$
127
!
Design'and'characterization'of'a'synthetic'NO'cross?feeding'community.$
128
!
!"#$J<>Q$+#.&7#$1&.06/.4$6$-'))$4'/0#$&-$,#45/,60&,8$#.987#4$-&,$0"#$1&75)#0#$
129
!
%/44/7/)60&,8$,#%'10/&.$&-$AZU*$0&$AD$YA6,C$A65C$A/,C$A&,C$A&4[$Yf/+',#$><[$Y<,6/C$DO>>[C$6.%$
130
!
5,#3/&'4$40'%/#4$"63#$4"&B.$0"60$0"#4#$40#54$&11',$4#^'#.0/6))8$YH6,)4&.$6.%$I.+,6"67C$>L_U[:$
131
!
<11&,%/.+)8C$B#$"85&0"#4/9#%$0"60$/0$B&')%$(#$5&44/()#$0&$56,0/0/&.$0"#$J<>Q$%#./0,/-/160/&.$
132
!
560"B68$(#0B##.$0B&$40,6/.4C$6$AZ$5,&%'1#,$6.%$6$AZ$1&.4'7#,C$0&$76V#$6$48.0"#0/1$
133
!
1&77'./08$B/0"$0"#$6(/)/08$0&$1606)89#$0"#$1&75)#0#$%#./0,/-/160/&.$,#610/&.$Yf/+',#$>FC$
134
!
;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$><[:$;#3#,6)$40#54$B#,#$.#1#446,8$0&$1&.40,'10$6$B#))*1&.0,&))#%$4840#7:$$
135
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
5!
f/,40C$B#$+#.#,60#%$6$40,6/.$&-$J<>Q$)61V/.+$0"#$./0,60#$,#%'1064#$Y1)*+2345C$1&.4'7#,$>C$
136
!
;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$><[$6.%$+,#B$/0$/.$6$,/1"$7#%/'7$6.&2/16))8$/.$0"#$5,#4#.1#$&-$./0,60#:$
137
!
H&756,#%$0&$B/)%$085#$J<$Y=![C$+,&B0"$B/0"&'0$./0,60#$,#%'1064#$B64$4/+./-/16.0)8$4)&B#,$
138
!
Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$>FC$&,6.+#$)/.#[:$A#20C$B#$+#.#,60#%$6$40,6/.$&-$J<>Q$)61V/.+$0"#$./0,/1$
139
!
&2/%#$,#%'1064#$Y1)'+67C$5,&%'1#,$>`$;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$><[`$B"#.$+,&B.$'.%#,$0"#$467#$
140
!
1&.%/0/&.4C$0"/4$5,&%'1#,$40,6/.$4"&B#%$.#+)/+/()#$+,&B0"$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$>HC$&,6.+#$)/.#[:$
141
!
!"/4$)61V$&-$+,&B0"$B64$)/V#)8$%'#$0&$0"#$,#%'10/&.$&-$./0,60#$0&$AZC$B"/1"$"64$(##.$7#64',#%$0&$
142
!
('/)%$'5$0&$>TnP$/.$4/7/)6,$7'06.04C$,#5,#44/.+$./0,60#$,#%'1064#$#25,#44/&.$6.%$5,#3#.0/.+$
143
!
-',0"#,$./0,60#$,#%'10/&.$64$6$4',3/36)$7#1"6./47$YX&&.$#0$6):C$DOOR[:$="#.$B#$7/2#%$0"#4#$0B&$
144
!
40,6/.4$/.$#^'6)$,60/&4$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$>?C$&,6.+#$)/.#[C$0"#$7/20',#$+,#B$0&$6$"/+"#,$-/.6)$
145
!
Z?$6.%$.#6,)8$0B/1#$64$-640$64$0"#$1&.4'7#,$40,6/.:$
146
!
b&B#3#,C$%'#$0&$0"#$4#^'#.0/6)$.60',#$&-$0"#$,#%'10/&.$40#54C$B#$,#6)/9#%$/0$B64$5&44/()#$
147
!
0"60$0"#$./0,60#$,#%'1064#$7'06.0$Y1&.4'7#,$>[$40,6/.$1&')%$(#$,#%'1/.+$0"#$AZD*$/.0#,7#%/60#$
148
!
-,&7$0"#$./0,/1$&2/%#$,#%'1064#$7'06.0$Y5,&%'1#,$>[$40,6/.$(#-&,#$AZ$B64$#3#.$+#.#,60#%$Yd/)l6$
149
!
6.%$m&".4&.C$DO>T[C$&,$0"60$0"#$5,&%'1#,$B64$(#.#-/0/.+$-,&7$6$4#1&.%6,8$1,&4406)V$3/6$ADZ$
150
!
,#%'10/&.$5,&%'1#%$(8$0"#$1&.4'7#,$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$><C$1&*1')0',#$>[:$!&$#)/7/.60#$0"#$
151
!
5&44/(/)/08$&-$0"#4#$'./.0#.%#%$/.0#,610/&.4C$B#$,#7&3#%$0"#$./0,/0#$,#%'1064#$YA/,[$-,&7$0"#$
152
!
1&.4'7#,$40,6/.$6.%$0"#$./0,&'4$&2/%#$,#%'1064#$YA&4[$-,&7$0"#$5,&%'1#,$40,6/.$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$
153
!
-/)#$><C$1&*1')0',#$D[:$N,&B0"$&-$0"/4$.#B$5,&%'1#,$40,6/.$Y1)'+671)'#8C$5,&%'1#,$D[$6)&.#$B64$
154
!
'.1"6.+#%C$/.%/160/.+$0"60$AZ$+,&B0"$/."/(/0/&.$&,$0&2/1/08$B64$40/))$0"#$5,/76,8$5"#.&085/1$%,/3#,$
155
!
Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$>HC$+,##.$)/.#[:$!"#$.#B$1&.4'7#,$40,6/.$Y1)*+23451)-+9C$5,&%'1#,$D`$
156
!
;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$>FC$+,##.$)/.#[$)61V/.+$(&0"$0"#$./0,60#$6.%$./0,/0#$,#%'1064#4C$"&B#3#,C$
157
!
4"&B#%$,#%'1#%$+,&B0"$1&756,#%$0&$0"#$./0,60#*,#%'1064#$&.)8$7'06.0$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$>FC$
158
!
&,6.+#$)/.#[:$="#.$0"#4#$0B&$40,6/.4$B#,#$+,&B.$0&+#0"#,C$0"#,#$B64$40/))$6$,#41'#C$6)0"&'+"$
159
!
4)&B#,$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$>?C$1&756,#$&,6.+#$6.%$+,##.$)/.#4[:$=#$/.0#,5,#0$0"/4$%/--#,#.1#$/.$
160
!
+,&B0"$,60#$0&$(#$%'#$0&$%/--#,#.0/6)$1,&44*-##%/.+S$>[$0"#$40,6/.4$&.)8$1,&44*-##%$AZ$Y+,##.$
161
!
0,61#[$&,$D[$0"#$40,6/.4$16.$1,&44*-##%$7&,#$0"6.$AZ$Y8#))&B$0,61#[:$
162
!
I.$#25#,/7#.04$B/0"$&',$4#1&.%$4#0$&-$1&*1')0',#$40,6/.4$Y+,##.[C$B#$.&0/1#%$0"60$0"#$
163
!
1&.4'7#,$%/45)68#%$,#%'1#%$+,&B0"$'5&.$0"#$,#7&36)$&-$./0,/0#$,#%'1064#C$#3#.$0"&'+"$0"#$
164
!
7#%/'7$&.)8$1&.06/.#%$6%%#%$./0,60#:$!"/4$)#%$'4$0&$45#1')60#$0"60$0"#$5#,/5)647/1$./0,60#$
165
!
,#%'1064#$YA65[$7/+"0$(#$1&.0,/('0/.+$0&$1&.4'7#,$+,&B0"C$&,$60$)#640$,#%'1/.+$0"#$./0,60#$
166
!
636/)6()#$0&$0"#$5,&%'1#,`$A65$/4$1&77&.)8$0"&'+"0$0&$(#$'4#%$-&,$,#%&2$(6)6.1/.+$1&756,#%$0&$
167
!
0"#$7#7(,6.#$(&'.%$./0,60#$,#%'1064#$YA6,[C$B"/1"$1&.0,/('0#4$0&$5,&0&.$0,6.4)&160/&.$6.%$
168
!
')0/760#)8$<!J$+#.#,60/&.$Ya/1"6,%4&.C$DOOO`$;56,61/.&*=60V/.4$#0$6):C$DO>Q`$j6.$<)40$#0$6):C$
169
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
6!
DOOL[:$!&$0#40$0"/4$5&44/(/)/08C$B#$+#.#,60#%$6$.#B$4#0$&-$56,0/0/&.#%$40,6/.4$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$
170
!
><C$1&*1')0',#$UC$Q[C$B"#,#$A65$#/0"#,$B64$%#)#0#%$-,&7$(&0"$0"#$1&.4'7#,$6.%$5,&%'1#,$
171
!
Y1)*+23451)-+91)*:;7C$1&*1')0',#$UC$5',5)#[$&,$-,&7$0"#$1&.4'7#,$&.)8$
172
!
Y1)'+671)'#81)*:;7C$1&*1')0',#$QC$,#%[:$I.$(&0"$164#4$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$>?[$B#$&(4#,3#%$
173
!
4)/+"0)8$-640#,$+,&B0"$-&,$0"#$0"/,%$6.%$-&',0"$1&*1')0',#4$1&756,#%$0&$0"#$4#1&.%$1&*1')0',#$4#0C$
174
!
)/V#)8$%'#$0&$0"#$,#40,/10/&.$&-$./0,60#$,#%'10/&.$(8$0"#$7&40$#.#,+#0/16))8$-63&,6()#$560"$Y/:#:$0"#$
175
!
5,&%'1#,$40,6/.$1&')%$&.)8$,#%'1#$./0,60#$3/6$A6,[:$F64#%$&.$0"#4#$,#4')04C$-&,$0"#$,#76/.%#,$&-$
176
!
&',$40'%/#4C$B#$%#1/%#%$0&$-',0"#,$/.3#40/+60#$0"#$(#"63/&,$&-$0"#$./0,/1$&2/%#$5,&%'1#,$
177
!
Y1)'+671)'#8[C$1&.4'7#,$Y1)*+23451)-+91)*:;7[C$6.%$1&*1')0',#$%#41,/(#%$64$1&*1')0',#$Q$
178
!
Y"#,#6-0#,$,#-#,,#%$0&$64$0"#$g1&*1')0',#h[$Yf/+',#$>FCH[:$$
179
!
!&$3#,/-8$0"60$0"#$+,&B0"$&-$0"#$40,6/.4$/.$0"#$1&*1')0',#$B64$%'#$0&$0"#$,#7&36)$&-$AZ$
180
!
-,&7$0"#$5,&%'1#,$(8$0"#$1&.4'7#,C$/.$6$4#56,60#$#25#,/7#.0C$B#$-'.10/&.6))8$,#5)68#%$0"#$
181
!
1&.4'7#,$B/0"$0"#$1"#7/16)$AZ$4163#.+#,C$1*J!IZC$+,&B/.+$0"#$AZ$5,&%'1#,$40,6/.$6)&.#$/.$/04$
182
!
5,#4#.1#$&,$6(4#.1#:$I.$/04$6(4#.1#C$0"#$5,&%'1#,$-6/)#%$0&$+,&BC$1&.4/40#.0$B/0"$0"#$/."/(/0&,8$
183
!
#--#10$&-$AZ$611'7')60/&.:$b&B#3#,C$0"#$6%%/0/&.$&-$1*J!IZ$,#40&,#%$+,&B0"C$4'55&,0/.+$0"#$
184
!
/.0#,5,#060/&.$0"60$AZ$,#%'10/&.$%,/3#4$+,&B0"$/.$0"#$1&*1')0',#$Yf/+',#$>?[:$
185
!
'$
186
!
Single'cell'intermixing'under'planktonic'and'sessile'anoxic'conditions'suggests'NO'
187
!
cross?feeding'is'mutually'beneficial'and'proximity'dependent.$
188
!
F#16'4#$&',$5)6.V0&./1$+,&B0"$#25#,/7#.04$4'++#40#%$0"#,#$/4$6$.#0$1&77'./08$(#.#-/0$
189
!
0&$40,6/.4$/.$1&*1')0',#$B/0"$6$56,0/0/&.#%$%#./0,/-/160/&.$560"B68$'.%#,$6.&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4$Yf/+',#$
190
!
>H[C$B#$.#20$4&'+"0$0&$%#0#,7/.#$B"#0"#,$0"/4$,#-)#10#%$6$7'0'6)$&,$1&77#.46)$,#)60/&.4"/5:$!&$
191
!
6%%,#44$0"/4C$B#$1&*1')0',#%$6.%$/76+#%$40,6/.4$#25,#44/.+$1&.40/0'0/3#$-)'&,#41#.1#$76,V#,4$
192
!
YNfJ$&,$7<55)#[$6-0#,$D$%684$&-$+,&B0":$J&5')60/&.$,60/&4$/.%/160#%$0"60$(&0"$40,6/.4$+,#B$/.$0"#$
193
!
1&*1')0',#4$B/0"$0"#$5,&%'1#,$"63/.+$6$4)/+"0$6%36.06+#$)/V#)8$%'#$0&$/04$6(/)/08$0&$1&.0/.'#$
194
!
,#%'1/.+$./0,60#$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$D<[:$;B655/.+$0"#$-)'&,#41#.0$5,&0#/.4$(#0B##.$40,6/.4$%/%$
195
!
.&0$1"6.+#$0"/4$&'01&7#C$/.%/160/.+$0"60$0"/4$#--#10$/4$45#1/-/1$0&$0"#$%#./0,/-/160/&.$#--#104$6.%$
196
!
.&0$6.$6,0#-610$&-$NfJ$&,$7<55)#$#25,#44/&.:$!"#4#$,#4')04$4'++#40$0"60$0"/4$1,&44*-##%/.+$
197
!
/.0#,610/&.$/4$7'0'6)$Y0"#$5,&%'1#,$6.%$0"#$1&.4'7#,$,#5,#4#.0$655,&2/760#)8$"6)-$&-$0"#$0&06)$
198
!
5&5')60/&.[$/.$B"/1"$0"#$"6,7$&-$AZ$0&$0"#$5,&%'1#,$/4$6))#3/60#%$(8$0"#$1&.4'7#,C$B"/1"C$/.$
199
!
0',.C$+6/.4$6.$#)#10,&.$611#50&,`$0&+#0"#,C$0"#$560"B68$16.$5,&1##%:$$
200
!
F'/)%/.+$&.$0"#4#$,#4')04C$B#$B&.%#,#%$"&B$4560/6)$40,'10',#$7/+"0$/.-)'#.1#$0"#$+,&B0"$
201
!
&-$0"#$5,&%'1#,$6.%$1&.4'7#,$+/3#.$0"60$AZ$/4$6$"/+")8$,#610/3#$6.%$%/--'4/()#$7&)#1')#:$=#$
202
!
"85&0"#4/9#%$0"60C$'.)/V#$'.%#,$4"6V#.$5)6.V0&./1$+,&B0"$1&.%/0/&.4$/.$B"/1"$0"#$B"&)#$
203
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
7!
5&5')60/&.$(#.#-/0#%C$'.%#,$4560/6))8$1&.40,6/.#%$6.&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4C$5,&2/7/08$B&')%$%#0#,7/.#$
204
!
0"#$4'11#44$&-$1&77'./08$7#7(#,4:$!&$0#40$0"/4$5,#%/10/&.C$B#$7/2#%$-)'&,#41#.0)8$)6(#)#%$1#))4$
205
!
&-$0"#$467#$&,$%/--#,/.+$+#.&085#4$/.$#^'6)$,60/&4C$6.%$0"#.$%/)'0#%$0"#$1')0',#4$6.%$46.%B/1"#%$
206
!
0"#7$(#0B##.$6$1&3#,4)/5$6.%$6$./0,60#*4'55)#7#.0#%$6+6,$7#%/'7$56%$4'1"$0"60$4/.+)#$1#))4$
207
!
B#,#$,6.%&7)8$%/40,/('0#%$-,&7$&.#$0&$%&9#.4$&-$1#))$)#.+0"4$-,&7$#61"$&0"#,:$f,&7$0"#4#$
208
!
406,0/.+$5&4/0/&.4C$4/.+)#$1#))4$1&')%$%#3#)&5$/.0&$6++,#+60#$(/&-/)74$&3#,$6$Q_*"&',$5#,/&%:$
209
!
f/+',#$D<$+,65"/16))8$,#5,#4#.04$0"#$40,6/.$7/20',#4$4"&B.$/.$56.#)$F$64$B#))$64$0"#/,$5,#%/10#%$
210
!
/.0#,610/&.4$(64#%$&.$0"#$,#4')04$&-$&',$5)6.V0&./1$+,&B0"$#25#,/7#.04:$<4$1&.0,&)4C$B#$7/2#%$
211
!
=!$B/0"$=!$0&$#25)&,#$"&B$0B&$1#))4$B/0"$0"#$-'))$560"B68$6.%$.&$+,&B0"$%#-#104$B&')%$/.0#,610$
212
!
'.%#,$0"#4#$1&.%/0/&.4C$64$B#))$64$0"#$1&.4'7#,$6.%$5,&%'1#,$40,6/.4$B/0"$0"#74#)3#4:$f/.6))8C$
213
!
0"#$5,&%'1#,$6.%$1&.4'7#,$40,6/.4$B#,#$7/2#%$0&$3/4'6)/9#$0"#/,$/.0#,610/&.:$
214
!
!"#$0B&$40,6/.4$YNfJc7<55)#[$/.$0"#$=!$7/20',#$+,#B$64$)6,+#$1)&.6)$#256.4/&.4$B/0"$
215
!
)/00)#$4/.+)#$1#))$/.0#,7/2/.+C$/.%/160/.+$.#/0"#,$40,6/.$B64$/75610#%$(8$0"#$&0"#,$YH/116,#4#$#0$6):C$
216
!
DODO`$=#/.40#/.$#0$6):C$DO>R[:$I.$1&.0,640C$0"#$1&.4'7#,$7/20',#$4"&B#%$6$%,6760/1$,#%'10/&.$/.$
217
!
+,&B0"$1&756,#%$0&$=!C$/.$)/.#$B/0"$0"#$/.6(/)/08$&-$0"#4#$40,6/.4$0&$,#%'1#$./0,60#C$6$0#,7/.6)$
218
!
#)#10,&.$611#50&,:$!"#$5,&%'1#,$7/20',#C$)/V#$0"#$1&.4'7#,$7/20',#C$4"&B#%$6$76,V#%$,#%'10/&.$
219
!
/.$/.%/3/%'6)$6++,#+60#$+,&B0"C$('0$6)4&$6$,#%'10/&.$/.$0&06)$6++,#+60#4$&3#,6)):$=#$/.-#,$0"60$0"#$
220
!
5,&%'1#,$40,6/.$)/V#)8$B64$/."/(/0#%$-&,$+,&B0"$('0$7/+"0$6)4&$"63#$(##.$'.%#,+&/.+$)84/4:$I-$B#$
221
!
1&756,#$0"#$=!$Yf/+',#$DH[$6.%$1&*1')0',#$Yf/+',#$D?[$'.%#,$0"#4#$1&.%/0/&.4C$7&40$40,/V/.+)8$
222
!
B#$&(4#,3#$6.$/.1,#64#$/.$4/.+)#$1#))$/.0#,7/2/.+$(#0B##.$0"#$0B&$40,6/.4$-&,$0"#$1&*1')0',#:$!"#$
223
!
0B&$=!$40,6/.4$YNfJc7<55)#[$655#6,$0&$+,&B$64$1)&.6)$#256.4/&.4C$5'4"/.+$6+6/.40$&.#$
224
!
6.&0"#,$,60"#,$0"6.$&50/7/9/.+$1#))*1#))$1&.0610:$H&.3#,4#)8C$0"#$1&*1')0',#C$6)0"&'+"$4/+./-/16.0)8$
225
!
)#44$%#.4#$0"6.$0"#$=!$7/20',#C$655#6,4$0&$-63&,$1#))*1#))$1&.0610$(#0B##.$40,6/.4$6.%$-&,7$
226
!
7/2#%$6++,#+60#4C$4'++#40/3#$&-$6$7'0'6)$,#)/6.1#$&.$#61"$&0"#,$-&,$1&.0/.'#%$+,&B0":$!"#4#$
227
!
7/2#%$6++,#+60#4$B#,#$)/V#)8$0"#$,#4')0$&-$1)&4#$406,0/.+$5&4/0/&.4$&-$5,&%'1#,$6.%$1&.4'7#,$
228
!
1#))4$,#)60/3#$0&$&.#$6.&0"#,:$
229
!
I.$6%%/0/&.$0&$/.0#,7/2#%$1&*1')0',#$6++,#+60#4C$B#$6)4&$&(4#,3#%$6$%/--#,#.1#$/.$0&06)$
230
!
/%#.0/-/6()#$6++,#+60#4$(#0B##.$4/.+)#$+#.&085#$7/20',#4$6.%$0"#$1&*1')0',#:$=#$&(4#,3#%$-#B$
231
!
5,&%'1#,*&.)8$6++,#+60#4$B"#.$+,&B.$6)&.#$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$DF[C$)/V#)8$%'#$0&$+,&B0"$
232
!
/."/(/0/&.$&,$0&2/1/08$&-$AZ:$b&B#3#,C$B"#.$+,&B.$/.$1&*1')0',#C$B#$&(4#,3#%$6.$/.1,#64#$/.$
233
!
5,&%'1#,$6++,#+60#$1&'.0$61,&44$4#3#,6)$-/#)%4$&-$3/#B$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$DF[:$="/)#$
234
!
1&.4'7#,*&.)8$6++,#+60#4$B#,#$/./0/6))8$7&,#$.'7#,&'4$0"6.$5,&%'1#,*&.)8$6++,#+60#4$
235
!
Y1&756,#$;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$DH$gH&.h$B/0"$DF$gJ,&h[C$B#$-&'.%$0"60$1&*1')0',#$B/0"$0"#$
236
!
5,&%'1#,$40,6/.$/.1,#64#%$0"#$36,/6(/)/08$&-$1&.4'7#,$6++,#+60#$1&'.0$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$DH[:$
237
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
8!
I75&,06.0)8C$,#%'10/&.$/.$0&06)$6++,#+60#4$B64$&(4#,3#%$&B/.+$0&$-/#)%4$&-$3/#B$/.$B"/1"$&.)8$&.#$
238
!
/.0#,7/2#%$1&*1')0',#$6++,#+60#$B64$5,#4#.0:$!"#4#$,#4')04$4'++#40$0"60$B"/)#$4/.+)#$1#))$
239
!
/.0#,7/2/.+$16.$&11',$B"#.$0"#$0B&$40,6/.4$6,#$4##%#%$60$1)&4#$/./0/6)$406,0/.+$5&4/0/&.4$Yf/+',#$
240
!
D?[C$AZ$768$6)4&$%/--'4#$&'0B6,%$-,&7$5,&%'1#,$1#))$6++,#+60#4$0&$,#61"$1&.4'7#,$1#))4$60$
241
!
-',0"#,$%/406.1#4C$0"#,#(8$/.1,#64/.+$0"#$/.0#,610/&.$,6.+#:$$!&+#0"#,C$0"#4#$,#4')04$#20#.%$&',$
242
!
5)6.V0&./1$+,&B0"$&(4#,360/&.4$/.0&$6$4560/6)$1&.0#20C$,#3#6)/.+$"&B$1&77'./08$7#7(#,4$B/0"$6$
243
!
56,0/0/&.#%$%#./0,/-/160/&.$560"B68$16.$/.0#,610$'.%#,$6.&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4$B"#,#$AZ$16.$%/--'4#:$
244
!
$$
245
!
Oxygen'availability'induces'synthetic'community'interaction'and'dials'it'from'a'
246
!
mutualistic'(anoxic)'to'commensal'(hyp(oxic))'interaction'by'increasing'NO'toxicity.$
247
!
a#1&+./9/.+$0"60$76.8$#.3/,&.7#.04$B"#,#$%#./0,/-/160/&.$&11',4$#25#,/#.1#$36,/6()#$
248
!
67&'.04$&-$&28+#.C$B#$B&.%#,#%$B"60$B&')%$"655#.$0&$AZ$,#610/3/08$6.%$/.$0"#$5,#4#.1#$&-$
249
!
&28+#.:$;0,6/.4$4'1"$64$J<>Q$6,#$-61')060/3#$6.6#,&(#4C$7#6./.+$0"#8$5,#-#,#.0/6))8$,#45/,#$
250
!
&28+#.$B"#.$/0$/4$636/)6()#$Y&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4[C$('0$B"#.$&28+#.$/4$)/7/0#%C$0"#8$/.%'1#$560"B684$
251
!
Y4'1"$64$0"#$%#./0,/-/160/&.$560"B68[$0"60$5#,7/0$#.#,+8$1&.4#,360/&.$'4/.+$6)0#,.60/3#$#)#10,&.$
252
!
611#50&,4:$<$1)644/1$#2675)#$&-$0"/4$5"#.&7#.&.$/4$B"#.$1#))4$+,&B$5)6.V0&./16))8$('0$6,#$.&0$
253
!
4"6V#.$%',/.+$+,&B0":$H#))4$60$0"#$4',-61#$&-$0"#$7#%/'7$,#%'1#$&28+#.$-640#,$0"6.$/0$16.$
254
!
%/--'4#$/.0&$0"#$7#%/'7C$,#4')0/.+$/.$6.$&28+#.$+,6%/#.0$YJ,/1#*="#)6.$#0$6):C$DOOR[:$!&$#256.%$
255
!
&',$'.%#,406.%/.+$&-$B"#.C$B"#,#$6.%$"&B$AZ*1,&44$-##%/.+$&5#,60#4C$B#$#25)&/0#%$0"/4$
256
!
5"#.&7#.&.$6.%$7#64',#%$+,&B0"$/.$4"6V/.+$&,$406.%/.+$g&2/1h$1')0',#4:$=#$"85&0"#4/9#%$
257
!
40,6/.4$"6,(&,/.+$6$56,0/0/&.#%$%#./0,/-/160/&.$560"B68$B&')%$#2"/(/0$%/--#,#.0$(#"63/&,4$
258
!
%#5#.%/.+$&.$0"#$67&'.0$&-$&28+#.$6.%$./0,60#$5,#4#.0C$/.$6$76..#,$,#-)#10/.+$0"#$
259
!
6+60"&V6V&)&+/16)$#--#104$&-$&28+#.$6.%$AZ$&.$1#))4:$
260
!
!&$0#40$0"/4$"85&0"#4/4C$B#$0,61V#%$0"#$+,&B0"$&-$%/--#,#.0$5,&%'1#,$6.%$1&.4'7#,$
261
!
40,6/.4C$6)&.#$6.%$/.$1&7(/.60/&.C$&3#,$Q_*"&',4$/.$6$1&.0/.'&'4)8$4"6V/.+$5)60#$,#6%#,$0&$
262
!
5,#3#.0$6.$&28+#.$+,6%/#.0$-,&7$-&,7/.+:$I.$0"#$6(4#.1#$&-$./0,60#$6))$40,6/.4$+,#B$4/7/)6,)8C$64$
263
!
#25#10#%C$/.%/160/.+$0"#$+#.#0/1$7&%/-/160/&.4$"6%$.&$&--*06,+#0$#--#104$Yf/+',#$U<[:$H&.3#,4#)8C$
264
!
B"#.$B#$6%%#%$M$7P$./0,60#$0&$0"#$7#%/'7C$0"#$1&.4'7#,$40,6/.$4)/+"0)8$%#1,#64#%$/04$+,&B0"$
265
!
1&756,#%$0&$0"#$=!$6.%$0"#$5,&%'1#,$40,6/.4$%/45)68#%$6$(,/#-$+,&B0"$6,,#40$7/%B68$0",&'+"$
266
!
#25&.#.0/6)$5"64#C$B/0"$+,&B0"$0"#.$56,6))#)/.+$0"60$4##.$-&,$0"#$=!$&,$7/2#%$5,&%'1#,$o$
267
!
1&.4'7#,$1')0',#4$Yf/+',#$UF[:$?#45/0#$1&.0/.'&'4$4"6V/.+C$60$0"#4#$1#))$%#.4/0/#4C$B#$4',7/4#$
268
!
-,&7$5,/&,$B&,V$0"60$0"#4#$40,6/.4$(#+6.$0&$#25#,/#.1#$&28+#.*)/7/060/&.$%',/.+$7/%$#25&.#.0/6)$
269
!
5"64#$YJ,/1#*="#)6.$#0$6):C$DOOR[:$
270
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
9!
!&$/.%'1#$"85&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4$/.$6$B68$0"60$&28+#.$1&.1#.0,60/&.$1&')%$(#$7#64',#%C$B#$
271
!
5#,-&,7#%$0"#$467#$+,&B0"$#25#,/7#.0$/.$6$5)60#$,#6%#,$B/0"&'0$4"6V/.+C$0"'4$/.%'1/.+$6.$
272
!
&28+#.$+,6%/#.0:$<+6/.C$/.$0"#$6(4#.1#$&-$./0,60#$B#$%/%$.&0$4##$6$%/--#,#.1#$(#0B##.$0"#$
273
!
40,6/.4$Yf/+',#$UH[:$b&B#3#,C$/.$0"#$5,#4#.1#$&-$./0,60#C$+,&B0"$&-$0"#$5,&%'1#,$6.%$1&.4'7#,$
274
!
/.%/3/%'6))8$4)&B#%$1&756,#%$0&$0"#$=!$('0$B64$,#41'#%$/.$1&*1')0',#$Yf/+',#$U?[:$I75&,06.0)8C$
275
!
#3#.$B/0"&'0$0"#$6(/)/08$0&$,#%'1#$./0,60#C$0"#$1&.4'7#,$B64$6()#$0&$,#61"$0"#$467#$-/.6)$Z?$64$
276
!
=!C$4'++#40/.+$0"60$B"/)#$/04$+,&B0"$B64$4)&B#%C$/0$B64$6()#$0&$&3#,1&7#$/04$/.6(/)/08$0&$'0/)/9#$
277
!
./0,60#$64$6$0#,7/.6)$#)#10,&.$611#50&,$'.%#,$0"#4#$1&.%/0/&.4:$H&.3#,4#)8C$0"#$5,&%'1#,$
278
!
40,6/.Y4[$4"&B#%$6$%,6760/1$%#1,#64#$/.$Z?$)60#,$/.$0"#$+,&B0"$1',3#C$4'++#40/3#$&-$1#))$)84/4:$
279
!
!&$36)/%60#$0"60$6.$&28+#.$+,6%/#.0$"6%$-&,7#%$&3#,$0/7#C$B#$'4#%$7/1,&#)#10,&%#4$0&$5,&-/)#$
280
!
&2+8#.$1&.1#.0,60/&.4$0",&'+"&'0$0"#$%#50"$&-$406.%/.+$1')0',#4$-&,$(&0"$=!$6.%$0"#$1&*1')0',#$
281
!
Yf/+',#$UG[:$$
282
!
AZ$B/))$,#6%/)8$,#610$B/0"$4'5#,&2/%#$YZD*[$0&$-&,7$0"#$,#610/3#$./0,&+#.$45#1/#4C$
283
!
5#,&28./0,/0#$YZAZZ*[:$ZD*$/4$6$(8*5,&%'10$6.%$/.0#,7#%/60#$&-$&28+#.$,#45/,60/&.$B"/1"$/4$
284
!
,#7&3#%$(8$4'5#,&2/%#$%/47'064#$Y;Z?[C$6.%$ZAZZ*$16.$&'0$1&75#0#$4'5#,&2/%#$-&,$;Z?$
285
!
)#6%/.+$0&$6.$611'7')60/&.$&-$,#610/3#$&28+#.$45#1/#4$6.%$&2/%60/3#$40,#44$YF,'.#))/$#0$6):C$
286
!
>LLM[:$!"'4C$B#$,#64&.#%$0"60$0"#$)84/4$B#$&(4#,3#%$'.%#,$"85&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4$7/+"0$(#$
287
!
1&,,#)60#%$B/0"$6.$/.1,#64#%$5,&%'10/&.$&-$4'5#,&2/%#:$!&$0#40$0"/4$/%#6C$B#$'4#%$6.$/.0,61#))')6,$
288
!
AZ$4#.4/0/3#$%8#$Y?<f*D?<C$f/+',#$UN[$6.%$6$4'5#,&2/%#$4#.4/0/3#$%8#$YH#))aZpC$f/+',#$Uf[$0&$
289
!
%#0#10$0"#4#$7#06(&)/0#4:$F&0"$AZ$6.%$4'5#,&2/%#$/.1,#64#%$&3#,$0"#$+,&B0"$1',3#$/.$0"#$
290
!
5,&%'1#,$40,6/.$6)&.#$Yf/+',#$UfCN[C$B/0"$6$,/4#$/.$4/+.6)$6,&'.%$UO$"&',4C$1&,,#)60/.+$B/0"$0"#$
291
!
%,&5$/.$Z?$Yf/+',#$U?C$6,,&B4C$g)84/4h[:$$
292
!
'$
293
!
Differences'in'the'transcriptional'regulation'of'nitrate'reductases'leads'to'spatiotemporal'
294
!
control'of'NO'production'during'aggregate'biofilm'development.'$
295
!
F64#%$&.$0"#$&(4#,360/&.$0"60$0"#$5,&%'1#,e4$+,&B0"$6.%$4#)-*0&2/1/08$B64$1&,,#)60#%$B/0"$
296
!
&28+#.$636/)6(/)/08C$6.%$(#16'4#$&28+#.$+,6%/#.04$)/V#$0"&4#$4##.$/.$406.%/.+$1')0',#4$Yf/+',#$
297
!
UG[$,#6%/)8$-&,7$/.$(/&-/)7$1&.0#204$Y<,4"6%$#0$6):C$DO>Q`$;5#,&$6.%$A#B76.C$DO>_`$;0#B6,0$#0$
298
!
6):C$DO>T[C$B#$.#20$4&'+"0$0&$3/4'6)/9#$)84/4$64$6$4560/6)$5,&28$-&,$AZ$5,&%'10/&.:$!&$61"/#3#$
299
!
0"/4C$B#$+,#B$%/)'0#%$1#))4$&.$6+6,$56%4$'.%#,$&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4$0&$-&,7$6++,#+60#$(/&-/)74C$
300
!
-&1'4/.+$&.)8$&.$AZ$5,&%'1/.+$1#))4:$a#16))/.+$0"60$0"#$4'(40,60#$-&,$0"#$./0,/0#$,#%'1064#$0"60$
301
!
5,&%'1#4$AZ$16.$(#$+#.#,60#%$(8$(&0"$A65$6.%$A6,C$B#$1&756,#%$0B&$%/--#,#.0$5,&%'1#,$
302
!
40,6/.4C$&.#$0"60$1&.06/.#%$(&0"$A65$6.%$A6,$6.%$&.#$0"60$&.)8$1&.06/.#%$A6,$Yf/+',#$Q<[:$
303
!
F#16'4#$)*:$6.%$)*+$+#.#4$6,#$,#+')60#%$(8$%/--#,#.0$0,6.41,/50/&.$-610&,4S$)*:$(8$a5&;$
304
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
10!
Y4060/&.6,8$5"64#c^'&,'7$4#.4/.+[$Y;1"'40#,$#0$6):C$DOOQ[$6.%$)*+$(8$<Aa$Y./0,60#$6.%$)&B$
305
!
&28+#.[$Y<,6/C$DO>>[C$B#$"85&0"#4/9#%$0"60$AZ$5,&%'10/&.$/.$6++,#+60#$(/&-/)7$7/+"0$(#$6$
306
!
%/--#,#.0/6)$4560/6)$%/40,/('0#%$64$6$-'.10/&.$&-$0"#$40,6/.e4$+#.&7/1$1&.0#.0$6.%$0"'4$
307
!
0,6.41,/50/&.6)$,#+')60/&.:$
308
!
I.&1')60#%$6+6,$56%4$B#,#$5,#*/.1'(60#%$60$URqH$'.%#,$&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4$-&,$>_$"&',4$0&$
309
!
#.6()#$6++,#+60#$(/&-/)7$%#3#)&57#.0$6-0#,$B"/1"$B#$5#,-&,7#%$0/7#$)654#$/76+/.+$60$URqH$0&$
310
!
0,61V$4'(4#^'#.0$+,&B0"$6.%$)84/4:$!"#$5,&%'1#,$1&.06/./.+$(&0"$A65$6.%$A6,$+,#B$/.0&$&3#,6))$
311
!
476))#,$6++,#+60#$(/&-/)74$1&756,#%$0&$0"#$5,&%'1#,$1&.06/./.+$A6,$&.)8$(#-&,#$'.%#,+&/.+$6$
312
!
B63#$&-$)84/4$406,0/.+$60$0"#$5#,/5"#,8$6.%$7&3/.+$/.B6,%$Yf/+',#$QF[:$b/+"$76+./-/160/&.$3/#B4$
313
!
&-$)84/4$/))'40,60#$0"60$1#))4$.&$)&.+#,$655#6,$()61V$'.%#,$5"64#$6.%$.&$)&.+#,$1&.06/.$
314
!
-)'&,#41#.1#$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$Q<[:$I0$/4$5&44/()#$0"60$0"#$5600#,.$&-$)84/4$&(4#,3#%$/.$0"#$
315
!
(/&-/)74$,#-)#104$,#)60/3#)8$7&,#$AZ$(#/.+$76%#$(8$5#,/5"#,6)$1#))4$0"60$"63#$+,#60#,$611#44$0&$
316
!
&28+#.$6.%$.'0,/#.04$Y;7,/+6$#0$6):C$DOD>[`$(8$0"#$467#$0&V#.C$0"#4#$1#))4$6,#$0"#$-/,40$0&$
317
!
#25#,/#.1#$AZ*/.%'1#%$0&2/1/08$6.%$%/#:$!&$0#40$0"/4$/%#6C$B#$'4#%$0"#$&2/%60/3#$40,#44$
318
!
-)'&,#41#.0$5,&(#C$H#))aZp$&.$4/7/)6,$(/&-/)74$Y1&.06/./.+$(&0"$A65$6.%$A6,[$0&$3/4'6)/9#$)&16)$
319
!
0&2/1/08$/.$,#)60/&.$0&$1#))$)84/4:$!"&'+"$&',$5)6.V0&./1$#25#,/7#.04$4'11#44-'))8$%&1'7#.0#%$6$
320
!
1&,,#)60/&.$(#0B##.$4'5#,&2/%#$6.%$AZ$5,&%'10/&.$B/0"$-)'&,#41#.0$5,&(#4$Yf/+:$UfC$UN[C$0"#$
321
!
AZ$5,&(#$B64$0&&$%/7$0&$^'6.0/-8$,#)60/3#$0&$0"#$6'0&-)'&,#41#.0$(61V+,&'.%C$0"'4$4'5#,&2/%#$
322
!
%#0#10/&.$/4$&',$5,&28$-&,$AZ:$=#$&(4#,3#%$6$40,&.+$1&,,#)60/&.$(#0B##.$H#))aZp$/.0#.4/08$
323
!
5600#,.4$6.%$)84/4C$,#/.-&,1/.+$0"60$&2/%60/3#$40,#44$(#+/.4$60$0"#$5#,/5"#,8$6.%$7&3#4$0&B6,%4$
324
!
0"#$1#.0#,$64$)84/4$5,&+,#44#4$Yf/+:$Q?C$QG[:$;'1"$5#,/5"#,6)$%#60"$B&')%$1&))654#$6.$&28+#.$
325
!
+,6%/#.0C$,#4')0/.+$/.$6$)84/4$16416%#$64$%##5#,$1#))4$1&.0/.'#$0&$5,&%'1#$AZ$.&B$/.$0"#$
326
!
5,#4#.1#$&-$7&,#$&28+#.$'.0/)$6))$1#))4$"63#$)84#%:$$
327
!
H&.3#,4#)8C$0"#$5,&%'1#,$0"60$&.)8$1&.06/.4$A6,$/./0/6))8$%#3#)&54$/.0&$)6,+#$6++,#+60#$
328
!
(/&-/)74C$)/V#)8$%'#$0&$)/00)#$AZ$5,&%'10/&.$'.0/)$A6,$/4$610/360#%$/.$,#45&.4#$0&$)&B$&28+#.$/.$0"#$
329
!
/.0#,/&,$6.%$0"#$5,#4#.1#$&-$./0,60#C$)#6%/.+$0&$/.0#,.6)$AZ$5,&%'10/&.$6.%$)84/4$Yf/+',#$QH[:$
330
!
I.0#,#40/.+)8C$B"#.$B#$1&756,#%$H#))aZp$406/./.+$&-$0",##$%/--#,#.0$5,&%'1#,$YA6,[$(/&-/)74$60$
331
!
%/--#,#.0$406+#4$&-$)84/4C$B#$6)4&$46B$6$%,6760/1$/.1,#64#$/.$406/./.+$0"60$406,0#%$1#.0,6))8$6.%$
332
!
B&,V#%$/04$B68$&'0B6,%:$!"#4#$,#4')04$+/3#$1,#%#.1#$0&$&',$7&%#)C$('0$6)4&$/.%/160#$0"60$)84/4$60$
333
!
0"#$5#,/7#0#,$&,$1&,#$6,#$(&0"$%'#$0&$&2/%60/3#$40,#44:$!"/4$1&')%$#/0"#,$(#$%'#$0&$0,61#$&28+#.$
334
!
(#/.+$5,#4#.0$/.$0"#$1&,#$/./0/6))8C$6))&B/.+$4'5#,&2/%#$5,&%'10/&.C$&,$6.&2/1$AZ$('/)%'5$
335
!
/."/(/0/.+$7#06(&)/47C$0"#,#(8$16'4/.+$6$1&))654#$&-$0"#$&28+#.$+,6%/#.0:$$
336
!
'$
337
!
Microenvironmental'control'of'NO'cross?feeding'leads'to'predictable'spatial'patterns.'$
338
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
11!
!&$3/4'6)/9#$%8.67/1$/.0#,610/&.4$(#0B##.$AZ$5,&%'1#,4$6.%$1&.4'7#,4C$B#$6+6/.$
339
!
7/2#%$0"#$40,6/.4$B/0"$0"#74#)3#4$&,$#61"$&0"#,$6.%$/.1'(60#%$0"#7$'.%#,$&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4$&.$
340
!
.'0,/#.0$6+6,$56%4$1&.06/./.+$./0,60#:$<-0#,$DQ$"&',4$&-$+,&B0"C$B#$&(4#,3#%$0"60$=!C$)/V#$'.%#,$
341
!
6.&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4C$+,#B$/.0&$6++,#+60#$(/&-/)74C$('0$,60"#,$0"6.$64$7&.&)68#,4C$0"#4#$(/&-/)74$
342
!
655#6,#%$0"/1V#,C$5#,"654$%'#$0&$0"#$6(/)/08$0&$4'55&,0$&2/1$6.%$6.&2/1$+,&B0"$Yf/+',#$M<[:$!"#$
343
!
1&.4'7#,$7/20',#$6)4&$+,#B$/.0&$)6,+#$6++,#+60#$(/&-/)74$Y7'1"$)6,+#,$0"6.$'.%#,$6.&2/1$
344
!
1&.%/0/&.4$%'#$0&$/04$611#44$0&$&28+#.$64$6$!G<[C$0"&'+"$0"#$#256.4/&.4$B#,#$.&0$64$%#.4#$
345
!
%'#$0&$0"#$/.6(/)/08$0&$4'55&,0$6.&2/1$+,&B0"$B/0"$./0,60#$Yf/+',#$M<[:$!"#$5,&%'1#,$&.)8$7/20',#$
346
!
6+6/.$4"&B#%$)84/4$Yf/+',#$M<[:$;0,/V/.+)8C$0"#$(&,%#,$(#0B##.$0"#$0"#$5,&%'1#,$6.%$1&.4'7#,$
347
!
/.$1&*1')0',#$B64$%,6760/16))8$%/--#,#.0:$$
348
!
<4$4##.$'.%#,$6.&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4$Yf/+',#$DH[C$=!$40,6/.4$4"&B#%$.&$/.0#,7/2/.+C$
349
!
4'++#40/3#$&-$.&$/.0#,610/&.c6%36.06+#$&,$,#)/6.1#$&.$#61"$&0"#,$Yf/+',#$MF[:$!"#$1&*1')0',#C$
350
!
"&B#3#,C$4"&B#%$)84/4$&-$5,&%'1#,$1#))4$B"#.$.&0$/.$5,&2/7/08$0&$1&.4'7#,$1#))4$6.%$6.$
351
!
/.1,#64#$/.$4/.+)#$1#))$/.0#,7/2/.+$Yf/+',#$MH[:$!"/4$4'++#404$0"60$-,&7$0"#$(#+/../.+C$0"#$1&*
352
!
1')0',#$4/.+)#$1#))4$+,#B$/.0&$1)&.6)$#256.4/&.4C$.&0$/.0#,610/.+$'.0/)$0"#$7/1,&#.3/,&.7#.0$B64$
353
!
7#06(&)/16))8$6)0#,#%$Y%#5)#0/&.$&-$&28+#.C$(#+/../.+$'0/)/960/&.$&-$./0,60#[`$0"#$5,&%'1#,$(#+6.$
354
!
0&$)84#$&.$/04$&B.C$('0$B"#.$/.$5,&2/7/08$0&$6$1&.4'7#,C$B64$,#)/#3#%$&-$AZ$0&2/1/08:$$I.$&0"#,$
355
!
B&,%4C$&3#,$0/7#C$7#06(&)/1$%8.67/14$'.)&1V$6$4560/6)$./1"#$B"#,#$1,&44*-##%/.+$5,&3/%#4$6$
356
!
4#)#10/3#$6%36.06+#:$;'1"$5,&0#10/&.$76./-#40#%$/.$4#3#,6)$B684$Yf/+',#$M?[S$4&7#$5,&%'1#,$
357
!
1#))4$655#6,#%$0&$1)/.+$0&$0"#$1&.4'7#,$1#))4C$-&))&B/.+$0"#/,$1&.0&',`$&0"#,$5,&%'1#,$1#))4$
358
!
655#6,#%$0&$(#$5,&0#10#%$(8$6$5&1V#0$-&,7#%$(8$1&.4'7#,$1#))4`$6.%$40/))$&0"#,4$B#,#$5,&0#10#%$
359
!
(8$,#+/&.4$&-$"/+"$/.0#,7/2/.+:$@.&B/.+$0"60$0"#$5,&%'1#,$1#))4$B&')%$)84#$B/0"&'0$)&16)$AZ$
360
!
%#5)#0/&.$Yf/+',#$Q[$5#,7/04$'4$0&$)/.V$1#))')6,$4560/6)$6,,6.+#7#.0$0&$5"84/&)&+/16)$610/3/08:$!&$
361
!
-',0"#,$0#40$0"/4$/.0#,5,#060/&.C$B#$4#0$'5$6%%/0/&.6)$56%4$B/0"$0"#$1&*1')0',#C$5,#*/.1'(60/.+$0"#7$
362
!
'.0/)$l'40$(#-&,#$0"#$5,&%'1#,$4"&B#%$)84/4C$6.%$,#1&,%/.+$0"#$1#))')6,$%8.67/14$&3#,$0/7#:$<4$
363
!
5,#%/10#%C$0"#$5,&%'1#,$YA65cA6,[$1#))4$)84#%`$"&B#3#,C$'.)/V#$B"#.$+,&B.$6)&.#$B"#,#$)84/4$
364
!
(#+6.$60$0"#$5#,/5"#,8$Y1&756,#$0&$f/+',#$QF[C$0"#$5,&%'1#,$/.$0"#$1&*1')0',#$#25#,/7#.0$
365
!
4"&B#%$)84/4$(#+/../.+$4#3#,6)$1#))$)#.+0"4$-,&7$0"#$5#,/5"#,8$B"#.$/.$1)&4#$5,&2/7/08$0&$
366
!
1&.4'7#,$40,6/.4$Yf/+',#$MG[:$$
367
!
I.0#,#40/.+)8C$/.$1&.0,640$0&$7/20',#4$'4/.+$0"#$A65cA6,$5,&%'1#,$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$
368
!
Q<[C$B"#.$0"#$467#$#25#,/7#.0$/4$5#,-&,7#%$'4/.+$0"#$5,&%'1#,$0"60$&.)8$1&.06/.4$A6,C$,#41'#$
369
!
&-$0"#$5,&%'1#,$/4$.&0$&(4#,3#%$(8$0"#$1&.4'7#,C$5,#4'76()8$%'#$0&$AZ$&.)8$(#/.+$+#.#,60#%$
370
!
/.$0"#$(/&-/)7$1&,#C$0&&$-6,$-,&7$0"#$1&.4'7#,$0&$0,/++#,$6$7'0'6))8*(#.#-/1/6)$/.0#,610/&.$
371
!
Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$QF[:$!"#4#$,#4')04$4'++#40$6$7&%#)$/.$B"/1"$/./0/6))8$0"#$0B&$40,6/.4$%&$.&0$
372
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
12!
/.0#,610$(#16'4#$0"#8$"63#$-'))$611#44$0&$&28+#.$6.%$%&$.&0$8#0$.##%$./0,60#:$b&B#3#,C$64$0"#8$
373
!
+,&B$)6,+#,$6.%$6.$&28+#.$+,6%/#.0$-&,74$/.$0"#$7/1,&#.3/,&.7#.0C$0"#$5,&%'1#,$(#+/.4$
374
!
+#.#,60/.+$AZ$B"/1"$)#6%4$0&$4#)-*)84/4$'.)#44$0"#$5,&%'1#,$/4$5,&2/76)$0&$0"#$1&.4'7#,C$B"/1"$
375
!
,#)/#3#4$0"#$5,&%'1#,e4$4#)-*0&2/1/08$6.%$5,&3/%#4$0"#$1&.4'7#,$6$0#,7/.6)$#)#10,&.$611#50&,$
376
!
Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$QH[:$$
377
!
'$
378
!
Discussion$
379
!
P/1,&(/6)$7#06(&)/47$/4$/.1,#64/.+)8$655,#1/60#%$-&,$/04$1&.0,/('0/&.4$0&$"'76.$6.%$
380
!
#.3/,&.7#.06)$"#6)0"$Yb#40#,$#0$6):C$DO>L`$J&.&76,&36$6.%$J60/)C$DO>M`$\']/+6$#0$6):C$DO>R[C$
381
!
6.%$6B6,#.#44$&-$0"#$%/3#,4/08$&-$7/1,&(/6)$7#06(&)/1$/.0#,610/&.4$/4$#256.%/.+$B/0"$/75,&3#%$
382
!
0#1"./^'#4$-&,$/%#.0/-8/.+$.#B$560"B684$6.%$&(4#,3/.+$/.0#,610/&.4$YH&,%#,&$6.%$?6006C$DO>T`$
383
!
?6,$#0$6):C$DOD>`$?#J64$#0$6):C$DO>T`$J#44/$#0$6):C$DODO`$=/)(#,0$#0$6):C$DODO`$\']/+6$#0$6):C$DO>R[:$
384
!
I.$0"#$-61#$&-$0"/4$5,&+,#44C$+6/./.+$6$(#00#,$'.%#,406.%/.+$&-$"&B$0"#4#$/.0#,610/&.4$768$4"/-0$
385
!
64$6$-'.10/&.$&-$%8.67/1$&28+#.$+,6%/#.04$/4$6.$/75&,06.0$+&6):$=#$%#3#)&5#%$6$48.0"#0/1$
386
!
7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./08$)/.V#%$(8$0"#$#21"6.+#$&-$AZC$6.$6+60"&V6V&)&+/16)$7&)#1')#$B"&4#$
387
!
(/&)&+/16)$#--#104$6,#$0'.#%$(8$0"#$5,#4#.1#$&-$&28+#.C$64$6$40#5$0&B6,%4$0"/4$#.%:$Z',$B&,V$
388
!
4"&B4$0"60$0"#$/.0#,610/&.4$0"60$%,/3#$AZ$/.0#,1#))')6,$#21"6.+#$6.%$,#%'10/&.$6,#$/.%'1#%$6.%$
389
!
4#.4/0/3#$0&$0"#$+#.#0/1$1&.0#.0$&-$1&77'./08$7#7(#,4$6.%$7/1,&#.3/,&.7#.06)$+,6%/#.04C$
390
!
V.&B)#%+#$&-$B"/1"$)#6%4$0&$5,#%/106()#$&,+6./960/&.6)$&'01&7#4:$
391
!
?/--#,#.0/6)$,#+')60/&.$&-$0"#$A6,$6.%$A65$#.987#4C$(&0"$&-$B"/1"$5,&%'1#$./0,/0#C$0"#$
392
!
7#06(&)/1$5,#1',4&,$&-$AZ$/.$0"#$%#./0,/-/160/&.$560"B68C$%/,#10)8$/756104$AZ$5,&%'1#,$6.%$
393
!
1&.4'7#,$/.0#,610/&.4:$A6,$/4$/.%'1#%$'.%#,$6.&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4$6.%$1&.0,/('0#4$0&$#.#,+8$
394
!
1&.4#,360/&.$Y<,6/C$DO>>[$B"#,#64$A65$16.$(#$#25,#44#%$/.$Y"85[&2/1$#.3/,&.7#.04$6.%$
395
!
-61/)/060#4$,#%&2$(6)6.1/.+$YF,&.%/lV$#0$6):C$DOOQ`$N60#4$#0$6):C$DOO_[:$!"#4#$%/--#,#.1#4$/.$
396
!
,#+')60/&.$0"#,#(8$1&.0,&)$AZ$5,&%'10/&.$6.%$,#%'10/&.$61,&44$6$,6.+#$&-$&28+#.$,#+/7#4:$
397
!
d/.V/.+$7#06(&)/1$/.0#,610/&.4$0&$7/1,&416)#$7/1,&(/6)$&,+6./960/&.4$/4$6.$/75&,06.0$6.%$
398
!
/.1,#64/.+)8$655,#1/60#%$+&6)$Yf'",76.C$DOOL`$N,6)V6$#0$6):C$DODO`$@'".4$#0$6):C$DO>M`$P6$6.%$
399
!
H&,%#,&C$DO>_`$J,&10&,$6.%$a#)76.C$DO>R`$=/%%#,$#0$6):C$DO>T[:$!"60$+#.&7/1$1&.0#.0i
400
!
/.1)'%/.+$,#+')60&,8$40,'10',#i4"65#4$7/1,&(/6)$/.0#,610/&.4$/4$.&0$4',5,/4/.+C$8#0$0"#$5&/.0$0"60$
401
!
%/--#,#.0/6)$,#+')60/&.$&-$V#8$40#54$/.$6$56,0/0/&.#%$7#06(&)/1$560"B68$16.$%#0#,7/.#$/.0#,610/&.$
402
!
&'01&7#4$/4$/75&,06.0$0&$V##5$/.$7/.%$B"#.$600#750/.+$0&$'.%#,406.%$6.%$5,#%/10$B"#.$6.%$
403
!
"&B$7#7(#,4$&-$1&75)#2$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./0/#4$768$4560/6))8$644&1/60#:$$
404
!
Z',$-/.%/.+4$45&0)/+"0$)&16)$&28+#.$636/)6(/)/08$-&,$/04$6(/)/08$0&$0'.#$(&0"$0"#$.60',#$6.%$
405
!
.##%$-&,$6$1,&44*-##%/.+$,#)60/&.4"/5:$I.$&',$#2675)#$164#C$AZ$16.$+#.#,60#$0&2/1$(85,&%'104$/.$
406
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
13!
0"#$5,#4#.1#$&-$&28+#.C$)#6%/.+$0&$1#))')6,$+,&B0"$6,,#40:$$X#0$/.$0"#$6(4#.1#$&-$&28+#.C$AZ$16.$
407
!
(#$6$)/-#)/.#C$4#,3/.+$64$6$0#,7/.6)$#)#10,&.$611#50&,$6.%$5,&7&0/.+$#.#,+8$1&.4#,360/&.$6.%$
408
!
+,&B0":$!"#4#$6+60"&V6V&)&+/16)$#--#104$6,#$/75&,06.0$(#16'4#$&28+#.$/4$&-0#.$
409
!
"#0#,&+#.#&'4)8$636/)6()#$/.$.60',6)$4840#74C$#2"/(/0/.+$40##5$#.3/,&.7#.06)$+,6%/#.04$&3#,$
410
!
476))$4560/6)$416)#4$Y@&)5#.$#0$6):C$DO>Q`$@,/1"#)4$#0$6):C$DO>L[:$F#16'4#$&-$0"/4C$&28+#.$
411
!
636/)6(/)/08$/.-)'#.1#4$B"#0"#,$40,6/.4$B/0"$6$(/-',160#%$%#./0,/-/160/&.$560"B68$#2"/(/0$7'0'6)/47$
412
!
Y/.$6.&2/1$#.3/,&.7#.04C$+,&B0"$&-$0"#$AZ$5,&%'1#,$6.%$1&.4'7#,$/4$1&*%#5#.%#.0[$&,$
413
!
1&77#.46)/47$Y/.$Y"85[&2/1$#.3/,&.7#.04C$+,&B0"$&-$0"#$AZ$5,&%'1#,$/4$1&.40,6/.#%$%'#$0&$
414
!
0&2/1/08$/.$0"#$6(4#.1#$&-$0"#$1&.4'7#,C$B"#,#64$0"#$1&.4'7#,$%&#4$.&0$,#)8$&.$AZ$0&$4'55&,0$
415
!
+,&B0"[:$P&,#&3#,C$&28+#.$+,6%/#.04$16.$4"65#$7/1,&(/6)$/.0#,610/&.4$(&0"$/.$5)6.V0&./1$6.%$
416
!
4#44/)#$1&77'./0/#4C$B/0"$0"#$416)#4$&3#,$B"/1"$0"#4#$/.0#,610/&.4$&11',$(#/.+$4#0$(8$0"#$
417
!
5,&2/7/08$&-$/.0#,610/.+$1#))4$6.%$0"#/,$)&16)$7/1,&#.3/,&.7#.0C$B"/1"$0"#8$/.$0',.$6)0#,$/.$4561#$
418
!
6.%$0/7#:$$
419
!
="/)#$&',$B&,V$B/0"$6$B#))*1&.0,&))#%$48.0"#0/1$1&77'./08$6))&B#%$'4$0&$76V#$0"#4#$
420
!
&(4#,360/&.4C$6.$/75&,06.0$.#20$40#5$B/))$(#$0&$%#0#,7/.#$B"#0"#,$7/20',#4$&-$.60',6)$/4&)60#4$
421
!
B/0"$56,0/0/&.#%$7#06(&)/1$560"B684$5)68$(8$0"#$467#$,')#4:$Z',$B&,V$+/3#4$,/4#$0&$0#406()#$
422
!
5,#%/10/&.4$6(&'0$B"#.$6.%$B"#,#$AZ$1,&44*-##%/.+$768$&11',:$f&,$#2675)#C$/0$/4$B#))$
423
!
655,#1/60#%$0"60$AZ$/4$6.$/75&,06.0$/.0#,7#%/60#$45#1/#4$/.$0"#$./0,&+#.$181)#$Y@'85#,4$#0$6):C$
424
!
DO>_[C$B"&4#$0',.&3#,$,60#4$768$%#1/%#$0"#$-60#$&-$4&/)$./0,&+#.$40&,#4:$I.0#,#40/.+)8C$,#1#.0$
425
!
7#06+#.&7/1$40'%/#4$/.%/160#$0"60$B/0"/.$1#,06/.$"6(/0604C$0"#,#$6.$#.,/1"7#.0$-&,$&,+6./474$
426
!
0"60$16.$&.)8$,#%'1#$AZ$0&$ADZC$6.$/75&,06.0$+,##."&'4#$+64$YJ#44/$#0$6):C$DODO[:$!"'4C$6.$
427
!
'.%#,406.%/.+$B"60$1&.40,6/.4$AZ$,#%'10/&.$768$5,&3/%#$/.4/+"0$/.0&$6$7#06(&)/1$5,&1#44$B/0"$
428
!
/75&,06.0$#.3/,&.7#.06)$1&.4#^'#.1#4:$a#1#.0$40'%/#4$"63#$%,6B.$600#.0/&.$0&$0"#$5&0#.0/6)$-&,$
429
!
56,0/0/&.#%$560"B684$0&$/.-)'#.1#$0"#$,60#$&-$./0,&+#.$-)'2$/.$4&/)4$(8$,#4/%#.0$7/1,&(#4$YN&B%6$
430
!
#0$6):C$DODO`$J#44/$#0$6):C$DODO[:$Z',$B&,V$600#7504$0&$%/,#10)8$)/.V$40,'10',#$6.%$-'.10/&.$&-$4'1"$
431
!
56,0/0/&.4$64$/4$4'++#40#%$(8$0"#$+#.&7/1$1&.0#.0$&-$#.3/,&.7#.06)$/4&)60#4$YJ#44/$#0$6):C$DODO[:$
432
!
I.$6.$#.0/,#)8$%/--#,#.0$1&.0#20C$&',$-/.%/.+$0"60$"0!*$+%,-)'#*$16.$0",/3#$(8$,#%'1/.+$AZ$
433
!
5,&3/%#%$(8$6.&0"#,$1#))$)#.%4$1,#%#.1#$0&$0"#$"85&0"#4/4$0"60$J<$768$4',3/3#$0"#$"&40$/77'.#$
434
!
AZ$60061V$(8$/04$,#%'10/&.$0&$ADZC$6.%$768$1&,,#)60#$B/0"$0"#$655#6,6.1#$&-$ADZ$/.$0"#$(,#60"$
435
!
+64$&-$1840/1$-/(,&4/4$560/#.04$Y@&)5#.$#0$6):C$DO>Q[:$I75&,06.0)8C$"0!*$+%,-)'#*$16.$(#$-&'.%$
436
!
5,&2/76)$0&$"&40$/77'.#$1#))4$/.$0"#4#$/.-#10#%$#.3/,&.7#.04$Y?#J64$#0$6):C$DO>T[:$
437
!
f/.6))8C$B#$.&0#$0"60$AZ$/4$&.)8$&.#$&-$76.8$6+60"&V6V&)&+/16)$7&)#1')#4C$(&0"$&,+6./1$
438
!
6.%$/.&,+6./1C$0"60$768$"#)5$40,'10',#$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./0/#4$&3#,$476))$4560/6)$416)#4$64$6$
439
!
-'.10/&.$&-$&28+#.$636/)6(/)/08:$f&,$#2675)#C$&0"#,$,#%&2*610/3#$7#06(&)/0#4$4'1"$64$5"#.69/.#4$
440
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
14!
16.$-'.10/&.$64$.60',6)$0&2/.4$&,$(#.#-/1/6)$6+#.04$&-$.'0,/#.0$61^'/4/0/&.$6.%c&,$,#%&2$
441
!
"&7#&4064/4C$%#5#.%/.+$&.$0"#$7/1,&#.3/,&.7#.06)$1&.0#20$Y?6")40,&7$#0$6):C$DODO[:$;/7/)6,)8C$
442
!
4')-/%#$"64$)&.+$(##.$V.&B.$0&$5)68$.'6.1#%$,&)#4$/.$.60',#C$B/0"$/04$1&.1#.0,60/&.*%#5#.%#.0$
443
!
0&2/1/08$/.-)'#.1/.+$B"/1"$5"&0&0,&5"/1$45#1/#4$6,#$6()#$0&$0",/3#$Yf/.%)68$#0$6):C$DO>M[C$6.%$
444
!
B"#,#$%/--#,#.0$#.#,+8*1&.4#,3/.+$5,&1#44#4$16.$&11',$B/0"/.$7/1,&(/6)$7604$Ym'.+()'0$#0$6):C$
445
!
DO>T`$J,/#0&*F6,6l64$#0$6):C$DO>_[:$=#$"640#.$0&$.&0#$0"60$76.8$&0"#,$56,67#0#,4$768$(#$
446
!
4'(l#10$0&$4/7/)6,$%8.67/1$4560/&0#75&,6)$+,6%/#.04C$4'1"$64$16,(&.C$5b$6.%$)/+"0C$6.%$6,#$)/V#)8$
447
!
0&$6)4&$5)68$/75&,06.0$,&)#4$/.$%#0#,7/./.+$0"#$./1"#4$B"#,#$1,&44*-##%/.+$&,$&0"#,$085#4$&-$
448
!
7#06(&)/1$/.0#,610/&.4$16.$&11',$Y\"6.+$#0$6):C$DOD>[:$!&B6,%4$0"#$+&6)$&-$+6/./.+$6$5,#%/10/3#$
449
!
'.%#,406.%/.+$&-$B"8$%/3#,4#$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./0/#4$6,#$40,'10',#%$0"#$B68$0"#8$6,#C$6$
450
!
1&.40,'10/3#$.#20$40#5$B/))$(#$0&$7&%#)$0"#4#$/.0#,610/&.4C$/0#,60/.+$B/0"$#25#,/7#.04$'.0/)$1,&44*
451
!
1'00/.+$5,/.1/5)#4$16.$(#$/%#.0/-/#%$B/0"$5,#%/10/3#$5&B#,:$$
452
!
$
453
!
Materials'and'methods$
454
!
Bacterial'strains'and'growth'conditions.'<))$40,6/.4$'4#%$6,#$1)#6.$%#)#0/&.$7'06.04$
455
!
&,/+/.60/.+$-,&7$0"#$B/)%*085#$Y=![$"#$%&'(')*#!*$+%,-)'#*!KHFJJ*J<>Q$40,6/.$64$%#41,/(#%$
456
!
(#)&B:$;0,6/.4$B#,#$40&,#%$64$MOr$+)81#,&)$40&1V4$60$*_OqH:$F#-&,#$'4#C$40,6/.4$B#,#$40,#6V#%$
457
!
-,&7$-,&9#.$40&1V$&.0&$F610&$6+6,$YF?C$;/+76[$5)60#4$1&.06/./.+$dF$YP/))#,C$F?C$;/+76[$&,$dF$
458
!
4'55)#7#.0#%$B/0"$MO'+c7d$+#.067/1/.$YN&)%F/&[$0&$4#)#10$-&,$,#0#.0/&.$&-$#25,#44/&.$1644#00#4$
459
!
B/0"/.$-)'&,#41#.0$40,6/.4C$6.%$+,&B.$&3#,./+"0$60$URqH:$f,&7$40,#6V$5)60#4C$6$%6($&-$1')0',#$B64$
460
!
'4#%$0&$/.&1')60#$M7d$)/^'/%$1')0',#4$/.$dF$&,$dF$5)'4$MO'+c7d$+#.067/1/.$)/^'/%$7#%/6:$
461
!
H')0',#4$B#,#$4"6V#.$60$DMO,57$60$URqH$&3#,./+"0$'.0/)$-'))8$460',60#%$60$4060/&.6,8$5"64#:$!&$
462
!
406.%6,%/9#$/.&1')'7$4/9#4$(#0B##.$40,6/.4C$#61"$40,6/.e4$&50/16)$%#.4/08$YZ?MOO.7[$B64$
463
!
7#64',#%$(8$45#10,&5"&0&7#0,8$YF#1V76.$H&')0#,[:$;0,6/.4$B#,#$0"#.$#61"$B64"#%$6.%$
464
!
%/)'0#%$0&$6.$Z?$&-$>$3/6$1#.0,/-'+60/&.$6.%$,#4'45#.4/&.$/.$>p$5"&45"60#$('--#,#%$46)/.#$
465
!
YJF;[:$;0,6/.4$B#,#$0"#.$#/0"#,$-',0"#,$%/)'0#%$%/,#10)8C$&,$-/,40$7/2#%$60$#^'6)$,60/&4$-&,$1&*
466
!
1')0',#$#25#,/7#.04:$f&,$6))$#25#,/7#.04C$B#$'4#%$6$d&B$;6)0$dF$Yd;dF[$/.$5)61#$&-$406.%6,%$dF$
467
!
5&B%#,$%'#$0&$7/1,&#)#10,&%#$,#610/3/08$0&$"/+"$A6H)$/.$dF:$!"#$1&75&4/0/&.$&-$d;dF$/4$>Q>7P$
468
!
!,850&.#$YF?C$;/+76[C$>T7P$X#640$G20,610$YF?C$;/+76[C$QM7P$A6H)$Yf/4"#,$H"#7/16)[C$B"/1"$
469
!
B#,#$%/44&)3#%$/.$P/)/*s$B60#,$6.%$6'0&1)63#%:$M7P$A/0,60#$B64$4'55)#7#.0#%$/.0&$dF$&,$d;Fd$
470
!
B"#,#$/.%/160#%$(8$%/)'0/.+$-,&7$6$>P$40&1V$&-$@AZU$Yf/4"#,$H"#7/16)[:$
471
!
$$
472
!
Construction'of'mutant'bacterial'strains.'!6()#$;>$1&.06/.4$6$-'))$)/40$&-$5,/7#,4$'4#%$/.$0"#$
473
!
1,#60/&.$&-$%#)#0/&.$1&.40,'104$6.%$7'06.0$40,6/.4$'4#%$/.$0"/4$40'%8:$F,/#-)8C$6$>V($-,6+7#.0$'5*$
474
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
15!
6.%$%&B.40,#67$&-$0"#$06,+#0$+#.#$B64$675)/-/#%$3/6$JHa$6.%$1)&.#%$/.0&$0"#$5PsUO$5)647/%$
475
!
'4/.+$N/(4&.$1)&./.+$YAGF[$6.%$0,6.4-&,7#%$/.0&$<0!/'=-$1#))4$64$5,#3/&'4)8$%#41,/(#%$Y;5#,&$
476
!
6.%$A#B76.C$DO>_[:$?#)#0/&.$1&.40,'104$B#,#$0"#.$/.0,&%'1#%$0&$56,#.0$40,6/.4$Y=!$J<>Q$6.%$
477
!
&,$%#)#0/&.$40,6/.4$&-$J<>QC$4##$!6()#$;>[$3/6$0,/56,#.06)$1&.l'+60/&.:$<0!/'=-$5)647/%$6.%$"#)5#,$
478
!
40,6/.4$B#,#$4#)#10#%$6+6/.40$(8$(#6%$5)60/.+$1&.l'+60/&.$&.0&$jFPP$5)60#4$1&.06/./.+$
479
!
MO'+c7d$+#.067/1/.$YH"&/$6.%$;1"B#/9#,C$DOOT[:$H)#6.$%#)#0/&.$40,6/.4$B#,#$0"#.$(#6%$5)60#%$
480
!
&.$6$>Or$4'1,&4#$5)60#$0&$/.%'1#$"&7&)&+&'4$,#1&7(/.60/&.$B/0"$0"#$1&.40,'10$1&.06/./.+$0"#$
481
!
,#+/&.4$'5*$6.%$%&B.40,#67C$('0$)61V/.+$0"#$06,+#0#%$+#.#$)&1'4$YF6406$#0$6):C$DO>R[:$P'06.0$
482
!
40,6/.4$B#,#$1&.-/,7#%$-/,40$(8$5601"/.+$&.$4'1,&4#$6.%$+#.067/1/.$5)60#4C$6.%$4'11#44-')$
483
!
7'06.04$+,#B$&.$4'1,&4#$('0$.&0$+#.067/1/.:$A#20C$JHa$+#.&085/.+$B64$5#,-&,7#%$'4/.+$
484
!
5,/7#,4$0"60$456.$0"#$%#)#0/&.$,#+/&.C$4#^'#.1/.+$1&.-/,7#%$0"#$/%#.0/08$&-$0"#4#$%#)#0/&.4C$6.%$
485
!
6.6#,&(/1$+,&B0"$1"6))#.+#4$,#3#6)#%$#25#10#%$5"84/&)&+/16)$#--#104$Y#:+:$t./,;$B64$'.6()#$0&$
486
!
+,&B$&.$./0,/0#C$#01[:$f)'&,#41#.1#$40,6/.4$B#,#$1,#60#%$64$5,#3/&'4)8$%#41,/(#$YF6406$#0$6):C$
487
!
DO>R`$P#/,#))#4$6.%$A#B76.C$DO>_[$'4/.+$-)'&,#41#.0$NfJc7<55)#$5)647/%4$%,/3#.$(8$0"#$
488
!
1&.4060/3#$,/(&4&76)$5,&7&0#,$,54N$/.0,&%'1#%$/.0&$0"#$!.R$4/0#$&-$45#1/-/#%$40,6/.4$'4/.+$0#0,6*
489
!
56,#.06)$1&.l'+60/&.:$<0!/'=-$"#)5#,$40,6/.4$B#,#$6+6/.$4#)#10#%$6+6/.40$'4/.+$jFPP$1&.06/./.+$
490
!
MO'+c7d$+#.067/1/.:$H&.-/,760/&.$&-$/.4#,0/&.$B64$5#,-&,7#%$3/6$7/1,&41&58C$3/4'6)/9/.+$
491
!
1&)&./#4$/.$(&0"$+,##.$6.%$,#%$-)'&,#41#.1#$1"6..#)4$6.%$4#)#10/.+$0"&4#$0"60$B#,#$(,/+"0$/.$
492
!
0"#/,$,#45#10/3#$1"6..#):$f,&9#.$40&1V4$B#,#$6)4&$'4#%$0&$406,0$1')0',#4$6.%$/76+#$4/.+)#$1#))4$
493
!
B"/1"$4"&B#%$4/+./-/16.0$-)'&,#41#.1#$/.$655,&5,/60#$1"6..#)4$6(&3#$(61V+,&'.%$
494
!
6'0&-)'&,#41#.1#:$
495
!
'$
496
!
Growth'curves.'<.&2/1$+,&B0"$1',3#$7#%/6$B64$5)61#%$/.$6.6#,&(/1$1"67(#,$RD$"&',4$5,/&,$0&$
497
!
#25#,/7#.0$0&$6))&B$0/7#$-&,$&28+#.$0&$%#+64$-,&7$7#%/6:$>$Z?MOO.7$1')0',#4$B#,#$(,&'+"0$/.0&$
498
!
1"67(#,$6.%$-',0"#,$%/)'0#%$0&$O:OOM$Z?MOO.7$/.$6.&2/1$7#%/6:$N,&B0"$1',3#4$B#,#$5#,-&,7#%$
499
!
'4/.+$6$F/&!#V$;8.#,+8$Q$5)60#$,#6%#,$40&,#%$/.$6.$6.&2/1$1"67(#,$6.%$4#0$0&$URH$B/0"$4"6V/.+$
500
!
6.%$7#64',#%$Z?MOO.7$#3#,8$>O$7/.'0#4:$Z2/1$Y4"6V/.+[$6.%$b85&2/1$Y4060/&.6,8[$+,&B0"$1',3#4$
501
!
B#,#$4#0$'5$64$6(&3#$('0$'.%#,$.&,76)$607&45"#,#:$Z2/1$+,&B0"$1',3#4$B#,#$5#,-&,7#%$'4/.+$
502
!
6$!#16.$;56,V$>OP$4#0$0&$&,(/06)$4"6V/.+:$b85&2/1$+,&B0"$1',3#4$B#,#$5#,-&,7#%$'4/.+$6$
503
!
;5#10,6762$PU$YP&)#1')6,$?#3/1#4[$5)60#$,#6%#,$4#0$0&$.&0$4"6V#:$G61"$1&.%/0/&.$B64$
504
!
5#,-&,7#%$/.$0#1"./16)$0,/5)/160#$&,$^'6%,'5)/160#:$G61"$B#))$1&.06/.#%$DOO$n)$&-$1')0',#$B/0"$
505
!
QO'd$&-$7/.#,6)$&/)$6%%#%$0&$0"#$0&5$&-$#61"$B#))$0&$5,#3#.0$#365&,60/&.$&-$Q_*RD*"&',$+,&B0"$
506
!
1',3#4:$!,61#4$-,&7$6))$+,&B0"$1',3#4$Yf/+',#$>C$f/+',#$UC$;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$>[$B#,#$6.6)89#%$
507
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
16!
(8$5)&00/.+$7#6.$Z?MOO.7$&3#,$0/7#$Y%6,V$1#.0#,$)/.#[$64$B#))$64$LMr$1&.-/%#.1#$/.0#,36)4$-,&7$
508
!
0"#$0#1"./16)$,#5)/160#4$Y4"6%#%$6,#6[$'4/.+$;#6(&,.$5)&00/.+$561V6+#4$/.$J80"&.:$
509
!
$$
510
!
Nitric'oxide'and'superoxide'quantification.'d#3#)4$&-$./0,/1$&2/%#$6.%$4'5#,&2/%#$B#,#$
511
!
^'6.0/060#%$'4/.+$-)'&,#41#.0$%8#4$%',/.+$"85&2/1$+,&B0"$1',3#4:$AZ$B64$^'6.0/060#%$'4/.+$
512
!
MOnP$?<f*D?<$YH6)(/&1"#7C$;/+76[$B"/1"$/4$/.0#,.6)/9#%$(8$1#))4$B"#,#$#40#,64#4$-,##$?<f*
513
!
D?<$0&$/.0#,610$B/0"$AZ$5,&%'1/.+$6$+,##.$-)'&,#41#.1#$4/+.6)$Y<6V6.V4"6$=6.8C$J,6%##5$
514
!
@'76,$J60"6VC$DODO[:$;'5#,&2/%#$B64$^'6.0/060#%$'4/.+$MnP$H#))aZp$?##5$a#%$Y!"#,7&[C$
515
!
B"/1"$/4$.&.*-)'&,#41#.0$/.$6$,#%'1#%$4060#$('0$#2"/(/04$6$40,&.+$/.%'10/&.$&-$-)'&,#41#.1#$'5&.$
516
!
&2/%60/&.$B/0"$,#610/3#$&28+#.$45#1/#4$YP1F##$#0$6):C$DO>R[:$!&$7#64',#$0"#4#$5,&(#4C$6$
517
!
"85&2/1$+,&B0"$1',3#$/.$d;dF$B/0"$&,$B/0"&'0$M7P$@AZU$B64$5#,-&,7#%$64$/.%/160#%$6(&3#$
518
!
6.%$0"#$;5#10,6762$5)60#$,#6%#,$B64$1&.-/+',#%$0&$6%%/0/&.6))8$7#64',#$+,##.$-)'&,#41#.1#$
519
!
YG2:$Q__.7C$G7:$MDO.7C$?<f*D[$6.%$-6,$,#%$-)'&,#41#.1#$YG2:$TQO.7C$G7:$TTM.7C$H#))aZp[:$
520
!
f&,$56%$/76+/.+$644684C$H#))aZp$B64$4'55)#7#.0#%$0&$0"#$6+6,$56%4$%/,#10)8$60$6$-/.6)$
521
!
1&.1#.0,60/&.$&-$>OnP$6.%$/76+#%$6-0#,$4/+./-/16.0$(/&-/)7$+,&B0"$"6%$&11',,#%$0&$,#3#6)$
522
!
4'5#,&2/%#$)&16)/960/&.:$?<f*D?<$B64$6)4&$'4#%$0&$3/4'6)/9#$AZC$"&B#3#,C$%'#$0&$B#6V$4/.+)#*
523
!
1#))$4/+.6)$6.%$40,&.+$(61V+,&'.%$6'0&-)'&,#41#.1#$/.$0"#$+,##.$1"6..#)C$B#$B#,#$'.6()#$0&$
524
!
3/4'6)/9#$0"#$4/+.6):$$
525
!
$$
526
!
Oxygen'profiling.'!&$1&.-/,7$0"#$5,#4#.1#$&-$&28+#.$+,6%/#.04$/.$406.%/.+$1')0',#4C$B#$
527
!
#75)&8#%$6'DMn7$%/67#0#,$&28+#.$7/1,&#)#10,&%#$#)#10,&%#$YK./4#.4#[C$B"/1"$B64$16)/(,60#%$
528
!
64$5,#3/&'4)8$%#41,/(#%$Y;5#,&$6.%$A#B76.C$DO>_[:$F,/#-)8C$d;dF$7#%/6$/.1'(60#%$60$URqH$
529
!
B64$'4#%$0&$16)1')60#$0"#$"/+"$5&/.0$ZD$1&.1#.0,60/&.:$<$9#,&*5&/.0$16)/(,60/&.$B64$&(06/.#%$(8$
530
!
%/44&)3/.+$D+$;&%/'7$<41&,(60#$/.$>OO7d$O:>$A6ZbC$B"/1"$4163#.+#4$ZD$-,&7$0"#$7#%/'7:$
531
!
K4/.+$0"#$K./4#.4#$;#.4&,$;'/0#$;&-0B6,#$0&$463#$16)/(,60/&.$36)'#4$6.%$0&$1&.0,&)$6$7&0&,/9#%$
532
!
7/1,&76./5')60&,$0&$5#,-&,7$5,&-/)/.+C$ZD$B64$7#64',#%$-,&7$0"#$4',-61#$&-$"85&2/16))8$
533
!
/.1'(60#%$5)6.V0&./1$1')0',#4$/.$>7d$G55#.%&,-$0'(#4:$!"#$4',-61#$B64$4#0$(8$#8#$6.%$
534
!
1&.-/,7#%$(8$6$,#%'10/&.$/.$7j$4/+.6):$ZD$B64$0"#.$7#64',#%$&3#,$6$>77$%/406.1#$(#)&B$0"#$
535
!
4',-61#$60$MOn7$/.0#,36)4:$!B&$7#64',#7#.04$B#,#$06V#.$60$#61"$5&4/0/&.C$6.%$0",##$0#1"./16)$
536
!
,#5)/160#4$B#,#$63#,6+#%$6.%$%/45)68#%$64$0"#$7#6.$36)'#$B/0"$LMr$1&.-/%#.1#$/.0#,36)4$
537
!
Yf/+',#$UG[:$H')0',#4$B#,#$5,#56,#%$64$/.$+,&B0"$1',3#4$('0$76/.06/.#%$64$>7d$3&)'7#4$/.$
538
!
0'(#4$,60"#,$0"6.$6)/^'&0/.+$/.0&$LT*B#))$5)60#4:$P/.#,6)$&/)$B64$.&0$6%%#%$%'#$0&$5&0#.0/6)$
539
!
/.1&7560/(/)/08$B/0"$#)#10,&%#4:$
540
!
'$
541
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
17!
Agar'pad'imaging'assay.'<-0#,$4/+./-/16.0$&50/7/960/&.C$/0$B64$%#0#,7/.#%$0"60$>$Z?MOO.7$
542
!
1')0',#4$%/)'0#%$0&$6$406,0/.+$1&.1#.0,60/&.$&-$O:OO>$Z?MOO.7$B64$4'--/1/#.0$0&$&(06/.$4/.+)#$1#))4$
543
!
,6.%&7)8$%/40,/('0#%$'.%#,$6+6,$56%4:$<+6,$56%4$B#,#$76%#$(8$1&7(/./.+$d;dF$7#%/6$B/0"$&,$
544
!
B/0"&'0$M7P$@AZUC$B/0"$Dr$Bc3$A&()#$<+6,$YF?C$;/+76[:$J,/&,$0&$'4#C$0"#$6+6,$B64$7#)0#%$(8$
545
!
7/1,&B63/.+:$!&$76V#$#^'6))8$4/9#%$6+6,$56%4C$>OOnd$B64$5/5#00#%$/.0&$#61"$&-$4#3#,6)$4^'6,#$
546
!
7&)%4$YT*R77$p$R77$p$>:T77$?#50"$I?C$DM77$p$RM77C$N,61#$F/&$d6(4[C$5)61#%$(#0B##.$
547
!
0B&$+)644$7/1,&41&5#$4)/%#4C$6.%$6))&B#%$0&$4&)/%/-8$60$QqH$'.0/)$'4#:$<.&2/1$56%4$B#,#$76%#$RD$
548
!
"&',4$/.$6%36.1#$6.%$5)61#%$/.$6.$6.6#,&(/1$1"67(#,$0&$%#+64:$M$nd$&-$O:OO>$Z?MOO.7$%/)'0/&.$
549
!
1')0',#$B64$6%%#%$0&$0"#$(&00&7$&-$6$B#))$/.$6.$_*B#))$d6(!#V$%/4"$Y!"#,7&[:$<.$6+6,$56%$B64$
550
!
0"#.$5)61#%$&.$0&5$&-$0"#$1')0',#:$d6(!#V$1')0',#4$B#,#$/.1'(60#%$60$URqH$-&,$DQ$"&',4$Y&2/1[$&,$
551
!
Q_$"&',4$Y6.&2/1[$/.$6$4#6)#%$1&.06/.#,$YT:R&'.1#C$;840#76[:$I75&,06.0)8C$B"#.$6%%/0/&.6)$
552
!
"'7/%/08$B64$6%%#%$'4/.+$6$B#0$0/44'#$'.%#,$4675)#4C$/.40#6%$&-$%/40/.10$6++,#+60#$(/&-/)74C$
553
!
1#))4$+,#B$7&,#$)/V#$/.0#,7/2#%$5)6.V0&./1$1')0',#4`$0"'4C$6%%/0/&.6)$"'7/%/08$B64$.&0$6%%#%:$
554
!
!/7#$)654#$/76+/.+$&-$56%4$B64$5#,-&,7#%$(8$-/,40$/.1'(60/.+$56%4$64$%#41,/(#%$6(&3#C$('0$l'40$
555
!
(#-&,#$)84/4$B&')%$&11',$Y#75/,/16))8$%#0#,7/.#%$0&$(#$60$655,&2/760#)8$>_$"&',4[C$d6(!#V$
556
!
1')0',#4$B#,#$4#6)#%$B/0"$56,6-/)7$0&$5,#3#.0$#365&,60/&.$/.$0"#$"#60#%$7/1,&41&5#$/.1'(60/&.$
557
!
1"67(#,:$<.&2/16))8*/.1'(60#%$1#))4$B#,#$.&0$/./0/6))8$-)'&,#41#.0$'5&.$,#7&36)$-,&7$1"67(#,$0&$
558
!
/76+#$%'#$0&$6.$/.6(/)/08$-&,$-)'&,&5"&,#4$0&$-&)%$/.$0"#$6(4#.1#$&-$&28+#.:$!&$&3#,1&7#$0"/4C$
559
!
56%4$B#,#$5)61#%$60$QuH$B/0"&'0$)/%4$-&,$&.#$0&$0B&$"&',4$5,/&,$0&$/76+/.+$B"/1"$,#4')0#%$/.$
560
!
4'--/1/#.0$4/+.6)$,#1&3#,/.+$0&$%/--#,#.0/60#$(#0B##.$NfJ$6.%$7<55)#$1#))4:$
561
!
'$
562
!
Imaging'and'image'analyses.'<))$/76+/.+$B64$5#,-&,7#%$'4/.+$6$A/V&.$!/D$B/%#-/#)%$
563
!
-)'&,#41#.1#$7/1,&41&5#:$G.%$0/7#$5&/.0$/76+#4$B#,#$1&))#10#%$'4/.+$6$J)6.$f)'&,$>OO2c>:UO$&/)$
564
!
5"64#$&(l#10/3#$6.%$0/7#$)654#$/76+#4$B#,#$1&))#10#%$'4/.+$6$J)6.$<5&$QO2cO:LO$%,8$5"64#$
565
!
&(l#10/3#:$NfJ$1"6..#)$'4#%$6$Q__.7$dG?$#21/060/&.$)/+"0$4&',1#$6.%$#7/44/&.$B64$1&))#10#%$
566
!
B/0"$6$fI!H$-/)0#,:$!"#$7<55)#$1"6..#)$'4#%$MT>.7$dG?$)/+"0$4&',1#$6.%$#7/44/&.$B64$
567
!
1&))#10#%$B/0"$6$!aI!H$-/)0#,:$f&,$0/7#$)654#$/76+/.+C$6.$Z@Z$d6(4$16+#$/.1'(60/&.$'./0$B64$4#0$
568
!
0&$URqH$4#3#,6)$"&',4$(#-&,#$/76+/.+$0&$#^'/)/(,60#$0"#$7/1,&41&5#$406.%$6.%$'4#%$-&,$0"#$
569
!
%',60/&.$&-$0"#$/76+/.+$#25#,/7#.0:$I76+#4$B#,#$1&))#10#%$#3#,8$DO$7/.'0#4$-,&7$7')0/5)#$406+#$
570
!
5&4/0/&.4:$!/7#$/.%/160#%$/.$-/+',#4$Yf/+',#$QFCHC$f/+',#$MG[$,#5,#4#.04$0/7#$4/.1#$0"#$56%4$
571
!
B#,#$/.&1')60#%:$I76+#4$B#,#$6.6)89#%$6.%$5,#56,#%$-&,$%/45)68$'4/.+$fImI$Y;1"/.%#)/.$#0$6):C$
572
!
DO>D[:$<.&2/16))8*/.1'(60#%$1#))4$4"&B#%$4/+./-/16.0)8$)#44$-)'&,#41#.1#$0"6.$&2/16))8$/.1'(60#%$
573
!
&.#4`$/.$&,%#,$0&$&50/76))8$&(4#,3#$1#))4$&3#,$(61V+,&'.%C$6$(61V+,&'.%$4'(0,610/&.$'4/.+$fImIe4$
574
!
('/)0*/.$-'.10/&.$B64$5#,-&,7#%:$F,/+"0.#44$6.%$1&.0,640$B#,#$6%l'40#%$&.$6$5#,$/76+#$(64/4$/.$
575
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
18!
&,%#,$0&$(#40$%/45)68$1#))$5&4/0/&.4$6.%$/%#.0/-/160/&.4C$'.)#44$&0"#,B/4#$.&0#%$Y#:+:$H#))aZp$
576
!
/.0#.4/08$/.$(/&-/)74$/76+#%$6.%$%/45)68#%$0"#$467#$-&,$1&756,/4&.$&-$/.0#.4/08$Yf/+',#$Q?[[:$!&$
577
!
611&'.0$-&,$4/+./-/16.0$%,/-0$&-$0"#$6+6,$56%4$%',/.+$0/7#$)654#$/76+/.+$6.%$5,&%'1#$0"#$3/%#&4$
578
!
6.%$7&.06+#4$%/45)68#%$"#,#/.C$6.$/76+#$,#+/40,60/&.$B64$5#,-&,7#%$'4/.+$0"#$;061Va#+$
579
!
5)'+/.$B/0"$0"#$a/+/%$F&%8$1"&/1#:$I76+#$4#+7#.060/&.$B64$'4#%$0&$^'6.0/-8$0"#$,60/&$&-$
580
!
NfJS7<55)#$1#))4$/.$0"#$6.&2/1$5)6.V0&./1$1')0',#4$Y;'55)#7#.06,8$-/)#$D<[C:$F,/#-)8C$1&.0,640$
581
!
B64$#."6.1#%C$(61V+,&'.%$4'(0,610#%$-)'&,#41#.1#$1"6..#)4$B#,#$1&7(/.#%$0&$1,#60#$6$0&06)$
582
!
1#))$764V:$!"#$<'0&$)&16)$!",#4"&)%$-'.10/&.$B/0"$0"#$J"6.46)V6,$4#)#10/&.$B64$'4#%$0&$
583
!
4#+7#.0$6.%$1&'.0$(&0"$0"#$0&06)$6.%$NfJ$1"6..#)$1#))4:$F#16'4#$1#))4$655#6,#%$0&$(#1&7#$
584
!
7&,#$-)'&,#41#.0$/.$0"#$7<55)#$1"6..#)$%',/.+$)&.+$6.&2/1$/.1'(60/&.4C$0"/4$5,#3#.0#%$'4$-,&7$
585
!
(#/.+$6()#$0&$4#+7#.0$7<55)#$1#))4$%/,#10)8:$!"#,#-&,#C$B#$16)1')60#%$7<55)#$1#))$1&'.04$64$
586
!
0&06)$1#))$1&'.04$7/.'4$NfJ$1#))$1&'.04C$0"#.$'4#%$0"#4#$36)'#4$0&$1&75'0#$5&5')60/&.$
587
!
5#,1#.06+#4:$
588
!
$
589
!
Acknowledgments.'!"#$B&,V$B64$4'55&,0#%$(8$0"#$A60/&.6)$I.40/0'0#4$&-$b#6)0"$
590
!
YaO>bd>MD>LO$0&$?:@:A:[$6.%$0"#$A60/&.6)$;1/#.1#$f&'.%60/&.$N,6%'60#$;0'%#.0$f#))&B4"/54$
591
!
J,&+,67$Y0&$;:<:=:[:$=#$B&')%$)/V#$0&$0"6.V$0"#$1',,#.0$6.%$5640$A#B76.$d6($7#7(#,4$-&,$
592
!
-##%(61V$6.%$%/41'44/&.4:$;5#1/-/16))8C$B#$0"6.V$?,4:$?6,18$P1a&4#$6.%$<3/$f)67"&)9$-&,$
593
!
1,/0/16)$76.'41,/50$,#3/#BC$?,:$P#)6./#$;5#,&$-&,$7&)#1')6,$0#1"./^'#$/.40,'10/&.C$?,4:$a#/.6)%&$
594
!
<)16%#$6.%$N#&,+/6$;^'8,#4$-&,$-,'/0-')$%/41'44/&.$6.%$0,&'()#4"&&0/.+$/76+/.+$644684C$6.%$?,:$
595
!
P/1"6#)$J/61#.0/.&$-&,$"#)5$B/0"$1&%/.+$6.%$+#.#,6)$7&,6)#:$'
596
!
$
597
!
Competing'interests.'!"#$6'0"&,4$%#1)6,#$.&$1&.-)/10$&-$/.0#,#404:''
598
!
' '
599
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
19!
References$
600
!
<6V6.V4"6$=6.8C$J,6%##5$@'76,$J60"6V$$6.%$@mN:$DODO:$P#0"&%4$-&,$P#64',/.+$A/0,60#$
601
!
a#%'1064#C$A/0,/0#$d#3#)4C$6.%$A/0,/1$Z2/%#$-,&7$J)6.0$!/44'#4$<6V6.V4"6$2057SMvT:$
602
!
<,6/$b:$DO>>:$a#+')60/&.$6.%$f'.10/&.$&-$j#,460/)#$<#,&(/1$6.%$<.6#,&(/1$a#45/,60&,8$
603
!
P#06(&)/47$/.$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46:$>+').!?-/+'@-'=$2S>OU:$
604
!
%&/S>O:UU_Lc-7/1(:DO>>:OO>OU$
605
!
<,4"6%$!<C$F&..#169#$a!C$;"#6,$mFC$="/0#)#8$PC$=#44#)$<@C$H&..#))$mdC$f/09560,/1V$P:$DO>Q:$
606
!
Z28+#.$d/7/060/&.$B/0"/.$6$F610#,/6)$<++,#+60#:$?7-'$5:$%&/S>O:>>D_c7(/&:OOLLD*>Q$
607
!
F6406$?=C$F#,+V#44#)$PC$A#B76.$?@:$DO>R:$I%#.0/-/160/&.$&-$-/0.#44$%#0#,7/.6.04$%',/.+$
608
!
#.#,+8*)/7/0#%$+,&B0"$6,,#40$/.$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46:$?7-'$8S>v>R:$
609
!
%&/S>O:>>D_c7F/&:O>>RO*>R$
610
!
F&,#,$FC$H/116,#4#$?C$m&".4&.$?C$Z,/$?:$DODO:$;560/6)$&,+6./960/&.$/.$7/1,&(/6)$,6.+#$
611
!
#256.4/&.$#7#,+#4$-,&7$0,&5"/1$%#5#.%#.1/#4$6.%$4'11#44-')$)/.#6+#4$F#.#%/10:$
612
!
6'((%)!7-'=$>v>O:$%&/S>O:>OU_c4QDOOU*ODO*O>QOL*8$
613
!
F,&.%/lV$!bHC$A/)63&.+4#$<C$f/)#.V&$AC$a/1"6,%4&.$?mC$H&)#$m<:$DOOQ:$A65Nb$1&75&.#.04$&-$
614
!
0"#$5#,/5)647/1$./0,60#$,#%'1064#$&-$G41"#,/1"/6$1&)/$@*>DS$d&160/&.C$0&5&)&+8$6.%$
615
!
5"84/&)&+/16)$,&)#4$/.$^'/.&)$&2/%60/&.$6.%$,#%&2$(6)6.1/.+:$7-'/A$(!4$379SQRvMM:$
616
!
%&/S>O:>OQDcFmDOOU>>>M$
617
!
F,'.#))/$dC$H,&B$mJC$F#1V76.$m;:$>LLM:$!"#$1&756,60/3#$0&2/1/08$&-$./0,/1$&2/%#$6.%$
618
!
5#,&28./0,/0#$0&$#41"#,/1"/6$1&)/:$;+/A!7-'/A$(!7-':AB#:$%&/S>O:>OOTc6((/:>LLM:>OQQ$
619
!
H6,)4&.$H<C$I.+,6"67$md:$>L_U:$H&756,/4&.$&-$%#./0,/-/160/&.$(8$J4#'%&7&.64$40'09#,/C$
620
!
J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46C$6.%$56,61&11'4$%#./0,/-/16.4:$;::=!<)C-+')!?-/+'@-'=$45S>DQRv
621
!
>DMU:$%&/S>O:>>D_c6#7:QM:Q:>DQR*>DMU:>L_U$
622
!
H6,,$NmC$J6+#$P?C$f#,+'4&.$;m:$>L_L:$!"#$#.#,+8!1&.4#,3/.+$./0,/1!&2/%#!,#%'1064#$4840#7$/.$
623
!
J6,61&11'4$%#./0,/-/16.4$?/40/.10/&.$-,&7$0"#$./0,/0#$,#%'1064#$0"60$1606)84#4$48.0"#4/4$&-$
624
!
./0,/1$&2/%#$6.%$#3/%#.1#$-,&7$0,655/.+$#25#,/7#.04$-&,$./0,/1$&2/%#$64$6$-,##$/.0#,7#%/60#$
625
!
%',/.+$%#./0,/-/:$<%+!4!7-'/A$($179ST_UvTLD:$%&/S>O:>>>>cl:>QUD*>OUU:>L_L:0(>QTO>:2$
626
!
H"&/$@bC$;1"B#/9#,$bJ:$DOOT:$7/./*!.R$/.4#,0/&.$/.$(610#,/6$B/0"$4/.+)#$600!.R$4/0#4S$G2675)#$
627
!
J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46:$D*.!"+'.'/$1S>MUv>T>:$%&/S>O:>OU_c.5,&0:DOOT:DQ$
628
!
H/116,#4#$?C$\'/%#76$<C$P#,)&$jC$m&".4&.$?a:$DODO:$I.0#,610/&.*%#5#.%#.0$#--#104$&-$4',-61#$
629
!
40,'10',#$&.$7/1,&(/6)$4560/6)$4#)-*&,+6./960/&.:$"A-='#!E+*)#!F!9'/!7!7-'=!9/-$
630
!
375SDO>LODQT:$%&/S>O:>OL_c,40(:DO>L:ODQT$
631
!
H&,%#,&$ZpC$?6006$P;:$DO>T:$P/1,&(/6)$/.0#,610/&.4$6.%$1&77'./08$644#7()8$60$7/1,&416)#4:$
632
!
6%++!G:-)!?-/+'@-'=$31SDDRvDUQ:$%&/S>O:>O>Tcl:7/(:DO>T:OU:O>M$
633
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
20!
?6")40,&7$@PC$P1a&4#$?dC$A#B76.$?@:$DODO:$@#840&.#$7#06(&)/0#4$&-$1,&5$,"/9&45"#,#$
634
!
7/1,&(/&7#4:$6%++!7-'=$30Sa>>U>va>>UR:$%&/S>O:>O>Tcl:1'(:DODO:O_:OOM$
635
!
?6)$H&$<C$<1V#,76..$PC$36.$j)/#0$;:$DO>L:$P#06(&)/1$610/3/08$6--#104$,#45&.4#$&-$4/.+)#$1#))4$0&$
636
!
6$.'0,/#.0$4B/01"$/.$40,'10',#%$5&5')60/&.4:$@-'FH-C:$%&/S>O:>>O>cM_OMTU$
637
!
?6,$?C$?6,$AC$H6/$dC$A#B76.$?@:$DOD>:$I.$4/0'$4/.+)#*1#))$610/3/0/#4$&-$7/1,&(/6)$5&5')60/&.4$
638
!
,#3#6)#%$(8$4560/6)$0,6.41,/50&7/14:$@-'FH-C$DOD>:OD:DQ:QUDRLD:$
639
!
?#J64$=bC$;06,B6)0*d##$aC$j6.$;67(##V$dC$@'76,$;aC$N,6%/.6,'$jC$A#B76.$?@:$DO>T:$
640
!
G25&4/.+$0"#$0",##*%/7#.4/&.6)$(/&+#&+,65"8$6.%$7#06(&)/1$4060#4$&-$560"&+#.4$/.$1840/1$
641
!
-/(,&4/4$45'0'7$3/6$"8%,&+#)$#7(#%%/.+C$1)#6,/.+C$6.%$,aA<$)6(#)/.+:$?7-'$7S>v>>:$
642
!
%&/S>O:>>D_c7F/&:OORLT*>T$
643
!
f6.+$XC$@&(6$@C$P6V6(#$<C$!6V6"64"/$HC$\"'$=C$b6864"/$!C$b&V6,/$<<C$K,6V6B6$aC$F6/$GC$
644
!
b&')0&.$F\C$p/$?C$\"6.+$;C$P604'4"/06$@C$!'$XC$d/'$?C$\"'$fC$=6.+$\C$\"&'$NC$H"#.$?C$
645
!
P6V/06$!C$!&%6$bC$d/'$pC$H"#.$sC$\"6.+$?C$d/$XC$X&"$P:$DO>M:$P/1,&(/6)$%#./0,/-/160/&.$
646
!
%&7/.60#4$./0,60#$)&44#4$-,&7$-&,#40$#1&4840#74:$"+'/!D*.=!;/*&!9/-!I!9!;$112S>QROv
647
!
>QRQ:$%&/S>O:>ORUc5.64:>Q>TRRT>>D$
648
!
f/.%)68$<mC$F#..#00$<mC$b6.4&.$!GC$d'0"#,$N=:$DO>M:$d/+"0*%#5#.%#.0$4')-/%#$&2/%60/&.$/.$0"#$
649
!
6.&2/1$9&.#$&-$0"#$1"#465#6V#$(68$16.$(#$#25)6/.#%$(8$476))$5&5')60/&.4$&-$5"&0&0,&5"/1$
650
!
(610#,/6:$;::=!<)C-+')!?-/+'@-'=$81SRMTOvRMTL:$%&/S>O:>>D_c<GP:ODOTD*>M$
651
!
f'",76.$m<:$DOOL:$P/1,&(/6)$1&77'./08$40,'10',#$6.%$/04$-'.10/&.6)$/75)/160/&.4:$D*.%+$$
652
!
459S>LUv>LL:$%&/S>O:>OU_c.60',#O_OM_$
653
!
N60#4$<mC$a/1"6,%4&.$?mC$F'00$mA:$DOO_:$j&)0677#0,/1$1"6,610#,/960/&.$&-$0"#$6#,&(/1$#.#,+8*
654
!
%/44/560/.+$./0,60#$,#%'1064#$&-$J6,61&11'4$56.0&0,&5"'4S$G25)&,/.+$0"#$610/3/08$&-$6$,#%&2*
655
!
(6)6.1/.+$#.987#$64$6$-'.10/&.$&-$#)#10,&1"#7/16)$5&0#.0/6):$7-'/A$(!4$409S>MLv>T_:$
656
!
%&/S>O:>OQDcFmDOOR>O__$
657
!
N&)%-&,%$mGC$d'$AC$F6l/w$?C$G40,#)6$;C$!/V"&.&3$PC$;6.1"#9*N&,&40/6+6$<C$;#+,x$?C$P#"06$JC$
658
!
;6.1"#9$<:$DO>_:$G7#,+#.0$4/75)/1/08$/.$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./08$644#7()8:$9/-$)/$!JKLM!N$
659
!
361SQTLvQRQ:$%&/S>O:>>DTc41/#.1#:660>>T_$
660
!
N&B%6$@C$J/.+$?C$P6./$PC$@'#".$;:$DODO:$<$456,4#$7655/.+$&-$40,'10',#$0&$-'.10/&.$/.$
661
!
7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./0/#4:$@-'FH-C$>v>T:$
662
!
N,6)V6$PC$;96(&$aC$;0&1V#,$aC$H&,%#,&$Zp:$DODO:$!,&5"/1$I.0#,610/&.4$6.%$0"#$?,/3#,4$&-$
663
!
P/1,&(/6)$H&77'./08$<44#7()8:$6%++!7-'=$30Sa>>RTva>>__:$
664
!
%&/S>O:>O>Tcl:1'(:DODO:O_:OOR$
665
!
b#40#,$GaC$m#00#.$P;PC$=#)0#$HKC$dy1V#,$;:$DO>L:$P#06(&)/1$&3#,)65$/.$#.3/,&.7#.06))8$
666
!
%/3#,4#$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./0/#4:$>+').!2$)$.$10S>v>O:$%&/S>O:UU_Lc-+#.#:DO>L:OOL_L$
667
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
21!
m'.+()'0$<?C$b6B#4$IC$P61V#8$!mC$@,'4&,$PC$?&,6.$J!C$;'7.#,$?XC$G/4#.$m<C$b/))76.$HC$
668
!
N&,&.18$<@:$DO>T:$P/1,&(/6)$760$1&77'./0/#4$6)&.+$6.$&28+#.$+,6%/#.0$/.$6$5#,#../6))8$
669
!
/1#*1&3#,#%$<.06,10/1$)6V#:$;::=!<)C-+')!?-/+'@-'=$82STDOvTUO:$%&/S>O:>>D_c<GP:ODTLL*>M$
670
!
@6)V&B4V/$I:$>LL>:$P#06(&)/47$&-$./0,/1$&2/%#$/.$%#./0,/-8/.+$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46$6.%$
671
!
./0,60#*,#45/,/.+$F61/))'4$1#,#'4:$><?9!?-/+'@-'=!O$..$82S>ORv>>D:$%&/S>O:>O>TcOUR_*
672
!
>OLRYL>[LOQDL*G$
673
!
@&)5#.$PC$@y")$PC$Fl6,.4"&)0$!C$P&4#,$HC$b6.4#.$HaC$d/#.+66,%$dC$@"6,697/$<C$J,#44)#,$!C$
674
!
bz/(8$AC$m#.4#.$J{:$DO>Q:$A/0,&'4$&2/%#$5,&%'10/&.$/.$45'0'7$-,&7$1840/1$-/(,&4/4$560/#.04$
675
!
B/0"$1",&./1$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46$)'.+$/.-#10/&.:$"O'9!G)$$9:$
676
!
%&/S>O:>UR>cl&',.6):5&.#:OO_QUMU$
677
!
@&55#.&)$bC$@&55#.&)$b:$DOD>:$A/0,/1$&2/%#C$4'5#,&2/%#C$6.%$5#,&28./0,/0#S$0"#$+&&%C$0"#$(6%C$
678
!
6.%$0"#$'+)8:$
679
!
@&4V#.V&,36$!C$<,&*@|,VV|/.#.$AC$F61"76..$?C$<,6/$bC$f,#8$<?C$@6))/&$J!:$DOO_:$
680
!
!,6.41,/50/&.6)$610/3/08$&-$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46$-"5$5,&7&0#,$/4$%#5#.%#.0$&.$0B&$
681
!
,#+')60&,4$/.$6%%/0/&.$0&$f"5a:$;+/A!?-/+'@-'=$189SU_MvULT:$%&/S>O:>OORc4OODOU*OOR*OUDL*
682
!
U$
683
!
@,/1"#)4$<C$?#d'1/6$GbC$;6.-&,%$aC$H"##*;6.-&,%$mC$X6.+$=b:$DO>L:$b/40&,/16)$4&/)$%,6/.6+#$
684
!
7#%/60#4$0"#$,#45&.4#$&-$4&/)$+,##."&'4#$+64$#7/44/&.4$0&$/.0#.4#$5,#1/5/060/&.$#3#.04:$
685
!
7-',$'/A$(-#.+B$142SQDMvQQD:$%&/S>O:>OORc4>OMUU*O>L*OOMQQ*2$
686
!
@,/1"#)4$<bC$X6.+$=b:$DO>L:$?8.67/1$H&.0,&)4$&.$f/#)%!;16)#$;&/)$A/0,&'4$Z2/%#$b&0$;5&04$
687
!
6.%$b&0$P&7#.04$<1,&44$6$P/1,&0&5&+,65"/1$N,6%/#.0:$4!2$':AB#!F$#!7-',$'#/-$)/$#$
688
!
124SUT>_vUTUQ:$%&/S>O:>ODLcDO>LmNOOMDDQ$
689
!
@'".4$?FC$J,/#)$?<dC$H"'$mC$\6,#7(#,$@<:$DO>M:$I4&)60/&.$6.%$f'.10/&.6)$<.6)84/4$&-$b'76.$
690
!
A#'0,&5"/)4:$6%++!"+'.'/!5((%)'=$111S>ULv>Q_:$%&/S>O:>OODcOQR>>QDRUM:/7ORDU4>>>$
691
!
@'85#,4$PPPC$P6,1"6.0$b@C$@6,06)$F:$DO>_:$!"#$7/1,&(/6)$./0,&+#.*181)/.+$.#0B&,V:$D*.!F$C!
692
!
?-/+'@-'=$16SDTUvDRT:$%&/S>O:>OU_c.,7/1,&:DO>_:L$
693
!
d/)l6$GGC$m&".4&.$?a:$DO>T:$;#+,#+60/.+$7#06(&)/1$5,&1#44#4$/.0&$%/--#,#.0$7/1,&(/6)$1#))4$
694
!
611#)#,60#4$0"#$1&.4'750/&.$&-$/."/(/0&,8$4'(40,60#4:$59?<!4$10S>MT_v>MR_:$
695
!
%&/S>O:>OU_c/47#l:DO>M:DQU$
696
!
d&B#,8$AjC$K,4#))$!:$DO>L:$;0,'10',#%$#.3/,&.7#.04$-'.%67#.06))8$6)0#,$%8.67/14$6.%$406(/)/08$
697
!
&-$#1&)&+/16)$1&77'./0/#4:$"+'/!D*.=!;/*&!9/-!I!9!;$116SURLvU__:$
698
!
%&/S>O:>ORUc5.64:>_>>__R>>T$
699
!
d81'4$JC$Fz0"'.$@dC$F#,+6'40$dC$;"65)#/+"$mJC$F6VV#.$daC$f,&40#+},%$~:$DO>R:$J"#.&085/1$
700
!
6.%$+#.&085/1$,/1".#44$&-$%#./0,/-/#,4$,#3#6)#%$(8$6$.&3#)$/4&)60/&.$40,60#+8:$59?<!4$
701
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
22!
11SDD>LvDDUD:$%&/S>O:>OU_c/47#l:DO>R:_D$
702
!
P6$dC$H&,%#,&$Zp:$DO>_:$;&)3/.+$0"#$40,'10',#*-'.10/&.$5'99)#:$D*.!?-/+'@-'=$3SRMOvRM>:$
703
!
%&/S>O:>OU_c4Q>MTQ*O>_*O>_T*R$
704
!
P#/,#))#4$d<C$A#B76.$?@:$DO>_:$F&0"$0&2/1$6.%$(#.#-/1/6)$#--#104$&-$58&186./.$1&.0,/('0#$0&$0"#$
705
!
)/-#181)#$&-$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46:$?'=!?-/+'@-'=$110SLLMv>O>O:$
706
!
%&/S>O:>>>>c77/:>Q>UD$
707
!
A/#"6'4$dC$F&)6.%$IC$d/'$PC$H"#.$@C$f'$?C$b#.1V#)$HC$H"6'.+$@C$P/,6.%6$;GC$?81V76.$;C$
708
!
H,'7$PC$?#%,/1V$;C$;"&'$=C$P&7#./$F:$DO>L:$P/1,&(/6)$1&#2/40#.1#$0",&'+"$1"#7/16)*
709
!
7#%/60#%$/.0#,610/&.4:$D*.!6'((%)$10:$%&/S>O:>OU_c4Q>QTR*O>L*>OOTD*2$
710
!
J#44/$I;C$j//067|V/$;C$G,&.#.*a64/7'4$GC$?#)7&.0$!ZC$d'&0&$PC$b')076.$m:$DODO:$!,'.160#%$
711
!
%#./0,/-/#,4$%&7/.60#$0"#$%#./0,/-/160/&.$560"B68$/.$0'.%,6$4&/)$7#06+#.&7#4:$@-'FH-C:$
712
!
%&/S>O:>>O>cDODO:>D:D>:Q>LDTR$
713
!
J&.&76,&36$ZC$J60/)$@a:$DO>M:$P#06(&)/1$/.0#,610/&.4$/.$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./0/#4S$K.06.+)/.+$0"#$
714
!
N&,%/6.$V.&0:$6%++!G:-)!?-/+'@-'=$27SURvQQ:$%&/S>O:>O>Tcl:7/(:DO>M:OT:O>Q$
715
!
J,/1#*="#)6.$<C$?/#0,/1"$dGJC$A#B76.$?@:$DOOR:$J8&186./.$6)0#,4$,#%&2$"&7#&4064/4$6.%$
716
!
16,(&.$-)'2$0",&'+"$1#.0,6)$7#06(&)/1$560"B684$/.$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46$J<>Q:$4!
717
!
7*/.$+-'=$189STURDvTU_>:$%&/S>O:>>D_cmF:OOMOM*OR$
718
!
J,/#0&*F6,6l64$HPC$j6)#.1/6*H6.0#,&$GC$;6.0&8&$N:$DO>_:$P/1,&(/6)$760$#1&4840#74S$;0,'10',#$
719
!
085#4C$-'.10/&.6)$%/3#,4/08C$6.%$(/&0#1".&)&+/16)$655)/160/&.:$<=$/.+')!4!7-'.$/A)'=$31SQ_v
720
!
MT:$%&/S>O:>O>Tcl:#l(0:DO>R:>>:OO>$
721
!
J,&10&,$?PC$a#)76.$?<:$DO>R:$!"#$d6.%4165#$G1&)&+8$6.%$P/1,&(/&06$&-$0"#$b'76.$A&4#C$
722
!
P&'0"C$6.%$!",&60:$6$==!3'#.!?-/+'@$:$%&/S>O:>O>Tcl:1"&7:DO>R:OU:O>>$
723
!
a609V#$HC$F6,,#,#$mC$N&,#$m:$DODO:$;0,#.+0"$&-$45#1/#4$/.0#,610/&.4$%#0#,7/.#4$(/&%/3#,4/08$6.%$
724
!
406(/)/08$/.$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./0/#4:$D*.!</'=!<C'=$4SURTvU_U:$%&/S>O:>OU_c4Q>MML*ODO*>OLL*
725
!
Q$
726
!
a/1"$mmC$b#/1"#.$a;C$F&00&7)#8$JmC$H,&761V$@C$P8,&)%$??:$DOOU:$H&77'./08$H&75&4/0/&.$
727
!
6.%$f'.10/&./.+$&-$?#./0,/-8/.+$F610#,/6$-,&7$<%l61#.0$P#6%&B$6.%$f&,#40$;&/)4:$;::=!
728
!
<)C-+')!?-/+'@-'=$69SMLRQvML_D:$%&/S>O:>>D_c<GP:TL:>O:MLRQ*ML_D:DOOU$
729
!
a/1"6,%4&.$?m:$DOOO:$F610#,/6)$,#45/,60/&.S$6$-)#2/()#$5,&1#44$-&,$6$1"6.+/.+$#.3/,&.7#.0:$
730
!
?-/+'@-'=',B$146'('Pt'3SMM>vMR>:$%&/S>O:>OLLcOODD>D_R*>QT*U*MM>$
731
!
;646V/$XC$Z+'1"/$bC$@&(6864"/$!C$@'4676$;C$;'+/',6$aC$P&,/86$@C$b/,606$!C$X'V/&V6$XC$!6V686$
732
!
AC$X6l/76$;C$I0&$;C$ZV6%6$@C$Z"46B6$@C$IV#%6$bC$!6V6.&$bC$K#%6$@C$;"&'.$b:$DO>T:$
733
!
A/0,&+#.$&2/%#$181)#$,#+')60#4$./0,/1$&2/%#$)#3#)4$6.%$(610#,/6)$1#))$4/+.6)/.+:$9/-!F$:$6S>v
734
!
>>:$%&/S>O:>OU_c4,#5DDOU_$
735
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
23!
;1"/.%#)/.$mC$<,+6.%6*H6,,#,64$IC$f,/4#$GC$@68./+$jC$d&.+6/,$PC$J/#0941"$!C$J,#/(/41"$;C$
736
!
a'#%#.$HC$;66)-#)%$;C$;1"7/%$FC$!/.#3#9$mXC$="/0#$?mC$b6,0#.40#/.$jC$G)/1#/,/$@C$
737
!
!&76.16V$JC$H6,%&.6$<:$DO>D:$f/l/S$<.$&5#.*4&',1#$5)60-&,7$-&,$(/&)&+/16)*/76+#$6.6)84/4:$
738
!
D*.!?$.A'&#$9STRTvT_D:$%&/S>O:>OU_c.7#0":DO>L$
739
!
;1"'40#,$PC$b6BV/.4$<HC$b6,B&&%$H;C$N,##.(#,+$GJ:$DOOQ:$!"#$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46$
740
!
a5&;$,#+')&.$6.%$/04$,#)60/&.4"/5$0&$^'&,'7$4#.4/.+:$?'=!?-/+'@-'=$51SLRUvL_M:$
741
!
%&/S>O:>OQTcl:>UTM*DLM_:DOOU:OU__T:2$
742
!
;7,/+6$;C$H/116,#4#$?C$F6((/.$<a:$DOD>:$?#./0,/-8/.+$(610#,/6$,#45&.%$0&$6.%$4"65#$
743
!
7/1,&416)#$+,6%/#.04$B/0"/.$56,0/1')60#$760,/1#4:$6'((%)!7-'=$4SMRO:$%&/S>O:>OU_c4QDOOU*
744
!
OD>*OD>OD*Q$
745
!
;56,61/.&*=60V/.4$HC$;0&)9$mfC$F64'$J:$DO>Q:$A/0,60#$6.%$5#,/5)647/1$./0,60#$,#%'1064#4:$
746
!
<K!bZae;$P<AK;HaIJ!:$6A$(!9'/!F$C$43STRTvROT:$%&/S>O:>OULc1U14TODQL%:A/0,60#$
747
!
;5#,&$P<C$A#B76.$?@:$DO>_:$H")&,60#$;5#1/-/16))8$!6,+#04$Z2/%6.0*;06,3#%C$<.0/(/&0/1*$
748
!
!&)#,6.0$J&5')60/&.4$&-$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46$F/&-/)74$P#)6./#:$?7-'$9S#O>QOO*>_:$
749
!
;0#B6,0$J;C$\"6.+$!C$p'$aC$J/004$FC$=6)0#,4$PHC$a&#$fC$@/V".#8$mC$P&0#,$<:$DO>T:$a#610/&.*
750
!
%/--'4/&.$0"#&,8$#25)6/.4$"85&2/6$6.%$"#0#,&+#.#&'4$+,&B0"$B/0"/.$7/1,&(/6)$(/&-/)74$
751
!
644&1/60#%$B/0"$1",&./1$/.-#10/&.4:$):P!7-'Q-=(#!?-/+'@-'($#$2S>v_:$
752
!
%&/S>O:>OU_c.5l(/&-/)74:DO>T:>D$
753
!
!/6.$bC$X6.+$mC$p'$aC$d'$HC$H6.6%#))$mNC$?63/%4&.$G<C$m61V4&.$aFC$<,.#0"$<C$H"6.+$mC$H/6/4$
754
!
JC$N#,(#,$;C$I0&$<C$m&&4$fC$d/#.#,0$;C$P#44/.6$JC$Z)/.$;C$J6.$;C$J#.+$HC$;6/V6B6$GC$
755
!
!"&754&.$adC$j'/1"6,%$AC$=/./B6,0#,$=C$\6#")#$;C$\"6.+$F:$DO>L:$N)&(6)$4&/)$./0,&'4$
756
!
&2/%#$#7/44/&.4$4/.1#$0"#$5,#/.%'40,/6)$#,6$#40/760#%$(8$6.$#.4#7()#$&-$0#,,#40,/6)$
757
!
(/&45"#,#$7&%#)4S$P6+./0'%#C$600,/('0/&.C$6.%$'.1#,06/.08:$2='@!6A*),!7-'=$25STQOvTML:$
758
!
%&/S>O:>>>>c+1(:>QM>Q$
759
!
j6.$<)40$AGC$;"#,,/))$d<C$I+)#B4V/$FbC$b6/%6,/4$HN:$DOOL:$H&75#.460&,8$5#,/5)647/1$./0,60#$
760
!
,#%'1064#$610/3/08$4'55&,04$6.6#,&(/1$+,&B0"$&-$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46$J<Z>$/.$0"#$
761
!
6(4#.1#$&-$7#7(,6.#$./0,60#$,#%'1064#:$6*)!4!?-/+'@-'=$55S>>UUv>>QQ:$%&/S>O:>>ULc=OL*
762
!
OTM$
763
!
j&FB/.V#)$aC$A#/%0$IC$F&0"#$b:$>LL>:$!"#$5,&%'10/&.$6.%$'0/)/960/&.$&-$./0,/1$&2/%#$(8$6$.#BC$
764
!
%#./0,/-8/.+$40,6/.$&-$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46:$;+/A!?-/+'@-'=$156STDvTL:$
765
!
%&/S>O:>OORcFfOOQ>_>_L$
766
!
j&)V$A:C$j&))7#,$?C$;1"7/%0$PC$Z55#,76..$=C$b'(#,$@:$DOOQ:$A/0,/1$Z2/%#C$6.$Z)%$P&)#1')#$
767
!
=/0"$A&()#$f'.10/&.4$/.$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46$F/&)&+8:$;&C!"'=B(!9/-$166SDLvTM:$
768
!
%&/S>O:>O>Tcl:1&4474:DO>O:OR:OO>$
769
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
24!
=#/.40#/.$F!C$d63,#.0&3/1"$PZC$P•(/'4$=C$P',,68$<=C$A#)4&.$?a:$DO>R:$N#.#0/1$%,/-0$6.%$
770
!
4#)#10/&.$/.$76.8*6))#)#$,6.+#$#256.4/&.4C$(/&a2/3:$%&/S>O:>>O>c>QMTU>$
771
!
=/%%#,$;C$<))#.$amC$J-#/--#,$!C$H',0/4$!JC$=/'-$HC$;)&6.$=!C$H&,%#,&$ZpC$F,&B.$;JC$P&7#./$FC$
772
!
;"&'$=C$@#00)#$bC$f)/.0$bmC$b664$<fC$d6,&1"#$FC$@,#-0$mKC$a6/.#8$JFC$f,#/)/1"$;C$;1"'40#,$
773
!
;C$P/)-#,40#%0$@C$j6.$?#,$P##,$maC$N,&(V&5-$!C$b'/476.$mC$f,##$<C$J/1/&,#6.'$HC$s'/.1#$
774
!
HC$@)655#,$IC$d6(6,0"#$;C$;7#04$FfC$=6.+$bC$;&8#,$Z;C$<))/4&.$;?C$H"&.+$mC$
775
!
d6+&76,4/.&$PHC$H,&9#$Z<C$b67#)/.$mC$b6,76.%$mC$b&8)#$aC$bB6$!!C$m/.$sC$m&".4&.$
776
!
?aC$%#$d&,#.9&$jC$P&(/)/6$PC$P',5"8$FC$J#6'%#1#,-$fC$J,&44#,$mIC$s'/..$a<C$a6)4#,$PC$
777
!
;7/0"$<NC$;0#8#,$mJC$;B6/.40&.$AC$!6,./06$HGC$!,6()8$GC$=6,,#.$JFC$=/)7#4$J:$DO>T:$
778
!
H"6))#.+#4$/.$7/1,&(/6)$#1&)&+8S$F'/)%/.+$5,#%/10/3#$'.%#,406.%/.+$&-$1&77'./08$-'.10/&.$
779
!
6.%$%8.67/14:$59?<!4$10SDMMRvDMT_:$%&/S>O:>OU_c/47#l:DO>T:QM$
780
!
=/)(#,0$;<C$P6,V$=#)1"$mdC$F&,/48$NN:$DODO:$;560/6)$G1&)&+8$&-$0"#$b'76.$!&.+'#$?&,4'7$
781
!
P/1,&(/&7#:$6$==!F$:$30SQOOU*QO>M:#U:$%&/S>O:>O>Tcl:1#),#5:DODO:OD:OLR$
782
!
X&&.$;;C$@6,6(')'0$<HC$d/541&7($m?C$b#../+6.$afC$d876,$;$j:C$N,&1#$;dC$b#,,$<FC$b&B#))$
783
!
PdC$@/)#8$JmC$;1"',,$PmC$N640&.$FC$H"&/$@bC$;1"B#/9#,$bJC$b644#00$?m:$DOOR:$!B&*
784
!
5,&.+#%$4',3/36)$40,60#+8$-&,$0"#$76l&,$1840/1$-/(,&4/4$560"&+#.C$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46C$
785
!
)61V/.+$0"#$16561/08$0&$%#+,6%#$./0,/1$&2/%#$%',/.+$6.6#,&(/1$,#45/,60/&.:$<?7G!4$26SUTTDv
786
!
UTRD:$%&/S>O:>OU_c4l:#7(&l:RTO>R_R$
787
!
X'$@C$P/01"#))$HC$p/.+$XC$P6+)/&99&$a;C$F)&&7$FaC$H"6.$m:$>LLL:$!&2/1/08$&-$./0,&+#.$&2/%#4$
788
!
6.%$,#)60#%$&2/%6.04$&.$781&(610#,/6S$P:$0'(#,1')&4/4$/4$,#4/406.0$0&$5#,&28./0,/0#$6./&.:$
789
!
E%@$+!O%),!R-#$79S>L>v>L_:$%&/S>O:>OMQc0')%:>LL_:ODOU$
790
!
\"6.+$IbC$P'))#.$;C$H/116,#4#$?C$?'7/0$?C$P6,0&1#))&$?GC$!&8&-'V'$PC$A&7',6$AC$;7,/+6$;C$
791
!
F6((/.$<a:$DOD>:$a60/&$&-$&,+6./1$16,(&.$0&$-/2#%$./0,&+#.$,#+')60#4$7#06(&)/1$
792
!
45#1/6)/960/&.$6.%$%#./0,/-/160/&.$%8.67/14$/.$J4#'%&7&.64$6#,'+/.&46:$f,&.0$
793
!
P/1,&(/&)$>DS>*>U:$"0054Scc%&/:&,+c>O:UU_Lc-7/1(:DOD>:R>>ORU$
794
!
\'7-0$=N:$>LLR:$H#))$(/&)&+8$6.%$7&)#1')6,$(64/4$&-$%#./0,/-/160/&.:$?-/+'@-'=!?'=!7-'=!F$C$
795
!
61SMUUvT>T:$%&/S>O:>>D_c77(,:T>:Q:MUU*T>T:>LLR$
796
!
\']/+6$HC$\6,67#)6$dC$\#.+)#,$@:$DO>R:$G)'1/%60/&.$&-$1&75)#2/08$6.%$5,#%/10/&.$&-$/.0#,610/&.4$
797
!
/.$7/1,&(/6)$1&77'./0/#4:$?-/+'@!7-'.$/A)'=$10S>MOOv>MDD:$%&/S>O:>>>>c>RM>*RL>M:>D_MM$
798
!
$
799
!
$$
800
!
$
801
!
$ $
802
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
25!
Figure'Legends'
803
!
$
804
!
Figure'1.$?#4/+.$6.%$1"6,610#,/960/&.$&-$48.0"#0/1$./0,/1$&2/%#$1,&44*-##%/.+$1&77'./08:$YA[$=!$
805
!
J<>Q$%#./0,/-/160/&.$560"B68$YB[$;1"#760/1$&-$AZ$1&.4'7#,$6.%$5,&%'1#,$40,6/.4$B"#,#$+#.#4$
806
!
0"60$"63#$(##.$%#)#0#%$6,#$+,68#%*&'0C$6.%$0"&4#$,#76/./.+$6,#$4"&B.$/.$()61V:$!"#$560"B68$
807
!
56,0/0/&.4$B"#,#$AZ$/4$5,&%'1#%$6.%$,#%'1#%:$YC[$N,&B0"$1',3#$&-$1&*1')0',#$Q$7#7(#,4$+,&B.$
808
!
/.%/3/%'6))8$6.%$0&+#0"#,C$1&756,#%$0&$0"#$=!C$&3#,$RD",4$'.%#,$6.&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4$B/0"$./0,60#$
809
!
5,&3/%#%$64$4&)#$0#,7/.6)$#)#10,&.$611#50&,$Y!G<[:$YD[$N,&B0"$,#41'#$&-$5,&%'1#,$40,6/.$'4/.+$
810
!
0"#$1"#7/16)$AZ$4163#.+#,$1*J!IZ:$$
811
!
$
812
!
Supplemental'file'1:$;8.0"#0/1$AZ$1,&44*-##%/.+$1&*1')0',#$1&756,/4&.4:$YA[$;1"#760/1$
813
!
,#5,#4#.060/&.$&-$+#.&7/1$/%#.0/08$&-$1&.4'7#,$6.%$5,&%'1#,$40,6/.4$64$%&.#$f/+',#$>F:'=/++)8$
814
!
6,,&B4$/.%/160#$/.0#,7#%/60#4$0"60$16.$(#$#21"6.+#%:$YB[$N,&B0"$1',3#4$-&,$45#1/-/#%$
815
!
40,6/.4c1&*1')0',#4:$$
816
!
$$
817
!
Figure'2.$J600#,./.+$&-$5,&%'1#,$6.%$1&.4'7#,$40,6/.4$'.%#,$4#44/)#$6.&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4:$YA[$J"#.&085/1$
818
!
5,#%/10/&.4:$YB[$a#5,#4#.060/3#$/76+#4$4"&B/.+$+,&B0"$5600#,.4$&-$/.%/160#%$40,6/.$7/20',#4$
819
!
1&.40/0'0/3#)8$#25,#44/.+$#/0"#,$NfJ$&,$7<55)#$6-0#,$6.&2/1$+,&B0"$-&,$Q_",4$'.%#,$6.$6+6,$56%$B/0"$
820
!
./0,60#$5,&3/%#%$64$4&)#$!G<:$YC,D[$\&&7*/.$&-$=!$7/20',#$4"&B/.+$40,6/.4$+,&B/.+$64$1)&.6)$5601"#4$
821
!
YH[$1&756,#%$B/0"$9&&7*/.$&-$0"#$1&*1')0',#$4"&B/.+$/.0#,7/2/.+$YD[:$H&.4'7#,$40,6/.$/4$
822
!
1)*+23451)-+91)*:;7:$J,&%'1#,$40,6/.$/4$1)'+671)'#8:$
823
!
$
824
!
Supplementary'file'2.$J)6.V0&./1$1')0',#$5&5')60/&.$,60/&4$6.%$4#44/)#$6++,#+60#$1&'.04:$YA[$
825
!
H&*1')0',#$Q$6.%$U$B#,#$+,&B.$64$45#1/-/#%$-&,$0"#$6.&2/1$+,&B0"$1',3#4$Yf/+',#$>[$('0$B/0"$
826
!
-)'&,#41#.1#$1&.40,'104$0&$/%#.0/-8$0"#$1&75&4/0/&.6)$,60/&:$H&*1')0',#4$B/0"$0"#$1&.4'7#,$
827
!
#25,#44/.+$NfJ$6.%$5,&%'1#,$#25,#44/.+$7<55)#$Y)#-0$0B&$%6064#04[$B#,#$1&756,#%$0&$0"#$
828
!
,#1/5,&16)$1')0',#4$B/0"$1&.4'7#,$#25,#44/.+$7<55)#$6.%$5,&%'1#,$#25,#44/.+$NfJ$Y,/+"0$0B&$
829
!
%6064#04[:$YB[$J,&%'1#,$6++,#+60#4$B"#.$+,&B.$6)&.#$YJ,&:[$34:$/.$1&*1')0',#$B/0"$0"#$1&.4'7#,$
830
!
YJ,&:$o$H&.:[:$YC[$H&.4'7#,$6++,#+60#4$B"#.$+,&B.$6)&.#$YH&.:[$34$/.$1&*1')0',#$B/0"$0"#$
831
!
5,&%'1#,$YH&.:$o$J,&:[:$H&.4'7#,$40,6/.$/4$1)*+23451)-+91)*:;7:$J,&%'1#,$40,6/.$/4$
832
!
1)'+671)'#8:$
833
!
$
834
!
Figure'3.$Z2/1$34$"85&2/1$+,&B0"$&-$5)6.V0&./1$1')0',#4$4'55)#7#.0#%$B/0"$6.%$B/0"&'0$./0,60#:$YA?D[$
835
!
Q_",$+,&B0"$1',3#4$1')0',#%$'.%#,$0"#$/.%/160#%$1&.%/0/&.4:$G3#.)8$&28+#.60#%$#.3/,&.7#.04$Yg&2/1*
836
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
26!
4"6V/.+h[$B#,#$61"/#3#%$(8$4"6V/.+$1')0',#4$%',/.+$/.1'(60/&.$Y<CF[C$B"/)#$'.#3#.)8$&28+#.60#%$
837
!
#.3/,&.7#.04$Yg"85&2/1*406+.6.0h[$B#,#$61"/#3#%$(8$1')0',/.+$B/0"&'0$4"6V/.+$YHC?[:$YE[$Z28+#.$
838
!
5,&-/)#4$-,&7$.&.*4"6V/.+$1')0',#4$&-$0"#$=!$1&756,#%$0&$5,&-/)#4$-,&7$0"#$1&*1')0',#$60$0B&$0/7#$
839
!
5&/.04:$YF,G[$f)'&,#41#.0$%8#$,#6%/.+4$&-$4'5#,&2/%#$6.%$./0,/1$&2/%#$611'7')60/&.$&3#,$6$"85&2/1$
840
!
+,&B0"$1',3#$B/0"$./0,60#$Y64$/.$?[:$$
841
!
$$
842
!
Figure'4.$;560/&0#75&,6)$5600#,./.+$&-$)84/4$B/0"/.$6++,#+60#$(/&-/)74$64$6$-'.10/&.$&-$B"/1"$./0,60#$
843
!
,#%'1064#$/4$5,#4#.0:$A[$!,6.41,/50/&.6)$,#+')60&,8$1&.0,&)$&-$A65cA6,$+#.#$#25,#44/&.$Y)#-0[:$
844
!
J,#%/10/&.4$&-$4560/6)$A65$6.%$A6,$610/3/08$/.$6$(/&-/)7C$+/3#.$0"/4$,#+')60/&.$Y,/+"0[:$A65$16.$,#%'1#$
845
!
./0,60#$YAZU*[$0&$./0,/0#$YAZD*[$0",&'+"&'0$(/&-/)7C$6.%$,#%'10/&.$60$0"#$4',-61#$5,#3#.04$./0,60#$%/--'4/&.$
846
!
/.0&$0"#$(/&-/)7$1&,#:$=/0"&'0$A65C$./0,60#$768$5#.#0,60#$%##5#,:$YB[$!/7#$)654#$&-$5,&%'1#,$YA65cA6,[$
847
!
(/&-/)7$)84/4$&11',,/.+$-,&7$0"#$5#,/5"#,8$/.B6,%:$YC[$!/7#$)654#$&-$5,&%'1#,$YA6,[$(/&-/)7$)84/4$
848
!
&11',,/.+$-,&7$0"#$1&,#$&'0B6,%:$YD[$<0$0"#$467#$0/7#$5&/.0C$0",##$%/40/.10$,#5,#4#.060/3#$(/&-/)74$
849
!
6,,6.+#%$(8$67&'.0$&-$)84/4$&(4#,3#%$5#,$5,&%'1#,$085#:$a#%$1"6..#)$,#5,#4#.04$H#))aZp$406/./.+$
850
!
/.%/160/.+$5,#4#.1#$&-$4'5#,&2/%#:$<))$/76+#4$6,#$%/45)68#%$'4/.+$0"#$467#$%/45)68$4#00/.+4$-&,$%/,#10$
851
!
1&756,/4&.:$YE[$;1"#760/1$/.0#,5,#060/&.$&-$,#4')04:$AZ$)#6%4$0&$4'5#,&2/%#$5,&%'10/&.`$4'5#,&2/%#$
852
!
)&16)/960/&.$1&,,#)60#4$B/0"$)84/4S$)#-0$,#5,#4#.04$0"#$%8.67/1$-&,$6$A65cA6,$5,&%'1#,C$,/+"0$,#5,#4#.04$
853
!
0"#$%8.67/1$-&,$6$A6,$5,&%'1#,:$$
854
!
$
855
!
Supplementary'file'3.'j/4'6)/960/&.$&-$)84/4$/.$6$A65cA6,$5,&%'1#,$(/&-/)7:$b/+"$76+./-/160/&.$/76+#$
856
!
4"&B/.+$)84/4C$B"/1"$/4$/.0#,5,#0#%$-,&7$6$)&44$&-$-)'&,#41#.1#$6.%$/.1,#64#$/.$0,6.456,#.18$/.$5"64#$
857
!
1&.0,640:$$
858
!
$
859
!
Figure'5.$J600#,./.+$&-$5,&%'1#,$6.%$1&.4'7#,$40,6/.4$'.%#,$4#44/)#$&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4:$YA[$
860
!
a#5,#4#.060/3#$/76+#4$&-$/.%/160#%$40,6/.4$+,&B.$64$(/&-/)74$-&,$DQ",4$'.%#,$&2/1$1&.%/0/&.4$/.$0"#$
861
!
5,#4#.1#$&-$./0,60#:$YB[$\&&7*/.$&-$=!$1)&.6)$#256.4/&.$4"&B/.+$.&$/.0#,7/2/.+:$$YC[$\&&7*/.$&-$1&*
862
!
1')0',#$Q$4"&B/.+$5,&%'1#,$4',3/36)$6%l61#.0$0&$0"#$1&.4'7#,$#256.4/&.$/.0#,-61#`$.&0#$0"60$1#))4$
863
!
655#6,$(,/+"0#40$5,/&,$0&$)84/4:$YD[$!",##$6%%/0/&.6)$"/+"$76+./-/160/&.$16))&'04$0&$45&0)/+"0$45#1/-/1$
864
!
40,'10',6)$-#60',#4:$YE[$!/7#$)654#$&-$1&*1')0',#$Q$4"&B/.+$0#75&,6)$5,&%'1#,$)84/4$&11',,/.+$/.$0"#$
865
!
6(4#.1#$&-$1&.4'7#,$1&.0610:$
866
!
$$
867
!
Supplemental'file'4.'H&756,/4&.$&-$5600#,./.+$&-$0"#$5,&%'1#,$/.$4#44/)#$&2/1$1&*1')0',#$YA[$J,&%'1#,$
868
!
YA65cA6,[$4"&B4$)84/4$0",&'+"&'0$(/&-/)74$6.%$B"#.$56/,#%$B/0"$0"#$1&.4'7#,C$,#+6,%)#44$&-$
869
!
-)'&,#41#.0$/%#.0/-/#,`$5,&%'1#,$4"&B4$)84/4$/.$0"#$6(4#.1#$&-$1&.4'7#,$1&.0610:$YB[$J,&%'1#,$YA6,[$
870
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
!
27!
4"&B4$)84/4$/.$0"#$1#.0#,$&-$(/&-/)7C$6.%$.&$4/+./-/16.0$%/--#,#.1#$1&756,#%$0&$/.$0"#$5,#4#.1#$&,$
871
!
6(4#.1#$&-$0"#$1&.4'7#,:$YC[$J,&5&4#%$7&%#)$/.$B"/1"$0"#$A65cA6,$5,&%'1#,$6.%$1&.4'7#,$40,6/.4$
872
!
(&0"$+,&B$1)&.6))8$'.0/)$0"#$7/1,&#.3/,&.7#.0$1"6.+#4$4'1"$0"60$0"#$5,&%'1#,$(#+/.4$0&$)84#:$!"#$
873
!
1&.4'7#,$6104$64$6$4/.V$-&,$AZ$/.$1)&4#$5,&2/7/08$0&$0"#$5,&%'1#,C$,#)/#3/.+$AZ$0&2/1/08$6.%$5,#3#.0/.+$
874
!
)84/4:$
875
!
$
876
!
Supplemental'Table'1:$$J,/7#,4C$5)647/%4C$1'0$4/0#4$6.%$40,6/.4$'4#%$0&$76V#$0"#$7'06.04$'4#%$/.$0"/4$
877
!
40'%8:$$
878
!
$
879
!
'
880
!
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
Figure 1
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
Supplementary file 1
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
Figure 2
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
Supplementary file 2
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
Figure 3
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
Figure 4
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
Supplementary file 3
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
Figure 5
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
Supplementary file 4
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
Supplementary Table 1
.CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0 International licenseavailable under a
(which was not certified by peer review) is the author/funder, who has granted bioRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. It is made
The copyright holder for this preprintthis version posted December 9, 2021. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.12.09.472001doi: bioRxiv preprint
... Strains used in this study include P. aeruginosa UCBPP-PA14 (wild type [WT]) and isogenic ∆narGHJI (Spero & Newman, 2018), ∆lasR (Basta et al., 2017), ∆lon (Basta et al., 2020), ∆nirS, and ∆norBC (Wilbert & Newman, 2021) (Spero & Newman, 2018, Figure 4d), such that any decrease in percent survival results from death rather than growth inhibition relative to the untreated sample. ...
Mechanisms of chlorate toxicity and resistance in Pseudomonas aeruginosa
Article
Full-text available
  • Aug 2022
  • MOL MICROBIOL
Pseudomonas aeruginosa is an opportunistic bacterial pathogen that often encounters hypoxic/anoxic environments within the host, which increases its tolerance to many conventional antibiotics. Toward identifying novel treatments, we explored the therapeutic potential of chlorate, a pro‐drug that kills hypoxic/anoxic, antibiotic‐tolerant P. aeruginosa populations. While chlorate itself is relatively nontoxic, it is enzymatically reduced to the toxic oxidizing agent, chlorite, by hypoxically induced nitrate reductase. To better assess chlorate's therapeutic potential, we investigated mechanisms of chlorate toxicity and resistance in P. aeruginosa. We used transposon mutagenesis to identify genes that alter P. aeruginosa fitness during chlorate treatment, finding that methionine sulfoxide reductases (Msr), which repair oxidized methionine residues, support survival during chlorate stress. Chlorate treatment leads to proteome‐wide methionine oxidation, which is exacerbated in a ∆msrA∆msrB strain. In response to chlorate, P. aeruginosa upregulates proteins involved in a wide range of functions, including metabolism, DNA replication/repair, protein repair, transcription, and translation, and these newly synthesized proteins are particularly vulnerable to methionine oxidation. The addition of exogenous methionine partially rescues P. aeruginosa survival during chlorate treatment, suggesting that widespread methionine oxidation contributes to death. Finally, we found that mutations that decrease nitrate reductase activity are a common mechanism of chlorate resistance.
View
Visualization of mRNA Expression in Pseudomonas aeruginosa Aggregates Reveals Spatial Patterns of Fermentative and Denitrifying Metabolism
Article
Full-text available
To understand bacteria in diverse contexts, we must understand the variations in behaviors and metabolisms they express spatiotemporally. Populations of bacteria are known to be heterogeneous, but the ways this variation manifests can be challenging to characterize due to technical limitations.
View
Ratio of Electron Donor to Acceptor Influences Metabolic Specialization and Denitrification Dynamics in Pseudomonas aeruginosa in a Mixed Carbon Medium
Article
Full-text available
  • Sep 2021
Denitrifying microbes sequentially reduce nitrate (NO 3 – ) to nitrite (NO 2 – ), NO, N 2 O, and N 2 through enzymes encoded by nar , nir , nor , and nos . Some denitrifiers maintain the whole four-gene pathway, but others possess partial pathways. Partial denitrifiers may evolve through metabolic specialization whereas complete denitrifiers may adapt toward greater metabolic flexibility in nitrogen oxide (NO x – ) utilization. Both exist within natural environments, but we lack an understanding of selective pressures driving the evolution toward each lifestyle. Here we investigate differences in growth rate, growth yield, denitrification dynamics, and the extent of intermediate metabolite accumulation under varying nutrient conditions between the model complete denitrifier Pseudomonas aeruginosa and a community of engineered specialists with deletions in the denitrification genes nar or nir . Our results in a mixed carbon medium indicate a growth rate vs. yield tradeoff between complete and partial denitrifiers, which varies with total nutrient availability and ratios of organic carbon to NO x – . We found that the cultures of both complete and partial denitrifiers accumulated nitrite and that the metabolic lifestyle coupled with nutrient conditions are responsible for the extent of nitrite accumulation.
View
In-depth characterization of denitrifier communities across different soil ecosystems in the tundra
Preprint
Full-text available
  • Apr 2022
Background In contrast to earlier assumptions, there is now mounting evidence for the role of tundra soils as important sources of the greenhouse gas nitrous oxide (N2O). However, the microorganisms involved in the cycling of N2O in this system remain largely uncharacterized. Since tundra soils are variable sources and sinks of N2O, we aimed at investigating differences in community structure across different soil ecosystems in the tundra. Results We analysed 1.4 Tb of metagenomic data from soils in northern Finland covering a range of ecosystems from dry upland soils to water-logged fens and obtained 796 manually binned and curated metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs). We then searched for MAGs harbouring genes involved in denitrification, an important process driving N2O emissions. Communities of potential denitrifiers were dominated by microorganisms with truncated denitrification pathways (i.e., lacking one or more denitrification genes) and differed across soil ecosystems. Upland soils showed a strong N2O sink potential and were dominated by members of the Alphaproteobacteria such as Bradyrhizobium and Reyranella . Fens, which had in general net-zero N2O fluxes, had a high abundance of poorly characterized taxa affiliated with the Chloroflexota lineage Ellin6529 and the Acidobacteriota subdivision Gp23. Conclusions By coupling an in-depth characterization of microbial communities with in situ measurements of N2O fluxes, our results suggest that the observed spatial patterns of N2O fluxes in the tundra are related to differences in the composition of denitrifier communities.
View
Genetic Drift and Selection in Many-Allele Range Expansions
Preprint
Full-text available
  • Jun 2017
We experimentally and numerically investigate the evolutionary dynamics of four competing strains of E. coli with differing expansion velocities in radially expanding colonies. We compare experimental measurements of the average fraction, correlation functions between strains, and the relative rates of genetic domain wall annihilations and coalescences to simulations modeling the population as a one-dimensional ring of annihilating and coalescing random walkers with deterministic biases due to selection. The simulations reveal that the evolutionary dynamics can be collapsed onto master curves governed by three essential parameters: (1) an expansion length beyond which selection dominates over genetic drift; (2) a characteristic angular correlation describing the size of genetic domains; and (3) a dimensionless constant quantifying the interplay between a colony’s curvature at the frontier and its selection length scale. We measure these parameters with a new technique that precisely measures small selective differences between spatially competing strains and show that our simulations accurately predict the dynamics with no additional fitting. Our results suggest that that the random walk model can act as a useful predictive tool when describing the evolutionary dynamics of range expansions composed of an arbitrary number of competing alleles with different fitnesses. Author summary Population expansions occur naturally during the spread of invasive species and have played a role in our evolutionary history when many of our ancestors expanded out of Africa. We use a colony of bacteria expanding into unoccupied, nutrient-rich territory on an agar plate as a model system to explore how an expanding population’s spatial structure impacts its evolutionary dynamics. Spatial structure is present in expanding microbial colonies because daughter cells migrate only a small distance away from their mothers each generation. Generally, the constituents of expansions occurring in nature and in the lab have different genetic compositions (genotypes, or alleles if a single gene differs), each instilling different fitnesses, which compete to proliferate at the frontier. Here, we show that a random-walk model can accurately predict the dynamics of four expanding strains of E. coli with different fitnesses; each strain represents a competing allele. Our results can be extended to describe any number of competing genotypes with different fitnesses in a naturally occurring expansions. Our model can also be used to precisely measure small selective differences between spatially competing genotypes in controlled laboratory settings.
View
Spatial Ecology of the Human Tongue Dorsum Microbiome
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2020
A fundamental question in microbial ecology is how microbes are spatially organized with respect to each other and their host. A test bed for examining this question is the tongue dorsum, which harbors a complex and important microbial community. Here, we use multiplexed fluorescence spectral imaging to investigate the organization of the tongue microbiome at micron to hundred-micron scales. We design oligonucleotide probes for taxa both abundant and prevalent, as determined by sequence analysis. Imaging reveals a highly structured spatial organization of microbial consortia, ranging in linear dimension from tens to hundreds of microns. The consortia appear to develop from a core of epithelial cells, with taxa clustering in domains suggestive of clonal expansion. Quantitative proximity analysis provides the basis for a model of tongue dorsum microbiome organization and dynamics. Our work illustrates how high-resolution analysis of micron-scale organization provides insights into physiological functions and microbiome-host interactions.
View
Interaction-dependent effects of surface structure on microbial spatial self-organization
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2020
Surface-attached microbial communities consist of different cell types that, at least to some degree, organize themselves non-randomly across space (referred to as spatial self-organization). While spatial self-organization can have important effects on the functioning, ecology and evolution of communities, the underlying determinants of spatial self-organization remain unclear. Here, we hypothesize that the presence of physical objects across a surface can have important effects on spatial self-organization. Using pairs of isogenic strains of Pseudomonas stutzeri , we performed range expansion experiments in the absence or presence of physical objects and quantified the effects on spatial self-organization. We demonstrate that physical objects create local deformities along the expansion frontier, and these deformities increase in magnitude during range expansion. The deformities affect the densities of interspecific boundaries and diversity along the expansion frontier, and thus affect spatial self-organization, but the effects are interaction-dependent. For competitive interactions that promote sectorized patterns of spatial self-organization, physical objects increase the density of interspecific boundaries and diversity. By contrast, for cross-feeding interactions that promote dendritic patterns, they decrease the density of interspecific boundaries and diversity. These qualitatively different outcomes are probably caused by fundamental differences in the orientations of the interspecific boundaries. Thus, in order to predict the effects of physical objects on spatial self-organization, information is needed regarding the interactions present within a community and the general geometric shapes of spatial self-organization that emerge from those interactions. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Conceptual challenges in microbial community ecology’.
View
Spatial Ecology of the Human Tongue Dorsum Microbiome
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2019
A fundamental question in microbial ecology is how microbes are spatially organized with respect to each other and their host. A test bed for examining this question is the tongue dorsum, which harbors a complex and important microbial community. Here, we use multiplexed fluorescence spectral imaging to investigate the organization of the tongue microbiome at micron to hundred-micron scales. We design oligonucleotide probes for taxa both abundant and prevalent, as determined by sequence analysis. Imaging reveals a highly structured spatial organization of microbial consortia, ranging in linear dimension from tens to hundreds of microns. The consortia appear to develop from a core of epithelial cells, with taxa clustering in domains suggestive of clonal expansion. Quantitative proximity analysis provides the basis for a model of tongue dorsum microbiome organization and dynamics. Our work illustrates how high-resolution analysis of micron-scale organization provides insights into physiological functions and microbiome-host interactions.
View
Cell biology and molecular basis of denitrification
Article
  • Dec 1997
Denitrification is a distinct means of energy conservation, making use of N oxides as terminal electron acceptors for cellular bioenergetics under anaerobic, microaerophilic, and occasionally aerobic conditions. The process is an essential branch of the global N cycle, reversing dinitrogen fixation, and is associated with chemolithotrophic, phototrophic, diazotrophic, or organotrophic metabolism but generally not with obligately anaerobic life. Discovered more than a century ago and believed to be exclusively a bacterial trait, denitrification has now been found in halophilic and hyperthermophilic archaea and in the mitochondria of fungi, raising evolutionarily intriguing vistas. Important advances in the biochemical characterization of denitrification and the underlying genetics have been achieved with Pseudomonas stutzeri, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Paracoccus denitrificans, Ralstonia eutropha, and Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Pseudomonads represent one of the largest assemblies of the denitrifying bacteria within a single genus, favoring their use as model organisms. Around 50 genes are required within a single bacterium to encode the core structures of the denitrification apparatus. Much of the denitrification process of gram-negative bacteria has been found confined to the periplasm, whereas the topology and enzymology of the gram-positive bacteria are less well established. The activation and enzymatic transformation of N oxides is based on the redox chemistry of Fe, Cu, and Mo. Biochemical breakthroughs have included the X-ray structures of the two types of respiratory nitrite reductases and the isolation of the novel enzymes nitric oxide reductase and nitrous oxide reductase, as well as their structural characterization by indirect spectroscopic means. This revealed unexpected relationships among denitrification enzymes and respiratory oxygen reductases. Denitrification is intimately related to fundamental cellular processes that include primary and secondary transport, protein translocation, cytochrome c biogenesis, anaerobic gene regulation, metalloprotein assembly, and the biosynthesis of the cofactors molybdopterin and heme D1. An important class of regulators for the anaerobic expression of the denitrification apparatus are transcription factors of the greater FNR family. Nitrate and nitric oxide, in addition to being respiratory substrates, have been identified as signaling molecules for the induction of distinct N oxide-metabolizing enzymes.
View
In situ single-cell activities of microbial populations revealed by spatial transcriptomics
Article
  • Feb 2021
Microbial populations and communities are heterogeneous, yet capturing their diverse activities has proven challenging at the relevant spatiotemporal scales. Here we present par-seqFISH, a targeted transcriptome-imaging approach that records both gene-expression and spatial context within microscale assemblies at a single-cell and molecule resolution. We apply this approach to the opportunistic bacterial pathogen, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, analyzing ~600,000 individuals across dozens of physiological conditions in planktonic and biofilm cultures. We explore the phenotypic landscape of this bacterium and identify metabolic and virulence related cell-states that emerge dynamically during growth. We chart the spatial context of biofilm-related processes including motility and kin-exclusion mechanisms and identify extensive and highly spatially-resolved metabolic heterogeneity. We find that distinct physiological states can co-exist within the same biofilm, just a few microns away, underscoring the importance of the microenvironment. Together, our results illustrate the complexity of microbial populations and present a new way of studying them at high-resolution.
View
Keystone metabolites of crop rhizosphere microbiomes
Article
  • Oct 2020
  • CURR BIOL
The role of microbes in sustaining agricultural plant growth has great potential consequences for human prosperity. Yet we have an incomplete understanding of the basic function of rhizosphere microbial communities and how they may change under future stresses, let alone how these processes might be harnessed to sustain or improve crop yields. A reductionist approach may aid the generation and testing of hypotheses that can ultimately be translated to agricultural practices. With this in mind, we ask whether some rhizosphere microbial communities might be governed by ‘keystone metabolites’, envisioned here as microbially produced molecules that, through antibiotic and/or growth-promoting properties, may play an outsized role in shaping the development of the community spatiotemporally. To illustrate this point, we use the example of redox-active metabolites, and in particular phenazines, which are produced by many bacteria found in agricultural soils and have well-understood catalytic properties. Phenazines can act as potent antibiotics against a variety of cell types, yet they also can promote the acquisition of essential inorganic nutrients. In this essay, we suggest the ways these metabolites might affect microbial communities and ultimately agricultural productivity in two specific scenarios: firstly, in the biocontrol of beneficial and pathogenic fungi in increasingly arid crop soils and, secondly, through promotion of phosphorus bioavailability and sustainable fertilizer use. We conclude with specific proposals for future research.
View
Methods for Measuring Nitrate Reductase, Nitrite Levels, and Nitric Oxide from Plant Tissues
Chapter
  • Jan 2020
Nitrogen (N) is one of the most important nutrients which exist in both inorganic and organic forms. Plants assimilate inorganic form of N [nitrate (NO3⁻), nitrite (NO2⁻) or ammonium (NH4⁺)] and incorporate into amino acids. The metabolism of N involves a series of events such as sensing, uptake, and assimilation. The initial stage is sensing, triggered by nitrate or ammonium signals initiating signal transduction processes in N metabolism. The assimilation pathway initiates with NO3⁻/NH4⁺ transport to roots via specific high and low affinity (HATs and LATs) nitrate transporters or directly via ammonium transporters (AMTs). In cytosol the NO3⁻ is reduced to NO2⁻ by cytosolic nitrate reductase (NR) and the produced NO2⁻ is further reduced to NH4⁺ by nitrite reductase (NiR) in plastids. NR has capability to reduce NO2⁻ to nitric oxide (NO) under specific conditions such as hypoxia, low pH, and pathogen infection. The produced NO acts as a signal for wide range of processes such as plant growth development and stress. Here, we provide methods to measure NR activity, NO2⁻ levels, and NO production in plant tissues.
View